Latest / UNCHAINEDTV'S Truth Files with Jane Velez-Mitchell / UnchainedTV: What is the state of the global vegan scene in food & fashion?
Transcript
- 0:02Oh, we are in the midst of a
- 0:08revolution or is it an evolution?
- 0:11As many, many people go out of their
- 0:13way to try to convince the world we
- 0:14don't need to kill kangaroos for shoes.
- 0:16We don't need to kill chickens for chicken
- 0:19wings.
- 0:20These are made from cauliflower and they're delicious.
- 0:24And we're gonna talk to the chef.
- 0:26We don't need to kill cows to make
- 0:28burgers.
- 0:28These are quinoa burgers with a perfect protein
- 0:31in them.
- 0:32So how are we doing?
- 0:34How are we convincing 8.1 billion humans
- 0:38that the ways of old not working for
- 0:43us now?
- 0:43We've got two incredible authors with us today.
- 0:47Jonathan Ohan of Fake Movement and Healthy Voyagers.
- 0:54Carolyn Scott Hamilton.
- 0:55They are amazing.
- 0:57I'm gonna start with Carolyn.
- 0:59Carolyn, you do everything you can to convince
- 1:03the public that you don't need to kill
- 1:05animals to have a fabulous, fabulous dish.
- 1:09How are we doing?
- 1:11How are we doing?
- 1:12Great, great.
- 1:13How are you?
- 1:14How are we doing as a movement to
- 1:17wake people up?
- 1:19I think I've been vegan for 26 years
- 1:23now and I am shocked and excited at
- 1:26how far we've come.
- 1:2926 years ago, people would look at me
- 1:32and say, oh my gosh, that's gotta be
- 1:34so hard.
- 1:34No one had heard of it.
- 1:35It was just kind of starting grassroots.
- 1:38And now the fact that I hear vegan,
- 1:41plant-based everywhere around the world, it's, I
- 1:45think we're doing really well.
- 1:46We still have quite a bit of a
- 1:48ways to go, but I've seen it just
- 1:51go leaps and bounds ahead further than I
- 1:54ever expected it to go, especially in this
- 1:55short amount of time.
- 1:57Well, I love the fact that you are
- 1:59positive about this because there are so many
- 2:01people who are saying right now we're under
- 2:04attack.
- 2:06We've got nasty articles being written about vegans
- 2:12and veganism and there's sort of a campaign
- 2:15being waged against veganism probably because we are
- 2:19successful.
- 2:21So I wanna bring in Jonathan Ohayon in.
- 2:23He's an amazing author of this book and
- 2:26we're gonna get to your book too, Carolyn,
- 2:27but this one is just out and it's
- 2:30a very provocative title.
- 2:31The Fashion Industry Does Not Want You to
- 2:34Read This Book.
- 2:36Oh my gosh, Jonathan, tell us why the
- 2:39fashion industry does not want you to read
- 2:42your book.
- 2:43Because they want to keep using greenwashing with
- 2:47us and to keep sending us things while
- 2:50we don't know what it truly is.
- 2:53So that's why they don't want you to
- 2:54be educated because they know that this is
- 2:57the power.
- 2:57The power is education.
- 2:59And yeah, I love to say we're all
- 3:02superhero.
- 3:03Our superpower is choice and the responsibility we
- 3:06have is education.
- 3:08That's how we will be able to make
- 3:09those choices.
- 3:10So that's why they don't want you to
- 3:12read this book.
- 3:13What are some of the things in the
- 3:15book that are alarming?
- 3:17Oh, there's over 70 questions.
- 3:20Each question could be a whole book on
- 3:22his own.
- 3:23So there's so many problem.
- 3:25I talk about the way we treat humans,
- 3:27the way we treat, of course, animals, the
- 3:30way we treat our environment.
- 3:31So it will be very hard to just
- 3:34pick one, but yeah, there's so many different
- 3:38example of the thing they don't want you
- 3:41to read.
- 3:42Well, I think this is a fascinating book.
- 3:45And one thing I really love about it
- 3:47is that, people go, oh, Amazon.
- 3:50Well, you are only printing out books after
- 3:54they are ordered.
- 3:55So there is no waste of like printing
- 3:5720, 30, 40,000 books.
- 3:59I hope it sells 40,000, but if
- 4:01it doesn't, there's no trees that are gonna
- 4:03be killed and it's also available on Kindle.
- 4:06So why did you choose that?
- 4:09And to me, it's obvious, but maybe people
- 4:11don't understand because what it means is that
- 4:14no tree has to be cut down if
- 4:16somebody doesn't buy that book.
- 4:18Exactly.
- 4:18A lot of people ask me, so how
- 4:20many did you print?
- 4:21And I print zero because that's the beauty
- 4:24of it.
- 4:24So you upload your book on Amazon and
- 4:27basically it's print on demand.
- 4:29So once someone place an order, they will
- 4:32print the book and then they will ship
- 4:33it.
- 4:34So yeah, this is why I choose this
- 4:36system.
- 4:38Love it.
- 4:38So Carolyn, you have a new series on
- 4:43Unchained TV.
- 4:45We are so delighted to have you on
- 4:48Unchained TV.
- 4:49We're thrilled.
- 4:50It's dozens and dozens of recipes.
- 4:54You've got all the favourite foods, the burgers,
- 4:59the wings, the enchiladas.
- 5:02And you did that on purpose, right?
- 5:05Because people generally say I could never give
- 5:08up, blah, blah and you're saying they don't
- 5:10have to give that up.
- 5:12That's true.
- 5:12And that's been my mission ever since I
- 5:14started Healthy Voyager.
- 5:16I started my travel show in 2006 before
- 5:19social media even started.
- 5:21And in that, having been a chef, I
- 5:24thought, you know what?
- 5:25Let me start taking all these traditional foods
- 5:28that I'm trying all over the world and
- 5:30veganize them so that people who either travelled
- 5:32and didn't get to try that food or
- 5:34grew up eating some sort of traditional food,
- 5:37missed having that food, could enjoy it in
- 5:41their own homes and not have to sacrifice
- 5:43flavour.
- 5:44So I launched two, well now three cookbooks
- 5:48and the cooking show.
- 5:50And I feel like I've helped kind of
- 5:53push the movement forward to prove that vegan
- 5:56food is delicious, that eating ethnic international foods
- 5:59is easy to do in your own home,
- 6:02vegan style.
- 6:03So I'm really excited that you guys are
- 6:05airing my show on Unchained.
- 6:07Yeah, and your book is called Global Kitchen,
- 6:10150 Plant-Based Recipes from Around the World.
- 6:15Oh my gosh, just even thinking of 150
- 6:18plant-based recipes is enough to blow my
- 6:21mind.
- 6:22I really have to ask you, how did
- 6:24you become this chef extraordinaire?
- 6:27I started kind of teaching myself on my
- 6:29own in the early days and then I
- 6:32went to culinary school and then I just
- 6:35kind of mixed everything I grew up with
- 6:37as a kid, I'm Colombian and French.
- 6:39So everything I learned from my grandmas, I
- 6:41always loved being in the kitchen mixed with
- 6:44traditional culinary training.
- 6:46I just love veganizing.
- 6:48And that actually is the original book.
- 6:50I released the 10th anniversary edition and now
- 6:53it has 175 recipes.
- 6:56So this is the one that's available on
- 6:58Amazon now.
- 6:59The previous one is now, I think out
- 7:01of print.
- 7:02So this is the one you wanna look
- 7:03for.
- 7:03It's the same book, just updated and with
- 7:06more recipes.
- 7:07All right, well, we've already got a caller
- 7:09to question you about our question.
- 7:13Our greater question is, how are we doing
- 7:15when it comes to convincing the world that
- 7:16we don't need to kill animals for a
- 7:18purse, a jacket, shoes, chicken wings, or a
- 7:22burger?
- 7:22Neelofar in Dallas, Texas, your question or thought.
- 7:27Hi, this question is for Jonathan Ohayoun because
- 7:31you're from Belgium.
- 7:33If we assume that Western Europe is walking
- 7:36on the frontiers of veganism, are you guys
- 7:40considerably ahead of the US in terms of
- 7:44the vegan scene?
- 7:46Western Europe has a population of about 200
- 7:50million US.
- 7:51We are at a population of 335 million.
- 7:56If let's say we give the United States
- 7:59one star as far as the veganism scene,
- 8:02how many stars would you give to Europe?
- 8:07Thank you.
- 8:08Go ahead, Jonathan.
- 8:10I'm not sure I understood right the questions.
- 8:13So you're saying that- Let me just
- 8:16say this.
- 8:16I understood the question.
- 8:18United States is often behind Europe.
- 8:21We're behind when it comes to environmental protections,
- 8:23cruelty-free, cosmetics, all sorts of things.
- 8:27When it comes to the vegan movement in
- 8:29general, how far is Europe ahead of the
- 8:31United States?
- 8:35Yeah, it's funny because I see it a
- 8:37little differently.
- 8:38I actually think that the US is a
- 8:41little forward.
- 8:42We have so many vegan options, way more
- 8:45than in France from my perspectives.
- 8:49I think it's a fight.
- 8:52It depends what we talk about.
- 8:54If we talk about food, I think the
- 8:55US is way above the French.
- 9:00When you go to a restaurant or somewhere
- 9:02and you ask for vegan options, people know
- 9:04what you talk about.
- 9:05In France, they don't understand as much as
- 9:09in the US.
- 9:10That's my perspective.
- 9:12Regarding textile, yeah, there's more law in France,
- 9:15but the US is about the same.
- 9:18That's why people produce overseas.
- 9:20It's because, yeah, I think it's about the
- 9:24same.
- 9:24I wouldn't say that one is better than
- 9:26the other.
- 9:27Well, I will say this.
- 9:30Here in the United States, we have more
- 9:33protests.
- 9:35Now, there are a lot of protests in
- 9:37England.
- 9:37I'll give you that.
- 9:38And in fact, we profiled a group called
- 9:40Animal Rising, which does incredible protests.
- 9:43But we kind of take the cake for
- 9:46protests about fashion.
- 9:48I want to show you one or two
- 9:51that are pretty darn interesting.
- 9:53This one just happened a couple of days
- 9:56ago in New York City against Adidas for
- 9:59using kangaroo leather on shoes.
- 10:02Kangaroos are not shoes!
- 10:04Kangaroos are not shoes!
- 10:05Adidas.
- 10:07Stop killing kangaroos to make soccer cleats.
- 10:10Stop the torture, stop the pain.
- 10:11Adidas football is not good.
- 10:13Kangaroos are not shoes!
- 10:14So here they go.
- 10:16They may be trying to go into the
- 10:17store.
- 10:18Let's see, maybe some of them will get
- 10:19in.
- 10:19This is called a disruption when they go
- 10:20inside.
- 10:22Adidas football is not good.
- 10:24Kangaroos are not shoes.
- 10:25Stop the torture, stop the pain.
- 10:28Stop the torture.
- 10:30It's clear, kangaroos are not shoes.
- 10:31That's the message.
- 10:32We're the largest slaughter of land-based mammals
- 10:35in the entire world of kangaroos.
- 10:37One million kangaroos are gunned down in the
- 10:40dark of night and Adidas hunters steal their
- 10:43skin to make soccer shoes.
- 10:44Kangaroos are not shoes.
- 10:46If Nike, Puma, and New Balance can make
- 10:48the switch in 2023 for kangaroo skin to
- 10:51cruelty-free material, then so can Adidas.
- 10:54Kangaroos are not shoes.
- 10:56Stop the torture.
- 10:58There you go, a very intense protest.
- 11:02And I know that the head of Adidas
- 11:06has responded and said, we're not gonna respond
- 11:09to protests, but I have a feeling that
- 11:12that's primarily what these companies respond to is
- 11:16pressure campaigns.
- 11:17And by the way, Adidas is invited on
- 11:19any time.
- 11:20Thanks to Danny Rukin for providing that video.
- 11:23So, you know, that's one side of the
- 11:26equation.
- 11:26On the other side of the equation, when
- 11:29I just am out on the streets and
- 11:31I live here in LA, I was just
- 11:32in Washington, DC, I was just in New
- 11:34York City, and I look at people's feet,
- 11:36it used to be that everybody was wearing
- 11:38leather shoes.
- 11:39And now I see the vast majority of
- 11:42people are not wearing, in my opinion, I
- 11:44look at people's feet.
- 11:47I've done this for a while, it seems
- 11:48more and more people are wearing non-leather
- 11:50shoes as just an unintended consequence, not as
- 11:53a political statement, Jonathan.
- 11:56Yeah, yeah, I totally agree.
- 11:57And that's what we need to do.
- 11:59We need to shift our mindset and stop
- 12:01to putting leather on a pedestal.
- 12:05Leather is horrible and we need alternatives.
- 12:08You can use amazing shoes made of organic
- 12:11cotton, organic hemp, and yeah, we don't need
- 12:14leather.
- 12:15And I find it funny how people, I
- 12:17mean, funny, it's not funny, but how people
- 12:19get offended and they get disgusted when we
- 12:22talk about kangaroo leather or dog leather, because
- 12:25it is something, it exists.
- 12:27And what about cow leather?
- 12:29What is the difference between a kangaroo and
- 12:31a cow?
- 12:32They are both beings.
- 12:33And yeah, I'm happy that this helps people
- 12:37to make the connection.
- 12:38But yeah, the next step is to make
- 12:41people realise that there's no difference between a
- 12:43kangaroo and a cow.
- 12:44Absolutely.
- 12:46We've got more callers lining up.
- 12:49Let's go to our callers.
- 12:51Lindsay in Tarzana, California, your question or thought
- 12:54for our fabulous panel.
- 12:55We've got Jonathan Ohio, author of the new
- 12:59book, The Fashion Industry Does Not Want You
- 13:01to Read This Book.
- 13:02And Carol Scott Hamilton, author of Healthy Voyager's
- 13:05Global Kitchen, a new edition just out, as
- 13:09well as a fabulous series on Unchained TV.
- 13:12What's your question?
- 13:15Question is more of a comment.
- 13:17I'm actually on the road, so hopefully you
- 13:20can hear me and I can hear you.
- 13:22I just wanted to say regarding the book
- 13:24about eating during travel, being able to have
- 13:29vegan food while travelling, I think that's an
- 13:31amazing, necessary thing for myself and many other
- 13:36vegans.
- 13:37I did have a question actually.
- 13:39Nike kind of caved very quickly, thankfully to
- 13:43the pressure campaign.
- 13:45Why do you think Adidas is resisting since
- 13:47you are an expert, you both are experts?
- 13:50I'd like to get your opinion on that.
- 13:54Jonathan.
- 13:55Thank you.
- 13:56Hey, I'm sorry it gets a little bit.
- 14:00What is the reason why Adidas is not
- 14:06responding the way Nike, Puma, and New Balance
- 14:09responded by stopping the kangaroo leather?
- 14:15Oh, I have no idea.
- 14:17Maybe we're not loud enough.
- 14:19It's, let's say, I think the problem is
- 14:21the educators are not educated.
- 14:23They keep buying goods that they probably don't
- 14:25know.
- 14:26It's kangaroo leather, because when you take the
- 14:28label, it doesn't say kangaroo leather.
- 14:30It say either genuine leather or okay leather.
- 14:34They might think it's a type of leather,
- 14:36but most of people, if we go on
- 14:38the street and we ask them, would you
- 14:40wear kangaroo leather?
- 14:41Most of them will say, oh no, this
- 14:42is horrible.
- 14:43I wouldn't.
- 14:44So yeah, again, I think it's the lack
- 14:46of education.
- 14:47We need to educate people and then people,
- 14:50meaning the consumers, are the one who will
- 14:52make this shift.
- 14:56Yes, very, very interesting.
- 14:59My theory is that they feel like they
- 15:01can get away with it.
- 15:04These companies, in my opinion, they only respond
- 15:07when it's, it's like a mathematical calculation.
- 15:10If it's costing them more in terms of
- 15:13their brand, in terms of their global image,
- 15:16in terms of dollars and cents to keep
- 15:19the kangaroo leather on because of all these
- 15:23protests, that's the ultimate reason when they will
- 15:26take it off.
- 15:27It's not like they're gonna have a change
- 15:29of heart or suddenly care about kangaroos.
- 15:31That's my humble opinion.
- 15:33I invite Adidas on anytime.
- 15:35And I also think when it gets personal,
- 15:38before any of these campaigns happen, organisations, including
- 15:43members of parliament from Australia have written letters
- 15:48politely urging these companies to stop, in this
- 15:52case, the largest slaughter of land-based wildlife
- 15:57in the world.
- 15:59And so it's not like people just wake
- 16:01up and start charging into stores.
- 16:04There's a whole thing that has happened prior
- 16:06to that where people are begging and pleading
- 16:09with people, these executives, to stop for environmental
- 16:14reasons.
- 16:15I mean, we have reduced wildlife biomass to
- 16:194% of total mammal biomass on this
- 16:23planet while increasing livestock biomass to 62%.
- 16:30And if you think about that, what that
- 16:32means is that most animals, most living beings
- 16:35on this planet were born to be paged,
- 16:39tortured, and killed at a very young age.
- 16:42And there is something profoundly, morally, environmentally, and
- 16:47spiritually wrong with that fact.
- 16:50And we wonder why our lives are in
- 16:54such turmoil, our world is in such turmoil.
- 16:57I mean, my God.
- 16:59So it's not like people haven't asked nicely.
- 17:03They ask nicely, it just doesn't work.
- 17:06So I wanna get back to the other
- 17:09side of this equation.
- 17:10Fashion is very controversial right now, but so
- 17:13is food.
- 17:13And it doesn't have to be that way.
- 17:16Carolyn, I wanna play a video of one
- 17:20of your many, many cooking segments.
- 17:23And they offer a way to have all
- 17:26this comfort food that people say they can't
- 17:29live without, a healthier version with better ingredients
- 17:34that have better qualities, antioxidants, anti-inflammatories, perfect
- 17:40proteins, all the amino acids.
- 17:42It's a win-win-win.
- 17:47Hi guys, it's me, Carolyn Scott-Hamilton, and
- 17:50welcome to another episode of the Healthy Voyager's
- 17:52Global Kitchen.
- 17:53It's summer grillin' season, and we're making a
- 17:55buffalo black bean quinoa burger.
- 17:57Good general hot sauce for all sorts of
- 17:59things.
- 18:00All right, so we'll flip these guys over
- 18:03one more time just to seal in the
- 18:05flavour of this hot sauce on those.
- 18:12Yeah, grill it.
- 18:16Yeah, those are gonna, like the fun thing
- 18:18about using quinoa too when you're making a
- 18:20burger is that it gets crispy too and
- 18:23crunchy.
- 18:24Wow, look at that.
- 18:25Look at that, big mouth burger.
- 18:27Huge.
- 18:27That's good stuff.
- 18:28Now, okay, we'll see.
- 18:30The bread is really big here.
- 18:31All right.
- 18:32All right, you first.
- 18:37Mm, mm, really good.
- 18:39It's pretty good, huh?
- 18:39Yeah, I'm not kidding.
- 18:40I mean, you know, I mean, I'm not
- 18:43a vegan eater.
- 18:44Yeah.
- 18:45And this is really good.
- 18:45The spice is great, by the way.
- 18:48All right, Carolyn, here he is.
- 18:51He's not a vegan eater, but he loves
- 18:54the vegan food.
- 18:55What's your takeaway on that?
- 18:57Because the burger, I chose that because it's
- 18:59the ultimate.
- 19:00It's really the ultimate battleground when it comes
- 19:02to food is the burger.
- 19:05Yeah, I think that's a good gateway into
- 19:08the non-vegans, right?
- 19:09That and some kind of pasta dish.
- 19:12And I get that a lot, and I've
- 19:13been getting that for years.
- 19:14A majority of my followers aren't even vegan.
- 19:19And I love that I get comments all
- 19:22the time.
- 19:23Oh, wow, I never would have known this
- 19:24was vegan.
- 19:25Oh, I didn't know vegan could taste so
- 19:27delicious.
- 19:28I think, you know, there's still such a
- 19:31weird myth of like, you know, 70s health
- 19:34food, you know, of like dry, tasteless, nothing
- 19:38food.
- 19:39And we've come such a long way, not
- 19:42just with, you know, inventing cool alternatives or
- 19:46recipes, but all the alternatives that exist now
- 19:49for vegan meats, vegan cheeses, which is the
- 19:52one I get the most.
- 19:53Oh, I could never give up cheese.
- 19:55I'm like, you can.
- 19:56And now it's so easy.
- 19:59You know, back when I started, there was
- 20:00no such thing.
- 20:01I think we had Tofurella, which was terrible.
- 20:05And I thought to myself, well, I'll just
- 20:06have to give up cheese and make some
- 20:08kind of funky sauces, right?
- 20:09But now we have come so far and
- 20:13the amount of vegan cheeses and alternatives are
- 20:16just mind blowing.
- 20:17And this is worldwide.
- 20:19And it's funny that you guys were talking
- 20:21about in Europe.
- 20:22When I'm in Europe, the amount of vegan
- 20:25options at restaurants, as well as in the
- 20:28markets are just astounding.
- 20:30I'm so excited to see the constant growth
- 20:34in that space.
- 20:36I agree.
- 20:37It's funny because Jonathan, you're from France and
- 20:41I haven't been to France for a while.
- 20:42And when I was there years ago, I
- 20:45think it was like 2012, there were no
- 20:47vegan options that I could find.
- 20:48But I've heard that that's changed.
- 20:51Now, when I went to Berlin and on
- 20:53Unshamed TV, we have an entire mini doc
- 20:57on vegan Berlin.
- 20:58It was so vegan that I actually had
- 21:01to stop videotaping because we couldn't get a
- 21:03couple of blocks.
- 21:05The same thing for London.
- 21:06So it really depends just like in the
- 21:09United States, there's Texas and then there's LA.
- 21:12It depends on where you are in Europe.
- 21:14We've got another caller, Paige from Los Angeles,
- 21:17your question or thought for our fabulous panel.
- 21:23Paige.
- 21:26Hello.
- 21:27Yes, Paige, your question or thought.
- 21:30Thank you.
- 21:30I'm sorry.
- 21:31Yes, great.
- 21:32Hi, thank you.
- 21:33I know we were talking about food and
- 21:35cheese here, but I wanted to circle back
- 21:37to Jonathan's book, which I have in my
- 21:38hand.
- 21:39Incredible.
- 21:40And one thing I've noticed is there's so
- 21:43much conversation about the greenwashing, right?
- 21:46As well as vintage, retro, transparent, zero waste,
- 21:50all these terms, these buzzwords and terms, it
- 21:53kind of gets confusing.
- 21:54Where do you shop?
- 21:56How do you shop?
- 21:57And then also, I know I brought this
- 21:59up when we were in person, wool.
- 22:02A lot of people come up to me
- 22:03at the LA Fashion, the LA Fur Vigils
- 22:06that we hold, with the signs that say,
- 22:08I am not wool, which are the sheep.
- 22:12Can you please advise us the best way
- 22:15to answer that question of, is it wool
- 22:18ethical?
- 22:20Great question.
- 22:21Jonathan.
- 22:22Yeah, it's not ethical at all, especially nowadays.
- 22:27Basically before, the wool were having their hair
- 22:31growing during the winter to protect from the
- 22:34cold.
- 22:35And when the summer arrived, the wool will
- 22:39naturally fall, which is normal.
- 22:43But now they genetically choose them to breed
- 22:47them into this kind of sheep that have
- 22:51wool that keep growing and never stop growing.
- 22:54And so like that, they can produce more.
- 22:57The way they shred them is horrible.
- 23:00You can Google it, you will see there's
- 23:01so many horrible videos about this, because they
- 23:03don't get paid per sheep, but they get
- 23:07paid per hour, but per sheep.
- 23:10So the more sheep they can have, the
- 23:13more wool they can have per day, the
- 23:17more they're gonna make money.
- 23:18So that's why they go super fast.
- 23:20The sheep are very scared.
- 23:22But that's not only that, it's their entire
- 23:24life that is suffering.
- 23:25They have to do a nose sling, which
- 23:28is basically cutting a piece of the tail
- 23:30so they don't get infected.
- 23:33They do it without anaesthesia.
- 23:35And one of the worst thing I ever
- 23:37watched is what they call the dipping.
- 23:40So there's a cage where you can have
- 23:42maybe 10 sheep.
- 23:43They're gonna put 15 to 20 sheep inside.
- 23:45So they are compacting this cage.
- 23:47And this cage will slow being totally submerged
- 23:51in a pool of pesticides.
- 23:53And this is to kill all the flea
- 23:54and all the little insects that can be
- 23:57on them.
- 23:57And they are inside this pool, completely submerged
- 24:00for like 10, 20 seconds, and then it
- 24:03goes up slowly.
- 24:04So it's a lot of horrible practises like
- 24:07that that they have.
- 24:08And yeah, definitely wool is horrible, especially you
- 24:12have so many alternatives.
- 24:13You have organic cotton.
- 24:15You're asking where you can find those.
- 24:17There's many places online.
- 24:19There's a marketplace that actually I'm gonna start
- 24:22helping them to develop in US called Shop
- 24:25Like Give Them.
- 24:26Yeah, on fakemovement as well, fakemovement.com.
- 24:29But yeah, the marketplace shop like you give
- 24:31them, you have, I think, hundreds of brands
- 24:35already inside from Europe, US, from everywhere.
- 24:39So yeah, you can find solution easily online.
- 24:43All right, wonderful.
- 24:45We're gonna go to our next caller, Tiffany
- 24:47in Los Angeles.
- 24:49Your question or thought for our fabulous panel.
- 24:52Where are we when it comes to the
- 24:53vegan movement in food and fashion?
- 24:56Thank you, Jane, for taking my call.
- 24:59And Carolyn, it looks like lunchtime and you're
- 25:03showing these beautiful burgers.
- 25:05And Jonathan, I'm excited to order both of
- 25:08your books.
- 25:08And I was wondering how, all right, do
- 25:11you have a background in fashion or what
- 25:14was your inspiration for this book?
- 25:16Was there an incident or something that happened?
- 25:20Yeah, so all my life I was into
- 25:24fashion.
- 25:25Both my grandfather and grandmother were tailor.
- 25:28They had their own store.
- 25:30They even used to sell fur.
- 25:32They were teaching me how to recognise real
- 25:35fur from fake fur.
- 25:36They even had fur made of cats, like
- 25:39crazy, but it was like very long time
- 25:41ago.
- 25:42And also since I'm a kid, I'm working
- 25:44with my dad on the street market, selling
- 25:47bags, selling gloves.
- 25:50So I've always been around this entrepreneur fashion
- 25:54life.
- 25:55And recently, I mean, recently, 10 years ago,
- 25:59when I became vegan, with me, my dad
- 26:03and my brother, we built a brand called
- 26:05Arsayo.
- 26:06It's a backpack brand and we try to
- 26:09always make it as sustainable as possible.
- 26:13It was vegan already, but we wanted to
- 26:14be more and more ethical every time.
- 26:16So we tried new alternatives and I created
- 26:19the fake movement, which stands for fashion for
- 26:21animal kingdom and environment out of necessity because
- 26:25I couldn't find places where I could probably
- 26:27showcase the backpack that we created.
- 26:33And yeah, that's how everything started.
- 26:34I create ethical fashion pop-ups.
- 26:37Then we had a vegan fashion museum.
- 26:39We had fashion show all over the world
- 26:41in Tel Aviv, Los Angeles, Paris.
- 26:44And yeah, that's how I realised that the
- 26:46biggest gap in the fashion industry was education.
- 26:51And I realised I have to write this
- 26:53book.
- 26:53I did it out of necessity.
- 26:55I never see myself as an author.
- 26:57It was just that we need a book
- 27:00like that.
- 27:00So that's how I did it.
- 27:02And can you get the, people wanna know
- 27:04where can they get the backpack?
- 27:05Can they get it?
- 27:07It's a cork backpack because I have it
- 27:10and it's fabulous.
- 27:11Can they get it on savemovement.com, fakemovement
- 27:15.com?
- 27:16Yes, you can find it there or directly
- 27:18on the website, arsayo.com, A-R-S
- 27:21-A-Y-O.
- 27:22And we have different, we have a synthetic,
- 27:25we have cork, we have apple leather, we
- 27:27have different fabric.
- 27:29Of course, cork being for me the best
- 27:32as well as apple leather.
- 27:33But yeah, we have different style, different fabric,
- 27:36different pricing, so yeah.
- 27:38Yeah, well, I have it again, the cork.
- 27:41And at first when I got it, I
- 27:43thought, let's see how long this lasts, right?
- 27:46Brainwashing, conditioning, it is the sturdiest.
- 27:49I have thrown it around, it's gotten stomped
- 27:52on and the cork is just, it's immutable.
- 27:56And it's a beautiful bag, keeps the colour,
- 27:58keeps the shape.
- 27:59It's really, really amazing.
- 28:01I just wanna talk a little bit about
- 28:03what you said, is that here we are
- 28:05in the 21st century.
- 28:07You know, we're talking about putting people on
- 28:08Mars.
- 28:09We're talking about driverless cars.
- 28:11We're talking about artificial intelligence.
- 28:13We're talking about robots that are gonna replace
- 28:16humans.
- 28:17And yet somehow we still can't get our
- 28:19head around the idea that, hey, you don't
- 28:22need to kill a cow to have a
- 28:23frigging purse.
- 28:24And this was New York Fashion Week and
- 28:27Anna Wintour and all sorts of fashionistas were
- 28:30there as animal activists took over the runway
- 28:34and they paraded proudly until they were tackled.
- 28:39You'll see that in a second, but their
- 28:40message is, leather kills.
- 28:43Coach, leather kills.
- 28:45We invite coach on anytime.
- 28:47But you know, it doesn't take a brain
- 28:48surgeon to know that, hey, if you're gonna
- 28:50have a product with leather, an animal died.
- 28:53And yet it seems like while we embrace
- 28:57all the modern conveniences, you know, and I'm
- 29:01asking things on chat GPT now, you know,
- 29:03whip up a recipe.
- 29:04There she is getting tackled.
- 29:06The amazing activist, Jamie Logan.
- 29:08Yep.
- 29:09But it's somehow all these fashionistas and these
- 29:11people are taking private planes and oh my
- 29:14gosh, using artificial intelligence and embracing robots.
- 29:17They can't get their new guns around the
- 29:20concept that you don't have to kill a
- 29:22cow or a kangaroo or any of animal
- 29:27to have a frigging purse or shoes.
- 29:30You know, I don't, you're nodding your head,
- 29:33Carolyn.
- 29:33I know you're in the food space, but
- 29:34what is this cognitive dissonance that doesn't wanna
- 29:38go away?
- 29:39Well, it's funny.
- 29:40I was thinking about a conversation I had
- 29:41with a friend years ago.
- 29:43And I remember her saying, well, since they
- 29:47have to kill the cow for meat anyway,
- 29:49they may as well use the leather.
- 29:50I said, no, no, no, no.
- 29:51Those are two completely different factories.
- 29:55They have animals just for leather and they
- 29:58have animals just for meat.
- 29:59And it blew her mind.
- 30:01I said, no, it's not like none of
- 30:04the animal goes to waste.
- 30:05That's not how it works.
- 30:07It's totally different.
- 30:08She's like, oh, and I think that's the
- 30:10thing.
- 30:10I think people don't realise that it's a
- 30:14completely separate animal, literally, that's being used for
- 30:18fashion versus meat, which shouldn't be used at
- 30:21all.
- 30:22But I think people are thinking, well, they're
- 30:24using them for food anyway.
- 30:26They may as well use their skin.
- 30:27I'm like, that's totally not how it works.
- 30:30And I think that's what it is.
- 30:31People just don't connect those dots.
- 30:34Yeah, I mean, people tell themselves fairy tales,
- 30:37but for what?
- 30:38Do they tell themselves?
- 30:40I mean, I'm actually astounded at the rapidity
- 30:43with which the artificial intelligence technology has been
- 30:48embraced.
- 30:49I mean, literally people that I think can't
- 30:51even figure out how to programme their television
- 30:56are working with artificial intelligence.
- 30:59No problem, no problem.
- 31:02Well, why is it so difficult to figure
- 31:04out that you can have a beautiful, sustainable
- 31:06purse without killing an animal?
- 31:09And there's the status too.
- 31:11I wanna talk about that in a second,
- 31:13but we've got, I believe, another caller, Annie,
- 31:16in Sherman Oaks, your question, who thought?
- 31:18Annie just dropped off, I'll let you know
- 31:19if she calls back.
- 31:19Oh, she dropped off, okay.
- 31:21Well, I wanna get to this point, and
- 31:23that is status.
- 31:24I was recently going to the Vegan Women's
- 31:28Summit, and I decided to get a cup
- 31:30of coffee, and I normally don't shop in
- 31:33fancy stores at all, right?
- 31:35I don't really shop in stores much at
- 31:37all.
- 31:37But I went in because I was killing
- 31:40time, and I saw all these fashionable stores
- 31:43right in West Hollywood, like the hipster Ground
- 31:46Zero, and there's cashmere, and there's leather, and
- 31:51there's all these things, and I realised they're
- 31:53still status symbols.
- 31:56Oh my God, how, you know, because vegan
- 31:59leather, love him or hate him, I know
- 32:02he's extremely controversial, and he's torturing monkeys, according
- 32:07to a lot of complaints with his Neuralink
- 32:11company, and he's invited, Elon Musk, I would
- 32:13love to talk to you, please come on.
- 32:16But he did make vegan leather fashionable in
- 32:20cars, and I thought that was incredible.
- 32:23I thought that was a huge leap for
- 32:26humanity that suddenly vegan leather was a status
- 32:30symbol.
- 32:32So far, a cry from when I bought
- 32:34a car and tried to beg people to
- 32:36put vegan leather in it so it didn't
- 32:37have real leather, and basically I got a
- 32:41car that wasn't very well made as a
- 32:43result, but you know, there seems to be
- 32:47a divergence.
- 32:48In some areas, vegan leather and sustainable materials
- 32:54are becoming super hip, but yet there's still
- 32:56this old school kind of, I would say
- 33:0019th century mentality that equates dead animals with
- 33:04status, Jonathan.
- 33:06Yeah, I think the number one mistake people
- 33:09make as well with leather is to see
- 33:11it as a by-product.
- 33:12Leather is not a by-product, it's what
- 33:14we call a co-product.
- 33:16So when you call it a by-product,
- 33:18you feel like, oh, instead of wasting this,
- 33:21we should use it and wear it because
- 33:23it's better for the environment, it's better for
- 33:25the planet, but it's not this at all.
- 33:28A by-product will be to actually, once
- 33:31you remove the skin, to put it directly
- 33:33on you, which is impossible because it's gonna
- 33:35rot, it's gonna smell, it's gonna be horrible.
- 33:37So it has to go through a whole
- 33:39process.
- 33:40We call it tanning, is to make sure
- 33:42that it doesn't biodegrade anymore.
- 33:45We use horrible chemicals that are made to
- 33:47burn the hair, to bleach the colour, to
- 33:49make it completely flat and so it won't
- 33:53biodegrade.
- 33:54So this makes it a co-product.
- 33:56I love to talk about cotton, for example,
- 33:59to give the understanding of the difference between
- 34:02by-product and co-product.
- 34:04When you harvest cotton, you are left with
- 34:06the cotton seeds.
- 34:08If you use these cotton seeds and you
- 34:09sell it, you can sell it as a
- 34:11by-product.
- 34:12But if you crunch it and you modify
- 34:14it to make cotton seed oil, this becomes
- 34:17a co-product because there's a whole production
- 34:19behind.
- 34:20And that's what's happening with leather.
- 34:21It's a co-product, which means that it's
- 34:24a brand new product on its own.
- 34:26And it's one, I mean, not one of
- 34:28the most, it's the most horrible product for
- 34:31the environment.
- 34:33They usually produce it overseas because producing this
- 34:37with chromium and all these chemicals create a
- 34:40lot of waste water.
- 34:41And it's very hard to recycle this water,
- 34:43especially with the low you have in Europe
- 34:46and the US.
- 34:47So they produce overseas.
- 34:48So then they can just dump this water
- 34:50on the river because there's no low where
- 34:53they produce it.
- 34:54And you have kids that are playing in
- 34:56those river that are fishing, that are depending
- 34:59on those resources on this water.
- 35:02And they just throw all these chemicals in
- 35:04this water.
- 35:05So people don't realise the impact that the
- 35:09leather has on their environment.
- 35:10And I think if they do, again, I
- 35:12go back to this, to the education.
- 35:14If they knew what is the impact of
- 35:16the leather, I don't think they will want
- 35:18to wear that.
- 35:20They will realise- Yeah, but I remember
- 35:21talking to this so-called environmentalist, top environmentalist
- 35:26when I was in New York and media.
- 35:27And I looked down and she had like
- 35:29a Birkin bag or one of those status
- 35:32bags.
- 35:32And I thought, you know what?
- 35:36You're playing both sides of the fence here,
- 35:38lady.
- 35:39Either you're an environmentalist or you're a status
- 35:42seeking, low self-esteem queen.
- 35:46You gotta choose one.
- 35:47You can't be both.
- 35:49All right, we've got some more callers.
- 35:51Annie in Sherman Oaks, quick question or thought.
- 35:55Oh, hi, yes.
- 35:56Thank you for having this so, Jane.
- 35:58And oh, Jonathan, you're awesome.
- 36:00And Carolyn, oh my gosh, I'm so excited.
- 36:03The books and what you're doing, amazing, amazing.
- 36:06The chemicals, can you tell a little more
- 36:09about it?
- 36:09That was something that I wanted to address.
- 36:11You read my mind, Jonathan.
- 36:13People don't seem to understand that how much
- 36:15of this chemical is dangerous for even the
- 36:17people that are, they don't understand that these
- 36:20industries are oppressing humans as well as the
- 36:23animals and the environment.
- 36:24Everything is going in our soil, water, and
- 36:26air.
- 36:27And we do protest urban outfitters of the
- 36:30kangaroos or we organise all this, H&M.
- 36:33I mean, they're all, it's so prominent, it's
- 36:36disgusting.
- 36:38So, you know, how- All right, thank
- 36:39you.
- 36:40Okay, we're gonna get you to answer the
- 36:42question, Jonathan.
- 36:48Yeah, it's chemicals that go into the water.
- 36:51And Annie's point is that if you're an
- 36:53environmentalist, if you care about marginalised communities, this
- 36:58chemical-filled water is not going into the
- 37:01sewers in Beverly Hills.
- 37:03There's no slaughterhouses in Beverly Hills or on
- 37:06Park Avenue.
- 37:08And this is what the other thing I
- 37:09don't get is that it's hurting the very
- 37:13people that a lot of the folks who
- 37:15use these products purport to wanna help.
- 37:19Yeah, I actually, in the book, I put
- 37:22a list of 50 chemicals, the most common
- 37:26used in the leather industry, but you can
- 37:28have- Basically, when they tan the leather,
- 37:31they do their own recipe.
- 37:33So each tanning factory have their own recipe.
- 37:37So you can have anywhere between 50 to
- 37:39250 different chemicals.
- 37:42And those chemicals, of course, are horrible.
- 37:44The worst of them is chromium.
- 37:45So some people tell you, but it's okay,
- 37:47they use chromium-3 because chromium-3, it's
- 37:50actually an oligo element that is good for
- 37:52the humans.
- 37:52But what they don't tell you is that
- 37:54once you go through the process and you
- 37:56get heated, it becomes chromium-6, which is
- 37:59extremely carcinogenic.
- 38:01In those countries, you can see they have
- 38:02their hands that is completely bleached.
- 38:05They have a problem of asthma, of many
- 38:08different diseases.
- 38:09They die very young.
- 38:10At 30 years old, they get disease that
- 38:14make them dead.
- 38:16There's many documentary about this.
- 38:18And yeah, also for us, when we wear
- 38:21it, there was this other documentary where this
- 38:24guy in the shipping, he's taking all the
- 38:28container to see the level of chromium in,
- 38:33I mean, chromium and other different chemicals in
- 38:35the container.
- 38:36And he explained that there's not enough people
- 38:38to check that.
- 38:39So 99% of the container just come
- 38:42in the country.
- 38:43They cannot check them.
- 38:44So you have a lot of chromium everywhere
- 38:48and you wear that on you.
- 38:50And then this can affect you as well.
- 38:53And it has been proved.
- 38:54There's many study as well.
- 38:55I talk about it in the book.
- 38:57But yeah.
- 38:59I mean, you're scaring the wits out of
- 39:01me, but I'm not that scared because I'm
- 39:02not wearing leather.
- 39:03I'm not wearing fur.
- 39:05I'm not wearing cashmere.
- 39:06I'm not wearing silk.
- 39:08And guess what?
- 39:08Here I am, okay?
- 39:10I'm surviving just fine, thank you.
- 39:12And actually saving a heck of a lot
- 39:13of money.
- 39:14That's one thing.
- 39:15Being an environmentally conscious consumer means consuming less
- 39:19and it saves you money.
- 39:22I wanna talk to you about how you
- 39:24also try to, Carolyn, approach people from the
- 39:29standpoint of tradition.
- 39:30Because tradition is one of the biggest excuses
- 39:34that people use to validate their, I would
- 39:40call it sometimes mediaeval choices.
- 39:41Let's look at another quick clip of one
- 39:44of your amazing recipes, now streaming on Unshade
- 39:46TV, and we'll get you on the other
- 39:48side.
- 39:51Hey guys, it's me, Carolyn Scott Hamilton, the
- 39:53Healthy Voyager.
- 39:54And welcome to another holiday edition of the
- 39:56Healthy Voyager's Global Kitchen.
- 39:58Today, we're making a vegan shepherd's pie.
- 40:00And it's perfect for this time of year
- 40:02because you can make it ahead of time.
- 40:04You can put it in the freezer.
- 40:05It's nice and crispy and golden brown.
- 40:07The potatoes are a little bit of the
- 40:09sauce bubbled up.
- 40:10That's all right.
- 40:10It just makes it pretty.
- 40:12So we're gonna serve some up so you
- 40:14can see how nice it looks once you've
- 40:18gotten it out.
- 40:20And it's shepherd's pie.
- 40:21It's not like lasagna or anything like that.
- 40:23So it can be a little messy to
- 40:25get out, but we will do our best.
- 40:28But that's kind of the fun part of
- 40:29shepherd's pie.
- 40:30All right.
- 40:32Wow, that made me hungry.
- 40:35I don't think there's anything more traditional than
- 40:37shepherd's pie.
- 40:37It makes me wanna have an Irish accent.
- 40:40I am half Irish, so I can do
- 40:41that.
- 40:42All right.
- 40:43So Carolyn, what's this hang up that people
- 40:47have with tradition?
- 40:49Actually using it as a cudgel.
- 40:51I'm often reminding people that the first fast
- 40:56food hamburger, the first cheeseburger was invented in
- 40:591920.
- 41:00Take it away.
- 41:02Yeah, I think we're just programmed and most
- 41:06people are programmed to believe that the way
- 41:10things have always been is as they should
- 41:12be.
- 41:13But if that were the case, we'd all
- 41:15still be living in caves.
- 41:16So progress is the thing here, right?
- 41:20We wanna move forward.
- 41:21We wanna learn.
- 41:22We wanna grow.
- 41:23And tradition is the excuse that people use
- 41:26for so many things.
- 41:27Being Hispanic, I would get that a lot
- 41:30early on in my vegan days.
- 41:32Like, oh, well, what do you do being
- 41:34vegan with your family?
- 41:36I'm like, I'll cook my own stuff or
- 41:38I'll cook for them.
- 41:40And it's grown so much that my family
- 41:42is now vegan.
- 41:43My mom, my dad, a couple of cousins
- 41:45and their children.
- 41:46I actually have another cookbook that just came
- 41:49out.
- 41:50This one, it's all about Latin American vegan
- 41:53recipes.
- 41:54So it's a bunch of different Latin American
- 41:56countries.
- 41:57And you know- What's it called?
- 41:59Put it right in the camera.
- 42:00Want people to see it so they can
- 42:02get it.
- 42:02Cause this really interests me.
- 42:04Latin American, the healthy voyage.
- 42:07This is out just now.
- 42:09You are very prolific.
- 42:10I have to say, it's hard to keep
- 42:12up with you.
- 42:13I was gonna interview you and I'm like
- 42:15exhausted just coming up with all the incredible
- 42:19achievements that you have.
- 42:20All the cookbooks, all the cooking episodes.
- 42:23You know, when you agreed to send me
- 42:25some episodes and I was so thrilled.
- 42:27And then I got like 40 of them.
- 42:29I'm like, wow!
- 42:30This woman really knows how to cook.
- 42:33So yeah, I don't buy the tradition argument.
- 42:36I mean, it's absolutely ridiculous.
- 42:40And even when it comes to, let's say,
- 42:42the Latin culture in general, which is so
- 42:45many different cultures.
- 42:46And that's one of my things.
- 42:48I'm Puerto Rican and Irish.
- 42:49Puerto Rican culture is so different than the
- 42:51Mexican culture.
- 42:52That's different from the Cuban culture, the Argentinian
- 42:54culture, on and on and on.
- 42:56Different foods, et cetera.
- 42:57But there is a growing vegan movement within
- 43:00all of those countries.
- 43:02And I've been told Mexico City has something
- 43:05like 90 vegan restaurants and it's a hotbed
- 43:08of veganism.
- 43:09Absolutely, yeah.
- 43:11I eat so well in Mexico.
- 43:13Some of the best chefs in the world
- 43:15exist in Mexico and vegan or not, they
- 43:18know how to cook vegan food and really
- 43:21celebrate plants and just make it so beautiful.
- 43:24And in Colombia, where I'm from, it's become
- 43:26quite a big deal, especially in the bigger
- 43:28cities like Bogota and like Cartagena, Medellin for
- 43:32sure.
- 43:34Yeah, but all over the world, I've seen
- 43:36such a huge, huge movement.
- 43:40So I think as time kind of trudges
- 43:44on, we're gonna see the excuse of tradition
- 43:47go by the wayside because I've veganized pretty
- 43:52much everything that I grew up with, foods
- 43:55that I loved.
- 43:57And in all the countries that I've been
- 44:00to, and I've been to 140 countries now,
- 44:03I have been able to enjoy their traditional
- 44:06foods in a vegan way.
- 44:09So that excuse I think is gonna die
- 44:11off fairly quickly, I hope.
- 44:13All right, we've got still more callers.
- 44:16This is a hot topic.
- 44:18Michael in Los Angeles, your question or thought?
- 44:21Oh, hi everyone.
- 44:23Thanks so much for taking my call.
- 44:25Yeah, this question is for Carolyn.
- 44:27I was wondering, in all your travels, what
- 44:30do you consider to be the most vegan
- 44:32-friendly cities in the world?
- 44:35Thank you.
- 44:36Well, definitely Europe takes the cake.
- 44:40Anywhere in Germany, like Jane said earlier, Berlin
- 44:43is like vegan Mecca.
- 44:45And all over Germany, they're so progressive when
- 44:48it comes to vegan.
- 44:48A lot of Scandinavian countries, like wow, like
- 44:52Stockholm had amazing vegan options and gourmet, beautiful
- 44:56foods.
- 44:57France is definitely becoming vegan, like Jane said
- 45:00earlier as well.
- 45:01London, it's very easy.
- 45:03And Southeast Asia, and yes, Mexico.
- 45:07So all over the world, it's popping up,
- 45:10but I think my favourite places to find
- 45:13great vegan food are Germany, Mexico, and Scandinavia.
- 45:18And Southeast Asia.
- 45:20Yeah, well, again, Berlin, it blew my mind.
- 45:25The gourmet, the five-star, the vegan supermarket,
- 45:30it was just so vegan.
- 45:32It was shocking in a good way.
- 45:35One more caller, Michelle in Los Angeles, your
- 45:38question or thought?
- 45:40Hi guys.
- 45:42Well, my question is both for Carolyn and
- 45:44Jonathan.
- 45:45How do we reinforce that vegan food is
- 45:49delicious and beautiful as well as vegan fashion?
- 45:54I talked to Kip Anderson at the Christ
- 45:56Thirsty premiere, and he's wearing this gorgeous leather,
- 46:00non-leather jacket, and he's like, this is
- 46:02luxury.
- 46:03And I think that's the perception that we
- 46:05have to get across that it's compassionate and
- 46:09it's luxurious and it's beautiful and the food
- 46:11is amazing.
- 46:13How do we change people's perceptions?
- 46:17Jonathan, you wanna start?
- 46:18That's the $24,000 question.
- 46:22I think, again, I'm sorry I'm gonna repeat
- 46:25myself again, but I think it's all about
- 46:27education.
- 46:28It's understanding how horrible leather industry, wool industry,
- 46:33silk industry, all these industry are horrible and
- 46:36how good it is to have vegan alternatives
- 46:38for the environment, for the planet, for our
- 46:40health, for the humans, for everyone.
- 46:43So I will say again, I'm sorry I
- 46:46repeat myself, but education is the number one.
- 46:50Yeah, well, education, people say education.
- 46:53We've got 8.1 billion human beings.
- 46:57So the reason I started Unchained TV, which
- 46:59is a 501c3 nonprofit, by the way, feel
- 47:02free to donate, become a monthly donor.
- 47:04We rely on monthly donors to sustain us,
- 47:07but it's because we don't have time to
- 47:10educate everybody one-on-one.
- 47:12We're running out of time.
- 47:15There's only nine boundaries.
- 47:17And that's not me saying that, that's Sir
- 47:18David Attenborough, who has a documentary called Breaking
- 47:21Boundaries.
- 47:22And there's nine boundaries, once we cross them,
- 47:26there's no going back and our planet is
- 47:28gonna become unlivable.
- 47:30And we were already bursting through six of
- 47:32them.
- 47:32And one of them is wildlife extinction.
- 47:35Again, we've reduced wildlife down to just 4
- 47:37% of total mammal biomass.
- 47:39And it's because they're killing kangaroos in Australia.
- 47:43It's because people leave poison traps out here
- 47:46where I live in LA, which I would
- 47:48love to see be illegal.
- 47:49And then, you know, it just goes right
- 47:51up the food chain while we're simultaneously trying
- 47:54to save the hawks and the owls and
- 47:57all these animals.
- 47:58And they're dying because people wanna use poison
- 48:02when there are other solutions.
- 48:05Okay, I had mice in my apartment.
- 48:06I had it sealed.
- 48:08I brought people in who sealed the entire
- 48:10thing.
- 48:12No more mice.
- 48:13We didn't have to kill any mice to
- 48:15make that happen.
- 48:16And don't get me started.
- 48:19We've only got a couple of seconds.
- 48:20It's your turn, Carolyn, to answer that question.
- 48:23I think that the vegan movement has crossed
- 48:27the line of being kind of fringe to
- 48:30cool.
- 48:31Vegan restaurants, vegan fashion, vegan celebrities, I think
- 48:35all of this becoming the new school of
- 48:38what's cool is what's changing minds.
- 48:42Regular restaurants, you know, mainstream restaurants, having vegan
- 48:46options, just the insane amount of how much
- 48:50I hear vegan, vegan, vegan in every aspect
- 48:53of my life, from food to fashion to
- 48:55celebrities.
- 48:56I think that's what needs to keep happening,
- 48:59proving that it's cool.
- 49:00And it's not just some fringe hippie thing
- 49:02from, you know, 30 years ago.
- 49:04Oh, I agree with you entirely.
- 49:06And, you know, one of the reasons we're
- 49:08doing this today is that The Guardian, which
- 49:10is a very, very respectable, journalistic organisation that
- 49:15happens to be independent.
- 49:17So it's not beholden to its advertisers.
- 49:19So it does a lot of articles that
- 49:21you don't see in other mainstream media that,
- 49:25well, look at their commercials, meat, dairy, and
- 49:27pharmaceuticals.
- 49:28They're not gonna cover this stuff.
- 49:29And The Guardian reported that the meat industry
- 49:31has a ginormous like Pentagon slash newsroom style
- 49:37facility in Colorado, where they send out negative
- 49:41stuff about veganism and they try to make
- 49:43it sound unhealthy.
- 49:45And they try to, and this is 24
- 49:47seven, 365.
- 49:49And they also have something called a Masters
- 49:51in Beef Advocacy, where they train all these
- 49:54social media people to go out and advocate
- 49:57for meat.
- 49:58That's one of the reasons why you're seeing
- 50:00nasty articles popping up where quote unquote mainstream
- 50:05writers are attacking veganism because look, I was
- 50:08in media for 38 years.
- 50:12These things happen in waves, they happen in
- 50:15trends and people don't do the kind of
- 50:16fact-checking they should.
- 50:18For example, they talk about some vegan burgers
- 50:22being processed.
- 50:23Well, first of all, there's not all processes
- 50:26created equal because processed meat is officially cancer
- 50:31causing.
- 50:32According to the World Health Organisation, processed vegetables
- 50:35are not officially cancer causing at all, they're
- 50:38in fact good for you.
- 50:40So if you took a mango and a
- 50:41banana and stuck it in a smoothie machine,
- 50:44that would be processed.
- 50:45That doesn't mean it's unhealthy for you.
- 50:47But they're twisting, they're using terminology to try
- 50:53to scare people off because we are growing
- 50:55so fast.
- 50:56So we only have a couple of minutes.
- 50:59I wanna get final thoughts from each of
- 51:01you.
- 51:03Yes, we've come far, but how do we
- 51:05get over the finish line to hit the
- 51:08tipping point?
- 51:08Because we are running out of time.
- 51:11Jonathan, Jonathan.
- 51:17Again, I say to Caroline, can you hear
- 51:20me?
- 51:21Sorry, my reception is a little bad.
- 51:22I'm gonna start with Caroline, you broke up
- 51:23a little bit.
- 51:24Let me start with Caroline, see if your
- 51:25signal gets better.
- 51:27Go ahead, Caroline.
- 51:28I've always been an advocate for leading by
- 51:30example.
- 51:31Having been vegan for so long, showing that
- 51:35I can travel the world, I can have
- 51:37fun with my friends and have a social
- 51:38life and do all the things that everyone
- 51:40else does normally as a vegan, I think
- 51:45has been proof positive for now almost three
- 51:47decades that people are starting to realise that
- 51:51it's not difficult and that you're not gonna
- 51:54lose your social life because of it.
- 51:55And if we continue to be positive and
- 51:58showcase the best of veganism, I think that's
- 52:01gonna continue to push it forward.
- 52:03Very well said.
- 52:04Jonathan, we're back to you.
- 52:06Yeah, can you hear me?
- 52:08Good.
- 52:08Yes.
- 52:09Yeah, like I was saying, education, but the
- 52:12next step of education is then to educate
- 52:14others, to become an activist.
- 52:16And activist doesn't mean to scream at people,
- 52:21it's just to be active and to talk
- 52:24to people, to educate them, to plant seeds,
- 52:26to if they already have seeds, to just
- 52:28put some water and make sure that this
- 52:30grow in people's mind and yeah, help people
- 52:35to understand the ramification of their choice.
- 52:39Well, I end with this video of the
- 52:42New York Fashion Week Coach Runway Show being
- 52:45disrupted by advocates who are trying to educate.
- 52:50This wasn't violent.
- 52:51In fact, they themselves were tackled very roughly
- 52:55at the very end, at least the one
- 52:57holding the sign, Jamie Logan.
- 52:59But this is what you would call nonviolent
- 53:03confrontation to let people know, it's like, there
- 53:09she gets, oh, look, there she goes, there
- 53:11she goes, there she goes, right?
- 53:13It's like, if you could just tell people,
- 53:17here's the reality, the killing of animals is
- 53:21destroying the environment.
- 53:23It's terrible for the people who are forced
- 53:25to do the killing or the tanning.
- 53:27It's terrible for people who have to live
- 53:29next to slaughterhouses or factory farms.
- 53:32It's also terrible for your health when it
- 53:35comes to eating or wearing it.
- 53:37It's terrible for the environment because it's a
- 53:40leading cause of climate change, the deforestation, the
- 53:45wildlife extinction, the habitat destruction, the human world
- 53:48hunger, because we're feeding a huge percentage of
- 53:52the food that we produce, not to people
- 53:54who are starving, but to cows.
- 53:56Most people don't know the majority, the vast
- 53:59majority of soybeans produced is fed to farmed
- 54:01animals.
- 54:02So we tell people these facts when they
- 54:05don't listen, then you do the protest.
- 54:08But I don't have the answer.
- 54:11If I had the answer to what is
- 54:13going to change people, I would reveal it.
- 54:16I think there's many, many, many answers depending
- 54:19on who those people are.
- 54:21We have to really throw all this against
- 54:24the wall and see what sticks.
- 54:26Different people are gonna respond to health.
- 54:28Different people will respond to the environmental issue.