Latest / The Vegan Report / Psychedelics: the Antidote to Speciesism? With Elin Pöllänen | Ep. 34
Transcript
- 0:00Each time I would get high, I experienced more and more connectedness to life.
- 0:06I experienced empathy in deeper ways than I ever had, and this followed through even
- 0:11to when I was sober.
- 0:13It culminated in an arguably bad trip, where I experienced the life of a factory-caged
- 0:19creature who never saw sunlight or socialized for its whole life.
- 0:24That experience played a large part in going vegan for me, which happened the next week.
- 0:30I stopped eating meat while on a mushroom trip.
- 0:32I was eating chicken and it tasted like ash and death, and I felt an omniscient presence
- 0:38that wanted me to stop, and so I decided that moment to stop eating meat.
- 0:43That was 14 years ago.
- 0:45I became vegan a few months later just as a logical next step.
- 0:48I was confronted with my guilt for eating animals during a psychedelic experience.
- 0:54I didn't immediately go vegan though.
- 0:57I continued to consume animal products until about five months later when I came across
- 1:02Earthling Ed on YouTube, and I decided to go vegan overnight.
- 1:07While my decision did come a while after having that psychedelic experience, I do think it
- 1:12played a major role.
- 1:14I don't know when or if I would have gone vegan had I not had that experience.
- 1:19I watched the Unity documentary on LSD in 2020, the part where it says,
- 1:25When you look in an animal's eyes, you can see that they love their life.
- 1:30They love their life to the same degree that you love your own.
- 1:34I started crying with how beautiful it was.
- 1:38Ever since then, I was vegan.
- 1:41I found the hopeful message of Unity to be more personally inspiring than Earthlings
- 1:46had been.
- 1:47When taking LSD, I feel that veganism is 100% the way to go.
- 1:52It helped me not only stay vegan for the rest of my life, but also to be even more active
- 1:57to help nature and animals.
- 1:59So yeah, the feeling of compassion is real.
- 2:02I mean, LSD was banned for a reason in the 60s and 70s.
- 2:06It got banned because people started taking LSD and stopped supporting the Vietnam War.
- 2:12Of course there were more reasons, but you know.
- 2:15So I'd say LSD and psychedelics will make you rethink your actions as well as make you
- 2:19feel compassion, which then leads you to be more open to veganism, or at least against
- 2:24any kind of violence.
- 2:26Welcome to the Vegan Report.
- 2:28My name is Ryan and today we are going to talk about psychedelics and connecting with
- 2:33nature.
- 2:35For years, I have been hearing stories of people taking psychedelics and being transformed
- 2:41by the experience, overcoming depression or an addiction, overcoming PTSD, stimulating
- 2:48their creativity, and more to the point of this podcast, gaining a sense of connectiveness
- 2:54with nature, a higher level of empathy towards others, including animals, and even a willingness
- 3:02to become vegan.
- 3:04When I hear such stories, I cannot help but think, maybe psychedelics are the powerful
- 3:11ally that the vegan movement needs.
- 3:15Maybe we should fight for them to become legal and more readily available as they might provoke
- 3:21the cultural reset we need to overcome speciesism.
- 3:26To discuss this topic, I have with me Ellen Polanan.
- 3:30She is the co-author of one of the only studies out there examining the link between the use
- 3:36of psychedelics and how we treat animals.
- 3:40The study is titled Classic Psychedelics and Human-Animal Relations, and you can find a
- 3:46link to the study in the description below.
- 3:49But Ellen is more than a researcher, many of you know her as Kelly, a talented musician
- 3:55and singer, in the background of the real life testimonies you heard in the introduction
- 4:01of the episode was playing Crane's, one of her songs.
- 4:05Again, visit the description below to access all of Kelly's music.
- 4:11Ellen welcome to the show, thank you so much for being here.
- 4:13Thank you so much for having me.
- 4:16So I actually don't know much about psychedelics, I never had a psychedelic experience, so my
- 4:22first question for you is what are psychedelics?
- 4:27I must just say before we start that if you would have said to me like 10 years ago that
- 4:34I would be on a podcast talking about psychedelics, I would have laughed in your face because
- 4:39I am not an expert on psychedelics.
- 4:43I am an expert on what I call being annoying, which means that I tend to place myself in
- 4:51rooms and ask questions, shouldn't we look at this?
- 4:56And that is what happened also with my colleagues who are very knowledgeable in psychedelics
- 5:03and that were so kindly inviting me to the discussion and created the study with me where
- 5:11we looked at human relations and psychedelics.
- 5:14So what I really did in this study was to kind of post that question.
- 5:20We knew that previous studies have looked at psychedelics and nature relatedness and
- 5:27there was really a gap there.
- 5:29Why?
- 5:30Because of the testimonies that you shared before, we kind of talked about it but it
- 5:36hadn't really been studied before.
- 5:38So that was kind of an insight that we should probably look at this as well because as many
- 5:45of us know, human relationships with animals has fundamentally changed the surface of our
- 5:53planet in a negative way due to how we treat them and how we imprison billions of them.
- 6:02So a kind of important thing to ask ourselves is how do we change this and what kind of
- 6:09interventions could we use?
- 6:11And that's where psychedelics come in.
- 6:14So psychedelics, today when I kind of historically emailed my colleague, I'm going to talk about
- 6:23psychedelics today.
- 6:24What should I say?
- 6:25I don't know if I remember anything.
- 6:29But then he kind of reminded me, like, you know, you wrote this article, so you know,
- 6:39but if you want to know a fun fact, the word psychedelics come from a Greek, has Greek
- 6:49roots and that stems from kind of being something mind revealing.
- 6:55And that is something that we associate with psychedelics kind of being mind revealing.
- 7:01So from what I've come to learn, what is included in the word psychedelics is still debatable
- 7:13within the scientific community.
- 7:15But in our article, we refer to kind of classic psychedelics, which is a group of psychoactive
- 7:21drugs that can produce changes in perception, mood and cognitive processes in different
- 7:29ways.
- 7:30So in daily terms, that can mean, you know, magic mushrooms or GMT, which is the primary
- 7:38ingredient in ayahuasca.
- 7:41So kind of the ingredients that we know alter our perceptions of reality and our place in
- 7:49reality.
- 7:50So I would say that that is what psychedelics mean.
- 7:54And we can talk about, and that is probably what we're going to talk about in this context,
- 7:59those famous psychoactive ingredients that alter, can alter the way we experience life.
- 8:09I like the fact that you bring the animal rights agenda to your work and use your perspective
- 8:17to ask pertinent questions about important topics.
- 8:22What has been, you know, what have you studied in university?
- 8:26What are your expertise in terms of, you know, your place in that study and your role?
- 8:33I think I've been quite of a hedonist when it comes to studying.
- 8:37I've made my own programs.
- 8:39I first I did a bachelor's program in political science, but I kind of shaped my own program
- 8:48and the courses.
- 8:50I can say like this, that everything I have studied on university has always been with
- 8:57the kind of animal perspectives in the back of my mind.
- 9:00Like how could I use these tools, these research tools or methods or mindsets to carry forth
- 9:10the importance of altering our relationship to animals for the better in a positive way
- 9:16and show the positive consequences that come from that positive transition.
- 9:22So for instance, when I studied public science, I saw the need to kind of, okay, how could
- 9:30we see animals as members of society, even if, for instance, political parties that are
- 9:38based on animal rights often get ridiculed.
- 9:40You can't get kittens to vote.
- 9:42I mean, duh.
- 9:44But how could we make sure that animals are included in the decision-making processes
- 9:55in a rightful way when the decisions really impact their lives?
- 10:00So more about really the rights side of it.
- 10:05So how can we make decisions that really impact animals' lives and not really try to even
- 10:13have them present in the room or have somebody that speaks for them in the room?
- 10:18And how could that be called a democratic process if we do not do so?
- 10:23So those kinds of questions.
- 10:24And also I studied environmental law and philosophy and noticed how easily those classical moral
- 10:34philosophers divide between body and mind and logic and feeling.
- 10:43And those kind of things that are just kind of boring and untrue.
- 10:50So I kind of had that as a perspective with me all along.
- 10:55And it made it quite fun as well, because even if I studied the most really not my cup
- 11:02of tea courses with whatever that might be, I could always think about how could I use
- 11:11these processes to carry forth animal rights or that kind of perspective.
- 11:20So it kind of helped me as well to go through different phases in life.
- 11:27And I also wrote my bachelor's thesis on a kind of I did a discourse analysis of meat
- 11:36consumption in relation to climate change and how that was discussed in the Swedish
- 11:41politics.
- 11:43And that was over 10 years ago.
- 11:45And unfortunately, I don't see a lot of changes in that area.
- 11:50And then I studied public health and learned about quantitative methods, which was horrific,
- 11:59because it was a bit scary to sit there with a computer and doing all these kinds of statistical
- 12:06analysis.
- 12:07But that was really insightful as well to be able to look at research and say, OK, how
- 12:16could I criticize this or how could this be a sane argument?
- 12:25Because there is so much misinformation out there as well.
- 12:28And it's really important to try to get the tools, as much tools as possible, to kind
- 12:34of scrutinize the research out there in its biases.
- 12:40And I tried to do that with my own research as well.
- 12:45Why didn't this could not be true or closer to truth or whatever?
- 12:50We all know there are a lot of research out there saying this and that about plant-based
- 12:56diets and this and that about everything.
- 12:58So just learning about these different methods and the different ways that we calculate what
- 13:04is closest to the truth can be very fruitful in realizing, aha, this is what research means
- 13:11and this is how research can be used in different ways.
- 13:17And in those public health classes, I learned a lot about what was not being said.
- 13:23That is usually the thing that has taught me the most in every academic setting I've
- 13:27been in and also in every research setting I've been in is that there's also something
- 13:33that we learn from what is not being said.
- 13:35So in the public health class, it was we never talked about plant-based diets.
- 13:41We didn't talk about the relationship between climate change and environmental destruction,
- 13:47animal exploitation and human health.
- 13:51We didn't talk about pandemics.
- 13:53I read that on the site because I found that very important and a very important argument
- 14:00to transition from the way we are living now to a way that at least minimizes the risk
- 14:08of future pandemics and epidemics.
- 14:11So really in the heart of everything that I've done academically has always been just
- 14:21a wish to learn more about the world and how I can see it in different ways and how I can
- 14:29learn from that and to bring that into the conversations I have.
- 14:38And I think animal rights have been a very central part in that in the decisions I've
- 14:41made and it's been joyful.
- 14:44We usually talk about the things we have to give up when we talk about animal rights,
- 14:48but I do think it's been just joyful to have that as perspective.
- 14:51It's really helped me to kind of find the passion and motivation to go through those
- 14:58big books.
- 14:59I want to go back to your study and some of the words that you have used in that study
- 15:08that maybe most listeners would not be familiar with.
- 15:12And I want to take the time to maybe define them.
- 15:16So talking about psychedelics, you talk about something called ego dissolution.
- 15:23So what is ego dissolution?
- 15:26It has been found in studies on psychedelic use and it can really be said to be a loss
- 15:34of self-identity, your boundaries, the boundaries between yourself and your surroundings is
- 15:41decreased or absent.
- 15:44It's a feeling of being that is different from the ones that we might know now as the
- 15:52ego that here is where I begin, there is where my surroundings begin.
- 15:57So it's really about dissolving that boundary, a feeling of that boundary being dissolved.
- 16:03And it's a really interesting term.
- 16:08I found it interesting because it made me think about how human exceptionalism is such
- 16:20a common theme in our culture and especially in Western culture, colonial culture.
- 16:28Sorry, Ellen, can you define that?
- 16:30Because in vegan circles, we hear about speciesism, but we don't hear about human exceptionalism
- 16:38that often.
- 16:39Well, it's really linking terms because you can't really have speciesism without human
- 16:44exceptionalism in a way because speciesism is really pushing your species in front of
- 16:51other species and thinking that you're superior.
- 16:54And that could not really be done without human exceptionalism, believing that, well,
- 17:00we are the exception.
- 17:02And I've been in very, very, well, very, no, that's not really an exaggeration.
- 17:08I've been in many rooms, scientific rooms as well, with brilliant minds.
- 17:16But when it comes to human animal relations or the way we relate to each other, there
- 17:25is almost an ideological feeling in the room that, well, this is established.
- 17:33The human exceptionalism is established.
- 17:36Animals don't have culture.
- 17:38Animals don't have languages.
- 17:40Animals don't have this.
- 17:41And usually it is used in a way to describe humanity and the way we humans work.
- 17:49And in many instances, it's very, very wrong, according to the research that we know.
- 17:56So human exceptionalism is a really sociocultural phenomenon that we construct to make it easier
- 18:06to place ourselves above other species.
- 18:09Well, another question I'm dying to ask.
- 18:14Why is the research that we have currently on animals describing them as having personalities
- 18:21and feelings and being complex creatures?
- 18:24Why is it not making any impact on the way we think about them?
- 18:30And I will go as far as to talk about Darwin.
- 18:37Why Darwin's discovery of natural selection have not completely and radically changed
- 18:46our interactions with the natural world, with the rest of the animal kingdom.
- 18:52He's the one who said, and I think you quote him or paraphrase him in the study or in one
- 19:00of your interviews, but he's the one who said the difference between humans and animals
- 19:06is a difference of degrees and not of kind or nature.
- 19:11So why is it not making an impact on the way we think about the world?
- 19:16Wow.
- 19:17If we knew that.
- 19:23I believe that in our, and I think we will come back to this, but I think that the way
- 19:33that we currently, I think that the way I feel, and I think many others feel like that,
- 19:39who fights for animal rights or who is part of the ongoing battle, so to say, is trying
- 19:48to see how could I reach this individual or how could I change this and that.
- 19:54And I think in that insight in wow, how much we could change with just changing the way
- 20:02people eat, for instance, what a tremendous effect and impact that might have.
- 20:07So we focus on the individual and reaching that individual, but I think that is a very
- 20:14important effort, but I do think that sometimes we forget the powerful and resourceful industries
- 20:22that are behind these habits that make up our lives and the enormous amounts of propaganda
- 20:32that has been fed to us and is continuously being fed and that a lot of the decisions
- 20:39that have made a horrendous impact on earth and on public health and on animal health,
- 20:48those decisions have been made in rooms that are closed and that are not made by politicians,
- 20:54but in boards, in economic institutions and businesses.
- 21:01So while I think that a lot of frustration comes from, oh, we could do so much by just
- 21:08changing how individuals think about this and that, I think that we should also remember
- 21:14that the frustration that some of us carry might also be directed to the people in power.
- 21:23Why didn't you have our interest in mind?
- 21:27Because we're normalizing talking about this when it comes to the tobacco industry, but
- 21:36we should normalize talking about this when it comes to all industries because too many
- 21:43free cards have been handed out at the expense of our planet and public health.
- 21:49And I think that is important to remember.
- 21:54And I think when we talk about, for instance, climate change and environmental exploitation,
- 22:04the tendency and the daily rhetoric is that it's an external problem that can be fixed
- 22:11through technology.
- 22:12But I do think that many of us who knows the consequences of technology, which means that
- 22:18the industries are more efficient, which creates a lot of suffering.
- 22:24So we understand the kind of negative sides of technological innovations if it doesn't
- 22:28come with inner dimensions of change.
- 22:33So I think when we talk about climate change, when we talk about animal rights, when we
- 22:37talk about human rights, when we talk about everything that has to do with rights, we're
- 22:42talking about attitudes.
- 22:44We're talking about our internal lives that we manifest on a daily basis.
- 22:51And that can be really hard to change, but we are social animals.
- 22:57We are.
- 22:58And I think that one small transition can create, can do something, can create a domino
- 23:06effect.
- 23:07So I do think that there is a place for hope, but I do think that we also need to remind
- 23:11ourselves that years and years of misinformation and propaganda is behind these daily habits
- 23:21of individuals.
- 23:22And we need interventions and we need people who want this to change and who wants to put
- 23:31our health before profit.
- 23:36And that is also a way to go about it to kind of win people over because when we cause the
- 23:42suffering of billions of animals, we're not putting human health first.
- 23:49Our health is always interconnected.
- 23:51We saw that in the pandemic.
- 23:54So we need to alter that perception and ego dissolution.
- 23:59It can be a way to do that because it can remind people that the boundaries that we
- 24:05have socially and culturally created towards the outside world is not really the way the
- 24:12world works.
- 24:13It's not really the way the world works.
- 24:15And the pandemic was a harsh reminder, but other things can be a harsh reminder as well
- 24:21when the climate starts to change around us or as in my personal experience, the forest
- 24:28in my home village is being turned into clear cuts and I'm very personally affected by this.
- 24:38We are reminded that we know this.
- 24:43We know that we are interconnected with the world around us, even if we are fed with the
- 24:49idea that there is a separation going on.
- 24:54Pets can remind us about this.
- 24:58There's so many reminders.
- 25:00And I think we also write about that in the article about these kind of reminders in our
- 25:06daily lives and in the context where we are that can remind us about this interconnection.
- 25:13It can also feed us with separation.
- 25:16I think one important thing to hold on to is to find these moments of interconnection
- 25:22to guide us forward because I think that is the closest to reality that will ever come
- 25:27as humans.
- 25:29So if I understand well, ego dissolution is about finding back that connection with your
- 25:39environment.
- 25:42Basically that sense that you are separate from the world disappears.
- 25:49I think that ego dissolution is a phenomenon where you feel that that boundary is dissolving.
- 25:56I don't think and it has been linked to different measurements, if I'm not wrong.
- 26:02I think they have seen that it has been associated with well-being, for instance, and positive
- 26:08outcomes.
- 26:10But I'm hesitant to say that ego dissolution is the way to go.
- 26:15But I think it's an interesting phenomenon.
- 26:21And particularly because we are so trained to rather feel the opposite, to feel a separation.
- 26:32So that was what kind of sucked me into the concept.
- 26:35Oh, that's intriguing.
- 26:37It's something I love breaking barriers.
- 26:40So when I heard that, I was like, oh, you have my attention, ego dissolution.
- 26:46But yeah, so yeah.
- 26:52Well that's why I think that psychedelics are an interesting prospect for activists,
- 26:58because I'm not sure you can reach that goal of connecting people with nature just by the
- 27:06Socratic method of stopping people in the streets and debating them about veganism.
- 27:13Like we see it with the cube of truth.
- 27:17I think there are as many ways as there are people.
- 27:19I think you can reach people in many, many different ways.
- 27:23I think we can all do it in our own way just by being who we are in the context that we
- 27:28are.
- 27:29I think one of the most important insights that I got from the psychedelic study was
- 27:33that context is so important.
- 27:36Context and mindset.
- 27:40It would also be a bit risky to say that psychedelic would act as a kind of quick fix, because
- 27:47I know that we humans, we tend to also in our culture, we tend to look at, oh, quick
- 27:55fix.
- 27:56How can I quick fix this?
- 27:58And that is also a risk that we culturally appropriate, that we exploit just to get to
- 28:06that lesson that we need to learn to move forward.
- 28:11I think we need to also sit in the discomfort of what has been done and how can we do better
- 28:22and create contexts that really help us see the positive impacts of human-animal nature
- 28:29relations.
- 28:30For instance, after psychedelic experience, people are very vulnerable to stimuli.
- 28:36What happens if you go on a spiritual ego-dissolving journey or whatever we should call it, and
- 28:43then you come back into your daily life and you're still met with the individualized pieces
- 28:52of products that animals represent in the store, for instance?
- 28:56What happens when you're constantly fed with that kind of division again and that kind
- 29:03of culture again?
- 29:07It's really about context, I believe.
- 29:10If you're open to it in the beginning or if you have a community where that kind of way
- 29:17of looking at animals is more accessible and possible.
- 29:26I do think context is really the key in this study as well, that just enabling for other
- 29:33relationships with animals that are more positive and less de-individualized and more nuanced
- 29:41could really do something.
- 29:43If you add psychedelics in there, wow, the results might be very fascinating and very
- 29:50effective.
- 29:51But also if you add music in there or if you add whatever ingredient in that context, who
- 29:58knows?
- 30:00We could have made ourselves a transformative community just by creating those kind of ingredients.
- 30:06Of course, I'm thinking about the 1960s and 70s and how psychedelics were used and
- 30:14what was the impact on the society of that time.
- 30:19It's fascinating.
- 30:20There was an explosion of culture and art and music.
- 30:28Some of the best singers we can think of were born from that era.
- 30:37Also we get stories of scientists who have used psychedelics from that time to make breakthroughs.
- 30:49We have a model of what society looked like with a more accessible use of psychedelics.
- 30:58Yeah, that's super interesting.
- 31:04That was the introduction of an article I read.
- 31:07I remember when I was writing the article, it was about that and the music and the pro-environmentalism
- 31:15that was occurring at the same time was the psychedelic movement and the environmental
- 31:20movement went alongside.
- 31:23That's really interesting for sure.
- 31:26Yes, I have the image of hippies in mind.
- 31:33I want to quickly go back to the hostile forces, to those ideas.
- 31:41When you said that you studied environmental science, I think, environmental law, and in
- 31:50the context of your studies, there was no mention of pandemics.
- 31:55I thought about the risk that factory farming poses on public health in terms of zoonotic
- 32:01diseases.
- 32:03Then I thought, okay, do you believe that academic institutions that you visited from
- 32:17which you got your education were in a way captured by the agriculture industry or big
- 32:27corporation or I don't want to get conspirational here, but I want to ask you that question
- 32:36still.
- 32:37I'm going to answer that by saying something that has nothing to do with it.
- 32:44When I graduated from upper secondary school, which also was a political science focused
- 32:53program, I said to my teacher that I wanted to focus on animal rights in going forward
- 33:03to the university.
- 33:04She was like, oh, that's such a shame.
- 33:06You were so good at human rights.
- 33:10I think that is still the way that most people live their lives because that is the way that
- 33:20we are being taught from day one to make that separation.
- 33:28Really what many, many researchers before me have been saying for a long time, not just
- 33:34researchers but poets and artists, is that that is really not true.
- 33:42That is not the way we live our lives.
- 33:45But it's still very present because I think that what happens in academia, and I don't
- 33:51think it's a willful ignorance.
- 33:55I don't think so.
- 33:56I think it's just because we have created academia in a way that makes it very accessible
- 34:06in a way that we make these boxes and this is what we should learn and this is how reality
- 34:10looks like.
- 34:11That is one purpose of research, to make it easier to categorize and to do all these things.
- 34:19But I do think that issues that have to do with animal rights have been drowned a bit.
- 34:28It has been hard to reach the surface for many different reasons.
- 34:35But I can't really, I do think it's just cultural.
- 34:39I do think that we are trained to say, we will deal with that later.
- 34:46We haven't figured this thing out yet, so we will deal with that later.
- 34:50Or it's not as relevant as talking about tobacco and alcohol, for instance, when it came to
- 34:54the public health program, which in a way is really important to talk about.
- 35:00But it's also important to talk about diets and the way that animal exploitation is really
- 35:07harmful to all of us and especially for the often marginalized communities living close
- 35:12by or for the people working within these horrible institutions that suffer, many suffer
- 35:21from PTSD, for instance.
- 35:22So I think it's still seen as a bit of a marginalized or very, very specific subject, animal rights
- 35:32or things that has to do with animals, when it really is just ingrained in our lives in
- 35:36most things that we talk about.
- 35:38A lot of things we have in our homes are made from animals.
- 35:42We don't even think about it or people who live, we can think about it.
- 35:46But normally we don't stop and go, wait, this candle, is that?
- 35:54And I've worked because I was also part of a research project that looked at the pandemic
- 36:04and its consequences and I was part of a team where I again said, well, what about the way
- 36:11we treat animals and the reason why we have a pandemic?
- 36:15Why aren't we talking about that?
- 36:17And my colleagues said, here, here, that is what we want to look at.
- 36:21So we did that.
- 36:22And we collaborated with one of the founders of One Health in Sweden.
- 36:27And One Health is a concept that looks at the interconnectedness in health between humans,
- 36:32animals and the environment.
- 36:36And he told me that years before the COVID-19 pandemic, I don't remember if it was one year
- 36:44or if it was a time before the pandemic arrived to Sweden, that he wanted to have a seminar
- 36:52to politicians talking about the risks of a pandemic happening linked to the way we
- 36:58treat animals.
- 37:00And he has been specializing in bird flu and things like that.
- 37:06But he really wanted to have a seminar to kind of inform politicians about the risks
- 37:12of future pandemics, which he found to be bound to happen due to the way that the world
- 37:20is functioning right now.
- 37:23And there was not a lot of interest.
- 37:27And he even had a book about pandemics that was completely covered in dust there on the
- 37:35bookshelf.
- 37:36And then the pandemic happened and the interest just skyrocketed.
- 37:43And that is kind of an example of how I think these voices have always, the voices of resistance
- 37:50have always been there.
- 37:52It's just very hard for them to be heard because there are so many other things that are
- 37:56pushed forward to be prioritized.
- 38:00And especially in a world where we are trained to not see that connection, it's not seen
- 38:06as the most important subjects to look at because, well, I do think it's not a willful
- 38:17act.
- 38:18I do just think that it is just the way the world works because of how we've been trained
- 38:25to think.
- 38:27And sadly, in institutions where great minds are, we all have blind spots.
- 38:33I have my blind spots, we all have them.
- 38:37And they are more easy to have when we're trained to walk with the cognitive dissonance
- 38:42all day long.
- 38:47You make the point in, I think, the introduction of the study that people who have a sensitivity
- 38:54towards animals, who care about animal rights, are also people who are less likely to be
- 39:04criminals, to be intolerant, to be abusive.
- 39:12And the opposite is true when we think about animal abusers.
- 39:17There's this image, a cliche of the murderer, the serial killer, then, was torturing animals
- 39:27during his childhood.
- 39:29And when we talk about sexism, who are the first to kill and abuse animals?
- 39:38And so many, for instance, dogs in shelters will be afraid of human men and will only
- 39:50interact with human females.
- 39:55And I feel like it's just there.
- 40:00People are conscious of it, but they're just not making the connection.
- 40:04They're not able to step beyond that cognitive dissonance you're talking about.
- 40:13The last push is not there.
- 40:17So yeah.
- 40:21In that type of research, I think I've read a lot of Aisha Akhtar's work, and I must say
- 40:28that I really recommend everyone reading her work, because she talks a lot about, especially
- 40:35from a public health view, how human rights are connected to animal rights and those relations
- 40:44that you were talking about, for instance, through abuse and violence.
- 40:50And how I've come to think of it is that the key element in all this, I think, is the role
- 41:00of dehumanization or the de-individualization.
- 41:04If you animalize someone, which we do with animals, but we also do with other groups
- 41:09of people, it's easier to not see how these individuals, how you can inflict pain in these
- 41:18individuals, or how if something happens to their bodies or violence or whatever, you
- 41:28kind of discredit or you ignore the sensations that these individuals can have.
- 41:34So I think the key element in this is dehumanization and how those processes work.
- 41:43And cognitive dissonance is also a coping mechanism.
- 41:53So if your values and your actions, they conflict what to do.
- 42:03And parts of that answer can be that, well, if that individual that I'm doing this to
- 42:12is not really an individual, then this gap doesn't exist anymore.
- 42:16So in our very high human intelligence, we have a lot of ways to rationalize bad behavior
- 42:24or rationalize things to ourselves to make us feel better.
- 42:29And I do think an important part of moving forward is to get the tools to look at ourselves
- 42:39and sit in that discomfort and just be, okay, what have I been taught and what have I learned?
- 42:46And do I have dehumanizing tendencies or do I have blind spots or whatever?
- 42:52And I do think that doing that as a society and as a community could be really healing
- 42:57and could be really transformative.
- 43:00Continuing on, by the way, the term de-individualizing, I love it.
- 43:11One of my new favorite terms now.
- 43:15Another term you used in the study and that I want you to define is something you call
- 43:23the biophilia hypothesis.
- 43:25So what is that about?
- 43:28Well, that is really a term that emphasizes the human innate need to connect with the
- 43:38natural world.
- 43:42And has been suggested, inspired by that term, that nature connectedness, to feel connected
- 43:50with nature is a human need even.
- 43:53So it's really a term that wants to say that we have a need to connect with the natural
- 44:04world.
- 44:05And this need might not only be physical, but also spiritual.
- 44:11And it can have many, it can have nuances to it.
- 44:14So it can also be a very spiritual term and kind of psychological term as well.
- 44:23And as we've talked about, I do think that there's something that we experience, even
- 44:32though I know you said that we've kind of built away a lot of nature and we kind of
- 44:37created a human world in a sense.
- 44:42I think just going on the subway in town can be a really good reminder that you cannot
- 44:49build away nature in a way.
- 44:51Nature is always there.
- 44:52You can just alter the way nature looks like.
- 44:57But we never live in human worlds.
- 45:00We always live in interconnected worlds with a multi-species world with nature.
- 45:06And just like standing on the subway and the pigeon walks in and you're like, okay, there
- 45:10you are.
- 45:11How nice, how lovely.
- 45:12And you can join us and then the pigeon, the group of pigeons stand there for a couple
- 45:16of stops and then they just walk out.
- 45:18And I think those instances are lovely reminders of that we can try with humans.
- 45:25And I don't think that is a goal.
- 45:27I think that is a horrible goal, but we can try to kind of build our human world.
- 45:34But the world would just remind us like, hello, here I am.
- 45:40And I find that just wonderful.
- 45:44And I think during the pandemic, the biophilia hypothesis was probably experienced by a lot
- 45:52of people.
- 45:53So for instance, people who couldn't...
- 45:55In Sweden, we had the fortune to not be as restricted in our movements.
- 45:58So we could go outside, for instance.
- 46:01And a lot of us went to the forest to reflect and to help us distress and to mirror ourselves
- 46:09in another kind of a more...
- 46:12A reality that is more still and peaceful.
- 46:17And also for the people who had to be inside, research has shown that if they had a tree
- 46:22they could look at, it helped them to kind of establish this connection to the natural
- 46:27world anyway and feel less isolated.
- 46:32And all those research says, showing that if you have a tree outside of your hospital
- 46:37window, it helps you feel faster.
- 46:41And all of these things, I think really just pinpoint what that hypothesis is trying to
- 46:45say that we have this innate need, even if we have created somewhat a culture that is
- 46:57based upon this human exceptionalism and based on this kind of separation of nature and culture
- 47:02and animals and humans, that we have this need.
- 47:10And when we really realize that, I think we need to in these times, we need to realize
- 47:19that the time to really act on this need is now because we are doing so much to this planet
- 47:28that we will regret and that will have consequences for also our health, for instance, deforestation
- 47:35and environmental degradation and all of these things.
- 47:43I think I've read a Danish interview or what it was that inspired me to write my lyrics
- 47:49for O and it was that he had been biking with his son and he had not been experiencing the
- 47:57insects in the same way that he had summers before.
- 48:01Just these minor changes in the way we experience life when these change, we will miss the interactions
- 48:06we had with other animals.
- 48:08We will miss it because it is information that we receive and that make up our lives,
- 48:13but we take them for granted.
- 48:16So when the birds silence, we will know and we will miss it.
- 48:22So I do think that it's time to act on this kind of thesis now more than ever.
- 48:31By the way, oh, my favorite song of yours.
- 48:52I'm just realizing in how much of a mess we are talking with you.
- 49:10Oh no.
- 49:11No, in the sense of how chaotic and nonsensical our situation is.
- 49:22Because, yes, I agree that we feel a need to connect with nature.
- 49:30I absolutely agree with the biophilia hypothesis, the premise of that theory.
- 49:41But you talked about the pandemic and how people went hiking a lot.
- 49:49And that is something we also experience in Canada.
- 49:53People instead of going to Southern America, where they usually go for vacation, went and
- 50:00visited our national parks.
- 50:04But then there was a big scandal about how the national park were getting lots of garbage
- 50:15and nature was getting destroyed and trees were being cut and it started lots of fires.
- 50:27And from an individual perspective, we want to live near a forest or near a park or a
- 50:36garden and our houses that are near green zones are worth more on the market.
- 50:46But if we see a spider in the kitchen or we get all crazy and we want to kill it and we
- 50:57don't like mosquitoes and we're intolerant of any kind of...
- 51:10Like if it's too sunny, we complain.
- 51:13If there's too much rain, we start to complain.
- 51:17We're always complaining about nature.
- 51:21And so there is that and then there's the whole aspect of, like you mentioned, like
- 51:30we talked before, we understand that there is a link between us and the natural world,
- 51:39that we are part of the animal kingdom.
- 51:43We have so much data and studies backing up the fact that animals are sentient.
- 51:47But then we have this big cognitive dissonance and we're not able to take the leap.
- 51:58And so I find myself being in wonder of how much, again, nonsensical our attitude and
- 52:09behaviors are.
- 52:11Yeah, it's so interesting what you're saying because that is one of the things that I think
- 52:20you realize when you read human animal studies or attitudes to animals, that they can be
- 52:26so contra-intuitive and just conflicting in themselves, that they can be very ambivalent
- 52:37and why do we eat that animal and not this, and very culturally linked just to habit or
- 52:46class or status or whatever.
- 52:49And it's so interesting what you said with the kind of opposite to having a need for
- 52:56nature, that the kind of the fear of nature, which is really interesting now when we talk
- 53:01about the pandemic, because that was one of the risks that we saw when we did explore
- 53:07the consequences of the pandemic in relation to human animal nature relations is that in
- 53:14the word that we use, or not we, but the governments use or doctors use or whatever, animals and
- 53:22nature can be seen as threats to human health.
- 53:29And how does that alter our willingness to protect animals and nature if they are a threat
- 53:35to us?
- 53:36And that is a problem because usually when an animal poses a threat to us, for instance,
- 53:42if a bat population has a disease that can be transmitted to humans, the standard is,
- 53:51oh, we should kill all the bats.
- 53:55But maybe the problem why the infection was easily transmitted to us in the first place
- 54:01was because we destroyed the habitat of the bats.
- 54:07So what we really should do is that we should protect bats.
- 54:12And in today's world, that can be very counterintuitive also because of the relations that we created
- 54:16with animals that are very based on anthropocentric means and what is good for us humans and animals
- 54:24being a function to us humans.
- 54:26Why should we protect something that wants to kill us?
- 54:31So I really see an importance here in getting the message out to people.
- 54:38And a more nuanced way of seeing our relationship to animals means, okay, the risk exists, but
- 54:48why?
- 54:50And if we think about the animal perspective and the animal life, a suitable measure should
- 54:56not be to kill all the individuals.
- 54:59It might be to protect its habitat and make sure that they have a space where they can
- 55:04be.
- 55:05So we tend to see, when we talk about fear and we talk about those kinds of things, and
- 55:11it's a valid fear because infectious diseases are increasing in this world, we usually tend
- 55:19to double punish the animals that have these infections and not maybe think about ourselves
- 55:24as the problem.
- 55:25Usually we are the problem because we've built away their natural environments and that means
- 55:32that they live closer to us.
- 55:35So I do think that it's really important, especially after the pandemic, where there
- 55:41is a risk that we can talk about animals as a risk to human health and also nature as
- 55:45risks to human health, to really understand that we can create a kind of movement that
- 55:59shows politicians or decision makers that we are not okay with calling as an option
- 56:07for treating this problem because we as a community or whatever, we want to create buffer
- 56:17zones that decreases the risk of transmission and that can mean keeping that forest intact,
- 56:24for instance, or maybe not building houses where bats live, for instance.
- 56:30So I think the fear that we feel towards animals, especially here in the Western world, especially
- 56:39in Sweden, where we have been quite fortunate with diseases and things like that, is that
- 56:48it has...
- 56:49Oh, they can't come here.
- 56:50We've had the problem with wild boars and in Norway, they just killed everyone off.
- 56:56And here in Sweden, they tried to restrict the area in which the disease is.
- 57:02But also here, we have a very active forest industry that clear cuts a lot of natural
- 57:12areas where the animals live.
- 57:15So I do think that that fear that animals live where we live and that fear might guide
- 57:25us to something.
- 57:26It might guide us to, yes, because we are not letting them have their space.
- 57:35I think just creating a more positive relationship with animals also come with...
- 57:39Like in every healthy relationship, it comes with knowing when do I have to give you space?
- 57:47How can I create a safe space for you and I to function?
- 57:51I do think we need to see it more as a personal relationship to understand, but it takes of
- 58:00us to transform.
- 58:04So it was really interesting what you said, because a lot of what I've been reading recently
- 58:09is about that fear messaging or risk messaging and the negative consequences that might come
- 58:16from that.
- 58:17Yeah.
- 58:18Thanks.
- 58:19Well, also, I would be remiss not to mention how in the vegan community, but also everywhere,
- 58:32the word nature and natural comes with a positive perception.
- 58:39So we want natural products and it's not very scientific because in a way, everything is
- 58:47natural.
- 58:49What do you mean by this is natural?
- 58:53What do you make of the use or misuse of the term natural to sell products, to cast a positive
- 59:06light on something?
- 59:11It has become kind of an accessory for capitalism and for big corporations.
- 59:18Yes.
- 59:19For sure.
- 59:20It is kind of a rabbit hole, isn't it?
- 59:25Or natural.
- 59:27It throws you out.
- 59:31When you phrased that question, I was like, wow, that could be an endless or just like
- 59:36a 24-hour discussion just about the world natural and how it's so ingrained in so many
- 59:42things.
- 59:43Well, I was also thinking of that ad.
- 59:46I don't know if you watched that ad of Apple inviting Mother Nature to their headquarters.
- 59:54You have Tim Cook, who's the CEO of Apple, talking with Mother Nature about how Apple
- 1:00:02is great and has a great relationship with nature and is environmentally friendly.
- 1:00:10Mother Nature congratulates them for being a wonderful, environmentally friendly company,
- 1:00:20which they are not.
- 1:00:21They are absolutely not.
- 1:00:22That sounds super surrealistic.
- 1:00:24That sounds so surreal.
- 1:00:27I haven't heard of it.
- 1:00:30I just think about it because now I'm very active in the kind of the forest movement
- 1:00:37here in Sweden trying to come by clear cuts.
- 1:00:39I'm very into that area right now.
- 1:00:43That might be why I'm constantly moving in that direction.
- 1:00:46The word natural is a very problematic term there as well because a forest is seen as
- 1:00:53something that is renewable, which in a sense, okay, understandable.
- 1:00:58You can cut down a tree and it grows up again, but then you tend to miss the fact that a
- 1:01:04forest comes with an ecosystem, comes with something that has been growing and living
- 1:01:12and developing there for hundreds and hundreds of years, and that is now renewable.
- 1:01:20There's a really ongoing trend here in Sweden, I think all over the world, that Sweden wants
- 1:01:25to pose itself as a very, very environmentally friendly country with, we have these solutions
- 1:01:31for this.
- 1:01:32It's a commercial on TV that you can replace everything with trees, with wood.
- 1:01:39They just walk around with everything is made from a tree and then you just think, okay,
- 1:01:47there the old growth forest went like this because we barely have anything left.
- 1:01:52What's left is fields of trees of production, which is not a forest.
- 1:02:02It's the typical way that we are trained to think as consumers or as citizens that we
- 1:02:12are, I'm going to use one of your new favorite terms now, de-individualizing.
- 1:02:17We are also de-spiritualizing places and individuals and not seeing the forest for its arrays of
- 1:02:27relationships and networks and things that we have barely started to care about and explore
- 1:02:36that are being destroyed due to the forest industry.
- 1:02:41We are just learning to see the trees.
- 1:02:44There's one tree, there's a second tree, and we're not really being trained to see the
- 1:02:48relationship these trees have with each other and all the species that live there and everything
- 1:02:54that has been growing and et cetera, et cetera.
- 1:02:57This is another example of when we are trained to just commodify life into product.
- 1:03:06When we look at a product and we see, oh, natural, it's made out of trees from blah,
- 1:03:10blah, blah, it's certified.
- 1:03:14The more I learn, the more disappointed I get in these labels.
- 1:03:20I get sad because I wish they were true.
- 1:03:24I wish that the certifying sustainable forestry, this notepad was made from a certified sustainable
- 1:03:34forestry and I know what that means.
- 1:03:36I've seen the clear cuts.
- 1:03:39It's not sustainable.
- 1:03:43It really needs to happen something and I think we need to demand as consumers, unfortunately,
- 1:03:50that's the way the economy works.
- 1:03:51We need to demand that for more transparency within the industry.
- 1:03:55I mean, to use natural, but to use harvested meat, just to use these terms that makes us
- 1:04:04forget that these animals were born, raised, and killed in these industries, for instance,
- 1:04:10it's a very, very... It can be an efficient way to make us forget where things come from.
- 1:04:21That products, that resources were taken to create something, even if it's natural or
- 1:04:33more sustainable, it still took something for that product to end up there.
- 1:04:41It's not a very popular view, especially not in a capitalist society, but to use less perhaps.
- 1:04:53I don't think we will save the world by driving electric cars.
- 1:04:57I'm sorry.
- 1:04:59I don't think so, but I think that is what is more profitable for the system that we
- 1:05:09live in, but it's not better for us.
- 1:05:12Absolutely not.
- 1:05:14But yeah, the word natural can be a very efficient label, for sure.
- 1:05:24Clean also, clean, green, what else?
- 1:05:29Non-gibble, whatever, everything, every label is... It's hard to be a consumer these days.
- 1:05:36It's really hard.
- 1:05:37That's why we need to put pressure on governments and companies, because individuals can do
- 1:05:43a lot of work, but it's impossible to do all the work.
- 1:05:47I guess they are literally capitalizing on our bio-failure, our needs to be close to
- 1:05:55nature.
- 1:05:56Yeah, sure.
- 1:05:57Sure.
- 1:05:58They have recognized that, and instead of making reforms in culture, they instead wanted
- 1:06:02to use it to make profits for their company.
- 1:06:05Yeah.
- 1:06:06Instead of doing better, and instead of doing things that actually is positive for that
- 1:06:13term, they just say, we know you care about this, but you should also not care about it.
- 1:06:19Yes, it's a bit psychopathic.
- 1:06:27If I had to go to the essence of your study, I get the sense that you consider psychedelics
- 1:06:36as maybe a way to get clarity in the middle of this confusion and those lies and this
- 1:06:47senselessness, clarity about our place in the world and about who we are.
- 1:06:56It goes against cultural norms and understandings of psychedelics, because we believe psychedelics,
- 1:07:03I think most people, to be something akin to alcohol, it makes you confused and it makes
- 1:07:12you lose your mind.
- 1:07:19You're not a serious person if you take psychedelics, but instead you're making the point that, no,
- 1:07:29this will bring us clarity or this might bring us clarity.
- 1:07:34Yeah.
- 1:07:37I would perhaps say that psychedelics should be further explored, because this is just
- 1:07:45the beginning.
- 1:07:46We don't know enough to really say anything else than that, huh, we found an association.
- 1:07:53This might be worthy of further investigation, really, if it might be an intervention to
- 1:08:01alter perceptions and alter human animal relations also in a long lasting way, because we don't
- 1:08:07have any longitudinal data.
- 1:08:11We don't have any long-term data, so we don't really know.
- 1:08:13We just know what the participants recall.
- 1:08:18It can be also a bit of a self-reporting bias there, that people want to feel connected.
- 1:08:27We really need to see more studies that show, okay, so people feel an increased connection,
- 1:08:35but does that translate into the way they live their lives in long term and how they
- 1:08:41behave after a while?
- 1:08:43We don't really know.
- 1:08:45We did see some associations with animal solidarity and also with, what was it, speciesism, lower
- 1:08:59speciesism or negative effects with speciesism.
- 1:09:03We did see associations that showed that, okay, it can alter human animal relations,
- 1:09:10but again, what my colleagues really want to emphasize as well, and I know they want
- 1:09:16to, so I have to emphasize it again, is that, and I believe this as well, it is really context
- 1:09:22dependent.
- 1:09:27Previous studies have seen that, for instance, if people do psychedelics in nature, that
- 1:09:31can increase their relatedness to nature because it's made in a nature setting, et cetera,
- 1:09:38in a more wild or non-human setting.
- 1:09:43Nature is everywhere.
- 1:09:48I think the core of the article is really, again, I think a lot can be seen in what we
- 1:09:57can say.
- 1:09:59I think it's really interesting that we don't have enough answers about this, even despite
- 1:10:08the fact that it is so important to change these relations that we have with animals
- 1:10:13because they do really alter the world and health and everything, and a lot of things.
- 1:10:26How can we not, to this day, have more studies on interventions that can alter these relations?
- 1:10:35How can we not know more how we can efficiently try to transform these relationships into
- 1:10:42a more positive one?
- 1:10:44I think that is the most fundamental question in all of this, and that the psychedelic study,
- 1:10:52I love discussions and articles.
- 1:10:55I do love the discussions, and I do like the discussion in this article because there we
- 1:10:59can talk about, okay, ego dissolution, but not lifetime classic psychedelic use was positively
- 1:11:06associated with the desire to help animals.
- 1:11:10What can that mean?
- 1:11:12That might mean that it has something to do with that our coping or defense mechanisms,
- 1:11:21for instance, cognitive dissonance, is decreased because our ego, our ego's, our boundaries
- 1:11:29are dissolving, and we are not as inclined to have these win and lose mentality and this
- 1:11:36kind of notion of human exceptionalism.
- 1:11:40We don't lose our humanness by seeing that animals have their own lives, for instance,
- 1:11:46and their own personalities, for instance.
- 1:11:48We can re-individualize animals again because it doesn't make us less of who we are.
- 1:11:55Maybe we don't know, but that is one of the things that we talk about in the discussion
- 1:12:00that I really like is how can psychedelics, as one of many interventions, help us to instead
- 1:12:10see the win-win situations in improving our relationship with animals and having enriched
- 1:12:16and respectful relationship with animals and nature.
- 1:12:24Another thing that I find really puzzling with the study and just by studying human
- 1:12:29behavior and attitudes is that our connection with nature, what does that mean?
- 1:12:40It can mean a lot of things.
- 1:12:41We haven't really pinpointed what that means to every individual who has answered the survey.
- 1:12:46It can mean to feel connected, but what does it mean, as I said, with how you live your
- 1:12:54life or in some ways connection can be experienced as also a separation.
- 1:13:03I feel a connection with nature, but I'm not part of nature.
- 1:13:07How does that work?
- 1:13:09I'm very fascinated with these kind of mindsets that we carry and how they translate into
- 1:13:16the world and how interventions such as psychedelics can help us get insight into these cognitive
- 1:13:23processes that we all carry because it's very fascinating.
- 1:13:27They seem complex.
- 1:13:34That is my takeaway from the article.
- 1:13:37I do hope that more research will show more long-term answers.
- 1:13:46Blogitudinal studies would be amazing and also looking at other interventions other
- 1:13:51than psychedelics, maybe just community-based also interventions would be amazing just because
- 1:14:00we do think that the context and setting is so important.
- 1:14:05What happens when we mix all these ingredients?
- 1:14:07Could that alter people's mindsets?
- 1:14:11Could that make people feel like the threshold to change their behaviors is lower, is easier,
- 1:14:18more accessible?
- 1:14:19That is really the question that I had and I carry forth in this article, those kind
- 1:14:26of questions.
- 1:14:27I'm happy you're making that point because just from anecdotes, I know that there are
- 1:14:36plenty of people out there who are big fans of psychedelics.
- 1:14:43Psychedelics have made a great impact, transformative impact in their lives, but they are the opposite
- 1:14:51of a vegan or an environmentalist in a way.
- 1:14:56I'm thinking here about Joe Rogan.
- 1:15:01We're recording a podcast.
- 1:15:04The king of podcasting is of course Joe Rogan and he is infamous for being against vegans
- 1:15:12and against eating a plant-based diet.
- 1:15:16He thinks it's unhealthy and he's all about hunting.
- 1:15:21Yet at the same time, he talks a lot about psychedelics and how that transformed him
- 1:15:28and made him more receptive to the world, more empathic.
- 1:15:35He goes on and on about the importance of psychedelics in his life.
- 1:15:42He talks about it as something spiritual.
- 1:15:47It's hard to understand how can someone go through such a profound experience and still
- 1:16:00finds sadistic pleasure in hunting, killing, and eating animals.
- 1:16:07That is something that we did discuss.
- 1:16:19Some research suggests that you can also strengthen the connections already existing or your mindset
- 1:16:25is very important when you go through this experience.
- 1:16:29Even if you can feel a sense of dissolving your boundaries, again, the context seems
- 1:16:36to be very important and also the mindset that you already carry.
- 1:16:43As you said, maybe he had different goals.
- 1:16:49Sometimes I think that is just typical of the way we handle things in our society.
- 1:16:56I read an interesting article that talked about mac-mindfulness, how we kind of integrated
- 1:17:05yoga into the Western culture.
- 1:17:08That has also been created some kind of mindfulness practices, some kind of quick fix.
- 1:17:17There are so many instances for you here in places like, I meditate 20 minutes a day to
- 1:17:23get the optimal results of this.
- 1:17:28It's still in this kind of context of production and capitalism and hustle culture and whatever.
- 1:17:37It feels like the context is really important.
- 1:17:48Harps and prejudice, they come with harmful things also for the people who are seen as
- 1:17:59having more power.
- 1:18:01It feels like the goals that you set when you have that role as people call them alpha
- 1:18:11males or like a toxic masculinity.
- 1:18:16You should be this and do that.
- 1:18:18It's very restrictive as well.
- 1:18:25I wish that his experiences might have been, oh, I can be the interconnectedness of liberation
- 1:18:36and if I'm free and they're free and we're all free.
- 1:18:40But no, I did this and I feel more open now so I can do these and these goals.
- 1:18:47It feels like a way of using something to move forward and it doesn't have to mean inner
- 1:18:56work.
- 1:18:57That might also be a really important point that maybe the reason why you consume psychedelics
- 1:19:06is important in the first place, just also with the context.
- 1:19:13There are people from Western culture traveling to these small villages where they have practices
- 1:19:22and have been doing these practices, for instance, ayahuasca for many, many, many years, hundreds
- 1:19:27of years.
- 1:19:28They have that rooted in their culture and their community and individuals consume it
- 1:19:36individually and might not focus on the experience of the community, for instance.
- 1:19:44That might be the case locally, traditionally.
- 1:19:50What does that do with us when we still have that individual anthropocentric way of consuming
- 1:19:58something?
- 1:19:59Can that really then alter our minds or is the context so important that we need to invest
- 1:20:07in the community first to create a safe space?
- 1:20:12Those are questions I don't have the answer to, but I do think that they are very important.
- 1:20:16I do think that when we talk about psychedelics, that cultural misappropriation and also exploitation
- 1:20:22of these cultures are important to talk about because it's a risk due to the history of
- 1:20:32colonialism and due to the ongoing colonialism that we are seeing.
- 1:20:39There are many, many, many things that we could talk about in terms of this article.
- 1:20:48Your explanation has truly helped me to understand why he behaves that way.
- 1:20:57The mindfulness analogy speaks to me as a Buddhist.
- 1:21:02I see the difference between the meditation that is taught by monks who have to meditate
- 1:21:11for 10 years before having the privilege to teach meditation to students versus people
- 1:21:19here in the West who go through a six-month certification program to be able to host meditation
- 1:21:32classes for anyone who wants to advance or have better mental health or something like
- 1:21:39that.
- 1:21:40Then the meditation I have learned from monks is much more profound in its purpose, in its
- 1:21:49intention, in its goals than the meditation we find on apps.
- 1:21:58It truly speaks to me that difference.
- 1:22:04It's weird how meditation is also a practice of ego dissolution, at least the way I see
- 1:22:13meditation.
- 1:22:14It's all about disappearing.
- 1:22:20I find the link between that and also psychedelics interesting.
- 1:22:26It can be really hard for individuals to...
- 1:22:36I think it's hard in this society because it's easy to think that our value is just
- 1:22:46related to our productivity.
- 1:22:49The transformative processes that we do, like meditation, whenever the end goal is just
- 1:22:55to increase our productivity, what happens?
- 1:23:00What happens with the practice?
- 1:23:01What happens to our experience of ourselves and things like that?
- 1:23:07It's really context dependent.
- 1:23:10It can be hard to lose those shackles that capitalists put on us that we are just worthy
- 1:23:20when we're productive.
- 1:23:22Also in these age of social media, when the doing is unfocused, it can be really hard.
- 1:23:29It's not easy.
- 1:23:30LR Well, there was a monk who once said, I remember,
- 1:23:37he said, you can be a mindful assassin.
- 1:23:40It's possible.
- 1:23:42If you're not taking the practice as a whole, it doesn't make sense.
- 1:23:48But yeah, here we go.
- 1:23:52Another practice that might promote a connection with nature is music.
- 1:24:02When I think about the history of music, I think of, for instance, the muse.
- 1:24:09I had the experience of visiting Greece and the Greek ruins and temples.
- 1:24:17At some point, we visited a cave at the top of a mountain and it was surrounded with forests.
- 1:24:27We were told that this is the cave of the muse and the muse inhabits the forests surrounding
- 1:24:39us or something like that, if I remember correctly.
- 1:24:45But I remember very clearly being a bit surprised by it because for me, music was synonymous
- 1:24:54with civilization and culture.
- 1:24:58I was not expecting for arts and anything that has to do with it to inhabit a wild forest
- 1:25:09and to be about a cave.
- 1:25:12It's the link between a cave and music or poetry or whatever.
- 1:25:22I don't know how many muses there are, but they're all like sent patrons of a different
- 1:25:31art form.
- 1:25:34I find it truly interesting.
- 1:25:37I wanted to ask you, as a musician, has it helped you make that connection with nature?
- 1:25:44How do you experience your art, basically?
- 1:25:48I love this question.
- 1:25:51I do think growing up with music because I'm brought up in a family where music was very
- 1:25:56present and where we sang together.
- 1:25:59My mother is a music maker and my sister also sings and dances and my dad loved music.
- 1:26:06So he was a great appreciator of music.
- 1:26:13I do think that it helped.
- 1:26:14It also helped, of course, in combination with living on the countryside and living
- 1:26:19with animals.
- 1:26:20But I do think that music helped me because my first language was communicating through
- 1:26:28music.
- 1:26:29That was my first language, was music, to sing or to create sounds.
- 1:26:35I did sing before I spoke.
- 1:26:39So I do think that just having that relationship with a non-verbal way of communicating really
- 1:26:47showed me that our human words are not everything that is embedded in the word communication.
- 1:26:57It comes with a lot of things.
- 1:26:58It comes with, and just growing up performing, it's also about body language.
- 1:27:03Communication means so many different things.
- 1:27:07I think music really helped me to see that and just appreciate the music of nature of
- 1:27:14other animals and just birds singing.
- 1:27:18I could listen for hours.
- 1:27:20I remember when I was a kid, I was thinking, wow, that is so beautiful how they communicate.
- 1:27:26And learning more about that helped me to dissolve the barriers between cultural and
- 1:27:32biological diversity because I do not think that that separation is correct.
- 1:27:39I think that whenever we are erasing biological diversity, very actual now with the mass extinction
- 1:27:47of animals, we are also losing cultural diversity and cultural practices that we have barely
- 1:27:54started to know more about because we have been quite into our human exceptional ideas
- 1:28:00of culture.
- 1:28:03There's whale singing and there's so many different ways of art.
- 1:28:12And I think culture is also a biological function.
- 1:28:17It's just navigating through life.
- 1:28:19Music has helped me navigate through life.
- 1:28:21It helps me to integrate the feelings that I have felt and the experiences that I have
- 1:28:28and to create something with it and to share it with other people.
- 1:28:32And it can have a soothing effect for people that might be able to reflect themselves in
- 1:28:37music.
- 1:28:38I think it's a way of navigating through life.
- 1:28:40And I do think that most, if not all, other animals do need to navigate through life.
- 1:28:46And then, of course, I can experience music in the natural, less human-made environments
- 1:28:56as well.
- 1:28:57For instance, with trees, like scratching and things like that.
- 1:29:01I'm like, ah, do you hear that?
- 1:29:03That's beautiful.
- 1:29:04And sounds, rather.
- 1:29:06And sometimes I sample them and I hear the music in them.
- 1:29:10I think music is just a collection of sounds.
- 1:29:14And I love seeing music that way because that makes me appreciate the kind of unpolished
- 1:29:19sounds that infiltrate my compositions, no matter if I want them to or not.
- 1:29:23It's like, oh, that squeaky thing that came into the recording.
- 1:29:27And then I really love that squeaky sound because it's life.
- 1:29:31Sounds just infiltrate your life.
- 1:29:34And as a musician, I love that.
- 1:29:36So yeah, I think that music really helped me to gain that perspective from early on.
- 1:29:48And when I make music or when I perform, I feel very integrated.
- 1:29:56And also when I play music, I feel that the boundaries are also dissolving.
- 1:30:02The way you talk about meditation, I think I said when people asked me what I wanted
- 1:30:08to be when I grew up as a kid, I would say that I wanted to be music because it was a
- 1:30:13state of being to become music in a way that you're so integrated with all of the parts
- 1:30:19that you are one.
- 1:30:22So sometimes I feel that and I'm very lucky to experience that feeling.
- 1:30:27I felt that yesterday when I was rehearsing for a gig, when I was playing violin, I felt
- 1:30:33it afterwards.
- 1:30:34Oh, I had that experience again when I was just completely integrated into the being.
- 1:30:43That's a beautiful answer.
- 1:30:45And it's not a surprising one because when I listen to your music, it's very immersive.
- 1:30:53I feel like I'm transported by the music and the lyrics.
- 1:31:01Do you have that goal in mind?
- 1:31:03Do you think of the people who are going to listen to your songs when you make music or
- 1:31:11do you just let yourself be guided by your creativity, by your muse?
- 1:31:17Will I sound like a terrible person if I just say no?
- 1:31:21I don't think of other people.
- 1:31:24I do think about other people when I get cold feet before releasing music.
- 1:31:27Like, oh my God, will they even find this as music or is it noise?
- 1:31:36So interesting, that process as well from the creative stage of being into the scrutinizing
- 1:31:43yourself and thinking about, you know, commercializing and the thing that is so personal to you is
- 1:31:48a very interesting process in this day, modern day.
- 1:31:55But no, it just comes to me, really.
- 1:32:02I sit in front of an instrument and I think it's something that has been happening in
- 1:32:07my subconscious and then it just comes out.
- 1:32:09And then sometimes I do have a feeling, for instance, that something I've been thinking
- 1:32:15about or something I've been trying to embody and then I have walked around with it.
- 1:32:20And then when I sit down, it usually just comes and then after a while I realize, oh,
- 1:32:25okay, this song is about this because now I'm experiencing this.
- 1:32:29And then I try to finish it with that kind of emotion.
- 1:32:38I say in a lot of interviews, and I think it is because I want to kind of give credit
- 1:32:46to my roots that I have Swedish roots.
- 1:32:49I also have Finnish Karelian roots and Karelian is an endangered culture.
- 1:32:57And there's a practice in Karelian culture that is lamentation and lamentation is, you
- 1:33:01know, it practices all over the world.
- 1:33:03But in Kareli, it is a female-led tradition.
- 1:33:08And historically, it was often an older woman who was present at different occasions.
- 1:33:19It could be happy occasions like a wedding or it could be sad, like a funeral.
- 1:33:24And the mission of the lamenter was to help people to channel all their emotions in a
- 1:33:34transition.
- 1:33:35And that is something that has really inspired me in my personal life, but also in my artistry
- 1:33:41that I think that music has that role in our lives, again, navigating through life, but
- 1:33:48also helping us to feel all the emotions at the same time.
- 1:33:52Because usually it's like, is it a happy song?
- 1:33:54Is it a sad song?
- 1:33:57It's usually a sad song will be into happy song or both or, you know, it's usually many
- 1:34:03feelings at the same time.
- 1:34:05When I'm writing, I'm usually carrying all of these feelings and I need to give myself
- 1:34:09space to explore these different emotions in different languages or with different instruments
- 1:34:14and sounds.
- 1:34:17And of course, when I'm doing it, I'm just trying to be as present as I can and to really
- 1:34:23just also find the joy and playfulness in it.
- 1:34:29But of course, I wish that my role could be a little bit like the lamentator in the way
- 1:34:37that I can help people process different emotions and to help them kind of not deny themselves
- 1:34:47the safe space where all of these feelings can be felt at the same time.
- 1:34:52So I really wish that I create a space where people can express themselves in different
- 1:34:59ways and just to just feel all the emotions.
- 1:35:02That is my wish.
- 1:35:05But I do think that the way I can facilitate this is by just making sure that I'm being
- 1:35:14the most honest version of myself as I can when I create the music.
- 1:35:19And I don't think about the end results and how that can be, you know, met and with different,
- 1:35:31you know, just positive or negative or whatever.
- 1:35:34I just think about being as present as I can in that moment and giving myself that space.
- 1:35:39And then I can invite other people in that safe space.
- 1:35:42And yeah, I hope.
- 1:35:45Yeah.
- 1:35:46I haven't asked you yet, but have you ever tried psychedelics?
- 1:35:52No, but my, I am intrigued by what would happen because when I talk about my experiences,
- 1:36:00my one of my co-authors of the study and the specialist in psychedelics, he's like, but
- 1:36:07sometimes you sound like you're already on psychedelics.
- 1:36:10So I don't really know how you would react because I talk with trees and I'm the typical
- 1:36:21tree hugging stereotype in that way.
- 1:36:24But I'm a proud tree hugger.
- 1:36:26I think it's a very, it's my innate need and I accept it.
- 1:36:32Same.
- 1:36:33I mean, I had a chat with Emma who's known as whispers red on, on YouTube.
- 1:36:41She makes ASMR videos and she describes herself as a, as being hypersensitive and that sense
- 1:36:48of being receptive to the world and to its sounds.
- 1:36:54She reflected that.
- 1:36:55You know, she talked about it.
- 1:36:57She also talked about it in the conversation we had.
- 1:37:01And I do think there is a link between being hypersensitive and being creative, but also
- 1:37:13caring for animals and having this different relation with animals.
- 1:37:18Yeah.
- 1:37:19There might be something there.
- 1:37:22And I think some studies that, or, you know, just, just argumentations that, you know,
- 1:37:30why would you want to care about animals or be, you know, vegan or whatever, because it,
- 1:37:35you know, it just makes you depressed and you feel bad.
- 1:37:39I do think that it is hard to feel good when all the time and be shippy hip, like shippy
- 1:37:49happy when you know that, but there is an ongoing industry that creates suffering.
- 1:37:58I, I, I, I think that it is the same with, you know, terms such as echo or climate anxiety.
- 1:38:06I do think that they are healthy responses to an unhealthy way of living life and, you
- 1:38:12know, an unhealthy way of treating the planet.
- 1:38:16And so I do think that some of, you know, the negative consequences of caring is healthy
- 1:38:21responses to something that is sick.
- 1:38:27So I, I think that sometimes maybe, I don't know, but maybe it can be, you know, you want
- 1:38:34to show the positive things about being an animal rights activist or caring about different
- 1:38:41causes, but, but it's also a struggle.
- 1:38:43And we, we feel sad sometimes and overwhelmed and really powerless and, and just being against
- 1:38:51these powerful, powerful industries and trying to do what we can.
- 1:38:54It can be, it can be really hard.
- 1:38:58And I just recently, I mean, I've experienced burnout and I do, and I, and I, and I think
- 1:39:06that, you know, we always carry the feeling of that we have to do more and that what we
- 1:39:13do is not enough, et cetera.
- 1:39:15But it is really important to find the way, the best we can in an unsustainable world,
- 1:39:23but to try to find sustainable ways in our activism and in our lives where we can still
- 1:39:29care, but we take care of ourselves and not stigmatizing that we feel bad because it's,
- 1:39:37I think it's, it's a very normal and healthy response to something.
- 1:39:42I mean, just knowing what happens is, it's hard.
- 1:39:48It, it, well, to, to be really plain, it sucks.
- 1:39:54It sucks, but yeah, and it can be really hard.
- 1:39:57So self-compassion is, it's also important.
- 1:40:03Yeah.
- 1:40:04Well, my message and the message of the podcast is that action is a way to overcome those
- 1:40:15feelings to find strength in your situation.
- 1:40:20Yep.
- 1:40:21And because what you're describing is a sense of being overpowered.
- 1:40:26Well, claim back your power, find the action you can do and go outside and do something
- 1:40:35and connect with people and make a difference that will make you feel better.
- 1:40:42So what is your message for the people who are dealing with that, with those emotions,
- 1:40:48but who stay passive?
- 1:40:51They're not prepared.
- 1:40:52It depends.
- 1:40:53I mean, I can understand that if you, if you feel like it's, it's, it's really hard to
- 1:40:58do something because of the environment that you're in or whatever, that you might be in
- 1:41:04a strong opposition or I think just finding ways of finding rooms where you can express
- 1:41:15yourself maybe might be a start to find the rooms where you, where you can dive into more
- 1:41:21topics or learn more or also I think that animal rights is not, it can be treated as
- 1:41:32a, as a, as a marginalized, you know, like subtopic, but it's, it's really interlinked
- 1:41:39with other forms of oppression.
- 1:41:41And if, if it's, if it is hard where you're at to kind of do something for animal rights,
- 1:41:47it's also important to just be an ally for other causes because they're interlinked.
- 1:41:51So if you just do something to decrease the risk of dehumanization of any being, it is
- 1:41:57really, I do think that it, it helps the world.
- 1:42:02And I do also think that for us, there are active in the animal rights movement to also
- 1:42:06be good allies to other movements because we, we do have the same movement.
- 1:42:10We are part of the same social justice movement.
- 1:42:13Animals are included in the social justice movement and we're kind of one movement against
- 1:42:21again, the commodification and just the individualization of different bodies.
- 1:42:29And maybe I think just for me, I think just being, I've come to learn with, with all the
- 1:42:39years now that I've, that I've been advocating for animal rights.
- 1:42:45When I've just been myself in different rooms, no matter if it's with relatives that were
- 1:42:49like, Oh, this is such a trend.
- 1:42:51I'm like, okay, like 15 years later.
- 1:42:54No, but the thing that is a trend or whatever, just, just being who you are consistent and
- 1:43:00being just standing up for what you believe in and what you buy or, or just asking a question
- 1:43:08like, Oh, you think that animals are like that.
- 1:43:10Why do you think that?
- 1:43:11Because I know the studies have shown this, just being somebody in the room that asks
- 1:43:16a question that might just a little bit combat the human exceptionalism in the room, maybe
- 1:43:23can do, can, can start something.
- 1:43:27And years later, a relative might come to you and say, do you know what?
- 1:43:31I've just, I I'm only eating plant based now.
- 1:43:34And that was the relative that were freely thought that you were going through a phase
- 1:43:42and after a while saw, Oh, that is a way that you can live your life.
- 1:43:45Okay.
- 1:43:46I'm going to try.
- 1:43:47And then the, you've made all of a sudden you've made the lifestyle that you've, you've
- 1:43:52chosen more accessible to other people just by showing another person how to live that
- 1:43:57life.
- 1:43:59Other ways that you said, I think is really important.
- 1:44:01I mean, just organizing with other people and finding your groups and maybe finding
- 1:44:09the group locally.
- 1:44:12I think locally is a really good way to start.
- 1:44:15If everyone would organize themselves in local groups, you could do a lot of things.
- 1:44:21Just just a personal example of deforestation and here in Sweden, I've, it's so easy to
- 1:44:28just have anxiety over all the reports on planned clear cuts that are coming in.
- 1:44:35And I just feel like, Oh my God, just an ongoing amputation just happening.
- 1:44:40And the, the really tangible anxiety that I feel in those moments.
- 1:44:46And when I try to avoid looking at them, that doesn't help because I still know that they're
- 1:44:51happening.
- 1:44:52So persistence is really can really be an act of hope, an act of a missioning in other
- 1:44:57future and together that is really powerful.
- 1:45:00So I've organized with other local people in my hometown, just writing emails, talking
- 1:45:07to professional biologists and getting help on the way, finding allies.
- 1:45:13That is, that is just like you say, that is really a strategy for not getting stuck in
- 1:45:20that anxiety.
- 1:45:22And of course, finding ways how to express yourself that works to help you become resilient
- 1:45:33in a world that, that can really break you down because of the way it is.
- 1:45:38So for me, it's music or sometimes it's dancing or whatever, just finding those expressions
- 1:45:44that help you to also grieve.
- 1:45:49It's really important, I think to grieve because it's so much loss.
- 1:45:57It's so sad.
- 1:46:00And when we give ourselves permission to grieve, we also help ourselves to feel that powerful
- 1:46:08joy in experiencing life the way we do with interaction with animals or other humans that
- 1:46:16have, that wants to do what we want to do with goals or to combat whatever issue.
- 1:46:25So I do think, I agree with you, finding ways to organize yourself and, but also finding
- 1:46:31ways to rest and express yourself individually and collectively in ways where you see that
- 1:46:41there's a lot of emotions that come with transformation and struggle and trying to create something
- 1:46:48resilient.
- 1:46:51Who wins when we break down and we can't do anything?
- 1:46:55So, status quo.
- 1:46:59So it's important.
- 1:47:01And I mean, I've myself experienced burnout, so I'm not an expert at all.
- 1:47:09I don't live as I learn.
- 1:47:11I haven't always, but that's also how I know that it's hard.
- 1:47:18Yeah.
- 1:47:21I never heard about grieving the loss of animals before.
- 1:47:30And I truly admire that, that you went and taught about that because I definitely thought
- 1:47:41that we should have something like a monument remembering all of these, all of those animals,
- 1:47:50the billions of them.
- 1:47:52And we can't even wrap our mind around that number.
- 1:47:58And we should at least have some kind of monument to their memory.
- 1:48:03But you might be on something here when you say, when you talk about grieving, because
- 1:48:10maybe lots of vegans are not so much experiencing being powerless, but being in grief of all
- 1:48:22of that loss that nobody sees.
- 1:48:26So truly it's powerful stuff here.
- 1:48:32Yeah.
- 1:48:35I personally experienced grief.
- 1:48:40I lost my dad a couple of years ago and just seeing how society, due to his illness and
- 1:48:52his age and other isms that you could attach to him, how I felt that my grief wasn't as
- 1:49:03acute or like, I really understood what I've learned throughout the years when it comes
- 1:49:13to processes of dehumanization.
- 1:49:15And I'm really grateful for that knowledge because it helped me to kind of be prepared
- 1:49:22for those personal experiences of grief and experience that kind of grief with your family
- 1:49:30member and then experiencing grief on a collective level.
- 1:49:37And also grief of seeing how your natural surrounding, who was one of your safety nets
- 1:49:43in keeping yourself sane during this period of time, was destroyed, really made me realize
- 1:49:49the importance of what you're saying, that our grief is seen and how we are given the
- 1:49:58space to grieve.
- 1:50:00And in society, we might not be given that time to grieve or that space.
- 1:50:11And depending on what we grieve or who we grieve, society might be more or less willing
- 1:50:16to acknowledge that grief.
- 1:50:19So it's very important to create communities and have people around you that identifies
- 1:50:25and sees your grief and says, I understand that you are grieving.
- 1:50:30And if you don't have that, well, at least to give yourself the permission to grieve
- 1:50:38and finding ways how to connect with your grieving body through different ways of experiencing
- 1:50:48yourself to dance or whatever has really helped me.
- 1:50:53And I do think we talk too little.
- 1:50:58I do think we need to have a conversation about grief when it comes to climate change,
- 1:51:04for instance.
- 1:51:05I do think that, I mean, I'm working on an instrumental album right now that is really
- 1:51:12about that, that is about instrumental music, about grieving processes related to climate
- 1:51:20change and just how are we supposed to deal with the transformation that we are facing,
- 1:51:32that we're having to prepare ourselves for.
- 1:51:37It can be also a positive transformation, just like when we talked about lamentation
- 1:51:42and how we need to get help to process different emotions in transformation.
- 1:51:47It doesn't matter if the transformation is a good one.
- 1:51:51We will still probably need to grieve.
- 1:51:54So for instance, if we transform our relationship with animals to a more positive one, we will
- 1:51:58still have to grieve what we lost, all the relationships that we lost because we didn't
- 1:52:06acknowledge the relationships that were relationships.
- 1:52:09We just thought they were business trades or whatever.
- 1:52:13We just thought they were objects.
- 1:52:14So I do think that we need tools as communities, as societies, as individuals to kind of process
- 1:52:23all these emotions.
- 1:52:24And culture and music can be one tool, but also just creating cultures and politics that
- 1:52:31acknowledge that when our surroundings change or when something happens in our lives, we
- 1:52:38need to grieve and we need to have the contexts where we can process these emotions.
- 1:52:48And if these are destroyed or disrespected in a way, of course that hurts us.
- 1:52:57So I am so happy that you jumped on the grief train because that is a train that I've been
- 1:53:03on for a lot of years now.
- 1:53:08And I appreciate that you were the one bringing this up in a way because we went there.
- 1:53:19Amazing.
- 1:53:20And thank you for sharing your insights.
- 1:53:25This discussion reminds me of a concept that I truly love.
- 1:53:32It's about spirituality because that's the underlying theme of what we're talking about
- 1:53:39here, spirituality.
- 1:53:42And it says that spirituality doesn't have to be vertical about a pantheon of gods and
- 1:53:49angels and stuff like that.
- 1:53:51It can also be horizontal.
- 1:53:55We can have a horizontal spirituality in the sense of building, again, connections and
- 1:54:02relationships with our community, but also here with nature and animals.
- 1:54:09And I truly love that reference image of horizontal versus vertical spirituality.
- 1:54:24I want to ask, feel free to answer however you want, but do you find that there is any
- 1:54:34vertical spirituality to our understanding of nature and our relationships with animals?
- 1:54:46As I interpret your question, you can let me know if I didn't understand you correctly.
- 1:54:58But in many ways, the way we look at animals is really based on power dynamics.
- 1:55:10It really stems from the agricultural and domestication of the early agricultural revolution
- 1:55:18when it comes to domestication of animals happened at the same time as the major religions
- 1:55:22came in.
- 1:55:23So from what I understand it.
- 1:55:25So I do believe that religion was a way of rationalizing how to treat animals and how
- 1:55:33to domesticate animals and how to create an animal industry.
- 1:55:37And I do think that seeing humans as godlike can also be a way of encouraging human exceptionalism
- 1:55:47in a way.
- 1:55:48And I mean, I am, personally speaking, I've never, I'd heard to a certain religion brought
- 1:55:59up in a household quite the contrary, where my mother has been studying theology.
- 1:56:06It's called theologi in Swedish.
- 1:56:08I don't know if it's the right word in English, but you know, the history of goddesses and
- 1:56:16those kind of things.
- 1:56:20And we have a famous poet in Finland called Eva Kilpi, who has written, she's 97 or something
- 1:56:29now, I think.
- 1:56:30And she wrote a whole book with the theme of nature and animals called Animalia.
- 1:56:37And if I remember correctly, yeah.
- 1:56:41And she wrote that if you look into an animal's eye, you will see God or the Almighty.
- 1:56:46And that was very controversial for that time.
- 1:56:49But I do agree with her in a way, even though I don't, you know, I talk with the God or
- 1:56:57whatever.
- 1:56:58I do think that the way I see it is that we live in a world where we're striving towards
- 1:57:05monoculture, where everything is, you know, you see trees in line, it's a monoculture.
- 1:57:11The way we've created our agricultural productions, the way we've done, the way we've created
- 1:57:19our religions is now very monocultural.
- 1:57:22And for me, I think a more variety or many gods or many practices will be quite nice.
- 1:57:37I don't know, the horizontal view that you said, I like that because that reminded me
- 1:57:43of the Eva Kilpi poem.
- 1:57:44It reminded me that at least you can believe in God, but also be part of it somehow.
- 1:57:51That's the connection thing again.
- 1:57:52Do you feel connected to something and still separated from it?
- 1:57:55What is that connection?
- 1:57:59Instead of connection, I would like to say relationship, because that requires us to
- 1:58:04place ourselves like in the room or in something that is an active ongoing thing where we have
- 1:58:10to be, even if it's a negative relationship or positive, we place ourselves easier in
- 1:58:15the room when we talk about the word relationship.
- 1:58:18Relationship can be something that we kind of connect into server, logging out.
- 1:58:24Our relationship requires something from us and can also give us something more.
- 1:58:29So I like the term relationship and relations and how we can just experience life through
- 1:58:38relationships and having role models or having an awe, an awe for something can be, doesn't
- 1:58:47have to come with power and balances and things like that.
- 1:58:58I like the horizontal view, but I'm biased because I'm brought up that way.
- 1:59:05I do understand the role of religious communities and I'm absolutely not, again, I understand
- 1:59:11I have pretty much the same sentiment for some kind of universe and interconnection
- 1:59:18and interrelations.
- 1:59:21I have that notion, but I mean, sure, we're talking about spirituality once again.
- 1:59:26It's maybe the term is spirituality.
- 1:59:31I like the way you put it more.
- 1:59:35I think you should just erase my answer, just like your question asks also the answer.
- 1:59:44Can we do that?
- 1:59:47Your answer was great.
- 1:59:49I don't know why you say that.
- 1:59:51I should feel it was so poignant.
- 1:59:53It was there.
- 1:59:54But yeah, I agree.
- 1:59:56I should have just said I agree.
- 1:59:58No, it was good.
- 2:00:01I truly like the thing you said about seeing God in the eyes of animals.
- 2:00:13I think this will be shocking to hear for a listener who is not vegan and for whom animals
- 2:00:22have no presence and absolutely no personhood.
- 2:00:29But I think if you accept that animals are more than what we have been brought up to
- 2:00:35believe they are, I think why not consider them and integrate them in our religious practices
- 2:00:45and our spirituality?
- 2:00:48Yeah.
- 2:00:49And maybe just like making a full circle, maybe that is what we have done and humans have
- 2:00:57done and all thinkers from thousands of years ago said that you could see the God in the
- 2:01:07animal eyes.
- 2:01:09But as a culture, we have just not highlighted those people because we know that there have
- 2:01:15been acts of resistance towards the way animals are being treated throughout history.
- 2:01:19And we talked about it before with the academia and why animals are not as highlighted or
- 2:01:26a marginalized subject in different fields and etc.
- 2:01:33It's where we place our focus and how we tell the story of humankind.
- 2:01:38And it's good if we raise more positive examples of what it might mean to take the animal perspective
- 2:01:48if you say like that.
- 2:01:50And how many of us, how many have been before us and how we're part of something bigger.
- 2:01:57We tend to also maybe do the human exceptionalism or the exceptionalism with ourselves.
- 2:02:03Like I am the exception.
- 2:02:06And in some way, sure, we are because we are marginalized in the way that we see and want
- 2:02:16to treat animals.
- 2:02:17But in other way, we're not exceptional.
- 2:02:19We're just part of a bigger movement, a resistance movement, also a larger social justice movement
- 2:02:27with other related issues.
- 2:02:30So I think that that can be empowering as well to remember that throughout history,
- 2:02:36there have been voices that have said things that were talked about things that maybe you
- 2:02:39and I are talking about right now and that we should highlight them because we humans
- 2:02:43are continuously writing our own history and who gets to write that history.
- 2:02:51And that is also like an act of resistance and trying to combat the way that that is
- 2:02:56being written, it's being written humans as superior and whatever.
- 2:03:01So I think that that can also be a fun conversation to find the role models of today and yesterday
- 2:03:12and thousand years before that.
- 2:03:14And yeah, at the beginning of the conversation, you talked about how this was liberating for
- 2:03:21you to discover the animal rights fight.
- 2:03:26And this is what psychedelics are about, liberating your mind.
- 2:03:34And I think it could be the theme of our conversation, liberating ourselves from all of those dogmas,
- 2:03:44cultural beliefs and things that are just burdening us and working to harm us.
- 2:03:55So Ellen, I have been talking with you for about two hours now.
- 2:04:01I think it's the longest podcast episode I ever recorded.
- 2:04:07Have a fun time in the post-production.
- 2:04:08Well, I think most of it was incredible.
- 2:04:14I don't think that I will have to edit lots of things in what was said.
- 2:04:24I hope listeners think the same way.
- 2:04:26I feel like, oh my God, why is it stopping?
- 2:04:31No, but thank you.
- 2:04:32It was a really interesting discussion.
- 2:04:35Can I just ask you something before we go?
- 2:04:41And here is half an hour more.
- 2:04:43No, I'm kidding.
- 2:04:44No, but you said something about how you've experienced that some terms are being used
- 2:04:50within the movement or when it comes to speciesism and those kind of things.
- 2:04:55And to be fair, I have not been, because I've moved a bit away from research and human animal
- 2:05:02studies towards more culture and the music now and focusing on the forest issue here
- 2:05:11in Sweden.
- 2:05:12So I feel a bit unpolished on that area now.
- 2:05:14So could you kind of develop a bit more what you meant with those kind of terms that you
- 2:05:21have experienced and those kind of things?
- 2:05:23Because that stuck with me.
- 2:05:27What terms?
- 2:05:28I'm not remembering.
- 2:05:29We're talking about how speciesism is used and how it's kind of a shallow way of seeing
- 2:05:36things.
- 2:05:37Or you were talking about kind of going deeper into certain things and kind of nuancing in
- 2:05:42different terms.
- 2:05:43Yes, I think we had that conversation before I started recording.
- 2:05:48I'll develop that now because I do want to know.
- 2:05:54Well I was thinking about how we often in the public discourse around veganism, we tend
- 2:06:05to take a kind of a more superficial way, but more simplistic way.
- 2:06:13I think that this vegan movement and the ideas we're putting forth are radical in many ways,
- 2:06:24going against centuries of traditions.
- 2:06:30But we are not maybe fully conscious of the implications of this philosophy.
- 2:06:42Or maybe we simplify veganism because we are on this activism mode all of the time, always
- 2:06:51speaking to non-vegans instead of speaking to vegans.
- 2:06:56So maybe less conversations between ourselves and more conversations directed to non-vegans.
- 2:07:08And if I had to give maybe concrete examples of that, I would say we use veganism and we
- 2:07:18often mean plant-based diet.
- 2:07:21So we reduce sometimes veganism to a diet and we concentrate on the health and lifestyle
- 2:07:29aspect.
- 2:07:30So yeah, I'm a bit vague right now.
- 2:07:33I don't know if I'm clear.
- 2:07:35Yeah.
- 2:07:36No, but I see what you mean.
- 2:07:39And of course there's a value in simplifying depending on the kind of target group or messaging
- 2:07:46and trying to make it simple for people to understand or what can I do to do this or
- 2:07:56for this result and blah, blah.
- 2:07:57But as you say, as we talked about before with kind of like internal or external solutions
- 2:08:04to problems when it comes to like climate change or whatever, that a lot of these things
- 2:08:09happen inside of us, these processes, and we manifest them in our lives.
- 2:08:17But we're not born with them.
- 2:08:18They come from somewhere.
- 2:08:20We are being fed by these kind of social cultural ideas of, for instance, human-animal relations
- 2:08:26and how they should look like.
- 2:08:29And the foundation of that is really questions like who has worth, why, who is part of nature,
- 2:08:41who's part of culture, who is a body, who's a mind, who is worth, those kind of questions.
- 2:08:48And that is why I liked research in the first place because I can just ask a lot of questions.
- 2:08:55But that is also why I like just being, having conversations because you, usually the questions,
- 2:09:04I think now is the time for questions.
- 2:09:08How can we create, how can we create interventions that help us transform the way we treat animals
- 2:09:15and like our surroundings in a positive way?
- 2:09:23How can we connect these oppressive mechanisms in, through words, for example, like dehumanization
- 2:09:35and how can we see our blind spots?
- 2:09:38I think just by asking ourselves questions, we have done something.
- 2:09:45We have, and that's why research love questions because we have realized that we might not
- 2:09:50know everything, but we can just move on from there and try to gather as much information
- 2:09:56as possible and most importantly, embody what that means to ask these questions and embody
- 2:10:03the answers that we find.
- 2:10:05I completely agree.
- 2:10:09I think we have realized so much, but we're still reacting to those realizations, not
- 2:10:18having fully appreciated the depth of those realizations and what they mean for our cultures
- 2:10:26and for ourselves.
- 2:10:28Yeah.
- 2:10:29And we have all of these technical means to kind of quickly answer like some questions
- 2:10:37that are more external, fix this and fix that and how can we do this?
- 2:10:41But we've seen, as we've talked about, we've seen the consequences of technology in its
- 2:10:46worst light.
- 2:10:49I mean, one solution to decreasing the risk of pandemics is to just keep animals more
- 2:10:55compact in a really closed space.
- 2:11:00But is that a solution that we want?
- 2:11:03Is that something that we would face and say, oh, sounds appropriate?
- 2:11:11Or would our cognitive dissonance be like ding, ding, ding, ding, ding, ding, ding?
- 2:11:16We need to say that they're harvested and it's a nice environment with a big TV where
- 2:11:22they can see other animals.
- 2:11:23I don't know how we would rationalize that, but you know what I mean.
- 2:11:29And these other questions that have to do with who we are I think are the most important
- 2:11:35now in moving forward.
- 2:11:39And again, as you said, it's also a part of spirituality.
- 2:11:44Who am I?
- 2:11:48What do I find important?
- 2:11:49How can I support other people?
- 2:11:53What can I do to create the world that I envision and create the spaces that we need to dare
- 2:12:02ourselves to envision that another world is possible?
- 2:12:07It's very important to not restrict ourselves and our potential.
- 2:12:12And I want to give an example that is close to my heart of one of those questions that
- 2:12:25you're referring to.
- 2:12:27The very first episode of this podcast was a conversation with Dr. Jens Vult, who is
- 2:12:33a primate communication expert.
- 2:12:37And the very first question I asked her was, do chimpanzees truly understand human language
- 2:12:45when they communicate with sign language?
- 2:12:47We have seen those famous videos of chimpanzees using sign language.
- 2:12:52Or is it just like a conditioning trick, like a parrot repeating phrases and words?
- 2:12:59And she said, no, we know that they understand the sense, the meaning of the word, and that
- 2:13:06they're truly using human language.
- 2:13:09And then she said, it's interesting.
- 2:13:12It remains so controversial because it rattles the foundation of who we are as a species.
- 2:13:17Yeah.
- 2:13:18I mean, we have the information, but we don't know what to do with it.
- 2:13:22Exactly.
- 2:13:23We don't want to embody it.
- 2:13:25Yes.
- 2:13:26Chimpanzees can use human language.
- 2:13:27Now what?
- 2:13:29That's why I love the Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy and just also using humor to help
- 2:13:37us humans see ourselves from the outside and see the pride that we might have the way we
- 2:13:43see ourselves.
- 2:13:45Because it really helps.
- 2:13:46I mean, just taking that example, for instance, as aliens coming and just looking at us and
- 2:13:55how we are doing things and just they're super smart or AI, whatever the beings might be,
- 2:14:02and just seeing ourselves from the outside, just like in the Hitchhiker's Guide to the
- 2:14:07Galaxy where the animals are like, no, we knew what was going on.
- 2:14:12I love that so much.
- 2:14:15I think it does something with us.
- 2:14:16I think that's why I do think that culture has a huge role to play in this because it
- 2:14:21helps us in our imagination to also envision another world, a world that is very much here
- 2:14:29already because we live in an interconnected world.
- 2:14:32But our role might be different in this new envisioned world or our feelings or our mindsets.
- 2:14:39But just helping us envision these worlds and help us envision, it's just like how
- 2:14:48humans might be perceived by other animals.
- 2:14:51Or to quote Franz de Waal, are we smart enough to know how smart animals are?
- 2:14:58Are we?
- 2:14:59Or maybe we are smart enough, but maybe we just don't, as you say, we're not ready.
- 2:15:05Because it would just, again, then our human exceptionalistic argumentations would not
- 2:15:12work anymore.
- 2:15:15And wouldn't that be a bliss?
- 2:15:17I look forward to the day.
- 2:15:20Well, I think it's a great way to end the conversation.
- 2:15:25Ellen, thank you so much for having accepted my invitation and for having answered my question.
- 2:15:32What an interesting and fascinating and inspiring conversation we had.
- 2:15:36I will certainly be thinking about it in the coming days.
- 2:15:41So Ellen, thank you again.
- 2:15:43Thank you so much.
- 2:15:45It was great.
- 2:15:47Thank you everyone for listening.
- 2:15:49I kindly invite you to share this podcast with the vegans you know.
- 2:15:53Let's encourage more people to take action.
- 2:15:56Again, thank you so much for caring, and I will see you next Tuesday for a new episode.