Latest / Beyond The Horizon / Alex Acosta And His Epstein Interview With OIG Inspectors (Part 9)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up, everyone, and welcome to another episode of the
- 0:03Epstein Chronicles. In this episode, we're going to pick up
- 0:06where we left off with the OIG interview of alex Acosta. Question, Okay,
- 0:13I just want to sort of round out the little
- 0:15bit of this the state the state only resolution. You
- 0:20use the term a couple of times, backstopping. What do
- 0:22you mean by that? Answer? What I mean by that
- 0:25is a sense that the state wasn't doing enough, and
- 0:28perhaps backstopping is a polite way of saying encouraging the
- 0:32state to do a little bit more. Question, all right,
- 0:35did you have any discussions about whether this disposition comported
- 0:39with the Ashcroft memo in that you were hunting to
- 0:43the state for a minor charge, for a fairly minor charge,
- 0:46what your office had already understood from the evidence was
- 0:50a quite wide ranging scheme of predatory my term behavior
- 0:54regarding minor victims. Answer, so, I don't recall a discussion
- 0:58around the Ashcroft memo. I would characterize that we did
- 1:02differently in that there are any number of instances where
- 1:05the federal government or the state government can proceed and
- 1:08state charges are substantially less and different, and on a
- 1:12fairly regular basis, the federal government allows, the state, not allows,
- 1:16but stands aside and lets the state proceed. Question, but
- 1:21in this case, you actually had an active investigation that
- 1:24had been proceeding for a year. Answer. So, let's take
- 1:27a drug context, where there might be any number of
- 1:30active investigations where the federal charges can be rather substantial.
- 1:35But ultimately the federal government says, just let the state
- 1:38proceed with this, or violent crime cases where the federal
- 1:41government could bring gun charges using a felon in possession
- 1:45or another mandatory minimum, but the state goes forward with
- 1:49So in that sense he gets cut off. Question, but
- 1:52the state goes forward with what answer forward with different
- 1:56charges that have a lesser term. And so I don't
- 1:59think it's unusual. We can talk about, you know, whether
- 2:03this was the best disposition or not, but I don't
- 2:05think it's unusual to have a fact pattern that are
- 2:08under investigation that proceed in state court where the disposition
- 2:12is different then and would have been if it had
- 2:15proceeded in federal court. Question, all right, do you have
- 2:18anything on that redacted on the two years or something
- 2:23else redacted? No, I'm going back the two years redacted okay,
- 2:28question did you think did you believe at the time,
- 2:31if this was part of your thinking that because it
- 2:34was so important to get sex offender registration and even
- 2:37later developed damages monetary damages for the victims under the
- 2:41state plea arrangement, that pretty much the only thing that
- 2:44the government had the federal government had to give in
- 2:48the negotiation with jail time. If you wanted three things
- 2:52you've said, jail time, sex offender status, and some kind
- 2:56of restitution or damages or mechanisms sex offender registration, there's
- 3:01really no give there. You either register or you don't.
- 3:05I'm being binary again. I'm sorry, it's binary, and likewise
- 3:10the monetary recovery provision. So really the only thing to
- 3:13negotiate is time. Right answer. And so your question is
- 3:18why did we not start at three? So we ended
- 3:20up at two? Question? Well, that's that's a consequence of
- 3:24what I was asking. Answer. So again, my recollection is
- 3:28I understood this to reflect what he would have received
- 3:31as opposed to some arbitrary let's start at three, so
- 3:35we end up at two. I'm sorry, do you have
- 3:38a question? Question? No, go ahead? Answer? You know. I also,
- 3:42from my perspective, was you know, early on, when we
- 3:46sat firm on the two years, I thought two years
- 3:48would have been the right outcome. We ended up on
- 3:51eighteen months. I can't say how. There are some documents
- 3:54that might help, but I was least initially firm on
- 3:58those two years. Question right, when you say I thought
- 4:02the two years was the right amount, is that based
- 4:04on your understanding that that's what he would have gotten
- 4:07in the state? Answer? Correct, And the point I'm trying
- 4:11to convey there is that this wasn't, to my understanding,
- 4:14a random number, but it was informed by this is
- 4:17what he would have received, and therefore it's reasonable agree
- 4:21or disagree with the analysis, but it was an informed
- 4:24number to begin with. Question, but don't you recall how
- 4:28the analysis was done or conducted or that analysis? Answer?
- 4:33I don't recall that question, or even whether it was accurate. Actually,
- 4:37answer again, I don't recall that question. And I understand
- 4:41that explanation. Answer right, question what it's tied to. But
- 4:48was there any consideration because this case was not about
- 4:51one or two victims. It was a very large scheme
- 4:54by this older wealthy man to essentially turn miners into prostitutes,
- 4:58have sex with them or all sex, get other pe
- 5:00pople involved. You've described it in prior statements as grotesque
- 5:03and deserving a punishment. What I'm not hearing through this
- 5:06process is anybody taking a look at this overall conduct
- 5:09and saying, what is the appropriate punishment for this man's conduct?
- 5:14Was there such a consideration and did you feel that
- 5:16two years adequately punished him for the scope of his conduct?
- 5:20Answer a fair question, and perhaps going back to where
- 5:23we started, which is petit. To my mind, at the time,
- 5:26there was a distinction between what would be the adequate
- 5:29punishment if this was a purely federal case versus what
- 5:33is necessary so that it's not, to put it in
- 5:36petit language, a manifest injustice, so that it would have
- 5:40had to come to the office in the first place.
- 5:44And that I think is the important distinction, because if
- 5:47the two years is what he would have received, and
- 5:50therefore it would not have come into the office under petit,
- 5:53then if there is a state disposition to that, that
- 5:56is one possible outcome. It would be a different outcome
- 5:59if this is truly a federal prosecution independent of the state,
- 6:03which goes back to the point I was making about
- 6:05concern about a federal precedent with this kind of sentence,
- 6:09because then when the next person comes along, they say, well,
- 6:13here is this precedent under three seventy one or whatnot.
- 6:17And so this was rightly or wrongly. And I understand
- 6:19the pushback an analysis that distinguished between what is necessary
- 6:24to prevent manifest injustice versus what is the appropriate federal
- 6:28outcome to that. Agree or disagree with that logic is
- 6:32one thing, But did I explain the logic question? You've
- 6:36explained the logic question. And I'm going to push back
- 6:39a little bit on that because the petite policy specifically
- 6:43says it does not apply where the state conduct is
- 6:46only a minor part, an insignificant part of the entire
- 6:49course of conduct. And they give examples about where you
- 6:52have some type of rico scheme and the state has
- 6:55indicted or convicted the perpetrator based on something that could
- 6:59be one single overt act in the government conspiracy, and
- 7:03doesn't that really show what is going on here that
- 7:07what the state had done was really just a small
- 7:09minor part of the scheme, that the federal government had
- 7:13a real opportunity to punish him for this entire course
- 7:16of conduct. Answers. So possibly. But if I can circle
- 7:20back to your question previously, it's interesting that you characterize
- 7:24this as he's turning these girls into prostitutes. And then
- 7:27I think that's really interesting because in twenty nineteen, thirteen
- 7:31years afterward, despite all the changes in the law, there
- 7:35is still some element somewhere that says he's turning these
- 7:38girls into prostitutes. Whereas this was a typical trafficking case
- 7:42of the kind that you'd see in the Low Debacca days,
- 7:45where you know, I was called modern day slavery. That's
- 7:48a very different fact pattern. So you know, a girl
- 7:51who's held captive is forced to serve multiple men per day,
- 7:55where this part of an ongoing business arrangement. And so
- 7:58I hear what you're saying. But if they're at this table,
- 8:02at least some element of that characterization is live. What
- 8:06would it mean in two thousand and six when these
- 8:08laws are still being developed? And that consideration, rightly or wrongly,
- 8:13was part of this analysis? Question? Was it explicitly? In
- 8:17other words, was that aspect of it the I perception
- 8:21that this case was perhaps activity that in which the
- 8:24victims cooperated. Was that part he gets interrupted here by
- 8:29a costa. No, No, let me let me distinguish. I
- 8:32didn't say the perception that this was activities in which
- 8:36the victims cooperated. What I was going to, what I've
- 8:40gone to before, is would jurors Is there at least
- 8:43one juror that might say, look, we've got conflicting victim testimony.
- 8:47Some of them said he did nothing wrong, They all
- 8:49knew each other, They kept going back and taking payment.
- 8:52Is this trafficking or is this prostitution? I'm not saying
- 8:56I agree with that, and I don't think that prosecutors due.
- 9:00I'm saying, is there is there at least the possibility
- 9:02of that question? Was that articulated to you by the
- 9:06people who were listening to by redacted and redacted and
- 9:09redacted answer? So that certainly was part of the discussion
- 9:13when I talk about the victim issues. Would at least
- 9:16some jurors view it that way? Rightly or wrongly? Question?
- 9:20And do you recall having those conversations? Answer? I recall
- 9:24having not only how would the witness stand up in court?
- 9:27But how would jurors view them? And then the second
- 9:30part of that is as it goes up in the
- 9:32appellate process, with respect to the federal nexus and so
- 9:37I hear you, but you know it's the sort of
- 9:39one of the factors, and so yeah, question what I'm
- 9:45getting at though, is that there doesn't seem like there
- 9:49was consideration or a discussion about is this two years
- 9:52capturing the scope of his conduct versus we're just going
- 9:56to tie it to this potential state crime that could
- 9:58have been charged to affair. And I would say that
- 10:02the two years was not meant So the petit policy
- 10:05has several prongs. And to my recollection, the petita analysis
- 10:08was not based on and let's not even call it
- 10:11petita analysis that overstates it. But it was much more
- 10:15of a is this a manifest injustice? And if the
- 10:18original and so you sort of see it in Exhibit three,
- 10:22this would not have been brought to the office in
- 10:24the first place, if you know, if he had pled
- 10:26the jail time and registration and rightly or wrongly, that
- 10:30was understood from the beginning of the case and was
- 10:33a factor in how the case was viewed. Question, and
- 10:37how do you know that it wouldn't have that it
- 10:39wouldn't have been upset with a minimal jail time even
- 10:43if there was sex registration answer. So I can't, twelve
- 10:47years later say how we knew that. I can't say that.
- 10:51My general impression was that this was proceeding at the state,
- 10:54that there were certain charges, and that those charges changed
- 10:58when it went to the grand jury, and that it
- 11:00went from I think they even changed the ASA involved.
- 11:04Question they did. Answer I can't speak for certain, but
- 11:10you probably have that from the record, and that when
- 11:14they changed the ASA involved and took it to the
- 11:16grand jury, the charges that came back were substantially less.
- 11:22Question do you remember the circumstances? Did you know the
- 11:25circumstances under which that ASA was changed? Answer? I don't know.
- 11:29Question all right. By the way, do you remember an
- 11:31occasion in which redacted came to your office in Miami
- 11:34to oppress you on what was going to be happening
- 11:37with the federal case? Answer I don't recall. Question You
- 11:40don't recall answer, I don't recall question. So, before we
- 11:45leave this one little thing, So, if this case had
- 11:49come into the federal system as a part from the
- 11:53taken the digression through the state system, do you think
- 11:56that the two years was an appropriate punishment given the
- 11:59scope of conduct. Answer? I think that if it had
- 12:02come into the federal system apart from the whole state
- 12:05and the petitue consideration and all of that, we may
- 12:08have ended up in a different place. I viewed the
- 12:11two years, to my recollection, as a manifest injustice standard
- 12:14and not an appropriate punishment standard question, meaning whether it
- 12:19was manifestly unjust that he got two years? Answer no,
- 12:23whether it was so let me let me rephrase, no,
- 12:26jail time was a manifest injustice if he had gone
- 12:29to jail for two years in the state system and
- 12:32registered the question of whether it would have come to
- 12:35the office at all, and to my recollection, the consensus
- 12:38was and redacted based on Exhibit three, agrees with that
- 12:43that it would have never come to the office in
- 12:45the first place, because we would not view that under
- 12:48petite as a manifest injustice. There are any number of
- 12:52cases that are prosecuted around the country where an individual
- 12:55gets a jail time that the federal government may not
- 12:58agree with, but that doesn't mean the federal government reprosecutes
- 13:01those cases. The instances where the federal government reprosecutes a
- 13:06state case are pretty rare to my knowledge, and so
- 13:09under the Petite standard, the manifest injustice it would have
- 13:13been a manifest injustice to have zero jail time and
- 13:16zero registration. But if the original charges had remained, that
- 13:20would have been a different matter. That does not mean
- 13:23that this is the best outcome in the state system,
- 13:26and so perhaps beating a you know, an issue. But
- 13:29let me maybe give an example. One concern that I
- 13:32had was that in the violent crime side, the state
- 13:35brings a case the you know, there's a deferment, no
- 13:38jail time. The state when it brings a second case
- 13:41and there's minimal jail time, well, now the person has
- 13:44done three violent crimes, they have a gun. They go
- 13:47to federal and it's like, please don't do that, pretty
- 13:49please don't do that. You know, we're going to punish
- 13:51you a little bit. And then all of a sudden
- 13:54incomes the federal government with the big, big punch to
- 13:56the face. Because the federal sentences are so different than
- 14:00the state sentences, and that happens all the time in
- 14:03any number of context in Florida. That doesn't mean that
- 14:06all those cases get reprosecuted as gun cases in Florida.
- 14:11That means that we understand that Florida system is very
- 14:14different than the federal system, and so the way we
- 14:17looked at it, at least based on my recollection those
- 14:20two years, was not what we would have received if
- 14:22this was a purely federal case. But would this case
- 14:26have been prosecuted by the federal system additionally if he
- 14:29had received jail time and registration in the state system?
- 14:33Question is it fair to say that this particular concern about,
- 14:38for lack of a better word, federalism or the petit
- 14:41policy was a primary concern of yours versus any of
- 14:45your employers in terms of redacted or redacted? Answer? I
- 14:49think it's fair to say that I focused more on
- 14:51the legal side of things, and my team focused more
- 14:54on the trial and how this would play out at trial,
- 14:57and both of them, both of them sort of informed
- 14:59the outs. Question and are you including this petite policy
- 15:03and your consideration of the legal issue? Answer? Yes, yeah,
- 15:08I think that they're all tied together. All right, folks,
- 15:11We're gonna wrap up right here, and in the next
- 15:13episode dealing with the topic, we're gonna pick up where
- 15:15we left off. All of the information that goes with
- 15:19this episode can be found in the description box.