Latest / Shiny New Object - a Marketing Podcast / AI makes human relationships the real advantage - ft. Kenvue's Mark Cibort
Transcript
- 0:23Mark Cibort: We took our kids to a family therapist when they
- 0:24were very, very small. And the therapist said to the children,
- 0:25"All feelings are appropriate, all behaviours are not." And we
- 0:26were like, "That's amazing!" And we used it for a very long time
- 0:28when they would start to act up and then they started to use it
- 0:29against us as they got older, but I realised as a, from a
- 0:30professional setting, very relevant, you know, it keeps you
- 0:31from having outbursts or acting out in a way when you're feeling
- 0:33unfocused or overwhelmed. So accepting like the way I'm
- 0:34feeling 100% legitimate. What do I do? How do I act? So that's
- 0:36like the, sort of grounding myself in the moment when I'm
- 0:41feeling that way.
- 0:45Tom Ollerton: Hello and welcome to the Shiny New Object Podcast.
- 0:51My name is Tom Ollerton. I'm the founder of Automated Creative,
- 0:54the creative effectiveness adtech platform. And this is a
- 0:57podcast about the future of data driven marketing. Every week or
- 1:01so, I have the pleasure and the privilege of interviewing one of
- 1:05our industry's leaders, and this week is no different. I'm at
- 1:08this lovely podcast studio. Thank you, Gotham, in New York
- 1:11City. Very exciting for an East Londoner such as myself. And I'm
- 1:14here with Mark. I'm here with Mark Cibort, who is Global Head
- 1:18of Marketing Operations at Kenvue. So, Mark, for anyone who
- 1:22doesn't know who you are and what you do, could you give us a
- 1:24bit of background?
- 1:25Mark Cibort: Absolutely. First, let me thank you, Tom, for
- 1:28inviting me. This is amazing. And again, amazing set up here
- 1:32So thank you, Gotham, for hosting us. Who I am? What I do?
- 1:36The short version... At Kenvue, I really do look after people,
- 1:40process, and product that run on a platform for all content
- 1:44creation for Kenvue. So we have wonderful brands, household
- 1:49names, all of the things so very fortunate but it feels a little
- 1:54bit like all roads led to this point. You know what I've done
- 1:57in my past, heavy agency side for a long, long time, longer
- 2:00than I'll mention now. But being able to work for organisations
- 2:04like Ogilvy & Mather, RGA, some West Coast agencies, Razorfish,
- 2:10Trailer Park, Rest in Peace Trailer Park. But yeah, a lot of
- 2:16interesting experience across production, across running
- 2:18businesses about developing teams. So having this
- 2:21opportunity now all culminated to this point. So feeling very
- 2:27fortunate for the role that I have.
- 2:28Tom Ollerton: So people, process, and product?
- 2:31Mark Cibort: Yes.
- 2:31Tom Ollerton: Right. That's a lot. And as you mentioned, some,
- 2:34some household names. Big agency relationships.
- 2:38Mark Cibort: Yes.
- 2:38Tom Ollerton: Big platform relationships. Big budgets, big
- 2:40everything. That's got to get overwhelming. So...
- 2:44Mark Cibort: It can.
- 2:45Tom Ollerton: When the... When the deluge happens, how do you
- 2:48look at 3000 emails and you know, it's 7:00 on a Friday
- 2:52night. How do you deal with that overwhelm?
- 2:54Mark Cibort: As a producer, typically you're most
- 2:56comfortable when you're in control. But some things you
- 2:59can't control. So when I approach a point of feeling
- 3:02either overwhelmed or unfocused, I start with accepting the fact
- 3:07that what I'm feeling is legitimate. We took our kids to
- 3:11a family therapist when they were very, very small. And the
- 3:14therapist said, to the children, "All feelings are appropriate,
- 3:18all behaviours are not." And we were like, "That's amazing!" And
- 3:22we used it for a very long time when they would start to act up.
- 3:26And then they started to use it against us as they got older,
- 3:30but I realised as a, from a professional setting, very
- 3:34relevant, you know, it keeps you from having outbursts or acting
- 3:37out in a way when you're feeling unfocused or overwhelmed. So
- 3:41accepting like the way I'm feeling, 100% legitimate what do
- 3:45I do? How do I act? So that's like the sort of grounding
- 3:50myself in the moment when I'm feeling that way. But the other
- 3:53thing that I often refer to, and some people call it the
- 3:57Eisenhower framework, like urgent versus important. There's
- 4:01a variant. Yeah, that quadrant, but there's a variant that I use
- 4:06for myself that's more focused on...
- 4:08Tom Ollerton: It's better than Eisenhower, yeah?
- 4:09Mark Cibort: Yeah, well, you know, I think...
- 4:13Tom Ollerton: What is it?
- 4:14Mark Cibort: Well, I think in threes as opposed to in four,
- 4:17but it's avoid, accept, or address and it helps sort things
- 4:25out because if you're avoiding something, it's either passive
- 4:28or active and there's a level of I might have to change something
- 4:33because I'm avoiding something that may be happening. The
- 4:36accept part is really letting yourself off the hook, like this
- 4:41thing is happening. Not much I can do about it, so I, I'll just
- 4:44accept it. And then course correct or whatever I need to
- 4:48do, which then leaves when you have to address something. And
- 4:52typically that's the thing that requires the most energy.
- 4:55Sometimes it's a battle. Sometimes you're going head onto
- 4:58something. But using those filters of avoid, accept, or
- 5:01address on a regular basis helps me like, okay, now I have a
- 5:06better idea of what I need to do or where I need to start. It
- 5:09keeps me in check.
- 5:11Tom Ollerton: I'm trying to agent myself out of overwhelm.
- 5:13You know, which is, it's kind of going okay. Claude's been a
- 5:19huge, huge focus for having Automated Creative this year. So
- 5:23now I've got like, I come in the morning, I'm like, "Plan my day,
- 5:26what should I be doing today?" And it's got like, right, well,
- 5:29I'm trying to grow the business, develop this, that, and the
- 5:31other, and it maps it out and goes, "All things considered,
- 5:34Tom, you should just go and do these three things." And I found
- 5:36it so transformational to be, because I'm, I've got like an
- 5:41ADHD style brain whether I... They're not diagnosed, but I
- 5:45will say yes to everything. You know, you want a cup of tea?
- 5:49Yes. And my brain goes, "Well, why don't we do this thing?
- 5:51Yeah, I'll do that." So I just have this giant pile of yeses
- 5:54and I cannot decide what to do. But having an agent go "3:00,
- 5:59you've got a call with so-and-so, it's, you know, it's
- 6:02a big bit of work. You've got to make that happen. Don't do
- 6:04anything else until that is perfect." And you're like,
- 6:07"Okay. Great."
- 6:09Mark Cibort: It's, it can be liberating, you know, having
- 6:11those constraints wind up being very liberating, and whether
- 6:15it's that agentic approach that you're talking about or if it's
- 6:19more of a, you know, self-imposed framework, you have
- 6:22then more freedom because you can decide, I'm going to avoid
- 6:26this, I'm going to accept this, or I'm going to address it. And
- 6:28like, you know, sometimes it's, it happens very, like it's not
- 6:32even above a subconscious thought. It just starts to
- 6:36naturally take shape because you see patterns that start to form
- 6:39and you're like I'm just going to avoid this or like, I got to
- 6:44go after this one. So it's, it's helpful. It starts out
- 6:48uncomfortable because I think a lot of times as a professional,
- 6:53you might be trained action equals busy equals value. And
- 6:58you can still be valuable without appearing to be busy all
- 7:02the time. Because if you don't use the time to think about what
- 7:06you're doing, you're doing everything, but you're really
- 7:09doing nothing. Like you've got 80 things started but nothing is
- 7:12progressing or you've got things that aren't important that
- 7:15really don't drive any value.
- 7:17Tom Ollerton: Wow, that's painful, man, like because I
- 7:19have this thing like you know, you get on those calls, you
- 7:20know, how are you doing? How are you doing? Yeah, I'm really
- 7:22busy. I'm like, dude, the opposite of busy in this
- 7:25industry is unemployed.
- 7:26Mark Cibort: Yeah.
- 7:27Tom Ollerton: Do you know what I mean?
- 7:27Mark Cibort: Yeah.
- 7:27Tom Ollerton: We're all like, even if, even if your giant
- 7:30campaign has just gone live and it's great you still got you
- 7:34know, because with marketing, it's not an exact science,
- 7:36right? So you need to give yourself the opportunity to know
- 7:39enough to make the right decision all the time, which is
- 7:41you are constantly busy.
- 7:43Mark Cibort: Yeah.
- 7:43Tom Ollerton: I kind of feel we can do the whole podcast on just
- 7:47this, but I really like your triple A method, so... So what
- 7:51advice? What one, kind of silver bullet, quotable bit of advice
- 7:56do you have for someone to be a better data-driven marketer in
- 8:002026?
- 8:01Mark Cibort: I think now it's, it's easy to be data rich, but
- 8:07insight or action poor and you can have all the data in the
- 8:12world, but if you don't have the ability to either sort that or
- 8:16if something, someone is helping you sort it to be able to get to
- 8:20a place of... And what do I do with it? You're kind of lost
- 8:23because you can be swimming in data and really not be able to
- 8:28do anything with it or do anything about it. And I think
- 8:31one of the most difficult things is the discipline of what's the
- 8:36right signal that I should be focusing on or that the
- 8:39organisation should be focusing on. So that means you have to
- 8:42know your brand, you have to know the way that it needs to
- 8:44show up, you have to know who you're talking to, and then that
- 8:49starts to drive some of those what you're looking for in all
- 8:53of the, the data that you have or the patterns that start to
- 8:56present themselves that you think might be, well, no one
- 8:59else is there, I'm going to go there. But it's, it's not...
- 9:02like I've just made it sound super easy. It's not.
- 9:05Tom Ollerton: No, of course. I always say that the industry
- 9:08suffers from the three Ds. You go three As, I'm going to come
- 9:11back at you with three Ds which is data, dashboards, decks.
- 9:15Mark Cibort: Yes.
- 9:15Tom Ollerton: Everyone loves those three things. Give me the
- 9:17three Ds. You're like, look, I'm gonna 3D you. We recently
- 9:22published a book called Using Creativity in Data and
- 9:24Marketing, interviewed Meredith, Boss Lady.
- 9:27Tom Ollerton: For the book as well as like the Rory
- 9:27Mark Cibort: Yep!
- 9:30Sutherland, Neil Patel, like incredible people for the book
- 9:34and one of the, I can't remember who this quote was from, but
- 9:37they said one of the Ds: data, dashboard, and decks, does it
- 9:41inspire, inspire action? If it doesn't, it's a distraction.
- 9:45Mark Cibort: Yeah.
- 9:45Tom Ollerton: And I like, is this thing you're showing me
- 9:48going to make me do a thing? If there's no action off the back
- 9:51of it then it's noise.
- 9:52Mark Cibort: Right. I mean sometimes it's helpful to have
- 9:56dashboards that indicate health from an operational standpoint,
- 10:00but that's more of like keep doing that so there's still some
- 10:04implied action or you have to say this doesn't look right. So
- 10:08then I need to intervene again. Action. But the higher order
- 10:13when you're talking about effectiveness or when you're
- 10:15talking about something that needs to be transformative,
- 10:17that's when it's super important that the data that you have is
- 10:20leading to some level of insight, some way to be able to
- 10:24discern this is an important thing for us to focus on. But
- 10:27it's a, it takes discipline and whether it's imposed from
- 10:33outside or it's your own level of discipline to be able to look
- 10:37at those things much more carefully. And, you know, being
- 10:40a discerning, data driven marketer to say this is
- 10:43important for me to pay attention to.
- 10:45Tom Ollerton: So we're going to talk about your shiny new object
- 10:47now.
- 10:48Mark Cibort: Sure.
- 10:48Tom Ollerton: The name of the podcast and your shiny new
- 10:51object is navigating an agentic world. What could be more
- 10:56relevant to right now? So I think we all know what that is.
- 11:00But can you explain to the audience what navigating an
- 11:05agentic world is and why you've chosen that area of discussion
- 11:08today?
- 11:09Mark Cibort: It is difficult to have a conversation today from a
- 11:11professional standpoint without A.I. or some variant coming into
- 11:16the conversation, and for good reason. It is. It's all around
- 11:20us. It will continue. You can't ignore it. You can't be afraid
- 11:24of it because then career limiting move. So when you think
- 11:28about how do you navigate in agentic world thinking about you
- 11:34will very soon, all of us will have agentic employees.
- 11:38Different skill set required to manage an agentic employee than
- 11:42a human employee. And there's also the prevalence of platforms
- 11:48and elements of technology that will either separately or
- 11:54together start to create these vast decision making types of
- 12:01applications. And you have to be really comfortable with that.
- 12:04And you have to figure out how do you harness that. There are
- 12:07things that will happen that it's trust but verify in that
- 12:10type of a set up. But when you really look at I'll have a mix
- 12:15of a team, some of them I won't really be able to talk to or
- 12:19crack a joke with or have like a human relationship with, but
- 12:24you'll have a relationship with that agentic employee, but it
- 12:28will be a very different type of relationship and you may be
- 12:31managed by an agentic boss at some point in the future as
- 12:35well, which is really terrifying. Like the singularity
- 12:38is just around the corner. And you know, all of the things when
- 12:41you watch Terminator and Wall-E and all of the movies where they
- 12:45sort of dance around it or address it in a entertaining way
- 12:48like that shit's real, it's coming, but it's not to be
- 12:52afraid of it. I think the more curious you are, the more likely
- 12:56you are to figure out, how do I make that mine? How do I, how do
- 12:59I fit in and how do I use it to stand out?
- 13:02Tom Ollerton: How are you, how are you doing it now? Like, so,
- 13:04so you're curious, you're not afraid. You've gone a bit like
- 13:09dystopian, you know, calling out those movies. So what do you
- 13:13like? It's 10:15, and it's like next Tuesday when you're back at
- 13:17work. Like how, what is your agentic workforce at the minute?
- 13:20How is that act like, without giving away anything
- 13:24confidential, what does that look like for you today?
- 13:27Mark Cibort: Well, there are certain tools, agentic may be
- 13:30the ultimate realisation. So there's A.I. and then there's
- 13:34agentic because some of the things that you use on the
- 13:37regular basis don't necessarily make the decisions or act on
- 13:41those things, which is true agentic because it has data, it
- 13:45learnt and then it can do things without any human involvement
- 13:49and it continues to learn. I personally am not at the point
- 13:53where I have an agentic employee that I work with. I work with
- 13:57people, agency partners and the like that do. So I am a
- 14:00beneficiary of them having agentic employees, but in the
- 14:04near future I wouldn't be surprised if it would be a
- 14:07direct team made up of agentic employees and humans. But even
- 14:11for myself, the way that I leverage it either like, I will
- 14:15say mundane tasks, but I will perseverate on an email or a
- 14:19team's message that I want to make sure it's just right. Now,
- 14:23I'm just like, all right, run it through Copilot and optimise the
- 14:27shit out of it. So I know that it's concise. It's kind of a
- 14:31lazy person way but you know, it ends up saving a lot of time. It
- 14:35makes decisions in that way that it's like, "You know what, I
- 14:39really love that word, but it doesn't matter." This, it comes
- 14:43back and like, "Okay, cool." So there's efficiency gains. There
- 14:47is headspace gains that you pick up because you're using
- 14:50something as simple as Copilot or something as straightforward
- 14:54as Gemini or ChatGPT to help you accelerate certain things. But
- 14:58when you have tools at your disposal where there's, you
- 15:02know, not visible to you, but those things happening in the
- 15:06background, it's also the same thing. Like how do you optimise
- 15:10for this particular marketplace, for this particular brand? And
- 15:14then it starts to move you along to a decision making path where
- 15:18it just becomes easier, becomes cleaner, and you don't have to
- 15:22spend a lot of time agonising over data points.
- 15:25Tom Ollerton: So I'm going to play devil's advocate a bit
- 15:27here, right? So I cannot stop thinking about this subject
- 15:33right? I mean, Automated Creative were founded on the
- 15:35idea that something called generative A.I. would happen.
- 15:37And that was in 2017. So we were early on this. The A.I. at the
- 15:43time was not anything like what it is today. And you're talking
- 15:47about efficiency gains, right? You're talking about it,
- 15:49coaching you a bit on an email or a team Slack, whatever, what
- 15:53do you perceive as being the competitive advantage of these
- 15:57tools? So being efficient isn't a competitive advantage, right?
- 16:02So the Mark Cibort at Haleon, yada, yada, yada, you know,
- 16:07could... Right. So it's not a competitive bunch, it's an
- 16:10efficiency play.
- 16:11Mark Cibort: It is.
- 16:11Tom Ollerton: So like looking 6, 12, 18 months. What is going to
- 16:16be the competitive differentiator when it comes to
- 16:20this stuff as opposed to everyone just doing the same
- 16:23thing? Now, while you think about that. I'll give you an
- 16:25anecdote. So I was in Amsterdam with my friend and he runs the,
- 16:30the creative operations at a fashion brand. And he, yeah,
- 16:34told me the story, showed me like 12 pictures of models
- 16:37wearing clothes, I don't know, I'm not a fashion guy. And he
- 16:40said that cost me £35,000, right, to make this. And it's
- 16:44A.I. models, normal clothes, A.I. background. So that
- 16:47normally would have cost me £750,000, right? For the same
- 16:52thing. Flights, crew. And he said, I now do it for 35 and I'm
- 16:56like, "Yeah but so can all your competitors, and all the other
- 16:59dudes who've only got £35,000 are now on a par with one of the
- 17:01biggest fashion brands in the world." Right? So it's not a
- 17:04competitive advantage. So how are you seeing using this stuff
- 17:07moving forward to create a differentiating, compelling
- 17:11advantage for you?
- 17:12Mark Cibort: Yep, so there's two in my mind, there's two pieces,
- 17:15there's as the individual, what competitive advantage does it
- 17:19create for you? And then as an organisation, what competitive
- 17:23advantages are created? I think as the individual when you are
- 17:27more curious or continuously curious and you try these things
- 17:31and you adapt them into your way of working, it allows you to
- 17:34become more human because your time isn't spent spending on
- 17:39certain things. You're really able to focus on a relationship.
- 17:44One of the, there's a gentleman, his name is Rishad Tobaccowala,
- 17:47who is a brilliant strategist, writer. I've consumed, he has a
- 17:52weekly, a weekly email that is distributed and I consume it on
- 17:58the regular. Some that I share with my family. Like it's very
- 18:01helpful stuff. But he talks about being the most human
- 18:04person in the room. And when you think about that, that is a
- 18:08differentiator because now it's, it's not about having knowledge
- 18:11because you, you have the knowledge within any agentic
- 18:14tool or anything from an A.I. standpoint, it's like modern
- 18:17equivalent of a calculator. I don't know math, I don't need to
- 18:20know it. I have a calculator, same thing, but it lets you
- 18:24become a more human and spend time developing and
- 18:28strengthening relationships. And as an individual, I see that as
- 18:32a competitive advantage because people will remember who you are
- 18:36as a human. Not as well, like I had all of this information. No,
- 18:41he was a good person, like he helped me, whatever that might
- 18:45be. And then when you extrapolate that to an
- 18:48organisation, I'm not saying it helps an organisation become
- 18:51more human, but it allows an organisation to focus on higher
- 18:55order things that are important to that organisation, much like
- 18:59as a human being more human, an organisation... What are the
- 19:04things that are most important that you should be focusing on
- 19:06either where you differentiate yourself in the marketplace?
- 19:10Where is someone, where are your competitors not now, that is a
- 19:14place for you to go to or where are they that they're not
- 19:18nailing it, that lets you do it better, do it differently. So
- 19:21it's, it's a, it frees up thought and opportunity for how
- 19:27you handle situations. It's another thing that requires that
- 19:30level of discipline because there are people who just get
- 19:32locked in on, they have to know things and that's how they see
- 19:37their value because they have knowledge. You can get the
- 19:40knowledge, you can learn things, but you don't have to be so
- 19:43consumed by it that it's all, that's all you have room for.
- 19:47This lets you have more room.
- 19:48Tom Ollerton: So there's two scenarios that I was walking
- 19:51around Manhattan talking to a business partner about
- 19:53yesterday, Alex Hobhouse those two futures that I see and this
- 19:57was based on an article by Professor Ceci Dones and she was
- 20:02talking about different industries that have been
- 20:04affected by A.I.. Right? So, you know, like you had lift
- 20:08operator. You know, I was like, what floor? I don't know. But
- 20:12when that became automated, there was no like, those dudes
- 20:16just had to get other jobs. There's no like master, like
- 20:19controller, right? And then the, the other scenario she talks
- 20:23about was the trading floor at the stock exchange. All the
- 20:27dudes with the...
- 20:28Mark Cibort: Chaos.
- 20:28Tom Ollerton: Yeah, yeah. They're not there anymore. Now,
- 20:30there's just like, I don't know, five, ten, 1500 people. Writing
- 20:34the algorithms for that, all of that stuff to happen, right? And
- 20:37so that's what automation does. It either just wipes people out
- 20:40completely like dinosaurs or it like it or automation is then
- 20:44controlled by up by a few. So her point was that, is that
- 20:48that's certainly going to be happening with media buying? You
- 20:51know, like this, the idea of someone coming in and planning
- 20:53it out and, you know, like that could be automated, and we're
- 20:56going in in that direction. So there's that kind of version of
- 20:59the future for, for our industry, for your role, for my
- 21:03role, my business, maybe even yours to a degree. But that's if
- 21:07A.I. works, right?
- 21:09Mark Cibort: Right.
- 21:10Tom Ollerton: Not the promise for it actually working. And
- 21:13that is predicated on it being a financially viable industry. So
- 21:18you look at, look at the data. I'm sorry, I'm going to get the
- 21:20numbers wrong, but it's we're in the area that I think Amazon
- 21:22have made. I think it's like $1.7 billion in turnover from
- 21:28its A.I. products. $1.7. That's a lot of money.
- 21:32Mark Cibort: Yeah.
- 21:33Tom Ollerton: Not compared to the 300 billion i t's invested
- 21:36in CapEx for that product. Right? And it's the same like
- 21:40Meta, OpenAI, blah, blah, blah... They've all invested
- 21:43this near getting on for half a trillion dollars worth of
- 21:47investment for like niche in return, right? So that is wild,
- 21:51right? Like how many more half a trillion are left, right? None
- 21:55of them have a profitable product.
- 21:58Mark Cibort: No.
- 21:58Tom Ollerton: Gemini, Anthropic... So at some point
- 22:02there's going to be a reckoning, right?
- 22:03Mark Cibort: Yes.
- 22:03Tom Ollerton: And none of that the guys in Meta who've invested
- 22:06like tens of billions of this. They can't stop. No one could
- 22:09go. I think we may have a reck- No, no... We're half a trillion
- 22:15in. We need more. So at some point and in the United States,
- 22:19it's like it's so interesting. One view I heard yesterday was
- 22:23the economics of this country is so focussed around a very small
- 22:26group of companies all betting on the same industry. That
- 22:29industry goes in the other direction. What does that do to
- 22:31the US economy? What does that do to the world economy? So
- 22:34everyone is buying into this A.I. belief that it's going to
- 22:38get better, it's going to turn into money. So I'm not like I
- 22:42ain't got to call it. I'm not an economist. But there is a like
- 22:46if you look at the numbers, there's a very real chance that
- 22:49this A.I. thing isn't going to work.
- 22:51Mark Cibort: Yeah.
- 22:52Tom Ollerton: So that doesn't work. Then actually we will have
- 22:54to go back to doing some stuff manual. So which camp are you
- 22:58going to bet on? Are you going to bet on A.I. making up the
- 23:01half a trillion dollars that it's sure? Or are you going to
- 23:03bet on actually, it's a bubble. It's going to pop and we're
- 23:05going to have to adapt.
- 23:07Mark Cibort: I think it is going to be a mix of both because if
- 23:10you look historically, the first industrial revolution and the
- 23:14second industrial revolution, all of that was built up to this
- 23:17thing that was happening, that everybody was racing to be the
- 23:21first ones, then to be the best ones. And then sometimes they
- 23:24were the only ones because they were able to ride it out last a
- 23:27little bit longer than some of their competitors who fell by
- 23:29the wayside. And then they were the only show in town. And we
- 23:33see that cycle repeating. So there is the bubble. It does
- 23:36burst and then there are people who have the cash or have the
- 23:40courage to just keep going until it becomes either obscured by
- 23:45the next thing. They can just focus on the thing that they're
- 23:47doing to really get the, the returns from it that are
- 23:50required, or they will be the ones to drive that thing forward
- 23:54to its logical conclusion of you realise all of the things, but
- 23:58it's the cycle time is getting increasingly less. So if I think
- 24:04about that first industrial revolution and how that was
- 24:07spread out over a number of decades and then dating myself,
- 24:11but I remember starting at RGA in 2005 at like the, it was sort
- 24:16of the second wave of the internet because the original
- 24:19dot com bubble burst in 2001, I think something like that. And
- 24:23then it was new players that were coming into it a little bit
- 24:27more cautiously, a little bit more responsibly, and then being
- 24:30able to scale that. So you saw the bubble and then you saw the
- 24:33aftermath, and then it was everything related to social.
- 24:36Internet 2.0, same cycle, but much shorter. And then you get
- 24:41to this place now where you're talking... Well, we had large
- 24:45language models and we've had machine learning for a long,
- 24:48long time, but now that it's all wrapped up in agentic, all
- 24:52wrapped up in gen A.I. or just A.I. as a catch all, that cycle
- 24:57is there arguably shorter. There's going to be some people
- 25:00who lose their shirts because they made big bets and it didn't
- 25:02pay out for them. But there's going to be a few that are like,
- 25:06I'm cool. Like I'll ride it out. I don't buy your distressed
- 25:09assets.
- 25:09Tom Ollerton: Who's that gonna be though? That's the thing
- 25:10because if you talk about the internet-
- 25:11Mark Cibort: Amazon or Google, like I think
- 25:13Amazon and Google. They have different approaches one is a
- 25:15walled garden. One is open. Yeah. And it's ironic that the
- 25:19walled garden was the open predecessor because they wanted
- 25:24everything for everybody and now they're ring fencing. And but I
- 25:28think it will be down to those two as the serious players.
- 25:32They'll just continue to absorb.
- 25:34Tom Ollerton: I can't get my head around this. How are they
- 25:36going to make any money out of it? It's like they're losing so-
- 25:42Mark Cibort: They don't have to because they're, there's money
- 25:46that will be made in other places variety to fund that...
- 25:49Tom Ollerton: It's a lure.
- 25:50Mark Cibort: It's just, right...
- 25:52Tom Ollerton: Just $300 billion lure.
- 25:54Mark Cibort: Pool and like you have it over here and you put it
- 25:58over here. But the investors and even the people who are
- 26:03consuming it, people are inherently lazy. So they're
- 26:05going to want what they want. And if Amazon is that show in
- 26:08town, it doesn't really matter like... Eh, that's okay. I mean,
- 26:12they felt the same way about Walmart, like they were getting
- 26:14all of their things at a low, low cost. Not thinking about the
- 26:17displacement of the mom and pop shop. They had to differentiate
- 26:21by providing superior service not low, low price. Amazon's
- 26:25going to do the same thing. And it's like, I love Amazon Prime.
- 26:30I love having the ability to get something or to find something
- 26:34and have it sent to my home.
- 26:35Tom Ollerton: So you think that like Amazon are going to provide
- 26:37some kind of LLM thing. And you'll just use that and that'll
- 26:41be on your Echo, on your watch...
- 26:42Mark Cibort: Or I won't even, I won't even know they're going to
- 26:45be doing it for me. They're doing it now like they're making
- 26:47product choices before I even have to choose a product. So
- 26:51it's up to organisations to make their stuff, their content
- 26:55findable by those LLMs to be able to say, "Hey, here's
- 26:59something that we're going to pre-populate in somebody's
- 27:01consideration set before they even know they need it."
- 27:04Tom Ollerton: You know, it's interesting, when I was
- 27:05researching the book and like the key moments in data driven
- 27:08marketing and digital and it was Amazon, whether it was like
- 27:12Seattle or some other... In their original office, they
- 27:15didn't have desks, right? They had like filing cabinets with
- 27:18doors on like, you know, a door like and there was apparently
- 27:21there was this coffee machine and it would just like leak
- 27:24coffee all over the floor. And I can't- Sorry, whoever wrote this
- 27:28algorithm, can't remember his name and he wrote this thing
- 27:31called a recommendation algorithm. So he went to Jeff
- 27:34Bezos and he was like, you know, if you've read, you know, Mark
- 27:38Twain or whatever, like you got recommended, you know, Steinbeck
- 27:40or whatever. And apparently Jeff Bezos like, knelt down in this
- 27:44coffee sodden carpet and like did a Wayne's World thing. And
- 27:48if you think about it, that data driven marketing campaign, which
- 27:53is you like this, you might like this.
- 27:54Mark Cibort: Yeah.
- 27:55Tom Ollerton: It's probably the most successful marketing
- 27:58campaign ever and ever will be for the amount of money. I mean,
- 28:01obviously, the algorithm's changed, but it's just grown and
- 28:03grown and grown and now where it's like agentic level, right?
- 28:06So, you know, stuff's going to come through the door and you're
- 28:09going to be like, oh, great. I didn't even realise, you know...
- 28:11Mark Cibort: Yeah. I didn't know that I needed this or that. You
- 28:14know, I have a choice in front of me of three things. There
- 28:18could be 300 things, but because somebody's content, somebody's
- 28:22information, somebody's data was more findable, more spreadable
- 28:26by LLMs, this is, this is what I'm looking at. So it's that the
- 28:31combination of agentic and human together in getting marketers
- 28:36out in front of the consumers that they want to touch, that
- 28:39they want to reach. But I don't think it's going to fall off. It
- 28:43might get replaced by something else. There will be some new,
- 28:46new, new thing. But what we're in right now, that will continue
- 28:50and it will it'll continue to refine and optimise, maybe not
- 28:54at the same breakneck pace or with as much scrutiny just
- 28:57because something else has taken its place, something else has
- 29:00stolen the headline as the thing.
- 29:02Tom Ollerton: Yeah. I can't wait until the industry starts
- 29:04talking about quantum again because I mean I- I'm not a
- 29:08massive expert in quantum computing, but I was reading
- 29:11recently saying that no one really knows exactly why it
- 29:13works. And, and there's a possibility that quantum
- 29:17computing borrows intelligence from different parallel
- 29:20universes. And you're like, how is that going to affect my click
- 29:23through rate on a, you know...
- 29:26Mark Cibort: No, quantum computing organisation where I
- 29:29used to work, there were a group of people who were focused in on
- 29:32that and they were so nerded out by it, it was just like this
- 29:35obsession that it was going to be the thing and it probably
- 29:39still could be the thing. I mean, it consumes large amounts
- 29:43of energy more than anything that's what we're... More than
- 29:47any particular or singular A.I. related elements now with all
- 29:51the data centres that are popping up everywhere in that
- 29:54level of investment that I think is going to burst before A.I.
- 29:58itself bursts because there's only so much money you can
- 30:01invest in physical location before where's the water?
- 30:05Where's the resource that's cooling, powering, doing all of
- 30:08the things? I grew up in a small town in Pennsylvania near the
- 30:12nuclear power plant, Three Mile Island that almost melted down
- 30:15back in in the late seventies. They turned that into an A.I.
- 30:19centre. It's the same nuclear power plant that they've
- 30:22retooled and turned into a data centre, which is insane.
- 30:27Tom Ollerton: Sounds a lot.
- 30:27Mark Cibort: Right, like it's... Yeah, but I think that's going
- 30:32to be an area that people have to be careful of. Like if you're
- 30:34throwing your money into the building and creation of data
- 30:37centres, watch out.
- 30:39Tom Ollerton: Mark, you know, I could happily sit here for the
- 30:42rest of the day, get some lunch and some coffee, but we have,
- 30:45you got a call and that we have, we are massively over but
- 30:48because I've enjoyed it so much.
- 30:49Mark Cibort: Same.
- 30:50Tom Ollerton: If someone wants to talk to you about rehashed
- 30:53nuclear underground sea bunkers, agentic, parenting tips and the
- 31:01three As, where is a good place to get in touch with you and
- 31:04crucially what makes a message that you will reply to.
- 31:08Mark Cibort: So LinkedIn is the best way because that comes
- 31:11through for me as a professional filter. So reaching out, whether
- 31:15it's a direct message or connecting on LinkedIn and hey,
- 31:19I saw you on the podcast is always going to be the right way
- 31:22to get someone's attention for somebody to get my attention,
- 31:26especially after doing this with you.
- 31:28Tom Ollerton: Mark, thank you so much.
- 31:29Mark Cibort: My pleasure. Thank you.