Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Wake Up Call (10.21.24): Why BTC's Volatility is Uniquely Desirable with Chris Kuiper & Jesse Myers
Transcript
- 0:00Thank you for joining us today. We're excited to bring you a
- 0:02brand new show from the On Ramp Media umbrella.
- 0:05Wake Up Call is a weekly show that will be streamed live on
- 0:08LinkedIn every Monday morning. To catch the premiere of each
- 0:11episode, follow On Ramps LinkedIn page and add Wake Up
- 0:14Call events to your calendar. After the live premiere on
- 0:17LinkedIn, we will distribute each episode across On Ramp
- 0:20Media's podcast channels and YouTube page.
- 0:23Wake Up Call aims to educate financial professionals on the
- 0:26merits of the Bitcoin investment thesis, how this asset
- 0:29represents both a threat to legacy financial service
- 0:31businesses and an opportunity to differentiate oneselves and
- 0:35retain and attract new clients. Hosted by Mark Connors, Onramp's
- 0:39Head of Global Macro Strategy, and Rich Kerr, Onramp's
- 0:42President of Managed Wealth, this show seeks to provide
- 0:45financial professionals the wake up call they need, prompt them
- 0:48to have an open mind with respect to Bitcoin, rethink
- 0:51their prior assumptions, become more educated on the topic, and
- 0:54learn from others who are already farther down this path.
- 0:57Mark and Rich bring a combined 60 plus years of experience
- 1:00across traditional markets and financial services and will
- 1:03share their unique perspectives and how their peers and
- 1:05colleagues can approach the realm of Bitcoin.
- 1:08Wake Up Call will feature guests from various backgrounds and
- 1:10industries will also share their own journeys to Bitcoin and how
- 1:14others can get up to speed. Now time for the show.
- 1:18Oh, we live, huh. OK, good.
- 1:20Well, welcome everybody. I'm Rich Kerr and I'm joined
- 1:26today by Chris Kiper, who is the Director of Research at Fidelity
- 1:32Digital Assets. And we also have Jesse Myers, Co
- 1:36founder and Chief Investment Officer of at Onramp.
- 1:39So welcome gentlemen. Good to have you guys.
- 1:44Yeah, so we have an interesting show today for everybody.
- 1:47We're going to be talking about a research for paper, excuse me,
- 1:51a research report that was just released by On Ramp and authored
- 1:56by our very own Mark Connors, who's our head of global macro.
- 2:01And it's called the big or it's called Bitcoin.
- 2:03The emerging asset class has arrived.
- 2:05And so we're delighted to have Chris join us from Fidelity
- 2:10Digital Assets. Excuse me and Jesse from on ramp
- 2:15and we're going to chop up this interesting research report,
- 2:18which basically talks about how you as an advisor can enhance
- 2:23both absolute and risk adjusted returns for a traditional 6040
- 2:29bond portable or excuse me, allocation.
- 2:33So Mark, I'm going to kind of kick it over to you since you
- 2:36kind of, you know, spent the better part of the last several
- 2:41months really digging in and, and doing some interesting
- 2:45research around volatility in particular.
- 2:47That's one of the things that I'm going to be picking your
- 2:49brain on throughout the day and, and Chris and Jesse as well.
- 2:52But love to hear some of your thoughts on the research that
- 2:57you did and maybe a quick summary for those who don't have
- 3:01or haven't had the chance to read that report as of yet all.
- 3:04Right. Thanks, Rich.
- 3:05And again, this is great to have Jesse Myers here and Chris Kiper
- 3:10from Fidelity, who I've picked brains, both picked their brains
- 3:15over the over the years from their different experiences.
- 3:18And that's really rich when when I did this report, it is a
- 3:21compilation and it's an oil painting.
- 3:23I mean, it's not done yet. There's always more to add to it
- 3:27because the title of the report didn't come until after we wrote
- 3:33it. And you and I talked, you know,
- 3:35with Michael and Jesse about what we're trying to do and
- 3:38we're trying to show the unique qualities of Bitcoin, its
- 3:40returns, but also the other thing, which is its volatility,
- 3:45which we deem to be good and not bad.
- 3:48That's the headline. And if you, if people leave this
- 3:52call and you know, whether they're watching it live or on,
- 3:56on our pod, on our YouTube channel, ask the question, how
- 4:00can volatility be good? Keep asking it until we've
- 4:03answered it for you or your, your advisor or your or your
- 4:06clients understand it because that's the key.
- 4:09And I think Chris mentioned in the green room that he has seen
- 4:13that other advisors or professionals in the space are
- 4:16also maybe pulling at this thread of volatility being
- 4:20something that mean we may want to be seeking as a resource and
- 4:25not something to avoid. So, so Bitcoin, the emergent
- 4:29asset class has arrived is about this unique quality drawing
- 4:35asset managers like Fidelity and others into the space
- 4:40potentially. Not to put words in Chris's
- 4:41mouth, he has a lot to say, but I think this is what is helping
- 4:46people add risk adjusted returns and absolute returns.
- 4:52That's the second level. Good vault, bad vault.
- 4:55Let's answer that question. And the next one is, yeah,
- 4:58Bitcoin makes a lot of money for people, but boy, it's too
- 5:02volatile. And then we're going to say no,
- 5:05we're going to show you how actually the volatility is worth
- 5:09the ride. And that's really what people
- 5:13look at. And they talk about sharp ratios
- 5:17and then sortinos. All right, ring the bell.
- 5:19I went too wonky. It only took me two minutes.
- 5:22Jesse, you're supposed to talk me off the Cliff when I start
- 5:24doing that over 90 seconds. So I'm going to give it back to
- 5:26you. But that's it.
- 5:28It's a three-part series. This bitcoins got more than
- 5:31people know about and the institutions are coming for it.
- 5:34That's that's where I'll leave it back.
- 5:36Back to you, Rich. Yeah.
- 5:39To add on to that, yeah, Mark, I, I'm, I'm really excited about
- 5:43the, the work you've put together on this topic.
- 5:46I, I'm a simple, I'm a simple man.
- 5:48I like the charts that you put together.
- 5:51I think they really emphasize the point that you're talking
- 5:55about in less wonky details. So it's easier to understand in
- 5:57my opinion, how Bitcoin flips what asset allocators are used
- 6:04to in the sense it with regard to volatility, because in
- 6:09traditional assets, stocks and bonds, volatility, volatility
- 6:14tends to be bad more often than it is good.
- 6:17So on the whole, people try to avoid volatile volatile assets
- 6:22because volatility is bad. And then Bitcoin flips that
- 6:26paradigm and suddenly volatility is your friend.
- 6:28Volatility is good because more often than not it's to the
- 6:31upside than it than it is to the downside.
- 6:34So anyway, I love the charts that you put together to just
- 6:38surface this simple idea that's been hiding in the data for a
- 6:42long time and I think is a big part of telling the story to
- 6:46bridge the gap between Bitcoin and traditional finance about
- 6:50why Bitcoin is so important to include in portfolios.
- 6:53And I think before we get too into the weeds, I just want to
- 6:56point out how in the paper you distinguish between the true
- 7:01definition or that, or I shouldn't say true, but the
- 7:03academic definition of volatility versus how people
- 7:06think about it. And volatility, of course, is
- 7:08just a statistical measure. It's it's how much something
- 7:10moves around a mean. And but of course, as you say,
- 7:14everyone thinks it's bad. And in the paper, I like how you
- 7:16put think of it as uncertainty. You know, it's maybe
- 7:20uncertainty, but it's not necessarily bad.
- 7:22And I think one of the, the simple ways to think about this
- 7:25is when the the age-old question comes up about Bitcoin being too
- 7:30volatile. And, and you linked my, my
- 7:31Nashville speech and I reference how this is the number one
- 7:34barrier to Bitcoin as an investment we get from
- 7:36institutional investors. Five years in a row, this has
- 7:39been #1 and either people just don't get this concept yet, or
- 7:45they're, they're using it as a convenient excuse.
- 7:46That's a different story. We could probably talk about but
- 7:49but this idea of, of volatility being being bad at versus no,
- 7:54it's just uncertainty. Like think of I use except for
- 7:56example, you have an objective, an investment objective to meet.
- 8:00And maybe that's a certain amount of money for retirement
- 8:03or a certain return that you have to get and you want to
- 8:06match up the investments. That's, that is going to have
- 8:09the best chance of meeting that objective.
- 8:12And so if your objective is way off into the future 10/20/50
- 8:15years and if you hold just cash, all of us know with almost
- 8:20certainty, very high probability, holding just cash
- 8:23is not going to meet that future cash flow need that objective,
- 8:27but it's not going to be volatile along the way, along
- 8:29the way. And so people say, of course you
- 8:31have to add something like equities or bonds or something
- 8:33like that to meet that objective.
- 8:35And you said, but it's going to, it's going to add volatility.
- 8:37And they say, So what you're, you're going to hold it for 50
- 8:39years? Is your objective to have 0
- 8:41volatility or is your objective to meet this, this cash flow
- 8:44need in the future? Well, of course, it's to meet
- 8:46this thing in the future. So who cares what happens along
- 8:49the way? But of course, people conflate
- 8:51these two things. They think it's the volatility
- 8:53along the way that's the problem.
- 8:54And that's not, that's not the objective and that's not what
- 8:57we're trying to do here. Well, Zed, so that that
- 9:03perspective when you've been speaking to in investors, Chris,
- 9:07and that was the the title or the theme of your Nashville, if
- 9:14I remember correctly. Does that perspective help and
- 9:18what type of people or topics have unlocked the opportunity or
- 9:25even getting the audience to do that?
- 9:27You know, so we're I'd I'd love to stay with that before we go
- 9:30into anything else on on the report or volatility like Jesse
- 9:33was talking about. So because that perspective you
- 9:35gave, I haven't thought about, even though I probably danced
- 9:39around it about, you know, what, what do they call it liability
- 9:42driven investing or you know, the target dates, funds and all
- 9:46that type of thing. How would that, how would you,
- 9:50how would you position Bitcoin in that conversation, you know,
- 9:54using this topic of volatility with other traverses, what they
- 9:58use today like high yield or equities or EM?
- 10:02Yeah, I think it gets back to the point of what is risk to
- 10:05you. And for some people and
- 10:07strategies, volatility is risk depending on what they're doing,
- 10:11especially if they're using leverage because there's there's
- 10:13chances that they blow up. And this is something you talk
- 10:15about in the fund. But if you're talking about it's
- 10:17just a simple RAA advisor, someone who's saving for
- 10:21retirement, risk is not volatility.
- 10:23Risk is ultimate loss of capital, risk is not meeting
- 10:27your investment objective. And I think that's what you have
- 10:29to keep, keep the, the, the, your eye on the ball with this.
- 10:33And of course, this gets to the marketing problem.
- 10:36It's, it's and, and the emotional problem.
- 10:38So I think there's two things we could go with this.
- 10:40And you actually bring both up in, in the report too.
- 10:42I think there's the number side, the, the pure academic side.
- 10:45And then there's how do we educate people around this to
- 10:49embrace volatility, Stick with this.
- 10:52And this is something too that I, I mentioned in the green
- 10:55room, we can talk about as well the fastness of AQR huge quant
- 10:59shot talks about this in a recent report in praise of high
- 11:02volatile alternatives. The one of the components is
- 11:06just getting people to stick with it.
- 11:08And so when they see that draw drawdown, they see that loss,
- 11:11they have to fight their emotions.
- 11:12So there's kind of two things. There's get their head around
- 11:16the numbers, the academics, and then get their their heart and
- 11:19emotions around embracing this as well.
- 11:24Yeah, the behavioral finance component is such an interesting
- 11:27one and and I have a lot of conversations with advisors in
- 11:31particular around the volatility and and in an advisor mind I
- 11:36think you know, and it makes sense, right?
- 11:38They don't want clients to feel bumps, right?
- 11:41Like they're, they're constantly looking to smooth things out for
- 11:44clients because any bumpiness means that they have to come in
- 11:48and, and, and work on those behavioral finance instincts
- 11:52that an individual investor might have where they start
- 11:55getting really nervous. And, and their, and their, and
- 11:58their time horizon, while it might be 10-15 years, all of a
- 12:03sudden shrinks down to that very moment and they struggle with
- 12:07that. And I think it's, it's a
- 12:09difficult conversation to have, but I think, you know, the
- 12:12successful firms do a very good job of educating clients to
- 12:16extend their time horizons and, and recognize that volatility
- 12:22can actually be our friend if we manage it effectively.
- 12:24Not just the emotion that the individual investor has, but but
- 12:29the but the tactical execution of rebalancing a portfolio and
- 12:33and cost averaging into positions.
- 12:36All of these things kind of help capture that volatility and and
- 12:41smooth it out a little bit along the way.
- 12:43But they all it, it's extra work And it in any time that you make
- 12:49an an end client nervous, you know, an advisor gets
- 12:54uncomfortable themselves, right, because they didn't, they never
- 12:56want to lose clients for any reason and they want to continue
- 13:00to do the good work that they do.
- 13:02And so I think education is a big piece of the the puzzle, but
- 13:06also recognizing, you know, the human behavior and the things
- 13:13that cause disruption in terms of successful investment
- 13:18planning. Yeah, Chris, you mentioned that
- 13:22this has been the top topic. And by the way, Rich, your mic
- 13:25is blaring a bit. You might want to turn down your
- 13:28sensitivity or volume if you can.
- 13:32And, and yeah, mute was good for getting rid of the background
- 13:35background noise. So Chris, you mentioned the five
- 13:39years in a row volatility is the number one concern for.
- 13:43And I, I, I take it that was a survey you guys did of potential
- 13:47adopters. I'd love to hear more about like
- 13:51what are the anecdotal objections or concerns or did
- 13:57did survey respondents include like we're waiting for X to be
- 14:01met in terms of volatility before we consider this asset
- 14:05class? Any other color around around
- 14:08how folks that you've talked to or you know through the survey
- 14:12are thinking about bitcoins volatility?
- 14:15Yes, it's a survey. We've done five years in a row.
- 14:18We survey over 1000 people or institutional investors.
- 14:22These are not our clients, but worldwide and institutional
- 14:25investors are very broad bucket for us.
- 14:26So it's anywhere from high net worth individuals, Rias, family
- 14:30offices, multifamily offices, hedge funds and then on the
- 14:32other side, pensions, endowments, foundations.
- 14:35And volatility is the number one that's been cited five years in
- 14:38a row. A lot of the other barriers to
- 14:41entry that they mentioned have changed over the years.
- 14:43And I think they, they kind of change with the excuse du jour.
- 14:47I want to say things like, oh, dark markets and illicit goods
- 14:51that used to be 1 early days. Now that's dropped much, much
- 14:55lower. But volatility stayed number
- 14:56one. And unfortunately the survey
- 14:58doesn't have more information on that.
- 15:00Maybe we could extend it or something like that, but I think
- 15:04there's a good group of people who are just saying that because
- 15:07it's an easy one word answer. And this is my personal opinion.
- 15:10Of course. The the I'm not going to read
- 15:12into the survey, but it it's just a, a hand waving thing
- 15:14where they, they either haven't done the work, they haven't had
- 15:17the time, they view it as too small, or they just have a
- 15:20personal bias against it. And instead of saying that it's
- 15:23easier to say something more sophisticated sounding like
- 15:26volatility, but I'm increasingly getting frustrated with it and
- 15:30coming back and saying you're institutional investors, this is
- 15:33your job deal with volatility, this is your opportunity,
- 15:35exactly what we're talking about.
- 15:37You should not shy away from it. The other side of volatility is,
- 15:41is opportunity. And so you should understand
- 15:44this and then manage it either through simple position sizing
- 15:48or something else. But unfortunately that's that's
- 15:51about all we have right now on it.
- 15:53Yeah, I, I, I was sort of poking to see if if you felt that it
- 15:57was an excuse because it sort of sounds like a very convenient,
- 16:02exactly as you said, a sophisticated excuse.
- 16:05And ironic too because like, like so many things with
- 16:09Bitcoin, the surface level objection is completely opposite
- 16:14of the reality for her. This is actually good volatility
- 16:17as Mark has now has now spotlighted.
- 16:21And so that objection of of oh, Bitcoin's too volatile.
- 16:26I don't I want to stay away from it is actually the complete
- 16:29opposite of what you want to be doing.
- 16:30You want to lean into that positive volatility.
- 16:33And you know, the don't trust verify ethos of Bitcoin yet
- 16:37again gets people who think they are have a sophisticated reason
- 16:44for objecting to Bitcoin, but in fact they're mistaken.
- 16:47Yeah. And and to another point of this
- 16:50is some of them might just be working on old data.
- 16:53And so this is one things I addressed in in the speech and
- 16:56what you're addressing in this report as well.
- 16:59Volatility has been declining for many years on a long term
- 17:02horizon. So they're still thinking of
- 17:03Bitcoin 2014, 150 close to 200 Vol asset at times.
- 17:08They're not thinking of today's Vol averaging 6070 and
- 17:13currently, you know, it got as low as 3040.
- 17:16And we would put up against some of the magnificent 7 stocks.
- 17:19It's right in the middle. There's, there's larger market
- 17:22cap companies that are more volatile than Bitcoin right now.
- 17:25There are many S&P 500 companies more volatile.
- 17:28So some of it's bad data that we have to help people, get them,
- 17:32get them educated on this. They're still operating on this
- 17:34old notion. And then to, to Rich's point
- 17:37too, there's, there's the emotional part of it.
- 17:40Even if people's, even if you construct a portfolio where as
- 17:43you show in your report, you're not actually increasing
- 17:46volatility because it's a diversifier, people are still
- 17:49going to see that line item. And they're, or they're going to
- 17:52get a chart that says like your top ten and top worst
- 17:54performing. And they're going to see a big
- 17:56fat, you know -70% or something for one item on there.
- 18:00And they might freak out. And then as you know, especially
- 18:02in the advisor space, there's some poor incentive structures
- 18:07where people are worried about career risk, about getting fired
- 18:10as an advisor, people moving on. So there's, it's tough, it's a
- 18:13tough, tough problem to deal with it.
- 18:15But that's of course why we're here and why your your report is
- 18:18so great. Yeah, the, the, that was kind of
- 18:21the original thread that Mark wanted to pull on was this
- 18:26excellent report from 2 Ocean, 2 Ocean Trust where they, they
- 18:32pointed out within the numbers that a small percentage
- 18:37allocation to Bitcoin actually reduces overall portfolio
- 18:40volatility while increasing performance, which is the Holy
- 18:44Grail of asset allocation. That's, that's everything that
- 18:48anybody should be looking for. And yet, as you, as you rightly
- 18:51point out, Chris, that you know, that the volatility in that
- 18:54small bucket can be a problem. You know, it can stick out.
- 18:58It'd be a sore thumb. And so people are scared of
- 19:02that, even though that uncorrelated volatility reduces
- 19:05overall portfolio volatility. That's everything you want,
- 19:09Mark. Maybe it'd be a good a good time
- 19:11to to toss up a couple of your charts, perhaps starting with
- 19:18volatility in traditional assets versus the the histogram of
- 19:24volatility in Bitcoin, just to see what you know how different
- 19:27they are. OK, cool.
- 19:30This is like asking a parent to show pictures of their children.
- 19:32Don't ask me twice. So.
- 19:44Well, yeah, I'll. I'll look at the, you know, when
- 19:46Chris was talking about. Yeah, not seeing anything on
- 19:50screen. Oh, there we go.
- 19:50Perfect. So this is everyone says, you
- 19:53know, let's be safe and go to treasuries, Treasuries, you know
- 19:58the I look at the 20 year ETF out there on our scorecard we
- 20:03posted on to promote this. Live session, it's down in the
- 20:07last five years, it's down in the month, down year to date.
- 20:12And the volatility of the of the Treasury curve is is increasing.
- 20:16It's actually at 125 right now. This is it's a measure, this is
- 20:21a move index, it's a popular measure to look at implied
- 20:25volatility of Treasuries. So the Treasury volatility, talk
- 20:29about uncertainty back to what you know Chris mentioned from
- 20:32our report, uncertainty is higher in Treasuries.
- 20:35There are fewer buyers, there's more coming.
- 20:38It's a problem, they don't know where to put them and it's
- 20:42they're bouncing around in price.
- 20:44So the the trend line is there. In fact it hasn't come down
- 20:48since they first rose rates. So that's treasuries.
- 20:53NASDAQ its volatility is trending higher as it gets more
- 20:59concentrated. You know, we all know five to
- 21:01seven names account for anywhere between 50 to 80% of returns on
- 21:05any you know, one year rolling one year basis in the last few
- 21:08years. So the few are carrying the rest
- 21:11and that that can create some volatility as as market breath
- 21:16decreases. Then you got this guy up here a
- 21:19little Bitcoin pops up. Bitcoins volatility has been
- 21:22trending lower and still back to that uncertainty.
- 21:26You know, it's it's gotten to be bigger.
- 21:28The basing impact is kicking in no longer 120 Vols as Chris
- 21:34mentioned. And Jesse, I think you were
- 21:37talking more about the histograms, but I think this is
- 21:39just overall bitcoins volatility is not increasing.
- 21:43It's becoming more certain. And I didn't know if you had
- 21:47another chart that you want to mention, because I have more
- 21:50kids that I can. Show you too.
- 21:52Yeah, No, this is a perfect spot to start.
- 21:55It'd be cool to see the the histograms of I I think it's
- 21:58equities. I don't know if it's equities
- 22:00and bonds and and show that the skew to one side versus then
- 22:06Bitcoin with the skew to the other side.
- 22:08Yeah. So here is Bloomberg, there we
- 22:12go. Yeah, US large cap equity index,
- 22:16which is effectively the S&P. Bloomberg just did it because
- 22:20they want to, you know, put their own name on it and they do
- 22:22some other things for their indices.
- 22:24It's effectively the S&P. So this is the rolling quarterly
- 22:29returns over the past five years give us a lot of metrics.
- 22:32You know, it's daily data looking over the last rolling
- 22:36effectively 3 months and it looks kind of like a normal
- 22:40distribution. But when you look at the kind of
- 22:43the tails, you got a lot of zeros, ones and threes on the on
- 22:47the gains. And then here you have some more
- 22:49chunky on the lost side punching through and this 3.7 mean now
- 22:58we're going to get a little wonky is less than the median,
- 23:03which is about 5 1/2. And so that's a classic
- 23:07negatively skewed distribution when the average is not equal to
- 23:15the most frequent return or the median return or the middle of
- 23:20return rather, which is about 5 because you have a lot of
- 23:24negative returns. And, and in case there are any
- 23:27traders on the phone or, or people who back to parenting who
- 23:31realize things are good until they're not when you have kids,
- 23:33when you get that call, I have teenagers or used to.
- 23:35So trading is in traditional assets is like taking the
- 23:42escalator in the way up, Bang, bang, bang.
- 23:44You're accruing interest on a bond until one day it's a
- 23:48default and you take that elevator shaft the way down.
- 23:51Not fun. That's what this chart shows
- 23:54you. It's the elevator shaft.
- 23:55Those losses appear. And that's what a negatively
- 23:59skewed distribution does. Yeah.
- 24:04And, and, and so that's why traditional asset allocators are
- 24:08so afraid of volatility because they've hundreds of years, well,
- 24:12generations, let's say, of learning that the elevator shaft
- 24:17is what you want to avoid because it's not fun and it goes
- 24:21down and, and then, and now you can tee up the, the inverse
- 24:26here, Mark. All right, so now this is my
- 24:29star child here. Not gold used to be gold, but
- 24:33it's Bitcoin. So look at this distribution.
- 24:37You you didn't even you don't need to know math to just ask
- 24:40the question. This is different and then say
- 24:43why. And you have four people on the
- 24:46on the call here will tell you well, it's because it has good
- 24:50volatility. It punches to the right and will
- 24:53surprise to the upside much more than a surprise to the downside.
- 24:57So I'm going to push it back to you guys to riff on this
- 25:01distribution. How you think it's best shared
- 25:05with the audience or investors? Or should we pivot to something
- 25:09else? For, for me, this is, this is my
- 25:13favorite chart. And, and Mark, we talked about
- 25:17this before, so I'll, I'll sort of bring up the highlights of
- 25:21that conversation of for Bitcoin's entire history,
- 25:26there's been this vague awareness that if you miss the
- 25:3010 best days of the year, you're flat.
- 25:34So, you know, if you try to time the market and you happen to
- 25:37miss the 10 best days of the year, you're not seeing any of
- 25:40Bitcoins gains. So you got to stay in the
- 25:42market. But you know, what that's really
- 25:44saying is that there are 10 days a year where it jumps upwards
- 25:48and you want that positive volatility.
- 25:50So you better hold on, you know, through the boring times in
- 25:54order to get those those big days.
- 25:57There's also Mark, we also talked about how the closest
- 26:00analog to this is probably gold in the 70s.
- 26:04And we talked about how that was because gold in the 70s was
- 26:09going from prohibition to suddenly now you're allowed to
- 26:12invest in it. And there had been price
- 26:15suppression and now suddenly a decade of price discovery, you
- 26:18know, allowing gold's value to go upwards through market
- 26:22forces. And so, you know, gold had been
- 26:27suppressed down from where its natural price equilibrium should
- 26:31have been. And it it took took a decade to
- 26:35float up to that and overextend beyond that.
- 26:39And Bitcoin is not going from prohibition, but it's going from
- 26:42not existing to now existing. And there's this price discovery
- 26:48that's been playing out for 15 years of how do you, how do you
- 26:51value something that had no value day one and, and how much
- 26:54value should it accrue in the global asset landscape?
- 26:57And we're, we're witnessing that price discovery play out over a
- 27:00couple decades. And so there's, there's
- 27:03similarities there of of punctuated equilibrium where
- 27:11it's boring for a while, but then price discovery happens to
- 27:14the upside because we're still trending towards where this
- 27:18asset should be quote, UN quote in the global asset landscape in
- 27:22the same way that gold had to go through that price discovery in
- 27:24the 70s. Get on.
- 27:28Yeah. I think that's a great point
- 27:29that I often use that chart as well showing the volatility
- 27:32spiking for gold. And it's exactly what you said,
- 27:35Jesse kind of said it better. It's, it's going through a
- 27:37monetization process, a price discovery process, and the
- 27:41keyword is a process people don't know from one day gold is
- 27:45fixed $35.00 an ounce. You couldn't even own it as a
- 27:48private citizen. Next day you can now own it.
- 27:51It's freely traded. Everyone just knows the price.
- 27:53They don't it, it has to be an emergent process where the
- 27:57information is generated through the market itself, which is a, a
- 28:01nuanced point, but I think very, very interesting for people to
- 28:04really think about like you, you can't, you can't get the
- 28:07information without it being volatile, without it going
- 28:12through this process and and expressing all the opinions of
- 28:15billions of people and investors around the world.
- 28:19But one question I I had on this is, is one I've gotten from
- 28:22people, especially from my trad FI colleagues and friends, where
- 28:26they say, OK, but why? Why should this persist?
- 28:30It seems like Bitcoins well known.
- 28:32What's what's my edge is what I often get.
- 28:34And and of course, in their minds as a traditional investor,
- 28:37to beat the, the market, to improve your portfolio, you have
- 28:40to have a competitive edge. You have to have a variant
- 28:42perception. You have to have information
- 28:44that someone else has. So I'm curious what you say to
- 28:47that question like why should this persist and why should it
- 28:51continue that it will still have this long right tail continue to
- 28:55be non correlated and add diversification and and risk
- 28:59adjusted returns? I'll, I'll take a quick stab at
- 29:04it and then it's not anyone else.
- 29:07The I, I started to get involved in Bitcoin only in 2020 when I
- 29:12was a Credit Suisse. I was on a desk that provided
- 29:15data to hedge funds, sentiment data to help them provide get
- 29:20alpha for their systems in order to look at positioning changes.
- 29:27And I noticed that our client list kept rolling over the
- 29:33ability to generate alpha and hedge funds is very difficult.
- 29:36And then it was like, why is it why these big firms are so well
- 29:40resourced? Why can't they, you know, beat
- 29:42the S&P and then I looked over my shoulder at at the bigger
- 29:46animal which was the Fed as far as accumulating and driving
- 29:52flows and liquidity. So they would the markets would
- 29:56go sideways, say there was a energy shock like 2016 or
- 30:01Chinese devaluation in August of 15 markets.
- 30:05What goes would go break hedge funds make money for about 8
- 30:09minutes and then the Fed would come in, step in, provide
- 30:12tremendous amount of liquidity and all volatility compression
- 30:15would come down. So I guess I saw that as why
- 30:20hedge funds didn't make money. But then I saw that there was a
- 30:23negative residual and growing problem of our debt load,
- 30:27whether it be the Fed monetizing all the treasury debt.
- 30:30So now we're getting into something like Lynn Alden would
- 30:33call not financial repression, but of fiscal dominance, which
- 30:40is where. So why do I think this is going
- 30:42to persist? Because I look at market data
- 30:45and I saw that bonds were slowly losing their ability to act as a
- 30:49as a safety net. Chris, they were wonderful in
- 30:532008. I think the 10 year made like
- 30:5522%. It was a great offset.
- 30:58It's a parachute, man. It worked. 6040 thumbs up.
- 31:03It hasn't since then, and I think it's because it's been
- 31:08captured by the Fed. They're the one the only buyers.
- 31:12Other folks aren't buying it. And we all know a healthy system
- 31:16needs to have breath. Like the convert market back to
- 31:19where I grew up. It was a great market because it
- 31:23was a wide, a lot of different buyers, a healthy ecosystem.
- 31:28But then over time it became one buyer like a ball buyer.
- 31:31So I say that for the small audience of convert folks
- 31:33listening, you need to get involved here because this is
- 31:36this is exactly what's happening in treasuries.
- 31:38It's getting an attenuation of buyers and it's not acting as a
- 31:41parachute. So I think it's going to persist
- 31:44because we our deficit will continue to grow.
- 31:47And I think that real stalwart of treasury support that you got
- 31:52in a downturn, that parachute that's not going to come
- 31:55unpacked anymore and it hasn't for five years and I don't think
- 31:58it's going to. So that is a fundamental
- 32:00question or answer, which is going to be part three of our
- 32:04series, which is the problem in Tratify and why it's terminal.
- 32:10And then so the the other one is everything that's been going up
- 32:15is because every business has been shifted to a technology and
- 32:18software layer. NVIDIA was a hardware company.
- 32:22They figured out how to integrate software onto the chip
- 32:25and voila, they're one of the largest, fastest growing
- 32:28companies in the world. They took the analog hardware
- 32:32world and they turned it or morphed it into a software
- 32:36solution, Chris, and that's what this is.
- 32:39This is a monetary software solution in or a monetary taken
- 32:49software and converting our traditional monetary system to a
- 32:55decentralized secure software solution.
- 33:01Yeah, that I think that's a big part of it right there, Mark,
- 33:05the, you know, the, the context of, I guess for me, Chris, it's
- 33:11all about context and the context of fiscal fiscal
- 33:15dominance and national debt and all that is a huge part of it,
- 33:21probably the single biggest part of it.
- 33:24And then the other side of that same context that Mark was
- 33:27alluding to is like what is a bond really doing in your
- 33:30portfolio? Like what, what, what's it
- 33:32really providing? It's OK.
- 33:33It's, it's delivering 3-4 percent, 5% and stated inflation
- 33:41is 3%. But is, are those numbers real?
- 33:45Is real inflation more like 7%? That's actually what Michael
- 33:49Saylor has included in his recent model that, you know,
- 33:53that's, that's real inflation. So if you're holding a bond,
- 33:56you're actually, you're losing, you're destroying value If, if
- 34:00real inflation is higher than stated inflation.
- 34:05And then there's that bigger context.
- 34:07Of course, I'm going to go back to my little baby of the global
- 34:11asset landscape chart where I show the, you know, $900
- 34:18trillion of global asset value by my estimation.
- 34:21And Bitcoin is 1 trillion. So one one thousandth of the
- 34:26world's value is, is digital gold.
- 34:29And it that's obviously been, that's the current state after
- 34:3415 years of monetization. And then the question becomes,
- 34:37where does that stop? Does it stop right there at, at
- 34:40one one thousandth of the world's value is digital value?
- 34:45I don't think so, especially in the context of, of fiscal
- 34:49dominance, in the, in the context of bonds not serving
- 34:52their, their purpose as well as Bitcoin does.
- 34:57So, you know, if I'm an investor, I and I learn about
- 34:59Bitcoin, I, I think this is a better form of bonds that
- 35:03delivers way higher returns with actually lower risk, which is
- 35:09mind bending. And I'm going to put more
- 35:11capital in it. And yeah.
- 35:15So where does that stop? It sort of becomes a question of
- 35:19if gold monetized until it reached its equilibrium in the
- 35:2370s, Bitcoin is monetizing until it reaches its equilibrium place
- 35:28in the global asset landscape. Now, does it stop at one one
- 35:32thousandth of the world's value? Does it go to gold?
- 35:35Does it match gold, which would be A10 to 15X from here?
- 35:41Or does it exceed gold and become something better than
- 35:44gold because it has properties that are more attractive than
- 35:47gold? That's my view.
- 35:49It's is that gold is the, the, the minimum of what Bitcoin will
- 35:54achieve. And so if that's, if you believe
- 35:58that, then this process of monetization will continue until
- 36:01that point or whatever is the right equilibrium for Bitcoin.
- 36:05So that's how I view it. I guess at Onramp, we believe
- 36:09that Bitcoin is the most important asset of the 21st
- 36:12century. The hard part is securing it
- 36:14right. There are shortcomings with
- 36:16keeping your coins on an exchange, but also with setting
- 36:19up your own self custody arrangement.
- 36:22Onramp solves for these concerns.
- 36:24Our multi institution custody solution maximizes security and
- 36:28minimizes counterparty risk, ensuring that your Bitcoin
- 36:31remains securely in your possession and provides built in
- 36:34inheritance planning to ensure your family is protected as
- 36:37well. On Ramp provides Peace of Mind
- 36:40for your Bitcoin journey, whether for your whole stack or
- 36:43for part of it as a compliment to your existing self custody
- 36:46set up. For more information, check us
- 36:48out at on rampbitcoin.com. Yeah, that makes sense.
- 36:53And that that is the multi trillion dollar question of
- 36:56course. But I've seen charts where
- 36:59before, you know, we're in such a small portion of history where
- 37:04gold is not the financial foundation to the global
- 37:07monetary system as it was for hundreds or even thousands of
- 37:10years before. So it's a very small portion,
- 37:14but before when it was, it was double digits, right?
- 37:18It wasn't the whole thing, but it was double digits of what
- 37:20people built on top of it. So you start to think of that as
- 37:23the potential scenario as parity.
- 37:26But then to to Mark's point, it's more than that.
- 37:29It's, it's a software system. So it could be embedded and
- 37:32built on even more than the gold of the past, but don't have a
- 37:36good answer to that. Just just some of the ways to
- 37:38think about that, that multi trillion dollar question of what
- 37:41does Bitcoin, what could Bitcoin potentially monetize to in
- 37:46relation to all these other assets?
- 37:48One other thing I wanted to not so much a question, but just a
- 37:51comment that I definitely want to get to is your repeated use
- 37:55in this paper of harvesting volatility.
- 37:59And Mark, you know, you brought this to myself and our team
- 38:02years ago at Fidelity, this idea, and it was the first time
- 38:05I had heard it that way and presented that way and it really
- 38:08unlocked something from me and it's something I've used.
- 38:10So I'd love to hear more, hear you tell people more about this
- 38:14idea of harvesting volatility. How does that work?
- 38:17What do you mean by that? And what are we talking about
- 38:20there? OK.
- 38:25On harvesting volatility, Bitcoin jigs when other assets
- 38:32Jag. So when we were when, when I was
- 38:39in the in the markets and we dealt with high yield bonds,
- 38:42it's like are you wearing the volatility meaning like you're
- 38:45just riding and it's ripping you or are you harvesting it?
- 38:48If you if you are riding the volatility, it means that you
- 38:52are holding on to the asset. Think of it like a wild horse.
- 38:55You're thrown, but you're still attached to the saddle.
- 38:57You being dragged all over God's creation.
- 38:59You may get to dinner, but you're not going to feel too
- 39:01good. So, so that's, that's really
- 39:04kind of like, you know, riding the ball harvesting means that
- 39:08you're sort of stepping back and you're able to when it comes up,
- 39:11you clip it off and then you pull it in and you put in your
- 39:14sack and you know, you are, you know, think of it like like a
- 39:20geyser. You know, where you're taking
- 39:21the, the water comes up, you're able to, you know, use it and,
- 39:26and grab it and then go down and then not, not beyond the geyser.
- 39:29That's, that's my mix of, of analogies.
- 39:33Please give me it's, it's early here and, and let me just go
- 39:38through some numbers and then I want you guys to direct me
- 39:40because I found that working with Jesse, he's better pulling
- 39:42it out of me than I am by delivering it.
- 39:44So here numbers, this is a 5 year study and we do a six and a
- 39:49quarter year study. We do rolling 10 years which are
- 39:52coming out in an addendum. So don't even consider saying
- 39:55that we're cherry picking because this is a persistent
- 39:59pattern we took. A regular 6040 portfolio.
- 40:05We took 1 1/2% out of equities, 1 1/2% out of bonds.
- 40:10Again, don't ask us about cherry picking.
- 40:12We do it for one year, five year, 10 year, 25 year.
- 40:15I mean, 25% allocations of Bitcoin also coming out in a
- 40:19week or two. In an addendum, it's just 3%.
- 40:22So we put 3% in. Here's a regular 6040 portfolio,
- 40:27probably keeping up with monetary debasement, 5.9% return
- 40:32over five years when Bitcoin only returned about 18%.
- 40:38But when we put 3% in that portfolio and rebalance it
- 40:43quarterly, we don't leave it there over time, but we say
- 40:46every quarter, let's rebalance it.
- 40:48If Bitcoin goes up, we're going to take some out, put into bonds
- 40:51and equities, harvest it, it goes up, pull some out like the
- 40:54geyser just put in our back pocket.
- 40:56And then if Bitcoin goes down, we take some from equities and
- 40:59bonds and we throw it into Bitcoin.
- 41:01And over this period of time and as we show in most any four year
- 41:05period, Bitcoin doesn't hasn't has gone back up.
- 41:11And we're able to then harvest that volatility by pulling from
- 41:15lower Vol assets into Bitcoin when it falls and then it rises.
- 41:20And when it rises, we grab it back out, put it into bonds and
- 41:23equities, and then when Bitcoin comes down, yes, rinse and
- 41:28repeat. So that gave us 200 and 190
- 41:34basis points more annualized return by just allocating a 3%.
- 41:39It's almost like renting Bitcoin.
- 41:41So that's good. Thumbs up.
- 41:42You made more money. Everyone's like, yeah, but it's
- 41:44more volatile. Let's go to the right chart
- 41:46here. This is volatility down
- 41:49volatility. What's the volatility of all the
- 41:53losses? It's 8.2% in your regular bond
- 41:57and equity portfolio. It's less here's the home run.
- 42:01You have less uncertainty on the downside when you have Bitcoin
- 42:07in your portfolio. And then for allocators, back to
- 42:10what Jesse or Chris, I forget which one said, when you have
- 42:13that down 70% quarter or or drawdown, well, a 3% drawdown
- 42:19when you rent it, when you rebalance it quarterly, you kind
- 42:22of don't accumulate those losses, but you can compound the
- 42:25gains. It doesn't have a materially
- 42:28different drawdown that keeps the allocator that has permanent
- 42:32capital in the job because his job's not permanent.
- 42:37The capital is his isn't or hers isn't.
- 42:39And so that's, this is the really the trifecta of graphs.
- 42:44And now I'll show you one more where it goes into some of the
- 42:51math. Harvesting volatility means you
- 42:54have to actively have a plan with an advisor, whoever it is
- 43:00to say, I'm going to regularly rebalance your portfolio.
- 43:04Mr. Client misses client because this is a, this is a Bronco.
- 43:08It has higher volatility. It is trending lower, but we can
- 43:12use it to our advantage. Bitcoin made 17.8% in that five
- 43:18year period where I just showed you the graphs.
- 43:21So if you put 3% in and just held it hold your held your nose
- 43:25and rode that volatility, which probably wasn't pleasant, you
- 43:28made like 50 basis points right here.
- 43:30That's it. Static five years, 17.8 * 3%.
- 43:36It's math 50 basis points. But if you took that 3% and
- 43:42rebalanced that whole portfolio among the three assets, nothing
- 43:47fancy. Every quarter Q created 880
- 43:52basis points of value to your portfolio and that's why a 3%
- 43:58allocation gave you 2120.7% of your whole value.
- 44:04We gold levered. No asset we've seen can do that.
- 44:09This is the home run. This is the sequencing of charts
- 44:12about good volatility being harvested for your client where
- 44:17drawdown doesn't really 'cause you too much heartache and the
- 44:21volatility actually decreases. So that was my 3 1/2 minute run
- 44:26and hang it up. And please, you guys have seen
- 44:30this as much as I have. Let me know when I minister what
- 44:32you want to focus on that. The, the first time I heard you
- 44:36say this, this, this floored me. I, I was so surprised at these
- 44:40results and this idea because you think that by rebalancing in
- 44:45the tradition, because in the traditional sense, we all have
- 44:47this intuitive feeling and the data will show it.
- 44:48You rebalance your, you're staying conservative, right?
- 44:52You're, you're lowering your wrist.
- 44:53You're not letting anything get too crazy, but somehow when you
- 44:56add Bitcoin and you rebalance, you do better than just holding
- 45:00it. It shouldn't make sense, but
- 45:02yeah, it does. And it's it does for those
- 45:04reasons that you're talking about.
- 45:06And what I love about this is that this is such an easy sell
- 45:10and A and a great tool, especially for the advisor
- 45:13space, because you're strengthening and playing into
- 45:17people's emotions. What we just talked about,
- 45:19right? They know that if Bitcoin runs
- 45:23like crazy, it's not going to take over their portfolio and
- 45:26give them bigger swings. They know every quarter it's
- 45:29going to get paired back and it it seems like an active strategy
- 45:33because someone has to to pare it back.
- 45:34But it's not active in that you're trying to bet or time or
- 45:37anything. It's purely it's purely passive,
- 45:40right? It's purely just re simple
- 45:42rebalancing and it's something that's as old as as time.
- 45:46But then once you look at it with with Bitcoin in it, it, the
- 45:49results are incredible. And we were just talking about
- 45:51this earlier. I mentioned earlier AQR big
- 45:54quant shop, they released a perspective piece September 4 of
- 45:58this year called in praise of high volatility alternatives.
- 46:01And so I've got in front of me here, if you'll you'll indulge
- 46:03me, you'll see how this exactly connects.
- 46:06But first of all, Cliff talks about you shouldn't.
- 46:11Everyone knows that volatility is a is a drag over time at the
- 46:15portfolio level. If something goes up 50%, down
- 46:1750%, you're down 25%. But the key is you got to look
- 46:21at the individual components of it, right?
- 46:24And so he gives a hypothetical what if, what if you have an
- 46:28investment and a superior hypothetical investment?
- 46:31There's a 2/3 chance that you double your money and one third
- 46:35chance you lose it all and then assume this investment is
- 46:38uncorrelated to anything else. So he says two things are
- 46:41obvious. So they seem very obvious.
- 46:43The multi period compound return is clearly going to hit -100%.
- 46:48You're going to lose it at some point and then it's going to
- 46:51stay there. So obviously you want to put
- 46:53your whole portfolio into this, but anyone should put or should
- 46:58consider putting part of their portfolio in this investment
- 47:00because it has a positive expected return and only -100%
- 47:05on a very small part, part of the overall portfolio.
- 47:08It's imminently survivable. So when you lose or win, and
- 47:12this is his quote, you just reload and do it again.
- 47:15And that's the key. That's the volatility harvesting
- 47:17you're talking about. You have the ability to to
- 47:19reload when it goes down. And when it goes up, you take
- 47:22some chips off the table, right? And then he goes through with an
- 47:25actual example of stocks and bonds and then adding an alt and
- 47:29the alt he adds as a, as a quote, high Volt alt of only 25,
- 47:34which Bitcoin has couple multiples of that.
- 47:37But what's interesting is he shows as, as you add a higher
- 47:40volatility alt, if you're, if you're targeting a portfolio
- 47:46that has a total volatility and he uses only 10%.
- 47:49So you're optimizing the portfolio for a certain amount
- 47:52of volatility, the higher Volt alt is going to become a smaller
- 47:56and smaller part. And that's what allows you to,
- 47:59to do this because at any time you're only losing a small
- 48:03portion and you reload it again. And anytime it goes and
- 48:07outperforms you harvest that and take it off the table.
- 48:09So thanks for indulging me. I just came across this paper I
- 48:13read a couple weeks ago and, and a big light bulb moment went off
- 48:15where it's like, this is exactly what Mark is talking about.
- 48:18And he doesn't mention Bitcoin at all on this.
- 48:19Just to be clear, this is purely just a, a alts, purely
- 48:22quantitative way of thinking about this.
- 48:24So I, I, I think you're in solid quant foundational territory
- 48:28here with this idea. Yeah, it's support and there is
- 48:34when I was presenting once to someone up in Canada at one of
- 48:37the bigger banks, they said don't use the word Bitcoin in
- 48:41your chart, call it Vega Strategy 4.
- 48:48It's your option based with a little bit of bond and
- 48:51overwrites show that it's a construction using traditional
- 48:54assets that generates these types of returns.
- 48:57You'll get an audience. If you say add 3% Bitcoin,
- 49:00you're losing to 80% of people all.
- 49:02Right. It goes back to the knee jerk
- 49:04reaction against it, right? The personal bias that some
- 49:08people might have. Exactly.
- 49:11It's interesting how Chris, your example takes it to the extreme
- 49:16and if you, if you can accept the logic there, the the pure
- 49:20math of it in this extreme scenario of like of double or
- 49:24nothing, then and and you can wrap your head around, OK, yeah,
- 49:30if you get the small enough portfolio size or allocation
- 49:33size for that, then it's mathematically starts to make
- 49:36sense. You can convince yourself of, of
- 49:39the logic of it before you've even, you know, in the, in the
- 49:43abstract, in the theoretical realm without having to consider
- 49:47what asset you're even talking about.
- 49:49It's sort of a, a funny way to to math pill Bitcoin skeptics.
- 49:58And then and then the solution is, Oh, by the way, this is
- 50:01actually just Bitcoin. Yeah, it's like the old Pepsi
- 50:05Coke challenge, right? You, you drink it and they say
- 50:08who one you like better and then they reveal which one it was.
- 50:11You should, you should do that. Give them the the math, give
- 50:13them the stats, give them the chart and then reveal what it
- 50:15what it actually is. I love that.
- 50:20What do you think Rich? Would that would that work with
- 50:22the folks you're speaking with? You know, interestingly enough,
- 50:26I, I, I do think that, you know, over the course of the past 12
- 50:31to 18 months, the sentiment towards Bitcoin is evolved in a
- 50:35healthy way. And as it should.
- 50:37Frankly, I think, you know, there's been a lot of dispelling
- 50:40of, you know, fear and misunderstanding in the
- 50:43marketplace. And, and kudos to Fidelity
- 50:47digital assets and, and BlackRock and, and other
- 50:50companies that have really kind of stepped forward with an
- 50:56evolving point of view that allows, you know, for the
- 51:01broader registered investment advisor, family office
- 51:05investment professional to kind of refine and, and get a little
- 51:09bit more comfortable or take a second look and, and start
- 51:12acclimating, you know, to the virtues of the, of the asset.
- 51:18I'll, I'll tell you, you know, four years ago when I was
- 51:21working at Schwab, you know, when I would talk to people
- 51:23about, about Bitcoin with the conviction that I had and, you
- 51:28know, it was, you know, a non starter, like people would
- 51:32literally freeze up and, and, and, you know, you would be
- 51:38having a lot of, I don't know what I want to say, but just
- 51:42kind of rudimentary kind of basic level conversations with
- 51:45people, you know, from, you know, what may have started as a
- 51:48high level and interesting conversation to something that's
- 51:52very basic. And so I think the world is
- 51:54evolving very quickly and, and rightfully so, the asset is
- 51:58continuing to win and and the monetary policy, you know,
- 52:02continues to do the monetary policy of Bitcoin.
- 52:05And and I think, you know, people start recognizing that it
- 52:10was a very unique asset class and it's work like yours.
- 52:13Mark, you know that you just really produced here that help
- 52:20bring the academic, you know, and mathematic exercise that I
- 52:26think a lot of people need, right.
- 52:28When you are skeptical of something, you need relevant
- 52:33proof. And that's where a report like
- 52:37this, I think really, you know, hits the home run.
- 52:40It allows people to get out of the theoretical and and start
- 52:44actually looking at the academics of it and and you
- 52:47offer relevant proof that I think becomes hard for people to
- 52:51deny. And so at this point in, in, in
- 52:55bitcoins evolution, you know, I think people are starting to
- 53:00really warm to it. And, and I think that that's an
- 53:04exciting proposition. The question now becomes, you
- 53:07know, how do you access it And, you know, and how quickly can
- 53:11infrastructures be be built that make things easy on advisors?
- 53:15And where is the regulatory and, and the compliance world on
- 53:21these things too? So I mean, there's a lot of
- 53:22hurdles that advisors are sorting through.
- 53:25So we have to be fair to them, you know, in in saying it, they
- 53:30may actually really like the asset and have something
- 53:33interesting or have an interesting point of view about
- 53:35it. But they're but they're
- 53:36struggling with what is the right way to step into the
- 53:39asset. And I think that that's a
- 53:41healthy debate today that, you know, a lot of firms are having.
- 53:48The the reticence is just palpable.
- 53:52When we go to meetings, sometimes you'll be walked out,
- 53:55maybe by the CIO, sometimes by, you know, a, a junior or mid
- 54:01level analyst and they'll whisper, I own Bitcoin, but you
- 54:07know, we're not ready yet. Like it's almost like it's a,
- 54:11it's one of those POW things like blinking messages saying
- 54:14like, you know, I'm in, but we're not quite there.
- 54:17So it is at the edges. It is being discussed in the
- 54:21offices and as an anecdote, when you've been in it so long and
- 54:26Jesse's been in Bitcoin and I think Rich, you've been in
- 54:29longer than I have. And Chris, I know your your firm
- 54:33has been doing it before anyone knew about it.
- 54:36So I come at it from the problem side.
- 54:38But even in 3 1/2, almost four years in it, when I saw Judge
- 54:43Rowe's decision come out on August 29th of 23 and read her
- 54:47language that was saying the SEC was acting in a way that was
- 54:54arbitrary and capricious 8 times.
- 54:56And she basically held her feet to the fire about allowing the
- 55:00spot Bitcoin ETF for reasons like it's like a future getting
- 55:03not getting into the details. It was clear, it was pretty
- 55:06clear that the law was going to allow this.
- 55:09Bitcoin went up for like 2 days back down.
- 55:11It didn't move until the SEC decided not to pursue an appeal
- 55:17on October 13th, October 10th, that Friday I think of 23 and
- 55:23said no mas and then Bitcoin went straight up for six months.
- 55:28I don't know. It went up almost three times
- 55:30what 28,000 to 73,000 through March of 24.
- 55:35And I think this is a total show me asset.
- 55:38People need to be sold Bitcoin. The ETS helped your work.
- 55:43Chris is obviously helping, but showing how you can do it
- 55:46without getting in trouble. That's why I like this
- 55:48rebalancing. You won't even see it folks.
- 55:51It'll just help you. You don't have to.
- 55:54You can tell your clients. I know other folks have multi
- 55:57assets where they have the ability to put it in and they're
- 55:59just putting in one to 3% because they have the ability to
- 56:03do it in their, you know, close end funds etcetera.
- 56:07So that's what we're offering. Come to us, come to obviously
- 56:10Chris and team have been doing this forever.
- 56:13We'll walk you through it as advisors, but there's a way to
- 56:16offer it without having it hit you in the back of the head.
- 56:20We believe it passes Prologue. Interesting, Mark.
- 56:26And something that's not displayed in the report.
- 56:28But you know, you did a lot of work behind the scenes with with
- 56:32other allocations too inside of a 6040 model.
- 56:37I mean, you took it, you know, 135710, you know, I think you
- 56:44even went up to 25% allocations. Now, I'm not, you know,
- 56:47suggesting that that's anything that an advisor would do, but
- 56:53but really quite compelling numbers regardless of where you
- 56:58were on a risk adjusted basis. It was quite fascinating.
- 57:03And, and I applaud you for all the great work that you've done
- 57:06and a lot of fun to to kind of see that process unfold.
- 57:12I know it was a labor of love on you, on your end and you, you,
- 57:16you certainly involved a lot of different people, you know, to
- 57:20get a second set and third set of lenses on it and contribute
- 57:23to the report. And so, you know, it's a pretty,
- 57:27pretty amazing report. And so if if somebody wants to
- 57:31get a hold of that report, Mark, maybe maybe share how, how,
- 57:36what's the best way for people to get that?
- 57:39I would e-mail, you know me, Mark, at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 57:45It's we'll have it on our website, it's on our LinkedIn.
- 57:50And yes, I don't know if you have any other suggestions, but
- 57:54I think those are the main ways. Cam Strom is also and Jackson
- 58:01Mikhailich are are two of our lead salespeople.
- 58:05So yeah. Just reach out to us.
- 58:07Just reach out to us and and you mentioned about Sharon, I want
- 58:10to thank there were a lot of people who went over this.
- 58:13I couldn't believe some of the results.
- 58:14I want to make sure I got the math right.
- 58:17Chris mentioned speaking to your firm.
- 58:19Part of it was just sharing it for, like, feedback, very
- 58:22helpful from your team when you gave it to me injured.
- 58:26Barden, who ran a division of equities at Merrill Lynch and
- 58:31then at Credit Swiss later. I went over with him three years
- 58:34ago when I first discovered it, and I couldn't believe it.
- 58:36And he helped me. And then there were a bunch of
- 58:38others more recently like, you know, Joel at 2 Ocean and his
- 58:44team. So this is collaborative.
- 58:47I'm not a quantified design and that's why it helps to have
- 58:52Cliff's Cliff's notes help me out and support that.
- 58:56You mentioned Chris from from AQR just to get that support.
- 59:02Yeah, it's, it's another one of those examples of, of Bitcoin
- 59:06being requiring some quant analysis, but also a certain
- 59:11high level ability to ask the right questions, you know, as
- 59:19almost an art rather than, you know, pure quantitative science.
- 59:25And I think that's a big part of why people have missed this to
- 59:28date, Mark is it's it's the right, it's the right lens, the
- 59:32right questions, which comes from a place of understanding
- 59:38the asset first. You have to have a certain level
- 59:41of understanding of what's going on and then identifying the
- 59:45pattern that you're experiencing and then wondering why that's
- 59:49happening. And then you get to the the
- 59:51right data from there. But you know, it's and I think
- 59:54that's why someone, Someone Like You who has a background in
- 59:58markets, but is maybe not necessarily a traditional quant
- 1:00:02had the right set of questions, the right experience to say,
- 1:00:06hold on, something's different here.
- 1:00:08Let's see if I can put my finger on it.
- 1:00:10And Mark, I know we've talked about for me I think.
- 1:00:15I think what you've spotlighted here will be the story for
- 1:00:20traditional finance getting into Bitcoin over the next decade.
- 1:00:27That story will be one of at what point in time does each
- 1:00:31shop on Wall Street realize that this is the reality of Bitcoin,
- 1:00:36that this data is playing out and that this is good volatility
- 1:00:41that you should seek out and include in your portfolio
- 1:00:44allocations. That's, that's, that's just a
- 1:00:48exercise that every shop on Wall Street, every traditional
- 1:00:53finance firm in the world will have to go through at some point
- 1:00:56because Bitcoin is simply there, it's delivering this kind of
- 1:01:00performance. And it's, it's there to be
- 1:01:03harvested, as you point out. And you're either going to get
- 1:01:08left behind by the firms that do embrace this, or you're going to
- 1:01:12be at, you know, the tip of the spear of the leading edge and
- 1:01:16you're going to get an, an advantage on your competitors.
- 1:01:19That's going to be the story of, of traditional finance and
- 1:01:22Bitcoin over the next 10 or 20 years is when do you embrace
- 1:01:25this and include it in, in your strategy for your clients?
- 1:01:30Or do you fall behind because your competitors do?
- 1:01:35Yeah. And back to what Chris was
- 1:01:38highlighted, Jesse, when you're talking about where I come from
- 1:01:42asking the questions definitely because I wasn't not a quant,
- 1:01:45I'm like, wait a minute, how's this working?
- 1:01:47So I got even more whether it be insecure or or rigorous in my
- 1:01:52work about making sure that I hit this right.
- 1:01:57It's along the lines of what Chris, in your Nashville speech
- 1:02:01you pulled from out of those Munger or Buffett or on the
- 1:02:05invert. But why don't you talk about
- 1:02:07that? Because I did that without even
- 1:02:09knowing that that was what, you know, a process that he pulled
- 1:02:13on. Yeah, it's a phrase I've been
- 1:02:17borrowing from Munger. Who he actually hated Bitcoin,
- 1:02:20you know, the late Charlie Munger, Warren Buffett's
- 1:02:22partner. But he said he of course had a
- 1:02:25very unique perspective as as to how he analyzed investments.
- 1:02:28And he's one of the keys to his success was always inverting the
- 1:02:32question. And it actually doesn't come
- 1:02:33from him. It's just we know it more from
- 1:02:35him because of the investment side.
- 1:02:37It comes from a mathematician almost a century or more before
- 1:02:42him who was able to figure out a lot of different mathematical
- 1:02:46discoveries by inverting the question.
- 1:02:48So to make it more tangible though, the the the funny one
- 1:02:51that Munger says is he was a meteorologist in the Army or the
- 1:02:55Air Force and his job was to look at weather patterns and
- 1:02:58make sure planes were OK to fly and, and keep them safe.
- 1:03:01So rather than saying how do I keep planes safe and keep the
- 1:03:04pilot safe, he inverted the question and said if I wanted to
- 1:03:07kill as many pilots as possible, what would I do?
- 1:03:10And he came to two conclusions. He would say, I'd, I'd put them
- 1:03:13in weather where they couldn't land, sock them in fog or, or
- 1:03:16storms, so they'd run out of fuel or I, or it would be too
- 1:03:20icy. I put their, their wings in icy
- 1:03:21conditions. And so those were his two
- 1:03:24guideposts that he laser focused on.
- 1:03:26And of course, he did that with his investments as well.
- 1:03:29And so I took that idea and I said, let's stop from this
- 1:03:34perspective of here's Bitcoin, here's what it is, here's why
- 1:03:37you should consider it. Here's all the stats and invert
- 1:03:40the question to people because I think we're now at a point of
- 1:03:43maturity where we've got the the data on our side and your report
- 1:03:47adds a huge amount to that. We have the data on our side
- 1:03:50where we should be putting it to these investment advisors and
- 1:03:53asking them, why haven't you considered Bitcoin?
- 1:03:56Why aren't you, Why aren't you looking at this?
- 1:03:59Why don't you have an answer? Why is it always just a hand
- 1:04:02waving or too volatile or something like that?
- 1:04:04And, and of course, I mean that a bit facetiously.
- 1:04:06We're not going to be as rude or blunt to people, but it is
- 1:04:10getting to that point where you've been in the space a long
- 1:04:13time and you start to get frustrated with with this, this
- 1:04:15idea and this question that I think we're there.
- 1:04:18We have the infrastructure, we have some regulatory clarity.
- 1:04:21All of these barriers are falling by the wayside and that
- 1:04:23number one volatility needs to be broken down as well.
- 1:04:27And so that's where this report and and others I think are
- 1:04:30really going to help in that endeavor.
- 1:04:31Well. Thanks for that.
- 1:04:35I'll add that Bitcoin is the 10th largest asset by market
- 1:04:39cap. And guess what number 11 is?
- 1:04:42Berkshire, Right. Well, and the powerful thing
- 1:04:47about that question is it forces people to have an opinion.
- 1:04:51And to be clear, for some people, it still might not make
- 1:04:54sense for whatever reason. And that's, that's fine.
- 1:04:57But at least have an opinion. At least do the exercise, at
- 1:05:01least do the homework, do your due diligence.
- 1:05:03Take your, your, your responsibility seriously here.
- 1:05:07Your, your fiscal responsibility for this, your fiduciary
- 1:05:11responsibility. That's, that's what we want to
- 1:05:13emphasize here. At least have an opinion.
- 1:05:17And and as Pierre, I think Pierre Rashard points out, there
- 1:05:19are no well informed critics. So you you might find that as
- 1:05:24you develop your opinion through informed research, you may
- 1:05:30become you may your views may shift from what they previously
- 1:05:35were. Yeah, well, that's AI think a
- 1:05:40healthy, healthy place for us to call it a call it a wake up
- 1:05:44call. And Chris, I can't thank you
- 1:05:48enough for taking the time to join us.
- 1:05:51And, and, and also Fidelity digital assets.
- 1:05:55You know, you guys have been great champions of of Bitcoin
- 1:06:00and and certainly have been a great partner to us and giving
- 1:06:04us second set of eyes on the work that we're doing.
- 1:06:07And and so we're, we're grateful for all that you're doing in the
- 1:06:12space to advance Bitcoin and bring it forward for others.
- 1:06:16And, and Jesse, thank you also. I know you're a little bit under
- 1:06:20the weather, but it didn't show you look fantastic and only a
- 1:06:25few little coughs along the way. But thank you for taking time
- 1:06:28and sharing your perspectives with our audience.
- 1:06:32And we'd love to have you guys both back on the show at some
- 1:06:34point in the in the not too distant future.
- 1:06:38Mark, congratulations on a terrific piece.
- 1:06:42I know that segment 1 is, you know, out and and we'll be
- 1:06:48talking about, you know, the three-part series.
- 1:06:51We tried to break it down, I think partially because it is a
- 1:06:54behemoth of a report. Remind me off the top of my
- 1:06:58head, I want to say it's roughly 50 pages long.
- 1:07:01So we we tried to dissect it. Yeah, 45 pages.
- 1:07:05OK, With that being said, you can if you want to learn more
- 1:07:11about the work that has been produced in the conversations
- 1:07:15that we've had, we'll do whatever we can to support you
- 1:07:18and your firm to, you know one providing the report to you.
- 1:07:24So you can visit on rampbitcoin.com or you can reach
- 1:07:28out to Mark or or myself directly.
- 1:07:32We'll be happy to make certain that you get that report and
- 1:07:36then, you know, perhaps we'll even do a webinar or something
- 1:07:40where you can sign up and and be a participant and ask questions
- 1:07:44along the way. So stay tuned on that and we'll
- 1:07:47continue to try to bring things that help you, one, you know, be
- 1:07:54better for your clients and two, to attract new and interesting
- 1:07:59clients as well to your business.
- 1:08:00And, and hopefully this research helps solidify that and, and put
- 1:08:04you in a position of a, you know, a first mover and gives
- 1:08:09you some level of advantage with, with how you're trying to
- 1:08:13grow your business in your market.
- 1:08:14So thank you all, Chris, Jesse, Mark loved listening to you and
- 1:08:21thanks for joining us today. My pleasure.
- 1:08:24Thanks for having. Me.
- 1:08:24Thanks, Chris. Thanks everybody.
- 1:08:26Thank you, Rich. Thanks for listening to this
- 1:08:29week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 1:08:32valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 1:08:34rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 1:08:36All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 1:08:39notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 1:08:42reminder that On Rat Media is for informational and
- 1:08:44entertainment purposes only and nothing should be construed as
- 1:08:47investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 1:08:50your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 1:08:52Visit on rantbitcoin.com Contact to schedule a consultation with
- 1:08:57one of our private client advisors.