Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E022: A New Custody Standard with Mitch Kochman from BitGo
Transcript
- 0:00Before we get into the episode, a quick reminder that the last
- 0:03trade is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 0:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 0:10Now for a word from on RAMP on RAMP is a Bitcoin asset
- 0:14management platform built on multi institution custody.
- 0:17We serve high net worth individuals, institutional
- 0:20investors and financial intermediaries with the best in
- 0:23class suite of products which include.
- 0:25Multi Institution Custody, A spot Bitcoin fund?
- 0:29Onram Wealth for Rias and private wealth services for high
- 0:33net worth individuals leveraging our partnership with Bit Go and
- 0:37other industry leaders. Onram's Multi institution
- 0:40custody is a first of its kind institutional grade vault
- 0:44requiring two of three institutions at any point in
- 0:48time to sign once a client's unique permissions have been
- 0:51met. Our multi institution vaults
- 0:54utilize cold storage, key signing and authentication at
- 0:57the direction of the client. To maximize security for client
- 1:01assets, This pioneering approach to custody is the foundation of
- 1:05On Ramp's financial products, which reduce counterparty risk
- 1:09associated with trusting a single institution.
- 1:12To learn more about how On Ramp can help you secure a new or
- 1:16existing Bitcoin position, please visit our website at on
- 1:19rampbitcoin.com, where you can schedule a consultation and
- 1:23connect directly with our team. What you're telling me is that
- 1:28music is about to stop, and we're going to be left holding
- 1:31the biggest bag of odorous excrement ever assembled in the
- 1:36history of Doctors 1974? 198792972. 1000 and whatever we
- 1:44want to call this, it's all just the same.
- 1:46Thing over and over. We can't help ourselves, I say.
- 1:50When we sell, hey, I say. When we sell.
- 1:56Gentlemen, back for another episode of the last trade.
- 2:00How we doing this week? We're.
- 2:03Good. We got like a somebody fat
- 2:05fingered the ETF approval. That's a good engagement hack.
- 2:10I'm thinking about doing it from the TFTC account Bitcoin ETF
- 2:13officially approved. I'm not gonna delete the tweet
- 2:17though. What was a?
- 2:21Lot of attention. Not not all the best kind of
- 2:24attention though. Yeah, people should have known
- 2:28Coin Telegraph breaking the ETF news is not likely.
- 2:32It'll probably be Reuters or somebody like that.
- 2:35Yeah, and the apparently where it got sourced from was some
- 2:38random Telegram chat, You know, fake breaking news announcement.
- 2:44And then then they just like copied that and ran with it as
- 2:46if it was some real source I. Mean you know the best
- 2:49information's on those CD telegram groups?
- 2:51Yeah. That's where that's where Larry
- 2:54thinks. Going to drop the news that the
- 2:56was approved, but alas, we're joined by Mitch Kochman this
- 3:03week, the Director of Platform Sales at Bit Go.
- 3:06Really excited for this one Mitch, because bit go.
- 3:11I mean, outside of Coinbase, it's probably the only reputable
- 3:15company that's been around for a decade in the Bitcoin space.
- 3:19Mike Belshi, founder and CEO. Really popularized multi sig and
- 3:25have built your whole company around multi sig security and
- 3:30obviously we're here because the on ramp Bicca relationship has
- 3:35matured to a point where you guys are doing some really cool
- 3:39stuff. I'm sure we'll touch on that,
- 3:40but before we get into that. Michael and and Jesse have told
- 3:46me that you're the bitcoiner within Bitco.
- 3:48So what is your back story? How do you find Bitcoin and how
- 3:51did you end up at Bitco? Absolutely, yeah.
- 3:54President Maxi. But so came into the OR found
- 3:58Bitcoin 2017. My dad actually worked in Crypto
- 4:01VC for a little bit and really first introduction to it was
- 4:06price goes up and you know, was really all it was for 2017 in
- 4:11that bull run 20/18/19 started really falling down the rabbit
- 4:15hole. I'd say, you know, first I came
- 4:19from IBM, spent eleven years over there.
- 4:20The technology grabbed me first. Then really it was the the
- 4:24cypherpunk ethos, the libertarian, you know, ethos
- 4:27that surrounds it that we all sort of get engaged into.
- 4:31Punk rock was a important, formidable part of my my
- 4:35childhood and I think that sort of laid the foundation for for
- 4:38some of those ideals really struck a chord in me.
- 4:42So 2020 rolled around, I was on a sabbatical from IBMI was in
- 4:47Argentina, and I saw the impact that inflation actually had on
- 4:51the people there. And you know I think it was a it
- 4:55was a bartender that I was talking to that told him about
- 4:59the efforts that he had to go through to to buy the bar that
- 5:02we were sitting at and had to go you know black market to get
- 5:08currency exchange to you know Argentine peso the US dollar to
- 5:12keep you know the amount in escrow as they were waiting for.
- 5:15You know closing on the on the property and how we had a
- 5:19backpack with all his money and because you know the fees of
- 5:22going through a bank for for that currency exchange were were
- 5:25outrageous could have been robbed you know outside both
- 5:29times that he made the exchanges and it really kind of had that
- 5:34you know check your financial privilege Bitcoin fixes this
- 5:36moment of we can actually really make a difference here in that
- 5:41moment sort of thought perhaps this is this is where I should
- 5:45be working. Ended up coming back early from
- 5:47that trip and there was a pandemic and you know came back
- 5:53to IBM and sort of fell into what ended up being like had had
- 5:57been my dream job over there. I was global client exec for for
- 6:01JP Morgan. It was an incredible job got so
- 6:05much exposure to you know scale and you know traditional finance
- 6:09that you know the the infrastructure that that powers
- 6:12you know bank like JP Morgan is pretty pretty insane when you
- 6:16talk about raw compute power. But I had, you know, it was
- 6:21actually, it was one day I was out, I was taking Fridays as his
- 6:24paternity leave. And I looked at my son.
- 6:27It was the day of the Bitcoin or it's been on Thursday for the
- 6:30day of the Bitcoin conference. And I I looked at my son after,
- 6:36you know, watching the whole day of the conference.
- 6:38And I kind of had this moment where I wanted him to be proud
- 6:44of the work I was doing. And you know, I was inspired by
- 6:46the conference and you know, making, you know, JP Morgan more
- 6:51efficient and you know, saving people resources was not exactly
- 6:55what I had in mind for for how I I want him to view the work that
- 6:59I'm doing so that they made the decision to go work in the
- 7:02industry and you know, after but here.
- 7:07I am. That's powerful.
- 7:08It is for the kids. It's become somewhat of a meme,
- 7:11but I have very similar moments with my boys when I'm looking at
- 7:15them and looking out at the world that they're completely
- 7:18oblivious to. It's like, what can we be doing
- 7:20to to ensure that they don't have to deal with the madness
- 7:24that we all have had to deal with?
- 7:26So at least me, 32 years into my life, it's been pretty chaotic.
- 7:30There's three decades of my life.
- 7:34Michael, you're on mute. Thanks.
- 7:37Rookie mistake. Mitch and I have had a lot of
- 7:39conversations. I didn't know that about his
- 7:41journey, but also for more importantly about kind of you
- 7:45know, looking at your son and having this decision, cuz I
- 7:47think to Marty's point. You don't know like how this
- 7:51ends up. We don't know the other side.
- 7:53But you want to be able to look back and at least or somebody
- 7:55look back and say like at least they tried, at least they were
- 7:57doing something in the best use of the time.
- 8:00And so, yeah, I mean we had Larry Laparte on last week and
- 8:03he's another kind of, you know, kindred spirit that I think we
- 8:05get along with everybody on this group or on this call.
- 8:08And it's the same thing. Like he just never took the easy
- 8:11way out. It wasn't the the the thing that
- 8:14his peers did. But he was still there and he
- 8:17saw the other side and he's gonna be able to always keep his
- 8:19head up with his children. And so that's a, that's a cool
- 8:21story to hear that your son was the, you know, kind of forcing
- 8:25function to get you to to contribute and you're definitely
- 8:27contributing I'd say son and me and my wife pushing me to
- 8:31actually, you know follow the dream and you know.
- 8:34That's awesome. Yeah, we can't.
- 8:35We can't forget the wives. I think everybody, I shout.
- 8:40Out to the wives. I love you, baby.
- 8:42Yeah, I know how hard everybody on this call works and it
- 8:45wouldn't be possible without having a significant other that
- 8:47that was understanding. Oh, yeah, very true.
- 8:51Yeah. Mitch, I I keep thinking about,
- 8:53you know, the the thing that that always bounces around in my
- 8:55head is that that we are a part of some next wave of the like
- 9:01the American Revolution, the Enlightenment, you know,
- 9:04something like that in terms of advancing, asserting and
- 9:09advancing human freedom. And you know, the right to money
- 9:14and free money, money that is not controlled by anyone and
- 9:19that is just so important. It it it, there's no higher
- 9:22calling when you put it in that kind of, you know, historical
- 9:26context. And and then I also think about
- 9:30like there's there's a beautiful poem.
- 9:34Most people are familiar with the Ozymandias, or however it's
- 9:37pronounced where you know. Some great king in the desert
- 9:43has erected monuments to himself, but they're viewed as
- 9:48crumbled ruins in the in, you know many years later.
- 9:51And look on my works in despair as the the quote carved into
- 9:58some crumbled pillar. I am, I am Ozymandias.
- 10:01Look at my works in despair. Something like that.
- 10:04And. And that to me is like what we
- 10:08spend, what most people spend so much of their time doing in
- 10:10corporate America. You know you're you're building
- 10:13something that is you know a few years after you depart your your
- 10:19efforts there amount to crumbled ruins.
- 10:21They they they fall into disuse or you know they're papered over
- 10:25by some other improvements or updates and and it's like you
- 10:28were never there, but by working in Bitcoin you're part of
- 10:32something that's like. A lasting human movement for
- 10:39liberty that that it's just it's just night and day.
- 10:42And so those are the things that have been motivating me as well
- 10:45of, you know, the the calling of it is just a just a different
- 10:51level entirely. And I I truly think you know,
- 10:55that way I get to work with companies across the industry
- 10:57like anyone who is still here, you know they're working because
- 11:02they have that calling, they've got that edge.
- 11:04You know it's sort of that you know all the Liberty and
- 11:08American Revolution things that you're Speaking of.
- 11:11It's it's what drives us. And you know, those who you know
- 11:15who are still here are are definitely fuelled by that.
- 11:20Yeah, it pays to state or in the bear markets.
- 11:22I've been in this for 10 years now, six years professionally,
- 11:26and that's when you really find out who's who's in it for the
- 11:30cause. Who's in it for number go up and
- 11:33who's in it for the revolution. The like part of the revolution
- 11:37is number go up. You just got to learn how to be
- 11:39patient, not not ride the hype waves.
- 11:42But no, that's important. I think particularly this bear
- 11:45market, maybe we're coming out of it, who knows?
- 11:49We're hovering around 28 and a half, $1000 right now.
- 11:52There's a lot of good headlines out there, some fake, some real.
- 11:57We had Larry Fink on CNBC earlier this week.
- 12:00Saying that quote UN quote crypto is the flight to safety
- 12:03asset or one of the flight to safety assets that people will
- 12:06be flooding into as the turmoil in the world continues to
- 12:09increase both on the financial side and the geopolitical side
- 12:13of things. And alongside that in parallel,
- 12:17I mean we've talked about this many times in the last few
- 12:20months on this show, but it just becomes more pronounced day in
- 12:25and day out, I think particularly with the
- 12:27partnership that on ramp and bitco.
- 12:30Are announcing this week after we record this, but by the time
- 12:34this is live it will have been announced.
- 12:37I think the infrastructure at the base layer of the industry
- 12:40that actually gives people access to Bitcoin, the asset in
- 12:45the network is more mature than it has ever been and we're
- 12:49setting standards in this bear market that will be long lasting
- 12:53moving forward, which is really exciting to see.
- 12:57Yeah. And maybe before going into bit
- 13:00go Mitch, you'd love to hear kind of like so you had this
- 13:02journey close to 10 years, I think it was your whole career
- 13:05and coming into to bit go like what the process was looking at
- 13:11other firms and then deciding on bit go because you know there's
- 13:16interactions across your organization and they're world
- 13:18class in the sense of like it's just a different built firm.
- 13:22And I think it goes back to like Mike being a former Googler and
- 13:24just like having the operational execution chops and then it just
- 13:27stems from the top. But would just love to hear kind
- 13:30of like what the culture and how that process was because it's
- 13:33just been, it's been like eye opening and refreshing because
- 13:37I've seen a lot of people in this industry do the opposite of
- 13:39it and they don't exist anymore. And so I'd love to just hear
- 13:41kind of like how that process went and like what ultimately
- 13:44made you choose Bitco before you know jumping into Bitco and as a
- 13:47whole for sure. So I mean breaking into this
- 13:50industry is not easy. So really how I started it was
- 13:5511 years at IBM and how do I take what I do best at IBM and
- 14:01then bring that into the industry so focused I was AB to
- 14:06B seller how do I like let's try to stay in that realm and you
- 14:12know repurpose that for you know broadly you know it was crypto
- 14:15my you know obviously my my heart's in Bitcoin but you know
- 14:20was gassing the net out. I I knew wallets.
- 14:23You know, I'd say fairly deeply you know spent some time.
- 14:27You know, I've been a Casa customer I think since 2019 you
- 14:32know, had a great multi six set up before before I came in.
- 14:35But I was really looking for how I can really move into the IBM
- 14:41of the industry. I know how to sell a, you know a
- 14:46solution that might be more expensive but is you know more
- 14:49reliable more secure. And you know the the old mantra
- 14:53of nobody gets fired for, for buying IBM was trying to you
- 14:57know replicate that for this industry especially one that you
- 15:01know you got to rely on your counterparty you know, being
- 15:03there, you know tomorrow, the next year and the next five
- 15:06years. I think it was it was largely
- 15:11largely that that that that brought me in and you know as
- 15:18far as you know what you know I I personally you know we do
- 15:24we've got quite a bit of platform business we have quite
- 15:26a bit of institutional business. I I wanted to focus on you know
- 15:30companies that were doing the you know the work of onboarding
- 15:33the, you know the next users you know to Bitcoin and filling out
- 15:38like my work actually, you know, helping those companies being
- 15:42the critical rails for those companies definitely you know
- 15:45was was the passion project for me and why I'm here.
- 15:51And what particularly do you think is Bitco again?
- 15:56It's been around for a decade, and I think hardcore Bitcoiners
- 15:59understand. That they're a pretty integral
- 16:01part of a lot of the infrastructure, particularly on
- 16:04the custodial, custodial side of things with their multi sig
- 16:07product. But and I think many people
- 16:11understand like the unique intricacies and sort of process
- 16:16that Bitco has. I don't want to say it's been
- 16:18like a black box, but it's almost been they've just sort of
- 16:24been nose to the grindstone, getting stuff done and not
- 16:27really worrying about others. Are doing in the space at least
- 16:30is the impression that I've gotten being in the space for 10
- 16:33years. Yeah.
- 16:34So what they go, they go as a wallet company at really its
- 16:38core focus on you know we've got cold, cold storage and hot
- 16:42wallets but really known for for cold qualified custody.
- 16:46And and what we do is, you know, we've got an armed guard you
- 16:51know, with banquet vaults separation of duties where you
- 16:56know when Bigo is, you know signing a transaction from cold
- 16:59storage. You know we've got a key signing
- 17:01ceremony where you know there are multiple people who are
- 17:06going into that vault. You know, to go sign key shards
- 17:09and you know constitute them together to go you know half
- 17:12sign a transaction which then you know gets countersigned by
- 17:17by our HSM, different different secure location, you know take
- 17:21it to go broadcast to our nodes and that's how transactions get
- 17:24signed from cold storage at Bigo.
- 17:25You know it's a pretty tried and true process that's you know, I
- 17:30think 20% of all on chain Bitcoin transactions are going
- 17:34in or out of a Bigo wallet. And you know, we've been doing
- 17:38this for 10 years and and it really it works and that's why
- 17:42we're the one of the corner signs of the industry.
- 17:48Yeah, yeah. Having you walk through that
- 17:51process of like these are competencies and and
- 17:55capabilities that have been built over literally a decade
- 17:58and and coming from a starting point of extreme technical
- 18:01competence where you know Mike Belcher's my understanding is
- 18:07invented multi sig and so you know that's the that's your
- 18:11starting point 10 years ago and the amount of of.
- 18:16Process and Polish that has accumulated over that 10 year
- 18:21period, you know it strikes me as like this is obviously the
- 18:26way that people should be the gold standard for how you should
- 18:31be as an as an institution, as a company trying to handle your
- 18:37digital asset custody and. And that's part of what we're so
- 18:41excited about is like through this multi institution custody
- 18:45model that that on ramp is, is championing people get to
- 18:50incorporate your best practices into how they are custodying
- 18:55their Bitcoin via on ramp without having to build all that
- 19:01that infrastructure and and know how that you guys have built
- 19:06over 10 years. Yeah, I think, I think it's
- 19:10important also like bit go, and this is something I didn't know,
- 19:13I've learned a lot the past year.
- 19:15But bit Go's been successful. A portion of success is like
- 19:19from deeply understanding Bitcoin, the technical aspects
- 19:23of it, and then pushing out security to the edges.
- 19:26And so it's my understanding of the core offering and it was
- 19:28this understanding of the keys. In multi sig where whether it's
- 19:33jurisdictional from the protocol level or whatever reason that
- 19:36Bigo would participate in one of the keys but then open up their
- 19:40infrastructure for the exchange or their counterparty to hold
- 19:44two or three of the keys. And so that allows and has
- 19:48allowed for years different variations or flavors of
- 19:52custody. If it doesn't centralized the
- 19:54asset and then increase the risk of all the things that we've
- 19:57seen. And I think that just like core
- 19:59first principle starts the, it starts the foundation of
- 20:02something that can be long standing because it's it's baked
- 20:05in at the core of just understanding Bitcoin deeply and
- 20:08then just being an engineer at heart.
- 20:11And I think when that happens, at least from my experience and
- 20:15background in Mitch, you can correct me is that I think
- 20:17that's where the market. Sometimes doesn't really
- 20:19recognize or know as much of the market share that Bitcoin bit go
- 20:23has or the infrastructure that it powers and provides.
- 20:26There's some crazy stats that I don't know off the top of my
- 20:28head, Mitch, you probably know better like one of those like
- 20:2920% of all I think transactions like daily happen via like a bit
- 20:33go wallet or something in that direction.
- 20:36But because it comes from more of an engineer focus versus like
- 20:39a sales and marketing, that's where it's really like the it's
- 20:42not to mean a pejorative like the blue collar, like the the
- 20:44sound infrastructure similar to what you referenced with IBM
- 20:47versus the the loud and flashy because it's just baked in those
- 20:52ethos. At least that's my perception of
- 20:53it from from a market participant.
- 20:56Yeah, I mean you got it right. I think most of our, many of our
- 20:59competitors have an exchange arm and you know tend to you know
- 21:04because they've got a retail presence in in that regard you
- 21:07know. They've got more name
- 21:09recognition than we do, but those, you know that are in the
- 21:11industry, definitely you know, know about us and know, you know
- 21:16that you know, we're a cornerstone here.
- 21:21Yeah, and going back to this particular bear market in this
- 21:25sort of shift, it seems like the perception between of Bitcoin
- 21:32and where it fits in the crypto is beginning.
- 21:34They're beginning to separate. There's this demarcation between
- 21:37Bitcoin and crypto that's becoming clear.
- 21:40After 15 years of almost 15 years since the white paper
- 21:43launch, it'll be in 13 days, which is hard to imagine.
- 21:48There has been a lot of pump and dumps, a lot of hype cycles, and
- 21:53it seems like I don't wanna speak too soon or jinx anything
- 21:58or call like peak crypto. But it does seem like this
- 22:01particular bear market, and especially after.
- 22:04The FDX debacle and Celsius and Block Fi and Three Hours
- 22:08Capital, all of that Terra Luna go down the list has really
- 22:13positioned Bitcoin in the eyes of institutional allocators as
- 22:16something that is unique and different than than crypto.
- 22:21And it seems like bit Go is really leaning into this as well
- 22:27at this particular point in time where it's.
- 22:29OK, let's focus on the most important asset, which is
- 22:32Bitcoin. Has there been a shift
- 22:33internally in the focus on Bitcoin specifically?
- 22:38A lot to break out on, on, on this question.
- 22:41I'd say at least internally I know we had some conversations
- 22:46post FTX that were you know well we we guess we we support 700
- 22:52plus assets and as a custodian you sort of need to be around.
- 22:59I think there was a there there was, there was certainly an
- 23:02internal push to increase the the amount of this Bitcoin
- 23:05business that we were doing just to to ensure you know, Bitco
- 23:10makes money on you know one of the biggest metric is assets
- 23:13under custody. And if you know that metric goes
- 23:17down because price action for for an asset goes down, Bitco
- 23:19makes less money. I think there was, you know,
- 23:22certainly a focus that bitcoins going to have lasting power
- 23:26here. And in in a bear market let's
- 23:30you know make sure we we shift some energy.
- 23:32You know in that regard I'd say you know one of the you know as
- 23:38far as Bitcoin is a focus and you know why you're starting to
- 23:41see a lot more from us. Bitco has really all one of
- 23:48really the the critical failure points you know for for us would
- 23:54be you know. If there was you know some sort
- 23:57of you know technical issue soft hard fork that happened in
- 24:01Bitcoin and we needed you know the, you know the technical team
- 24:04to go support that. And because of that you've got
- 24:09absolutely outstanding you know tech like technical resources
- 24:14that we've had from you know Jameson Lobb to Brandon Black to
- 24:17you know our Bitcoin team is outstanding here.
- 24:21And I think we had we had a moment where.
- 24:25We we you know very much believe we've got the best commercial
- 24:29wall in the industry. And we we have the thought of
- 24:32how do we not just secure assets in those wallets, but how do we
- 24:39actually help companies build products and services.
- 24:43And you know, actually productize and put those wallets
- 24:46in the hands of the most people actually do the hard work of you
- 24:49know, onboarding bitcoiners here.
- 24:52You know focusing in a post FTX world of.
- 24:55You know I think a narrative in the next you know cycle is going
- 24:58to custody is going to matter. You know whether you know multi
- 25:00institution custody like what we're talking about on ramp to
- 25:04you know what we did with Swan Vault where the infrastructure
- 25:09you know behind you know the Swan key and that key signing to
- 25:14you know what we're seeing you know at Unchained in that
- 25:16announcement. I think we need solutions.
- 25:19We need to do a better job as the industry to to go provide
- 25:22solutions to to, you know. Help onboard those retail users
- 25:26and have them feel better about, you know, the story that we're
- 25:30telling here. So I think because of, you know,
- 25:35opening up those wallets, you know, there was a bigger
- 25:39presence that at least we had. You know, if you read Bitcoin
- 25:41Miami, you know, Bitco was everywhere and we had the same
- 25:45with Pacific Bitcoin. I think we're we're doubling and
- 25:48tripling down on the the Bitcoin, Bitcoin only, Bitcoin
- 25:51first base. Yeah, I got.
- 25:54I got AI, got a great tote bag from Bitcoin Miami that has Pico
- 25:58on it. But yeah, you know I keep
- 26:02thinking about how if we're if we're really going to, if this
- 26:06is turning into digital gold and it's still very early in that
- 26:11monetization process bootstrapping from zero to
- 26:15matching gold, let's say of $12 trillion, we're at 500 billion.
- 26:20So we're still early in that process and.
- 26:23To get further into the adoption curve we have to cross the
- 26:26chasm. You know the the the spooky
- 26:30metaphor there of like how do you go from your early adopters
- 26:34to your mainstream. And the way you do that is not
- 26:38only through like effective marketing or propagating the
- 26:41value proposition of Bitcoin, but the the tooling has to get
- 26:44better. It has to get easier, more
- 26:47secure, more reliable and. I in my mind Bitco is like at
- 26:52the forefront of that process of making institutional capital
- 26:58more comfortable with Bitcoin as an asset.
- 27:00Because Bitco is, you know, creating better solutions for
- 27:06for feeling confident that you know your your Bitcoin is going
- 27:12to stay in your vault until the time when you decide to to move
- 27:16it. And you know with FTX and.
- 27:20Prime Trust and Fortress trust the there.
- 27:23There has been ample reason to to doubt that that's the case.
- 27:26But the way we're going to get past the chasm is because the
- 27:30Bitcoin native companies who are doing it right, Bicco first and
- 27:35foremost in my mind, are creating that tooling to make it
- 27:39easier for people to take the leap into Bitcoin.
- 27:43Yeah, I think that's a really important note because
- 27:46ultimately what we're talking about democratizes the ability
- 27:50to build a business or a company and all the things that Mitch
- 27:53referenced on the different styles of custody, they're all
- 27:57right and they're all wrong. And that's why it's so
- 27:59controversial when it comes to custody, because it's always
- 28:01moving all the time for everybody and for whatever
- 28:04reason in the industry. And it hasn't been like gotten
- 28:07through yet where everybody believes there's a certain form
- 28:09of custody that should exist and it's just not true.
- 28:12Everybody has their own unique risk factors and will continue
- 28:15to change based on whatever is personal or the price
- 28:18appreciation and everything in between.
- 28:20And so bit go instead of saying this is how we feel you should
- 28:23do it or you have to build or leverage our solution for X.
- 28:25It's like hey, we believe that this native you know technology
- 28:29along with keys are important and we talk about it a lot.
- 28:32But it's like very often externally do I hear it talked
- 28:35about where like hash rate, you know nodes are important.
- 28:38I think keys are right up there. I think it's 1A1B1C because of
- 28:43the fact like if all, if you have all the hash rate, you know
- 28:46decentralized, but you have the key sitting on 2 exchanges, it's
- 28:49not a good situation. And so it's just cool like to
- 28:52see that as part of the guiding principle of how you guys think
- 28:55about infrastructure. Yeah, I mean, I we have the
- 29:02most, you know, decentralized money, you know, really.
- 29:07That that the world has ever seen and how it exists today
- 29:11it's sitting on the most centralized you know, financial
- 29:14systems that we've ever encountered.
- 29:17You know where your exchanges are.
- 29:19You know for the most part, you know, holding the actual assets
- 29:23themselves and you know they're the broker dealer.
- 29:26It's it's a it's an absolute mess and.
- 29:29It's sometimes sitting in like in text files, as FTX revealed.
- 29:37I know. So I think and it's because of
- 29:40that, that you know when you talk to you know most of the
- 29:43population out there, your normally friends that you know,
- 29:47we get laughed at and we've got to actually build these rails
- 29:50properly to actually make this, you know, a success and let us
- 29:56actually win here. Yeah, it's like the beginning of
- 29:592000 A Space Odyssey or 2001 A Space Odyssey when Bitcoins just
- 30:04let that black. Rectangular.
- 30:07Yeah. Monolith that people are like
- 30:08slapping like what the hell is this thing again?
- 30:11Almost 15 years in it feels like, oh like if we're really
- 30:15going to practice what we preach, eat our own dog food
- 30:17here. Like when we would talk about a
- 30:19Bitcoin standard. Like Bitcoin has these native
- 30:21properties that allow you to create these new financial
- 30:25products and ways to interact with them.
- 30:27Like let's leverage the tech. And again, I do think it's
- 30:31important to really. Beat this dead horse.
- 30:34But like, it feels like this cycle particularly has really
- 30:38driven that to everybody's, the front of everybody's mind where
- 30:41it's like, OK, the Mount Cox, plenty more Bitstamp, FTX,
- 30:51Celsius, Quadriga, Voyager. Like they all simply did not
- 30:58know how to manage keys. Not only that, they didn't know
- 31:00how to architect. Sort of a a risk design like a a
- 31:07way to mitigate risk by leveraging Bitcoin's native
- 31:09multi sig properties. And I've been saying this for
- 31:12two years now. Multi sig, multi institution,
- 31:15multi sig I think will be the standard moving forward 'cause
- 31:19when you distribute that key risk, it's first layer via multi
- 31:24sig and then second layer multi sig via multi institutions,
- 31:27you're just really dispersing that centralized third party
- 31:30risk cross. Your security set up?
- 31:35Yeah, maybe that. I was gonna say maybe that ties
- 31:38into to the extent is what you you can share willing like we
- 31:42could talk about you know our interaction and kind of like
- 31:45this coming across you know what we're working on and you know
- 31:48you really leaning in along with the team and how that kind of
- 31:50plays into what Marty just talked about.
- 31:54So I I think I read this in a in an on ramp you know press
- 31:58release but. It was a quote that you guys had
- 32:01that you know this is this is the first asset that you don't
- 32:04necessarily, you don't only have to worry about the actual asset
- 32:07price going to 0, but you can experience a you know a loss of
- 32:11the actual asset and you know have your balance go to 0
- 32:15because mismanagement of keys and I think you know that
- 32:19strikes fear in in a lot of you know Ras and you know asset
- 32:25allocators but. I think you know the setups you
- 32:31know looking at multi institution custody and you know
- 32:34division of that counterparty risk.
- 32:36I I don't know how you can have a fundamental understanding of
- 32:41Bitcoin in the asset and not think this is a better model.
- 32:47You know the ability to, you know you've got a two or three
- 32:50key signing structure where you're relying on 3 institutions
- 32:53and. Something happens to institution
- 32:56#3 or one and you know working with the other two institutions
- 32:59to go you know move to migrate to another wallet where you've
- 33:03got a you know another sound institution holding a third key
- 33:09I it it just simply makes sense. You know when Michael you
- 33:14mentioned when when I this first came across my desk and you know
- 33:17I first started talking to you guys, I think you fundamentally.
- 33:23Got that. You know, I think you know this
- 33:26idea of multi institution custody is not not necessarily
- 33:28new, but the unrelenting focus on doing this and building this
- 33:35the right way where the you know, the user is in you know.
- 33:42Can there there's no situation where where these funds can get
- 33:45moved without a user's permission to you know truly
- 33:51building the company you know with with this as the mindset
- 33:54and you know the core competency and that's what you're calling a
- 33:57market with. I just you know I saw the
- 34:00vision. I saw, you know, really the
- 34:05unrelenting focus on, you know, that core competency and that's
- 34:11why you guys stuck out to me. And I think to really help
- 34:16listeners visualize this, who may be a bit new to this concept
- 34:20as a whole. I mean just think about the
- 34:22banking crisis that that happened earlier this year
- 34:25started actually probably this time last year and rolled into
- 34:28the the first quarter of this year, second quarter actually I
- 34:32can imagine you're a Silicon Valley Bank customer and you're.
- 34:37Hearing rumors that there's a run on your bank and you're
- 34:41scaring to get away? Move your funds, set up another
- 34:43bank account to move your funds to, or move your funds to a bank
- 34:46account you already have set up and you're worried.
- 34:49And luckily for those customers that got bailed up by the
- 34:52government, they were made whole.
- 34:54But you can easily make the argument that that's not going
- 34:58to be true moving forward for all the banks.
- 35:00Obviously we had wamu fail. In 2008 and a bunch of others
- 35:04but this set up what Bitcoin enables be this multi
- 35:07institutional model is God forbid it happens but we would
- 35:11be naive to think it's not possible down the road.
- 35:14If you have your your funds secured in two or three multi
- 35:18institution, multi sig and one of those institutions has a run
- 35:22or they just simply go bankrupt seek you don't have to freak out
- 35:26as much as Mitch said you can move your Bitcoin using the
- 35:31other two institutions. To a secure wallet, add in
- 35:34another key into that quorum, another institutional key, and
- 35:38then be set. You don't have to worry as much.
- 35:40And so like really comparing this to the incumbent financial
- 35:45system and banking infrastructure, like it is a
- 35:48step function improvement on just Peace of Mind in terms of
- 35:53knowing that your funds are relatively safe compared to the
- 35:57banking system that exists now. I'll take a little further too
- 36:03and say that, you know, in this scenario where Silicon Valley
- 36:07Bank happens, you're OK because the government's going to step
- 36:11in and and save you because they control the currency so they can
- 36:14make more of it. And it's just kind of the, the
- 36:18social contract of of of Fiat money is that governments are
- 36:24going to step in. And that's why.
- 36:27That's why you're all right with this system.
- 36:30And obviously Bitcoin doesn't allow for that.
- 36:32And so making the transition as a user, as a as a saver, saving
- 36:38your value in a currency that the government will step in and
- 36:44help you and transitioning from that to a currency where nobody
- 36:48can step in to help you ever, that is a non starter unless the
- 36:57the systems in place for the. Security of that asset in the
- 37:03new system are vastly superior to what exists in the old system
- 37:09and and I think that before multi institution custody that
- 37:15in my opinion was not true for Bitcoin of like there's risks in
- 37:20self custody of you might screw it up or you might accidentally
- 37:24reveal too much to some prying eye.
- 37:27And get your funds stolen. Self custody has risks.
- 37:31On the other side, the third party custodian has risks too.
- 37:35Like that's what we saw with with prime trust, with 4th
- 37:39fortress trust, with FTX, with with all of the others that you
- 37:43listed before. Those were centralized
- 37:46custodians and they screwed up and users in this world.
- 37:51Are left holding the bag. In the Silicon Valley bank
- 37:54world, the government steps in to make it so that you know
- 37:57nobody's left, no end user is screwed.
- 38:01But in Bitcoin, the end user gets screwed by by centralized
- 38:05custodians who screw up. And so with both of those
- 38:09models, self custody and 3rd party custody, there are risks
- 38:13that make it unattractive or hard to a hard pill to swallow.
- 38:18You're taking a risk. Setting things up and you
- 38:21better, you better know that you're you've done it right
- 38:23yourself. That's in my opinion to date the
- 38:26best approach has been self custody, where you have to
- 38:29invest a lot of time and energy into setting to learning what
- 38:33you need to do and then setting it up right in collaborative
- 38:35custody. Solutions like Unchained or Casa
- 38:38have made that easier, but it's still hard and there's still
- 38:42risks. But now?
- 38:45Looking forward going into a multi institution custody world
- 38:48that was simply never possible in the in the dollar universe in
- 38:54the traditional asset landscape. Because only with this kind of
- 38:58asset, a truly digital asset that's rooted in cryptography
- 39:02are you able to have this two of three custody solution that's
- 39:06not possible in in the traditional world and that two
- 39:10of three custody solution that Mitch was was talking about
- 39:13where if one. One of those legs of the tripod
- 39:17goes out, you can swap in a new one.
- 39:20And that level of assurance I think in in my mind takes the
- 39:27the quality of the systems of of custody in Bitcoin world.
- 39:33It creates that order of magnitude improvement on custody
- 39:36that's necessary to go from a world where the government can
- 39:39step in. To a world where nobody can step
- 39:42in, but it's OK because it's so much safer and and more secure
- 39:46than than any previous form of custody ever.
- 39:50So I think that's, I think it's like a tipping point in custody
- 39:53for Bitcoin. And that will enable the
- 39:55maturation of the asset class and the adoption of this asset
- 39:59because it it lowers the barrier to entry for people who have
- 40:03been, you know, scared of. I don't know if I trust crypto.
- 40:10Because FTX happened, but I think you know we're gonna see
- 40:14multi institution custody emerge as the gold standard because the
- 40:18FTX scenario can't happen if you've set it up right.
- 40:22Thanks for tuning in to the last trade.
- 40:25If you're enjoying the show and want to dive deeper, check us
- 40:28out. At on rampbitcoin.com where
- 40:31you'll find a full suite of institutional grade research and
- 40:35analytics. Including our recently published
- 40:37white paper, Bitcoin's full potential valuation and our new
- 40:42tool, the On Ramp Terminal. Now back to the show.
- 40:47Yeah, I think, I think it's exactly right.
- 40:49I think, I think what we're talking about here is actually
- 40:52like to get a little meta in the sense of like the custody.
- 40:57It's always. The cat's out of the bag
- 40:59independent of of on ramp and and Mitch will speak to this and
- 41:02and maybe we can give even more insights into what we're working
- 41:05on. So he can explain, you know,
- 41:08Betco's involvement and why they've invested in this
- 41:10infrastructure. But I think taking a step back,
- 41:14I think Bitcoin's very hard to understand for a lot of people
- 41:18because. Half of it is just assuming that
- 41:23if they took the time to invest in understanding it, it doesn't
- 41:25really matter because it can all go up and smoke either way.
- 41:29And so Mitch alluded to and I don't know if it was in a blog
- 41:31or if we if it made it to a draft, but there was something
- 41:34we were saying or like playing around with the wording of like
- 41:37never has it been before where you're like looking at an asset
- 41:39then maybe you want to allocate to and then you you possibly
- 41:43could be a zero the next day because of misappropriation of
- 41:46funds or or leverage or whatever it is.
- 41:48And so to Jesse's point, like if you live in this world where it
- 41:53can always disappear and you keep hearing the number of 200
- 41:55million wallet addresses, 200,000,000, but the reality is
- 41:59it's like one 100th if lot less of that has material exposure to
- 42:02Bitcoin because most people have it as a flyer and it's like, oh,
- 42:06it can always disappear. I don't want to take possession
- 42:08because I have messed it up, but the exchange, if they go under,
- 42:10it's just like whatever. And it's this chicken or egg
- 42:14with whether it's institutions or individuals and like, do I
- 42:17really even want to like go down this rabbit hole or understand
- 42:19it. It has been the best performing
- 42:20asset, all the things we know. But this reality of like it can
- 42:24just be taken at a moment's notice and there is no recourse.
- 42:27And we know there's no bailouts, but then to the point of
- 42:30increasing redundancy. And reducing counterparty risk
- 42:34starts to bring a different kind of market structure for
- 42:37individuals to step in and then I'll and feel very confident in
- 42:40like, OK, so the custody of the assets similar to if I bought
- 42:43Amazon stock or if I bought gold, you know, Counterparty
- 42:47risk I think is going to come to the forefront in all things just
- 42:49given the the nature of leverage in the system and that some
- 42:53people just can't are going to be left holding the bag and it's
- 42:55going to suck. And that's where I think
- 42:56counterparty risk in Bitcoin starts to really make sense.
- 42:59As a like a value prop that most people discount.
- 43:02But it's a different story. It's more of just the fact that
- 43:04like you can get exposure to something and know again, there
- 43:08are no there are no perfect solutions for custody.
- 43:13In my mind, they're perfect trade-offs.
- 43:14And there is a reality that things can happen in in multi
- 43:17institution that still have your Bitcoin lost.
- 43:20But our vision of the future at least on the on ramp side is
- 43:23that as the market grows and reputations and trust is built.
- 43:28It's similar in financial institution in like the free
- 43:30banking world where those who fulfill their obligations, those
- 43:33who fulfill their security requirements and all the things
- 43:36associated with, you know, storing cryptographic material
- 43:39and fulfilling the obligations will be the market leaders.
- 43:42In participating and then obviously those that have the
- 43:45TXT file in the drawer will not. Jesse, you mentioned a few weeks
- 43:50ago, I think it was something along the lines of innovation in
- 43:54the custody space has certainly lagged what's what's possible on
- 43:58chain and you know in the asset itself, you know Mike actually
- 44:02said something similar at Pacific Bitcoin last week or two
- 44:05weeks ago when? He said you know we have the
- 44:07infrastructure in place to to handle billion dollar wallets
- 44:11and we we have few at BECO. What we don't have in place is
- 44:16you know what's going to be required to for the trillion
- 44:18dollar wallet and when the industry actually grows there
- 44:21like we all believe it does and it's things like multi
- 44:24institution custody. It's things like time locks, you
- 44:27know, God forbid a key is lost. You know, new ways to recover
- 44:31them. And it's the things that we're
- 44:33going to be focused on over here to, you know, and.
- 44:36The businesses like you guys that that we need to enable to,
- 44:39you know, place the rails down right now in this bear market
- 44:42for you know, the rapid appreciation, you know, we
- 44:46expect to come in the years to come.
- 44:48Yeah, time locks, mini scripts, vaults, covenants, whatever it
- 44:52may be. I mean, out of that list, I
- 44:54think mini scripts the only thing that's possible right now.
- 44:56But things that bitcoiners are talking about on the line,
- 45:00things like covenants, there's no innovation.
- 45:02There's no innovation on Bitcoin.
- 45:04That's that's all happening elsewhere, Marty.
- 45:09Let them think that, let them think that.
- 45:10I love that people think that gives us more alpha, more time
- 45:13to accumulate. But I think it's important to
- 45:16note pulling on this thread even further, like the existence of
- 45:20multi institution custody. I mean we were analoging it to
- 45:24the incumbent banking system. And yes, Michael, I know you
- 45:27mentioned there still could be some pitfalls within this model
- 45:31and ways to rug people, but I do think.
- 45:33The fact that it exists and is out there creates an incentive
- 45:39structure that really reduces the likelihood of this because
- 45:41it becomes much harder. And you're sort of forced, since
- 45:44you're in this quorum with other institutions that had their own
- 45:48reputations that they want to preserve, like the the
- 45:52likelihood of fuckery, for lack lack of a better term, goes down
- 45:57pretty significantly. I think that's exactly right.
- 46:00Like Jesse and I talked about this and I think we both have
- 46:02coalesced around a vision of this will be a little
- 46:05controversial in this call and it'll be for a while is like
- 46:08multi institution, it doesn't have to be two or three, it can
- 46:10be two or four or three or four client participates, ultimately
- 46:14ends up where 80% of Bitcoin is custody.
- 46:16Long term Bitcoin ends up is money.
- 46:17But the important part about self custody and the fact that
- 46:20you can spin up a wallet or set up a multi sig wallet or
- 46:22collaborative custody where you hold unilateral control.
- 46:25Keeps everybody honest. It's that valve that you can
- 46:27take the asset out and you can always prove when you want is
- 46:30that gun, you know, to everybody's head saying like,
- 46:33hey, I don't have to trust you, I can actually take it out and
- 46:35then bring it back. And that's like if you guys
- 46:37listen or Mitch, if you heard the Glenn Cartwright.
- 46:40It's been so fun. Doing all the stuff we're doing
- 46:44because we haven't announced all the products and the services
- 46:46we're going to build around multi institution from the
- 46:48ground up. But then it clients coming our
- 46:50way saying hey like we're we've been looking for this like we've
- 46:53been looking for a fund that has reduced counterparty risk or be
- 46:56able to take delivery. And so to the point of like this
- 46:59cycle and what you guys are building for and what we're
- 47:01building, it's like we, we think it's a very opportunistic time
- 47:05because the market's going to come back as we know it with a
- 47:07vengeance. Probably greater than anything
- 47:09we've ever seen in the past 15 years.
- 47:11And all the right tooling is going to like start to, you
- 47:13know, surface to the top because people have recognized like,
- 47:16hey, I don't want to get rugged again.
- 47:19It is amazing I I get to work with most of the the large
- 47:23Bitcoin platforms out there. Amazing watching the building
- 47:27that's going on right now as the rails really are getting laid
- 47:30for for the next bull run, you know, companies focused on you
- 47:35know. Make like when FTX happened,
- 47:39everyone was trying to figure out how do we still trade.
- 47:41You know with market makers, you know going down and liquidity
- 47:46drying up, you know we have to build the redundancy, resiliency
- 47:51to make sure that doesn't happen again.
- 47:53So between, you know, the large players building out, you know
- 47:57second, third, fourth options, you know to keep trade going.
- 48:00To, you know, rethinking business models and you know,
- 48:04custody solutions. You know, like what you guys are
- 48:06doing, what's quit Swan's doing, you know, figuring out how to
- 48:10actually do lending the right way.
- 48:13You know how to do that on chain.
- 48:14How to, you know, do that where you know you're, you know,
- 48:20there's no really, you know, risk of, you know, the blow UPS
- 48:26that happened over collateralization like.
- 48:29These are the things that are getting focused on right now.
- 48:31It's beautiful watching. It's like really inspiring and
- 48:36Brofoot should be a part of it. Yeah, I mean the the fascinating
- 48:42thing is I said a lot about the the meta and like the market
- 48:48perception ahead because of just having lots of conversations the
- 48:50past, you know three years and onboarding.
- 48:53And I I feel the same way about what I'm about to say on, I
- 48:55don't think there's another firm honestly on the planet Earth
- 48:57that's doing or would have done what BET Go's doing.
- 48:59We can probably get into like what they're doing with on ramp,
- 49:01but it's because we've talked to the fidelities and the BNY
- 49:05Mellons and large scale firms. And while they're doing a lot in
- 49:08digital asset ecosystem, they're still mired in the in the first
- 49:12principles thinking from their old world of financial services
- 49:16and you want to control and hold all of the asset.
- 49:19To be able to do what you want to, whether it's re lend or
- 49:22control or charge on it. And the problem is that we've
- 49:26seen over the past 15 years of Bitcoin's history like that's
- 49:29just a recipe for failure and disaster because that's not what
- 49:32the asset wants to do. It doesn't want to centralized
- 49:34for a number of reasons. And so to see you guys building
- 49:37like that, it's like it, it makes sense from a Bitcoin angle
- 49:41or from somebody that's like native, you mean call it go as
- 49:44far as crypto native? But once you come from the old
- 49:47world, it's like why would you ever do anything like this.
- 49:50And so it's just a that thought hit me because I don't think the
- 49:54new leaders are the leaders that end up building the financial
- 49:57products of the future. I I feel like few if any will be
- 50:01incumbents because it's such a radical shift in how you treat
- 50:05an asset and risk as we've seen like Block Fi, you know, God
- 50:09bless them, like they're just going to be a poster trial
- 50:10because it's just. The exact model that you don't
- 50:13want to do, and I just fear like a BlackRock is going to be
- 50:15blocked by at orders of magnitude larger, same concept
- 50:19centralization, doing potentially some other things
- 50:22that are going to paper BTC. And then at the end of the day,
- 50:25if you get caught offsides, there's a bunch of people left.
- 50:27Hold in the bag. I think that like the reason
- 50:31why, you know, we did this, you look at Mike's background at
- 50:35Google, Lookout companies based in Palo Alto, you know.
- 50:41Heart of Silicon Valley, it's technology is you know in our
- 50:45DNA it's at the forefront here. You know we open source all our
- 50:48wallets. It's because we know it's the
- 50:51most secure way to do it. And you know, really at our core
- 50:56we're able to sort of think with that, you know, disruptor, you
- 51:02know, mindset of you know, we've got to make sure we're still
- 51:06here and you know, knowing that. Like you said the the asset you
- 51:12know is decentralized and you know and wants to find that home
- 51:17and you know I hope the market plays out that that that is the
- 51:20case. We've got to play in that world
- 51:22and I think we can we can kind of see around that corner and
- 51:25you know make sure you know at least in the Bitcoin space where
- 51:29you know if if we're not you know the the sole custodian of
- 51:32the asset, how do we make sure we're the best key agent in the
- 51:34industry and you know if you know.
- 51:39We're making, you know, less money doing that.
- 51:43You know, perhaps we actually 34X revenue because more capital
- 51:49is actually coming into the industry because they actually
- 51:51trust the infrastructure and the models that are being built for
- 51:53for custody. It's a long term bet, but I I
- 51:56think it's good for the industry and I think it'll be good for
- 51:58big CO2. Completely agree and it's
- 52:02Michael. You mentioned the incumbents.
- 52:04I think that is going to be the innovator's dilemma that they.
- 52:08They are confronted with and Mitch you just made a great
- 52:12point like it is counterintuitive particularly if
- 52:14you're using incumbent business models and trying to apply them
- 52:19to Bitcoin. Like there is a very strong case
- 52:22to be made that yes doing this multi institution custody model
- 52:27and sort of splitting up fees. Let's just be frank like this.
- 52:32This is what's gonna happen if we go to this models the.
- 52:37Fee structure that exists in the incumbent world where one
- 52:40institution holds the assets and reaps fees from that like that's
- 52:44going to get sort of shattered and split amongst many
- 52:49institutions is creating these new business models in these new
- 52:52fee structures that that work within this new paradigm due to
- 52:58the fact that we can build these models with Bitcoin's multi sig
- 53:01technology and. That is going to be a hard pill
- 53:05for a lot of people to swallow, and I agree with you like
- 53:08swallow the pill early and have the vision to recognize that it
- 53:12is worth swallowing the pill. Because the market's gonna be so
- 53:15massive that even if you're getting smaller fees in a multi
- 53:20institution model, the overall revenue is likely gonna be
- 53:24larger in the future 'cause we're going to be dealing with
- 53:28one of the most important, most valuable assets on the planet.
- 53:32Yeah. And maybe this is a good time to
- 53:34take a step back because I think we have a lot of context for
- 53:37what we're talking about. Maybe the audience does it and
- 53:40then the ultimately the innovator's dilemma that Mitch
- 53:43is sharing. I don't know Mitch, do you want
- 53:47me to like share or would it be helpful for you to from your
- 53:49from your eyes what we're working on in your part in it?
- 53:53Why Why don't you go for it? I'll fill in the yeah something.
- 53:56OK, we can leave it, Logan. Like this.
- 53:57We can turn it in a conversation.
- 53:59I think I'll we're gonna record. A more focused pod on what we're
- 54:04launching in the history. So this will be just like a
- 54:07paraphrase and and Jesse please jump in or I'll defer on some
- 54:09aspects of it. But when we launched on ramp we
- 54:13had this vision of you know multi institution with that it
- 54:17was a differentiator and it was more important like just in the
- 54:20same way from a Bitcoin first principle that we talked about
- 54:23with Mike like you just don't want to have unilateral control,
- 54:25you don't have unilateral control from a risk perspective
- 54:27like imagine any of us having to go to sleep at night.
- 54:30Managing billions of dollars and they're under your provision let
- 54:33alone you know from whether it's the government any reason, you
- 54:37just don't necessarily want to be have that.
- 54:39But also from what we've seen in the market and this is before a
- 54:42lot of the the blow UPS that we had started with this like
- 54:45vision close to over a year ago now, but then adding a few other
- 54:49components to it which was like the GBTC situation with the you
- 54:54know spot price and trading at a discount or premium.
- 54:59And this fact that like funds don't allow for delivery and
- 55:02there's like natural precedent, you know bitcoin's a commodity.
- 55:05We embarked on this journey, Jesse and I with his background
- 55:08managing a fund and mine managing you know onboarding
- 55:11individuals to multi sig that there was a better way to just
- 55:14reduce that. And so we started you know the
- 55:16first spot Bitcoin Trust in the US or in Nash internationally
- 55:20that was leveraging this multi institution model.
- 55:24The problem or the issue with it was that we were directing the
- 55:28clients like we had the keys split up Bitco's core model.
- 55:32There's others that are out there like it.
- 55:34Bitco holds a key Kingdom trust into this new model.
- 55:37Coin Cover will be announced as a partner and then on ramp and
- 55:42that's what we were in the process of building.
- 55:44We launched that. We had a lot of demand.
- 55:45We brought on clients, we had international demand for
- 55:48different products. And so we started to look at,
- 55:51well, what are the other things that we're doing here and that.
- 55:54Crawl like what are the core principles we're doing and we
- 55:56came you know obviously Bitcoin only we're building this brand
- 55:59that we believe is going to be trusted in the space that ties
- 56:02to a lot of Jessie's and our team's content that helps and
- 56:05educate. But then this multi institution
- 56:08is a core pillar around it. But we were still and I don't
- 56:11actually even go know if what we were doing in the sense of if we
- 56:15were going to go with that model because what Marty alluded to is
- 56:18the hard part, getting the keys separated is actually the easy
- 56:21part. It's like it just takes
- 56:22recognizing them. We can all set up our own multi
- 56:25institution. The hard part is getting a
- 56:27financial institution or somebody with a track record
- 56:29like bit go to say hey I will participate but not only will I
- 56:32participate, I will own the client relationship and I will
- 56:36actually onboard them and I'll leverage you know the things
- 56:39that I can share a little bit make Biko unique in this
- 56:41situation. That was the part where Mitch
- 56:44stepped in, saw what we were doing.
- 56:45I was like, oh, this makes sense and.
- 56:49I'll just give a teaser on it and Mitch, we'll explain more.
- 56:52But Biko's unique positioning in this and why we really think
- 56:56this unlocks large scale allocations and also movement of
- 57:00custody funds at the, you know, incumbents.
- 57:02I would think of calling base as as an incumbent at this point.
- 57:05Is the simple fact that we can never unilaterally direct any of
- 57:09the institutions to move funds in the way we've set up.
- 57:12Our custody structure always requires that the client not
- 57:16only gets on boarded with multiple institutions and Bitco
- 57:19will have their own, but then at the end of the day they have to
- 57:22do the same in reverse order and whatever permissions the, you
- 57:25know, principals or parties set. And then the other aspect is
- 57:29Bitco and the the way that they're utilizing their key.
- 57:33In that in this quorum has really never been done and I'll
- 57:35maybe hand it over to Mitch if he wants to kind of share like a
- 57:38little bit more about that it's. Funny you guys mentioned
- 57:41Innovator's Dorm that's been sitting on my my desk I I was
- 57:45trying to really step back and think is this is this technology
- 57:51that that that is disruptive or or is it sustaining for the the
- 57:55existing players and you know. To be honest like what we built
- 58:00on the the PSBT side which is how we how we accept 1/2 sign
- 58:04transaction you know from from on ramp so bitco can counter
- 58:08sign. And for any listener out there,
- 58:10PSBT stands for Partially Signed Bitcoin transaction.
- 58:14Appreciate it. You know, it's not easy work.
- 58:18You know, everybody in the industry is running different
- 58:21tech. So, you know, adopting that
- 58:24standard, you know, was difficult.
- 58:27You know, we're we're there now. You know we continue to innovate
- 58:30on it. But I I do think that you know
- 58:33if this is the model of the future.
- 58:34And I personally, in my heart of hearts do believe that you know,
- 58:38the existing incumbents are going to be left behind and
- 58:42you're going to have you know, new players that that come in
- 58:45that that truly you know, understand, you know from you
- 58:49know that that this matters, how to set up companies to to be key
- 58:53agents rather than you know. True custodians, you know, in
- 58:57the way that we do it, we're we're holding, you know, the
- 58:59freakies and you're going to see companies, companies die as a
- 59:04result if this is. You know the future here.
- 59:08Yeah, it really does come back to, yeah, I I think BICCO makes
- 59:15you having the innovator's dilemma on your desk shows that
- 59:18you guys are are approaching change in this industry from the
- 59:24mindset of Netflix as a as a mail order, DVD business or
- 59:30whatever. However you would call that
- 59:34seeing you know oh there's a shift to digital streaming
- 59:37that's going to happen and we're going to get in front of it
- 59:39versus being a blockbuster, which I think I think will be
- 59:44the fate of a lot of traditional custodians, people who are
- 59:47unprepared to adopt A mentality of multi institution models.
- 59:57Because because there's a long history of of you know the best
- 1:00:00way to do custody is to to build your fortress and guard it well
- 1:00:05and hope for the best. Put some keys on the Swiss Alps.
- 1:00:08You know, just, yeah, bury them on the mountains.
- 1:00:11And guard the hell out of them and and that's that's been
- 1:00:14what's been best because you know that's that's why we have.
- 1:00:18That's why we built banks and and vaults to put the gold in
- 1:00:21because you know, put put them under it, put it, put it in a
- 1:00:24big vault with some guards. And that's the best you you got
- 1:00:27in the physical world. And there's going to be a lot of
- 1:00:29people, a lot of institutions who come from the traditional
- 1:00:32finance world in in particular, who are unprepared to accept a a
- 1:00:38changed model of the best way to do custody in the digital
- 1:00:42landscape is through the collaboration of multiple
- 1:00:46entities. That's that's completely
- 1:00:48paradigm breaking for how custody has been done.
- 1:00:52And I think it gives a big advantage to companies like bit
- 1:00:55Go and on Ramp who are inherently thinking about it
- 1:01:00from you know a digital first mindset.
- 1:01:04And they're prepared to to take on what I, what I think will
- 1:01:07become the, you know, the gold standard in in how custody is
- 1:01:11done for any asset, because Bitcoin can be custodied, vastly
- 1:01:16better. Orders of magnitude better, more
- 1:01:18securely than traditional assets because of the properties that
- 1:01:22we're only just beginning to unlock.
- 1:01:25Yeah. And I think it'll be really
- 1:01:28interesting to see. I agree.
- 1:01:29I think we all agree this is going to be the standard.
- 1:01:31And what I'm very fascinated to find out is how quickly it
- 1:01:37becomes the standard because that's I think if we truly
- 1:01:40believe this, I think it should be our goal as individuals in
- 1:01:44the space and operators in the space to make it clear to the
- 1:01:47market that this is superior. And we really, we can do as much
- 1:01:52marketing and explaining as we want via this show and all of
- 1:01:56our materials that we send to prospective clients and content
- 1:02:02to educate just individuals out there.
- 1:02:04But I do think at the end of the day for this to become the
- 1:02:06standard, there has to be that that mental light switch that
- 1:02:10goes off in individual market participants heads that says no,
- 1:02:14I got to demand, I'm demanding this like I'm not interacting
- 1:02:18with a company that does not custody Bitcoin this way.
- 1:02:21Yeah. I think that like we have a
- 1:02:24really unique perspective on this and this is where we focus
- 1:02:27our our where Mitch appreciates is like we're building this firm
- 1:02:31from the ground up around this vision, a multi institution and
- 1:02:36the reality is. It's not available for everybody
- 1:02:39and the reason why it's not available for everybody because
- 1:02:41it requires a lot of like when you think about the
- 1:02:45institutional overhead and it's it's very often thought right,
- 1:02:48like Bitcoin because it's digital.
- 1:02:50You shouldn't trade for execution.
- 1:02:51You shouldn't pay for execution. You shouldn't pay for custody.
- 1:02:54But like, there's a whole slew in the same way that you know
- 1:02:56gold has between exchange and commissions, from the time it
- 1:02:59either gets out of the Earth or like the London bar to the time
- 1:03:02you buy a coin. There's a lot of things in
- 1:03:04between. And the same thing that happens
- 1:03:05when you're cryptographically safeguarding and running a
- 1:03:08business. So there there's fees
- 1:03:11associated. Where that ties in to is, I
- 1:03:14think it starts there. I know it starts there.
- 1:03:16I believe it to start there because institutions can pay for
- 1:03:18that and because the upside is so great in Bitcoin that it will
- 1:03:21be justified. But then just like any, like,
- 1:03:24you know technology, you start from the top end.
- 1:03:26And then as you be able, as you're able to, not only as
- 1:03:30you're able to just innovate and refine and have better
- 1:03:33processes, it starts to get democratized.
- 1:03:36And why I say all of that is to Marty's point about, like, who's
- 1:03:40going to recognize it? The reason why people aren't
- 1:03:42going to recognize it right off the bat, some will and we see it
- 1:03:45is because there's a big fallacy in the industry and it doesn't
- 1:03:48ever get talked about. I'm excited to bring up is that
- 1:03:50custody has been subsidized by Fiat, money and venture.
- 1:03:55Every business that runs a custody shop that doesn't charge
- 1:03:58for it is is paid for and is practically losing money and at
- 1:04:03in one point. So This is why people lose like
- 1:04:06their keys or why I like custody.
- 1:04:07They use it as a loss leader. And so when you do that, it's
- 1:04:11like hard for people to perceive why would I pay for custody?
- 1:04:15Like I just keep it at X so they can't charge for it.
- 1:04:18But the second you start to differentiate and I'll go as far
- 1:04:21as saying the one thing for sure people should pay for is
- 1:04:24custody. If it's differentiated.
- 1:04:26And you feel comfortable that the Bitcoin will be there
- 1:04:28because the delta between 27 K and wherever we all think
- 1:04:32Bitcoin can go, whatever your benchmark is.
- 1:04:34Is worth whatever the bits as long as you know that you feel
- 1:04:38in high confidence this is the best solution for you.
- 1:04:41And so that's the that will be the equilibrium shift or that
- 1:04:44mindset shift in the market is you should actually be paying
- 1:04:47for custody because that's how you keep the asset and most
- 1:04:50people have not. And so these firms that either
- 1:04:52hold in your Bitcoin, participate in Bitcoin, if
- 1:04:55they're not profitable, they you don't know who's going to hold
- 1:04:57that firm. At the end of the day, that's
- 1:04:59your counterparty. So they could be acquired by
- 1:05:00somebody they could go out of business into.
- 1:05:02You always want to know like where the assets are.
- 1:05:05Our individuals paying for that because that's your, that's your
- 1:05:07ultimate, your counterpart, it's facilitating the economic, you
- 1:05:10know, equivalent of a transaction and signing.
- 1:05:13So anyway, I think that's where the custody mindset is going to
- 1:05:16mine. Set is going to shift is the
- 1:05:19people that can pay for it, the people that recognize it.
- 1:05:21And then ultimately as these other firms that aren't making
- 1:05:24money with custody, say, hey, why don't I just participate
- 1:05:26'cause I already built all this infrastructure.
- 1:05:28And so we'll see it in the crypto world and then ultimately
- 1:05:31the financial world, if you can sell it good enough.
- 1:05:33It's like you don't have to build, you know, $10 million
- 1:05:36worth of infrastructure, participate in the key quorum,
- 1:05:38build the right, you know processes and now you're in the
- 1:05:41economy and now you can start generating revenue and you don't
- 1:05:43lose your your flow of dollars out to the coin bases of the
- 1:05:46world. So I think it's going to be a
- 1:05:47burn, but yeah, that was a long way of saying I think that's how
- 1:05:50this plays out. It's not right off the bat, but
- 1:05:52for the money it'll it will be. I do think that like you're
- 1:05:57going to, like you said, you're going to have people who realize
- 1:05:59right away this business model. I think you know, credit to you
- 1:06:04guys, you know, for knowing that you know this solution is going
- 1:06:08to have a lot of value. There is a differentiator here
- 1:06:11and you know. From a monetization standpoint,
- 1:06:15you know making sure you know you're not doing this as a loss
- 1:06:17leader, you know and you know running you know some venture
- 1:06:23backed company where you know you, you know you keep that that
- 1:06:26operation going. It's it's knowing what you have
- 1:06:30making sure you sell it to you know for for the actual you know
- 1:06:36value that you're bringing and you know really good on you guys
- 1:06:41appreciate it. Yeah I think that's that's the
- 1:06:45under discussed thing is the multi institution makes sense in
- 1:06:49our head but the end of the day like new custody models or or
- 1:06:53one at the margins like you have to get the person that's like
- 1:06:58they know Coinbase they understand it and and it's it's
- 1:07:01this visceral feeling we talked about it a lot at Unchained when
- 1:07:05you like it's it's very it's it's eerily similar to venture
- 1:07:10in that if you're allocating money.
- 1:07:13And you're not in it full time and LP won't give you their
- 1:07:15dollars because those are their full time dollars.
- 1:07:18In the same way that unless you like know the model in and out,
- 1:07:21whether it was like the in your head or you use it or it was,
- 1:07:24you visually understand it at the margins with the new custody
- 1:07:27product, you have to be able to translate that to a person
- 1:07:31parking their their wealth, their dollars or it just looks
- 1:07:34like. Because I've sold a lot of
- 1:07:36things in my life, whether it was like at Google or at Wework.
- 1:07:39It's like you can get good enough to fake things, like you
- 1:07:41can get good enough to be dangerous.
- 1:07:43But when it comes to like real wealth and money, people know.
- 1:07:46Exactly. That's like the one thing that
- 1:07:47they can look at and say like he this, he, this guy doesn't know
- 1:07:50exactly what what's going. And that's where we're excited
- 1:07:53about this because this is like all in our brains.
- 1:07:55This is like years of culmination of like all the
- 1:07:57things we've been working on to say, like, OK, this is where we
- 1:08:00see the market going. And so, yeah, we're we're
- 1:08:02incredibly excited to have it out.
- 1:08:05I think like like similar to you know what we do today in you
- 1:08:08know some of the companies that we're you know positioned
- 1:08:12against like true cold storage, you know is in, you know how I
- 1:08:17outline, you know how we store keys and vaults like that story
- 1:08:20works and you know it's got 10 years of working and ultimately
- 1:08:25like obviously that stuff's more expensive and but when you know
- 1:08:29we're treating these assets like they're going to be the trillion
- 1:08:32dollar assets, you know that we believe they will be.
- 1:08:34And you know when you're talking a couple of bits here and there
- 1:08:38of of you know difference in cost.
- 1:08:40I you know as long as you're talking to an audience that
- 1:08:45understands the value of what they're holding.
- 1:08:47I you know, I do think you know you're going to have people who
- 1:08:51get that right away. And then slowly, probably as
- 1:08:53price goes up, you know, you'll, you'll see more demand and see
- 1:08:59more interest and more people that get it, but you know.
- 1:09:03It's now. It's really the time to go lay
- 1:09:05that foundation and do this the right way.
- 1:09:08No, I mean just when the price starts ripping, that bag gets
- 1:09:12really heavy, metaphorically, and and it weighs on you and
- 1:09:16your mind. If at one point you you get a
- 1:09:20bunch of Bitcoin, the price is low.
- 1:09:22You write down your 12 word seed phrase on a piece of paper, you
- 1:09:25put it in your sock drawer. The price runs 10X that.
- 1:09:28That piece of paper's on your mind.
- 1:09:30Pretty pretty much all day, every day.
- 1:09:33And then that's when for me personally, that's when I was
- 1:09:37like, all right, I need to spin up and unchain, vault,
- 1:09:39distribute this, get this risk out of my mind.
- 1:09:43But you like when you bring in institutions and the type of
- 1:09:46capital that we're talking about.
- 1:09:47Like if I as an individual think that bag is heavy, you can only
- 1:09:52imagine how heavy it gets for for large institutions that are
- 1:09:55fiduciaries on behalf of hundreds of thousands, millions
- 1:09:59of individuals. And go ahead, I.
- 1:10:03Remember when I had my castle wallet for the first time?
- 1:10:05It was 2019 and I had, I had moved the funds over.
- 1:10:08One hardware wallet, I had a three of five was already
- 1:10:11distributed. And you know, I was sitting
- 1:10:14there going to bed at night and you know, realized that one of
- 1:10:18the keys was my phone had two at home.
- 1:10:20It's like someone you know, you get the, you know the, you know,
- 1:10:24whatever the two dollar $10 bench attack, like someone can
- 1:10:27go take all these funds and this was.
- 1:10:29You know we were we were starting to rip you know 2019 on
- 1:10:31price and you know if I, as you know somebody who you know is a
- 1:10:39lot more native having these fears have screwed this up to
- 1:10:45the degree that you know I've I we've got a critical point of
- 1:10:48failure here. You know, how are we going to
- 1:10:51onboard? You know, the next users who who
- 1:10:55are not as native, we've got to make this a lot easier.
- 1:10:59And really think through these problems a lot better than we
- 1:11:01have. Yeah, I think that's the
- 1:11:03interesting point 'cause it's the same dynamic or concept.
- 1:11:06I listened to Mike's talk and it was, it's really good.
- 1:11:08It was cool to hear, you know, his supporting of people at
- 1:11:11Bitco that you know, the the Bitco mafia that seems to be
- 1:11:14building outside of Bitco, but then also him thinking through
- 1:11:18like trillion dollar wallets. We don't use that term a lot,
- 1:11:21but I guess with the amount of dollars we're gonna be using it
- 1:11:23more. But the same way of a trillion
- 1:11:27dollar wallet, how do you build a business?
- 1:11:29It's like, how do you build a custody solution for yourself,
- 1:11:32like as an individual when the price to Marty's point goes at
- 1:11:3510X or 100 and we just like aren't prepared for that as
- 1:11:39individuals. Just we've never seen it.
- 1:11:40But then it happens and you like start freaking out.
- 1:11:43And that's where I always anchor back to.
- 1:11:44It's like do we really like right now, you know, leverage
- 1:11:48collaborative custody personally, but there's a
- 1:11:51certain point. Where I think about to Mitch's
- 1:11:54points, like if somebody knew, it's the whole it's like Michael
- 1:11:58Saylor and Balaji, where biology references that there's never
- 1:12:01been a bill until Bitcoin. There's never been a billionaire
- 1:12:03like a true billionaire that you can, like, move a billion
- 1:12:05dollars whenever you want at a moment's notice.
- 1:12:08And that's powerful, but it's also scary because if you wake
- 1:12:10up and somebody knows whether you're early or somebody's date
- 1:12:12or gets late or whatever reason that you have a bag of Bitcoin.
- 1:12:15Do you really want it to be known that somebody can pick up
- 1:12:17your child or that somebody can pick up something in course you
- 1:12:20or manipulate you into being able to affect control of the
- 1:12:23asset versus today? If somebody wants to do that,
- 1:12:26it's just impossible because you have to go to the bank, you got
- 1:12:28to call, you got to, you know, there's a bunch of things to do
- 1:12:31to really move money in size like that.
- 1:12:33And so I think that's just not fully understood.
- 1:12:35And and what we talked about before, if you set up your own
- 1:12:37custody, everybody can do it. It's not rocket science.
- 1:12:40The problem is it takes a good while.
- 1:12:42It takes a good while to set it up and then it takes a good
- 1:12:44while to understand where all the backups are, how you can
- 1:12:46reconstitute, how you can recover if somebody goes down,
- 1:12:49if you have a collaborative customer partner, what happens
- 1:12:51if they go away. And that that's not, again,
- 1:12:53rocket science. The problem is.
- 1:12:55Most people have a lot of other things to do and they don't have
- 1:12:58the six plus months to make sure that they do it and where it
- 1:13:02gets really heady. As we all know, this turns into
- 1:13:03money. Like at the end of the day, this
- 1:13:06thing ends up being money. We go from 2% allocations that
- 1:13:08people have or institutions, the 10% and 50 and whatever the
- 1:13:11number is. And it's OK to leave it on
- 1:13:13Coinbase when it's 1% or 2% or 5%, but if it starts becoming
- 1:13:18like your entire net worth? Or you really feel comfortable
- 1:13:21like leaving it right underneath the desk, you know, in your
- 1:13:25setup or whatever the case may be.
- 1:13:27It just all starts. It gets really, as Marty said,
- 1:13:31the bag gets a lot heavier, even though it's digital.
- 1:13:34And that's the idea of building this.
- 1:13:36So whether it's the day somebody realizes or when it's the price,
- 1:13:3910X is there's just a solution ready for them to be able to
- 1:13:42trust? Yeah.
- 1:13:47If you're new to this industry, you're getting in in this bear
- 1:13:51market, just let this be a warning.
- 1:13:53That bag gets heavy if you don't secure it properly.
- 1:13:56We got to you got to embarrass Mitch a little because I don't
- 1:13:59think all this stuff we're doing happens unless Mitch and Mitch
- 1:14:02and and Mike. But Mitch like recognized it and
- 1:14:05also like really saw the vision of where this can go and why the
- 1:14:09importance of it when you were alluding to your Casa.
- 1:14:12Like there's a lot of stuff that happens that's path dependent in
- 1:14:15this process and in all things. And you had all those like
- 1:14:18things already in your head. It's like.
- 1:14:20Oh, this actually makes sense because again, we're tell Bitco.
- 1:14:22But the reality is it still takes individuals to, like,
- 1:14:25recognize things and be able to champion them.
- 1:14:27I. I appreciate that.
- 1:14:28Like, I don't know, stepping back into, you know, my story
- 1:14:32and you know what got me here. I was trying to see how I can
- 1:14:37figure out how I can use my skills to, you know, go help
- 1:14:41Bitco in adoption in some way. And I was selling software, so
- 1:14:46you know, really the. Ability to help Bitcoin
- 1:14:51companies and to you know really enable you guys to get to go do
- 1:14:56that hard work at you know, I I couldn't imagine you know a you
- 1:15:01know greater privilege and you know better thing that I could
- 1:15:03be working on. So I'm grateful for you guys in
- 1:15:06doing the hard work and you know let me navigate the the big
- 1:15:09company here. That's what I was doing at IBM.
- 1:15:11That's what I do here and go. Try to make you know meaningful
- 1:15:16change by by enabling you guys. You tell Mitch is a bitcoiner,
- 1:15:21'cause he went directly to the $10 he like accounted for
- 1:15:23inflation. With the $10 wrench attack, it
- 1:15:26was like. It's Brooklyn, Brooklyn wrench
- 1:15:31prices right now wrenches are not part of the core CPI.
- 1:15:37So yeah, no, it is. So I guess I don't know if you
- 1:15:42guys talk about this internally a bit go obviously I haven't
- 1:15:45been involved with the day-to-day conversations that
- 1:15:48you guys been having between each other.
- 1:15:51But like in terms of how the opportunity like what
- 1:15:57opportunity lays before bit go like how do you guys view
- 1:16:00yourselves like 10 years out, 50 years out, 100 years out, like
- 1:16:04what types of institutions are we building right now, whether
- 1:16:07it's bit go on ramp TFTC 1031, like what, like how do you see
- 1:16:15the mark that we're beginning to leave now looking again 1050, a
- 1:16:21hundred years out? I mean I think it's the future
- 1:16:24of money and future of finance for you know I think Jesse
- 1:16:29mentioned you know this is this is you know American Revolution
- 1:16:32like I think we're all doing work that you know we'll be
- 1:16:36we'll be in history books one day and or I hope so I I think
- 1:16:40we're going to win, but we're going to win.
- 1:16:46If we're keep doing the work we're doing I think we're gonna
- 1:16:48win but it's it's building in this bear.
- 1:16:51But ultimately you know how this shakes out.
- 1:16:54You know which institutions you know bubble up to the top and
- 1:16:58you know have lasting power. I I kind of, I go back to you
- 1:17:02know the the Jack Mallers, Jack Dorsey, you know, thought of
- 1:17:05same team and it's making sure we don't spend the time
- 1:17:09bickering with each other, you know.
- 1:17:12Yeah, I think it's important to call each other out when when we
- 1:17:15screwed up. But it's being collaborative,
- 1:17:17it's helping each other, making sure, you know, we focus on the
- 1:17:21broader goal of, you know, sound money and you know, making the
- 1:17:25future that we want here. We keep our eye on the ball
- 1:17:28there and sort of keep that, you know, revolutionary spirit, that
- 1:17:31grit that we've all got that powers us to, you know, keep
- 1:17:35waking up every day and doing what we do.
- 1:17:37I think we do, yeah. People see it as naive, crazy,
- 1:17:43bombastic, but you gotta think big.
- 1:17:46We gotta dream big here. The the world as it stands
- 1:17:49today, as we mentioned earlier, is a bit chaotic and we need big
- 1:17:52change. And I don't think it's crazy.
- 1:17:55We're bombastic or hubristic to say, hey, we're gonna change the
- 1:17:59world. We're gonna create these
- 1:18:01institutions that are long lasting and that people will
- 1:18:04look back centuries from now and say, holy crap, look at what
- 1:18:06they did back then. You should have that type of
- 1:18:09mentality in this industry. I was actually, I was having a
- 1:18:12conversation this morning sort of about negative effects of
- 1:18:15social media, you know, and, you know, go into, you know, the
- 1:18:20Israeli Palestinian conflict and sort of how the spread of
- 1:18:24misinformation is damaging. And, you know, psychologically.
- 1:18:28And I sort of, I view, you know, social media sort of like
- 1:18:33Pandora's box and all this negative, you know,
- 1:18:38consequences. Are are coming out of it.
- 1:18:40But at the same time you're truly, you know if we bought
- 1:18:45this right, but you've got the free distribution of ideas and
- 1:18:49that democratization did not exist beforehand.
- 1:18:53And I do think that you know the ability for that information to
- 1:18:57to truly spread, for Bitcoin to truly spread and you know,
- 1:19:02global S regions that you know truly be the most.
- 1:19:07I I think will ultimately be that that positive that comes
- 1:19:10out of Pandora's box. And you know, changing money,
- 1:19:14changing the world is not easy. But we do need, you know, rails
- 1:19:18like social media, you know and you know, free exchange of ideas
- 1:19:22to to make that possible. Yeah, it's another paradox
- 1:19:26that's like weird because you obviously need the Internet for
- 1:19:29Bitcoin, but it's just like the Internet if if you, let's
- 1:19:32pretend, you could transfer Bitcoin over the Internet, but
- 1:19:34you don't have social. I don't think you see the same
- 1:19:37growth as fast as it is, you know, like the the proliferation
- 1:19:41of like content and all the what's that?
- 1:19:44No way. Yeah, but as you're saying like
- 1:19:46it's just part of like the whole thing.
- 1:19:47It's a double edged sword which we should probably give if we're
- 1:19:51gonna embarrass everybody. You guys can do me is we're
- 1:19:53gonna you know Congrats to Marty and getting we're talking social
- 1:19:56media his new media brand out that where I was initially
- 1:20:02thinking about this was you asked what do you think about
- 1:20:03like a long term. And the fun part is like all
- 1:20:06these things just need to be built, right.
- 1:20:07It's not like we're thinking and maybe we're we're obviously
- 1:20:10biased, but we just generally believe like there's a lot of
- 1:20:12broken stuff and it's not that hard.
- 1:20:15I mean it is hard to fix, but it's there.
- 1:20:16It's like going to the gym. It's like it's not complex, it's
- 1:20:18just you got to do it. And the way that the money's
- 1:20:21broken and infrastructure's broken is the same way that news
- 1:20:24and media and the content and the incentive models are broken.
- 1:20:27And I think Marty's working on fixing that.
- 1:20:29And so Congrats to see any truth for the common around and then
- 1:20:33pumped to see where it where it goes.
- 1:20:35Thank you, Sir. No, that was, I was going to
- 1:20:37piggyback on Mitch's comments. Mitch's comments.
- 1:20:40I've actually been very relieved that I've been busy getting that
- 1:20:43launch out over the last two weeks, particularly because it's
- 1:20:46forced me to focus and not pay attention to the madness on
- 1:20:49social media right now. Again, no, it's, I think it's, I
- 1:20:55mean Michael, you and I have talked about this for years, TFT
- 1:20:58CS been standing there and there's definitely something
- 1:21:01that we can do with it to blow it up and really.
- 1:21:04Again, eat our own dog food and inject Bitcoin into it and
- 1:21:07change the content monetization model using Bitcoin and the
- 1:21:11Lightning Network. And due to our partnership with
- 1:21:13Mash, we're really excited for where that can go.
- 1:21:17We've already seen some really cool stuff and really good
- 1:21:21responses to to what we've done. It's one of those things like
- 1:21:24you said. We've been staring at this.
- 1:21:26Me and you personally have been talking about this for years.
- 1:21:28It's like, all right, somebody's just got to go build it.
- 1:21:30It's going to take work. It did take work.
- 1:21:32We've got it out there now. And the response over the last
- 1:21:3524 hours has been pretty incredible to see it, especially
- 1:21:39after the TFTC episode of Recorded with Lewis from MASH
- 1:21:43Like that got out there. And there's people like in the
- 1:21:46incumbent media and they're sure you're like, oh, I finally get
- 1:21:48it now, even though we've been talking about it and writing
- 1:21:50about it for years. I think we just need to get
- 1:21:52something out there to show people, yeah, people discount
- 1:21:56the value of the idea. It's really the thing in this
- 1:21:58space and never experience it. If you have it and it's not
- 1:22:00there and people like a couple people say you like, that's a
- 1:22:03good idea. Why it doesn't exist.
- 1:22:04It's not generally it's it's 'cause it's a dumb idea like
- 1:22:06'cause somebody already done it in a in the regular world.
- 1:22:09But in Bitcoin world, it's just because nobody's done it yet.
- 1:22:11We're that early. So yeah, it's it's very cool to
- 1:22:15see that people are recognizing it.
- 1:22:17Yeah, but we're we're gonna win. It's gonna take time.
- 1:22:24So Mitch I identify with your, your like measured we're we're I
- 1:22:29think we're going to win we're on the path to winning whereas
- 1:22:33Marty comes in and and Michael with the extreme confidence that
- 1:22:37frankly I find very encouraging because it's too easy for me to
- 1:22:42think about focus on how we could possibly not win when in
- 1:22:46reality it looks like we're going to win.
- 1:22:48Mentality is everything. I've I've coached a couple
- 1:22:50championship teams and mentality is everything.
- 1:22:52You literally have to have a winner's mindset.
- 1:22:53We're going to win. I think if Coinbase held all
- 1:22:56the, if Coinbase held all the Bitcoin, I don't know if we'd
- 1:22:58win. That's what we had to do, what
- 1:22:59we had to do. That was the we got to do
- 1:23:02something if, if you, if you spot a hole.
- 1:23:04That's what I'm focused on because I, I, I don't think
- 1:23:07being digital gold is winning. I think fixing money is winning.
- 1:23:11And you know, if we're just a Black Rock ETF and.
- 1:23:16You know, people are making money because you know price
- 1:23:18goes up and you know bitcoins are, you know, an X percentage
- 1:23:21of, you know, someone's portfolio.
- 1:23:23I think that's wonderful. But that's not winning.
- 1:23:25It's, you know, doing the actual work that you've got, you know,
- 1:23:32recheck your financial freedom or doing the work that actually
- 1:23:35helps. You know, those in, you know,
- 1:23:38debt reading countries, you know, ours being one of them for
- 1:23:42the future, but like, you know. Being in Argentina hearing those
- 1:23:46stories like that's who we like these people need the exit ramp
- 1:23:49here and you know if sure networks going up is great but
- 1:23:56you know actually you know letting people giving them a a
- 1:24:01you know an exit valve of of non sovereign money I think that's
- 1:24:04winning and and I think that work started but it's it's
- 1:24:09building the rails now it's. You know companies like on RAP
- 1:24:13and it's companies in those regions and you know making sure
- 1:24:16that the, you know this market cycle we don't get an FTX making
- 1:24:21this actually reliable where you actually can, you know average
- 1:24:28person, high net worth person have that you know exit valve
- 1:24:32that you can feel good about. I think that's winning and
- 1:24:36that's why you know, I. I see the companies doing the
- 1:24:39work. It's inspiring.
- 1:24:40I we need to you know keep notes of the grindstone, keep doing
- 1:24:44it. But that's that's where the
- 1:24:47reservations come from. It's like look I I get the, you
- 1:24:50know supply demand you know the economics of this this thing's
- 1:24:54going to a million or you know whatever feel dollar you know
- 1:24:58forecast you want to put on it. But you know, working is a
- 1:25:02different definition for me, and I do think we get there.
- 1:25:08We're gonna end it there. We're gonna win.
- 1:25:11We're gonna win anything you guys wanna wrap it up with?
- 1:25:16You know, I'm, I'm gonna send Mitch an article after this
- 1:25:20about Bitcoin in the American West, 'cause you got me thinking
- 1:25:24about that. It's all about, you know, the
- 1:25:28nascent infrastructure slowly being built out and you go from
- 1:25:33trading posts to to roads to railroads.
- 1:25:37To to, you know, integrated Hwy. system and we're still in the
- 1:25:45trading post era of of Bitcoin infrastructure development, but
- 1:25:50that is how we win. You know, I feel different
- 1:25:54jurisdictions in America are certainly fighting against it or
- 1:25:57if you know institutions. But I I do think, you know, at
- 1:26:00its core ideal wise, you know, I Bitcoin is American, you know
- 1:26:04and I. From an ideals perspective, this
- 1:26:07does feel like a revolution. You know the way that, you know
- 1:26:10we read about revolution in the history books it's it does have
- 1:26:16a lot of that ethos and I think it's a pretty cool thing to be a
- 1:26:19part of. Yeah.
- 1:26:22Tied into the the Jesse's comment about us being confident
- 1:26:26it's like I'm really excited about all the stuff that's
- 1:26:30happening and and it's going to be a journey but it it was
- 1:26:33thinking of like what we're doing is honestly the like
- 1:26:35mostly sexy thing that you can ever imagine during this
- 1:26:37monetization. We're just like figuring out how
- 1:26:39you fucking store the Bitcoin and and it and it and it hit me,
- 1:26:43it's like thinking about what's going to happen and I always
- 1:26:46anchor back to David Bailey he he said actually on Marty's Pod
- 1:26:51years ago. It's an all time classic too, if
- 1:26:53you haven't listened to it. But he said the real party
- 1:26:56starts when the dollar ends. It's always stuck in my head
- 1:26:59because we talk about like Marty and the the media and like the
- 1:27:02incentive model and like all the different ways that the
- 1:27:05incentives and we talked about it last week with Larry and
- 1:27:07accountability like that vision of the world is just so
- 1:27:11incredible. We can't even fathom and like to
- 1:27:13get to that other side. And the way like capital
- 1:27:15formation happens in businesses and like returns and all and
- 1:27:17cost of capital like all those things.
- 1:27:19We never have gotten to live in that world.
- 1:27:21And just to be able to see like little glimmers of it and
- 1:27:23participate even if you don't see the other side like there's
- 1:27:26nothing better I can imagine if you doing.
- 1:27:28Because we know, like we know that it's there, like we have
- 1:27:30the, we can see the map, like we just got to like stay alive long
- 1:27:34enough to get to the other part of it.
- 1:27:37I mean like, but like bringing it back like the for the kids
- 1:27:40aspect, like imagine living in a world where you're not trying to
- 1:27:42outpace inflation, You're not trying to, you know, worry about
- 1:27:45being an asset allocator every day of, you know, sure I'm
- 1:27:48bringing in my money, but then I got to worry about, you know,
- 1:27:51how I'm going to, you know, outpace inflation and you know,
- 1:27:55make sure my net worth is, you know, growing up to you know,
- 1:27:58support the living standard I want sounds like a great world
- 1:28:01for for for the kids that hopefully we're building.
- 1:28:05Yeah. We gotta do it.
- 1:28:08If not us, then who? If not you, then who out there
- 1:28:10listening? I know you got some ideas.
- 1:28:12I know you're sitting in that that cube smashing some
- 1:28:15functions into Excel. You're about to get replaced by
- 1:28:17some AI you need to pick up. You need to pick up your your
- 1:28:22hammer and get to work in the Bitcoin economy.
- 1:28:24That is true. Please e-mail us.
- 1:28:26We have the best people that have reached out cold.
- 1:28:28So if you're interested we have a we have a mission and we're
- 1:28:31also going to be with Bitgo and Coincover in Vegas hosting a a
- 1:28:35few events. So please reach out.
- 1:28:38You'll find a way to reach out to us if you're interested.
- 1:28:40We'll get you on the list. Marty we got a course and to go.
- 1:28:44Still TBD but hopefully Marty will be there with us.
- 1:28:47And yeah, I headed. I headed you our our Vegas plug.
- 1:28:52Better get to Vegas. You get by the time this drops
- 1:28:54you get you get 3 days. So if you're in Vegas for money,
- 1:28:582020, Oh yeah, be there. A run on the, you know, Vegas
- 1:29:02flights? Post this pod.
- 1:29:04It's gonna be nuts. All right, this was fascinating.
- 1:29:09Let's go record another podcast. We'll be back next week with the
- 1:29:14last trade.