Latest / Educating All Learners Alliance / Leading with Learner Variability in San Diego Schools
Transcript
- 0:00Hi, this is Aurora from the Educating All Learners Alliance,
- 0:03and today we're speaking to Andrea Pino-Antl and Jenny Chen for a deep dive
- 0:08into school leadership.
- 0:09Andrea is the principal of Creative Performing and Media Arts,
- 0:13a magnet middle school in San Diego, California, that allows students to seize
- 0:17their creativity in the classroom.
- 0:19And Jenny Chen is the principal of Casita Center, an IB school with a STEM focus,
- 0:24also located in San Diego. So it's so great to have both of you on the podcast, Jenny and Andrea.
- 0:31We've both been part of the EALA ecosystem for a while. So to get us started,
- 0:35tell us a little bit about your school communities.
- 0:37What makes your school unique? What's a bright spot or something that you're
- 0:40particularly proud of right now?
- 0:42Hi, everyone. I'm Andrea Pino-Antl, and I'm the proud principal of the Creative
- 0:45Performing Media Arts Middle School in San Diego Unified School District.
- 0:49We're a six through eight arts magnet school, and all our students engage in
- 0:53arts curriculum every day.
- 0:55And we embed arts integration into our core academic classes as well.
- 1:00One of the major focuses that we've been working on and really focused on is
- 1:05in improving our academics as well and really focused on what effective teaching practices look like.
- 1:10We are excited because we've seen growth and we grew in every demographic area
- 1:15last year on our dashboard.
- 1:16And one area that I'm insanely proud of is our school culture.
- 1:21So when I got here, we had like a 15% suspension rate. It was rough.
- 1:26And we're down to like 1%. So we are making a huge, huge change in the culture.
- 1:32Students feel safe. And now I want to capitalize on that and increase the learning in the classroom.
- 1:39I'm Jenny Chen. I'm the principal of Casita Center.
- 1:43We are an IB World School with a STEM focus, and we are a magnet school as well.
- 1:49So we service our kindergarten through fifth graders. We have about 740-ish
- 1:54students, and we draw from all over our district as well as neighboring districts,
- 2:00and it creates a really beautiful community.
- 2:03Something I'm most proud of at our school is similar to Andrea is our culture.
- 2:09I feel like we have a learning culture where our teachers are constantly learning
- 2:16and growing and figuring out how to evolve our programming that will be tailored
- 2:21to our students and making sure that we are removing barriers and keeping learning
- 2:27exciting and relevant for them.
- 2:30And I think that, you know, if we didn't have our staff wanting to do that,
- 2:35we would not be continuously evolving. So I'm very proud of them.
- 2:39And it's great to be amongst colleagues that want to do this work with our learners.
- 2:45I love that. And Hila had a chance to visit both of your schools,
- 2:49I think, during our inaugural school study tours. And I remember seeing.
- 2:53Such interesting things at both of your schools, truly, like your schools really do stand out.
- 2:59And it's great to have you part back in the EALAverse, back in the EALA ecosystem
- 3:03as part of this cohort of school leaders as part of our All Learners Action Lab.
- 3:08You both have some interesting insights around math in particular, math instruction.
- 3:14It's always a subject that students or even teachers can, you know,
- 3:19folks struggle with that fixed mindset. So tell us a little bit about,
- 3:23and I'll start with you, Jenny.
- 3:25Can you tell us more about what approaches you're taking when it comes to math
- 3:30at your school and what's truly working for your students?
- 3:34Yeah, no, thank you. It's always, you know, it's exciting to kind of see innovation happening.
- 3:41But you also want to make sure we're offering quality math instruction.
- 3:45And so we constantly analyze our math teaching and learning approaches and our
- 3:52data that would work alongside with it.
- 3:55And our data really kind of spoke that, you know, we are a higher performing
- 4:00school. We're doing well.
- 4:02Obviously, there are areas that we can work on in math instruction.
- 4:05But one of the areas that we had to kind of dig deeper with was this idea of
- 4:10our learners and how they see themselves as math people, as a math person.
- 4:16And even though our kids were higher performing, they didn't see themselves
- 4:20as math people. They had math anxiety and, you know, it felt they felt a certain way about it.
- 4:27And so we had to kind of tease out that piece and figure out as a staff,
- 4:31are we cultivating experiences in math where it is engaging and they can see
- 4:36themselves as math people?
- 4:38And is it helping them build their self-confidence? So about three years ago,
- 4:43using that as the impetus, we really tried to dig into different strategies
- 4:48that would make math more engaging, but still fostering thinking skills and that rigor and depth.
- 4:55So we started our journey by looking at low floor, high ceiling approaches and
- 5:01bringing back number talks and evolving it to dot talks and splat and all these other experiences.
- 5:07We started digging into the React Math.
- 5:09So that was that whole year just doing staff meetings as professional development, engaging in math.
- 5:16Then the following year, which was last year, we started realizing that we needed more modeling.
- 5:23And so we had one of our teachers that was at our school, she got promoted to
- 5:29being a math chosen in our district. So we booked her for three days out of the month, every month.
- 5:34And she basically modeled lessons for our teachers, our ed specialists,
- 5:38to show how that would be facilitated so the teachers could see that modeling
- 5:43and do some shoulder-to-shoulder coaching as well.
- 5:46So that really kind of helped move things along. And then this year,
- 5:50we're working with an organization called Math Transformations that are helping
- 5:54us kind of plan out using our district-adopted curriculum, but all the other
- 5:58resources and helping us plan more of a scope and sequence. So we're still on that journey.
- 6:03We're also seeing that, you know, other teachers might need more support.
- 6:07And so we're scaffolding some of the supports and kind of tuning in to what
- 6:12they need and tailoring it to the teacher's needs so that they're able to facilitate
- 6:16and feel comfortable with shifting their pedagogy. So it's definitely been a journey.
- 6:21But like I said, I'm super grateful that sometimes you're flying the plane as you're building it.
- 6:27So it kind of feels like that at times. And it could feel very frustrating.
- 6:31And I want to honor that feeling with our teachers.
- 6:33But I'm grateful that they're, you know, working on trying to build that plane
- 6:38while they're flying it.
- 6:39And we're, you know, going through the trenches and figuring out what works best for our students.
- 6:43I get inspired listening to all the things that Jenny and her school are doing
- 6:46and, you know, so many ideas.
- 6:49So one of the things that I notice heavily when we return, you know,
- 6:55from COVID, a lot of, you know, we're a one-to-one school district.
- 6:58A lot of our classrooms were looking like computer labs, walk in to computer lab.
- 7:03The teacher is really facilitating, but not in the facilitating the way that
- 7:07we really want to see them facilitating student agency.
- 7:10So for the last two years, one of our instructional focus is student agency in the classroom.
- 7:15And so that's one of the things that Jenny and I really connected on is like,
- 7:18how are we going to see student learning happening in the classroom?
- 7:22And specifically in math, because they need to be engaged. And when a student
- 7:26just sees it on a screen and they don't get feedback, they're not truly engaged in it.
- 7:32In that activity. So we have, we use the Amplify Desmos curriculum,
- 7:36the district adopted it, and we were part of the early adopters at our school.
- 7:40So we had some support from our school district in terms of mentors and lesson
- 7:44studies and getting our team to work together to really take this online curriculum,
- 7:48but how do we make it visible and how do we make it engaging for the kids?
- 7:52So I've been working with our teachers on those teacher moves.
- 7:55Like, yes, it's an online platform, but that doesn't mean that that's what the
- 7:58student should be doing at all times. Like it can be removed from the computer.
- 8:02Let's get them learning and really focused on the depth of knowledge.
- 8:07So I know that Jenny mentioned that earlier when we were introducing our schools
- 8:12is really knowing that we want our students to take that content and apply it
- 8:17to other things. And the way that we do that is through arts integration.
- 8:22So we have actually a math lab classroom that we set up that doesn't have any chairs.
- 8:27And the students go in and they can do kinesthetic movement and learning to
- 8:31go with their math curriculum.
- 8:32And our math teachers also go into the art lab and they do their arts instruction.
- 8:37So that's another way to get the students using what they're learning in a tangible and a visible way.
- 8:43It hasn't been easy. I mean, we also, as my teachers, are receiving sixth graders.
- 8:49So we're sixth through eight.
- 8:50This year specifically, 90 of our 153 sixth graders were testing on iReady diagnostic
- 8:58multiple grade levels below standard, right?
- 9:01So we also have to recognize like we are teaching the standards,
- 9:05but we also have how are we systematically supporting our students to improve
- 9:10and fill in the gaps of learning.
- 9:12And so we, you know, part of the technology pieces is I want them off the computer.
- 9:19With the curriculum and doing collaborative and engaging lessons where they're
- 9:23active and they're learning with each other.
- 9:26But then I'm asking them to do, we're using iReady MyPath to fill in for that tier two instruction.
- 9:33So the teachers are right now balancing that technology aspect of,
- 9:38we don't want them so much in front of the computer because we want them to
- 9:41be agents of their learning and collaborating with each other.
- 9:45And using language and helping each other understand.
- 9:50But then we also want them to access this tool because with the number of students
- 9:54that have learning gaps, we want to use that to our advantage.
- 9:58So we're growing and we are hoping to see some fruits of our labor.
- 10:05I used to think that when teachers verbalized barriers, that it was a bad thing,
- 10:12right? Like, I'm not doing something right as a leader.
- 10:14They couldn't do it. And like, I just kind of, I didn't want any of that.
- 10:18I didn't want to, like, I didn't want to hear it. I didn't, you know,
- 10:21but I think in the last few years, especially this year, I'm really seeing that
- 10:25that's really an opportunity, right?
- 10:26So if teachers didn't want to do something, they probably wouldn't say anything
- 10:30and just like close their doors.
- 10:31But the fact that they're sharing some of their barriers out loud,
- 10:35whether in a small group, individual, or as a whole staff, I think is really
- 10:39valuable information. And I really have been leaning into it and leveraging
- 10:43that in how to inform next steps.
- 10:46So one of the strategies that I really have appreciated and we've really embraced
- 10:52is the numberless word problems in math.
- 10:54And so we modeled it.
- 10:57We had students or we had teachers open up their classrooms so that other teachers
- 11:02can go in. We cover classes.
- 11:04But, you know, even then, we still had some teachers that, you know, were hesitant to try it.
- 11:09And one of the teachers who was a seasoned teacher on campus,
- 11:12she said, I tried it, but I just did a whole group, which kind of defeated the
- 11:16purpose a little bit, you know, and at first I was like, okay,
- 11:19why did she not do it that way, you know, but then I said, you know what, it's okay,
- 11:23that's part of her journey of where she needed to go in order to get to,
- 11:28you know, to eventually get to where she needed to go. So I really took time
- 11:34to listen to that feedback.
- 11:36And we opened it up in her grade level to kind of unpack why she felt that way.
- 11:42And her fear was that she would lose control of the class, you know,
- 11:46if we did this numberless, small groups, random groups, type of approach.
- 11:50And so her colleague was the one who said, you know, why don't you instead of
- 11:53doing random groups initially, why don't you start with, you know,
- 11:56doing intentional groups.
- 11:58And then you train up the kids with the protocol and the expectation,
- 12:02call out, you know, all the great thinking that's happening.
- 12:04And then eventually you can maybe move into random grouping.
- 12:07And so I like that moment of just a teacher being vulnerable enough to share
- 12:15her barrier and having kind of a think tank amongst her team and then being
- 12:19able to kind of work through that. It was just really beautiful to see.
- 12:23I think that as a leader, it's scary at times to hear why someone can't do something.
- 12:29But I also think like they're saying something and it's they're voicing their
- 12:33concerns and we have to kind of walk through it with them so that they can eventually
- 12:37get to where they need to.
- 12:38But it's it's not it's not this linear line of like, OK, you're going to go from point A to point B.
- 12:43It's more like this like mumble jumble in the beginning or in the middle where
- 12:47you're trying to figure it out.
- 12:48And then eventually you'll get, you know, to where you need to.
- 12:51But you kind of have to walk through it.
- 12:52And part of that journey and that process is what makes it a beautiful way to help shift pedagogy.
- 12:59How are you ensuring at your school that students with learning differences are.
- 13:04Are at the heart and not an afterthought in terms of your school's structure and culture.
- 13:10That has been a huge focus for my school.
- 13:14We have a lot of different programs. We have different self-contained versus
- 13:21inclusion programs at our school, and it's just a non-negotiable for me.
- 13:26We're still trying to fine tune of what it looks like, but because every kid
- 13:30is different, every kid needs something different.
- 13:32We really have done some maybe not traditional things.
- 13:38For instance, like we have a student who is in eighth grade that maybe is a
- 13:42third grade level for math, also has an IEP.
- 13:46Instead of struggling through, we provide a totally different math experience for that student.
- 13:53That student's with an ed specialist for math instruction that has a math credential.
- 13:58And that student is, that's, we want the learning experience to be positive
- 14:03and not a painful experience where they're going to fail.
- 14:07And so we are trying these alternative settings for students that is as inclusive
- 14:12as possible, but meets their needs.
- 14:15Because we want learning to be enjoyable and be a lifelong experience and not
- 14:20feel like they're going to fail.
- 14:23I have a similar philosophy. I, you know, I definitely, we were trying to strengthen,
- 14:32our tier one so that it can be more inclusive of all learners and entry points for them.
- 14:39And so like the numberless word problems, for example, that I referred to before,
- 14:42we wanted to make sure that all students had access to that.
- 14:46So how do we, and it really breaks down the language of a word problem for our
- 14:50students to really unpack that and develop conceptual understanding before they
- 14:53get into the calculation piece, the computation.
- 14:57And so we really had to, before we just jump into tier three or tier two,
- 15:03we really wanted to make sure that it was accessible with our tier one.
- 15:08And then within our classrooms, we do do a lot of small groups or conferencing
- 15:14with our students so that they're able to get their needs met,
- 15:17whether through different manipulatives, different types of approaches.
- 15:22And we also try to memorialize on our walls that we value different approaches
- 15:28so that it's also a mindset shift for our community and our classrooms that,
- 15:32you know, there isn't just one way and the right way to do it,
- 15:35but there's different ways.
- 15:36You get your answer, but there's always different ways and we value all of them.
- 15:40And then, of course, our ed specialists working on tier threes are working closely
- 15:44with our teachers to make sure that we help remove the barriers.
- 15:47We've had a lot of conversations about accommodations versus modifications and
- 15:52making sure, like you said, Andrea, that the supports are appropriate for the kids.
- 15:56It's not just a bank of, here are all the math things that we can put into a
- 16:00plan, but we want to make sure they are appropriate to that child.
- 16:03So it is, I think as educators, you're just trying to be more intentional when
- 16:09you service our students and helping them meet their needs and remove those barriers.
- 16:13And I'd like to add, too, like, I think more than ever, as educators,
- 16:18we understand that every student is unique.
- 16:20I do, you know, there used to be, like, this is how we learn.
- 16:24And if they don't get it, I don't know what to do with them, right?
- 16:27So I think more than ever, our teachers understand that every student approaches
- 16:30things differently. And I do see that being valued in the classroom.
- 16:34And that's a huge shift for me, even though it might not be a standard that
- 16:38I can check or something on my dashboard, right? Like I do, but I do think that
- 16:42the parents and the students feel that and they, that makes them want to come
- 16:45to school and, and that's important.
- 16:48And they, and we embrace fully like our continuum of services.
- 16:53So if, you know, we have, we have the whole continuum of services.
- 16:58I think the only program we do not have on our campus is deaf and hard of hearing.
- 17:02We have every other one. So we can, any student comes to our school,
- 17:07we feel confident that we can
- 17:08support them. and we will work together as a team to find where they fit.
- 17:14So that means we might have some students that are extensive support needed
- 17:19students that are in more gen ed classes. And it's.
- 17:24It is like tailored to their needs or a student who is mild mod but might be
- 17:29in a math class in the census support needs program because that's what they need or a student who is,
- 17:36severely autistic and then and takes one class in our autistic program and the
- 17:41rest in our gen ed right like we are doing that as much as we can to be responsive
- 17:46um to where they so that they can feels successful so that behaviors or disability is not,
- 17:52is being removed as a barrier as much as possible to their learning.
- 17:56And like, that's, that's been our goal. And I think like, that is something
- 18:00I'm super proud of at our school, that we do support all students as best as
- 18:05we can. And I think, I think we're doing okay. I haven't got many complaints lately.
- 18:10So that's, that's where I go from, right? Like parents are happy.
- 18:13And, and we honestly had a, have a waiting list for our extensive support needs
- 18:17program at our school. So that's exciting. Yeah, that's wonderful.
- 18:22Well, we're at our last question for today.
- 18:26Leadership can feel overwhelming. I don't need to tell you that, right?
- 18:30We know school leadership can feel overwhelming. What's one piece of advice
- 18:34you might want to give a principal who maybe they're listening and they want
- 18:38to make a difference and they don't know where to start?
- 18:41What's one piece of advice you would give?
- 18:44Okay. So I, you know, it's funny, I was just talking to somebody about this
- 18:49yesterday and I, I wish, I mean, I do,
- 18:54I I'm super grateful for the program that I went through to get my admin credential
- 18:58and love the mindset that they provided.
- 19:02I do wish that this idea of how to influence your campus was a part of that
- 19:12conversation because you,
- 19:15I kind of had to figure that part out is you could have the best ideas.
- 19:19You could be so research-based. You could be well-read. Like you could be all the great things.
- 19:24You could like, you know, work on operations and you're an instructional lead.
- 19:28But if you don't know how to influence, you don't have impact.
- 19:32And so I think for me, advice for other leaders kind of stepping into this world
- 19:39is making sure that you know your players.
- 19:43So on your staff, who are your early implementers?
- 19:47Always willing to try things out. You can use them as lighthouse teachers.
- 19:51Who are your influencers who, if they try something, they will spread things very quickly?
- 19:57Who are your are teachers who are tried and true, but they really lean into
- 20:03more traditional methods.
- 20:04And, you know, how do you, like, how do they learn and what motivates them?
- 20:09So you have to know your players, you have to know your team,
- 20:13and you have to know your community, and then be able to leverage those relationships
- 20:18and what you know and those strengths to move and make impact in your community.
- 20:23I think that is the one thing that I think I was never taught and I had to really
- 20:27pick up that has helped me shift and transform school.
- 20:35Yeah. And exactly. I think Jenny hit that on the head as well is the idea that
- 20:42you have to come in and, and yes, it's, it's going slow to go fast.
- 20:46And I think the, the unifying factor for me is I, I rely heavily on vision.
- 20:51Like I'm a vision person. If I don't have a vision or a framework or a pathway,
- 20:55like I even get, you know, a little bit stuck. So it's the horse and the rider,
- 21:00it's the rider and the elephant from a switch.
- 21:04It's the idea of if I want my teachers to go somewhere, like I want to provide
- 21:08that path for them to get there on their own,
- 21:10they are going to do better and they're going to be more engaged and more bought
- 21:15in if they are riding the elephant, if they are taking that idea forward themselves
- 21:22because they were shown a vision of the path that they're going to go.
- 21:25So, you know, we did a lot of work. like Jenny, when you mentioned like that
- 21:28first year of like just PDs, like that's what we did.
- 21:30And we learned, we defined everything from what is collaboration? What is creativity?
- 21:35Like, these are the things that we want to see in our classrooms.
- 21:37So how are we going to get there?
- 21:39And so it was that collaborative, that team spirit of we can do this and we're
- 21:46going to have the best school in the universe.
- 21:47They didn't, a lot of them didn't believe me. And now they come to me and they're
- 21:51like, thank you for saving our school.
- 21:54Like they have seen it and they're bought in and now it's like hey we are gonna
- 21:58have at our school we are an arts integration school.
- 22:02A math class is gonna look different here than anywhere else in our district
- 22:05and they're embracing that and and so it's it's leading them to believe um that
- 22:10they can giving them the tools to get there.
- 22:13And for a lot of our teachers, what are the arts? I'm a math person.
- 22:18How do I, right? So we do, and we've also adopted a series of,
- 22:22we're all learners. We're all going to be artists.
- 22:24So we do a monthly arts workshop.
- 22:26We paint for Thanksgiving.
- 22:29We learn how to paint pumpkins and do contour drawings. The amount of teachers
- 22:33that are still talking about that PD and how they felt successful,
- 22:38that translates into what they can offer their kids in the classroom.
- 22:42So it is like knowing who your students are, which are students, teachers,
- 22:46I'm still a teacher, and really getting them behind the vision and really having
- 22:52that vision, setting that vision together as a community, and then feeling that
- 22:56team effort to move forward. So, yeah.
- 22:59Thank you both so much for your insights, for your time, your energy, your expertise.
- 23:03It's no easy feat to get two principals together in the middle of the school
- 23:07day, right before testing, right during testing. So, Jenny and Andrea,
- 23:12thank you so much on behalf of our listeners. It's been great chatting with you today.
- 23:17Thank you for the opportunity. Thank you so much for having us.
- 23:22That's it for us today, folks. Thank you to Andrea and Jenny.
- 23:25And to learn more about their schools, visit cpma.sandiegounified.org and cas.vistausd.org.
- 23:37If you enjoyed this episode, don't forget to subscribe on your favorite podcast
- 23:41platform and follow us on social media.
- 23:43I'm Aurora from EALA, and this was a deep dive into school leadership.