Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / Deinstitutionalization & Asylums: The History of Mental Illness Treatment
Transcript
- 0:00usually when we talk about a medical diagnosis.
- 0:02There's this expectation of absolute precision.
- 0:05Right, like engineering or something. Yeah, exactly,
- 0:07like engineering. You break your arm, the x -ray
- 0:10shows that jagged white line, and the doctor
- 0:12just points at the film and says, well, there
- 0:14it is. Yeah, it's visible, objective. It's completely
- 0:17visible. And human beings love that clean categorization,
- 0:20right? Yeah. Because it offers this tremendous
- 0:22comfort. Oh, absolutely. I mean, it's binary.
- 0:24It's either broken or it's not. We just desperately
- 0:26want a mechanical explanation for why something
- 0:29is going wrong. But. If a broken bone is easy
- 0:33to see, a broken mind is terrifyingly invisible.
- 0:37And historically, when society can't see the
- 0:40root of a problem, they don't just like throw
- 0:42up their hands. No, they definitely do not. Right,
- 0:44they fill in the blanks with whatever belief
- 0:46system they have on hand, which has historically
- 0:48meant demons, dungeons, and forced sterilizations.
- 0:52So grab a coffee and pull up a chair. Welcome
- 0:55to the Psychology Underground. Yes, welcome.
- 0:57We are two undergraduate psychology students
- 0:59doing a massive deep dive into the source material
- 1:02on the history of mental disorders, and you,
- 1:05our listener, are our third study buddy today.
- 1:08We are super glad you're here because the mission
- 1:10for this study session is to map out a truly
- 1:13wild, extremely dark, and well, surprisingly
- 1:16inspiring timeline. Yeah, it really goes all
- 1:19over the place. It does. We are tracing the human
- 1:22attempt to understand mental illness, starting
- 1:25from ancient skull drilling all the way up to
- 1:27the modern prison pipeline. Quite the jump. Right.
- 1:31And the core thread we really want to pull on
- 1:33today is how a society's religious, spiritual,
- 1:36and moral beliefs have constantly, just relentlessly,
- 1:40dictated how they define and treat what they
- 1:42used to simply call madness. And since we're
- 1:45all trying to wrap our heads around this for
- 1:48the long haul, we're going to share some mental
- 1:49frameworks and analogies along the way to help
- 1:51keep these massive historical shifts organized
- 1:53for you. Sounds like a plan. So let's start at
- 1:56the absolute beginning. Before neuroscience,
- 1:59before anyone even conceptualized what a brain
- 2:01scan might be, how did early humans make sense
- 2:05of severe depression or schizophrenia? Well,
- 2:07everything was viewed. through a strictly religious
- 2:10and spiritual lens. Right, which is honestly
- 2:13an entirely logical leap for the era. Oh, totally.
- 2:16I mean, if you have zero understanding of brain
- 2:18chemistry or neurotransmitters, mental illness
- 2:21looks profoundly unnatural. It really does. If
- 2:24your neighbor suddenly starts speaking to people
- 2:27who aren't there or acting erratically, and you
- 2:29have a deeply spiritual worldview, the only plausible
- 2:33explanation is demonic possession. Like a literal
- 2:36demon. Yes. You assume an evil spirit has literally
- 2:39invaded their physical body. And if a spirit
- 2:42is trapped inside, the medical treatment is to
- 2:44figure out a way to let it out. Which brings
- 2:46us to trephanation. So this is circa 2000 BCE.
- 2:49The accepted medical procedure was to literally
- 2:52drill or scrape a hole into a person's skull
- 2:54to create a physical exit door for these evil
- 2:57spirits. Just brutal. I know, right? To help
- 2:59visualize this era, I like to use the analogy
- 3:02of spiritual plumbing. Spiritual plumbing. OK,
- 3:04I like that. Yeah, early healers essentially
- 3:07treated the human brain like it was just a container.
- 3:10If the water was bad, you just drilled a hole
- 3:12to drain the bad spirits out. Makes twisted sense.
- 3:15But here's the detail from the reading that absolutely
- 3:17stops me in my tracks. Archaeologists have unearthed
- 3:21fossilized skulls with these holes that show
- 3:24clear signs of bone healing. Wow. Yeah. meaning
- 3:27the patients actually survived having their heads
- 3:31bored open with primitive tools. I mean, they
- 3:33survived the immediate procedure, which really
- 3:36just speaks to the incredible resilience of the
- 3:38human body. Seriously. But we have to look at
- 3:40how that spiritual framework evolved, because
- 3:43it didn't just end in ancient times. It morphed
- 3:46into a highly structured practice of exorcism.
- 3:49Oh, right, the classic exorcism. Exactly. The
- 3:52erratic behavior of mental illness was framed
- 3:54as a literal high stakes battle between the devil
- 3:57and God taking place inside a human being. It's
- 4:00like a cosmic war zone. Yes. And the fascinating
- 4:03thing is how long that dual framework survived.
- 4:06Like, even in 1999, the Catholic Church updated
- 4:09its official exorcism guidelines to explicitly
- 4:12recommend that exorcists consult mental health
- 4:15professionals first. Wait, 1999? Yes, 1999. They
- 4:18essentially acknowledged that the medical reality
- 4:20of psychiatric disorders operates right alongside
- 4:23their spiritual doctrines. It's wild to think
- 4:25about that overlap happening so recently. Yeah.
- 4:29If we rewind back to the 13th through 17th centuries,
- 4:32that spiritual framing had utterly catastrophic
- 4:35consequences. Oh, you mean the witch hunts? Yeah,
- 4:37the witch hunts. Hundreds of thousands of people
- 4:39were put on trial and over a hundred thousand.
- 4:41And these were overwhelmingly marginalized women,
- 4:44widows, outcasts. They were burned at the stake.
- 4:46It's just horrific. It is. And modern historical
- 4:49consensus in our source material is that a significant
- 4:52portion of these so -called witches were simply
- 4:54women suffering from untreated mental disorders
- 4:56like postpartum psychosis. or schizophrenia,
- 5:00society's religious panic literally criminalized
- 5:02a medical condition. Because the symptoms of
- 5:05mental illness hallucinations, disjointed speech,
- 5:08severe isolation, they were weaponized. Right,
- 5:12exactly. Religious and local authorities viewed
- 5:14those exact symptoms as undeniable proof of a
- 5:17pact with Satan. And it was deeply systemic.
- 5:21How so? Well, when a few early medical thinkers
- 5:24tried to publish arguments suggesting these women
- 5:26were merely sick and needed help, the religious
- 5:28authorities actively banned their writings. It
- 5:31was a complete moral hijacking of a biological
- 5:34reality. OK, wait, hold on. Let me go back to
- 5:36the trepanation holes for a second because something
- 5:38is bothering me about that. Sure. What's up?
- 5:40If the skulls healed and the people lived. Did
- 5:43those ancient practitioners genuinely believe
- 5:45the surgery had cured the mental disorder? Or
- 5:48were these patients just so traumatized by having
- 5:50a hole drilled into their skull without anesthesia
- 5:53that they went entirely catatonic and the doctors
- 5:56just like took their silence as a win? See, that
- 5:59is the exact critical question we need to ask.
- 6:01We obviously don't have patient outcome surveys
- 6:04from 2000 BCE. Yeah. But if you consider the
- 6:07immense physical shock of that procedure, It
- 6:11almost certainly caused massive brain trauma
- 6:13or profound psychological withdrawal. Which would
- 6:17make anyone quiet down. Exactly. The practitioners
- 6:20weren't looking for nuanced mental well -being.
- 6:23They were looking for an end to the erratic behavior.
- 6:26The severe trauma quieted the person down, which
- 6:29perfectly confirmed what their moral framework
- 6:31wanted them to see. To them, the demon was quiet.
- 6:34Therefore, the treatment was a success. It's
- 6:36all about what the observer is biased to see,
- 6:39I guess. And eventually, as the scientific revolution
- 6:42slowly began and society secularized a bit, blaming
- 6:45demons just didn't cut it anymore. Right. But
- 6:47it's not like society suddenly became compassionate.
- 6:49They just replaced spiritual exile with physical
- 6:51exile. Yeah. And that brings us to the birth
- 6:53of the asylum. The shift here is profound. As
- 6:56Europe moved out of the Middle Ages, the civic
- 6:59approach to mental illness became entirely about
- 7:01hiding the problem. Out of sight, out of mind.
- 7:03Literally. The early institutions they built
- 7:06weren't hospitals meant for healing. They were
- 7:09literal dungeons meant to protect the public
- 7:11from the patients. The two most infamous examples
- 7:14being the Hospital of St. Mary of Bethlehem in
- 7:17London, which is where we get the word bedlam,
- 7:19and the Salle Petrière in Paris. The reality
- 7:21of those places just physically sickening. At
- 7:25Bedlam, patients were chained to the walls. And
- 7:28the hospital actually raised money by letting
- 7:30the public pay a penny to walk through and stare
- 7:32at them like animals in a zoo. It's so dehumanizing.
- 7:35It really is. At the Salpetrière, women were
- 7:38kept in freezing rat -infested dungeons, in chains.
- 7:42The authorities justified this with this bizarre
- 7:44moral logic. They believed that because these
- 7:47people had lost their reason, they had also lost
- 7:49their sensory perception. Wait, really? Yeah,
- 7:52they honestly told themselves the patients couldn't
- 7:54feel the cold or the pain of the iron shackles.
- 7:56That is just a horrific rationalization to avoid
- 7:58dealing with human suffering. But eventually
- 8:00the sheer inhumanity sparked a reform movement.
- 8:03Thank goodness. Yeah. In Paris, you had Philippe
- 8:07Pinel, who famously demanded the patients be
- 8:09unshackled and treated with basic decency. And
- 8:12in America, the major catalyst was Dorothea Dix.
- 8:15Oh, she's fascinating. She really is. Her motivation
- 8:18is deeply tied to our theme of morality. She
- 8:22was a Sunday school teacher who went into local
- 8:24jails to do religious outreach. And she was horrified
- 8:28to find mentally ill people locked in unheated
- 8:30cages alongside violent criminals. I mean, anyone
- 8:33would be. Right. So she leveraged that moral
- 8:35outrage into a massive, relentless lobbying campaign
- 8:39across state legislatures, ultimately pushing
- 8:42the government to build over 30 dedicated state
- 8:44psychiatric hospitals. Which was, you know, a
- 8:46mass step forward on paper. Around this same
- 8:49time, we get Dr. Benjamin Rush, who is widely
- 8:52cited as the father of American psychiatry. Ah,
- 8:54yes, Dr. Rush. He published the first major textbook
- 8:57on the subject in 1812, and he aggressively promoted
- 9:00what was called moral treatment. And the foundational
- 9:03theory for that was actually quite lovely, right?
- 9:05It was. The idea was if you put a patient in
- 9:08a peaceful rural environment and treated them
- 9:11with kindness, it would appeal to their rational
- 9:13mind and they would recover. The theory was lovely,
- 9:16yes. The execution was something else entirely.
- 9:19Oh, absolutely. Dr. Rush firmly believed in moral
- 9:22treatment, but his actual medical practices were
- 9:25brutally physical. He regularly utilized intense
- 9:29bloodletting to balance the body. Yanks. And
- 9:32he also invented a device called the tranquilizer
- 9:34chair, which strapped the patient down so tightly
- 9:36they couldn't move a muscle, supposedly, to reduce
- 9:39their pulse. And he built a gyrator, which was
- 9:42a spinning board designed to increase blood flow
- 9:44to the brain by basically centrifuging the patient.
- 9:47OK, this is where I have to push back on the
- 9:49historical glorification we sometimes see in
- 9:51the text. Go for it. How do we keep referring
- 9:53to Benjamin Rush as a pioneer of moral treatment
- 9:55when his go -to methods included strapping a
- 9:58human being to a board and spinning him until
- 10:00they passed out? It's a massive contradiction.
- 10:03Right. That doesn't sound like medical treatment
- 10:05to me. It sounds like a crusade to force compliance
- 10:08onto people who refuse to conform to polite society.
- 10:12You're touching on the exact dark underbelly
- 10:14of the moral treatment movement. In that era,
- 10:17morality was synonymous with societal compliance.
- 10:20A cured patient was a quiet, obedient patient.
- 10:23Exactly. And nowhere was this twisted definition
- 10:26of morality more devastating than in how these
- 10:30institutions handled race. Oh yeah, the source
- 10:32material goes deep into this. It does. When you
- 10:34look at Virginia's Central State Hospital, which
- 10:36was initially founded as a segregated asylum
- 10:39for black patients, the moral framing becomes
- 10:42a literal weapon of white supremacy. During and
- 10:46immediately after slavery, black individuals
- 10:48were frequently diagnosed as mentally ill simply
- 10:51for expressing a desire for freedom or for attempting
- 10:54to escape bondage. It's sickening. The historical
- 10:57records show their psychiatric evaluations were
- 10:59heavily focused on evaluating their usefulness
- 11:02for physical labor rather than any actual medical
- 11:05criteria. Just completely corrupted science.
- 11:07Exactly. So a good framework for us, you know,
- 11:10our third study buddy listening to track the
- 11:13life cycle of this era is the three Rs of early
- 11:16psychiatry. OK, let's hear the three Rs. It starts
- 11:18with restraint. The literal dungeons of Bedlam,
- 11:22then it moves to reform with Dix and Pinel demanding
- 11:26better conditions and finally regression regression.
- 11:30Yeah, because the tragedy is that those beautifully
- 11:33designed state hospitals, Dorothea Dix fought
- 11:35for. quickly became hopelessly overcrowded, underfunded
- 11:39nightmare facilities. And that regression sets
- 11:41the stage for sheer panic. Right. When the medical
- 11:44establishment realized these massive state hospitals
- 11:47were overflowing with hundreds of thousands of
- 11:49patients they couldn't help, the moral imperative
- 11:52shifted violently. Oh, so? They abandoned the
- 11:54idea of sheltering people and became obsessed
- 11:56with aggressively forcing a cure. or worse, eradicating
- 12:01the populations they labeled feeble -minded.
- 12:03Which takes us into some of the darkest treatments
- 12:05imaginable in our deep dive today. When the peaceful
- 12:08rural retreats failed, the hospitals turned in
- 12:11the laboratories. We really did. They began experimenting
- 12:13with early electroshock therapy. And we have
- 12:17to be super clear here. This is nothing like
- 12:20modern, carefully administered ECT performed
- 12:23under anesthesia. Not at all. In the 1930s and
- 12:2640s, they induced massive violent convulsions
- 12:30while the patient was fully conscious. We read
- 12:32firsthand accounts of attendants physically holding
- 12:35patients down, shoving rubber heels into their
- 12:38mouths just so they wouldn't bite their own tongues
- 12:40off during the seizures. The underlying theory
- 12:42was just so primitive. They noticed that people
- 12:45with epilepsy rarely had schizophrenia. So they
- 12:48erroneously concluded that inducing a seizure
- 12:50could somehow reset the brain chemistry of a
- 12:53psychiatric patient. Which is just wild logic.
- 12:55It was brutal physical trauma masquerading as
- 12:58a reset button. And right alongside that, we
- 13:00see the explosion of psychosurgery, most notoriously
- 13:03the lobotomy. Right. Surgeons would physically
- 13:05sever the neural connections in the prefrontal
- 13:07cortex, the part of the brain responsible for
- 13:09complex thought and personality. The case of
- 13:12Rosemary Kennedy, the sister of President John
- 13:14F. Kennedy, is a prime example of how this was
- 13:16misused. Yeah, in 1941, her father authorized
- 13:20a lobotomy for her, largely because she was a
- 13:22rebellious young woman with some developmental
- 13:24delays. And her mood swings were viewed as a
- 13:27potential political embarrassment to the family's
- 13:29pristine image. Exactly. It's so sad. The procedure
- 13:33was botched, leaving her with the mental capacity
- 13:36of a toddler. She was institutionalized and hidden
- 13:39away for the rest of her life. It perfectly illustrates
- 13:42how medical procedures were used to solve social
- 13:45and political problems But the darkest extreme
- 13:48of this era wasn't just attempting to alter individuals.
- 13:51It was attempting to alter the entire human gene
- 13:54pool. The eugenics movement. Yes. The push to
- 13:57forcefully eliminate genetics that society deemed
- 14:00unfavorable. Places like the Oregon Fairview
- 14:03Training Center institutionalized thousands of
- 14:05disabled Americans. But they didn't just lock
- 14:07them away. Residents were frequently caged, subjected
- 14:11to physical abuse, and systematically forcibly
- 14:14sterilized. And this wasn't some fringe rogue
- 14:16science operating in the shadows. This was backed
- 14:19by the highest legal authority in the country.
- 14:21The Supreme Court. Yes. In 1927, the Supreme
- 14:25Court heard the case of Buck v. Bell. Carrie
- 14:29Buck was a 17 -year -old girl in the foster system
- 14:31who was raped by a family member. Just heartbreaking.
- 14:34And when she became pregnant, instead of going
- 14:36after her abuser, The state declared her a feeble
- 14:38-minded moral delinquent and thought to forcibly
- 14:41sterilize her, and the Supreme Court overwhelmingly
- 14:44upheld the state's right to do it. It's hard
- 14:46to even process that. The majority opinion explicitly
- 14:49compared forced sterilization to a mandatory
- 14:52public vaccine. They argued that cutting a woman's
- 14:55fallopian tubes was legally no different than
- 14:57mandating a smallpox shot for the greater good
- 14:59of public health. The legal argument relied entirely
- 15:02on the moral justification of protecting the
- 15:05so -called purity of society from an inferior
- 15:08citizen. Right. And the fallout of that Supreme
- 15:10Court decision is hard to overstate. It legally
- 15:13empowered state eugenics boards to forcibly sterilize
- 15:15over 65 ,000 Americans. 65 ,000, that's a staggering
- 15:19number. Furthermore, the architects of Nazi Germany's
- 15:22racial hygiene programs explicitly cited American
- 15:25laws and the Buck v. Bell decision as inspiration
- 15:28and legal precedent for their own atrocities.
- 15:30Wow. It is the ultimate warning of what happens
- 15:33when medical authority and moral judgment are
- 15:36fully weaponized by the state. It is genuinely
- 15:38terrifying how quickly public health was used
- 15:41as a moral shield to justify mutilating a teenager.
- 15:45To keep this era straight, the framework I use
- 15:48is the three E's of the Dark Age. Let's hear
- 15:51them. Electroshock. Excision, meaning the physical
- 15:54cutting of lobotomies and eugenics. It's a grim
- 15:57reminder of what happens when the system panics.
- 16:00It is grim, but it's essential context for what
- 16:02happens next in our reading, because eventually
- 16:04the sheer horror of these institutional interventions
- 16:07reached a breaking point. Something had to give.
- 16:09Exactly. The walls of those massive state hospitals
- 16:12didn't just fall on their own. They were pushed
- 16:14down by a convergence of two massive, entirely
- 16:17different forces, a scientific revolution and
- 16:20a grassroots civil rights uprising. So let's
- 16:23talk about the science first, because it flips
- 16:24the entire paradigm. Yes, the medications finally
- 16:27arrive. In 1949, lithium was discovered to stabilize
- 16:32bipolar disorder, and in 1952, Thorazine was
- 16:35introduced to treat severe psychosis, like hallucinations
- 16:39and delusions. Which is huge. For the first time
- 16:42in human history, there was a pill that could
- 16:44chemically manage the symptoms of severe mental
- 16:46illness. If a chemical could fix it, it proved
- 16:49that madness wasn't a moral failing, and it wasn't
- 16:52a lack of willpower, it was a biological mechanism.
- 16:55Exactly the point. The pharmacological breakthrough
- 16:58shattered the justification for mass institutionalization.
- 17:02If you can manage a patient's delusions with
- 17:03a daily pill, you suddenly cannot justify keeping
- 17:06them locked in a ward for 30 years. This medical
- 17:09reality opened the door for a massive political
- 17:12shift. Which brings us to the 1960s. Yeah, in
- 17:141963, President John F. Kennedy signed the Community
- 17:17Mental Health Act. The grand vision was to completely
- 17:20defund the horrific state hospitals and transition
- 17:23care to local community -based mental health
- 17:25centers, allowing people to live at home. But
- 17:28the irony of JFK signing this is so layered.
- 17:31He championed this act, largely driven by the
- 17:34guilt and trauma over what his father did to
- 17:37his sister, Rosemary, a deeply personal family
- 17:40tragedy, literally altered national mental health
- 17:43policy. It's incredible how personal it was.
- 17:46Yeah, but yet at the exact same time. The disability
- 17:49rights movement was gaining serious momentum,
- 17:52and the brilliant activists driving it had to
- 17:54fight tooth and nail against the very government
- 17:57infrastructure JFK was leading. The push and
- 18:00pull of that era is fascinating. And we are just
- 18:03imparting the facts from the source material
- 18:04here. But the civil rights aspect is incredibly
- 18:06crucial because it wasn't just doctors deciding
- 18:09patients should go free. It was disabled people
- 18:11demanding their humanity be recognized legally.
- 18:14Right. They had to fight for it. The activists
- 18:16leading this charge were absolute powerhouses.
- 18:18You had Judith Heumann, a polio survivor who
- 18:21orchestrated a legendary 28 -day sit -in at a
- 18:24federal building in San Francisco, just to force
- 18:26the government to implement civil rights protections
- 18:28that had already them past 28 days that's incredible
- 18:31stamina and then there's Bessie Blount a black
- 18:35physical therapist who invented self -feeding
- 18:37technology for amputees just refusing to let
- 18:40society strip disabled people of their independence
- 18:42so inspiring then you hear Johnny Lacey A black
- 18:46woman paralyzed by polio who faced unimaginable
- 18:49intersectional barriers. She had to fight racism
- 18:51within the disability movement, ableism within
- 18:54the civil rights movement, and sexism everywhere
- 18:56else just to found independent living centers.
- 18:59What these advocates brought to the table was
- 19:02a profound revolutionary moral concept known
- 19:05as the dignity of risk. The dignity of risk.
- 19:08I love that term. Right. For centuries, society's
- 19:11excuse for locking people up was protection.
- 19:13We are protecting them from themselves. Which
- 19:15was just a convenient excuse. Exactly. The disability
- 19:18rights movement argued that people with mental
- 19:20and physical disabilities have an absolute right
- 19:23to autonomy. They have the right to make their
- 19:25own choices in the community. And crucially,
- 19:27they have the right to fail, to take risks and
- 19:30to live a messy human life rather than being
- 19:32protected in a sterile cage until they die. The
- 19:35dignity of risk. I think that might be the most
- 19:37powerful concept we've covered in our deep dive
- 19:39today. So to visualize this massive societal
- 19:42pivot, think of it as a chemical key and an activist
- 19:45battering ram. Oh, I like that visual. Yeah,
- 19:48the introduction of thorazine and lithium provided
- 19:50the chemical key that unlocked the asylum doors.
- 19:53But it was the relentless pressure of the disability
- 19:55rights movement that acted as the battering ram
- 19:58to ultimately knock the institutional walls down.
- 20:02A perfect way to look at it. But as we move into
- 20:04the modern era of the text. We have to face the
- 20:07fallout. Because it wasn't a fairy tale ending.
- 20:09No, it wasn't. The walls came down. Deinstitutionalization
- 20:12happened. Hundreds of thousands of patients were
- 20:15finally freed from the state hospitals. But the
- 20:18critical agonizing question that immediately
- 20:20followed was, where did they all go? And the
- 20:23answer is, frankly, a massive societal failure.
- 20:25The noble moral dream of community based care
- 20:29violently crashed into the reality of economics
- 20:32and political apathy. Yeah, it's pretty bleak.
- 20:34This era is often called optimism without infrastructure.
- 20:38The Community Mental Health Act promised a network
- 20:40of fully funded local support centers. But only
- 20:43about half of them were ever actually built.
- 20:46And the federal and state funding quickly evaporated
- 20:48because lawmakers simply didn't want to foot
- 20:51the bill once the patients were out of sight.
- 20:53The infrastructure just didn't exist to catch
- 20:55them. No safety net at all. When you release
- 20:57hundreds of thousands of vulnerable people into
- 21:00communities without housing support, job training,
- 21:03or reliable access to those new medications,
- 21:06the result is predictable. A massive portion
- 21:09of this population ended up on the streets or
- 21:12swept into the criminal justice system. The modern
- 21:15statistics in our text are deeply sobering. Today,
- 21:18it's estimated that between 20 and 30 percent
- 21:21of the unhoused population in America lives with
- 21:23a serious mental illness, like severe schizophrenia
- 21:26or bipolar disorder. It has a huge percentage.
- 21:29And roughly 50 percent have a traumatic brain
- 21:32injury. This leads us to the modern crisis known
- 21:34as transinstitutionalization. Transinstitutionalization.
- 21:37It's a mouthful. It is. The theory is that we
- 21:39didn't actually liberate the patients, we just
- 21:41relocated them. We moved them from one massive
- 21:44institution, the state psychiatric hospital,
- 21:47directly into another. The prisons. Right. Today,
- 21:51the largest providers of mental health services
- 21:53in the United States are not hospitals. They
- 21:55are massive county jails and state prisons. It
- 21:58is a devastating indictment of the system. Individuals
- 22:01with mental disorders are arrested more frequently.
- 22:03They get stuck in jail longer because they can't
- 22:05afford bail. And they are routinely denied pretrial
- 22:09release. It's an endless trap. Once inside, they
- 22:12rarely receive consistent psychiatric care, which
- 22:15drastically worsens their condition and virtually
- 22:18guarantees they will reoffend. trapping them
- 22:20in an endless loop. Now wait, let me pause here
- 22:22because I don't think it's as simple as the word
- 22:25transinstitutionalization makes it sound. What
- 22:27do you mean? Well, it implies a passive direct
- 22:31transfer like we closed hospital A and the patients
- 22:34just naturally wandered into prison B. But that
- 22:37ignores the massive societal shifts of the 1970s
- 22:40and 80s that the authors discuss. I see where
- 22:42you're going. The explosion of incarcerated people
- 22:44with mental illness wasn't an accident. It was
- 22:47massively fueled by the punitive war on drugs
- 22:50and the systematic defunding of affordable housing.
- 22:53Again, just looking objectively at this historical
- 22:55timeline, it wasn't just populations passively
- 22:59shifting. It was policies that ended up criminalizing
- 23:02the survival tactics of an already vulnerable
- 23:04group. That is a phenomenal distinction and absolutely
- 23:07correct based on our sources. It wasn't a passive
- 23:10pipeline. It was a perfect storm of de -institutionalization,
- 23:15gutted healthcare infrastructure, skyrocketing
- 23:17housing costs, and a criminal justice system
- 23:20that aggressively policed substance abuse and
- 23:23homelessness. Right. All of those deliberate
- 23:25policy choices converge to construct the crisis
- 23:28we are looking at right now. Which means my final
- 23:30mental framework for us to hold on to is trading
- 23:33a locked door for a revolving door. A revolving
- 23:35door, yeah. We successfully closed the locked
- 23:37doors of the abusive state psychiatric hospitals,
- 23:40but we just replaced them with the revolving
- 23:42doors of the modern criminal justice system and
- 23:45the streets. So let's zoom out and look at the
- 23:47whole picture we've mapped out for our study
- 23:50buddy today. It's been quite a journey. We have
- 23:52followed an incredible tragic and continuing
- 23:55through line. We watched ancient communities
- 23:57drill physical holes into skulls to release demons.
- 24:01We saw the Middle Ages try to hide the problem
- 24:03away in the freezing dungeons of Bedlam. Then
- 24:06the panic. We witnessed the medical establishment
- 24:09panic, leading to the horrors of eugenics and
- 24:12the attempt to literally breed out the feeble
- 24:14-minded. And finally, we arrived at the modern
- 24:17tragedy of mass incarceration and widespread
- 24:20homelessness. It's heavy stuff. If this history
- 24:23teaches us anything, it is that how a society
- 24:25defines, treats, and cares for mental illness
- 24:28is the ultimate unfiltered test of its moral
- 24:31compass. I couldn't have said it better. And
- 24:33I think that leaves us with a deeply provocative
- 24:35thought to chew on before we close out this study
- 24:37session. Oh. Lay it on us. It is so easy for
- 24:41us to sit here today looking backward and judge
- 24:43the past. But if our ancestors honestly, genuinely
- 24:47believed that drilling holes in skulls, spinning
- 24:50people on boards until they passed out, and performing
- 24:53lobotomies was cutting edge, compassionate medicine.
- 24:57What perfectly normal, universally accepted mental
- 25:00health treatments of today will psych undergrads
- 25:03100 years from now look back on in absolute horror.
- 25:09profoundly humbling question. It really is. It
- 25:11forces you to realize that when it comes to the
- 25:13human mind, that clean, simple x -ray machine
- 25:16we talked about at the beginning, we haven't
- 25:17invented it yet. Not even close. The picture
- 25:19is still incredibly murky and the work is far
- 25:22from over. Thanks for joining us for this session
- 25:24on the Psychology Undergrad. We'll catch you
- 25:26next time.