Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / The First 100 Days in IP Litigation Leveraging Early Strategy to Improve the Outcome
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, everyone, and welcome to today's Beverly
- 0:06Hills Bar Association production of the first
- 0:08100 days in IP litigation, leveraging early strategy
- 0:12to improve the outcome. I'm Adrian Sihann, chair
- 0:15of the BHBA's intellectual property law section,
- 0:18and I'm delighted to introduce our speakers,
- 0:21Rebecca Horton and Manny Caccero. Rebecca is
- 0:25a skilled litigator who helps clients protect
- 0:27their intellectual property and brands, advising
- 0:29business across technology, financial services,
- 0:32and consumer goods and retail on the protection
- 0:35and enforcement of their IP rights. Having litigated
- 0:38more than 20 trials and represented clients in
- 0:41federal and state courts nationwide, she guides
- 0:43clients through high -stakes disputes involving
- 0:46trademarks, copyrights, patents, and trade secrets
- 0:49from pre -litigation strategy through trial.
- 0:53A repeatedly recognized super lawyers rising
- 0:56star in intellectual property, Rebecca is also
- 0:59active in the legal community as a speaker, writer,
- 1:02mentor to junior attorneys and dedicated pro
- 1:05bono advocate. Manny Caccero represents industry
- 1:08leaders and cutting -edge companies in high -stakes
- 1:11commercial and intellectual property litigation
- 1:13with deep experience in patent damages, valuation,
- 1:17and licensing matters across software, medical
- 1:20devices, financial services, and entertainment.
- 1:24He enforces clients' rights under a wide range
- 1:26of contracts, including merger, acquisition,
- 1:29licensing, OEM and employment agreements, while
- 1:33also defending consumer class actions and litigating
- 1:36business tort claims such as fraud and breach
- 1:38of fiduciary duty. Manny is also a skilled protector
- 1:42of trade secrets and proprietary information,
- 1:44having litigated numerous trade secret, restrictive
- 1:47covenant, and patent disputes spanning medical
- 1:50devices, software, networking, and mobile applications.
- 1:54And now let's get started. Thanks, Adrian, for
- 1:58that very fulsome introduction. We're very excited
- 2:03to be joining BHBA and the IP division to make
- 2:07this presentation on the first 100 days of IP
- 2:11litigation and how to sort of best leverage strategy
- 2:16at those early stages to improve the outcome.
- 2:18As Adrienne said, my name is Rebecca Horton.
- 2:20I am a partner in Venable's San Francisco office
- 2:23and I'm here joined by my venerable colleague
- 2:27Manny. Hey, everyone. Manny Cachero from the
- 2:31Venables Los Angeles office. And while it's true
- 2:36I've done everything in the long introduction
- 2:39that Adrian gave me, I really focus a lot of
- 2:42my practice nowadays on what I like to call technology
- 2:45litigation. So a lot of patent work, a lot of
- 2:47licensing work, and related counseling. So thank
- 2:50you for having us here. We're excited to talk
- 2:52to you about this today. And as Manny notes,
- 2:55our respective practices cover the cross section
- 2:57of IP. So my focus is mainly on copyright, trademark,
- 3:00and AI. And with Manny's patent experience and
- 3:03trade secret as well, we'll be giving practical
- 3:06examples across that IP spectrum in terms of
- 3:10this sort of how to best leverage this early
- 3:12strategy. All right, let's get started. So how
- 3:19did we decide on this topic? Why did we think
- 3:21that we could take up an hour of your time and
- 3:25discuss this? And a lot of this came from the
- 3:27fact that in our day to day, we employ this strategy
- 3:30with our clients and some clients are, it's their
- 3:33first instances coming across litigation and
- 3:35some clients that are very experienced. or have
- 3:39had a lot, deal regularly with litigation. And
- 3:43we noticed that at the end of the disputes, these
- 3:46clients would comment about how they see this
- 3:48through line of some of these discussions that
- 3:50we had early on in the case, some of these early
- 3:53strategic discussions that we had and how that
- 3:57directly impacted the outcome. They could see
- 4:00that they all of a sudden had this clarity on
- 4:02the process. And as a result, although each of
- 4:05these cases is different, we realized that There
- 4:08are these common threads across that can serve
- 4:11as a general guide to help maximize that unique
- 4:15strategic opportunity that is made available
- 4:18in the early stages of litigation. And so that's
- 4:20where that was sort of the genesis of this presentation.
- 4:25We're going to be talking about this in four
- 4:28segments. So the first section is going to be
- 4:29talking about pre -litigation strategies. So
- 4:31this is when a dispute's been identified, but
- 4:34it might not have been filed yet. And so what
- 4:37are some of the strategic processes that you
- 4:40can get going to maximize the benefits of this
- 4:43early stage? The second part of the discussion
- 4:46is going to be focused on those first 100 days
- 4:48of litigation. So once a complaint's filed, what
- 4:51those early stages of a case look like and opportunities
- 4:54available. to sort of affect the strategy that
- 4:56you put into place. The third section, we'll
- 4:59talk about actual case studies, so situations
- 5:03that we've been through where we've really been
- 5:04able to maximize the benefits of this early case
- 5:08strategy and sort of really improve the outcomes.
- 5:12And the section four, we'll go through questions
- 5:15and discussion. That said, we invite questions
- 5:18throughout. We'll try to answer them in real
- 5:19time. But if we don't get to them during that
- 5:24slide, that will sort of make sure that we provide
- 5:27some time at the end to cover. All right. And
- 5:31actually, sorry, on that note briefly, my understanding
- 5:33is the way to ask questions is through the Q
- 5:36&A in the Zoom. I think that's what you're supposed
- 5:40to do. So we will be monitoring that. All right.
- 5:45So. Pre -litigation, there are two parallel tracks
- 5:49that should be immediately implemented when a
- 5:52dispute has been identified. And as you can see
- 5:55from this slide, those tracks are an in -house
- 5:57workflow and an outside council workflow. This
- 6:01might seem counterintuitive or costly that you're
- 6:03sort of engaging these workflows simultaneously
- 6:06rather than sort of one after the other, but
- 6:09we have repeatedly seen this result in cost savings
- 6:12rather than waste. And this is because these
- 6:15simultaneous workflows, better ensure that critical
- 6:19steps are not being missed. You're delegating
- 6:21the right issues to the right parties. Some are
- 6:23better handled in -house, some are better handled
- 6:26at first by outside counsel, and it maximizes
- 6:28this valuable time in an IP litigation case,
- 6:32and that's that early stage. So as Rebecca indicated,
- 6:39one of the workflows here is in -house. And so
- 6:42for this portion that we're directing it towards,
- 6:44in -house counsel, or maybe if you're outside
- 6:46counsel but you're really working with an in
- 6:48-house element, some of the things you're going
- 6:52to need to do initially, the first thing is the
- 6:55most obvious. Initiate your litigation hold.
- 6:58Make sure you're preserving all evidence. Make
- 7:00sure you're identifying all evidence. We're not
- 7:03going to say a lot about that. A lot of ink has
- 7:06been spilled over the years about how important
- 7:08that is and what happens if you don't do that
- 7:09properly. Now, avoiding privilege waivers. When
- 7:15it comes to IP and IP disputes, one of the things
- 7:19you're going to hear that's going to be a through
- 7:21line throughout this presentation is that some
- 7:25of the internal stakeholders, whether it be an
- 7:27author, whether it be an inventor, are going
- 7:30to have very strong views. on the substance of
- 7:35the case. And if you as in -house counsel are
- 7:39not creating the correct and privileged and protected
- 7:43protocols for having those communications, what
- 7:47you're going to find is that your inventor is
- 7:51sending non -privileged communications to other
- 7:53inventors with their own personal thoughts. on
- 7:56the patent or an author, their own personal thoughts
- 7:59about a copyrighted, potentially infringing work.
- 8:05And that's the last thing you want when you're
- 8:08about to get into a litigation. You want control
- 8:13over what is being communicated, and you want
- 8:17to ensure that privilege is holding. Obviously,
- 8:22insurance coverage, work with your insurers,
- 8:26your carrier if necessary, figure out which policies
- 8:29cover the claim and do it early. I've seen cases
- 8:33where clients go down a path only to learn there
- 8:36was coverage later and then find themselves in
- 8:38a difficult situation where maybe they need to
- 8:41switch. counsel because the counsel they wanted
- 8:43to work with wasn't a panel counsel for the insurer.
- 8:48Or conversely, I've seen situations where the
- 8:49client assumed there'd be coverage and learned
- 8:51later that there wasn't. Better to understand
- 8:54at the front end. Again, when it comes to economics,
- 8:58consider whether to establish a reserve. Consider
- 9:01required disclosures. And by that, what I'm really
- 9:03referring to is two contexts come to mind. One
- 9:06is If you have an active dispute, you may need
- 9:10to report that in your annual audit or your annual,
- 9:14if you're a public company, your annual reports
- 9:17and think about that. Think about what that's
- 9:19going to look like to investors or people who
- 9:21are following that. Then the other thing is if
- 9:24you happen to be, I tend to work often with emerging
- 9:29companies and when a litigation hits at a moment
- 9:33when you might be on the market, consider how
- 9:36that's going to look when it's disclosed to potential
- 9:41buyers or sellers. And then, obviously, and maybe
- 9:46most important of all, is have a robust discussion
- 9:49with the business. In order for everything else
- 9:53we're going to talk about today to work, the
- 9:57key is getting as much alignment as possible
- 9:59between the business and the legal apparatus.
- 10:03So you identify the stakeholders who within the
- 10:05business is going to care about it, about this
- 10:09dispute, and who should be involved in it. Because
- 10:11you might find there are a lot more people who
- 10:13want to have a voice than should be having a
- 10:15voice here. Figure out who are the implicated
- 10:18people and departments. And besides employees,
- 10:20I want to flag, it's often important to figure
- 10:23out which former employees are relevant here.
- 10:26Has an inventor left? has a key witness or key
- 10:29inventor left the company? And are you what's
- 10:33your relationship like with them? And are you
- 10:34able to bring them under the fold? And if not,
- 10:36that might impact how you approach the early
- 10:41stages of litigation. And of course, third parties.
- 10:44Are you a retail company? And this is going to
- 10:50deal with, you've got to get your manufacturers
- 10:52aware, your resellers aware. And what does that
- 10:57look like for you? Implicated objectives and
- 11:00what I mean here is not just the objective of
- 11:02winning the case, which is obviously everybody's
- 11:04objective, but for instance, is there a new product
- 11:09launch that's happening in the upcoming quarter?
- 11:12And you want to try to find ways to time a dispute
- 11:15around that or mitigate the impact of that dispute
- 11:18on a business objective. And you wouldn't know
- 11:22that unless you're running this by the business
- 11:25team. And then, as I mentioned, establish clear
- 11:28processes and parameters for future communications.
- 11:30In other words, once you've identified this group
- 11:34of people who are going to be part of the legal
- 11:36team and that you're working with them, make
- 11:38sure they know to copy counsel on all relevant
- 11:42communications, not to talk to each other about
- 11:44these issues outside of counsel, what the repercussions
- 11:47can be. I can tell you it's going to be herding
- 11:51cats, and nobody's going to follow your instructions
- 11:55completely. But if you don't give the instructions,
- 11:58then real chaos can ensue. And I think, and back
- 12:03to that point about insurance, I think each of
- 12:05these steps, it's intuitive. It makes sense.
- 12:08It's easy in theory. But in practice, it takes
- 12:11some planning and delegation in order to make
- 12:15sure that you're checking these boxes. And that's
- 12:17particularly true for insurance. where the relevant
- 12:21policy might be, what it applies to the time
- 12:24frame because the infringement or the accusations
- 12:27of infringement might go back in time and it
- 12:29might be a different policy that's in play. In
- 12:32copyright and trademark matters, sometimes it's
- 12:34housed in a different policy and it's under like
- 12:36an advertising clause and it relates to an advertising
- 12:39tort. And so, you know, submitting that early,
- 12:42first of all, because insurance providers require
- 12:44it, you don't want to make it easy for them to
- 12:46reject the claim, but it's also then sort of
- 12:48a preliminary step because you can get outside
- 12:50counsel then involved, whether it's to petition
- 12:53for coverage or to inform the sort of risk assessment
- 12:57as to whether or not you do have insurance coverage.
- 12:59And then also in turn, it's part of mandatory
- 13:02disclosures anyways, once you actually are engaged
- 13:05in litigation, you have to disclose whether or
- 13:06not there is insurance or potentially insurance
- 13:10coverage for the claim. Next slide, I would just
- 13:13add on that point, because it comes up a lot.
- 13:16I can tell you typically when it comes to patent
- 13:18disputes, those generally are not covered by
- 13:21your standard, your DNO policy, whatever typical
- 13:24policy. If you haven't gotten a specialized policy,
- 13:26I would not assume that it's covered by something
- 13:28you have. All right. So simultaneous to that
- 13:33in -house council workflow is the outside council
- 13:36workflow. And a lot of this is going to be oriented
- 13:38around getting you as many metrics or helping
- 13:41to get as many metrics as possible to inform
- 13:44the strategy and the strategic decisions going
- 13:46forward. And the first is financial metrics.
- 13:50financial metrics to determine the bottom line
- 13:52of the litigation. Now this is not an exercise
- 13:55of precision. It can't be because the dispute
- 13:57is still at the early stages, but you're going
- 14:00to get a lot of questions as outside counsel
- 14:02or in -house counsel as to what is this going
- 14:05to cost? And you might not be able to answer
- 14:07that, right? You're going to get the answer that
- 14:08everyone hates, which is it depends. But you
- 14:11might be able to answer the question, what could
- 14:13it cost? And that's sort of an exercise that
- 14:16you can sort of work with outside counsel to
- 14:17go through. And so the first is the damages exposure.
- 14:21So how much you might be on the line. Once again,
- 14:24the dispute's not fully defined yet, but you
- 14:26can sort of go through this exercise by assuming
- 14:28the worst case scenario. So if you were to be
- 14:31found liable of these claims, what does that
- 14:33look like monetarily, right? Like how much money
- 14:36might you have to sort of pay? Now, this is something
- 14:39that it might sound familiar because this is
- 14:41what damages experts do often, but this is substantially
- 14:43further down in the line of a case and the damages,
- 14:46well, first of all, they're experts. And second
- 14:48of all, they have a lot of information available
- 14:50to them. They have all the parties financial.
- 14:52and, you know, metrics and that sort of thing.
- 14:55You don't have that at the early stage, but you
- 14:57do have some, you know, relevant information.
- 15:00You have your own, the own client or the company's
- 15:02financial metrics related to the IPA issue that
- 15:06can be used. You can also look at recent verdicts,
- 15:08right? In similar types of claims, like what
- 15:11have jury awards look like? How much of the party's
- 15:13been on the hook? And use that to sort of inform
- 15:16a worst case scenario outcome, assuming liability.
- 15:21The next piece is, is how much is it gonna cost
- 15:24you to sort of litigate the case, right? How
- 15:27much are the attorney's fees and costs? And so
- 15:29you're, as outside counsel, you can budget, outside
- 15:32counsel can budget this, right? They can budget
- 15:34how much it costs, sort of, you know, a rough
- 15:36estimate for the early pre -litigation stage,
- 15:39pleading stage, discovery, and onwards and so
- 15:43forth, all the way through trial. Once again,
- 15:45there's gonna be a lot of assumptions being made.
- 15:47It's not precise, but all of a sudden, if you
- 15:49sort of, and engage in these two sort of financial
- 15:53metric assessments, right? All of a sudden you
- 15:56now have anchor points to have this discussion
- 15:58of what could it cost and sort of, and then that
- 16:02will then inform the next piece that outside
- 16:04council should be doing, which is sort of understanding
- 16:07and identifying the material defects in the liability
- 16:11case, right? So if these claims were to be asserted,
- 16:14are they strong claims? Are they weak claims?
- 16:16And also what would be the point of time in a
- 16:19case to attach? Is it the pleading stage, which
- 16:22is very early in the case? It could be within
- 16:24the first three, four, five, six months of a
- 16:27case. Or is it summary judgment, which sometimes
- 16:29might not happen for years into a case? Because
- 16:32that is a very different sort of, they might
- 16:34have weak claims, but if they're not really susceptible
- 16:37to challenge until summary judgment, you're then
- 16:40on the hook for the attorney's fees and whatnot
- 16:42that would cost to get to that stage in the case.
- 16:45And it has you evaluating that metric difference.
- 16:49So then once you sort of have these metrics as
- 16:52to, you know, worst case scenario of what this.
- 16:54what the case could cost, the attorney's fees
- 16:56to get there, and then sort of how strong the
- 16:59liability case is. That really then helps outside
- 17:03counsel and in -house counsel have a discussion
- 17:05about doing that cost benefit analysis, right?
- 17:08Like, what does this actually look like for the
- 17:10company? And also, so if you have a strong case,
- 17:14you might go in eyes open and want to litigate
- 17:16aggressively, and you know what that could potentially
- 17:18look like monetarily. But if you have a weak
- 17:22case and you realize it's going to cost a lot
- 17:24of money, money, well, that might then give you
- 17:26some helpful reference points to then have the
- 17:29discussion about redirecting some of those resources
- 17:31to early settlement, as opposed to sort of getting
- 17:35into the thick of a case. And that money's gone
- 17:39out the door. And I think in this instance, I've
- 17:43had multiple cases involving a lot of types of
- 17:45cases I litigate involve multiple types of IP.
- 17:48So that's a lot of different types of risk and
- 17:51it sort of implicates a lot of different aspects
- 17:53of the business. And going through this exercise,
- 17:57right? Sort of doing that damages model, worst
- 17:58case scenario, if you were to be found liable
- 18:01on all these claims, what could that look like?
- 18:03You know, what have recent jury verdicts look
- 18:05like? And then the attorney's fees, I've sort
- 18:07of modeled it out or budgeted it out in a rough
- 18:10estimate as to what each of the stages would
- 18:12look like. And then we were looking at the liability
- 18:16case and saying, well, actually, some of these
- 18:17claims are really, really subject to, they have
- 18:20some major flaws to them. And it would actually
- 18:22be that we'd challenge them at the beginning
- 18:24because they run up against black letter law
- 18:28such that they are so. you know, susceptible
- 18:31to dismissal early. So then that allows the client
- 18:34to sit there and look, OK, you know, this is
- 18:36what the liability or this is sort of what it
- 18:38could look like if we had to litigate this all
- 18:40the way to the end. But, you know, our counsel
- 18:42is saying, well, let's give it a shot. Let's
- 18:45engage in this motion to dismiss practice. And,
- 18:48you know, if we spend this money up front, you
- 18:49know, we stand to sort of get the case cut down.
- 18:52And ultimately, it did happen in that way, such
- 18:55that although there was more money spent up front
- 18:58in that pleading state, It then substantially
- 19:01better placed the clients going into discovery
- 19:05because the case was substantially pared down.
- 19:08The scope of discovery is less. And then when
- 19:09you're talking, engaging in those early settlement
- 19:12discussions that Manny and I will get into shortly,
- 19:15the scope of risk is a lot smaller and it gets
- 19:18everybody focused. And as a result, it was able,
- 19:21the business could understand by nature of these
- 19:24metrics, the business could understand why that
- 19:26was an investment well spent. Actually, just
- 19:30a couple quick, very quick points that onto that.
- 19:32One is just directionally, if you're working
- 19:35with a client or business that is not familiar
- 19:39with IP litigation. It is going to tend to be
- 19:43a more expensive form of litigation than some
- 19:45of the other kinds of litigation they're used
- 19:47to. If you're used to doing some relatively small
- 19:51-scale employment arbitrations, you're going
- 19:54to be looking at an order of magnitude of expense
- 19:57higher than that, and the business team needs
- 19:58to understand that. And the second thing, just
- 20:01a small detail on what Rebecca was saying that
- 20:05I found, is always be careful communicating with
- 20:10the business team. about if you're giving an
- 20:13exposure analysis versus a likely outcome analysis,
- 20:19because what I've found is that people can hear
- 20:21what they want to hear at the right times, and
- 20:24you're going to want to create a clear record
- 20:26on what you're actually saying. This is what
- 20:29you could face versus this is what I think you'll
- 20:32likely face. Absolutely. And that's where those
- 20:35disclaimers and assumptions become very critical
- 20:38and you really want to think it through. And
- 20:40then relatedly, and this is something that it's
- 20:42the discussion after sort of the workflow that
- 20:44Mandy talked about on the in -house council side,
- 20:47something that you're going to talk with outside
- 20:48council that's going to form that cost benefit
- 20:51analysis are intangible considerations, right?
- 20:55It's concern about any reputational risks associated
- 20:58with the litigation. If that's going to put in
- 21:01peril, customer relationships, competitive positioning.
- 21:04market perception, all of these can be very relevant
- 21:08and material considerations, especially depending
- 21:11on what the business is looking to do in the
- 21:13immediate term and in the long term as well.
- 21:18All right, but that's a lot of information. That's
- 21:21a lot of sort of tasks on the respective workflows,
- 21:23but it doesn't really do you much good. It's
- 21:26helpful information, but it doesn't do you much
- 21:27good if it's just all loose and floating about.
- 21:30So you... And so you need to sort of figure out
- 21:33a way to package that information and synthesize
- 21:37it in a way that it can be this sort of working,
- 21:40living, strategic document that is useful to
- 21:43you in the moment, but then also going forward.
- 21:45And so that's sort of the point one, is that
- 21:47strategic content, and that's sort of the workflows
- 21:50we talked about. But then the sort of two through
- 21:52four on this slide talk about the packaging.
- 21:55And you want it sort of in a useful format. You
- 21:57want it tailored to the audience. in a communication
- 22:01style. And I'll say it, I think Manny and I probably
- 22:04covered the spectrum of the way you deliver this
- 22:06information in a package and sort of. consolidate
- 22:09and package this information to the client so
- 22:11it's useful. You know, everything from a full
- 22:13-blown litigation memo with, you know, footnotes
- 22:16and case law citations to an email summary, a
- 22:20PowerPoint presentation, and a lot of it was
- 22:22informed by, is it going to just, is it going
- 22:25to reside with in -house counsel? Does in -house
- 22:27counsel then have to present that to the board
- 22:30or the C -suite sort of or, you know, and or
- 22:34is it something that Or is it just going to non
- 22:38-lawyers at the company or lawyers? And in some
- 22:42instances, it's not helpful if you present it
- 22:45in a 10 -page memo and the love language of the
- 22:49client is a PowerPoint. And sometimes it's a
- 22:52combination of this. But I think having that
- 22:54discussion then really allows you to walk away
- 22:57with and maximize the value of implementing these
- 23:00work streams. So this next slide, I won't spend
- 23:07a lot of time on, but this is a suggested way
- 23:11that you might structure your thought process
- 23:13around this if you're really sitting at the center
- 23:15of these pre -litigation decisions. What is our
- 23:20goal and how does that support the business's
- 23:23objectives? And essentially, you walk through,
- 23:26what are we going to need to do that? And do
- 23:28the benefits of litigating outweigh the risks?
- 23:32And then do we have off -ramps for settlement,
- 23:34and what's our best leverage there? This is an
- 23:38example, and you're free to use this when you're
- 23:42talking to your business teams. But if we go
- 23:45to the next slide, I did want to take a moment
- 23:49to talk about the fact that we are focusing this
- 23:53conversation on IP and IP disputes. And in a
- 23:57world where you might be seeking to enforce your
- 24:00IP, There are a few more precise and more specialized
- 24:06steps you're going to want to take well in advance
- 24:09of the litigation. So the first thing is making
- 24:15sure that your IP is readily identifiable and
- 24:18organized. If the origin of your dispute is that
- 24:21the business team has come to you and said, we
- 24:24see a competitor doing X, Do we have trademark
- 24:28protection that covers that or do we have patent
- 24:30protection that covers that? Well, I mean, the
- 24:34first step is do you know what protection you
- 24:37have and is it easily accessible to you? And
- 24:41if you haven't gotten that in a really strong
- 24:45form now, do that to start doing that today because
- 24:49once the question comes to you, it'll be too
- 24:51late. And then relatedly, do you know what are
- 24:55your strongest and weakest assets? So speaking
- 24:59now in terms of patents, which I deal with a
- 25:01lot, what are your strongest patents? And can
- 25:05you risk that patent in a litigation? If you're
- 25:07going to enforce the crown jewels against your
- 25:12competitor, well, what happens if you lose? And
- 25:14what are the implications of that? Conversely,
- 25:18do you know which of your assets are even strong
- 25:24enough to overcome a basic invalidity challenge.
- 25:27I mean, I do counseling on the patent procurement
- 25:30side. And look, it's much easier to get a patent
- 25:33than it is to know that you have something that's
- 25:37really useful. Make sure all your maintenance
- 25:42fees are paid up. Identify any inventorship or
- 25:46authorship issues. And again, this goes to that
- 25:48issue of inventors who have left or witnesses
- 25:53who have left, are you going to need to track
- 25:55down somebody and rely on them to get this case
- 25:58to stick? And if so, what is your relationship
- 26:01with that person? I'll get to litigation funding
- 26:05in a second. But when it comes to patents, one
- 26:09of the other really interesting issues is, do
- 26:12you have open families for continuation patents?
- 26:15And what that really means is this. depending
- 26:18on how you've structured your prosecution, you
- 26:22may be able to see something on the market today
- 26:25and recognize that as a variation on a patent
- 26:31that you already have. And you could, on one
- 26:35hand, you could try to enforce that more general
- 26:37patent against the thing that's on the market.
- 26:39But if you have open families for continuation,
- 26:43you could tailor a patent more specifically to
- 26:47the thing that you're seeing on the market and
- 26:49thereby help avoid some defenses that you're
- 26:52going to face. Now, the only way you can do that
- 26:53is if you have open applications. I won't get
- 26:57into the details of that today other than to
- 27:00say this relates back to a much larger, much
- 27:03more comprehensive IP strategy whereby your prosecution
- 27:08is marrying to what is eventually a litigation
- 27:11strategy. Before I get to litigation funding,
- 27:15I know Rebecca, you have some specific thoughts
- 27:17on trademark and copyright. Yeah, I think with
- 27:20these two, it's similar. You want to take accounting
- 27:23of sort of the implicated IP. And is it on the
- 27:26trademark side, because you can have common law
- 27:28rights in addition to registered rights. And
- 27:30they can be registered on the state level or
- 27:32the federal level. And the scope of protection
- 27:34associated with it, the classes of goods and
- 27:36services associated with it. On the copyright
- 27:39side, if you're thinking about asserting a copyright
- 27:41or sort of or works that of which copyrights
- 27:44are implicated by it. the copyright has to be
- 27:47registered. And that's sort of, you know, black
- 27:50-letter law is you have to have a registered
- 27:51copyright in order to assert it in litigation.
- 27:54But the timing of that registration in relation
- 27:57to infringement may limit the statutory damages
- 28:01and attorney's fees that might be available to
- 28:04you or as one sort of avenue of recovery if you're
- 28:06going to assert that copyright. And so once again,
- 28:09some of this, and I think it's true across the
- 28:11type of IP of trademark copyright and patent
- 28:14is timelines, right? And that's something you
- 28:17might do internally. It might be something that
- 28:19you have outside counsel do, but it's a timeline
- 28:21of sort of when, you know, when the works were
- 28:26derived or the marks were beginning to be used,
- 28:29when you started noticing infringement in the
- 28:32marketplace, or when you received notice of a
- 28:35potential dispute, that sort of thing, to sort
- 28:37of inform and understand any sort of... available
- 28:41or limitation, availability or limitations in
- 28:44terms of any sort of potential litigation that
- 28:46you're contemplating or you might be on the receiving
- 28:49end. And I think especially when it comes to
- 28:51copyright, making sure the sort of houses is
- 28:54in order is particularly important because chain
- 28:57of title for copyright is can be more complicated
- 29:00than I think people originally think is saying,
- 29:03you know, like, oh, it's a copyright art, like
- 29:05we are the named authors of it. Because with
- 29:08copyright, sometimes you're dealing with commission
- 29:10work, freelancers, agencies, production partners,
- 29:13and other contributors that might under the law
- 29:15be also perceived to be authors as well. And
- 29:18whether or not it's a work for hire, that sort
- 29:20of thing. So you really want that sort of chain
- 29:23of title and ownership to be well documented
- 29:26and understood before you go through the exercise
- 29:29of asserting it because that is a basis to challenge
- 29:33a copyright claim early on is that you actually
- 29:36sort of you're the asserting party. You're not
- 29:37actually the owner of the copyright or you don't
- 29:39own the rights and the ability to assert it in
- 29:42litigation. Yeah, that's exactly right, Rebecca.
- 29:46And so the last point I want to make on this
- 29:48is about litigation funding. And look, I do a
- 29:50lot of defense side work. where litigation funding
- 29:54is the bane of everybody's existence, and it's
- 29:57got a well -deserved reputation over the years
- 30:01as being problematic for a lot of different reasons.
- 30:05But I think that view is also a little narrow.
- 30:09and ignores that there is a lot of benefit to
- 30:12litigation funding and that it's become much
- 30:15more sophisticated and used by many more significant
- 30:20well -known companies as of late. Why? Because
- 30:23it's a way to share risk and control your cash
- 30:26flow, right? As I mentioned earlier, IP litigation
- 30:30is expensive and this could be a way to mitigate
- 30:34those risks. The other really noteworthy thing
- 30:39about considering litigation funding and IP disputes
- 30:42is your funder, the funding companies, will do
- 30:47extensive diligence into your IP before agreeing
- 30:52to fund your assertion. So it's a second set
- 30:54of eyes. And often the funding might be for something
- 30:58like getting continuation patents. And at minimum,
- 31:04it can allow you to proceed to litigation with
- 31:07that much more comfort that what you're asserting
- 31:11is a robust asset. That takes us through when
- 31:16a dispute has been identified, but not necessarily
- 31:18when it's filed. So sometimes this happens simultaneously,
- 31:21right? You find out, or really quickly in time,
- 31:23you find out there's a dispute or you have a
- 31:26dispute with a third party and then you're filing
- 31:28within a week or two. And sometimes there's a
- 31:30bit of time in between of when a dispute's been
- 31:32identified and when it's being filed. But this
- 31:35next section, we're really gonna... focus on
- 31:38sort of a dispute is imminent and then also those
- 31:42early stages that first hundred days of litigation
- 31:45and that's typically sort of gets you into the
- 31:47you're certainly in the pleading stage you might
- 31:49be already into discovery at the end of those
- 31:51100 days after a case has been filed. All right,
- 31:55so first up is pre -suit demands and cease and
- 31:58desist. So you're probably familiar with this
- 32:00term. Pre -suit demands oftentimes come in the
- 32:04format or are delivered via a cease and desist
- 32:07letter. And there's a lot of considerations as
- 32:09to whether or not to go about making a pre -suit
- 32:12demand and also responding to a pre -suit demand
- 32:15or a cease and desist letter. So on that first
- 32:17piece, on deciding whether or not to make a pre
- 32:21-suit demand, a lot of this is tied to the if
- 32:26it opens up an avenue for early resolution, right?
- 32:28So if you're reaching out to a third party saying,
- 32:31hey, I think you're infringing our IP and of
- 32:35course it's that friendly, then in that sort
- 32:38of instance, right? That might then invite a
- 32:42discussion as to sort of the dispute and the
- 32:46issues and maybe there becomes an opportunity
- 32:48to sort of resolve the dispute before you actually
- 32:50even have to file the case. It also can help
- 32:53with your damages, right? Because by nature,
- 32:55of sending that cease and desist letter, you're
- 32:57putting a third party on notice of potential
- 33:00claims of infringement, which then for a damages
- 33:03case, sometimes the courts are looking for at
- 33:06sort of when you had notice of, when a party
- 33:08had notice of infringement and whether they continue
- 33:11to infringe thereafter. And that sort of becomes
- 33:14a material part of the damages period. And then
- 33:18also whether or not willfulness and intentional
- 33:21infringement and the associated monetary sort
- 33:25of rewards that are associated with that finding
- 33:27become available. Now on the other side of making
- 33:31a pre -suit demand, depending on how it's formatted
- 33:34and what's stated it, it might actually give
- 33:36the receiving party a basis to race to the courthouse
- 33:40and file an affirmative defensive litigation
- 33:43or sort of preempt the litigation and assert
- 33:47sort of a defensive claim and it's called a declaratory
- 33:50judgment claim. Asking the court to judge that
- 33:53there is not been infringement that there's not
- 33:56sort of misuse of a trademark or of a copyright
- 33:59non infringement of the patent. And so a lot
- 34:02of that to sort of avoid that risk a lot of it
- 34:05kind of comes or to sort of be aware of that
- 34:07risk is important because that directly informs.
- 34:12how you phrase the letter and how strongly it
- 34:15is worded. I think there's a lot of sort of balancing
- 34:18considerations and pros and cons in terms of
- 34:22sending out a letter and not. I think a lot of
- 34:24times I find clients interested in that option
- 34:26in terms of reaching out to a third party and
- 34:29hopes that maybe it does resolve the dispute
- 34:31before they actually have to file. But a very,
- 34:34very helpful discussion I think always in that
- 34:36is setting an expectations on the timing, right?
- 34:39So in the letter itself, definitely want there
- 34:42in the letter to say, you know, we need to hear
- 34:43back from you by X date. But part of the discussion
- 34:47that you need to have with the client and what
- 34:49clients should be having with outside counsel
- 34:50is not only when do we expect to hear back. from
- 34:53the third party, but also when do we expect them
- 34:56to cure these defects, right? And also setting
- 34:59a timeline in terms of the expectation in the
- 35:01letter itself, but then also an expectation on
- 35:03the back end saying, well, if we don't hear back,
- 35:06what are our next steps? Are we just gonna go
- 35:08ahead and file or are we gonna try to reach out
- 35:10to them again? Or if we hear back from them,
- 35:13but it seems like they're not really sort of
- 35:15fixing it and they're just buying time, do we
- 35:16just move forward with filing? And sort of having
- 35:19that discussion as to expectations on timing
- 35:22and the next, after that, if those expectations
- 35:24are not realized, is very critical and important.
- 35:29And it seems intuitive in theory, but in practice
- 35:32can really help then sort of get everybody oriented
- 35:35on the next steps. And one nuance on this that's
- 35:40really, I think, more present in patent litigation
- 35:43than some other kinds of IP litigation is how
- 35:47this all relates to the venue question. Because,
- 35:51you know, when Rebecca mentioned that one of
- 35:54the risks of making a pre -suit demand is that
- 35:56you might run into a declaratory judgment. In
- 35:59the patent space, at least, whoever files first
- 36:03is going to generally control the venue. And
- 36:05there are certain venues that defendants want
- 36:09to avoid and that plaintiffs want to be in. And
- 36:12if you are creating an opportunity for a potential
- 36:15defendant to take the case to a defendant -friendly
- 36:19venue, well, That's something you need to consider
- 36:22before you make your demand. And then, Manny,
- 36:29you want to cover the thoughts and considerations
- 36:32on responding to a cease and desist? Oh, sorry.
- 36:34Yeah. So there, again, you need to analyze it
- 36:38and think through how you want to address it.
- 36:43I think there's a strategic choice you're going
- 36:47to want to make about how robust you want to
- 36:49make your response. The more you say, it may
- 36:54feel good to say it. It may feel like in your
- 36:59mind, like you're really scoring points. But
- 37:02in my experience, I tend to think less is more
- 37:06when it comes to these responses, unless you
- 37:08have something truly game changing. For instance,
- 37:11they've accused a product that you never sold.
- 37:13or they accused a product that predates their
- 37:17patent. But unless you've got something black
- 37:19or white, most times you're going to want to
- 37:23keep that response straightforward, simple, minimalistic,
- 37:32and focusing on things that might actually move
- 37:34the discussion forward. And to the end, these
- 37:38are really streamlined and intentional about
- 37:41what is put in them and both the affirmative
- 37:43sort of outreach and then the response, because
- 37:45this becomes part of the record. This is not
- 37:47a pleading in and of itself, but this is very,
- 37:49this might be exhibit one, right? And this is
- 37:52something that is referenced back to, it serves
- 37:54as a basis and a reference point for discovery
- 37:59and that sort of thing. So as a result, these
- 38:00are sort of very, although they might be very
- 38:02streamlined and simplified in terms of the verbiage,
- 38:06it's very, informed and needs to be substantiated
- 38:08in terms of what's said on either side. And to
- 38:11that point, a misconception about these can be
- 38:14that they are inadmissible under 408 always,
- 38:17or that they're confidential. They are not necessarily
- 38:23confidential or inadmissible, depending on what's
- 38:26in there. To the contrary, in a patent world,
- 38:30one of the substantive elements of an indirect
- 38:32infringement claim is that the defendant needed
- 38:35to be needed to know of the patent. Well, this
- 38:40letter and this correspondence might be the best
- 38:43evidence of whether a defendant knew or did not
- 38:46know of the patent. So as you're doing this,
- 38:49do not assume that this back and forth is necessarily
- 38:54going to be outside of the record. One of the
- 39:03other major considerations early in the case
- 39:05is whether or not there's going to be a preliminary
- 39:07injunction. And I think the availability of injunctions
- 39:13and how often they're pursued varies by IP class.
- 39:17In the patent world, they're relatively rarely
- 39:20sought and relatively rarely obtained, especially
- 39:26in non -practicing entity or what we used to
- 39:30call them patent troll cases. Under the Supreme
- 39:33Court's eBay decision, what that effectively
- 39:37held is that the four traditional elements of
- 39:40getting an injunction apply even in the patent
- 39:45space. There used to be a thought out there that
- 39:48a patent right is a right to exclude. And therefore,
- 39:54preliminary injunctions should be granted liberally,
- 39:57if not routinely. But the eBay decision really
- 40:01changed that and said, no, you have to prove
- 40:04that you're entitled to an injunction and that
- 40:07the equities favor an injunction, that there's
- 40:09no, that legal damages won't satisfy you, et
- 40:12cetera. One thing that's really interesting in
- 40:15the patent space lately, and especially in what
- 40:19we call standard essential patents. So those
- 40:21are patents that allow major technologies to
- 40:25work interoperably with each other. These disputes
- 40:29are becoming much more global, and there are
- 40:34jurisdictions in the world where preliminary
- 40:37injunctions are much easier to get. And that's
- 40:41one of the reasons we're seeing patent litigation
- 40:44take on a global flair, and especially with a
- 40:48focus on Europe and countries like Brazil, where
- 40:53where the culture of the jurisprudence is still
- 40:56very much in favor of granting these injunctions
- 40:59and that there's not the same need to show all
- 41:01of the eBay factors. And then on the, as this
- 41:06slide says, soft IP, some people take offense
- 41:08to that term. No offense is intended by it. But
- 41:12when we're talking about trademark or copyright
- 41:14cases or trade secret, for example, or right
- 41:17publicity cases, a lot of times the analysis
- 41:20about whether or not to go the PI route comes
- 41:23down to the immediacy of the dispute and the
- 41:26scope of the dispute. So are we talking about
- 41:29a new product that's being launched, an advertising
- 41:32campaign that's going out? that a new show that
- 41:35has just aired or that sort of thing that sort
- 41:39of in which the IP is implicated, where once
- 41:42the sort of cat's out of the bag, right, then
- 41:44all of a sudden, a lot of the sort of value associated
- 41:47with it is lost. And so you really wanna get
- 41:51ahead of it and preempt it. And that is oftentimes,
- 41:54and it's not only it sort of directly. relates
- 41:56to the elements of a PI case and whether or not
- 41:59you actually have a viable PI case. But as a
- 42:02practical consideration, that's sort of the thing
- 42:04that we're thinking about with clients and talking
- 42:08through is, so why does this have to be adjudicated
- 42:12now on the merits? Because that's effectively
- 42:14what a PI is. It's this likelihood of success.
- 42:18on the merits of a case before the case has actually
- 42:21got underway, right? So a court's going to be
- 42:23looking at that, like, why does this make this
- 42:25case different? What's the pressing need as opposed
- 42:28to just going through the ordinary course of
- 42:30litigation? And the pressing need is not like
- 42:33it would cost us less, it's some money upfront,
- 42:35but, you know, sort of a case getting resolved
- 42:37via a PI in six months is less expensive than,
- 42:41you know, two years of litigation. That's not
- 42:44the pressing need to the court. You're going
- 42:46to have some sort of extenuating circumstance,
- 42:49something additional that's happening in the
- 42:50marketplace that requires this expediency. All
- 42:58right. So another part of the first 100 days
- 43:01of a case in this sort of early litigation is
- 43:05challenges to the pleadings and challenges to
- 43:09the claims. So one of the ways that this can
- 43:11happen is a motion to dismiss. And so that is
- 43:14where you're challenging the lawsuit itself or
- 43:17the claims that have been asserted in it. And
- 43:19it can come in a lot of different forms. It can
- 43:21be because the The claims are insufficiently
- 43:23pled. They're not plausible. Standing issues,
- 43:27venue, jurisdiction for the patent side on the
- 43:30patent side and eligibility. Motions to dismiss
- 43:33have to be brought within a certain period of
- 43:36time of the complaint being filed. Sometimes
- 43:37you can get some extensions on that. And then
- 43:40some of the arguments and the issues being raised
- 43:44in a motion dismiss. that you'd raise via motion
- 43:46dismiss must be raised in the response to the
- 43:50complaint. Otherwise, they're waived. You might
- 43:52be able to re raise those issues subsequently,
- 43:55similar issues subsequently in the case, but
- 43:57that's not going to come until potentially summary
- 43:59judgment. So you really sort of this evaluation
- 44:02as to whether or not claims are susceptible or
- 44:05the litigation is susceptible to a motion to
- 44:07dismiss has to be sort of evaluated on the front
- 44:10end as either sort of are we going to answer
- 44:12the complaint or are we going to sort of challenge
- 44:14the complaint? via this motion to dismiss. On
- 44:18the sort of across IP, the pleading threshold
- 44:22is lower. So it's not that you have, you obviously
- 44:24don't have to prove the case at the pleading
- 44:26stage. You don't have discovery yet. So the plausibility
- 44:29threshold is pretty low. And so a lot of times
- 44:33when we're sort of looking at whether or not
- 44:34the claims are susceptible to a challenge via
- 44:37motion to dismiss is we're looking at sort of
- 44:39issues with fundamental issues with like black
- 44:42letter law. completely fail to allege a element
- 44:46of the claim. Is there a standing issue? For
- 44:49some reason, this party doesn't sort of appear
- 44:52in this jurisdiction. They're not in this venue,
- 44:54right? This court does not have jurisdiction
- 44:56over the defendants. They have no presence in
- 44:59this area. And some of the things that we talked
- 45:01about earlier about sort of making sure your
- 45:03IP is in order before you're asserting it. Like
- 45:06the plaintiff, to assert a copyright claim, you
- 45:08have to own the copyright. There has to be a
- 45:10registered copyright. on the trademark side,
- 45:13if it's not alleged in the complaint that there's
- 45:15a likelihood of confusion, that's a fundamental
- 45:18flaw because that's a required element of a trademark
- 45:20infringement case. And that's different than
- 45:23saying, well, you know, they've only identified
- 45:26one instance of confusion or that sort of thing.
- 45:30you know, if that's the issue, right? If that's
- 45:33the flaw that you've identified in the complaint,
- 45:35that might, that gets a little bit more into
- 45:36the facts and that makes it really easy for the
- 45:38court to kick it and say, this is just a factual
- 45:40dispute. This is something that I'll deal with
- 45:42down the road as summary judgment. Yeah, one
- 45:48other emotion dismissed point I would make that's
- 45:50unique to patents that can be achieved on emotion
- 45:53dismissed is a concept of ineligibility. based
- 45:56on some case law that came out of the Supreme
- 45:59Court a little over 10 years ago, if a patent
- 46:05that's asserted against you claims ineligible
- 46:08subject matter, and I won't get too in the weeds,
- 46:11but the most obvious example is abstract subject
- 46:14matter, which... which by itself is a question
- 46:17what that means, but that is an area where you
- 46:21can win on a motion to dismiss primarily because
- 46:23the case laws developed that you can get an ineligibility
- 46:26finding based on comparison to other patents
- 46:29that have been found ineligible in other cases.
- 46:31So you can basically argue by analogy and win
- 46:34a motion to dismiss. When it comes to patents,
- 46:38at least, the other thing to consider early on
- 46:41is PTAB proceedings. One of the common defenses
- 46:47to patent infringement is to assert invalidity,
- 46:52that the patent being asserted against you should
- 46:54never be granted most often because it was already
- 46:57invented or was obvious in view of what had already
- 47:00been invented in what we call the prior art.
- 47:05There are two paths. So you could challenge that
- 47:08in district court or You could go back to the
- 47:12to the baton office and raise that certain forms
- 47:15of that infinity challenge in in the patent office
- 47:19up until about a year ago year and a half ago.
- 47:24The most favored way to do this was what we called
- 47:26IPRs or Interparties Reviews. This was essentially
- 47:30an administrative proceeding created in the America
- 47:34Invents Act that allowed somebody who'd been
- 47:37accused of infringement to go back to the PTAB,
- 47:41to the patent office, show prior art, make arguments,
- 47:46and argue in this alternative forum why the patent
- 47:51never should have been granted. Statistically,
- 47:55at least, the success rate was very high, especially
- 47:58in certain fields like software. At one point,
- 48:0370 % of instituted IPRs were resulting in invalidations.
- 48:10Recently, that has changed primarily because
- 48:13of a different set of views on intellectual property
- 48:17and a different set of priorities from the federal
- 48:20government. which has made inter -parties review
- 48:24much, much, much, much, much more difficult to
- 48:28get instituted and to win. There's a second process
- 48:32called ex -party review, which basically is a
- 48:37little different. First of all, it's slower.
- 48:41In an ex -party review, one of the things that
- 48:43distinguishes it from inter -parties review is
- 48:46that it's not really the same kind of quasi -litigation
- 48:49forum. Really what you're doing is just submitting
- 48:51some prior art to the patent office and allowing
- 48:54the examiner to make his own or her own decision
- 48:57based on that. So one of the risks of ex -party
- 49:00review is you can lose control over the argument
- 49:03and end up seeing that the patent office essentially
- 49:09affirm the strength of the patent that you were
- 49:11trying to invalidate and have it really backfile.
- 49:16A couple other small notes on this to always
- 49:18be aware of. One is just because you filed or
- 49:24even had instituted an IPR or an ex -party review,
- 49:27it does not mean that your litigation cases stayed.
- 49:31And frankly, there are judges who will not, in
- 49:35most cases, stay the district court case in view
- 49:39of what's happening at the patent office. So
- 49:40it really is a parallel proceeding and can mean
- 49:43significantly more expense. The other thing to
- 49:48realize that if you do raise, get an instituted
- 49:51IPR, you will be forfeiting the right to raise
- 49:55certain defenses that you raised or could have
- 49:57raised in the IPR. The priority that you've,
- 49:59what you, The prior art that you argued about
- 50:02in the IPR or could have argued about in the
- 50:04IPR, you could be restricted from arguing the
- 50:06same prior art in district courts. You're going
- 50:08to get one bite at the apple. So that's a lot
- 50:18of opportunities to challenge and to sort of
- 50:21dictate the scope of the dispute early on in
- 50:23the case in those first hundred days. And that's
- 50:25all sort of with the idea that it's been mapped
- 50:28out before you're engaging in it, all with the
- 50:31idea that maybe you're sort of better positioned
- 50:33or more well positioned going into early settlement
- 50:36exploration. So the opportunities, and there's
- 50:38multiple opportunities, not only just sort of
- 50:41picking up the phone and reaching out to opposing
- 50:43council, but more formal opportunities to encourage
- 50:46and push this early exploration of whether or
- 50:49not early settlement is possible or feasible.
- 50:52One of those is ADRs, this is alternative dispute
- 50:55resolution. and I think nearly all of the jurisdictions
- 50:58in their rules talk about encouraging the parties
- 51:02to engage in in settlement discussions. Now some
- 51:06jurisdictions have a very, very formal process
- 51:09and some just encourage it in the rules and you
- 51:11have to sort of attest that the parties are exploring
- 51:14it. Some jurisdictions require it. So you have
- 51:17something as some, you have either mediation
- 51:19or arbitration, parties can opt into it or they
- 51:22have a required early neutral evaluation and
- 51:24E &E process. And that's sometimes with a magistrate
- 51:28judge. Sometimes it's a magistrate judge that
- 51:30will be presiding over your discovery disputes.
- 51:33So, you know, but they're a party that's gonna
- 51:35get very well acquainted with your case. So it's
- 51:37sort of an early opportunity to get before them.
- 51:39The thing that's nice about ADR options is one
- 51:43of the things is if you opt in to sort of the
- 51:45court provided ones, it can minimize the costs
- 51:48associated with it. You're still gonna have to
- 51:50sort of pay for the attorney's costs, but you're
- 51:52not paying for a mediator necessarily or the
- 51:54early neutral evaluator. It can be beneficial,
- 51:59right? It can have the parties, you get a lot
- 52:01of... more transparency as to like what the critical
- 52:03issues are for the other side, it can also cause
- 52:06the parties become more further entrenched and
- 52:08further distant. So it's definitely something
- 52:10to, it's a sort of a strategic discussion. You
- 52:13have to sort of represent to the court that you
- 52:16are exploring it, right? But which avenue you
- 52:19choose and what's most sort of cost effective
- 52:21and viable is more as sort of specific to your
- 52:24case. Another sort of Avenue that's available
- 52:27is a rule 68 offer. So this is a formal settlement
- 52:31offer that allows judgment to be entered against
- 52:33the offering party, the defendant on on specific
- 52:37terms. But if it's rejected that and the and
- 52:41the plaintiff ultimately does worse than what
- 52:43the sort of the offer was, then that might result
- 52:46in the plaintiff bearing certain post offer costs
- 52:49and sometimes it stops the accrual of attorney's
- 52:52fees that the defendant could be on the hook.
- 52:54for after the offer was made. Now, these are
- 52:57very sort of a strategic consideration to be
- 53:00made, but it often, it's sort of a, when it comes
- 53:03across the table and you receive something like
- 53:06this, it really forces a discussion as to how
- 53:08this sort of changes that risk benefit analysis
- 53:11that ideally you've already sort of engaged in
- 53:13that discussion with your client. But the only
- 53:20thing I would also add when it comes to this
- 53:22is, This goes back to something I said earlier.
- 53:26Make sure you understand at all times when you're
- 53:29having a confidential discussion, when you're
- 53:31having a rule 408 discussion. Because, again,
- 53:35you may find later in the case that the other
- 53:38side doesn't have the same view as you did on
- 53:41this. Yeah. I wanna make sure that we get to
- 53:46our practical example. So I'm not gonna go through
- 53:48this slide, but this is sort of just key principles
- 53:50that sort of overlay the things that we've talked
- 53:54about in section one and section two. And I think
- 53:58what we're sort of trying to underline here is
- 54:00that these early stages of identification of
- 54:04a dispute and of the litigation itself reward
- 54:07preparation not in... And if you sort of work
- 54:13through and spend a little bit more time on the
- 54:15upfront, creating that clear strategic plan,
- 54:18it's a lot easier than to pivot or recalibrate
- 54:22because you know what you're moving from and
- 54:24then the discussion and the focus is then on
- 54:27what you're moving towards. But you've already
- 54:29gotten everybody oriented. What you don't want
- 54:31to be in a situation of is sort of a whack -a
- 54:33-mole situation in those early stages. Then all
- 54:37of a sudden, you're into discovery. And then
- 54:40the discussion comes through. It's like, OK,
- 54:42what is this actually going to cost us? What
- 54:44does this actually look at? What are we actually
- 54:47at risk for in this case? Having those discussions
- 54:49early on mean that you're not then having that
- 54:52discussion. And the case has been underway for
- 54:53eight months or so. All right, so practical impacts
- 54:58and case studies. And so the first thing is talking
- 55:01about how early application of these strategies
- 55:04really did improve, substantially materially
- 55:07improve the outcome. And one of the first examples
- 55:11was sort of, it harps on some of the things I
- 55:13talked about earlier, but. had a sort of, in
- 55:17a few matters have had this sort of very informed
- 55:20initial case assessment that was presented in
- 55:22an informal way, but it was informed by the nature
- 55:25of the claims asserted, the risk associated with
- 55:28it, talking with the client about some of the
- 55:32business objectives that they had in terms of
- 55:34the business. In some instances, you know, they're
- 55:37looking to sort of sell or exit within, you know,
- 55:40a two year span. And so want to get the case
- 55:43as sort of as small as possible, but then also
- 55:47have as little burden on the company as possible
- 55:52too, because they were focused on these sort
- 55:53of broader business initiatives. And then sort
- 55:57of paired with and doing this sort of analysis
- 56:00as to the liability of all the claims, you know,
- 56:02if we didn't sort of worst case scenario, right,
- 56:06if all the sort of there was liability found
- 56:08on all the claims and then sort of attorney's
- 56:10fees that would cost to get us there. And then
- 56:14looking at the sort of the claims themselves
- 56:16and realizing that some of them are very viable
- 56:18for attack early on, meant that the case got,
- 56:23the client could make an informed decision and
- 56:24say, you know what, this is actually really worth
- 56:26that, sort of spending that money upfront, getting
- 56:28the case substantially narrowed, it was narrowed,
- 56:31it better place the client for those early settlement
- 56:33discussions. And although that took time, and
- 56:36it was over sort of the motion practice is not
- 56:38immediate, right? And you have to wait courts
- 56:40are backed up in terms of when we got the orders
- 56:42and that sort of thing. It then meant that the
- 56:45whole period of time might've taken about a year,
- 56:47a little bit longer than that. But at the end
- 56:49of that year period of time, the case was substantially
- 56:51diminished. It well positioned it for settlement.
- 56:54And all of that happened before the business
- 56:56broader objectives in terms of that exit. And
- 56:59as a result, although everyone would prefer not
- 57:01to have to. get into litigation in the first
- 57:03instance, it was sort of the best case scenario
- 57:06in light of the circumstances. Yeah, and I just
- 57:11want to add a situation I had about this commitment
- 57:13to aggressively litigate and often, especially
- 57:18in I think younger companies or companies that
- 57:21are not as experienced with IP litigation. There
- 57:25is a skepticism about it and there is a belief
- 57:28that, well, there has to be a negotiated solution
- 57:31to any problem. And I had a case a few years
- 57:33ago where a competitor sued my client and was
- 57:39saying, we are going to file a preliminary injunction
- 57:41to get your product off the market. And there
- 57:44was this period of disbelief where the client
- 57:47refused to accept that that was the situation
- 57:51it was in. And it took a lot of work with the
- 57:54business team to understand, no, these are the
- 57:55stakes. And what was important about that is
- 57:58we then got buy -in to litigate this case to
- 58:04the hilt. And we ended up winning and invalidating
- 58:06all of the patents. But that would not have happened
- 58:08had there not been this communication upfront.
- 58:11And just real quick on the change of business
- 58:12strategy, when it comes to patents specifically,
- 58:15you're always going to want to look into, hey,
- 58:17can we sidestep this whole dispute? by making
- 58:20a small change to our product that undeniably
- 58:24gets us outside of the scope of any of these
- 58:26patents. And then also there are lessons learned
- 58:31from when the strategies were not implemented
- 58:33early on. And so there's been instances where,
- 58:36you know, matters have come over to us because
- 58:38the original firm that came on, you know, identified
- 58:42very legally viable arguments and challenges
- 58:45at the early stage, but didn't go through the
- 58:47discussion with the business and with the in
- 58:50-house team about what that looked like as a
- 58:51practical matter. So they opted to sort of challenge
- 58:53venue and jurisdiction at that very early stage.
- 58:57But as a practical matter, If you do so, that's
- 59:00a lot of motion practice to start with. And also
- 59:02sometimes the court will allow then the plaintiff
- 59:05to engage in jurisdictional discovery, which
- 59:09is effectively one way discovery of the defendant
- 59:11to figure out their contacts in that venue. And
- 59:14part of that analysis, not only where the business
- 59:17is present and whatnot, but it might be in terms
- 59:19of their activities in that jurisdiction and
- 59:22activities related to the claims of infringement.
- 59:26And as a result, and then there's a lot of dispute.
- 59:28over the proper scope of discovery. So all of
- 59:30a sudden you're... engaged in one way discovery,
- 59:32it's very expensive. There's all these discovery
- 59:35disputes and the case is not actually even proceeded
- 59:38into discovery. So the defendant is not getting
- 59:40options to serve discovery on the plaintiff and
- 59:42it's very, very expensive and there's not much
- 59:44to show for it, right? Because the case hasn't
- 59:46moved along, the case hasn't been narrowed in
- 59:49scope. And so, I mean, nothing makes the business
- 59:52less happy than seeing substantial attorney's
- 59:55fees with very little work product or sort of
- 59:57case development to show for it. And as a result,
- 1:00:00it caused the sort of irreconcilable rift and
- 1:00:03then they were shopping for new council. And
- 1:00:05so, but that would have been avoided had they
- 1:00:08gone through that sort of dual track and an analysis
- 1:00:10as to sort of legally viable options and attacks,
- 1:00:14but then also what that looks like for the business
- 1:00:16and the burden on the business to sort of opt
- 1:00:18for that strategy or maybe offer a different
- 1:00:21one, right? And ultimately end up in a better
- 1:00:24place. So the last point I'll make, because I
- 1:00:27know we're just out of time, is on this idea
- 1:00:29of rushing without assessing risk and value.
- 1:00:31As I mentioned, IP disputes can be weirdly emotionally
- 1:00:35charged. You've got inventors who put their life
- 1:00:38into inventing something, including on the defense
- 1:00:39side. I invented this product. I had no idea
- 1:00:42about some other patent that was out there. And
- 1:00:44I want to fight and prove. that I invented something
- 1:00:48myself and same thing with authorship, right?
- 1:00:51This is my pride and joy and I need to enforce
- 1:00:55it because I put my soul into it. And we as attorneys
- 1:01:01need to consider that, but we need to constantly
- 1:01:04be looking at objective factors such as how much
- 1:01:07is it going to cost and what is the benefit you
- 1:01:10could achieve here? Because at that initial stage,
- 1:01:13there's going to be Potentially momentum for
- 1:01:16fighting fighting fighting, but the client needs
- 1:01:19to understand what that looks like six months
- 1:01:21from now when maybe the the emotion is worn off
- 1:01:24and now you're in a case where you're spending
- 1:01:27a lot of money and the only way out is either
- 1:01:30to to to leave that as a sunk cost or keep going
- 1:01:34deeper not because you have a bad case not because
- 1:01:37anybody's doing a bad job, but because the priorities
- 1:01:40as they felt like on day one. didn't match the
- 1:01:44priorities as they were on six months in or a
- 1:01:47year in or 18 months in. And that's why that
- 1:01:50recalibration is so important. Sort of orienting
- 1:01:52at the beginning and then being able to recalibrate
- 1:01:55and pivot and then being able to sort of understand
- 1:01:57where you're moving towards helps everybody sort
- 1:01:59of be in a, it helps that sort of pivot be a
- 1:02:03lot easier and a lot less friction because you've
- 1:02:06sort of aligned up to that date. So I think on
- 1:02:10that. And so this is just sort of an overview
- 1:02:13of everything that we talked about, some helpful
- 1:02:14graphics accordingly. And I just checked, I don't
- 1:02:18think that there were any sort of open questions
- 1:02:19that we were able to sort of cover in the content
- 1:02:22that we talked about to date, unless I'm missing
- 1:02:25something. So I - We do have one question, which
- 1:02:28I'll try to address quickly. The question is,
- 1:02:31when asserting trade secrets, they can presumably
- 1:02:34be protected in court proceedings. What risks,
- 1:02:37if any, are there that can result? in losing
- 1:02:40trade secret protection in litigation. One of
- 1:02:44the concerns there is waiver or loss of the trade
- 1:02:49seeker. One of the elements you have to prove
- 1:02:52to win a trade secret case is that you've taken
- 1:02:55reasonable steps to maintain the secrecy of a
- 1:02:58trade secret. And part of that factor could be
- 1:03:01what one of the considerations that can go into
- 1:03:02that decision is, well, if you've allowed other
- 1:03:05people to to use your trade secret without repercussion
- 1:03:13and you've done that on multiple occasions. Well,
- 1:03:15is it even a trade secret anymore? Have you signaled
- 1:03:18to the world that they're free to use this without
- 1:03:21repercussions? And you can expect then that could
- 1:03:24be used against you if you subsequently try to
- 1:03:28enforce that trade secret against somebody else.
- 1:03:30I'm able to say, Mary was able to do it. Why
- 1:03:33shouldn't I be able to do it? Yeah, and you can
- 1:03:36you know the risk is also and related to that
- 1:03:38the risk can be that you get a judgment or court
- 1:03:40saying on the record saying what you're saying
- 1:03:43our trade secrets are not trade secrets that
- 1:03:45are not being maintained as trade secrets and
- 1:03:47that can have a lot of implications on the business
- 1:03:48side because in all your outward -facing sort
- 1:03:51of statements and for investors or whatever it
- 1:03:53may be for the market you say you have this proprietary
- 1:03:56technology these proprietary processes, but now
- 1:03:59you have a public document that says well at
- 1:04:02least some of this is not trade secret and if
- 1:04:05it's not being protected in another avenue, right?
- 1:04:08All of a sudden that can have major implications
- 1:04:10for sort of those business objectives as well.
- 1:04:13So it's definitely something, and that's where
- 1:04:15you sort of are talking through with your outside
- 1:04:17counsel, what's the worst possible scenario here
- 1:04:19and what does that look like? And are there steps
- 1:04:22to take that we could take to mitigate or sort
- 1:04:24of sidestep or minimize that risk associated
- 1:04:27with something that's valuable, be it trade secret,
- 1:04:29another form of IP? All right, well, on that
- 1:04:33note, we really appreciate everyone taking the
- 1:04:35time to spend the hour with us. If you have any
- 1:04:37further questions, feel free to reach out. Our
- 1:04:39contact information is on the slide. And thank
- 1:04:43you to BHBA for having us. Yes, thank you very
- 1:04:46much.