Latest / Politics with Paul / How Do We Make Civics Education More Accessible? w/ Roneka Matheny | Politics with Paul #64
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:04political science and civics.
- 0:06I am your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:09It's yet another guest episode on tap, and for those of you who are new, no matter who it is,
- 0:14I always give disclaimer that I do not take a stance for or against a guest's political views
- 0:20or groups they support.
- 0:21But as always, today's topic is one that concerns all of the political spectrum.
- 0:27Specifically, how do we make civics education more accessible for the public?
- 0:32It's faced a lot of challenges in recent decades with even some of the more basic civics
- 0:37concepts not understood by as many citizens as they should be.
- 0:41But we cannot simply put the whole onus on citizens.
- 0:45How we teach civics and make it available is also flawed.
- 0:48So how do we fix these problems and make civics more accessible to the general public?
- 0:53That's what my guest, Ronnika Matheny, is on today's podcast to talk about.
- 0:57Ronnika and I actually know each other from back when we both used to work for Ballotpedia.
- 1:02Beyond that, though, her civics credentials also include working as a visiting professor
- 1:08for American Government and Policy Analysis at the College of Charleston over in South
- 1:12Carolina, a local elections official in South Carolina and Michigan, a US politics instructor
- 1:18for California Intercontinental University, and a civics education consultant.
- 1:22And she's also the founder of the nonprofit Civics for All.
- 1:26And through Civics for All, Raneka is promoting her new book, Civics for All, A Crash Course in
- 1:32US Government and Politics coming out in December.
- 1:36And that's the main crux of the discussion today.
- 1:39So let's talk about her book and all things civics education and how we can make it more
- 1:45accessible, both for students and adults that are past their classroom days.
- 1:50Please welcome Ronnika Matheny to the show.
- 1:52Ronnika, thanks for coming on.
- 1:53Long time no see.
- 1:54How are you?
- 1:55Thank you so much.
- 1:56It's a pleasure to be here.
- 1:58Thank you so much, Paul.
- 2:00Yeah.
- 2:00No.
- 2:01Absolutely.
- 2:01It's it's it's nice to have somebody that I mean, obviously, I I enjoy having all my guests
- 2:06on here, but a lot of them I only, like, have recently met.
- 2:08So it's cool to have somebody that is for a blast from the past, for lack of a better term,
- 2:13even though it really wasn't that long ago that we were at Ballipedia.
- 2:16Sure.
- 2:16But I like to go back in time for the first question for our guests to the formative time
- 2:22that spawned their work.
- 2:23So what motivated you to get into civics education as a career?
- 2:28Well, I love this question.
- 2:30So when I was working on the book, which is something that we're going talk a little bit
- 2:34more about later, I really had to think deeply about this.
- 2:38I wondered about what was my, I like to call it, my political origin story.
- 2:43And for people like us who spend our time writing about politics and teaching about
- 2:49politics and things like that, typically, can sort of look back in our past and pinpoint one
- 2:54moment as our sort of political origin story, which set us on the path.
- 2:58And so for me, I talk about that story at the beginning of the book.
- 3:02I call it my spark.
- 3:03And Bill Clinton, if you believe it or not, actually was the source of that spark for me.
- 3:11So, when he was running for president for the first time in 1992, I was about eight years
- 3:15old.
- 3:16And I tell this story in the book about how I sat down in front of the couch with my brother
- 3:20and my parents to watch the Arsenio Hall show, and, we saw him come on with his sunglasses,
- 3:26playing the saxophone, and telling jokes.
- 3:28And, really, what that moment did for me was completely change my attitude towards politics.
- 3:34You know, at eight, it wasn't something that I was really paying much attention to.
- 3:37I sort of thought of politics as something that old people talked about that I couldn't really
- 3:41understand.
- 3:41And, you know, Bill Clinton actually made me think of politics as something that could be
- 3:46fun and exciting and something that maybe I should pay a little bit more attention to.
- 3:50And so I consider that to be really my political origin story.
- 3:54Now I do wanna say that, of course, I'm sure there were a lot of other kids who watched that
- 3:59broadcast and didn't come away with the same sort of life changing feeling.
- 4:03And so I don't wanna take anything away from my parents and my upbringing because I think that
- 4:06was a large part of it as well.
- 4:08So my parents were small business owners and were very sort of deeply invested in the
- 4:13community.
- 4:14My mom ran for school board.
- 4:16I can remember as a young person going door to door with her in our neighborhood, asking
- 4:20people to vote for her.
- 4:22My dad was the president of our local Sartoma club, and he actually was the announcer at some
- 4:27of the Little League football games.
- 4:29And so he was just kind of somebody who everyone in the community knew.
- 4:33And they both instilled in me this idea that being just a member of a community or society
- 4:40is not enough, that you need to be an active member, that you need to take a leadership role
- 4:47and really try to do something in life that's going to make people's lives better other than
- 4:53just your own.
- 4:54And so I think that that's really what kind of set me on this path.
- 5:01Gotcha.
- 5:02Yeah.
- 5:02I'm I'm trying to think.
- 5:04I was born shortly into Bill Clinton's tenure.
- 5:08I'm 1993.
- 5:09So me old.
- 5:10No.
- 5:12No.
- 5:12I'm not doing that.
- 5:13I'm just but it is kinda funny to think about, like, all these kids now that are just like,
- 5:19boy, kids who are turning 18 were barely alive when George w Bush was president.
- 5:24And it's just like, well, that was like that that that was most of my childhood was during
- 5:29those years.
- 5:30I was I was seven when he when he became president, and I obviously as a seven year old,
- 5:35I didn't know I I sort of understood what was going on since I'm I'm a Floridian.
- 5:40Obviously, Florida is notorious for its role in the two thousand election.
- 5:45So I sort of knew what was going on then, but I was a seven year old.
- 5:49I I didn't I didn't really know.
- 5:51But I do remember back in, I wanna say it was second or no.
- 5:56Actually, I think it was when it was 2004 because I think it was when John Kerry and
- 5:59George w Bush were going toe to toe.
- 6:02And I remember back in so that would have been fourth grade?
- 6:06No.
- 6:07Fifth grade.
- 6:08Because I
- 6:09was towards the end of 2004.
- 6:10Yeah.
- 6:10See, I'm trying to remember all these.
- 6:12I remember they had, like, a, like, a sample ballot kind of thing for teaching kids
- 6:18basically about civics.
- 6:19So I I I kind of remember that a little bit.
- 6:21So it it you're what you were talking about just made me think about that now.
- 6:25But, yeah, as as I think it's always fun to go back into those old times and just see, like,
- 6:30what all those little things that really led you on to that panel or seemingly little things
- 6:36that eventually had a big impact.
- 6:37I mean, I remember having a conversation with a guy once who told me that that his political
- 6:43origin story was he remembered being a kid when the challenger exploded, when Reagan was
- 6:47president.
- 6:48And sitting in his elementary school classroom, and, you know, all of the teachers and the
- 6:52adults were all, you know, just didn't know what to do and were super nervous.
- 6:56They turned on the television, and Reagan gave that speech.
- 6:59And, you know, he said he became a lifelong Republican after that, just because he really
- 7:04appreciated how Reagan made him feel safe and explained things to children at that time that
- 7:10just made him feel like he was someone who was being talked to directly by the president.
- 7:16And so I think it kind of goes back to the feeling that I had.
- 7:19Spoiler alert, Bill Clinton actually won that election in 1992, right, and became president.
- 7:23And so I had this feeling of almost being like a superhero, right, that I, along with my mom,
- 7:29had helped to elect the most powerful person in the country.
- 7:33And they always took me to vote with them.
- 7:35It was something that ever since I was a baby, they took me into the voting booth to vote with
- 7:39them.
- 7:39And so I remember pressing the electronic voting machine button next to his name and just
- 7:44feeling like I really did something.
- 7:46And later on in life, when I was studying political science, I realized that we have a
- 7:50term for this.
- 7:50Right?
- 7:50It's called political efficacy.
- 7:52And it is this feeling that you, as an individual, can actually make a difference in
- 7:56politics by participating.
- 7:57And so a lot of people don't have that.
- 7:59They feel that nothing that they do will make a difference, so why try?
- 8:03Why bother?
- 8:04And so I'm very fortunate to have had that experience at that particular point in my
- 8:09formative years to sort of develop this sense of, yeah, what I do matters and I can make a
- 8:14difference.
- 8:15See, I just did it at eight.
- 8:18And so I think that that really is kind of what set me on the path.
- 8:22And from there, went on to study political science in college at Emory University, you
- 8:27know, got my graduate degrees from the Ohio State University, have to say the, the Ohio
- 8:33State University, and then went on to teach and and write about politics and and all of that
- 8:39kind of stuff as well.
- 8:40So it kind of set me on this lifelong path.
- 8:45Gotcha.
- 8:45Yeah.
- 8:46That's yeah.
- 8:47It it is just amazing just the the the what seems to be a little thing like you were just
- 8:53talking about, with your friend or or whoever you just met, just hearing a a speech from
- 8:58Reagan just suddenly, you know, set the path for him for his his political views later on in
- 9:05life.
- 9:05You never you never know what little things are are going to have that impact.
- 9:09Now let's get more specifically into Civics For All, your nonprofit.
- 9:15Why found this nonprofit, and what are you ultimately trying to do with it, and what
- 9:19successes have you seen through Civics For All?
- 9:23So the idea, the whole overarching idea behind it is to take the information that I was
- 9:29teaching my students in my intro level political science class at the College of
- 9:34Charleston called American Government and disseminate that information to as many people
- 9:38as possible.
- 9:39So that's the idea behind the organization.
- 9:42So in terms of why I decided to do that, or why I decided that it needed to be done, it's
- 9:48another sort of story from my background.
- 9:50So it kind of goes back to 2016 for me, around the twenty sixteen election.
- 9:56My mom had just passed away in 2015, and I'd taken some time away from teaching and my
- 10:00community roles and was just sort of trying to heal.
- 10:03But as just an average citizen, I was sort of experiencing the same fear and anxiety and all
- 10:10of that sort of stuff that was going on around the twenty sixteen presidential campaign.
- 10:14And I saw former students of mine who were arguing with each other online about politics
- 10:18and threatening to disown people and never speak to people again because they disagreed
- 10:22with them.
- 10:23I just was really sad about it.
- 10:26And I wanted to get involved and do something, but I wanted to do something positive.
- 10:31And so I wasn't sure what exactly to do.
- 10:34I thought about a couple of different things.
- 10:35And and what I landed on, was actually volunteering, to work the elections that year
- 10:40at my local polling place in Charleston County.
- 10:43And so I just, you know, just wanna take a a second to say, for people who today may be
- 10:48overwhelmed by politics and overwhelmed by all of the anger and the vitriol, you know, and and
- 10:53just kind of not really knowing what to do, my advice is just to find one thing, one positive
- 11:00thing, that you can do that you have the talent, that you have the skills to do, and
- 11:05then focus on that.
- 11:06Just focus your attention and your efforts on that instead of doom scrolling or instead of
- 11:14arguing with people online.
- 11:16And so that's kind of what I did in 2016.
- 11:20So I decided to volunteer.
- 11:21Shout out to the Charleston County Board of Elections.
- 11:23You guys are awesome.
- 11:25It was such a rewarding experience for me to go through poll worker training and to learn how
- 11:31elections work.
- 11:32So it's kind of weird that I'm saying that, right, as somebody who had already been
- 11:36teaching political science for years at that point and who had studied and gotten graduate
- 11:39work done in political science.
- 11:42But I guess most of us, when we learn about things in political science that have to do
- 11:46with elections, we're learning about the national level.
- 11:49We learn about how the electoral college works and all of that sort of stuff.
- 11:53But what we don't learn about is every single state has different laws.
- 11:58We learned a lot about this at Ballipedia.
- 12:00Every single state has its own rules, right, about how elections are run, what dates
- 12:05elections can be held on.
- 12:06Right?
- 12:07Even down to, in some states, they only do, vote by mail.
- 12:10That's the only option.
- 12:11Right?
- 12:12Whereas in other states, they might not even allow vote by mail.
- 12:15Right?
- 12:16So there are just so so much variation, in terms of voting laws and rules.
- 12:20And so being able to sort of get into the nitty gritty of my state, at that time and the way
- 12:24that our elections were administered really helped me to even develop even more of a love
- 12:30and a trust for politics and government, just to see The fact that you have every county
- 12:36clerk across the country is basically recruiting an army of temporary workers and
- 12:40volunteers who are coming from their local communities to help them administer elections.
- 12:45And these people may be older retirees, or they may be stay at home parents who don't have
- 12:50other jobs, or they may be people who are just out of work at the time.
- 12:53These people are Republicans and Democrats and independents.
- 12:56They're coming from all different walks of life, but yet they're all coming together to
- 13:01help their local community to administer an election.
- 13:03And it's just something there's something beautiful about that.
- 13:06And I think that a lot of people don't really understand how elections are administered, like
- 13:10how their votes are actually counted.
- 13:12And so that poll worker training is super helpful just to see how things work.
- 13:17Because in that lack of knowledge, what you actually have is this sort of opening for all
- 13:22of this misinformation and conspiracy theories and doubts and all of that sort of stuff to
- 13:26creep in.
- 13:27And so, I mean, if I had my way, it would be every five years.
- 13:31Every American citizen would have to volunteer and have to work the polls in their local area
- 13:36just so that they understand how their system works.
- 13:38I'm sorry.
- 13:39That's my little headphone.
- 13:41Just so that they understand how their system works.
- 13:42So basically, the situation or the experience that I had in 2016 with working my local
- 13:51elections in Charleston County, it gave me the opportunity to sort of see how our elections
- 13:56were administered, but it also gave me the opportunity to interact with voters on an
- 13:59individual level.
- 14:00So the job that I was doing, I actually went to work a couple weeks before the election.
- 14:05And the job that I was doing was working at the phone bank.
- 14:09And so local voters would call, and they would ask whatever questions they had about the
- 14:14upcoming election.
- 14:15And so it was my job to answer those questions.
- 14:17And it gave me the opportunity to interact with all these voters from different walks of life
- 14:21who really cared, who wanted to make sure their votes were counted.
- 14:26But what I saw was that a lot of them had a profound lack of just basic civic knowledge.
- 14:33There were so many conspiracy theories coming from voters at that time.
- 14:36This is four years before the controversial twenty twenty election.
- 14:40This is 2016.
- 14:42So I had people calling in that were upset about the color of the I voted sticker because
- 14:46they thought that it favored one party over another.
- 14:49People called in who were upset at the order that the parties appeared on the ballot,
- 14:55realizing that that order is actually set by statute, and it rotates every election cycle.
- 15:01So this year, it may be that party that's on the top of the ballot, but next time, it'll be
- 15:05a different party that's on top of the ballot.
- 15:07And so all of these things were sort of spun into conspiracy theories by voters who were
- 15:11just really anxious and wanted to make sure that their votes were gonna be counted
- 15:14properly.
- 15:15And so that is what kind of created this need in my mind.
- 15:22So I've got these two very different realities.
- 15:25On the one hand, I'm a former professor at that point of political science.
- 15:29I teach this intro level class, so I know that the students who I personally am dealing with
- 15:34and who I'm teaching in my classes, that they're learning this information.
- 15:37Right?
- 15:37They have this basic level of knowledge.
- 15:39But then I'm working elections, and I'm dealing with all of these voters who are calling in
- 15:43that are adults, you know, who are living their lives every day, who don't have this basic
- 15:48level of knowledge.
- 15:49And so I just wanted to find a way to bridge that gap and to share the information that I
- 15:54was teaching my students with as many people, as I possibly could.
- 16:00Yeah.
- 16:00You're you're speaking exactly to one of my values is is one of the overarching things I do
- 16:05is or reasons I do what I do is trying to bridge these civic knowledge gaps.
- 16:10And and, I even when every once in a while when I'm researching for these episodes,
- 16:14particularly the ones that I'm just doing on my own, even if it's a topic I know about, I'll
- 16:18find some new information.
- 16:19It's like, I didn't know that.
- 16:21And it it really rounds out everything well.
- 16:23And it's even you and I who have been educated in this, you know, it's it's a lot different
- 16:27when you actually ingrain yourself even more in the actual system.
- 16:32And I I've thought about doing local election official stuff, especially because people don't
- 16:37realize how much it's all if not entirely local or, like, elections are administered by local
- 16:45governments.
- 16:46It's not state and it's certainly not federal.
- 16:48I mean, there's there you obviously have, like, federal elections commission and all or
- 16:51commission and all that, but they they don't handle all the really nitty gritty stuff.
- 16:56They're not the ones that bear the brunt of the cost of these elections.
- 16:59It's the it's the local governments that do.
- 17:01And and, unfortunately, though, like you said, there's a lot of people that don't have this
- 17:06knowledge and, unfortunately nefarious actors of all political stripes capitalize on that to
- 17:13try to manipulate them, and that's partly why civics education is so important and really
- 17:18tamps down on this polarization.
- 17:20So you've written a book called Civics for All, a crash course in US government and politics,
- 17:26and I'll include links when this episode comes out.
- 17:29And by the way, welcome to the self published author ranks.
- 17:34I'm I'm not the emcee or anything for it, but I'm I'm gonna dub myself the the the greeter
- 17:40for it, so welcome aboard.
- 17:42But what compelled you to write this book specifically, and what do you hope its impact
- 17:47will be?
- 17:50Well, you know, I you know, I so we talked about my sort of overall motivation for knowing
- 17:56that there's this lack of of political information out there and wanting to sort of
- 18:00fill that gap.
- 18:01But then the question becomes, like how, right?
- 18:04How do you fill that gap?
- 18:05So my first, impetus was to create a website.
- 18:10I wrote essays, corresponding to each week of the course that I taught, and then posted them
- 18:15on this website.
- 18:16And I was like, you know what?
- 18:18Now I'm done.
- 18:18Got it out there.
- 18:20America's going to know how everything works, right?
- 18:24And of course, that is not what happened.
- 18:27I really don't know how many people actually ever saw that website at all.
- 18:32And I just didn't account for the fact that it's not just about writing it, but it's also
- 18:36about figuring out how to get people's eyes on it.
- 18:40And so I started to realize that maybe a website wasn't the best way to go about things.
- 18:44If you've got a website that's just got a couple of pages that have these very, very long
- 18:50pages worth of text on them, that's not a very good website.
- 18:54It's not going be very attractive for people.
- 18:56And then on the other hand, there's this sort of problem of it not being comprehensive,
- 19:00because how are people finding your website?
- 19:02Well, more than likely, they're finding it through Googling a particular term that's gonna
- 19:06pop up on just one of those pages, and there's no guarantee that they're even gonna realize
- 19:09that you have all of these other pages that are a part of the website and that it's going in
- 19:13some sort of order.
- 19:14And so what I really started thinking about is the fact that maybe technology isn't the answer
- 19:20to this particular problem.
- 19:22All these technological advances that we've had over the past several decades have given us the
- 19:27ability to basically look up anything we want.
- 19:29There's endless information on the internet, but just because it's there doesn't mean that
- 19:33it's good information.
- 19:34And especially when it comes to politics, you have a really high chance when you're doing
- 19:39your own research that you're gonna run into some bias and political spin, some
- 19:44misinformation, some disinformation, or at the very least, some inaccuracies.
- 19:52And so what is the best way to sort of go about educating people who are well out of the
- 19:58classroom, people who are just adults who are living their daily lives.
- 20:02What I came to the realization of is that we really don't have a better vehicle than just a
- 20:08plain old book.
- 20:10And so I thought the strength of a book is that I get a chance to put all of the information
- 20:16that I want in there, organize it in a structured, ordered way, the same way that I
- 20:22would do in a classroom.
- 20:24It doesn't require anybody to sign up for a class.
- 20:26It's not going to take them weeks or months to complete.
- 20:28There's no assignments that they have to do.
- 20:30There's no tests that they have to take.
- 20:32People can read this book at their own pace.
- 20:36They can learn at their own time, on their own time.
- 20:40Also, a novel sort of size book.
- 20:43Right?
- 20:43It's not something that's gonna be thousands of pages long like a textbook that you would have
- 20:47in a typical class, that an average person would have to try to navigate through.
- 20:51I've also made an effort to include a few personal stories and a little bit of humor in
- 20:55the book to keep it interesting, so it's not so dry like you would necessarily find from a
- 21:00civics textbook that you might be able to get your hands on from when you were in school.
- 21:04So I've made every effort to try to make this a very streamlined vehicle to get the majority of
- 21:11civic education information as much as I can from the class that I taught into the hands of
- 21:16regular people.
- 21:18So, yeah, I wanted to make it easily digestible and easily accessible.
- 21:24And I just came to the realization that a book is probably the best way to do that.
- 21:29Yeah.
- 21:29That's that's the big thing.
- 21:31Right?
- 21:31Is not only figuring out how to package that information, but how to make it enticing to
- 21:36people, and then how do you actually get them to find it in the first place?
- 21:39And as something obviously I've been, you know, trying to work on to how to best bring this
- 21:44information and make people realize, hey, this stuff does matter.
- 21:48You are involved and it does impact you.
- 21:50And now unfortunately, lot of people, they really don't don't see the point whether it's
- 21:55because they're they just feel like the system's just not gonna work for them no matter
- 22:00what.
- 22:00And that's why I try to make a big emphasis on trying to how do we tackle this political
- 22:05apathy?
- 22:06And that's why I made an episode on that in particular.
- 22:09I actually had another guest that came on to talk more about that.
- 22:12But but, yeah, it look just like you said, it is that's one of the big things is trying to
- 22:18how do you make that more accessible for people?
- 22:21And that's that's why we're here today.
- 22:23And speaking of accessibility, politics can be so complex and there are so many different
- 22:31aspects of civics to teach.
- 22:34But what aspects of civics in particular do you especially see a gap between how much people
- 22:40understand it and how much people should understand it?
- 22:43And in which one of these are in your new book?
- 22:47So I think that's a really good question.
- 22:49And to me, it sort of relates to a similar question that I get all the time, which is just
- 22:54basically like, what should people know?
- 22:57Right?
- 22:57So if I'm if I'm constantly talking about how there is this lack of civic knowledge among
- 23:02average Americans, what is lacking exactly?
- 23:06What is it that people know that they that don't know, that they should know?
- 23:09And so I spent a lot of time researching for the book, talking about the history of civic
- 23:15education in America, but also looking at the current state of civic education in America.
- 23:19I looked at a lot of different researchers in terms of what kinds of questions, they were
- 23:26looking at, when they were judging civic knowledge levels, across Americans, and just
- 23:31sort of boiled all of that down to what I like to call three buckets of information, that the
- 23:37every average citizen, should know about the way that their government works.
- 23:41So there are three buckets.
- 23:43The first bucket is, we'll call it the rules of the game.
- 23:45So people need to know how our government is structured and why it's structured that way,
- 23:51right?
- 23:51So the history of it kind of plays into that.
- 23:53Why do we have three branches of government?
- 23:54Why is our Supreme Court separate?
- 23:56Why is the justice system independent?
- 23:58Why you know, all of these different things, right?
- 24:00And so how our system is structured, what the rules are, that's the first bucket.
- 24:04Second bucket is the game's major players, right?
- 24:08So most people need to understand who the president of The United States is, which I
- 24:12think we're doing pretty well on that.
- 24:14No issues there.
- 24:16But I definitely think that people also need to know who the vice president is, who the speaker
- 24:20of the house is, who the senate majority leader is.
- 24:23Right?
- 24:23These are our leaders in Washington.
- 24:24Who are the people that represent you in Washington?
- 24:27Right?
- 24:27Who's the member from your house district that represents you?
- 24:31Who are the two senators from your state that represent you?
- 24:34Who's the governor of your state?
- 24:35Who are your state legislators that represent you in your area?
- 24:38Right?
- 24:39And then also at the local level, so at the national, state, and local level.
- 24:42At the local level, who's your mayor?
- 24:45Do you have a town council or a city council, who are those people?
- 24:48Is there somebody that represents you in your particular area?
- 24:51And so I think that those are the first two buckets that people really need to sort of wrap
- 24:56their minds around.
- 24:57The first one, the rules of the game, we're doing okay there, but, I have some statistics
- 25:01that I'm gonna cite in a minute to show you that, like, not as many people as you would
- 25:05think understand what the three branches of government are and the sort of basic rules.
- 25:09And then when it comes to key players, you know, if any of you guys are old enough to
- 25:13remember, Jay Leno used to do this thing where he would go out on the street and ask people
- 25:17basic questions.
- 25:18Jaywalking.
- 25:20Yes.
- 25:20And so if
- 25:21you
- 25:21Is see jaywalking?
- 25:23Anybody who anybody who's done anything similar to that, where they ask people questions that
- 25:28you think they would know the answer to, like, who's the vice president or who's the speaker
- 25:31of the house, you'd be surprised that there are a lot of people who actually don't know who
- 25:36those people are.
- 25:37Right?
- 25:37And it's just important to know who are the people whose actions are going to affect your
- 25:44life.
- 25:44And that's why you need to know.
- 25:46You don't need to know just for some trivia game.
- 25:48You need to know because these people's actions could affect something that you do in your
- 25:54daily life or a program that you take advantage of or something along those lines.
- 25:58So it's the rules of the game, the players of the game, and then the third bucket is the
- 26:03issues that are being discussed.
- 26:05People should have just a basic understanding of when the president is talking about health
- 26:10care.
- 26:11People need to know what the ACA or Obamacare, they need to know what that is.
- 26:16They need to know what Medicare is.
- 26:18They need to know what Medicaid is, so that when politicians are talking about their
- 26:23differing opinions on what should be done with these programs, you know what their suggestions
- 26:28are going to do in terms of how that's going to impact you.
- 26:31So if you are a young person, let's say, and you aren't on Medicare, so you think you don't
- 26:36have to care about it, well, what about your grandparents?
- 26:39What about older people in your life that you do care about?
- 26:42Those people may be affected.
- 26:44And so it's important for you to understand what the program is and how it works.
- 26:47And the same thing with, we've got a lot of foreign policy issues that are going on right
- 26:51now, and everybody doesn't understand all the nuances of what's going on.
- 26:55But you just need to have a basic understanding of what's happening there so that you can
- 26:59understand when politicians are talking about things.
- 27:02To me, what's so important when it comes to civic knowledge is not just having this
- 27:06knowledge for knowledge's sake.
- 27:08Right?
- 27:08It's not just, you just need to know this stuff because you're a citizen.
- 27:11And so as a citizen, you need to know this stuff.
- 27:14Right?
- 27:14It's it's because it's for a reason.
- 27:15It's all for a purpose.
- 27:17And that purpose is to hold politicians accountable.
- 27:20The whole way that our system works is it's the voters' job to hold politicians accountable for
- 27:25their actions.
- 27:26We put people into office, we vote for them in a representative democracy, to make decisions
- 27:31on our behalf and to take actions on our behalf.
- 27:34And so when they take actions that we don't like or when they make decisions that we don't
- 27:38agree with, then at the next election, it's our job to hold them accountable.
- 27:42Now, if they are doing things that we like, then it's our responsibility to help to keep
- 27:48them in that position because we like what they're doing.
- 27:50And so that's just, you know, how the system works.
- 27:53And if you don't understand how the system works, then how are you supposed to play your
- 27:58very critical role of holding politicians accountable?
- 28:01And I do wanna say also that I mean this not just as some veiled, you know, attack on Donald
- 28:06Trump.
- 28:06I also mean politicians who are closer to your local level.
- 28:10Right?
- 28:10I also mean politicians who may be in your in your political party.
- 28:14You need to make sure that you're not just looking at the label, but you're also looking
- 28:18at what these politicians are actually doing and what they're saying that they're going to
- 28:21do when they're running for election.
- 28:23Then make your decisions based on that in terms of you know, instead of just making it based on
- 28:27whatever the party is.
- 28:30And that's such a great point about the accountability aspect.
- 28:33That's that's one of mine.
- 28:35Obviously, I try to I try as best as possible to practice what I preach and to be self aware.
- 28:41It's just this whole There is a huge problem we have with accountability.
- 28:48Personally believe we do a poor job of it because a lot of people think accountability is
- 28:54just going after the flaws of the quote unquote other side.
- 28:58If you're only taking to task people who don't agree with you, that's not real accountability.
- 29:03Real accountability comes from holding people accountable that think more similarly to you.
- 29:08So if it's Republicans with Donald Trump or if it's with Democrats with their own party,
- 29:14Doesn't matter.
- 29:15Every everybody needs to be held accountable because nobody's infallible.
- 29:19And voters have to be held accountable too.
- 29:21We we we all are accountable Absolutely.
- 29:23To some degree.
- 29:24But, yeah, I I I do appreciate all those points.
- 29:29And really that whole breakdown of those several buckets, I think that's a really great
- 29:33way of putting it to it, especially with the the local level because, you know, it's not
- 29:38just we we don't or people don't know about their local level and to a lesser extent, the
- 29:45the state level.
- 29:46It's also extraordinarily difficult to find this information.
- 29:50You you remember from Yeah.
- 29:52Especially some of the stuff I did from ballot for BallotPD and stuff you did for BallotPD.
- 29:56When we're trying to find stuff about local level politics, it can be extraordinarily
- 30:01difficult to find this information.
- 30:02You're owned in New York City or Chicago or Los Angeles.
- 30:04Okay.
- 30:05Yeah.
- 30:05Those are the biggest cities, so they're gonna then if you're finding something out, I don't
- 30:08know, Gary, Indiana or something like that, not not picking on you, Gary, just as an example.
- 30:14But yeah.
- 30:15So many of these other places or, like, even my my my town is that I live in is is a pretty big
- 30:23town.
- 30:23It's not it's not incorporated, but it's a pretty good sized town.
- 30:26It's it's really blown up in in recent years, but it it still can be extraordinarily
- 30:31difficult to find information on that too.
- 30:34It just the information's just not there.
- 30:36Or I remember one particular project I did for ballot pedia where I was looking for every
- 30:44single county's elections website, if they even had one, and some of them looked like they were
- 30:49made in like early 2000s geo cities.
- 30:51Like what is George W.
- 30:53Bush still the president here?
- 30:54What are we what are we doing here?
- 30:55Have you updated this website recently?
- 30:58But, yeah, you're right.
- 30:59That that is a really interesting way of putting it in those little buckets and actually
- 31:04makes a good segue into this next question.
- 31:07These are sort of buckets too.
- 31:09So when we look at the state of civics education, I think it's useful to break it down
- 31:13into a students and classroom category and then an adults and continuing education category.
- 31:18And a lot of times when we talk about civics education, we're usually just talking about the
- 31:21former, but not enough on the latter.
- 31:24But but we'll we'll break these into two different questions.
- 31:27So they have similar yet also unique obstacles facing them.
- 31:31But in your opinion, for students and our schools, what are two to three of the biggest
- 31:37issues facing civics education for them, and which ones do you bring up in your book?
- 31:45So to me, I think the two biggest issues that we're facing when we talk about civic education
- 31:50at the K through 12 level for students, is, kinda like the both of these things are sort of
- 31:56one.
- 31:57We don't take it seriously enough.
- 31:59And the the sort of evidence that we don't take it seriously enough is the lack of
- 32:04requirements.
- 32:05So you would think as a citizen of a democracy, that in order to graduate from high school, you
- 32:12should have, at some point, have been required to learn about civic education, to have civic
- 32:17classes, civic instruction, in order to receive your high school diploma.
- 32:21There are lots of things that we require students to have, you know, and and these
- 32:25requirements vary by state.
- 32:26But I do talk a little bit about this in the book.
- 32:28I have, some of the statistics in front of me.
- 32:31And last I checked, it looks like 40 states in Washington DC actually require, some sort of
- 32:38civic instruction in order to graduate from high school.
- 32:41So, I mean, I guess if we ignore the other 10 states, that's good, because that's the
- 32:46majority.
- 32:47But the idea is that 10 states in The United States don't even require you to have any civic
- 32:52instruction at all in order to graduate from high school, so that's kind of a problem.
- 32:57But then if we look a little bit deeper into those 40 states, it turns out that only nine of
- 33:01them actually require whatever that required civic course is to be a full year long or more.
- 33:08So what we're talking about is a situation in The United States today where 10 states don't
- 33:13require you to have any civic education at all in order to graduate from high school, and then
- 33:1830 additional states only require you to have one semester, which for those of you who have
- 33:24been out of school for a long time, is only about three and a half months of civic
- 33:28instruction in order to graduate.
- 33:30So that is an indication to students and also an indication to the rest of Americans that we
- 33:35just don't care enough, right, about this particular subject.
- 33:39We don't make this a priority.
- 33:40So I think that is the biggest problem that I see.
- 33:44It really sort of feeds into the next question that you said you were going to ask about adult
- 33:50education, Because what age are most students when they graduate from high school?
- 33:5517 or 18 years old, right?
- 33:57And 18 is the age they become eligible to vote.
- 34:00So what we have is a bunch of voters who we are not preparing adequately to participate in
- 34:06politics and to basically play this huge role in keeping our system going.
- 34:12And so we have evidence that we're not really preparing them.
- 34:16So it's not just about the lack of instruction, but it's about what that lack of instruction
- 34:20means.
- 34:21So because of that, we actually have statistics that are showing us that students are not
- 34:25learning nearly enough.
- 34:27They're not prepared adequately.
- 34:29So there is an organization called NAEP, which stands for the National Assessment of
- 34:34Educational Progress.
- 34:36And they are part of the government.
- 34:38Their job is to basically collect information about how students across the country are doing
- 34:44in various subject areas.
- 34:46And so they administer these assessment tests to a nationally representative sample of
- 34:49students in elementary schools, middle schools, and high schools on different topics.
- 34:55And they do this every year, then they report the results.
- 34:57We actually call them for short, we call them the nation's report card.
- 35:00Right?
- 35:00And so they're sort of our way to tell how we're doing in education generally at
- 35:05elementary, middle, and high school level.
- 35:07So they give all these tests out to all these different schools across the country, and then
- 35:10they take all the student scores, and they break them down into three categories.
- 35:14The categories are proficient, basic, and below basic, which I think below basic actually
- 35:21sounds kind of mean.
- 35:22But those are the three categories that they choose.
- 35:24And so I actually, I talk about this a little bit in the book.
- 35:29I actually brought the numbers with me so I could go over them with you.
- 35:32So the most recent civics assessment that they've done for high school seniors.
- 35:39I mean, because they've done it more recently at the elementary school and middle school
- 35:42level, but we're talking about voters, so I think high school seniors is appropriate.
- 35:46The most recent one was in 2010.
- 35:48And in 2010, what NAEP found was that only twenty four percent of high school seniors were
- 35:55considered proficient in civic education.
- 35:58So that's less than a quarter of graduating high school seniors that achieved the level of
- 36:02proficiency.
- 36:03As a matter of fact, more students in 2010 were actually considered to be below basic than
- 36:08proficient.
- 36:09I think the below basic number was 36.
- 36:12So you might be thinking, Oh, wow, maybe something really bad happened in 2010 and
- 36:16students just weren't paying attention.
- 36:17But no, when you go back and you look at the scores before that, these numbers actually
- 36:22remained remarkably stable.
- 36:23So if you go back to 2006, it's twenty seven percent proficient and 34% below basic.
- 36:29If you go back to 1998, it's 26% proficient, 35% below basic.
- 36:36So basically what we're seeing is not only are we not adequately preparing our high school
- 36:41students to participate in life, in civic life, but we haven't been preparing them for quite
- 36:47some time.
- 36:48This is not something that just started that's new.
- 36:50This is something that's been going on for a while and it's remained pretty stable.
- 36:54So if what we're seeing with these numbers is that high school students are scoring this low,
- 36:59well then what do we think happens when those high school students graduate and they go out
- 37:02into the world and then they become regular voters?
- 37:05They have that same low level of civic knowledge.
- 37:08They're unprepared for the very important role of keeping our system going that we expect them
- 37:15to play.
- 37:16And that's sort of the issue that we're struggling with here when it comes to what are
- 37:21students facing, and then it feeds directly into the situation that we're facing when we're
- 37:26looking at adults.
- 37:30Yeah, I I don't think you can disagree with the idea that we don't take it seriously enough for
- 37:35our students.
- 37:36Obviously, the the statistics you brought up are a clear example of that.
- 37:40But just in general, as you know, we can look at.
- 37:45How just generally how well prepared they are, how much people participate, how much people
- 37:50feel that they know about politics, that internal political efficacy.
- 37:54Now how exactly to address it?
- 37:57Yeah.
- 37:57There's a discussion to be had about, like, well, then you gotta take if you're gonna put
- 38:01it in school, then you might have to take an elective out, for example, even though we have
- 38:04a bunch of electives that that kids can have.
- 38:08So I'm not gonna pretend that I know the exact answer for that, but there definitely needs to
- 38:12be something more concrete put in our high schools and even arguably middle school as as
- 38:19well.
- 38:20So I I definitely agree with that.
- 38:22But now on to the adult side of things, and you did go into it a little bit because inevitably
- 38:27how we teach our students feeds into how well they know civics as adults.
- 38:32But maybe make it more specifically about adult education and what programs are there for them
- 38:39in that continuing education sphere.
- 38:41So what are two or the three of the biggest issues that you see facing civics education on
- 38:46that front for adults?
- 38:48And do you talk about them more in your book?
- 38:51So yes, definitely.
- 38:53I talk about adult civic education the majority of of the time in my book.
- 38:58And I think that, so I start off with the first chapter after the introduction being called
- 39:03What is Civic Education?
- 39:05Where we trace the history of civic education.
- 39:07We talk about these, civics requirements and what we see for high school students and then
- 39:11explain how that feeds into adults.
- 39:13I have a couple more numbers that I wanna share.
- 39:15We have different organizations who do regular civics surveys once a year where they ask basic
- 39:23questions to a representative sample of American adults, just to see sort of where we
- 39:28are.
- 39:30And the numbers are not good.
- 39:32They're basically reflecting the same thing that we see in the NAEP numbers.
- 39:36But the Annenberg Public Policy Center, I want to give them a shout out at the University of
- 39:39Pennsylvania.
- 39:40They do the constitution day survey.
- 39:43They've done it almost every year since 2006.
- 39:45They tend to find numbers that are not very encouraging.
- 39:50So in 2023, for example, they surveyed 1,500 people.
- 39:54They found that only 66% could name all three branches of America's government.
- 40:00So that's not even three out of four.
- 40:0317% of the people that they surveyed in 2023 couldn't name one of the three branches of
- 40:10government, which that's not a lot of people, but I'm concerned for those folks.
- 40:14Only 16% of people surveyed could correctly name all of the rights guaranteed in the First
- 40:19Amendment.
- 40:21About half of them, 49%, failed to name more than one freedom of speech, which we all know
- 40:26that one, right?
- 40:29In 2016, so the same Constitution Day survey, it found that only 26% of Americans could name
- 40:37all three branches of government, which at that time in 2016 was a decline from recent years.
- 40:43So not only are we not getting better, but at that point, we were getting worse.
- 40:46So that's not good at all, right?
- 40:48So we're looking at numbers that are not just about asking people gotcha trivia questions
- 40:54that maybe they weren't thinking about at the time.
- 40:56Maybe they left the interviewer, and then later on, they were like, oh, yeah.
- 40:59I should have said this.
- 41:00Right?
- 41:01But it's just something that they hadn't had to think about in a while.
- 41:03But I think that other numbers that we get from these surveys kind of reflect a little bit more
- 41:08of what's going on underneath the surface.
- 41:10So the other thing that the constitution day surveys look at is they look at trust in
- 41:14government.
- 41:15And in 2023, they found that public trust in government was at only 18%.
- 41:21That's incredibly low, right?
- 41:23And I can only imagine that it's gotten lower, right, since then with as much as everybody is
- 41:29just so very angry and concerned and all the conspiracy theories that are going on.
- 41:36There's also this question about voter participation.
- 41:39We've had very low levels of voter participation historically in The United
- 41:45States.
- 41:45We have seen some evidence over the past ten to fifteen years that that number, for some
- 41:51elections, particularly presidential elections, will go up depending on, just to be blatant,
- 41:57whether Barack Obama or Donald Trump, if one of them are on the ballot, we see the numbers go
- 42:01up a little bit.
- 42:03But besides that, we see them being pretty low.
- 42:06Even in midterm elections, we see political participation numbers being very low.
- 42:11And so all of this is sort of contributing to this sense that not only do people not
- 42:16understand how government works, but now they don't trust it and they're angry about it.
- 42:20Right?
- 42:21And so all of these things kind of join together to create the situation that we have
- 42:25now.
- 42:26And I mean, you have to imagine, like, why would you trust something that you don't
- 42:29understand?
- 42:30Right?
- 42:31Government, to I think most people just seems weird and nefarious, and there's all these
- 42:36weird rules, and it just seems like everybody's doing what they want to do.
- 42:39And if you don't understand the nuances of how things work, it's very easy to believe that
- 42:44it's just the other side manipulating everything and that they're lying about
- 42:47everything, right, because you don't really have any sort of basic understanding of what's
- 42:52real.
- 42:52So I think that's a really important part of this.
- 42:57Let's see.
- 42:58Another thing that I actually wanted to say too is you mentioned earlier about civics classes
- 43:03and what happened to civics classes.
- 43:05I just want to take a few minutes to tell a quick story about that.
- 43:09So a lot of times, when I talk to people about writing this book and talk about civic
- 43:13education, people always say, yeah, back in the '40s and '50s, we had these, what people call
- 43:19Soviet style civics classes, and that was actually a good thing.
- 43:23And what happened to that?
- 43:24Why did we get rid of those?
- 43:25And the story of civic education in America is actually a lot more interesting than you think.
- 43:30I think most people just believe whichever party they are a member of, that it was the
- 43:35other party that messed it up somehow, and actually, it's more complicated than that.
- 43:40It's both parties or members from both sides of the ideological spectrum that sort of join
- 43:46together to get rid of civics.
- 43:50So long story short, I'll see if I can condense this into about a few minutes.
- 43:54Basically, when public school started in The United States, it was around the 1840s.
- 44:00Before then, education was only reserved for people who were very wealthy and private
- 44:08tutors.
- 44:08Those people would hire private tutors, and that's how their kids would be educated, or
- 44:11they would send their kids to Europe or something like that in order to get educated.
- 44:15And so what we find in the 1840s is there is this sort of national impetus to try to start a
- 44:21public school system in America.
- 44:23There are some leaders in this particular movement, like Horace Mann from Massachusetts,
- 44:28who are the people who are pushing for this the most.
- 44:30But the idea is completely based on civic education.
- 44:35If you have a system that you've set up that's going to be a democracy where you're expecting
- 44:39for voters to actually play a role in voting and voicing their opinion and how things work,
- 44:44then it only makes sense that you need to have some sort of basic level of education for all
- 44:48of those people so that they're making informed decisions.
- 44:50And so the decision was made to go ahead and create a public education system.
- 44:56Well, then fast forward about fifteen or twenty years, and you get to the end of the civil war,
- 45:00and all of a sudden you have this new group of citizens, right?
- 45:04People who are formerly enslaved, right?
- 45:07And so all of a sudden you have all of these new citizens and then the question becomes,
- 45:11well, should these new citizens also get the benefit of learning about the civic education
- 45:16to sort of understand what their role is to prepare them to participate?
- 45:19And as you might imagine, with the history of Jim Crow segregation in the South, there were a
- 45:24lot of people who did not want that to happen.
- 45:26And so there were a lot of, schools and places of education where, in particular, education
- 45:32about the government, education about civics was suppressed.
- 45:35And people were not given up to date textbooks and things like that to try to stop them from
- 45:42learning a lot about their status in society.
- 45:45So for some people, okay, that might be the story that you expect, right?
- 45:48But that's not where it ends.
- 45:49That's only the beginning.
- 45:51So if you fast forward another fifty to seventy five years, you get to the Cold War.
- 45:56And all of a sudden, those same people who are trying to stop certain communities from
- 46:00learning about civics and learning about the history of America and government, well, they
- 46:04now want them to learn about it as quickly as possible.
- 46:06Right?
- 46:07They want them to learn as much as they can about America to instill patriotism and to make
- 46:11sure that they're not going to be susceptible to communist influences.
- 46:14And so all of a sudden, the same people who are trying to stop these communities from learning
- 46:18about civics are now trying to put more civic instruction into classrooms in low income areas
- 46:25and inner city areas and in areas that are predominantly populated by people of color.
- 46:30And so what we find is that all of a sudden, members on the left who are leaders of these
- 46:36groups of communities of color, of low income people, of workers, things like that, well,
- 46:41become very suspicious of the fact that the government is trying to teach their students
- 46:46about history and about politics.
- 46:48They start thinking about this in terms of being some sort of brainwashing scheme, some
- 46:52sort of government plot to whitewash American history and to teach their kids this sort of
- 46:59version that's been dumbed down or distilled or that makes the founding fathers seem infallible
- 47:05or something along those lines.
- 47:07And so all of a sudden, get these leaders on the left who are railing against civic
- 47:12education, calling it something that's an attack on their children, saying that their
- 47:16children are being brainwashed, which sounds a lot like what we've seen in America over the
- 47:21last few years coming from conservatives who are worried about education, saying that their
- 47:25children are being brainwashed.
- 47:26So this is not the first time that we've seen that happen in American history.
- 47:30And so long story short, basically, those liberal leaders join together with leaders on
- 47:35the right who, at this point, are concerned about America falling behind in the space race
- 47:40and want to start redirecting education money towards science and math and other STEM topics.
- 47:46All of a sudden, we get these strange bedfellows where we have liberal leaders who
- 47:50are worried about whitewashing, and we have conservative leaders who are worried about
- 47:55science and technology.
- 47:57And they come together to basically reallocate education funding across the country towards
- 48:03different avenues, right?
- 48:05Whether it be STEM or whether it be studies in liberal arts that are studies of certain
- 48:11regions and ethnicities and cultures and things like that.
- 48:13And lo and behold, civic education across the country is defunded.
- 48:16And so my point with saying all of that, sorry for taking up so much time there, but I think
- 48:21it's important for people to understand that history because it's not one group or another,
- 48:26it's not one ideology or another that has gotten us to the situation where we are now.
- 48:31This is Republicans, Democrats, Liberals, Conservatives, Independents, right?
- 48:37All of these people sort of joining together at some point and playing a role basically killing
- 48:43civic education in America or at least strangling it, right?
- 48:46And so now, because all of these people have worked together to destroy it, all of these
- 48:51people are going to have to work together to fix it, to rebuild it, right?
- 48:55There's no scenario in which one group in American society is going to be able to fix
- 49:01this problem.
- 49:02Everybody is going to have to come together and work together to fix this problem.
- 49:07That's a really fascinating history.
- 49:09That's a lot a lot of that stuff I I did not know about, but I mean, it it, you know, it
- 49:17goes to show you just how long we've had this issue with civic education, and it's easy for
- 49:24one side or the other to say, well, see, yeah, you know, they ruin it because conveniently,
- 49:29they're on the other side of the aisle, kinda like you said.
- 49:31There's something else I was gonna say in regards to that story, but I can't oh, oh, I
- 49:38was gonna say, it's some interesting context added to not necessarily it's not really an
- 49:44alternative view, but it's a it's another viewpoint, some extra context to I had a guest
- 49:50on I I wanna say it's like episode 52 or something on this podcast, Alex Vassar.
- 49:56He's over at the California State Library, and he made an interesting observation about how
- 50:03the the focus had changed from teaching civics and how it impacted people, how they the
- 50:13relation people had to their government to just teaching straight up government being very rote
- 50:18fact based, not really focusing on what people's role in a proper society is.
- 50:25And so that that just was just kind of an interesting thing I thought about in context of
- 50:30what you were talking about.
- 50:31I don't know if you have anything to add to that or if that's something you had heard about
- 50:36before this this transition from teaching civics to teaching just straight up government,
- 50:42if that also kind of goes in line with what you were just talking about or if you have anything
- 50:47in particular you wanna add to that.
- 50:50Yeah.
- 50:50Absolutely.
- 50:51So I remember that episode.
- 50:53Long time listener, first time caller.
- 50:56I actually thought actually thought, that that was incredibly profound.
- 51:02I loved, that, distinction that he made because, yeah, 100%, when you hear, you know, I
- 51:09talk about civic education because that's what in general, right, we are trying to do, in
- 51:15terms of prepare people to be better citizens, by teaching them about politics and government.
- 51:20But the classes that we see that are being taught across the country today are all called
- 51:25like American government or US politics or something along those lines.
- 51:29None of them are called civics 101 or anything comparable to that.
- 51:33Right?
- 51:33We don't use that terminology, civic education, anymore.
- 51:36And I think that, there is a very, specific reason for that.
- 51:42I think it's important what he's saying in terms of this general transition that we've
- 51:45made, from teaching people about the role that they play to teaching them just how the
- 51:49government works and just focusing on that first bucket when we were talking about
- 51:53buckets.
- 51:53So I think that's like a figurative transition that we've made that we can see sort of how the
- 51:58classes are structured and what the effect has been.
- 52:01But then I also think that it falls in line with the history that I laid out because what
- 52:06we see is that it was civic education up until it got killed, During that time period after
- 52:13Sputnik, when we've got liberals and conservatives that are against it.
- 52:17And basically what they did was rebranded it.
- 52:19Right?
- 52:19So at that point, now it's not civic education anymore.
- 52:23Now it's just American government or US politics, and we're just teaching you how the
- 52:27system works, like bare minimum, right?
- 52:29What we can do in one semester, which is all that's required in most states in America.
- 52:33And I think that part of that is because there was this effort to sort of distance the
- 52:38government from whitewashing, manipulation, all of the sort of negative epithets that were
- 52:44being thrown at those classes.
- 52:45And so trying to rebrand them as, Hey, just the facts, ma'am.
- 52:48We're just going to be teaching people about government and how government works was a way
- 52:54to bring those classes back or to continue them without pissing people off, for lack of a
- 53:00better terminology.
- 53:04But, yeah, I thought that that sounds great.
- 53:07Yeah.
- 53:08Yeah.
- 53:08That that yeah.
- 53:09That's something that still sticks with me.
- 53:12I don't I've actually mentioned it in, like, a couple of episodes now.
- 53:14And then, you know, what you said kind of fell in line with what Alex was talking about in
- 53:20that episode.
- 53:20So I guess that kind of already I wanna say already answers this question, but it it is, I
- 53:27guess, part of the answers to this next question.
- 53:29So why do you think some efforts to fix civics education haven't been successful as they could
- 53:36have been.
- 53:36And we'll we'll say more specifically for more recent initiatives since you you talked about
- 53:43more historical ones, so more recent initiatives, or put a different way.
- 53:47Why do you what do you think some civics initiatives get wrong when trying to improve
- 53:53the civic knowledge of the citizenry?
- 53:54And I'm talking about ones that are legitimately trying to improve civic knowledge.
- 53:58And what do you recommend instead?
- 54:02So I guess so I have a little bit of an issue with the premise, right?
- 54:07Because I I don't think that there's a lot of initiatives that are out there that are trying
- 54:10to improve the civic knowledge of citizens.
- 54:12So it's not that there's all of these initiatives out there and that then they'll
- 54:15tell you what they're doing wrong.
- 54:17So I think that there are a few, and a lot of the ones that are organized, sustained programs
- 54:25that are attempting to increase civic knowledge are focused on students.
- 54:28They're looking at civic education as something that happens in the classroom, And they're
- 54:32focused on what they can do to get those numbers up from Nate that we talked about, to
- 54:37make sure that students that are in school, elementary school, middle school, high school,
- 54:41are going to come out of there with a better understanding of civic knowledge.
- 54:45And I think that the biggest mistake that those school focused initiatives get is that they're
- 54:52not looking at civic education as something that requires lifelong learning.
- 54:56And I think that's the biggest issue that I try to drive home in this book.
- 55:00The book that I created is not just about teaching people how government works in terms
- 55:05of there's three branches, and this is what the legislative branch does, and this is what the
- 55:08other branch does.
- 55:09That's in there, but that's not the point.
- 55:13Right?
- 55:13The point of the book is to say civic education is a lifelong learning tool.
- 55:20Right?
- 55:20I consider it to be a tool.
- 55:22As we talked about before, it's, in my opinion, every citizen's most important tool.
- 55:27It's the most important tool that you have to help you cut through misinformation and
- 55:31disinformation, you know, lies and political spin.
- 55:35It's the most important tool that you have as a citizen to help you to actually, hold
- 55:39politicians accountable and play the role that you're meant to play in our society to keep our
- 55:44democracy going.
- 55:45So I think that civic education is a tool, and it's not something that should be relegated to
- 55:52the classroom.
- 55:53I think the biggest problem in general, not just with these initiatives, but just in the
- 55:57way that we talk about civic education in America, is that it's all focused on students.
- 56:01It's all focused on K-twelve classroom learning.
- 56:04And that is very important.
- 56:07I mean, we see from NAEP's statistics that that is very important.
- 56:11But that shouldn't be the only place that people are learning about civic education.
- 56:16So I guess this kind of segues for me into what I see as the call to action in the book.
- 56:23So what I want is I want to create nothing short of a community education movement.
- 56:31My mantra is think outside of the classroom.
- 56:34Civic education is not something that is only for K through 12 students, or even college
- 56:39students for that matter.
- 56:40Civic education is not just for students.
- 56:43It's something that's important for every American, you know, across the country,
- 56:48everybody, even if you don't vote, right?
- 56:50Civic education is what's going to be important for you in order to be able to make an informed
- 56:55decision as to whether you want to vote or not, let alone who you want to vote for if you
- 57:00decide to participate, Right?
- 57:02So I think that civic education is so important.
- 57:06It's the sort of bedrock of our society, but we treat it in terms of, it's just a class that
- 57:13students need to study for, and they need to get better grades.
- 57:16They need to score higher on these exams, and then we just kinda leave it at that.
- 57:21I use an analogy in the book where I compare it to driving.
- 57:26And I say, around the same time in your life, you're faced with these two different
- 57:35decisions.
- 57:35One of them is to start driving a car.
- 57:38And then a couple years later, the other one is graduating from high school, figuring out what
- 57:41you want to do in your life, and deciding whether or not you wanna register to vote.
- 57:45Right?
- 57:45So as somebody who is 15 or 16, 17, whatever the the laws are in your state, you decide to
- 57:52go get your driver's license.
- 57:53Well, you have to take a test.
- 57:54Right?
- 57:55You have to take a written test, and you have to take a road test.
- 57:57And then once you take that road test, unless you really screw up, unless you do something
- 58:02bad, you don't have to take any more tests.
- 58:05Never have to take that test again.
- 58:07Just, you you can drive for the rest of your life until we say you can no longer drive,
- 58:11right?
- 58:12And that kind of makes sense, I guess, because the rules of the road aren't gonna change that
- 58:17much.
- 58:18The signs on the road aren't gonna change.
- 58:21The way that you drive, what lane you're supposed to be in, that's not gonna change.
- 58:24But when it comes to voting, that should not be treated the same way.
- 58:29It shouldn't be just you take a test or you take a class when you're 17 or 18 years old,
- 58:34and then that's it.
- 58:34You never have to learn anything else about civics or the way that our government works for
- 58:38the rest of your life.
- 58:40Excuse me, it should never be that way.
- 58:42This requires lifelong learning.
- 58:44This is something that we should be constantly visiting, constantly learning about, because it
- 58:49is such an important part of the way that our society works, the way that our country works.
- 58:54And so I think that that's really the biggest problem, right?
- 58:58We need to think outside of the classroom.
- 59:00We need to stop thinking about civic education as something that just happens in schools.
- 59:04We need to stop thinking about it in terms of, if students don't know something, it's because
- 59:08the schools and the teachers got it wrong and they need to fix it.
- 59:12Instead of it being a they problem, we need to think about it in terms of a we problem, an Us
- 59:17problem.
- 59:18So it is my job to take responsibility for my civic education.
- 59:22If I wanna make sure that I am playing my role in society and that I am holding politicians
- 59:28accountable, then it's my job to make sure that I know what I need to know.
- 59:32And so that's what I wanna start, is this community I call it a community education
- 59:36movement, and I really compare it to Black History Month.
- 59:39So when I was teaching at the College of Charleston, I didn't just teach political
- 59:43science, I also taught African American studies.
- 59:45And that gave me the opportunity to really learn about one of my heroes, who is Carter G.
- 59:51Woodson, who's the guy that invented or created Black History Month.
- 59:55So most people don't know the story behind it.
- 59:57Quick story, because I'm all about the stories.
- 1:00:02Quick story is, in the nineteen teens, Carter G.
- 1:00:06Woodson, who had been one of the first African Americans to receive a PhD in education in The
- 1:00:12United States, he was an educator, and he had worked at a couple of different schools and
- 1:00:17realized that there was no information being taught in these schools about black people's
- 1:00:22accomplishments or achievements in history, or about African civilizations at all.
- 1:00:26And so he went to a couple of different educators and to administrators, talked to them
- 1:00:30about it, and basically the response that he got back was, What are you talking about?
- 1:00:34There's nothing to see here, Right?
- 1:00:35There are no accomplishments.
- 1:00:37If there were, we'd be teaching about them.
- 1:00:39And so because we're not teaching about them, that just means they don't exist.
- 1:00:42Right?
- 1:00:43He knew that that wasn't the case.
- 1:00:46So he decided to, instead of moaning and complaining about it, he decided to take
- 1:00:51matters into his own hands.
- 1:00:52He didn't have any way to affect the curriculum at different schools, and so he decided to do
- 1:01:00what he could do on his own.
- 1:01:01So he started an organization, and then out of that organization, he started a journal.
- 1:01:07And this was, I believe it's still being published today.
- 1:01:11And the the whole point behind it was basically an early version of crowdsourcing.
- 1:01:17So he would invite different researchers and scholars from all across the country and across
- 1:01:22the world, really, who were writing about these things, black people's accomplishments
- 1:01:27throughout history and also African civilizations, and he would get all of the
- 1:01:31research and collect it in these journals.
- 1:01:33And so he was basically creating this body of knowledge about black history through these
- 1:01:37journals.
- 1:01:38And so, well, the journal doesn't matter if nobody reads it, right?
- 1:01:41And so he hired an army of graduate students to travel all around the country selling these
- 1:01:47journals door to door, like door to door salesman.
- 1:01:49And they went to people's homes, they went to small schools and community groups and
- 1:01:53churches, and tried to get people to get subscriptions to these journals.
- 1:01:57And so once he got to a certain level of success with this, and he wanted to draw even
- 1:02:04more attention to it, he created what he called Negro History Week as a celebration to just
- 1:02:09sort of highlight the efforts, right, and to focus people's attention on this for one week
- 1:02:13out of the year.
- 1:02:14And that way it would kind of make people want to subscribe to these journals and let more
- 1:02:19people know about what was going on.
- 1:02:20And so long story short, Negro History Week was the celebration that grew into Black History
- 1:02:26Month.
- 1:02:27It started in 1922.
- 1:02:28Oh.
- 1:02:29And by 1970, it was being celebrated at colleges all across the country.
- 1:02:33And the students at Kent State University decided that they actually wanted to extend
- 1:02:38this celebration to be an entire month long instead of just one week.
- 1:02:42And so they renamed it Black History Month, extended it to a whole month, and that's the
- 1:02:46celebration that we all kind of follow along with today.
- 1:02:50Even McDonald's famously has put a lot of investment over the years into celebrating
- 1:02:55Black History Month.
- 1:02:56We have the Black History three sixty five and different things that come on television.
- 1:03:01And all of this, that started just because this one guy saw where there was this lack of what
- 1:03:05was being taught in schools, realized that he couldn't do anything about it through the
- 1:03:09school curriculum itself, but that if he could raise awareness in just the average community
- 1:03:14among Americans, that he could encourage people to do their own research and sort of learn
- 1:03:18about this in their own way.
- 1:03:20And that's really the sort of model, the big picture for me of what I would love to do, is I
- 1:03:26would love to just encourage people across America to stop thinking about civic education
- 1:03:30in terms of the classroom and teachers and students, right?
- 1:03:34Start thinking about it in terms of a responsibility as an American citizen.
- 1:03:39Start thinking about it in terms of a tool that every citizen should have that they can use to
- 1:03:45sort of help them get through this weird political environment that we find ourselves
- 1:03:50in.
- 1:03:51And so that's kind of what I want to do.
- 1:03:56That's an interesting parallel that you you brought up with the Black History Month, but I
- 1:04:00I I agree.
- 1:04:01You know, just this there is a lot of times too much of a short term focus on how do we teach
- 1:04:09kids now or teach adults now about this, but not a don't really have that sustainability
- 1:04:16focus on the how do we make this long lasting where it's actually going to stick with them?
- 1:04:22I think that's a very good point to bring up.
- 1:04:26Mean, really so many things that we teach people just especially when you you prep teach
- 1:04:32people practice and make them practice for a test or an exam.
- 1:04:36And then after that, the information's gone.
- 1:04:39Poof.
- 1:04:40And, you know, did they really ultimately learn anything kind of thing?
- 1:04:43And and is I think you see that with civics especially.
- 1:04:46So definitely can appreciate that motive, that goal
- 1:04:50And and woe to anyone who has to just depend has to just depend.
- 1:04:56I'm sorry.
- 1:04:57I was just gonna say woe to anyone who has to depend on only the knowledge that they learned
- 1:05:03when they were 17 years old for any particular topic.
- 1:05:06If you had to deal with something every single day in your life for the rest of your life, and
- 1:05:11the only thing that you ever learned about it was when you were 17 years old, good luck.
- 1:05:17Right?
- 1:05:18It's not going to go so well.
- 1:05:21Right.
- 1:05:21Well, that's that.
- 1:05:22I mean, whenever I post something on LinkedIn or on Medium or talk about the book that I
- 1:05:28wrote or anything like that, I try to give more critical thinking tips of like, give them
- 1:05:34questions to think about, not just straight up tell them information or if we bring it back to
- 1:05:38that civics versus government civics really make you think about your place in a civic
- 1:05:45society, whereas governments just wrote information, which I personally find
- 1:05:49fascinating, but not everybody is going to.
- 1:05:51So you have to really make it more applicable to them like you just said.
- 1:05:55So we're running a little low on time, but we'll we should be able to get through these
- 1:05:59last few questions.
- 1:06:00No.
- 1:06:00No.
- 1:06:01You're good.
- 1:06:01Hey.
- 1:06:01Hey.
- 1:06:02Storytime is good.
- 1:06:03It it it it helps flash out or flesh out, excuse me, all these points that we're talking
- 1:06:09about, especially because stories often particularly stick with people more.
- 1:06:12So let's be a little bit more positive here now.
- 1:06:15So what are some of the improvements you've seen in civics education in recent years?
- 1:06:19I know you said that there's not really actually that many civics initiatives, but what
- 1:06:23are some of the positives that you've seen?
- 1:06:26Well, I think this is a really important question too because I definitely don't wanna
- 1:06:29seem like I'm only looking at the negatives.
- 1:06:31Right?
- 1:06:32One of the things that I find really interesting about this recent time that we find
- 1:06:38ourselves in when it comes to politics is that lots and lots and lots of people are paying
- 1:06:43more attention.
- 1:06:45It used to be, as I talked about at the beginning, people like us are people who are
- 1:06:50always sort of interested in politics, right, ever since we were younger.
- 1:06:53But when I was younger, it was kinda hard to get people to even know what I was talking
- 1:06:57about.
- 1:06:57Right?
- 1:06:57People weren't paying attention to what the president had to say on any particular issue.
- 1:07:02Nobody knew what was going on unless they were somebody who was personally, you know, kind of
- 1:07:07taking their their time out of their day, to watch political news and and to figure out and
- 1:07:12to follow along with what was happening in politics.
- 1:07:14And today, it's almost inescapable.
- 1:07:16Right?
- 1:07:17It is something that, you know, everybody is aware and for lots of different reasons, for
- 1:07:22technology reasons, for personality reasons, for, you know, the personalities that we have
- 1:07:27at the head of the government at this particular point in time.
- 1:07:29But for lots of other reasons, all of a sudden, political interest used to be something that we
- 1:07:36saw numbers very low in.
- 1:07:38And today, I mean, don't have the statistics in front of me for that, but I don't think that
- 1:07:42we're seeing numbers that are nearly as low as we saw over a decade ago, because people are a
- 1:07:48lot more interested in politics.
- 1:07:50They're following it, they see what's happening in their daily lives, they're following it on
- 1:07:53social media, but they just don't have the basic sort of background knowledge to really
- 1:07:58interpret everything that they're seeing.
- 1:08:00And so when people don't know, they don't have the background knowledge, the only thing that
- 1:08:06they can do is sort of think about things in terms of my team versus your team.
- 1:08:09Right?
- 1:08:09And so if I don't know what the actual truth is and I hear somebody saying something and
- 1:08:14they're a politician from the other side, well, I'm just going to assume that they're lying or
- 1:08:18that they're distorting something or, you know, they're trying to make my guys look bad because
- 1:08:23that's how politics works.
- 1:08:24And so I think that that's really the important role that civic education plays, is that it
- 1:08:29helps you to sort of parse out what's going on, cut through all of the bias and the lies and
- 1:08:35all that kind of stuff that people are spitting at you to really see what's going on underneath
- 1:08:41the hood.
- 1:08:42And so I think that's important.
- 1:08:44I do have a couple of numbers that I wanted to share though, because we were talking earlier
- 1:08:48about that Constitution Day survey.
- 1:08:50And one of the really kind of surprising and encouraging pieces of information that has come
- 1:08:55out recently is that they It was September 17, not too long ago, and they did that survey
- 1:09:01again.
- 1:09:01And the Annenberg Public Policy Center released a very encouraging report saying that they did
- 1:09:06actually see some increases in civic knowledge among some of the key indicators that they ask
- 1:09:10about in that particular survey.
- 1:09:12And so what we saw was five point increases, which is a pretty significant difference
- 1:09:19between 2024 and 2025.
- 1:09:21So more than two thirds of US adults were able to name all three branches of government in
- 1:09:272025.
- 1:09:28So that's 70% in 2025.
- 1:09:30It was only 65% in 2024.
- 1:09:33So that's just in one year.
- 1:09:34And I mean, okay, so that's basic.
- 1:09:36Obviously, most of the people who would be deciding to watch this podcast know what the
- 1:09:40three branches of government are, and so that seems like very basic information.
- 1:09:43But the fact that we have so many Americans who don't, who aren't able to readily recall what
- 1:09:48those three branches of government are, is important and kind of a worry.
- 1:09:51But the fact that we see so much shift in one particular year on this question, I think, is
- 1:09:59very encouraging.
- 1:10:00I mean, it gives us something to sort of look forward to.
- 1:10:02Another one that we saw a big 5% jump in is when asked which specific rights are guaranteed
- 1:10:07by the First Amendment, the survey finds that nearly four in five people, which is 79%, can
- 1:10:13name freedom of speech, which is a statistically significant increase over the 74%
- 1:10:19that we're able to name it in 2024.
- 1:10:22So, I mean, like you said, they don't seem like they're really big differences, but they are.
- 1:10:27They're pretty, pretty large, significant increases that we see.
- 1:10:30And all of that is just about people paying more attention in politics and people doing a
- 1:10:34little bit more research, trying to figure out what's going on.
- 1:10:36And that's always good, right?
- 1:10:38We want people to be curious.
- 1:10:39We want people to look up information.
- 1:10:41In some cases, I think people are even doing it just so that they can have the upper hand when
- 1:10:45they argue with people online.
- 1:10:47They want to get their facts straight.
- 1:10:48But hey, whatever the motivation is, I'm glad that people are looking up information.
- 1:10:54Yeah.
- 1:10:55That's also true too.
- 1:10:57Yeah.
- 1:10:57I I was thinking about that.
- 1:10:58You when you brought up the Annenberg survey, was thinking about it before and I forgot, but
- 1:11:02I'm glad I did did forget it.
- 1:11:04So you could you could bring it up now and really, it's a really good point to bring it up
- 1:11:08here towards the end.
- 1:11:10And obviously, yeah, it'd be nice if more people knew not only what the three branches of
- 1:11:15government were, but what the significance of having those three branches of government is.
- 1:11:19You know, that's that's an that's another thing too.
- 1:11:22But, you know, like you said, there are there are things to look forward to things to find a
- 1:11:28glimmer of hope in.
- 1:11:29Definitely can appreciate you pointing those out as well.
- 1:11:34So one more question before we get to the random question of the day.
- 1:11:39What are some other civic minded groups that you would recommend people go check out and
- 1:11:44help out in some way?
- 1:11:45And then for your Civics For All organization, what are some ways that people can help out
- 1:11:50that?
- 1:11:52So, obviously, I love this question.
- 1:11:54Thank you so much for giving me the opportunity to talk about my website and also some of the
- 1:11:59other content creators in this area.
- 1:12:01So, I'll talk about mine first.
- 1:12:04My website is called civicsforall.org, and that's the number four.
- 1:12:07So civicsforall,numberfour,.org.
- 1:12:09And on my website, I have links to where you can read my blog, which is the same as the
- 1:12:17newsletter that I publish on Substack.
- 1:12:19I also simultaneously publish all of those articles on my own blog on my website.
- 1:12:24So that's some really good information about my background and some of the particular areas
- 1:12:29that we've talked about in this interview.
- 1:12:31I go into sort of longer articles about those things.
- 1:12:35And then also information about the book itself.
- 1:12:37I have a page on the website where you can find out all the information that you need.
- 1:12:41If you want to support me, please do pre order the book.
- 1:12:44It's now available for preorder in paperback, audiobook, and ebook formats.
- 1:12:50The ebook format is starting at only $12.95.
- 1:12:52So you can go onto my website and access the preorder links.
- 1:12:56Preorder in any format that you like.
- 1:12:58The scheduled publication date for the book is in December, the December.
- 1:13:03So as soon as those books are available, we will be either mailing or emailing them out.
- 1:13:07So I really, really appreciate anybody that is willing to go ahead and preorder the book now.
- 1:13:12That helps to show my publishers that people are interested and that there is an appetite
- 1:13:17for this type of publication.
- 1:13:19So that's the first thing.
- 1:13:21Also, if you are so inclined, there's an opportunity to donate on the website as well.
- 1:13:26I wanna talk also about I love the idea that I get a chance to highlight other content
- 1:13:31creators.
- 1:13:32So besides you, Paul, which I encourage everybody to listen to Politics with Paul,
- 1:13:35great website or I'm sorry, great podcast, where you you really give a lot of people like
- 1:13:42me who maybe aren't the, you know, the biggest names, people who can't necessarily get on Fox
- 1:13:47News or MSNBC or CNN to talk about our work.
- 1:13:50You give us a platform and an opportunity to share what we're doing, so I really appreciate
- 1:13:54that.
- 1:13:57I talked about earlier how there's not a lot of, sort of organized initiatives that are
- 1:14:02reaching out, for civics for adults specifically.
- 1:14:06But there is one website that I wanted to highlight.
- 1:14:08It is called civicsforlife.org.
- 1:14:11And in this case, the four is actually spelled out, not the number four, like it is in my
- 1:14:15website.
- 1:14:15But civicsforlife.org is actually a website, sponsored by the Sandra Day O'Connor
- 1:14:20Foundation, Sandra Day O'Connor being our first female Supreme Court Justice.
- 1:14:25She has organizations which are devoted to civic education for students at the school
- 1:14:32level.
- 1:14:32She has one called iCivics.
- 1:14:34But this one, Civics for Life, is specifically geared towards adults.
- 1:14:37You can go on this website, you can take quizzes, You can read articles.
- 1:14:42You can do different activities that are all designed to sort of increase your civics
- 1:14:47knowledge, not as a middle schooler, but as somebody who's an adult and leads a busy life.
- 1:14:52So I think that that is wonderful.
- 1:14:55Their website is a model for some of the things that I would love to be able to do, on my
- 1:14:59website moving forward into the future.
- 1:15:02The other thing that I would encourage people to do is, read newsletters and listen to
- 1:15:06podcasts, that have to do other podcasts, that have to do with, history, the history of
- 1:15:12America, and also, about politics and government.
- 1:15:16So I would suggest, my two favorite newsletters on Substack, if you guys are, active on
- 1:15:21Substack, Civics for Adults by Donna Blankenship, who is just a wonderful person,
- 1:15:26one of my favorite writers on Substack.
- 1:15:28She does a good job of connecting current events to civic education and the sort of the
- 1:15:34ideas.
- 1:15:34If my book is gonna be Politics 101, her, newsletter is more about sort of connecting
- 1:15:41that to what's going on in current events.
- 1:15:44And then also, The Information Bank by Sharon, Lawrence.
- 1:15:48That is a wonderful newsletter that is all about giving people information about local
- 1:15:53elections and different things, ways that they can participate in politics in their local
- 1:15:57area.
- 1:15:58Also, I wanted to suggest two history focused podcasts, American History Tellers, which is
- 1:16:03one of my favorite podcasts right now.
- 1:16:05They do a great job of telling lesser known stories from history and really giving you all
- 1:16:08the details there.
- 1:16:10And then also, History That Doesn't Suck, same thing, also does a great job of laying out
- 1:16:17historical events from American history and really getting into the nitty gritty details of
- 1:16:21everything that happened and and trying to tell the stories in a way to where it's not boring
- 1:16:26for people.
- 1:16:26So I I love all of those creators.
- 1:16:30Kudos to you guys.
- 1:16:31Hopefully, you get some more listeners and followers off of this.
- 1:16:36Hey.
- 1:16:36Well, I I really appreciate that, and I appreciate you, of course, coming on and all
- 1:16:40the other guests I've had coming on here.
- 1:16:43Always good to to talk about these things with people who care, you know, just as much about
- 1:16:50all this civic stuff.
- 1:16:51And, of course, I'll I'll put the links for the preorders and stuff.
- 1:16:56Well, at at the end, I'll give you the chance to talk more about the links you wanna share.
- 1:17:01But before we get to that, let's go ahead and get to the final question, the random fun
- 1:17:08nonpolitical question of the day.
- 1:17:10So for anybody who is new at the end of guest episodes, I like to pose a random question to
- 1:17:16our guests.
- 1:17:18So Renika, today's question is, and I actually have a specific reason I bring it up and I will
- 1:17:24mention that afterwards.
- 1:17:26But random question of the day for you is, what is the best kind of cookie?
- 1:17:33Oh, okay.
- 1:17:36So great question.
- 1:17:39I would say that my attitudes about this have actually changed recently.
- 1:17:44So, throughout my whole life, I have been a white chocolate macadamia nut girl.
- 1:17:50Like, I absolutely love white chocolate.
- 1:17:52I know for some people, white chocolate is, you know, not real chocolate, and they get really
- 1:17:58angry about it.
- 1:17:59But I love white chocolate macadamia nut cookies.
- 1:18:01They've always been my favorite until I think now I'm really sort of more focused on
- 1:18:08chocolate chip peanut butter cookies.
- 1:18:11Now that I have been introduced to peanut butter chips, and the fact that you can buy
- 1:18:15peanut butter chips just like chocolate chips, and then if you mix them together in a cookie,
- 1:18:19it's just a beautiful thing.
- 1:18:21So I think that right now, I'm kind of stuck on the chocolate chip peanut butter.
- 1:18:27Might lose a few listeners, but I must live my truth.
- 1:18:31I do not like peanut butter.
- 1:18:34Oh, no.
- 1:18:35The chocolate chip the the chocolate chip part, I am I I'm I'm I guess I'm very basic.
- 1:18:40I chocolate chip cookie is the absolute way to go for me.
- 1:18:43But, yeah, no, I'm not a peanut butter guy.
- 1:18:45But, anyways, the reason why I bring up this question to you, so I don't remember if you
- 1:18:50were here at this point about for Ballopedia.
- 1:18:53So a little bit of story time from name from me now for the listeners.
- 1:18:57So so Ballopedia, I think they're still doing this, but every every year they have a
- 1:19:05competition for a poll for readers to say what is the best Christmas related cookie.
- 1:19:11And there was some consternation about chocolate chip winning just because chocolate
- 1:19:14chip is admittedly not specifically Christmas related, but it it it was it it did win several
- 1:19:22years in a row, and then I think sugar cookie won or whatever.
- 1:19:25But that's that's not why I bring it up.
- 1:19:27Nothing wrong with sugar cookie, but it's it's a little too it's a little too much for me, but
- 1:19:31I I love chocolate chip.
- 1:19:31But the reason why I bring it up is and it was hinted at a couple times in the poll.
- 1:19:38I'm not gonna say her name.
- 1:19:40I mean, it's it's it's it's it's a funny story.
- 1:19:42It's not like I'm actually putting her on blast, but there is a former employee of
- 1:19:47Valipedia.
- 1:19:48She left some time before you and I did, but I don't remember how it came up, but something
- 1:19:55about the peanut butter balls came up or the Buckeyes.
- 1:19:58Are those are those Buckeyes, the peanut butter balls?
- 1:20:00I think they are.
- 1:20:01Oh, yeah.
- 1:20:01Well, peanut butter balls covered in
- 1:20:03chocolate.
- 1:20:03Yeah.
- 1:20:06She insisted that those were cookies, and basically nobody else agreed with her.
- 1:20:14She was
- 1:20:15balls are not cookies.
- 1:20:16She was adamant that it was a cookie, and she was like she she was that was absolutely her
- 1:20:24hill to die on.
- 1:20:25And so, oh, no.
- 1:20:27Think Renee got dropped out.
- 1:20:29But oh, man.
- 1:20:31I'll I'll have to get the the links from her if she if she did drop out.
- 1:20:35That stinks.
- 1:20:36But but, yes, former employer employee, she was very, peanut butter balls are cookies, and she
- 1:20:43was ready to die on that hill, and it became a running joke for for a little while there at
- 1:20:51Ballipedia.
- 1:20:51And it got hinted at a couple times in a couple of the polls for which one was the best kind of
- 1:20:58cookie.
- 1:20:59But oh, yeah.
- 1:21:00Fun fun times there in the Ballipedia Slack channel.
- 1:21:04But that is gonna wrap it up for today's episode of politics with Paul.
- 1:21:08Unfortunately well, luckily, at least, Renika was able to answer all the questions we had.
- 1:21:13I'll I'll get the any more of the links that she wants to specifically share and put them in
- 1:21:17the show notes here.
- 1:21:20But my links, my Facebook, Paul Raider author and speaker, my LinkedIn, mymedium.com profile,
- 1:21:27my five day educational email course on how to more effectively mitigate polarization and
- 1:21:32politics, my book on Amazon, and my email, PaulRayderWritesgmail dot com.
- 1:21:40So we're gonna wrap things up here, and thank you so much for listening.
- 1:21:44Please like, comment, and subscribe, and until next time, take care.