Latest / Interfaiths / 25 Years After 9/11: A Muslim Convert's Reckoning with Grievance Politics — Ismail Royer
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, good morning, everyone. We are very honored
- 0:04today to have Ismael Royer, who is the director
- 0:09of the Islam and Religious Freedom Action Team
- 0:12at the Religious Freedom Institute in Washington,
- 0:15D .C. He's a member of President Trump's Religious
- 0:20Liberty Commission. He works and coordinates
- 0:25sort of amicus brief efforts on behalf of religious
- 0:27liberty litigants of all faiths and has been
- 0:30involved in more than 100 such briefs. Converted
- 0:33to Islam in 1992, and he's going to talk to us
- 0:35a little bit about that. He studied traditional
- 0:38religious Islamic studies and Islamic sciences
- 0:42and has spent more than a decade working I would
- 0:46say maybe more than two decades. Yeah, at this
- 0:49point. Working at Islamic non -profit organizations.
- 0:52He's authored a book on Islam and religious violence.
- 0:57He's a prolific author. been featured in the
- 1:01Washington Post, USA Today, Newsday, American
- 1:04Conservative. And he is going to be talking to
- 1:08us about 9 -11 and particularly thinking about
- 1:13the American Muslim community, so the past, present,
- 1:16and the future. So we're very honored to have
- 1:19Ismail as our speaker. He's going to talk for
- 1:21about... 30 minutes or so, and then we'll open
- 1:24it up for questions and answers. If you have
- 1:26questions, you can put it in the chat, or you
- 1:28can just message me directly. So with that, I'll
- 1:31turn it over to Ismail. Thank you so much, Professor
- 1:36Iqbal, and it is an honor indeed to join you
- 1:40and to be your guest. This is indeed a very grave
- 1:51and auspicious day and anniversary that we're
- 1:57marking today. And, you know, it's very hard
- 2:03to wrap our heads around, really, I think the
- 2:07significance of that day 25 years ago. I'll just
- 2:16mention, I think, my own personal reflections
- 2:19and experience with 9 -11, and then I'll segue
- 2:23from that into the broader questions that we're
- 2:27looking at about the American Muslim community.
- 2:32I converted to Islam in 1992, as you mentioned,
- 2:35in St. Louis, Missouri, at the age of 19. And
- 2:39pretty soon after converting, I became familiar
- 2:45with what was going on in Afghanistan and the
- 2:51deteriorating situation there at the time, the
- 2:54civil war between the various Mujahideen groups.
- 2:57I had been following news generally very closely
- 3:00at the time that I converted and was very politically
- 3:02active in many causes, particularly left -wing
- 3:07political causes, opposition to the Gulf War,
- 3:09the first Gulf War, and different causes like
- 3:13that, and opposition to U .S. policy in Central
- 3:16America. So I was very, very familiar with and
- 3:19very adept at political science and current events.
- 3:25So when I became Muslim and converted to Islam,
- 3:30I became very familiar with the Afghan war from
- 3:36the perspective of Muslims, because there were
- 3:38a number of Afghan refugees. There were Afghanis
- 3:42who had fought in the civil war or fought, sorry,
- 3:44fought in the war against the Soviets and then
- 3:45against the communist regime there. I spoke with
- 3:49them. And also there were at the time floating
- 3:51around videotapes, VHS tapes that were produced
- 3:55by Abdullah Azzam's organization, Maktib al -Khidmat.
- 4:03their us -based uh distributors and activists
- 4:06and so on and this was known i mean everyone
- 4:08knew about this and there was nothing really
- 4:10particularly suspicious about it because um it
- 4:13was uh the side that the united states was on
- 4:15and i remember watching these videos i probably
- 4:17had been muslim for two months at most um and
- 4:20really being inspired by the um these mujahideen
- 4:24fighting uh the soviets and this is kind of where
- 4:27my head was at the time i was very active politically
- 4:29active guy you know and um dare i say somewhat
- 4:33militant guy um even at the time um in my kind
- 4:37of pursuit of what is good and what is right
- 4:39uh and what is noble against injustice i was
- 4:43you know an anti -racism activist and all kinds
- 4:46of things like that so this is what i the baggage
- 4:47that i carried with me into Islam. And this is
- 4:50where I was coming from. So I admired them a
- 4:54lot. And then the Bosnian war started very shortly
- 4:58after I converted to Islam. In fact, actually,
- 5:00probably a few months before I converted to Islam
- 5:03in St. Louis, as it happened, became a destination
- 5:06city for refugees because we had a refugee resettlement
- 5:09agency there in St. Louis. And they had a contract
- 5:12or an arrangement with the government where they
- 5:15were resettling Bosnian refugees. So I started
- 5:17as those refugees started pouring in, I began
- 5:20to work with them as a volunteer at my mosque
- 5:23there in St. Louis to help them, you know, with
- 5:27their, you know, getting, you know, with their
- 5:29furniture, with their doctor's appointments,
- 5:31with their, you know, getting, you know, applying
- 5:34for social security and different things. And
- 5:38although most of them didn't speak English, I
- 5:41got a very personal understanding of of the suffering
- 5:46that they were going through. And as the news
- 5:48began to report about rape camps and that the
- 5:51Serbs had, and in the genocide that was unfolding,
- 5:54a lot of people think of Srebrenica as the genocide.
- 5:56The genocide was the entire war. That was the
- 6:00purpose of the war was genocide. The purpose
- 6:03of the attack by the Yugoslavia and the Serbs.
- 6:06So this news started coming out and I was...
- 6:11I had firsthand understanding of this. So when
- 6:16I went off to college in Washington, D .C., to
- 6:19American University in 1993 -ish, one of the
- 6:26first things that happened to me was that I started
- 6:28working for the World Assembly of Muslim Youth,
- 6:31which was a Saudi organization, just as a side
- 6:35job through someone I had met. you know, a student
- 6:39at American University who was the office manager
- 6:41of that organization, their branch in Falls Church,
- 6:46Virginia. So I started working there, and then
- 6:48I started going to Dar al -Hijrah Mosque for
- 6:51Jumu 'ah because I was out there, working out
- 6:54there while I was going to school. And so all
- 6:59of this, you know, and I eventually moved to
- 7:00Falls Church and lived there until 2001, actually,
- 7:03until October 2001. um and then in fact i i as
- 7:09i'll talk about i went overseas and then i um
- 7:11returned for for almost a year and i returned
- 7:13back and continued living in falls church so
- 7:15falls church and that area of dc is where i've
- 7:18lived for most of my adult life um and um you
- 7:24know as everyone probably knows or or many people
- 7:27know um that area is really um central to you
- 7:33know grand central station as it were for um
- 7:36for Islamic movements, various Islamic movements
- 7:41of various different stripes. I mean, it's extraordinary.
- 7:44It's an extraordinary microcosm, just like New
- 7:48York is in a way, but it's, you know, and Chicago
- 7:50in another way. So while I was working at the
- 7:55World Assembly of Muslim Youth, I... I learned
- 7:57two things. One, someone told me, well, hey,
- 8:00you know, there's this new organization, CARE,
- 8:02Council on American Islamic Relations, that's
- 8:04hiring. And this is, at this point, it's about
- 8:0694, sometime in 94, maybe fall of 94. And also,
- 8:13in another conversation, unrelated conversation,
- 8:16did you know that there are Arab Mujahideen fighting
- 8:20in Bosnia? And someone told me that, who worked
- 8:23there at the office with me, one of my coworkers.
- 8:27So, by the way, the head of that office was Abdullah
- 8:31bin Laden. I'm not sure if he's like an uncle
- 8:35or something like that, but he's related to Osama
- 8:38bin Laden. And so I decided to go and apply at
- 8:46CARE. And so I went and applied at CARE. And
- 8:50I was hired. And at that time, there were three
- 8:52people working there. It was the executive director.
- 8:55There was the communications director. And there
- 8:56was a guy answering phones who was actually a
- 8:59very beautiful human being and fortunately died
- 9:02of pneumonia several years back. If anyone's
- 9:08from the DMV area, you'll know who I'm talking
- 9:09about. So I started working there and my initial
- 9:15job was really helping them. in their move. They
- 9:19had just moved from Texas. Well, one principal
- 9:23had moved from Texas, another one from Minnesota.
- 9:25So I was helping to unload all the files that
- 9:28they had and all the research and all the documents
- 9:30and all the equipment that they had and putting
- 9:33it into filing cabinets and then began doing
- 9:37other things at the time. And this is just as
- 9:40Stephen Emerson and Daniel Pipes and others began
- 9:44their campaign. uh, against Holy Land Foundation
- 9:48and Islamic Association for Palestine, and then
- 9:50eventually, uh, care. Um, so me, I mean, being
- 9:54a naive guy, you know, I'm like, well, those,
- 9:57those are bad guys and I'm with the good guys.
- 9:59And, and I, uh, you know, as I'll talk about,
- 10:01I mean, to this day, I love, um, uh, I love,
- 10:04uh, the, the, the folks that I worked with there.
- 10:08And I think that they, uh, for their mistakes
- 10:10and everything, you know, um, uh, you know, I,
- 10:13I have a very personal fondness for them and
- 10:16well -wishing for them as much as I disagree
- 10:19with, with much of, or most of, of what, you
- 10:23know, of, of where we're at now, I guess we can
- 10:26say, and I have to be diplomatic and honest at
- 10:29the same time, you know. So I worked at CARE
- 10:32and at the same time I began. to get really really
- 10:36wired up and wound up i guess about bosnia i
- 10:39mean even more like every day as the news is
- 10:41coming out it's getting worse and worse and i'm
- 10:43thinking about oh i'm thinking the videos that
- 10:46i'd seen of them fighting the soviets and then
- 10:48i'm thinking of you know i'm thinking of um uh
- 10:52i'm thinking of the you know the the people that
- 10:56i know personally you know taking rape victims
- 10:58to to doctors offices and then reading about
- 11:00how widespread and systematic that was and um
- 11:04so i decided that i was going to quit school
- 11:07i was going to leave my job at care and i was
- 11:09going to go um join the mujahideen in bosnia
- 11:13and find them somehow and join and i did that
- 11:15um and i i left um i went you know i i went to
- 11:20bosnia i stayed there until the end of the war
- 11:22with the um the Dayton Accords. And then I returned
- 11:27when those were signed and the war was clearly
- 11:30over and fought in battles with Arab fighters.
- 11:37And when I returned home, I tried to get back
- 11:41into, you know, into life. And I don't want to
- 11:44go too much. I could actually make this all about
- 11:47that particular journey, but I want to fast forward
- 11:51to 9 -11. And CARE is an organization that is
- 12:00incredibly influential and was incredibly effective
- 12:05at what they did. And, you know, it's very understandable
- 12:11why they took the approach that they did. And
- 12:14it bears very strongly on the current state of
- 12:18Muslims, American Muslims right now after 9 -11.
- 12:23I think I heard Sheikh Hamza Yusuf, you know,
- 12:27back in the 90s, late 90s, talking about care
- 12:30as firefighters. And he wasn't condemning them.
- 12:32He was just saying that, you know, they're firefighters.
- 12:34They are going around. When something happens,
- 12:39a crisis happens, or, you know, they go and they
- 12:41deal with it. And he said, you have to have firefighters.
- 12:45And I look at this now as I say that that is
- 12:48probably correct. Like every community has to
- 12:51have some emergency response team that comes
- 12:55in and that can be harsh and that can be reactive.
- 13:02But what I was reflecting on at the time, and
- 13:06I'll say this too, is that like. Some of my most
- 13:09meaningful work that I ever did in my life was
- 13:11at CARE because I developed their civil rights
- 13:15department. Initially, it was one person there,
- 13:21the communications director, who was handling
- 13:23complaints that would come to CARE. And this
- 13:25is interesting how just the dynamics of nonprofits
- 13:27and institutions and how they go down certain
- 13:30paths because they had not initially really begun
- 13:33with the idea of, well, we're going to become
- 13:34the nation's premier Muslim. employment discrimination
- 13:39agency or organization, but they did. And they
- 13:46don't really have that employment discrimination
- 13:48angle as much now, but this is how they began
- 13:53really with that. Because they had handled one
- 13:57case of a Muslim woman at a hotel who had been
- 14:00discriminated against on the basis of her hijab,
- 14:02and they wouldn't accommodate that. And then
- 14:05we come to find, oh, there's this thing called
- 14:07Title VII. We had an attorney there who wrote
- 14:09a letter and handled the legal aspects of that.
- 14:11And then we just used that attorney's letter.
- 14:14uh martin mcmahon's name good man uh you know
- 14:17use that letter to um as a model for future things
- 14:21because people in the community heard about that
- 14:23they would call care and say hey you guys did
- 14:25that well i'm doing i'm dealing with something
- 14:27like that or i'm a muslim and they won't let
- 14:29me wear my beard or i'm a muslim they won't let
- 14:31me go to jama and so you know through that i
- 14:33you know we all started to educate ourselves
- 14:35none of us are lawyers um you know i was uh you
- 14:38know uh you know, in college, you know, so I
- 14:41started learning about Title VII, and I used
- 14:44to write letters, you know, the Constitution
- 14:46says, you know, and then I was talking with a
- 14:51lawyer one time from a company that I was dealing
- 14:53with, and the guy says, very early on, he says,
- 14:55well, you know, the Constitution doesn't apply
- 14:56to us, right? Because we're a private employer.
- 15:00I was like, oh, yeah, I know that. I'm just putting
- 15:01that for the context. I was like, oh, I guess
- 15:05you're right. And I Googled, there was no Google
- 15:07at the time, but I looked that up. And, you know,
- 15:09so anyway, through these kind of trial and error
- 15:11things, I actually got pretty sharp. And then,
- 15:13you know, at employment discrimination. And so
- 15:17I did that for most of my time there, as well
- 15:20as learning about media relations and communications,
- 15:23public relations, that sort of thing. And I really
- 15:27mentored and learned to write under the communications
- 15:30director there. That was some of the most meaningful
- 15:34work that I did. And in that process where I
- 15:37am learning, okay, when you have a complaint
- 15:40of discrimination, you can't just go in there
- 15:44charging and say it's all the fault of the company
- 15:47without doing a kind of investigation, calling
- 15:49the other side, asking them, the manager, asking
- 15:52those folks, can you tell me what happened there?
- 15:56And you have to go through a process in that
- 15:59of mediating. and trying to find common ground.
- 16:03And first of all, trying to find out if you learn
- 16:05there's always two sides to every story. And
- 16:08so it's ironic, but through that process of year,
- 16:12because if you don't, I mean, you come out looking
- 16:14stupid and with no credibility and therefore
- 16:19ineffective for the job that you're trying to
- 16:21do. And so it's ironic that my niche in care
- 16:26through that. I learned, you know, that you have
- 16:30to find some kind of common ground, some middle
- 16:34ground, you know. Another example, I, we had
- 16:37a woman, Muslim woman who was a teacher at a
- 16:40Catholic school, and they wouldn't, the Catholic
- 16:41school wouldn't allow her to wear hijab. And,
- 16:44you know, oh, this is outrageous, you know, and
- 16:46I'm just dive right in and, you know, send a,
- 16:50you know, intimidating lawyerly letter to the,
- 16:54you know, to the diocese. And, you know, and
- 16:56I'm on the phone with, you know, the someone
- 16:59over there and they're like would you allow a
- 17:03Catholic woman who's working at a Islamic school
- 17:08would you would you allow her to wear a cross
- 17:10and you know obviously the hijab is not the same
- 17:13thing as a cross but you know we're at a religious
- 17:15school we have the right to say what you know
- 17:18to to to we have the right to say that um what
- 17:21what people wear and when it's communicating
- 17:23that you're a muslim and you know and it's commuting
- 17:26communicating a religious message even if you're
- 17:28not attending it and so and i would not i was
- 17:30having none of it you know absolutely not this
- 17:33is wrong and of course they're not you know subject
- 17:37to title vii and they're not subject to to the
- 17:39same laws that um that uh private employers not
- 17:42secular employers or government employers are
- 17:45are subject to so I was actually way off base
- 17:49and I, you know, and, and doing that, I damaged,
- 17:52he's told me, the guy says, look, you're really
- 17:55harming our relations here. This is, we have
- 17:58to come to a common ground here and understanding
- 17:59and understand one another. No. And, and this
- 18:03is one of these cringy moments when I look back
- 18:05and I say, wow, you know, this is, I, I, I learned
- 18:08so much from mistakes as well as, you know, the
- 18:13right way and good way to get things done. And
- 18:16I have to say, you know, that we as a Muslim
- 18:20community did not learn that lesson that I was
- 18:22learning there, you know. And another thing,
- 18:27before I get to 9 -11, I was at a protest, a
- 18:31Palestinian protest. We were actually protesting
- 18:34against Ariel Sharon, who had come to speak at
- 18:38an AIPAC conference in D .C. And so it was on
- 18:42DuPont Circle. uh the the the um the muslims
- 18:48it was a muslim organized event it was care and
- 18:51um daryl hijra and others had um had organized
- 18:54the the protest against ariel sharon who is you
- 18:57know definitely a horrible um human being you
- 19:01know um or had at least committed a horrible
- 19:03uh uh acts you know um in you know subra and
- 19:08other you know types of uh you know events you
- 19:13know so so it's not that this is not worthy yeah
- 19:16it's not that that's not worthy of protest but
- 19:18um you know anyway uh the i'm not actually at
- 19:23this point like i'm not criticizing the president
- 19:24i'm just saying this was this was happening so
- 19:26you know since since um there's very narrow uh
- 19:30sidewalk where you can stand on the the the protesters
- 19:33were like way up and down connecticut I think
- 19:49we lost him for a moment. Hopefully he'll be
- 19:51back. Okay. I got dropped off for a second there.
- 20:11Are we good? yeah we're good um yeah we just
- 20:15missed you from and you were just talking about
- 20:16um the protesters that were lined right so so
- 20:21on the other side of the of connecticut avenue
- 20:23you had the hotel and you had apac um i guess
- 20:27interns or whatever came out they were all young
- 20:29people came out and they set up like a speaker
- 20:31and with a microphone and they were shouting
- 20:33stuff and so both sides are shouting things at
- 20:36each other both sides are um you know and so
- 20:39i my job at that event was to record. Oh, Ismael,
- 20:50we can't hear you for some reason. Can you hear
- 21:01Chris or not? You can't hear. Yeah, okay. I'm
- 21:04kind of neutral in the situation. Okay. Can you
- 21:11guys hear me okay? Yeah, now we can hear you.
- 21:13Yeah. Okay. All right. Just let me know if I
- 21:15break up. And as I'm going on, you know, I'm
- 21:20on the Muslim side. Obviously, I am the Arab
- 21:22side. Obviously, I understand everything that
- 21:24they're saying. You know, this is my side. You
- 21:27know, I don't need to empathize. I don't need
- 21:31to make an exercise in empathy because I already
- 21:32empathize. I'm already there, you know. And then
- 21:35I'm going on the other side and I'm listening
- 21:37to these people. And these people are shouting
- 21:39and screaming things like Saddam Hussein is terrible.
- 21:42I really don't know why they were yelling that.
- 21:43It was just kind of something they were yelling
- 21:45and they were feeling. But I noticed something.
- 21:48I noticed that those folks were feeling attacked.
- 21:51They were feeling something very personal. They
- 21:55were feeling something very, very, I mean, it
- 21:58didn't make sense to me. Like, why are you so
- 22:00personally offended by this protest? And I started
- 22:05talking to people over there just to understand.
- 22:08And I started realizing that they were seeing
- 22:10this as their perception, right, is that this
- 22:15was something that was anti -Jewish. And it was
- 22:18anti -Israel, yes, but it was kind of, you know,
- 22:20because they identified so much with Israel as
- 22:24part of their identity and what it means to be
- 22:26Jewish, they were taking this as a, you know,
- 22:28personal attack, you know, against them and against
- 22:32their faith and, you know, and against their
- 22:36identity. And, but at the same time, while I'm
- 22:40over there, I'm like, well, I understand that,
- 22:42but did you, I'm asking people, did you, did
- 22:44you think about how they might feel in terms
- 22:46of like, you know, they, people who have homes
- 22:48and they lose their home and, you know, through
- 22:50the, and I was talking to one guy who was, who
- 22:53had been screaming, you know, and I started just
- 22:55having a conversation and then he kind of like
- 22:56stopped screaming his unreasonable things that
- 23:00he was screaming and, and stopped to listen to
- 23:02me, you know? So that incident right there. There's
- 23:07another thing that kind of like struck me as,
- 23:09you know, sometimes if you just talk to people,
- 23:12you know, they can at least if they're not going
- 23:14to convert, you know, they're at least become
- 23:16open to looking at the other side. So it really
- 23:24struck me that this was something we had not
- 23:27been doing. And it was maybe two weeks before
- 23:309 -11, two or three weeks that I reflected on.
- 23:36everything that we had done, you know, at CARE.
- 23:40And by the way, CARE was not the only American
- 23:43Muslim organization that had, you know, that
- 23:46constituted the national Muslim leadership. You
- 23:49know, you also had very crucial organizations
- 23:51like MPAC, Muslim Public Affairs Council, and
- 23:56American Muslim Council, another organization,
- 23:58which ended in infamy. But that's another thing
- 24:03they did for a long time. They did a lot of actually
- 24:05good work, in a way, I think, to their credit,
- 24:08a lot of, you know, a lot of questionable things,
- 24:11but, you know, they helped form that, and then,
- 24:14you know, and so once, whereas MPAC was more,
- 24:20you know, so, but CARES very quickly overtook
- 24:26the entire tenor of our community's relations,
- 24:31if you will, with the broader community. Again,
- 24:34it's not a critique of care. I mean, it sort
- 24:37of is, yes, but I really want to step beyond
- 24:40that, and I want to look at how the American
- 24:47Muslim interaction with the broader community
- 24:51took on a tenor of and a tone of shrill demands.
- 25:00It's we demand, we reject, we condemn, we insist,
- 25:07we call on, you know, it's it's that sort of
- 25:10that sort of tenor, you know, became. And to
- 25:14be fair, I mean, this this is really an extrapolation
- 25:17of the civil rights movement. And, you know,
- 25:22and it's it's a it's a it's a mode of of advocacy.
- 25:29and representation of one's community that care
- 25:36adopted. And what ended up happening was that
- 25:40because there was no sort of normal, calm, conciliatory
- 25:52let's say like, I don't know what all the adjectives
- 25:54I'm looking for, but like where you're, where
- 25:56you're, you know, where you're working with the
- 25:58community, the broader community for the common
- 26:01good in partnership with people you really deeply
- 26:04disagree with, you know, on matters of common
- 26:07concern, you know, there, we didn't have that
- 26:11really. Now that's not to say, obviously there,
- 26:13there were people in local, especially locally,
- 26:15you know, you had Iman in Chicago, inner city
- 26:18Muslim action network. You had you know, the
- 26:22Mosque Cares, you know, I don't know if they
- 26:24had that name at the time, the Worthy Muhammad
- 26:26community. You had different in New York and
- 26:30Brooklyn and stuff. You had a lot of that going
- 26:34on where there were people involved in the community
- 26:37and trying to make the community that they lived
- 26:39in better on a local level. But that is not what
- 26:44came to dominate the the, the, um, the tone of
- 26:50our relationships. And, um, it occurred to me,
- 26:54as I said, just a few weeks before nine 11, I
- 26:56said to myself, you know, I do not, I, I, I,
- 27:02everything that we have been working for all
- 27:04the respect that we have gained. And we, I mean,
- 27:06really, there was a great deal of it, but there
- 27:08was an article in a society for human resource
- 27:11management. Um, journal where they quoted me
- 27:14and actually interviewed me for it sometime around
- 27:1899 or something like that about how companies
- 27:22now, employers now, are much more aware than
- 27:25they were previously in years past about the
- 27:29obligations of Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights
- 27:32Act on employers to accommodate religious practices
- 27:36and so on. So our work had actual real impact
- 27:40there. You know, like I said, it occurred to
- 27:43me, I said, all of this respect that we've gained
- 27:46can be wiped away or would be wiped away like
- 27:50in an instant with some kind of major terrorist
- 27:53attack. I was thinking that just right before
- 27:559 -11. So we had just moved into our office in
- 27:57D .C. And I can even remember where I was in
- 28:00the office when I was thinking that. And so I
- 28:05came to work one day, late as usual, around 9
- 28:09-05. in DC, driving past the Pentagon, as I did
- 28:13on 395. And we had in our conference room, we
- 28:17had a TV set up there with cable TV. And I was
- 28:21at my office and my computer, just doing my thing
- 28:25that I usually did in the day. And I hear my
- 28:29boss shouting, Ismael. So I go and I went into
- 28:36the conference room and on the TV is. the twin
- 28:39towers and one of the towers is you know on fire
- 28:42smoking and he's and and they were you know they
- 28:46had figured out obviously at that point it was
- 28:48a plane he had just turned it on and uh i said
- 28:52oh my god you know i said i said maybe it's not
- 28:55muslims that's what i said to him you know maybe
- 28:57it's not muslims and this is what he said to
- 28:59me he said no he said we're we're very unfortunately
- 29:04we're professional at nothing except for doing
- 29:07evil That's what he said. And, you know, I mean,
- 29:12it was a very cynical statement, but it was,
- 29:14you know, when you look at, I understand, I was
- 29:16like, you know, yeah, because we had, there's
- 29:19an ongoing kind of critique among Muslims that,
- 29:23well, we just don't seem to be doing, we don't
- 29:24seem to be able to do things very professionally,
- 29:26you know? I can't say I'm any different. Like
- 29:30I said, I got to work late that day as usual,
- 29:32you know? So, you know, uh 9 11 happened and
- 29:38um i at the time had been working with this is
- 29:41something i kind of you know because i was telling
- 29:44one there's many different angles to this i at
- 29:47the time had been working with um an organization
- 29:50based in pakistan that was fighting against india
- 29:53uh because i was still had in my mode in my mind
- 29:57of oh i'm i'm fighting to to help the muslims
- 30:00you know to free the muslims from oppression
- 30:02and i was doing that in a kind of like you know,
- 30:05in the background, you know, not care, knew nothing,
- 30:08obviously, about what I was doing, but it was
- 30:11part of my life. And I was also a Salafi. And
- 30:15I was, you know, if you're familiar, if anyone's
- 30:17familiar with like the jihadi milieu at the time,
- 30:20and there were different waves, stages of the
- 30:24jihadi movement, and then earlier stages, kind
- 30:26of like the freedom fighter, foreign legion.
- 30:29And then that, that, you know, kind of segues
- 30:32into Another phase where other leaders and ideologues
- 30:37take over and it becomes anti, you know, it becomes
- 30:42against America and adopts a much more extreme
- 30:45and fanatic. Not to say that the previous stage
- 30:48was not, but, you know, it morphs and metastasizes.
- 30:51So this was really kind of like the spark of
- 30:55that. Although the embassy bombings in Africa
- 30:57had been kind of that as well, you know, but
- 30:59this was a real wake up call. So now me, I said,
- 31:02well, where does this leave me? I'm someone who,
- 31:04I'm an American. I love America. I want good
- 31:07for America. I was just reflecting on how we
- 31:09need to do more, you know, for the common good,
- 31:13if we're going to really be part of this country,
- 31:16you know. We were excited about, I was excited
- 31:19about Bush because there was a neighborhood partner,
- 31:21you know, the faith -based partnerships and stuff
- 31:23that was going to be part of the new administration,
- 31:26you know. and uh and then this i mean this like
- 31:30ruined and it did exactly what i thought it wiped
- 31:34away all of the you know um everything that we
- 31:38had built you know and our response to that there
- 31:42was a lot you know the response initially was
- 31:44just confusion but the american muslim community
- 31:46response initially was condemnation but also
- 31:49don't blame us you know And, you know, and there
- 31:53was a lot of backlash against Muslims. It's understandable
- 31:56that there would be concern. You know, but it
- 32:01was a very self -centered response. And I think
- 32:05we can talk more about that and the questions
- 32:07and answers. And I've, you know, perhaps spent
- 32:09more time than I should on the preparatory discussion
- 32:13here. But, you know. what we had to fall back
- 32:19on. What did we have to fall back on? I mentioned
- 32:21that, you know, if you know, let's put it this
- 32:26way. If you know, if you have a friend, you know
- 32:29him very, very well, and he's a good friend,
- 32:32and you have a lot of things in common, and it's
- 32:37to the point where you see that friend's good
- 32:39as your good, and your friend sees your good
- 32:42as his good. You're really in tune when it comes
- 32:48to your vision of what's good and looking out
- 32:55for each other. You just know each other really
- 32:58well. Then that person, you hear that this person
- 33:01gets into, for example, a road rage incident
- 33:03or something like that and does something completely
- 33:06out of character. You say to yourself, well,
- 33:08look, that guy most likely was having a really
- 33:11bad day, doesn't excuse what he did. but he is
- 33:14most likely having a really bad day and you know
- 33:17he regrets what he did and you know and so with
- 33:21muslims uh the analogy is not perfect because
- 33:25we did muslims living in america did not have
- 33:27anything to do with 9 11. these were these were
- 33:32people who came from outside but That's not really
- 33:35the point. That's beside the point. The real
- 33:38point here is that this is the image that Americans
- 33:42are getting with Muslims, is their experiences,
- 33:47their experience with Muslims. And psychologists
- 33:49have said that if you have that one negative
- 33:55experience with a person, it takes something
- 34:00like 15 positive experiences to alleviate. or
- 34:04to overcome that negative experience. And I'm
- 34:09paraphrasing what I have read about this. And
- 34:14we know that to be true from our experience.
- 34:17I mean, for example, as a husband, if your wife
- 34:20sees one negative thing from you it takes a long
- 34:26time to you know a lot of doing a lot of good
- 34:28you know to make up for that um and and it's
- 34:32it's it's really interesting that how how human
- 34:34beings work so if muslim if all that americans
- 34:37know about muslims generally is we demand we
- 34:41condemn we reject we insist we call on we you
- 34:45know and they don't have a well of um of good
- 34:51uh of goodwill you know developed or they may
- 34:54not know you at all let's say and if they do
- 34:56know you that's what they know about you you
- 34:58know um now that's not to discount obviously
- 35:01in every individual you know we there are muslim
- 35:03doctors and firefighters and and you know and
- 35:06and people that and neighbors people know their
- 35:09neighbors people know you know there is that
- 35:10right of course people know that you know but
- 35:13when you know when this is your i mean we are
- 35:16we put pouring our resources into making sure
- 35:19that this country and its leaders know of us
- 35:24as not to be messed with. We are hard, we are
- 35:29tough, and you are not going to mess with us,
- 35:31and you are not going to insult us, and you are
- 35:33not going to discriminate against us, and you
- 35:35are not going to, this is like the, okay, all
- 35:38right, but where is the, all right, and we'll
- 35:40work together in partnership for things that
- 35:43everyone cares about. You know, you don't have
- 35:45that. We just didn't build that. And one reason
- 35:47for that is it's a new community. It's a relatively
- 35:49young community. You know, the institutions are
- 35:52not there. The maturity is not there. You know,
- 35:55there has been a recent, there was a study a
- 35:57few years back that American Muslims spend more
- 36:00on charity than the average American, but our
- 36:04charity goes overseas and it goes to civil rights,
- 36:08right? It goes to rights, demands, demands, demands,
- 36:13and then it goes overseas. But it's not going,
- 36:16our efforts are not, have not gone and still
- 36:18are not going to, you know, to the common good,
- 36:22to ways that we all live here. This is, this
- 36:25is just, this is not merely a ploy to win people
- 36:29over. It's that we also live here. And that's
- 36:31the interesting thing about the golden rule is
- 36:33that it has benefits. It has pragmatic use, but
- 36:37it is also, it is also for something beyond oneself.
- 36:43It's for God, first of all. It's for our creator.
- 36:46And the way that we treat others is a reflection
- 36:50of our relationship with our creator. So in their
- 36:56hadith about this, that one could go on and on
- 36:59and on about. But we didn't have any of that.
- 37:02And after 9 -11, we didn't have that to fall
- 37:06back on. We didn't have partnerships with people.
- 37:10We didn't have deep relationships and friendships.
- 37:14We didn't have that with the broader community.
- 37:18And so what do we have to rely on? We have to
- 37:21go back to grievance, guilt, persecution, playing
- 37:29on or playing to the, I don't want to say playing
- 37:32in a pejorative way, but trying to resonate with
- 37:35people on their... empathetic side. And it's
- 37:38fascinating. And I did a study for the Saudi
- 37:40government, actually, in 2002. It was actually
- 37:44for Salman al -Awda's institution, but he was
- 37:49doing this study at the request of the Roya family.
- 37:55And it's available online still. I did a study
- 37:58on a kind of survey of surveys of before and
- 38:03after 9 -11. It was published in April 2002.
- 38:05And I found something very striking that the
- 38:07American Muslim, I mean, sorry, that the American
- 38:10public's opinion of Muslims and Islam was actually
- 38:15more favorable after 9 -11 than it was before.
- 38:18And there's no question in my mind, and this
- 38:20actually came out in some of the questions that
- 38:22were asked, that this had kind of the result
- 38:25here is due to empathy, you know, and got it.
- 38:33But that runs out. That's the thing. That's not
- 38:36a foundation. That's not a foundation to build
- 38:39on. And so here we are 25 years later. And I
- 38:43was writing in 2002. And those essays are available
- 38:47on my blog. I have agoodtree .net. I reposted
- 38:56some of the essays I had published in 2002 where
- 38:58I was saying this grievance thing, it's not working.
- 39:02It's not. It's not enough. It's ultimately going
- 39:06to be harmful. 25 years later, we have not done
- 39:12that. We didn't do what we could have done before
- 39:169 -11, and we didn't learn the lesson of how
- 39:21we are to function as a community that is part
- 39:27of America. So that's what I'm... And I say that,
- 39:33before we take questions, I say that not as a
- 39:36way of berating, only berating the Muslims, self
- 39:39-flagellation. You know, I say that as, okay,
- 39:43let's, you know, let's not do the finger pointing.
- 39:47Let's learn this lesson. And let's do something
- 39:51different. Let's change our mentality. Let's
- 39:54change our, let's ask ourselves, how did we contribute
- 39:56to the situation where 50 % of America now looks...
- 40:00down, has a negative opinion about Muslims, much
- 40:03worse than it was immediately after 9 -11. And
- 40:07yeah, we could say, oh, there's a campaign against
- 40:09Muslims in Islam. And yeah, okay. But again,
- 40:13you can campaign all you want against someone
- 40:16who has a deep well of goodwill. It's not going
- 40:19to work. Why is it working so well? Why is it
- 40:21so effective? That's the question we have to
- 40:24ask. And it's very difficult to ask, but we have
- 40:27to ask it. And we'll go ahead and take questions.
- 40:31Thank you so much. This is really important.
- 40:33I think that's kind of the space that eventually
- 40:36I think we're hoping to build is kind of an intellectual
- 40:40sort of space for internal understanding, critique,
- 40:45discussion, so that we're able to strengthen,
- 40:48I think, the American Muslim community and sort
- 40:52of their engagement in American civil society.
- 40:55So thank you so much for. the tireless work that
- 40:58you've been doing. Unfortunately, very thankless
- 41:00as well. So I think with that, I'll open it up
- 41:03for questions. If anybody has a question, they
- 41:06can just unmute themselves because there are
- 41:09enough people here that should be pretty easy
- 41:12to do. And then I guess I can start off. So I
- 41:22have a question. I mean, where... what would
- 41:33a yeah no no you went out for a minute no i'm
- 41:38just wondering i mean like so what would a um
- 41:41but you know what i you know what i call covenantal
- 41:45but kind of this type of uh politics um Like,
- 41:49what are the types of organizations that would
- 41:51have to develop? What would they look like? Because
- 41:54I'm thinking of sort of institutional terms,
- 41:56right? That's the challenge that we really have.
- 41:58Like, we have individuals that are trying to
- 42:00do interfaith dialogue. They're trying to do
- 42:02sort of relationship building. But at institutional
- 42:04level, there's no major institution. At least
- 42:07I know in terms of doing Muslim Jewish work,
- 42:09all of that stuff at the major institutional
- 42:12levels have completely fallen apart, right? With
- 42:14ISNA and sort of these other organizations. what
- 42:18type of organizations need to develop to create
- 42:22those partnerships? I mean, what would it look
- 42:24like? Well, one thing is that, first of all,
- 42:29there needs to be a general change in mentality.
- 42:32I mean, that's really important because otherwise
- 42:33you end up having efforts that are not deeply
- 42:40rooted. People don't understand why they're doing
- 42:43those efforts. The efforts will not have the
- 42:46kind of, sincerity about them. We have to mature.
- 42:52This is really important. And that is not as
- 42:55hard as it's obviously very hard, but it's not
- 42:57as hard as it sounds because what you need is
- 42:59you need leaders. You need leaders who are thought
- 43:04leaders, who are leaders in local communities,
- 43:07who are leaders nationally to begin this process
- 43:12of evaluation. you know, and self -analysis.
- 43:15And this is, and the touchstone here is our religion,
- 43:18you know. It's an understanding of, because our
- 43:22religion, because it's from the creator, Islam
- 43:24is from the creator, and the creator created
- 43:26us, created our hearts and our minds of all human
- 43:30beings, you know. And so, so much of this is
- 43:32intuitive, you know, when you talk about the
- 43:34golden rule, you know. I mean, I think that's
- 43:36a great place to start is. The golden rule. Want
- 43:39for others what you want for yourself. Want for
- 43:41your neighbor what you want for yourself. Love
- 43:43for your neighbor what you love for yourself.
- 43:44Love your neighbor as you love yourself. These
- 43:46are things that are part of our religion explicitly
- 43:49and also implicitly. So we have to develop a
- 43:55mentality that is not self -centered and that
- 43:59is not transactional. We have to develop that
- 44:02mentality. And that is not only an intellectual.
- 44:07process, although it is, and spiritual process,
- 44:10although it is, but it is also practical and
- 44:14pragmatic that can be modeled. You know, this
- 44:17is what I try to model. I'm not claiming that
- 44:19I'm perfect, but I try to really, I mean, 90
- 44:23% of what I do is aimed at helping people of
- 44:29other faiths in what is important to them and
- 44:34what is meaningful to them. And I do that because
- 44:37I want good for them, you know. And, you know,
- 44:41you can say that all you want, you know, but
- 44:43when you've been for 10 years, you know, putting
- 44:47in work for others and getting to know them and
- 44:50they're getting to know you, you can't fake that.
- 44:53Whereas up until now, interfaith dialogue, you
- 44:58know, those sorts of things, those are important,
- 45:00but they're not as we can see. they evaporate,
- 45:04I mean, the instant they come under stress, you
- 45:08know, because they're not, you know, they're
- 45:11not really meaningful, you know, they're not
- 45:13really meaningful, ultimately, in the end, much
- 45:15of it is based on insincere, we're all going
- 45:20to heaven, or we're all, you know, universalism
- 45:23and stuff, which Muslims don't even believe,
- 45:25you know, although some Muslims do, you know,
- 45:28and so you have You know, you have these kind
- 45:31of things happening. And again, I don't mean
- 45:33to downplay them. But I mean, I think if you
- 45:37see, for example, Pastor Bob Roberts and what
- 45:41Imam Majid, Muhammad Majid, they did with their
- 45:46network that they had of pairing Christians and
- 45:49Muslims together to do actual work. You know,
- 45:52if you're actually out there and there are people
- 45:53doing this locally, by the way, you know, I know.
- 45:56For example, in California, in Southern California,
- 46:00the Muslims there work with Habitat for Humanity.
- 46:04It's just there has to be, it's a matter of focus.
- 46:09IMAN, Inter -City Muslim Action Network, the
- 46:12mosque cares, those kind of efforts have to be
- 46:14the number one. There's a clinic that the Pakistani
- 46:20Muslim physicians are doing in Hoover, Alabama.
- 46:24Another one that has been, these can't be just
- 46:27like outlier things. They have to be our main
- 46:30thing, our main thing. And then you have, I mean,
- 46:37I am right now preparing a lawsuit against the
- 46:39state of Illinois, working to, not the only one
- 46:43doing it, I'm working, and I initiated this effort.
- 46:47It'll be filed next week by Muslim physicians.
- 46:51to block the physician -assisted suicide law
- 46:54there because it puts Muslim physicians in a
- 46:57bad position unconstitutionally. And working
- 47:02with Catholics to do it and Lutherans and others.
- 47:05So this is an example of, yes, it's not that
- 47:10we don't advocate for ourselves and for our rights
- 47:12and so on, but even when we do that, we're doing
- 47:15it in partnership and cooperation for the greater
- 47:18good. not just for for us last thing i'm gonna
- 47:21say on this is like the other day there was a
- 47:22um an organization put out here's a uh here's
- 47:27a here's a list of things you should ask your
- 47:28legislators you know kind of a document lobbying
- 47:31type document you know uh electoral politics
- 47:34type thing and like um every single one of them
- 47:40those questions it was like 12 questions every
- 47:42single one of them had to do with things that
- 47:44were very very specific to the Muslim community.
- 47:49I mean, very, I don't want to say selfish, but
- 47:52self -centered, self -directed. Yeah, okay, we
- 47:57care about ourselves and our interests, but we
- 47:59have to think of our interests as being coterminous
- 48:03with our values and with the good of the greater
- 48:08society. And there are very rare circumstances
- 48:11where advocating for someone else's good is going
- 48:15to actually be harmful to you. You can think
- 48:17of, thought experiments where that might be the
- 48:20case. But it's very rare. And in those cases,
- 48:24that's case -by -case basis. For example, just
- 48:27quickly, you wouldn't want to advocate for the
- 48:31right of fully automatic machine guns when you're
- 48:41in a political situation where that could be
- 48:45used against not only Muslims, but against people
- 48:47generally you know so so though there are examples
- 48:50of that sort of thing you know but maybe that's
- 48:53not a great example but it's just something that
- 48:55popped in my mind sure um let me take ian's question
- 48:59and then chris um so ian has a question um and
- 49:03he put in the chat do you find the ethnic diversity
- 49:05of the muslim american community has acted as
- 49:08a possible obstacle or strength to this greater
- 49:11civic society for muslim americans Well, you
- 49:15know, that's a very interesting question. And
- 49:17I think that, you know, it's very obviously,
- 49:21it very obviously could be a strength, you know,
- 49:24in where you're, you know, this is the great
- 49:26thing about the Jama 'at, you know, the group,
- 49:29you know, like a diverse group brings different
- 49:32skills and experiences and backgrounds to the
- 49:35table. The fact that I am, you know, European
- 49:38American, I can communicate and I can relate.
- 49:44to people in ways that might be difficult for,
- 49:48for, you know, for, from both sides, you know,
- 49:52and if, if, if I, you know, for folks of different
- 49:55ethnic backgrounds and national origin, you know,
- 49:58and I remember what, just briefly, I remember
- 50:01one time I was doing khutbas or sermons, Friday
- 50:06sermons among predominantly African -Americans
- 50:10and in prison. And someone said to me, you know,
- 50:16people are complaining. They say they have white
- 50:18people telling them what to do all week and they
- 50:20don't want to come on Friday and have another
- 50:22white guy telling them what to do, you know?
- 50:23And I could have like taken that offensively
- 50:26if I were immature, you know, but you know, the
- 50:32fact is that, and there's some people have reflected
- 50:35on this as well. Like religious leaders from
- 50:38the black community have also thought about this.
- 50:39Like, why is it we have in all these. mosques
- 50:43in the inner city, they have white imams. It
- 50:45doesn't make a lot of sense. This is in the Salafi
- 50:47community. And I think there's something to be
- 50:51said there where, you know, but this is an example
- 50:53of where diversity is good because you have people
- 50:55able to speak to different parts of the community.
- 51:01You know, and that's just a small example. We
- 51:03have in the Indo -Pak, Indian subcontinent community,
- 51:07we have um, physicians and, um, so many, like
- 51:115 % of them are doctors, you know, I mean, it's
- 51:13amazing, you know, um, of what they, what they
- 51:17bring, you know, and so on. And you have, you
- 51:19know, so I, uh, but, but the reality though,
- 51:22unfortunately is, is that there's often do become,
- 51:24um, grounds for, um, uh, for division. Um, you
- 51:29know, I can think of the, for example, the support
- 51:32for George Bush, um, which I think was actually
- 51:35wise. But there was an enormous amount of friction
- 51:40because the organizations led by those of immigrant
- 51:44backgrounds had not even consulted with the worthy
- 51:47Mohammed community or others from the African
- 51:49-American community. And this led to an enormous
- 51:51amount of tension over the decision to endorse
- 51:54President, the candidate Bush at the time. You
- 52:01know, we could, you know, leverage this to our
- 52:05advantage, I think, much more. It's a great advantage.
- 52:08So we do have a great resource that we have.
- 52:10Great. I'll turn it over to Chris for his question.
- 52:13And this will probably be our last question because
- 52:16then we're going to be ending. Sure. In five
- 52:19minutes. First off, I just want to thank you
- 52:22all for putting this on. I mean, I think this
- 52:24is the first time I. I've seen an event where
- 52:29an American Muslim is speaking about 9 -11. I'm
- 52:32sure there's a lot more. I don't know how many
- 52:33more there are going on now. But not only that,
- 52:37someone who's sharing openly about their career
- 52:39and changes and some reflection on what you've
- 52:44seen change in the Muslim community over years.
- 52:47I think just some of the things you said are.
- 52:52A lot of firsts here for me. You're one of the
- 52:54first Muslims I've heard speak out on 9 -11 at
- 52:57all. I spend a lot of time in Christian communities,
- 53:01so I also work with Muslims and multi -faith,
- 53:05interfaith, with MFNN and the Center for Public
- 53:08Faith as well, and still don't hear a lot of
- 53:11this. So I think this is, it's really, for me,
- 53:14important that you did this and you guys put
- 53:18this on. One of the things that you said about
- 53:21empathy running, I think is just so on point.
- 53:26And someone in this room told me not long ago,
- 53:29it's the infrastructure and development of Muslim
- 53:32communities that I heard echoed here that you
- 53:34spoke about. It needs to develop more. And some
- 53:39people are working with gatekeepers and imams,
- 53:41the stuff Bob Roberts Jr. is doing and Michael
- 53:43Freese over at Multifaith Neighbors Network.
- 53:46There's so many. I'm getting to my question here.
- 53:51Having worked with Muslims across the world and
- 53:56here in the U .S., I've noticed that Muslims
- 53:59are extremely charitable financially and in many
- 54:06other ways as well. There's so much one -sidedness
- 54:09to giving funding to building infrastructure,
- 54:15to building institutions. help people think through,
- 54:19help Muslims think through this issue and Christians
- 54:22as well and Jews and everyone else. And so just
- 54:26wondering if you could speak to, you know, you
- 54:29spoke to some of the money going to other overseas
- 54:32or to Muslim advocacy, more demanding, but what,
- 54:36is there an explanation for this kind of one
- 54:40way? what seems to be like a one -way street
- 54:44in funding here in America, the institutional
- 54:47development of Muslim and supporting Muslim organizations
- 54:52that aren't just advocacy -based. Sorry, it's
- 54:57a good question. Yeah, no, that's okay. The explanation
- 55:05is, I have a... I have a child here. You have
- 55:13a friend? Yes, I have a friend. Can I have a
- 55:19snack? Sure. My father said I can have cantaloupe.
- 55:22Yeah, go have cantaloupe. I've thought a lot
- 55:27about that question. What is the reason for that?
- 55:33Why have we... I'll be honest. I just, I see,
- 55:42I see a kind of arrested development. You know,
- 55:46I see, I see, I see a very understandable decision
- 55:54to utilize the grievance model back in 94, you
- 56:03know, that was tactical and strategic, but also
- 56:08reflected. to a very large extent, the personalities
- 56:12of the individuals involved. You can look at
- 56:18things, for example, like After the Ball, the
- 56:21book by two gay activists that was written to
- 56:29try to map out a strategy for the so -called
- 56:33gay liberation movement in the 80s. in the 90s.
- 56:41I'm discussing this with zero implication for
- 56:46what I think about that or anything like that.
- 56:49I'm talking specifically about the approach,
- 56:52which was to intentionally follow the model of
- 56:58the civil rights movement. But the interesting
- 57:03thing about the civil rights movement, is that
- 57:07it did teach the lesson of, you know, the squeaky
- 57:12wheel gets the grease. You have to go out there
- 57:13and you have to advocate for yourself and you
- 57:16have to, you know, but the thing about it is,
- 57:19right, the civil rights movement itself had two
- 57:21elements to it. And we'll wrap up. One tendency
- 57:24within that was that America is a lie. Everything
- 57:28it's built on is a lie. It's all hypocrisy. There's
- 57:31no meaning to it. It's all interest. It's all
- 57:35power. You know, and this actually, even though
- 57:40that sounds like postmodernism, I mean, that
- 57:41actually has roots back into the abolition, some
- 57:45aspects of abolition movement with William Lloyd
- 57:49Garrison and so on. But then you have another
- 57:51strand, and that was not the strand of Martin
- 57:54Luther King and others. You know, the other strand
- 57:56of Frederick Douglass, Martin Luther King, and
- 57:58these who said, no, the principles that are in
- 58:02the Declaration that lay at the heart of the
- 58:04American founding. are good and true. They're
- 58:07true. But we are just falling very short in realizing
- 58:14those things. And so that approach is an approach
- 58:21of let us come together on what we agree on and
- 58:25what we know to be true and what we believe and
- 58:27what we hold in common to get closer to that.
- 58:33We never get to to the practical implementation
- 58:39of what is by definition an ideal. But we have
- 58:46a common vision and let's try to at least make
- 58:48ourselves closer to that, a more perfect union.
- 58:52Of course, more perfect unions were reflecting
- 58:55on articles of Confederation before, but in another
- 58:58very real sense, more perfect, not perfect, but
- 59:00just more perfect. So I think that... We missed
- 59:05that. We didn't reflect on that deeply. We didn't
- 59:09reflect on what are our actual premises? What
- 59:14are our axioms? Rather, it was more kind of like
- 59:17shooting from the hip. Oh, this seems like the
- 59:19thing to do. Now this seems like the thing to
- 59:21do. Oh, this is happening. Now this is how we're
- 59:24going to react to that. And we haven't stopped
- 59:27to think about what do we believe? as Muslims.
- 59:34Right now, we're selling out what we believe
- 59:38as Muslims to do the thing that we think it should
- 59:42be done. We have abandoned the golden rule and
- 59:46the teachings of our faith. Those are things
- 59:49that are kind of expedient. We're looking for
- 59:51things that seem like the thing to do. So in
- 59:54conclusion, really here, what I'm saying is we
- 59:57need to reset. And we need to think about what
- 59:59our principles are and what do we believe in
- 1:00:01and what do we know to be true? And where do
- 1:00:02we find that? What practical opportunities do
- 1:00:09we have in our life as Americans, as neighbors
- 1:00:12and as citizens and so on to put that into practice?
- 1:00:17If we did that, we would find ourselves 25 years
- 1:00:21from now in a very, very different. place, in
- 1:00:24a much less vulnerable place, in a much less
- 1:00:26precarious place, in a much less marginalized
- 1:00:28place. And we can do that without, on the contrary,
- 1:00:33it's not, that is not, that does not create a
- 1:00:38kind of cognitive dissonance as to being Muslim
- 1:00:40and American. That actually resolves the cognitive
- 1:00:42dissonance. Yeah, thank you so much, Ismail.
- 1:00:47Yeah, I mean, these are, I mean, we could have
- 1:00:49another hour or two of these discussions. I think
- 1:00:51it's very deep and very important for us to be
- 1:00:53able to To think strategically, I wanted to thank
- 1:00:55everybody for coming. It's been really an honor
- 1:00:59that we were able to, you know, have this sort
- 1:01:04of conversation on a very solemn anniversary.
- 1:01:07You know, our thoughts and prayers go out to
- 1:01:09the people and their families who are affected
- 1:01:11on 9 -11. And we hope that this is one small
- 1:01:15contribution to ensuring that that never happens
- 1:01:17again and making a better society for all of
- 1:01:19us. We're very grateful for your time. Have a
- 1:01:24wonderful weekend. And we I'll send you the recording
- 1:01:29as well. So if you guys are interested in sharing
- 1:01:32it with friends and, you know, hopefully this
- 1:01:36is the beginning of more and more fruitful discussions
- 1:01:39on this really important day. Thank you so much.
- 1:01:42I appreciate it. Thank you. All right. Take care.
- 1:01:45Thank you all.