Latest / Bad Decisions Podcast / #48 The Art of Cinematography: Inside 'The Creator' with Oren Soffer
Transcript
- 0:00If you had a dollar for every time someone asked you about the
- 0:02Sony FX3 on the Creator, how much money would you?
- 0:05Have. I wouldn't be rich, but I could
- 0:07buy a few FX threes. This is Oren Sofer, an
- 0:12award-winning cinematographer who recently shot the feature
- 0:14film The Creator. The film was on the short list
- 0:17for Best Cinematography at the Baptist and was nominated for
- 0:20two Academy Awards. Oren has also shot dozens of
- 0:23commercials and music videos for clients like Avicii, Nike, HBO
- 0:27and many more. People need to realize is that
- 0:30this was an $80 million studio film.
- 0:32If the FX3 cost $50,000, we would have shot.
- 0:36We wanted to go to a village in Thailand and just take out a
- 0:39camera and start filming. We wanted to integrate real
- 0:41people, almost kind of documentary style, and create a
- 0:44world for the film that felt grounded and real.
- 0:47Was there any shot that you guys took that couldn't be tracked?
- 0:50I mean. It's incredible work.
- 0:52The team should have won the Best Visual Effects Oscar.
- 0:55There's so many more AI models coming out, so many more people
- 0:57using them. I want to know where you stand
- 0:59on this. I am very much in favor of any
- 1:01tool and any technology that makes a workflow more efficient.
- 1:05What I cannot get behind is. I'm going to take it all the way
- 1:09back. I want to know what did you do
- 1:11right in your life to be the man you are today.
- 1:14Oren, welcome to the Bad Decisions podcast.
- 1:16Hey, happy to be here. Let's make some good decisions.
- 1:21Yeah, come on. It's supposed to be about the
- 1:23bad decisions, man. It's like the name.
- 1:26Right. But why not learn from the bad
- 1:28decisions so that we make good decisions in the future?
- 1:32Exactly. That's the whole point.
- 1:34That's the whole point. I mean, we talk about this
- 1:36sometimes with the guests. The whole idea of the name was,
- 1:39you know, a lot of the things that you do in your life, they
- 1:42start as bad decisions, 'cause people around you always tell,
- 1:44yay, don't do that. That's not good.
- 1:46You know, Don't. Don't quit school, don't take
- 1:48this job. But it's always going to turn
- 1:50out well if you know what you're going after, if you believe in
- 1:52yourself. So that's the whole idea behind
- 1:54the bad decision. 100% cause ultimately bad and good are just
- 1:58subjective. It's everything is just a
- 2:00decision and we have to trust our gut.
- 2:01This is the biggest thing I've learned and so you know a bad
- 2:05decision for one person is a good decision for another.
- 2:08It's all, it's all It's all a matter of perspective.
- 2:12I love that. I love that.
- 2:13You know what? For Bad Decisions Intro, one day
- 2:15I'm going to cut this up and put in the intro so people know why
- 2:17Bad Decisions was there. Use that as your promo, but I do
- 2:20need 10% of every future podcast.
- 2:23Oh, man, we should have talked about the content.
- 2:25We have our lawyers here. Come on.
- 2:27Listen, we should have. See, you're a professional.
- 2:29I forgot about that. See, we're learning from bad
- 2:30decisions right now. That's the first bad decision
- 2:34made on this. Podcast.
- 2:34We lost 10% already in the beginning.
- 2:38Well, Oren, it's it's great to have you here, man.
- 2:40You know, you're an amazing cinematographer.
- 2:43You know, we watched the creator and we, we've been following
- 2:45some of your work. Now we stalked you a little bit
- 2:47as well on Instagram. See all of your posts and
- 2:50there's so much to learn from and there's so much to talk
- 2:52about today. But I've got to take it all the
- 2:54way back because, you know, clearly we want to learn from
- 2:57your journey. Let's talk about when you were a
- 3:00teenager, perhaps. And I want to know what did you
- 3:02do right in your life to be the man you are today?
- 3:06How was it like being young or in in in college?
- 3:09Maybe, well, college? I don't feel like I was that
- 3:17young when I was in. College.
- 3:20I was already an adult. I was like, you wanna go back
- 3:22and take it back to childhood? I think there's there's.
- 3:25Well, you know, I gotta say one thing.
- 3:27Sorry to interrupt. If you wanna take it all the way
- 3:29back, if you think that's the best place to begin, please,
- 3:32you're more than welcome to do the stuff.
- 3:33Well, yes, on the day I was born.
- 3:39Picked up a camera and started shooting well.
- 3:41Yeah, so I I I think the, the the The thing is is the reason I
- 3:45would take it back further is because by the time I got to
- 3:47college, I already knew what I wanted to do.
- 3:50Wow, So that's amazing. So, so my desire to pursue a
- 3:54career in film and even specifically cinematography was
- 3:57already fully formed by the time I got to college.
- 4:00So all the steps that that I took in order to get to that
- 4:04place where I was arriving at, I went to NYU film school, Tisch
- 4:07School of the Arts and I went to film school and I I already knew
- 4:12I wanted to to to make films and work in the film industry and I
- 4:15loved movies and I I loved cinematography.
- 4:17So I already knew all of that by the time I got there.
- 4:20But the steps that I that that I followed in order to get to that
- 4:24place started earlier for sure. And I think my interest in
- 4:28filmmaking really started when I was maybe like eight or nine
- 4:34years old. I mean, I think, well, you know
- 4:38at that age I wasn't thinking about about acting on
- 4:42filmmaking, but I was interested in the filmmaking process and I
- 4:46and and I was actually just taking a trip down memory lane
- 4:50the other day, 'cause I have, I have my photo albums from around
- 4:52this time and when I was nine years old my family took a trip
- 4:57to California and we did well, we we did all of the state.
- 5:02But the formative part happened in Los Angeles because I
- 5:06remember, and I have the photos to prove it, visiting Universal
- 5:10Studios, doing the studio tour and the stunts show and the
- 5:15special effects show and all that stuff.
- 5:17And then going to the Chinese Theater and seeing the hand
- 5:19prints and that was I think the the start.
- 5:23Like by that point I was already interested not just in movies
- 5:27but in how movies were made and like the behind the scenes and
- 5:30the people who made them and starting to get an understanding
- 5:33of that. I don't think I still connected
- 5:35the dots that I could do that, but at the very least I I
- 5:38started showing the interest in that and then in middle school,
- 5:43by the time I was, you know, 12/13 by that point, my friends
- 5:50and I were making little movies on mini DV camera or it actually
- 5:55wasn't mini DV, sorry, it was just a a camcorder.
- 5:58So it was like it was a digital magnetic tape, like off the
- 6:04shelf, just it was my dad's camcorder.
- 6:07And I remember, I mean we did music video recreations.
- 6:13I wish I had all this stuff. I wish I scanned it.
- 6:16We we recreated Red Hot Chili Peppers music videos.
- 6:20It was all lo fi like. Did you ever see the movie?
- 6:23Be Kind. Rewind Michelle Gondry.
- 6:25I haven't seen that. I haven't seen.
- 6:27That terrific movie. So one of the concepts in that
- 6:30movie is that the characters in the movie, the premises that I,
- 6:34I don't actually remember the plot details, but they run a
- 6:37video store and all the videos are taken away.
- 6:39So they have to recreate all of the movies in their video store.
- 6:43But odd with no budget, so they call it.
- 6:45It's such a cool concept. It's great.
- 6:47It's hilarious. It's a Jack Black great movie,
- 6:50underrated. And so they call it sweding.
- 6:52So they're sweding the movies and so the whole movie is them
- 6:56just recreating classic films with zero budget, like with
- 7:00cardboard and and you know, miniature car chases and and
- 7:05like shitty costumes. So anyway, we This was before
- 7:10the movie came out. This movie came out by the time
- 7:12I was in college. But when I was 10 years prior to
- 7:15that, my friends and I were Sweeting movies already.
- 7:19We were doing low, but no budget.
- 7:21I mean, it's not even low budget.
- 7:22It's literally like. No budget, No because.
- 7:24It's just we were doing it with stuff that we just had around
- 7:26the house, like we weren't like buying things or investing
- 7:30money. We did like Matrix parodies and
- 7:35we would recreate music videos, Red Hot Chili Peppers music
- 7:38videos, and we were editing in camera, 'cause we didn't have
- 7:41editing software or or or a computer.
- 7:43So you would shoot your, you know, a shot of somebody and
- 7:48then cut and then turn around and shoot the other.
- 7:50Shot and. Then cut and then turn around
- 7:53and shoot that go back to the other one so that when you then
- 7:55rewound the tape and press play you would watch the whole thing
- 7:59in in order. So yeah, that, that, that those
- 8:02were the early days and I think it's sort of just grew from
- 8:07there. We had, I was very lucky, very
- 8:10lucky. We had a filmmaking class in
- 8:12high school and. Oh, that's amazing.
- 8:15Yeah, and I was still pretty cheap and and pretty low FI
- 8:18compared to what what it would be today 'cause this was in
- 8:212003, I'm aging myself right now.
- 8:25And so we did not have state-of-the-art equipment.
- 8:27We did have A1 mini DV camera that we all had to share.
- 8:31But so the the the technical quality was not high but that
- 8:37was my first exposure to fundamental concepts of
- 8:40filmmaking. Wide shot, medium shot, close up
- 8:43telephoto lens. Wide angle lens like different.
- 8:45You know all the all the basics. And at that point I was also
- 8:49inhaling filmmaking books, which I also I still have on my shelf
- 8:54the five CS of cinematography and directing shot for shot.
- 8:57These are all the staples. And so by the time I graduated
- 9:02high school and was getting ready to go to college, I
- 9:04already knew by by the time I got to the end of it, I was like
- 9:08filmmaking, cinematography. This is what I want to do.
- 9:11I'm, I'm, I'm dead set on it. So, you know, college, I, I view
- 9:15less as a discovery period and more as the start of my
- 9:18professional career. Really.
- 9:20And other things were still pretty low fi in college too,
- 9:23don't get me wrong. But it that it definitely was
- 9:29the the idea was fully formed in my head by that point pretty
- 9:32much. Were your family supportive of
- 9:35the idea of going to the art school and persuading
- 9:39cinematography? They were, and I'm very grateful
- 9:45for that and very thankful. I know that that's not the case
- 9:47for for for a lot of people, but you know, I I think I would
- 9:52describe them as skeptically supportive like that's.
- 10:01A good category? They they they definitely were
- 10:04supportive fully. But I think we're also just
- 10:10skeptical and and also just didn't really know what an
- 10:14actual career would look like. You know how does one actually
- 10:17make money doing this and how does one you know create
- 10:22something sustainable. And I I think, but the the most
- 10:25excited my family ever got at at up to a certain point.
- 10:30Obviously now they understand of course.
- 10:33Yeah, come on if. They're still skeptical.
- 10:36Then there's if. They get it now, they get it,
- 10:38they get it. But in the early years, you
- 10:40know, it takes time to get things going.
- 10:42So in the early years, the most excited they got was when I went
- 10:48back to I I took a teaching job at at at Tisch and as an adjunct
- 10:54professor this was for about two years just to make money while I
- 10:59was pursuing cinematography. And I think that that was the
- 11:03happiest they had been up until a certain point.
- 11:05They're like a, a teacher, a a an adjunct professor, a teaching
- 11:09job. This is great stability,
- 11:14guaranteed income. You know the I have a lot of
- 11:17professors in my family. So they they they they
- 11:20understand that job. So yeah, that was, yeah, that
- 11:26was many years ago. I mean, at this point they
- 11:27really do understand it, but. Let me let me ask you a question
- 11:31then, talking about the bad decision, right.
- 11:34I'm sure when your parents or maybe your friends at the time
- 11:37were skeptical, you might have also had those thoughts where
- 11:40you were thinking to yourself, is this going to work out?
- 11:43Are you? Am I sure about this?
- 11:44Of course you said that at A at an early early age you knew this
- 11:48is the path you wanted to follow.
- 11:49But everybody has doubts, of course, at different times.
- 11:52I wanted to know if that occurred to you as well, those
- 11:55doubts, and how did you overcome them when people were skeptical?
- 11:59Well that's a great question. I I I don't think I I didn't
- 12:03have any doubts at the time, at least not when you're going into
- 12:07school. I mean film school in hindsight.
- 12:11Also it's funny part of this I I can I can recognize now that
- 12:15part of this is an illusion that is intentionally created by film
- 12:19schools. But they're really designed for
- 12:22you not to feel skeptical or or or worry really about anything
- 12:26going into it. I mean the film school is
- 12:27designed to be encouraging and and and and and a positive
- 12:32creative environment and like you know, really make you
- 12:35believe that you can accomplish anything.
- 12:37And I definitely drank that kool-aid at the time and you you
- 12:41know you go into it without a care in the world.
- 12:43Like you don't really think about what does this look like
- 12:45professionally, what does a career look like.
- 12:48What are the steps I need to take them to school.
- 12:50I think for better and worse really insulates you from
- 12:55thinking about that, at least up until maybe, you know, your
- 12:58final few months in senior year. And even then they only do a
- 13:02very basic job at really at at trying to expose you to what,
- 13:08you know, a career would look like.
- 13:09They keep the experience very pure and very creativity, focus
- 13:13and learning focus, which I actually do think is the right
- 13:16thing. I think that's correct.
- 13:19But yeah, so at the time you're not really thinking about it.
- 13:22I think the the worry and the the worries about how is this
- 13:27going to go and what do I need to do and is this was this the
- 13:29right thing? And and and all that comes after
- 13:32you graduate from film school, not during and not before.
- 13:35You know, it's once you graduate and then you're, you know a year
- 13:38out, two years out, still trying to understand like am I doing
- 13:43the right things? Am I taking the right steps?
- 13:46Am I making the kind of progress that I want for myself?
- 13:49That's the hardest period I think is is and if you don't go
- 13:53to school, which a lot of people don't go to film school which is
- 13:55totally fine. It's still the same thing like
- 13:57that early period of the career. Once you've made the decision,
- 14:01making the decision is easy. It's then getting through the
- 14:04the lean years as as as I call them and and many, many people
- 14:08call them. That's the hard part.
- 14:10That's the real test. Wow.
- 14:13How did you navigate those first few years right after finishing
- 14:17the college? I mean it you know it's it's not
- 14:19easy and I think you you you take it day by day and you focus
- 14:27on the positive and you focus on the projects that you do that do
- 14:32come across your desk and and and you focus on the things that
- 14:35are within your control and and it's very easy for me now in
- 14:40hindsight to look back and say that because at the time it's
- 14:42not that easy to act on this advice.
- 14:44It's very easy to get distracted by comparison and anxieties
- 14:49about am I doing enough. Am I doing the right things.
- 14:52Am I meeting the right people am I making the right choices.
- 14:55And I think all of that is normal and it's a normal part of
- 14:58the process. But I think the only way to
- 15:00navigate it is one step at a time and and and not wavering in
- 15:05your confidence in yourself and I mean at the end of the day
- 15:10this sounds kind of glib but there's a truth to it You I
- 15:14navigated and and I'm sure other people do as well because I
- 15:17don't have a backup plan Like I, you know, there's nothing
- 15:20there's nothing else. I I don't really have another
- 15:22skill set. I mean I have a bachelor's
- 15:24degree in film production Like that's not going to get me a job
- 15:27anywhere else. I was never good at math.
- 15:29I don't really have you know I I can't go into engineering or
- 15:32anything technical. So this is kind of all I can do,
- 15:37so I guess I really don't have a choice but to keep going pretty
- 15:41much. Listen, it that's that's that's
- 15:42a fantastic thing. I mean, I think it was Arnold
- 15:44Schwarzenegger who said it. I hate plan BS.
- 15:47There's there's no point having a Plan B because you're always
- 15:49thinking about falling back and having a safety net.
- 15:52Of course it's good to sometimes, depending on the
- 15:56case, play it safe. But more often than not, I feel
- 15:59like it's better for you to just go all in into what you believe
- 16:02is right for you and try to make that work, because otherwise
- 16:05you'll regret it. And in this case, I mean, you've
- 16:07done a fantastic job and I want to, I want to get a little bit
- 16:10more specific with that. Wait, listen, did you know that
- 16:13you can create highly photorealistic scenes with
- 16:15photogrammetry by taking in what exists in the real world into?
- 16:193D We've been using Polycam to do exactly that using our phone
- 16:23and drone. Yes, that's right.
- 16:25And guess what, they sponsor this video to give you guys 30%
- 16:29off their pro plan. So you guys can go ahead and try
- 16:31it for yourself. Use the code that decision in
- 16:34the link in the description. You did mention how during film
- 16:37school they did prepare you creatively, but not necessarily
- 16:40for how to get the jobs right after, you know how you navigate
- 16:44those roads. So what was the exact thing that
- 16:46you did? Were you actually working at the
- 16:48same time that you were in film school?
- 16:50Or were you just focusing on the projects?
- 16:52And then after film school you only realize, oh shit, now I
- 16:54need to now I need to get myself into a project.
- 16:57How did that look like? Yeah, pretty much.
- 16:58I mean the transition. So one advantage of film school,
- 17:02especially NYU and I can only really speak to Tish NYU, I I
- 17:06can't really speak about other film schools.
- 17:07But what what was really great about NYU TISH is that the
- 17:11entire program is designed in a way that gets you as a freshman
- 17:17in front of upperclassmen. So there's a lot of
- 17:21encouragement because there's so many projects that happen at the
- 17:23school, which is unlike some other film schools where there's
- 17:27a selection process of which films get produced.
- 17:30At NYU, anybody who wants to direct a film can direct.
- 17:33And every class has 250 people. So in any given year there are
- 17:39literally hundreds of student films being produced at the
- 17:43junior level and the senior level.
- 17:45So all of those films need crew. And the way the school is really
- 17:48set up is it sets, it's set up to encourage lower classmen,
- 17:54freshmen and sophomores to crew on upperclassmen films.
- 17:58And that way A gaining onset experience on student films and
- 18:03B meeting upperclassmen who by the time we are now seniors,
- 18:08they've already graduated and they're already working in the
- 18:11real world. And so it creates basically a a
- 18:14a constantly lowering ladder where the people who graduate
- 18:19then start working on various projects outside of school,
- 18:26let's say as cinematographers. So for example there's some
- 18:29cinematographers that that I would I would have pulled focus
- 18:34or second a seed or or gripped, even though I was terrible at
- 18:37gripping on their student films when they were seniors and I was
- 18:42a freshman or a sophomore. So now by the time they are out
- 18:45of school they're now working professionally at the early
- 18:48stages of the of their career. So lower budget project, smaller
- 18:52things and they're hiring seniors or recent graduates to
- 18:58come on to those projects to crew to be focus pullers and do
- 19:02the same thing. So that way the latter keeps
- 19:05lowering and so the the the transition if you've sort of
- 19:09played your cards right and if you have gone on student films
- 19:13and worked on student films and met upperclassmen there, there
- 19:17is a nice transition out. So.
- 19:18So when I graduated there was this a a pool of working
- 19:22cinematographers and again these were kind of smaller low budget
- 19:26projects music video here a lot of web series where we're going
- 19:31at the time like there was a this was this was right during I
- 19:34guess we were kind of lucky with this timing.
- 19:36This was right during what's called the the the pivot to
- 19:39video bubble where in hindsight it was revealed that Facebook
- 19:44was cooking the numbers. I don't know if you guys know
- 19:46about all this, but every online media company was encouraged by
- 19:51Facebook and other platforms to pivot to video.
- 19:54Everybody was like, text content is out, video content is in,
- 19:58everybody needs video. YouTube is surging.
- 20:01YouTube monetization just started like this was new and
- 20:05and Facebook video was like. Facebook watch was huge.
- 20:08The numbers were crazy. And then later everyone found
- 20:11out that the numbers were being inflated but by Facebook.
- 20:15But at the time everyone was pivoting to video.
- 20:18So I was doing shoots for like Bon Appetit, Weight Watchers,
- 20:24bunch of other like online publications basically that
- 20:27were. I mean now it's quite common
- 20:29that everybody has a little video component, BuzzFeed and
- 20:32this and that. But at the time it was new and
- 20:35all of this was for the web and it was very cheap.
- 20:37I mean these were like shot on DSLR S, really small crews, not
- 20:41great pay, so perfect jobs for just out of film school kids,
- 20:47you know College Humor was doing a lot of stuff at that time.
- 20:50So there was a lot of work there and a lot of.
- 20:56So I had a few cinematographer mentors basically when I was in
- 20:59school that I had worked for that would then hire me on as an
- 21:02operator or focus puller. We did a bunch of stuff like for
- 21:06two years I had a fairly regular gig with somebody for Maybelline
- 21:11and once a month we would do makeup tutorials for for
- 21:14YouTube. So again, this is like pretty
- 21:17dry content, but it was work and it was a way to make money while
- 21:22I was pursuing my own cinematography opportunities at
- 21:25the time which were also low budget, various web series and
- 21:29and music videos and a few spec commercials, low budget stuff
- 21:35and and a couple of features as well, very low budget features
- 21:40and short films. So all of that just kind of
- 21:43continued in the years after and it definitely took a few years
- 21:47to kind of find the footing and find a way.
- 21:49Like at that time I think the hardest thing to figure out is
- 21:54you're doing all these kind of low budget or amateur projects
- 21:57and you and and the the thing that feels attainable but just
- 22:02out of reach is OK. But how do I take this up to a
- 22:04professional level? Like how do I, how do I shoot
- 22:07the the professional stuff that I see other people doing Like
- 22:10and I what meanwhile I'm here with a 5D, you know shooting
- 22:14makeup tutorials like how do I bridge that gap.
- 22:16That's so that's that's a tricky thing to kind of figure out how
- 22:19to get past and and that's the one that the only way to cope
- 22:23with that is just having that that belief in yourself and that
- 22:26faith that with enough time and patience and perseverance and
- 22:32continuing to just do good work and and improve and and learn
- 22:35and grow as an artist that you will get to that place the the
- 22:39the path will reveal itself and it did.
- 22:42So I guess I was right but it's it's it's a tough thing because
- 22:47there are no specific steps that you have to take.
- 22:50I mean, it's like everybody's journey is a little bit
- 22:52different, but you just sort of have to have that somewhat blind
- 22:55faith in yourself, even if it feels naive or if it feels
- 22:59delusional at times. Like, you just have to believe.
- 23:02I mean, I know it sounds corny, but like, I think it's true.
- 23:08No, I I love that the way you described it was amazing.
- 23:11And I know so many people feel that way not just specifically
- 23:14in your industry but in other industries as well.
- 23:16And I I want, I think Farrah might agree with me here.
- 23:18While you were talking about the education system that you were
- 23:21in, I found a a really exciting contrast that I want to talk
- 23:24about which was the way that the education systems was set up in
- 23:28where you studied. It helped people find a network
- 23:32where you would use that network after you graduated and help
- 23:36each other out, get better jobs and work as a team.
- 23:38Because we have a lot of 3D artists watching this channel
- 23:41and listening to the podcast and sometimes you talk about
- 23:43education and the people that come on the podcast say you know
- 23:46what. For example, if you want to
- 23:47become a 3D artist, you know the the traditional way of education
- 23:51is not really that important. You can learn things much
- 23:53quicker online. The software's update all the
- 23:55time and so it's much quicker for you to learn that way and
- 23:58you can find your network online.
- 24:00But now that I think about it in your industry, like if you want
- 24:03to be a cinematographer, it helps so much to follow the path
- 24:06that you did specifically because of the network, right,
- 24:09because of the amount of people that you find you cannot.
- 24:12I I assume finding all of the people that you met in school
- 24:17online would be much more difficult And so it's it's
- 24:20invaluable what you've gathered in in in film school in my
- 24:24opinion. Yeah, I mean The thing is is, is
- 24:26film making is still an in person activity for the most
- 24:31part. And so it a major component of
- 24:35it is, is interpersonal relationships.
- 24:39And not just not just, you know, 'cause you could have
- 24:41interpersonal relationships online.
- 24:42I mean even just this, like we're talking and and and
- 24:45interacting and meeting each other.
- 24:47But it's different because you have to physically work together
- 24:50in a space, right? And so it's not just about
- 24:53interpersonal relationships, it's about group dynamic, it's
- 24:56about physical interactivity, meeting people in person,
- 25:01working with people in person like online.
- 25:03I mean it's certainly possible and I do know people who didn't
- 25:06go to film school and who launched their careers online
- 25:09and through Instagram and through self being self-taught
- 25:12and all of that is completely valid and very possible.
- 25:15I would say. I agree.
- 25:16I think it's probably harder for this exact reason because it's
- 25:20still it's hard through that way to kind of prove what your show,
- 25:24what you're like in person and ultimately filmmaking is an in
- 25:27person activity. So at some point that will that
- 25:31does have to translate and and many people find a way.
- 25:35But I I reckon it probably is harder.
- 25:38Yeah. And it's and and whereas with 3D
- 25:40artists or editorial or post or graphic design or anything like
- 25:44that, it's different because those are jobs that especially
- 25:50nowadays are very much conducted online anyway.
- 25:54Like even you know we worked with ILM on the creator and even
- 25:58a big post house like that. Most of their work is remote now
- 26:01anyway. Like it just because of the
- 26:04pandemic and all sorts of other things like you know people have
- 26:07realized like well why why do we you know any that type of office
- 26:12job. I mean film filmmaking isn't an
- 26:14office job. Like being on set being in
- 26:15production is very different. Whereas post is kind of similar
- 26:19to an office job. Like you go to a physical space
- 26:22and da da da and people realize you know the value of being at
- 26:25home and being with their families and not having to
- 26:28travel and being able to work from anywhere.
- 26:30So I think like as time has gone on those jobs like 3D and and
- 26:35and VFX and all that like it becomes a lot more comfortable
- 26:38to do that like this. And so that also opens up new
- 26:43opportunities for people who are self-taught or are just at home
- 26:47somewhere, you know, which is great.
- 26:49And but filmmaking, filmmaking is different.
- 26:54Production is different, I guess I should say because production,
- 26:57you got to be somewhere physically with other people.
- 27:00So yeah, I do agree. I think the network part is is
- 27:03massive. I think that's really
- 27:04everything. And and I do know people who
- 27:07managed with it without it. I mean I have AI have a buddy
- 27:10who he never went to film school.
- 27:13He showed up in New York City one day with the, you know, 22
- 27:18pennies in his pocket and basically started walking around
- 27:21the streets and knocking on the doors of production trucks and
- 27:26introducing himself and offering himself as APA.
- 27:28And and now he's a cinematographer.
- 27:31He's working. He's a working cinematographer.
- 27:33So, you know, just goes to show like some people just have the
- 27:37gumption and have the ability to like do that without anything.
- 27:40And I really admire that. I don't know if I could do that,
- 27:44but it's cool that somebody has succeeded that way, you know?
- 27:48Wow, I love that. You mentioned that early days of
- 27:51your career, especially after school, you were working on
- 27:55projects, but you were looking at the future where you wanted
- 27:58to take those professional job or let's call it the high budget
- 28:02feature films. When was the first moment that
- 28:04you realized that? OK, I moved past that step, and
- 28:08now all the patience and the perseverance really was worth
- 28:11it. And I made it.
- 28:13I don't know if I've reached that moment yet.
- 28:16Oh man, come on. I don't know if I've reached
- 28:18that moment yet, because the honest truth is that the the
- 28:22goal, the goals, the goal posts, they just, they keep moving.
- 28:27So, so each each milestone. I mean, I distinctly remember my
- 28:33mom visited me in New York like one or two years after
- 28:37graduation and we were sitting at a diner in New York and
- 28:42talking about career and everything and how things were
- 28:44going. And and I told her then I was
- 28:48like, I just really remember this.
- 28:49I was like, I'll be, I'll be satisfied when I can reach a
- 28:53point where I'm making enough money from cinematography that I
- 29:00don't have to do any other jobs in in throughout the course of
- 29:03the year. I can just make money from that.
- 29:06Like that's the goal that I'm trying to hit.
- 29:09And the first year that I accomplished that was 2018, 20
- 29:16or 2019. Sorry, 20/19 was the first year
- 29:20that I only, I didn't do any other set jobs.
- 29:24I didn't camera operate. I didn't, I wasn't a camera
- 29:27assistant. I had left my adjunct job at NYU
- 29:31and from January 1st to December 31st, my only income in the year
- 29:362019 was from cinematography. So I I achieved that goal.
- 29:40But now The thing is is when you get to 2019 and I've done that,
- 29:45you get to the end of it and now you're like, OK this was cool,
- 29:49this was great. But my my goals already moved
- 29:53because now it's like I want to shoot bigger commercials, you
- 29:56know, and I want to join the union and I want to shoot union
- 30:00commercials and I want to big get bigger budgets and and and I
- 30:04want to shoot a studio movies and all of these things, right?
- 30:07So, you know, now cut to I've done all those things.
- 30:12Yeah. You know and I.
- 30:14Where is it now? I shot a studio movie.
- 30:15So now it's like OK well I've shot one studio movie and I was
- 30:19a coaster. So and now I need to shoot a
- 30:24solo studio movie and I need to continue this the the momentum
- 30:29of that, you know, and make sure it doesn't slow down and I still
- 30:31have all these goals and commercials that I haven't done.
- 30:34So the the the point is is that I think I think those I think
- 30:39this is a good thing by the way because I think this is the
- 30:41motivator this is what keeps you going is like there's always an
- 30:45ambition to kind of reach for something that's a little bit
- 30:49further and and stretch and challenge yourself in that way.
- 30:53But I do think it's important, and I I've definitely fallen
- 30:56into this trap before and I'm I'm being trying to be better at
- 30:59not. It's important to look back and
- 31:02acknowledge the things that you have accomplished up until that
- 31:05point, 'cause it's easy to forget that and then only focus
- 31:08on what you don't have yet, you know, and the aspirational side
- 31:12of it, which is good as a motivator.
- 31:14But you, you do have to look, remind yourself to look back and
- 31:18appreciate how far you've come so.
- 31:20Well, I I really love this mentality.
- 31:22This is a winner mindset. When you don't really stick to a
- 31:26goal and stay stagnant after you reach something, you are aiming
- 31:30for a bigger goal and every year and every quarter you're looking
- 31:34for something bigger. And I think that really shows in
- 31:36your career how you can move forward, how to can, how you can
- 31:39take bigger project. I think that's an amazing
- 31:41mindset to have for anybody, not only in in this industry but in
- 31:45any industry. Yeah.
- 31:46And by the way, I think there's a potential trap with the
- 31:50mindset because if it's focused only on bigger and on growth, at
- 31:55some point it, it stops. You know, at some point you
- 32:00reach the peak and then you're like, well, where does?
- 32:03It but does it what do you. OK that's that's that's that's
- 32:07actually quite interesting because I feel like maybe you
- 32:09can always set something higher as long as the goal is not
- 32:13monetary. Right.
- 32:14Because monetary I feel like at some point, yeah.
- 32:16You're like OK, I already have enough, right.
- 32:18I've, I've already gotten everything I want.
- 32:19But in terms of career, do you think there is a peak?
- 32:22Do you think there's always something new to learn?
- 32:25Yeah, I mean I guess I'll yes and I'll use like I'll use Greg
- 32:28Fraser as an example here because obviously I've worked
- 32:30with him and and all that. So you know and I'm not speaking
- 32:33on his behalf. This is more just as an outside
- 32:36observer. So I don't actually know how he
- 32:38feels about this, but this is just me speculating and using
- 32:41him as as an example. You know, Greg over the last few
- 32:44years won an Oscar. He's shot the biggest movies,
- 32:49He's shot Dune, The Batman, Dune, Part 2, etcetera.
- 32:52Like that to me is, is the peak. Like you're operating at the
- 32:57highest level of cinematography, right.
- 33:00So, So then if once you reach that point, let's say, let's say
- 33:04where I'm sitting right now, I look at that and say, well, in
- 33:0614 years I want to reach that point.
- 33:10OK. So let's say I, I, I get to 4850
- 33:13and I'm there. I still have 20 more years left,
- 33:16at least in my career. So.
- 33:18So then the question becomes where do you go from there and
- 33:21that's why I think the the sole focus on growth is has a limit,
- 33:26it has a ceiling. So what's more important is
- 33:29continuing to stay curious and interested.
- 33:32I think and and again I can sort of just speak from as an
- 33:36observer from Greg is like where you go from there is you now
- 33:39start to look for at different things like what what is
- 33:43challenging me, what is something I haven't done yet.
- 33:47You know maybe once you reach that point where you're doing
- 33:50massive blockbuster after massive blockbuster after
- 33:52massive blockbuster, the new challenges, can I go back and
- 33:56shoot like a small indie film, you know, but but now with all
- 34:00of the experience that I have, 'cause I think that would be
- 34:02really interesting cat, you know, so the budget is going
- 34:05down to a super low budget movie and or you know, I don't know
- 34:11that's what I mean is it's it's like it's hard to imagine what
- 34:13that is until you get there. But the point is, is it's less
- 34:16about, it's less about growth from a size perspective and more
- 34:22about growth from a depth perspective like how do I deepen
- 34:27my artistry, my interest, my chat, you know, challenging
- 34:32myself and that kind of thing. And I think that maintaining
- 34:35that and having constantly moving goal posts in that regard
- 34:39is really important because the the, the, the what the what this
- 34:41is, is it's sort of like you know it's not imagining it as a
- 34:45mountain where you kind of get to the top.
- 34:47It's more about like a pathway and it's it's a, it's a it's
- 34:52winding and it's complex and it's sometimes it goes uphill,
- 34:55sometimes it goes downhill, sometimes it goes left and
- 34:57right. But the important thing is to is
- 34:59is to always find some new thing to try to to to reach towards.
- 35:04And it doesn't necessarily need to be up like I think that's I
- 35:07think that's sort of the fallacy is is is that the idea of
- 35:11constant growth can lead to stagnation.
- 35:14And I I think that that's something I want to avoid.
- 35:17But as of right now, I definitely have growth ambitions
- 35:20'cause I feel like I've it's not.
- 35:23Time to go down, not right. Now, not yet.
- 35:26Right now, like next 10 years, all the way up.
- 35:28It's up. It's up.
- 35:29Yeah, So that's the goal. You know when, when that
- 35:32happens, when you talk about, I don't know, in 10 or 15 years,
- 35:34we're gonna have another episode of the podcast, right?
- 35:36Episode 2000 something and we're gonna talk about you're at the
- 35:40peak now, you're at the peak now.
- 35:42What's the next challenge? I feel like I I mean, I totally
- 35:45agree with you. That's why I even brought up the
- 35:47point, because I feel like some people do this, like some actors
- 35:50try and give a go at writing or directing, you know, they
- 35:53completely switch the roles. I feel like whenever you feel
- 35:57stagnant or when you said the growth becomes a trap, the best
- 36:00thing you can do, if you're really good at what you do and
- 36:02everybody respects you, it's time to go and do something.
- 36:05Maybe you're not respected in, right?
- 36:06Because you you're you're you're weak again, right.
- 36:09And as humans, I feel like that's a very strong emotion to
- 36:12push you to learn something new, because that's those are the
- 36:16moments where I think life is most fun.
- 36:18And you suffer the most as well. Of course, because no one thinks
- 36:22you're good, you're probably shit at it.
- 36:23And especially at an older age, it's more difficult to have that
- 36:26feeling because again, you've already gained that respect over
- 36:28the years. But it's, I think, a very
- 36:30special power to be able to humble yourself once again at
- 36:34different levels in your life, to take on a whole new challenge
- 36:37where you're not good, and then you become good at that too.
- 36:40And then that way you'll you'll become this wise old person
- 36:43who's done multiple things in their life.
- 36:45I feel like that that would be the way I want to.
- 36:47I want to live my life at least. Yeah, I I, I I relate to that.
- 36:52It's awesome. I I don't know about Farhad.
- 36:55I wanna talk a little bit about the Creator.
- 36:56Or do you have anything you wanna talk?
- 36:58About before first start, how did Oren get into the creator?
- 37:02So. So what?
- 37:02What was? Yeah, yeah, yeah, what was that?
- 37:04How did that happen? Well it it's it's actually the
- 37:06not a very interesting story but basically you know I I had met
- 37:10Greg Fraser who was my Co cinematographer on the Creator
- 37:15many years ago and and for anyone listening who maybe
- 37:18doesn't know even though I already mentioned Greg has shot
- 37:22the Batman Dune part one and two.
- 37:24Rogue One Lion Foxcatcher Zero Dark 30 bunch of just incredible
- 37:31incredible movies and and so I've I've looked up to him for a
- 37:35long time admired his work had a chance to meet him and get to
- 37:40know him and and sort of become acquainted and and then over the
- 37:46years he kept tabs on on my work.
- 37:48I would send him new work and we had a bit of a kind of
- 37:51mentorship going on unofficial and yeah I kind of out of the
- 37:55blue he called me for this because he was looking for a a
- 37:58Co cinematographer to bring on because he wasn't going to be
- 38:00able to do the whole project. So Gareth Edwards was the
- 38:05director of the creator also directed Rogue One and Greg had
- 38:09worked with Gareth on Rogue One. So they were working together on
- 38:11this project looking to bring on an additional cinematographer to
- 38:15to to fill an availability gap because of Dune Part 2.
- 38:19So yeah, it was purely logistics, but Greg had been
- 38:23keeping tabs on my work and my growth over the years.
- 38:25And I think obviously I'm very flattered and honored to to have
- 38:30been thought of for this and to have been brought onto it.
- 38:33And they, you know, they really kind of gave me this opportunity
- 38:36and and and yeah, and and that's that's really it.
- 38:41OK, so before we get into the details I want to ask you some
- 38:45like a really fun question if I wanna so this is something
- 38:50because me and fairer have been discussing this.
- 38:52I just wanna know how much money would you have if you had a
- 38:55dollar right? For every time someone asked you
- 38:58about the Sony FX3 usage on the Creator?
- 39:02How much money would you have? Like how rich would you be right
- 39:04now? I could buy.
- 39:05I wouldn't be if I had a dollar for every time it came up.
- 39:08I wouldn't be rich, but I could buy a few FX threes.
- 39:15So The thing is, I I mean, I know, I mean you even mentioned
- 39:18it yourself, right. This is a very interesting topic
- 39:20for the the general audience because they haven't seen things
- 39:23like that. And for you guys what I found
- 39:25interesting was through some of the interviews that that
- 39:28decision was made not because of the price tag of the camera, but
- 39:32because you guys thought it fit the the situation well.
- 39:35So maybe, you know, before we get into the nitty gritty, I
- 39:39think it's best heard from yourself of why you guys went
- 39:42ahead and chose that that camera because again, a lot of people
- 39:44think it's because of the price tag alone.
- 39:47Yeah, yeah, yeah. I mean, I think people need to
- 39:50realize is that this was an $80 million studio film, so we could
- 39:53have shot on whatever camera we wanted.
- 39:56And as Gareth has said in past interviews, if the FX3, if that
- 39:59camera cost $50,000, we would have shot on it.
- 40:04Because it wasn't about the price.
- 40:05It was about having a small, tiny little camera with a tiny
- 40:11footprint that we could use that would influence having a small
- 40:14crew so that we could be nimble and on our feet and shoot the
- 40:18movie in the way that Gareth wanted to.
- 40:21Which was all about creating a a small footprint and a fast
- 40:26working pace in order to be able to shoot on location in remote
- 40:30locations in Southeast Asia, mostly in Thailand, and create a
- 40:35footprint of production that felt very guerrilla and very
- 40:41immersive and very organic and very authentic.
- 40:45Where? Because the issue with the big
- 40:47machinery of filmmaking is that the more big machines you have,
- 40:52the more the the easel, the more easily things start to feel
- 40:56artificial. And what Gareth wanted was
- 40:58authenticity. And he wanted to go to a village
- 41:02in Thailand and just take out a camera and start filming.
- 41:05We didn't want to set up lights. We didn't want to bring in
- 41:08actors besides our our main actors.
- 41:11We wanted to integrate real people, almost kind of
- 41:14documentary style and create a world for the film, science
- 41:17fiction world that felt grounded and real.
- 41:20So that's what the camera was for was to because the minute
- 41:24it's so funny how quickly the knock on effects of having
- 41:28bigger equipment is. And I just mean by physical
- 41:30size. Like the minute you have a
- 41:32bigger camera you need a bigger truck to transport it, you have
- 41:36more cases, more boxes and you need more crew to support it.
- 41:40Every one of those decisions has a knock on effect.
- 41:43Even just moving it from one place to the other takes more
- 41:46effort and more time than a smaller camera.
- 41:49I know it sounds so silly and obvious to say that out loud,
- 41:52but that really is what went into the decision.
- 41:57And yeah, the FX3 was just the right camera at that time that
- 42:00was capable of delivering the image that we needed because we
- 42:03needed a high quality image to be able to put the film in
- 42:05theaters and you know it got an IMAX release and all of that.
- 42:08So needed a high quality image that in the smallest and
- 42:12lightest weight possible camera body and that was the FX3.
- 42:18Actually, I have a very important question that just
- 42:20popped up. Who has the final say on what
- 42:24camera has to be used for the film?
- 42:26And I want to know because especially now that you had this
- 42:29experience and how much it's affected, you know, the the
- 42:32magic in the film moving on to the next films, is this
- 42:35something you're going to recommend?
- 42:36You know the people you're going to work with that you know, not
- 42:38not the Sony FX3 necessarily, but to go with this leaner
- 42:42approach. Yeah, yeah.
- 42:43Ultimately the the cinematographer does have a lot
- 42:46of influence on that decision. You, you, you of course need buy
- 42:51in from the director. Ideally they are contributing to
- 42:55the decision and and understanding it and
- 42:57understanding the implications and the repercussions of it in
- 43:00the approval. And then on on a studio level,
- 43:03often you will need the studio to approve because they
- 43:07ultimately are in charge of distribution.
- 43:09They need to confirm that the quality will be you know at the
- 43:14level that it needs to be and all that but all of those things
- 43:16can be demonstrated just by shooting test footage and
- 43:20projecting it. It's it's a whole process but
- 43:22ultimately everybody does kind of need to approve it.
- 43:27Some studios are very specific like Netflix that are sort of
- 43:31famously has a list of of approved cameras because of they
- 43:35have a 4K mandate in order to deliver 4K to their which which
- 43:40is something they promised to their customers is if you have
- 43:43the 4K subscription they say well we we we want to guarantee
- 43:48that you're getting a 4K image. Now of course we could, You
- 43:52know, I don't want to get into the technical, but that's
- 43:55somewhat of a fallacy because the the the acquisition format
- 43:59has little to do with the actual resolution of something, because
- 44:04resolution is is relative, resolution is something is about
- 44:08the eye, it's about perception. Whereas K, you know the number
- 44:13of pixels does not really have anything to do with resolution,
- 44:17because for you could have a 4K image that is technically 4096
- 44:22pixels but is blurry, you know, because you use like a crappy
- 44:28lens or something. So like that's a low resolution
- 44:31image no matter how many pixels it has.
- 44:34So anyway, the, the, the so the. Well, they fulfilled their
- 44:37promise still, right? Well yes, but the point is yeah,
- 44:41the point is they could use whatever camera they want
- 44:42because ultimately if the promise is just 4096 pixels you
- 44:46can get that from you can up resolution, you know something
- 44:49shot on on for example HD and if it's high quality camera it
- 44:53it'll look fine. But this is a unnecessary rant
- 44:57that I'm going down. This has been over litigated by
- 44:59many other people in other other contexts but the the point is is
- 45:04is that it was the form factor. It was the the size and shape
- 45:07and studios do end up needing to approve it.
- 45:09This wasn't unorthodox choice, but we did our testing, we shot
- 45:13test, we proved it to the studio that it would be viable and and
- 45:18they approved it. Wow, I love it.
- 45:21And talking about the shot test, you went on a four month trip
- 45:25for Tick scouting for the location, scouting all over
- 45:28Southeast Asia, right? For true love.
- 45:30True Love. Yeah, we saw it on your
- 45:31Instagram that the whole journey was called True Love.
- 45:33Well, the film was originally called True Love.
- 45:36Oh, right. That's why project true love
- 45:39then. Yes, so the the original title
- 45:41of the movie was called True Love.
- 45:43So the whole shoot it was True Love.
- 45:45The Creator was a title that came about later in marketing.
- 45:49So they they changed the title. I still prefer the original
- 45:52title. I have to true love, true love.
- 45:54I have to admit I do prefer. It's provocative.
- 45:57But but yeah so the the scouting process happens before the film.
- 46:01So we were scouting for about four months.
- 46:06This was mostly in Thailand. We scouted in Cambodia as well.
- 46:09But and the scouting is not full time.
- 46:12So we're also prepping the movie at the same time.
- 46:14So we're doing lighting tests, planning sessions, scheduling
- 46:19like it's all happening at the same time, and the scouts are
- 46:22happening in between all of those other processes.
- 46:25But then we we saw some of the shots that you guys took during
- 46:28the scouting time ended up in the final, final film as well
- 46:32right. Yes.
- 46:34OK. That's that's does that.
- 46:35Happen often in in in movies. I wouldn't say often, but it
- 46:39does happen on Elvis, for example, Mandy Walker, the
- 46:44cinematographer on that and Baz Luhrmann.
- 46:46They shot a lot of test footage of Austin Butler as Elvis in the
- 46:50costume and and rehearsals and testing his performance and his
- 46:55movements and his, and actually a lot of that footage is in the
- 46:58movie. So it's not unheard of.
- 47:01People do use test footage and and scout footage in the final
- 47:06film that we're not the first people to do that but it is I It
- 47:10is always fun. I do like when that happens I
- 47:12just think it's cool. I I.
- 47:14Agree with you. If I wanted to talk a little bit
- 47:17about the tech scouting, how rigorous was the the pre
- 47:20planning and the pre production in that stage and recording all
- 47:23the test footages, the hours that you guys put in, you know I
- 47:26I want to get a little bit into the details of that.
- 47:29Yeah, well for people who might not be super familiar with film
- 47:32production the the prep pre production or prep for short is
- 47:40the most important part of of the process because it that's
- 47:44really where most of the work happens.
- 47:46Once you're actually on set it's like a moving train like there's
- 47:51only so much you can do. You're but a a big part of it is
- 47:54you're kind of just along for the ride like you've you've
- 47:57basically you know I guess the best analogy is it's like it's
- 48:02like Domino's, it's like setting up a beautiful domino display
- 48:07And so prep is the work of actually setting up the
- 48:10Domino's. It's the designing like what is
- 48:13the design I'm going to do figuring out OK so if this is my
- 48:17design which color pieces do I need you know where do they need
- 48:20to be placed, how far apart do they need to be placed.
- 48:22Maybe testing the the knock on effect, like seeing how fast
- 48:26they can collapse, like all of that stuff happens in the
- 48:30planning process and the preparation process and then the
- 48:33film shoot itself is just knocking down the first domino.
- 48:37And then once you've done that the whole thing just goes and
- 48:41you can't really stop. Like you can't change things you
- 48:44can't really plan. I mean you can to a certain
- 48:46extent. Like I guess the best analogy
- 48:49would be like once the dominoes are already falling, you can
- 48:52still add some to the end if you know but you're not you know the
- 48:57but but it is already falling. So like there's only so much you
- 49:01can add, but so, so that's how important the pre production is.
- 49:07Like shooting a film is very much like that.
- 49:10Like it's it's all in the planning and it's all in the pre
- 49:13production. So the more thorough you can be
- 49:17the better. So you know we try to visit
- 49:19every single filming location that we that we go to, which in
- 49:24this movie in the creator was quite a few.
- 49:27I think there's over 100 locations in the movie.
- 49:33We try to to we we have a lighting plan, we have a design
- 49:36and a plan for every scene. We test as much of it as we can.
- 49:42We we test how things look on camera.
- 49:45We have to test the the the color and the the editing
- 49:50process and the color grading and the everything.
- 49:52So all of that goes through testing, visual effects tests.
- 49:55Everything gets tested so that you when you then go in to
- 49:58execute it on the day, there's a familiarity like, oh, we've done
- 50:02this before. We thought about this.
- 50:03We planned it. We're not just winging it right?
- 50:08And there's a little bit of winging it always.
- 50:10There's always a there's always one location you you couldn't
- 50:13get to or a location falls through and you have to replace
- 50:16it at the last minute. Things like that happen all the
- 50:19time, or you plan to be here at this time of day, but because
- 50:23you were delayed earlier, you're late and so now you have to
- 50:25rethink something for later. All of that is also part of the
- 50:29process, but the more planning you do in prep, the more the
- 50:31easier it is to pivot when things.
- 50:35Change. Yeah.
- 50:37We saw how much planning actually went through it because
- 50:39you published a series of 10 episodes of Post on your
- 50:42Instagram, because inside the creator, first of all, great
- 50:46job. We've never seen anything like
- 50:48that before. The way you went through all the
- 50:50details, all the insight that you provided and with the
- 50:53screenshots with the screens from the movie, what was the
- 50:57motivation behind and sharing all those information?
- 50:59Because I I think it took a lot of your time to, yeah, going
- 51:02through all those details. Yeah.
- 51:05I can't do that more. Well, I think, I think I'm, I'm
- 51:08just a a filmmaking nerd, you know, deep down.
- 51:11Like this kind of goes back to when I was nine years old and I
- 51:15was inspired by the behind the scenes of of Jurassic Park and
- 51:19Star Wars and Back to the Future and and just having access to
- 51:23that material like really inspired me to go into
- 51:26filmmaking and and and be interested in it so.
- 51:29So I think a part of me just wants to continue that you know
- 51:33and and provide that kind of inspiration for other people and
- 51:37also there's a part of me that's just a nerd about it and then
- 51:39you know I just like the behind the scenes details and and I
- 51:42think certain ways that we achieve things are really cool
- 51:46and interesting and I just want to share them with the world
- 51:48because it's fun to share things that you're interested in and
- 51:51find cool and and and yeah and and you know there's an there's
- 51:58also an element of it of of that I'm just a proud of it I'm proud
- 52:02of the work and and I'm proud of the cut the process and and I I
- 52:07think it's it's also cool and and good to share things that
- 52:10you're proud of and to and to show your work and and yeah I
- 52:16just I really firmly believe in education and inspiration for
- 52:19people and and being transparent about those things and I I just
- 52:24think it's cool I think filmmaking is cool and I think
- 52:26it's fun to share it to share the process.
- 52:29It's it's awesome. I mean, for anybody that hasn't
- 52:31looked at it yet, I'm just going to tell you there's so much
- 52:34problem solving happening and you see that in every post
- 52:37because you've numbered the carousel.
- 52:38Photos 10 image per episode and there are 10 episodes so you
- 52:43will get at least I would say 90 or 100.
- 52:46Different problem solving puzzles.
- 52:48It's all puzzles and you talk about how you guys lit different
- 52:52scenes and especially the serious shots at night.
- 52:54I I love those and that's what I want to ask you.
- 52:57I mean, during the tech scouts especially and and while you
- 52:59guys started shooting due to the unpredictable nature of the
- 53:03shoot, I mean, first of all, you guys are in Thailand, but like,
- 53:06I mean from Thailand and Cambodia and other countries,
- 53:09we've lived in Malaysia for more than a decade.
- 53:11We know it's hot as hell, right? There's a lot of rain.
- 53:15It's. Unpredictable.
- 53:16It's unpredictable. How?
- 53:17Would you guys were shooting in a tunnel at some point like?
- 53:21Oh my God, that should be so humid.
- 53:23It's. That tunnel.
- 53:24That tunnel was hell. That was the hottest.
- 53:27That was the hottest part of the shoot.
- 53:30Yeah. I mean, look, there's an
- 53:31element, again, because production is, is in person and
- 53:34physical, that's sort of baked into it a little bit like you
- 53:38sort of acknowledge that when you're on location, there are
- 53:43going to be elements, mainly the elements as in nature, that are,
- 53:48that are outside of our control. Now that's not to say they're
- 53:51unpredictable because they can be predicted to a certain
- 53:55extent. You can predict well it's going
- 53:58to be hot. So we can prepare for that.
- 54:00You can predict like, well, we don't know exactly when it's
- 54:03going to rain, but it could rain, so we could be prepared
- 54:06for if it rains, here's what we'll do.
- 54:08So it's again, it goes back to planning.
- 54:10It's just about knowing you know, planning and understanding
- 54:15like what could happen and thinking about what we do and
- 54:18then also taking certain steps to avoid risk as much as
- 54:21possible. So you know for example, we shot
- 54:23in the dry season, so which was very specific timing, you know,
- 54:28like the shoot was scheduled in a very specific way because we
- 54:30knew if we had to slide into summer, our exteriors would just
- 54:34be hosed because it was just rain, non-stop monsoon season
- 54:38for for months. So we we had to shoot, we made
- 54:41sure to shoot all of our exteriors early so that by the
- 54:45time we got to April, we were mostly shooting interiors which
- 54:49were unaffected by weather. So just things like that, like
- 54:53all of that factors into the planning process in the prep
- 54:56process. But there is always an element
- 54:58of unpredictability when shooting in nature and in the
- 55:00elements. And you just have to deal with
- 55:02it and deal with the elements and deal with the heat and deal
- 55:05with being wet and just accept being uncomfortable for a little
- 55:08bit and fantasize about the shower at the end of the day.
- 55:11Which definitely, definitely is a strong motivator.
- 55:16And also I guess in Thailand, the Tom Yum and the mango sticky
- 55:20rice. I don't know if you guys had
- 55:21that. I mean, you guys spend a long
- 55:22time there. I I love Thai food.
- 55:24I don't know about you. It's amazing.
- 55:25I love, I love it. I love Thai food.
- 55:27I mean, we definitely got a little, you know, we got our
- 55:31fill. Yeah, we we you know the
- 55:37catering on set, they had the Thai catering and they had the
- 55:39Western catering. They were next to each other.
- 55:43But you know you could choose do you want the Thai food or or the
- 55:47the whatever western food they made.
- 55:49And I I would definitely say that a lot of the crew slid
- 55:53towards the Western food as the shoot.
- 55:56Went on towards the end. Well just by nature of, you
- 55:58know, it's it's like how many times can you have Thai basil
- 56:02chicken like. In a row and.
- 56:06I love Thai basil chicken, but at some point you're like, I've
- 56:08had enough Thai basil chicken. Maybe I should have some some
- 56:13some meatballs. I totally get that, man.
- 56:17I don't know. I feel like, especially because
- 56:19the food is really spicy as well.
- 56:21And if it's hot, I don't know. When we lived in Malaysia, it
- 56:23took a really long time for us to adapt to the food, 'cause it
- 56:26was so hot. And then they're eating these
- 56:28hot soups. I'm like, how are you guys?
- 56:30I'm sweating. I.
- 56:32Know. I know the the soup.
- 56:34I yeah, the soup was not really my thing because of that,
- 56:37because of the heat. I was like the soup was great.
- 56:40When we're shooting on an air conditioned interior, Tom Gum is
- 56:44perfect. But yeah, like when we're
- 56:45outdoors it's you know 100% humidity.
- 56:50I don't know. I don't know how they do.
- 56:51They also all, they wear long sleeves to protect themselves
- 56:54from the sun and that's also something I I, I just, I'm like,
- 56:57how do you do it? The crew, the Thai crew, 'cause
- 57:00I would always show up every day with short shorts and and and
- 57:03short sleeves and you know you're still sweating.
- 57:06So I'm I'm just amazed at at at, you know what you can tolerate
- 57:10when you're used to those environments exactly.
- 57:12Yes, yes, absolutely. I wanna far.
- 57:14Sorry. I have one really exciting one.
- 57:17What was the most challenging day for you on set?
- 57:20Like the day where you're like, holy shit, I don't know how to
- 57:22solve this. I'm gonna figure it out.
- 57:24And you eventually did, but what was the most challenging one for
- 57:26you? I think the most challenging
- 57:31lighting set up was the night exteriors.
- 57:33Like that was definitely something.
- 57:35And night exteriors are always hard because they require a A.
- 57:41You know when you're shooting it in the daytime you you already
- 57:44have a light source. So it's actually quite easy once
- 57:47you've once you've sort of accepted that you know, well
- 57:49everything's going to revolve around the sun.
- 57:51So everything else that we're doing, whatever we're adding,
- 57:54modifying, taking away, adjusting.
- 57:55I mean not to say that that's easy to do to to curate and
- 57:59control the sun, but at least you're starting from something
- 58:03at night, there's no light, so you have to artificially create
- 58:08it. But the difficulty on this
- 58:10project was we wanted everything to feel naturalistic and real.
- 58:14So this is night exterior has stumped film makers for for for
- 58:19decades for many many years because you can't really
- 58:23recreate what night time feels like and looks like because the
- 58:27human eye works in such a strange way in the way it
- 58:31adjusts to darkness and exposure and all these things.
- 58:34So it's it's quite tricky and also camera sensitivity is a
- 58:38factor but this was another big advantage of the FX3 is it can
- 58:40actually shoot in very low light situation.
- 58:43So that helped us a lot. So we landed on an approach that
- 58:48we thought was going to work. But the first time that we'd
- 58:50actually did it on set, you know, was definitely nerve
- 58:52wracking. Because honestly, that was
- 58:55something we didn't really get to test properly.
- 58:58Because the proper way to test the night lighting is you have
- 59:01to go out onto a location with no light in order to try it.
- 59:07But we were prepping in Bangkok, so there's light everywhere.
- 59:11So we can't. And and you know it's we
- 59:14basically in order to properly test it, we needed to like drive
- 59:17out into the countryside in the middle of the night with all of
- 59:21our equipment and everything. And it's just logistically just
- 59:23doesn't make sense. So we didn't and we tested it in
- 59:27Bangkok and we're like, well, we think that this will work on
- 59:31location, but we're not really going to know until we get
- 59:33there. So yeah, that first night
- 59:35exterior was quite nerve wracking and that was in the
- 59:37first week of production. So at least it came quickly and
- 59:41we sort of got it out of the way and of course once we did it
- 59:43once then you become very confident in that approach for
- 59:46the next time. But yeah, I think that, you
- 59:49know, so it maybe wasn't a difficult day, but it was, it
- 59:52was certainly nerve wracking and but we got through it and
- 59:56thankfully the plan worked. Were you shooting all the night
- 1:00:02exteriors during the sunset time so you had a little bit of light
- 1:00:07or no absolute darkness? Wait.
- 1:00:09For yeah, there's a mix. There's a mix.
- 1:00:11So there's there's a lot of scenes in the movie that are
- 1:00:13shot at blue hour at dusk, but then there's others that are
- 1:00:16shot at full night time. So it's it's a mixture.
- 1:00:19So the the ones that are during blue hour, you have a very short
- 1:00:23window in Southeast Asia, especially because it wouldn't
- 1:00:26take that long for the Blue Hour to finish.
- 1:00:29Yeah, it's our gaffer. Called it Blue 15 minutes.
- 1:00:33It's not blue hour, it's blue. Well, this is where the having
- 1:00:38the small camera came into play because being able to move so
- 1:00:41quickly and and have that small footprint allowed us to maximize
- 1:00:45every minute of of that blue hour.
- 1:00:49So we were never wasting time. Like we basically wouldn't cut
- 1:00:51the camera. I mean once the sun disappeared
- 1:00:55and and you know we got into that dusky time, we basically
- 1:00:58just roll the camera and then shoot until you couldn't see
- 1:01:01anything anymore. So and get as much footage as we
- 1:01:04can. And then we had eighty shoot
- 1:01:06days, so that is 80 blue hours, which is not bad.
- 1:01:12You know it adds up and when you actually look at how much of
- 1:01:14that material is in the movie, it's a it's a handful of scenes.
- 1:01:18So you know, it goes back to planning and we would shoot them
- 1:01:21over multiple nights sometimes if we needed more time and that
- 1:01:24kind of thing, yeah. There was far as I want to
- 1:01:28highlight this. There was one of the scenes that
- 1:01:30when I watched the behind the scene and I realized the Grand
- 1:01:34Canyon that the van is driving right through it is just the
- 1:01:38key. Put by I love that.
- 1:01:39Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:01:40That part, I'm going to be going to overlay the video.
- 1:01:42You guys lied to us. Yeah?
- 1:01:45Where did that come from? I think what that came from is,
- 1:01:50I don't know if you guys have had this, but like when I was a
- 1:01:52kid and I think a lot of creative people when they're
- 1:01:54kids, like, you know, I can speak for myself.
- 1:01:57Like when I was a kid, I would pretend that the woods behind
- 1:02:03our elementary school, which were, you know, just very basic,
- 1:02:06like small woods were was was Endor, you know, the the, the,
- 1:02:12the, the forest mood of Endor where the trees are gigantic and
- 1:02:16you would have like, you know, your Star Wars toys.
- 1:02:19So when you place your Star Wars toys next to a regular tree, the
- 1:02:23tree looks massive. You know, like the scale.
- 1:02:26You can kind of play with scale in that way.
- 1:02:29Or, you know, anytime you're building a sand castle and
- 1:02:32you're like, you know, you're pretending that you're building
- 1:02:34this huge thing, but it's actually small.
- 1:02:37So I think just using that sort of childlike imagination, like I
- 1:02:41think many film makers and many artists probably just still have
- 1:02:45that. I I certainly do.
- 1:02:46I feel like I do You just have that still that still you still
- 1:02:50have that kind of childish like childlike way of looking at
- 1:02:54environments in the world. And it's very imaginative and
- 1:02:57you and and and so I think that that was sort of just, well, we
- 1:03:02noticed that on the scout we, you know, we were walking around
- 1:03:05this rocky terrain. And both Gareth and I noticed
- 1:03:10especially because there were there were actually these like
- 1:03:12trickles of water that were trickling down through it and
- 1:03:16they looked like massive rivers on this huge environment.
- 1:03:21Like it looked like something you would see in Iceland.
- 1:03:24And we both commented like, oh wow, doesn't this look like, you
- 1:03:29know, this massive landscape and we're just flying overhead And,
- 1:03:33and and then Gareth had the idea like, oh, when we come back, we
- 1:03:36should shoot some of this as plates because maybe we could
- 1:03:39use it for visual effects shots. So it wasn't necessarily
- 1:03:44specifically planned. It was like we just shot a few,
- 1:03:47a few shots of the landscape and then turns out that there was a
- 1:03:53use for that. Yeah.
- 1:03:56So it's really cool. I love that.
- 1:03:58It's just I love that. No, I loved watching that.
- 1:04:02I mean, when me and Farrad figured that out after we
- 1:04:04watched the behind the scenes, we were amazed by that.
- 1:04:06It's, it's amazing. And I agree with you.
- 1:04:08I think the imagination is so important, especially in in in
- 1:04:11your role, right? Your the roles that you guys
- 1:04:14play and it helps so much as well.
- 1:04:16And and people don't realize it right, 'cause you're watching
- 1:04:19the movie, you're so immersed. Especially when the VFX is
- 1:04:22amazing, you don't really notice.
- 1:04:23You just immersed. The story's great.
- 1:04:25It looks beautiful. So it just passes by and you
- 1:04:28don't notice it. And then later you figure it out
- 1:04:30and it's even more amazing after you figure out how you guys did
- 1:04:33it. That's why going back to why the
- 1:04:35behind the scenes is so important, 'cause people get to
- 1:04:37see these things and they're like, Oh my God, that's that's
- 1:04:39the best problem solving I found.
- 1:04:41Like that's that's what I want to do.
- 1:04:43It's it inspires people to do the same.
- 1:04:45Exactly. And it's a magic trick.
- 1:04:46And you know, people, people love seeing how magic tricks are
- 1:04:51done, even though you know when it's when it comes to actual
- 1:04:55magic, that's considered a faux pas because you want to maintain
- 1:04:59the illusion and the trickery. But with filmmaking, I think,
- 1:05:02especially for people who are interested in it, the revealing
- 1:05:06the magic trick I think is part of the fun and learning about
- 1:05:08it. So I really enjoyed that.
- 1:05:11Can I ask you a question about the the robot simulants and all
- 1:05:15that? It's it's very interesting
- 1:05:17because from, you know, we watch even the the corridor video
- 1:05:20where Gareth Edwards was on and you know they were talking about
- 1:05:23how only afterwards you guys decided on who's gonna be, you
- 1:05:27know, turned not beforehand, right.
- 1:05:29You get shot humans and then later on you guys made that
- 1:05:32decision. How much more difficult did that
- 1:05:35make your job in terms of knowing, OK, so if this guy is
- 1:05:39going to be turned, then I'd probably need better lighting on
- 1:05:41him right, 'cause we might need to track his face.
- 1:05:44I feel like I might have been kind of well, stressful at at
- 1:05:48times for you. How did you overcome that?
- 1:05:50What was the solution in in that scenario?
- 1:05:52Well, the fun thing about that decision is that it had the
- 1:05:55opposite effect is that it made it.
- 1:05:58It made it so that we just didn't worry about it at all.
- 1:06:01Wow. Because that was, that was sort
- 1:06:03of the point. The point was we're just going
- 1:06:05to shoot everything as naturalistically as possible
- 1:06:08without taking into account like, Oh well, if this person,
- 1:06:11it needs to be tracked, then we need to get more light on them.
- 1:06:14We we didn't want to do that. Because the minute you start
- 1:06:17doing that, things start to feel artificial.
- 1:06:19Because the minute you start to be driven by technical needs,
- 1:06:22you abandoned naturalistic needs and realism in favor of that.
- 1:06:27So that's why we didn't really shoot with green screens.
- 1:06:30That's why we didn't pick decide which people.
- 1:06:33Well, aside from the main characters, of course, which
- 1:06:36background characters were going to be simulants and which ones
- 1:06:38weren't, because that lended to the authenticity of the whole
- 1:06:42thing, both and. And from my perspective, it
- 1:06:44lended to the authenticity of the lighting.
- 1:06:46Like, you know that person who happens to be standing in the
- 1:06:50background, who happens to be in shadow, that's probably the most
- 1:06:53interesting person to turn into a simulant because it's
- 1:06:56unexpected, because it's just a throwaway.
- 1:06:58It's like somebody that you barely even see.
- 1:07:00So that that's sort of what went into it and that is why they
- 1:07:04wanted to choose after the fact was so that it would feel random
- 1:07:08and not deliberate. And so it didn't actually affect
- 1:07:11anything I did at all. It it made it.
- 1:07:13It was the opposite. It made it so that I was just
- 1:07:15wasn't even thinking about that, which is great.
- 1:07:18I love that. That's that sounds awesome.
- 1:07:20And you can also notice that magic when you watch it.
- 1:07:24I do have one question though. Was there any shot that you guys
- 1:07:27took that couldn't be tracked after the fact like the the
- 1:07:30guys? Kind of like we can't, we can't
- 1:07:32track the shot like it's too dark or something like that.
- 1:07:34Not that I know of. They I think they they did.
- 1:07:37They nailed it, Then they. Nailed every single shot.
- 1:07:39I mean, it's incredible work. It really is.
- 1:07:42And you know, no disrespect to Godzilla -1, but I I do think
- 1:07:46that that the the the team should have won the the Best
- 1:07:50Visual Effects Oscar. It's it's unbelievable work.
- 1:07:52Like if you really see what went into it, it's even more
- 1:07:55unbelievable what they were able to accomplish.
- 1:07:57So 100%. Is what it is.
- 1:08:00You know, one of one of the one of my favorite scenes was the
- 1:08:04part that the robot started running on the bridge and it
- 1:08:07will explode after 10 or 15 seconds.
- 1:08:10Oh yeah, yeah, the entire run on the bridge.
- 1:08:12And then when I look at the behind the scene, yes.
- 1:08:15And when I look at the behind the scene, there was a guy with
- 1:08:17a 3M pole on his backpack and he's running and they were real
- 1:08:21explosive in place. That shot was one of my favorite
- 1:08:24part of the movie. I agree.
- 1:08:25Super fun. I, I I love stuff like that.
- 1:08:28Everything we shot had a had a practical element that the VFX
- 1:08:35team would use as a reference. So you know, like for example,
- 1:08:38you could totally shoot that scene on the bridge without a
- 1:08:40guy running and then and then you would just decide where to
- 1:08:44put it later. But for whatever reason, just
- 1:08:46having a guy running it, it influences, you know, the camera
- 1:08:50movement and the other characters react to it and so
- 1:08:53on. It's just much easier to react
- 1:08:55to something than it is to react to just to pretend.
- 1:08:59And so it's helpful to have that reference even when the plan is
- 1:09:04to completely remove that reference and replace it.
- 1:09:06But I think it is. It is really helpful.
- 1:09:10You know, I want to talk to you about something that we spend a
- 1:09:13lot of time working on, which is Unreal Engine.
- 1:09:16That's one of the the softwares that we use heavily and as you
- 1:09:18are already aware it's used a lot in filmmaking nowadays,
- 1:09:21especially in the pre production stage where they recreate
- 1:09:24environments and they light the scenes before going to those
- 1:09:27environments physically to test shots.
- 1:09:31In this case, because you guys did such an amazing and cool
- 1:09:34approach as to going into the tech scout, really doing the
- 1:09:36test footages, making sure the movie works, you know by by
- 1:09:40testing rigorously. I don't know if you guys use
- 1:09:43Unreal Engine at all in the workflow, but I just want to
- 1:09:46know first of all what do you think about that workflow
- 1:09:48specifically? Actually I before I ask my
- 1:09:51question I have to ask did you guys use Unreal Engine at all in
- 1:09:53the pre production phase to to check out some of the scenes
- 1:09:56like recreate them? Yeah, we didn't, but we did use
- 1:09:58Unreal Engine on the vault. We so we did shoot on the volume
- 1:10:02for two. Yes, yes.
- 1:10:04Towards the end of the movie so So those environments were
- 1:10:07created in Unreal but we we didn't use it in pre production
- 1:10:10for scouting. I love that though I I I I love
- 1:10:12the software and I love that workflow and I love the idea of
- 1:10:17being able to do that. I mean honestly to me The thing
- 1:10:20is, is location work is relatively easy lighting wise
- 1:10:24because again you have the sun, so you're already relying on a
- 1:10:29on a fixed lighting source and it's actually not very difficult
- 1:10:33to all you need to really do, at least for me is show up to a
- 1:10:36location and then plan the lighting approach based on what
- 1:10:41you observe. So recreating it in Unreal for
- 1:10:46certain circumstances is helpful.
- 1:10:48Like, I know Greg did a little bit of that on Dune Part 2 and
- 1:10:51it was for a very specific use which was actually relying on
- 1:10:58the sun, but they were shooting in rocky outcroppings of a sand
- 1:11:04dune and the shadows played an important part of the story.
- 1:11:09Now what's difficult about that is the shadows are obviously
- 1:11:14quite different from when you scout to when you're shooting
- 1:11:16months later. So what they used Unreal for was
- 1:11:19to calculate what the shadows would look like on that location
- 1:11:22in four months to then plan out their shots.
- 1:11:25So that's a very specific use of on location recreation to to to
- 1:11:29plan lighting. Where I see it as being
- 1:11:32extremely useful is planning sets.
- 1:11:35So if you're building a set on a stage, being able to pre light
- 1:11:41and pre plan your lighting approach for a set in Unreal is
- 1:11:45so unbelievably helpful. Like it's just incredible
- 1:11:49because you don't have to play guesswork at all.
- 1:11:52I mean, the difference, of course, of a location and a set
- 1:11:54is from a set you're starting from scratch and there usually
- 1:11:57isn't really a set. I mean, the sets are often built
- 1:12:00right up to the time when they're filmed because that's
- 1:12:02how the rhythm of film production goes.
- 1:12:06So you don't really have an existing location to go into and
- 1:12:10scout and look at what the lighting look like and make
- 1:12:12adjustments and make plans. It has to entirely be planned in
- 1:12:14advance. So yeah, being able to recreate
- 1:12:17an environment fully and Unreal, which design production
- 1:12:21designers do anyway, because when you're designing a set, you
- 1:12:24already have a 3D asset anyway. So it's the easiest thing in the
- 1:12:27world to port that into Unreal or just use Unreal to from the
- 1:12:32get go and light that set and and go through the
- 1:12:37experimentation phase, virtually try things out like what does
- 1:12:42this lighting look like, What does this lighting look like?
- 1:12:44And actually I have a potential upcoming project where I'm
- 1:12:47hoping to actually do that. So we'll see if we'll see it.
- 1:12:51It's not official yet, but I'm. I'm very much hoping to to
- 1:12:54integrate that into it, yeah. That's amazing to hear.
- 1:12:58Thanks so much for sharing that because again I I know more and
- 1:13:01more people are using Unreal Engine and that's why I was so
- 1:13:04curious to find out. I understand that it's used a
- 1:13:06lot in in volumes on the volume, but I wanted to know if that
- 1:13:10would also help the the, you know the locations that you guys
- 1:13:13were scouting, if you guys could recreate that and set up
- 1:13:15lighting earlier. But I love the way you you
- 1:13:18talked about that and described that.
- 1:13:19Thank you for that. Yeah, absolutely.
- 1:13:21I mean, it could be helpful for location work.
- 1:13:24The thing is our filmmaking approach was so guerrilla and
- 1:13:27spontaneous that I don't think it, I don't think it really
- 1:13:31would have we were would have leveraged it much.
- 1:13:33But if we I was if we were shooting something a little bit
- 1:13:35more traditional with you know planned shots and all of that.
- 1:13:39One way that would really benefit from that is if you
- 1:13:43light our scan a location when you scout it and then recreate
- 1:13:47that space in Unreal. Then you could go into those
- 1:13:50environments and even figure out, for example, like how much
- 1:13:53Jolly track do I need in order to get this shot, you know?
- 1:13:56Or where do I need to place track in order to get this frame
- 1:13:58in the location? Like how can I back up?
- 1:14:00And then also planning lighting, like I could totally see myself
- 1:14:04doing that on another project. It's just this one.
- 1:14:07The specific filmmaking approach was so kind of loose and
- 1:14:10spontaneous that I don't know if it would have really helped us
- 1:14:13much, but. No, but.
- 1:14:15I think it's really cool, yeah. And there were so many locations
- 1:14:18too, probably too many to do that.
- 1:14:20Oh, yeah. Actually, if you guys were to do
- 1:14:22all of those locations. Oh my God.
- 1:14:24Well, we wouldn't. But it's the beauty of it.
- 1:14:26Yeah, we wouldn't. Yeah.
- 1:14:27No, No way. For any aspiring cinematographer
- 1:14:31who's listening now or watching, what do you think makes a good
- 1:14:36cinematographer? I think there's good
- 1:14:41cinematography. Well, another mentor of mine,
- 1:14:45Reed Murano, who I worked with during film school.
- 1:14:48She always had a saying that I'm sure was borrowed from someone
- 1:14:51else as well, but which was that cinematography is split very
- 1:14:55neatly into thirds and 1/3 of it is art, craft, you know,
- 1:15:03creativity. And that's that's one side of
- 1:15:05things. And I think any good
- 1:15:08cinematographer will well, I think any good cinematographer
- 1:15:11is good at all three things. But you know, all of them are
- 1:15:14important. They're all, they're all pillars
- 1:15:16of cinematography. So being having a good eye,
- 1:15:20having good taste, being good at the craft, understanding the
- 1:15:23tools and technology, understanding film language, all
- 1:15:26of that's important. And then the second pillar is
- 1:15:30diplomacy. You have to know how to work
- 1:15:32with people, work with crew, work with producers, negotiate,
- 1:15:36understand human dynamics, understand leadership,
- 1:15:40understand you know all of these things that that there are
- 1:15:45equally as important, they really factor into the role
- 1:15:47because you can't, you are a leader, you are a department
- 1:15:50head and you are so. So it's important to to
- 1:15:57understand those dynamics and to to be well versed in them.
- 1:15:59And then the third pillar is psychology, where you have to be
- 1:16:04the director's best friend, confidante, supporter, shoulder
- 1:16:10to cry on. You know person who like I do
- 1:16:13believe that it is the third pillar of cinematography is
- 1:16:17really just being there for the director and and being there for
- 1:16:20what they need and and providing those needs for them.
- 1:16:23Being of the support system and helping them achieve their
- 1:16:26vision and translating it to visuals and translating it to
- 1:16:31the crew and communicating with the producers and the production
- 1:16:34with what they need and supporting them so.
- 1:16:39And talking them off a ledge when they don't believe in
- 1:16:41something or when they're feeling down or when they're
- 1:16:44feeling lacking or when they're doubting themselves or whatever.
- 1:16:48So a. Degree in psychology would help
- 1:16:51then I assume, right? If if a cinematographer has some
- 1:16:54extra time, a degree in psychology might be a good idea.
- 1:16:57Yeah, I mean, maybe, you know, I don't know if Freudian
- 1:17:00psychology specifically is really gonna help you with.
- 1:17:02Being well versed in Carl Jung is necessarily what you need.
- 1:17:06But you do need people skills. Like in you do.
- 1:17:08You need to. You need to know how to
- 1:17:10understand people. And more importantly, like you
- 1:17:12just need to be an open person. You need to open yourself
- 1:17:17emotionally, mentally to the director and to another person
- 1:17:22and to the crew and and yeah, and really understand how those
- 1:17:25dynamics. Work.
- 1:17:27Any specific resources that you use to help you learn all of
- 1:17:30this? I mean, you mentioned some of
- 1:17:31the books that you know you studied early on.
- 1:17:34Any any of them that you're willing to share that you think
- 1:17:36would be helpful to people watching and?
- 1:17:38Listening too many to name like I I I should just.
- 1:17:42Your favorite. Yeah, I should just go to my
- 1:17:43bedroom. I should go to my shelf.
- 1:17:45And yeah, I mean new cinematographers.
- 1:17:53Blaine Brown cinematography. The Cinematographer's Manual.
- 1:17:58Every issue of American cinematographer, like people
- 1:18:01should be subscribed and read every month.
- 1:18:04So many resources online, so many YouTube channels, so many
- 1:18:07resources. I mean, I love Patrick Tomasso.
- 1:18:11I love Thomas Flight. I love Quarter Crew are great
- 1:18:18for visual effects. I love.
- 1:18:23There's other books that have kind of collected interviews
- 1:18:27with cinematographers that are really great to read.
- 1:18:30Shot Deck is an amazing resource for reference images and
- 1:18:35studying, watching movies, going out into nature, taking photos
- 1:18:40every day like inspiration comes from everywhere.
- 1:18:42I have a lot of photo books, like still photography books.
- 1:18:46So yeah, it's there's it's it's hard to even know where to
- 1:18:50start. But I guess where I would start
- 1:18:51nowadays is I would I would Google search best books about
- 1:18:56cinematography and usually it's all it's the same ones that pop
- 1:19:00up and those are the ones that I read, I'm sure.
- 1:19:01So yeah. And I would add your Instagram
- 1:19:04page. To all of that?
- 1:19:05Oh yeah, 100%. Yeah, that, that that definitely
- 1:19:08is helpful. Happy to contribute in a small
- 1:19:10way that I can. No, it's it's honest.
- 1:19:13It's great and I definitely recommend everybody watching a
- 1:19:15listen check it out. Thanks so much for sharing that
- 1:19:17list. I'm sure a lot of people will be
- 1:19:19jumping On top of that, we have to talk about one more thing
- 1:19:22today, and that is about something that I saw you post
- 1:19:25about on your story and I'm going to give a little bit of
- 1:19:27context to everybody. It was about a documentary
- 1:19:30Series, A crime documentary series of something called what
- 1:19:34Jennifer did on Netflix, on Netflix.
- 1:19:36I haven't, I haven't actually watched it myself, but
- 1:19:38apparently she was convicted for murder.
- 1:19:40And there's this part where they're showing her, you know, I
- 1:19:45think somebody's talking about her and talking about how she
- 1:19:48was happy and and confident before being convicted of
- 1:19:51murder, and they're showing a photo of her being all happy.
- 1:19:55Apparently that photo was generated by AI, and it's been
- 1:19:59pissing a lot of people off. I assume it's pissed you off a
- 1:20:02little bit as well. I I want to know where you stand
- 1:20:05on this because this is just the early days.
- 1:20:07I mean, this is only going to grow, right?
- 1:20:09There's so many more AI models coming out, so many more people
- 1:20:12using them. And it's not necessarily the AI
- 1:20:15itself. It's also it's mostly the people
- 1:20:17using them. How people.
- 1:20:19Yeah, how people use them. So I want to know where you
- 1:20:20stand on this and what you thought about it when you first
- 1:20:23heard of it. Yeah, I mean I well there's two
- 1:20:27separate things going on here. There's the, there's the micro
- 1:20:30issue of this specific documentary and then there's the
- 1:20:32broader issue of of generative AI.
- 1:20:35The micro issue of the documentary is I think you know
- 1:20:40whether or not the image was was generated with a with an AI
- 1:20:44generator, you know, mid journey or whatever, there is a core
- 1:20:51unethical act of faking you know something and passing it across
- 1:20:58as as real. So let's say if a documentary
- 1:21:02came out ten years ago that did this without AI but with
- 1:21:05Photoshop that would be just as bad.
- 1:21:07We. Just had this conversation
- 1:21:10before. Wow, you mentioned an important
- 1:21:13point. Yeah, because the issue here is
- 1:21:14ethics. It's not about the technology
- 1:21:16because the ethics of of passing across something as real that is
- 1:21:21not real, I think is not controversial.
- 1:21:25Like you know, people talk about the risks of of generative AI
- 1:21:28with regards to disinformation, you know, fake news, faking
- 1:21:34clips of people saying things they didn't say etcetera,
- 1:21:37etcetera, etcetera. But that's been a problem
- 1:21:39forever. Like people have as early as,
- 1:21:45you know, digital, and I'm sorry, not digital as early as
- 1:21:49as laboratory. You know, photography,
- 1:21:52retouching, you could create fake news.
- 1:21:56And they did, You know there were issues of fake images, fake
- 1:22:01sound bites, manipulated audio, manipulated photographs going
- 1:22:05back to the dawn of those technologies in the 1800s and
- 1:22:111900s. And all throughout that process,
- 1:22:14people have had to play whack A mole with calling out, you know,
- 1:22:18fake things that are being passed across as real.
- 1:22:22And I think this is no different.
- 1:22:23I do think Gen. I poses, Gen.
- 1:22:25AI poses a unique threat because of how good it is at faking
- 1:22:29things, or at least how kind of convincing it is to the
- 1:22:32untrained eye. Of course the trained eye, I
- 1:22:36think can see where the faults of these things are.
- 1:22:40But, but to the untrained eye, I mean, you know, just open
- 1:22:43Facebook now and it's like all you see is just people
- 1:22:47commenting on on very obviously AI images being like, Oh my God,
- 1:22:51so cute. And it's like, what do you, it's
- 1:22:53not real. So, and you know, that's
- 1:22:55obviously I guess a more innocent example, but or not
- 1:22:59innocent but harmless, I guess, 'cause it's like people
- 1:23:02commenting on some fake AI image of an animal, you know, is
- 1:23:06doesn't really hurt anybody. But when it comes to ethics and
- 1:23:10journalism and documentary and truth telling, I I I think
- 1:23:14that's unambiguous that that's that should be called out and
- 1:23:21and criticized. The larger issue of Gen.
- 1:23:24AI is this for me at least I have zero issues.
- 1:23:30And in fact, I am very much in favor of any tool and any
- 1:23:34technology that comes along that makes a workflow more efficient
- 1:23:39and simpler. For example, generative AI in
- 1:23:45Photoshop I use quite a bit and it's quite useful because what
- 1:23:49it does is it takes what would normally be a tedious task.
- 1:23:53For example, you know there was an image, a photo that I took
- 1:23:59just the other day of of of of a couple family members, lovely
- 1:24:03portrait. And there's this really ugly car
- 1:24:05in the background, I thought for a.
- 1:24:10Second, you're gonna say there was this ugly family member.
- 1:24:16No, but but but like, dude, no. But it's funny that you bring
- 1:24:20that up, because now we're entering, you know, the the
- 1:24:22moral Gray zone. Removing a car from the
- 1:24:27background of a photo because it's distracting is something I
- 1:24:30would have done 10 years ago. I would have used clone stamp
- 1:24:34and and and other tools that you know exist in in order to to do
- 1:24:38it manually and it would take a few minutes.
- 1:24:40Da, da, da. And now I can select it and go
- 1:24:43to generative fill and say remove the car and it
- 1:24:46extrapolates that it basically does the clone stamp for you.
- 1:24:50I have no issue with that. You know, I don't think there's
- 1:24:52any fundamental problem with that.
- 1:24:54In fact, I think that just frees up more time for me to do
- 1:24:57creative things that I want. So anything like that, Anything
- 1:25:00like what I just described, Obviously in visual effects,
- 1:25:04color grading, tracking, rotoscoping, modeling,
- 1:25:09texturing, like all of these are tedious processes that
- 1:25:13technology can improve and make more efficient and make it so
- 1:25:18that we can spend more time on being creative and less time on
- 1:25:21menial, tedious tasks. So all of that I have, I, I, I
- 1:25:25actually support. I mean I'm I'm strongly in favor
- 1:25:28of, of embracing technology and making processes more efficient.
- 1:25:32What I cannot get behind is the concept of replacing the act of
- 1:25:38creativity with an algorithm because it is fundamentally in
- 1:25:44opposition to the the purpose of creativity, which is to express
- 1:25:49human emotion and express something from within ourselves.
- 1:25:53So like I just honestly and fundamentally I don't understand
- 1:25:57the point. Like I don't understand the
- 1:25:59point of saying, hey, instead of going out and taking a camera
- 1:26:07and experiencing the world and seeing something interesting and
- 1:26:11finding a composition and taking a few photos and trying things
- 1:26:14out and exploring and finding, I can just go home and type in
- 1:26:18some words and it can generate the image like it to me.
- 1:26:23It just defies the entire purpose of the act of creating
- 1:26:27an image. Because the act of creating an
- 1:26:29image is not just to have a final image.
- 1:26:33It's the act of expression. It's the act of seeing
- 1:26:38something, finding that inspiration, looking for the
- 1:26:40composition. Like that is the act of
- 1:26:43creation. It's not the final image, it's
- 1:26:45the whole process that went into it.
- 1:26:48And the same goes for illustration.
- 1:26:50The same goes for painting, drawing, filmmaking,
- 1:26:53cinematography, visual effects. All of it is there's there's an
- 1:26:56intentionality to the ACT that is lost when you just type some
- 1:27:02words into an algorithm and then the algorithm averages out the
- 1:27:07appearance of those keywords in millions of images that it's
- 1:27:10scraped from the Internet and then determines, well, that word
- 1:27:14is often associated with this kind of image.
- 1:27:16And so I'm going to recreate and generate an image that would
- 1:27:21match this description if it was done in reverse, like that's not
- 1:27:25creativity, that's reverse image search, but but fancier.
- 1:27:32And so I just don't I I don't understand the the desire to
- 1:27:40embrace that kind of technology. Like I fundamentally don't
- 1:27:43understand it and and this applies also to music.
- 1:27:46It applies also to to to anything.
- 1:27:50And so that's my fundamental problem with it is is So now
- 1:27:54setting aside the documentary problem because again that's
- 1:27:56that's like an unethical use of it, of it.
- 1:27:58Whether or not whatever you think about the technology, it's
- 1:28:01an unethical use. But I also think it's not it's
- 1:28:05not only an unethical use, it's also a it.
- 1:28:09It's a use that defies the purpose of art and creativity
- 1:28:13to, for example, use AI to generate a poster for a movie.
- 1:28:17Because like, what's the point? A poster is a work of art.
- 1:28:23It's a piece, it's a visual piece of art and some.
- 1:28:27And there is an intentionality behind the design of such a
- 1:28:31thing. So if you're just letting an
- 1:28:34algorithm design it, and I use design here with that's doing a
- 1:28:38lot of work cuz the algorithm isn't designing anything, which
- 1:28:41is sort of part of the point. There's no creative act
- 1:28:44happening. There's no intelligence
- 1:28:46involved. It's an average.
- 1:28:49It's it's, it's, it's it's it's it's numbers.
- 1:28:53It's guesswork. It's a slot machine of of well,
- 1:28:58I guess this word correlates with this type of image.
- 1:29:02That's not creativity, and that's setting aside the legal
- 1:29:07issues with AI right now with where the data's from what?
- 1:29:11Images and it started on that source was scraped.
- 1:29:14From the Internet and from who? And I think that stuff
- 1:29:16ultimately is going to be resolved in the in the legal
- 1:29:18system anyway. So eventually that'll be
- 1:29:21resolved. And by the way, once that's
- 1:29:22resolved and let's say we reach a point where it is definitively
- 1:29:29determined that AI generators cannot scrape copyrighted
- 1:29:34material without compensation. And if the companies are saying,
- 1:29:38well, if we need to compensate then we won't be able to sustain
- 1:29:41our, our business model, then to me that's just that means that
- 1:29:46this is not a technology that can exist in its current form if
- 1:29:50that's what is, if that's what's required.
- 1:29:53There's also issues with data usage, storage, energy
- 1:29:58consumption, all of these things.
- 1:30:00And I think we are very much at the beginning of it, but I'm not
- 1:30:03really sure we're at the beginning of its capabilities as
- 1:30:07a technology. I think we're at the beginnings
- 1:30:09of maybe understanding what the limitations are of the
- 1:30:12technology, and we'll see how that parses out of the next few
- 1:30:15years. My ultimate hope.
- 1:30:17If I had my way, I would just get rid of the whole thing.
- 1:30:20Honestly, I think the world would be better without it, but
- 1:30:24we'll see what happens. It's hard to see a net positive
- 1:30:26for any of it, honestly. It feels to me like it's just
- 1:30:29making everything a little bit worse, and that includes
- 1:30:32ChatGPT, that includes all of it.
- 1:30:34Like AI, chat bots, I think are just fundamentally worse than
- 1:30:38just talking to a person. ChatGPT is demonstratively
- 1:30:42fundamentally worse than looking things up on your own because it
- 1:30:47does not have intelligence it it.
- 1:30:50So it creates, it generates false nonsense.
- 1:30:54I mean, I'll give you one example.
- 1:30:56And then I'm. I'll start to get off my
- 1:30:57soapbox. Instagram recently replaced the
- 1:31:01search function with meta AI, which is their version of
- 1:31:05ChatGPT. It's a it's a chat box.
- 1:31:08Why? I don't know.
- 1:31:10Well, I do know to push it to face to meta users so that they
- 1:31:14can start using it so that it can scrape more data so that it
- 1:31:17can get better. Anyway, out of pure curiosity, I
- 1:31:20clicked it and it shows you a few suggestions of like here's
- 1:31:23some things you can search for. So I searched.
- 1:31:26I clicked one of them. I searched for top 10 television
- 1:31:31dramas of the two the 2000s. So I clicked that now when I
- 1:31:39Google or search engine cuz Google also sucks now.
- 1:31:45But when I search engine Top 10 television dramas, what will pop
- 1:31:49up are websites, blogs, critics, you know, things where various
- 1:31:54different lists where people have written their subjective
- 1:31:58opinion of what the top 10 television dramas are.
- 1:32:01And I can click them. I can see like, oh Vulture, I
- 1:32:04like vultures writing about pop culture.
- 1:32:06I bet their list would be interesting.
- 1:32:08Let me click and see what they what they said, what meta AI
- 1:32:12does. It's a it's a generative AI.
- 1:32:14So it's not leading you to existing resources.
- 1:32:19It's just it has scraped the Internet and is now generating
- 1:32:23what it thinks the answer to top 10 television dramas would be if
- 1:32:28you were to search for it. And again I'm using thinks here
- 1:32:33in you know, it's doing a lot of heavy lifting because it's not
- 1:32:35thinking. It's just averaging out what the
- 1:32:38what the results of this kind of search would be.
- 1:32:40And the results were as follows. I don't remember exactly but you
- 1:32:44know I have a screenshot somewhere.
- 1:32:48Arrested Development. The Office, Grey's Anatomy.
- 1:32:55Family Guy. Parks and Recreation, NCIS,
- 1:33:02etcetera. Now, you'll already notice two
- 1:33:06things. One, none of these are would be
- 1:33:07on anybody's list of best dramas.
- 1:33:11And the other thing is that half of them are comedies.
- 1:33:14And this was the first thing I clicked and used to just try out
- 1:33:20Meta's generative AI. And from first impression I can
- 1:33:25say I think it's a useless hunk of shit.
- 1:33:29But but so when I see that and I see how much these companies are
- 1:33:33embracing this and kind of pushing it down our throats as
- 1:33:36users, I worry because I think it's all bad.
- 1:33:40Like I just think it's it's a lowering of the quality level
- 1:33:43that we would expect from human curation, human creativity,
- 1:33:48human writing, human expression, etcetera.
- 1:33:52So where I'm at with it right now is my biggest hope is that
- 1:33:57all of these companies biggest fears about financial solvency
- 1:34:00come true and they all just abandoned this project.
- 1:34:03Like they abandoned the Metaverse, and like they
- 1:34:04abandoned NFTS and like they abandoned all these other
- 1:34:06nonsense useless things that nobody wanted.
- 1:34:09We'll see if I'm right, but it's impossible to predict.
- 1:34:13But as of right now I am pretty much firmly anti generative AI
- 1:34:19which is mid journey, Sora, ChatGPT, etcetera.
- 1:34:24Now leveraging the technology to improve our creativity, I'm all
- 1:34:27for it, but we'll see if maybe people will wise up and realize
- 1:34:31that that's going to be more useful to people than replacing
- 1:34:35things that were already working and good with things that are
- 1:34:38just less good. I don't know.
- 1:34:41No, I'm not that over. No.
- 1:34:43No, no. It's a very interesting point
- 1:34:45because at some at some point you mentioned about ChatGPT and
- 1:34:49I think we had this conversation with Faras.
- 1:34:51Whenever you receive an e-mail and it's obvious that the person
- 1:34:54used Chachi PT. The credibility for Feast your.
- 1:34:58Eyes I've heard. I've seen that freaking phrase
- 1:35:01in 10 different freaking texts right now.
- 1:35:04Feast your eyes. I swear to God that's a Chachi
- 1:35:06PT thing. And then the credibility
- 1:35:08immediately drops or whoever the e-mail that we are receiving.
- 1:35:11So the the moment we think about that, the person didn't even
- 1:35:15want to put some effort to write the e-mail.
- 1:35:17Even if they want to get hired, if they want to be partner, if
- 1:35:20they want to, if they want to use us as a partner,
- 1:35:22immediately, we are like, OK, I don't.
- 1:35:24If they don't want to spend 10 minutes to write an e-mail to
- 1:35:26introduce themselves, and they are sending us this buzzwords
- 1:35:29that you know every ChatGPT can spit it out for us, the
- 1:35:32credibility has dropped. Bingo.
- 1:35:34Exactly. I'll give you another short
- 1:35:36anecdote. A friend of mine went to a
- 1:35:38wedding recently. Sorry, no, it wasn't a wedding.
- 1:35:42It was a gala. It was a fundraiser.
- 1:35:44And the the head of the the nonprofit, like, gave the speech
- 1:35:49and my friend's a writer, and my friend said the speech was
- 1:35:53pretty bad. It was all just like, it was
- 1:35:55just the most generic, you know, cliche, like platitudes
- 1:36:00imaginable, like lame jokes. It it wasn't good.
- 1:36:06And afterwards the guy asked him like, hey, So what did you think
- 1:36:08of the speech? And so my friend, to be polite,
- 1:36:12said, oh, well, you know, it was, it was pretty good.
- 1:36:15And and this, this, this guy who gave the speech is not a writer,
- 1:36:18so you wouldn't really expect him to write something eloquent
- 1:36:21or anything. So considering that my friend
- 1:36:24was kind of like, oh, well, you know, he wrote some jokes and
- 1:36:28some some platitudes, they're all corny and cliche and and
- 1:36:32stereotypical and and bad, but at least he wrote them.
- 1:36:36And then the guy smugly said, aha, well actually I had ChatGPT
- 1:36:41generate the speech for me. And then immediately, like, Oh
- 1:36:45well, of course it sucked. And also, not only does it suck,
- 1:36:49but like, I've now lost even what little respect I had for
- 1:36:53you. They even had a little bit of
- 1:36:54respect to say like, well, you're not a good writer, but at
- 1:36:57least you tried. You tried.
- 1:36:59It's like you didn't even try. You just gave up.
- 1:37:02You just, you took the laziest possible route of, you know, you
- 1:37:08had an opportunity in a speech to express yourself and your
- 1:37:12feelings towards another individual that you were
- 1:37:14honoring. And you couldn't even put in the
- 1:37:16minimum amount of effort for that person to express yourself.
- 1:37:20And I think that's very telling about a person.
- 1:37:22So I agree with you guys and I guess we'll see where that goes.
- 1:37:26If it does become something that's more widely accepted and
- 1:37:29used in society, like I don't know what that says about us.
- 1:37:34I guess we'll find out, but I don't know.
- 1:37:36We'll see. I'm worried about that.
- 1:37:38I'm worried about that, yes. I'm worried about the specific
- 1:37:41laziness. Yeah, and the.
- 1:37:43Exactly. That's the point.
- 1:37:45For the next generation. It would be extremely difficult
- 1:37:47to learn something new, even. For example, for any software
- 1:37:51that you use, specifically 3D software, there is a path for
- 1:37:54you to use coding so you can use soft computer programs to write
- 1:37:57the code. If the future students always
- 1:38:00use any sort of GPTS or generative AI to come up with
- 1:38:04those codes, they will never learn the logic, they will never
- 1:38:07learn the concept, they will never learn the basic, and if
- 1:38:10one day that thing is not there, they cannot do anything.
- 1:38:13Exactly. Now again, here's another
- 1:38:14example where for me it's like this is a good use of it.
- 1:38:17If you write a code and then use an AI software to debug, I think
- 1:38:24that's great. That's super useful for an
- 1:38:27individual coder like who's making stuff on their own needs
- 1:38:30somebody to check their work. Maybe there's an error that you
- 1:38:33can't find. I took one semester of computer
- 1:38:36science and freshman year of high school because all my
- 1:38:38family are computer scientists. So I was like, well, I'll give
- 1:38:41it a try. So we were learning C Plus and I
- 1:38:43was terrible at it. I mean, just awful.
- 1:38:45Like I writing code. I would also make one little
- 1:38:48mistake somewhere and then run the program and it wouldn't work
- 1:38:51and I would never be able to find it.
- 1:38:52So, you know, little things like that, little things that help us
- 1:38:57in our daily lives and enhance our experience and our, our our
- 1:39:03productivity and and our creativity I think is great.
- 1:39:06But anything that completely replaces the process of learning
- 1:39:10and creating and expressing I think is is a 1 ticket, you know
- 1:39:14one way trained a a society that I don't think any of us want to
- 1:39:17live in. And my hope is that people will
- 1:39:20realize that. Like I I hope that you know you
- 1:39:23guys myself like we all probably have more exposure to generative
- 1:39:27AI tools than the average person just because we work in in in a
- 1:39:32media field and in technology. So this is all in our wheelhouse
- 1:39:36and even we are already you know experiencing like the what what
- 1:39:40some people have coined the the end shitification of of these
- 1:39:45processes and have a negative reaction to it.
- 1:39:48So I hope that more people will as well as it becomes more
- 1:39:52widespread or that these business models really just
- 1:39:55don't work and you know eventually they just move on to
- 1:39:58something that they can actually make money off of and and that's
- 1:40:02that and call it a day, we'll see.
- 1:40:06And and for anybody who's watching and listening who wants
- 1:40:09to know a little bit about the scraping of data, I recommend
- 1:40:11you check out the interview with the Was it the CTO of Open AI
- 1:40:14and the CEO of YouTube? When they asked about Sora and
- 1:40:18they both couldn't answer anything, they were like, oh, I
- 1:40:20don't know, you have to ask the other person about that, about
- 1:40:25that source of data for Sora they know of.
- 1:40:28Course. They know.
- 1:40:30They know. They know.
- 1:40:31They know and I think that this will all eventually come out.
- 1:40:36There will be government will get involved, there will be
- 1:40:40hearings and there will also be litigation and and in courts.
- 1:40:44But we'll see. It's like you said, it's early
- 1:40:46and those processes take time. So we'll see.
- 1:40:49I'm tracking it, I'm monitoring it.
- 1:40:51But what I can say confidently for myself is much like how a
- 1:40:57generation of film makers, you know, Chris Nolan, Spielberg, PT
- 1:41:01Anderson, like all these directors, you know, they came
- 1:41:05up shooting film and that's what they know and that's what they
- 1:41:09like. And they took a look at the
- 1:41:10digital revolution in cinematography and filmmaking
- 1:41:14that came about in the 2000s and 2000 tens something that that
- 1:41:19that I very much embraced the digital tools and all that.
- 1:41:22They took one look at that and said no, thank you, I'm good
- 1:41:28with my current process. That's how I feel about
- 1:41:31integrating certainly generative AI into any of my work flows.
- 1:41:36I look at it and say, yeah, not for me, no thank you, no, thank
- 1:41:41you. I like no thank you.
- 1:41:43Yeah, I like the way that I currently make movies.
- 1:41:45I would rather not, you know, sit in a room typing prompts
- 1:41:49into a slot machine and hoping that it'll generate the shot
- 1:41:52that I want. I and I know there will be some
- 1:41:56of that, at least for now. Like people will try it, but not
- 1:41:59for me. Well, let's put it this way.
- 1:42:03If we don't have the apocalypse and we are going to do that
- 1:42:07thing where in 10 years we'll have another podcast episode,
- 1:42:11we'll look back and see how it all happened.
- 1:42:14We'll see where the data came from and then we'll see how
- 1:42:16people are using it the next generation.
- 1:42:18And I think it'll be a really fun conversation.
- 1:42:20I think that'll be very interesting to see.
- 1:42:23Well, Oren, can I lock you down for 2035 or something like that
- 1:42:27or? Yeah.
- 1:42:28We'll put it on my calendar right now just to make sure it's
- 1:42:30it's in my schedule. Please tell your AI chat bot to
- 1:42:33do that for you. I appreciate that.
- 1:42:35Will do, yes. By then hopefully I'll have just
- 1:42:38a full on, you know robot like like in the Jetsons and and that
- 1:42:42I would 100% get behind. Well awesome man.
- 1:42:46Oren, you've been amazing. I I truly enjoyed the
- 1:42:49conversation. Thank you so much for your time
- 1:42:51and I wish you all the luck there is for the the next things
- 1:42:55you're gonna. Do thanks guys.
- 1:42:57I really appreciate. It was a great chat.
- 1:42:58Thank you. Awesome.
- 1:43:00For everybody watching on listening.
- 1:43:01Thank you guys so much as well. We'll see you guys on the next
- 1:43:03episode. Until then, Ciao.