Latest / Interfaiths / Interfaiths: Dr. Yasemin Saib on Rumi, Sufism, and Modern Islam
Transcript
- 0:06Welcome back to another episode of Interfaith
- 0:09Miami podcast here at FIU. We are honored to
- 0:16have Yasmin here who is joining us and she's
- 0:19part of our Muslim Jewish dialogue and she's
- 0:22a local faith leader and a Muslim theologian.
- 0:26So we're very honored to have her as part of.
- 0:30our scholars. She's also a professor here at
- 0:36FIU and teaches courses on religion in the Department
- 0:40of Religious Studies. So we're very honored to
- 0:43have you here with us. Talk to us a little bit
- 0:47about yourself and your background. First of
- 0:49all, I'm very honored to be here. I think this
- 0:51is a great idea. So thank you so much for inviting
- 0:54me on this show. My background. So Ethnically,
- 1:00I come from the Middle East, Iraq, Turkey, Saudi
- 1:05Arabia, add a little sprinkling of Armenian,
- 1:09and then we found ourselves in the United States
- 1:14when I was about to start college, and I have
- 1:18been here, but I've really lived in three continents,
- 1:22six countries, and seven states within the United
- 1:25States. for a very long period of time. And I
- 1:29spent 28 years in the Arab world, another five
- 1:33years on top of that in Turkey. I was in Germany,
- 1:37I was in England, and in many different places.
- 1:40So I was exposed to a lot of different things.
- 1:43And I can say that throughout the course of my
- 1:44life, I think I've definitely, the one consistent
- 1:47thing that I... can say about myself is I've
- 1:51always been very curious about being a seeker
- 1:56of truth and what that looked like. But what
- 1:59that looked like for me in my early days was
- 2:01very different than who I am now. But I'm grateful
- 2:06for the transformation. Talk to us about your
- 2:09spiritual progress. Okay. So I grew up in Saudi
- 2:13Arabia. I was born and raised there. And my parents...
- 2:17Unlike most non -Saudis who used to go to American
- 2:22schools, British schools, French schools, etc.,
- 2:25foreign schools that were tied to embassies,
- 2:27my parents decided to put myself and my brothers
- 2:31in Saudi schools, Saudi Arabian madrasas, hardcore
- 2:35Islamic schools, where we studied five different
- 2:39Islamic subjects every single day for 12 years.
- 2:45and it was very strict it was highly segregated
- 2:48it was very serious and it was you know it inculcated
- 2:53a certain understanding a certain flavor of of
- 2:58Sunni Islam typically today I don't I'd like
- 3:02to shy away from labels but unfortunately we
- 3:04live in a world where when you use language,
- 3:06you have to really use labels too. So very loosely,
- 3:10you know, Wahhabi or Salafi kind of. ideology
- 3:15towards Islamic practice and so that was my upbringing
- 3:19and then I came to the United States and all
- 3:21of a sudden I was exposed to freedom of thought
- 3:24and I didn't quite know what to do with it initially
- 3:27I was overwhelmed and I had a very brief I would
- 3:32say agnostic period and then I found that that
- 3:36didn't really satiate me I couldn't make meaning
- 3:40of it. I couldn't understand or grapple with
- 3:44the idea that something comes from nothing. I
- 3:48couldn't make sense of a world without grand
- 3:51design. And so there are many different atheistic
- 3:55tendencies that didn't sit well with me. So I
- 4:01sought the truth at that time. And incidentally...
- 4:06And this is a very important story because it
- 4:08changed the course of my life. When I was 19
- 4:10years old, one of my friends who actually wasn't
- 4:13even Muslim from college gifted me a book. It
- 4:17was called The Essentials of Rumi. And in Saudi
- 4:21Arabia, all the books of Rumi at the time, not
- 4:24now, at the time were banned. So I grew up not
- 4:28knowing anything about the poet, philosopher,
- 4:31theologian Jalal ad -Din Rumi. So when I first
- 4:35picked up the book, and this was pre -internet
- 4:37generation, I had no idea what it was. And the
- 4:41gentleman, the boy who, you know, the guy who
- 4:43gave it to me, he was just a normal friend. But
- 4:46when I opened and I started reading some of the
- 4:48poetry, it felt initially like it was a love
- 4:52between a man and a woman. I couldn't understand
- 4:54why he would give me this book. But then I quickly
- 4:57understood that it was actually the love between
- 5:00a human and the divine. And that really struck
- 5:06me because, you know, you grew up in, theological
- 5:11tradition that teaches you fear where you know
- 5:14God is something that you feared God wasn't necessarily
- 5:17something that you loved and I was like wait
- 5:19what do you mean love God who loves God you fear
- 5:22God and so I decided to go on this quest and
- 5:26I have been on this journey since I was 19 years
- 5:29old Wow of what it means to be in a love affair
- 5:34with the divine okay and So you're also an Islamic
- 5:41theologian. What does the study of Islam bring
- 5:47to you? So, you know, even that has taken me
- 5:55from one step to another where where i started
- 5:57isn't where i am right now uh even in my own
- 6:01uh beliefs and and and my theological evolution
- 6:04uh initially uh after you know i became a seeker
- 6:09of truth of this divine love it was i would again
- 6:12have to use some labelings i was very interested
- 6:15in the sufi path uh of uh of of um islam but
- 6:21you know i was inculcated in sunni Hanafi Islam.
- 6:25Those were the tendencies or the terminologies
- 6:29that I was raised with. And so initially, I was
- 6:32sort of pigeonholed within that. So my worldview,
- 6:35I felt, was still quite narrow. So I drew upon
- 6:44Sufi ideology, but I was still, I would say...
- 6:48stuck with Sunni Hanafi Islam. And I can say
- 6:53that quite confidently now because I feel that
- 6:56I've broken those boundaries. So what unstuck
- 7:00you? So what unstuck me is I felt that there
- 7:05was a need for us to create these cages for ourselves
- 7:13because that's where... felt comfortable and
- 7:18you know it's how we were raised it was in my
- 7:20environment it was our social sector we had created
- 7:22these uh self -imposed restrictions and i felt
- 7:26that you know if god is limitless then why can't
- 7:29we expand our world view and see things from
- 7:33other people's perspective there's you know we
- 7:35have a world at the time now we're probably over
- 7:38a billion at the time it was you know younger
- 7:41but then the more you travel, I've traveled to
- 7:45over 70 countries, and you go and you see so
- 7:49many genuine people who grew up in different
- 7:54environments, different families, right? Whether
- 7:56they're Buddhist or even Hindu, things that were
- 7:59so alien to me. We were like, oh, Hindus are
- 8:04just idol worshipers. And you go into their temple,
- 8:07and when you focus on the form, you might actually
- 8:10say that because, you know, you see the elephant
- 8:12and the snake and the monkey and so on and so
- 8:14forth. Same thing with, I traveled all over the
- 8:18Far East, right? You see different forms of Buddha
- 8:21laying, standing. They look different, you know,
- 8:24whether it's Taoist or Shinto or whatnot. But
- 8:27then... I realized something very critical, and
- 8:30this is my latest journey, which is when you
- 8:33focus on the form, things can take you to a very
- 8:38restricted place. But when you focus on the meaning,
- 8:42you can very easily, or at least I was very easily,
- 8:46able to understand what it really meant to say
- 8:50we believe in the oneness of God. And to me,
- 8:53that no longer means believing in the oneness
- 8:56of God. you don't have statues in front of you
- 8:59that you worship. Believing in the oneness of
- 9:01God to me means that there's everything. manifest
- 9:05from it. And the essence of all is one. The essence
- 9:08of all creation is one. And so even my traditional
- 9:12Islamic identity that was very much focused on
- 9:17rituals and community, I really felt the need.
- 9:24It was suffocating me. I felt that I had to break
- 9:26those barriers. And I say this as a Muslim theologian,
- 9:30actually, because My worldview of a Muslim theologian,
- 9:35in my understanding, is a very inclusive, adaptive,
- 9:40ever -evolving worldview of what Islam ought
- 9:47to be, not necessarily what we see the form being
- 9:51presented today. So you have a very unique perspective,
- 9:57I think. within the Islamic tradition. I mean,
- 10:01what is the reception by other Muslims then?
- 10:04Oh, you know, generally, I don't, you know, I
- 10:10try to, as an academic, you know, you have to
- 10:12know your audience. Sure. So... Sometimes I take
- 10:16a different approach. So depending on where I'm
- 10:18at, if I'm invited to speak at a mosque, I try
- 10:24to gauge, depending on the conversation, I have
- 10:26to be harmonious and congruent with my beliefs.
- 10:31So it's not like I can't say that I say something
- 10:33I don't mean, but I have to use a language that
- 10:36my audience is able to understand. And so sometimes
- 10:41I don't approach subjects that I feel that, my
- 10:44audience is not receptive to or i'm not really
- 10:46invited there to talk about those subjects so
- 10:49i keep a lot of my thoughts, unfortunately, to
- 10:54myself, because I feel that the receptiveness
- 10:58level is actually very low. There are very, very
- 11:03few people, you certainly would be one of those
- 11:07very few people, who I can sincerely say that
- 11:10I would be able to express my Islamic beliefs
- 11:16in a way where I don't feel like I would get
- 11:19any backlash. So Are there any spaces I Mean
- 11:29you've traveled all over the world. So are there
- 11:32any Muslim communities where you feel? The most
- 11:35sense of community where you're able to fully
- 11:37be yourself So I would say More than a specific
- 11:45country. Yeah, I would say where I felt the most
- 11:52safe to able to sort of, or a community that
- 11:57where I felt the most compatible with was a community
- 12:03that I joined, loosely joined, it's not really
- 12:07a club, but it's sort of a, you know, a community
- 12:09in Istanbul, led by a lady, her name is Cemal
- 12:14Nur Sargut, and her... outlook, her world, her
- 12:19Islamic worldview really resonated with me. She
- 12:22took me on a path of this thing that's known
- 12:27in Tasawwuf called the nothingness, hijik, where
- 12:32you lose yourself in, and it's a very philosophical
- 12:38way, and it's very hard to do it justice in this
- 12:40form, but it's a way where You really go on this
- 12:46journey through different stations to fade away
- 12:51in your love of the divine. Now, I'm very much
- 12:57aware that I am a human being. I'm a mother.
- 12:59I'm a spouse. I'm a daughter. And I have daily
- 13:02responsibilities. But I feel that if you really
- 13:06know how to stretch those spiritual muscles,
- 13:09you can genuinely... live in that hal stage,
- 13:17whether you're cooking or driving or working,
- 13:21you really can't. Is it easy? No. I think it's
- 13:25very difficult because we're human, we're fallible,
- 13:29and we can get angry. But at least I have a destination.
- 13:34At least I'm trying, I'm making an effort to
- 13:38stretch those muscles in every... instance or
- 13:42every moment of my life. Wow, that's very interesting.
- 13:45Yeah, I mean, that's been something that growing
- 13:49up in the United States, I think American Muslims
- 13:55kind of think of themselves as being exceptional
- 13:57in many ways. But in terms of, I think, the diversity
- 14:04and complexity of Islamic thought, I... At least
- 14:09from what I've seen, American Muslims are definitely
- 14:11not at the cutting edge. I've seen some going
- 14:14to even places like Pakistan, which you wouldn't
- 14:17kind of think about. But there's some very interesting
- 14:20discussions I've had in Lahore and Istanbul and
- 14:24many of these other parts of the Islamic world
- 14:26where you're in the thick of Islamic culture
- 14:30and ideas, and you're actually able to be very
- 14:34generative. Whereas I think In the United States,
- 14:39I think there's just a lot less, I think, knowing
- 14:42of the diversity of the Islamic tradition. And
- 14:45then being a minority, you kind of feel, especially
- 14:49after September 11th, so for the last 25 years
- 14:54or so, being in a state of kind of having to
- 14:58defend your religion. And so then there's very
- 15:00little space for diversity of thought and sort
- 15:02of opinion and things like that. I couldn't agree
- 15:05more. I can only speak for South Florida. I've
- 15:09definitely had a lot of engagement with the Muslim
- 15:11community in all the seven states that I lived
- 15:13in because I was always a seeker. I was always
- 15:16a seeker of truth and I would try to go to different
- 15:18congregations and mosques and so on. I can't
- 15:23say in all honesty that there's a single Islamic
- 15:27center here in South Florida that is anywhere
- 15:30near where... where I would feel safe to be able
- 15:37to examine some of those ideas at all. But do
- 15:41I go? Do I go at least on a weekly basis? Absolutely.
- 15:44But I go for the camaraderie. I go for the community.
- 15:47We go because we have book clubs and children
- 15:50have activities. And those are where my friends
- 15:52are. Do I go there for intellectual thought?
- 15:56Absolutely not. And what I sense and what I've
- 15:58observed is that the Muslim community, you know,
- 16:02maybe here in South Florida maybe I can generalize
- 16:04I don't know is that you know how sometimes people
- 16:07convert to Islam and they become so protective
- 16:11right over what they know I even remember one
- 16:16time having a conversation with Cat Stevens you
- 16:18know the singer whose Muslim name I just forgot
- 16:25right now I can't remember. Anyway, it'll come
- 16:28back to me. So, you know, I remember meeting
- 16:31him in Dubai and, you know, we had spoken. Yusuf
- 16:34Islam. Yusuf Islam. Thank you. You know, where
- 16:37we came from, he told me about his journey. Sure.
- 16:41And I feel a lot of Muslims in the United States
- 16:44are also like that. They're so insular and they
- 16:50want to protect. They want to protect their mosques
- 16:52and their community and their traditions and
- 16:54their practices. And the reason why I say they,
- 16:58even though I'm Muslim, is that I can no longer
- 17:01relate to that. It's come to a stage where I
- 17:04genuinely feel like oftentimes I have to not
- 17:09go to a Friday sermon or not go to a khutbah,
- 17:13because I have to protect my ears so that I can
- 17:17protect my heart. It really impacts me a great
- 17:21deal. And I feel that... I feel so incredibly
- 17:26disconnected. I can't overstate it enough. Yeah,
- 17:30no, I mean, I think I felt, I mean, that's why
- 17:32I think it's been, for me, what's been really
- 17:35remarkable about the interfaith work, like working
- 17:38with different faith communities, is that you're
- 17:41able to see very different perspectives or insights
- 17:45and have spiritual discussions that you're not
- 17:48necessarily able to have within your own community.
- 17:52I think the Jain community has been remarkable
- 17:54working with them because ideas of nonviolence,
- 17:58for instance, just remarkable. Or the idea of
- 18:02plurality of perspectives, right? You know, anekantavad
- 18:08or aparigraha, sort of the idea that we don't
- 18:11want to, the non -acquisitiveness of sort of
- 18:14living a life without sort of... desiring or
- 18:17attachment. You know, there are really remarkable
- 18:20aspects that I don't think are things that don't
- 18:25exist in Islam, but these are ideas and thoughts
- 18:28that have existed in Islamic history and Islamic
- 18:31philosophy and Islamic theology that are just
- 18:34not either known to American Muslims or for some
- 18:39reason they don't see it as relevant at all because,
- 18:41you know, that sort of separation between the
- 18:46mystical and the legal like the focus is all
- 18:48on the law and just sort of observance of the
- 18:51law rather than you know understanding the spirit
- 18:54and sort of the nature and the mystical aspects
- 18:55of the religious tradition very true and that's
- 18:58actually one of the main reasons why i chose
- 19:03to focus, when you go into a PhD program within
- 19:07Islamic theology, you have to focus on one of
- 19:11the four tracks. You can't just do everything.
- 19:13And so I focused on Islamic law and jurisprudence
- 19:16specifically because I found it to be so incredibly
- 19:19problematic. I found that, you know, even within
- 19:24the Muslim tradition, this idea that the Quran
- 19:27is protected, but then that translated to Hadith
- 19:31is protected, and that translated... to football
- 19:33has predicted and I was just like well no I don't
- 19:36know who told you that and who made that claim
- 19:38and so this static rules and regulations that
- 19:43is cookie cutter that somehow needs to be universal
- 19:47and applied to all time and place has actually
- 19:51no basis in this Islamic theology whatsoever.
- 19:55And yet, it's a slapstick approach. And it's
- 19:59behooving to me, to be honest with you. And so
- 20:02one of the reasons I went into it is because
- 20:04I found it so incredibly problematic. And I really
- 20:08felt the need to study it so that I can have
- 20:14uh you know a more formed discussion about these
- 20:17subjects right that's amazing well thank you
- 20:20so much for sharing your spiritual journey two
- 20:22last questions um one is in terms of the interfaith
- 20:25work um why do you think it's important what
- 20:28do you hope to learn from it so uh i think that
- 20:33my my understanding of interfaith work used to
- 20:39be where two people from different traditions
- 20:41come together and each one says what they want
- 20:44to say and what they believe and then you know
- 20:48we have pastries and everybody goes home and
- 20:50then we pat each other on the back and say you
- 20:53know what we're like you know really swell people
- 20:56who just we're so open -minded and we got together
- 20:59I think that we're fooling ourselves when we
- 21:01do that I think that real interfaith work is
- 21:05when you genuinely make every effort in trying
- 21:09to imagine their truth as being yours and that's
- 21:15a very difficult thing to do but really is interfaith
- 21:19work often and I've been in lots of interfaith
- 21:22work, especially after September 11th, where
- 21:24you're really just there to try to convince the
- 21:28other person of what you believe. And I don't
- 21:30believe that that's interfaith work. I think
- 21:32that you see two people just having a monologue.
- 21:36It's not real dialogue. But it's very difficult.
- 21:39What I'm saying is also very difficult because
- 21:42human beings, even if you belong into the same
- 21:44tradition, even if you're two Muslims or two
- 21:47Jewish people, you filter. knowledge and information
- 21:52through your own life lenses. And so my hope
- 21:56through all of the efforts that you're making
- 22:00and FIU is making in the Jewish -Muslim dialogue
- 22:02is for me to genuinely go to these gatherings
- 22:07really trying to understand somebody else's truth.
- 22:11Genuinely try to really embody that truth and
- 22:15also hope that perhaps I can share some of the
- 22:19truth. that I see as well and hope that they
- 22:21may be able to, because ultimately the idea is
- 22:25that if we can really have that compassionate
- 22:27understanding of each other, then perhaps we
- 22:30can. go home to our families and to our communities
- 22:34and communicate other people's truth to one another.
- 22:37And that's when, you know, real change hopefully
- 22:41can happen so that we can live in a much better
- 22:44world where we live in harmony and safety and
- 22:48pursue collective love and happiness that we
- 22:52all human beings seek. I see. Yeah, absolutely.
- 22:55Good. Last question. What is your message to
- 23:01future generations? Well, I would say be a good
- 23:07person. I know that that sounds really cliche
- 23:11and very generous in general, and somebody might
- 23:14say, well, what does that really mean? I believe
- 23:18in a journey towards excellence in whatever you
- 23:25do, in character and conduct. Ultimately, those
- 23:28are the two litmus tests for how we measure ourselves.
- 23:33So the advice that I give to my children would
- 23:35be the same that I give here today is that really
- 23:38elevate your character and conduct. Be the best
- 23:43version of yourself. Invest in whatever God -given
- 23:49capabilities that you have to serve humanity
- 23:52in the best way. Uphold universal truths and
- 23:55really believe in the power of goodness. Wonderful.
- 24:03Well, thank you so much, Yasmin. It's been an
- 24:04honor and a pleasure having you and working with
- 24:08you and looking forward to many, many more conversations
- 24:10together. Thank you so much for having me. Thanks
- 24:13a lot.