Latest / MetroNews Talkline / Talkline for Wednesday, April 24, 2024
Transcript
- 0:00H good morning, Welcome to talk Line on the Metro News Radio Network.
- 0:31Change. You are surrounded an emergency heat your radio turned off from the studio,
- 0:41so w v RC Media and the Metro News Radio Network, the Voice
- 0:46of West Virginia comes the most powerful radio show in West Virginia. This this
- 0:52is Metro News Talk Live with Hobby Kerchible activated. So it's net where can
- 0:59told from Charles Morning stand by you, Hoppy. You're on Metro News talk
- 1:04Line with Hoppy Kerchival is brought to you by in Covia Insurance, encircling you
- 1:08with coverage to protect what you care about most. Visiting Covia dot com to
- 1:14learn more. We're broadcasting from the Encovi Insurance studios in the Dale Miller Building.
- 1:19Fun number one hundred and seven sixty five eight two five five, Text
- 1:22me three oh four, talk three oh four. There's always a lot going
- 1:26on today. I want to remind you too that you can watch the show
- 1:30on our video stream at wv Metronews dot com. Okay, So, the
- 1:36participation or lock thereof of transgender students in sports in West Virginia is not the
- 1:44biggest issue in West Virginia. There are many other much bigger issues, the
- 1:49economy, roads, jobs, trained workforce, public education, drug issue,
- 1:57on and on. I could go on. However, the whole issue of
- 2:05whether or not a transgender girl can participate in girls sports has become a lightning
- 2:08rod in this gubernatorial campaign in West Virginia for a couple of reasons. One
- 2:15is that a couple of the candidates have made it so with their advertisements,
- 2:20and also because of the federal appeals Court decision last week which said that a
- 2:28transgender girl who participates in the track team at Bridgeport Middle School that the state
- 2:34law that would prohibit that cannot stop her from participating, That she can participate
- 2:40on the girl's track team, and that the state law aimed at preventing that
- 2:46could not in fact stop her from participating. It would be a violation of
- 2:50Title nine and her rights. So that's where we are, and frankly,
- 2:54it has contributed to a ton of confusion in West Virginia as to what coaches
- 2:59administrators are supposed to do when and if these instances come up again. There
- 3:06are new developments in destroy Today we're joined by Brad macliny Metro in New State
- 3:08White Cars sponded on Skype Brad, what is that new development today? A
- 3:13h right, Well, A couple of things. The main one that I'm
- 3:15looking at, the one that has the most sort of direct impact about Westford's
- 3:22direction, is the Attorney General, Patrick Morrissey, whose office has been defending
- 3:27the state law in federal court, plans a one fifteen PM announcement about I
- 3:34anticipated to be the route the state is taking for an appeal. There is
- 3:38no guaranteed appeal at this point, but there are a couple of things the
- 3:43state could do. One is to ask for This case was decided with the
- 3:49Fourth Circuit US Court of Appeals among a three judge panel, two of whom
- 3:54voted in favor of the plaintiff Becky Paper Jackson, and one of sided with
- 4:00essentially sided with the state's position, so it was a split split decision.
- 4:06The state could ask to go en banc, which is a phrase that in
- 4:12legal terms means ask the entire appeals court fifteen or so judges to hear this
- 4:17case, potentially having a different outcome. The other possibility is to ask for
- 4:24cert from the US Supreme Court. You know in that case, I think
- 4:30that this is such a bubbling matter across the nation the participation or lack of
- 4:36participation among transgender athletes. The US Supreme Court is bound to take up one
- 4:42of these cases, but will it be West Virginia. That's not as clear
- 4:45to me. I think one big question, and it's legal is this case
- 4:50was decided on pretty narrow grounds. It was decided on the specific situation,
- 4:58the specific can additions of this athlete and does not invalidate necessarily West Virginia's law.
- 5:06So is that the kind of thing that the US Supreme Court would take
- 5:10up. It's a big question in my mind. It is, indeed,
- 5:12Brad. And also at the press conference today, the Attorney General is going
- 5:15to be joined by a special guest who is familiar nationally with his transgender or
- 5:19sports participation issue. Yeah, you know, and that shows where the policy
- 5:25of the state crosses over into politics as well. The special guest that you
- 5:29mentioned is Riley Gaines, former collegiate swimmer, who is very involved across the
- 5:33nation in the politics of transgender athletes competing on girls sports teams. There's another
- 5:42event today, a noon more purely political event with both Attorney General Morrissey and
- 5:48Riley Gaines that is offsite from the Capitol but that shows you that Riley Gaines,
- 5:56again former collegiate swimmer involved in conservaive of causes, is very involved in
- 6:02this strand of politics in West Virginia. Expand on how this issue of transmitting
- 6:10transgender sports participation has become a I almost hesitate to say issue. I guess
- 6:15it's an issue, but a lightning rod in this campaign for the Republican nomination
- 6:19for governor. Mm hmm, I mean I would I would bet you something
- 6:26that there may be a political advertisement as soon as you and I are done
- 6:30dealing with transgender issues in this governor's race. On our very air. It
- 6:36is it is entirely possible. So that there is a contention mostly being waged
- 6:45by Chris Miller, the businessman who is running for governor against Patrick Morrissey and
- 6:50others. Uh. It is a contention that in Morrissey's lobbying days he worked
- 6:57for a firm that it sounds like separately from him. I need an entire
- 7:01whiteboard for this claim, but that that firm did other work in the realm
- 7:09of transgender therapy, and those advertisements have been hot and heavy. Another competitor
- 7:17for that governor's race, Mac Warner, came out with a press release saying
- 7:21that Morrissey should refuse himself from this federal case because of that same claim,
- 7:29and each of them trying to influence public opinion contend that Morrissey, of all
- 7:35people, has been soft on transgender stuff. Morrissey, of course, has
- 7:42been battling back. I don't know if you've heard happy. He is a
- 7:45fighter and a couple of things. These events today, I think are intended
- 7:51not only to state the straightforward path that West Virginia is going to take on
- 7:57appeal, but to shore up UH Morrissey's bona fides on on the transgender issue,
- 8:03UH, to support his campaign. And I did a fairly straightforward story
- 8:09last night, UH, saying point pointing at what the announcement is going to
- 8:13be today, And you know, got a communication from Morrissey's campaign. I
- 8:20had quoted Miller and mac Warner and they said, hey, can you put
- 8:22the campaign in also. Uh. Morrisey's campaign called the claims of Warner and
- 8:28Miller lies UH and said the fact is the swamp is spending millions lying to
- 8:33us about Patrick Morrissey. Brad. Finally, you asked Governor Jim Justice about
- 8:37this yesterday because his briefing and Justice is uniquely qualified. He's the governor of
- 8:41the state, he's running for the US Senate. This issue is really unresolved
- 8:45in West Virginia, and he happens to be a coach of young ladies at
- 8:48Greenbrier East h Yes, and that was the point of my question. You
- 8:54know, I think whether you agree with this policy or not, local sports
- 8:58teams, at athletic directors, coaches are potentially going to be in a buying
- 9:03This appeals court ruling did not knock down West Virginia law. It is still
- 9:07in effect. However, it made it clear that if there were a transgender
- 9:11athlete in a similar situation to Becky Pepper Jackson having put off puberty, going
- 9:18on puberty blockers, maybe taking estrogen, that athlete in a court battle could
- 9:24cite the same grounds. And you know, the Fourth Circuit has ruled,
- 9:28they've said what they've said, So coaches potentially could be in a difficult position.
- 9:35So that's what I ask Governor Justice about. But he answered on very
- 9:39broad terms, merely saying that he respects the law, but he believes that
- 9:43girls should be playing girl sports, you know, Brad, But given the
- 9:48federal Appeals Court decision on Becky pepper Jackson. Given the West Virginia state law,
- 9:54given the emotional aspect of this, and all points of this debate,
- 10:01what are coaches and athletic directors. I mean, they're in limbo. They
- 10:05could follow the West Virginia law and they could block a transgender student from participating
- 10:09a girl's sport. They might get sued and this case might be cited.
- 10:15They could allow the transgender girl to play on the girls team and maybe get
- 10:18grief from other girls. We know about the protest last week or recently of
- 10:22five girls who were on the Lincoln Middle School track team, or hear from
- 10:28upset parents. I don't know if they know what to do. And you
- 10:31reached out to the SSAC, so nobody really knows, right, Yeah,
- 10:37I can only imagine that it's going to take yet another test case. The
- 10:41Fourth Circuit has ruled, but they did rule narrowly. They said, the
- 10:46question before us is whether the Act West Virginia's law may lawfully be applied to
- 10:50prevent a thirteen year old transgender girl who takes puberty blocking medication and as publicly
- 10:54identified as a girl since the third grade, from participating in her school's cross
- 10:58country in track teams. So my point is a lot of qualifiers there.
- 11:03Every human is different. There could be another kid who is under similar conditions,
- 11:11but nobody's situation is the same, and I think it makes it tough
- 11:13if the situation comes up with your basketball team or your volleyball team, what
- 11:20at this point should be the legal guidance for you if it comes up again.
- 11:24These situations are very rare, but they do occur, so right now
- 11:31there's really not much guidance on that. More on this later in the show.
- 11:35Actually, as I'm gonna speak with a specialist, specialized attorney on this.
- 11:39Right back when you Metro News DA why car sponderbad, You'll be covering
- 11:41the Attorney General's briefing later today. We look forward to reporting. Thank you
- 11:46very much. Hey, thanks all right, talk line continues. We'll be
- 11:48right back. Stay with Winning the lottery means time to work on my skylining
- 11:52skills. I'm a thrill seekind love the rush, arm stretch, wide free
- 11:58falling on the cheeks. I want to join the skydiving acrobat too. Man,
- 12:05your turn is up. You have to exit the car wash driver.
- 12:07Oh sorry, just skuydipe training I'll see you tomorrow. It's a car wash.
- 12:13I better check my tickets. This could be my chance West Virginia Lottery.
- 12:16What if it could happen to you? Please play responsibly. Larry Pack
- 12:20is a proven conservative Republican running for State Treasurer who fights for our families.
- 12:26Larry Pack is one hundred percent pro life and supports the Second Amendment. Larry
- 12:30Pack has real West Virginia values. Larry Pack is a proven job creator and
- 12:35knows what it takes to grow our economy. Larry Pack helped Governor Justice deliver
- 12:39the largest tax cut in state history. Our families now keep more of their
- 12:43hard earned money. Let's all vote for Republican Larry Pack for State Treasurer.
- 12:48Paid for by Larry Pack for West Virginia Larry Pack Treasurer. The Wound Institute
- 12:52the only wound center in the area with providers who are Board certified in wound
- 12:58and owstomy care. Doctor Carry Frame and her dedicated team of skilled professionals are
- 13:01ready to provide you with the latest treatments and personalized care. Visit their new
- 13:07office location on Kenton Drive in Charleston for cutting edge woundcare. Find more information
- 13:11and start your recovery today at the Woundinstitute dot org. The Wound Institute healing
- 13:16complex wounds using advanced treatments takes at the trough. They can't stop eating.
- 13:26Kind Of like Patrick Morrissey when it comes to making money from the woke sex
- 13:30change industry. Morrissey lobbied to spend Medicare dollars on a New York hospital that
- 13:35performs gender reassignment surgery, and his wife's firm lobbied for Planned Parenthood. They're
- 13:41not just an abortion provider. They're also a group that gives puberty blockers to
- 13:46kids, and they have a clinic right here in West Virginia. Her firm's
- 13:52lobbyists have given thousands of dollars to Morrissey's campaigns. So let's review, shall
- 13:56we kids transitioned morris See guzzled millions in trans cash. Patrick Morrissey says he's
- 14:03a true conservative. He's just a liberal lobbyist that's pigging out on the woke
- 14:09sex change industry. Morrissey is wrong for West Virginia. Paid for by West
- 14:13Virginia Forward, not authorized by any candidate or candidate's committee. This is talk
- 14:20line on Metro News. The Voice of West Virginia. Metro News this morning
- 14:26The biggest stories from around the state of West Virginia when you want them,
- 14:31Brought to you by Burdett Camping Center, home of the RV warranty Forever.
- 14:35Chris Lawrence at the anchor desk, we are ready to get to the day.
- 14:37Who started in West Virginia with all of the information you made. Harry
- 14:41hooda sec brings the day's headlines. Employees at two long standing restaurants at the
- 14:45Charlestontown Center Mall are without a job this morning. The Chop House and Tidewater
- 14:50Grill abruptly closed Saturday, but no reason was given and no notice was given
- 14:52to employees. Venture's Restaurant Group, who owns both the Chophouse and Tidewater,
- 14:56says it has offered jobs to management and employer have properties outside Charleston. Kyle
- 15:01Wiggs at the sports desk par France for players from the University of Illinois committed
- 15:05to join the Mountaineer. Six free guards since here Harris six eight Forward,
- 15:09Amani Handsbury each said Sunday they were headed tow WVU and Hoppy Kirchible's daily commentary.
- 15:16Metro News this morning brought to you by Burdette Camping Center Listen where you
- 15:20get your favorite podcasts and online at WV metro news dot com. It's two
- 15:24hours of sports conversation to wrap up your weekend. It's the city Net Sunday
- 15:30Night Sports Line. Hey, this is Travis Jones, joined myself and Greg
- 15:33Hunter every Sunday night from six oh six until eight o'clock as we wrap up
- 15:35the sports weekend. We talk Mountaineers, high school, Mountain East Conference,
- 15:39and the latest in the national scene. The Sunday Sports Line is listener interactive.
- 15:43You could call or text the show at three oh four Talk three oh
- 15:48four. It's a perfect weekend sports wrap up on your favorite Metro news aphilia
- 15:52or watch the show at WV metronews dot com. Hey there, Dave Weekly.
- 15:56Here at your host from Metro News Hotline. Get ready for an epic
- 15:58journey. Every weekday from three to six pm, We've got all the excitement
- 16:03you need from sports to tech, music, pop culture, and everything in
- 16:06between. Join Coop and I as we bring you engaging discussions, captivating interviews,
- 16:10fun games, and the latest sports and entertainment headlines that will keep your
- 16:14hood. Metro News Hotline is your go to source for sports, news,
- 16:17entertainment, and most importantly fun. Tune in weekdays from three to six on
- 16:21Metronews and wv metronews dot com. Metro News Talkline with Hoppykerchible is brought to
- 16:40you by Incovia Insurance, encircling you with coverage to protect what do you care
- 16:44about most? Visit in covid dot com to learn more. Being up to
- 16:48date on your COVID nineteen shots is the best protection against severe COVID for everyone
- 16:52six months and older. Staying up to date on your COVID nineteen shots means
- 16:55you're far less likely to get really six, stay in the hospital, or
- 16:57die from COVID, even if you do test positive. At this time,
- 17:02most folks are due for a COVID nineteen shot. From more information, visit
- 17:04vaccinate WV dot gov. That's vaccinate WV dot gov. Florida in all likelihood
- 17:11will go Trump. So what was President Biden doing there? Jared Halpern,
- 17:14Fox News Radio. What was the story here? Well, you know,
- 17:18the abortion issue is a big issue right around the country. It has emerged
- 17:22as a big issue, by the way, in Florida. I think you're
- 17:25right that there's certainly a strong advantage for former President Trump in Florida. That
- 17:29being said, Democrats the reelection campaign see some opportunities there because of that six
- 17:36week abortion band that is taking effect in that state. The other thing that's
- 17:40happening in that state in November is a constitutional referendum issue on the ballot basically
- 17:48to protect abortion access in the state. You are seeing those types of ballid
- 17:52issues now pop up in several key states, and it is an issue in
- 17:57which Democrats believe that it could really energize voters who may otherwise not be really
- 18:03energized about this election and really help out, you know, top of the
- 18:08ticket kind of races, very similar perhaps to what we saw happen in the
- 18:14early two thousands when a lot of these same sex marriage amendments were showing up
- 18:18on ballots in states across the country. Right, it seemed to galvanize social
- 18:25conservatives, some evangelical voters in a way that maybe would not have been energized
- 18:30as say, otherwise would have been in those types of races. So it
- 18:34was an opportunity for President Biden yesterday in Florida to highlight, you know,
- 18:41this issue and really put its front end center. I think it's going to
- 18:42be an issue that you see certainly this administration or just the campaign run on,
- 18:49but also one in which maybe President Biden takes a little bit more of
- 18:53a more prominent role. You know, this has been an issue in which
- 18:56Vice President Kamala Harris has largely led the charge on abortion for the administration.
- 19:03President Biden has been maybe not the best messenger on the issue, right,
- 19:11He's his own kind of struggle with that issue has been pretty well documented,
- 19:14right, given his base, but given his kind of politics on the issue
- 19:18and kind of delineating those two. But yesterday he spoke about it in a
- 19:22way that was very similar to how we hear Kamala Harris talk about it.
- 19:26And so I do think that it's an issue that a lot of democratsy is
- 19:30perhaps one of those issues that can galvanize and energize voters. And Jared I
- 19:37can't help but to notice the contrast, and I wonder how many other Americans
- 19:41do. And I'm not talking about the base. I'm not talking about the
- 19:42base of the left, of the base of the right, but of folks
- 19:45who follow the news every day. And on one hand, you have Biden
- 19:49on the campaign trail, essentially controlling the narrative. On the other hand,
- 19:55you have Donald Trump going to a shabby courthouse in New York and trying to
- 20:00defend himself, and the charges of the charge itself has almost become secondary to
- 20:07some of the sordid stuff that comes out in the trial, and the contrast
- 20:11is significant in terms of campaign optics in my opinion. Yeah, no,
- 20:15you're absolutely right. I mean, and keep in mind that the only real
- 20:18images we get of Trump is walking in and out of the courtroom. Cameras
- 20:22are not in there, so we're not getting you know, kind of that
- 20:26OJ trial kind of which I think it would be, right, I mean,
- 20:29this would be like wall the Wall. Yeah, you know, second
- 20:33to second if there were cameras in the court. It's not unusual for cameras
- 20:37not to be allowed in New York courtrooms. I think there were some lessons
- 20:41learned maybe from the OJ coverage kind of allowing cameras in the courtrooms. At
- 20:45any rate, you're right, and it's one in which by and large President
- 20:49Trump's schedule is dictated by that trial. Right, he is there in court
- 20:53every day. Now Wednesdays are off days for the trial, so you know,
- 20:59maybe you see him out doing some other things today. But that's another
- 21:03really big question mark right now, as we get kind of closer to summer,
- 21:07you know, kind of that time where I think more people are maybe
- 21:10paying a little bit more attention. Certainly that's going to pick up, I
- 21:12think after kids are out of school and you know, after labor days,
- 21:15kind of like when people really start you know, honing in. If these
- 21:19trials are still going on, and you've got Biden who's able to you know,
- 21:22just go across the country and talk about what he wants to talk about
- 21:26and largely talk about Donald Trump, and Trump's kind of you know in trial
- 21:32mode that you hear Trump usually talk about kind of how unfair this trial is
- 21:37and this trial and the other trials and charges that is taking time from him
- 21:42to kind of message on any other issues. And so you're right, it's
- 21:47going to be fascinating to see how that plays out. Especially you know,
- 21:51let's say this trial stays on schedule, it's over in five or six weeks.
- 21:55We don't think it's going to be the only trial. Now there's a
- 21:57big Supreme Court case tomorrow out immunity, and that will have big implications for
- 22:03the trial here in Washington moving forward, which has been on hold, and
- 22:07again that's federal court no cameras, so you're going to get images of the
- 22:11president coming in coming out, but not a whole lot else. Charret hauprin
- 22:15Fox News Radio in Washington, Jared, always a pleasure. Appreciate you,
- 22:18sir, Sure, thanks all right, man. Text three h four talk
- 22:21three oh four. Texter says, distractions and my child is trans. Sick
- 22:26of him being a whipping point. He's my son, my flesh and blood,
- 22:30as is every trans person. It's time. A lot of you will
- 22:33find out in time, a lot of you will find out you were wrong.
- 22:37Textapy, I don't care what the court says or you say about this
- 22:41gender dysphoria. This young man at Bridgeport is a male. He is not
- 22:45a she. He has male sex organs and male internal organs. No amount
- 22:49of hormone blockers is political maneuvering or political maneuvering can change that. He's a
- 22:56biological male, says the texture Hobby. I would like to see a chart
- 23:02of the number of people identifying as trands over time. It sure seems to
- 23:04have really picked up over the past few years, Habbi, you're the man,
- 23:14the Walter Cronkite of my generation. Kind of you to say. Meantime,
- 23:18Meanwhile, anyone under fifty said, who's Walter Cronkite? Haby, This
- 23:25is getting out of hand, and I'm seriously considering changing who I planned on
- 23:29voting for in this governor's primary. Habi. As an athletic director, I
- 23:34would follow the West Virginia state law, and that participation is based on a
- 23:40sex at birth. It would be up to the individual athlete and the parents
- 23:44if they wanted to litigate that decision, says the Athletic Director. AD says
- 23:48that they would follow the West Virginia law. All right, we'll take a
- 23:52break of me back. This is talk Line on Metro News, the Voice
- 23:55of West Virginia. It's ten thirty. Let's get a news update, checking
- 24:00with the Metro News Radio network. Final what's happening statewide this hour, all
- 24:03across the great state of West Virginia. West Virginia Metro News. I'm Kerrie
- 24:10Houda Sek. We'll get an update later today about a recent federal appeals court
- 24:14ruling that says a new state law violates the rights of Harrison County transgender student
- 24:17Becky Pepper Jackson, who identifies as a girl and wanted to run on her
- 24:21school's girls track team. Governor Jim Justice says this is going way too far.
- 24:25Before you know it, you're going to have Lebron James or somebody you
- 24:30know with a talent beyond belief say I want to be a girl and I'm
- 24:36gonna play as a girl. And we say, well, okay, that's
- 24:38fine. It's not okay to me. State Attorney General Patrick Morrisey has an
- 24:42announcement set for one point fifteen this afternoon at the state Capitol. US Senator
- 24:47Shelly Moore Capito joining other senators sending a letter to Biden administration officials urging them
- 24:52to restore order to campuses that have been effectively shut down by antisemitic mobs that
- 24:56are targeting Jewish students. Steel Workers Will twenty nine to eleven. President Mark
- 25:00glypt says it's possible the idle Cleveland Cliffs, ten Mill and Weirton may become
- 25:06a plant to produce steel to make transformers used in the electric grid. Clipt
- 25:10To says the company is considering the moves. We have a grow opportunity to
- 25:15provide for the for the employees, be good for the community, be good
- 25:18for Cleveland, the states. So if it happens, it'll be good for
- 25:25many people. More than nine hundred workers lost their jobs last week when Cleveland
- 25:27Cliffs idled the mill because of the effects of international steel dumping. You're listening
- 25:33to Metro News, the voice of West Virginia. Well West Virginia Scholar Program
- 25:38changes the lives of families forever. High school juniors can now apply for full
- 25:44scholarship at West Virginia Wesleyan College, one of our state's finest institutions of higher
- 25:48learning. If your child is a high school junior, now is the time
- 25:52to go to WV metro news dot com. Have them apply today and they
- 25:56could win a full scholarship to West Virginia Wesleyan that includes room, board,
- 26:00tuition, and thieves. To apply, simply log on to WDV metrodews dot
- 26:04com and click on the West Virginia scholarlink. You have until midnight April twenty
- 26:10eighth to apply. A twenty twenty four West Virginia Scholar Program is sponsored by
- 26:15Greer Industries, West Virginia Hospital Association ZML, Architects and Engineers, a West
- 26:21Virginia Farm Bureau and Friends of Coal. If you're a high school junior in
- 26:23West Virginia, here's your chance to possibly change your life forever. Go to
- 26:29wv Metro News dot com, click on the West Virginia scholarlink and apply today.
- 26:36Rolly County father Ricky Lafferty says he never gave up hope that his missing
- 26:38daughter would be found. Investigators located the remains of ten year old Alex Carter
- 26:44and her mother, Susan Carter Monday at a home in Beckley after they went
- 26:47missing in August of two thousand. You're happy they found her if you're sad
- 26:52of the circumstances of her not being alive. The suspect, Larry Webb,
- 26:57died in custody Monday, just out before the bodies were located. From the
- 27:02Metro News anchor desk, I'm Carrie Huda sec talk line from me and COVID
- 27:19Church Studios. This is an incredible story. Twenty four years ago in Raleigh
- 27:26County, Susan Carter and her ten year old daughter, Alex Carter disappeared,
- 27:30disappeared, and all along the way Susan Carter's this man, Larry Webb,
- 27:38who was apparently in a relationship with Susan Carter, was a person of interest,
- 27:42but he was never charged until recently, and the bodies were never found
- 27:48if in fact they were murdered. But there have been these incredible developments just
- 27:52in the last couple of days in this case. Joining us on Metro News
- 27:56talk line is Raley County Prosecuting Attorney Ben Hatfield. Been good morning for joining
- 28:00us. How are you good morning? Thanks thanks for having me. I'm
- 28:04good this morning now. It's good to have you on. So how did
- 28:07what was the big break in this case that led authorities to the bodies of
- 28:12Susan Carter and little Alex Carter And just that what was the break? So,
- 28:19you know, I'd be remiss if I didn't say it was a series
- 28:22of breaks. Really, probably around twenty twenty one, this case kind of
- 28:29picked up and got a little more attention. It was staffed with the FBI,
- 28:33specifically Special Agent Jennifer King, and with Corporal Ryan Stowers of the Bureau
- 28:41of Criminal Investigations at the West Tunes State Police. So they start working on
- 28:45the case in twenty twenty one. In working on it, they Ryan Stower's
- 28:51consults with me on various search ones that he wants to obtained in things of
- 28:55that nature. When they obtained a search ont to go into that's home,
- 29:00they ultimately find, among many things, Alex Carter of the little girl's blood
- 29:10inside the home. That leads to a little more testing, and that leads
- 29:17me to believe that I have an insurmountable amount of circumstantial evidence with which I
- 29:22can indict Larry Webb with the first ary murder of Alex Carter. Now,
- 29:29at this point the remains had not been found. But in October of twenty
- 29:33twenty three, specifically on October the twenty third of twenty twenty three, I
- 29:37indeed Larry Webb for first yeary murder once i'd tam the indictment. You know,
- 29:42mister Webb at this point is eighty two years old. He's an advanced
- 29:48age and has some declining health both physical and mental health issues. My investigator
- 29:56Jeff Chum and I go to visit him in the nursing home earlier this month,
- 30:00and Larry Webb in the nursing home gives a full confession to my investigator
- 30:07Jeff Schuemate with me present, And it was that confession that led to subsequent
- 30:12search warrants to search the back of his property. It was searched for three
- 30:21days with excavators. I was searched two weeks ago for two days, and
- 30:25then two days ago for one day. And two days ago was where the
- 30:30remains of Susan and Alex Carter were found. Well Ben, So it was
- 30:36literally a deathbed confession by Larry Webb. And give us some context about that
- 30:42is something he wanted to get off his chest. Give us more about that.
- 30:48I don't know. Here's the thing is a bit weird. I don't
- 30:52know that it was a death fix. I don't know that he thought he
- 30:53was going to die. I know that. I mean he knew what stage
- 30:56of life he was in. He was in a nursing home and hold the
- 31:00absent having someone in his home to care for him. He would probably never
- 31:03return home, So he knew what stage of life he was in. But
- 31:07he certainly didn't have a chronic health condition that would indicate that he was about
- 31:11to die. So it was a lengthy conversation over over a two hour period,
- 31:21and he did indicate that he wanted to get this office chest and that
- 31:26he had been carrying it too long. So he confessed to both murders.
- 31:30He confessed in very good detail about how those murders were committed and for what
- 31:36reasons they were committed. What were the reasons. It was initially a domestic
- 31:41violent flash financial argument between Larry Webb and Susan Carter. That was the initial
- 31:49reason for the acute incident that happened back in two thousand. He did indicate
- 31:56that he killed Susan Carter first and that he then knew he had to kill
- 32:00Alex because she was there and she was going to be a witness, although
- 32:06she was sleeping at the top. So he shoots and kills a ten year
- 32:09old child after he shoots and kills the child's mother, That is correct.
- 32:15Why look, I don't want to be a armchair law enforcement officer here,
- 32:23Ben, but this was twenty four years ago. You weren't around, and
- 32:27the officers were around. I get it, But that seems like a case
- 32:30where it could be fairly easily linked to him at the time. I mean,
- 32:36the end of this, I'll be honest, You're probably right in a
- 32:39percentage, although everything's a bit more complicated. I'm not okay, it shouldn't
- 32:45have been done differently. It was initially reported as a potential abduction, that
- 32:51Susan had a potentially committed what we call a parental abduction of her child.
- 32:57I believe mister Lafferty and her we're going through a child custody battle in family
- 33:02court, and the initial indicator from law enforcement, and keep in mind,
- 33:08I'm finding this out years and yearsly, but the initial indicator is that potentially
- 33:14she had had abducted Alex in an attempt to keep sole custody of her and
- 33:22win that custody battle. Yeah, away from Alex's father. Mister Lafferty,
- 33:25Well, that was his initial thought because they went missing. But you know,
- 33:32the longer they went with no contact, Ricky certainly got suspicious prior to
- 33:38anyone else. Yes, that's correct, So he got suspicious before anyone else.
- 33:44But due to the initial nature of having opinion family court, having a
- 33:50custody case open, I believe that's why it was met with some rebuff early.
- 33:54That is me armchair corter backing as well some you know, on twenty
- 34:00two, twenty one years later as well. But whatever whatever happened that led
- 34:07to the lapse in time that I can't really speak to, it's something that
- 34:14initially because she was declared missing. Initially it was part of the US Marshall
- 34:22initiative to find missing children. And when the US Marshals investigated it, they
- 34:29and this is around twenty twenty twenty, nineteen twenty twenty, when they investigated
- 34:34it, they quickly began to suspect that Susan and Alex Carter had been murdered.
- 34:43So they referred it based the Marshalls are an investigative agency typically looking for
- 34:47people. Based on the fact that they thought it was an active crime,
- 34:52they referred it to the Federal Bureau of Investigation. Now Ben hadfields with is
- 34:54Rollay County Prosecuting Attorney and props of those law enforcement officers who got involved and
- 35:00stuck with it. And there is this this tragic, this not tragic.
- 35:05There is this this odd circumstance, odd circumstance concerning the death of Larry Webb
- 35:12who killed Susan Carter and Susan Carter's daughter, Alex Carter. There's an odd
- 35:16circumstance to when the bodies were found and when Webb died. What was it?
- 35:21Yeah, And so it's you know, it's a bit of a script
- 35:23that writes itself Larry Webb was in mount Olive because he had been indicted on
- 35:30first cy murder. He was in mount Olive because mount Olive has a nursing
- 35:32home wing, not all of it is typically where people are sent for life
- 35:37sentences as a nursing home wing, and so that's where Larry was. Larry
- 35:42began to experience severe health problems two days ago and he was transported to Montgomery
- 35:49General Hospital where at ten thirty that morning he was pronounced dead. And then
- 35:55between the hours of four thirty pm and five pm same days when the crew
- 36:05of the stead Of Bureau of Investigations to Weshington State Police in my office found
- 36:09the remains of Susan and Alex Carter on Larry Webb's property. HM, that's
- 36:16that's that's odd. That's a weird coincidence. Did did Did you all know
- 36:22where to where to dig? No? And so that's why it had taken
- 36:27you know, it was we were working with excavators and a landscaping company,
- 36:30New Horizons Landscaping. They were searching the property, which is a backyard of
- 36:37approximately a half acre, but there is there's acreage into the woods behind it.
- 36:42We were searching that property in a grid with excavators and so we found
- 36:47it on the third day. We found them. On the third day we
- 36:51found the grave. Larry Webb was able to tell us they were out back.
- 36:57He was unable to PenPoint specifically where they were, which is why it
- 37:00took so long, even with equipment to find to find the grave was at
- 37:07Webb until he went to the nursing home and then to Mount Olive had had.
- 37:09Webb continued to live at the house. Yeah, So Webb lived at
- 37:15the house until the fall of twenty twenty three. He had a care in
- 37:21home caretaker. That caretaker was elderly himself. He passed away, and so
- 37:28when when Larry Webb's caretaker passed away, he had to go into a long
- 37:32term care facility. So Webb lived in the house for twenty years, twenty
- 37:38plus years, while the woman he killed and her ten year old daughter were
- 37:44buried feet away, yards away. That is that is correct. Been anything
- 37:52else, that's a heck of a story. Anything else you want to add
- 37:55an anybody you want to note about this, because I do, I will
- 38:00tell you you know, this is an investigation that took two and a half
- 38:05decades and for whatever reasons it took that long. Initially, I will tell
- 38:09you about the part of the investigation that to me was impressive. Between twenty
- 38:14twenty one and now, working on a two decades old case, it took
- 38:19a really large collaborative effort between the FBI specifically Special Agent Jennifer King, the
- 38:27Western State Police specifically Corporal Ryan Stowers, my office, the US Marshall's,
- 38:31the Beckley City Police Department gave a as well as two very special cadaver dog
- 38:38canines. It was a canine Theo and a canine Charlie that worked with us
- 38:45on the site specifically two days ago that we're able to help us locate those
- 38:52grades. And if you know how cadaver dogs works, a quarter century is
- 38:58a long time. They can give quite the radius. Uh So those dogs
- 39:04were very impressive, and so it was. It was a very large interagency
- 39:08effort that we're able to get this done and give Ricky Lafferty some closure as
- 39:14to what happened to his little girl. Yeah, it's been great work by
- 39:19everybody, and just there must be an over I mean, it's terribly sad,
- 39:22it's tragic, it's awful, it's horrible, but there's also this,
- 39:25I think this feeling of some peace, finally, some resolution in case.
- 39:30I've described it as as a as conflicted as I've ever been. You're happy
- 39:35that you found them and that you can give the family closure. But just
- 39:39as Ricky said, you're you're sad that it happened, and finding them means
- 39:45on what you feared the entire time. It was just a it was a
- 39:50it was a contradiction of emotions. Two days ago, Ben Attfield, Proscutting
- 39:53attorney in Rawley County. More on that at our website at WV metro News
- 39:58dot com. Ben, thanks for coming on pre shite. Good work by
- 40:00y'all. Thank you, I appreciate you. All right, take care,
- 40:02We'll be right back. Stay with us. We can all agree that hearing
- 40:06aids are expensive. No more. Fruit Pharmacy now offers hearing aids at affordable
- 40:10pricing. You can find the perfect over the counter Nuva met hearing aid and
- 40:15you'll have money left over to go to a concert and put that new aid
- 40:17to the test. Choose from the digi ear Plus Max Pro or Light.
- 40:22Not only are you saving hundreds of dollars, but you also get a one
- 40:24year warranty and Nuvahmed has a forty five day money back guarantee. Visit your
- 40:29local fruth today for your next hearing. Aid your hometown Family Pharmacy for over
- 40:34seventy years, jackpots in the millions here in West Virginia. Who doesn't want
- 40:37to be a millionaire? Get in the Powerball drawings Mondays, Wednesdays and Saturdays,
- 40:42the Mega Millions drawings on Tuesdays and Fridays. Will you be the next
- 40:45big winner? Play today? The Powerball jackpot is one hundred and twenty nine
- 40:49million dollars. The Mega Means jackpot two hundred and twenty eight megion dollars.
- 40:52If West Virginia matters to you, then downloading the all new met for News
- 40:57TV app on all your content devices. Well, it's a and it's free.
- 41:00You'll gain access to both live and archived content including talk Line, Sports
- 41:05Line, three, Guys Before the Game, and much more. It's Metro
- 41:07News for your ears and your eyes. Log one to wv metronews dot com
- 41:13or download the free app on Roku, Amazon devices, Apple TV iOS and
- 41:17Android. Metro News TV Now you can watch the Voice of West Virginia.
- 41:23You're listening to talk Line on Metro News The Voice of West Virginia. West
- 41:30Virginia Outdoors is the Mountain states only hook and bullet radio show dedicated to the
- 41:36more than quarter million hunters and anglers across the state. Award winning host Chris
- 41:39Lawrence has been tracking down hunting and fishing stories for more than twenty five years.
- 41:45I shot him. He ran over to the edge of the field.
- 41:47He made it about five ten yards out of the edge of the field and
- 41:51fail over there. Whether it's hunting and fishing news or just compelling stories about
- 41:55the enjoyment of the great outdoors. He stuck his head through the blind into
- 42:00where you were. Yeah, yeah, well he had jump, he leaked,
- 42:04okay, the blonde oh gosh, you know, yeah, he had.
- 42:07His whole body was in the air for a couple of seconds and is
- 42:12the only thing that landed in the blonde was you know? Of course at
- 42:15Bartley, West Virginia Outdoors covers it all Saturday mornings at seven oh six am
- 42:20and for your daily fix, Outdoors Today brings you two and a half minutes
- 42:23of news and notes from the woods and water every weekday morning on Metro News
- 42:29of Voice of West Virginia. Hey, everybody, It's Tony Courritty, I'm
- 42:31Greg Hunter, and I'm Brad Howse, and we invite you to join us
- 42:36Sunday through Fridays right here on the Metro News radio network. It's the city
- 42:39Net statewide sports line. We talk West Virginia University, football, basketball,
- 42:45baseball, you name it. If it's got anything to do with the Golden
- 42:47Blue, we're on it. And don't forget the text line available every night.
- 42:51So we invite you to join us. The Senator Coach Hunter and me
- 42:54Tony Coritti. It's the city Net state wide sports line on Metro News.
- 43:00News in the Mountain State happens quick and for decades you have depended on Metro
- 43:04News for accurate news delivered fast. Now here's your chance to help keep your
- 43:08fellow West Virginians informed. If you see news happening, become a Metro News
- 43:13hawk by texting News to three five sixty five to one. If you take
- 43:16a picture or video of what you see, submit that as well. Text
- 43:21the word news to three five sixty five one to submit your tip or story.
- 43:24Standard texting rates apply. Please don't text and drive. Metro News Talk
- 43:44Line with Hoppy Kerchible is brought to you by Encovia Insurance, encircling you with
- 43:49coverage to protect what you care about most. Visit in Covia dot com to
- 43:52learn more. Talk line from the Cova Insurance studios. Let me do some
- 43:55texts three oh four talk three oh four hoppy. The tran issue is just
- 44:00the latest car driving by that Republicans are barking at, says the Texture.
- 44:08That's nice, that's nice. What's a compliment? But I appreciate that,
- 44:12But I don't want to be overly self indulgent here this morning. We are
- 44:17prosecuting parents for school shootings. We need to prosecute parents now for brainwashing their
- 44:24kids into transgenderism. This is nothing but one hundred percent child abuse. Are
- 44:30you going to let an eight year old give you heart surgery? Says the
- 44:34Texture. I'll be didn't We used to call them transvestites, like in the
- 44:39movie Rocky Horror Picture Show. Maybe forty years ago, I would have loved
- 44:47to have run track as a female on my high school track team. Could
- 44:52have won the state championship. Text Topy predict how soon after Justice is elected
- 44:58that his debts will be paid. Also help us understand what raising the minimum
- 45:01wage does to folks in the economy. I haven't good much thought to the
- 45:06minimum wage lately, except that well on you know, in Justice's debts.
- 45:15I don't know. I mean I I don't know what can or will happen
- 45:21there on minimum wage. I have always believed that the best determiners of the
- 45:28value of labor is are the employer and the employee. I don't spend a
- 45:36lot of time anymore arguing for or against any minimum wage. And frankly,
- 45:42the minimum wage has become generally irrelevant, not always, I understand, but
- 45:49in many cases irrelevant. Why Because employers need employees. How do you get
- 45:58an employee? Well, you have to pay and offer whatever it takes to
- 46:02get those employees to work for you. So now you see the I mean,
- 46:06I don't even know what the minimum wage is now in West Virginia seven
- 46:09eight bucks. N I don't. It doesn't seem it doesn't matter. I
- 46:14mean, if you're a employer and you're going to hire somebody and they say
- 46:19at an entry level position, entry level position, no experience necessary, and
- 46:27and you say we'll pay you a minimum wage, they're not going to take
- 46:30the job. That's why you see the entry level spots like fast food places
- 46:35other places saying it'll start at twelve, fourteen, fifteen dollars an hour.
- 46:39So and also I've been reading about California. I think their new minimum wage
- 46:45is like twenty dollars or twenty two dollars, and okay, some people will
- 46:50benefit from that, there's no question. However, those things don't happen in
- 46:54a vacuum. So if you raise the minimum wage to twenty your twenty two
- 46:58dollars an hour, employers are required to pay that, then the people are
- 47:02getting paid that they're going to benefit. However, then what does the employer
- 47:07do. I mean, it's squeezing a balloon, So the employer is going
- 47:09to say, okay, then I have to charge more, or if I
- 47:13can't charge more, then I'm going to use few employees or have those employees
- 47:17have fewer hours, or that person who is making fifteen dollars an hour now
- 47:22making twenty two dollars an hour has to do more work, take on more
- 47:24responsibility. So point being, it doesn't happen in a vacuum. Hopey,
- 47:32can you explain why Republicans what Republicans mean by the term woke? You'd have
- 47:37to ask Republicans. It gets to me, woke has almost lost all meaning
- 47:44because it's like fake news. Is that anything you don't like now gets referred
- 47:51to. If you don't like the news, you call it fake. If
- 47:53you don't like whatever the policy is, you call it woke. I think
- 47:57it's lost, not all, but most meaning. Take a break of me.
- 48:00Back talk like continues in just a moment. Winning the lottery means time
- 48:04to work on my skydiving skills. I'm a thrill seek her. I love
- 48:07the rush, armstretched wide, free falling, win on the cheeks. I
- 48:14want to join the skydiving acrobat too. Man, your turn is up.
- 48:19You have to exit the car wash driver. Oh sorry, just skuydife training.
- 48:22I'll see you tomorrow. It's a car wash. I better check my
- 48:25tickets. This could be my chance West Virginia Lottery. What if it could
- 48:30happen to you? Please play responsibly. A West Virginia scholar program changes the
- 48:36lives of families forever. High school juniors can now apply for full scholarship at
- 48:40West Virginia Wesleyan College, one of our state's finest institutions of higher learning.
- 48:45If your child is a high school junior, now is the time to go
- 48:49to wv metronews dot com, have them apply today and they could win a
- 48:52full scholarship to West Virginia Wesleyan that includes room board, tuition and thieves.
- 48:59To apply, log on to WV Metro news dot com and click on the
- 49:02West Virginia scholarlink. You have until midnight April twenty eighth to apply. A
- 49:07twenty twenty four West Virginia Scholar program is sponsored by Greer Industries, West Virginia
- 49:13Hospital Association, GML, Architects and Engineers, a West Virginia Farm Bureau,
- 49:17and Friends of Coal. If you're a high school junior in West Virginia,
- 49:22here's your chance to possibly change your life forever. Go to WV metro news
- 49:27dot com, click on the West Virginia scholarlink and apply today. Trump's plan
- 49:34to stop woke gender ideology from poisoning our kids will investigate Big Farmer and the
- 49:38big hospital networks that participate in sex transitions of minor children, and Big Farmer's
- 49:45lobbyists should be held accountable too, like Pat Morrissey. As a DC lobbyist,
- 49:50Morrissey helped steer taxpayer funds to a gender transition clinic. For children and
- 49:54got Rich lobbying for a drug company peddling puberty blockers. Morrissey's family still owns
- 50:01the DC firm that Love. He's for a child transition provider with a clinic
- 50:06at West Virginia, pro transliberal lobbyist. That's Pat Morrissey, the pro Trump
- 50:12conservative businessman Chris Miller. Miller supports Trump's plan to protect our kids. As
- 50:17the father and the eleven year old girl, You're darn right, I don't
- 50:21want her sharing a locker room with biological mails. We doctors are literally practicing
- 50:25mutilation, not medicine, and they should be at christ. I'm Chris Miller
- 50:30and I'll sign that loss Governor Pete four by Miller for Governor. This is
- 50:32talk Line on Metro News, the voice of West Virginia. WV metronews dot
- 50:39com, the only website you need to stay informed in the Mountain State.
- 50:45Get the latest news and sports story, information on the great outdoors, and
- 50:49never miss an episode of your favorite Metro News programs and podcast including Talkline,
- 50:53Hotline, sports Line, and Three Guys Before the Game. Make a bookmark
- 50:58now and visit WV metronews dot com first thing every morning to five out what's
- 51:02happening all across the state. Wv metronews dot com. West Virginia Outdoors is
- 51:08the Mountain states only hook and bullet radio show dedicated to the more than quarter
- 51:14million hunters and anglers across the state. Award winning host Chris Lawrence has been
- 51:17tracking down hunting and fishing stories for more than twenty five years. Stockfish for
- 51:22repatriation purposes to that's reintroduction, re establishment of Brookshout and two of those streams,
- 51:29the oldest that we have worked on, the earliest ones that we started
- 51:32putting fish into. We've noticed natural reproduction in both of those streams, whether
- 51:37it's hunting and fishing news or just compelling stories about the enjoyment of the great
- 51:40outdoors. It was a pretty good fight. It tooked me about ten minutes
- 51:45to get it in. My dad actually had to run to the truck and
- 51:49grab anat because there's my way I could list him up over top of the
- 51:52rail. West Virginia Outdoors covers it all Saturday mornings at seven oh six am
- 51:58for your daily fix. Outdoors Today brings you two and a half minutes of
- 52:00news and notes from the woods and water every weekday morning on Metro News,
- 52:06the Voice of West Virginia. It's two hours of sports conversation to wrap up
- 52:09your weekend. It's the City Net Sunday Night Sports Line. Hey, this
- 52:13is Travis Jones joining myself and Greg Hunter every Sunday night from six oh six
- 52:16until eight o'clock as we wrap up the sports weekend, we talk Mountaineers,
- 52:21high school, Mountain East Conference, and the latest in the national scene.
- 52:24The Sunday Sports Line is listener interactive. You could call or text the show
- 52:29at three oh four Talk three oh four. It's a perfect weekend sports wrap
- 52:32up on your favorite Metro news Aphilia or watch the show at wb metronews dot
- 52:37com. Talk Line from Ning COVID Insurance Studios. Measles. Measles has been
- 52:55called by some of the most contagious virus known demand. It was decreed eliminated
- 53:00in the US in two thousand, butts seems to be making an unwelcome comeback.
- 53:05According to WVU Medicine and now the first case of measles has been reported
- 53:08in West Virginia in fifteen years. On the next Live Healthy West Virginia,
- 53:14they talk with epidemiologists doctor Michael Stevens about how to protect your family from getting
- 53:19this serious disease. Live Healthy West Virginia is brought to you by WVU Medicine
- 53:23and is now streaming on the West Virginia Metro News podcast platform and the Metro
- 53:29News TV app. Live Healthy West Virginia aiming to help everyone live a better,
- 53:32healthier life in West Virginia and beyond. When we come back after the
- 53:37news, Chris Steyerwaltz from News Nation joins us. This is talk line on
- 53:42Metro News. Metro News is the Voice of West Virginia. Welco about our
- 54:15number two talk line on the Metro News radio network all across the great state
- 54:19of West Virginia. Broadcasting from the in Cove Insurance Studios in the Dale Miller
- 54:22Building. Coming up Neil Brown coming up at eleven forty five on the Spring
- 54:27Game, which is on Saturday. But right now. Chris Starwal joins us.
- 54:30Host of The Hills Sunday on News Nation, joined us Viace Guide from
- 54:32his palatial basement apartment in Washington, DC. Morning, sir, how are
- 54:36you? It's very glamorous down here. It's very glamorous down here. We're
- 54:40keeping the mold at bay. I'm glad to hear that. I'm glad that
- 54:44you and I talked before going on the air and you were willing to weigh
- 54:46in on this, and I appreciate that because I have not talked at all
- 54:52about the Protestations going on on these campuses, primarily in the Northeast, for
- 54:57two reasons. One is, there's stuff going on in West Virginia and that's
- 55:00going on up there. And second of all, I'm really afraid my old
- 55:02white guy Gene is just going to take over and I'm going to say get
- 55:07off my campus lawn because I find it all very irritating. But enlighten me.
- 55:14You know that's a knee jerk emotional response. It is not a thoughtful
- 55:17academic response. So help me understand. We have a system of government designed
- 55:27to avoid the tyranny of the majority, which is to say, we have
- 55:30a system we have a Madisonian democracy. We have a liberal democracy in which
- 55:37the rights of the minority are protected against the will of the majority. Cool.
- 55:42That's good, But we also don't want to have the tyranny of the
- 55:45minority, right. We don't want a situation where a small number of people
- 55:51can interfere with the rights and liberties of the majority unduly. When you shut
- 55:58down the road to the airport in Chicago, when you obstruct the campus from
- 56:05going about its work, you say, Okay, this is civil disobedience and
- 56:10it's not violent per se, so we should listen. Okay, so you
- 56:15listen, you say what do you what do you all have to say?
- 56:19And it's not super hoppy, it's not it's not super what is being said
- 56:24the I think that there are a lot of well meaning, mostly younger people
- 56:30who are anti war. They're not anti Semitic. They're not against Israel,
- 56:36or maybe they're against Israel, but they're not. It's not hate and they're
- 56:40not pro war. But they're hanging out with some folks who are right.
- 56:45They're hanging out with some folks who are part of these protests, who are
- 56:47who are the students or justice in Palestine is pretty obviously anti semitic in its
- 56:53in its position. When you have people who are wearing pins that celebrate the
- 57:00we're a trooper terrorists who killed the people on October seventh, all of that
- 57:04stuff says, okay, you have a problem here, right. This is
- 57:07like on January sixth, most of the people who turned out for that Trump
- 57:12rally were either gawkers or duped, but they weren't violent. But when the
- 57:20violence started, you know what you're supposed to do. Leave, You're supposed
- 57:24to go. You're supposed to say, oh wo woa, whoa, whoa,
- 57:27whoa. This is not for me. And what we are observing at
- 57:32these elite institutions like Colombia, like Barnard College other places is what happens when
- 57:42let's let's just do some level seting. It is very important to have academic
- 57:47independence and freedom of inquiry. That's why tenure is a good idea. You
- 57:52can't fire somebody because they have an unpopular opinion, and expressing an unpopular opinion
- 57:58in academ is a good and important part of inquiry. Dig it. Free
- 58:04speech is your right as an American citizen. The government cannot disenfranchise you from
- 58:12your right to express yourself. But when you enroll in a college, when
- 58:16you become when you enter an institution, it's not that you're giving up your
- 58:22right to free speech. You are submitting yourself to the rules of that institution
- 58:28lest you be kicked out. And the obvious right thing to be happening here
- 58:35is when you have these ten cities of protesters who are whether they're saying it
- 58:43themselves or whether they're just adjacent to some virulent, awful anti semitism, some
- 58:49really gross stuff. So the naive are hanging out with the wicked, and
- 58:53at that point you say, we're not doing this anymore. We're not doing
- 58:58it anymore. You're kicked out, you're suspended, you're gone. When people
- 59:02obstruct other human beings from their pursuit of happiness, though I can't say that
- 59:08going to Chicago O'Hare's airport is ever much of a pursuit of happiness. I've
- 59:12bet crossing the San Francisco a Golden gate bridge that would be my pursuit of
- 59:15happiness to get across the bridge, right, right, So, if you're
- 59:19impeding other people from enjoying their rights as Americans, what happens. You get
- 59:23arrested. That's what is supposed to happen, is because you're interfering with me
- 59:29living my life, and the folks should be happy and willing to be arrested
- 59:35for the cause. That's what Martin Luther King, and that's what the SELMA
- 59:38protests, That's what they said, Yeah, yeah, we know we're going
- 59:42to get arrested. But it's worth getting arrested to call attention to this fine,
- 59:45but they have to get arrested. They have to get arrested. And
- 59:50this is a very difficult thing for Joe Biden because the popular answer in a
- 59:53general election is to say cut it out, to echo what Fetterman and Shapiro,
- 1:00:02the governor Josh Shapiro, the governor of Pennsylvania, and other Democrats have
- 1:00:06said, which is cut it out. This is out of hand, this
- 1:00:08is gross, stop it. Biden can't say the popular thing because he is
- 1:00:15held if you'll pardon me no pun intended hostage by these voters in Michigan,
- 1:00:22these voters in Wisconsin who are strongly anti Israel, and they're really fired up
- 1:00:29about this, and the margins are so close. So what Biden ends up
- 1:00:31doing is both sides of it. They're you know, it's not as bad
- 1:00:35as trumpet Charlottesville, but it's the same idea of there are many good people
- 1:00:38on both sides, and that's that's not a good general He's but he's stuck.
- 1:00:45I think he's just stuck. I look at I watch it and some
- 1:00:52of it, and I read about it, and I have kind of a
- 1:00:52visceral reaction, and I don't know if it's a function. I suspect it's
- 1:00:58a function of age and of thinking. I know more from life experiences,
- 1:01:04and I want to look at some of the young people kindly go do you
- 1:01:07As my late father used to say, he doesn't understand all he knows?
- 1:01:13Yeah, is there some of that going on? I don't know what generation
- 1:01:19generational cohort you consider yourself to be a part of, but I am claiming
- 1:01:22you for gen X because you have a good Gen X kind of sensibility and
- 1:01:27I want you in Gen X. The Baby Boomers, Joe Biden's generation,
- 1:01:32Donald Trump's generation, the valorization and glamorization of listen to the young people must
- 1:01:40we must listen to the young people. We must hear the voices of the
- 1:01:44young. No, that's not what we do. That's the opposite of what
- 1:01:49we do. When you are twenty, you don't know anything. I didn't
- 1:01:53know anything when I was twenty. I was so no one knows more in
- 1:02:00world than a seventeen year old. Just ask them. They know everything and
- 1:02:05they will tell you why you're wrong about everything, because they do not have
- 1:02:07wisdom, knowledge and wisdom are two different things. And the willingness, and
- 1:02:14you see it in the coverage, the reflex to say young people are very
- 1:02:20upset. There's a lot of reasons that you can dislike the movie Forrest Gump.
- 1:02:24There are many reasons to dislike the movie Forest Gump, but one of
- 1:02:29them is the glorification of anti Vietnam protests. Here's a little clue. The
- 1:02:37Vietnam protesters did not get us out of the Vietnam War. You know what
- 1:02:42got us out of Vietnam war, bombing North the bombing of North Vietnam was
- 1:02:50what got them to the peace table. Richard Nixon got elected in nineteen sixty
- 1:02:55eight and overwhelmingly re elected in nineteen seventy two because people looked at a Democratic
- 1:03:01Party that was in the thrall of children, that was choked by the adolescent
- 1:03:08rage of children and protesters, and said, this is poppycock, this is
- 1:03:14preposterous. And the valorization, the glorification of protest that is so deeply embedded
- 1:03:22in the baby boomer mind about how great it was that they protested the Vietnam
- 1:03:28War is not only inaccurate, it doesn't reflect what actually happened in history,
- 1:03:34but it creates a blind spot for any time young people come out and do
- 1:03:37or say something that we say, oh, we must listen. No,
- 1:03:40we must not. We must hear, we must say, Okay, maybe
- 1:03:45you have a point. But the people that we should listen to are the
- 1:03:46people who have experience. We should listen to people who understand things and know
- 1:03:52that the world is not black and white. Chris Starwalt is with us.
- 1:03:55How about Mike Johnson? How about Mike Johnson? What do you say about
- 1:03:59this? Just saying, you know what, I don't like to have this
- 1:04:01job, but I'm going to do the right thing of it costing my job
- 1:04:04Rock and Roll. He's a CAG. He's a he's a CAG operator.
- 1:04:11I'm I'm very surprised. He went down tomorrow lago and he sucked up to
- 1:04:17Trump and he gave Trump what Trump wanted, which was basically, yeah,
- 1:04:23we'll say some stuff about stealing the election. We're going to lay down so
- 1:04:27we're going to lay down some markers about if you decide that you don't like
- 1:04:30the outcome of this election that we're going to we're going to start building the
- 1:04:33case now. And he did that, and then he went back to Washington,
- 1:04:39and he said, you know what, I'm good. I'm good with
- 1:04:42Trump. I got Trump's blessing, and here's what we're going to do.
- 1:04:45We're passing it. We're going to do it. And it is significant,
- 1:04:49by the way, that Johnson wanted a border security piece in there too.
- 1:04:56And it was not squishes but Kok's who bottled it up in and I shouldn't
- 1:05:02call them koks, but right wing nationale, the counter yeah, who blocked
- 1:05:11it in the Rules committee, right, it was, it was right.
- 1:05:15It was Freedom caucusy folks who blocked it from actually coming out because it would
- 1:05:18have definitely passed in the whole house. We heard Mitch McConnell dressed down the
- 1:05:26Republicans for all of their perfidy on Ukraine and the many failures of leadership.
- 1:05:35Johnson has a different road to hoe than Mitch McConnell. Mitch mcconald's done,
- 1:05:41he's he has put in his notice and he this is his last ride,
- 1:05:45so he can say and do stuff that Johnson probably can't. What we're going
- 1:05:49to see two things. Here's what we're going to say. Number One,
- 1:05:53when the members come back from home, how angry is the Republican primary electorate
- 1:05:59about the U cranead, I think they're probably pretty angry. And if that's
- 1:06:03the case, then Marjorie Taylor Green and Thomas Massey and Paul Gosar will have
- 1:06:10new friends on the motion to vacate. But here's an interesting wrinkle in all
- 1:06:15this. If they do, the Republicans might not just lose their current speaker,
- 1:06:21they might lose the House and before the election, if just two more
- 1:06:28or two or three more Republicans retire early, because we've seen all these Republicans
- 1:06:31leave say nope, I'm done. Ken Buck, Mike Gallagher, other members
- 1:06:35of the House have said I'm not sticking around for this. It is possible,
- 1:06:40and this would be wild, but it certainly could happen that the Republicans
- 1:06:45would lose their majority before the election and that they wouldn't have a speaker at
- 1:06:49all. So that's I think Trump knows and Trump maga knows it's bad to
- 1:06:57have a speaker fight right now, but the hardcore folks maybe don't. And
- 1:07:03then the last question then I promise I'll shut up is Democrats. If you
- 1:07:09did it today, plenty of Democrats would come in and help keep Johnson because
- 1:07:14he kept his work. He said, I'm going to do it, and
- 1:07:15they said we'll back you, and so they did it. As time goes
- 1:07:18by, will Democrats come to say well? He then he said, and
- 1:07:23did some stuff I didn't like. So now I'm not going to do it.
- 1:07:26Now We're gonna let him twist because it would definitely be good for Democrats
- 1:07:30to have Republicans this summer. In another Kevin McCarthy, got your dammerung,
- 1:07:36Chris Stywald, host of The Hill Sunday on News Nation. You're working on
- 1:07:42Sunday show already. Yeah, we've got John Fetterman looking forward, Okay,
- 1:07:46looking forward to talking to him. We're going to have a great show.
- 1:07:49We've got a great panel of journalists and just raw, just raw, excellent,
- 1:07:54ro excellence. Ten o'clock Eastern Ladies and Gentlemen, The Hill Sunday on
- 1:07:57News Nation with Chris Starwelt. Thanks buddy, Thanks brother. Later, I'm
- 1:08:02JB. McCuskey, candidate for Attorney General. I've been a mountaineer my whole
- 1:08:08life, and we know mountaineers are always free, but that freedom is under
- 1:08:14attack. Woke activists want to defund our police, strip away our rights,
- 1:08:18and destroy our way of life. As West Virginia's Attorney General, I won't
- 1:08:24let that happen. I'll back the blue, defend the Second Amendment, and
- 1:08:29protect our right to frack, mine, farm, and timber. I'm JB.
- 1:08:32McCuskey. As Attorney General. I'll fight for West Virginia. I'll hold
- 1:08:38politicians accountable, end federal overreach, and crush the woke mob. I'm JB.
- 1:08:45McCuskey. Woke activists mistreat and look down on us, But as your
- 1:08:47Attorney General, I'll fight for West Virginia values and keep the Mountain State free
- 1:08:54painful. By JB. McCuskey for West Virginia Attorney General. Peelbox one one,
- 1:08:58three five nine, Charleston Westfriget Junior two, five, three six one.
- 1:09:01A new episode of Live Healthy West Virginia is now posted on the podcast
- 1:09:04center of metronews dot com and all new Metronews TV app. Once declared eliminated
- 1:09:10measles is making an unwelcome comeback, and it's here in West Virginia. It's
- 1:09:15actually probably the most infectious virus known to man. Making sure you're up to
- 1:09:19date with vaccination is the best thing you can do to prevent getting measles.
- 1:09:24Listen to Live Healthy West Virginia for candid conversations with insights about improving your health
- 1:09:28and wellbeing. Live Healthy West Virginia is presented by WU Medicine, jackpotch in
- 1:09:32the Millions. You're in West Virginia. Who doesn't want to be a millionaire?
- 1:09:34Getting the Powerball drawings Mondays, Wednesdays and Saturdays. The Mega Megan's Drawings
- 1:09:39Tuesdays and Fridays. Will you be the next Big Winner? Play today?
- 1:09:42The Powerbault jackpot is one hundred and twenty nine million dollars, the Megamingus jackpot
- 1:09:45two hundred and twenty eight million dollars. Trump's plan to stop woke gender ideology
- 1:09:50from poisoning our kids will investigate Big Farmer and the big hospital networks that participate
- 1:09:56in sex transitions of minor children. And Big Farm as lobbyist should be held
- 1:10:00accountable too, like Pat Morrissey as a DC lobbyist, Morrissey helped steer taxpayer
- 1:10:06funds to a gender transition clinic for children and got rich lovying for a drug
- 1:10:12company peddling puberty blockers. Morrissey's family still owns the DC firm that lobby's for
- 1:10:17a child transition provider with a clinic in West Virginia, pro transliberal lobbyist.
- 1:10:24That's Pat Morrissey, the pro Trump conservative businessman Chris Miller. Miller supports Trump's
- 1:10:30plan to protect our kids. As the father and the eleven year old girl,
- 1:10:34You're darn right, I don't want her sharing a locker room with biological
- 1:10:38mails. Well, doctors are literally practicing mutilation, not medicine, and they
- 1:10:43should be in prison. I'm Chris Miller, and I'll sign that loss governor
- 1:10:45paid for by Miller for Governor. You're listening to talk Line on Metro News,
- 1:10:49the voice of West Virginia. Metro News this morning the biggest stories from
- 1:10:57around the state of West Virginia when you want them, brought to you by
- 1:11:00Burdett Camping Center, home of the RV warranty forever. Chris Lawrence at the
- 1:11:04anchor desk, we are ready to get to day who started in West Virginia
- 1:11:06with all of the information you nag. Harry Houdas secrings the day's headlines.
- 1:11:11Employees at two long standing restaurants at the Charlestontown Center Mall are without a job
- 1:11:15this morning. The chop House and Tidewater grill abruptly closed Saturday, but no
- 1:11:19reason was given and no notice was given to employees. Venture's Restaurant Group,
- 1:11:24who owns both the Chophouse and Tidewater, says it has offered jobs to management
- 1:11:28and employees at properties outside Charleston. Kyle Wiggs at the sports desk par France
- 1:11:31for players from the University of Illinois committed to join the Mountaineer. Six free
- 1:11:36guards since her Harris six eight Forward Amani Hansbury each said Sunday they were headed
- 1:11:42tow WVU and Hoppy Kirchible's daily commentary Metro News This Morning brought to you by
- 1:11:47Burdett Camping Center Listen where you get your favorite podcasts and online at WV Metro
- 1:11:53News dot com. It's two hours of sports conversation to wrap up your weekend.
- 1:11:57It's the City That's Sunday Night Sports Lot is Trap Shows, joining myself
- 1:12:00and Greg Hunter every Sunday night from six oh six until eight o'clock. As
- 1:12:03we wrap up the sports weekend, we talk Mountaineers, high school, Mountain
- 1:12:08East Conference, and the latest in the national scene. The Sunday Sports Line
- 1:12:12is Listener Interactive. You could call or text the show at three oh four
- 1:12:15Talk three oh four. It's a perfect weekend sports wrap up on your favorite
- 1:12:19Metro News ap Philia or watch the show at wv metronews dot com. Hey
- 1:12:24there, Dave Weekly, here your host from Metro News Hotline. Get ready
- 1:12:27for an epic journey. Every weekday from three to six pm, We've got
- 1:12:30all the excitement you need from sports to tech, music, pop culture,
- 1:12:33and everything in between. Join Coop and I as we bring you engaging discussions,
- 1:12:38captivating interviews, fun games, and the latest sports and entertainment headlines that
- 1:12:42will keep your books. Metro News Hotline is your go to source for sports,
- 1:12:45news, entertainment, and most importantly fun. Tune in weekdays from three
- 1:12:48to six on Metro News and wv metronews dot com. Metro News Talkline with
- 1:13:06Hoppy Kerchival is brought to you by in Covia Insurance, encircling you with coverage
- 1:13:11to protect what you care about most. Visit in covid dot com to learn
- 1:13:15more, talk on from the in Covid Insurance studios. Being up to date
- 1:13:19on your COVID nineteen shots is the best way to protect against severe COVID for
- 1:13:24everyone six months and older. Staying up to date on your COVID nineteen shots
- 1:13:28means you're far less likely to get really sick or I have to stay in
- 1:13:30the hospital, God forbid, even die from COVID even if you do test
- 1:13:34positive. At this time, most folks are due for a COVID nineteen shot.
- 1:13:38From more information, visit vaccinate dot WV dot gov. Again, that's
- 1:13:42vaccinate WV dot gov. Let me do some text cher don't forget coming up.
- 1:13:45Neil Brown at eleven forty five this morning, text dopy Donald Trump has
- 1:13:50no legitimate complain about having to be in court for charges made against him.
- 1:13:55His own conduct is solely responsible for these charges. Says that texture text three
- 1:14:02four Talk three four Hoppi, you have asked the question whether people believe in
- 1:14:09gender dysphoria. You mean, is it a real condition where people are born
- 1:14:14in a wrong body or they think they are born in the wrong body?
- 1:14:16How about mental illness? The research I've done indicates or says that the medical
- 1:14:25community recognizes gender dysphoria as a real condition, although its causes are unknown or
- 1:14:31there is not consensus about the causes, and that it does happen that individuals
- 1:14:38are born and their gender identity does not correspond with their sex at birth,
- 1:14:45that it is a real condition. There is, however, controversy and no
- 1:14:50controversy, but also just not consensus over treatment. In fact, there's a
- 1:14:57new study, comprehensive study just outs from England a couple of weeks ago that
- 1:15:04said there should be more research into treatment for gender just for you. Let's
- 1:15:15see, that's kind of a joke. Not going to read that hoppy.
- 1:15:19Coming from an independent person who watches middle school and high school sports, I
- 1:15:24can say with high confidence, no matter the gender of your child or the
- 1:15:27children your child is competing against, I can say they aren't very good.
- 1:15:30The only reason your child wins is due to attrition. If your child is
- 1:15:34getting a sports scholarship, it's due to attrition. Watching sports events anymore is
- 1:15:39taxing to the brain, says the texture. I wrote about today, and
- 1:15:44I think I've mentioned it on the show, that the Department of Education came
- 1:15:47up with guidelines for how to handle students student athletes who are transgender would seem
- 1:16:00to be some fairly reasonable recommendations. However, US Department of Education put it
- 1:16:05out for comment. There were thousands and thousands of comments. Then the rules
- 1:16:09would be finalized and then the White House would release them. However, according
- 1:16:14to the Washington Post, and I wrote about this in the commentary, the
- 1:16:16Biden administration is not going to issue these guidelines before the election because they're worried
- 1:16:25that it's going to cause a firestormby how do you think the Supreme Court will
- 1:16:30rule on the total immunity claim before them? Now? I don't know,
- 1:16:34generally speaking. I mean, I haven't read the briefs. I mean,
- 1:16:36I've followed the story, but I do not think that a president should have
- 1:16:43total immunity. Obviously, you need a level of immunity, a pretty high
- 1:16:47level of immunity protect against civil suits, for example, all kinds of civil
- 1:16:54suits. But if that immunity, I don't see how that immunity could extend
- 1:17:00in to potential criminal behavior. General comment, Uh, Hoppy, what about
- 1:17:11this? What the Senate passed the Foreign eight bills. Brad Macklheney wrote about
- 1:17:15that. Both Capitol and Mansion voted in favor of those bills, and Mansion
- 1:17:19will be on this program tomorrow ten or six. Hoppy said, when are
- 1:17:27you gonna call the Biden trials against Trump? When are you gonna call the
- 1:17:30Biden trials against Trump election appearance, asked the Texter, all right, got
- 1:17:36a break, We'll be back when come back. On Metro News talk Line,
- 1:17:40I'm gonna talk to an attorney who works on these athletic gender just for
- 1:17:44you cases. What are you supposed to do? This is talk line on
- 1:17:46Metro News, the Voice of West Virginia. It's eleven thirty. Let's get
- 1:17:50a news update. Checking with the Metro News radio network. Fin out what's
- 1:17:54happening state wide this hour, all across the great state West Virginia. Metro
- 1:17:58News. I'm Chris right. It's Governor Jim Justice paid a visit to the
- 1:18:00Metro Dad one one Center in Kanawak County Tuesday. He was there to sign
- 1:18:04the nine to one one retirementville, a first in the nation, but also
- 1:18:08took time to thank those who answered the phone when things are going wrong,
- 1:18:12I mean, when it really boils right down to it. You're heroes.
- 1:18:16You've done so much for this great state. It's unbelievable. The new law
- 1:18:20creates a pathway for dispatchers and telecommunicators to retire as early as age fifty if
- 1:18:25they have twenty years of service. Derek Johnson's been with Kanawak County nine to
- 1:18:28one one for sixteen years and says it'll be a big improvement. It takes
- 1:18:32it from being a job to a it's a career, and he says that
- 1:18:39will also help stem the high turnover rate in the dispatching ranks. The governor
- 1:18:43today is traveling in north central West Virginia's starting the day in Bridgeport for the
- 1:18:46grand opening of a building expansion at Aurora Flight Services at the North Central Regional
- 1:18:50Airport. He's also accepting a check to support drug prevention and will then break
- 1:18:56ground on a large tourism project at Mylon Park. There could be new line
- 1:19:00for the now idled Cleveland Cliffs ten mil in Weirton. We have a grow
- 1:19:03opportunity to provide for work for the employees, be good for the community,
- 1:19:10to be good for Cleveland if it happens, be good for many people,
- 1:19:15as local steel Workers president Mark Glyptis, who says the companies and talks to
- 1:19:17transform the mill into making material for power transformers. You're listening to Metronews the
- 1:19:24Boys of West Virginia. Attention West Virginians. Patrick Morrissey is the one proven
- 1:19:30conservative running for governor with an unmatched record of delivering victories for our state.
- 1:19:34Conservative Republican Patrick Morrissey has been endorsed by the NRA, stood up against federal
- 1:19:41overreach, fought and sued Joe Biden to protect West Virginia jobs, and defended
- 1:19:46our values against the far left agenda. When Biden screws West Virginia, I
- 1:19:53sued Biden and West Virginia wins a lot. I'm Attorney General Patrick Morrison.
- 1:20:00I fought against the deep state and one to protect our jobs, defended our
- 1:20:03Second Amendment rights, upheld the sanctity deep life, protected our kids from the
- 1:20:10woke left and the radical rejective. And the only proven conservative running. I
- 1:20:15was the first to endorse Trump in this rates paid four by Lewrissey twenty twenty
- 1:20:19four. Patrick Morrissey is the one proven Conservative running for governor. A Hardy
- 1:20:25County magistrate has dismissed criminal accounts against Alleghenny Wood Products president John Kritt, the
- 1:20:30second Critz, whose fifty year old company closed its doors earlier this year due
- 1:20:34to financial problems, was charged with two fellony accounts of obtaining goods under false
- 1:20:39pretenses in connection with logs that were delivered at the company's yard near Moorfield in
- 1:20:44Wayne County. An ATV crash claimed to life Tuesday. The victim identified as
- 1:20:47Jimmy Flowers, who died when the machine flipped over from the Metro News anchored
- 1:20:51ESK, I'm Chris Lawrence talkline from the in Co Insurance studios here in West
- 1:21:15Virginia. So, West Virginia's Save Women's Sports Act, the legislature past in
- 1:21:19twenty twenty one, specifies that sports teams for girls and women quote unquote,
- 1:21:25shall not be open to students of male sex. That prohibits a transgender girl
- 1:21:30from participating on girls teams. Last week, by that two to one decision
- 1:21:35by the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals cast that law into question. It cleared
- 1:21:40the way for a Bridgeport Middle School transgender girl to continue to participate on her
- 1:21:44school's track team. Now, the ruling did not invalidate West Virginia's law against
- 1:21:49such participation, but it did determine that the law unfairly discriminated against the student,
- 1:21:54Becky pepper Jackson. Under Federal Title NON, the law the prohibits discrimination
- 1:21:58at schools it received funding. So what does all this mean going forward?
- 1:22:02Case you have a cost is a former NCAA D one student athlete and an
- 1:22:06attorney who specializes in collegiate athletics compliance issues and specifically on the whole transgender issue.
- 1:22:15Casey, good morning, Thanks for joining us. How are we even
- 1:22:16supposed to think about this now? Yeah? Thanks, thanks for having me
- 1:22:20on today. It's a really interesting space that we're in right now with Title
- 1:22:28nine and interclusiate athletics. But I think moving forward, I mean you see
- 1:22:33states, I think around now twenty four states have the Stablemen's Sports Acts law,
- 1:22:40and then you see the federal government also trying to regulate this through Title
- 1:22:45nine. We saw this regulation come last April that did not get finalized,
- 1:22:50but that would have addressed eligibility on athletic teams in sederally funded education programs,
- 1:22:58including athletics, but that did not go forward. So now we're left with
- 1:23:02the Title nine regulations that came out last week. I do not specifically address
- 1:23:09the issue, but they do redefine sex discrimination, which now includes gender identity.
- 1:23:16So we will probably see that conflict with some of these state laws which
- 1:23:23do prohibit biological males from participating on women's teams. So we were definitely seeing
- 1:23:29a conflict with state law and federal law. So we'll definitely be interesting to
- 1:23:32see how this plays out the next few months. So let me try to
- 1:23:35walk through this. So, West Virginia has a lall that is a blanket
- 1:23:41prohibition. The federal Appeals Court narrowly addressed the case of the transgender student in
- 1:23:48Bridgeport. The federal government has come out with a Title nine update that says
- 1:23:55discrimination against an individual based on gender orientation is a violation of Title nine.
- 1:24:01So does that mean does that mean that in West Virginia, for example,
- 1:24:09that if a transgender girl wanted to participate in a girls sports that they would
- 1:24:13need to follow the Title nine rule or follow the West Virginia wall or who
- 1:24:17knows. It's really a who knows right now. It goes to this concept
- 1:24:23of preemption. Does the federal rule trump the state law? And who really
- 1:24:28has the authority to regulate these types of eligibility decisions and these rules. So
- 1:24:34I can see a circumstance where you might have West Virginia saying that they're going
- 1:24:41to want to regulate this and want to enforce to say Women's Sports Act and
- 1:24:46Title nine that the Department of Education overreached on their part SUF where I can
- 1:24:54see some litigation happening in the future because how Title nine came out and defined
- 1:25:03on the basis of sex, that's in direct conflict, like I said,
- 1:25:06with the state law. So I'm it's not it's very muddy right now,
- 1:25:14not super clear. So yeah, case you have a cost is with her.
- 1:25:16She's a former NCAAD one student athlete and an attorney specializes in these issues.
- 1:25:21I read through the Department Education's proposed rules on this, and again they've
- 1:25:29they proposed these rules. There was a common period, and then the bid
- 1:25:31administration kind of indicated quietly, we're not going to put these out here now,
- 1:25:36We're going to wait probably till after the election. But I thought there
- 1:25:40was some reasonable guidance there, and it said essentially it was nuanced like elementary
- 1:25:45school level probably doesn't make much difference, but when you get into the high
- 1:25:48school level, where there are legitimate issues of competition, that schools would have
- 1:25:57some discretion there to make a call. And again I'm generalizing it, but
- 1:26:00I thought those rules at least provided some some sense to this. What do
- 1:26:03you think? Yeah, so it did provide that balancing test that I think
- 1:26:10would is a good compromise. It would have looked at the different sports because
- 1:26:16I mean the argument too is the fairness in competition, and it would have
- 1:26:23looked looked at the sports that issue. The competitive level, Like you said,
- 1:26:28elementary, elementary and T ball sports is a lot different than NCA Intercollegiate
- 1:26:33Division on sports, so there might be a more more of an interest in
- 1:26:40collegiate sports to promote UH fairness. And it also looked at the level of
- 1:26:45edgy education too. There was a lot of different balancing factors there with this
- 1:26:51UH proposed Title nine regulation that was released last year. But like you said,
- 1:26:57they when they forwarded at the Title nine sex discrimination rules that were just
- 1:27:02finalized on Friday to really the last stage of the rule making process, they
- 1:27:09did not forward move forward with the athletics and PRM, which was the big
- 1:27:15question. I mean that to me, that was the big that was the
- 1:27:17big issue. Is not is that but I interrupted you, but go ahead,
- 1:27:23no, And you're exactly right. So now we're left with eligibility and
- 1:27:29who can actually play on these men's and female teams, and it's still not
- 1:27:38not super super clear. Yeah. Finally, Casey, is we have this
- 1:27:43one instance in West Virginia. It has got national attention. It is the
- 1:27:46attorney general who's also running for governors holding a press conference today with Riley Gains.
- 1:27:53So it's it's a big deal on one instance. But do you get
- 1:27:57calls about this? It's just is are these kinds of things coming up across
- 1:28:00the country. Yeah. So, our our law firm is mainly out of
- 1:28:05Ohio, and they passed a similar law that was supposed to go into effect
- 1:28:11actually today, but it's it's in court right now being litigated. There's preliminary
- 1:28:16injunctions tros So in these twenty five states, there have been lawsuits filed challenging
- 1:28:25the validity of these laws on constitutional grounds, on Title nine grounds. Some
- 1:28:29of them have been mostly unsuccessful, saying most courts have concluded that these laws
- 1:28:39violate Title niners and or the Equal Protection Clause. But West Virginia is not
- 1:28:45the only one going going through this right now, and I anticipate that they
- 1:28:51will continue not to be the only one as as we move forward here the
- 1:28:57next few months. Indeed, at a former NC double D one student athlete
- 1:29:00and attorney specializes in collegiate athletics and compliance issues, Casey Good Insights I appreciate
- 1:29:05you coming on. Thank you so much. Yep, thank you. Have
- 1:29:09a good day. All right, you too. We'll be right back.
- 1:29:10Neil Brown's Next. A new episode of Live Healthy West Virginia is now posted
- 1:29:14on the podcast center of metronews dot com and all new Metronews TV app Endoscopy
- 1:29:18is used for so much more than colonoscopes, and now with AI, levels
- 1:29:23of early detection are much higher. The data has shown us that it increases
- 1:29:28your AT and no money tection rates, which are the pre cancerous poems anywhere
- 1:29:31from ten to fifteen percent. Listen to Live Healthy West Virginia for candid conversations
- 1:29:35with insights about improving your health and wellbeing. Live Healthy West Virginia is presented
- 1:29:39by WU Medicine. Larry Pack is a proven Conservative Republican running for State Treasurer
- 1:29:45who fights for our families. Larry Pack is one hundred percent pro life and
- 1:29:49supports the Second Amendment. Larry Pack has real West Virginia values. Larry Pack
- 1:29:55is a proven job creator and knows what it takes to grow our economy.
- 1:29:59Larry Pack Governor Justice delivered the largest tax cut in state history. Our families
- 1:30:03now keep more of their hard earned money. Let's all vote for Republican Larry
- 1:30:08Pack for State Treasurer. Paid for by Larry Pack for West Virginia Larry pac
- 1:30:12Treasurer. Technology can be daunting. Gigs ISPs HD, this cybersecurity that all
- 1:30:19you know is you wanted, fast, reliable, and affordable. City Net
- 1:30:24delivers all three. They're leading the way to connect West Virginia. Also,
- 1:30:29citty Net is your neighbor. Their national headquarters is in Bridgeport, and just
- 1:30:32like you, their phone number begins with three zero four. Visit citynet dot
- 1:30:38net. When it comes to technology, city Net connects, protects, and
- 1:30:42perfects. This is talk Line on Metro News, the Voice of West Virginia.
- 1:30:49West Virginia Outdoors is the Mountain states only hook and bullet radio show dedicated
- 1:30:55to the more than quarter million hunters and anglers across the state. Award winning
- 1:30:59host Lawrence has been tracking down hunting and fishing stories for more than twenty five
- 1:31:02years. I shot him. He ran over to the edge of the field,
- 1:31:06and he made it about five ten yards out of the edge of the
- 1:31:10field and fell over there. Whether it's hunting and fishing news or just compelling
- 1:31:15stories about the enjoyment of the great outdoors. He stuck his head through the
- 1:31:18blind into where you were. Yeah. Yeah, well he had jumped,
- 1:31:23he leaped in. Okay, the blonde oh gosh, yeah, so he
- 1:31:27had his whole body was in the air for a couple of seconds and is
- 1:31:30the only thing that landed in the blind was you know, of course,
- 1:31:33his head in his spart leg. West Virginia Outdoors covers it all Saturday mornings
- 1:31:38at seven oh six am and for your daily fix, Outdoors Today brings you
- 1:31:42two and a half minutes of news and notes from the woods and water every
- 1:31:45weekday morning on Metro News, the Voice of West Virginia. Hey everybody,
- 1:31:49it's Tony Carritty, I'm Greg Hunter and I'm Brad Howse, and we invite
- 1:31:54you to join us Sunday through Fridays right here on the Metro News Radio network.
- 1:31:58It's the City Nets stay wide sports Line. We talk West Virginia University
- 1:32:02football, basketball, baseball, you name it. If it's got anything to
- 1:32:06do with the Golden Blue, we're on it. And don't forget the text
- 1:32:10line available every night. So we invite you to join us. The Senator
- 1:32:13Coach Hunter and me Tony Courritti. It's the city net state wide sports line
- 1:32:16on Metro News. News in the Mountain State happens quick and for decades you
- 1:32:21have depended on Metro News for accurate news delivered fast. Now here's your chance
- 1:32:28to help keep your fellow West Virginians informed. If you see news happening,
- 1:32:31become a Metro News Hawk by texting News to three five sixty five to one.
- 1:32:35If you take a picture or video of what you see, submit that
- 1:32:39as well. Text the word news to three five sixty five one to submit
- 1:32:43your tip or story. Standard texting rates apply. Please don't text and drive.
- 1:33:01Metro News Talk Line with Hoppy Kirchibal is brought to you by Incovia Insurance,
- 1:33:05encircling you with coverage to protect what you care about most. Visit in
- 1:33:10Covia dot com to learn more. Dannuel WU gold Blues Spring football Game,
- 1:33:14presented by in Cova Insurance, is this Saturday at noon at Mylin Pushcar Stadium
- 1:33:18out in your field. Admission is free gates opening eleven o'clock, but all
- 1:33:23fans are required to claim a ticket. You can go on the WVU sports
- 1:33:26website and find that all tickets are issued via mobile device. Fans are encouraged
- 1:33:30to make a donation to WVU Medicine Children's WVU Medicine Children's Please welcome Neil Brown,
- 1:33:36head football coach at WVU coach. Good morning, How are you hoppy?
- 1:33:40Good morning? I appreciate you having me on. Well, it's good
- 1:33:43to talk to you. Sound you sound cheery today? Is because you only
- 1:33:45have a couple days of practice left and you can move on. No,
- 1:33:48Actually, I enjoy the practice, spring practice and fall camp. Yeah,
- 1:33:54those are enjoyable times. My son, who is in second grade, their
- 1:34:00class went on a field trip and they were visiting here today. So really,
- 1:34:04yeah, so I just I left. I went from second graders to
- 1:34:09your show. Well that's you went up like one or two grades to me.
- 1:34:13I was a really I was really good in the fourth grade, you
- 1:34:15know. That was that was my I was probably I probably peaked in the
- 1:34:16fourth grade. Were you were you a good student? Academic? I was.
- 1:34:21I didn't have a choice. You got to remember, so when I
- 1:34:26started from first grade through my senior year in high school, fifth, sixth,
- 1:34:31seventh, and eighth grade were the only time in school that I didn't
- 1:34:35have a parent in the building. My mom was my elementary school librarian,
- 1:34:39and then my dad was my high school principal. And so both of both
- 1:34:43of them are educators obviously, and then three out of my four grandparents were
- 1:34:46educator. So I didn't have a choice. I had no choice but to
- 1:34:49do well in school. Did you have those days though? Like you like,
- 1:34:54I don't want to go to school today. I don't feel well.
- 1:34:57Could you pull that? Could you pull that off? Yeah? But they
- 1:34:59were I mean I might pull it, but they're not listening to that.
- 1:35:01You know, there's no compassion. There wasn't any compassion. No, no,
- 1:35:05that was here's the thing like this is, uh, this will age
- 1:35:10me a little bit. So my dad was the the principal of my high
- 1:35:15school. And in those days, substitute teachers had to call our house and
- 1:35:21and uh and so you know, or the teacher who was sick would call
- 1:35:27our house and say, hey, I'm not going to be able to make
- 1:35:29it in today. You know now it's all automated, but back then,
- 1:35:33and so my dad would go to the high school early. So I'm I'm
- 1:35:36fielding calls, I'm taking substitutes early and my freshman sophomore year, so you
- 1:35:41wait to me, you were arranging the substitutes. Okay, I'll get somebody
- 1:35:44to cover that. I was telling my dad. And there there would be
- 1:35:47this a couple of different occasions where I'd be sitting in my first period class
- 1:35:53and you know, the classrooms have the glass window on the door, and
- 1:35:57I'd hear a loud thump, dump dump, and my dad, who's kind
- 1:36:00of an imposing figure, his finger would be pulling pointing to me, telling
- 1:36:04me come out, and he would be he would say, did so and
- 1:36:08so call this morning and ask for a sub And I'm like, uh,
- 1:36:11yes, sir, and he and he would proceed to tell me how the
- 1:36:15first period of class that they were supposed to be at, who I did
- 1:36:17report was sitting down there without a teacher and that was my fault. So,
- 1:36:21oh jeez, that's I mean, that's brutal. That's brutal. And
- 1:36:25was it like you when when I mean your dan's the principle and you know,
- 1:36:30you're walking down the hall on somebody goes at mister Brown. That's so
- 1:36:32in sad. I mean, does that put you? Did that put you
- 1:36:34in an awkward spot? That's kind of like my kids when they're complaining about
- 1:36:39the Mountaineers during the season. You just kind of weather's it. Wait a
- 1:36:42minute, Wait a minute, your kids complain about the mountaineers. No,
- 1:36:45No, the the other kids in the class, they're complaining. Go they
- 1:36:47hear the part complaining, or maybe they're listening to your show. I don't
- 1:36:51know, but no, I was up on you last year, man,
- 1:36:56I was. I was up on you know. I'm I'm a bandwagon guy.
- 1:36:59Man was in on the bandwagon. Yeah. I appreciate the upfronts I
- 1:37:04do. Now, It's uh, I would just get blamed if people got
- 1:37:08in trouble. I'm like, hey, I don't have anything to do with
- 1:37:11that, bud. Like you guys, you're gonna deal with the principle on
- 1:37:15that you got to deal with the man. I got no juice. I
- 1:37:15can't help you on that I got. I got no juice at all on
- 1:37:19that whatsoever? What did you get out of spring practice? So? I
- 1:37:24think the first thing is personnel. It's about evaluating personnel. And what I
- 1:37:30mean by that is you really want to find out, like who's made improvements,
- 1:37:34so maybe whose role is ready to increase. Who's a guy that maybe
- 1:37:39was a backup that's ready to move into a starter role. Who's somebody the
- 1:37:42red shirt that's now ready to be in the rotation or even be a starter.
- 1:37:46How do the new people? What are their skill sets so they we
- 1:37:49know how to use them. So personnel's first, and I think the second
- 1:37:53thing is is understanding schematics. You're always tinkering, not necessarily over hauling,
- 1:38:00but you're tinkering. You're adding or you're taking out schematics. In spring is
- 1:38:03the time to trial and error. And so that's I think the two things
- 1:38:08we got out is I have a really good understanding. And the final kind
- 1:38:12of evaluation is on Saturday, because it's an actual game. This is the
- 1:38:15closest to a game we'll have until we kick off against Penn State. Most
- 1:38:18people in the stands it's on TV, et cetera. And so it's our
- 1:38:25last really point where we can see guys in a in a game like situation.
- 1:38:30But evaluating the personnel and then understanding, you know, what do we
- 1:38:34want to do from a scheme standpoint. As far as changes are are taking
- 1:38:40things out out of each face, do you do you still have portal work
- 1:38:43to do? Yeah? I do? You know? The biggest portal work
- 1:38:46is always retaining your own team. And so we've got to work and that
- 1:38:50is a work. It's a it's a continuous process of making sure you're able
- 1:38:56to hold on to the players that you need to hold on to. We're
- 1:38:58gonna lose some. We lost one yesterday. You know, I think that
- 1:39:02who is that? I'm sorry, who was that? Who was it?
- 1:39:04Tell me? Yeah, e J. Horton, who's a reserve receiver.
- 1:39:06He went in the portal. We wishing, well, it's a good kid,
- 1:39:10but you're not gonna be to keep everybody happy. And we've got to
- 1:39:13and there's we've got to have three or four spots come open anyway, and
- 1:39:15I think it'll kind of hap happen naturally. Yeah, Okay, the what
- 1:39:21are you going to do this summer? So this summer is well, going
- 1:39:27back to your your question, I need fully answered, we do. We'll
- 1:39:30have to add another a few guys, a couple of secondary guys in the
- 1:39:32portal, and then the first thing in the summer is really getting your new
- 1:39:39people. So we'll have several incoming freshmen that will start the day after Memorial
- 1:39:44Day, and uh, there'll be a small group of transfers that is that
- 1:39:48is coming in and so it's really about getting them caught up and getting them
- 1:39:51ready to compete, and then the summer is about getting in shape and at
- 1:39:59the same time is growing your team together. The summer is when you kind
- 1:40:03of create the chemistry of your team and you have shared sacrifice, you do
- 1:40:09you learn how to do hard things better. You're really gonna play Galager Rodney
- 1:40:14Gallagher on defense as well. Yeah, I want to continue to evaluate that
- 1:40:17he's gonna He's practiced there from about you know, practice six through the game
- 1:40:23on Saturday, and when I say practice, you know, ballpark ten snaps
- 1:40:28of each practice. He's a receiver. He came here to play receiver.
- 1:40:30He's going to play receiver. But I do believe with TV timeouts, et
- 1:40:35cetera, the way the game's played now that it's possible for a two way
- 1:40:40player in a limited role, and he has the athleticism to do that,
- 1:40:44and we have a need and so we're gonna do that. Well, We'll
- 1:40:47continue to coach him during the summer on that as part of our OTA workouts,
- 1:40:53and then we're gonna do it in fall camp. And if he continues
- 1:40:55to progress like he's done thus far, then yes, he'll be a two
- 1:40:59way player. Who is the leader, Who's the guy or guys that after
- 1:41:03you give your talk and walk out of the locker room that is going to
- 1:41:08step up and reinforce what you say. Well, we've got quality leadership,
- 1:41:12I think offensively if you look at it, Garrett Green and Wyatt Mile and
- 1:41:16they do, and they both lead in a different manner. But Garrett's earned
- 1:41:20his stripes and he's a charismatic guy. He's very well spoken. Wyatt is
- 1:41:29a leader by example. He sets the standard. Extremely hard worker. There's
- 1:41:31probably not a harder worker on our team. And then on defense, Sean
- 1:41:35Martin and Sean is Is played a lot of football here. He's had some
- 1:41:41adversity he's had to overcome. Extremely intelligent Aubrey Berks has played probably other than
- 1:41:46Wyatt has played the most football of anybody in our locker room. And he
- 1:41:53is beginning to feel more comfortable using his voice. And so those those right
- 1:41:58now are the leader on each side of the ball. And and I feel
- 1:42:02really good about what we've been able to do as far as retention and those
- 1:42:06guys that we've retained that have not only played a lot of football, but
- 1:42:11they're also really good people. And and those guys are now using their voice
- 1:42:15in a proactive way in our locker room and leading, are you going to
- 1:42:18you and your family going to the beach this summer? We will, we
- 1:42:21will be going. We will be going. We're that seems like a long
- 1:42:25time off. We are. We are right in the midst of high school
- 1:42:29softball, middle school softmare, travel soccer, rec league, baseball, and
- 1:42:35so and then uh, you know, we do our tour in May,
- 1:42:39well, we'll do the coaches caravans, we'll tour around and then in June
- 1:42:43it's official visits and camps. So, but in July we will we'll be
- 1:42:46heading to the beach. But that that seems like a long time away right
- 1:42:49now. You get bored at the beach, you know, I don't.
- 1:42:55It's good reset for me. Now I'm not a I'm not a good,
- 1:43:00good, nothing on my schedule guy. So I'll be I'm fine for a
- 1:43:03couple of days and I'll get a little antsy. I like to do things,
- 1:43:09and so it's a good time for me to kind of reset. I
- 1:43:12think changing scenery does that for me. And the beaches. We go consistently
- 1:43:17to the same spot. It's a good reset and I like to read.
- 1:43:21You know, I think that I enjoy reading. It's a you know,
- 1:43:25I think that's the is a way to improve yourself and to really continue to
- 1:43:29grow. And so I do a lot of that at the beach. Luck.
- 1:43:33I hope the game goes well started. Don't get anybody hurt. Don't
- 1:43:35get anybody hurt. That's the case. We don't want to get anybody hurt.
- 1:43:39We want to be entertaining. And I'll tell the fans this is hopefully
- 1:43:43we'll have this locked in and we're gonna have guest coaches for the game,
- 1:43:46and they're going to be prominent West Virginia alumni and and so, and I
- 1:43:54hope we'll have some We'll have a good crowd come and and and to see
- 1:43:58and so I'm excited about that. And we've got a good football team,
- 1:44:02hoppy, we really do. I think we are. We're progressing well,
- 1:44:06and we've got a chance to play great home schedule and so help our fans
- 1:44:11is going to be a nice on Saturday, they come out and get their
- 1:44:13get their first glimpse of what the twenty twenty four Mountaineers are going to look
- 1:44:17like. All right, coach, have fun. Good to talk to you,
- 1:44:20Hobby, Thanks Bessel luck during the politics season. Man, I know
- 1:44:25it's a busy time for you. It is a busy time. It's my
- 1:44:27it's my fault. It's my fault, camp Man. You know all right.
- 1:44:30I'm ready for it to be over, just so quick getting these jump
- 1:44:33text messages on my phone. Thanks coach. Good to talk to you,
- 1:44:36tick here right now? Was pe I A open enrollment? But did you
- 1:44:42know you have options when selecting your pe I A coverage. The Health Plan
- 1:44:45is a West Virginia based option and has been the most trusted carrier for over
- 1:44:49forty years with the pomputer, zero dollar cost for routine lab work and all
- 1:44:54participating lap core locations, and the use of telemedicine through Healthiest You. There
- 1:44:59were rea plans to choose from. Make the health Plan your choice. Remember
- 1:45:03you have a choice with Peia. Choose the health Plan. Log on to
- 1:45:08Healthclan dot org for more information. You're listening to Talkline on Metro News,
- 1:45:12the Voice of West Virginia Wvmetronews dot com the only website you need to stay
- 1:45:20informed in the Mountain State. Get the latest news and sports story information on
- 1:45:25the great outdoors and never miss an episode of your favorite Metro news programs and
- 1:45:30podcast including Talkline, Hotline, sports Line, and Three Guys Before the Game.
- 1:45:34Make a bookmark now and visit do WV metronews dot com first thing every
- 1:45:40morning to find out what's happening all across the state. Wvmetronews dot com.
- 1:45:45West Virginia Outdoors is the Mountain states only hook and bullet radio show dedicated to
- 1:45:50the more than quarter million hunters and anglers across the state. Award winning host
- 1:45:55Chris Lawrence has been tracking down hunting and fishing stories for more than twenty five
- 1:45:59years stockfish for repatriation purposes. So that's reintroduction, re establishment of Brooks trout
- 1:46:04and two of those streams, the oldest that we have worked on, the
- 1:46:09earliest ones that we started putting fish into. We've noticed natural reproduction in both
- 1:46:14of those streams, whether it's hunting and fishing news or just compelling stories about
- 1:46:17the enjoyment of the great outdoors. It was a pretty good fight. It
- 1:46:21taked me about ten minutes to get it in. My dad actually had to
- 1:46:26run to the truck and grab a NAT because there's my way I could lift
- 1:46:29him up over top of the rail. West Virginia Outdoors covers it all Saturday
- 1:46:33mornings at seven oh six am and for your daily fix. Outdoors Today brings
- 1:46:38you two and a half minutes of news and notes from the woods and water
- 1:46:41every weekday morning on Metro News, the Voice of West Virginia. It's two
- 1:46:45hours of sports conversation to wrap up your weekend. It's the city that Sunday
- 1:46:49Night sports Line. Hey, this is Travis Joes joining myself at Greg Hunter
- 1:46:54every Sunday night from six oh six until eight o'clock as we wrap up the
- 1:46:57sports weekend. We talked Mountaineers, High School, out to East Conference,
- 1:47:00and the latest in the national scene. The Sunday Sports Line is listener interactive.
- 1:47:04You could call or text the show at three oh four Talk three oh
- 1:47:09four. It's a perfect weekend sports wrap up on your favorite Metro News affiliate,
- 1:47:13or watch the show at wb Metronews dot com. Well, tempest,
- 1:47:31fugit or fugit however you say tempes fugit All right, got to run,
- 1:47:35Thanks for listening in today and I'll see you tomorrow at ten o six.
- 1:47:40This has been talk Line on Metro News. Metro News is the voice of
- 1:47:44West Virginia.