Latest / Film And Whiskey / Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 2 / Rowan's Creek
Transcript
- 0:00In 2011 director, David Yates in the child acting Dream Team,
- 0:04gave the world, a climactic finale to literature's greatest
- 0:08young adult Series in 2022. We returned to Kentucky, to try
- 0:13a whiskey with a distinct Funk. The film is Harry Potter and the
- 0:19Deathly Hallows part 2. The whiskey is Rowan's Creek and
- 0:23we'll review them both. This is the film and whiskey
- 0:27podcast. Welcome to the film and whiskey
- 0:48podcast, where each week, we review a classic movie and a
- 0:51glass of whiskey. I'm Bob book, I'm Reggie and
- 0:55this week we are looking at. Did you say Eleven Bob.
- 1:00Wow, I was thinking that we were going to hit the ten year
- 1:03anniversary but we missed it. It's where you going to be
- 1:06eleven year anniversary of the eighth Harry Potter, film, The
- 1:10Deathly Hallows Part 2 henceforth, which will be known
- 1:13as Harry Potter 8. I can't say all that Brad.
- 1:16It's just it's too much. It's an assassination of the
- 1:21Jesse James by the coward. Robert Ford cynic Voldemort by
- 1:25the coward Neville Longbottom. Do you want to know a fun fact
- 1:29that I've learned in researching for this movie?
- 1:31Oh, please Voldemort in French means, flight from Death more.
- 1:38Literally cheat of death or steel of death.
- 1:41Wow, mmm. Good.
- 1:44So, like if we, if we knew any french at all, it would just hit
- 1:47us off to everything that's going.
- 1:49It's kind of like, if, you know, German like Darth Vader is a
- 1:52very easy thing to figure out exactly.
- 1:54Wow. Brad, you know, where I want to
- 1:56start today. On Harry Potter.
- 1:57Eat because this is it man. We've gone through the entire
- 2:00series. We started this season with
- 2:02Harry Potter 7. We bookended it with Harry
- 2:05Potter 8. Is this the first time that they
- 2:09did? The thing where they were
- 2:11adapting a series of books and they split it into two because I
- 2:14think this is the first time they did that it has to because
- 2:17I remember when they did that, it was like, not an uproar, but
- 2:21everybody was like, whoa, why did they censor?
- 2:23Third splitting it into two. You you could fit into one and
- 2:27They just called a kerfuffle. Yes, there is a kerfuffle
- 2:31exactly. Yeah.
- 2:32Yes, I believe you are correct. This is the first time they took
- 2:36a book series and split the last book into two and then everyone
- 2:42thought that they could do that in subsequent series, I mean,
- 2:45it, you know, the The Hunger Games, movies did it?
- 2:47The Twilight movies did it? You could argue that this
- 2:50influenced The Hobbit movies to split into the alley, I was
- 2:54about to say The Hobbit. So, I mean, just Serious points
- 2:59against this movie for starting. Probably the worst friend ever.
- 3:02Yeah, I really think that you could have made one like, three
- 3:08to three hour and 15 minute movie out of the Deathly Hallows
- 3:13rather than to, like, I don't know.
- 3:16They're both probably around like to 10 or so.
- 3:20So, like four hours and 20 minutes or like, actually, like
- 3:24concise 3 hours and 15 minutes. Now, you've read the book.
- 3:28I've never read the book. I stopped after book 5 which is
- 3:32something that I think. I've said on every episode, it's
- 3:34still wild to me, man. I wear it like a badge of honor
- 3:37at this point. You gotta get back in there and
- 3:38read it. Man.
- 3:39I guess those books. I've never going to read them at
- 3:41this point. That's like, that's like saying
- 3:43like f Scotch. I wear it as a badge of honor.
- 3:46I've never tasted a sip of scotch in my life.
- 3:50I mean, okay, so back to my point, you've read the book is
- 3:57the division. Vision of the movies.
- 3:59Like, roughly, the halfway point of the book, I believe it is
- 4:03about my, I think that when he added, we have to say spoiler
- 4:07alert, know if you've been listening to this podcast for
- 4:10any length of time, you know, that we dive deep into spoilers
- 4:13and we've already spoiled seven. Harry Potter movies.
- 4:15So I think we might as well just continue the trend.
- 4:18Okay, so when he buries Dobby feels like, at the very least, I
- 4:22don't remember if it's right in the middle of the book.
- 4:24I think it's in a good narrative beat.
- 4:28To, to split the two movies in half.
- 4:31Okay, I'll give him credit there and one thing that we really
- 4:34liked about Harry Potter 7, was that it had a different Rhythm
- 4:39and a different vibe and feel from the rest of the films.
- 4:43And, you know, I we kept trying to avoid using the word Shaggy,
- 4:47but like, it definitely felt more loose.
- 4:49It felt like the characters had room to breathe.
- 4:52I really got a sense that you understood the dynamic between
- 4:57these three, In a way that you really never got a chance to
- 5:00because there's so much plot happening in the first six
- 5:03movies. And there's a ton of plot
- 5:04happening in this last year of Hogwarts as well.
- 5:08But because of the way that they let these movies kind of are
- 5:11out, I think it really benefited number 7, but by the time you
- 5:15get to number eight, I think one thing I really noticed on this
- 5:18watch through Brad and I guess spoiling my own feelings towards
- 5:22this movie, is that, I would say, the first 35, 40, 45
- 5:27minutes. Of this movie felt just
- 5:29completely aimless. Like there was no rhythm to it,
- 5:33it felt like I didn't have a starting point.
- 5:36In fact, when I was watching it, I don't even remember this
- 5:38happening in the theater. And so it's one of those things
- 5:40where I don't know if they inserted it later.
- 5:43But the movie starts with like, you know, last week on Harry
- 5:48Potter and they do like a montage of like what we saw,
- 5:51last time we were visiting with Voldemort and then it starts the
- 5:54movie. After that it was very weird to
- 5:57see him Stealing the Elder Wand again and then replaying the end
- 6:01of number 7. It didn't even feel like,
- 6:04episodic television, it just kind of was going.
- 6:08And then I was like, oh, the movies on and I kept doing that
- 6:12for 40 minutes because I was so disinterested with everything
- 6:16that was happening. Yeah.
- 6:17The entire Gringotts sequence just feels awkward.
- 6:22I mean, I will give credit where it's due.
- 6:24I think that whoever played griphook Check the goblin
- 6:29Warwick Davis was. Yeah, Warwick my dude from Star
- 6:32Wars Warwick freaking killed it when that when they're like
- 6:37talking to him about the sword and he's like asking them where
- 6:40they got it. I just remember taking a note, I
- 6:43was like, griphook. Here is terrifying.
- 6:47Like he is dark and brooding and I just loved everything.
- 6:52He was doing in that scene, but other than that, the first in
- 6:56the first like, third of this, He's just really boring, Bob and
- 6:59bad. It's like it's badly done.
- 7:02And you could tell where they focused their efforts and their
- 7:04energy and their money, frankly, because I think the first, let's
- 7:08talk about that Gringotts sequence and we will get into
- 7:11Brad explains and all that in a minute, but we're on a roll
- 7:13here, so I don't want to get us. Harry Harry tries to kill
- 7:15Voldemort and stuff happens. Boom, the yeah, that explains
- 7:20Brad explains. They have to go down into the
- 7:23bowels of Gringotts bank and Brad.
- 7:26I mean the green screening is off.
- 7:27Awful when they're riding that like trolley cart Indiana, Jones
- 7:31style reminded me. Of when they go visit the Goblin
- 7:34King in The Hobbit and how bad that looked like it looked even
- 7:37worse and you know the dragon doesn't look good.
- 7:41And then there's a part where they're trying to Escape from
- 7:44Gringotts and they're kind of hiding behind a wall and I don't
- 7:48know if it's like goblins or whoever it is.
- 7:50Someone shooting Spells at them and you could kind of tell that
- 7:54they were filming it in reshoots because they never Back outside
- 7:59to what was happening outside that room that they were hiding
- 8:01in. You never got a shot with the
- 8:04three kids and whoever their enemies were in the same shot
- 8:08and it just kind of felt like, oh, they must have really
- 8:11botched this the first time around and they're trying to
- 8:14piece something together in reshoots.
- 8:16But man, I texted you at, like the 45-minute Mark of watching
- 8:20this movie and was shocked at how bad it was to that point, it
- 8:26really felt like we were back Back to David Yates of the Order
- 8:31of the Phoenix. Yeah, that like, he just didn't
- 8:34really know where he was going. He didn't know how to handle the
- 8:37characters. It felt like he needed to hit
- 8:40certain story beats, but there was no real Rhythm to the film.
- 8:44I think he finds it later in the film but you're right man.
- 8:47The first third, almost the first half of this movie just
- 8:51feels kind of disjointed and wonky and there's not as much
- 8:55money thrown behind the CGI. I'm You know, there's a few
- 8:58beautiful shots when they, you know, when they're riding the
- 9:00dragon off into the sunset and they're there in the middle of
- 9:03all these locks and mountains and stuff like, yeah, it's
- 9:06beautiful. But for the most part, it's a
- 9:10rough 30, 40 minutes to endure. Yeah, it sure is.
- 9:13And it feels like the kind of thing where man, I wish that
- 9:17this series I just implemented the Star Wars like open and
- 9:20crawl. We don't even like, hey, our
- 9:22heroes went and got this thing from a bank.
- 9:24And now let's get back to Hogwarts because If go ahead of
- 9:28the opening crawl, had become so pervasive that every single
- 9:32movie utilize it like Juno. This is the opening crawl about
- 9:38getting pregnant. Yep.
- 9:40You dropped in half way through young teen.
- 9:43Girl, she, you know Finding herself raging with hormones.
- 9:47All right, well, on that note, let's pivot hard out of that
- 9:50conversation and Brad. Let's move into Brad explains.
- 9:54This is the part of the podcast, where Brad breaks down the movie
- 9:57that he Just seen often for the first time Brad.
- 10:00This is probably the latest in an episode we've ever intro to
- 10:03Brad explains but I thought that it was it's pretty late man.
- 10:07It was necessary to structure our episode the same way this
- 10:10movie is structured with the beginning, that is Meandering
- 10:14and aimless before finally, getting into the meat of things.
- 10:16So you have 60 seconds on the clock.
- 10:19Can you break down the plot of Harry Potter 8?
- 10:24Harry and his friends. They got to get a few more
- 10:28horcruxes there's like two or three more.
- 10:31I think the annual like debate that anyone has when they're
- 10:35watching this movie is like how many horcruxes are left?
- 10:38Like wait, there was a blank to their like, you guy know but
- 10:40also you there's one more. But yeah, so they destroy they
- 10:46find like a cup and they do it in Gringotts and then they're
- 10:52there. Doing good.
- 10:54And and I can't remember the plot of this movie for the life
- 10:59of me. It's literally they find the
- 11:02last few horcruxes, they realized that Harry is a
- 11:04horcrux. They go back to Hogwarts and
- 11:09they mounted defense against all the bad Death Eaters and Harry
- 11:15dies to Voldemort after seeing Snape cry.
- 11:19And then he comes back to life and kills Baltimore.
- 11:23Boom, the end is that it it's like, you know, there's a bad
- 11:29murder and then there's a good murder and then we celebrate the
- 11:31good work. Yeah, yeah, that's.
- 11:35That's about it. All right, so let's jump back
- 11:38into nitpicking this movie because there was a very
- 11:41specific point in the movie, at which everything started
- 11:45clicking for me. And I was ready to come on here
- 11:47and just poop all over this movie and then it just really
- 11:50started working. And so, We'll get to a point
- 11:53where I start praising this movie, but we're not there yet
- 11:56because I have to talk about, hold your horses.
- 11:58Yeah, I have to talk about how Voldemort starts broadcasting,
- 12:02his thoughts into the ears of everyone inside Hogwarts.
- 12:06So Voldemort leads this very ill-advised ground assault on
- 12:10Hogwarts, which I don't understand.
- 12:12Everyone has brooms. Like, why are you not attacking
- 12:15real like, really attacking from all angles here?
- 12:17Dude, I was thinking that when, when McGonagall does the cool
- 12:20locomotive spell and all the Statues.
- 12:23Come out there on the bridge. They put, like a four-time like
- 12:25round it. Yeah.
- 12:26And then the and then they're like telling Neville and the
- 12:29other children to blow up the, the back, the the back entrance,
- 12:33which is this big wooden bridge, right?
- 12:35Like, you do realize that you've spent the last, like I think
- 12:39it's in the third or the fourth movie, I think it's in the
- 12:41fourth movie that they establish that Death Eaters can like fly
- 12:46around like banshees. Yes the only.
- 12:50Okay so they can do that. I think of all of the Then two
- 12:52things in like every movie, the flying car and the flu powder
- 12:58and you're like talking to people through fireplaces.
- 13:01And like, there are so many ways, they could have gotten
- 13:03into Hogwarts. That plays was not on lockdown
- 13:06at all. Yeah.
- 13:08I mean, I will say in the books they make it clear that you
- 13:11can't like teleport into Hogwarts and there's like
- 13:14restrictions and stuff. But if you're if you have an
- 13:16army standing right outside, put them on.
- 13:19Brooms, have the Giants. Throw them into the courtyard.
- 13:22I don't know. No, like you got magic like
- 13:25you'll figure it out. So anyway, Voldemort is just
- 13:29standing outside feeling very thwarted and decides to make
- 13:33threats and he broadcasts his mind into the minds of everyone
- 13:37in there and he's like, it's me Voldemort.
- 13:40And they're like, oh my God. And then he says like give up
- 13:43Harry Potter and I'll reward you and then he signs off with you
- 13:47have one hour and that's it. It's so unintentionally funny.
- 13:50It sounds so desperate bike. And I think they're trying to
- 13:53underscore the fact that at this point Voldemort is desperate
- 13:57because he understands what Harry and Ron and Hermione are
- 14:00doing. And but it's just every decision
- 14:04with Voldemort in this movie, I feel like really takes away from
- 14:08the Mythos of Voldemort. You know what I mean?
- 14:11Like, he stops being a very threatening character at about
- 14:14the 15-minute Mark of this movie and they do their best to show.
- 14:19He's just a very sad and desperate, man.
- 14:23But it also like it doesn't underscore how sad and desperate
- 14:28it. He is it just comes across as
- 14:29unintentionally funny for a lot of the movie.
- 14:32Well, the the struggle for me is he is supposed to be the most
- 14:36powerful wizard of all time. Barring maybe Dumbledore but
- 14:40Dumbledore's dead. So like I don't know I don't
- 14:44know if I agree with you that he doesn't come across as menacing
- 14:47anymore. Like the one our comment I
- 14:50didn't find funny at all. Picture didn't like talking into
- 14:54a telephone and being like, give me Harry Potter and then going
- 14:57to put it down and then just like putting it right back up to
- 15:00his ear saying like you have one hour and then hanging up again
- 15:04and then just seems like such an afterthought and then Harry
- 15:07going. I have a very special set of
- 15:09skills, right? Yeah.
- 15:14I don't know. I didn't perceive that in that
- 15:16manner. I think that Voldemort.
- 15:20He kind of struggles in this movie because they tie a lot of
- 15:22his power to the Elder Wand and like this this kind of comes
- 15:26back to me with. I think my big problems with
- 15:29this movie are not necessarily with the movie itself.
- 15:32Although there are some struggles that Yates has as a
- 15:35director. I think that the source material
- 15:38is just really hard to turn into a movie, and I think that is the
- 15:43biggest struggle. And the thing is, I like the
- 15:45seventh book. I like, I like every single book
- 15:47of the Harry Potter series, I think they work Really
- 15:50phenomenally as young adult literature, but as a movie, the
- 15:55seventh book is hard to turn into a movie and I think that it
- 15:59does kind of affect the way you view Voldemort.
- 16:03And you spend so much time with Ron and Hermione, trying to find
- 16:08the horcruxes and make their way around the castle and talk to
- 16:12ghosts and and do all these somewhat mundane type of things
- 16:16that you just kind of get lost in the shuffle of like they're
- 16:20doing these cool things outside with the Army and they're
- 16:23putting up this shield and they're bombarding it and you
- 16:27know all this stuff is happening but in the end Voldemort just
- 16:31doesn't come across as the most powerful wizard in the world in
- 16:34this movie. You know.
- 16:35And I think that is a problem of David Yates is a director that
- 16:39like the final battle between Harry and Voldemort is frankly
- 16:44just kind of boring and like not not much really happens.
- 16:49And at this Point, they've relied on the wands, connecting
- 16:53to one another, with a spell like 17 times and it just kind
- 16:58of gets old. And so I just, I don't know,
- 17:00man, this movie just overall, doesn't do it for me very well.
- 17:04So to give it a compliment, I will say that as a guy who
- 17:08doesn't like to get really deep into lore of things like this,
- 17:13like especially when it's an adaptation like if I'm reading a
- 17:15book, absolutely, hit me with the Lord.
- 17:18Sounds great in a move. Movie.
- 17:20It needs to be well, constructed enough that my brain isn't
- 17:25constantly questioning the rules.
- 17:27And as long as you do that, I'm on board, like you just have to
- 17:31buy into the premise that it's like the you know I'll call it
- 17:33like the Jurassic Park theory in the movie Jurassic Park.
- 17:37The science makes enough sense. The way that it's explained that
- 17:40you're like awesome. Let's go see some T-Rexes.
- 17:43You know what I mean? This science makes enough sense
- 17:45that I think there's a lot of people out there who believe
- 17:49that. Like if you found a mosquito
- 17:52encased in Amber Amber that you could make that, like I think
- 17:57people actually believe that. It I mean it sounds plausible
- 18:00and it's plausible enough. That you're just like, cool.
- 18:02I'm rolling with it, you know. Yeah, exactly.
- 18:04And in Harry Potter, especially in this one.
- 18:06I will say that the more that I have like gone on the Harry
- 18:11Potter Wiki's and everything else to learn more about
- 18:14horcruxes, the more my eyes glaze over seeing it all,
- 18:18spelled out makes it It more boring and this movie does just
- 18:22enough to be like here's a little piece of information.
- 18:25Here's why that horcrux isn't working, here's the reveal that
- 18:29Harry is a horcrux and we're going to do it in just these
- 18:32little bits that Propel The Narrative forward and whet your
- 18:36appetite and don't leave you completely confused.
- 18:39And I actually really appreciated that because I think
- 18:41one knock that I've seen against this movie is that it doesn't
- 18:44dive deep enough into the lore or that it doesn't.
- 18:48It doesn't lay it out in a way that A lot of sense, but I
- 18:51thought that it made enough sense that what was happening on
- 18:54screen was still highlighted and it wasn't just the mythology and
- 18:59the backdrop that was being highlighted because I think that
- 19:01would have made this movie drag even more.
- 19:03No, I'm with you. I think that there's always
- 19:06opportunities to over explain what's going on in the books for
- 19:10any series that's based on books.
- 19:12You just have a lot more pages for people to read in a book.
- 19:16Then you have minutes for someone to watch a film.
- 19:19And so I'm okay. When they they kind of concisely
- 19:23bring the information to a point that people need to understand
- 19:28what's going on. Like you said, give me the
- 19:29premise and I can roll with the implications of that premise.
- 19:34I think that with the World of Harry Potter it can just for me
- 19:38every once in a while, get confusing because and I think
- 19:41that the newer Harry Potter movies, struggle from this, the
- 19:44the Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them franchise at a
- 19:47certain point. You have to just ask the
- 19:51question, when what are the limits on Magic?
- 19:55And I think in the in the original series, they do a
- 19:57pretty good job of like sticking to the world that that Rowling
- 20:01created of like There are rules to Magic.
- 20:04There's like research that goes into making new spells and you
- 20:08know you have to really study and learn and and do all this
- 20:11stuff and some people are more naturally powerful but you still
- 20:14have to study and all that. But by the time you get to this
- 20:18one at a certain point, your It does just kind of feel like, are
- 20:21we just making magic, do whatever we want?
- 20:24Now like are there any rules and and Voldemort kind of epitomizes
- 20:29that? And this it's like he just gets
- 20:31angry enough that the The Shield barrier comes down and he's just
- 20:36flying around and doing stuff and you just kind of cool and do
- 20:40whatever he wants. And I don't know, I just hit a
- 20:43certain point where I'm like is it just a little bit ridiculous?
- 20:46And I think that a series like this is always going to like
- 20:49open itself. To the criticisms about having
- 20:51like a day use ex machina rate. Like that something that comes
- 20:54in in the 11th Hour that they're like, oh, remember this magical
- 20:59pen is going to write our way to Victory and they're like, hey,
- 21:03you know, the pain wasn't even in the plot until 3/4 of the way
- 21:07through the movie. And that's just, that's how
- 21:10worlds of magic are and I accept it and I understand it.
- 21:13And so you have to give it take her, the little bit of a grain
- 21:16of salt, but I agree with you that this Be in particular or
- 21:20this you know, book in the series, it introduces so many of
- 21:24those and it's like we have to explain all of the Loose Ends of
- 21:29this prophecy. And was this prophecy true or
- 21:31was this prophecy just misinterpreted, and OU he
- 21:34created another horcrux on accident and you're that
- 21:36horcrux. And so you have to die now and
- 21:38then once you die, it's like well guess what?
- 21:41He was misinformed about the Elder Wand and then you go back
- 21:43and there's more about the Elder Wand and it's like, I don't care
- 21:46anymore. I want to see The Final Duel
- 21:48between these two. But I don't want the, the rules
- 21:52of this duel and who's going to win to only be based on some
- 21:55weird loophole technicality. And I think that's the thing
- 21:58that really bothers me about it is like, it doesn't feel like
- 22:02Voldemort and Harry are fighting as equals.
- 22:06And I don't even mean that like, you know, to your point like if
- 22:09Voldemort is the most powerful wizard, like he would kick
- 22:11Harry's ass and we all understand that.
- 22:13But even even if you just present like a weakened
- 22:17Voldemort fighting his hardest, Against Harry like, that's
- 22:21compelling and it's good versus evil, but it's the fact that
- 22:25it's like, you're going to defeat him because the Elder
- 22:27Wand isn't loyal to him. What's the significance of that?
- 22:32Like, hmm, there's so much in these books that that tries to
- 22:37be metaphorical, and I think at that point, it's like, what's
- 22:42the point? What's the, the symbol here is
- 22:44it? That Voldemort is putting Blind
- 22:46Faith in things that he doesn't understand.
- 22:48He's just too. Angry and hateful to see what's
- 22:51going on in front of his face. But honestly, like even as an
- 22:54audience member, they don't explain what the hell is going
- 22:57on with the Elder ones, Allegiance, until way, after the
- 23:01fact like Voldemort's dead and everyone's happy and saying her
- 23:05a and then her mind he's like, hey, what was going on with that
- 23:08older one? By the way actually we've seen
- 23:12to explain it that late in the movie than just don't freakin do
- 23:16it. And yeah so that's your right.
- 23:18It's one of my biggest. Pigs with the whole series, I
- 23:21couldn't care less about the Elder Wand and they make it like
- 23:25the most important point of the plot towards the end of this
- 23:28film. I think that the Deathly Hallows
- 23:31in general, just feel like such a weird addition to the series
- 23:35because they're not even mentioned in the books before
- 23:39the seventh book like they're like, there's just nothing about
- 23:43them. And then all of a sudden, the
- 23:44entire seventh book is about them trying to find them as
- 23:48they're fine. Being the horcruxes and I just
- 23:52struggle with them becoming such a focal part of the series, so
- 23:55late in the series, and I think that it undermines like Harry's
- 24:00growth as a character. Like, the final battle should
- 24:05represent Harry reaching the Pinnacle of belief in himself,
- 24:10right? Because what, where do we have
- 24:12Harry at the start of the whole series?
- 24:15He's living in a Cupboard. Beneath the stairs in his
- 24:19Abusive, aunt and uncle's house where he is last place in
- 24:24everything and unwanted and uncharitable.
- 24:27And so like the end of the movie should be a place where he has,
- 24:32you know, if we're talking about like Maslow's hierarchy of
- 24:34needs, he has self-actualized, he knows who he is.
- 24:39He has sacrificed himself for the greater good.
- 24:43He believes in himself and his friends that have become family
- 24:47and because of those things, he has become more powerful than
- 24:51the most powerful wizard who ever lived and beats him in a
- 24:56fair and square. Yes.
- 24:57Yes. That like, that would represent
- 25:00the Pinnacle of good triumphing over evil.
- 25:04Well, and that's the thing about these, the Deathly Hallows as
- 25:06that there's such such aids to him like and it's not that they
- 25:11do a job but it's that they're like these all powerful things
- 25:14and they come at the point in the story where he should need
- 25:16the least amount of help. Yeah.
- 25:18You know, in book, 1. The kid is like 11 years old and
- 25:21they're like hey man all you get to fight this guy who has a face
- 25:25growing out of the back of his head is an invisibility cloak
- 25:28like good luck which which was a dud Deathly Hallow.
- 25:32Right. But yeah.
- 25:33But by the time you get to the seventh book.
- 25:35It's like, hey, what if you had a stone that could raise you
- 25:38from the dead? Like what if you were all
- 25:40powerful and had a resurrection Stone?
- 25:42And it's like, well then there's no snakes to anything.
- 25:45Well, but even that though, it's not that it raised him from the
- 25:48dead. Is that it brought the spirits
- 25:51back to give him support to go die.
- 25:57And so like it wasn't really necessary because you already
- 26:01pulled his parents dead Spirits out once in the fourth book,
- 26:05when you had their wands connect the first time.
- 26:07So why don't you just? I don't know, do something like
- 26:09that. Like, I don't know, the Deathly
- 26:12Hallows, just feel like such a weird device MacGuffin, if you
- 26:16will. I like, they just feel like a
- 26:18weird addition and once again, I will iterate that I'm not
- 26:22necessarily talking about the movie.
- 26:23I am talking about the source material at this point.
- 26:26So it if y'all look just love that part of the source material
- 26:29great, like that's awesome. I just never fully understood
- 26:33why it's there and see I have always said that I'm a movie guy
- 26:37and this is a movie podcast and if you come back to me and say
- 26:42like will just read the book. I shouldn't have to read the
- 26:45book to understand the movie. The movie is a thing that stands
- 26:47on its own or should and So I am coming at it from the point of
- 26:51the movie because I have not read The Source material and to
- 26:54its credit. I think that the internal logic
- 26:57of the movie works, like, I understand what's going on.
- 27:00I just think that sometimes it's sloppily constructed and and
- 27:05they introduced way too many of these get-out-of-jail-free
- 27:07cards. Brad, when we come back from
- 27:10break we will talk more about the filmmaking here.
- 27:12We haven't talked to performances at all and I do
- 27:15think that I Want To Praise some things that David Yates does
- 27:17particularly in the second half. For the film.
- 27:20But before we get there let's hit pause.
- 27:22Let's try this Rowan's Creek. What do you say?
- 27:24Can I complain about one? Other source material thing?
- 27:28Yeah, sure. Let's do it.
- 27:30All right, so I like how you waited till the very end of me
- 27:33saying, like, let's get to it. And then you're like, no, no, no
- 27:36one more complete. I mean, how was I supposed to
- 27:38interrupt you? You were just, I was I on
- 27:40through, I was on a roll, man. I don't want to interrupt you
- 27:44material Severus Snape. Hmm.
- 27:47So here's the thing I'm I know I'm about to piss off, a lot of
- 27:50people and I'll accept that so Severus Snape sshole deal, is
- 27:56that he loves Lily you. All right.
- 28:00I'm just gonna give you a scenario.
- 28:02Bob, you tell me what you think of this scenario.
- 28:05Kid grows up, you know, he's a little bit poor.
- 28:09He has this little girl that he's like, genuinely just good
- 28:11friends with they get to high school.
- 28:13He develops a crush on her really falls in love with her
- 28:17because they've been friends for forever.
- 28:18And she's one of the only people that's ever been nice to him.
- 28:21She ends up dating somebody else.
- 28:23He's sad about it. Probably probably a little angry
- 28:26about it. She gets married to this other
- 28:28guy. He's just Heartbroken crushed
- 28:32he/she goes on and has a kid with this other guy.
- 28:36Just still just really sad and heartbroken and then they both
- 28:39die. They're both killed.
- 28:41They're both murdered like at a certain point.
- 28:45When does it become weird to still be obsessively in love
- 28:50with your friend from childhood? Yeah.
- 28:52And is it when she's dating someone else, is it when she's
- 28:55married to someone else? Is that when she's had kids with
- 28:58someone else, right? Because it is A certain point.
- 29:01I don't think what he is doing is loving, I think it is sad and
- 29:06I think that it is harmful to himself, it's others and to
- 29:12others. So that the thing is that
- 29:14Harry's dad is kind of a great and I kind of love right?
- 29:16They never give him a Redemption Arc like you never find out that
- 29:19he like you know, pull the baby out of a.
- 29:21Well, he's just has to live with that forever.
- 29:25But yep, which is cool. I mean, like, you know, I'm glad
- 29:28they did that and and didn't try to You heard in some weird
- 29:30growth there, but like at a certain point, you're kind of on
- 29:35team James Potter because like imagine it from his point of
- 29:38view, you are married. It's like, it's like the reverse
- 29:42Mavis Gary, like, like Yammer is Snape is Young adulting, the
- 29:47Potter family? Yes, Thank you.
- 29:51Bob. I as long as you can understand
- 29:54my angst with that part of the story and like I've talked to
- 29:57people who are like, oh, Severus Snape always, it's adorable.
- 30:02He has her Petronas as his I'm like, and I usually try to just
- 30:06be nice and be like, oh yeah, that's that's kind of cool.
- 30:09Like, that's an interesting part of the story.
- 30:12Like, at a certain point mass will be creepy.
- 30:15It is and it looks like I've never understood why we so like
- 30:19glorify what? He does because yes, even to
- 30:23Harry like as he's dying. He's like you have your mom's
- 30:26eyes and also like I've still totally want to your mom like,
- 30:30like his whole motivation is, I'm in love with your dead mom.
- 30:35And you never really get the sense that he is motivated by
- 30:39doing the right thing. Like his whole reason when you
- 30:43read the lore for like going to Dumbledore in the first place
- 30:46was like, I'm a Death Eater. I have made some bad mistakes.
- 30:50I want Lily Potter to be protected and that's why he
- 30:53starts working for the good guys, as a double agent and
- 30:56like, all the way through after Lily dies, and he swears to
- 31:00Dumbledore that he's going to protect Harry.
- 31:01He's motivated by the fact that he wants to a dead lady.
- 31:05And like, you never really truly get a sense that it's just like
- 31:10no Voldemort is bad and I need to do the right thing.
- 31:14It's kind of just like, I've made a vow to this dead woman
- 31:18that I love, and I'm It for her. And I just don't understand why
- 31:23we see that as like some huge Act of Valor and not just like
- 31:27this, really desperate pathetic in cell guy, I don't know.
- 31:32Yep. Dude, I am happy as a clam you
- 31:36could give this movie A 1 out of 10 or 10 out of 10, I wouldn't
- 31:39even care. That's all I needed to get out
- 31:41in this episode. All right, let's drink some
- 31:43whiskey. What do you say?
- 31:44Ha ha I'm ready. Dude, today's sponsor is a
- 31:47little bit of a departure from our usual area of T sand, man.
- 31:51Oh, man, I was blown away by their product.
- 31:54Once we received it, I am talking about manscaped.
- 31:58Now, if you're like me at all, you probably seen the manscaped
- 32:00ads and kind of Wonder to yourself like, do I really need
- 32:03like some sort of specialty trimmer to take care of my
- 32:05downstairs business? And I've just got to be honest.
- 32:09I was absolutely wrong there trimmers called the lawn mower
- 32:134.0 and I got to say it is the Rolls-Royce of trimmers.
- 32:17It's got a ceramic blade that reduces Is Hap's, a wireless
- 32:21charging base and an awesome flashlight.
- 32:23That keeps things illuminated while you're working and beyond
- 32:26all that it's waterproof. This thing is really changing
- 32:29the game when it comes to below the belt hygiene.
- 32:31Now this is just me talking about my experience, but this
- 32:34trimmer really is Way Beyond anything I've ever used to keep
- 32:38things neat. And tidy, you can use our
- 32:40discount code film whiskey to get 20 percent off your order
- 32:44and free shipping head on over to manscape.com and use code
- 32:47film whiskey, to get 20% off free shipping.
- 32:50And you will be well on your way to hygiene heaven.
- 33:00Alright, so today we are checking out Rowan's Creek.
- 33:04Now Brad, this might sound kind of familiar to you because it
- 33:07has a brother whiskey called Noah's Mill.
- 33:10This is produced by Willett Distillery originally, when this
- 33:13came out, it was a 12-year age stated product.
- 33:15It is no longer age stated, which means it's a blend of some
- 33:19whiskeys, but it's kind of known as like Noah's Mill.
- 33:23Light its Will Dad a little bit lower proof and always Mill is
- 33:27114 proof this clocks in at 100.1.
- 33:31Proof very very necessary that .10, you know, it.
- 33:35But you know, from everything I've read about it.
- 33:37I think I've had this maybe one time before Brad, but I can't
- 33:40remember because I'm such a huge fan of Noah's Mill.
- 33:43I just keep buying that. So from everything I've heard,
- 33:46everything I've read, this is kind of like a slightly more
- 33:49tamed version of Noah's Mill. And Brad.
- 33:53It's been a little while since we've had no is Mill.
- 33:55I think we drank it when we did A League of Their Own and we had
- 33:58Bourbon and blondes on the podcast.
- 34:00I believe that was it. Yeah.
- 34:02And I'm a huge fan of it. I think everybody else was a
- 34:04little cooler on it than me, but this is our first return to will
- 34:09it in a while. How are you feeling about it?
- 34:12Dude. I this is this is the funk man.
- 34:14I'm ready. This, it's just Funk, the ha,
- 34:18man. All right, so then let's just
- 34:20dive in. I want to know like You knows
- 34:22this is there a funk on it or am I just crazy for me?
- 34:27There's a little bit of a floral note that is dissonant with the
- 34:31rest of the nose because most of it.
- 34:34I got like Cherry caramel and cream.
- 34:37Just like a really nice pleasant nose but there's just some weird
- 34:42floral just kind of some like rose lavender.
- 34:47Flowery stuff going on that was unique and interesting and a
- 34:50little bit funky. So I'll give it a seven and a
- 34:53half on the nose. I think Rose is the perfect.
- 34:56Note to describe what I get on, will it products?
- 34:59Like it's dusty. There's some sawdust to it and I
- 35:02think like when I pick up on that dusting as and other things
- 35:05I'm immediately like oh, will it but then when I go back to a,
- 35:09will it product? It's not so much just that it's
- 35:11dusty. You're right.
- 35:12It's this really interesting Rose kind of character that's on
- 35:16this in Spades, man. Like I really like this a lot.
- 35:19It doesn't smell incredibly sweet.
- 35:22I think the floral note really kind of dominates in the glass,
- 35:26I'm excited to see where it goes, but it doesn't have a ton
- 35:28of bourbon e character behind it.
- 35:30I'm going to give it an 8 out of 10 on the nose.
- 35:33When I get into the actual palette, I really enjoy this.
- 35:37That cherry comes through strong for me.
- 35:39There's a nice bit of vanilla that's that's kind of hinted in
- 35:42there with it and then there's like a little bit of a pepper
- 35:46like a black pepper note that I I'm really intrigued by the
- 35:50floral stuff kind of disappears. For me, it's not as there.
- 35:55It's not there. Quite as much on the palate but
- 35:57it's a really nice fun, interesting palette I'll give it
- 36:00an 8 out of 10. I think I'm going to split from
- 36:03you here a little bit. Brad I don't really care for
- 36:05this as much as Noah's Mel and part of it is because it doesn't
- 36:07have a consistent sweetness throughout like it really kind
- 36:10of tips into almost some tannic like wine character for me on
- 36:15the palate. A lot of rice spice.
- 36:18Like in fact I think that the front of my palate would have
- 36:21mistaken this for Rye. And then, as I kind of kicked it
- 36:24to the back of my mouth, it has a nice kind of dark red wine
- 36:27character when you go to swallow and I'll get into this on
- 36:30finish, it turns, really bitter and the oak is pretty prominent,
- 36:34but not in a way that tastes like chard.
- 36:36I don't know if you remember when we did Elijah.
- 36:38Craig toasted Barrel. We talked about the differences
- 36:41in flavor between a toasted barrel and a charred barrel.
- 36:45And this really does seem to have kind of like a, I don't
- 36:48know, like a really youthful kind of underseasoned.
- 36:52Wood flavor going on to it. Not a huge fan of this palette.
- 36:56I'm going to give it a six and a half.
- 36:57Yeah, the the finish. I'm right there with you.
- 36:59Bob, it gets very Oaky. It's a long finish and there's a
- 37:03little bit of spice going on to me, it's the least impressive
- 37:07part of the whiskey so far, but it's still decent.
- 37:11I'll give it a 7 out of 10. Yeah, man, the second sip I just
- 37:15took it definitely was a little bit more sweet on the tip of my
- 37:18tongue but it goes so tannic and So bitter on the end.
- 37:23It's like it's like drinking really, really strong black tea
- 37:27and not a huge fan. The Finish is your right as
- 37:32long, it's mouth-watering and I know I said it was tannic so you
- 37:35wouldn't think it was mouth-watering but it's not,
- 37:37it's not one that burns too much is not one that just kind of
- 37:40saps, all the moisture out of your mouth.
- 37:43I just don't really care for this flavor, that's left behind.
- 37:45So I'm only going to give it a 5 and a half on Finish.
- 37:49Well, that brings us to our balance honestly, Bob for me, I
- 37:52I think this is a good mix of flavors that stay decently
- 37:55strong throughout. I'll give it a seven and a half
- 37:59on balance. It's pretty decent.
- 38:01Yeah, I'm gonna go 26 on balance.
- 38:02I know it's probably unfair for me to compare this so strongly
- 38:05to Noah's Mill. But man, I just think that's
- 38:07such a better product all the way through.
- 38:10This one really tapered off from the nose, into the palette, into
- 38:13the finish. I'm going to give it a go to
- 38:16five and a half again, unbalanced.
- 38:18All right. Bob, you're at the liquor store.
- 38:21You're looking at all the Because you could buy and you
- 38:23see this for $48 state of Ohio. Yikes, that is a lot of money
- 38:31for this whiskey and I think I'll give it a 5 out of 10 on
- 38:34value. I think it's a solid whiskey.
- 38:37I just think it should be like a thirty five dollar bottle, 38
- 38:42dollar bottle. Not $48 Noah's Mill is like
- 38:46eight dollars more and it is Barrel strength.
- 38:49I mean like I don't bottle it entails drink but it's like a
- 38:51cask strength. The whiskey and it's just so
- 38:54much more consistent and you look around at other things in
- 38:56this price point. I mean, wild turkey Rare Breed
- 38:59is like five dollars less than this.
- 39:01If you're talking about something that's bottled at 100
- 39:03Proof, that's this good. I mean, you can look at pretty
- 39:05much everything in the Rebel Yell line.
- 39:08I man I just I don't see it dude.
- 39:11I'm gonna give it that. Let's give it a five and a half.
- 39:13Again I think that's kind of like my consistent theme here
- 39:15today. So I'm coming out to a thirty
- 39:18one out of 50. Brad.
- 39:20What's your final score? I'm going to 30.
- 39:22Five out of 50. Wow.
- 39:23Okay so we're averaging out to a 33 or a 66 out of 100.
- 39:28I think that's a pretty good point for this.
- 39:30It's just below where we would normally recommend trying and or
- 39:34buying, I actually don't think you need to try this and I don't
- 39:37think you need to buy this. I really would recommend just
- 39:41going for Noah's Mill. It's better all around for me.
- 39:44I think I'd recommend trying it, if it's something that's that,
- 39:47you know, there's like mixed sweetness, a little bit of
- 39:51spice. Iciness some.
- 39:53Okay. If it's, if that sounds like
- 39:55your profile like, yeah, sure, go for it.
- 39:57But I'm with you don't buy a bottle of it.
- 39:59Just try a poor at your local bar and it might be something
- 40:02that tickles your fancy Brad before we get back into Harry
- 40:06Potter. I just want to give a quick
- 40:07shout-out because do you know who sent us this?
- 40:09Sample of Rowan's Creek. It's our friends Bourbon and
- 40:12stuff. They send us that box of
- 40:15whiskey. Have they sent us stuff yet?
- 40:17They have not sent us stuff, they really need to get on that,
- 40:20but we have been sitting on this sample.
- 40:22For like two seasons now, we finally worked it into the into
- 40:26the episodes, so I'm sorry that it was a little bit more of a
- 40:30letdown than we expected. But we are eternally grateful to
- 40:34Bourbon and stuff. Yeah, if you want to go head on
- 40:37over to Instagram, check out Bourbon and stuff.
- 40:39They are a phenomenal whiskey page and we're just incredibly
- 40:43thankful for them. They're great people.
- 40:46All right Brad it's time to get back into talking about the
- 40:48movie. So let's pivot back to Harry
- 40:51Potter, 8. Wait, what do you say pivot?
- 40:58All right, everybody that was Rowan's Creek, a whiskey that we
- 41:01are a little bit cool on and honestly Bob, it feels like it's
- 41:04paired with a movie that we're a little bit cool Lon.
- 41:07Yeah. Yeah, we'll see Pops like
- 41:11getting ready to give it a nine and a half.
- 41:14You see Bob as we have been the last few episodes.
- 41:17Here we are about to move into our newest segment one which I
- 41:21just found out today. I have had it confirmed by our
- 41:25favorite Canuck himself, Put your flash has confirmed for me.
- 41:30That this is Canada's favorite segments?
- 41:35Well, that's that's great. Because America's favorite
- 41:37segment is Brad explains. So yeah, we can amicably split
- 41:40these two things. We're covering both sides of the
- 41:43Border man. So what's the segment two facts
- 41:45in a falsehood? There it is.
- 41:47Alright, let's get into two facts and a falsehood and see if
- 41:51Brad can stump me. Hit me with fact.
- 41:53Number one, bread fact. Number one Harry's, lightning
- 41:56bolt scar was applied. Bye.
- 41:58Makeup teams, approximately five thousand eight hundred times by
- 42:03the end of the film franchise. Daniel Radcliffe had the scar
- 42:06applied to thousand times. While the rest were applied to
- 42:08stunt doubles and stand-ins. Fax number two, all told Harry
- 42:15War 52, different outfits for the movies and many of the
- 42:19street clothes that he wore were from his own wardrobe.
- 42:23Fax number three, Daniel Radcliffe went through, 160
- 42:27pairs of glasses across all eight films, and the majority
- 42:31did not have lenses in them to avoid a reflection on the
- 42:34camera. These seem incredibly trivial.
- 42:38So this is really really hard because I mean it it is a
- 42:42trivia, it is a trivia segment. So I know the story about Daniel
- 42:48Radcliffe constantly breaking his glasses in his wand.
- 42:51I know he went through like 41's, I'll say, the glass is to
- 42:55who freaking knows this is hard because I mean it could just be
- 42:58any of these three things. I'm gonna say I was gonna say
- 43:04ones the falsehood because that seems like a high number.
- 43:07Like 2000. Seems like a lot.
- 43:10But I'm gonna say twos the falsehood just because I don't
- 43:14know about Daniel Radcliffe's own wardrobe.
- 43:17So I'll say to the falsehood Bob you are 100%, correct.
- 43:23Number two, was the falsehood cool.
- 43:26I did it. Yeah, you did.
- 43:28I mention proud of myself? And I will say the, the facts
- 43:32about his scar application. And his how many glasses he went
- 43:36through. Were provided by Warner Bros
- 43:40studio of London. They did like a whole Twitter
- 43:46series talking about. It was like a trivia section
- 43:49where you could vote. For which will answer you
- 43:51thought was right. And so they did they did a whole
- 43:53thing. I'm like just behind the scenes
- 43:55movie trivia, that's cool. We don't have to worry about
- 43:58anything being fake this episode verified by the studio itself.
- 44:02That's right. All right, Brad.
- 44:03So we have not talked to performances.
- 44:05We don't really have time to talk performances especially
- 44:08with a cast of this large, so why don't you just single out?
- 44:12Someone you thought was really good and someone that you
- 44:15thought underwhelmed in this movie.
- 44:18I think that Daniel Radcliffe is a little underwhelming.
- 44:21Yeah, yeah. And this one.
- 44:23Yeah II think we kind of got Peak Daniel Radcliffe in.
- 44:28Was it the third or the fourth one that we liked him in?
- 44:31Yeah, I can't remember. It was like, I was one of those
- 44:33movies that we were like, oh, that's too bad because the movie
- 44:35was not great, but he was really good.
- 44:36It was the fourth. It was the fourth.
- 44:38Well, yeah. Because that's the one where he
- 44:41like yeah. Definitely the fourth one.
- 44:44Yeah, Daniel Radcliffe. Just here's the thing.
- 44:47I'd Can't imagine anyone elses Harry Potter.
- 44:50Sure why? I like, I genuinely like him as
- 44:52Harry Potter, but overall, I think his performances are up
- 44:57and down throughout the series, with a few more downbeats than
- 45:00up. Hmm.
- 45:02All right. Yeah, I'm with you on that.
- 45:04I will hand the award for underwhelming to Daniel
- 45:06Radcliffe, but that's only because I think one of the Fatal
- 45:09flaws with this movie is there is so much plot to get through
- 45:13that. Some characters, barely even
- 45:16show up in the movie. And it got to the point where,
- 45:19you know, Harry goes out into the woods to meet Voldemort and
- 45:23they've got Hagrid tied up, and I was like, oh, sure, it's
- 45:26haggar. Like I forgot I could then we
- 45:29leave things out about Hagrid and the only like, you're only
- 45:32introduction to him. Is that like they cut to a
- 45:34close-up and he's like, hey Ray, what are you doing here?
- 45:38What I call Hagrid. So I just want you to record the
- 45:41entire episode and that as a grass.
- 45:44That's correct. Wait, so it's kind of hard for
- 45:49me to give out an award for someone who really impressed me
- 45:52because it's still just about Harry and Voldemort and a little
- 45:56bit of Hermione and that's about it.
- 45:58So, I'll mean, I'll just say Emma Watson still acts circles
- 46:04around the rest of the child actors.
- 46:07Like, she's the only convincing one.
- 46:08Even at the end of the movie, where they're trying to make
- 46:11them look like they're 37 years old but it ranges from like 20
- 46:14to 50 based on the makeup. Yeah, like she's Pretending to
- 46:18be sad that her fake child is going away on the Hogwarts
- 46:21Express and it she sells it like she's really good.
- 46:24Yeah 100%. So I mean, you know, I'll give
- 46:27her that and I'll give the underwhelming to Daniel
- 46:30Radcliffe. I will say, I think that every
- 46:33scene that they are in throughout all of the movies,
- 46:37the twins who play Fred and George are just spectacular.
- 46:42I absolutely love them. And even even the place where,
- 46:46you know, they are standing On the wall together, waiting for
- 46:50the impending Invasion. Like just that little moment,
- 46:54they have together. You can just feel their
- 46:57sincerity through the screen that they genuinely love one
- 47:00another. And when, when one of the two
- 47:03dies, I don't remember if it's Fred or George, who dies, which
- 47:06feels appropriate because the mom can't even tell them apart
- 47:10when, when they are mourning his loss.
- 47:12That's probably the one part of the movie where I feel the
- 47:15crushing weight of what's happened, the Most so II love.
- 47:20Love the twins. They're, they're probably some
- 47:22of my favorite of all the secondary characters throughout
- 47:25the movies. All right.
- 47:27We're done with performances. Forget the rest of the cast
- 47:29there, all mediocre. So over it.
- 47:33Yeah. What about Ray finds?
- 47:36No, I'm not feeling him in this movie.
- 47:37You know what it is either. It's bringing Voldemort into the
- 47:40daylight Like just that he looks so badass.
- 47:45He does the like the, the weird little laugh at Neville and you
- 47:49know, like that's what he sounds like.
- 47:51What do you laughs? It's just it ruined the
- 47:52character. It's so bad, dude.
- 47:55I will say the moment where he hugs Malfoy, like, when he comes
- 48:00across is like on the edge of being terribly cringe-worthy,
- 48:07but like it just fits the character so well so that's a
- 48:11Moment that I do like the awkwardness of like Tom Felton
- 48:15being like what the hell am I supposed to do?
- 48:17There were laughs in my theater at that moment really?
- 48:21Oh 100%. Yeah and it pulls you out of the
- 48:23movie I mean Bobby have you ever laughed at a movie at a point
- 48:28where nobody else in the theater was laughing?
- 48:30So frequently. Okay guys, I've done that in a
- 48:34few very key points of movies. And my wife is just like,
- 48:40elbowing me, like, shut up. That is kind of the nice thing
- 48:42about watching. Movies at home though, is like,
- 48:44every once in a while. I watch a movie that just is so,
- 48:47Preposterous that out loud. I'll just be like, like you
- 48:50like. Yeah, you can't do that in a
- 48:52real movie theater. Yeah.
- 48:55Oh man. All right, so just quickly, I do
- 48:57want to say that. I think David Yates really turns
- 49:00things around in the second half of this movie.
- 49:02And for me, it started with this Montage of Harry kind of going
- 49:06back out into the battlefield and it's done in slow motion and
- 49:09the sound kind of Fades and There's a troll and you find
- 49:14that lavender Brown is died. And like from that moment on, I
- 49:17think the editing is nearly impeccable.
- 49:20The filmmaking is really, really well done.
- 49:23And the whole sequence, where Harry returns to Dumbledore's
- 49:27office and puts his memory into the whatever that thing is
- 49:30called like that upholds. The the pensive, the pensive is
- 49:35so that whole sequence of finding out Snape's backstory
- 49:41And the way it's edited together and the score, it is probably
- 49:45the best, like, the most cinematic thing to happen in all
- 49:49eight movies, like it's that or something the cuaron did in the
- 49:53third one, and I have to hand it to him like it is just so well
- 49:57done. And I feel like if there's any
- 50:00flaw to it, it's that the emotion of watching Alan Rickman
- 50:04find Lily dead is undercut by the fact that immediately
- 50:09they're like let's get back to the plot.
- 50:11And then you get the voice-over of Dumbledore being like so.
- 50:13Yeah. Anyway Harry has to die and I'm
- 50:15like I want to dwell in this a little bit longer because I feel
- 50:18very moved by it and so I think again sometimes the necessities
- 50:24of the plot like are working against what Yates is trying to
- 50:29do as a filmmaker. So it's not always just that
- 50:32he's doing something poorly or that he wasn't thinking things
- 50:35through. I think sometimes it's just that
- 50:37they feel this need to go as fast as they can through.
- 50:41You know, the mechanisms of the plot to get to the end and
- 50:46nowhere. Was that more apparent for me
- 50:48than when Harry comes back from the dead and reveals himself and
- 50:52Dumbledore and him somehow get close enough to like hug and
- 50:55fall off a bridge and and Harry's triangle, did I say?
- 51:00Dumbledore Voldemort? You know, the same thing
- 51:04basically. And here he's trying to say like
- 51:07hey I don't think you understand that the Elder one And is not
- 51:11allegiance to you, but that whole plot point is so fuzzy at
- 51:15that point. And it's going so quickly that
- 51:17he's just like, hey, what if, what if the wind isn't isn't a
- 51:20legion to you at all, man? Come on, Tom, let's finish this
- 51:22together and they dive off a bridge and I'm like, this is
- 51:25going way too fast. I don't understand what's going
- 51:28on. So, even though the second half
- 51:30of this film worked for me, there always seems to be
- 51:34something working against it being completely successful.
- 51:38I'm with you, dude. And I think by the end of the
- 51:40film, like, You have the Victory and you're like, yay, we won.
- 51:45And then like the final scene with and I'm not talking about
- 51:49the, the the, you know, 20 years later scene, like, the final
- 51:54scene is Ron and Hermione and, and Harry.
- 51:59And they don't even really enjoy the victory.
- 52:02They just kind of talk about plot, some more and look at each
- 52:07other and then Harry snaps the wand and like even in That
- 52:11moment Ron is like, that's a powerful one.
- 52:15We can use it and you're like, that's literally like did you
- 52:20learn anything learned, nothing? Yeah, it's just the dumbest
- 52:24thing. And here's a place where they
- 52:26could have used the source material.
- 52:29I know, you don't know this Bob because you've never read the
- 52:31book, but Harry uses the Elder Wand once and he uses it to fix
- 52:38his old wand, the one that he got.
- 52:41That represented him entering the Magical World come on and
- 52:45that's like the that would have been the perfect thing to do,
- 52:49you know that sucks. I'm glad I'm glad he just threw
- 52:51it off the bridge. No, get out of here, man.
- 52:54The like I said before the whole movies, the whole book series,
- 53:01The whole idea of Harry Potter is about him, finding a place
- 53:04where he belongs. And so at the end of the series,
- 53:08the object that really Marked him as joining the Wizard World
- 53:13was the one because the wand chooses the wizard and a wand
- 53:16wouldn't choose you. If you weren't a wizard, he
- 53:19fixes that and he gets rid of this object of power, which is
- 53:24what Voldemort was chasing, after power.
- 53:26And all these things, it's a perfect way to thematically end
- 53:30the series and they just don't do it.
- 53:34So that is something that I was very disappointed with the
- 53:36ending. All right, so let's hear your
- 53:39final score because I think are going to come out.
- 53:41Lower than me on this. Six and a half.
- 53:44Hmm, I think this is because I want it to be so much better.
- 53:49I think this is the worst of the Harry Potter series.
- 53:52I think that I want to give this an 8 out of 10 because I really
- 53:57enjoyed it. Like the end of the movie.
- 53:58I was like yep. The first half was probably the
- 54:02worst thing in any of the eight movies and the second half
- 54:06worked so well that I was like it's an eight.
- 54:09But I think objectively I'm going to give it a seven and a
- 54:11half like I When I enjoyed it more than it, probably is good.
- 54:16So I'm going to I'm going to talk to a seven and a half on
- 54:18this. That brings our average to a 7
- 54:20out of 10, which would make this, I believe the
- 54:22lowest-ranked of all of the Harry Potter movies except for
- 54:26maybe Chamber of Secrets. And I think we weren't super
- 54:30high on order the Phoenix either.
- 54:31But I think it came out above a 7.
- 54:33Yeah, I think order the Phoenix. We probably around a seven and a
- 54:36half. Yeah.
- 54:39I think that this and Chamber of Secrets are We my lowest two of
- 54:45the of the eight films. Well, Brad, this has been quite
- 54:48the journey. We're done with Harry Potter.
- 54:50We have finished the Original Trilogy of Star Wars.
- 54:53We got to find a new franchise to walk through.
- 54:56I think I might have given us that already.
- 54:58I think we need to do Mission Impossible.
- 55:01Dude, I'm with you, man. All right, but we want to know
- 55:04what you think. Where does Harry Potter eighth
- 55:06rank? Among the eight Potter films for
- 55:09you, you can find us on social media, on Facebook, Twitter, or
- 55:12Instagram. M at film whiskey or jump into
- 55:15the conversation on Discord. We are on there every single day
- 55:18talking to our fans. So come on in, you can find a
- 55:21link to our Discord at the end of every single, one of our show
- 55:24notes. Brad, this is it man.
- 55:26Season 5 has wrapped up, except for probably the most important
- 55:31episodes we do. Each season will be back next
- 55:33week with part 1 and part 2 of our bracket challenge to
- 55:38determine the winner of season 5.
- 55:41But until then I'm Bob book, I'm Reggie and we'll see you next
- 55:46time.