Latest / Toronto Talks / We Need to be a Country of Business with CIBC's Lisa Raitt
Transcript
- 0:00Lisa Raitt: Canada has to turn into a country of business. We're not at the moment. We're not.
- 0:05GIles Gherson: Hello, I'm Giles Gerson, and this is Toronto Talks, the voice of Toronto's business community.
- 0:11GIles Gherson: What are we talking about? Each episode is a conversation with top business leaders about
- 0:16GIles Gherson: how they're shaping growth, driving competitiveness, and building up our economy. It's about what they
- 0:21GIles Gherson: believe it will take to make sure the Toronto region remains one of the world's great global
- 0:26GIles Gherson: cities. Here's today's conversation. Lisa, welcome to Toronto Talks. Thank you very much.
- 0:32GIles Gherson: And we're delighted to have you and actually excited to have you. We've been looking to have
- 0:36GIles Gherson: you for some time. Why? Because you have your respected voice, a long-standing respected voice,
- 0:42GIles Gherson: an influential voice on economic and business policy, which is what we like to talk about.
- 0:47GIles Gherson: And of course, you are a member of the Business Council of Toronto's Climate and Energy Transition
- 0:52GIles Gherson: Council, which is
- 0:54GIles Gherson: incidental in this conversation, but important
- 0:56GIles Gherson: because you do play a significant role there.
- 0:58GIles Gherson: But when I think about your career,
- 1:00GIles Gherson: and I want to ask you a little bit about this, but
- 1:02GIles Gherson: you were an MP for 11 years.
- 1:04GIles Gherson: You were a member of cabinet
- 1:06GIles Gherson: in three big portfolios.
- 1:08GIles Gherson: Natural resources, labor,
- 1:10GIles Gherson: and transport.
- 1:13GIles Gherson: Deputy chair of CIBC.
- 1:16GIles Gherson: And
- 1:17GIles Gherson: that's all.
- 1:18GIles Gherson: And then you started, of course,
- 1:20GIles Gherson: with Anne McClellan.
- 1:21GIles Gherson: a whole organization devoted to productivity and growth,
- 1:25GIles Gherson: which is what we're very keen on ourselves.
- 1:28GIles Gherson: But I want to just ask you, you grew up in Sydney, Nova Scotia.
- 1:32GIles Gherson: You had an incredible career.
- 1:34GIles Gherson: Was it planned?
- 1:36Lisa Raitt: No.
- 1:38Lisa Raitt: No, no, no, no.
- 1:38GIles Gherson: Did you imagine as a child that you would be doing what you're doing today?
- 1:42Lisa Raitt: As a child, I wanted to be prime minister.
- 1:45Lisa Raitt: Oh, there we are.
- 1:45Lisa Raitt: So there's always been some kind of interest in politics.
- 1:49Lisa Raitt: No question about that.
- 1:50Lisa Raitt: I've always been attracted to leadership.
- 1:52Lisa Raitt: So I was part of the student council, that kind of stuff.
- 1:55Lisa Raitt: I've always been a little bit of a climber kind of thing.
- 1:58Lisa Raitt: But did I think I was going to be at the Port of Toronto?
- 2:00Lisa Raitt: No.
- 2:01Lisa Raitt: Didn't even think I was going to be a lawyer.
- 2:03Lisa Raitt: Harbormaster and CEO.
- 2:04Lisa Raitt: It was a great corporate secretary.
- 2:06Lisa Raitt: What a place to learn about everything.
- 2:10Lisa Raitt: And I was just blessed.
- 2:11Lisa Raitt: But no, no plan at all.
- 2:13Lisa Raitt: Went to St. FX.
- 2:13Lisa Raitt: In fact, I started in science.
- 2:15Lisa Raitt: I got a master's in chemistry.
- 2:17Lisa Raitt: And yeah, don't really use that.
- 2:18Lisa Raitt: But it's, you know, I just kind of, every time something came up, I leveled up and put my hand up for it.
- 2:26Lisa Raitt: And it just dragged me along.
- 2:28GIles Gherson: Grabbing the opportunities as they came.
- 2:30Lisa Raitt: Yeah, kind of getting swept up.
- 2:31Lisa Raitt: NCIBC being there now, I never would have thought I'd work for a bank, quite frankly.
- 2:35Lisa Raitt: Listen, I'll tell you a secret.
- 2:37Lisa Raitt: When politicians are thinking about their next move in life, the holy grail is to land a place at the bank.
- 2:43Lisa Raitt: Absolutely.
- 2:44Lisa Raitt: Internally, there's always a pecking order.
- 2:46Lisa Raitt: It's like, well, no, Prentice and then Flaherty and Baird and maybe Kenny.
- 2:50Lisa Raitt: Raitt's name never came on the list of where you'd end up at a bank.
- 2:53GIles Gherson: But then I did.
- 2:53Lisa Raitt: Glad I did.
- 2:54GIles Gherson: Yeah.
- 2:55GIles Gherson: And you've enjoyed that, obviously.
- 2:56Lisa Raitt: I really do.
- 2:56Lisa Raitt: I like it.
- 2:58Lisa Raitt: And I think it's because the government has become so entrenched in economic policy in
- 3:03Lisa Raitt: the last six years that I've actually been able to be useful.
- 3:06Lisa Raitt: And I'm glad.
- 3:07Lisa Raitt: And thank you for the invitation to sit on the Business Council of Toronto.
- 3:10GIles Gherson: Well, that's all about, as you know, business leaders leaning in on productivity and growth.
- 3:15GIles Gherson: I mean, one of the things that I think is probably fair to say is that the business community in Canada is polite and relatively passive, I think, compared to their U.S. counterparts.
- 3:27GIles Gherson: And I think from our perspective, we felt that we needed a little bit more energy in terms of fighting for the kinds of policies that would drive economic growth and prosperity.
- 3:38GIles Gherson: Because I think one of the things we reflect on here at the board is that we've had about 10 years of flatlined income growth in Canada.
- 3:48GIles Gherson: And that's not good for anyone.
- 3:49GIles Gherson: But the only way you're going to drive that up is with a stronger economy.
- 3:52GIles Gherson: And so how do you get that economy onto a higher growth path for all of our benefits?
- 3:56GIles Gherson: And that's what we're really interested in.
- 3:58Lisa Raitt: Yeah.
- 3:58Lisa Raitt: And you guys push on policy.
- 4:00Lisa Raitt: So the thing that Ann and I do is we came at it from a different point of view, recognized, obviously, the problem we were having, particularly in GDP per capita.
- 4:08Lisa Raitt: And you know that is a metric that if it keeps going down is going to really show up in people's day-to-day lives.
- 4:14GIles Gherson: I think it is.
- 4:15GIles Gherson: I think it is.
- 4:16Lisa Raitt: And it has.
- 4:16Lisa Raitt: So we started this organization with the help of the Business Council of Canada, actually.
- 4:21Lisa Raitt: They're no longer part of it, but they got us going.
- 4:23Lisa Raitt: and we measure markers we measure kpis every year the same 21 kpis just to catch trends on what's
- 4:31Lisa Raitt: happening in the country trend isn't good giles it's not good at all it's going like that yeah
- 4:35Lisa Raitt: and we're not making any progress in a couple of the key areas we communicate that to yourself we
- 4:41Lisa Raitt: communicate it to politicians bureaucrats just kind of like sending them the message you really
- 4:46Lisa Raitt: got to do something now now is the time you don't have the luxury of waiting 10 years boom by no 10
- 4:53GIles Gherson: I mean, it's interesting because when I became CEO of the Board of Trade, we did some work with Boston Consulting Suicider.
- 5:03GIles Gherson: What is the GDP per capita?
- 5:04GIles Gherson: I know.
- 5:05GIles Gherson: So what is our income per capita in the GTHA compared to U.S. cities?
- 5:11GIles Gherson: Because we almost compare ourselves to Canadian cities, but we're the largest city in Canada, 20% of the national economy.
- 5:17GIles Gherson: What's more interesting is how are we comparing with our neighbors to the south?
- 5:20GIles Gherson: And so they went away and did the work and they came back.
- 5:22GIles Gherson: And what they told us was, this is about three years ago now, that GDP per capita in the GTHA was $113,000 Canadian.
- 5:32GIles Gherson: To the average of 11 U.S. major metros, it was $185,000.
- 5:37GIles Gherson: So a $72,000 per worker gap in output.
- 5:41GIles Gherson: Wow.
- 5:42GIles Gherson: That's significant.
- 5:43GIles Gherson: Actually, we asked them to do it a year ago, to go back and look at the numbers.
- 5:47GIles Gherson: To your point, has anything improved?
- 5:49GIles Gherson: It was now a $99,000 gap.
- 5:51Lisa Raitt: So nearly $100,000 is getting worse.
- 5:53Lisa Raitt: It's getting worse.
- 5:54Lisa Raitt: And people are struggling, and they don't know why they're struggling, but it's this constant drip, drip, drip, drip, drip.
- 6:00Lisa Raitt: And the problem with long-term growth, you know it, is it takes a while to get that flywheel going before you can actually see the results.
- 6:07GIles Gherson: And people want immediacy, but it's hard to get that.
- 6:09GIles Gherson: What I was going to ask you was, given the scale of the gap, I mean, the way to define it, I think, is to say we are poorer than our American neighbors.
- 6:18GIles Gherson: If there's a $100,000 gap between what our workers put out and what their sort of workers put out in terms of the economy, that is significant.
- 6:28GIles Gherson: And we're a lot poorer than we probably think we are, to coin a phrase.
- 6:34GIles Gherson: And so yet there's still a lot of complacency around that.
- 6:38GIles Gherson: I mean, I find that interesting because, you know, people travel to the U.S.
- 6:41GIles Gherson: They see essentially, I think, you know, a landscape that is wealthier.
- 6:46Lisa Raitt: because they believe one thing that makes them erroneously build in extra money to their 99,000,
- 6:55Lisa Raitt: which is healthcare is free. That's what they think to themselves.
- 6:58GIles Gherson: Yeah. Well, especially paid for by our kids, probably.
- 7:00Lisa Raitt: I agree with you. I agree with you. But healthcare is free. Therefore,
- 7:04Lisa Raitt: we're not as bad as the United States. And until you see, and you're seeing it right now,
- 7:08Lisa Raitt: quite frankly, the amount of people who are choosing to start businesses in the United States,
- 7:14Lisa Raitt: go to their careers in the United States.
- 7:15GIles Gherson: We've talked about this.
- 7:16GIles Gherson: We've talked about the outflow of capital.
- 7:17Lisa Raitt: This is a big problem.
- 7:18Lisa Raitt: Not only capital, human resources.
- 7:20Lisa Raitt: Human resources.
- 7:21Lisa Raitt: Lots of kids, professionals, especially in this city,
- 7:23Lisa Raitt: have decided they're going to make their path in the United States
- 7:26Lisa Raitt: because they figured out the delta,
- 7:28Lisa Raitt: which is houses are a little bit more affordable in the United States.
- 7:31Lisa Raitt: They're getting paid $100,000 more, at least.
- 7:34Lisa Raitt: You have the numbers yourselves.
- 7:36Lisa Raitt: And they can buy their health insurance.
- 7:37GIles Gherson: Yeah.
- 7:38Lisa Raitt: They can buy it.
- 7:39GIles Gherson: They rely on it probably too.
- 7:40GIles Gherson: I mean, that is becoming the issue though.
- 7:43GIles Gherson: that is this flow of talent.
- 7:47GIles Gherson: And what we find is that many people
- 7:50GIles Gherson: who have made it here then go to the U.S.
- 7:53GIles Gherson: because they think their opportunities are larger there.
- 7:56GIles Gherson: And probably they are.
- 7:57GIles Gherson: And they're seeing their kids do the same thing
- 7:59GIles Gherson: as you just pointed out.
- 8:00GIles Gherson: And then companies, what we're finding
- 8:02GIles Gherson: is a number of our members are really in the last year,
- 8:06GIles Gherson: interestingly, I mean, it was happening for 10 years.
- 8:08GIles Gherson: But it's kind of sped up
- 8:09GIles Gherson: because companies want to get behind the tariff wall.
- 8:11GIles Gherson: Of course.
- 8:12GIles Gherson: access to that large market, don't have to worry about tariffs. And then you get all kinds of
- 8:17GIles Gherson: benefits once you're there that people often aren't aware of. You get a property tax rebate
- 8:22GIles Gherson: probably for 10 years. You're going to have some subsidy for your-
- 8:25GIles Gherson: Yeah. Your mortgages are very different down there.
- 8:27GIles Gherson: Yeah. And we don't realize, I think, the gap. And so once you're there, I mean, I've talked to a
- 8:32GIles Gherson: number of folks who've gone there and expanded their businesses there. And what I always hear
- 8:37GIles Gherson: back from them is, wow, I wish I'd done this earlier. And I hate to hear that because we're
- 8:41GIles Gherson: about growing the Canadian economy and growing the Toronto economy, but what can we do about that?
- 8:46GIles Gherson: We had an election last year, a new prime minister, Mark Carney. What intrigued us about his agenda
- 8:56GIles Gherson: was a phrase, which is, we need a wave of capital. We need to ignite a wave of capital
- 9:02GIles Gherson: to grow our productivity and our economy. And we completely agree with that.
- 9:06GIles Gherson: What's your assessment of the past years? You said that numbers haven't really changed
- 9:10GIles Gherson: yet? What are we seeing? Okay, so it's not necessarily a positive review, but what I'm
- 9:16Lisa Raitt: going to say is this stuff takes time. So I'm not going to hack on them for not trying. A for effort,
- 9:22Lisa Raitt: A plus for effort, no question about it. But we got to have a reality check, right? Some of the
- 9:28Lisa Raitt: projects that he's talking about, so the data centers, pipelines, listen, we don't need foreign
- 9:33Lisa Raitt: investment. We've got big companies right here in Canada who have a balance sheet who can do these
- 9:37Lisa Raitt: things. What they need is regulatory certainty, which the prime minister can deliver a little
- 9:42Lisa Raitt: bit quicker than going to Saudi Arabia or going to the Emirates and bringing back investment. So
- 9:47Lisa Raitt: when we talk about bringing investment here, be really careful about what it is we actually need.
- 9:53Lisa Raitt: I think we do need investment in terms of manufacturing. I think there's a lot of
- 9:58Lisa Raitt: Canadian manufacturers who would love to have access to bigger pools of capital. So more
- 10:02Lisa Raitt: investors that are available, angel investors, mid investors, all those kinds of things.
- 10:07Lisa Raitt: Not necessarily foreign investment.
- 10:10Lisa Raitt: So look in the pool that you have here as well.
- 10:12Lisa Raitt: Make it easier for people to be able to invest in Canadian things.
- 10:17Lisa Raitt: Make it easier for the pension plans to be able to invest in things that are going to
- 10:20Lisa Raitt: drive productivity and connectivity.
- 10:22Lisa Raitt: Those things, I think, are matter.
- 10:25Lisa Raitt: So I agree that he has to do what he's doing to open up markets, but it's not just about
- 10:30Lisa Raitt: investment.
- 10:30Lisa Raitt: It's about making sure that we have that good balance going forward.
- 10:35GIles Gherson: I mean, when you hear the government, the prime minister talk and cabinet, they talk about crowding in investment, which is kind of interesting phrase because I think for the last 10 years, we kind of crowded out investment.
- 10:45GIles Gherson: Right.
- 10:46GIles Gherson: And they talk about crowding in investment and they really focus on three areas that are kind of government driven.
- 10:53GIles Gherson: Defense, growing the defense budget and having a defense investment agency to sort of try to coordinate, I guess, investment in defense industries.
- 11:02GIles Gherson: They've talked about housing, which is a critical issue, building houses faster across the country through the Build Canada housing.
- 11:13GIles Gherson: And then you've got infrastructure with the major projects office in Calgary trying to coordinate.
- 11:20GIles Gherson: But interestingly, it's sort of using government capital to try to pull in capital from domestic sources, from private sources.
- 11:30GIles Gherson: What's missing, it seems to me, is the rest of the economy.
- 11:34GIles Gherson: Lisa Raid has a company.
- 11:35GIles Gherson: She wants to grow her company.
- 11:36GIles Gherson: It's in manufacturing.
- 11:39GIles Gherson: What's she going to do?
- 11:39GIles Gherson: She needs to grow.
- 11:41GIles Gherson: She needs to probably bring on new technology.
- 11:44GIles Gherson: We're seeing a massive wave of technology change.
- 11:46GIles Gherson: You have to invest in that technology.
- 11:48GIles Gherson: Where are you going to get that capital from?
- 11:51GIles Gherson: What about the regulations?
- 11:52GIles Gherson: What about the taxes that you're going to be paying?
- 11:55GIles Gherson: And so it seems to us that the big missing piece in the agenda so far
- 11:59GIles Gherson: has been unleashing private capital to do whatever it wants to do, as opposed to defense, which is
- 12:06GIles Gherson: important, housing, very important, and infrastructure, very important. But what about
- 12:11GIles Gherson: the rest of the economy where you're going to get the flywheel spinning? And it seems to have some
- 12:19GIles Gherson: regulation attacks. We haven't seen a whole lot. We have not. And I agree with you vehemently. I
- 12:24Lisa Raitt: think you're exactly correct. When you take a look at housing, look, that is a silo of importance
- 12:29Lisa Raitt: from a political point of view as well, right? People are very frustrated and upset by the fact
- 12:35Lisa Raitt: that they can't afford the market. Well, you can't afford the market for two reasons. We haven't
- 12:39Lisa Raitt: built because of all the regulatory expenses and all that stuff. But as well, you don't make enough
- 12:43Lisa Raitt: money, right? Salaries are deflated. They're just not making enough money to get into the market.
- 12:49GIles Gherson: That's not flatlining of income. That's exactly it. If it had grown, maybe you've been able to
- 12:52Lisa Raitt: grow with the market, maybe because that's a market force. On defense, what foreign investment
- 12:58Lisa Raitt: is going to be truly able to bring in money for defense in our country. Like really, when you
- 13:04Lisa Raitt: think about it, the Chinese, the Germans, I don't know how that's necessarily going to work. Perhaps
- 13:11Lisa Raitt: what it's about is just buying subs from South Korea or whatever they're going to do with the
- 13:15Lisa Raitt: subs with Sweden, that kind of horse trading in terms of we'll give you this if you give us that.
- 13:20Lisa Raitt: So those are big plays. But again, the jobs associated with those are finite and they're
- 13:27Lisa Raitt: not getting to the number of the problem, which is innovation and entrepreneurship, in order to
- 13:31Lisa Raitt: create those great new Canadian companies. And they are bereft of policy around that stuff. I know
- 13:36Lisa Raitt: that's not fair to say, but I'm not seeing anything that gets my 21-year-old son excited about starting
- 13:42Lisa Raitt: a company in Canada. All he hears is it's going to be so difficult. Well, it's interesting. When
- 13:46GIles Gherson: you think about both the Biden administration and then the Trump administration in the U.S.,
- 13:51GIles Gherson: in the Biden administration, they were trying to re-industrialize quite aggressively using
- 13:56GIles Gherson: subsidies, right? The IRA subsidies, the Inflation Reduction Act subsidy. It was like a piñata,
- 14:03GIles Gherson: right? A huge amount of, like almost a trillion dollars. And even Canadian companies said,
- 14:08Lisa Raitt: how do I grab a stick and beat that piñata and get the money? And so a lot of companies
- 14:13GIles Gherson: moved south under the Biden administration to get access to these kinds of subsidies.
- 14:18GIles Gherson: Then came Trump and the Big Beautiful Bill Act, significant tax reform again. He did it Trump one,
- 14:24GIles Gherson: did it in Trump too. And the combination of those two has really left our corporate tax system
- 14:30GIles Gherson: way out of line with the US. Putting aside things like taxes on small business,
- 14:38GIles Gherson: I mean, we're really far out of line. And when we talk to politicians, they'll say,
- 14:44GIles Gherson: or government administrative finance, both federal and provincially, they'll say, well,
- 14:49GIles Gherson: Two things. One, we've got a limited amount of resources to do tax reform.
- 14:55GIles Gherson: And then the second thing they'll say is, often you don't get much of an impact.
- 15:01GIles Gherson: But I beg to differ because it seems to me that what Biden did and what Trump did was turn heads.
- 15:07GIles Gherson: They did big stuff that caused people to say, I got to get a piece of that, right?
- 15:12GIles Gherson: Even Canadian investors, I got to get a piece of that in the US.
- 15:14GIles Gherson: We tend to do small things here.
- 15:17GIles Gherson: Small adjustment to tax here, small adjustment to regulation there.
- 15:21GIles Gherson: Heads aren't really turned.
- 15:22GIles Gherson: And then the finance departments, whether in Queens Park or in Ottawa, say, well, we didn't
- 15:28GIles Gherson: get much of an impact for that.
- 15:28GIles Gherson: Why would we do more?
- 15:30GIles Gherson: The answer is you didn't do enough to cause people.
- 15:33GIles Gherson: I mean, Lord Keynes, the great economist, said economics is about animal spirits, right?
- 15:38GIles Gherson: It's getting excited, either positively or negatively, right?
- 15:43GIles Gherson: Yeah.
- 15:44GIles Gherson: Where's the animal spirit?
- 15:45GIles Gherson: You know, you got to get those animal spirits going.
- 15:48GIles Gherson: What do you think about that?
- 15:49GIles Gherson: I mean, do you think that, I mean, I think we need a more aggressive policy.
- 15:52Lisa Raitt: We do, but we also need execution.
- 15:55Lisa Raitt: So let's use India as an example.
- 15:57Lisa Raitt: Big trip to India.
- 15:58Lisa Raitt: Very important relationship.
- 16:00Lisa Raitt: So when you think about it from Modi's point of view, right, 2047 is the 100th anniversary
- 16:06Lisa Raitt: of independence.
- 16:07Lisa Raitt: Big anniversary.
- 16:08Lisa Raitt: They want to be ready for it.
- 16:09Lisa Raitt: They talk about, they want 200 new airports in India.
- 16:12Lisa Raitt: They talk about adding thousands and thousands and thousands of gigawatts to the actual grade.
- 16:19Lisa Raitt: Canada can play very well in those two spaces.
- 16:22Lisa Raitt: It is an incredible opportunity for Canada.
- 16:24Lisa Raitt: So yeah, Prime Minister goes.
- 16:25Lisa Raitt: That's great.
- 16:26Lisa Raitt: And they say, hypothetically, I'm not saying this is what they said, but hypothetically,
- 16:30Lisa Raitt: they say, we'll take everything you got.
- 16:32Lisa Raitt: Like, we need it all.
- 16:33Lisa Raitt: Just send it.
- 16:34Lisa Raitt: But can you send it to us?
- 16:35Lisa Raitt: And we only have like between 2026 and 2047.
- 16:40Lisa Raitt: We've got 20 years here.
- 16:41Lisa Raitt: I don't have 11 years to wait for you to go through a regulatory process.
- 16:45Lisa Raitt: So can you deliver in the next three years?
- 16:47Lisa Raitt: And I think that is the piece that's missing in order to get people excited.
- 16:51Lisa Raitt: I think the major projects office was an exciting announcement.
- 16:54Lisa Raitt: I think that allowed the prime minister to go out and say, I'm in charge.
- 16:58Lisa Raitt: Things are different.
- 16:59Lisa Raitt: Watch me.
- 17:00Lisa Raitt: And now we're not seeing anything.
- 17:02Lisa Raitt: And the longer that time goes, the more difficult it's going to be for the other big players
- 17:07Lisa Raitt: in the world who want to import from us, not companies coming in to invest, but people who
- 17:11Lisa Raitt: want to buy our stuff, saying, well, can they really depend upon them? Can they really get it
- 17:16Lisa Raitt: done this time? Because everybody knows that we totally fumbled the ball when it came to LNG the
- 17:22GIles Gherson: first time around. We got a second chance to do this. Let's see. Now it's going, which is good.
- 17:26Lisa Raitt: Maybe. Yeah. Well, it is. No, we have LNG and we've got Cedar coming on and we've got wood fiber. I
- 17:31Lisa Raitt: mean, all those good things are really good. But yeah, let's see. They're saying, yeah, let's see.
- 17:36GIles Gherson: Well, I mean, it's interesting. I mean, I think that we probably are going to see some announcements from the major projects office.
- 17:40GIles Gherson: My sense is they're kind of spooling up and then they'll make some announcements soon, which will be great, I think, for confidence.
- 17:46GIles Gherson: But it's a finite number of projects.
- 17:48GIles Gherson: I mean, if you look at Southern Ontario here for where we are, there's really only one project out of the 33 that have been announced so far.
- 17:58GIles Gherson: It's the SMRs in Darlington.
- 17:59Lisa Raitt: Oh, of course. Yeah.
- 18:00GIles Gherson: And that's a huge, interesting issue because we're spending a lot on those SMRs, which is great, in order to be a first mover for commercial SMRs out of Canada, out of Ontario.
- 18:12GIles Gherson: But the Americans have just announced six SMRs, and they're going to be the same model that we're building.
- 18:18Lisa Raitt: And if they build them faster, then the supply chain won't be here.
- 18:23GIles Gherson: It'll be in the U.S.
- 18:24GIles Gherson: And we will have kind of spent all this money to be kind of an also-ran.
- 18:29GIles Gherson: Again, it's to your point about speed.
- 18:31GIles Gherson: We don't tend to move with the speed we need to that the U.S. increasingly is moving at,
- 18:36GIles Gherson: and other countries are as well.
- 18:37GIles Gherson: I mean, it is about, they're highly aggressive.
- 18:40GIles Gherson: And I would say it's a kind of offensive, they use offense.
- 18:45Lisa Raitt: We're defense, I feel.
- 18:47Lisa Raitt: Always.
- 18:48Lisa Raitt: We want to protect what we have, and we don't want to necessarily anyone to disturb us.
- 18:52Lisa Raitt: That's why you got the big elbows up thing happening.
- 18:54Lisa Raitt: Don't take my stuff away.
- 18:56Lisa Raitt: That's kind of the reaction.
- 18:57Lisa Raitt: Donald Trump's going to take something away from me, as opposed to we need to be very much on the
- 19:02Lisa Raitt: offense and saying, okay, opportunity time. What can we do? Let's get this going.
- 19:07GIles Gherson: I mean, to your point about, I mean, we're agreeing with this, how to get Canadians
- 19:12GIles Gherson: sort of exercised about this to see the need for a real push on economic growth.
- 19:18GIles Gherson: Back to housing, you made the point about income sort of flatlining. And as a result,
- 19:22GIles Gherson: people are struggling to buy houses. And it is interesting that we've seen a significant increase
- 19:29GIles Gherson: in the cost of building houses. We've seen substantial construction inflation, particularly
- 19:34GIles Gherson: since COVID. And while incomes have been fairly flat. And so now what's happened is it costs more
- 19:39GIles Gherson: to build a house than people can afford to buy. So now buildings are saying, well, I'm not going
- 19:45GIles Gherson: to go build a new housing subdivision because no one can afford the $1,000 a square foot or whatever
- 19:51GIles Gherson: it is that it now costs to build. So that gap is really holding us back. And why are people not
- 19:56Lisa Raitt: getting paid more? What's happening? Well, you put the squeeze on governments. How many times do we
- 20:01Lisa Raitt: see, not to go after the Trudeau government, but how many times did you hear a finance minister say
- 20:06Lisa Raitt: the rich can pay a little bit more? The rich can pay a little bit more. Companies can pay a little
- 20:09Lisa Raitt: bit more. They should have excess profits taxes, all those kinds of things. When you squeeze a
- 20:14Lisa Raitt: company, where do you think it's going to come out of? It's going to come out of how many people you
- 20:18GIles Gherson: employ. That's where it's going to come out. And I mean, every dollar the government spends
- 20:22GIles Gherson: presumably comes out of, unless it's debt, comes out of business profits, right? And the employees
- 20:29GIles Gherson: that they pay and the taxes that they pay and the consumption taxes that they pay. Great way of
- 20:32GIles Gherson: looking at it. So if you don't have those business profits, you're not having business growth,
- 20:36GIles Gherson: you're not going to grow revenues to government, right? And that's the big problem. And I think
- 20:41Lisa Raitt: we need to focus on having people increase. We need to focus on making sure people get paid more.
- 20:46Lisa Raitt: I don't know how we're going to do it over time.
- 20:49Lisa Raitt: That's why when we talk about the auto sector, those are really good paid jobs.
- 20:52Lisa Raitt: Losing those, that's going to be problematic.
- 20:55GIles Gherson: Well, we've got to keep that sector.
- 20:56GIles Gherson: I mean, one of the things that I found interesting when I was in government was when we worked hard on the auto sector because I was in economic development.
- 21:03GIles Gherson: And we actually sort of worked hard on the EV strategy and the batteries.
- 21:08GIles Gherson: And the premise for us was if we could keep the GDP, the economic growth, from having the production here.
- 21:17GIles Gherson: Because remember, auto production here and the supply chain around it leads to exports.
- 21:22GIles Gherson: So we get export earnings, hugely valuable to the country, hugely valuable for our balance of payments.
- 21:26GIles Gherson: We don't have many other alternatives.
- 21:28GIles Gherson: I mean, autos is a huge source of payments from abroad.
- 21:33GIles Gherson: It pays for our imports by exporting.
- 21:35GIles Gherson: And then all of this production.
- 21:37GIles Gherson: And then employment as well.
- 21:38GIles Gherson: But I found governments tend to sort of focus on the employment first rather than the GDP, which can create employment.
- 21:46Lisa Raitt: Yeah.
- 21:46Lisa Raitt: But that's our metric, right?
- 21:48Lisa Raitt: Whenever you see an announcement from a government official, from a politician, it's always how many jobs have we created because it's that connection, connectivity with the individual.
- 21:56Lisa Raitt: You're telling the voter you have a chance of getting a job out of all of this.
- 22:01GIles Gherson: And the problem with that is it doesn't look at the multiplier effect.
- 22:04Lisa Raitt: Agreed.
- 22:04Lisa Raitt: Look, I think we've been incredibly, for many years, including within my own government,
- 22:09Lisa Raitt: Giles, to be honest, we've been really, I would say, blind to the fact that we have to think about
- 22:14Lisa Raitt: the economy. Other countries do this all the time, and they do it really, really well. I mean,
- 22:18Lisa Raitt: we got stuck on this whole thing. We need industrial policy. No, we just need people
- 22:22Lisa Raitt: thinking about it from a business point of view. I don't feel Canada is necessarily a business
- 22:28Lisa Raitt: oriented country all the time, quite frankly. And we need to. We need to have the wins. We need to
- 22:32Lisa Raitt: have more Shopify's. We need to have those kinds of companies to spur us on. But it shouldn't be
- 22:38Lisa Raitt: just one. It shouldn't be 11 or 12. We really need to do better. Because if you look at the
- 22:44Lisa Raitt: statistics, I saw an interesting chart. If you take a look at the Canadians who are running
- 22:48Lisa Raitt: big companies around the world, we really punch above our way. We're sending our best and our
- 22:53GIles Gherson: brightest. We're making the world great again. Well, it's true. So many Canadians of talent
- 22:59GIles Gherson: have gone to run large corporations, you say, around the world and into the U.S.
- 23:04GIles Gherson: And they tend to do very, very well because we have an excellent education system.
- 23:08GIles Gherson: They've been well-educated and they're smart.
- 23:11GIles Gherson: And if only those people were here, I think we'd be doing a lot better.
- 23:15GIles Gherson: We'd probably agree on that.
- 23:16Lisa Raitt: I do agree with you, but that's getting to the nub of the psyche of the Canadian,
- 23:20Lisa Raitt: of the Canadian business person.
- 23:21Lisa Raitt: And this was told to me.
- 23:23Lisa Raitt: Anne and I did a roundtable.
- 23:24Lisa Raitt: It was business people, senior people.
- 23:26Lisa Raitt: And this was the analysis that when a Canadian sells their company and they make $100 million,
- 23:33Lisa Raitt: they think, how big is my cottage going to be in Muskoka?
- 23:36Lisa Raitt: When an American makes their $100 million, they say, okay, great.
- 23:39Lisa Raitt: How do I employ that to do this again?
- 23:41GIles Gherson: And that's the difference.
- 23:42GIles Gherson: I mean, it's exactly right.
- 23:45GIles Gherson: And changing that mentality, I think, is going to be probably a job for the ages, but it has
- 23:48GIles Gherson: to be done.
- 23:49GIles Gherson: I'm certainly hopeful that even the current government, with its focus on economic growth,
- 23:53GIles Gherson: and keep that focus can help change that mindset to some degree.
- 24:00GIles Gherson: I mean, it needed to be done.
- 24:01GIles Gherson: The provincial government here is also interested in doing the same thing.
- 24:05GIles Gherson: But funnily enough, I do think it does come back to something that the prime minister said,
- 24:10GIles Gherson: and we've been saying it a little bit, I think, last year before that,
- 24:13GIles Gherson: which was you look at the amount of dollars spent on consumption,
- 24:17GIles Gherson: that the government will spend on consumption, versus on growing productive capacity.
- 24:21GIles Gherson: I know Minister Bethlehem Favre, the finance minister of Ontario will say, I've got 85% of my budget goes to social infrastructure, 15% goes to economic infrastructure.
- 24:32GIles Gherson: And I would argue that if you went back 50 or 60 years, looking at a federal or provincial government, you would have found a much better balance between essentially the resources that were devoted to growing the economy and daily consumption.
- 24:45Lisa Raitt: Yep. And you can blame politicians wanting to get elected for all of that, quite frankly, because nothing gets you more votes than dropping the price on dropping the amount of GST that you bring in or by adding another program or another another amount of money going out to pensioners about increasing the pensionable age to 67.
- 25:04Lisa Raitt: That's gone. It's back to 65. And other countries have moved forward on those things. But we are so
- 25:10Lisa Raitt: intent in this country politically on 25 ridings that can swing you between a majority and a
- 25:17Lisa Raitt: minority and a win and a non-win that we tend to, we as a politician, tend to promise the world
- 25:23Lisa Raitt: just to get that one specific individual community vote that's needed in order to put you on the
- 25:28GIles Gherson: for a short-term period. That's it. It's all short-termism, not long-term stuff.
- 25:31GIles Gherson: But we've been rattled by Trump. We've been rattled by the disruption, by the tariffs, by the threats of more tariffs. Is that enough to change that mindset? Because that's essentially what gave us the government approach today that we have versus 10 years ago.
- 25:45Lisa Raitt: Yeah. So are we on the burning platform? I mean, have we hit rock bottom yet? No,
- 25:48Lisa Raitt: we haven't hit rock bottom yet. I think there's a little bit of ways to go. I think that with the
- 25:54Lisa Raitt: ports in Iran being closed right now, by virtue of Donald Trump and his massive amounts of military
- 26:01Lisa Raitt: might, we are going to feel and hit an incredible amount of, I would say, inflation that is going to
- 26:08Lisa Raitt: be noticeable for people. And I'm not just talking about gas. I'm talking about everything.
- 26:12Lisa Raitt: It's everything. Well, plastics, you know, everything is plastics. It's fertilizers.
- 26:17Lisa Raitt: It's everything. And we're going to seal it. And that $99,000 that we currently have right now is
- 26:23Lisa Raitt: going to feel smaller and smaller and smaller. And it's going to bring on this kind of notion of not
- 26:28Lisa Raitt: only scarcity, not only hoarding, unfortunately, but it's also going to be, okay, right now, what?
- 26:33Lisa Raitt: Now what are we going to do? And that's where the prime minister and the premier, quite frankly,
- 26:37Lisa Raitt: have to step in and say a little bit more than just, we're going to fight Donald Trump.
- 26:42Lisa Raitt: great. We need you to do that because those section 232 tariffs and those section 301
- 26:49Lisa Raitt: investigations, really problematic. And we're probably in a bad spot.
- 26:53GIles Gherson: Well, we've got a bunch more coming.
- 26:54Lisa Raitt: The China stuff is a problem in our supply chain. Pharmaceuticals,
- 26:57Lisa Raitt: right around the corner. We know that's going to be a hit as well.
- 27:00Lisa Raitt: We need to get that sorted. That's incredibly important, but it's not everything.
- 27:05GIles Gherson: And it does mean keeping your eye on the ball on growing the economy, getting us out of this rut.
- 27:12GIles Gherson: if we're going to have the kind of prosperity that we want to have for our kids.
- 27:16Lisa Raitt: Don't chase ghosts, right?
- 27:18Lisa Raitt: Don't chase, don't try to be the next thing that you think is going to happen.
- 27:21Lisa Raitt: And we get into these worldwide competitions on data centers, for example, and everything else.
- 27:26Lisa Raitt: Look, when a proponent comes to you, make the deal as attractive as you possibly can.
- 27:31GIles Gherson: Yeah, and get it, yeah.
- 27:31Lisa Raitt: And get the deal done.
- 27:32Lisa Raitt: I think that's what it comes down to instead of saying-
- 27:36GIles Gherson: Taking advantage of opportunities is what you're saying.
- 27:37Lisa Raitt: Take advantage of opportunities.
- 27:38Lisa Raitt: but you got to show the opportunity is going to be frictionless or less frictioned when you go for
- 27:44Lisa Raitt: the process of regulatory systems or taxation or whatever. It's business. Canada has to turn into
- 27:52GIles Gherson: a country of business. We're not at the moment. We're not. One last thing on regulation,
- 27:57GIles Gherson: because one of the things I think that has, you know, there's a concern to us is that we see
- 28:03GIles Gherson: from time to time efforts to simplify regulations, to reduce regulations, but it's always
- 28:08GIles Gherson: overwhelmed by new regulations that keep on coming. And it seems to me that if you look at the federal
- 28:13GIles Gherson: government and you look at the government of Ontario, there isn't, and probably other provincial
- 28:18GIles Gherson: governments across the country, there isn't really a structured approach to simplifying regulation,
- 28:24GIles Gherson: right? I mean, we just did a report on this and we called for a regulatory simplification,
- 28:30GIles Gherson: weird term, regulatory simplification commissioner reporting to the prime minister and reporting to
- 28:35GIles Gherson: the premier, so one in each level of government, with real authority, speaking for the prime
- 28:40GIles Gherson: minister, speaking for the premier to cabinet members, as opposed to what the federal government
- 28:46GIles Gherson: has, which is Treasury Board. Part of what it does is ready to reform, but I don't really sense that
- 28:51GIles Gherson: it's driving anything, right? And in Ontario, with the best effort in the world, they've got,
- 28:56GIles Gherson: you know, a more junior minister of red tape production, which sounds great, and has had very
- 29:01GIles Gherson: good people in it, generally speaking. But it's hard from that capacity to get the attention of
- 29:07GIles Gherson: the senior regulatory ministers, right? And so it seems to me the structure of both isn't serious.
- 29:12GIles Gherson: It isn't really going to deliver the kinds of change we need to see.
- 29:17Lisa Raitt: Agreed. So two things on regulation. The first one is, anecdotally, I have probably 30,000 photos
- 29:24Lisa Raitt: on my phone and on my computer in the iCloud. It is overwhelming. AI can help me find the duplicates.
- 29:30Lisa Raitt: It can help me organize them.
- 29:32Lisa Raitt: It can help me put them in batches.
- 29:33Lisa Raitt: It can help me make quicker decisions on whether or not I want this picture or I don't want
- 29:37Lisa Raitt: this picture.
- 29:38Lisa Raitt: Regulations can be exactly the same thing.
- 29:40Lisa Raitt: You should be employing AI in order to batch out what it is, what's happening here and
- 29:45Lisa Raitt: here.
- 29:45Lisa Raitt: What happens right now, Giles, is you'll go to a federal, provincial, territorial, indigenous
- 29:51Lisa Raitt: meeting of all the ministers, and someone will mention, you know this, you've been there.
- 29:55Lisa Raitt: Someone will mention a regulation and we'll go in Ontario.
- 29:57Lisa Raitt: Really?
- 29:58Lisa Raitt: You do that?
- 29:58Lisa Raitt: That's crazy.
- 29:59Lisa Raitt: Why would you do that?
- 30:00Lisa Raitt: Now I understand why we're not working with one another.
- 30:02GIles Gherson: Right.
- 30:02Lisa Raitt: You can't have that happen.
- 30:04Lisa Raitt: You've got to have the data, the facts, and the understanding.
- 30:06Lisa Raitt: So that's one part.
- 30:07Lisa Raitt: I think AI has evolved.
- 30:10Lisa Raitt: I mean, my God, we are the, this is the birthplace of AI, for goodness sake, here in Toronto.
- 30:16Lisa Raitt: Why doesn't somebody write that for the Canadian government?
- 30:19Lisa Raitt: What a gift.
- 30:20Lisa Raitt: Like, give it to them.
- 30:21Lisa Raitt: Don't let the government run it.
- 30:23Lisa Raitt: Have it run outside.
- 30:24Lisa Raitt: But figure that part out.
- 30:26Lisa Raitt: The second piece on regulation is this.
- 30:27Lisa Raitt: And this is where it takes boldness.
- 30:29Lisa Raitt: It's not just regulation that you can see that needs to be removed.
- 30:32Lisa Raitt: It is the Canada Labor Code.
- 30:35Lisa Raitt: It is Investment Canada Act.
- 30:37Lisa Raitt: Those are regulations as well.
- 30:38Lisa Raitt: Oh, absolutely.
- 30:39Lisa Raitt: You can't get rid of them.
- 30:40Lisa Raitt: And we're not going to get rid of them.
- 30:41Lisa Raitt: What we can do.
- 30:42Lisa Raitt: Streamline them.
- 30:44Lisa Raitt: What we can do.
- 30:45Lisa Raitt: We can streamline.
- 30:46Lisa Raitt: Yeah.
- 30:46Lisa Raitt: But what we can do is also this.
- 30:48Lisa Raitt: I think, and you've heard this policy around, I think we have to declare an emergency.
- 30:54Lisa Raitt: And I think we have to say the supply chain of Canada is in such a state right now that
- 30:58Lisa Raitt: we need time and we need to protect it in order to be able to build on it and grow it and show
- 31:05Lisa Raitt: the world that we are a strong supply chain. And for a limited period of time, you do suspend
- 31:12GIles Gherson: certain rules. Well, I think that makes sense. I mean, one of the things you could also do is use
- 31:17GIles Gherson: your AI example to shift many of our regulations to international standards. We have a lot of made
- 31:26GIles Gherson: in Canada, made in Ontario standards that are just different enough to cause friction, right?
- 31:33GIles Gherson: And cause cost and delays. You know, we don't live in a world now where, you know, there's vast
- 31:38GIles Gherson: disparity actually in standards. By and large, much of the world, certainly, you know, I think of
- 31:42GIles Gherson: Europe, you think of Asia, you think of, you know, many parts of the world, now the Middle East,
- 31:46GIles Gherson: where standards are really shifted towards what we have. Why not have international standards as
- 31:51GIles Gherson: opposed to made in Ontario, made in Canada? It is an excellent question. When I was minister
- 31:56Lisa Raitt: transport, we were trying to amend a rule where how many flight attendants you needed, depending
- 32:01Lisa Raitt: upon whether or not you're a wide body or a narrow body. And we wanted to follow the European
- 32:06Lisa Raitt: example or the American example. And I just kept being told by officials, no, Minister, we can't do
- 32:11Lisa Raitt: that. We have to do our own complete entire study from the ground up. I just say, just adopt their
- 32:16Lisa Raitt: standards. These are flying to those countries. We have a general understanding of what's important
- 32:23Lisa Raitt: and safety, aviation, aviation safety.
- 32:25Lisa Raitt: Why don't we just implement it?
- 32:26Lisa Raitt: No, we can't do that.
- 32:27Lisa Raitt: Same thing with using your phones on planes, right?
- 32:30Lisa Raitt: For the longest time, you had to stow it in the thing in front of you
- 32:33Lisa Raitt: to show that you weren't touching it at all.
- 32:35Lisa Raitt: Other countries got rid of it a long time,
- 32:36Lisa Raitt: taking your shoes off in airports.
- 32:38Lisa Raitt: Like, I could go on and on and on.
- 32:39GIles Gherson: One of my favorite examples, and I'll end on this,
- 32:42GIles Gherson: since you were a minister of transport.
- 32:44GIles Gherson: Billy Bishop Airport, right?
- 32:46GIles Gherson: It has a tripartite agreement.
- 32:47GIles Gherson: That's right.
- 32:47GIles Gherson: The tripartite agreement says one airplane can fly
- 32:51GIles Gherson: into Billy Bishop Airport commercial aircraft, the Q400 that was...
- 32:55Lisa Raitt: Essentially, yeah.
- 32:56GIles Gherson: Well, and so...
- 32:57GIles Gherson: It's a triple prop, yeah.
- 32:58GIles Gherson: But it doesn't say here's the emission standard.
- 33:00GIles Gherson: It doesn't say here's the noise level.
- 33:03GIles Gherson: It says this actually identifies the actual plane.
- 33:05Lisa Raitt: Yeah.
- 33:05GIles Gherson: And so you can't fly anything else really into it.
- 33:10GIles Gherson: But talk about prescriptive regulation.
- 33:11Lisa Raitt: Yeah.
- 33:12GIles Gherson: Anyway, that's going to change, hopefully,
- 33:14GIles Gherson: because we're going to get a change in the tripartite, we think.
- 33:17Lisa Raitt: I would love to see that.
- 33:18Lisa Raitt: And there's always going to be a noise contour that you have to abide by.
- 33:21Lisa Raitt: I think that makes a lot of sense.
- 33:22GIles Gherson: Absolutely.
- 33:22GIles Gherson: But just what's the international standard for it?
- 33:24Lisa Raitt: But that's fine.
- 33:25GIles Gherson: But that's fine.
- 33:25Lisa Raitt: And we can mitigate against that.
- 33:27Lisa Raitt: You can put those walls up like they've done already down there.
- 33:29GIles Gherson: Those blast walls, yeah.
- 33:30Lisa Raitt: Absolutely.
- 33:31Lisa Raitt: On this topic, if I could just say one thing, the scare mongering and the fear mongering
- 33:35Lisa Raitt: with respect to that airport is completely blown out of proportion.
- 33:39Lisa Raitt: It's a very, very safe airport.
- 33:40Lisa Raitt: And it's run impeccably by the Port of Toronto.
- 33:44Lisa Raitt: And I think we've got a jewel there.
- 33:45Lisa Raitt: And I'm biased.
- 33:47Lisa Raitt: But I don't use it because I live out in Milton.
- 33:50Lisa Raitt: Right, right.
- 33:50Lisa Raitt: But I know lots of people who do.
- 33:52GIles Gherson: Oh, yeah.
- 33:52GIles Gherson: I mean, for your colleagues in the financial services sector, for sure.
- 33:56GIles Gherson: Oh, for sure.
- 33:56Lisa Raitt: For sure.
- 33:57Lisa Raitt: So I think it's an ability for us to get out of our own way.
- 34:00GIles Gherson: I think we're turning the corner on that one.
- 34:02GIles Gherson: Lisa, thank you very much.
- 34:03GIles Gherson: Lovely to have you.
- 34:04Lisa Raitt: Thank you very much, Vass.
- 34:05Lisa Raitt: Great.
- 34:05GIles Gherson: Thanks.
- 34:07GIles Gherson: Thanks for listening to Toronto Talks,
- 34:09GIles Gherson: conversations with the leaders shaping the region's economy.
- 34:13GIles Gherson: Follow us wherever you get your podcasts.