Latest / Surrounded / Allie Beth Stuckey vs 25 Liberal Christians
Transcript
- 0:00Do you believe that gay people are supposed to be celibate?
- 0:03I think that we are all called to deny what the Bible calls sin.
- 0:07I don't believe it's a sin to be gay.
- 0:09The Bible does condone slavery,
- 0:11that does not mean that I agree with instituting slavery.
- 0:14You are very good at this.
- 0:15You should keep moving the goalposts,
- 0:16OK?
- 0:17How am I moving The claim you made.
- 0:20that the Bible does not to and around about slavery.
- 0:22I'm not gonna,
- 0:23I'm not gonna let it go.
- 0:24What we're suffering from right now on the right
- 0:26and on the left is a massive lack of empathy
- 0:29for each other.
- 0:30We're being fed algorithms that show each other
- 0:32these crazy versions of the other side,
- 0:35and we don't look each other in the eyes and and feel for one another.
- 0:41From Jubilee Media,
- 0:42this is the Surrounded podcast,
- 0:44where one brave soul faces a room full of disagreers.
- 0:47In the center today is Alibeth Stuckey.
- 0:49She's an author,
- 0:50podcaster,
- 0:51and conservative Christian,
- 0:53and she will be debating 20 liberal Christians.
- 0:56They will debate her one on one until they are
- 0:58voted out by their peers and replaced by someone new.
- 1:01Let's get into it.
- 1:03Hi,
- 1:04I'm Ali Beth Stuckey.
- 1:05I'm the host of the podcast Relatable,
- 1:07and I'm author of the book Toxic Empathy,
- 1:09How Progressives exploit Christian Compassion,
- 1:12and I'm surrounded by 20 liberal Christians.
- 1:15My first claim is the Bible says marriage is only between one man and one woman.
- 1:28You got it.
- 1:29Good job.
- 1:30OK,
- 1:30so I am an independent,
- 1:32but on this issue I do lean liberal.
- 1:35So I don't disagree with you that the Bible
- 1:38doesn't show same-sex couples in a marriage,
- 1:41that it's just not there.
- 1:43My view is that it's because it wasn't going on culturally at the time,
- 1:47and I do understand.
- 1:48You know that Jesus talks about in the beginning,
- 1:51right?
- 1:51Like God made them male and female,
- 1:53and there is a lot of
- 1:54Old Testament
- 1:56examples of marriage that aren't always just one man,
- 1:58one woman,
- 1:59but I do understand what you're saying.
- 2:00My question to you,
- 2:01Ali,
- 2:02is,
- 2:02do you think that it's OK if we preserve those principles
- 2:06that are in a marriage between one man and one woman?
- 2:09Two same-sex couples,
- 2:10you know,
- 2:11considering that they are honoring each other for following 1 Corinthians 13,
- 2:14right?
- 2:15That they honor each other as themselves,
- 2:17especially if the man is authentically gay like me and has
- 2:21no attractions to women.
- 2:23What do we,
- 2:24what do I do with that?
- 2:25You know what I'm saying?
- 2:26And so if I can find a partner
- 2:28in a monogamous covenantal marriage
- 2:31and be with them even
- 2:33abstinent until marriage,
- 2:34OK,
- 2:34giving all of those things,
- 2:36how do you feel about that?
- 2:38Yeah,
- 2:39so what we see in scripture is that
- 2:40it's not actually cultural how God defines marriage.
- 2:43We go all the way back to the very first chapter of the first book of the Bible,
- 2:47and we read in Genesis 1:27 that God made us male and female,
- 2:50male and female.
- 2:51He created us in His image.
- 2:53He created us.
- 2:54So the definition of marriage is not only rooted in creation,
- 2:57reiterated throughout Scripture like Honor your father and mother,
- 3:00repeated by Jesus,
- 3:01Matthew 19:45,
- 3:03but here's an important point
- 3:04why what you're saying can't be supported by Scripture,
- 3:07because in Ephesians 5,
- 3:09we see that marriage is not just an earthly physical reality,
- 3:12but it is actually representative of an eternal reality,
- 3:15the marriage between Christ and the church.
- 3:18Christ is described as Groom,
- 3:20the church is described as the bride,
- 3:22and in Ephesians 5 we read that marriage on
- 3:25earth is actually a reflection of that eternal reality.
- 3:28The Bible starts with the marriage between Adam and Eve,
- 3:31but it ends with a marriage between Christ,
- 3:33the bridegroom,
- 3:34and the church,
- 3:36the bride.
- 3:36And so earthly marriage and the gender designations that
- 3:40we read in Scripture actually speak to an eternal
- 3:43reality that is fixed and cannot be changed because
- 3:47As a man and woman reflect that eternal reality.
- 3:50Two men can't do that and two women can't do that.
- 3:52So eternal.
- 3:52So is it your view that
- 3:54marriage goes into heaven?
- 3:56It's an earthly reflection of the eternal reality
- 3:59of the marriage between Christ and His church.
- 4:01Now,
- 4:01we actually read that we are not married or given in marriage in heaven,
- 4:05but no male,
- 4:06no female on earth,
- 4:08this earthly union between one man and one woman reflects the eternal reality
- 4:14that Christ the.
- 4:15He is married to his church,
- 4:17the bride.
- 4:17That is what it is supposed to reflect here on Earth,
- 4:20and only one man and one woman can do that.
- 4:22Do you believe that gay people are supposed to be celibate?
- 4:25Do you think that they should be called to celibacy?
- 4:27I think that we are all called to deny what the Bible calls sin,
- 4:31and that looks different for everyone.
- 4:33And I know that that is difficult to hear.
- 4:37I've talked to a lot of people
- 4:39that have heard that,
- 4:40and it's difficult to hear,
- 4:41but all of us,
- 4:42every single Christian.
- 4:43In one way or another,
- 4:44it's called to take up our cross,
- 4:46to deny our flesh,
- 4:47and to follow Christ.
- 4:48We're to repudiate all forms of sexual immorality,
- 4:51not just homosexuality,
- 4:52but all forms of sexual immorality that goes for all of us.
- 4:55OK,
- 4:56so if I am a gay person.
- 4:58You believe that I should be celibate,
- 5:00and there are a lot of us,
- 5:02correct?
- 5:03How do you feel about mixed orientation or lavender marriages?
- 5:06In other words,
- 5:07if somebody's like,
- 5:07well,
- 5:08I have these feelings,
- 5:09right?
- 5:10And I can't engage with them,
- 5:11I have no healthy way to express them with another man.
- 5:14What should I just marry a woman?
- 5:15Is that fair to her?
- 5:17How do you feel I'm not saying that you must marry a woman.
- 5:19I think
- 5:20what I would want for you,
- 5:21what I want for myself,
- 5:22what I want for everyone
- 5:24is to deny our flesh,
- 5:26deny our sin,
- 5:26and to follow Christ.
- 5:27And I can't say what exactly that's going to look like.
- 5:29Like for you,
- 5:31but in Christ,
- 5:32no matter who we are or what our desires is,
- 5:35we can have the fullness of satisfaction and fulfillment.
- 5:39Marriage is not necessarily the ideal of holiness for every single person.
- 5:44But is your understanding?
- 5:46It's nice to talk to you.
- 5:48Nice to talk to you.
- 5:48Thank you so much.
- 5:55Tim,
- 5:56I know who you are.
- 5:58I see a familiar face.
- 5:59It's nice to meet you in person.
- 6:00Pleasure.
- 6:01Um,
- 6:02I want to hone in on this claim that
- 6:04the Bible,
- 6:05um,
- 6:06only supports the idea of one man,
- 6:08one woman in marriage.
- 6:09The Bible doesn't though,
- 6:11unless you think,
- 6:11I mean,
- 6:12for example,
- 6:12David,
- 6:13he had 8 wives.
- 6:14That's what the Bible says.
- 6:15So there's a difference between prescription and description.
- 6:18I understand that,
- 6:19but the Bible still
- 6:20says that someone had multiple wives.
- 6:23That's a description of something that's not God saying that is good and holy.
- 6:26Well,
- 6:26I mean,
- 6:27David's a man after God's own heart,
- 6:28right?
- 6:28Yes.
- 6:29And David also committed murder and he also committed adultery,
- 6:33which we know he repented of those things and was sorrowful over those things.
- 6:36But that's very different than that does not mean,
- 6:38that does not mean,
- 6:39first of all,
- 6:39we don't know that David consummated the marriage.
- 6:42With all of Saul's wives,
- 6:43and it's true.
- 6:45We don't know that you said wives plural.
- 6:46So again,
- 6:47you're proving the point that I'm making is that the Bible,
- 6:49but the Bible Solomon had a lot of wives too.
- 6:52No wives,
- 6:52no problems actually is what we see over and over
- 6:55again it's still in the Bible is my point.
- 6:57Yes,
- 6:57there are a lot of things in the Bible that the Bible only
- 7:00says prescribes,
- 7:02what's the original claim that you made
- 7:03that the Bible says that marriage is only between one man and one woman.
- 7:08But the Bible says.
- 7:10That Lame took two wives,
- 7:11that Jacob married his first cousins,
- 7:14right,
- 7:14and married that they were sisters as well.
- 7:16So and that's where the whole line of Israel comes through,
- 7:19right?
- 7:19existed that marriage the Bible doesn't condemn it.
- 7:21Well,
- 7:21the Bible doesn't condemn Jacob's marriages,
- 7:23so,
- 7:24so when we read the Bible,
- 7:25this is where I'm coming from,
- 7:26but I take your point that maybe I should add a descriptor in there that
- 7:30the Bible says
- 7:32what I am claiming is that the Bible says that holy marriage,
- 7:35that good marriage,
- 7:36that right marriage,
- 7:37the marriage.
- 7:37that God condones and calls holy
- 7:39is only between one man and one woman.
- 7:42And when I read the Bible,
- 7:43I'm not just saying,
- 7:44OK,
- 7:44what can I get away with?
- 7:45What did all these bad sinners do?
- 7:47And can I do that too?
- 7:48And God won't condemn me.
- 7:49I'm also looking at what God calls good.
- 7:52And when I look at the definition of marriage,
- 7:53like I just talked about with the,
- 7:55uh,
- 7:55with Gilbert,
- 7:56it's rooted in creation.
- 7:58It's reiterated throughout Scripture.
- 7:59It's repeated by Jesus in Matthew 19.
- 8:02It is representative of Christ in the church in Ephesians 5.
- 8:05And it is reflective of the gospel as we see in Revelation 20.
- 8:09And so it is more
- 8:10than just saying,
- 8:11well,
- 8:11yeah,
- 8:11a lot of people had a lot of wives.
- 8:13A lot of people did a lot of bad things in the Bible.
- 8:15That doesn't mean that God accepted them.
- 8:16You keep saying bad things.
- 8:18The Bible does not
- 8:19explicitly condemn the marriages of multiple different people,
- 8:22though,
- 8:23only one kind of marriage,
- 8:24good and holy,
- 8:25and the example for us to follow in Genesis we see
- 8:27that in the first and last chapter of the Bible.
- 8:29So Genesis 1,
- 8:30right,
- 8:30also prescribes eating vegetables only.
- 8:33Yes,
- 8:33so do you believe we shall be vegetarians?
- 8:35No,
- 8:36I don't believe that's in the creation order,
- 8:38isn't it?
- 8:38By your,
- 8:38by your own logic,
- 8:39it's in the creation order of Genesis 1 that we should only,
- 8:42or Genesis 1 and 2.
- 8:43I believe in reading every piece of scripture in all of contexts.
- 8:46I totally agree with you,
- 8:47and
- 8:48I think that there are some things that we
- 8:50would probably agree that existed and were the case pre-fall
- 8:54that were the case
- 8:55post fall.
- 8:56So for example,
- 8:57walking around,
- 8:58walking around naked.
- 8:59One
- 8:59walking around naked,
- 9:00that's not something that we typically see today.
- 9:02Maybe that can be another claim that I make that y'all would disagree with.
- 9:05But so there is a reason
- 9:07for things to be prescribed pre and post fall.
- 9:09But what we see,
- 9:10because I didn't just say it's rooted in creation,
- 9:12I also said
- 9:13it is reiterated throughout Scripture.
- 9:15I also said it's repeated by Jesus.
- 9:17I also said it's representative of Christ in the church.
- 9:19So it's not just about Genesis 1.
- 9:21But even the idea of Christ in the church is multiple people with one person.
- 9:25Yes,
- 9:26but multiple singular.
- 9:27Church is singular.
- 9:28It's not Church is not the brides of Christ.
- 9:30Church is the one bride of Christ,
- 9:32the collective bride of the collective,
- 9:34many people,
- 9:35right?
- 9:35So are you saying that the Bible condones polygamy?
- 9:38What I'm saying,
- 9:39the Bible absolutely it doesn't condone it.
- 9:42It does look at Solomon's life.
- 9:43Mo wives,
- 9:44mo problems.
- 9:45We do not.
- 9:45That's see one example.
- 9:47David was a man after God's own heart,
- 9:49problems.
- 9:49had to again,
- 9:50David had.
- 9:51Problem with the wives.
- 9:53That is,
- 9:53I would
- 9:54argue that over and one more question for you.
- 9:56Do you believe in Genesis 1?
- 9:57Do you believe that that's a literal account of how the earth was created?
- 10:00Is that correct?
- 10:01So Adam and Eve were the first two people ever,
- 10:03right?
- 10:03So how did they and their kids,
- 10:05hold on,
- 10:07I want to finish.
- 10:07I want to finish.
- 10:08How did they and their kids
- 10:10have more kids without breaking,
- 10:12first off,
- 10:12the rule of incest,
- 10:13which we know we deeply deplore,
- 10:14and also multiple partners.
- 10:17Yeah,
- 10:17well,
- 10:18they wouldn't have had to have multiple partners.
- 10:20I don't know how that would work.
- 10:21We don't know exactly how everything was populated,
- 10:24but that's also not the claim that I'm making.
- 10:26The claim that I'm making is that the only holy definition of
- 10:30marriage in the Bible is between one man and one woman.
- 10:33It's not just about Genesis 1,
- 10:34the log It's about every claim throughout Scripture,
- 10:36the logic of Genesis 1,
- 10:38which you rooted,
- 10:38that was your first point in creation.
- 10:40It's rooted in creation portrayed by the logic of having
- 10:43to populate the entire earth out of one couple.
- 10:45It doesn't work.
- 10:46That's not.
- 10:46Necessarily true.
- 10:47So God set things up so it's only one man and one woman for life,
- 10:50right,
- 10:51in the marriage,
- 10:51and then set things up so they had to pre procreate,
- 10:54assume,
- 10:55assumingly,
- 10:56possibly with their own children.
- 10:57We don't know how many children they had,
- 10:59and we don't know how exactly it was populated.
- 11:01Well,
- 11:01I mean,
- 11:02we,
- 11:02we know how kids are made,
- 11:03right?
- 11:03So at some point kids were,
- 11:05or then adults,
- 11:06think about that you are not undermining my claim that the Bible
- 11:09only calls one kind of marriage holy that we should be representing today
- 11:14because it's not just about Genesis one.
- 11:19Pleasure,
- 11:19truly nice to be with you.
- 11:24Oh,
- 11:26hey,
- 11:26what's your name?
- 11:27Paul.
- 11:28Paul,
- 11:28nice to meet you.
- 11:29Where in the Bible does it condemn homosexual marriage or homosexuality?
- 11:32Homosexuality.
- 11:33We could look at both the Old and the New Testament,
- 11:36but I prefer to look at Romans 1 because it doesn't just say the word homosexuality.
- 11:40We can contend over when that was added to the Bible.
- 11:42I know that's a claim that people make,
- 11:44but it actually describes the behavior of homosexuality and says that God.
- 11:48Gave them over to the impurity of their hearts,
- 11:51gave them over to their lusts,
- 11:52and said that women exchanged natural relations
- 11:55with men for unnatural relations with women.
- 11:57Men exchanged
- 11:59natural relations with women for unnatural
- 12:01relations with men,
- 12:02and this is condemned in Scripture not only there but also in 1 Corinthians 6.
- 12:07And so
- 12:07yeah,
- 12:07we see it condemned multiple places throughout Scripture.
- 12:10OK,
- 12:10yeah,
- 12:10let's talk about Romans 1 real quick.
- 12:12Let's get that out of the way.
- 12:13Do you understand that Romans 1 is speaking about how the Gentiles have to do all this
- 12:18as a rhetorical trap in Romans 2
- 12:20to go ahead and say to the Jews,
- 12:22you're all actually guilty as well,
- 12:23and you all need Christ?
- 12:24Where are you getting that idea?
- 12:25Have you read Romans 1?
- 12:27Yes,
- 12:27of course I've read Romans 1.
- 12:28I have it in front of me.
- 12:29I can read it for you right before,
- 12:30right before 26,
- 12:31right before 25,
- 12:32uh,
- 12:33right before 27,
- 12:34all about idolatry.
- 12:35So why is it,
- 12:36why is it that this is not about idolatry all of a sudden?
- 12:38Yes,
- 12:39actually,
- 12:391 Corinthians 6 says the same thing to flee from idolatry,
- 12:42flee from all forms of sexual immorality,
- 12:45and then it lists specifically men who practice
- 12:47homosexuality as one of the practices that's condemned.
- 12:50And so idolatry and sexual immorality,
- 12:53all forms of it,
- 12:54we do see.
- 12:55are hand in hand throughout scripture,
- 12:57including in Romans 1.
- 12:58So I'm not seeing your point that this is some sort of rhetorical trap,
- 13:01a trap or that he's not speaking literally here.
- 13:04So this is the only reference of lesbianism
- 13:06in the New Testament,
- 13:07you would say that,
- 13:07right,
- 13:08that I can think of,
- 13:09sure,
- 13:09except
- 13:10Saint Augustine,
- 13:11Thomas Aquinas,
- 13:13Gregory,
- 13:14all of them said it wasn't,
- 13:15because what's actually happening here in Greco-Roman times
- 13:18is that women are having anal intercourse
- 13:20as part of ritual taboos.
- 13:21That's why it's idolatry.
- 13:22You want to go back to the Old Testament?
- 13:24You want to go reference 1822,
- 13:26uh,
- 13:26because we can go there too.
- 13:27Um,
- 13:28I'm not sure that I know what you are referring to when you say 1822,
- 13:32but I also don't see any evidence for,
- 13:36yeah.
- 13:36Oh,
- 13:36you're talking about,
- 13:37oh,
- 13:37I thought you meant the year Leviticus 1822.
- 13:40Yes,
- 13:40but again,
- 13:41it's Old Testament,
- 13:42it's New Testament,
- 13:43and not only is it condemned in multiple places,
- 13:45but again,
- 13:46we certainly can't say,
- 13:47and I don't think that you would be able to.
- 13:49Say that homosexual relations are ever talked about in any
- 13:53sort of positive or holy sense throughout Scripture.
- 13:55So
- 13:55as a Christian,
- 13:56when I'm reading Scripture,
- 13:57I'm not saying,
- 13:58OK,
- 13:58what can I get away with?
- 13:59I want to know how can I glorify God most,
- 14:02and I want to look at what does he talk about positively.
- 14:04What word is used in the Old Testament to talk about male on male relationships?
- 14:09I'm not,
- 14:09I don't remember the Hebrew term.
- 14:11Which is actually male prostitutes,
- 14:13and you're talking about,
- 14:14do you believe that it was just pederasty or it
- 14:16was pedophilia that they were condemning at the time.
- 14:19Kadisham literally means male prostitutes,
- 14:21but in the New Testament,
- 14:22the Greek words used are just male lies with male.
- 14:25There is no denotion whatsoever that this was
- 14:27not consensual or that this was a man and a child.
- 14:30There's a different word for that.
- 14:32Arsenokota.
- 14:33Arsenokota is one of the words that's used for that.
- 14:36There's also another word that's used in Romans 1.
- 14:39To condemn homosexuality,
- 14:40but
- 14:41we don't actually see that this denotes any sort of pederasty or pedophilia.
- 14:45It's very clear that we're talking about two adults.
- 14:47I'm not talking about pedophilia here.
- 14:48I'm talking about pederasty.
- 14:51Arun Kotai,
- 14:51do you know the earliest usage of it?
- 14:53I don't.
- 14:54It was actually used as economic exploitation of men
- 14:57because back then the only homosexual relationships you had,
- 14:59keep in mind the word homosexual,
- 15:00came in the 1860s,
- 15:02the earliest is exactly why it wasn't added,
- 15:04added to Scripture till 19.
- 15:066,
- 15:06not because the act was not
- 15:09described in scripture.
- 15:10Yeah,
- 15:10so Arseokotai has been used for economic exploitation in its earliest usage,
- 15:14and above that,
- 15:15Malakoy was used for effeminate men
- 15:17that were castrating themselves
- 15:19for the goddess Athena.
- 15:20When Christianity first came around,
- 15:22there was a huge pantheon of Roman gods,
- 15:23and people in Ephesus were worshiping them as well,
- 15:26and they were saying,
- 15:26oh,
- 15:27there's actually multiple gods.
- 15:28And all around Scripture,
- 15:29that's,
- 15:30that's exactly the case that's happening.
- 15:31There's actually No usage at all.
- 15:34We actually have Greek words that Paul likely knew about
- 15:37that reference homosexuality.
- 15:39Why didn't he use them?
- 15:40Why did he only use two words that mean effeminate men,
- 15:43which he was describing for men that castrate themselves for Athena,
- 15:45and arsenna kotai,
- 15:47which refers to men that take advantage of smaller men like sex slave trades.
- 15:50So your is your argument that the Bible never condemns homosexuality anywhere
- 15:54and that homosexual relations,
- 15:56as long as they were consensual and between two adults.
- 15:59is actually elevated to a place of morality in the same place
- 16:02that a man a marriage between a man and a woman is.
- 16:05Is that your argument?
- 16:06I'm saying the Bible has no condemnation of it,
- 16:08no condemnation.
- 16:09But when we look at Scripture,
- 16:10what is the one kind of relationship that we see described
- 16:13as holy,
- 16:14as representative of Christ in the church,
- 16:16as having the ability to go forth and be fruitful and multiply?
- 16:19All of us are
- 16:20born with our full digestive systems,
- 16:23our full circulatory systems,
- 16:24but all of us are only born.
- 16:25With half a reproductive system,
- 16:27don't you think that science tells us a little bit of
- 16:30something about how human beings are supposed to join together?
- 16:33No,
- 16:33because not all human beings join together.
- 16:35Many don't.
- 16:36Many people don't even have sexual in principle.
- 16:38Well,
- 16:39no,
- 16:39by nature,
- 16:39in principle,
- 16:40sure,
- 16:40that that's to multiply,
- 16:41you know,
- 16:42if that's your natural law and interpretation.
- 16:43However,
- 16:44Jesus teaches us that we're not our body parts.
- 16:46We're a lot more than them.
- 16:47Jesus also teaches that in the beginning he made them male and female,
- 16:50and the two shall come together and become one.
- 16:52Flesh.
- 16:53What is that about?
- 16:54Matthew 19:45.
- 16:55That's what is it about?
- 16:57He is answering a question about divorce,
- 16:58and instead of just saying God hates divorce,
- 17:00he goes all the way back to the creation ordinance
- 17:03and the definition of male and female and marriage is between one man and one woman.
- 17:07He does not do that.
- 17:07He,
- 17:08he does.
- 17:08He doesn't Matthew 19:45.
- 17:10He does.
- 17:10He goes all the way back explicitly.
- 17:12I know he does that.
- 17:12I know he talks about creation order.
- 17:14Creation order is not condemnation of homosexuality.
- 17:16You keep talking about and keep postulating that
- 17:18just.
- 17:19Because of these descriptive
- 17:20parts of the Bible,
- 17:21as you used in your last argument,
- 17:23all of a sudden that's prescriptive,
- 17:24that homosexuality is out.
- 17:25No,
- 17:25but it is prescriptive because it says that these people will
- 17:28not inherit the kingdom of God in 1 Corinthians 6,
- 17:31and that includes men who practice homosexuality.
- 17:33Romans 1,
- 17:34it's also condemned and described that he is giving them over to
- 17:37a depraved mind to do what ought not to be done.
- 17:40That is a prescription to not do something,
- 17:43except.
- 17:47Thank you very,
- 17:47very much.
- 17:48Pleasure meeting you.
- 17:53Hey,
- 17:54how are you?
- 17:54What's your name?
- 17:56Danny,
- 17:56nice to meet you,
- 17:56Danny.
- 17:57Yeah,
- 17:57just to say you're doing a wonderful job.
- 17:59I really appreciate it.
- 18:00Everyone's doing a great job so far.
- 18:02So
- 18:03you had made a comment
- 18:05earlier,
- 18:05I think maybe with Tim or one of the other conversations about,
- 18:08um,
- 18:08more or less you said the fruit of relationships,
- 18:11right,
- 18:11or the fruit of people you had kind of implied at least,
- 18:14but I think scripture talks about the fruit of the kind of Christians that we are,
- 18:17right,
- 18:17this idea that we grow up.
- 18:18I don't know that I brought that up,
- 18:19but it's a good point.
- 18:21I can go on that,
- 18:21I think you said it maybe not explicitly,
- 18:23but you,
- 18:23the heart of it was there.
- 18:24So I'm a pastor of a church that is growing.
- 18:28And not just with straight individuals,
- 18:30not just with people that look like me,
- 18:32but
- 18:32queer individuals that have some of like the greatest fruit
- 18:35of the spirit that I've ever seen.
- 18:37Love,
- 18:37joy,
- 18:38peace,
- 18:38patience,
- 18:38kindness,
- 18:38gentleness,
- 18:39self-control,
- 18:39all of those things.
- 18:41First,
- 18:41I just
- 18:42would love to hear your thought on how
- 18:44someone so sinful could produce such wonderful fruit.
- 18:47Um,
- 18:47but I'm really happy to talk about this,
- 18:48but I just want to hear that because
- 18:50you've given really interesting and good arguments,
- 18:52but that's one that I have a hard time reconciling.
- 18:54Well,
- 18:54all of us sin,
- 18:56and all of us struggle with sin,
- 18:57and I've met lots of people from all different walks of life that are joyful and kind,
- 19:02and God gives us what we call the gift of common grace,
- 19:05that there are people who are not Christians who might exude
- 19:08some of the characteristics that we want to embody as Christians,
- 19:11but that doesn't mean
- 19:12That everything they do or everything they believe or
- 19:14everything they say is in alignment with scripture.
- 19:18And so that's what I would say there.
- 19:19I have no doubt that the people that you know who identify as LGBTQ are also really
- 19:24kind and really patient and really joyful and might
- 19:27have characteristics that we all want to emulate,
- 19:29but that doesn't mean that every part of their life
- 19:32is in alignment with what we see God say in His word.
- 19:35And because of that,
- 19:36they wouldn't inherit the.
- 19:37Kingdom of heaven,
- 19:37like pretty much every one of those all of us,
- 19:40if we don't pick up our cross and follow Christ,
- 19:43by the grace of Christ,
- 19:44by the way,
- 19:44it's not our own merit.
- 19:46None of us bring none of these individuals,
- 19:47yeah,
- 19:49nothing
- 19:50that we could do could ever deserve salvation.
- 19:52God gives it to us in Christ,
- 19:54but because of that grace,
- 19:56because of that love that He has given us,
- 19:58all of us are told to deny sin.
- 20:00All of us are told to repent,
- 20:02and so.
- 20:02I think when we tell someone
- 20:04who says,
- 20:04you know what,
- 20:05this is how I identify,
- 20:06it's not in alignment with,
- 20:08with what God
- 20:09God calls good and holy,
- 20:10that we are actually
- 20:11burdening them
- 20:13with more sin,
- 20:14whereas we all need to be free
- 20:16of our slavery to sin.
- 20:17I would agree with that.
- 20:17So one of the biggest critiques I hate about progressive Christians,
- 20:20we don't believe in sin.
- 20:21We certainly do.
- 20:21We actually reject it,
- 20:22sin and brokenness everywhere we find it and try to push it back.
- 20:24I
- 20:25would not argue that being a queer person is a part of that.
- 20:27But I would go back to Genesis,
- 20:28and you made a great point.
- 20:29Like,
- 20:29it's not all in Genesis,
- 20:30but Hebrew scholars,
- 20:32rabbis,
- 20:33and people that study this
- 20:34would not read this as literal.
- 20:36They would read as an archetypal story.
- 20:37So we could probably find Hebrew scholars that would,
- 20:40and there are probably a lot of competing theologians
- 20:43when it comes to the literalism of the,
- 20:44let me rephrase it then,
- 20:45uh,
- 20:46all of my friends who are practicing rabbis
- 20:49across the board would not read it.
- 20:50is literal,
- 20:51and so I'm sure you could certainly get someone,
- 20:53they would view it as an archetypal story,
- 20:55like the idea that we are put together,
- 20:57uh,
- 20:57and there's a helper,
- 20:58and that there
- 20:59is an idea of us together and that the helper is not just the woman,
- 21:02the helper
- 21:03is
- 21:04together in this collaborative relationship.
- 21:06And so
- 21:06I think understanding Genesis is something that's read to be literal,
- 21:09which again the people that author that text are siblings in faith,
- 21:12are Jewish brothers and sisters like.
- 21:14Wouldn't have read it as literal.
- 21:15So I just,
- 21:16I again,
- 21:16another thing I have a hard time,
- 21:17I'm a Christian and so I want to read the
- 21:19Old Testament also in the context of the New Testament,
- 21:22believing
- 21:23that Jesus is God Himself.
- 21:25So the Old Testament and the New Testament,
- 21:27Jesus
- 21:27is in,
- 21:28Jesus agrees with.
- 21:29I would not separate those two things.
- 21:32So I read
- 21:33Genesis 1 also in the context of Ephesians 5,
- 21:36also in the context of Matthew 19,
- 21:38in the context of Revelation 20,
- 21:40where again we see marriage
- 21:41is a.
- 21:42Reflection between Christ the bridegroom
- 21:44and church the bride.
- 21:45Those gender designations are fixed.
- 21:49So where does Jesus,
- 21:50a first century rabbi,
- 21:52tell us to read that literally,
- 21:54to go back and do we see that Jesus seems to take it literally.
- 21:58For example,
- 21:58when he's answering a question about divorce in Matthew 19,
- 22:01he doesn't say,
- 22:02well,
- 22:02metaphorically,
- 22:04God made them male and female.
- 22:06I don't know that everything Jesus said was recorded,
- 22:08but that's not what you asked.
- 22:09You asked,
- 22:10where.
- 22:10Do we see that Jesus took Genesis literally and when he
- 22:13what does he say that we should take it literally,
- 22:15not where does,
- 22:16well,
- 22:16he takes it literally implying that,
- 22:17but he takes it literally.
- 22:19I can,
- 22:20there's a lot of things from that he might not say that we should do today,
- 22:24but I think that you would call yourself a follower of Jesus,
- 22:26that we're to follow his example.
- 22:28And if he takes Genesis literally,
- 22:30or it seems like he does from Matthew 19,
- 22:33then I think my best bet is to take it literally too.
- 22:36I would say he takes it seriously.
- 22:39OK,
- 22:40thank you very much.
- 22:43My next claim is abortion is a grave moral evil.
- 22:53Hello,
- 22:53my name is Jared.
- 22:54What is Jared?
- 22:54I'm Ali.
- 22:55Nice to meet you.
- 22:56It's very nice to meet you here.
- 22:57Yeah,
- 22:57if it's OK with you,
- 22:59I'd like to start with a couple yes or no questions,
- 23:01and then I'd like to hear your response fully without interruption.
- 23:03OK,
- 23:04can I define our terms first and then I'll let you go and I won't interrupt you.
- 23:08OK,
- 23:08so because these terms are so contentious,
- 23:10I just want to make sure that we agree.
- 23:12So abortion,
- 23:13the intentional killing
- 23:15of a human being in the womb.
- 23:16Can we agree on that?
- 23:18I don't agree that abortion is murder.
- 23:20I said killing.
- 23:21Can we agree on that?
- 23:22I believe that it is killing life in the womb.
- 23:24Killing what species of life?
- 23:27A human.
- 23:27A human.
- 23:28OK,
- 23:28so we can agree that abortion is the intentional killing of a human
- 23:31inside the womb.
- 23:32Um,
- 23:33grave,
- 23:33just obviously,
- 23:34I mean serious moral,
- 23:36right versus wrong,
- 23:37evil,
- 23:37bad,
- 23:38wrong,
- 23:38sinful.
- 23:39So I believe that the intentional killing
- 23:41of an innocent human being is evil.
- 23:43Do you agree?
- 23:45No,
- 23:45you don't.
- 23:46OK,
- 23:46I don't go ahead.
- 23:47Yes or no,
- 23:47is abortion murder.
- 23:49Yes,
- 23:50in Matthew 5:28,
- 23:51when Jesus says that if I look at a woman lustfully,
- 23:53that I've already committed adultery with her in my heart.
- 23:56Yes,
- 23:56do you agree?
- 23:57Jesus doubles down on so many moral laws of the Old Testament.
- 24:01Just yes or really that's important.
- 24:03Do I agree with what
- 24:04Look at a woman lustfully that I have
- 24:06already committed adultery with her in my heart.
- 24:08Do you agree?
- 24:08Yes or no?
- 24:09in your heart.
- 24:09OK.
- 24:10In Matthew 5:22,
- 24:11when it says that if I'm angry with my brother or sister,
- 24:14then I,
- 24:14then I am guilty of the same judgment as if I had committed murder.
- 24:18Yes,
- 24:18spiritually,
- 24:19spiritually.
- 24:20Would you
- 24:21not necessarily legally,
- 24:22would it be fair to say that Jesus is implying that lust can lead to adultery
- 24:26and that anger can lead to murder?
- 24:27Yes,
- 24:28I would agree with that,
- 24:29but he is also saying that actually
- 24:31following the law is not just about what you do outwardly,
- 24:34but what you do in your heart and what you think and feel inside.
- 24:37Absolutely.
- 24:38Are pregnant women
- 24:39angry with the baby?
- 24:41When they undergo an abortion,
- 24:43yes or no,
- 24:44I have no idea.
- 24:44I don't think either of us can say how every
- 24:47single pregnant woman feels when she has an abortion.
- 24:50Do you know what every single pregnant woman is feeling when she has an abortion?
- 24:53Maybe some of them are angry at the baby.
- 24:54Maybe some of them are scared.
- 24:56Maybe some of them are desperate.
- 24:57Maybe some of them just don't want to be pregnant anymore.
- 24:59But ultimately it still leads to the same outcome
- 25:02that an innocent human being is being killed.
- 25:05Yes or no?
- 25:05That's all I'm asking.
- 25:06So you would,
- 25:07I gave you more than that.
- 25:08That's fine.
- 25:08I'm just,
- 25:09just trying to one more.
- 25:10Then how can abortion be murder if they do not share the same intention?
- 25:14How can an apple seed grow an orange tree?
- 25:16Jesus doesn't say that anger is the only thing that leads to murder.
- 25:19As we saw in the case of David,
- 25:21it was lust that led to the murder of Bathsheba's husband.
- 25:24So murder can still be murder even if the intent
- 25:28does not start with anger,
- 25:29and that is what I believe we see with abortion.
- 25:31What about
- 25:32Matthew 26:24 when Jesus says that it would be better if Judas had never been born?
- 25:36Why do Christian Conservatives believe that each conception
- 25:39deserves to be birthed when Jesus says otherwise.
- 25:41Well,
- 25:41Jesus doesn't say that Judas should have been
- 25:43murdered or that he should have been aborted.
- 25:45It said that he should have never been born,
- 25:46which we can deduce probably means never been conceived,
- 25:49and he is speaking figuratively there,
- 25:51that it would have been better for him to not
- 25:52be born than endure the judgment that he's going to endure
- 25:55because of what he did.
- 25:56That is not condoning killing the innocent people that Jesus defends.
- 26:02Thank you.
- 26:02Thank you so much.
- 26:08Hi,
- 26:08what's your name?
- 26:09Steve.
- 26:10Steve,
- 26:10nice to meet you,
- 26:10Steve.
- 26:11My concern
- 26:12about
- 26:13the way that you present the abortion issue,
- 26:16um,
- 26:17is
- 26:18you have claimed in the past that
- 26:21the liberal pro-choice position
- 26:24is that we don't give the whole truth
- 26:27about the abortion issue and you liken it
- 26:29as violent.
- 26:30You've described it here as killing.
- 26:33Abortion is violent and painful.
- 26:35Yes,
- 26:35for the child.
- 26:36Absolutely.
- 26:37My problem,
- 26:38my concern is that you are doing the same thing
- 26:42by not telling women the truth,
- 26:44that when the majority of abortions happen,
- 26:46which is in the 1st 6 weeks of pregnancy.
- 26:48That fetus has not developed pain receptors.
- 26:51That doesn't happen till
- 26:53maybe at the earliest 10 weeks.
- 26:54Ali.
- 26:55So are you saying that experts say 22 to 24 weeks.
- 26:58Is killing only wrong if someone can feel pain?
- 27:01It's wrong for you to characterize it as violent.
- 27:04It is violent painful when it's not.
- 27:07It is violent,
- 27:08of course it's violent,
- 27:08even when you take the abortion pill,
- 27:10you are starving that human being.
- 27:12If you want to call.
- 27:13Him or her,
- 27:13a zygote or a fetus,
- 27:15that's all fine.
- 27:15Those are all stages of development that all of us went through,
- 27:18that all children go through.
- 27:19It is still the killing
- 27:21of a human being.
- 27:22And when you take the abortion pill,
- 27:24the two-part abortion pill,
- 27:25you are starving that human being of the nutrients that he or she needs to survive,
- 27:30and that is violent that they can't.
- 27:32Are you saying there are a lot of people who are murdered who can't feel it?
- 27:35Are you saying that that murder is justified?
- 27:37Because they can't feel it.
- 27:38No,
- 27:38we're talking about abortion.
- 27:39We're,
- 27:40we're not talking about something else.
- 27:41We're talking about abortion.
- 27:42But I'm trying to understand your logic.
- 27:44You are saying that abortion is OK because babies don't feel it.
- 27:47So I'm asking you,
- 27:48is killing another innocent person when they don't feel it,
- 27:51is that justified?
- 27:52Abortion is
- 27:54health care for women who need it,
- 27:56who have unwanted pregnanies case is killing an innocent girls who have been raped,
- 28:01who.
- 28:01That have
- 28:02experienced incest,
- 28:03Ali,
- 28:04that's less than 1% of all abortions.
- 28:07Can we agree?
- 28:07So mostly abortions happen within the 1st 6 weeks,
- 28:10if I said to you,
- 28:11OK and violent,
- 28:12if,
- 28:12if I said to you,
- 28:13OK,
- 28:14fine,
- 28:14we will only allow,
- 28:15which this is not my position,
- 28:17but if I said we will only allow abortion in
- 28:19those 1% of cases in which it's rape or incest,
- 28:22would you agree with me
- 28:23to ban the rest of abortions?
- 28:25Did the Now 99 denial of abortion health care to women is 100% harmful
- 28:30to the woman who absolutely needs abortion is 100% harmful to the child care,
- 28:35physical healthcare.
- 28:36Killing an innocent person is not healthcare.
- 28:39Can you tell me another situation in which
- 28:40killing a person intentionally is health care?
- 28:43Here's the problem with the whole pro-life movement.
- 28:46You talk a lot about,
- 28:47look at,
- 28:47look at the evil origins of these movements.
- 28:50Look at your movement,
- 28:51Ali.
- 28:52The religious right movement
- 28:55started with the Southern strategy,
- 28:56and it didn't start with abortion.
- 28:58They figured out abortion was a great issue to raise a lot of money.
- 29:01No,
- 29:02no,
- 29:02no,
- 29:02no,
- 29:02this is your issue.
- 29:03We're no,
- 29:04my argument is that abortion is a grave moral evil.
- 29:07You say it's not because.
- 29:09Babies in the womb don't feel pain until a certain point in gestation.
- 29:12I'm asking you to apply that logic to people outside of the womb.
- 29:16Is murder OK when the victim
- 29:18doesn't feel pain,
- 29:19and why or why not?
- 29:20Here's the issue.
- 29:21You don't want to apply your logic to people outside of the womb.
- 29:24Tell me why.
- 29:26You don't want to listen to the logic that
- 29:28that.
- 29:28Is say that logic you won't support your logic.
- 29:32You won't support it.
- 29:33Jesus was a Jew,
- 29:33Ali,
- 29:34and Jews believed that life begins at first breath,
- 29:37not at conception.
- 29:38So this whole idea that life begins at conception,
- 29:41it's not biblical.
- 29:42It's not Jesus.
- 29:43I'd love to answer that before you get
- 29:45voted out because I think that's really important.
- 29:47I've heard that a lot,
- 29:48that life begins at first breath.
- 29:50First,
- 29:51we don't actually see that throughout scripture.
- 29:53That's number one.
- 29:54We can see in Jeremiah 1:5,
- 29:56we can see in Psalm 139
- 29:58that God actually consecrated people.
- 30:01God actually
- 30:02knitted them together in their mother's womb
- 30:05with intentionality and purpose and love.
- 30:07That's what we read in Psalm 139,
- 30:10that your eyes saw my unformed substance before any of
- 30:14my days came to be.
- 30:15That's what we read in Psalm 139.
- 30:17The other thing is people say.
- 30:19That life starts at first breath.
- 30:21First of all,
- 30:22breath is not an indicator of moral worth.
- 30:24There are people that depend on a ventilator to breathe.
- 30:27That's not a justification to murder them.
- 30:29And then the third one is that babies actually do breathe inside the womb.
- 30:33They're not breathing air.
- 30:34They're breathing in amniotic fluid,
- 30:36which is practicing those breathing motions.
- 30:39And so I still am not understanding your
- 30:41logic or the science behind what you're claiming.
- 30:43Yeah,
- 30:43so the abortion issue.
- 30:45Thank you.
- 30:52Hey,
- 30:52what's your name?
- 30:52Hi,
- 30:53I'm Katrina.
- 30:54Katrina,
- 30:54I'm Ali.
- 30:55Nice to meet you.
- 30:56Nice to meet you.
- 30:57Um,
- 30:57I've loved all the points that you've said.
- 30:59You've really stood your ground.
- 31:01I could not do what you're doing,
- 31:02so props.
- 31:03I'm glad you're here.
- 31:04Um,
- 31:04I just wanted to
- 31:06talk about how,
- 31:07for me as a progressive Christian,
- 31:09many behind me,
- 31:10I,
- 31:10I think we often
- 31:11talking about the conservative side,
- 31:13relate to the fact that there seems to be
- 31:15a hierarchy of sins and.
- 31:17And abortion and LGBTQ issues seem to be at the top of that,
- 31:20that that's really
- 31:22just like targeted a lot.
- 31:24It's really villainized.
- 31:25Um,
- 31:26and so,
- 31:27I would like to bring up an example,
- 31:29a biblical example,
- 31:30where there is a hierarchy,
- 31:32and abortion falls
- 31:34underneath
- 31:35adultery.
- 31:36Uh,
- 31:36I don't know if you've heard of Numbers 5 in the Bible,
- 31:40when it talks about
- 31:42that.
- 31:43If a woman cheats on her husband,
- 31:46if the husband suspects that the woman has cheated,
- 31:48not if she's cheated,
- 31:50right,
- 31:50if he even suspects that she's cheated on her husband,
- 31:54um,
- 31:54that she is to go and have a ceremony performed by a priest where the priest,
- 32:00um,
- 32:00it says that he.
- 32:01is the sand from the tabernacle ground,
- 32:04puts it into a holy water,
- 32:06and that water says that if there is a curse,
- 32:10if she's done the wrongdoing,
- 32:12there will be a curse and there will be
- 32:15a miscarriage,
- 32:16which
- 32:17what it sounds like is like an intentional.
- 32:20Removal of,
- 32:22yeah,
- 32:22I could see how someone would get that.
- 32:24Although I would say that all of us could probably
- 32:26agree this is a very strange and complex passage,
- 32:29and every theologian that I've read,
- 32:32that phrase her thigh fell away is very confusing.
- 32:35I think what we can read from this is that God is providing a way
- 32:38for a woman to prove her innocence
- 32:40if she is innocent and escape the punishment of her jealous husband,
- 32:44because
- 32:45back then a man and a woman who were caught in adultery,
- 32:48they had.
- 32:48It was the death penalty,
- 32:49actually the same penalty that it is for murder.
- 32:52So I would not agree that's a hierarchy.
- 32:54The punishment for adultery and the punishment for murder was death.
- 32:57Still,
- 32:57a fetus is the one who's going to be
- 33:00removed.
- 33:00We don't that we actually don't know.
- 33:02I don't think that we know clearly that this is a miscarriage.
- 33:05I think it is pretty confusing
- 33:07and that we can actually just see that this is a way
- 33:09for God to provide a woman to prove her innocence.
- 33:12It's certainly not condoning abortion,
- 33:15but I think we could look at every verse.
- 33:16That way that every verse is nuanced and complex,
- 33:18and I think that's the biggest thing
- 33:20from the progressive side that there's a lot of nuance
- 33:23to
- 33:24biblical verses,
- 33:25and you can't speak an thou shalt thou shalt not murder is an absolute.
- 33:29There's no nuance and those verses for sure,
- 33:31but all the verses that we're talking about surrounding
- 33:33like this particular one you refer to it as strange.
- 33:36Yes,
- 33:36it is very strange because there's a lot of nuance around it,
- 33:38saying
- 33:39the verses about homosexuality,
- 33:40there's a lot of nuance.
- 33:41There's different contexts going on.
- 33:42I think we can agree there,
- 33:44and I think It gets dangerous when we speak
- 33:46and the black and whites and villainize people.
- 33:48Some things are black and white,
- 33:49but I'll agree with you that some things are complicated.
- 33:52Sometimes we as finite Christians are like,
- 33:54OK,
- 33:55I don't really know what's going on here.
- 33:56Let me do my best to try to understand within context.
- 33:59However,
- 33:59when it comes to murder,
- 34:01when it comes to killing an innocent person,
- 34:03I think that you would say,
- 34:04put the abortion issue aside.
- 34:05Would you say that killing an innocent person,
- 34:08a defenseless person,
- 34:09is always wrong?
- 34:10Yes,
- 34:11always wrong,
- 34:11but I don't,
- 34:12I don't agree.
- 34:13that the removal of a fetus of a group of cells is murder.
- 34:17OK,
- 34:17I think that's where the language is really what's happening inside the womb.
- 34:21When does a human being become a person?
- 34:23Because you're saying that this is
- 34:24not a person inside the womb,
- 34:26correct?
- 34:27OK,
- 34:27so when does a human become a person?
- 34:29I think that when you can actually visibly see the little feet,
- 34:32the little fingers,
- 34:33the little body,
- 34:34so you're,
- 34:34you're in favor of abortion
- 34:36only before 9 weeks,
- 34:38because at my,
- 34:39at my 9 week ultrasound,
- 34:40I
- 34:40All the little buds in the wiggling little baby,
- 34:43so you're only OK with abortion before 9 weeks,
- 34:45I think
- 34:45early,
- 34:46early on before 6 weeks because it's just a group of cells.
- 34:49But also let's talk about it's still a human being,
- 34:51talk about how abortion
- 34:55disproportionately affects those who don't have access to it,
- 34:57people who are in low income situations.
- 35:01And
- 35:01if you look at the juveniles who are in the jail system,
- 35:0475% of juveniles in the jail system come from low
- 35:07income situations where A woman could have otherwise said,
- 35:11I cannot give this life the best chance that it deserves.
- 35:14And then they're in jails,
- 35:15and then we're talking about euthanizing people in jail,
- 35:18sad,
- 35:18but killing a person doesn't heal that woman.
- 35:21Killing a person doesn't make her plight better targeted thing that everybody is so
- 35:27passionate about when there are so many people here,
- 35:30OK,
- 35:30even if you don't agree with this,
- 35:31can I just help you understand our perspective?
- 35:33I know that you,
- 35:35no,
- 35:35I don't think that you do because you.
- 35:36That it's the removal of a fetus.
- 35:39This is OK.
- 35:40No,
- 35:40whatever you think about when a person has value and rights,
- 35:44this is a human being from the moment of conception.
- 35:46It's he or she.
- 35:48It's X X or XY,
- 35:49their own DNA.
- 35:51They're going to have their own fingerprints.
- 35:53They have their entire genetic makeup
- 35:54that with time and with sustenance will grow into what you and I look like.
- 35:59And so killing so hard for them versus the children
- 36:02that are here that are not care about murder.
- 36:04No,
- 36:04no,
- 36:04no.
- 36:04That's a red herring.
- 36:05We can talk about what we should do for children outside of the womb.
- 36:08I'm with you on that.
- 36:09We can unite on that,
- 36:10our desire to help those,
- 36:12but I don't see why your compassion for kids outside of the womb
- 36:16stops just based on a child's location or size or age.
- 36:20A group of cells versus a living,
- 36:22breathing human being in front.
- 36:23It's just completely different.
- 36:24It's something that's not,
- 36:26yeah,
- 36:26it's not,
- 36:26it's a human being,
- 36:27and we were all,
- 36:28we're clumps of cells too,
- 36:30and I think it would be wrong to murder you.
- 36:33Thank you.
- 36:34Yes,
- 36:35thank you.
- 36:40Hey,
- 36:42hi,
- 36:42I'm Angie.
- 36:43Angie,
- 36:44nice to meet you.
- 36:45Thanks for being here.
- 36:46So the first thing that I want to bring up is,
- 36:48uh,
- 36:49we can go back to the Bible,
- 36:50but I will say clearly,
- 36:51I do have
- 36:53personal convictions about abortion,
- 36:55um,
- 36:55that,
- 36:56uh,
- 36:57may not everyone in this circle may agree with.
- 36:59I was raised very conservative.
- 37:01Texas,
- 37:02Bible Belt,
- 37:03like I was homeschooled,
- 37:04all of that.
- 37:04And so like,
- 37:05I understand the idea of like how horrible it is.
- 37:09To kill like
- 37:11an innocent life,
- 37:12but I think we need to go and talk about Exodus 21,
- 37:16because that,
- 37:16I,
- 37:16I don't know if you know which passage I'm
- 37:18about to talk about because that is describing where um
- 37:22If two men are fighting
- 37:24and they hit a pregnant woman.
- 37:26If she has a miscarriage,
- 37:27and again there is debate on if it's miscarriage,
- 37:29if she has a premature birth,
- 37:32but the child survives,
- 37:34the man has to pay only a fine.
- 37:36But if it says that there's further harm,
- 37:38that's when it goes to life for life,
- 37:40eye for eye,
- 37:41tooth for tooth,
- 37:42all that stuff,
- 37:43and that is in regards to the woman,
- 37:45the harm caused to the woman by the men who have hit her.
- 37:48So I think that like if we're talking about how the Bible defines personhood,
- 37:52it's clear that in that.
- 37:53the unborn child was not like killing them or,
- 37:57you know,
- 37:57causing their miscarriage is not
- 37:59considered murder been considered manslaughter,
- 38:01which it sounds like because it was accidental.
- 38:03The passage that you're describing is not intentionally killing an unborn child.
- 38:07That is what abortion is.
- 38:08And so what you're talking about is accidental.
- 38:10We also,
- 38:11if someone
- 38:12accidentally killed someone today,
- 38:14they would be charged with manslaughter.
- 38:15They wouldn't be charged with murder.
- 38:16So I don't think that passage proves
- 38:19anything even still,
- 38:20if they They are fighting and they hit the woman and she and she dies,
- 38:23they pay the penalty for the death of her.
- 38:25That is not manslaughter as exactly how you just described it.
- 38:29You said that the causing the miscarriage would be would be manslaughter,
- 38:33but in the same case,
- 38:33it's it's viewed the same way.
- 38:35Do you understand what I'm saying?
- 38:36I because it was,
- 38:37it was accidental to a woman.
- 38:39You believe that that passage proves that a woman's value
- 38:43is more,
- 38:44is more important than the child's value because the punishment.
- 38:48for accidentally killing that child was not as severe
- 38:51as the punishment for accidentally killing the woman.
- 38:54Is that correct?
- 38:54Is that the argument
- 38:55that would you say that's fair?
- 38:57That would be fair,
- 38:57but that would be fair.
- 38:58I'm trying to talk about the how the Bible defines personhood.
- 39:03The Bible defines as
- 39:05in this,
- 39:06I mean,
- 39:06again,
- 39:06of course,
- 39:07in context,
- 39:07we need to talk about every,
- 39:08all the other verses,
- 39:09etc.
- 39:10talking about,
- 39:10you know,
- 39:11how you knit me,
- 39:11how you knit me and my mother's,
- 39:13what do you think about that?
- 39:13I'm curious what you think.
- 39:15And I think that is important,
- 39:16but also it's beautiful pathetic language.
- 39:18It's prophetic,
- 39:19it's poetic poetic.
- 39:21But then whenever it gets to,
- 39:22I think it's,
- 39:23what is it,
- 39:23Jeremiah 5.
- 39:25Yeah,
- 39:25whatever,
- 39:26it's talking about you I formed you.
- 39:29I mean this is talking about how God knows each and every one of us,
- 39:32and He cares for all of us.
- 39:33It means that you are not forgotten.
- 39:35That's kind of,
- 39:36that's,
- 39:36that's how I view that.
- 39:37But again,
- 39:38as I said,
- 39:39I
- 39:39personally have reservations against abortion.
- 39:43in some ways.
- 39:43Can you tell me why you have reservations against abortion?
- 39:46I have reservations because it's my personal beliefs.
- 39:50But listen,
- 39:50let me just tell you this,
- 39:51this is what I have done as a person.
- 39:53I've been on multiple jubilee videos,
- 39:55as,
- 39:56because
- 39:57I am,
- 39:57as some of y'all may know,
- 39:59but I am a virgin.
- 40:00I am saving myself for marriage.
- 40:03I like this,
- 40:03this is what I want to do,
- 40:05but,
- 40:05and not just because I think it's a purity thing or whatever.
- 40:09Which is beautiful.
- 40:10It is beautiful,
- 40:11but I'm just,
- 40:14it's.
- 40:14It is,
- 40:15yeah,
- 40:15I do think it like it is a smart decision because again,
- 40:18it saves me from ever having to be put
- 40:20into the possibility,
- 40:22the realm of even thinking like,
- 40:23oh,
- 40:24is abortion a possibility?
- 40:25We can agree there.
- 40:26I have often said that most of our problems in the world
- 40:29would stop if people stopped having sex outside of mar I mean,
- 40:31not necessarily that.
- 40:32I'm just,
- 40:33well,
- 40:33yeah,
- 40:33sure,
- 40:34but also what I want to get to.
- 40:37These are my personal beliefs,
- 40:38these are your personal beliefs.
- 40:39We should not be using the law to enforce our personal
- 40:42beliefs on people who are not who are not Christian.
- 40:45Every law enforces a personal belief on everyone.
- 40:47That's what a law is.
- 40:48But this is,
- 40:49yes,
- 40:49but this is like,
- 40:50these are,
- 40:50these are more universal laws.
- 40:52They're laws we have a law against No,
- 40:54no,
- 40:54no,
- 40:55let me,
- 40:55let me finish this point.
- 40:56There's a lot of these are common sense universal
- 40:58laws that are actually reflected in many different religions,
- 41:01not just Christianity,
- 41:02about murder,
- 41:03about stealing,
- 41:03about theft.
- 41:04These are things I think our founders founded our
- 41:05laws based on the principles of the Bible.
- 41:09I'm sorry,
- 41:09I missed that.
- 41:10Our,
- 41:10our founders founded our laws and wrote our laws
- 41:13specifically with the principles of scripture in mind,
- 41:16not created a theocracy,
- 41:17but on the values of the principles.
- 41:19And so they weren't saying,
- 41:20well,
- 41:20let's just pick the laws that sound good to Buddhists too.
- 41:23That's not how they formed those laws.
- 41:25I mean,
- 41:25I'm sure they have limited access to Buddhists.
- 41:27I mean,
- 41:28let's be,
- 41:28let's be real and what their theology or,
- 41:30you know,
- 41:30but that's.
- 41:31I think we need to get back to the point that with Christians really trying to force
- 41:37our personal beliefs on non-Christians throughout the throughout our country,
- 41:42because we have these personal convictions,
- 41:44I think that is incorrect,
- 41:46because it can go to so many different ways,
- 41:48especially if it's a different religion that came into power.
- 41:51Christians would be upset about that laws that allow abortions,
- 41:55laws that allow abortions
- 41:57is enforcing your.
- 41:58Personal belief system on that child.
- 42:00We don't see it as enforcing a personal belief system.
- 42:03Again,
- 42:03I'm going back.
- 42:04The law is to protecting the right to go back to Exodus 21.
- 42:08Exodus 21,
- 42:09where again the personhood of an unborn child is not defined.
- 42:12It is a fine not the child about purposeful killing of a child.
- 42:16Do you think
- 42:17killing an innocent person intentionally is always wrong?
- 42:20Do you think it should be illegal to murder me or you talk about Jeff Pat's daughter.
- 42:25She ran out.
- 42:26You,
- 42:26no,
- 42:27we are talking about innocents killing innocent people
- 42:31and judges.
- 42:31Do you remember this?
- 42:32He made this promise to God and said that,
- 42:34you know,
- 42:34whatever,
- 42:34whoever the first thing that comes out of my home,
- 42:36I'm going to sacrifice that.
- 42:38And that ended up being his daughter,
- 42:39and he was he was wrong and he grieved,
- 42:41but he still went through with it.
- 42:43He still killed his daughter.
- 42:44And we're talking about David and Bathsheba,
- 42:46and we're talking about David and Bathsheba was murdered.
- 42:48Yes,
- 42:49he murdered,
- 42:49he murdered.
- 42:50Yes,
- 42:50he murdered and he committed adultery and probably was.
- 42:53Forceful on her,
- 42:54but he didn't,
- 42:55he didn't experience that,
- 42:57that,
- 42:57the wrongness.
- 42:58The child did.
- 42:59So the baby that should not be illegal.
- 43:02No,
- 43:02no,
- 43:02no,
- 43:02I'm just telling you,
- 43:03you just said that innocent life,
- 43:05every time it's intentionally taken is wrong,
- 43:07and there are cases in the Bible is wrong.
- 43:09I'm telling,
- 43:09yes,
- 43:10of course.
- 43:10No,
- 43:10no,
- 43:11no,
- 43:11of course,
- 43:11of course he was wrong.
- 43:12I'm not saying that.
- 43:13I'm saying that the results of David and Bathsheba's
- 43:17adultery or coercion,
- 43:18because I mean he was a man in power.
- 43:20Um,
- 43:21and the,
- 43:21the baby was killed.
- 43:23God,
- 43:23it says that God struck the child,
- 43:25and the child was
- 43:27like they lived.
- 43:28She had the baby,
- 43:297 days later,
- 43:30the baby was killed.
- 43:32OK,
- 43:32that is the case where innocent life,
- 43:35I mean,
- 43:35was taken.
- 43:36The
- 43:36had no,
- 43:37had no,
- 43:38like they didn't do anything to deserve that,
- 43:40but it was what his father did.
- 43:42And so
- 43:44I know,
- 43:45but it's wrong to kill innocent.
- 43:47Don't get to this is what I want to get to,
- 43:49because a lot of times Christians will say that two wrongs don't make a right.
- 43:52In that case,
- 43:53it kind of seems like that's what God did.
- 43:55What do you mean?
- 43:56What do you mean?
- 43:57I,
- 43:57I'm not taking an innocent life.
- 43:59David took an innocent life,
- 44:01but the baby,
- 44:02the baby's I understand David was wrong in taking an innocent life,
- 44:06but also God let God took the innocent life of his child
- 44:10as recompense for what he did to Usiah or
- 44:13Usaiah,
- 44:14Uriah,
- 44:14whatever,
- 44:14you know,
- 44:15whatever
- 44:17your husband was.
- 44:18Hey,
- 44:18thank you so much.
- 44:19That was fun.
- 44:20Thank you.
- 44:22My next claim is empathy can be toxic and lead to sin.
- 44:32Hey,
- 44:32what's your name?
- 44:33I'm Paul.
- 44:34Paul,
- 44:34another Paul.
- 44:34Nice to meet you,
- 44:35Paul.
- 44:36Let's start,
- 44:37if we can,
- 44:37on what your definition of empathy is.
- 44:39Thank you for saying that.
- 44:40I agree.
- 44:41The etymology of empathy means to be in someone's feelings,
- 44:44whereas sympathy means to feel for someone.
- 44:46Compassion means with suffering,
- 44:48so to suffer with someone.
- 44:50But empathy
- 44:51literally means to be in someone's feelings.
- 44:55Do you think that when
- 44:57God became flesh.
- 44:59He dwelt among us that he was taking on the idea of human feelings on some level,
- 45:03not the idea of human feelings.
- 45:04He actually did feel human feelings.
- 45:06He didn't just,
- 45:07he wasn't just in our feelings.
- 45:09He didn't just have empathy for our weakness,
- 45:11but he actually felt much of that weakness himself,
- 45:14which is amazing.
- 45:15Do you believe that
- 45:17empathy may not be where we want to end,
- 45:19but empathy is definitely where we should start?
- 45:22As Christians
- 45:23that we as people have the ability to be able to
- 45:26start and think if we are to love our enemies,
- 45:29if we are to love our neighbors,
- 45:30if we are to love those around us in our community,
- 45:33we first have to be able to feel what they're feeling.
- 45:35And if you look at the way Christ lived,
- 45:37he tried his best in every opportunity to first see where they were coming from,
- 45:42asking questions first,
- 45:44making comments later.
- 45:45Is that a possibility that we start with empathy,
- 45:48but we just.
- 45:49Don't end with empathy.
- 45:50OK,
- 45:50I love that distinction that you said that we shouldn't end with empathy.
- 45:53We definitely agree on that.
- 45:55Here's where I would probably caveat what you said.
- 45:58I would say we can start with empathy.
- 46:00So my argument is not,
- 46:02which you're not saying this,
- 46:03but just to clarify that empathy is always toxic or always simple or always bad.
- 46:07I think it can lead you toward kindness.
- 46:10It can lead you toward love,
- 46:11but
- 46:12it doesn't have to be where we start.
- 46:14I think that you can love someone,
- 46:15sacrifice.
- 46:16for them,
- 46:16be kind to them,
- 46:17be generous to them
- 46:18out of virtue,
- 46:19out of the desire to follow Christ.
- 46:22You don't necessarily have to feel how someone feels in order to be kind.
- 46:26And actually I would argue that that kind of love
- 46:28is a lot more powerful because even if I
- 46:30can't understand someone's circumstance or where they're coming from,
- 46:33God calls me to love
- 46:35them and to serve
- 46:36them.
- 46:37Really,
- 46:37empathy doesn't have to have anything to do with that.
- 46:41Well,
- 46:41I would completely disagree.
- 46:42In fact,
- 46:42I would even
- 46:43as an example of the woman caught in adultery.
- 46:45When that woman was brought out,
- 46:47right,
- 46:47and,
- 46:48yes,
- 46:48and all the men
- 46:49were ready to stone her.
- 46:51What did Jesus do?
- 46:52He got down on her level,
- 46:54lowered himself so that he could see the perspective from her
- 46:57point of view.
- 46:58He then looked at everyone and said he was without sin,
- 47:01cast the first stone,
- 47:02saying to them,
- 47:03Remember when you sinned?
- 47:05Why did you sin?
- 47:06Do you remember the time in which you
- 47:07did something maybe you weren't completely agreeing with?
- 47:10Maybe this is the time for you to step back and say,
- 47:12why would someone sin,
- 47:14as opposed to immediately going and just calling it sin,
- 47:17looking at it and saying,
- 47:18what's the road to get us there?
- 47:19And from there we begin to understand them.
- 47:21From there we begin to love them.
- 47:23From there we begin to be able to cherish them and
- 47:25honor them and see them as the human beings they are,
- 47:27not political movements.
- 47:29The way that the evangelical right has
- 47:30turned every single thing into a political movement
- 47:33on every podcast,
- 47:34this is a different claim.
- 47:35OK,
- 47:35let's get there because I think that's a.
- 47:37Interesting claim,
- 47:38but let's go back to the empathy piece,
- 47:40because we could maybe agree that you can start with empathy.
- 47:43My argument is that you don't have to start with empathy,
- 47:45and actually
- 47:46empathy,
- 47:46if we always start there,
- 47:48has the possibility.
- 47:49I would say Jesus always and potential to lead us to sin,
- 47:52and I would say God always.
- 47:53Jesus is God.
- 47:54First John 4:8 says God is love,
- 47:56so Jesus embodied love.
- 47:57He showed us what it looks like.
- 47:59It can mean Adam and Eve sinned.
- 48:02What's the first act God did?
- 48:04After the curse,
- 48:05empathy,
- 48:06he gave them clothes.
- 48:07He covered their nakedness.
- 48:08It's not necessarily empathy.
- 48:10You're reading empathy into the to.
- 48:12It's not necessarily there in their naked.
- 48:15Let's go back to my claim.
- 48:16Let's go back to my claim and see and see if you agree with it.
- 48:19Empathy can be toxic
- 48:21and lead to sin.
- 48:22No,
- 48:22I'm getting us back to the claim because we've got off the reservation now.
- 48:26Empathy can be toxic and lead to sin.
- 48:28Do you think it's possible to Feel so deeply how
- 48:30someone feels that you can end up affirming something bad
- 48:33and wrong and harmful and sinful in their life.
- 48:35That is my claim.
- 48:37Well,
- 48:37do you think it's possible?
- 48:38Anything's possible,
- 48:40but that doesn't mean that doesn't mean it's irresponsible.
- 48:43But that doesn't mean it's irrespons is irresponsible to affirm someone's sin or a
- 48:47behavior that is harming them because you feel so deeply how they feel.
- 48:50It is much better to be tied to virtue and truth and love,
- 48:53which is rooted.
- 48:54When Christ was on the 1 Corinthians 13:6,
- 48:56not empathy,
- 48:57which is feeling.
- 48:58Christ was on the cross,
- 48:59He didn't ask what everyone's sin was.
- 49:00He said,
- 49:01just forgive them,
- 49:02forgive them,
- 49:02for they know not what they do.
- 49:04That's not necessarily.
- 49:05That's how he felt.
- 49:06That's not necessarily empathy.
- 49:07But again,
- 49:08we're not going back to my claim.
- 49:09I'm asking you to address my claim.
- 49:12Do you think it's possible to feel so deeply how
- 49:14someone feels that you end up affirming their sin?
- 49:17That's my claim.
- 49:17Then we agree.
- 49:18Some people could.
- 49:19You did great.
- 49:20Good job.
- 49:26Hello,
- 49:27what's your name?
- 49:27Kyle.
- 49:28Nice to meet you.
- 49:29I feel like if you're gonna completely cut out empathy,
- 49:31you're also gonna include,
- 49:33uh,
- 49:33toxic individualism and toxic apathy because
- 49:36you're completely cutting out on empathy.
- 49:38I'm sorry,
- 49:39an element.
- 49:39I don't think we have to cut out empathy altogether.
- 49:42So what is toxic about empathy?
- 49:43I'm sorry.
- 49:44So it's not that empathy is always toxic.
- 49:46It's not that there is a perpetual component of empathy that is toxic.
- 49:50It's that empathy can be toxic and lead to sin.
- 49:54So if I feel so deeply how someone feels that I end up validating a lie,
- 50:00telling them something that's not true to make them feel better,
- 50:03or affirming what God calls sin,
- 50:05or I would argue.
- 50:06If it leads us to support destructive policies,
- 50:09policies that are bad for the individual,
- 50:11bad for society,
- 50:12then your empathy has led you to a really dangerous place,
- 50:15even if you started with good intentions.
- 50:17But I think you can empathize with somebody and
- 50:19not agree with the things that they're doing.
- 50:21I agree,
- 50:21yeah,
- 50:21and I agree.
- 50:22So in that sense,
- 50:23I don't think that toxic,
- 50:24or I'm sorry,
- 50:24empathy can be toxic because
- 50:26I think by your logic also you can say
- 50:29love can be toxic.
- 50:31Love can be toxic,
- 50:31right?
- 50:32Because yeah,
- 50:32I would love to distinguish between empathy.
- 50:34In love if I can,
- 50:35and you can tell me if you agree with me.
- 50:37So empathy means to feel how someone feels,
- 50:39and I think that could either lead you toward kindness or like you said,
- 50:43you described what I like to call like empathy that is in submission to truth.
- 50:48So I can feel how you feel and still say,
- 50:50hey,
- 50:50what you're doing is not right.
- 50:51What you're believing is not true,
- 50:53right?
- 50:53Like you would say that that's possible.
- 50:55I think that's possible in a lot of cases,
- 50:57yes,
- 50:57and I think you and I would agree with that,
- 50:59where I am saying empathy can lead.
- 51:01Astray
- 51:02is when we feel so deeply for someone and we feel so deeply how they feel that we
- 51:07end up telling them the lie that they want
- 51:08to hear that leads to a destructive behavior.
- 51:11But I don't think that's true empathy.
- 51:12I think what you're doing is you're,
- 51:14you're creating,
- 51:15you're using the word empathy and you're creating a structure of manipulation
- 51:18when true empathy is actually caring about somebody.
- 51:21It's,
- 51:21it's,
- 51:22you're not saying
- 51:23if you care about me x amount,
- 51:24you would do this for me.
- 51:26OK,
- 51:26let me give you an example of what I think is toxic empathy.
- 51:29And
- 51:29this will probably unleash a can of worms,
- 51:31which will be fun.
- 51:32If I feel so deeply that someone who sits across from me says,
- 51:36you know what,
- 51:37I was assigned male at birth,
- 51:39but I am trapped in the wrong body and I am,
- 51:41I,
- 51:41I identify
- 51:43as a girl.
- 51:44I would say that feeling so deeply
- 51:46how that person feels that you get to
- 51:48the point of affirming their identity and saying,
- 51:51yes,
- 51:51you are the opposite sex.
- 51:53The Bible doesn't condemn
- 51:55transgenderism.
- 51:55Let's get there.
- 51:56Let hang on.
- 51:57That is an example of what I would say
- 52:00is empathy that has turned toxic because you are affirming something
- 52:03that is not true and is destructive for the individual.
- 52:06If it's not true,
- 52:07then you're saying that God is not sovereign because he did he is.
- 52:10He made their body with from the moment of conception.
- 52:13Then he also created theology is their identity.
- 52:15Their mind is their identity,
- 52:17their consciousness,
- 52:18because biology is not an individual.
- 52:20I mean,
- 52:21that's not a biblical idea to separate your identity and your spirit.
- 52:24From your body is dualism.
- 52:26That's more of a kind of a Gnostic idea,
- 52:27not a biblical idea.
- 52:29We see in Genesis 1:27 that God created us male and female.
- 52:32We don't see any other category or possibility to
- 52:35identify as something other than what you biologically are.
- 52:38So I would say it is toxically empathetic
- 52:40to feel so deeply how someone feels that you affirm the
- 52:43lie that you can be born in the wrong body.
- 52:44You're right,
- 52:45God is sovereign.
- 52:46He does not make a mistake.
- 52:47If you are born a man or a woman,
- 52:49boy or a girl,
- 52:50that is what you are.
- 52:51OK,
- 52:51but.
- 52:53Hey,
- 52:53you did really good.
- 52:54Thank you.
- 53:00Hey,
- 53:00what's your name?
- 53:01My name is Jaden.
- 53:02Hi Jaden.
- 53:02So your claim is that empathy can be toxic and lead to sin.
- 53:05Yes,
- 53:05and you described a scenario in which it can be toxic and lead to sin.
- 53:09Yes.
- 53:09So do you think that,
- 53:12so Brene Brown said that
- 53:13empathy leads to connection and sympathy leads to,
- 53:16I believe,
- 53:17disconnection is the word that she used.
- 53:19So if you're able to say,
- 53:20and are you familiar with Brene Brown?
- 53:21I love her work,
- 53:22but would you say that if you had somebody that came up to you and said,
- 53:25you know,
- 53:25listen,
- 53:26I've had struggling with bladder dysmorphia.
- 53:28Um,
- 53:28if you're able to sympathize,
- 53:29you're saying,
- 53:30oh jeez,
- 53:30that's something over there.
- 53:31I'm not,
- 53:32I'm not really going to feel where you're at because that sounds really hard
- 53:35and I can't understand where you're coming from.
- 53:37Does that sound right?
- 53:39Well,
- 53:39I would say to that person,
- 53:40because here's what I believe.
- 53:41It's not that I necessarily believe in choosing sympathy over empathy.
- 53:45I believe in choosing
- 53:47love.
- 53:47And again,
- 53:48empathy could lead you to love,
- 53:49but love should be the endpoint for the Christian,
- 53:52and God gets to define love.
- 53:53First John 4:8,
- 53:54God is love,
- 53:54so he gets to define it.
- 53:56He tells us in 1 Corinthians.
- 53:5713,
- 53:58what love is.
- 53:59He defines it for us,
- 54:00and one of the characteristics that we read in
- 54:01verse 6 is that love never rejoices in wrongdoing,
- 54:05but rejoices with the truth.
- 54:07So if I am to love the person who says,
- 54:09I'm struggling with this identity crisis,
- 54:11I feel like I'm born in the wrong body,
- 54:13I don't think it's wrong for me to say,
- 54:15Wow,
- 54:15I've never been there.
- 54:16But that must sound really distressing.
- 54:18But let me tell you about the God who loves you
- 54:20and did not make a mistake with your body.
- 54:23And
- 54:24what we can do is we can help you as much as possible,
- 54:27and I I can love you and I can be your friend,
- 54:29but I am not going to sacrifice for the
- 54:30truth just because I empathize with your feelings.
- 54:33Do you think it's possible,
- 54:34so God lets things happen that may not be
- 54:37what you might call perfect,
- 54:39I guess moral will.
- 54:41Yeah,
- 54:41yeah,
- 54:41absolutely,
- 54:42and we're all sinful.
- 54:43Yeah,
- 54:43no,
- 54:43absolutely.
- 54:44But like if somebody is born,
- 54:45do you think there is a possibility that they
- 54:46could have been born into the wrong body?
- 54:48No,
- 54:48I don't think it's possible.
- 54:49I think it's possible that they could
- 54:51feel that they are.
- 54:52I don't think that makes up most people who identify as transgender today,
- 54:56but all of us.
- 54:56Have feelings that are disconnected with reality,
- 54:59and that doesn't mean,
- 55:00you know,
- 55:00if your little child says,
- 55:02Hey Mommy,
- 55:03there's a monster in my closet,
- 55:05the loving thing to do is not to say,
- 55:06Yeah,
- 55:06it is,
- 55:07sorry.
- 55:08It's to turn the lights on and say,
- 55:09No,
- 55:09that's not a monster in your closet,
- 55:11that's OK.
- 55:11The loving thing to do is to tell the truth or to go in and see if there's a monster.
- 55:15But there's not,
- 55:16but,
- 55:16but the empathy here,
- 55:17right,
- 55:17the empathy might be to actually try to understand where they're coming from.
- 55:21And I'm not saying,
- 55:22you know,
- 55:22I wouldn't jump into it and say,
- 55:23oh well then I feel transgender,
- 55:25absolutely not.
- 55:26But to Understand where somebody else is coming from and to have the love,
- 55:29I believe empathy and love go hand in hand.
- 55:32And I cannot love that person if I cannot try to understand where they are coming.
- 55:36You can try to understand where they're coming from and still tell them the truth.
- 55:39Do you agree with that?
- 55:40Oh,
- 55:40absolutely.
- 55:41But I guess where we differ on that is,
- 55:42is kind of where the,
- 55:44where the truth lies.
- 55:44That is definitely where we differ.
- 55:46Yeah.
- 55:46So if,
- 55:47if I believe in my
- 55:49understanding of the world,
- 55:50is it,
- 55:50it is entirely possible for somebody to be born
- 55:53into the wrong body.
- 55:54What does that mean?
- 55:55Can you explain that to me?
- 55:57What is telling them that they're born in the wrong body?
- 55:59How can it be wrong?
- 56:00Well,
- 56:00I believe that gender is a characteristic,
- 56:03male and female in heaven as spirits,
- 56:05we have male and female.
- 56:06I believe that.
- 56:06OK.
- 56:06OK.
- 56:07Do you identify as a Christian?
- 56:08I am a Christian.
- 56:09So where do you get,
- 56:10where do you get that idea that we have spirit,
- 56:12gendered spirits in heaven before we come to Earth?
- 56:14I've never heard that before.
- 56:15Yeah,
- 56:16sorry,
- 56:16I'm a member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints,
- 56:18and we tend to have some ideas that
- 56:20some people wouldn't even conflate with Christianity.
- 56:22Oh,
- 56:22OK.
- 56:23Hey,
- 56:24you did good.
- 56:24Nice to meet you.
- 56:30Wow,
- 56:32that's impressive.
- 56:32Nice to meet you.
- 56:33What's your name?
- 56:33Shane.
- 56:34Shane.
- 56:35So here's,
- 56:35I'm going to kind of like lay out my argument and then tell me
- 56:38the issue you might have with it,
- 56:39OK?
- 56:40So my argument is
- 56:41empathy in and of itself cannot be sin because it is a biblical statue.
- 56:44sin.
- 56:46I would say it can't lead to sin either
- 56:49because sin.
- 56:49Uh,
- 56:50I'm going to say sin,
- 56:51kind of thinking of like a concupiscence kind of way here.
- 56:53I don't know if you're familiar with the word.
- 56:55Um,
- 56:55not that you're not,
- 56:56I just,
- 56:56it's weird.
- 56:57But the idea simply is,
- 56:59when we affirm things that are sinful,
- 57:01it is by our fallen nature and desire,
- 57:04not by the empathy itself.
- 57:06Empathy,
- 57:07right,
- 57:07is the thing we use to
- 57:08Enact care and love for people,
- 57:10Romans 12:15,
- 57:11I think it is,
- 57:11where it says rejoice with those who rejoice,
- 57:13weep with those who weep,
- 57:14right?
- 57:14We step into that just as Christ stepped into our humanity,
- 57:17we step into that with those people.
- 57:19And then from there,
- 57:20if we as corrupted fallen beings mess up in some long way,
- 57:24twist it to then affirm something that is sinful,
- 57:27that is on the sin,
- 57:28not on the empathy itself.
- 57:30Does that make sense?
- 57:31Yes,
- 57:31and I understand what you're saying.
- 57:32I think we agree on a lot.
- 57:34My argument is that empathy,
- 57:37because it is so powerful,
- 57:39can initiate a path to affirming sin
- 57:42because you feel so deeply how someone feels,
- 57:45because you don't want to hurt their feelings,
- 57:47because you don't want to make them feel bad.
- 57:49That deep empathy that may might be well intentioned
- 57:52could lead you to saying something that's not true
- 57:54or affirming sin.
- 57:55So
- 57:56I would just disagree.
- 57:57I,
- 57:57I would think that the empathy can lead you there.
- 58:00That doesn't mean all.
- 58:00Empathy is always bad or dangerous.
- 58:03My hesitation is just going to be,
- 58:04it's still going to be on the labeling that empathy as toxic,
- 58:07right?
- 58:07It's toxic because it led to this conclusion.
- 58:10Well,
- 58:10that's not really how that worked.
- 58:12What worked within that is the fallen human nature,
- 58:14which we all participate in as
- 58:16fallen people,
- 58:16right?
- 58:17Well,
- 58:17do you think it's possible because we are fallen humans for any feeling that we
- 58:22have for love to be perverted into lust or for empathy to be perverted into
- 58:27To unhealthy and sinful affirmation.
- 58:29Right?
- 58:29But the perversion of the thing,
- 58:31so love is a great example,
- 58:32right?
- 58:32If I love improperly,
- 58:34it is a result of me being a sinner,
- 58:37not saying that love itself is now sin.
- 58:39It's not saying that that love
- 58:41or that love itself can become toxic.
- 58:43It's the way that we use love is seen as toxically.
- 58:46I wonder if we're splitting hairs.
- 58:48I wonder if we basically agree that we're sinners and that we can
- 58:51pervert things that.
- 58:53Started out really good or that we can start with good intentions
- 58:56and we know what the road to hell is paved with.
- 58:59And so I think we actually probably agree,
- 59:00maybe it's just a semantic argument.
- 59:02I wouldn't disagree.
- 59:03Here's my hesitation.
- 59:04The calling of empathy to be toxic
- 59:07is where I'm like very much like the law needs the line needs to be drawn
- 59:12because
- 59:13when we do that,
- 59:13when we see something that is necessarily a biblical principle,
- 59:17and we say,
- 59:17well,
- 59:17hold on,
- 59:17this biblical principle is toxic.
- 59:19Or we can,
- 59:19it can be toxic.
- 59:21We are then now saying,
- 59:22well,
- 59:22there's steps and we have to back up here
- 59:24and maybe we shouldn't be empathetic in these cases.
- 59:26And then that leads to,
- 59:27I think,
- 59:27what this divide is evidently showing,
- 59:29which is that people end up on
- 59:31different nuances
- 59:32and different applications.
- 59:33So my argument is that
- 59:35we don't need to pursue empathy in and of itself,
- 59:38that we should be pursuing love,
- 59:40and love is different than empathy.
- 59:42Love never rejoices in wrongdoing,
- 59:44but rejoices with the truth,
- 59:45whereas Empathy really,
- 59:46I say it's neutral.
- 59:48It really is not concerned you don't think empathy is like a biblical statue.
- 59:51You don't think that like the Bible is very clear can lead you to love.
- 59:55I think what we see a lot more in the example of Jesus,
- 59:57that whether or not
- 59:59we can see someone's circumstance or feel someone's feelings,
- 1:00:03we are called to love them anyway.
- 1:00:05And the story of the Good Samaritan,
- 1:00:06for example,
- 1:00:07the Samaritan was a stranger.
- 1:00:09He was an outsider.
- 1:00:10He was someone that people rejected
- 1:00:12and And
- 1:00:13the Good Samaritan was the person who stopped
- 1:00:15on the side of the road to help this person who was bleeding and dying,
- 1:00:19not because necessarily he could see his circumstance,
- 1:00:22but because he was doing a righteous deed,
- 1:00:24because he was glorifying God and loving.
- 1:00:27So you would say that's empathy.
- 1:00:28Yeah,
- 1:00:28I would say remember why that story is being told.
- 1:00:30That story is being told because I believe I'm reading the context right.
- 1:00:33That's Luke 10 if I'm remembering correctly.
- 1:00:34The lawyer goes to Christ and he's like,
- 1:00:37What must I do to inherit an eternal life?
- 1:00:39Inheriting eternal life,
- 1:00:40right?
- 1:00:40What must he do to do that?
- 1:00:42Jesus then says,
- 1:00:42love God and love your neighbor.
- 1:00:44And then the question the man asks back is,
- 1:00:46how do I love my neighbor,
- 1:00:48right?
- 1:00:48So the way that we love our neighbor,
- 1:00:50right,
- 1:00:51is by when they're in that lowly place,
- 1:00:53seeing them,
- 1:00:53recognizing them,
- 1:00:54and stepping into that just as,
- 1:00:55like I said,
- 1:00:56Christ steps into our humanity,
- 1:00:57and then we,
- 1:00:58we be biblical from there,
- 1:01:01right?
- 1:01:01It's not a,
- 1:01:02and I would call that.
- 1:01:02Love.
- 1:01:03I wouldn't necessarily say that's empathy because I think empathy,
- 1:01:07it can be,
- 1:01:08but
- 1:01:08I think,
- 1:01:09and I make the argument in my book that
- 1:01:10empathy can lead you towards sacrifice and kindness,
- 1:01:13which is the ultimate goal through love,
- 1:01:15but I still believe
- 1:01:16that empathy can also lead you in a direction that is not biblical or healthy,
- 1:01:20and I think that's where we disagree.
- 1:01:22That's definitely,
- 1:01:22I think the love.
- 1:01:24Hey,
- 1:01:24you did great defending your side.
- 1:01:25Good job.
- 1:01:31Hi,
- 1:01:31what's your name?
- 1:01:32John.
- 1:01:32John,
- 1:01:33nice to meet you,
- 1:01:33John.
- 1:01:34Nice to meet you too.
- 1:01:34I think the immediate reaction you said you guys
- 1:01:36are gonna love this when you said the claim,
- 1:01:38and I think the reason is because it immediately is,
- 1:01:41it puts people.
- 1:01:42Ill at ease,
- 1:01:44on edge,
- 1:01:44exactly.
- 1:01:45And I think,
- 1:01:45I think the reason our heart
- 1:01:47feels that is because I think
- 1:01:49what we're suffering from right now on the right and on the left
- 1:01:52is a lack,
- 1:01:54a massive lack of empathy for each other.
- 1:01:56We're being fed algorithms that show each other
- 1:01:59these crazy versions of the other side.
- 1:02:01And we don't look each other in the eyes and and feel for one another.
- 1:02:05I understand that it can be,
- 1:02:07um,
- 1:02:08manipulated and that,
- 1:02:09that you can as a response
- 1:02:12to empathy,
- 1:02:13um,
- 1:02:13make some poor choices.
- 1:02:14Like the first thing that comes to mind is like a drug addict who's like,
- 1:02:17oh my gosh,
- 1:02:17I need something.
- 1:02:18You know,
- 1:02:19you,
- 1:02:19yeah,
- 1:02:19OK.
- 1:02:20So,
- 1:02:21uh,
- 1:02:21but that,
- 1:02:22that's a response
- 1:02:23to something.
- 1:02:24And my fear with with what you're talking about
- 1:02:28is that it's gonna
- 1:02:29be misinterpreted in heart and hearts
- 1:02:32more than open them up.
- 1:02:33The the risk is not worth what you're trying to get at in my sense.
- 1:02:36Yeah,
- 1:02:37so what I'm arguing is not that we necessarily have to kill empathy,
- 1:02:41but that there is something deeper and better
- 1:02:43because I might not be able to understand the thinking or the circumstance
- 1:02:48of someone who is across the aisle from me or someone in a totally
- 1:02:51different situation.
- 1:02:52than me,
- 1:02:53but whether or not I can feel for them,
- 1:02:55whether or not I think they've been cruel,
- 1:02:57whether or not
- 1:02:58they have supported things that
- 1:02:59I don't like,
- 1:03:01God has made them in His image.
- 1:03:02God has died for them as Jesus on the cross,
- 1:03:05and I am called to love them regardless of how I feel.
- 1:03:08So what I see a lot,
- 1:03:10I see a lot of people say,
- 1:03:11Well,
- 1:03:11I can't feel empathy for that person,
- 1:03:14or that person wasn't empathetic,
- 1:03:15so I don't feel empathy for what they went through.
- 1:03:18And see that to me shows the superficial.
- 1:03:21and the kind of just the lack of strength,
- 1:03:24the weakness
- 1:03:25of empathy as a driving force.
- 1:03:26I think love,
- 1:03:27I would agree with that and virtue are a lot more powerful.
- 1:03:30I understand that.
- 1:03:31I think,
- 1:03:32I think that the average Joe isn't going to download all that.
- 1:03:35I think they're going to get from your message I wrote a book on it.
- 1:03:38Well,
- 1:03:38great.
- 1:03:38Is everybody going to read it though?
- 1:03:39They hear,
- 1:03:40they see that title,
- 1:03:41and,
- 1:03:41and I hear it too.
- 1:03:42It's not just you.
- 1:03:43There's this thing,
- 1:03:43and you know,
- 1:03:44it's,
- 1:03:44it's,
- 1:03:44it's a,
- 1:03:45it's a quip.
- 1:03:45It's quick.
- 1:03:46It's easy to say and tweet,
- 1:03:47but
- 1:03:48the issue is,
- 1:03:49um,
- 1:03:50I think,
- 1:03:50I think the problem with a lot of these hot
- 1:03:52button topics we talked about like the hierarchy of sin,
- 1:03:55I think it's because a lot of times on the right.
- 1:03:58It's the things you're not able to identify with that you're feeling.
- 1:04:01Why do you think homosexuality is,
- 1:04:03it's,
- 1:04:03it gives people on the right the ick
- 1:04:05in a lot of ways,
- 1:04:06because they don't
- 1:04:07get it.
- 1:04:07They,
- 1:04:08they're not,
- 1:04:08they're not entering into that.
- 1:04:09And so it's easier to say,
- 1:04:11oh,
- 1:04:11that is outrageously,
- 1:04:12God is frowning on that as opposed to,
- 1:04:15um,
- 1:04:15as opposed to pride,
- 1:04:17um,
- 1:04:17as opposed to the disparity between we should look at all of those as sins,
- 1:04:22but I'm probably the only one in this room right now
- 1:04:25that would say that both of those things.
- 1:04:27You just listed are sins,
- 1:04:28and that's really kind of the disparity in the disagreement that
- 1:04:31we see is that even if I have empathy for someone,
- 1:04:34that does not mean I am going to affirm a sexual identity
- 1:04:37or a so-called gender identity that does not align with the Bible.
- 1:04:40And that's what I see a lot from my progressive
- 1:04:42friends.
- 1:04:42And that's why I wrote the book,
- 1:04:43not as a quip,
- 1:04:44not as just a hot take to put out there,
- 1:04:46but actually because I see very well-intentioned,
- 1:04:49compassionate,
- 1:04:50deeply feeling people
- 1:04:52use empathy to justify things that I think are not only unbiblical.
- 1:04:55But destructive for society,
- 1:04:57whether it's immigration or gender or marriage or social justice.
- 1:05:01All of that starts with,
- 1:05:02well,
- 1:05:02I feel how this person feels,
- 1:05:04and that leads,
- 1:05:05I believe,
- 1:05:05to supporting policies that are bad for that person
- 1:05:08and bad for society.
- 1:05:10I understand where you're coming from.
- 1:05:11It's,
- 1:05:11it's,
- 1:05:11it's uh the parent who's not going to let their kid
- 1:05:13do things that are going to hurt them out of love.
- 1:05:15It's,
- 1:05:15it's,
- 1:05:16I totally get it.
- 1:05:17I don't draw the lines in the same places as you,
- 1:05:19but you get the,
- 1:05:20but I get the,
- 1:05:21I know,
- 1:05:21I understand the,
- 1:05:22the essence of it.
- 1:05:23I think what's,
- 1:05:24what's What's upsetting
- 1:05:25is that we need to lean further into
- 1:05:27identifying with one another and loving each other.
- 1:05:30Jesus talks about us being the vine and the branches.
- 1:05:32Your pain should be my pain,
- 1:05:33and we shouldn't just go,
- 1:05:34oh,
- 1:05:34you're on the right,
- 1:05:35you're on these,
- 1:05:36these,
- 1:05:36these labels like Jesus actually wasn't
- 1:05:38either party.
- 1:05:39That's not what he was doing.
- 1:05:40He was breaking down all these divides
- 1:05:43of
- 1:05:44neither,
- 1:05:45neither Jew nor Gentile,
- 1:05:46male nor female.
- 1:05:47To me,
- 1:05:48I think today he would say neither right nor left.
- 1:05:49He's,
- 1:05:50he's trying to break us into some sort of shared humanity.
- 1:05:53That is transcendent of,
- 1:05:55of our,
- 1:05:55our,
- 1:05:56our
- 1:05:57left brain argumentative mind that takes control of these so often and leads
- 1:06:01people into an actual place of transformation with a real living spirit,
- 1:06:04right?
- 1:06:04That's what we're talking about here,
- 1:06:05right?
- 1:06:06We're talking about if you go inward,
- 1:06:07you're going to find something that's going to change you.
- 1:06:10So where we invite people into that place as opposed
- 1:06:13to drawing lines and labels that make people harden immediately,
- 1:06:17then God will take care of the rest of the spirit,
- 1:06:19we agree on so much and I love so much of what you said.
- 1:06:22I hope that people hear it because it's really important.
- 1:06:24So thank you for saying that.
- 1:06:26I actually think that when empathy leads us to sin and to validate lies,
- 1:06:29that it leads us to very harmful places.
- 1:06:31So,
- 1:06:32I argue that
- 1:06:33this form of toxic empathy,
- 1:06:34not all empathy,
- 1:06:35but this form of what I argue is toxic empathy,
- 1:06:38blinds us to reality and morality and makes us forget about
- 1:06:41the victim on the other side of the moral equation.
- 1:06:43So,
- 1:06:44not that we're going to rehash abortion again,
- 1:06:46just to give you an example of where I'm coming from.
- 1:06:48So when we have so much strong empathy for The woman,
- 1:06:51her plight,
- 1:06:52what she's going through,
- 1:06:53and we say I have to support her right to choose because I feel her plight.
- 1:06:58What we've done there is we've ignored the humanity and the
- 1:07:01need and the rights of that child inside the womb.
- 1:07:04We have sacrificed on the altar of empathy a
- 1:07:07living human being when it comes to the gender debate
- 1:07:09because we feel so deeply for this person over
- 1:07:12here who says they're born in the wrong body.
- 1:07:14We forget about all the women and girls over here
- 1:07:16who are now denied their fairness and their rights.
- 1:07:18Sure,
- 1:07:18but without digging into.
- 1:07:21Cool.
- 1:07:21You did great.
- 1:07:22Thanks.
- 1:07:22Yeah,
- 1:07:22you too.
- 1:07:23Thanks.
- 1:07:24My final claim is progressivism and Christianity are at odds.
- 1:07:33Hello Danny,
- 1:07:34how's it going?
- 1:07:35Should we define progressivism?
- 1:07:37Yeah,
- 1:07:37thank you so much.
- 1:07:37I would love to hear kind of where you're going
- 1:07:39on kind of an ideological.
- 1:07:40OK,
- 1:07:41so I was thinking about this,
- 1:07:42and it's so broad.
- 1:07:43I don't know if we're going to be able to agree on
- 1:07:45an answer and a clear definition,
- 1:07:47so I'm happy to workshop it with you,
- 1:07:49but I kind of define progressivism as the belief that
- 1:07:51morality and truth evolve with culture and the human experience,
- 1:07:55and that that would kind of encompass a lot
- 1:07:57of the what I would call progressive views.
- 1:07:59Sexuality and gender,
- 1:08:01even economics and justice.
- 1:08:04What do you think about that definition?
- 1:08:06I think it's fabulous.
- 1:08:07I think it's,
- 1:08:07I think God is pulling us into greater levels of understanding of
- 1:08:10God's grace and justice and story and all of that.
- 1:08:12So I would agree with that.
- 1:08:13So what do you think our authority is when we're
- 1:08:15trying to figure out what's moral and what's not?
- 1:08:17Well,
- 1:08:17I think,
- 1:08:17so we're going to use the word authority maybe differently.
- 1:08:19I look at scripture,
- 1:08:20but I think you and I look at scripture certainly differently.
- 1:08:23Yeah.
- 1:08:23How do you,
- 1:08:23how when you're looking at scripture,
- 1:08:25how do you decide,
- 1:08:26OK.
- 1:08:27Yes,
- 1:08:28this is right.
- 1:08:29I need to listen to what Jesus says about praying for my enemies,
- 1:08:33but when he talks about the definition of marriage,
- 1:08:36I don't think that's literal.
- 1:08:37How do you work with that?
- 1:08:38Yes,
- 1:08:39I imagine we're both talking about the 66 book Protestant Bible as well.
- 1:08:42It's a lot of different compositions of scripture and all that,
- 1:08:44but I mean,
- 1:08:45I would look at it in terms of context.
- 1:08:46I try really hard not to prove text in anything.
- 1:08:48I try really hard not to pull something out and say,
- 1:08:50you know,
- 1:08:51the Bible says that,
- 1:08:51that settles it.
- 1:08:52I think if any Christian
- 1:08:54progressive.
- 1:08:54conservative tells you that they're a liar.
- 1:08:56The Bible is not a parlor trick,
- 1:08:58and it's not something that ought to be
- 1:09:00proof texted.
- 1:09:01So I think in the whole totality of scripture,
- 1:09:04the story that God is weaving and the story that God is writing,
- 1:09:06which is the story of God and us,
- 1:09:07like both of us,
- 1:09:08and that's not because we agree.
- 1:09:09It's because God loves us,
- 1:09:10both of us.
- 1:09:11God is telling a story of greater levels of justice and redemption.
- 1:09:15We look at this
- 1:09:16through,
- 1:09:16you talked about America being founded on Christian
- 1:09:19biblical principles,
- 1:09:20right?
- 1:09:21There are a lot.
- 1:09:21Of my friends of color that were up here,
- 1:09:23that the Bible would have condemned their personhood.
- 1:09:25The Bible would have conferred how people,
- 1:09:27how people interpreted the Bible may have condemned their personhood,
- 1:09:31but the Bible didn't change and God didn't change.
- 1:09:33So Hebrews 13:8 says that Jesus Christ is the same yesterday,
- 1:09:37today and forever.
- 1:09:38So He and His word don't change.
- 1:09:39But I agree,
- 1:09:40I think we both agree that human beings are fallible,
- 1:09:42that we're finite,
- 1:09:43and that we don't always get it right.
- 1:09:45I would say there's one correct interpretation of Scripture,
- 1:09:48and We do our very best to do exactly what you said,
- 1:09:51to read everything in context,
- 1:09:52to try to understand what that correct interpretation is.
- 1:09:55I don't have a lot of time.
- 1:09:56Can I ask you a question?
- 1:09:57Where do you think maybe you are getting it wrong?
- 1:09:59Where do you think,
- 1:10:00when,
- 1:10:01when you're interpreting scripture,
- 1:10:02because who gets to be the arbiter of what's right and wrong?
- 1:10:03Like the people that thought slavery was just,
- 1:10:06they felt certainly right.
- 1:10:07The people that oppressed women
- 1:10:08have felt certainly right.
- 1:10:09I feel certainly right that the Bible doesn't condemn queer people,
- 1:10:12and I would affirm that there are things I probably get wrong.
- 1:10:15Would you?
- 1:10:16Say that there's anything you think you have missed
- 1:10:17the mark on or that you're open to.
- 1:10:19Oh,
- 1:10:19I'm sure,
- 1:10:19because I'm a fallible person and so I could
- 1:10:22never say that I am the infallible interpreter.
- 1:10:25But of course I want to take the word of God as seriously in context as possible.
- 1:10:29And you know there were Christians who tried
- 1:10:31to justify all kinds of things using scripture,
- 1:10:33as you,
- 1:10:34I'm sure would agree with,
- 1:10:35but also the abolitionist movement
- 1:10:37was motivated and led by Christians who were inspired by that very same Bible.
- 1:10:43In it is the gospel,
- 1:10:45of course,
- 1:10:45which says all people are made in God's image and equally
- 1:10:47dead and sin apart from Christ by grace through faith,
- 1:10:49you have been saved.
- 1:10:51And so yes,
- 1:10:52human beings get it wrong.
- 1:10:53God does not get it wrong and God does not change.
- 1:10:56I agree with that.
- 1:10:56So I would say
- 1:10:57I would love my friends across the aisle
- 1:11:00to have more humility.
- 1:11:02I don't think there's toxic humility.
- 1:11:03I think that when I look at scripture,
- 1:11:05I try really hard to come at it with humility.
- 1:11:07I take the Bible really seriously enough to
- 1:11:10Dive into it and deconstruct it and find places that
- 1:11:13are not congruent with the story that God is writing,
- 1:11:16places that don't make sense,
- 1:11:17that are out of context,
- 1:11:18places that affirm the stories that are being said.
- 1:11:21I am certainly not right 100% of the way,
- 1:11:23and when I get up and preach in front of my congregation,
- 1:11:25I say that to them.
- 1:11:26I let them know,
- 1:11:27like,
- 1:11:27I am a person diving into God's word with you.
- 1:11:30See,
- 1:11:30I would argue that you're making yourself the authority because
- 1:11:33you could read clearly,
- 1:11:35for example,
- 1:11:35that Romans 1 condemns homosexuality,
- 1:11:37but you're saying I don't find.
- 1:11:40That congruent with the rest of scripture,
- 1:11:42and you are deciding that that's not true,
- 1:11:45whereas I might read something that,
- 1:11:46hey,
- 1:11:47is
- 1:11:48a little jarring for me,
- 1:11:49wives submit to their husbands,
- 1:11:51that's important.
- 1:11:51That's Ephesians 5.
- 1:11:53Women should not be pastors.
- 1:11:55That's also in scripture,
- 1:11:56and those things,
- 1:11:57you know,
- 1:11:58as a woman,
- 1:11:58as a strong woman,
- 1:12:00I still have to submit to myself
- 1:12:02to God's law and God's word,
- 1:12:04even when it might feel difficult because I'm a sinful person in my flesh.
- 1:12:09Yeah.
- 1:12:11Thank you.
- 1:12:11Good job.
- 1:12:17Hi,
- 1:12:17Ali.
- 1:12:18What's your name?
- 1:12:19Colby.
- 1:12:19Colby,
- 1:12:20nice to meet you,
- 1:12:20Colby.
- 1:12:21Great to meet you.
- 1:12:21Progressive is a complicated term.
- 1:12:23Yeah,
- 1:12:23it kind of is.
- 1:12:24It was hard for me to hear over there next to the fan.
- 1:12:26Can you redefine how you're using it?
- 1:12:28Yeah so how I'm defining it is the belief that
- 1:12:30morality and truth evolve with culture in the human experience.
- 1:12:34Which I think encompasses probably the justification for a
- 1:12:37lot of progressive views on things like sexuality.
- 1:12:39OK.
- 1:12:40Here's where I struggle with
- 1:12:41measuring that against Christianity.
- 1:12:44Progressive can be used as a noun,
- 1:12:46as an identity.
- 1:12:47Like there are some people in this room that might identify as progressive.
- 1:12:51That's kind of a moving target.
- 1:12:52Um
- 1:12:55for sure.
- 1:12:56Progressive as a verb,
- 1:12:57I think I'm far more interested in like an orientation,
- 1:13:00a way that you,
- 1:13:01a posture that you approach the world.
- 1:13:04I submit to you,
- 1:13:05and I wonder how you feel about this,
- 1:13:06that in his context,
- 1:13:08Jesus would have been seen as a progressive as it related to,
- 1:13:13if we're going to use modern labels,
- 1:13:14the conservative religion of Second Temple Judaism.
- 1:13:18He had a posture of,
- 1:13:19look,
- 1:13:20there are some things that have gone astray.
- 1:13:22There are some things that you've heard it said,
- 1:13:24but I say to you.
- 1:13:25There's a belief,
- 1:13:26you know,
- 1:13:27progress is built into a progressive.
- 1:13:28There's a belief that
- 1:13:30we can do
- 1:13:31better,
- 1:13:31like things can get
- 1:13:33better.
- 1:13:33So there's a part of Jesus that I see
- 1:13:35had a posture as not a progressive,
- 1:13:38but just as being progressive.
- 1:13:40So thoughts on that.
- 1:13:41OK,
- 1:13:41so
- 1:13:42say every single person
- 1:13:44in this country believed that transgenderism was right,
- 1:13:48that homosex.
- 1:13:48Sexuality is right.
- 1:13:49Something to be celebrated,
- 1:13:50believed in gay marriage,
- 1:13:51OK,
- 1:13:52except for this one person,
- 1:13:54and this one person started saying,
- 1:13:55Nope,
- 1:13:56we've got it wrong.
- 1:13:57We
- 1:13:58need to change what we're doing here.
- 1:14:00I know that we've been doing this for 100 years,
- 1:14:02but I don't agree with this,
- 1:14:04and I'm going to speak a different message.
- 1:14:06Would that person be progressive?
- 1:14:08I didn't hear your thoughts on Jesus.
- 1:14:09So you're saying that I'm,
- 1:14:11I'm trying to understand your logic.
- 1:14:12You were saying because Jesus was saying something.
- 1:14:14Different than the Pharisees and the Sadducees,
- 1:14:17saying something different than the message that a lot of
- 1:14:18people heard at the time that he was progressive.
- 1:14:21Really,
- 1:14:21what I would argue is that no,
- 1:14:23he was going back to what God's heart always was.
- 1:14:26When we see in Hebrews 11,
- 1:14:27for example,
- 1:14:28by faith Abraham,
- 1:14:30by faith Moses,
- 1:14:31we even read that by faith Moses considered the reproach of
- 1:14:34Christ more important to him than the riches of the Egyptians.
- 1:14:38So we actually see from the very beginning it was always faith in Christ.
- 1:14:41In the very beginning,
- 1:14:42God's law was always about hard posture obedience.
- 1:14:45So God wasn't bringing Jesus wasn't bringing something new.
- 1:14:47He was saying,
- 1:14:48Hey,
- 1:14:48I am the Alpha and the Omega.
- 1:14:50I am the Word,
- 1:14:51as John 1 says,
- 1:14:52we're going back to how it was always meant to be.
- 1:14:55OK,
- 1:14:55but he was bringing new things,
- 1:14:57and I feel like in a different context you would,
- 1:15:02you would admit that he was bringing things,
- 1:15:02so Leviticus,
- 1:15:03eye for an eye,
- 1:15:03tooth for a tooth.
- 1:15:04Jesus,
- 1:15:04you've heard it said,
- 1:15:06an eye for an eye,
- 1:15:06a tooth for a tooth.
- 1:15:07He was,
- 1:15:07he was adding,
- 1:15:08OK,
- 1:15:08so there's not,
- 1:15:09he doubles,
- 1:15:09I don't,
- 1:15:10he says I don't think that's a doubling down,
- 1:15:12Ali.
- 1:15:12I think it's a,
- 1:15:13I think it is a progress of,
- 1:15:14hey,
- 1:15:14we live in a new world,
- 1:15:15a new time.
- 1:15:16Let's do things differently.
- 1:15:17So
- 1:15:18here's why I think,
- 1:15:19I don't think so at all.
- 1:15:20Like in Matthew 19,
- 1:15:21for example,
- 1:15:22when he's asked about divorce
- 1:15:23and Pharisees are like,
- 1:15:24Yeah,
- 1:15:24what about divorce and who's the wife in heaven and all
- 1:15:27of this stuff trying to trap Jesus as they did,
- 1:15:29he doesn't say,
- 1:15:30I bring to you something new.
- 1:15:32He says,
- 1:15:32Oh no.
- 1:15:33Have you not read that in the beginning he who made them male and female
- 1:15:37said the man will join the wife and the two shall become one flesh.
- 1:15:40He goes all the way back to creation
- 1:15:42and Jesus says,
- 1:15:43I've not come to abolish the law,
- 1:15:45but to fulfill the law.
- 1:15:47Do you believe that Jesus is God?
- 1:15:48I think you're mishearing me.
- 1:15:49I'm not saying everything Jesus was teaching
- 1:15:52was
- 1:15:54a move forward.
- 1:15:55I'm saying he had a posture of saying,
- 1:15:57we've gotten off track.
- 1:15:58We've lost the plot on some things.
- 1:16:00My point is this,
- 1:16:01the people in this room who identify
- 1:16:03liberal Christians,
- 1:16:04progressive Christians,
- 1:16:05I don't know what labels they use,
- 1:16:06labels are helpful up until they're not.
- 1:16:07Like we,
- 1:16:08at some point we always hit a point where that doesn't really fit anymore for me.
- 1:16:11But I feel like we all have a posture in this room
- 1:16:15of saying
- 1:16:16we live in a different world now,
- 1:16:19and could have ever been anticipated 2000 years ago,
- 1:16:213000 years ago,
- 1:16:23except for by God,
- 1:16:24because he knows everything.
- 1:16:27Oh,
- 1:16:27sorry,
- 1:16:28you did great though.
- 1:16:29Oh,
- 1:16:29it's great to meet you.
- 1:16:30Thank you.
- 1:16:34Oh my goodness,
- 1:16:35that was
- 1:16:36wild.
- 1:16:37Are you OK there,
- 1:16:37Paul?
- 1:16:38I'm,
- 1:16:38I was so desperate,
- 1:16:39just so desperate to talk to you.
- 1:16:40No.
- 1:16:41Awesome.
- 1:16:41Well,
- 1:16:41you're here.
- 1:16:42Good job.
- 1:16:43Let's go.
- 1:16:44Are you OK with my definition of progressivism?
- 1:16:46I'm not,
- 1:16:46and I was actually just OK,
- 1:16:47you're going to contend with it.
- 1:16:48OK.
- 1:16:48Yes,
- 1:16:49I believe progressivism is the unraveling
- 1:16:51of traditional ideas.
- 1:16:53Unraveling is a great way to describe progressivism in my book too.
- 1:16:56Yes,
- 1:16:56unraveling
- 1:16:57through discovery.
- 1:16:58We discover things over time.
- 1:16:59At one point,
- 1:17:00slavery.
- 1:17:01Uh,
- 1:17:02abolition of it was progressive.
- 1:17:03At one point we discover
- 1:17:05we discovered through a moral truth,
- 1:17:07through natural law of reasoning,
- 1:17:08did we get that moral truth?
- 1:17:09Through rationale.
- 1:17:10Oh really?
- 1:17:11Well,
- 1:17:11rationale rationalized slavery for a long time.
- 1:17:14Yeah,
- 1:17:14I know.
- 1:17:14And then as rationalized child sacrifice and rationalized child prostitution.
- 1:17:19How can we trust our rationale to tell?
- 1:17:20Us these universal moral truths that we need to build our lives on.
- 1:17:23As a collective,
- 1:17:24we use rationality as a tool to unpack
- 1:17:26logic that we see all the time.
- 1:17:28Now what I want to ask,
- 1:17:28we trust our rationale.
- 1:17:30You and my rationale disagree so much.
- 1:17:32Exactly.
- 1:17:32So we look over
- 1:17:34and we use rationality as a tool to unpack these things.
- 1:17:36What I want to get to you,
- 1:17:37for example,
- 1:17:38is
- 1:17:39how can you read anything,
- 1:17:41right?
- 1:17:42And you can't look at it in the contextual,
- 1:17:44or you can look at it in the contextual.
- 1:17:46A lot of people didn't think of the ideas we have today.
- 1:17:48You think,
- 1:17:49for example,
- 1:17:50you said earlier that
- 1:17:51a woman should not be allowed to preach,
- 1:17:52right,
- 1:17:53because,
- 1:17:53you know,
- 1:17:54first Timothy says that.
- 1:17:55Yeah,
- 1:17:55no,
- 1:17:55I will say there are Christians that are truly Christians that disagree with me
- 1:17:59on that.
- 1:18:00But yes,
- 1:18:01Paul never said that.
- 1:18:02That's the thing.
- 1:18:02Paul is actually writing to Ephesians to tell Timothy
- 1:18:05to go ahead and Tell the Ephesians
- 1:18:07to stop letting all the pagan worship get in there.
- 1:18:10That's actually the point of it,
- 1:18:11because women were standing up in church and saying there's more God,
- 1:18:13worship materialism,
- 1:18:14all the gold that argument,
- 1:18:15but he goes all the way back to creation again,
- 1:18:18he says,
- 1:18:19because Adam was formed first
- 1:18:21and then Eve.
- 1:18:21So it seems to me like it's not cultural or circumstantial.
- 1:18:24He's going all the way back to Genesis
- 1:18:25to justify his reasoning for why women shouldn't lead in
- 1:18:28churches or why they shouldn't be pastors and preachers.
- 1:18:30Churches,
- 1:18:30so I don't see it as just something that had to do with women shouting at the time,
- 1:18:35although maybe I'm not sure how you get from he was created first,
- 1:18:37she was created second,
- 1:18:38and then women can't talk in church.
- 1:18:40Yeah,
- 1:18:40well,
- 1:18:40I think that's a question for Paul,
- 1:18:42and I think that's something that we could debate,
- 1:18:43but my point is that clearly he's not just talking about something circumstantial,
- 1:18:47he's going all the way back,
- 1:18:48and
- 1:18:49I might have paraphrased that wrongly.
- 1:18:50He might have said that Eve sinned first and then Adam.
- 1:18:54Someone out there can correct me,
- 1:18:55but he does go all the way back to creation.
- 1:18:57Yeah,
- 1:18:57what's interesting about that is you're saying we can ask Paul,
- 1:18:59but that's your interpretation.
- 1:19:01I have a different interpretation.
- 1:19:02Now what I wanna ask,
- 1:19:03going back to you is,
- 1:19:05how do you
- 1:19:06Know that you're correct.
- 1:19:08How do I know that I'm correct?
- 1:19:09We use rationality to unpack these things.
- 1:19:11For example,
- 1:19:12there's no Jew nor Gentile.
- 1:19:14We talk about what is natural,
- 1:19:15what is unnatural.
- 1:19:16Even so,
- 1:19:17Aquinas and Augustine,
- 1:19:18right,
- 1:19:19and a bunch of other church fathers actually said that women were below men in order.
- 1:19:22Do you not believe we have equal roles in society?
- 1:19:24I don't know that.
- 1:19:25I think we have equal value absolutely as people who are made in the.
- 1:19:28Image of God.
- 1:19:30But I don't think that I have the
- 1:19:31perfect interpretation because I'm not a perfect person.
- 1:19:34But I do look to the word of God to be my authority and humbly and humility,
- 1:19:38try to do the very best I can to understand all of it in context
- 1:19:41and apply it to my life.
- 1:19:43And I just find rationale,
- 1:19:44while really important,
- 1:19:45it's part of being made in God's image.
- 1:19:46He gave it to us.
- 1:19:47But to say that that is the determinant of morality,
- 1:19:50that's a really
- 1:19:51scary world.
- 1:19:52Think about what our rationale has rationalized for so long.
- 1:19:55But if we all just rested on this amazing fact that we are all made in the Imago day,
- 1:20:00we all have innate rights,
- 1:20:02well,
- 1:20:02that's how we get to the idea that we should abolish slavery.
- 1:20:04That's how we get the idea that we should
- 1:20:06treat people under our law with dignity and respect,
- 1:20:09not rationale,
- 1:20:09but natural law that's rooted in scripture.
- 1:20:12I never said that rational.
- 1:20:14Hey,
- 1:20:14you did good.
- 1:20:15I know.
- 1:20:20Hey,
- 1:20:20what's your name?
- 1:20:21Joseph.
- 1:20:21Joseph,
- 1:20:22nice to meet you.
- 1:20:22Nice to meet you.
- 1:20:23I actually grew up Church of Christ,
- 1:20:25which is
- 1:20:26theological cousins of the Baptists,
- 1:20:28as I
- 1:20:30got it.
- 1:20:30Maybe so.
- 1:20:31I'm not sure.
- 1:20:31I haven't done that genealogy yet,
- 1:20:32but I'll trust you.
- 1:20:33Um,
- 1:20:34well,
- 1:20:34we came out of the,
- 1:20:34the Campbell Stoner,
- 1:20:36Alexander Campbell movement.
- 1:20:38This
- 1:20:39prompt that progressivism and
- 1:20:42Christianity seem to be at odds with one another
- 1:20:44to me feels like it's a repackaged,
- 1:20:47um.
- 1:20:48Statement of of something that I've heard
- 1:20:51multiple times growing up
- 1:20:52that
- 1:20:53if you're a Christian,
- 1:20:54you have to vote a certain way.
- 1:20:57OK,
- 1:20:57that's not the claim that I'm
- 1:20:59making,
- 1:21:00but maybe I can come back and make that claim because I might,
- 1:21:04but
- 1:21:04I'm really talking more about the philosophy and the worldview of progressivism
- 1:21:09that our morality,
- 1:21:10that our interpretation of scripture is constantly evolving based on
- 1:21:13how we feel and based on what the majority of.
- 1:21:15Society thinks.
- 1:21:16I just don't think that that's a good basis for deciding what's
- 1:21:19moral and what's right and what should be legal or illegal.
- 1:21:21Do you think that
- 1:21:23our
- 1:21:24definitions of certain ideas
- 1:21:27change over time?
- 1:21:28And would you say that that's wrong,
- 1:21:30that they change over time?
- 1:21:30For the Christian,
- 1:21:31I think we should be getting closer and closer to Scripture.
- 1:21:34So I would argue,
- 1:21:35for example,
- 1:21:36when you had Christians who were justifying slavery using the Bible,
- 1:21:40and then we had Christians later who used that.
- 1:21:42Same Bible
- 1:21:43to fan the flame of abolition.
- 1:21:46William Wilberforce,
- 1:21:47for example,
- 1:21:48he was a great warrior for the truth and the dignity of people,
- 1:21:51using the truth of the gospel,
- 1:21:53that that is people moving more into what the Bible says,
- 1:21:57not away from what the Bible says based on society
- 1:22:00really for all of time,
- 1:22:01most of the world had no qualms with slavery.
- 1:22:03Still today,
- 1:22:03slavery exists in non-Western countries.
- 1:22:06So I think if we change,
- 1:22:08we should be changing.
- 1:22:10To be more in alignment with what with what God's word says,
- 1:22:13right?
- 1:22:13And I think I would agree with you on that,
- 1:22:16and I think what our
- 1:22:18You you'd asked a previous person what leads you to that movement.
- 1:22:22I believe that it's our,
- 1:22:23the Holy Spirit
- 1:22:24that we have that can lead us to
- 1:22:27justice,
- 1:22:28right?
- 1:22:28Micah 6:8,
- 1:22:29walk humbly,
- 1:22:30seek justice.
- 1:22:31And I think the question would be,
- 1:22:33which we probably disagree on,
- 1:22:34and we don't have time to get into it.
- 1:22:35Now
- 1:22:36is what justice looks like,
- 1:22:38and we know that God is one Father,
- 1:22:39Son,
- 1:22:40Holy Spirit.
- 1:22:40So the Holy Spirit in our hearts is not going
- 1:22:42to disagree with what God says in His word.
- 1:22:45And so if God says that justice or whatever is defined one way,
- 1:22:48then the Holy Spirit agrees with that.
- 1:22:50If we are feeling,
- 1:22:51oh,
- 1:22:51I don't like what the Bible says,
- 1:22:52that's not the Holy Spirit.
- 1:22:55Thank you so much.
- 1:22:56It was good to talk to you.
- 1:23:02OK,
- 1:23:02let's go,
- 1:23:03Tim.
- 1:23:03You believe that slavery is wrong?
- 1:23:04Yes,
- 1:23:05of course.
- 1:23:05Do you agree with John MacArthur's statements when he says that
- 1:23:08slavery can be great if you have the right master?
- 1:23:10No,
- 1:23:10I don't.
- 1:23:11I don't know that statement in context.
- 1:23:13The context he's talking about slavery.
- 1:23:14John MacArthur is a great teacher,
- 1:23:17was a great teacher,
- 1:23:17but he said that.
- 1:23:18So is he wrong on that?
- 1:23:19But I've never read that quote,
- 1:23:20and so I would have to know for sure exactly what he's talking about.
- 1:23:23But of course
- 1:23:24I condemn
- 1:23:25all dehumanization and all objectification of people who
- 1:23:28are all made in the image of God.
- 1:23:30No person.
- 1:23:31Should be owned.
- 1:23:32It comes from the same belief that I have about abortion,
- 1:23:34that it's wrong to kill babies inside the womb.
- 1:23:36Do you think it's always wrong to kill an innocent person problem with that though is
- 1:23:39that your evangelical fundamentalist tradition was on the
- 1:23:42other side of this conversation all the way.
- 1:23:44Bob Jones,
- 1:23:44the founder of Bob Jones University,
- 1:23:46used your exact same framework of how he saw
- 1:23:48the Bible to justify why the racists should stay
- 1:23:51separate,
- 1:23:52and then he said all kinds of frameworks to justify all kinds of bad things
- 1:23:55because we're really imperfect people your framework
- 1:23:58and he kind of used my framework.
- 1:24:00People,
- 1:24:00he said that people who wouldn't,
- 1:24:02who would not see it his way are liberals,
- 1:24:04are progressives trying to distort the truth of the gospel.
- 1:24:07This is the white evangelical tradition we should
- 1:24:09that go you're drawing further into scripture.
- 1:24:11I would say that he was unbiblical just in the same way I think that you,
- 1:24:15Paul says slaves obey your masters.
- 1:24:16Oh,
- 1:24:16it absolutely does.
- 1:24:17It does not condone chattel slavery.
- 1:24:19I think it acknowledges that it is a part of society,
- 1:24:23the goalposts.
- 1:24:23I think it acknowledges that it is a part of society,
- 1:24:26regulates it,
- 1:24:26but the Torah regulates of the in.
- 1:24:29I would argue prohibits the ownership of if you wouldn't be on the side of
- 1:24:33the progressives if you were back in
- 1:24:35the day when race-based child slavery happened,
- 1:24:36because you know what the argument was against that?
- 1:24:38The word of God has not changed.
- 1:24:39Ali.
- 1:24:40Yes,
- 1:24:40it does.
- 1:24:40Our interpret.
- 1:24:41Well,
- 1:24:41that's a different conversation,
- 1:24:42but the argument,
- 1:24:43the argument,
- 1:24:44that's the argument would be this,
- 1:24:46um,
- 1:24:46if you were around during race-based child slavery,
- 1:24:49show me in the Bible where it condemned slavery,
- 1:24:51and they couldn't.
- 1:24:52That was the whole point that we were in God's image.
- 1:24:54Paul says for slaves to obey your masters.
- 1:24:56Do you agree with that statement?
- 1:24:57Of course I.
- 1:24:58Agree with the Bible.
- 1:24:59OK,
- 1:24:59so you agree with the statement.
- 1:25:00The Bible does condone slavery.
- 1:25:02That does not mean that I agree with instituting slavery.
- 1:25:05But that's not what I said.
- 1:25:07I said the Bible condones slavery.
- 1:25:08You said no,
- 1:25:09it doesn't.
- 1:25:09I brought the passage where Paul says slaves obey your masters.
- 1:25:12You said I agree with the Bible.
- 1:25:13He did not in the book of Philemon?
- 1:25:15In the book of Philemon.
- 1:25:17What happens in the Book of Philemon?
- 1:25:18Do you know?
- 1:25:18I'm asking you to,
- 1:25:19I'm,
- 1:25:19I gave you a passage of Philemon.
- 1:25:21Hold on.
- 1:25:21You keep,
- 1:25:22you are very good at this because you keep moving the goalposts,
- 1:25:24OK?
- 1:25:25How,
- 1:25:25how am I moving the goalpost?
- 1:25:26We're still talking about slavery.
- 1:25:28I Bible allowed you to go around and around about slavery.
- 1:25:30I'm not going to,
- 1:25:31I'm not going to let it go.
- 1:25:32Paul says slaves to obey your masters.
- 1:25:35Do you agree with Paul on that wives submit to their husbands,
- 1:25:37and this is all in the context of children submitting to their fathers.
- 1:25:41That does not mean that as an institution
- 1:25:43that he is condoning slavery.
- 1:25:45He's saying it's good.
- 1:25:46I think we can read God's heart behind that.
- 1:25:48Well,
- 1:25:48that's a,
- 1:25:48I think that's a deep interpretation.
- 1:25:50That's not in the text.
- 1:25:52What is not in the text?
- 1:25:53Well,
- 1:25:53well,
- 1:25:53like I said,
- 1:25:54I'm,
- 1:25:54I'm going to hammer it again.
- 1:25:55Paul says.
- 1:25:56That slavery is good.
- 1:25:57Paul knew what was going on.
- 1:25:58He could have condemned it.
- 1:25:59You think he's saying that slavery is good because Paul's a part
- 1:26:01of this let's talk about a different kind of slavery that existed,
- 1:26:04which was bond servant,
- 1:26:06for example.
- 1:26:06So people were in debt and so to pay their way out of debt,
- 1:26:10sometimes they would have bond service for a certain
- 1:26:12amount of time to pay their way into freedom.
- 1:26:15It was not always the same as the chattel slavery that we see
- 1:26:18in the 19th century in America,
- 1:26:21for example.
- 1:26:22And so it was a different context
- 1:26:24and it was a different time.
- 1:26:25That does not mean that any of us should condone
- 1:26:28slavery.
- 1:26:29All I want to say is that you perfectly gave
- 1:26:31the framework for why we don't believe that homosexuality in
- 1:26:34the Bible is the same thing as it is today.
- 1:26:36It's the same.
- 1:26:37No,
- 1:26:37no,
- 1:26:37no,
- 1:26:37no,
- 1:26:38it's the same thing.
- 1:26:39You can't say slavery in the Bible back then was contextual
- 1:26:43and different than what race-based child slavery is,
- 1:26:45and then not do the same thing for homosexuality the correct way.
- 1:26:49The Bible has prescriptive and descriptive allegory and poem 100% hyperbole.
- 1:26:54Literalism and so we have to read everything in context
- 1:26:58and when we see homosexuality not only explicitly condemned,
- 1:27:02but we also see again from creation
- 1:27:04all the way to Revelation 20 that it's an earthly reflection of an eternal reality,
- 1:27:10the marriage between Christ and the church,
- 1:27:12which is gendered,
- 1:27:13by the way,
- 1:27:13as we see in Ephesians 5,
- 1:27:15we see that reiterated
- 1:27:16over and over again.
- 1:27:17So it's not only that the Bible condemns it again,
- 1:27:20it is the only relationship that God calls good.
- 1:27:24I'll let it go.
- 1:27:25I'm fine with that.
- 1:27:27You did great.
- 1:27:27You did really good.
- 1:27:27It was a lot of fun.
- 1:27:28We're out of time,
- 1:27:28so thank you.
- 1:27:30Allie will now choose someone from the circle to debate again based on their claim.
- 1:27:35Can I just say that y'all all did really well
- 1:27:37and I've really enjoyed this,
- 1:27:39and there's a lot of people that I wanna bring here to continue to have productive
- 1:27:44conversations.
- 1:27:45Um,
- 1:27:45I'm gonna go with Gilbert.
- 1:27:50The reason why is because I enjoyed our back and forth,
- 1:27:53and I think that you have a very kind and sweet countenance,
- 1:27:56and I think that we can have a conversation,
- 1:27:58at least from a police of hoping to understand,
- 1:28:01even if we
- 1:28:02don't agree.
- 1:28:05Yay.
- 1:28:06Well,
- 1:28:06first of all,
- 1:28:06thank you,
- 1:28:07Ali,
- 1:28:07for choosing me.
- 1:28:08So my claim is the church's condemnation of same-sex relationships
- 1:28:13causes profound damage
- 1:28:15and unnecessary suffering to gay people.
- 1:28:18OK,
- 1:28:19can you please define
- 1:28:21damage and suffering for me in this context?
- 1:28:24So gay kids are 8 to 12 times more likely to commit suicide,
- 1:28:28especially if they come from religious
- 1:28:30homes,
- 1:28:30and it's because they have no way to express,
- 1:28:33and I know we keep talking about sex,
- 1:28:35right,
- 1:28:36but I want the conversation piece that I think is
- 1:28:38always missing and that it's more than just sex.
- 1:28:40It's about love.
- 1:28:41It's who you love with.
- 1:28:42It's the way that you're wired,
- 1:28:43and I know we'll disagree with this,
- 1:28:45but I really feel that in my mother's womb,
- 1:28:47God designed me this way.
- 1:28:49I'm not just born in this in principle this way.
- 1:28:51It's the way that I'm designed.
- 1:28:52It's the way that I kind of see the world,
- 1:28:53and I don't want to affirm a lot of stereotypes,
- 1:28:55but there's markers.
- 1:28:56You can tell when someone's gay.
- 1:28:57You don't have to watch them having sex,
- 1:28:59right?
- 1:28:59So there's different ways that you can spot a gay person,
- 1:29:02and I think there's a reason for that.
- 1:29:04And I've noticed so many pastors.
- 1:29:07Kids come out as gay,
- 1:29:08and I really feel like there's this movement.
- 1:29:10And when you were talking about
- 1:29:12how there was the,
- 1:29:13you know,
- 1:29:14the abolitionists who use the same Bible
- 1:29:16to come against slavery,
- 1:29:18there's also an affirming movement where the same people that love,
- 1:29:21like me,
- 1:29:21love the Bible,
- 1:29:22revere the Bible,
- 1:29:23are using that same Bible to say,
- 1:29:25hey,
- 1:29:26maybe we've misunderstood something.
- 1:29:28Maybe we were condemning same-sex behavior
- 1:29:30because in those circumstances it absolutely was idolatrous,
- 1:29:33abusive,
- 1:29:34right?
- 1:29:34It wasn't about them being in committed.
- 1:29:37Monogamous covenantal relationships
- 1:29:39and the whole totality of Scripture tells us that if you love God with everything,
- 1:29:43your heart,
- 1:29:44your mind,
- 1:29:44your strength,
- 1:29:45your soul,
- 1:29:45everything,
- 1:29:46and you love your neighbor as yourself,
- 1:29:47you are keeping the whole law,
- 1:29:49which is why when Jesus
- 1:29:51healed people on the Sabbath,
- 1:29:52they thought he was breaking the law.
- 1:29:54But see,
- 1:29:55he went full circle and said,
- 1:29:56you don't understand.
- 1:29:57The law is made to show us how to love.
- 1:29:59And so I think what really hurts me when I see myself,
- 1:30:02I see gay people,
- 1:30:03they want to fall in love,
- 1:30:04they want to be in love,
- 1:30:05they're terrified.
- 1:30:06To tell their parents about
- 1:30:08what it is that I'm going through as a gay person,
- 1:30:10to say,
- 1:30:11well,
- 1:30:11you just need to stay single,
- 1:30:13because if you act on it,
- 1:30:14if you love someone,
- 1:30:15you're going to want to have sex with them.
- 1:30:17And if you have sex with them,
- 1:30:18it's evil and wicked and you're going to hell.
- 1:30:20When I see the LGBT community sometimes
- 1:30:23kind of,
- 1:30:24you know,
- 1:30:25if you can't beat them,
- 1:30:25join them,
- 1:30:26kind of getting really,
- 1:30:27really rebellious.
- 1:30:28I kind of envision
- 1:30:30like
- 1:30:31the,
- 1:30:31the good Christians that are all heterosexual are kind of guarding the well,
- 1:30:34and we all have a God-shaped hole.
- 1:30:36In our heart we're all thirsty for something.
- 1:30:38And if you're saying you can't drink here with me because you're wicked,
- 1:30:41well,
- 1:30:42they have to satisfy that thirst somehow.
- 1:30:44So they're going to go out and,
- 1:30:46well,
- 1:30:46I can drink this.
- 1:30:47It's,
- 1:30:48you know,
- 1:30:48a deserted pool water or sewage or whatever it is.
- 1:30:51And I'm not trying to shade the gay community,
- 1:30:53but some people are like,
- 1:30:54you know what,
- 1:30:54Gilbert,
- 1:30:54I don't care.
- 1:30:55I don't care if I go to hell.
- 1:30:56I welcome going to hell
- 1:30:58because I have no healthy outlet.
- 1:31:00I can't
- 1:31:00wait until marriage because I could never even get married.
- 1:31:03And I think that that pushes people into Promiscuity.
- 1:31:06OK,
- 1:31:07well,
- 1:31:07thank you so much for explaining all of that.
- 1:31:09And first I want to acknowledge that for people who are not attracted to the same sex,
- 1:31:13that it could be very difficult to understand
- 1:31:15the pain that someone would feel to hear,
- 1:31:17Hey,
- 1:31:18it is not biblical for you to get married.
- 1:31:20It is not biblical for you to be in a relationship.
- 1:31:22It's not biblical for you to
- 1:31:24love in that way.
- 1:31:25I imagine that that is extremely difficult,
- 1:31:28extremely confusing,
- 1:31:29extremely distressing from an early age,
- 1:31:31especially if you are raised in a home
- 1:31:33that says,
- 1:31:33hey,
- 1:31:33this is what the Bible says about marriage.
- 1:31:35Sexuality,
- 1:31:36and it's not that.
- 1:31:37So I think we should acknowledge that while also
- 1:31:39acknowledging that each and every one of us sins.
- 1:31:42Each and every one of us has a disordered desire.
- 1:31:45Each and every one of us
- 1:31:46has a feeling that is not in congruence with scripture,
- 1:31:49and God does not say,
- 1:31:51hey,
- 1:31:52well,
- 1:31:52you know what,
- 1:31:53if that feeling that you have,
- 1:31:55whether it's homosexual desire or whether it's desire
- 1:31:57to have sex with someone outside of marriage,
- 1:31:59if that feeling is strong enough,
- 1:32:01then you can just go ahead and do it.
- 1:32:02He asks us to do really difficult things.
- 1:32:05He Literally asks us to take up a cross,
- 1:32:07which is a form of execution and to carry it.
- 1:32:10And I know Christians
- 1:32:12who
- 1:32:13lived
- 1:32:14openly as gay for a long time,
- 1:32:16and I'm not giving you some trite,
- 1:32:18pray the gay away
- 1:32:19motto here.
- 1:32:20But people who truly have said,
- 1:32:22I am living in repentance because everywhere
- 1:32:25I see holy sexuality described in scripture,
- 1:32:27it's between one man and one woman.
- 1:32:29I see the condemnation of homosexuality,
- 1:32:31and they have chosen
- 1:32:32painfully
- 1:32:33yet joyfully to.
- 1:32:35Up that cross and deny themselves and to follow Christ,
- 1:32:37and that is what we are all called to.
- 1:32:39But they're still gay.
- 1:32:40I don't define people as that.
- 1:32:42I would say that they are Christians,
- 1:32:43so maybe they struggle with same-sex attraction,
- 1:32:45and they may not the problem,
- 1:32:47but they may the word same-sex attraction,
- 1:32:49it really is a way out of this conversation
- 1:32:51because it's erasing everything else that goes with it.
- 1:32:54I think being having your identity tied
- 1:32:57to whom you want to have sex with is wrong,
- 1:32:59and I think that that is unbi.
- 1:33:01I agree that it's not the totality of who you are,
- 1:33:03but it's part of you.
- 1:33:04You're.
- 1:33:04Heterosexual,
- 1:33:05I'm assuming,
- 1:33:05right?
- 1:33:06Right.
- 1:33:06Is that part of who you are?
- 1:33:08It is part of who you are.
- 1:33:09The same way that my being gay is part of who I am.
- 1:33:11It's not all of me,
- 1:33:13but it is part of me,
- 1:33:14and it will not change.
- 1:33:15So I don't think that I'm making up my identity to just stress,
- 1:33:18hey,
- 1:33:18there's something going on with me that I want to talk about
- 1:33:21because it's not just me ignoring something.
- 1:33:23And again,
- 1:33:24the whole ex-gay movement,
- 1:33:25the reason why that has even gone somewhere is because
- 1:33:28they've been successfully culturally able to redefine what gay means.
- 1:33:33It doesn't just mean
- 1:33:34You know,
- 1:33:34that's why I have an issue with same-sex attraction.
- 1:33:36They're saying that if we redefine what gay is and make it about behavior,
- 1:33:40then we don't have to deal with the orientation part,
- 1:33:42and that's,
- 1:33:42I feel,
- 1:33:43what the bigger issue is the orientation part.
- 1:33:46You're gay whether you act on it or not.
- 1:33:47All of us are oriented towards sin in one way or another,
- 1:33:51but then we have people who,
- 1:33:52I'm not saying that these people who I'm talking about,
- 1:33:55I'm thinking of Rosario Butterfield and Christopher Yuan and Beckett Cook,
- 1:33:58and you know,
- 1:33:59I don't know where all of them stand when it comes to their own
- 1:34:03feelings.
- 1:34:03And they wouldn't say necessarily that those feelings are going to go away
- 1:34:07in the same way that my desire to sin in other ways may never go away until glory,
- 1:34:12but we're saying that following Jesus,
- 1:34:14even when it's difficult,
- 1:34:15is worth it,
- 1:34:16and it might mean denying something that denying something that we really want.
- 1:34:19I agree with you that we should avoid sin,
- 1:34:21but see,
- 1:34:22again,
- 1:34:22there's,
- 1:34:22I don't believe it's a sin to be gay.
- 1:34:25How do you define sin and where do you get that definition,
- 1:34:27right?
- 1:34:28So if we want to talk about the word abomination,
- 1:34:30which a lot of people use for Leviticus Leviticus,
- 1:34:32Tovah,
- 1:34:33which
- 1:34:33To go against ritual,
- 1:34:34right?
- 1:34:34And then the words,
- 1:34:36is it hak?
- 1:34:36I can't pronounce the Hebrew,
- 1:34:38which is to miss the mark,
- 1:34:39right,
- 1:34:39right,
- 1:34:39right.
- 1:34:39So the difference,
- 1:34:40I believe that sin is to commit something that is unloving,
- 1:34:43right,
- 1:34:44to go against God's will and how do you define love?
- 1:34:46That's a great question.
- 1:34:48Well,
- 1:34:48love is an action.
- 1:34:50Love is a choice.
- 1:34:50Love is a decision,
- 1:34:52right?
- 1:34:52I love you.
- 1:34:53I just met you,
- 1:34:53but I love you.
- 1:34:55Um,
- 1:34:55I don't really know that any really,
- 1:34:57anybody really has
- 1:34:58a strong definition.
- 1:34:59It could be different for different people.
- 1:35:00So God is love.
- 1:35:01First John 48,
- 1:35:02when he says that.
- 1:35:03Corinthians in 1 Corinthians 13:6 that love never rejoices in wrongdoing,
- 1:35:07but rejoices with the truth.
- 1:35:09And when we see in separate parts
- 1:35:10of Scripture that he calls homosexuality wrongdoing,
- 1:35:13it seems to me,
- 1:35:15well,
- 1:35:15he does in Romans 1 and 1 Corinthians 6,
- 1:35:17Romans 1,
- 1:35:18the men were straight.
- 1:35:19They,
- 1:35:19they abandoned their wives to be with each other see that.
- 1:35:22I don't see that literally at all.
- 1:35:24They abandoned their women.
- 1:35:25Straight men don't have or gay men don't have women.
- 1:35:27They abandoned natural relations with women.
- 1:35:29It didn't
- 1:35:29say natural relations with their wives.
- 1:35:32Natural relationships and were inflamed with lust for one another.
- 1:35:35Lust,
- 1:35:36lust is not love.
- 1:35:37They were inflamed with lust for one another.
- 1:35:39It goes on to say that they were God hating,
- 1:35:41that they
- 1:35:42were murderers,
- 1:35:42that they were God,
- 1:35:43right?
- 1:35:44So when people a lot about gay people,
- 1:35:46no,
- 1:35:46when you apply Romans 1 to gay people,
- 1:35:49that's my whole point.
- 1:35:50You're reading Sodom and Gomorrah,
- 1:35:51and you think that gay people all want to
- 1:35:53gang bang each other and rape each other.
- 1:35:55Yes,
- 1:35:56I said that.
- 1:35:57But so do you think that Sodom and Gomorrah was destroyed because of homosexuality?
- 1:36:00Well,
- 1:36:00let me read you,
- 1:36:01Jude.
- 1:36:02I,
- 1:36:02well,
- 1:36:03I know that they're they're comparable,
- 1:36:04but,
- 1:36:04but,
- 1:36:05but,
- 1:36:05but with respect,
- 1:36:06Ali,
- 1:36:06a lot of people.
- 1:36:07Sodom and Gomorrah and the surrounding cities,
- 1:36:09which likewise indulged in sexual immorality
- 1:36:11and pursued unnatural desire,
- 1:36:14serve as an example by undergoing a punishment of eternal fire.
- 1:36:17So actually we read in the New Testament that Sodom and Gomorrah
- 1:36:20were actually did because of that unnatural exceedingly.
- 1:36:24Do you think if you're exceedingly wicked,
- 1:36:25you're like,
- 1:36:25we'll do everything but have weird sex.
- 1:36:26They did.
- 1:36:27But why do you think that God called that out?
- 1:36:29Because
- 1:36:30what are you calling weird sex?
- 1:36:32Rape,
- 1:36:33that's pretty weird.
- 1:36:34Yeah,
- 1:36:34I mean,
- 1:36:35of course that's morally wrong is weird,
- 1:36:37but they're
- 1:36:39intentionally calling out the homosexuality and the
- 1:36:41unnatural calling out homosexual disordered desire there.
- 1:36:46No,
- 1:36:46I,
- 1:36:46OK,
- 1:36:46we'll disagree on that part,
- 1:36:48but,
- 1:36:48and I will,
- 1:36:49I will say that on Romans one,
- 1:36:50I really find it offensive
- 1:36:52that people think that that of gay people that we all are.
- 1:36:56We hate faith.
- 1:36:56We hate our parents.
- 1:36:57We're murderers.
- 1:36:58We're gossips.
- 1:36:59Somebody sat me down and told me that.
- 1:37:01They're like,
- 1:37:02Look,
- 1:37:02Gilbert,
- 1:37:02this is,
- 1:37:02this is you.
- 1:37:04I said,
- 1:37:04Really?
- 1:37:04That's,
- 1:37:05you think that I'm this person?
- 1:37:07Because Paul's describing who this kind of person is.
- 1:37:10And I think that
- 1:37:11You know,
- 1:37:12earlier you were talking to somebody who
- 1:37:15you allowed context,
- 1:37:17right,
- 1:37:17about slavery.
- 1:37:19I would hope that the church would be more open
- 1:37:22to
- 1:37:22hearing context about why these same sex
- 1:37:26behaviors were condemned and not just think it was because they were the same sex.
- 1:37:30Can I ask you a question that actually doesn't have to do with that.
- 1:37:33Do you believe that Jesus is the only way to heaven?
- 1:37:35Absolutely.
- 1:37:36You do.
- 1:37:36You believe in John 14:6 that Jesus is the.
- 1:37:39Weigh the truth in the life that no one goes to the heaven Jesus.
- 1:37:42I'm so glad that we agree on that.
- 1:37:43So often I see when people deny
- 1:37:45Genesis 1:27 or they deny Romans 1,
- 1:37:48they also end up denying John 14:6.
- 1:37:51And so I'm glad that we agree on that because I know people will read this,
- 1:37:54be like,
- 1:37:54wow,
- 1:37:54Gilbert,
- 1:37:55I didn't know you felt this way.
- 1:37:56Um,
- 1:37:56it's because you won't have a savior.
- 1:37:58We're all going to be judged at the end of our life,
- 1:38:00and it's not that you're being punished
- 1:38:02for not believing in Jesus.
- 1:38:04It's you just won't have a savior.
- 1:38:05We're all going to be judged.
- 1:38:06So that's what it is.
- 1:38:07I want to have a savior.
- 1:38:08I had to learn what that was about,
- 1:38:10so I don't want people to think that I'm just being like,
- 1:38:12Oh,
- 1:38:12Jesus will punish you for not believing Him.
- 1:38:14It's because you won't have somebody
- 1:38:15on the final day to vouch for you.
- 1:38:18Well,
- 1:38:18that's your choice.
- 1:38:19That's an interesting,
- 1:38:20an interesting way to say it,
- 1:38:21and I'm glad that we agree on John 14:6.
- 1:38:23That's really,
- 1:38:24really important.
- 1:38:25So thank you so much.
- 1:38:27Thank you.
- 1:38:28We did it.
- 1:38:28We did,
- 1:38:29yeah,
- 1:38:29stop it.
- 1:38:31Good job.
- 1:38:32Thank you.
- 1:38:32Good to have you back.
- 1:38:33I thought Angie did a good job.
- 1:38:34I thought Danny did a great job.
- 1:38:36I thought Gilbert did a good job.
- 1:38:37Both Paul's,
- 1:38:38Tent,
- 1:38:39like I had honestly a lot of people did a really good
- 1:38:41job and were civil while not backing down off of their point,
- 1:38:45and I respected that.
- 1:38:46I felt like she listened to me a lot.
- 1:38:48I have these conversations with conservative Christians all the time,
- 1:38:52and they don't always listen as much.
- 1:38:53Generally pretty respectful of the people that were talking with her,
- 1:38:57which I think was.
- 1:38:58Refreshing and I'm thankful for that.
- 1:39:00I thought she was a very dishonest debater.
- 1:39:02I didn't interrupt her at all.
- 1:39:04She interrupted me 8 times.
- 1:39:06I had a counter,
- 1:39:07you know,
- 1:39:07in my pocket the whole time,
- 1:39:08and she spoke the entire time.
- 1:39:10She was speaking to a brick wall.
- 1:39:11I thought that she was on top of her stuff
- 1:39:15and she was actually really good at
- 1:39:17doing kind of a circular conversation and getting away when the points were
- 1:39:22getting really good.
- 1:39:23She obviously knows her positions,
- 1:39:25but she can't really pivot
- 1:39:27in my opinion.
- 1:39:27I think Democrats and Republicans
- 1:39:30could come together more than they do right now if we can agree on some fundamental
- 1:39:36things.
- 1:39:37For example,
- 1:39:37that political violence is always wrong,
- 1:39:40that you should be free to speak your
- 1:39:42mind no matter how controversial your opinion is,
- 1:39:45that debate is very healthy and that we should.
- 1:39:48Get out the things that we think and duke it out
- 1:39:51in the battlefield of ideas and let the best idea win.
- 1:39:55I hope to show you that truth and love can and should coexist,
- 1:40:00that you can see someone's humanity,
- 1:40:02have compassion for them,
- 1:40:04understand where they're coming from without wavering on
- 1:40:07the truth of God's word at all.
- 1:40:09There's actually a lot more,
- 1:40:10I think,
- 1:40:10things that we have in common than that that we have in opposition.
- 1:40:13Do you think we'll ever fully come together?
- 1:40:15I hope so.
- 1:40:16One of my favorite songs was Michael Jackson's We Are the World,
- 1:40:19so
- 1:40:19yeah,
- 1:40:20I kind of lived that way.
- 1:40:22Don't forget to subscribe to Surrounded wherever you get
- 1:40:24your podcasts so that you don't miss an episode.
- 1:40:27And if you want to watch the video version of Surrounded,
- 1:40:29subscribe to Jubilee on YouTube.