Latest / Dark Murder: True Crime Cases / Episode 94
Transcript
- 0:06Dark murder True crime cases five four, three, two, one one one.
- 0:27Welcome back. I'm your host, Jordan Lee. I'm sure you are
- 0:31all ready to dive into some dark, creepy stories, so let's get started.
- 0:39A deadly night in room sixteen oh three, things just got out of
- 0:47hand. How many times have you heard this phrase when it comes to crime?
- 0:52Far too many. I'm sure it is the criminal's motto when they want
- 0:56to justify and minimize what they've done in hopes of garnering a moniker of sympathy
- 1:00from a jury or judge. Here's a hint to the defendant. Stop saying
- 1:04this because it only makes things worse. But before this phrase was uttered by
- 1:10this criminal, we need a crime and thus a victim. Our victim's name
- 1:15in this case is Lenore Gilby, a middle aged mother of three who just
- 1:21happened to be visiting New York City in nineteen eighty three. Earlier in her
- 1:25life, Lenore had been married to a man who stood to inherit the Gilby
- 1:29Gin Empire, but at the time of her trip, she spent most of
- 1:33her days supporting various charities in both Europe and the United States. On the
- 1:38night of August fifth, nineteen eighty three. I'm sure Lenore, who was
- 1:42in her room alone, didn't think that she'd be having an unexpected visitor stopped
- 1:47by her room that was situated on the sixteenth floor of the Gorham Hotel.
- 1:52What she wasn't aware of, though, was the series of events that were
- 1:55going on at the same time in other parts of the building. No one
- 1:59says saw or heard anyone or anything come out of room sixteen o three.
- 2:04It was at four p m. The next day that a maid walked into
- 2:07the room and discovered Lenore's body. After detectives arrived, they assumed the woman
- 2:13had been suffocated by a pillow, but not before she'd been sexually assaulted.
- 2:17All of her clothes and other belongings had been thrown about the room, yet
- 2:22because of the state of things, it was impossible for police to tell if
- 2:25anything in particular had been stolen. Most surprising of all was a total lack
- 2:31of any fingerprints other than Lenore's, which was either a sign of a knowledgeable
- 2:36criminal or a lucky one. While looking through the room, detectives were drawn
- 2:42towards the room's balcony. They saw the drapes from the penthouse suite on the
- 2:46floor above them had been strung alongside the building to within several feet of where
- 2:50they were standing. It would have taken someone with no shortage of athleticism and
- 2:55a willingness to take the risk of repelling down the building on fact fab that
- 3:00wasn't designed for bearing weight. Still, it was possible. When police began
- 3:07questioning the hotel staff that was on duty the night before, they were told
- 3:12that two women had been startled when they ran into a nude black man outside
- 3:15their rooms. They had told the clerk that he hadn't said a word to
- 3:19them and made a quick exit. The two guests had checked out, but
- 3:23police were able to track them down and ask them a few questions. Not
- 3:27only did they tell detectives they could identify the man if they saw him again,
- 3:31but one of the women stated she thought she'd seen him once more on
- 3:35the morning of August sixth, leaving the hotel dressed in drag and wearing a
- 3:38shower cap. All of the hotel's guests that night were contacted, and one
- 3:45man told them he believed he had information that would be helpful. The only
- 3:50catch was he wanted to stay anonymous. He informed detectives that he'd met a
- 3:54man at a downtown bar who said his name was Lawrence Smith some time on
- 4:00the afternoon of August fifth. They spent the rest of the day drinking together
- 4:04and found themselves back in the business man's room together. At some point,
- 4:09the two had an argument and Smith was thrown out of the room naked.
- 4:14Police believed he had been the man who'd run into the two women out in
- 4:17the hall and left the hotel in drag the next day. All of this
- 4:21was fine, but that didn't make him a killer. As part of their
- 4:26investigation, they reconstructed the crime. After being thrown out by the businessman and
- 4:31running into the women, they believed Smith had made his way to the roof
- 4:34of the hotel, hoping to find a way to get himself out of this
- 4:39mess. This was when he discovered the drapes at the front of the hotel
- 4:43that leads to the sixteenth floor balcony. Smith didn't care who was in the
- 4:47room at the time. He was only looking to steal some clothes and some
- 4:50pocket money. When he managed to jump the rest of the distance to the
- 4:55balcony, he found himself confronted by the middle aged woman who occupied them room.
- 5:00After he sexually assaulted Lenore, he stole some clothes, which consisted of
- 5:04a pair of blue shorts, a red blouse, and some fuzzy slippers.
- 5:10At some point, he'd taken a pillow and suffocated the victim in order to
- 5:14keep her from reporting his crimes to the police. There was even evidence left
- 5:18behind that suggested he'd slept in the same bed while the body was still in
- 5:23it. One other tidbit that the business man was able to give the police
- 5:28was that Smith told him he worked in a print shop nearby, despite having
- 5:32a name to go on. Detectives were sure it was a fake, so
- 5:36they began making stops at every print shop near by. Finally they hit paid
- 5:42hert when they met a man by the name of Lawrence Foy, already with
- 5:46a criminal record. He truly believed he had gotten away with murder. When
- 5:50police questioned him, he claimed to have no knowledge of a crime, but
- 5:55when they showed him photographs of himself, he broke down and admitted to going
- 5:59to the business man's room for a sexual escapade. It wasn't until they informed
- 6:03him that he'd been identified as the individual wearing Lenore's clothing that he finally confessed
- 6:10to the murder. The reality of what happened was very similar to what detectives
- 6:15had recreated, and like many criminals before him, he stated that he had
- 6:19no plan to kill or rape Lenore. When he descended the building to her
- 6:23balcony, he had only wanted something to wear and things had just got out
- 6:28of hand. One item he did admit to taking was a make up compact
- 6:33that police would later find in an alley a few blocks from the hotel.
- 6:38When the trial came, the defense put up an unusual defense for Lawrence.
- 6:44Their claim was Foy had been the victim of a homosexual attack, which,
- 6:47when coupled with the amount of alcohol he had consumed that day, had pushed
- 6:51him over the edge emotionally, and thus he was not criminally responsible for what
- 6:57had occurred. A psychology just even testified to this on his behalf. The
- 7:02story might have been convincing to Foy and his attorney, but the jury wasn't
- 7:06buying it. When they came back from deliberating in their chamber, a guilty
- 7:12verdict was handed down for the charges of murder, robbery, and burglary.
- 7:17Judge Sybil Cooper evidently wasn't convinced either, since she handed Foy a sentence of
- 7:23twenty five to life