Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / Rodney Smith
Transcript
- 0:00This podcast is brought to you by Grand Gamers Guilds. If you like innovative
- 0:03games with fascinating themes in premium production, then you'll love the games from Grand
- 0:08Gamers guild. Find out more at grand Gamersguilds dot com. Out of the
- 0:17street corners, they scream. You knew it was coming. You've been waiting
- 0:21for this for months, rumor hardened into fear, and now they scream at
- 0:24you. The sirens, their hysterical wail, tearing through the white noise of
- 0:29the city, and you run. You run to pick up those things that
- 0:33can never be replaced, a picture of them in the days when they still
- 0:36loved you, your mother's wedding ring. And then you turn to your shelf
- 0:40of games. You only have room for five. Five Games for Doomsday.
- 0:49Five Games for Doomsday is a show in which board game personalities are thrust into
- 0:53a cabin in the woods to outrun an oncoming disaster, but can only take
- 0:58five of their games with them. Which will they choose? I guess this
- 1:00week loves teaching games an intermittent gamer until he felt for them hard. He's
- 1:06made a career in being the go to tutorial maker in the industry. He's
- 1:11transformed watch It Played from a playthrough channel to an all encompassing board game channel
- 1:15and is one of the most recognizable faces in the world of board game media.
- 1:19My guest this week is Rodney Smith. Rodney, welcome to the cabin.
- 1:23Well, thank you. It's lovely to be in the cabin. I
- 1:26feel very at home here in my plaid shirt. Plaid. Well, the
- 1:30thing is this is perfect for you because you know, in pre pre apocalypse
- 1:34you live in a cabin anyway anyway, so it's all this is just a
- 1:38this is an easy transition from me. I mean, just the zombies outside
- 1:42is slightly different. But apart from that, it's fine. It's having Canada
- 1:46with good zombies here. It's this is a wasteland up here in Canada.
- 1:49So my first question is, then, how difficult was it for you to
- 1:53pick the five games to tave the cabin? You know what? It wasn't
- 1:56too bad, and I thought it might be. But I took a smattering
- 2:00of things that have had some historical favor and then also some new things I've
- 2:06been enjoying lately, so and I tried to go for a variety of styles
- 2:08of games. So it was actually kind of kind of a fun exercise.
- 2:10It wasn't too bad. So, having followed you kind of since the beginning,
- 2:16it strikes me that your gaming attitude is also wrapped up in an element
- 2:23of nostalgia. To what degree did nostalgia factor into your choices? Oh,
- 2:28that's an interesting observation. Yeah, I think it did at least in a
- 2:31couple of the choices, certainly in I don't know, maybe I shouldn't spoil
- 2:36it. I won't spoil an the choices yet, but certainly some related to
- 2:38like family play, Some, although not nostalgic, tie back to some nostalgia
- 2:45for my youth. Some games I played then that are now like have modern
- 2:47designs that sort of call back to that. I'd say because gaming has been
- 2:52a part of my life ever since I was quite young, I've always been
- 2:53playing some kind of board games, So I think that's probably not a surprise
- 2:58that there'd be some some echoes of that in this selection. And sort of
- 3:02what are you like as a collector of games? So if there was an
- 3:07immolation and all your games are gone and you only had five, would that
- 3:09be a massive tragedy to you or would you be quite sanguine about it,
- 3:14you know what, I think I'd be okay, honestly. You know,
- 3:15I said earlier that making the selection wasn't difficult, and that's true. But
- 3:21there is a part of me if there was any difficulty, be like I
- 3:23wish I could just bring all my unplayed games with me to the cabin,
- 3:28because if there's something that sort of like hovers over me a little bit and
- 3:30causes a little bit of like frustration, probably is that sense of I have
- 3:35several games that I really would like to play that I just haven't had the
- 3:37time to get to the table. I think a common issue that gamers who've
- 3:40collected a certain number of games probably feel, you know, having more games
- 3:46than we have the time to play. So I think that sort of lingers.
- 3:50But as in terms of how I am collecting, I am a pretty
- 3:53aggressive color, meaning that I don't really want to have an endlessly growing collection
- 4:00of games. I have a certain number of shelves in my home, and
- 4:02if those shelves are full, that's fine, And I have plenty of shelves,
- 4:05so's it's more than enough, you know. I think the problem with
- 4:08having just like an endless growing amount of them is It's not like I can
- 4:11just pull one off the shelf and play it. I mean there's rules to
- 4:15learn again, you know. And I mean I thought about you, but
- 4:18it feels like if you have too much stuff, there is a psychic weight,
- 4:23right that sort of that makes you kinda miserable. I totally agree,
- 4:27Ben. There have been times I will confess where I've had a game that
- 4:30I haven't gotten around to playing, and I've just put it on the call
- 4:32pile, you know. And I think it's more about that psychic weight.
- 4:35If I don't know when I'm going to get to this, I don't have
- 4:36a sense I'm going to get to this, and I'd rather someone else is
- 4:40playing this than its just sitting here gathering dust effectively. So I remember a
- 4:46few years ago you did this initiative, and I was always inspired to do
- 4:49it, and then I never did. And you said that I'm going to
- 4:53play all of my games this year, and then the ones I don't get
- 4:57to playing at the end of the year, I'm going to sell because I
- 5:00clearly am not interested in them. Is this something you still do or is
- 5:03it gone beyond that at this point it's a good memory, then you're right,
- 5:06I did that. I don't know how long ago that was now,
- 5:09it's probably over five years ago. Excellent memory, I am, Well,
- 5:13it's the reason I remember it is because I thought, what a great idea.
- 5:15I'm definitely going to do that. Like every year I say I'm going
- 5:18to do a ten by ten. Sure, I never do well like that,
- 5:23and like the ten by ten. There was one year where I tried
- 5:25doing that too, and I haven't repeated that, but maybe I've kept kind
- 5:29of the principle alive at least somewhere in the back of my mind where when
- 5:33I'm thinking of calling some of my collection, I will make that I'll ask
- 5:36myself that question, have I played this game in the last year, And
- 5:40if not, why is that? Is there another game I'm always pulling off
- 5:43the shelf ahead of it? Well, that's probably not going to change.
- 5:47So this game can now leave, you know, I can give myself permission
- 5:53to leave. And there's have there been times when I've gotten rid of a
- 5:55game and then thought, oh man, I wish I still had that game.
- 5:59Sure, I think that linger feeling can be there, and I think
- 6:00all of us can be a concerned of having that feeling. But that feeling
- 6:04doesn't mean we would have actually played the game anyway, right, you know
- 6:08what I mean. And there's a little part of it. It's like if
- 6:11I just take a picture of the game and keep that, that might be
- 6:15just enough the memory of it. It's the same thing, right, It's
- 6:18the same thing. If I'm not playing it, then a photograph of it's
- 6:20the same as actually owning it, right to some extent. But I have
- 6:25not done that because that was very stressful. Then that was that that exercise
- 6:28was very stressful because there was a sense of, oh, some of these
- 6:31games that I haven't had a chance to play, I would like to keep.
- 6:36So I never did that again. But the exercise was good, it
- 6:39was It was helpful that way. Yeah. So let's go back to the
- 6:42beginning though, So, like me, we share a sort of a formative
- 6:46sort of childhood experience. You were a later rival and had siblings that were
- 6:51considerably older than you, and in the notes you sent me, you sort
- 6:56of said it was like it was kind of like being an only child,
- 6:59and I think that's a it was kind of the same for me. So
- 7:02what was that experience like growing up? Yeah, I mean, looking back
- 7:06on it, it was a positive experience. I would say there were certainly
- 7:09some benefits to being the surprise, the unexpected surprise, because my parents were
- 7:15a little more settled. You know. My siblings had moved around a fair
- 7:17bit, you know, as my dad was getting established in his career,
- 7:20and by the time I came along, they were a little more stable,
- 7:25you know, a little more financially stable all that. So I got to
- 7:27reap the benefits of those sorts of things. I had older siblings who were
- 7:30kind of rock stars to me, you know, like my brother for example.
- 7:34You know, he had a cool car, and he had a bit
- 7:38of disposable incomes. We always bought me really cool gifts of Christmas. You
- 7:41know, like it was kind of neat. But at the same time,
- 7:44and I don't know if you experienced this at all, I felt like there
- 7:48was this other life that the family had that I was never a part of.
- 7:51Like if I was going to some photo albums, you know what I'm
- 7:54talking about. You go through photobums and I see these shared memories that they
- 7:57all had together that I was never a part of. You know. There
- 8:00was so fascinating for me is that my parents divorce very shortly after I was
- 8:05born, so I never knew them as a couple. Where was my brother
- 8:07and sister did right? Right? So that is very yeah, very much
- 8:11distinctly a whole separate world of experience that you had with your parents, that
- 8:15your siblings had a very different one. So I think in that way,
- 8:18and because my siblings were older and moved out, I very much felt like
- 8:22an only child at that point, which I think also, you know,
- 8:24kind of led me to Ben. Would you say that that caused you to
- 8:28be a more I don't know if this is true, but if I feel
- 8:31like it made me a slightly more imaginative child. I didn't have like an
- 8:35built in playmate. I had imaginary friends. I remember that as a kid.
- 8:39I remember doing lots of imaginative play and and that sort of taking the
- 8:43place. I mean, I also had friends on the street and neighbors and
- 8:45things like that, but I felt there was more. I did more solitary
- 8:48activities that way. Did you find that, I mean, I thought it
- 8:50made me more gregarious. Actually, I kind of had to get out there
- 8:54and meet people otherwise I have to be alone, you know. Yeah,
- 8:58I think I had a few challenges that way. Because I was a bit
- 9:03of an odd kid, I think due to some of my like religious upbringing
- 9:07and beliefs that made me a bit of an outsider and an oddball to the
- 9:09other kids in my neighborhood. So it wasn't always easy to sort of fit
- 9:15into those friend groups. Thankfully though, I had a very like, loving
- 9:18and supportive household to come home to, which I think helped a lot that
- 9:22way. But yeah, I think that also. Yeah, I get what
- 9:26you mean though about being gregarious. Like, Okay, so I don't have
- 9:28friends, I don't need to go out there and find something. It makes
- 9:30sense, and so moving on to that, then when we think of Canada,
- 9:35we don't think of sort of people who wear their religion on their sleeve
- 9:39in the way that Americans do. And you grew up in a strict religious
- 9:43household, sort of firstly, what flavor of religion was able denomination was it?
- 9:48And secondly, how did that so firstly affect you growing up and do
- 9:54you feel any sort of lingering effect in the way you approach your life from
- 9:58growing up very religious? Yeah, I came from Are you familiar with pentepostalism,
- 10:05it's very obliquely Yeah, Okay, so it is. I would say,
- 10:09how would I describe it? An enthusiastic branch of conservative Christianity? And
- 10:16it was very much like it was the lens through which I understood everything,
- 10:20even from it like a very young age my neighbor when my neighbor moved in.
- 10:26I was about our next door neighbor, I was about four. And
- 10:28the story he always would tell is about this little boy me who came over
- 10:33into his yard. Well he was bent over in the garden, you know,
- 10:37and getting tapped on his butt by a plastic tennis racket I was holding.
- 10:41And he turns around and the first thing I say to him is are
- 10:43you a Christian? Like that was the lens through which I like understood everything,
- 10:48you know. And I had friends, you know, growing up who
- 10:52a lot of them would have, like, you know, on a survey
- 10:54checked the box of yeah, I'm a Christian. But I realized, oh,
- 10:58they go to church like on on, like for Christmas and Easter,
- 11:01you every Sundays. This is a daily part of my thinking. It's how
- 11:05I understand everything about my life, Like what kind of effect that ties sort
- 11:11of that oddball part, you know, the kid who like comes up and
- 11:13bop someone on the button and goes, hey, are you a Christian?
- 11:16Is going to stand out in a very like I would say my neighborhood was
- 11:20quite secular, and so my friends would have been into things I wasn't allowed
- 11:26to be into, whether that's like popular music or even like toys. So
- 11:31you mentioned in your notes that your parents were fully into satanic panic and D
- 11:35and D was something that you couldn't embrace, right right, Yeah, it
- 11:39says. I got older and I discovered things like from other friends at school
- 11:41who were like into dungeons and dragons, like that was just so attractive to
- 11:45me. Going back to that earlier thing talking about imaginative play, when I
- 11:48realized that there were games that existed that gave rules to your imagination, that
- 11:52fascinated to me, Like, oh, so the imaginary character I thought up
- 11:54could have stats and I could like imbue that character and play as a character
- 11:58in a game. Oh my god, that sounds incredible. And then to
- 12:01find out, yeah, but okay, this is full of monsters and magic
- 12:05and all sorts of things that would have been yeah, during this satanic panic
- 12:09scene as of the devil. Right, So I wasn't allowed to be into
- 12:13that. It didn't stop me from being very attracted to it, though,
- 12:16and borrowing my friends' D and D books at recess, and trying to understand
- 12:20how role playing games worked so I could make them up at home, Like
- 12:24I would write out rules and rules of pages myself so I could recreate for
- 12:30nobody, because I never end up playing these games, because actually designing a
- 12:31role playing game it turned out to be kind of complicated. But I threw
- 12:35myself into it that way, sort of creatively, to try to experience it
- 12:37from afar, you know. And so you said to me in your notes
- 12:41that you lost your faith in your twenties. I was a very serious little
- 12:46boy, and I was very religious up until about the age of eleven,
- 12:50and then something just clicked in my head and I went, hang on a
- 12:54minute. But I wasn't in any kind of religious assholt. So my religious
- 12:58beliefs were, you know, completely inconsequential to my parents' view of me.
- 13:03So, first off, how did you come to the conclusion that this didn't
- 13:07make sense to you anymore? And how did you break it to your family?
- 13:11Well, you know, like the I didn't sort of leave it overnight
- 13:16type of thing. It was a lot of wrestling, and it was very
- 13:18gradual, you know. It was like maybe finding myself in disagreement with certain
- 13:24theological principles but still believing in God, still believing in Christianity, still believing
- 13:28in Jesus Christ as my savior and things like that, but taking issue with
- 13:31certain particulars. I think probably the straw that broke the camel's back was,
- 13:37you know, certain biblical texts around slavery, and there was one in particular
- 13:41in Exodus that says you can beat your slave to within an inch of its
- 13:45life as long as it doesn't die within the first twenty four hours, that's
- 13:48okay because it's your property. And I found that to be a very difficult
- 13:54notion to square with what I understood about what Christianity represented and God's law,
- 14:00you know. And I certainly studied all the apologetics that would try to explain
- 14:03that away or explain why that's not in contradiction to a loving God and all
- 14:07the rest of it. But I think part of what I realized is,
- 14:11oh, you can rationalize anything. Healings are capable of rationalizing anything. And
- 14:16I don't know that I want to have things like that rationalized away. I
- 14:24think that that can lead you to dangerous places sometimes in your belief radical places
- 14:30in your belief systems that aren't healthy. So and I think another thing not
- 14:33to dwell on it too much, but it was like a pretty formal part
- 14:35of my life, I suppose is I remember being in a church service and
- 14:39you know, again still very much part of the church community and had been
- 14:43a part of it on my life, and realizing, Okay, there's something
- 14:46the pastor is saying here that I don't quite agree with. And I realized
- 14:48in that moment, if I was to say this out loud to all these
- 14:52people who've been a part of my life for so long, the way they
- 14:54viewed me would just change it immediately. You know, they're would be real
- 15:00concern for me, and they would look at me differently, like my questions
- 15:03would become a potential poison or virus, you know that needs to be dealt
- 15:07with. And there are just some things about that that I think slowly over
- 15:09time helped me kind of say, Okay, I think, uh, these
- 15:16are not principles I can really follow overall. So anyway, had that were
- 15:20I wrote an essay to my parents, is what I did. I knew
- 15:22it was something I had to explain to them. It was going to be
- 15:24kind of a shock to my family system. It sounds like in your case
- 15:28it was a little less ingrained in terms of like how I religious. My
- 15:33religious affiliation was entirely independent, right, Okay, yeah, yeah, so
- 15:39so so you know it was. It was difficult. I shared this essay
- 15:41kind of walking through theologically why I was having some challenges and then personally and
- 15:45why I felt that had a step away, and they they they called a
- 15:50meeting. I guess a family meeting. I didn't think of it as an
- 15:50intervention at the time. I suppose it was. It's not unusual in our
- 15:54family are big talkers, so it wasn't unusual for us to get together and
- 15:58wrestle with things. But I have to say, you know, it was
- 16:00difficult for them, for sure, But on the whole, I wouldn't say
- 16:04like it broke our family apart in any meaningful way. They still loved me
- 16:07and cared for me. But I think the challenge is when when your whole
- 16:11life is seen through that lens, as it was for my family, when
- 16:15someone comes along and says, I don't think I subscribe to this anymore.
- 16:18There's really only a couple of options I think for them to really see it
- 16:22as as one Rodney's being irrational, or two Rodney's being sinful. He's got
- 16:27sinful rejection of our faith. There's not really a third option of Rodney could
- 16:32be right. You know, that's not cool. That's not an option really,
- 16:36And I understand that when you're in that you can't really see it another
- 16:40way. So, so yeah, it's certainly informed. I mean, I
- 16:44think my upbringing, I certainly learned a lot of good lessons from the faith
- 16:48that I had. I think I carry some of that forward. But I
- 16:52think I probably ascribed to a principle more of good for goodness sake. I
- 16:56can't really imagine a higher principle than that, really doing good for the sake
- 17:00of good. Yeah, And so that I tried to have guided me now
- 17:04as much as I can, as much as any person can, I suppose.
- 17:08And so, so off a less weighty topic than when did games?
- 17:12What did games into your life? And what were the ones that really grabbed
- 17:17you? Well, So, when I was young, I played a lot
- 17:21of the mass market games, you know, like risk, Monopoly, careers,
- 17:23a lot of hand me downs from my older siblings, like games they
- 17:26would have had. But I remember it distinctly, and I told the story
- 17:29before, but I want to share it with you. Like I was in
- 17:32the mall. I would have been I think twelve, maybe ten around that
- 17:36area when I used to go to a mall and there was a place that
- 17:38sold pool tables, but they also had like a collection of war games.
- 17:42I didn't know them as war games then, I just saw them as boxes
- 17:45of games. And I took home from there a free Avalon Hill catalog,
- 17:49and I was thumbing through it on the drive home and I came across this
- 17:52game called Empires and Arms and it had it listed all the things about it
- 17:59an eighty page book and played one hundred and twenty to twelve thousand minutes.
- 18:07Okay, Like that's that was like seen as a feature for those doing the
- 18:11math at home. That's two hundred hours. Okay, right, So all
- 18:14you Twilight Imperium people, that's child Flay Child's play. But this, so
- 18:19this maybe illuminates a little something about me. Perhaps I think a lot of
- 18:22people that would have caused them to run screaming in the direction, And for
- 18:26me, it was fascinated. I was like, what could eighty pages of
- 18:30rules be simulating? I played Risk Monopoly and like, what is going on
- 18:33in this game? Like this is kinda it's gonna be something very rich and
- 18:37deep. That was my presumption, and I begged my parents. I couldn't
- 18:40afford this game. It was like eighty dollars Canadian or something. I think.
- 18:42I remember, I'm like, Mom, Dad, I have half the
- 18:45money. Will you pay the other half. I'll pay you back eventually,
- 18:48and so they very kindly did. This is also back that time when you
- 18:51know you could just order something it showed up like Amazon style. We had
- 18:53to plan a trip back to that store and some ride and you know.
- 18:57So I got this game, and I I read the rules. I was
- 19:00just engrossed in the whole thing, and of course never got to play with
- 19:03anybody, because who's going to play at the age of twen or twelve?
- 19:07This is this game. It was absurd, and there was something in that
- 19:11that was kind of heartbreaking looking back on it, because I had all this
- 19:14enthusiasm but noally, no one to play it with. I shortly after that
- 19:18discovered the game Ambush, which was a solo war game and then then it
- 19:21was off to the races. I even had a combination of a role playing
- 19:25on and you created characters, you gave them names, they had stats,
- 19:27and that's when I think I really discovered how much I loved the unpacking,
- 19:33the learning, the exploring of a deep, rich kind of rule set.
- 19:38And then there was like a long break I played games, and I was
- 19:41into magic with the gathering and a few different things. Games are always a
- 19:44part of my life. But then I had like a family at a young
- 19:45age, and life kept me busy for a while, so I got away
- 19:48from games. But it's always been there. It's always been a part of
- 19:52my memories in my childhood. So your first game, then, is is
- 19:56a game that I associate with you. You may not know that. You
- 20:02may not know this, but I've kind of been on the journey with you
- 20:07because I got into games late twenty eleven, early twenty twelve, and your
- 20:11channel was one of the first that I found that I and when I was
- 20:15in that really, uh what, I just wanted to watch everything. Yeah,
- 20:22this is one of the ones that I that I watched, and this
- 20:25is Mansions of Madness, second edition. I mean, how much of a
- 20:26space in your heart. Does this game have oh, huge, huge This
- 20:32is like when you said earlier about Nost Dowda. This is certainly one of
- 20:33the games that comes from that, not from my childhood, but from the
- 20:38very formative important part the time of my life. Now particularly mentions a Meta's
- 20:42first edition. I put second edition on the list because I think it's a
- 20:45better game than the original edition, but mentioned Amna's first edition did a lot
- 20:49of things. One, it was a game that I played with my kids
- 20:52and had a lot of fun playing with them and playing acting as these characters.
- 20:56And it has this Again, I mentioned like I grew up during a
- 20:57time I couldn't really explore a role playing The time kind of passed me.
- 21:00Obviously, I became an adult, I had those opportunities, but I didn't
- 21:03necessarily have people to play role playing games with, and like I said,
- 21:06had a young family, so it just never came around to it. Board
- 21:07games provided me a way to simulate sort of role playing games where you take
- 21:11on the role of the character and there's kind of a GM and that sort
- 21:14of thing, so that was great. I loved games that told stories,
- 21:18that allowed you to tell a story mansions of Matus certainly did that. But
- 21:21the other thing that's kind of crucial, very significant, is it's what gave
- 21:25me, in part, the motivation to start the watch It Play channel because
- 21:30I was, you know this again, just like you. Back then,
- 21:33I was very interested in the hobby and I was consuming everything I could,
- 21:37every video that was out, every podcast was out there wasn't quite as many
- 21:41as there are now, and reading blogs on BGG. And when it came
- 21:45to manchiness of Matus like this looks really good, but it's like eighty bucks
- 21:48or whatever it was at the time, that was still like that was something
- 21:52I had to think about, you know. And so I was looking in
- 21:55reading reviews and I read like four that said it was great and four that
- 21:57said it was bad. And I was like, well, I just if
- 22:00I could just see it being played, then I can make up my own
- 22:03mind. And that's when a light bulb went on over my head, you
- 22:06know, of because at that time I had been really thinking about the possibility
- 22:11of creating some kind of media for board games, but I couldn't think what
- 22:14would be something I could offer. I knew I didn't want to do reviews.
- 22:18I just I'm so thankful that people do reviews, but I knew I
- 22:21wasn't built for it, because I've always struggled with the idea of trying to
- 22:23tell people you'll like this game, because this game is. There also an
- 22:30element of putting yourself out there as an expert. Yes, I'm not feeling
- 22:36a little old. It is, and I always feel a little funny saying
- 22:40it aloud, because again, I'm not casting any aspersions on people who have
- 22:42a comfort level doing that. It's just it's always felt a little awkward for
- 22:47me. And maybe even some of that ties back to some of what we
- 22:49were saying earlier about religion, you know, because I came from a place
- 22:53where I believe things in very concrete terms and then didn't anymore. And I
- 23:00think what that maybe opened up in my brain is this sense of humans aren't
- 23:04afforded the luxury of certainty, only confidence, and that becomes even more true.
- 23:10And we're talking about subjective things. There's things that I play, games
- 23:12I play, or food that I eat that I love that somebody else can't
- 23:15stand. So how can I tell a stranger, oh, you're going to
- 23:18love this, you know? And I think reviewers, it's not that they're
- 23:22dictating to people what they're going to love. They're sharing their enthusiasm, which
- 23:26might indicate something to you, but it's always made me feel a little uncomfortable.
- 23:29So I prefer to be a little less involved in that area. And
- 23:33so one thing I remember about mentioneds and madness. Yeah, and this was
- 23:37before I thought about creating any sort of bold game medias. I remember one
- 23:41episode and I can't remember whether you just finished the scenario or something, and
- 23:45you sort of you ended the video and you looked into the camera and you
- 23:47said, I want to get serious for a minute, and you explained to
- 23:52the audience why you wanted their money, essentially, why you wanted support to
- 23:59start the thing. And if I often get criticized by my American friends because
- 24:03I'm terrible at asking people for sport, it's a very old thing, and
- 24:07yet American seemed to have no issue with it. I mean, how difficult
- 24:11was it for you to do that bit of the video to say to this
- 24:15Nasans audience, give me some money for this thing I just done. Ben,
- 24:19Again, Ben, you really were there for the journey. You're right,
- 24:23like it was part way through. So the original mansions of Madness series
- 24:27was multiple, like twenty episodes or something. I think stretched over many,
- 24:30many weeks because I would turn over at the end of the episode. We
- 24:34were playing actually with people specifically online who were controlling some of the characters and
- 24:40submitting their turns, and we'd come back in we'd take those turns, our
- 24:42turns and these viewers turns as well. And at some point, I don't
- 24:47know, I think it was about a month into the process, I remember
- 24:49going up to my wife and saying, I say going up because I shout
- 24:55everything in the basement, so going up to the rest of the housing of
- 24:59Christy, I think I love what I'm doing. I think there's something here
- 25:03that I'm really it feels like a good fit for potentially my skill set,
- 25:08and also like this connection I feel to the hobby, like maybe teaching and
- 25:12showing how games are playing is something I can do decently. I wonder if
- 25:18this is something I could pursue. I didn't have any vision about what that
- 25:21could ultimately be, but I thought, well, maybe a test case scenario
- 25:25to see if people would support it, because I couldn't imagine how else there'd
- 25:27be a way to make money doing this, you know, so I just
- 25:30wanted to see Like it's kind of like a tip jar kind of notion was
- 25:33in my head, like if I'm providing something that's of use and you like
- 25:37it and you'd like to see it continue if it's provided whatever. This is
- 25:41pre Patreon, This is pretty much everything like this is before tabletop with Will
- 25:45Wheaton, Like there wasn't any even anyone playing games, like recording plays as
- 25:48I recalled back then, you know, so it was kind of like a
- 25:52New Horizon sort of thing, and it was encouraging. I did put the
- 25:56call out there and some people did offer financial support. It just it gave
- 26:00me the confidence to say, not that hey, this support will always be
- 26:03there, but there's a possibility I'm doing something of value that people are getting
- 26:07something good from and that maybe means that something could work. Yeah, And
- 26:12so you wrote sort of in your notes sort of how when you came up
- 26:18with a channel. I thought it was very funny that that it's no coincidence
- 26:22when you started the channel, you came up with twelve commandments channel that you
- 26:26that you called the Rodney Rules. That's right, what were the Rodney Rules?
- 26:33Well, okay, so it's now nineteen I think there's nineteen of them.
- 26:34Now. I have added a few over time, but the core of
- 26:37them, I don't know what it was. That early on I thought to
- 26:41myself, I want to have some guide posts for what I'm doing. I
- 26:47guess it's maybe because I had been watching other creators right, and I was
- 26:51certainly seeing some things I liked and certain things I didn't like. And I
- 26:53thought, I want to like create a path for myself so that if this
- 26:57does work on some level, that I have something to help guide my decisions
- 27:02if I get hit with something I'm not expecting and I want to know how
- 27:04to react. So I do have ryls. I don't tend to share them
- 27:08too publicly just because I think they're a little embarrassing. On some level,
- 27:11they're very earnest. Then they're very earn I'm surely you know. But here's
- 27:18here. I'll give you the first one, the very first one off the
- 27:19list. Is I make videos for the individuals watching, not just to grow
- 27:26my channel views and subscriptions. So early on wanted I sensed that there is
- 27:33this compulsion to get subscribers, right, to grow an audience. I could
- 27:38see that that was something that seemed important to YouTubers, and I knew for
- 27:41myself as a viewer, having watched a lot of things, what was important
- 27:45to me was feeling a connection to what I'm watching, like I wanted it
- 27:51to feel personal. And so I said, Rodney, you got to remember
- 27:55that you're talking to an individual viewer, You're not talking to a faceless crowd,
- 27:59and try to try to work in a way that has that at the
- 28:03forefront. And guess what, right, if you do that, maybe the
- 28:07crowd will take care of itself. If you take care of individual people,
- 28:08maybe you know, the other will happen anyway. So I think that was
- 28:12helpful, and I think it also helped me maybe avoid some of the pitfalls
- 28:15that can come definitely when you're creating and you maybe aren't having the growth.
- 28:22Some people might say like, well, easy for you to say, Rodney,
- 28:23you've got a successful YouTube channel. But again, this was something I
- 28:26decided in twenty eleven when I had subscrippers. Right, this was a guiding
- 28:32principle for then, and I think I think it did serve served me.
- 28:36Well. You know, another principle actually reared its head just yesterday I put
- 28:41up a tutorial video and there was a rules er not a rules are it
- 28:44kind of a rules of mission. There was a scoring thing. I listed
- 28:47all the different scoring and game scoring conditions, and there was one I missed,
- 28:51and I made me unsatisfied with it, and so I pulled it down,
- 28:53shot a correction, re edited, put it back up again. And
- 28:57so this comes from the principle. So this is when other Rodney rules here.
- 29:00He is the designer, artist, editor, publisher, distributor, has
- 29:04put thousands of hours into their game. Therefore I can make the time to
- 29:07refilm the section a video that can be improved in the moment of like,
- 29:11oh, the video is already online. It's already you know out there.
- 29:17Am I gonna like fix this? Can I just make a note? Maybe
- 29:18I can just put a note in the description. Maybe I can just pin
- 29:21a comment. You know, it's really minor detail. But there's something about
- 29:25that about saying, no, Rodney pursue the long term thing over the short
- 29:30term, because in the long run, that video is gonna sit there for
- 29:32years potentially, right, and a lot of people are gonna watch it.
- 29:34And this also represents somebody else's pride and joy, like that game is somebody's
- 29:38pride and joy that designer, the artists that work on it, like they
- 29:41all cared about it. I want to try to care about what I'm doing
- 29:47in the same way, if that makes sense, you know, to sort
- 29:49of elevate what I'm doing to what they're trying to do. And so have
- 29:55you a history with teaching what makes you? What makes you? Without blowing
- 30:00smoke where smoke shouldn't be blown. You're so good at explaining game. Well,
- 30:04that's very kind of me to say. I think there's a couple of
- 30:07things maybe that have helped me. One is I'm very fussy about particulars.
- 30:11You know, I'm very the granular details matter to me. So you probably
- 30:15want that if you're going to be someone who's going to be teaching rules.
- 30:18But I think maybe if I was to pat myself in the back and blow
- 30:22a little smoke. One thing I think I'm pretty decent at doing is learning
- 30:26something and then remembering how to unlearn it so I can teach it to someone
- 30:32who doesn't know it. I think this is a really difficult thing to do,
- 30:34and the thing that probably a lot of us fall prey to doing when
- 30:37we're teaching. So you don't take things for granted exactly, because if I
- 30:42was to say something like, you know, you need to play three energy
- 30:45so you can collect a frame token, and the person's like, I have
- 30:48no idea what energy is. I have no idea what frame tokens are.
- 30:52I know what they are because I already know the rules. So I need
- 30:53to remember that the viewer or the audience or whoever sitting at your game table
- 30:59does not know of those things. And so you have to talk to your
- 31:02audience's knowledge level, not to your own, right, And that's that's a
- 31:06that's a little mental trick that can be hard to do, and I think
- 31:08that that's something I've I've a decent that I think, because that's the same
- 31:14thing about the tutorial videos is trying to teach them in order so it builds
- 31:17on knowledge as opposed to stepping over things you know. And so I find
- 31:22when so if I read a rule book and then teach a game, it's
- 31:26an absolute disaster. I have a there's a physical nature to games, and
- 31:33only when I've actually played them can I then can I then teach them in
- 31:37any decent way. Right, once I've understood the game mechanisms, then I
- 31:42think I'm Okay, how many times do you play these games before you record
- 31:48your tutory? Good question. I mean it's going to vary from game to
- 31:52game because some of the games, you know, it's a little harder to
- 31:55get your head around what's going on. There's more mechanisms than others. It's
- 31:56it's simpler. But basically, I want to play the game until I don't
- 32:00have any lingering questions. When I'm playing a game to do for a tutorial
- 32:04video, I'm making sort of copious notes to the side about things that were
- 32:07unclear to me, things that maybe your contradictions in the rule book or seem
- 32:09to be mistakes, or things that came up that I wasn't clear on,
- 32:13so I can then ask the publisher about that afterwards, so that all that
- 32:15gets built into the tutorial video, because I figure, if I'm having trouble
- 32:19with it, then maybe there's a good chance someone else is going to have
- 32:21trouble with that too. So yeah, it's rules. What you just said,
- 32:24I think is so valuable for people to understand when they're trying to learn
- 32:29a game and they're beating themselves up because they're not getting it. It is
- 32:34really difficult to get it. From the rule book alone, it's an abstraction.
- 32:37It's not until you have it in front of you, as you said,
- 32:39Ben, and you're moving the pieces around and you're seeing the mechanisms in
- 32:43action, that suddenly it can come to life. And that's one of the
- 32:45things, Listen, that's one of the things I love about rule books because
- 32:47a board game is just a box of stuff. It's just stuff. What
- 32:52brings it to life is that rule book and when suddenly the mechanisms tell you
- 32:55that that little wooden piece as a that you've chopped down and you're going to
- 33:00fashion it into the hilt of your sword and your characters like all that comes
- 33:05from rules. And I know rules are can be boring, can be very
- 33:07dry, but the rules are actually what give the game life. It gives
- 33:12it something. There's some there's some magic when an intellectual concept becomes a concrete
- 33:19thing that releases serotonin in the brain. Right. Yes, that's I think
- 33:23that's why this hobby bit me so hard because I saw that connection that basically
- 33:30we are I wrote this in interview once that basically when we play a game,
- 33:35we're taking a walk through the designer's brain, and that is magical.
- 33:39No, yeah, no, then I think you're exactly right. You know,
- 33:44someone had a vision, idea, a journey they wanted to take you
- 33:45on, and now we get to go on that journey, and there's a
- 33:47sense of self discovery. It's not just that you're going on their journey,
- 33:51because unlike a movie or TV show or something, you're going to have your
- 33:54own experience of it. You're going to be actively tinkering in that world that's
- 33:58been created. And that's that's exciting in its own right. So what the
- 34:00designer could never have conceived of? Right? I love this. I love
- 34:05this idea that the designers are never the best people at their own games.
- 34:08Right, there's always someone who's who clicks with it, and it's never the
- 34:13designer, right, And they can and they can do as many playtests as
- 34:15they want, But the reality is, once you get in front of potentially
- 34:19thousands of people, there's going to be things that happened the designer could never
- 34:22have guessed or imagined. And that's pretty cool too, Right. It gives
- 34:24us some define things that were never even like intended potentially in the design.
- 34:30And so when did when was that moment where you thought, wow, this
- 34:36is my job. Now, when did that happen. I don't know.
- 34:40It did happen though in the early days it was about seeing if it could
- 34:45be and at some point in time it probably did tick over the point of
- 34:46saying, oh, yeah, this is my I can say with a straight
- 34:50face, this is what I do for a living. Now, you know,
- 34:54probably some of the milestones were yeah, that that sense of discovery that
- 34:57I really loved doing it. You know what, probably one of the early
- 35:00things I have to credit plat HAC Games because that was probably the first publisher
- 35:05that I reached out to and said, Hey, I would like to create
- 35:07a video for one of your games. Would you hire me to do that?
- 35:13And they said yes. In that there was a level of legitimacy to
- 35:17that, or this feeling of oh I can I can do something that might
- 35:22be sustainable in the long run. For a long time, Ben I definitely
- 35:24needed and relied on the support of the audience members, just like you said,
- 35:28like in those early days of saying, hey, if you like what
- 35:30I'm doing, would you consider supporting it? And I could not have continued
- 35:35doing it without the superb of my wife, certainly because I was not making
- 35:37a lot of money. In those early days, you know, it wasn't
- 35:40sustainable, I guess, is what I mean. And so it took a
- 35:43long time to build up to being something sustainable. Probably took six years maybe,
- 35:46But in those early days of having publishers, having viewers, having people
- 35:51support it, it really made it a big difference. You know. It's
- 35:53actually one of the principles in the Rodney Rules is I've one of the principles.
- 35:58I've had a lot of help. I'll help my friends in future to
- 36:00be friends when I'm made, you know, just remembering that, like this
- 36:04is you can't do it on your own. Obviously this wouldn't exist if I
- 36:07didn't do something. But I can't do it on my own. There's just
- 36:10no way, right. So it's a big circle with gratitude. Really,
- 36:14it exists at all. Grand Games Guild is Parameter present the Holiday Hyjien's Fall
- 36:20Bundle, packed with three adventures celebrating Halloween, Thanksgiving and Christmas. The Kringled
- 36:24Caper, The Turkey Trial, and the newest title in the line, The
- 36:28Pumpkin Problem are available in this special seasonal bundle to help you get your escape
- 36:32room fix all season long. The Holiday Hyjien's puzzles will test your perception,
- 36:37wordplay, and lateral thinking. There are no repeat puzzles across the three games
- 36:43and no destruction, so you can share the holiday fun when you're done.
- 36:45This is a package that is fascinating. It's a little cardboard thing, it's
- 36:51tiny, and it's an escape room in eighteen cards. I played one of
- 36:54them and I thought it was absolutely fantastic. All the holiday Hygiene's eighteen can't
- 37:00Escape Room games are available now at your flgs on a grand game is guild
- 37:04dot Com. So your next game then, is a fabulous system that I've
- 37:13kind of just discovered in the last couple of years. And this is really
- 37:15beliebrate and so so firstly, why this coin game? Yeah, this is
- 37:22this is tricky choice in a way because today it's not familiar. Coin is
- 37:25a term that stands for counterinsurgency. It's a style of wargame. I am
- 37:30this was an itch like when I first encountered the coin games, it was
- 37:34years ago. It was actually Joel Eddie, my good friend Joe Eddie from
- 37:36Drive through Games. He did a review for Andy and Abyss, the first
- 37:38coin game, and I thought it sounded fascinating, and I bought that game,
- 37:43which was a war game. Think back to those Empires and Arms days.
- 37:45Okay, I bought a war game. I got a home guess what,
- 37:49just like Empires and Arms. But now, of course I'm an adult.
- 37:51Now I'm working through the rulebook. I'm head scratch and it's complicated,
- 37:53and I'm having those same thoughts I had back with Empires and Arms, which
- 37:57is, even if I do figure how to play this, who am I
- 38:00going to play this with that? Yeah? So I packed it away and
- 38:06I got rid of I called it, and it just itched at my brain
- 38:08because I could see there was something in there that I really was drawn to
- 38:12the idea of, like the asymmetric factions. This was before Route and other
- 38:15games that became popularized this asymmetric faction thing. Right. I was doing some
- 38:21work with GMT and they kindly sent me Kubleliever, which was another coin game.
- 38:23So that got to send my shelf, just you know, annoying me
- 38:28again thinking, oh, I don't know that I can. Should I try
- 38:30again? Should I try one of these games again? And Matthew Jude,
- 38:34who's also on the Watch of Play team, he had a copy of kuub
- 38:37Believer, and one day we just sort of said, like, should we
- 38:39try learning this together? And we did. We did a six hour live
- 38:43stream of just working through the rules together. It was kind of like a
- 38:45art performance piece in a way, like of just survival. Can we get
- 38:49through this, you know? But it was really a lot of fun.
- 38:51And the lights started to go on. I'm like, I think I'm starting
- 38:52to get this, you know. And sir, I know I'm laboring this.
- 38:57But it's the games. These coin games have in such a sort of
- 39:00a transformative part of my journey here. Because there was one day I didn't
- 39:04still have all the rules kind of in my head, but I just had
- 39:06it open day and I said, I'm gonna sit with this game. I'm
- 39:07gonna play through a whole game, controlling all four factions and just learn it.
- 39:10And I did. And boy, I tell you something like there's something
- 39:14going on in my brain just firing off. I was loving it. I
- 39:16was like it was that sense of discovery. Oh my goodness, when I
- 39:19do this, it affects the board state this way. Oh and now this
- 39:22faction is going to do this and tug and pull. And so that was
- 39:25Koba Libra and so it really was the Coin game that kind of opened my
- 39:30mind up to it, and I think it's one of the most approachable coin
- 39:32games. Now. There are a couple of other ones that have come out
- 39:35since that I might argue are maybe a little more approachable, but still it's
- 39:37one that I still love playing to this day. I'll play it anytime someone
- 39:42asks. I love teaching it, even though it's a bit of a bear
- 39:44to teach. But yeah, it's a really fascinating system. And being in
- 39:49the hobby as long as I have it's not like ages, but you know,
- 39:52a decade or whatever of this current era of my time in the hobby,
- 39:58it was like rediscovering a whole the thing, which was pretty exciting.
- 40:00You know. It's like a whole new corner of the hobby and rediscovering my
- 40:04roots again, right because of wargames is where I started and kind of got
- 40:07away from. It was like coming back to that in a way, which
- 40:08was pretty fun. And so coin has been the closest to wargames, sort
- 40:17of crossing over into the broader hobby game world. Why do you think that
- 40:23is specifically this system, That's a great question, Ben, You tell me
- 40:28if you agree because it sounds like you've you've been dipping a toe into the
- 40:30coin system as well. I think part of it might be the visuals.
- 40:32There's a certain it has wooden pieces, and when we think of like traditional
- 40:37war games like that Empires and Arms game, it's it's paper mats and thin
- 40:42chits on a hex board type of thing. And this is a nice stylized
- 40:46board with wooden pieces and components. It looks kind of like a euro If
- 40:50you swinted, you'd think, is this a europlaying here? So this is
- 40:53my theory. This is why game wargamers denigrate it and why non wargamers to
- 41:00it. It is cubes. When a Eurogamer sees cubes on a bold there
- 41:06is an instinctive, subconscious reaction that says, I can't play this right,
- 41:10right, I know, I think I think you're right, and something that
- 41:14vocal the designer advocated for right, you know, it was there was pushback.
- 41:19The wargame community was not interested in this coin system, as I understand
- 41:23it. It took a lot of advocating, you know, to get the
- 41:27publisher to stick with this vision, and now it's one of the most popular
- 41:30wargame systems. Out there with all kinds of incredibly inventive That's the other thing.
- 41:35There's multiple games in the coin system, and it impresses me how much
- 41:37variance and how many, how many different ones. I'm still playing new ones
- 41:40that are coming out now, and I'm still being further surprised at how much
- 41:44creative space there is there. So good for Vocal for having that vision and
- 41:46sticking to it, and I think possibly, you know, games like that,
- 41:52plus a lot of the great work that David Thompson and his many creative
- 41:54designers are doing making war games more accessible because there's a lot of I think,
- 42:00a joy to be found in that style of game, but there's also
- 42:02a pretty high barrier to entry sometimes. Sure, absolutely to a degree.
- 42:07I ask every wargame a wargame designer I interview, I ask, but to
- 42:12what degree are the educational pursuits? To what degree do you feel like when
- 42:15you play a war game you're eating your broccoli? That's a good question.
- 42:21I mean, listen, I've never, thankfully never been in war. I
- 42:24doubt that wargame can really give you a sense of the true experience of it,
- 42:30but I think it can teach lessons. I've watched a few war documentaries,
- 42:35and one of the consistent through lines is that unexpected mistakes, flaws,
- 42:40errors can have massive sweeping guides to, you know, the course of war,
- 42:45and I think wargames certainly can show that that the degree of you can
- 42:50do all the planning you want, but there's going to be curve balls,
- 42:52there's going to be, you know, things you can't expect. I think
- 42:55also wargames can tempt you to take us slightly deeper dive. They tend to
- 43:01approach the subject matter with a little more serious seriousness, I would say,
- 43:06And for example, a lot of the Queen games come with a historical document
- 43:08that you can really to learn about the period and you don't have to to
- 43:12play the game and enjoy it. But I have certainly found that I found
- 43:15the experience to be more enriching from doing that. Could Believer, for example,
- 43:19led me to read some books and watch a couple of documentaries, and
- 43:22it gave me a better appreciation for not just the game, but also the
- 43:29lives of the people who lived through this period. You know, I think
- 43:31you can play and be entertained and have fun with it, but I think
- 43:34it's kind of nice when you have a sense of the substance of what's going
- 43:36on during that time. I'm thankful for war games for having sort of contributed
- 43:39that to my gaming experience as well. And I had zero idea there was
- 43:44a Finnish civil war until I played All Bridges Burning and then I was like,
- 43:47oh my god, and this is super interesting too. Right, Yes,
- 43:51I haven't played that one yet, but I've read the rules and that
- 43:53you're right, like you also discover but conflicts and things you didn't even know
- 43:55exist, because of course we get bombarded by certain conflicts over and over and
- 43:59over the world or two being very popular, of course, but you know,
- 44:01you learn about other corners of the world and other places where humanity had
- 44:05struggles over their freedoms and power struggles. It's it's yeah, no, I
- 44:07think I think there's there's a lot to sort of dig in there if you
- 44:10want to in that area. And I think All Bridges Building because it's a
- 44:14three player game makes it a little shorter and makes it a little more accessible.
- 44:19It's the most accessible coin I've played. Think, well, you might
- 44:22enjoy checking out People Power. I am engrossed in it right now. Also
- 44:25a three player coin game, about conflict in the Philippines, and it is
- 44:29fascinating and interesting and I would say perhaps a little more easy to teach than
- 44:34even Kooper Libra. So it might be when you you you want to check
- 44:37out there, when I've when I've played the the two player one that's still
- 44:42sitting on my shelf that I have played yet, Okay, is that the
- 44:46Colonial Twilight? Exactly? Colonial? I need to get out to the table
- 44:51first, fair enough, fair enough, So I want to talk now about
- 44:55what I've called what you played two point two? Okay. Sure, throughout
- 45:00the watch it played channel. You've had other people on the channel. Pep
- 45:06for instance, springs to mind. But there seems to be a couple of
- 45:09years ago when you recruited Paula and Matt and Chazz, a sort of rebranding
- 45:16and an expansion of the channel. Why did you go in that direction?
- 45:22Well, I think you hit on it. You're right, the channel has
- 45:24always had other people. Like the beginning was my kids. It was me
- 45:27and my kids right exactly, Andrew and Luke actively part of everybody out pretty
- 45:30much, you know, and then they grew up and they had vives of
- 45:35their own and busy things, and then you're right. I started working with
- 45:37PEP, and then there was also a partnership period of time there with Board
- 45:39Game Gig and then you know, COVID and everything, And so I've always
- 45:45liked being able to do more than just tutorials and gameplays. I've often done
- 45:50news and updates, videos or conversational pieces and things like that. But I
- 45:54did find, boy, I love making tutorial videos. You know, it's
- 45:58really the focus was taking up a lot of my time, so I couldn't
- 46:00do some of those other things. I wanted the channel to be able to
- 46:04offer. And so Chas is a dear, dear, dear friend of mine
- 46:07and also very creative and has his own internal engine that drives him to create.
- 46:16And having a friend like that and realizing, oh, we can do
- 46:21this together and it won't require me managing something. You have your own internal
- 46:27powerhouse energy ball to like create and design and do everything else. It just
- 46:30we just started talking about what that could look like, and we got very
- 46:32excited about the possibility, and we took a long time, Like before it
- 46:37all happened publicly, behind the scenes, we were making sure that we understood
- 46:39what we were trying to do. There was some concern early on that that
- 46:43two point zero that you're calling it, you know, could turn off some
- 46:45viewers, you know, that this sudden influx of people. Because because Chaz
- 46:49was also working with Matthew and Paula at the time, people I was interested
- 46:52in working with and starting to develop a relationship, we thought, like,
- 46:53we'll bring everyone in together at the same time. And I said to Chaz
- 46:58at the time, because he was a little concerned, like what if people
- 47:00don't like all these new faces because they're here for watch and Play and they're
- 47:02used to you, Rodney, but like they didn't sign up necessarily for all
- 47:05of us. Sure, And I said to them, look, look man,
- 47:07like we could lose twenty five percent of our subscriber base. I will
- 47:12consider this a success because I believe in the long run we're doing the right
- 47:15thing. It won't be for everybody, and that's okay. Like the watch
- 47:20Play has gone through several different stages, you know, of growth and development,
- 47:22and it's not always going to be for everyone along the way. But
- 47:24my hope is that for some people it will be what they're looking for,
- 47:30and enough people will find it and be happy and satisfied with the vision that
- 47:32we have for what we want to do. And it seems like that's been
- 47:36the case, which has been very encouraging because I have I think personally,
- 47:38really benefited from working with other creative people who have their own unique skills and
- 47:45talents. It's helped me, It's invigorated me even in my own process.
- 47:49And so how does it work? Are you the boss then, and to
- 47:52people pitch you things and you yay or nay? Or is it is it
- 47:57more of a what is the word they use in modern in modern business?
- 48:01Horizontal? Oh? I see, yeah, I mean I suppose at the
- 48:05end of the day, sure the buck stops here. Yes, I mean,
- 48:07ultimately I'm responsible for making sort of final calls on things. But I
- 48:13do, I mean, maybe the other team should speak to this over me.
- 48:15I do try to be creator focused, meaning within certain parameters of production,
- 48:21like a certain I want things to look a certain way or be at
- 48:24a certain level. I want you to create in the way that you feel
- 48:29driven by. Like I don't want you just doing a job. It is
- 48:31a job. You know ultimately it isn't work, but I want there to
- 48:35be like this is you coming through because that's what was important to me right.
- 48:38I was just saying earlier, like I want to be reaching to an
- 48:40individual. I want people to feel like they're talking to a real version of
- 48:45me, not just something that's performing on camera. And I saw Paula and
- 48:49Matthew and Chaz as real people. I knew them as real people away from
- 48:52the camera, and I want them to be able to be on camera that
- 48:57way. So, yeah, it's collaborative. Certainly, some things get pitched.
- 49:00We tried to think of things that we can do together er con as
- 49:02a convention that we go to together, and we do that together collectively.
- 49:07There's certain videos we release every month that we all do together, but we
- 49:08also have our own individual things that we do as well on the channel and
- 49:12outside of it, like a number of them, you know, have still
- 49:15like Matthew and paul have their own works that they do. Minik and Nevin
- 49:17who came on and do gameplays with us, also do their own things as
- 49:21well on their own channel, and hopefully it's created a good mix, you
- 49:23know, for them as well. And so I was at Game Night a
- 49:29few weeks ago, and I think he was when we were sorting this,
- 49:31and you sent me a DM on Twitter and I was looking at my phone.
- 49:37I said something about you contacting me, and one of the guys opposite
- 49:42the table went, nah, that's bullshit, and I went, no,
- 49:44no, no, Rodney, send me a message, and he went really,
- 49:47And I showed him and he sort of he had that sort of look
- 49:50in his eyes of wow, that's amazing, you know, Rockey. And
- 49:54so you've become something within this very small world. You've become personality. And
- 50:00if if I say to anyone within board gaming Rodney, I think ninety percent
- 50:06of them are going to know who I'm talking about. How weird is that?
- 50:12Well? You know, I think for the most part, the extra
- 50:16tension that's come from Watch to Play in my work on it has been a
- 50:20positive thing. I mean, there's always negative, but I don't think those
- 50:22neigatives are worth dwelling on because the positive far exceed any any negatives. And
- 50:27I think also the typical energy that's pointed in my direction tends to be relatively
- 50:34positive, not always, but generally speaking. So I feel very fortunate that
- 50:42way. I mean, part of that is by design a little bit,
- 50:44ben I mean, like I said earlier, I'm not interested in being a
- 50:46polarizing figure in terms of, you know, giving opins on games. I
- 50:52remember like sometimes I would listen to a reviewer that I really enjoyed and admired,
- 50:55and if they trashed a game that I really liked, maybe that's a
- 51:00game that I played with my kids and we have all these wonderful memories attached
- 51:04to it, and they're running down the litany of why this game is garbage.
- 51:07Like I couldn't help but feel inside of me a defense mechanism kicking off,
- 51:13like arguing with this person in my head about how wrong they are,
- 51:15you know, And I was like, Oh, I don't know that I
- 51:17ever want to kind of like inspire that kind of feeling in somebody. I
- 51:21want people to be able to enjoy what they enjoy, or if anything,
- 51:23maybe watch it play can help them discover the game that's going to be a
- 51:27good fit for them, or if they buy a game and they're like wrestling
- 51:29with that rule book, ease some of that burden. So in that way,
- 51:32maybe that's helped somewhat. The attention tends to be relatively positive most of
- 51:39the time. So imagine you're a dinner party with people you've never met before,
- 51:47right, and they turn around and they ask you the question, so,
- 51:51Rodney, what do you do? What is your answers to that?
- 51:54I look them straight in the eyes, and I say, I make a
- 51:58YouTube channel to help people discover, learn, and play board games. There
- 52:04was probably a time when I would have felt a little funny saying that.
- 52:08I don't know if it was embarrassment as much as it was disbelief, you
- 52:13know, because I could only imagine in the other person's mind them thinking what,
- 52:20even if they were too polite to ask it, say that outloud,
- 52:22Yeah, I can't imagine any other natural response, and to go, what
- 52:23what did you say? You know, so trying to figure out how do
- 52:27I, like explain this in a way that doesn't go so far under the
- 52:29weeds that their eyes gloss over, but at the same time gives them some
- 52:31context. But now I think, you know, like a YouTube as a
- 52:36profession is not that bizarre, so you don't have to explain that parts so
- 52:38much. And you say board games, And I think board games have grown
- 52:42so much in the last decade that even that's not entirely shocking. I was
- 52:45at to dinner the other day with with the people that I did not know,
- 52:47and it came up and then we started talking about code names and a
- 52:51variety of different games that they were familiar with. Right, So it does
- 52:54make it easier to be sure. So your next game, an is so
- 52:59clover? Why this party game? You know, I I was thinking about
- 53:05this beforehand. How do I explain this to people who have never played it?
- 53:07It's probably a mistake to try, because it's kind of cerebral. But
- 53:10it's a game where you're going to be as a player given four pairs of
- 53:15words, and you have to think of a word to link the pairs together.
- 53:19So you know, I might have a word like like fever and roast,
- 53:22and so I think of a word that might link those, So maybe
- 53:23I write hot. Okay, then those pairs get like shuffled together. No
- 53:30one else sees the pairs shuffle together with like sixteen other words, And now
- 53:34everyone else at the table looks just at what I wrote hot and has to
- 53:37look at all these words and figure out what two words were linked to that.
- 53:40But the thing is, extra words get shuffled in, so like what
- 53:44if the word son ends up in that mix? And so now they're like,
- 53:46well, hot, it's got to be He's got to be Sun he's
- 53:49got to that must be one of the words, right, And there's other
- 53:52like deduction elements to help you anyway. Like I said, it's too hard
- 53:54to explain you you missed a crucial step actually, so tell me which is
- 53:58where you have to take a picture of the initial sets up of words so
- 54:02I remember it when you reset it. You're not wrong. If anyone's played
- 54:07event is absolutely right, you'll create this pattern in front of you. You'll
- 54:09come up with all your clues. You then mix everything together, and then
- 54:13afterwards you're sitting at the table thinking, wait, what are my two words
- 54:15that I tried to I don't remember. But I love that. I love
- 54:20game it's cooperative. I also enjoy cooperative games. I guess that's a similarity
- 54:22with to Mansions of Madness that way, but I do like both. I
- 54:27like cooperative and competitive, but I like that aspect of working together. I
- 54:30think it creates these wonderful moments for feeling clever when you do get figure something
- 54:34out. It's something where you're also talking through. I really like in those
- 54:37deduction games when there's that conversation that happens about why did you think that?
- 54:44Well, this game is all about saying that out loud, like you're hearing
- 54:46what everyone's talking and why they're making the connections they're making, and I really
- 54:51enjoy that and and win or lose, there's just sort of a laughter around
- 54:54that, kind of a joy around that, or or a real frustration,
- 54:58but frustration in a fun way, hopefully when you're amongst good players. And
- 55:01so how representative is this the games you play? Well, you know,
- 55:07actually pretty representative in a way because you know, listen Cooper Labor and coin
- 55:10games. I love them. I play a lot of them remotely and have
- 55:14ongoing games them actively happening all the time. But if I'm getting together with
- 55:19people, especially people that I don't know as gamers, I always bring out
- 55:22the soam clovers or the just ones or I always try to play to what
- 55:28I just make it a soft fall for them, like, you know,
- 55:30because I don't know what they're what their experience is going to be, and
- 55:32I want them to have fun. And there are games that I think are
- 55:37really fun, like a coin game, because it makes my brain sweat.
- 55:40Yeah, there's all that tension, but then there's that kind of fun that's
- 55:44more light, you know, the apples to apples kind of fun or something
- 55:45that's just an easier kind of fun. And so I'm very fortunate, I
- 55:50think then, because my tastes are quite broad, and I think that's been
- 55:53helpful because one of the things I want for Watch It Played is to be
- 55:57something that almost anyone might find a game on there that's an interest to them,
- 56:01and if they do have an interest in so Clover or a lighter game,
- 56:06maybe they'll give another game a try because they see and on watch a
- 56:08play and they go, well, I kind of like that gaming top.
- 56:12Maybe I'll give this one I wouldn't otherwise give a chance. Maybe I'll give
- 56:14it a chance. You know, maybe I discover like I did coin games,
- 56:16Like I discover something that you just didn't even have it on your radar
- 56:19and suddenly rise up this whole world. There was a long time, Ben,
- 56:22I don't know if you went through phases where you know, you only
- 56:23liked a certain style of game and then like like for me, it was
- 56:27Euros did not interest me, and then eventually I played a couple that really
- 56:30did. It's like I discovered a whole new world and now I love Euros.
- 56:32Like, did you have that kind of like phase It's one of those
- 56:36It's one of those weird things, right because I get into this wholeby and
- 56:39I went in because I'm an actor. I went in through social deduction and
- 56:43things like this right, right, because I'm not very bright and I've got
- 56:46a big mouth, so I'm good at social deduction game. And then there
- 56:52was there was one point sort of about a year into gaming, and I'm
- 56:55like, why am I so obsessed with fun Pumpkin? But this is so
- 57:02weird? Right, It's weird? Well it is. It is weird because
- 57:07these are not things, Like some of these themes and games that I really
- 57:09enjoy are not things I would independently pursue to go learn about. But you
- 57:15put it inside the box of the game, and suddenly I'm like, I'm
- 57:17actually very fascinated. I'm going to be playing a game about this thing I
- 57:20would otherwise never like really look into. This is a path in that's really
- 57:23fun. You mentioned social deduction games. That reminds me one I would have
- 57:29battled for this particular position of kind of like a party game would be a
- 57:31game called Don't Mess with Cuthulhu. I don't know if you've played it,
- 57:35yeah, but I really do like that as a social deduction game, one
- 57:37of my favorites. So we're recording this the week of Essen, and when
- 57:43I go through the Essen list, I'm actively looking for the blandest box cover
- 57:46possible because I know it's going to be holding the crunchiest euro inside it.
- 57:52You know, well, I know. Listen. I watched, I enjoy
- 57:55a lot of your your videos, Ben, and I remember you going through
- 57:59I think it was like the board games that made you like, the ones
- 58:01that really like speak to you, and one of those that I think fits
- 58:04the bill of what you just described as Trajan. I don't know if you'd
- 58:07agree. I love Trajan, but I find the presentation of it to be
- 58:10somewhat bland, some somewhat blund is an example of how nice you are.
- 58:16I'm trying, but that's a game that, again, like, I love
- 58:21the game, the mechanisms and and the brain sweats it gives me. If
- 58:24you don't mind that. Something else that just reminded me because thinking about watching
- 58:28that videgrs, you made a video one time that I found really really uh
- 58:31it moved me. It was talking about why you should be writing about board
- 58:35games. That video you made it right, you were talking about, like
- 58:38the joy that one of the three people who watched it, So thanks for
- 58:40you, no, no kidding, Like everyone listening to this, stop well
- 58:45maybe don't stop this, but do do go seek out this this video from
- 58:47Ben because it's really what was inspiring about it is it was that encouragement you
- 58:53were you were cheerleading people to consider putting some of your thoughts down on paper,
- 59:00considered the exercise of what that can do. But it encouraged me because
- 59:02even if you're not maybe someone who's a writer, maybe maybe for you it's
- 59:06video. Maybe for you it's a podcast. Maybe for you it's talking about
- 59:08games or or writing a blog post or whatever that thing is. And I
- 59:12think there can be a real enrichment in that creative process. You know,
- 59:15that was something obviously I felt a compulsion to do. I wanted to contribute.
- 59:20I was, you know in the early days, the twenty elevens that
- 59:22we were talking about when you could watch everyone who was making exactly and I
- 59:27watch, I watched I watched the Dice Tile. That's kind of it,
- 59:30right, yeah, yeah, Like it was Joel Eddie and Marco Ornardo and
- 59:32like that's a lot of those early like you know, but I just felt
- 59:37this something was inside of me I need to get out. I wanted I
- 59:39want to share. I want to share my passion enthusiasm too. I was
- 59:43I was getting so much from what other people were doing. I wanted to
- 59:45give some of that too. And we all have the capacity to do that.
- 59:47If you if you're taking games to a game night or something, you
- 59:52are sharing that passion. So I really appreciated that video that you made.
- 59:54It made me think about the practice of doing that and that that could be
- 59:58really fulfilling. Keep very about, very touching. So I want to talk
- 1:00:01now about your position within this hobby. Okay. And so occasionally there are
- 1:00:09scandals within board gaming and sometimes uh recent example with ai R for instance,
- 1:00:16you you weigh you weigh in on these scandals. Why that's a great question,
- 1:00:25because because going on Twitter and doing anything is is a road to madness.
- 1:00:31It seems to me, Yeah, you're you're kind of taking Yeah,
- 1:00:35it's a bit risky. You'll you'll probably notice when I do weigh in a
- 1:00:38lot of times I'll do it with a little video message yeah, because I
- 1:00:44think it can be it can be difficult to get a full thought across in
- 1:00:47a few words, you know, and I want Sometimes with the video it
- 1:00:51helps give tone to so a person can see you're not saying this with anger
- 1:00:54in your heart. It's like I'm asking questions. I want to know about
- 1:00:57this, or have you considered this? You know. It's it's that sort
- 1:00:59of more kind of prodding thing. I think, I mean, hopefully one
- 1:01:01of the reasons why I weigh in occasionally is because I have maybe something useful
- 1:01:06to say or something helpful to say, I think, you know. The
- 1:01:10challenge with social media then is that it messes with people's chemistry. And if
- 1:01:19let's say I'm having a bad day, okay, and I don't have a
- 1:01:22social media platform, the people who are most going to be affected by that
- 1:01:25is going to be like my wife, my kids, maybe my colleagues at
- 1:01:29work. The people who have more or less signed up to be burdened with
- 1:01:32me are going to have to deal with me when I'm not having a bad
- 1:01:36day. When you have a slightly larger social media platform. Now, when
- 1:01:43you're having a bad day or you're feeling negative and you put that out into
- 1:01:45the world, you're you're messing with a lot of people's chemistry. Like when
- 1:01:50I make a post. Lets you say, I made a post and it
- 1:01:52was just like, I'm having a rotten day, I'm really unhappy today,
- 1:01:53whatever the case may be. Now, that's a very valid feeling to have,
- 1:01:57and to be able to express that is good. But what if somebody
- 1:02:00is reading that, they're going through their feed and they're having the worst day
- 1:02:02of their life. Sure, and this is just one more negative neutron onto
- 1:02:07the pile, and maybe for them it's the camel that breaks the back that
- 1:02:09like man I thought Rodney was, you know, he's having a bad day,
- 1:02:13you know, it just it just adds this extra burden. So I
- 1:02:15try to be as responsible as I can be with how I use social media
- 1:02:21because I have no control over where it's going to go exactly and how it's
- 1:02:23going to affect people, maybe in ways I don't intend, but occasionally I
- 1:02:28do want to try to weigh on things. And I think part of that,
- 1:02:30maybe ben is because in some of the early days, there were situations
- 1:02:37where I probably could have weighed in ways that would have been helpful, and
- 1:02:38I didn't, you know, whether it was maybe some of my other media
- 1:02:43creator colleagues, you know, women or other marginalized members of our communities who
- 1:02:46were trying to talk about things that were of importance to them and things that
- 1:02:51they were being affected in negative ways. And I didn't either understand, appreciate,
- 1:02:55or burn the calories to try. And if I had, I think
- 1:03:01it could have alleviated some of the burden, you know, for for some
- 1:03:07of those people who deserved having some voices of support when they weren't getting any.
- 1:03:12So I think, you know, again, you know, you run
- 1:03:14into this whole problem of if you say something supportive of somebody, then you're
- 1:03:17being a white knight, You're being a virtue signilar And I just reject that
- 1:03:22whole notion. To me, that is okay. So then I guess I'm
- 1:03:27never allowed to be supportive then, because I might get accused of being a
- 1:03:30virtue signialar or something. I mean, I tend. I tend to not
- 1:03:34do it online essentially, Yes, yeah, I do in a public forum
- 1:03:38of line is mine. And that's the thing is. There can be performative,
- 1:03:45right, there can be a person making a performance saying it to show
- 1:03:50to against signal their virtue or whatever, right, but a lot of there
- 1:03:53can be some really negative forces online and I do think sometimes you know,
- 1:03:59these to be a little bit of a voice speaking back to that again,
- 1:04:01hopefully in a way that's productive when it can be. You know. Also,
- 1:04:05also I go from zero to one hundred when it comes to anger,
- 1:04:09So me putting it online is probably not the greatest idea in the world.
- 1:04:12Well, listen, I think that's really that's really wise though, to recognize
- 1:04:15that not everyone has the right temperament either, sometimes for social media. And
- 1:04:18I've seen some other colleagues who have stepped away, and I think it is
- 1:04:23the right thing for them to do, to step away from social media,
- 1:04:26because it winds them so tight or it affects them in a way that it's
- 1:04:30it's unhealthy, you know. And so I was going through Twitter one day.
- 1:04:34I don't really look at it anymore, but I was going through one
- 1:04:36day and I can't remember whether it was a post you did or something,
- 1:04:41but someone someone was steering people away from you because you were and a quoting
- 1:04:47here the center of woke wark gaming. So firstly, firstly, what do
- 1:04:54you think that means? And did you take that as a compliment or or
- 1:04:59you offended? That's an interesting question. I've forgotten about that but now you
- 1:05:03say it, I think, yeah, Like Fred Servil, I think also
- 1:05:06got caught up in that cubbola being accused of being a war war gamer.
- 1:05:11When I hear that, all I hear is jargon, so I don't know
- 1:05:14what any of it means. I don't know the person's trying to say.
- 1:05:17They could be right. If I understood what definition they were applying to those
- 1:05:21things, I might turn around and go, yeah, I guess I am
- 1:05:24that, But I don't know exactly what they mean by that. I would
- 1:05:27suspect by the framing they're trying to be insulting. Sure, they definitely are.
- 1:05:32I can tell you don't have to admit to that world. I'll say,
- 1:05:39I think, uh. Drive by critiques like that do almost nothing to
- 1:05:44my internal psyche. As best as I'm able to analyze that for myself.
- 1:05:47I think I'm fortunate that way, because my wiring is such that I try
- 1:05:54not to take any of that seriously, especially again, a drive by comment.
- 1:05:59I am. I've seen this, and I think this is a thing
- 1:06:02creative struggle with. Ben. You tell me, like you'll hear someone will
- 1:06:06say, like, I got a hundred positive comments today, but I got
- 1:06:09that one negative comment absolutely, like you know, stuck in my crawl and
- 1:06:12that's what I'm thinking about when I go to bed and all that kind of
- 1:06:14stuff. I feel somewhat fortunate that my brain really works in the opposite direction.
- 1:06:23I really do think about the one hundred people, and I go,
- 1:06:28not screw you to someone being negative, necessarily because criticism is important to listen
- 1:06:31to. Like there might be valid criticism, but like this, this woke
- 1:06:33wargame. I I don't think he's trying to be constructive here. I say,
- 1:06:38I can't give that more value. It'd be an insult to the hundred
- 1:06:42other people who have poured something positive and good into my life to listen to
- 1:06:45that. But I think it is important. Like you know, I do
- 1:06:48get negative comments kind of read you one. I actually have one here like
- 1:06:53this. So I got this, and again I share this more as maybe
- 1:06:57a way to help encourage other creators to wrestled with this sort of thing.
- 1:07:00So I got I got this one comment on my wingspan tatorial video. This
- 1:07:03guy is so dry, He's always terrible at explaining. Now here's my favorite.
- 1:07:08I forget which video this came from. I think it was one of
- 1:07:10the tiny epic games. This person's comment said, every time I get a
- 1:07:14new board game, I happened to stumble upon one of your videos to learn
- 1:07:16how to play. Every time, I am enraged at how pathetically bad your
- 1:07:21videos are and ended up learning somewhere else. You are not good at this.
- 1:07:26You do not explain anything well, you are too fast. I have
- 1:07:30come to despise your voice. Okay, so that that pretty good comment,
- 1:07:35right. So one day ago I got this comment from c Rose six and
- 1:07:42here's the comment. When I was first getting back into the hobby into hobby
- 1:07:45games after playing some years ago, I bought my Si Mystics to play with
- 1:07:48my kids. I opened it up and I tried to learn how to play
- 1:07:51from the rule book. All their expectant faces waiting to play the game,
- 1:07:56plus me being completely lost about terms like initiative track was altered in me being
- 1:08:00brought to literal tears. I was pregnant at the time, so there's that.
- 1:08:03I packed it up and regretted buying and trying a game clearly beyond what
- 1:08:06I was up to. I almost gave up on trying anything beyond sushould go.
- 1:08:10Ever, again, then I found this video by Rodney explaining it in
- 1:08:13a completely friendly and simple way, and I tried playing again with the kids
- 1:08:15and we have had fun playing a wide range of games ever since. Because
- 1:08:18I always check if Rodney has a how to play video before buying the game.
- 1:08:23It's thanks to you that my family of seven is now playing games regularly.
- 1:08:26So that comment there from c Rose six nine two, that is that
- 1:08:32is creation fuel for the rest of my life. Absolutely, those other comments,
- 1:08:38I will never give those other comments more weight than that comment from Cerros.
- 1:08:43When I go to bed tonight, I'm gonna be thinking with ce Rose,
- 1:08:45not these other two. I'm not gonna be for everybody. I'm not
- 1:08:47gonna make things that everyone's gonna like. My voice might be aggravating to somebody.
- 1:08:51That's okay. I hope that they find someone else that they enjoy more.
- 1:08:56And hopefully, on balance, I find that there are people who will
- 1:08:59like what I'm doing, and I'll I'll just make things for them, you
- 1:09:01know. So I don't want to be too Freudian about this, okay,
- 1:09:04But to what extent do you think with gaming? You've just found something else
- 1:09:12to evangelize about it? Oh you know what I think? No, Ben,
- 1:09:16I think you you're absolutely right. I think you're absolutely right. I
- 1:09:19mean, think about it. Think about this. So when I was deep
- 1:09:23in Christianity, what's the Bible, big rule book, big rule book?
- 1:09:26Right right? My career was before Watch It Played was I was with the
- 1:09:31federal government of Canada and I've managed policy, enforced policy. Government policy is
- 1:09:38a big rule book, you know. And so now I am teaching games.
- 1:09:41What are board games rule books? I do? There is something in
- 1:09:44me that likes structure, things that are concrete, you know, things you
- 1:09:47can point to and say, this is the way it is, you know,
- 1:09:50and and also being able to share that joy in helping people understand.
- 1:09:56Like even when I was with the federal government, I enjoyed explaining it and
- 1:09:59trying to help someone understand. No, the reason this is the way it
- 1:10:00is is because of X, Y and Z. I know this is complicated.
- 1:10:02Can I break this down so it's less complicated and now you feel empowered
- 1:10:05to understand what's going on here? And same thing in games like it won't
- 1:10:10work if we're all playing by a different set of rules, right, but
- 1:10:13when we play a game, we all agree temporarily despite our belief systems and
- 1:10:16everything else, to come together and agreed by one set of rules and abide
- 1:10:19by them. And when it falls apart, generally speaking, is when someone
- 1:10:21chooses not to right. And and that's so, I think you're right.
- 1:10:26I think there is something in the evangel evangel Oh gosh, that word evangelic.
- 1:10:30Lookasizing, evalizing, evangelizing, thank you, evangelizing. There's definitely something
- 1:10:36to that and that joy of like helping someone else find something that then they
- 1:10:40find fulfilling. Yeah. So your next game then is I think the only
- 1:10:45game that I sold and then it gnaweded me so much that I have to
- 1:10:49read buy it. I've done that, and this is and this is Ashes.
- 1:10:54So where where does Ashes rank in the pantheon of dueling car games?
- 1:11:00For me? And again again with my caveat that all this is very subjective,
- 1:11:04but at the top, it's my favorite card dueling game. There are
- 1:11:09things about that I really really enjoy. One of the things I love about
- 1:11:12It's really simple thing is the principle of first five, which means you pick
- 1:11:16your opening hand of five cards. They must all be unique cards, but
- 1:11:19you decide, so you've built this deck, You've got a strategy that you
- 1:11:23want to employ, you're still going to have plenty of randomness. The whole
- 1:11:27deck has been shuffled, but your first five cards you decide what they are.
- 1:11:30I think that's a really powerful piece of agency to give a player,
- 1:11:33to let them start the fundamentals of whatever they're imagining their deck's going to be
- 1:11:36able to do. I think that's really really cool. I love the resource
- 1:11:41system of the game, the dice that you roll that you can mitigate the
- 1:11:45randomness there. The actions that you take are also a resource, and every
- 1:11:47time you do something, you're exhausting items, and I think that's awesome.
- 1:11:51I really like the way it's packaged and sol I like that it's an LCG.
- 1:11:55I do enjoy sure, opening up a blind booster and seeing what's inside.
- 1:11:59I enjoy that sort of like a this is gonna sound dismissive. I
- 1:12:01don't mean it to be, but then like that childlike wonder of like what's
- 1:12:04in here? You know. I don't think it's nestly childish, but I
- 1:12:06think appeals to some element of me that likes a surprise. Right. But
- 1:12:11I'm now at a point in my life where I know that I want to
- 1:12:15have the thing I want to have I'd rather just pay for it. I
- 1:12:16don't want to chase it and open a bunch of things. And Star Wars
- 1:12:20Destiny I really enjoyed, but after I collected my fifteenth Jedi Robe card,
- 1:12:27I was like, I don't like this is not fun. It's not fun.
- 1:12:29I don't enjoy this part of it. So I like this an LCG
- 1:12:32model, and I like that when you buy a pack, you're not buying
- 1:12:35a pack, You're buying a deck. Yeah, you're buying like a fully
- 1:12:39playable deck that you can then break apart to put another decks. But you've
- 1:12:43got a whole new character and a whole new deck to play. I think
- 1:12:45that's awesome. And sorry I'm gushing, but I also love that they've got
- 1:12:48this cooperative solo mode now red Rains. I just finally tried it recently,
- 1:12:53and I thought it was excellent, like a really interesting, challenging solo play.
- 1:12:58I just played it over and over and over or over yet, and
- 1:13:00I don't often get a chance to do that. I just couldn't walk away
- 1:13:02from it. So yeah, I love I love every I think that the
- 1:13:05visuals of it are very appealing. I'm glad that you came back to it.
- 1:13:08I hope you've had a chance to enjoy it a little bit. I
- 1:13:10know, like I can't get the competitive game played. I just don't have
- 1:13:14that time in my life or space for it. But the solo player I
- 1:13:15have been. So if you haven't tried the Red Reins, i'd recommend it.
- 1:13:17Oh, I should absolutely. Yeah. So so I understand you're going
- 1:13:21to be biased, but so, okay, plant had got taken over by
- 1:13:27asthma DAE, right, and then well it got taken over t D and
- 1:13:30eventually after yea, And there was a part of me that was irrationally happy
- 1:13:41when Colby got the company back. Me too, because it felt to me
- 1:13:46that they kind of lost something in their acquisition. And so you've worked with
- 1:13:51them for years now, what is unique about them as a company? Would
- 1:13:57you say? Well, you know, I think there is something very indie
- 1:14:00about them that's very appealing. You know, it's it's it's not that large
- 1:14:05companies can't create amazing, creative, beautiful games. In fact, larger companies
- 1:14:10sometimes have the resources to be able to do things that smaller companies can't do
- 1:14:12that are also magical. But you know, Kolby started with a personal design
- 1:14:15some rewards that he loved. He found a way to self publish it,
- 1:14:18and he just kind of grew from strength to strength, but also was on
- 1:14:23his own journey. I suppose in the same way. Like I mean,
- 1:14:25part of what I feel is that plat hat kind of maybe like you and
- 1:14:29I been, we all kind of started around the same time. Yeah,
- 1:14:31and so we're all part of the same kind of class, graduating class.
- 1:14:34In the heart, I agree with you they were that they were one of
- 1:14:36the first board game podcasts I listened to. It was The Plate, Right,
- 1:14:40So there is something about watching them on their journey. I've made mistakes
- 1:14:44on my journey. They've made some mistake there's growing pains, there's things that
- 1:14:46you learn. And I did feel like Colby rebuying back his company it made
- 1:14:54me feel really good because I it's like you. I felt there was some
- 1:14:57maybe some missteps. There was some like getting along in the shuffle of a
- 1:15:00larger company. I'm sure they gained certain resources, certain things were taken off
- 1:15:04of their backs, like preparing for cons and other things, but some of
- 1:15:10the personal touches that they would have otherwise taken care of are now being managed
- 1:15:13by let's say, a faceless company more or less, right. And one
- 1:15:16of the things about I think plat Hat Games is they've always invested a lot
- 1:15:23of themselves into the games that they make, you know, So so I
- 1:15:27think, yeah, I think that's that's something that makes them special, and
- 1:15:29it's something that always has me rooting for their success. And I feel like
- 1:15:31we have seen that return to form in their games, you know, like
- 1:15:34Freelancers. I think is fantastic that just the other week complained it and I
- 1:15:40hadn't played. I hadn't played Forgotten Waters, so I wasn't familiar with the
- 1:15:43system, and I played Freelancers, and I thought it was infinitely charming,
- 1:15:47super interesting and kind of unlike anything else on the market, right, agreed.
- 1:15:53I agree. I feel the same way. And it felt like very
- 1:15:56much like a plat Hat game. It's me absolutely the whimsy and and everything
- 1:15:59else. So I'm glad you enjoyed it. Yeah, And for all of
- 1:16:01its all of its carbuncles and it's sort of clunkiness, I think City of
- 1:16:05Remnants is wonderful. Listen, same thing. You know they did a re
- 1:16:10release of it? What was it? I did jatori ovide for it?
- 1:16:13Neon Gods, which was a basically bringing back but taking off some of the
- 1:16:19rough edges. I like Neon Gods. I only do tutorials for games I
- 1:16:24like. I don't have to love them, I have to like something about
- 1:16:26them. But City of Remnants almost in its crunchiness, there was like there
- 1:16:30was like when I first played it, there was thinking about it, like
- 1:16:32something about this isn't quite working. It was an early design of Isaac's.
- 1:16:35Yeah, Isaac is a brilliant designer, and I love Isaac. This is
- 1:16:39a designer of ashes, but he was learning a lot of things, and
- 1:16:42I think that was like an early design of his. But there was all
- 1:16:45the makings of a great designer in that design. Yeah, So I want
- 1:16:50to talk about the future. So what is the future of what it played?
- 1:16:57I don't know. There are periods of time in Watch a Plane's Life
- 1:17:01where I would have a clear answer for that, where I know, oh,
- 1:17:04here's the next thing that I am doing. I would say, right
- 1:17:10now, I'm in a very production heavy period of the show where I'm focused
- 1:17:15on what's like just one foot in front of me right now. And what
- 1:17:18usually happens is once I get caught up to a certain amount of production.
- 1:17:23I come up for air. Cha As will say this to me every now
- 1:17:25and day, says Ronnie. When you come up for air, the things,
- 1:17:28the ideas you have, it's like your whole new person kind of thing,
- 1:17:30right, And it's true. I do. I kind of air and
- 1:17:32I start to have a vision. I start to see kind of what the
- 1:17:34next thing is, the next idea. And I'm not the only one on
- 1:17:38the team. Other people have visions and ideas for things too, But generally
- 1:17:41speaking, right now, I'm in a get things done mode. It's that
- 1:17:45time of year or two, like we're in a convention heavy area. There's
- 1:17:48a lot of releases, suitutorials are coming fast and furious, and as we
- 1:17:53head into the Christmas season, that's probably around the time I'll start to be
- 1:17:56imagining what the next evolution is for the show. She said to me that
- 1:18:00you've sort of abandoned the idea of designing games. But there's a little tickle
- 1:18:06at the back of the brain about maybe publishing. Is this just a passing
- 1:18:11fancy or are you thinking about it in a serious manner? No, I
- 1:18:15am thinking about in a serious manner. I'm thinking about setting a bunch of
- 1:18:18money on fire. I think I fear that that's what it's going to be.
- 1:18:24But I've always been curious about so I make tutorial videos about games,
- 1:18:30I make videos about board games. I would like to be inside of it
- 1:18:32a little more. I'd like to understand a little more that part of the
- 1:18:36process about production. I think that would be really educational thing. I'm not
- 1:18:40going to do something let's say, stupid is not the word, but maybe
- 1:18:44that is the word. I'm not gonna do something too risky. We're going
- 1:18:46to probably try to publish a small box card game just to sort of learn
- 1:18:50what that looks like. Do a small print run. So if we make
- 1:18:55a mistake in terms of shipping or something, we're not gonna like. I'm
- 1:18:58not interested in doing some like crazy fifty thousand unit thing because if we make
- 1:19:03a mistake, the impact of that will be huge. I'd rather make a
- 1:19:06mistake and have the impact of it be small. So I assume you like
- 1:19:11having a house, right I do. I like having a home, and
- 1:19:14I like people liking watch it played, and I feel like this could be
- 1:19:16a great way to burn all the capital, you know, if you don't
- 1:19:20run a campaign. Well, So we are looking at at licensing a design
- 1:19:26that's that's out of print right now and possibly bringing it back and putting our
- 1:19:29own little touch on it, which will give us a chance to explore art
- 1:19:32and rule book writing and the production side of it. And so yeah,
- 1:19:36we're serious about it. We're waiting for the ink to drive. We'll see
- 1:19:39if we get the license agreement signed. That's kind of a stage rat and
- 1:19:43then we'll go go from there. So I guess keep an eye out.
- 1:19:45There might be some announcements on that, or there might not. It might
- 1:19:46not, it might fall through, and that's fine. If it does well,
- 1:19:48we'll maybe look somewhere else. So I assume you're not giving me a
- 1:19:51scoop, then I'm not. I'd rather not, just because nothing's been signed
- 1:19:56yet. I think if something I've been signed, I would be happy to
- 1:19:59sort of tease it, but I don't want to. I've done this before.
- 1:20:01I've teased things, even when it comes to like a tutorial video I'm
- 1:20:04going to do, and then scheduling changes, and then for the rest of
- 1:20:08my life I'm answering comments about what about that totals And you said you were
- 1:20:11going to do for Ben Stars, and I still answer your questions about So
- 1:20:15I've learned to keep a few things close to the chest. So when you
- 1:20:19think about the sort of I guess it's a decade now of doing of doing
- 1:20:28this, and you I think, yeah, you look back to that,
- 1:20:32you know that first play through mention some madness, and you know you now
- 1:20:36have a set, and you have a career and you have a group of
- 1:20:43people who work on your channel and all the things you've achieved along those lines.
- 1:20:49How proud does that make you feel? And we know pride is a
- 1:20:55sin, but I will assume you're allowed to feel it. Then you're not
- 1:21:00wrong. Like there's some part of my brain that resists saying I'm proud of
- 1:21:03it, you know, definitely, Like confessing that out loud gives me pause.
- 1:21:09It's in my wiring to resist that. So I will I will resist
- 1:21:13it. I will say this. I feel very fulfilled. I feel very
- 1:21:16fortunate. I get to do something that gives me a great deal of satisfaction.
- 1:21:23It's not always fun, as you can imagine, you know, when
- 1:21:26you're because a lot of like what I do is alone here in this basement,
- 1:21:29talking to it. It works work at the end of the day,
- 1:21:31right when I'm staring down the barrel of detroial video and I'm sitting there and
- 1:21:35I'm delivering a paragraph for the twentieth time because I'm having trouble coordinating my words
- 1:21:40and my actions with a thing like that's not fun. But when I'm done,
- 1:21:45there's a feeling of fulfillment and satisfaction and feeling like I'm doing something that
- 1:21:48maybe maybe is contributing something positive to a hobby that I love. And it
- 1:21:54has brought friendships into my life that I would not otherwise have had. It's
- 1:22:00given me the opportunity, Ben to talk to you, someone who's work I've
- 1:22:02admired, Like we get to have this conversation. My day will be fuller
- 1:22:05better because of this conversation. That's a that's a real gift. I feel
- 1:22:09very fortunate about that. So, yes, I'm proud of it. It
- 1:22:15greasy, Yes, yes, So you last game that is comeback, come
- 1:22:19onand to Europe. All right. People who are into wool games tell me
- 1:22:24I need to play this why. It's like people are really into television will
- 1:22:29tell you have you have you watched the Wire yet? I can I can
- 1:22:32corroborate you need to watch the Wire yes, absolutely from season five. Season
- 1:22:36five is rubbish, but well it's you know, it was tough. It
- 1:22:40was a shortened season, but boy, that was a That was a great
- 1:22:43show. Okay. Combat Commander of Europe was a was a more recent discovery
- 1:22:47for me as well. I've had it for a while. No. I
- 1:22:49played it once at a convention with a friend who knew the rules and taught
- 1:22:51to me. And it was like one of those again, almost like playing
- 1:22:56that coin game for the first time. It was a really rich experience and
- 1:23:00not at all what I expected because visually, again we're talking paper mats,
- 1:23:03thin, cheapy kind of looking chits, you know, and again one of
- 1:23:06these thick looking rule books, war game rule books. And so I got
- 1:23:11a copy of it with the hopes of returning to it, and it took
- 1:23:13me a long time to get to the table. I had a friend who
- 1:23:15had a real interest in it and who was willing to play it remotely with
- 1:23:17me, and so we worked through the rules and we learned it and we
- 1:23:20started playing it. And once we started playing, we just could not stop.
- 1:23:23Scenario after scenario after scenario after scenario. What is it about that game?
- 1:23:27I think? For again, appearances doesn't necessarily look like much more than
- 1:23:33paper and bits of chits. Is there's so much life inside of that game.
- 1:23:36Ben like that there's a narrative element, unexpected emergent narrative. Going back
- 1:23:42to I talked about how like you know, you realize that you've watched Band
- 1:23:45of Brothers or you watch other these shows, these depictions, you realize just
- 1:23:48how fraught those situations are and how things can change on a dime, whether
- 1:23:53it's weather or something faulty, the radio getting conked out, whatever the case
- 1:23:58may be. And this has all of that happening inside of it, and
- 1:24:00you're constantly dealing with those random elements across a variety of different designs and incredible
- 1:24:04design space. And for a complicated wargame. Chad Jensen was somebody the designer
- 1:24:10who attempted where a lot of war gamers don't do a very good job of
- 1:24:14attempting to teach you the rules. In a lot of wargame rule books tell
- 1:24:18you the rules, they don't teach you the rules, and that's a very
- 1:24:21big difference. Chad Jensen tried to teach the rules in his rule books and
- 1:24:25making it well. I think it's a wonderful thing with the coin games,
- 1:24:28especially well, the ones I've played that have the playthrough book that takes you
- 1:24:31through a round of the game and you play from the rule books have a
- 1:24:36kind of idea how the game works. Right, Yeah, Kobligra is a
- 1:24:40great playbook that way. Yeah, exactly, And so so yeah, I've
- 1:24:44I've found it to be really again one of those games that when playing it
- 1:24:47just really excited me and made me excited again for the hobby. I've never
- 1:24:51My enjoy for the hobby has never diminished, I would say, of anything,
- 1:24:55it's probably more so than it ever has been. But it's wonderful to
- 1:24:58be this far and like we say, like twelve, if I get this
- 1:25:00sort of like the major part of the hobby and still discovering and finding new
- 1:25:03things and new joys, it's a delight. And this is one of those
- 1:25:05delights. So my definition of theme in games is that you feel like you're
- 1:25:13doing what you'll write to be doing. Right, I'm not gonna be farming
- 1:25:16or it can be shooting out in a Western saloon, but you know,
- 1:25:20and there's an inevitable abstraction, but you feel like you're doing that. Does
- 1:25:26this game give you that. Yeah, I think it does because it it
- 1:25:30has you at a more personal level. You're kind of at a squad level,
- 1:25:34you know, it's a little bigger than that. But the pieces represent
- 1:25:36that you have sergeants, corporals, like individuals, you also have like squads
- 1:25:41as well. And the scenarios give you a sense of place as well.
- 1:25:45They describe the situation what like narratively and historically what was going on. And
- 1:25:49then as you're playing the Magic of the Deck, you don't roll dice in
- 1:25:56the game. You draw cards in the deck and the deck has dice in
- 1:25:59the corners that basically tell you here's the values. But not only that,
- 1:26:01they trigger potential events on the cards, and so you'll be firing into you
- 1:26:08know, you walk into it a building that you know it's empty because there's
- 1:26:11no chits, there's no like fog of war. There are games, I
- 1:26:13think the version of that did, but this there's no fogg of works.
- 1:26:15You walk into the building, but then due to a card flip, turns
- 1:26:18out there's a sniper that just shot at you type of thing. And now
- 1:26:20you're like down in this building and you're thinking, well, now what I'm
- 1:26:24gonna do and this this was not something in the plans, it's not in
- 1:26:26the cards. It's just sort of random thing that the deck did to you.
- 1:26:29And there's lots of these little moments that just sort of bring the tension
- 1:26:31to life in the game. And it also causes wonderful tipping point. You
- 1:26:34can be in that game feeling like I'm just gonna lose, I'm gonna lose,
- 1:26:36I'm gonna lose, and something will happen to change the tide and put
- 1:26:40your right back in it. It's it's I don't know how to explain it,
- 1:26:43because there's a certain amount of randomness that I don't enjoy in games.
- 1:26:45This has a certain amount of randomness in it. But boy do I love
- 1:26:48it. I love it. It just keeps everything on a knife edge all
- 1:26:51the time. I'm sure there's I'm sure there's it's possible to play a game
- 1:26:55of that that's not very satisfying. I have yet to have that happen.
- 1:26:58So and I'm I don't know, twelve I think to the game. So
- 1:27:01Chad Jensen passed away a few years ago, and I love one of his
- 1:27:08games, Dominant Species. I think it's absolutely spectacular. I'm ashamed to say
- 1:27:12I haven't played it. It is I mean, it's a wargame, but
- 1:27:16using worker placements is its medium of deployment. It's it's absolutely spectacular, and
- 1:27:21people tell me Combat Commander is one of the best war games ever made.
- 1:27:25How much of a loss do you think he's been to the gaming world.
- 1:27:30I think I think huge. You know, even though Dominant Species is a
- 1:27:35well known game of popular game A love as other games were sat in the
- 1:27:38war game library, which isn't as doesn't that maybe as broader reach, so
- 1:27:43people might not recognize. But I think I think Chad Jensen, maybe similar
- 1:27:47to David Thompson in a way, is somebody who was interested in finding the
- 1:27:53common ground between some of the more niche aspects of the warriam hobby and those
- 1:27:58of us who maybe aren't as drawn to that or would like a path in
- 1:28:00that isn't quite so challenging as some of the war games present, And I
- 1:28:03think he would have continued to build on that, and I think he would
- 1:28:06have enjoyed where war games were going and found new ways to apply his touch
- 1:28:11to it. I haven't played Dominant Species, but it's one I hope to
- 1:28:13play. I have dominant Species Marine. I just Combat Commander had such a
- 1:28:18singular impact in terms of like my enjoyment of games again way back in the
- 1:28:21day when I first played it, and now the enjoy on having here.
- 1:28:25I wish I could have told him that just what his games meant to me,
- 1:28:29and it was wonderful. His wife sent me a message after I talked
- 1:28:33about Combat Commander and the impact of that game, and she said, Oh,
- 1:28:36Rodney, Chad would have loved hearing that. We used to watch your
- 1:28:39videos together. And that broke me, Like, I just just that connection
- 1:28:43that I didn't realize I had with somebody who'd meant something to me and something
- 1:28:46I'd done maybe it had meant something to him that was really really meant something
- 1:28:50to me. And it makes me, I think, enjoy the game all
- 1:28:53the moore, you know. So one more question for you. Okay,
- 1:28:58So you're heading out a Prince Edward Island. That's correct, isn't it.
- 1:29:00Yes, that's right. Yeah, yeah, yeah, you're heading out to
- 1:29:03Prince Edward Island to the cabin and you're hairing down the road. Did you
- 1:29:06go around the corner and the back door of the car flies open? Four
- 1:29:11of the games fly down a ravine. I'm sure you're replete with ravines there.
- 1:29:15It falls down a ravine into a river, and it's swept away to
- 1:29:18posterity. Which game, to your hope, is sitting on the back seat
- 1:29:20of Look, I mean, PI is pretty flat. It probably went into
- 1:29:24a ditch. I could probably retrieve those games. But let's say I was
- 1:29:26really on a tear, I'm going to I think this is a tough choice.
- 1:29:29Then you asked, was it difficult to pick the games? No,
- 1:29:31to pick the one to hang on to a little more challenging. I think
- 1:29:34I'm going to say Calmbat Commander Europe. I think right now, if someone
- 1:29:39has depressed me, I would say that it is my favorite game. That
- 1:29:42does not I want any listeners. That's not an endorsement. You know,
- 1:29:45you should assess this game to see if it's something you would enjoy, because
- 1:29:48it's quite an investment to get into. But what I've gotten out of it
- 1:29:51has I just think it's a game I'm going to continue playing for the rest
- 1:29:55of my life. Through the different scenarios, there's just loads and loads of
- 1:29:58those, and so it's a game I'd like to continue. Worry like that
- 1:30:00with somebody. Yeah, I think that's so brilliant. So if people want
- 1:30:03to if people I caught about you, and anyone listening to this doesn't know
- 1:30:09where you are. But if they, if they aren't, where can they
- 1:30:11get hold of you? Where can they see your work and all of that
- 1:30:14good stuff? I'd be happy to tell them. So most of our videos
- 1:30:16are posted on YouTube, so YouTube dot Com, slash watch it Played.
- 1:30:20As far as social media goes, you find them pretty much all the platforms
- 1:30:24like Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, as watch It Played, and Blue Sky.
- 1:30:29I have a Blue Sky account. I haven't say I do, and
- 1:30:30I see no purpose in it. I try to actively. It's it's difficult
- 1:30:34to make that migration when you've sort of been in one place for a long
- 1:30:38time. But I think I'd like to make that migration. So it might
- 1:30:41be Blue Blue Sky. That might be one I have heard. There's more
- 1:30:44and more board gamers starting to become active over there, so maybe this is
- 1:30:46the right time. Then maybe we should give it a shot. I don't
- 1:30:49know. Well maybe excellent. So Rodney Smith, thank you very much.
- 1:30:54This was a real pleasure. Ben. Thank you for being patient with me
- 1:30:57so we can make this happen, and I hope absolutely. It's only been
- 1:31:00five years, Rodney, so no worth the wait. I hope I really
- 1:31:05enjoy this. Ben, Thank you so much. You can support the show
- 1:31:09in many ways. You can tell your friends, you could talk about it
- 1:31:12on social media. You can talk about it in your own blog, podcast,
- 1:31:15or video. You can support it directly by going to Patreon dot com,
- 1:31:17forward slash five gfd for a rolling donation, or for a one off
- 1:31:20donation hitting the PayPal link at the bottom of the website five Games for Doomsday
- 1:31:25dot com. It's these donations that keep the show going. Also, if
- 1:31:29you want to say something nice about the show, if you want to say
- 1:31:30something horrible about the show, you can contact me on Twitter at five Games
- 1:31:34for Doomsday or send me an email at five Games for doomsdaygmail dot com.
- 1:31:39And if I managed to leg it from The Hammer, Horrors and the Cats
- 1:31:43Made out of Toes, I'll see you in two weeks for another five Games for Doomsday