Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / [Q3] Tesla Deep Value Analysis: Profit Collapse and AI Gamble
Transcript
- 0:00OK, let's unpack this. We have a massive amount of data
- 0:02here, a really deep financial research report covering Tesla's
- 0:05performance through Q3 and the full year 2025.
- 0:10And our mission here is to really get beyond the headlines.
- 0:12You wanted to know the true financial health of the company
- 0:15and specifically why revenue grew but profit just completely
- 0:18collapsed. Right.
- 0:19And what the data actually says about this push to value the
- 0:22company as an AI robotics company.
- 0:24Exactly. It's a huge.
- 0:26Pivot and that pivot comes from this this bizarre contradiction
- 0:30we saw at the end of 2025. You have Q3 revenue at $28.1
- 0:34billion, which you know beat expectations a top.
- 0:37Line win for sure, but. Then you look at the operating
- 0:39margin and it contracted so severely, the full year ended
- 0:42with a well, a stunning set back.
- 0:44It really did. The market saw the revenue beat
- 0:47and felt relief for what, a few hours?
- 0:49And then the alarm bells started ringing once they saw the cost
- 0:51of that gross. So let's jump right in there.
- 0:52Q32025 revenue is up 12% year over year, $28.1 billion.
- 0:58And a big part of that was demand being pulled forward.
- 1:00In the US, everyone was rushing to buy before those federal tax
- 1:04credits were expected to expire. So they move the cars, but what
- 1:07you're saying is the bottom line just suffered.
- 1:08What does that margin contraction really tell us?
- 1:11It tells us everything. This is where the story is.
- 1:14The key take away is this incredible pressure on
- 1:16profitability. Operating income just plummeted.
- 1:20How? Bad was it?
- 1:21It was down 40% year over year, 40% to $1.6 billion.
- 1:27OK. But hang on, $1.6 billion in
- 1:29operating income is still a huge number, isn't it?
- 1:31I mean, for most companies, that's a fantastic quarter.
- 1:34It is, but not when you look at the trend.
- 1:36The percentage is what matters here.
- 1:38It tells you about the health of the actual.
- 1:40Business and that percentage was?
- 1:41The operating margin contracted to just 5.8%.
- 1:44Wow, Yeah, that is a massive decline.
- 1:46We're talking 501 basis points from the 10.8% they had just a
- 1:50year before. So with a margin profile of
- 1:525.8%, they're not a tech company anymore.
- 1:54They're. They're a car company.
- 1:55You are now comparing them directly to Ford or GM, and
- 1:59that's the comparison that, you know, absolutely terrified the
- 2:01analysts. And that hit shareholders right
- 2:03in the wallet. Of course, non GAAP EPS came in
- 2:06at 53 cents. The consensus was what, 50-3
- 2:09cents and 55 cents, so a miss of 7 to 9%.
- 2:13That's just the math. So what happens when you slash
- 2:15prices to chase volume? OK.
- 2:17So if the car business is where the pain is, where did that 12%
- 2:21overall revenue growth come from?
- 2:22Something else must be working. It did.
- 2:24And this is the really interesting structural shift.
- 2:27The growth was definitely not coming from cars.
- 2:30Automotive revenue was up only 6% year over year.
- 2:32Just 6%. Right, single digits.
- 2:34And that's even with record Q3 deliveries of almost half a
- 2:37million vehicles. It just confirms that they sold
- 2:39more cars, but for a lot less money each.
- 2:41The average selling price is getting crushed.
- 2:44SO1 engine is sputtering but another one is accelerating like
- 2:47crazy. Precisely the new growth engine
- 2:49is energy generation and storage.
- 2:51That segment surged 44% year over year. 44%.
- 2:55To $3.4 billion, it's outpacing the auto segments growth by like
- 3:00a factor of 7. Which really validates that
- 3:03whole long term vision of Tesla being more than just cars.
- 3:05It's an energy company. It absolutely does, yeah.
- 3:08And when you drill down into the operational numbers, it's even
- 3:10more impressive. Storage deployments hit a record
- 3:1312.5 GW hours. And that's an 81% increase rate.
- 3:16An 81% increase year over year and that's mostly the Megapack
- 3:19business, which is so important because those are stable long
- 3:22term contracts. It's a buffer against the chaos
- 3:25of the auto market. And I'm guessing the services
- 3:27revenue is also growing steadily from the sheer number of cars on
- 3:30the road now. It is services and other that's
- 3:33supercharging insurance, all that it grew 25% year over year.
- 3:36It's this reliable compounding effect.
- 3:39The fleet is now over 7 million cars, so that revenue just keeps
- 3:42ticking up. It's like an annuity.
- 3:44OK, let's zoom out from Q3, the full year data for 2025.
- 3:49That paints an even starker picture, doesn't it?
- 3:51This is what forced that big pivot for management.
- 3:53Oh yeah, it showed the headwinds are not temporary.
- 3:57Q4 deliveries came in at about 418,000 vehicles that missed
- 4:01consensus and critically, it was a 16% decline from Q4 of the
- 4:05previous year. And that was the tax credit
- 4:07hangover. That's the air pocket.
- 4:08All that demand was pulled into Q3 and Q4 was left empty.
- 4:12And for the full year, this was the big one.
- 4:14For the first time in their modern history, annual sales
- 4:16volume actually went down. That's right.
- 4:19Total deliveries for 2025 were 1.64 million, a 9% decline from
- 4:232024. This is the clearest signal you
- 4:25could possibly get that the market for the current Model 3
- 4:28and Y lineup is getting saturated.
- 4:30So facing all of this, the margin collapse, the first ever
- 4:32volume decline, what did management do on the earnings
- 4:35call they. Change the subject completely.
- 4:37It was a very sharp strategic pivot.
- 4:39Elon Musk basically said you have to stop looking at us as a
- 4:42car company. He emphasized that Tesla must be
- 4:44viewed as an AI robotics company.
- 4:46So ignore the 5.8% margin over here and look at the cyber cab
- 4:49and the robo taxi of the future. That's the argument.
- 4:52The focus is now entirely on what they're calling the primary
- 4:55value driver, which is the robo taxi targeted for 2026.
- 4:59They're telling investors forget the current reality by the AI
- 5:02dream. So they're taking the cash from
- 5:05the auto business to fund a completely different, you know,
- 5:08high risk AI venture. What does that do to their
- 5:11competitive position, their economic mode?
- 5:14Well, the analysis here assigns them a narrow mode, but it's a
- 5:17very conflicted picture. You have a positive trend on
- 5:19one. Side the data assets, the FSD
- 5:21software. Exactly.
- 5:23But on the other side, you have a significant negative trend in
- 5:26their manufacturing cost advantage.
- 5:27Let's talk about that because that was their superpower for
- 5:29years. How did that cost lead just
- 5:32evaporate? It happened because the
- 5:33competition, especially Chinese automakers like BYD, caught up.
- 5:37They replicated and in some cases even surpassed Tesla's
- 5:40supply chain efficiencies. So things like LFP batteries.
- 5:43That's a key part of it. Rivals adopted the cheaper LFP
- 5:47battery chemistry faster and scaled up massively.
- 5:50It just proved that high quality, cheap EVs could be made
- 5:53by others. And when BYD sells 2.26 million
- 5:56Bevs in a year, well, that proves the competition is real
- 6:01and scaling fast. Which makes the Supercharger
- 6:03network even more of a lifeline, doesn't it?
- 6:05It's undeniably their strongest Moat.
- 6:07It's still the deciding factor for so many buyers, but even
- 6:10that's changing. By opening it up, it shifts from
- 6:12being this exclusive walled garden to more of a a platform
- 6:17utility. Still very valuable, but a
- 6:19different kind of mode. And what's the cost of chasing
- 6:22this new AI mode? Because that has to show up
- 6:23somewhere on the balance sheet. It's massive and you can see it
- 6:26in R&D spending. They have these huge fixed costs
- 6:29from the gigafactories. So when they run below capacity,
- 6:31like in Q4, margins get crushed. And on top of that, R&D is just
- 6:35spiked to fund the AI vision, the Dojo supercomputer, buying
- 6:39up all those expensive H-100 chips.
- 6:40So they're pouring billions from the car business into the AI
- 6:43dream, and that directly hurts the profitability of the car
- 6:46Business Today. That's the trade off they're
- 6:48making. So if we connect all this, what
- 6:51is the ultimate, you know, the existential risk that's driving
- 6:54this volatile stock price? It's all about AI execution
- 6:57risk, 100% the current market cap, that $1.4 trillion
- 7:02valuation, it basically implies that robotaxi is a sure thing,
- 7:06that it will be successful happen soon, and that they'll
- 7:08have a monopoly. And if it's not a sure thing, if
- 7:10autonomous driving just gets stuck at Level 3 and never makes
- 7:13that jump to true level 5 autonomy.
- 7:16Then the analysis suggests the stock could face a catastrophic
- 7:19RE rating. We're talking about a potential
- 7:21drop of 70% or more because the price you see today is not for a
- 7:25car company, it's for a technology breakthrough that
- 7:27hasn't happened yet. That really puts the volatility
- 7:29into perspective. Are there other big risks the
- 7:32analysts are flagging? Well, beyond the AI gamble,
- 7:35there's the ongoing commoditization of EVs.
- 7:37They're increasingly competing just on price.
- 7:40Then you have geopolitical risk. Their reliance on Giga Shanghai
- 7:43is a huge vulnerability. Right.
- 7:45Any US China tension is an immediate threat.
- 7:48A major threat. And finally, there's key man
- 7:50risk. Musk's focus is spread so thin
- 7:53across X SpaceX, and his persona, which has become more
- 7:57polarizing, could be putting a cap on the brand's total
- 8:00addressable market. OK, that covers the operational
- 8:03reality. Let's finish up by looking at
- 8:04valuation. How do the numbers actually
- 8:06stack up against, you know, classic value investing
- 8:09standards like something Buffett or Graham would use?
- 8:12What's really fascinating is how clearly it is not a value stock.
- 8:16I mean, it is unequivocally a growth stock.
- 8:19It fails pretty much every traditional stability metric you
- 8:22can throw at it. Give me the worst one, the.
- 8:23Price to earnings ratio, it's over 300, 300, so investors are
- 8:28paying $300.00 for every $1.00 the company earns.
- 8:30It's not a stock, it's a hope machine.
- 8:32Gross margin is only 18%. Return on equity is 6.6%.
- 8:36By any traditional metric, the price is just completely
- 8:38disconnected from reality. And yet, despite all of that,
- 8:42their balance sheet is a fortress, which is sort of the
- 8:45ultimate safety net for a company taking these kinds of
- 8:47risks. It's absolute cash fortress.
- 8:49They're sitting on $41.6 billion in cash.
- 8:52Wow. And their debt to equity is just
- 8:54.07. They're incredibly solvent.
- 8:56And what's really important is that management is pouring that
- 8:59cash over $11 billion in CapEx forecasted for 2025 into AI and
- 9:04manufacturing, not into stock buybacks.
- 9:06They're doubling down. So let's get to the DCF analysis
- 9:09from the report. The discounted cash flow, what
- 9:11is the range of Fair value here? What are the scenarios?
- 9:14This is where it gets really interesting.
- 9:16Even with aggressive modeling, the researchers just couldn't
- 9:18get anywhere near the market price of around $438.
- 9:21They ran three main scenarios. OK.
- 9:23What's the worst case? The floor AI fails?
- 9:26The car business stagnates. The no gross scenario If Tesla's
- 9:30just a car company with shrinking margins, the model
- 9:32spits out a share price of just $13.96. $13. $13.96 Yeah, it
- 9:38suggests the price is about 96% fantasy if the AI dream
- 9:41collapses. OK, what about a more moderate
- 9:43case? Auto business recovers a bit,
- 9:45energy grows. The conservative scenario that
- 9:47assumes the auto business stabilizes and energy grows
- 9:49moderately. That gets you a share price of
- 9:51$56.75. Still wildly overpriced today.
- 9:55And the bull case the most optimistic scenario you can
- 9:58reasonably model. So the nominals were bull
- 10:00scenario. This assumes energy grows 30% a
- 10:03year. Robo Taxi launches in 2026 and
- 10:06it scales really fast, but maybe not perfectly even under those
- 10:10very favorable conditions. The share price comes in at $167
- 10:14on $0.26 so. Even the absolute bull case from
- 10:17this professional research can't justify a price of over $400.
- 10:20Not even close. The conclusion is that the
- 10:22market price requires assumptions that go way beyond
- 10:25standard financial modeling. It's pricing in perfect instant
- 10:28monopoly success. I think what really stands out
- 10:30to me from this deep dive is just that incredible tension.
- 10:33You have a company with a $41 billion cash fortress and the
- 10:36best charging network on the planet, but it's core auto
- 10:39business is shrinking as profits are crashing and the operating
- 10:41margin is down to just 5.8%. And we saw that pivot where
- 10:45energy is the new growth star and the entire investment thesis
- 10:48has been forced under this high stakes AI execution risk.
- 10:51Which leaves a really important question for you to think about.
- 10:54Given that the company is committed to spending $11
- 10:56billion plus on CapEx for AI and manufacturing, how long can they
- 11:00keep slashing prices in the car business before the high cost of
- 11:03that long term AI vision starts to seriously drain that $41.6
- 11:07billion cash fortress?