Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Raise When You Were Hired at the Top of the Band
Transcript
- Lucas: So, you were hired at the top of your salary band. The offer was strong — maybe even above market. But now, a year later, you want more. And you're pretty sure there's no room to move. That's a genuinely awkward place to be. Luna: Yeah, and the classic advice — 'just ask for a raise' — kind of falls apart when the band has a ceiling. What do you do then? Lucas: Right. And before we get into it, quick thing. This show is ad-free because of listeners like you. If the conversations here have helped you think through a career move or a tough decision, and you want to keep it that way, the link is buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure, just that. Luna: Yeah, every little bit helps us keep the lights on without selling your attention. Lucas: Exactly. Okay, back to it. So the first thing to understand is what a salary band actually is. It's the minimum, midpoint, and maximum a company is willing to pay for a role. The top of the band is usually reserved for someone who comes in with rare expertise or who's expected to perform at a high level from day one. Luna: So if you're at the top, the company sees you as already at the ceiling. They might feel like there's no financial room to reward you further. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the trap. Last month I was talking to a product manager at a mid-sized tech firm — let's call her Priya. She was hired at the top of her band about eighteen months ago, and she's been killing it. Consistently strong reviews, led a major feature launch, even got a shout-out in the all-hands. But when she asked for a raise, her manager literally said, 'You're at the top of your band. There's nothing I can do.' Luna: Ouch. That's a dead end, right? Lucas: It sounds like one, but it's not. Because the band is a constraint on the role, not on the person. When you hit the ceiling, the real conversation shifts from 'raise' to 'restructure.' That's the key move. Luna: Restructure. You mean changing the role itself? Lucas: Yes. You're not asking for more money for the same job. You're asking for a different job that happens to pay more. That could be a title change, a broader mandate, or moving into a new role with a higher band. Luna: So instead of saying 'I want a raise,' you say 'I want to take on more responsibility, and that should come with a new title and a new band.' Lucas: Exactly. And that's a much easier conversation for a manager to say yes to, because it solves their problem too. They get more from you, and they can justify a new budget line. The worst thing you can do is just keep banging on the band ceiling. Luna: But what if the manager isn't open to changing the role? That's a real risk. Lucas: It is. But that's why you need to do the groundwork first. Let me walk through the three steps I gave Priya. Step one: document the gap between what you were hired to do and what you're actually doing now. If you're doing work that's clearly above your title, that's your evidence. Luna: So she needed to show that she's already operating at the next level. Lucas: Right. Priya had been taking on mentoring, owning strategy, even covering for her boss when she was out. But she'd never framed it as 'this is a different role.' Once she did, it changed the conversation. Luna: And step two? Lucas: Step two is research. You need to know what that next-level role pays in the market, not just within your company. If you can show that a senior product manager with your scope typically earns fifteen percent more, you're not asking for a favor — you're pointing out a market inefficiency. Luna: That's a good framing. It's not personal, it's just data. Lucas: Exactly. And step three is the most subtle: you need to make the case that your company risks losing you if they can't find a way to move you up. But you have to do that without making threats. It's about showing your value and your intent, not issuing ultimatums. Luna: So how did Priya actually play it in the meeting? Lucas: She went in with a one-page summary. She listed her responsibilities from her original job description, then a second list of what she actually does now. There was a lot of overlap, but the second list had things like 'owns the quarterly roadmap' and 'manages two junior analysts.' Her manager hadn't really noticed until she put it side by side. Luna: And then she proposed a title change? Lucas: She proposed 'Senior Product Manager' — which was the next step anyway — and she had market data showing the band for that role was ten to fifteen percent higher. She didn't ask for a specific number; she asked for a re-leveling based on the work. Luna: So the manager could either say yes to the re-leveling, or no — but the no would be awkward because the data was right there. Lucas: Exactly. And in Priya's case, the manager said, 'I can't do that right now, but let me talk to HR.' And two weeks later, they came back with a new title and an eight percent bump. Not the full fifteen, but it broke the ceiling. Luna: So even a partial win can be a win. But what if the manager just says no, flat out? Lucas: Then you have to decide whether to stay or go. And that's a legitimate decision. If the company is unwilling to look at your role honestly, that's information. But before you jump ship, there are other levers besides base salary. Luna: Like bonus or equity. Lucas: Right. A lot of people get stuck on the base salary number, but total compensation includes bonus potential, equity grants, even perks like extra vacation or flexible hours. If the band is truly fixed, you might negotiate a higher bonus percentage or a one-time retention grant. That gets you to a similar place without changing the band. Luna: And that's often easier for HR to approve than a band exception. Lucas: Exactly. Band exceptions usually need senior approval, but bonus percentages are more in the manager's control. I've seen people get a twenty percent bonus target instead of a raise, which, if they hit it, can actually pay more. Luna: So the key is to think creatively about your whole package, not just the annual salary line. Lucas: Right. And one more thing: timing matters. If your company is in a budget freeze — which a lot of firms were in August of 2026, given the economic uncertainty — then asking for a re-leveling might not get far. But you can plant the seed by saying, 'I'd like to discuss my career trajectory and compensation at the next review cycle.' That keeps the door open. Luna: So it's about playing the long game, not just one conversation. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the thing — asking for a raise when you're at the top of your band is a marathon, not a sprint. You need to be prepared for a process that might take a few months. But if you approach it with the restructure mindset, you're much more likely to get a yes. Luna: That's reassuring. I think a lot of people feel stuck when they hear 'you're at the top of your band,' like it's a dead end. Lucas: It's not. It's just a different starting point. You're not asking for a raise inside the same box; you're asking for a bigger box. And that's a much more powerful ask. Luna: So, to recap: document the gap, research the market, and propose a restructure — or negotiate other parts of your package. Lucas: That's it. And if you try all that and the company still says no, then you have your answer. But at least you'll know you gave it your best shot. Luna: And maybe the next episode should be about what to do when you're ready to leave because of that no. Lucas: Stay tuned for that one. But for now, I hope this helps you think about your own ceiling a little differently.