Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Se*ual consumption, VR therapy, and narcissistic clients
Transcript
- 0:00So, Bob, we have a new merch item that the listeners can buy,
- 0:05and I just unveiled it to you. It is a shirt, and
- 0:09I suppose you get a mug and all the other various things, and the
- 0:14merch is Everybody Loves Bob. Yeah, how do you feel about it?
- 0:20I think it's a riot. It's really funny. I kind of want to
- 0:23wear it and think I shouldn't at the same time. Well, as I
- 0:26was telling you, I think you are the perfect person. I'd be able
- 0:29to pull off a shirt like this because no one thinks of you as being
- 0:32narcissistic. And also you like a good joke shirt. I do. Yeah,
- 0:38so I think you can wear your own shirt that says everybody loves Bob.
- 0:41I wonder what Colleen's going to say, Jess probably all right. Emails
- 0:47patron May says, I noticed that I am unable to let go and just
- 0:52enjoy myself in a sexual setting. I feel uncomfortable being that vulnerable. I
- 0:58feel uncomfortable that someone cares for my pleasure. I feel uncomfortable receiving the pleasure
- 1:03of being focused on any advice on that. Thank you so much. By
- 1:07the way, these were all the questions that were submitted to you, Bob.
- 1:12So, what sort of answer do you have to that I can relate?
- 1:18Sexual pleasure is like really conspicuous consumption, you know, like there it
- 1:22is center stage, right between you and whoever you're with, and makes me
- 1:26very self conscious too. I wish I had good advice. I actually don't.
- 1:33Have you ever had that feeling or you were able to conspicuously consume?
- 1:41What was it? Conspicuous consumption? Yeah? Yeah, have you ever had
- 1:45that feeling where you're actually indulging? Yeah? Usually if I'm drunk that helps.
- 1:52And maybe in my earliest you know days, my early twenties or whatever,
- 1:57I probably didn't have as calcified in attitude, privileged youth and you know,
- 2:04fifty six now, so my body works the way it works, and
- 2:07yeah, so I have, though I'd say that that's been not the lion's
- 2:12share of that part of my life. Yeah, what path because you think
- 2:17about this and you work on it, I do, So what path forward?
- 2:23How do you see? You know? I wish I could say for
- 2:28me, it's a tough nut to crack, so to speak. Right,
- 2:35So I noticed that my own therapy, which has focused a lot on paying
- 2:39attention to how I feel and what I want is useful, but it hasn't
- 2:45at this point produced a direct result in my erotic life. I really actually
- 2:50don't have any advice for this person. I'm kind of curious what you would
- 2:53say. Well, it's the same advice generally that I would give regarding sense
- 3:00of self in general, in that it is anxiety provoking and also difficult.
- 3:06Even if you could overcome your fear of consuming conspicuously, there's still the matter
- 3:14of actually connecting with one's self and one's needs and one's emotions, one's desires,
- 3:21just in and of itself. Because when one is abused, even in
- 3:25one's mind, to go to what you want is a threat. It's not
- 3:30where the threat would occur, it's how the threat would begin. You would
- 3:35first notice you out a feeling, then you would want to act on it,
- 3:38maybe spontaneously. Then you'd be slapped across the face as you expressed it
- 3:44on your face or verbally or something. So even just noticing that you have
- 3:50a feeling can be hard for people sexually in otherwise, plus you have the
- 3:54added problem of a massively sex negative culture at makes it very difficult for people
- 4:03in your shoes to be able to progress. You know, it's one thing
- 4:08to overcome the barriers occasionally to express hey can you hand me the remote?
- 4:15That sort of thing. It's another thing for anybody regardless. You know,
- 4:19the most well raised person on the planet, you know, that had the
- 4:27best parents ever in our society in the United States, will still have a
- 4:30hard time asking for whatever sort of version of the remote sexually that we can
- 4:36think of, you know. And so it's rough, And yeah, I
- 4:43think that it's just a matter of safety and practice and talking. And you
- 4:49know, like with the remote, you're in bed, your wife has the
- 4:54remote to the TV on her nightstand. You have an impulse to get the
- 4:58remote, and normally you would get out of bed, walk around the bed,
- 5:01get the remote. But it's hard for you to just lay there and
- 5:06ask her for the remote, even though she's just reading a book. So
- 5:11how do you achieve that? Well, you notice, and then you put
- 5:15the fear and anxiety in its place, so to speak. You look at
- 5:18the anxiety and say, that's so irrational. There's no rationality. I feel
- 5:25it intensely, but there's no rationality to it. But I'm gonna push past
- 5:30the fear and I'm going to ask for the remote. She's gonna give me
- 5:33the remote, and I will have one more tick in the column of it's
- 5:39okay to feel my feelings and to ask for things, to begin to counterbalance
- 5:45my formative years of learning in which it was the opposite. It's the same
- 5:49with sex today. During sex, I'm definitely gonna ask for something, even
- 5:58though in the moment, I'm going to feel deeply afraid, but I'm going
- 6:00to put that fear in its place, and I'm going to try to absorb
- 6:05the moment as a corrective experience it. Maybe it'll even ruin sex for that
- 6:12session because I'll break down crying or something. But it's worth it overall because
- 6:19my partner would rather have that happen, honestly than going through the motions to
- 6:24please me the entire time, you know. So yeah, it's not easy,
- 6:30of course. I think a lot of people will just deprioritize the whole
- 6:33thing in lieu of other priorities like passing the remote or can you acknowledge I
- 6:41have a feeling? You know, those often can be I mean, I
- 6:43get the feeling that's kind of your situation. Yeah, yeah, because you
- 6:46know, sex is important. But for a lot of people, there are
- 6:51more fundamental day to day, minute to minute things like passing the remote or
- 6:58this is what I want to have for dinner? Or can I have a
- 7:00hug? You know, these fundamental things are perhaps a higher priority. Yeah,
- 7:08which sucks, but agreed. Yeah, my old supervisor, David Taylor,
- 7:13well he's passed away now. When he was sixty, he came out.
- 7:15He's been married twice. First wife died. Second wife he ended up
- 7:20splitting up with her when he was a little more than sixty because he's gay,
- 7:26and he hired someone called a sacred intimate, which was like someone to
- 7:30help him practice sex, and he was. He worked with that person for
- 7:35almost a year, I think, to just become comfortable with, you know,
- 7:41his sexuality, and then proceeded to have a lot of sex before he
- 7:44passed and seemed very happy about it. I delighted from the fifty watching from
- 7:51the sidelines. Yeah, do you think it's okay that you mentioned his full
- 7:55name? He's yeah, I think it's okay. I don't just make it.
- 7:58I mean it sounds like it, but I just want to make sure
- 8:00that Yeah, I think it'd be okay with him. He Yeah, he
- 8:03wasn't particularly I think it would be okay, So the sexual intimate had sex
- 8:11with him, yeah, sacred intimate, Yeah, as a transition or as
- 8:16a form of help. Yeah, what traditionally people used to think was sex
- 8:22therapy. I think actually sex therapy might have even been that a long time
- 8:28ago, decades ago, where the therapist would have sex with the client.
- 8:31Wasn't there a movie with the woman from Matt about You, Helen? Was
- 8:37that called sex therapy or something? No, that was a lovely film.
- 8:41Did you watch it? I think? Yeah. Right, he had a
- 8:45disability in which he was paralyzed, I believe. Yeah. And great actor
- 8:50that that guy. He shows up in so many things. I agree,
- 8:54he shows up in a lot of things. He has such a genuine like
- 8:58realness. You know, he plays the absolute mean guy in a Winter's Bone
- 9:05remember Winter's Bone with Yeah he's the leader of the cult. Yeah exactly,
- 9:09And he's an excellent version of that where he's both love bomby and you could
- 9:16feel his charisma, but there's a fragility and rage there. Yeah yeah,
- 9:22yeah exactly. And then he plays this lovely man who has uh some kind
- 9:30of major major disability like cerebral palsy. No, no, must go maybe
- 9:35spine of anyways, he has he's completely paralyzed. He's never had sex,
- 9:39and she is someone that he Yeah, they they have sex, and she's
- 9:48a sex worker. She's not necessarily a professional helper of sex or no.
- 9:52She keeps notes she's this is definitely therapeutic, like she was a professional.
- 9:58Yeah, she's she's married, she has a ray and she actually in the
- 10:01film anyways, has a hard time because she finds herself feeling really drawn to
- 10:07and attracted to him, and you know, it gets kind of muddy,
- 10:11like her boundary gets a little muddy in her own of course, because that's
- 10:13what they always want to do to us helpers. But you know, I
- 10:18remember liking it, and for Helen Hunt, it was quite a departure because
- 10:24she was at the height of her powers at the time and getting that role
- 10:28was or taking that role was I think quite a risk. I wonder if
- 10:33it actually harmed her career because she kind of dropped off the face of the
- 10:37earth. I don't know what happened to her. I would say there was
- 10:39a time when she was top ten, top five actresses in United States.
- 10:45Yeah, all right, next question from YouTube member live. They say,
- 10:50is i'm sorry you feel that way ever a legitimate apology? So if someone
- 10:56were to say i'm sorry you feel that way, perhaps in addition to other
- 11:01things, could that ever be a part of a legitimate apology. I don't
- 11:05think so. I'm sorry is a good apology. I'm sorry you feel that
- 11:09way is so qualified, and it just shifts focus from an actual apology to
- 11:16you're the one with the screwed up feelings. I don't just the way it's
- 11:20you're talking. We're talking about it right here. I would say, no,
- 11:24Yeah, I talked a lot about this in my deep dive regarding apologies.
- 11:28I'm sorry you feel that way is one of those non apologies. But
- 11:33I want to get away from people focusing on verbatim statements and more towards what's
- 11:41being communicated. I wonder if in the history of mankind has there ever been
- 11:46someone who legitimately or effectively apologized while saying the phrase i'm sorry you feel that
- 11:50way. I don't know, but you could make it work, you know,
- 11:54if you were indeed sorry that someone had feelings exactly, and you communicate
- 11:58like if I hurt your feel yesterday Bob, and I said something like,
- 12:03hey, man, I am truly sorry that you feel that way. I
- 12:07didn't want to make you feel that way. That's a weird way to phrase
- 12:13it a little bit, But you know, if it's felt and genuine and
- 12:16communicated and received, then it doesn't matter what the fuck you say. In
- 12:20fact, I actually tell people to forget about the words apology or sorry when
- 12:28you're trying to apologize, because to focus on those words actually able to distract
- 12:33people from what a real apology is. And most of the apologies that I
- 12:39have communicated probably never involved the word sorry or apologize, because that's not the
- 12:46point. You know. It's like to me, it's like saying, when
- 12:50you order food at a restaurant, when the waiter comes over, you have
- 12:54to say the word food, you know, like you don't have to.
- 13:00There's a lot of things that go into communicating something to a and also,
- 13:05an apology isn't just saying something, it's demonstrating something. You're demonstrating that you
- 13:13understand the transgression, that you understand the harm right, that you've taken the
- 13:16time to investigate or think about it, that you are also recognizing that you
- 13:22probably if it's a big enough transgression that you need to change, and you've
- 13:26thought about that too. I have this issue or you've already known you do
- 13:31this sort of thing, so you're already on a path of trying to change
- 13:33that aspect of your behavior or personality. Demonstrating that is what an effective And
- 13:39I say effective meaning that other people will say, yeah, I think I'm
- 13:45satisfied with that apology and or forgive and so anyway, let's take a break,
- 13:52get back more fast. Questions for Bob, what do you say?
- 13:54Right on? So, Bob, let's do an opp These people became patrons
- 14:03in twenty twenty one. These are all monthly Deserving listeners. We have Gwendolyn
- 14:11from Indianapolis, Indiana, Kristin from Itasca, Illinois. We have Portia or
- 14:18Portia probably from Johannesburg, South Africa. I'm realizing that I sorted this list
- 14:26by the town name, so you were in the Eyes and the Jays,
- 14:30and now we're in the case. Bailey from Kingston, Ontario. There's a
- 14:35Kingston, Washington across the water. Kristin from Lakewood, Ohio, Thomas from
- 14:43Lincoln, Nebraska, Marta from Madison, Wisconsin, Christy from Madison, Alabama.
- 14:50That's a twist. And Irian from Marietta, Georgia, Ha from Melbourne,
- 14:58Australia from Miami, Florida, Pauline from Mission, Texas. Sophia from
- 15:03Niagara Falls, Ontario. I wonder if that's near Niagara Falls. Imagine Hefty
- 15:11from Owens Crossroads, Alabama. Elsa from Philadelphia. Hey, thank you so
- 15:18much for being a patron and staying a patron through thick and thin and having
- 15:24a town name between the letters of I and P. Patron. Emily says,
- 15:33do you think VR therapy virtual reality therapy is going to be a thing?
- 15:37What could be the risks of it becoming mainstream? Bob? What do
- 15:39you think? What is it exactly? Is it zoom or is it the
- 15:43other thing? It could be a lot of different things. Well, the
- 15:46virtual reality is you know, a headset mix three D and all that stuff.
- 15:50Well, I heard I watched a documentary Allan All that was the guy
- 15:54in narrating it or whatever about using VR for spider phobia, and they had
- 16:00this electronic spider walking around and there was a glove version. There's a gloves
- 16:04attached to the thing and so it could walk on your hand or whatever,
- 16:08and it was effective as a way to move through spiderphobia. And I understand,
- 16:12though I don't I can't say with certainty where I heard it or but
- 16:17I understand that they used a VR therapy program for people who were eyewitnessed to
- 16:23the twin towers coming down, and it had you know, the visual and
- 16:29I think like smell like whatever the smell was, and it works, It
- 16:33worked really well to help people. What do you mean the smell whatever it's
- 16:37I don't know what it smelled like, but all that was the method of
- 16:40therapy. Well, it was a headset plus some some they put something in
- 16:44the smell, yeah, plus smell like dust or something. Yeah, yeah,
- 16:48for exposure to you know those you know, those experiences, those memories
- 16:52anyways, and what the let's be real that that exposure therapy well how people
- 17:00move through their fear, but it won't desensitize to the thing that happened.
- 17:06And you know, I was in this study once a long time ago where
- 17:10they were doing not VR therapy, but exposure therapy for women with PTSD who
- 17:15were you know, doing the DBT program or whatever. And to a person,
- 17:19they all they the ones that completed it said that they had less fear
- 17:26and they were filled with more sadness and anger, which, really, when
- 17:29you think about it, is appropriate for the kind of crap that they went
- 17:30through. So exposure therapy won't take away your feelings. It'll take away one
- 17:37particular fear so that you're not afraid of the memories of you know, or
- 17:41the you know, I fit spiders, whatever heights doesn't really matter, meaning
- 17:45that afterwards you'll still have feelings, Yeah, but they won't be excessive and
- 17:53ruin your life right right where they cause flashbacks or you have this urge to
- 17:56avoid or you know, you become numb. Yeah, and in you know,
- 18:00behaviorist language, desensitization is just that what we're saying. But you're using
- 18:07the word desensitized to mean that it doesn't take away one's human humanness, no,
- 18:15no, of anything. It helps a person connect with Yeah, I
- 18:18don't think that that could I doubt that that could ever be a replacement for
- 18:23good psychotherapy, except I mean, it's useful for specific phobia and PTSD if
- 18:30you can get a program that you know anyways, but I don't think it
- 18:34would be a replacement for psychotherapy. What do you think, Well, there's
- 18:38been a fair amount of research on this, because that's the way our field
- 18:45works, and our program at Anioch was actually a part of a pilot program
- 18:49regarding using VR therapy or actually as VR supervision or I'm trying to remember the
- 18:57exact method. It had something to do with the students. I remember,
- 19:02and I think it was supervision. But it's of course going to be a
- 19:07thing, and our first reaction to it as a society and maybe particularly as
- 19:14clinicians will tend to be negative. But if I've learned anything from the use
- 19:19of technology and therapy, is that my first reaction to it or my or
- 19:23my preference? You know, I don't. If VR is proven to be
- 19:29on average, even more effective than in person therapy, I still won't do
- 19:33it. I can almost guarantee you, because I'm old and I just don't
- 19:40want to, you know. And I mean I suppose if the evidence was
- 19:45overwhelming, then I would, And you know, and for maybe for particular
- 19:48applications like exposure therapy for sure, spiders included. But I've treated people with
- 19:56phobia's effectively without VR. You can find videos that will absolutely provoke the necessary
- 20:03exposure and a client in session and out or with spiders particularly, you could
- 20:08have plastic spiders or just thinking about you know, there's a lot you don't
- 20:12need vr simple ways to do it right, but could it be an effective
- 20:18way, you know, like with heights, for example, it might be
- 20:22hard to create a situation that was safe enough. You know, it's all
- 20:26about transition. So for someone with a fear of heights, like you did
- 20:30to yourself, Bob, you eventually were on a bridge just looking over the
- 20:37edge and habituating to that feeling or that stimulus so that your body just becomes
- 20:45used to it and thus you don't have a panic whenever you think about being
- 20:49in high places. But you didn't just go to the bridge the first,
- 20:55you know, foray into exposure therapy. I'm guessing at first you visualized it.
- 21:00I remember another time you got on top of your roof, which is
- 21:03not as far of a drop. Your house was a one story house with
- 21:08a basement, two story, a typical kind of Seattle Ballard house with a
- 21:15with the a frame roof kind of thing, and you know, a little
- 21:19harrowing. Eventually you're on the side of a cliff at Snake Ridge Ridge and
- 21:27Sequamba Pass east of Seattle in the mountains, and that is quite possibly aside
- 21:33from the Grand Canyon. I can't think of another cliff face that is more
- 21:40terrifying. My hands are and there's no railing, you just you could literally
- 21:44walk off the edge. It makes me wonder if people have just thinking like
- 21:48let's go, let's go over here and then just topple over. Yeah,
- 21:52it makes my hand sweat just thinking about it. But so with VR,
- 21:56might it be something like with heights that you use, you know, I
- 22:03would imagine that would be pretty intense, because like, have you ever done
- 22:07VR under some circuit? So there's a VR game where or some kind of
- 22:11application that it'll have you walk this plank, and there's a lot of hilarious
- 22:17videos of people who aren't really familiar with how technology, you know, like
- 22:22probably older people, you know, fifty sixty seventies, and and they're wearing
- 22:27the VR set and they will you know, they know they're in a game,
- 22:33but it VR can overtake one's rational mind. And so there's there's all
- 22:42these clips of people wearing the headset and I think they're walking a plank and
- 22:47they're expected to jump off the plank or something, and people will will literally
- 22:52jump and they'll fly into a TV or a wall or something. Putting a
- 22:56VR headset on my mom, who is almost eighty is one of the funniest
- 23:03clips we have of in my family. I watched it all the time.
- 23:07My mom she is I think she's a boxer, so she's like a guy
- 23:14wearing you know, she has a nice body, right, So she looks
- 23:18down at her body and she's like, oh. And then another time she
- 23:25was doing this thing and she didn't have a body. She was like floating
- 23:27over the Grand canyon or something, and she looks down and she just blood
- 23:33curdling scream. You know. She's just like you know, and me and
- 23:38all the rest of the family are just literally on the floor laughing. Yeah.
- 23:44But anyway, so with VR absolutely can have applications for a lot of
- 23:48phobia's and PTS exposure, as long as it is within the guidance of a
- 23:56competent therapist, which isn't necessarily easy to come by, by the way,
- 24:02but yeah, it could be. But in terms of VR therapy, you
- 24:07know what do we mean by that? As you were saying about there there's
- 24:10that application which already is being used and I think would be great. But
- 24:15not necessary in all situations. But like with Zoom, as you were saying,
- 24:18you could be on a headset, the client could be on a headset,
- 24:25and there either would be an avatar, or there would be a way
- 24:30because this is this is happening, where there would be enough cameras on the
- 24:36client and the therapist to actually and and you feed in a scan of your
- 24:41face because you know you have the headset on and it can't necessarily see your
- 24:45face. But the avatar will be a representation that is very very close.
- 24:51You know, in ten twenty years, the avatar will look indistinguishable from your
- 24:56real self. And you can just design your office however you want. You
- 25:00could tailor it to every client. You could sit as close or as far
- 25:06away. You could do remote therapy with multiple people in the room. Random
- 25:11experts could be hired for five minutes of drop in on a therapy session trippy,
- 25:17you know what I mean, Or a team meeting with another physician or
- 25:21something, or family members. You know, it sounds like it would be
- 25:25awesome. Sometimes these applications, at least in the near future, don't really
- 25:30because we have what I'm talking about right now, We basically have right now.
- 25:33But people don't really use it because it's just easier to call someone on
- 25:37the phone or at least just do zoom. You know, there's something about
- 25:41putting a headset on that's just kind of cumbersome and it's not comfortable. They're
- 25:45making them more and more comfortable and lighter, but it's still not doesn't feel
- 25:53natural right in a day at the office and that yeah, especially that imagine
- 25:57you know it's already bad hunched over or a laptop. Can you imagine having
- 26:00a headset on all day? Yeah, but you know, you could see
- 26:07how some people could use it. Another application is just with AI, where
- 26:14you have a chatbot that can manifest in a visual avatar and you wear VR
- 26:19and you headset and you could even walk around or fly around the Grand Canyon
- 26:26with your therapist and just have a conversation. You know, you could integrate
- 26:30soundscapes and landscapes to relax people. Maybe, or I just thought about this.
- 26:37You could have whether it's AI or US as therapist, you could tailor
- 26:44the environment to what you and the client think is a best setting for that
- 26:51exploration. If they're exploring their childhood, you recreate their childhood home. Wow,
- 26:56whether that's a good idea or not, you know, or if instead
- 27:00of that you recreate a very relaxing landscape with butterflies and a waterfall and nature,
- 27:08and that's where you go when you really want to talk about X,
- 27:12Y or Z or I don't know. There's all sorts of possibilities that I'm
- 27:18sure are already in development. Anyway, point is that with AI, we're
- 27:25in a world now where I never thought this was going to be possible that
- 27:30you can have in our lifetime a legit AI therapist who will even provide empathy
- 27:37and whatnot. Now will that replace us? Is that something that I would
- 27:41want as a client? Absolutely not, But I don't know if I give
- 27:47it a try. And you know, because it might even be more comforting
- 27:51for some people who have a harder time being vulnerable with an actual human you
- 27:56know, that may actually help to have a little bit of distance, you
- 28:00know, like the in the way that you have a VR headset walking across
- 28:03a bridge. The individual is intensely stimulated by it. You know they're having
- 28:11distress, but but they don't have full distress because they know it's not real,
- 28:15but they have still a lot of distress. One you know, someone
- 28:21with disorganized attachment or some sort of complex PTSD. To have an AI might
- 28:26provoke the feelings enough but still be safe enough for the person to actually tolerate
- 28:32it, such that it would be a step from from A to C and
- 28:36it would be be the B the B step. I have a client that
- 28:40uses a chat bot as a supplement to her personal counseling, and really she
- 28:45finds it very helpful and comforting. What bought? Is it a chatbot that's
- 28:49dedicated to therapy or I don't even know what that is. Yeah, well
- 28:55there's different chat bots out there. Well, let's try it out. Do
- 28:59you want to see what happens when I do CHET? So I will say,
- 29:03please be my therapist and start a session with me. I wonder if
- 29:12chat cheept will even oblige. I'm sorry, I can't provide help. Yeah,
- 29:18so I'm guessing that what she's talking about is, well, maybe if
- 29:23I just said, like, I'm feeling down, I'll just say I'm feeling
- 29:29down. I'm sorry you're feeling down. It's completely okay. Let's see if
- 29:36you're comfortable, could you share a bit more about what's been on your mind?
- 29:38Wow, so I feel like i'm working too much. I'll try to
- 29:48make it as genuine as possible. I'm not actually feeling down, but I
- 29:51do feel like I'm working too much. Feeling like you're working too much could
- 29:55be overwhelming and may contribute. So if I decided to really internalize this,
- 30:00you know, and really try to sit with it, you know, I
- 30:03could see it being at least a reminder of centering myself or yeah, and
- 30:08then it gives me a bullet point of things. Set boundaries, take breaks,
- 30:12prioritize self care, learn to say no blah blah blah if you're feeling
- 30:18overwhelmed. And then I'll say, but what if it's hard for me to
- 30:26deal with my anxiety about the ups and downs of self employment income. Let's
- 30:41see, dealing with the ups and downs of self employment income can indeed be
- 30:44challenging and may contribute to anxiety. Here are some strategies. Can you instead
- 30:53give me some more empathy. I'm sorry to hear that you're feeling anxious about
- 31:00the uncertainties. It's completely understandable that the fluctuations and income can bring about stress
- 31:06and concern. The journey of self employment can often involves unique challenges. It's
- 31:10okay to acknowledge these feelings and recognize the effort and indication. You know,
- 31:15you can see a therapist typing this outing this sort of thing. Anyways,
- 31:19it's not super personal to me, but you can imagine a chatbot if it
- 31:25was designed to kind of keep track of the client, that they would throw
- 31:27little bits in, like you know, like we were talking about three days
- 31:32ago, da da da, you told me about how you love your wife.
- 31:37What does she have to say about her? I don't know, Like
- 31:41it wouldn't be that hard for and I suppose you have to hand yourself over
- 31:45to it, right because if I'm not really used to that. But you
- 31:48could see some people wanting to in a pinch, and also you could see
- 31:55younger people acclimating to this kind of thing and being okay with it. So
- 32:00Emily you ask, you know, could there be risks of it becoming mainstream?
- 32:06What do you think? Probably? But maybe that's ways down the road,
- 32:10but not that far fifteen years. No, that's what I used to
- 32:15think, or longer. It's here. Now your client is currently using AI
- 32:21as an adjunct to you. Oh I thought they meant the VR bit.
- 32:25Oh right, yeah, Well, VR therapy is like saying zoom therapy,
- 32:36because you can do all forms of therapy over zoom or phone or VR,
- 32:42so I assume we're talking about AI VR. I don't know anyway. Are
- 32:49there risks? Yeah, there's all sorts of risks, I think. But
- 32:52I'm an old person and my here did you become a curmudgeon? My old
- 33:00self says that we're heading further and further into the danger zone of loneliness and
- 33:07disconnection and reliance and technology. And I'm not a fan. And if there's
- 33:15one thing that I would want to preserve, at least in my lifetime,
- 33:20it's at the very least we can have therapy be fucking genuine and real.
- 33:24And I'm worried about training of therapists, and it just seems to be taken
- 33:30as a given now. There doesn't seem to be any pushback even No.
- 33:35I think that's part of all that from the pandemic, right, Yeah,
- 33:37we've become more reliant on technology and used to it, which be included even
- 33:44you. I mean you could be doing in person. You're choosing not to,
- 33:47I am because why again, some of your clients want it to remain
- 33:52over zoom. Oh most of them? Yeah, Yeah, yeah, and
- 33:54so I don't have to pay office rent or figure out how to work from
- 33:59home. If you could snap your fingers and all your clients would be begging
- 34:02for in person, would you rather have that? Yeah, I'd build a
- 34:06I'd build an office in my backyard. Yeah, would I rather. I
- 34:10didn't have a strong preference one or the other, but if people did want
- 34:13to see me in person, I would. I have interest in accommodating it.
- 34:17But I don't have interest in renting an office. And I love my
- 34:22commute, yeah, which is just walk down the hall. Yeah huh,
- 34:27which is one of the main reasons people want like the Zoom is because they
- 34:30don't have to drive. They don't have to you know, I think we
- 34:34try to cram more shit in that's way Americans are, Oh can I get
- 34:37more? Can I ring more out of this time? And oh, it
- 34:40can go to therapy without having to leave my home? Great, because that's
- 34:45a you know, it's an hour round trip just in the car or more
- 34:49yeah, right, or more yeah, with parking and making sure you're they
- 34:53are on time. I have a couple that are live in Olympia. Yeah,
- 34:58yeah, I mean Olympia's ninety minutes south right, Yeah, and that's
- 35:02if traffic is good, right. Oftentimes it isn't, so yeah, yeah,
- 35:07Like if they came to see you in person, I would guess they
- 35:09would probably leave to two and a half hours before the appointment on just to
- 35:13make sure to make sure. And then yeah, you're looking at a five
- 35:19six hour But on the upside, the couples in the car on the way
- 35:22up, you chat, listen to music. Yep, you go to lunch,
- 35:25you make, you make a day of it, rather than ringing every
- 35:30bit of productivity out of a day so that we can live in a capitalistic
- 35:34society in which I worry about the ups and downs of self deployment income.
- 35:39But I well, hearing you say that, and you've said this before,
- 35:45because I don't know, because I'm my practice is so small that I just
- 35:50don't really know. And I haven't had a new client in so long years
- 35:53and years really, so I can't really evaluate it. Because the clients that
- 35:59I you see remotely, I know them so well from so many years prior
- 36:04to the pandemic of in person it just I don't know what it's like.
- 36:07And so to hear you say that, it tells me that it's probably fine,
- 36:09and that I'm I'm just being an old fuddy duddy. We're all resistant
- 36:14to change, and we do have reason to have caution about change. So
- 36:20yeah, yeah, bottom line, I just hope that everyone is able to
- 36:24recognize and meet their needs for connection, attachment, love, genuineness, the
- 36:31messiness of life, plus some of the randomness that happens when we have to
- 36:40do things that, on paper, at least to a capitalistic society, is
- 36:45inconvenient, like commuting to an appointment. You know, some of I don't
- 36:52know. I imagine a lot of who I am has to do with things
- 36:55that I did while I was bored or while I was trying to pass the
- 37:00time, you know, right, And we don't especially if you're spending it
- 37:08with other people. In fact, one of my favorite things to do is
- 37:13to carpool with people in my life, right. You know, Like my
- 37:19parents are wanting to go to Seattle Art Museum, and so I you know,
- 37:25they could easily drive downtown and park in a parking lot whatever, but
- 37:31since I'm on the way, they come to my They're going to come to
- 37:34my house and I'm going to drive them down there, and you know,
- 37:37it's just fun to. It takes away from my capitalistic efforts to drive them
- 37:45downtown and come back home and then drive back downtown to pick them up again.
- 37:49But it's or stay down there by myself and just kind of wander around.
- 37:52I wonder if you would me would be Oh, I'm sorry, I'm
- 37:54interrupting. No, well, I'm wondering if you and me would be the
- 37:58friends that we are if we'd done a program where we saw each other twice
- 38:00a year for a week, right, because one of the things I'd like
- 38:05to do is go out with you for a beer after class. That was
- 38:07fun, right, right, Yeah, you couldn't have that, and students
- 38:10don't have that. Yeah, to my knowledge, Well, if they're zooming,
- 38:15no, yeah, it's it's so easy to I mean, you could
- 38:16have a beer over zoom. But do they I don't know. I wouldn't.
- 38:22Yeah, just sit there in front of your computer over zoom having a
- 38:25beer. But I don't know. Maybe young people, maybe they do connect
- 38:30that way. I don't know. Maybe anyway, take a break, we'll
- 38:34get back more questions. Okay, Bob, let's do another opp who I'm
- 38:43sort of behind in my opps. So these people became patrons back in twenty
- 38:47twenty one, and these are also monthly deserving listeners. What letters p to
- 38:53T right of the cities? We have data from Portland, Oregon. Sarah
- 38:59from Portland, Oregon, Agnice Agnes from Latvia. I don't know how to
- 39:04pronounce this because it's a bunch of It's N E A with the little circle
- 39:08above it. I don't know what that sounded, and then A three fourths
- 39:13and then the letter A. So cool. But they're from the Netherlands,
- 39:16so I'm guessing it's probably some letter that just doesn't translate into English letters or
- 39:21something. Sorry about that. Tasha from San Diego, A bunch of people
- 39:23from San Diego, Tasha, Maury and Karen, Katie from San Francisco,
- 39:29Dana from Singer, Texas, Amy from Santa Clara, California, Zao Yu
- 39:36from Saskatoon, Alberta, Mark Zipan from Seattle, Deanna from Seattle, b
- 39:44w from Smyrna, Georgia, Ned from Tacoma, Washington, Jake from Taipei
- 39:51City, Taiwan, Kirsty from Estonia, and Elizabeth from Toronto. Thank you
- 39:58for being a patron and staying at patron all of this time. Seriously.
- 40:01Okay, Next question from patron Caleb. They say, how can you tell
- 40:07the difference between bipolar and general depression? I'm on an effectser and I read
- 40:13and I read that it may not be good if I'm by polar. So
- 40:17how do you tell differencing bipolar and general depression? I'm on an effects her
- 40:21and I read it's not good for a bipolar I'm pretty confident my mother is,
- 40:25though. I think I'm pretty sure my mother is what I'm guessing bipolar,
- 40:31though I know not to armchair diagnose. Her moods and her mood swings
- 40:37are quite rapid. Mine are longer lasting like bipolar two. Perhaps, Bob,
- 40:44what do you think, Well, whatever we say here will not be
- 40:47a substitute for you know, finding someone to you know, look into your
- 40:52situation, personally a prescriber, psychiatrist, or somebody. I My first thought
- 40:59is people people don't understand what mania really is. So when they talk about
- 41:04bipolar or bipolar two, I think oftentimes they're talking about just maybe mood swings,
- 41:09but but that are more related to, you know, what's going on
- 41:15in their lives as opposed to true mania. Mania is unmistakable when you see
- 41:21it. Yeah, even hypomania is unmistakable. Yeah, so at it almost
- 41:27always looks say, I mean it may or may not have psychosis, but
- 41:30it's always very particular. Yeah it is. And so when I used to
- 41:36work with bipolar folk, I mean up for days at a time because they
- 41:39can't sleep, can't slow down, can't sit still, oftentimes impulsive behaviors like
- 41:45well outside of what they might do when they're compensated when they're not in mania,
- 41:50very talkative, really talkative. Sometimes I remember one person really belligerent when
- 41:55they were manic, and another person who couldn't talk. Because we're not talking
- 42:00just irritability or even just rage. We're talking like irrational anger, because it
- 42:09all generates from this place where their brain is such that they believe, essentially
- 42:17that they rule the world. They're not necessarily narcissistic, but they think that
- 42:24it's an exaggeration of a good mood for people who don't have bipolar, where
- 42:30you just feel like you can take on the world. You know, like
- 42:32you go to this store and normally you wouldn't chat with the cashier, but
- 42:37today, you know, you have a little banter and you just feel like
- 42:39even if it doesn't go well you walk away just like, hey, you
- 42:42know, sometimes life doesn't go amazingly and I just love the world. And
- 42:49you take you times at times one hundred, and you're gonna get some odd
- 42:52behavior. So times one hundred like this. One client had entered into Mania
- 42:58and walked into restaurant and decided to order a bunch of stuff and was talking
- 43:05to all the all the workers there would just wander into the kitchen and say,
- 43:09you know, oh my god, you know your food. I have
- 43:13some ideas about how you could improve things, and and but you know,
- 43:16pleasant and people are kind of confused, and then and then and then he's
- 43:22just at a certain point he's just like, oh, I actually don't have
- 43:27the money to pay for this, but I'll totally get you because I'm working
- 43:30on this investment I'm going to make. I'll pay you ten times over.
- 43:35And he believed it. To believed it. He wasn't he wasn't trying to
- 43:38scam. He believed that he was going to make billions of dollars with this
- 43:45new idea and these new connections that he had made earlier that day. And
- 43:50he did not have the money and loved everyone in this restaurant intensely and when
- 43:54they said, I'm sorry, but that you can't do that. We're going
- 44:00to call the police if you just walk out of here, and that made
- 44:06him very irate because he was like, what are you talking about. I'm
- 44:10gonna be a Do you know who I am? Do you know who I've
- 44:13talked to? You know? It's it's not rage necessarily, but their mindset
- 44:19is such that when it doesn't gel with the world around them, then they
- 44:23get upset because they're absolutely sure that things are going to work out. And
- 44:29of course, if they're psychotics slightly, they might start hallucinating and having delusions
- 44:34and might literally think that they're elon Musk or whatever, and it can it's
- 44:39very particular. It's not just being angry. It's not being rageful. No,
- 44:44it's not being in a good mood or energetic or impulsive. It has
- 44:50a particular presentation. So, yeah, I agree that with everything that you
- 44:55were saying. It's just like, if I guess it's possible that someone you
- 45:00know, Caleb and or their mom might have mania in the way that we're
- 45:07talking about right now. But usually when we get these kinds of questions again,
- 45:12they need to be evaluated by a professional, but unless it's unmistakable.
- 45:16And if people are like, you know, sometimes I wonder if I have
- 45:21bipolar, you know, like they definitely know they have depression, and they're
- 45:23like, yeah, you know, sometimes I kind of wonder if I've got
- 45:27bipolar. No one with bipolar kind of wonders if they have bipolar, even
- 45:32bipolar too. But you go on TikTok and the internet and you're gonna get
- 45:38misled, right because people will literally post I would venture to say ninety nine
- 45:43percent of the content on TikTok, or maybe ninety percent of the content on
- 45:47TikTok about bipolar is a bunch of idiots saying with some song in the background,
- 45:53and then the title will be you know you're bipolar when? And then
- 45:59it's like a a joke and then oh yeah, oh my god, have
- 46:01you looked at TikTok now? And then but they think they're educating I don't
- 46:07know, o man. And then the person will be dancing as they are,
- 46:14you know, and the video is sped up and they're cleaning the kitchen
- 46:17at three in the morning or something, and they'll be communicating that that's a
- 46:22slam dunk indication that you have bipolar and and they're proud of it, and
- 46:27it's a funny thing. Oh, the people I've met that I'm bipolar are
- 46:30not happy about it in the least. No mania is is it's hypomania can
- 46:37be very enjoyable low grade hypomania, low gradia. But mania absolutely ruins people's
- 46:43lives. Yeah, So with regard to effects her though, some of the
- 46:45antidepressants are activating, and if you use them without a mood stabilizer, you
- 46:51do run the risk of inducing mania. So it is a reasonable question to
- 46:54check. Like, but you know, talking with your professionals, talk talk
- 47:00to your peep whoever they are. You know, it's funny. As I
- 47:04laid out that hypothetical TikTok, I almost guarantee you there's a TikTok. There's
- 47:08probably a dozen tiktoks that are exactly as I just described it. Patron shake
- 47:14in my head. Yeah, patronology says. I'm wondering what you would suggest
- 47:20for people who say therapy doesn't work for them. It's hard for me to
- 47:22imagine, and I've been curious about that recently. What types of people are
- 47:27not suited for therapy and furthermore, what alternatives to therapy would get them to
- 47:31healthier places in their lives. Wow, that's a big one. That's a
- 47:37big question, you know. When I think about this, like from a
- 47:39sociologic standpoint, like we don't have treatments that will cure all illnesses, right
- 47:46Like, like if a person had cancer, we don't have a therapies that
- 47:51will cure all cancer. It's hard to imagine a universe in which we have
- 47:54a psychotherapy that will cure all mental health troubles. So but and then,
- 48:02and then when I think about it from an individual perspective, I'm sort of
- 48:07like, well, how do we know that it won't help this one person
- 48:09here? Like like if we say that, how do we know that this
- 48:14person truly isn't treatable? Like, how do we know that? And what
- 48:19are the things that get in the way of therapy working? Well? It
- 48:21could be that the therapist is not following a protocol like thet they're not doing
- 48:27good therapy. Could be that we just don't have a therapy that fits whoever
- 48:30the person is. And that's always possible, but I'm always thinking we at
- 48:32least for the people I see, If it's not working, then maybe I'm
- 48:37not adjusting properly. I'm not seeing things properly. So good supervision, good
- 48:40mentorship, good, good consulting always, I mean, I consult with you
- 48:45all the time, so so I don't I can't actually remember the rest of
- 48:52the question. Well, when I hear someone say that therapy doesn't work for
- 48:57them, I don't know what that could be a result of. But I
- 49:00would put at the top of my list of hypotheses that they have a problem,
- 49:07because if you don't really have a problem, you probably wouldn't say that
- 49:10statement. So I think they know they have an issue, there's some kind
- 49:15of problem, and they've tried therapy, you know, maybe one, two,
- 49:22three times and found that it didn't really help them. And I would
- 49:27put at the top of the list that they didn't find the right therapist,
- 49:30they didn't give it enough chance, or they didn't meaningfully participate. Yeah,
- 49:36they just showed up. There's a fair amount of people, and there's a
- 49:38personality profile people in the narcisistic spectrum, for example, who I will treat
- 49:45and in the beginning of therapy, which I would characterize as the first couple
- 49:50years of therapy, it's frustrating, but a phase of therapy that needs to
- 49:53be worked through with these folks in that the client shows up and is basically
- 50:00there to prove to me that they're smart and or healthy and their decisions are
- 50:07all fantastic, and I have to endure that, which is fine, and
- 50:14provide them the corrective experience of praising them and giving them the space to say
- 50:21such things without rejection. And because that's the way they felt growing, they're
- 50:25trying to induce me to criticize and reject them. You know, can someone
- 50:30go to therapy, even with a specialist like myself, and just wake up
- 50:37one morning and say, you know what, I really just have it all
- 50:39figured out, or this therapist really just hasn't really given me any kind of
- 50:45gem that I think is worth the money and time I've been spending. You
- 50:50know, that'll happen. It's hard to hold onto NAR sixty clients even when
- 50:53things are going well. Honestly, you know, I've had narcissistic clients who
- 50:58will tell me have for years that they finally see it. And yet every
- 51:04session, you know, with with borderline folks, every session for years can
- 51:07be a struggle in that they will be convinced that I hate them or that
- 51:13I've wronged them or something, but they at least keep coming. They might
- 51:16occasionally threaten to break up, but there's a pretty strong pulsion to come into
- 51:22therapy. For narcisstic people, every session, every week is a struggle for
- 51:27them to tolerate or admit that they that they're vulnerable and that they need help
- 51:31like every human does. And they're in a constant For borderline people, they're
- 51:37constantly thinking is my therapist going to fire me? For narcissistic people, they're
- 51:42in a constant state of when do I fire my therapist? You know,
- 51:47is this the day? You know? So anyway, if I heard from
- 51:52someone that therapy didn't work for them, I wouldn't know what that meant,
- 51:54but that would be one of the hypotheses. Then you say, you know
- 52:00what types of people are not suited for therapy. I don't think there's a
- 52:02type of person that isn't suited for therapy. I think every type of person.
- 52:07I think there are types of problems that aren't suited to therapy, like
- 52:09if you have a cavity in one of your teeth, or or honestly,
- 52:15if you have bipolar. Therapy can help to cope also to get support to
- 52:22explain things. Of course, having bipolar doesn't mean you don't have other problems,
- 52:25right, But you're not gonna solve your bipolar with psychotherapy. Active psychosis
- 52:30is probably a thing that would get in the way of therapy helping. Yeah,
- 52:35so delusions about reality would get in the way. Yeah. Patron Audre
- 52:43has another question. She says, gift giving is not my love language.
- 52:49Okay, gift giving is not my love language. Not because I don't appreciate
- 52:53gifts. It's just that I really suck at giving gifts. No matter how
- 52:58hard I try, I get overwhelmed, I get details mixed up all the
- 53:00time, and I feel like even when I really know someone, I still
- 53:05don't quite nail it on the head. Sometimes I even think that if the
- 53:08gift isn't perfect, then it's not worth getting anything at all, because anything
- 53:13less than will only upset them. How are you guys with gift giving?
- 53:19Do you have any tips for not gift givers getting through the holidays? Bob?
- 53:23What do you think? Well, it sounds like a bit of perfectionism
- 53:28going on here, where you're sweating what you do. I think that gift
- 53:30giving, you know, Yeah, maybe we're not going to hit it out
- 53:34of the park. But it is a gesture of care and consideration. It
- 53:37means you mad enough to me that I use resources that are in that I
- 53:42have to provide something for you that I hope that you like. But if
- 53:46you don't like it, I don't think that that means the gift is ineffective.
- 53:52Like it's considerate. I just got a T shirt today. Yeah I
- 53:57really like my T shirt. Yeah right, But even if I didn't like
- 54:00my T shirt, the fact that you went out of your way to get
- 54:04me a T shirt is really nice. And Stacey designed it. Oh,
- 54:07really nice job, Stacy. Yeah, and the listeners demanded it. Oh
- 54:12well, yes, wisdom prevails, huh yeah. Yeah. Yeah. If
- 54:19you're not for whatever reason, even if it is neurotic, the reason that
- 54:24you don't like giving or receiving gifts, then I think that that's fine love
- 54:30language or just preference. In life. I've gone through phases where I would
- 54:36get burnt out on gift giving. I was really into gift giving for a
- 54:39period of time in my twenties. You know, I have a big family,
- 54:43and so there's a lot of birthdays, a lot of father's days and
- 54:46mother's days, and for US Japanese people there's Girls' Days and Boys Day and
- 54:52Valentine's Day, you know, of course Christmas, and so I would really
- 54:58get into it. And I didn't have a lot of so I would spend
- 55:01and there was no online shopping back then, so I would spend all this
- 55:05time going to stores in the mall and I would bring a little pad and
- 55:07paper and I would write prices down. But as like I was saying earlier,
- 55:13in terms of, you know, human life occurs in the moments that
- 55:17we don't necessarily think life is happening. And I have a lot of fond
- 55:23memories of going shopping with family and friends, and it became a warm,
- 55:29fuzzy feeling to think about that whole process. You know, it wasn't something
- 55:32I did by myself. And then of course thinking about what people want,
- 55:37and so I went through a period like that, and then I got burnt
- 55:39out and I just didn't want to give or receive gifts as much, maybe
- 55:45at all. You know what, you haven't given me half a frozen pizza
- 55:50since we were in our twenties, but I think I brought one over here
- 55:54last year. You did delicious. Yeah, we were with Stacy out of
- 56:00town or something, and you came over who played cards? And back in
- 56:04the day, Bob and I would come home after going out and I would
- 56:07throw in a frozen pizza into my oven, red barren four teeth. I
- 56:12was out, and we would I would when I put Tobasco Sasco on it,
- 56:16yeah, and we'd eat it. And so I, uh, you
- 56:24burned out on giving, Yeah, But then I got kind of back into
- 56:29it, and so I think it's fine. You know, it's just a
- 56:31matter of telling people and also giving people who love to give gifts some way
- 56:37of loving you in as a replacement. My mom loves to give gifts,
- 56:42and so when I went through this time, I had to. But me
- 56:45and my mom have a good relationship anyway, so something like it threatened it
- 56:49that much. Plus there were anyway point us is that that's fine? But
- 56:52yeah, as Bob said, it sounds more like some trauma has occurred around
- 56:58gift giving, whether it's specific gift giving or just you, I don't know,
- 57:04giving anything emotion or time or Whatever's something happened where you were criticized or
- 57:09attacked or rejected because of what you gave. And now you're very worried about
- 57:15it that. You know, what typically really works on people is consideration.
- 57:22It's not the gift. It's oh, you think about me, you care,
- 57:28you listen to me. You know, those kind of gifts that people
- 57:31notice, Like I remember six months ago, you said you like this thing,
- 57:35and so I thought, maybe you would like this thing. And you
- 57:38know, when I get gifts like that, and even if it's not really
- 57:43what I want, it's touching. That's the main gift, you know.
- 57:46Yeah, one more question here. Bob, anonymous patron from Chicago, says,
- 57:52Hi, Bob and Kirk, I currently I am currently experiencing an issue
- 57:57around attachment with my primary therapist. By the way, we got a lot
- 58:01of questions on the survey in this camp. So essentially people who are preoccupied
- 58:09or borderline or somewhere in this camp, they are going to their therapist and
- 58:15they have a lot of worries about being too attached. They have a lot
- 58:20of worries does my therapist actually really like me? I find myself to be
- 58:24obsessed with how my therapist sees me, or worried that my therapist is going
- 58:30to reject me. Am I codependent? Am I too attached. How do
- 58:36I cope with the feelings in between sessions? You know? I you know,
- 58:38one person said, I bring it up to my therapist and we do
- 58:42talk about it, but I still feel massively insecure. So what do you
- 58:49tell those folks? Keep at it? Of course you do, me too,
- 58:52By the way, it's the topic of conversation pretty much every Tuesday between
- 58:59the hours of nine and ten when I go to therapy, as we talk
- 59:01about our relationship and a moment of reassurance or a moment of peace with that
- 59:09doesn't necessarily mean that that's gonna does not mean for me anyways, that that
- 59:14will last forever and ever and you know, problems all solved, it doesn't
- 59:20we get to chip away. So like chip away, I think it's okay,
- 59:24and I think it's okay if you keep talking about it and your therapist
- 59:27is not going to burn out because you're talking about it again. It makes
- 59:30sense that a person would, you know, childhood wounds. They don't just
- 59:35like, oh no, my brain will be different now, you know.
- 59:37We we we keep at it. Yeah. Yeah. The way that people
- 59:44ask these questions seems to imply that if they could only get over these feelings,
- 59:52then the real therapy could begin. But it's the opposite. Once those
- 59:57questions are resolved, you won't need therapy anymore. So that is the therapy.
- 1:00:02That feeling, that ambivalence, that fear, that question, that rumination
- 1:00:07therapy is happening, and that means it's working. It takes as much time
- 1:00:13as it will need, whether it's a month or five years, that's just
- 1:00:17as long as it's going to take, and that means you're in there.
- 1:00:21You know. It's sort of like going to the dentist and saying, you
- 1:00:24know, if I could just get their hands out of my mouth, they
- 1:00:29could finally fix my cavity. You know, it's like, no, that
- 1:00:32that's yes, it's annoying to have people's hands in your mouth, but that's
- 1:00:37fixing your cavity. It'd be you know, for these people, it's like
- 1:00:39if I could only just not be ruminating, or if I could only just
- 1:00:44not worry about if I'm too attached, or if my therapist is you know,
- 1:00:47I don't. These are very These are nuisance feelings and there's no way
- 1:00:52around it to basic self denial, which sounds like just somebody's safety strategy.
- 1:00:58What do you mean if my safety strategy is to deny my feelings and see
- 1:01:02them as an inconvenience or as myself as an inconvenience to others. Then as
- 1:01:07long as I'm doing that, that's my safe place. My safe place is
- 1:01:10to be Oh, let's not be obtrusive, you know, let's just stay
- 1:01:14back. Oh nope, I can't worry about that. Or no, I
- 1:01:15can't get too connected. And if I'm worried about that, I've got to
- 1:01:19get my act together, because obviously I'm too worried about that. And that
- 1:01:22actually is the strategy that a person would learn to stay safe, to be
- 1:01:28invisible. It's like an attack of your own, an attack on self.
- 1:01:36I always think of it as a substitute for the attacks that I used to
- 1:01:37suffer from, you know, my folks or whatever. But when you mean,
- 1:01:45oh, prempt to strike, you know, like, if I'm down
- 1:01:46on me, then I can avoid my dad's wrath. Would that work when
- 1:01:51he were of No, he was unpredictably wrathful, no matter what. But
- 1:01:55that's what a kid does. A kid blames himself. So the idea that
- 1:02:00I've got to get my act together is another way to blame myself. Why
- 1:02:04do I got to get my act together, Like what does that even mean?
- 1:02:07And why can't I just be this way? Even though this way is
- 1:02:12whatever? This way is, you know, I might say, well,
- 1:02:15I'm weird or whatever. Well, yeah, everybody's weird. And so to
- 1:02:20me, if a person is saying, why can't I get these feelings under
- 1:02:23control, they're having trouble with accepting that these feelings do indeed exist. And
- 1:02:28when I think about that, I think that there's a four year old inside
- 1:02:31who is needing our attention and care. And you get to turn towards or
- 1:02:38away, And what you don't get to do is to decide when that part
- 1:02:44of you is satisfied. What do you mean that one is that part of
- 1:02:47you is satisfied when it's satisfied, and not a minute before. And so
- 1:02:52if it's one month or five years or fifteen, or you chip away for
- 1:02:58the rest of your days, then what else would you do? You chip
- 1:03:01away? But the last thing afore you would need is somebody to say,
- 1:03:07you know, wipe that look off your face, or I'll wipe it off
- 1:03:10for you. Like that's kind of what they're doing to themselves, right,
- 1:03:15It's what they do to themselves and they probably learned it when they were one
- 1:03:19or two or whenever. Anything less than patients and compassion is just a capitulation,
- 1:03:28recapitulation of the same bullshit. So keep at it and let it take
- 1:03:32as long as it takes. And if you're insecure, then fuck it,
- 1:03:36be insecure. If you're worried, then fuck it be worried. Did DBT
- 1:03:39have anything to say specifically to that feeling for people who are preoccupied and or
- 1:03:45borderline who are preoccupied with their therapists not actually caring about them, not that
- 1:03:52I recall, though I'm not an expert on individual DBT therapy, though I
- 1:03:57do in the class, and there was a thing, well what that was
- 1:04:00directly related, Not directly, but we did talk very specifically and purposefully intentionally
- 1:04:09on acceptance, including acceptance of self. So they wouldn't they wouldn't necessarily put
- 1:04:15it in terms of attachment language, which I think is probably a mistake,
- 1:04:19but the concept of acceptance is one of the cornerstones and DVT, I just
- 1:04:27don't think it's very specific. Yeah, so being specific about it's okay to
- 1:04:32accept yourself, like actually that that's necessary, that that that's one of the
- 1:04:39things that attachment therapists are more likely to do is to have an intentional focus
- 1:04:45on that and with that kind of language. All right, Bob, Well,
- 1:04:48we got some good questions in there. I want to circle back very
- 1:04:53briefly on something that I didn't I just want to comment on. And I'm
- 1:04:58sure this is another old man thing. So patron may the very first person
- 1:05:02with the question. When they were spelling the word sexual, they didn't actually
- 1:05:09spell the word sexual. They spelled it with an asterisk instead of the X
- 1:05:14se asterix. You know what does that mean? So what do you think
- 1:05:17it means? I think it's probably related to the world being flexible around gender,
- 1:05:25you know, so maybe it's a non binary thing or maybe guess,
- 1:05:28good guess, Probably not what it is, but any other guesses that's a
- 1:05:33good guess. I'm surprised to even have because I think of you as one
- 1:05:38of the most luddite individuals that I know pan sexuality, maybe I don't know?
- 1:05:43Yeah, right, well, okay in that direction, But is there
- 1:05:45any other guests that you have, Taypo, not a bad guess, not
- 1:05:50a bad guess. So what it is I'm ninety eight percent sure? Is
- 1:05:56that on TikTok, and I think other places they will censor or flag certain
- 1:06:03words, and there's just an algorithm because especially places like TikTok where there's not
- 1:06:11a human being reviewing every single post, so they have to err on the
- 1:06:15side of caution. And so like words like sexual or sex or rape or
- 1:06:20sexual abuse or maybe even just words like abuse. I don't know, maybe
- 1:06:26bullying. Let me actually google it. There's there's just a list of words
- 1:06:30that are essentially banned, So words that are banned from tick talk. And
- 1:06:41so what people will do is they will spell the words, you know,
- 1:06:45with these asterisks and stuff. Let's see words to avoid it says anything like
- 1:06:57like being like the word lesbian or gay or queer. What. Yeah,
- 1:07:00well, because you know, I don't know if it's because it's a Chinese
- 1:07:02company, I don't know. Oh so yeah, words like lesbian they'll do
- 1:07:08a dollar sign instead of the S, and you know, with gay they'll
- 1:07:11use an at sign. But you'd think the algorithm would figure that out,
- 1:07:15but I don't know. I do think it would. People will spell sex
- 1:07:17with g's like s E G G S. I'm reading an article on which
- 1:07:27human centered digital marketing, So this could all be silly. Abortion. Oh,
- 1:07:33words like murder or killed are changed as well to unalived. Have you
- 1:07:39heard this before? No? Yeah, So what is happening is because so
- 1:07:44many people, you know, live and breathe through TikTok, people are starting
- 1:07:47to use that language outside of TikTok. So someone submitted a question to us
- 1:07:54through a survey, an anonymous survey, right, and instead of just typing
- 1:07:58the word sexual, they But the other thing is like, it's not hard
- 1:08:02to know what someone is saying, you know what I mean, It's not.
- 1:08:05Actually, if some word was harmful to people somehow or triggering, replacing
- 1:08:12it with a couple asterisks doesn't obscure the communication. If the word sexual is
- 1:08:19triggering, it would still be triggering to read the word sexual with an ASTERIXK.
- 1:08:24But I'm pretty sure I'm just an old person in a similar way that
- 1:08:27when emojis and lol came out twenty five years ago, and all the old
- 1:08:31people were freaking out, and I thought, well, you're just old people,
- 1:08:34like it's not a big deal, you know, But I remember there's
- 1:08:40a lot of clutching of pearls and consternation and wringing of hands when lol entered
- 1:08:45the zeikeist and then entered the dictionary. I think you're really lol, like
- 1:08:51that's a disgrace. So, you know, I'm pretty sure I must be
- 1:08:55in that camp. But it's kind of weird to me because I'll be watching
- 1:08:59a TikTok video or YouTube video and the person will say the word sexual but
- 1:09:03in the captions it will be censored. They'll say the word rape or sexual
- 1:09:10abuse. Well that's the other thing instead of sexual abuse. It's all essay,
- 1:09:15like they won't say sexual abuse, and you know whatever. But on
- 1:09:19the other hand, I think it's sort of like nineteen eighty four new speak
- 1:09:25shit, where we are allowing corporations to shape the way that we talk and
- 1:09:30thus the way that we think. We should not be afraid of the fucking
- 1:09:33words sexual or rape or sexual abuse, or gay or lesbian, or abortion
- 1:09:41or other words on this list like disabled, what or what other words are
- 1:09:48queer, we should or killed or murder. These are things that happen.
- 1:09:54And sure, if it's triggering for folks, and if a content provider like
- 1:09:59myself is about to head into something that is likely to trigger, you know,
- 1:10:02a percentage of people like a detailed description of a murder then okay,
- 1:10:08trigger warning and maybe don't even necessarily mention those things, but mentioning words like
- 1:10:14sexual or murder or killed, and we have to change it for TikTok.
- 1:10:21I don't know. I'm not a fan. Yeah the tail wags and dog.
- 1:10:26Yeah, I think that we need to move towards acceptance of reality.
- 1:10:31These things are already stigmatized. Abortion sex is already stigmatized. So to make
- 1:10:38it so that we can't even say the word or write the word, do
- 1:10:42you know how nineteen eighty four that is? It's crazy. But I don't
- 1:10:45know. I'm probably just an old person because I you know, I'm pretty
- 1:10:50sure young because the younger people are doing this, Like literally, there are
- 1:10:55probably sixteen year olds that without blinking an eye, will mention a murder and
- 1:11:00they will use the word unlive. They'll be like, oh, today we
- 1:11:03studied how JFK was unalived by Lee Harvey Oswald. And they won't they won't
- 1:11:10blink an eye. It'll just be like the word that you use in that
- 1:11:13situation. And you know, language changes, I guess, and lol is
- 1:11:17fine, But I don't know. I just I think we need to embrace
- 1:11:23reality. Rape happens. Sex happens, gay happens, murder happens, abortion
- 1:11:31happens, and we have to you know, like when I teach sex said,
- 1:11:35you know, it's a well known icebreakers. You have all the kids
- 1:11:41say the word penis and vagina five times out, scream it all right,
- 1:11:45everybody, We're gonna say penis ten times loud. And now the kids are
- 1:11:48like, huh, They're like penis, penis, penis because penises are real
- 1:11:53and vaginas are real. Sex is real, abortion is real, and to
- 1:11:58be like children around the topic just of the word is just not a world
- 1:12:04I want to live in. But Patron May, I do not blame you.
- 1:12:10I don't even know why you did it personally, so I hope that
- 1:12:14you don't feel bad about yourself. I'm going to assume you're a young person
- 1:12:17and I'm an old dufist. You're practically yelling at people to get out of
- 1:12:23your driveway. Yeah, good damn kids. I mean so literally, I
- 1:12:28stopped the recording a couple of minutes ago because I could see on my security
- 1:12:34camera someone literally in my driveway that wouldn't move. And I stopped recording with
- 1:12:43me and Bob because I was almost about to go outside and tell them to
- 1:12:46get off my driveway because just till people know it's an Amazon delivery guy,
- 1:12:55and whenever they deliver, they always take a picture to prove that they delivered
- 1:13:00it. And on my security camera, I can see them. They always
- 1:13:03walk up. Sometimes they literally throw the package like ten yards at the door,
- 1:13:09They take a picture, and they walk away. This guy just sat
- 1:13:13there in my front you know, door area, just staring at my front
- 1:13:18and I thought he because he didn't ring the doorbell because it's not one of
- 1:13:24those things. He just sat there and I'm looking at him. My dogs
- 1:13:27are going crazy, and I'm kind of also worrying about Stacey because eventually she
- 1:13:30starts getting concerned, like, you know, because she can't see the security
- 1:13:34camera from where she is, and so I was literally thinking, get off
- 1:13:40my lawn. Yeah, And I want to be able to say words and
- 1:13:46everyone, please stay care of yourself because you deserve it.