Latest / Consumerpedia / 23 - Frequently Frustrated Flyers: How to Fix a Broken Airline Industry
Transcript
- 0:01Delays cancellations lost luggage.
- 0:04It was a trifecta of trouble this summer for airline
- 0:07passengers who paid Sky High ticket prices, and sometimes
- 0:11never made it out of the airport.
- 0:12Millions of airline passengers missed vacations graduations
- 0:16family, get-togethers and important business meetings
- 0:18because the US airline industry was not prepared for the
- 0:22increased demand. Why isn't something being done
- 0:24to fix a system? That is clearly broken.
- 0:27I'm her wise bomb the consumer man.
- 0:29A Ribbiting editor at checkbook. Dot-org, welcome to Consumer
- 0:33pedia at checkbook, dot-org where the nonprofit that helps
- 0:36consumers, select Services, avoid trouble and save money
- 0:40because we don't accept any advertising or take money from
- 0:43any business. We recommend you can rely on
- 0:45checkbook, dot-org to be completely independent and
- 0:48objective. Now, here's the host of consumer
- 0:51pedia America's consumer expert. The consumer man herbalife's
- 0:55bomb in this episode, we'll look at what domestic airlines are
- 0:58required to do for you, when Flight is delayed or canceled,
- 1:01it isn't much how the Department of Transportation has failed to
- 1:05regulate the Airlines and what consumer Advocates would like to
- 1:08see done to protect the flying public.
- 1:10Our Guest is Bill McGee, he's been around the tarmac a few
- 1:13times. He seen the airline industry up
- 1:15close and personal bill is an award-winning travel.
- 1:18Journalist and author of the book attention.
- 1:20All passengers, Bill recently landed at the American economic
- 1:24Liberties project is a senior fellow for Aviation and travel.
- 1:28For those who don't know the American.
- 1:29Comics Liberty project is a nonprofit that works to fight
- 1:33monopolistic practices in the US economy.
- 1:36I've known bill for a long long time.
- 1:38He's a straight shooter who knows what he's talking about.
- 1:41Bill. It is so nice to have you with
- 1:43us. Thanks very much.
- 1:44Our it's always a pleasure. So before we dive into this I
- 1:46want you to explain to everyone of your background.
- 1:49Why you know so much about the airline industry.
- 1:51Well I've been around the airline industry for a
- 1:54frightening number of years. Now 37 and all I started in the
- 1:57industry in 1985. I worked in Airline flight
- 2:00operations, license. By the FAA is an aircraft
- 2:03dispatcher. I did that for about seven years
- 2:06then I became a writer and a journalist and I've written
- 2:08about the industry. I wrote a book called attention
- 2:10all passengers, there's a bit of a warning for the things that
- 2:13we're seeing now, but for the last 15 years or so, I've been a
- 2:16consumer Advocate on behalf of airline passengers.
- 2:19So how would you describe the airline's performance during the
- 2:22busy summer travel season? I think there's no question in
- 2:25my mind that this is by far, the worst customer service summer.
- 2:29I've Ever seen in my 37 years. I've talked to some old timers
- 2:32to go back much further than me and they all agree and I think
- 2:35it's not just opinion. I think we can back it up with
- 2:38Statistics and we'll be seeing more in the coming months from
- 2:40the Department of Transportation but the bottom line is we saw
- 2:43tens of thousands of what the industry calls flight
- 2:45disruptions and that's severe delays.
- 2:47And most of all cancellations and I want to be very clear
- 2:50about something. When we're talking about flight
- 2:52cancellations, what we're talking about this summer is not
- 2:55due to weather and Air Traffic Control in issues like that.
- 2:58Much of this is on the Earth. And themselves and we can take a
- 3:01deeper dive into that we will. But let's look at those numbers.
- 3:04According to dot the ten largest domestic Airlines have canceled
- 3:073.1 percent of their flights in June by comparison in June of
- 3:112019. That's pre-pandemic the
- 3:13carrier's canceled 2.1 percent of their flights.
- 3:15And again, the airline seem to be placed in a lot of that blame
- 3:17on the weather and air traffic control.
- 3:19I know there were some weather problems and some air traffic
- 3:21control problems. But you're saying that's not the
- 3:23ultimate cause. Absolutely.
- 3:25And again I you know I've been in the belly of the Beast.
- 3:27I did this for a living for years.
- 3:29I dispatched thousands of flights and I canceled hundreds
- 3:33of flights. I know all about dealing with
- 3:35Summer thunderstorms and winter, snow, storms, and everything
- 3:38else that you can imagine. But that's not what we're
- 3:40talking about. This year.
- 3:41Was there bad weather that contributed this this summer?
- 3:43Of course. Yes, there was weather, Air
- 3:45Traffic, Control problems, and staffing issues, particularly in
- 3:48Florida. Yes, there was.
- 3:49But that is not why we're seeing tens of thousands of cancelled
- 3:52flights in 2022. For the most part, this is on
- 3:55the airline's. Let's not forget, they received
- 3:57a fifty four billion dollar bailout from all of us.
- 4:00Two years ago from the taxpayers and there was only one provision
- 4:03that Congress put on it. Keep your Staffing levels up to
- 4:05speed, don't start laying people off and then when covid recedes
- 4:09and people start flying again, you don't have enough Staffing.
- 4:12But what did they do? They found a loophole.
- 4:13He didn't technically lay off people but they certainly
- 4:16encouraged a lot of early retirements particularly with
- 4:18pilots and that's the mess. We have this year and I want to
- 4:22stress when I was when I was a flight operations manager and I
- 4:25had to cancel flights. That was because of situations
- 4:27that were occurring in real time.
- 4:30In other words, at the start of the day, we published the
- 4:31schedule that we had every intention of operating, but then
- 4:34there was a thunderstorm or then there was an air traffic control
- 4:37problem, where there was a power outage, something like that,
- 4:39that was beyond our control. And then, we started canceling
- 4:41flights. What we saw this summer was
- 4:43really reprehensible at American economic, Liberties project, we
- 4:46call them Phantom flights. There were flights that were put
- 4:49in reservation systems that people were able to book.
- 4:51And more important people were able to put their credit card
- 4:54down and pay for, and that money went into the airline coffers
- 4:57when it was clear that the airline's Have the support and
- 5:01the Staffing to operate, many of those flights and then people
- 5:04were finding out about cancellations you know on the
- 5:06day of or at the airport on their way to the airport, that's
- 5:09the part that's really unforgivable and that's the part
- 5:12quite frankly where the US Department of Transportation
- 5:14should have been doing a lot more.
- 5:15So as a result of all this disruption you're talking about
- 5:18the d-o-t was inundated with complaints.
- 5:20Nearly 5900 complaints in June that's up 35 percent from the
- 5:24month before. So in August of frustrated,
- 5:27Secretary of Transportation people to judge called the sea.
- 5:29Situation, unacceptable told the airline's?
- 5:32Look, we're going to unveil a new dashboard just before Labor
- 5:34Day. That's going to show what you're
- 5:36willing to do for passengers when you cancel or significantly
- 5:38delay a flight. So let's talk about the
- 5:40dashboard. It shows the 10 largest US
- 5:43airlines in their Regional operating Partners.
- 5:45What they promised to do if possible.
- 5:48When there's a cancellation or delay that they're responsible
- 5:50for maintenance equipment or crucial it is that sort of thing
- 5:53such as providing meal vouchers or rebook you on another flight
- 5:56at no cost. So the the dod is making a big
- 5:58deal out of this Dash Lord, what do you think about it?
- 6:01Well it's not often that I quote Sarah Palin but the term
- 6:04lipstick on a pig comes to mind. This is a lot of window dressing
- 6:08but underneath the content hasn't changed in any meaningful
- 6:11way. The dashboard Bill does make it
- 6:13easier for passengers to see what the airline's promise.
- 6:15But is that enough? No, it's not enough and I agree
- 6:18with you. It does make it easier.
- 6:19It's nice to have it all in one place for once.
- 6:21That's something that really should have been done years ago
- 6:23and it's great to see that but let's take a deeper dive.
- 6:26What is the content itself just to put things in perspective in?
- 6:29The European Union. There are regulations in place.
- 6:32So what airlines must do, it's called the passenger Bill of
- 6:35Rights. If there's an extended delay, if
- 6:37there's a cancellation, if your involuntarily bumped, Etc, any
- 6:40problems with mishandled baggage Canada, recently follow the
- 6:44European Union and also introduced the Pastor Bill of
- 6:47Rights, these systems work, they've worked for more than 15
- 6:50years in Europe their uniform. They're consistent, it doesn't
- 6:53matter what the airline is, and I want to stress, it doesn't
- 6:55even matter if it's a European Airline US Airlines ironically
- 6:59tree. Customers much better on foreign
- 7:01soil than they do in the United States.
- 7:03The think about that for a moment.
- 7:04So what do we have here in this country?
- 7:05What we have is the Wild Wild West, that's what it comes down
- 7:08to Airlines. Write their own contracts of
- 7:11carriage with very very few regulations from the dot and
- 7:15those contracts are written by and for the airline's attorneys,
- 7:19called them contracts of adhesion because you agree to
- 7:21them. Every time you book a flight and
- 7:23I've had people say, well, I didn't agree to it.
- 7:25You did if you swipe your credit card and the money was taken out
- 7:28of your account, you agree to a 60, or 70 or 90 or 200 Page
- 7:31contract again, written for the airlines.
- 7:34So they're intentionally vague, they're filled with legalese.
- 7:37I've talked to attorneys that can understand them.
- 7:39We're really in a bad situation when there is any kind of a
- 7:43flight disruption when there's a serious delay or there's a
- 7:45cancellation and the language and I have studied this going
- 7:49back, 25 years now the language in the contract of carriage for
- 7:52US. Airlines today are intentionally
- 7:54vague and by that, I mean they use the word.
- 7:57May a lot. Talk to any lawyer estimate.
- 7:59Good. The word.
- 8:00As in a contract. So it says you know, if there's
- 8:02an extended delay we may do this.
- 8:03We may do that now we appreciate what secretary Buddha judge is
- 8:07trying to do, he's trying to get them on the record as saying
- 8:10they're going to do this that and that you know, in terms of
- 8:12delays and cancellations and hotels and meal vouchers and
- 8:15things like that. And that's great.
- 8:16But the fact is without real hard and fast regulations, these
- 8:20things, they're ephemeral, they don't mean anything because they
- 8:22can be changed tomorrow. We have seen Airlines change
- 8:25contracts of carriage on 24 hours, notice or less.
- 8:27They can win and they'll change it.
- 8:29So, The airline promises, I'm sorry to be cynical but I've
- 8:32been dealing as a consumer advocate for enough years to
- 8:34know that promises from airlines that are not backed up by
- 8:37regulations or legislation, they don't mean anything.
- 8:40So just to be clear in other countries such as Canada and
- 8:42Europe, it's not the airline may do this.
- 8:44If they feel like it, it's the rules.
- 8:45Say you're going to do this for the passengers, if the flights
- 8:48are delayed or their canceled. Absolutely.
- 8:50And again, I want to stress that applies to all Airlines
- 8:52worldwide. So whether it's an Asian,
- 8:54Airline a Middle, Eastern Illinois.
- 8:55If they're operating in the EU and that includes US Airlines.
- 8:59So, as I said, That's the real irony here.
- 9:01I was on a delayed flight in Brussels a couple years ago, it
- 9:04was Delta Airlines and Delta handled the delay beautifully.
- 9:07They gave us meal vouchers and free internet access and they
- 9:11kept us updated and advised. And I had to laugh because I
- 9:14thought, well, you know, I give them an A-Plus for how they
- 9:17handled this delay in Brussels, but if it was an Atlanta their
- 9:20Hometown and their largest Hub, I can guarantee, you wouldn't
- 9:22have been nearly as good. I remember I was flying back a
- 9:25couple of years ago from Philadelphia and there were some
- 9:27delays and I have a picture on my cell phone of the TV monitor
- 9:30saying I like the flight will leave at 6:30 and then the time
- 9:33clock at the bottom says 6 47 which gives you some indication
- 9:37of how you know up to real time these the information they give
- 9:40passengers are sometimes yes there.
- 9:42Absolutely. And and look, I mean this
- 9:44summer, as I say it's not opinion.
- 9:46It's not because I'm a consumer Advocate and I'm always, you
- 9:49know, locking horns with the airline's.
- 9:51It's statistical, it's factual. We all know it.
- 9:54Everybody knows someone who, if they weren't affected
- 9:56themselves, this this summer by a flight disruption.
- 9:59And they certainly You're close to someone who was and I mean
- 10:02for me my phone just you know blew up all summer long, with
- 10:05friends and family saying, guess what my flights canceled, guess
- 10:08what. They're not telling us.
- 10:09You know, when the flight is going to operate, this was an
- 10:12extraordinary summer. And if this doesn't tell us
- 10:15that, this is a broken industry in terms of customer service and
- 10:18that the DLT is a broken regulatory agency.
- 10:21I don't know what would. So we're hoping at American
- 10:24economic Liberties project that the lessons from this summer,
- 10:27I'm going to translate into real meaningful.
- 10:29Change and one final point the promises, you see on that d.o.t.
- 10:33dashboard or when it's the airline cause problems such as
- 10:36not. Having a pilot not having the
- 10:38plane clean equipment Problem, whatever cancellations or delays
- 10:41caused by weather or air traffic control delays are not the
- 10:44airline's problem. So other than a refund, if the
- 10:47flight is canceled and we're going to talk more about that in
- 10:48a few minutes. They really don't owe you
- 10:50anything, right? That's correct.
- 10:51You're entitled to a cash refund but beyond that it's completely
- 10:54up to the airline's discretion. So when does the airline owe you
- 10:57a refund? We're going to talk to Bill
- 10:58about that next. Listening to Consumer pedia
- 11:01powered by checkbook. Dot-org checkbook has ratings
- 11:04for travel agencies in and around these Seven Cities,
- 11:07Boston, Chicago Philadelphia Seattle, San Francisco,
- 11:12Minneapolis st. Paul and Washington, d.c. if you
- 11:15live in one of these seven Metro areas and haven't joined
- 11:17checkbook, yet check us out at checkbook.
- 11:20Our advice is always free ratings of local services are
- 11:23available with a subscription. Get a free thirty day
- 11:25subscription by going to check book dot org.
- 11:28Slash consumer PDF If your flight is canceled, maybe before
- 11:32you leave for the airport, maybe, as you're waiting in the
- 11:34boarding area, maybe it's an equipment problem, maybe it's
- 11:36bad weather. When your flight doesn't take
- 11:38off, what is the airline required to do at something?
- 11:41A lot of people don't know, Bill sure, the DNC regulation states
- 11:45that if your flight is canceled for any reason.
- 11:48I want to stress that whether it's what the airline's call an
- 11:50act of God or a force measure such as whether air traffic
- 11:53control, or whether it's the airline's own fault.
- 11:55Due to a mechanical issue with an airplane accrue problem, you
- 11:58are entitled to a full Cash refund.
- 12:00I really want to underline and stress cashier because that is
- 12:03what the dod says. But then in the real world,
- 12:06every day, what we see is that Airlines will offer consumers
- 12:10credits. Vouchers frequent flyer mileage
- 12:13in place of cash. So it's a caveat emptor
- 12:16situation unfortunately but I try and always remember that.
- 12:19The average American flies less than once a year.
- 12:22And so for so many consumers they get offered a voucher and
- 12:26they think well if I don't take it I'm not gonna have anything
- 12:29so I better. Or take it.
- 12:30But the fact is, you are entitled to cash in the case of
- 12:33every single flight cancellation in the US.
- 12:35And if you think I'm embellishing by saying that
- 12:38Airlines often don't offer that cash, despite the dod
- 12:41regulation, I can tell you that, I have a smoking text that I
- 12:45could forward to you and that was from a colleague of mine in
- 12:47American economic Liberties project.
- 12:48Just last month on Delta Airlines.
- 12:50His flight was cancelled and he forwarded me a text.
- 12:53You receive saying we're sorry, your flight is canceled, we'd be
- 12:56happy to give you a credit for that flight.
- 12:58Now luckily he's To me and I told him he could get cash, but
- 13:02what is the average consumer supposed to do?
- 13:04This is the level of Deceit that we see in this industry every
- 13:07day. Even when there is one
- 13:09regulation, it's really the only meaningful regulation on this
- 13:12issue of delays and cancellations.
- 13:14And it's been in place for years and even in that case, they find
- 13:17a loophole and they find a way to work around it and to see if
- 13:19passengers. So you can see.
- 13:21There's a lot of work that still needs to be done.
- 13:24So if they want to offer you miles of, they want to offer you
- 13:26a voucher, whatever. That's fine.
- 13:28But they've got to tell you, you're old.
- 13:29Add a refund would you like that or would you like one of these
- 13:32other options and then you the passenger get to choose.
- 13:34Exactly and you know if you choose that you want a voucher,
- 13:37you want Mi that's your call, that's fine.
- 13:39But unfortunately every single day in the case of flat
- 13:42cancellations, we know for a fact that passengers are not
- 13:45being told they have the cash option.
- 13:47So DOD is considering a rule that would define the terms
- 13:50canceled and significant delay terms that are used to trigger
- 13:53those refunds and terms that are not consistently interpreted by
- 13:57the airlines under the proposal of canceled.
- 13:59It would meet a flight that was published in a carriers computer
- 14:02reservation system. At the time, the ticket was
- 14:04sold, but didn't take off his schedule.
- 14:06That seems fairly obvious. Is there really a need to Define
- 14:09canceled as how they get around that 10 there?
- 14:12Absolutely is in need because Airlines cancel flights.
- 14:15Sometimes at the last moment as I did when I worked in Flight
- 14:17operations but other times they do it months in advance.
- 14:20And so the nomenclature here gets very tricky because in some
- 14:24cases the industry will say well we're canceling a flight three
- 14:28months from now so That's a schedule change.
- 14:31Now, if you are planning to go to a wedding, and you booked a
- 14:34ticket 90 days out, and you're told that flight isn't going to
- 14:37operate, what would you call it? Except a cancellation, is that a
- 14:40schedule change to you? That's a cancellation.
- 14:42So there are different gradations of cancellations,
- 14:45according to the industry, you know, this is BS.
- 14:48Basically, I mean, it's ways of getting around these things.
- 14:52So we think these definitions have to be hard and fast and
- 14:55they need to be very clear on the cancellations and on the
- 14:58delays as well. It's kind of Agreeing, if you
- 15:00look up dot-gov and you look up what the rules are on extended
- 15:04delays, the d-o-t on its own site, says, in the case of an
- 15:07extended delay, and then in parentheses, it says, the dod
- 15:11has not defined. What an extended delay is, well,
- 15:14what are we supposed to do with that regulation.
- 15:15It hasn't been defined. So what's an extended delay?
- 15:18It's a very gray area and we really do need to nail down
- 15:22these definitions. So just to be clear if you
- 15:24booked your flight 90 days in advance to go to a wedding and
- 15:26they said flights canceled way in advance.
- 15:29Going to put you on this other flight and would get you to your
- 15:31destination after the wedding was going to take place.
- 15:33For instance, you have the right, you ordered owed a refund
- 15:36because they cancel that flight exactly.
- 15:38That should be a cash Refund. Now the department also wants to
- 15:42Define significant changes to a flight, it would mean changes
- 15:45that affect the departure or arrival times by three hours or
- 15:48more for domestic flights 6 hours or more for international
- 15:51flights changes to the departure or arrival airport changes in
- 15:54increase the number of connections and changes to the
- 15:57type of aircraft flown. If it A significant downgrade in
- 16:01the air travel experience or amenities aboard the flight that
- 16:04seems like a good regulation. Absolutely.
- 16:07There's a lot to discuss their. We could have a whole half-hour
- 16:10discussion on that. I won't get into it right now.
- 16:12I'll give you two minutes. Okay.
- 16:13Fair enough, you change of gauge is what the airline industry
- 16:16calls, the change of aircraft type.
- 16:19That goes all the way back to the railroad days.
- 16:20Believe it or not. And so, with the events
- 16:23surrounding the fatal accidents with the Boeing 737 Max a few
- 16:27years ago, for example, we spoke to an awful lot of people.
- 16:29That said, they never want to fly on a Max again.
- 16:31Well, you might go into a reservation system and you're
- 16:34booked on a 737, that is not a Max series, two different series
- 16:38of 737. And then at the last minute,
- 16:40that your life's changed to a Max.
- 16:41And they now tell you, well, we're operating it with this
- 16:44flight. So if you don't want to get on
- 16:45the max, you're out of luck. That's just one change.
- 16:48That could happen. What we also see all the time
- 16:50every day is that when there's a change of aircraft, what that
- 16:53usually means is that there is going to be a change of the
- 16:56seating plan and so it's like taking a deck of cards and
- 16:58throwing them up in the air. If you had an assigned seat, I
- 17:01have seen complaint after complaint from consumers.
- 17:04Did say we booked in advance, we did everything right, we booked
- 17:07our seats, we were all sitting together and then at the last
- 17:10minute, on the day of travel, they said, well, it's a
- 17:12different airplane now and you have to redo your seating
- 17:14assignments and everything. Got messed up, including
- 17:17traveling, with small children, people with disabilities, all
- 17:19kinds of situations. So we cannot be specific enough
- 17:23on these regulations. We need to hear comments from
- 17:27all sorts of groups, not just consumer.
- 17:29Ins and disability organizations.
- 17:31But from average consumers to that are experienced this, we're
- 17:34hoping the DLT gets inundated with comments.
- 17:36I should point out that checkbook asked Airlines for
- 17:38America. That's the trade group that
- 17:39represents a major US Airlines the comment on the proposed rule
- 17:43but it declined to do. So one more point with this
- 17:45proposed rule, as part of this to DOD announced that it has
- 17:47been investigating. The ten largest US Airlines and
- 17:51some enforcement action could be coming down the road.
- 17:53Sounds like maybe they're moving in the right direction here,
- 17:55hurry, but I don't know how good the microphone is going to pick
- 17:58up a very loud sound. That's the only way I can really
- 18:01hear it. Okay.
- 18:03Thank you. I want to tell you that I
- 18:05personally along with other consumer, Advocates have been in
- 18:08direct contact with the US Department of Transportation.
- 18:11Since March of 2020, that is more than two and a half years
- 18:15now asking about this issue and we have been told on more than
- 18:1911 occasions. I went back and added up all the
- 18:22meetings in the zooms. We have been told repeatedly for
- 18:25two and a half years. There's an ongoing
- 18:27investigation. How long does it?
- 18:29Take. Now the fact is in 2020.
- 18:32When the DLT published its annual number of consumer
- 18:35complaints, they went off the chart, we hit all-time highs
- 18:38since they first started doing this in 1987, and the complaints
- 18:42about refunds. Get ready for this number.
- 18:44It was 57 times the number in 2020 that it was in 2019.
- 18:49Now that tells you the system was broken, that tells you that
- 18:52US Airlines were saying, we're not going to pay refunds.
- 18:55Even in cases, where they clearly were supposed to, we
- 18:58won't even get into Gray areas of, you know, people being
- 19:01unable to travel due to health issues during covid and all the
- 19:03rest of it. Senator, Markey puts that total
- 19:06figure at more than 10 billion dollars in unpaid refunds.
- 19:09So when I hear the dod is still investigating this after two and
- 19:13a half years, it's like nails on a Blackboard to me, I'm sorry,
- 19:17you know, that's this should have been wrapped up a long time
- 19:19ago, the Department of Transportation.
- 19:21Absolutely has an aversion to regulating Airlines and defining
- 19:25Airlines and to disciplining them when they need to be.
- 19:29And and this is exhibit a, there's no question.
- 19:32Why is it taking all this time? We're going on almost three
- 19:35years. Now of investigating unpaid
- 19:38refunds. I could tell you right now, who
- 19:40the worst suspects were because I read the dod Zone consumer
- 19:43compliance. Start with United Airlines.
- 19:45Then take a look at Frontier Airlines united, add almost
- 19:47twice as much as many complaints about refunds as Delta or
- 19:51American or roughly the same size, they almost twice as many
- 19:54complaints, clearly something was wrong with the United refund
- 19:57system. Frontier Airlines had Most
- 19:59complaints on a purpose in your faces, a much smaller Airline.
- 20:02But the complaints were so bad that the Colorado attorney
- 20:05general publicly said my hands are tied but I wish I could do
- 20:08something here so enough with this.
- 20:11Now secretary footage has done numerous media appearances all
- 20:14summer long and he keeps citing record.
- 20:17Find that the d-o-t imposed on the issue of refunds.
- 20:21Well, that's a half-truth. Quite frankly.
- 20:23Yes, it was a record, fine, 25 million dollars but it was not
- 20:27against a u.s. air on. It was against air.
- 20:29De and it later got negotiated down to two million and the
- 20:32reason that the d-o-t find their Canada is that Air Canada,
- 20:35publicly humiliated the OT by saying publicly that they would
- 20:39not be paying refunds for you as Travelers.
- 20:42The dlts entire credibility was on the line.
- 20:44Now, that investigation didn't take two and a half years did
- 20:47it? That was pretty quick and they
- 20:48went in and they find Air Canada.
- 20:50But our question is, are counted as a pretty small slice of the
- 20:52pie. When you look at u.s.
- 20:54Travelers waiting for refunds from Airlines, what's going on
- 20:57with the US airlines that, it's taking two and a half years.
- 20:59So could more be done to protect the flying public.
- 21:02Maybe give the states the power to sue the airline's.
- 21:04When they believe consumer protection laws are violated.
- 21:06We're going to talk to Bill about that.
- 21:07Straight ahead. You're listening to Consumer
- 21:09pedia, powered by checkbook. Dot-org consumer pedia.
- 21:14Fast. Facts.
- 21:16Atlanta's Hartsfield-Jackson airport is the country's busiest
- 21:18airport. Handling more than 75 million
- 21:21passengers last year when it comes to customer satisfaction
- 21:25the best mega airport in the u.s. is Minneapolis-Saint Paul
- 21:28International. According to a recent JD Power,
- 21:31survey Singapore, Airlines operates, the longest nonstop
- 21:34flight in the world, New York to Singapore.
- 21:37The 9,500 mile flight takes nearly 19 hours.
- 21:42When Congress deregulated, the airline's back in the late 70s,
- 21:45it gave the d-o-t the Department of Transportation.
- 21:47The sole power to regulate the airlines in August, the National
- 21:51Association of Attorneys. General wrote Congress asking
- 21:54for the authority to enforce state and federal consumer
- 21:56protections for airline passengers.
- 21:58Currently State authorities, can't sue an airline even when
- 22:01the victims are in their state Bill, do you think this is a
- 22:03good idea? So it's a great idea.
- 22:05In fact, great minds must think alike because at the very, same
- 22:09moment that the state AG's and they were 38, Them by the way
- 22:12and it's worth noting. It was a very bipartisan group
- 22:15in terms of political parties. At the same time that they were
- 22:18announcing that they should have more Authority at American
- 22:21economic Liberties project. We were putting together a draft
- 22:24of what we're calling model legislation to repeal that
- 22:28Federal preemption Clause that was included in 1978.
- 22:31Now, when you start saying terms, like Federal preemption,
- 22:33I think, if you're not a lawyer, your eyes start to roll a little
- 22:36bit, back in your head. Let me just be very clear about
- 22:38what this means in the real world every day as a consumer
- 22:41in. America, you have fewer rights
- 22:44in dealing with an airline. Then you do in dealing with
- 22:46virtually any other company in any other industry.
- 22:49And what that means is that the dod is the only sheriff in town
- 22:53the OT in Congress. And so for the airline industry,
- 22:57you cannot Sue an airline in State Court.
- 23:00Which by the way, is where most class action suits are.
- 23:02So the airlines have this Shield, it's like an invisible
- 23:06shield that prevents them from the mass of lawsuits that every
- 23:09other industry has to deal with and state AG.
- 23:12Have no Authority, whatsoever and state legislatures have no
- 23:16Authority. We're saying, it's time for
- 23:18federal preemption to be eliminated.
- 23:20It is this protective shield that is keeping the airlines
- 23:24from having to respond to Consumers.
- 23:26You know, the honest talk a good game all the time about, you
- 23:28know, the free market. And they just want to do their
- 23:30thing, and not have too much oversight and not have
- 23:33burdensome regulations. Well, guess what?
- 23:35In the free market, you have to deal with the penalty of
- 23:38lawsuits and class action lawsuits and the airlines have
- 23:41this protective Shield against it.
- 23:42So we're saying, enough with Federal preemption, it's time
- 23:45for it to go, and I'm happy to say that we've had some
- 23:47conversations with members of Congress, who are looking to
- 23:49sponsor the legislation soon. Great.
- 23:51So before we go, do you have a message for the airline's who've
- 23:54gotten away with treating their customers poorly and so many
- 23:57ways for so many years I should I do.
- 23:59Yes. And that is that, you know, I'm
- 24:02someone who worked in the airline's, I came from an
- 24:04airline family. I remember when it was such a
- 24:06great industry to work in and it was so great to fly, it's not
- 24:10that way. Now customer service.
- 24:12Has just eroded to the point where it's all about the cost.
- 24:15Now for the airlines, they don't care.
- 24:17If you're sitting in a seat, that is dangerous.
- 24:19When there's an emergency evacuation, they don't care.
- 24:22If they're charging you fees that add up to more than the
- 24:24base fare and they certainly don't care when your flights are
- 24:27delayed and cancelled, they've really gone too far.
- 24:30I think that the summer of 2022 is going to be looked at as a
- 24:34watershed. This was the summer when
- 24:36everyone got angry simultaneously.
- 24:38I have people say to me all the time, there's something wrong
- 24:40with this industry. What is it?
- 24:42Well, I think we've all learned that this is a broken industry.
- 24:45It's a public utility because we all supported every time.
- 24:48There's a problem. We give them a bailout.
- 24:50Like the fifty four billion that the taxpayers gave two years
- 24:52ago. But when it comes to responding
- 24:54to customers they're just absolutely tone-deaf and federal
- 24:57preemption is a big part of that.
- 24:59So we're saying Federal preemption has to go and you
- 25:01have to start acting like every other company in America and
- 25:04start listening to customers. And for those who fly and are
- 25:07fed up and want to see things change, what can we do?
- 25:10It's important to wait. In at the Department of
- 25:13Transportation, they're asking for public comments now about
- 25:16the issue of refunds and it's important to log in on that, but
- 25:20also reach out to members of Congress.
- 25:22You know, the irony this summer is that normally members of
- 25:25Congress, or treat a little better by the airlines.
- 25:27But I've heard from so many members who were talking about
- 25:30their own flights, being extensively, delayed and
- 25:32cancelled. So, a lot of anger in Washington
- 25:34right now. So, I think it's sumers need to
- 25:35build on that reach out to members of Congress and let them
- 25:38know you want to see some meaningful change with the
- 25:40airline's film. She is a senior fellow at the
- 25:43American economics, Liberty project, he is fighting for
- 25:46consumer rights. In the skies Bill really
- 25:48important information. Thank you for spending time with
- 25:50us and I hope you enjoy your flight.
- 25:52Thank you, herb. It's always a pleasure to talk
- 25:53to you. Well, that's it for this edition
- 25:55of consumer pedia. You can subscribe to us on Apple
- 25:58or Google podcast Spotify, Stitcher or wherever you listen
- 26:01to your podcast. That way you won't miss an
- 26:04episode. Remember we release new ones,
- 26:06every other Thursday, another way you can support this show is
- 26:10to follow us on consumer PDF On Facebook and Instagram and at my
- 26:14consumer pedia on Twitter, I'm her Weiss bomb.
- 26:18Thanks for listening consumer. Pedia is a public service of
- 26:21checkbook, dot-org. We're a unique nonprofit that
- 26:23empowers you the consumer to save money and make smarter
- 26:27choices from auto repair shops to doctors plumbers to vets, you
- 26:31can count on checkbook, dot-org to help you find the best
- 26:33services, and avoid the worst local ratings are unbiased and
- 26:37accurate. If you live in, or around these
- 26:39Seven Cities and haven't joined checkbook, yet.
- 26:41Yet, check this out. Boston, Chicago Philadelphia
- 26:45Seattle, San Francisco, Minneapolis st.
- 26:48Paul. And Washington DC to get your
- 26:50free 30-day subscription. Go to check book dot org, slash
- 26:54consumer PDF consumer pedia empowering consumers to save
- 26:58money and make smarter choices. Yet, check this out.
- 26:43Boston, Chicago Philadelphia Seattle, San Francisco,
- 26:47Minneapolis st. Paul.
- 26:48And Washington DC to get your free 30-day subscription.
- 26:52Go to check book dot org, slash consumer PDF consumer pedia
- 26:57empowering consumers to save money and make smarter choices.