Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E062: The Evolution of Bitcoin Custody with Brian Cubellis & Bradley Chambers
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop and we're
- 0:04going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous excrement
- 0:08ever assembled in the history of darkness. 1974198792972000 and
- 0:18whatever we want to call this, it's all just the same thing
- 0:20over and over. We can't help ourselves.
- 0:23I say when we sell. Hey, I say when we sell.
- 0:33Hey everyone, welcome to the last trade.
- 0:35Today we have a special edition of the show to highlight our
- 0:39recently published report, The Evolution of Bitcoin Custody.
- 0:42It's a comprehensive white paper that walks through the history
- 0:45of custody and finance, Bitcoin's unique custodial
- 0:48properties, fundamentals of Bitcoin custody, evolving
- 0:51custodial solutions, and the incentives inherent to multi
- 0:56institution custody. You can find the report directly
- 0:58on our website at on rampbitcoin.com and we will be
- 1:01hosting a webinar on Tuesday, September 10th to discuss this
- 1:05in more detail and offer a live Q&A to the audience.
- 1:11We also shared more details about the webinar, so you should
- 1:14have found that in the On Ramp Research newsletter and our
- 1:16social channels For more information on how to sign up
- 1:19there. So without further ado, to
- 1:21discuss this report and all things Bitcoin custody today
- 1:24we're joined by Bradley Chambers, an On Ramp client and
- 1:28marketing advisor to the firm, and Brian Cabela's, Chief
- 1:31Strategy Officer, who authored the report today.
- 1:34Gentlemen, how are we doing? Doing well, great to be here.
- 1:39Yeah, I'm. Very.
- 1:41I'm very excited to have this discussion and hear, you know,
- 1:45how Brian went about the report and the research given.
- 1:49Custody is so multifaceted. And I think whenever we come
- 1:52into Bitcoin, there's a certain snapshot we start from and then
- 1:54only move forward. And we never really get to go
- 1:56back and hear how we got this far and where we're going.
- 1:59So excited for this conversation.
- 2:01At On Ramp, we believe that Bitcoin is the most important
- 2:04asset of the 21st century. The hard part is securing it
- 2:08right There are shortcomings with keeping your coins on an
- 2:11exchange, but also with setting up your own self custody
- 2:14arrangement. On Ramp solves for these
- 2:16concerns. Our multi institution custody
- 2:19solution maximizes security and minimizes counterparty risk,
- 2:23ensuring that your Bitcoin remains securely in your
- 2:25possession and provides built in inheritance planning to ensure
- 2:29your family is protected as well.
- 2:32On Ramp provides Peace of Mind for your Bitcoin journey,
- 2:34whether for your whole stack or for part of it as a compliment
- 2:38to your existing self custody setup.
- 2:40For more information, check us out at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 2:45Absolutely, Yeah. So Brian, maybe we'll start with
- 2:47you then just because you authored the report and I could
- 2:51pull up on my screen so folks that are listening through
- 2:54YouTube and other video platforms can follow along.
- 2:57So I'll pull that up now, Brian, and maybe we can just start
- 3:00wherever you'd like to in terms of a high level and get into
- 3:03some of the aims of the report and some of the key takeaways we
- 3:05found. Yeah, absolutely.
- 3:07Thanks, Jackson. This is an exciting one because
- 3:11because you know, honestly, this is a report that, you know,
- 3:15internally we've been talking about for many months and we all
- 3:19sort of knew that this would be a sort of cornerstone piece of
- 3:24collateral for the firm because it really speaks to in many ways
- 3:29why on ramp exists and, and how, you know, on ramp and our, our
- 3:34solutions for custody emerged. But you know, the, the goal and
- 3:38the aim of the report at a high level was really to take a step
- 3:42back and say, you know, why does, why does asset custody
- 3:46even exist in the 1st place? How did, how did the earliest
- 3:49forms of custody emerge? And why did humans coalesce
- 3:53around different forms of custody for assets?
- 3:56And so, you know, if you take it back hundreds or even thousands
- 4:00of years to the earliest forms of custody, there was there was
- 4:04a notion of, you know, you needed sort of different ways to
- 4:09secure and protect communal resources.
- 4:12And that sort of evolved into the earliest forms of banking
- 4:16and so different services that get layered on top of, you know,
- 4:20asset custodians. And so, you know, the
- 4:24fascinating part about where we are today relative to, you know,
- 4:28these earliest forms of custody is that sort of in the
- 4:31traditional world for most assets, you know, it hasn't
- 4:34changed a ton in the sense that most assets are are custody by
- 4:40single entities. And so there's been this sort of
- 4:44inherent trajectory of asset custody that has been prone to
- 4:49different forms of centralization.
- 4:51And so there's typically one single entity that's that's
- 4:54managing the custody of a given asset.
- 4:57And you know, for most assets, whether it's stocks or bonds in
- 5:02someone's portfolio, custody is kind of an afterthought in the
- 5:06sense that, you know, there are there are fall backs in place in
- 5:11case something goes wrong with the custody, whether it's
- 5:13reversing a transaction, papering over losses or, or
- 5:18different methods of of, you know, recreating shares of a
- 5:21business. If, if something went wrong on
- 5:23the custodial end. And that's just not the case for
- 5:26Bitcoin. So Bitcoin has these very unique
- 5:29custodial properties, it being a digital bearer instrument and,
- 5:33and sort of the biggest take away from that differences if
- 5:37something goes wrong with the management of the private keys
- 5:40associated with the Bitcoin, the Bitcoin's just gone forever.
- 5:44There's there's no sort of bailouts or fall back plans like
- 5:47there are for these other assets.
- 5:49And so if, if, if that is true, then custody is really the most
- 5:53important thing for allocating to and owning Bitcoin for the
- 5:58long term, right? Like your investment thesis on
- 6:02the asset, it's price appreciation going forward sort
- 6:06of becomes irrelevant if you can't secure the asset into the
- 6:09future, 10/20/50 years indefinitely.
- 6:12You know, ideally you want to have assurances that that assets
- 6:16going to be there in the future. And so because of, you know,
- 6:20these sort of decentralizing forces with traditional forms of
- 6:26custody, we've seen how that hasn't necessarily mapped to
- 6:32this new world of Bitcoin in a super clean way, right?
- 6:34Whether it's Mount Cox or FTX, there's countless examples of
- 6:39centralized custody for Bitcoin specifically going wrong.
- 6:43And and so, you know, that could take the form of negligence,
- 6:46malfeasance, any form of mismanagement where private keys
- 6:51are lost in some way and the bitcoins just gone forever.
- 6:56And so that's that's really sort of the core differences in terms
- 7:01of, you know, how custody has been done for hundreds of years.
- 7:06And you know, I think in the early days of custody, you know,
- 7:09if we're zooming out 15 years of bitcoins history, like it's a
- 7:12relatively short period of time. And the solutions we've put
- 7:15forth thus far are you manage the keys yourself, which is a
- 7:19great sort of trust minimize fall back option for people to
- 7:23be able to actually take possession of this digital
- 7:25bearer instrument. And then the other option has
- 7:28been trusting a single party custodian.
- 7:31And so, you know, like I said, we've seen very, you know,
- 7:34countless examples of that going wrong.
- 7:37And so, you know, really a lot of the impetus for on ramp being
- 7:42launched and and you know, us putting forth and pioneering
- 7:45this new form of custody is we want to evolve the space in the
- 7:50sense that as bitcoins price grows, the market cap gets
- 7:54larger, it's attracting the eyes of larger pools of capital.
- 7:59And those larger pools of capital genuinely are going to
- 8:03need better assurances over their ownership into the future.
- 8:06They're they're likely thinking very long term about the asset
- 8:09and they want to protect it and secure it into the future.
- 8:12And trusting a single entity, as we've seen, isn't necessarily
- 8:16the best way to do it because things can go wrong and there
- 8:18isn't a ton of recourse if something does go wrong.
- 8:21And so this concept of multi institution custody is really
- 8:27critically important to understand sort of the
- 8:29incentives at play when you introduce multiple participants
- 8:33into custody as opposed to just relying on on one counterparty.
- 8:36And it really shifts sort of the the game theory that underpins
- 8:41custody and, and shifts the incentives such that less things
- 8:46should go wrong in the sense that if you're a single entity
- 8:49and you're managing custody of Bitcoin, you know, in order for
- 8:54you to quote UN quote collude, you don't need to convince
- 8:57anyone. And so you can act unilaterally
- 8:59because you have unilateral control of the asset.
- 9:02And so whether it's, again, you know, negligence or malfeasance,
- 9:05some form of mismanagement, it's just on a single party.
- 9:09And there's, you know, as a client of that single party,
- 9:12there's not a lot of recourse for, you know, holding that
- 9:16firm, that entity accountable, holding them to task to ask, act
- 9:21in good faith. And so by introducing multiple
- 9:24participants. And so you know how how on ramp
- 9:27structures, our custody is is using two of three multi sig
- 9:31Quorums, which again is native to the Bitcoin protocol by
- 9:35introducing other parties, in our case Bitco and coin cover.
- 9:40And we recently added another partner in Tetra Trust.
- 9:46By introducing these other party parties and having them
- 9:48participate, it shifts the incentives at play in the sense
- 9:52that none of those entities actually have unilateral
- 9:57control. And so they are incentivized to
- 10:00act in good faith because there are other parties involved and
- 10:03there are other parties auditing the blockchain and seeing, you
- 10:06know, looking at these vaults, these quorums that we create for
- 10:09clients. And so you're naturally
- 10:12incentivized to act in good faith because, you know, in
- 10:15order for, in order for someone to go rogue, effectively, they
- 10:18would need to convince another, at least one other party to also
- 10:21go rogue. And so that's a, that's a sort
- 10:23of magnitude more difficult than one firm convincing themselves
- 10:28to go rogue. And so that's, that's sort of
- 10:30the, the fundamental shift in incentives and game theory at
- 10:33play here that actually sort of enforces good faith actions.
- 10:39And so that's, that's, you know, if there's one or two things to
- 10:43really take away from this report, it's, you know, that
- 10:46Bitcoin is very unique, again, from a custodial perspective.
- 10:49And due to that, you know, custody is sort of the most
- 10:54important thing when it comes to having a thesis on this asset
- 10:58asset and allocating, you know, meaningful amounts of wealth to
- 11:01this asset. And sort of the second point is,
- 11:06you know, the space needs to evolve in the sense that we've
- 11:10seen the again, the pitfalls of centralization, how things can
- 11:14go wrong and you know, linking it back to the unique properties
- 11:18of the asset. Those centralization forces are,
- 11:22are even more important for this asset specifically relative to
- 11:27other assets in your portfolio. And so, you know, we think we're
- 11:31pioneering a strategy here which, you know, allows for
- 11:36greater ownership assurances into the future and really the
- 11:40sort of distribution of counterparty risk so that, you
- 11:44know, you can sort of minimize again those those pitfalls of
- 11:47the the centralized custody. So maybe I'll, I'll stop there,
- 11:51but that that's sort of a very high level of what we tried to
- 11:54achieve with this report and just try to really sort of give
- 11:58people a sense for, you know, this is a very right, you know,
- 12:02everyone always says we're still early, we're still early and
- 12:05figuring out the custody of this asset in our minds.
- 12:07And we think this is sort of the the next step in that evolution
- 12:11is, is multi institution custody, which will actually
- 12:14allow again these larger pools of capital to get comfortable
- 12:18with allocating in size to the asset.
- 12:20And just maybe one other brief point is, you know, over a year
- 12:25ago when I joined on ramp, you know, I think I heard Michael
- 12:29and Jesse on a podcast talking about this model of custody.
- 12:33And it really struck me as something that needed to exist
- 12:38because given my prior experience at, at, you know, I
- 12:41was at Coinbase for a year Prior to joining on ramp.
- 12:44And prior to that, I was in the, in the traditional finance base
- 12:47working at a large bank. And so I was, I was dealing with
- 12:50those large pools of capital that I keep referencing.
- 12:53And there was a natural friction, even if even if a
- 12:57client or prospect could get there on the Bitcoin thesis,
- 13:00they understood the appreciation potential of this asset and they
- 13:03wanted to get exposure. They couldn't get comfortable
- 13:06with the custody options. And so those, you know, not
- 13:09everyone thought in the first principles way about this and
- 13:12and you know, some people are just fine, you know it getting
- 13:16exposure via a single third party entity.
- 13:20But for all the reasons we know there, you know, there are many
- 13:22ways in which that can go wrong. And so if you have a long term
- 13:25thesis on this asset and you want to allocate in size, you
- 13:28really do need to think critically about the custody and
- 13:31how are you going to get exposure.
- 13:32And you know, again, those ownership assurances into the
- 13:35future are are critically important.
- 13:39Yeah, it's a very great recap, Brian.
- 13:41I think one overarching theme that we kind of bring to the
- 13:45table everybody on this call and as a firm is there's decades of
- 13:49experience in the Bitcoin world managing assets across Jesse and
- 13:53his fund that he was managing prior to on Ramp and me helping
- 13:57build Unchained Capital and also across Trad fine understanding
- 14:01what what is needed in the market.
- 14:02I think it's very much talked about that in Bitcoin we're
- 14:06going to recreate the wheel and I think most people here would
- 14:09say we're not necessarily going to recreate it, We're just going
- 14:11to repurpose it in graft a lot of the things that works to this
- 14:14asset and reduce the counterparty risk.
- 14:17And so if you take that lens to the asset will, then it
- 14:20naturally has to evolve simply because it started basically
- 14:24worth 0. And so it was OK to use a
- 14:26plastic device to store 100 Bitcoin.
- 14:28And as that grows, you naturally went into passphrases multi say
- 14:33collaborative custody. There's a lot of different
- 14:34layers and flavors to that. But ultimately, I always anchor
- 14:37back to a Jesse's chart that Sailor often uses the full
- 14:42potential valuation chart of if you think about an asset
- 14:45starting to take more and more. Yeah, this charts great to
- 14:48illustrate like we all believe anybody probably listening to
- 14:52this podcast view and this believes that this asset is
- 14:54going to grow and take everybody probably has varying degrees of
- 14:57how much of the monetary premium from these other assets, real
- 15:00estate, equities, bonds, money. Well, we have to extrapolate.
- 15:04Well, then that means there's a bunch of other things that need
- 15:06to occur, financial services, bad actors.
- 15:09And so we have to evolve that custody situation.
- 15:12So I think multi institution is a natural evolution in this
- 15:15step. I like to think about it as a
- 15:17six figure product in the sense of like when it's 100K plus,
- 15:20everyone's gonna fully understand and Brock the gravity
- 15:22of having plastic devices and on their person and in their home.
- 15:27And so yeah, that was a great recap.
- 15:28And just wanted to frame around where we're going and the
- 15:31importance of secure. And if we think we're going past
- 15:33100K, there needs to be redundancy and fault tolerance.
- 15:36You're also going to want to live in a world where there's
- 15:38financial services that exist and you don't have to like maybe
- 15:41go into a dark room or or cave to get access and be tracked
- 15:44while you do it. Yeah.
- 15:46And to add on to that, I guess it's sort of a thought I've had
- 15:50more in the last six months. I think that that Bitcoins multi
- 15:56institution multi sig capability is part of how it ends up
- 16:02winning. It ends up becoming a preferred
- 16:04store of value. It ends up taking a larger slice
- 16:07of the global asset landscape because it has this ability to
- 16:12have a lower risk form of custody than anything else out
- 16:16there. And so you're going to capital
- 16:19is going to gravitate towards that as the as capital is
- 16:22looking for a good store value asset, you're looking for
- 16:25performance, but you're also looking for risk mitigation.
- 16:28You want to know that you can reliably expect that capital to
- 16:31exist in the future without hacks or insolvencies or any
- 16:37funny business from a a single custodian.
- 16:41And so I think multi institution custody is part of how Bitcoin
- 16:45wins. And and that is I, I think it's
- 16:49something that the Bitcoin landscape in general is not
- 16:52really thinking about yet at all.
- 16:55But multi institution custody is this we've, we've, we've multi
- 16:59stick unlocks this ability, this capability for Bitcoin that
- 17:05makes it grow into becoming the best store value in the world.
- 17:10And, and this is, you know, one of the things that I think we're
- 17:14going to see as a major tailwind over the next decade for for
- 17:17Bitcoin and for Bitcoin custody is, is multi institution custody
- 17:22taking more and more risk out of holding Bitcoin and therefore
- 17:27more and more capital saying, you know, what Bitcoin looks
- 17:30like. Not only is it outperforming
- 17:31everything, but it's now becoming less risky than the
- 17:33assets I'm currently holding from a custody perspective.
- 17:36So, you know, it's time to allocate more.
- 17:40And so I think this is, this is not yet understood about how
- 17:45Bitcoin becomes central to how the mainstream stores value.
- 17:52Yeah, it's a, it's a really good point.
- 17:54And the other thing I would sort of emphasize, and this is
- 17:57something I, I, I mentioned a lot, is that, you know, Bitcoin
- 18:03as an asset, as a network is genuinely one of the more
- 18:08decentralized things we've ever, ever seen, right, as a human
- 18:12species. And that's very core to its
- 18:14value. Why you would even be interested
- 18:16in Bitcoin from an investment perspective is it's
- 18:18decentralized, distributed nature.
- 18:21And so if you think about what we've seen over the past 15
- 18:25years, and even with the launch of these ETFs, it's like, does
- 18:28it really make sense to centralized the custody of a
- 18:31very decentralized asset? No, it doesn't.
- 18:35Because if you want to honor the ethos and the principles of that
- 18:39asset of that network, you should try to also distribute
- 18:43ownership of the custody. And like Jesse's saying, the
- 18:46coin has this very unique ability to do exactly that,
- 18:49right? And so, you know, Michael, one
- 18:51of the things you always say, which I love is like, you can't
- 18:54multi sig gold, right? But if you could, that'd be
- 18:57pretty attractive, right? Like that would be a better way
- 18:59to hold gold if you didn't have to trust one single vault and
- 19:04just hope that the gold was still there.
- 19:06And that would remove the Achilles heel of gold, right,
- 19:08Which is that it ends up in a single vault and then you get
- 19:11funny business based on that. Well, I look at it, I look at it
- 19:16too like we talk a lot about the ETS a lot and how like I believe
- 19:21they're a subpar product compared to holding the actual
- 19:24Bitcoin. But there are people that that's
- 19:25how they can only buy Bitcoin and that's OK.
- 19:28But even if you had an ETF that was held in multi institutional
- 19:31custody, it would be a better ETF.
- 19:34So it's not even that I would say like an ETF wrapper is as
- 19:38bad or as a bad investment. And we can get into the nuances
- 19:41of taking ownership of the Bitcoin one day.
- 19:43But like if you, if you knew it was like not held with a single
- 19:46entity and it was held in multi institutional custody across
- 19:49multiple entities, but that'd be a good product.
- 19:51And that would be that would be attractive to people because I
- 19:54think there is this notion of like, oh, the ETFs are quote UN
- 19:56quote easy. And they are like, you already
- 19:59have a brokerage account like that, that is easy.
- 20:02But if you just think through like, actually, how was that
- 20:04custody on the back end? It's it's not great.
- 20:07It's, it's fine. I mean, it's, it's not, you
- 20:09know, it's not in some ways it's, you know, it reduces the
- 20:12attack service and you personally, but like there is a
- 20:15still a centralization of that asset.
- 20:17That is, it could be could be much better with multi
- 20:20institution custody. Bradley, can you, you know, we
- 20:25kind of we did a quick intro, but maybe share a little bit of
- 20:27your background. One of the favorite parts about
- 20:30our conversations internally that we have is interviewed.
- 20:33Call yourself a student, but I feel like you've studied the
- 20:36Internet wave and adoption and and how what's happening here in
- 20:40bitcoins very similar there has similarities because I think
- 20:44that's helpful in understanding this lens of what we're talking
- 20:47about. And what I'm driving towards is
- 20:49effectively like multi institution.
- 20:52It's it's one thing and I think individuals really go that kind
- 20:55of makes sense. But I think for it to really
- 20:57make sense is to go back to the anchor point that I think that
- 21:00has kept most bitcoins safe, which is going to take this
- 21:04relearning that we were going to go into bitcoins monetization
- 21:08with everybody holding these keys offline on their person in
- 21:11their home. Because I think that is a very
- 21:14novel thing that is still not picked up.
- 21:16And it makes sense because historically, if you're telling
- 21:18somebody something that's not offline cold storage, it meant
- 21:21that you were getting scammed or there was a central point of
- 21:23failure. And that's radically different
- 21:26in this setup. And This is why it takes time
- 21:28because if everybody was telling you to have a better solution,
- 21:30they would be taking your Bitcoin.
- 21:32But I think Bradley's understanding that very early
- 21:34was helpful and even me just realizing how right we were, He
- 21:38had this notion that said, I like on Rent because I want to,
- 21:42I'm going to butcher it. But it was about believing in a
- 21:45positive version of the future. Or like, I don't know Bradley,
- 21:47you could probably give it share it back then I can.
- 21:49Yeah, so the the back story on the quote, and I'll run through
- 21:52my history in just a second was I want to live in the world.
- 21:55We still trust institutions and and I really see multi
- 22:00institution custody as a great option for holding massive
- 22:04amounts of Bitcoin in a secure way.
- 22:06And I really believe in the world and you all probably have
- 22:09used the technology Plaid where you can like securely log into
- 22:11your bank with a different firm. And that's really cool
- 22:14technology. Like I, I want to see that for
- 22:18like long term, for like you can pick your, your key holder.
- 22:21So maybe you have like a local bank, like I'm a big believer in
- 22:23local banks. Maybe you have a local bank and
- 22:26you want that to be one of your key holders for your custody.
- 22:28And you will only, you can only initiate transactions in person.
- 22:31Like I think that would be awesome.
- 22:33And so like I, I don't want to get in a world where we like
- 22:36don't have, we don't have any trust because, you know, even if
- 22:38you say hold all of your Bitcoin in self custody, there's still
- 22:42trust in your world. You're still trusting your
- 22:44butcher, you're still trusting the water company.
- 22:47Like they're, you can't get to a place where like you think it's
- 22:49going to be like Mad Max style, you're walking around with
- 22:52machetes. Because if that is the case,
- 22:54then like we just have a whole other set of problems.
- 22:56And so, but just just to back up and talk through my history, I
- 23:03have been a big believer in the Internet since, you know, long
- 23:06as I really can remember, like I was on Prodigy back in the day,
- 23:09I'm going to age myself. Like, you know, I remember I was
- 23:11paying for AOL, but parents were paying for AOL when it wasn't
- 23:13unlimited. So I've really grown up with
- 23:15technology my entire life. My first job while I was in
- 23:19college, just working at an ISP doing tech support.
- 23:22And I always tell people like that's a very humbling
- 23:24experience is doing IS, you know, ISP work and doing tech
- 23:27support because that's you really understand how regular
- 23:29people grasp technology. You know, you people in this
- 23:33colic, we're all probably even more than the tech savvy people
- 23:35and our families, we are the exception, like the average
- 23:39person, they don't want to worry about how they get to how they
- 23:42get to end result. They just want the solution.
- 23:43They want to buy something. And so I really come at Bitcoin
- 23:47from that mindset of like looking at it as a technology,
- 23:50you know, technology evolution and technology adoption, much as
- 23:53in the same way the Internet happened, but at first.
- 23:55So just to back up and and talk about my Bitcoin journey, I
- 23:59first, I should have gotten it like in 2010, like I should have
- 24:02gotten early on. I was always, you know, on the
- 24:05cutting edge of technology. In fact, I guess, I guess I can
- 24:08probably say this now because it's been long enough.
- 24:10Like my side hustle in high school was burning mixed CD's
- 24:13for people that I download from Napster.
- 24:15It was a great business. This was like in the late 90s.
- 24:17It was two. I charge $2.00 a CDN dollar a
- 24:19song. It's like, I've always kind of
- 24:21had this bleeding edge of technology and but I should have
- 24:24got Nick on earlier. I didn't.
- 24:25I don't know why it just didn't I, But where it finally clicked
- 24:28for me was in in late 2020. I was listening to a podcast
- 24:33called business casual. So in the morning brew network,
- 24:35it's a great newsletter and the Winklevoss twins were on there
- 24:39that you know, that found a Gemini and that was like the
- 24:41first time that I actually ever heard somebody explain Bitcoin
- 24:44and it immediately clicked like I like I remember I was ironing
- 24:47some clothes in my master bedroom at the time.
- 24:50I was listening to podcasts. I've always loved.
- 24:52I've been listening to podcasts since 2003, yes, 2003.
- 24:56And it just immediately clicked from him like, well, this
- 24:59changes everything. Like it was, it was such an eye
- 25:01opening. It just immediately clicked
- 25:03because they explained it in a way with the limited supply I
- 25:06should. And so I should have gotten much
- 25:07earlier because I was always a big believer in that the
- 25:10government was spending way too much money.
- 25:12I voted for Ron Paul in multiple primaries.
- 25:15Like I, I understood all all that was happening in our
- 25:17country. So I should have gotten earlier,
- 25:19but it didn't. And it's the old adage, you get
- 25:22it, the price you deserve. And I got it at the price I
- 25:23deserve. But I think what, what helped me
- 25:27is coming to Bitcoin in 2020-2021, because I'm afraid
- 25:31had I come in, in 2014, I would have been a trader and I would
- 25:35have said, well, I bought it here, It's not here.
- 25:37You know, I would have tried to kind of quote, UN quote, make
- 25:39money and not understand that Bitcoin was the money and that
- 25:43the goal was to accumulate more Bitcoin, not necessarily just
- 25:45accumulate more dollars. So I came at it at the right
- 25:47time. And one of the things that that
- 25:50really helped me on my journey was understanding Bitcoin as a
- 25:55protocol for money. And again, so back up again,
- 25:59I've worked in technology my entire career, 20 plus years and
- 26:03I my career has been built on the backs of protocols, SMTP
- 26:07protocol for sending communication around the world
- 26:10at the speed of light, essentially for free over
- 26:12e-mail. I think SMTP is one of the most
- 26:14incredible technologies in the world.
- 26:16I could send a message from here to Australia, you know, over it,
- 26:22multiple e-mail providers, different applications, but
- 26:24because we're all talking to the same protocol, it works.
- 26:28TCPIPHTTP, like these are all technologies we use every day.
- 26:32And these are protocols for technology.
- 26:35Bitcoin is a protocol for money. And So what that means is like
- 26:38there will be different ways to use Bitcoin, there will be
- 26:40different ways to custody Bitcoin, there will be different
- 26:42ways to adopt Bitcoin. And they're all fine.
- 26:45And it doesn't. There's no right or wrong
- 26:47answer, just as like there's no right or wrong e-mail client.
- 26:50Like you can just pick it whatever client that you want
- 26:52and you can use it with your, you know, e-mail provider and
- 26:56you can talk to anybody around the world.
- 26:57Bitcoin I think will operate much the same way where you will
- 27:00have different flavors of custody for maybe different
- 27:03amounts of Bitcoin and different thing, you know, some people
- 27:05won't hold it this way, some people won't hold that way And
- 27:07it's all great and it's all, we all grow together just as in the
- 27:10same way like our apps have changed over the years, the way
- 27:13we interact with technology is different in 2014 than it is in
- 27:1820/20/24. Like all these things have, you
- 27:20know, changed and a good, I talked to somebody the last week
- 27:22and we were talking about like, well, Bitcoin is never going to
- 27:25do X because of some limitation. Today I said you you forget
- 27:29like, I don't know, get you guys on the pod like remember had the
- 27:31first iPhone, like the first iPhone couldn't even send
- 27:33picture messages like you. It only worked on Cingular here
- 27:37in the US And again, I'm going to date myself like it only
- 27:39worked on Cingular. It literally couldn't send
- 27:40picture messages. Something that is like core
- 27:42today to the like mobile experience of sending messages
- 27:45over over text messages and whatever chat app couldn't do it
- 27:48the way you So you got a you got a link front and you didn't had
- 27:50to go and you couldn't copy and paste and you couldn't click on
- 27:52it. So you actually had just like
- 27:54manually retype the URL into Safari and view the view the
- 27:57picture message. And so you people think, oh,
- 27:59well, Bitcoin, whatever. This, it's like, guys, we were
- 28:02not that long ago, like you could even send text messages on
- 28:04the iPhone today. So like, don't, don't
- 28:06underestimate like what we can build in the short term.
- 28:09Because I remember when like loading a three Meg audio file
- 28:13on AOL took hours. Now you can view that, you know,
- 28:16in half a second on your phone. Like we really, really
- 28:19overestimate what we can do in maybe a few months, but we are
- 28:22vastly underestimating what we can do technology wise over the
- 28:26next, you know, 12 years. Yeah, there's this.
- 28:31Fascinating perspectives and you know, I think to your point,
- 28:35like we're 15 years into Bitcoin and a lot of times we like to
- 28:38think that we have it all figured out, right?
- 28:40Like we have the solutions that we want to point people toward.
- 28:43And, you know, we pretty much think that we've solved a lot of
- 28:47problems that already exist, but the reality is we're kind of in
- 28:50the Internet for in the 1990s, right?
- 28:52Like, as you pointed out, there were a lot of things that we
- 28:54kind of took for granted even in the 2000s as it relates to the
- 28:57iPhone, some of the things that I, I didn't even know
- 28:59personally. So like, how do you kind of
- 29:01think about now? How do you think about where we
- 29:04are today with Bitcoin, right? And, and the technologies that
- 29:07exist. Maybe you could also walk
- 29:08through people like over the past four years, what are the
- 29:11different technologies you've interacted with from, you know,
- 29:14signing devices and running notes and, you know, exchange
- 29:17experiences, Like what are the different technologies you've
- 29:20interacted with on Bitcoin? And how would you kind of equate
- 29:23where we are today in Bitcoin to where we would be in the
- 29:26Internet adoption? I, I really believe in, in
- 29:29probably like 1992, there were probably people like us sitting
- 29:34around a restaurant somewhere talking about the Internet and
- 29:38what it was going to be. And they all sounded crazy and
- 29:41they were all crazy, but they were all right.
- 29:43And I think there is an aspect of like we often feel like when
- 29:47we go like talk to people that like don't understand Bitcoin,
- 29:50we sound crazy and we are crazy. We are, we are implementing a
- 29:54new, you know, world reserved currency slowly but surely.
- 29:58And so it does sound crazy, but everything about the Internet
- 30:00sounded crazy then. I mean, the good example is like
- 30:03we were always told two things, you know, growing up, don't
- 30:07meet, don't meet people from the Internet, don't get into a
- 30:09stranger's car. Well, that is the business model
- 30:11for Uber and Lyft. So like things change can change
- 30:15over time. And it, it is, it is still the
- 30:18early 90s for adoption. Again, what we are doing with
- 30:21the Internet in the early 90s and the mid 90s was amazing.
- 30:23Like, you know, I remember one of the other things I did to as
- 30:26a site that's like I built websites for people.
- 30:28These websites were awful and compared to today's standards
- 30:31and to the, and people were arguing then about like the best
- 30:33way to build websites just like they are today.
- 30:35But like the technology is just gradually like, you know,
- 30:38gradually, you know, came about again, taking credit cards on
- 30:41the Internet in 1995 was really complicated.
- 30:44Today it's super easy. Like it's a turnkey solution.
- 30:46You can use Stripe or you can use any other square.
- 30:49So there is this like mantra of we kind of get frustrated in the
- 30:53moment of like, why do not more people get this?
- 30:55Like, do you not think people there were probably people like
- 30:57watching, you know, Amazon in like 1996, nineteen 97 IPO
- 31:02saying guys, this company is going to take over everything.
- 31:04And there are, and again, like they were, they did and they
- 31:07were right. And they were up and down and
- 31:09the number of times their stock has drawn down over time, like,
- 31:11yeah, they did. But they had this like long term
- 31:13thesis, their long term investors, like understood,
- 31:16well, the internet's going to change everything.
- 31:17And then mobility changed everything and then cloud
- 31:19changed everything once again. So like, if you just have this
- 31:22like, you know, where the end result is, the journey along the
- 31:25way can be a little bit bumpy. But you know, like we will
- 31:28figure these solutions out. So like I, you know, when I hear
- 31:30people say, oh, lightning doesn't do X, like, OK, we will
- 31:33build that or this doesn't do this.
- 31:35OK, we'll build that too. And it's like being mad in like
- 31:382011 that like multi institutional custody doesn't
- 31:41exist. Like it didn't need to exist in
- 31:422011. Just like things that we, you
- 31:44know, we don't need today, like Bitcoin's not going to take
- 31:47over, you know, all credit card processing tomorrow.
- 31:49So like we don't have to have the technology to do that today.
- 31:52We will build it as that comes and like problems for this
- 31:55present themselves and solution, we will build solutions.
- 31:57And like we've done that with technology over the years.
- 31:59And it's like everything with technology is not solved today.
- 32:02But like when new problems crop up, the free market figures it
- 32:05out and like, OK, how, how can we offer a solution?
- 32:07How can we offer this? You know, and I think too, you
- 32:13have to with Bitcoin too. Until you really understand the
- 32:16problem that Bitcoin solves and you feel that problem, I don't
- 32:19think people are interested in the solution outside of like
- 32:22maybe this is a specular asset that might go up in terms of
- 32:25dollar values. I think the critical thing for
- 32:28people with understanding of Bitcoin is they have to actually
- 32:29understand the problem that that we have today.
- 32:32And, and again right now within, you know, everybody's feeling
- 32:35inflation. So like they're starting to
- 32:37understand that more. But it's also like putting a
- 32:39lobster in a bowling pan, like you don't fill it right at once
- 32:42as it as it gets hotter. And I think that's kind of where
- 32:44the world is says particularly here in the US is that water is
- 32:47just getting hotter and hotter and hotter.
- 32:49And we've come around the past four years and like you look at
- 32:51the the price of groceries, you're like, this doesn't feel
- 32:54right. This is frustrating.
- 32:55Like what actually is the solution?
- 32:57And some people want to get mad and they want to, you know,
- 33:00blame politicians. They want to blame this or they
- 33:02like somebody else. And like we're all here saying
- 33:03like, we're just going to invent some better money.
- 33:05And we're going over and this is this is a better solution for
- 33:08us. And I think it's actually
- 33:10freeing too, when you really understand it, like, again, the
- 33:13what what is Bitcoin going to do in USD prices today, tomorrow?
- 33:17I don't, I don't know. But do I think 10 years from
- 33:19now, it's dramatically higher? I do.
- 33:20And the only way, you know, people say like what, what is
- 33:23the risk of Bitcoin is like government stops spending money.
- 33:25I don't see that happening. There's no talk of governments
- 33:28like actually stops, you know, deficit spending.
- 33:30So if that's the case, I'm just going to save in Bitcoin.
- 33:32And it's really, it's like freeing and simple, but it it
- 33:35you get to that almost like Zen like moment where you're like, I
- 33:38can be mad about all the things that are wrong in the world, or
- 33:41I can just go out and seek out a solution to my problems.
- 33:46But, you know, going back to custody, I've tried all
- 33:50different flavors of custody and again, going back to the
- 33:52protocol, I think they're all fine.
- 33:54I think there are there are reasons to have an, you know, a
- 33:58little Bitcoin on exchange. There's there's reasons to have
- 34:00a little Bitcoin in an iPhone app.
- 34:02There's reasons to have a little bit in collaborative custody.
- 34:05But I really kind of came to multi institutional custody from
- 34:09this mindset of like what works 30 years from now?
- 34:13Because I look at I look at Bitcoin as like a generational
- 34:16asset that I want to have in my family forever.
- 34:18And I love I have hardware devices that I've tinkered with.
- 34:22I love tinkering with stuff. But when I think through like
- 34:26actually what scales Bitcoin to the rest of the world, I look at
- 34:30as in some ways like how e-mail grew.
- 34:33I mean, again, in the 90s, like there wasn't like Gmail in the
- 34:3790s because I remember when Gmail launched, like, you know,
- 34:39your people were selling invites on eBay.
- 34:41Really the first mass market e-mail service was Hotmail.
- 34:44And it was so popular, Microsoft bought it because prior to that,
- 34:48these mass market you, you had to run your own e-mail server.
- 34:51And like, that was fine that that existed and it was a reason
- 34:54some businesses ran it. That's how they did it.
- 34:56And some people still do that. And that's great.
- 34:58Like, but e-mail is a protocol so people can use their own
- 35:00e-mail server. But what helped e-mail really
- 35:03grow dramatically were companies offering solutions to Interopter
- 35:07interoperate with that protocol. So again, you had Juno.
- 35:10I'm really aging myself now. Now you had Mindspring, you had
- 35:13Hotmail, then Gmail came along Apple iCloud, you had Yahoo
- 35:16obviously in there. And like, and again, then
- 35:19solutions came out where it's like, hey, you can run a, you
- 35:21know, we're going to run a, a squirrel mail, we're going to
- 35:24host it for you. It's another open source
- 35:25platform and you can choose your own domain.
- 35:26Like there are 1000 different ways to interact with e-mail,
- 35:29but what do we all know about e-mail?
- 35:31If I had your e-mail address, I don't have to think about what
- 35:34e-mail frontier you're using. I just send you a message.
- 35:36The apps handle it, the protocol handles it.
- 35:38That's to me, I look at Bitcoin like that.
- 35:40So that's going to be how Bitcoin scales is there's going
- 35:43to be different ways to interact with it.
- 35:45And they're all right. And they're all positives and
- 35:47negatives, all of them. And I think too, like when you
- 35:49get dogmatic about different, you get opinions and say, well,
- 35:52this is the only way to do X Like, well, maybe that's the
- 35:55only way for you to do acts. But like another person has
- 35:58different hopes and and strengths and weaknesses and
- 36:00like they don't want to do that. And I think that's what to me,
- 36:03what I love about multi institutional custody is it's a
- 36:06way to hold large amounts of Bitcoin in a way that is easy,
- 36:10scalable and secure. And again, I'd love the
- 36:13inheritance piece to solve with it.
- 36:15I don't have to worry about keeping, you know, plastic
- 36:18devices and plugging them up. And again, do I still hold a
- 36:21very, very small amount of Bitcoin in self custody?
- 36:23I do, but like over time, you know, as I as I migrated to on
- 36:27ramp and you know, I started out with a little bit and over time
- 36:29I realized like more and more and more and more and more of
- 36:32this needs to be in multi institution custody because this
- 36:34is this is the future. This is the most secure way,
- 36:37this is the most scalable way. And this is a way you could tell
- 36:40your neighbor the the person that delivers your mail, the the
- 36:43person at the coffee shop, like multi institution custody is
- 36:47scalable for everybody, regardless of their technical
- 36:50level. Do you want to can I view my
- 36:51Bitcoin on my own note in my house?
- 36:53I can. But does like, you know, and as
- 36:57family member that doesn't, you know, even care about
- 36:59technology, they want to do that.
- 37:00No, they they don't want to, but it's like it's important.
- 37:02They can, but they don't have to.
- 37:04And that's why I'm such a big believer in on ramps technology
- 37:07is because it is a way to, you know, on board billions of
- 37:10people to Bitcoin in a way that people, a lot of people are just
- 37:13never going to hold their own keys and physically hold them.
- 37:15They can legally control them with institutions, institutions
- 37:17spread across multiple jurisdictions, but they actually
- 37:20don't have to have USB keys where if something happened to
- 37:23those, if they did that wrong, that they've lost their wealth.
- 37:26And then, you know, again, it's important that people can do
- 37:28that from the protocol's sake, but the vast majority of people
- 37:31are not going to hold their own keys fiscally.
- 37:33And I know that may be controversial, but I've watched
- 37:36technology adoption long enough to know just like most people
- 37:39were not going to run their own e-mail server.
- 37:40They wanted a solution and Gmail, iCloud, Yahoo gave them a
- 37:44solution. They need a solution to securely
- 37:46and legally Bitcoin in a way that's easy.
- 37:49Yeah, it's a, it's a, you paint such a good picture there,
- 37:52Bradley, of like you, you said multi institution custody wasn't
- 37:58needed in 2011. I think that's an important part
- 38:00of this too, of like as the evolution of custody, Bitcoin
- 38:04custody has progressed. It's it's based on need, right?
- 38:06Like who held Bitcoin in 2011? The the the cypherpunks and
- 38:15related parties and it was a speculative thing that you knew
- 38:19you were like way out there and that you weren't like you
- 38:22weren't really betting the farm on it and you weren't relying on
- 38:25it right. And then now move forward in
- 38:28time. As that value of Bitcoin has
- 38:30grown, people have started to base their financial world
- 38:33around Bitcoin. Some people, right, some people
- 38:36who have been comfortable enough with the technical demands of
- 38:39self custody in particular and and multi sig custody in
- 38:44particular over the last few years.
- 38:46But that requires a lot of technical know how in the same
- 38:49way that the the e-mail story has you painted a great picture
- 38:52of, of how that tracked over time of we, we think about how
- 38:56the progress of technology involves the simplification of
- 38:59UI and UX. But I think it underneath that
- 39:03surface, there's a whole lot of of technical simplification or,
- 39:10or I guess removal of the user from the technical requirements
- 39:16involved in, in connecting to the Internet, getting your own
- 39:19e-mail, any, you know, setting up an iPhone back in the day was
- 39:26a lot harder than it is now anything and, and so making UIUX
- 39:32easier or better. And also it's a big part of
- 39:37that, making the tech requirements simplified and, and
- 39:41shifting the, the, the burden from the user to to companies
- 39:49who are helping the user is a big part of, of how technology
- 39:54goes from the bleeding edge innovators through the early
- 39:58adopters and into the mainstream.
- 40:00And that's that's the story playing out again with Bitcoin,
- 40:04the evolution of Bitcoin custody here, where as people are
- 40:08starting to center their work, their financial world around
- 40:11Bitcoin. We, we needed a better solution
- 40:16to remove some of the technical burden from the individual.
- 40:20Because if you set up a multi sig, if you set up a
- 40:22collaborative custody multi sig, that's kind of the best in class
- 40:26before multi institution custody in my opinion.
- 40:29And in that scenario, you still are responsible ultimately for,
- 40:33for the majority of the keys and how that material is held.
- 40:37So you could screw it up and that is comfortable enough for
- 40:42some people and pretty uncomfortable, I think for
- 40:45realistically the majority of of of people.
- 40:50Most of those people haven't adopted Bitcoin yet in part
- 40:52because of this, you know, in general or less technical.
- 40:56And so, you know, cometh the hour, cometh the man sort of
- 41:00idea here of like out of necessity and what's possible
- 41:05with Bitcoin, you develop the next step in the evolution of
- 41:10Bitcoin custody to reach the next group of people who by
- 41:15making it better UI, UX and removing a big chunk of the
- 41:18technical burden from the experience overall.
- 41:22And that is that next stepping stone is multi institution
- 41:25custody. And I think it's really more
- 41:27than a stepping stone. I think it is, but ultimately
- 41:30the format that is the the end state of where this goes.
- 41:34Of course there will be a ton of innovation, you know, with multi
- 41:37institution custody and what it ends up looking like.
- 41:40But from a from a conceptual format point of view, you've now
- 41:44risk mitigated about as much as you can.
- 41:48No solution is absolutely 100% perfect, but with multi
- 41:52institution custody you're in order of magnitude better than
- 41:55than any custody format in the traditional world, so I think
- 41:59that's about as much as you can hope for.
- 42:01I think it's really well put. Like there's a couple things
- 42:03that have come up here, Jesse reference as you center, as we
- 42:07center more of our lives, our net worths around the asset.
- 42:10Now you have to start thinking about it from a first principles
- 42:12perspective of risk and how do you secure it.
- 42:15And Bradley referenced how, you know, he should have got
- 42:18Bitcoin. He didn't.
- 42:19There's a lot of people that should, but there's a
- 42:23subconscious notion, and these are obviously on the different
- 42:26sides of the spectrums. But if you ask or pull, you
- 42:28know, the grandmother or parent, what do you know about Bitcoin?
- 42:32It'll end up in these two spectrums of, you know, it's
- 42:35kind of cool, but North Korean hackers will end up with it or
- 42:38it'll end up in a hard drive in the UK or wherever the hard
- 42:41drive, the famous, the infamous hard drive ended up.
- 42:44And so it naturally, everybody knows these growing problems of
- 42:47inflation, they're the stored value, having to pay, you know,
- 42:51multiple advisors, all the things associated.
- 42:54But they can't really look at the asset, even though they
- 42:55believe it's the best performing asset, even if they know it,
- 42:58simply because it's like, well, even if I get it, what do I do
- 43:01now? I have a bigger problem because
- 43:02I have to reframe my mind and also figure out what to do with
- 43:04this asset. And so now you start to
- 43:06naturally for the past 15 years, I joke and think like we're so
- 43:10early to Bitcoin, we haven't figured out how to actually
- 43:12custody it, that everyone has taken these insane trade-offs.
- 43:15And just so you put it nicely, it's like, I can guarantee you
- 43:18everybody that holds their own Bitcoin has a level of from one
- 43:21to 10 uneasiness with it. It's just how, how far right
- 43:25you're using collaborative custody.
- 43:26Well, if you leave the country, are you travelling with keys?
- 43:28Well, that's a problem or you're not travelling with keys.
- 43:29That's a problem as well. And we've gone in through the
- 43:32inner workings of this onboarding billions of dollars.
- 43:34It was the best that existed. It's not to take away from it.
- 43:37It kept Bitcoin off of block fight.
- 43:38It kept Bitcoin off of Celsius, but people also kept Bitcoin on
- 43:41block 5 and Celsius because they were too afraid to get set up
- 43:44with collaborative custody. You got hardware devices, you
- 43:46got multiple C phrases, you got wallet config file.
- 43:48You got to make sure they're all right.
- 43:49You got to make sure they're not all sitting underneath your
- 43:51desk, which guess what, most people have them set up none of
- 43:54their desk. And so that's this notion of
- 43:57into Bradley's point. There's no one-size-fits-all.
- 43:59It's how you keep the system honest as you have self custody
- 44:02to be able to take delivery. But then ultimately where we're
- 44:05going is you want to trust third parties.
- 44:07You want to be able to live in a world where you can access
- 44:09financial services. Somebody can pick up the phone,
- 44:12answer an e-mail if somebody passes away and there's death
- 44:15certificates in the right precautions that are provided
- 44:17along with a bunch of other things.
- 44:19So everything we get really passionate excited about this is
- 44:23because you just look at this space for so long and when you
- 44:26see what we see, it's like, wow, this is effectively what Jesse's
- 44:31kind of aligning the future. And now you get to start
- 44:33building all the products and services on top and the market
- 44:36gets to, you know, kind of catch up.
- 44:38Because at the end of the day, game theory plays in here where
- 44:41clients come to us and then clients of large institutions
- 44:45come to us saying, hey, I want to move my assets over.
- 44:47Will you participate? And if they say no, it's like
- 44:49where you're losing all the assets versus participating in
- 44:51one of the keys. So it's a really exciting time
- 44:54and really exciting for the evolution of Bitcoin as we think
- 44:57about it going into six figures. It's it's one of those things
- 45:01where multi sig and collaborative custody had to
- 45:02exist as a prerequisite to this because I don't think most
- 45:05people would understand a two of three modeling like, wait,
- 45:07what's happening here? But now that existed.
- 45:10So that's enough in the the like mind share.
- 45:13And so it just kind of now evolves into this next
- 45:15evolution. It's a protocol too, and I think
- 45:17that's the beauty. Just.
- 45:18Here just to add a little bit on to Michael's thing to make that
- 45:21actionable of for for a lot of people, you know, so far we've
- 45:26been painting a picture of like this has been the evolution of
- 45:28Bitcoin custody and into the future it it's going to shift
- 45:32more towards multi institution custody, but for the individual
- 45:36to make it actionable. That can be you.
- 45:39Now you can take the step from self custody or third party
- 45:46custody. If you're, if you still have
- 45:47coins on Coinbase and you've been afraid to set up your own
- 45:50self custody, well, here's the solution for you.
- 45:54And that allows you to reap the benefits psychologically and
- 45:58also the, you know, the, the risk mitigation benefits of
- 46:02multi institution custody that we've been enumerating and, and
- 46:05what that ultimately allows you to do, and we've heard this from
- 46:09our clients is, is that it, it allows you to feel like you're
- 46:15more secure with your Bitcoin and that you can start to shift
- 46:20your mindset about your Bitcoin position from it's this, this,
- 46:25this thing that I think it's going to work out, but I can't
- 46:28rely on it because I could screw it up or, you know, I need to
- 46:32have other things to trust other pillars and that, that are, that
- 46:38are the majority of My Portfolio, for example, to shift
- 46:41from that model to to a mental state of, you know, what, this
- 46:46is actually the most secure thing in My Portfolio.
- 46:49I can rely on this position and you can start to transition your
- 46:55mental model of what Bitcoin means in your portfolio
- 46:59accordingly. And, and I think that's like a,
- 47:01a, a hidden and rather powerful transformation that we see with
- 47:05our clients of, of Bitcoin goes from the speculative, hopefully
- 47:11it works out to you know what, I've now live in a Bitcoin
- 47:14standard world for my personal finances.
- 47:17And that is the heart and core of how I've organized my
- 47:22financial world. And I can rely on it because I
- 47:25am using this model of custody that is better risk mitigation
- 47:28than anything else out there. Well, and that's that was my
- 47:32journey to to moving in nearly all of my Bitcoin to multi
- 47:37institution custody as we had some international travel and I
- 47:40and again, I had keys separated by many, many, many miles.
- 47:44But I just look at these keys. I don't I had one, I don't, I
- 47:47don't know what to do with this. So I do I do I, what do I store
- 47:50this one? Do I take it with me?
- 47:52And that that was one of those like mental journeys I took was
- 47:55like, OK, over time, it made more and more sense to rely on
- 48:00multi institution custody and and again, the I'm sure
- 48:02somebody's listening to me like Bradley's wrong for like all
- 48:04these reasons and that's fine. I can be wrong for you and right
- 48:07for me. And the this is because again,
- 48:10again, I frame everything through technology.
- 48:12We can have differing opinions on like the best way to build a
- 48:16website because they're web standards.
- 48:17Like, you know, somebody wants to use Squarespace because they
- 48:19just like don't want to deal with managing a server.
- 48:21That's awesome. Go build square.
- 48:22Like you can build a billion dollar business using
- 48:24Squarespace. Somebody like, I want to put it
- 48:26by hand and run it on server in my own data center.
- 48:28That's awesome too. Like you can go do that.
- 48:29There's nobody stopping you to do that because we all agree on
- 48:31the rules of web standards. Everybody can come at it with
- 48:34their own opinions and offer varying solutions to the market.
- 48:37They can all be right. And it's just people's different
- 48:40level of experience and know how and desire to tinker into like
- 48:44all those things are right. Just as if you said, Hey,
- 48:46Bradley, I'm I want to so like I actually have all of my Bitcoin
- 48:50on a single sig that memorized in my head.
- 48:52OK, like that's if you want to do that, that's fine too.
- 48:54Like that works because we all agree on the rules of the
- 48:56protocol. You can do that.
- 48:58I wouldn't do that, but like somebody else can do that.
- 49:00If you said, hey Bradley, I'm going to use collaborative
- 49:03custody, that's awesome. That's great too.
- 49:05We can all use the same. We can all you can send me
- 49:07Bitcoin, I can send you Bitcoin back and somebody can send it
- 49:09from Coinbase to me. Like because this is a protocol.
- 49:12And again, this is where it, I think for a lot of technology
- 49:14people, it maybe hasn't clicked yet.
- 49:16Like if you built your business on the backs of TCP, IP and SMTP
- 49:20and HTTP, like this is protocol for money.
- 49:23You can do things with this and doesn't matter what country
- 49:25you're in, what, what services you're in, you can just send it
- 49:27back and forth and not worry about that.
- 49:30And so that's where like, you know, I, you find the custody
- 49:32model that scales for you with your own level of comfort.
- 49:35And you have to think through like, how do I want to be
- 49:37managing this Bitcoin in 10 years from now?
- 49:39If it's, if it's 100 extra value, do I still want keys in
- 49:42my desk? You may be OK with that today,
- 49:45but like be thinking like, OK, if Bitcoin suddenly went to
- 49:47$1,000,000 tomorrow, and it's probably not, it'd be great if
- 49:49it did be interesting, like would you feel comfortable with
- 49:52your current custody model? And I suspect most people
- 49:54wouldn't. And maybe, maybe as you know, a
- 49:58next step for a lot of people if they are very tech savvy today
- 50:00is like, hey, I have this amount of Bitcoin, I'm gonna shift 30%
- 50:05of it to multi institution custody.
- 50:06And every time the price goes up more and more, I'm gonna move
- 50:09more and more and more over here cuz I don't want to have that
- 50:12level of risk in my possession in my house.
- 50:15I personally do not want to be able to sign transactions just
- 50:18full stop. And that may be some people may
- 50:21think you don't understand Bitcoin.
- 50:22I think I understand it enough to know I don't want that risk
- 50:25that I can, you know, if someone sees me out and you know, hits
- 50:29me with a wrench, I don't want to be able to sign that
- 50:30transaction right there. That's, that's my mental model.
- 50:33And I could be some people could say you're wrong and that's OK.
- 50:36But that's the beauty of Bitcoin is we can have differing
- 50:38opinions. And what scales for you and how
- 50:40you want to use the protocol is different than how I use the
- 50:43protocol. Just in the same way as I'm not
- 50:45wrong to use Squarespace to build my website or Wix.
- 50:47And you're not wrong to cover yourself.
- 50:48And that's a helpful way for me to frame this is a protocol for
- 50:51money with a known supply that we can send anywhere in the
- 50:54world. And we will all use it in
- 50:55different ways. And as new problems arise, there
- 50:58will be new companies that solve new solutions.
- 51:01And so again, going back to like, are there things about
- 51:04lightning can be better today? Sure, when we'll fix it though,
- 51:06like we'll make it better, companies will come along
- 51:08because again, we're operating as a protocol here.
- 51:10We can as an industry drive it forward just to send the same
- 51:13way like the way the Internet worked in the late 90s, like it
- 51:16was. I mean, I don't know if you've
- 51:18ever seen the video like on the Today show in like 94.
- 51:20They're like, what is this app symbol?
- 51:21Like this is 1994. And then in like, you know,
- 51:242007, the iPhone launch, a lot of work happened between 1994
- 51:28and 2007 to get there to where we put a pocket computer in
- 51:32everybody's hand and it can go anywhere in the world.
- 51:34Like that's, you know, if you don't remember how the Internet
- 51:37was adopted, you probably, you know, are shocked that more
- 51:40people don't understand it. But like, people just didn't get
- 51:42the Internet. I mean, again, even after
- 51:44likethe.com bust in the 2000s, Oh, the Internet's a fad.
- 51:47This, that and the other a few years later, you know, we have
- 51:49the App Store that's changing everything.
- 51:51You know, the, the, the and two, it is very hard when you're
- 51:55outside of the industry to like to see it too.
- 51:58I mean, it's people say, well, how did every retailer not
- 52:01understand e-commerce? Like, I don't know if y'all do
- 52:02this. Like Toys-R-Us outsourced
- 52:04e-commerce to Amazon. Did y'all know that?
- 52:07Like they just completely out, like Toys-R-Us did not have a
- 52:09website early on. They outsourced every bit of
- 52:11their e-commerce to Amazon. Well, in hindsight, that sounds
- 52:14not smart because you can see what would happen, but at the
- 52:17time it just didn't make sense. Toys-R-Us was like, we don't
- 52:20understand this, so we're just going to let this other company
- 52:22do it. That's just what happened.
- 52:24And again, obviously, like in hindsight, that was a bad
- 52:25decision, but it's hard in the moment to know where the future
- 52:30is going to go, especially if you just, you know, aren't
- 52:33aren't forward thinking. Does your Bitcoin custody setup
- 52:36keep you up at night? Maybe you still have coins
- 52:38sitting on an exchange worried about hackers.
- 52:41Or maybe you've set up your own self custody, but don't feel
- 52:43safe with your Bitcoin savings stashed on a little plastic
- 52:46device in your desk drawer. Game Peace of Mind with On Ramp
- 52:50and our multi institution custody solution.
- 52:53Here's how it works. Onramp creates a dedicated multi
- 52:56sig vault just for you. 3 separate institutions each hold
- 53:00a key, Onramp bit go and coin cover, but none can move funds
- 53:05unilaterally. Instead only you have control
- 53:08over your coins. With Onramp's multi Institution
- 53:11custody, you'll sleep better at night knowing your Bitcoin is
- 53:14stored with best in class security on chain with fault
- 53:17tolerant multi sig. If you believe your Bitcoin is
- 53:20going to be worth a lot someday, don't jeopardize that future by
- 53:24exposing your coins to hackers on exchanges, $5 wrench attacks
- 53:28in the real world, or perhaps most importantly, the risk that
- 53:31you might screw something up with a highly technical self
- 53:34custody set up on ramps. Multi institution custody
- 53:38eliminates single points of failure, reduces your personal
- 53:41attack surface and technical burden, and provides access to
- 53:45financial services that allow you to confidently secure your
- 53:47Bitcoin, including inheritance planning, insurance backed
- 53:51warranties for all balances and transactions, low cost trading,
- 53:54and more. Bitcoin is a once in a species
- 53:57asset, secure it right. Learn more at onrampbitcoin.com.
- 54:02Yeah, I think I think there's a lot there when you just like
- 54:08look at the trajectory of the Internet in the sense of most
- 54:11people don't have to understand a lot of this.
- 54:12Where we focus heavily on education is because there's a
- 54:15certain segment of the entrenched minority that has to
- 54:18understand this stuff and then the rest will pick up the
- 54:20standard that ends up winning. I think we're still during in
- 54:23that phase. I think one of the things that
- 54:25we've seen just like inside baseball at on room is that, you
- 54:30know, we focus on education and a lot of this stuff because
- 54:32ultimately you can't get to multi institution until you even
- 54:34understand why Bitcoin And you can't even get to like why
- 54:37Bitcoin until you understand that it's risk off, not risk on
- 54:40which most institutional investors are still thinking
- 54:43about as a speculative outset similar to crypto.
- 54:45And so there's just still a lot baked into a lot of this.
- 54:50I want to share one thing, but before that, just like from an
- 54:52actual perspective that Jesse and Bradley shared is, you know,
- 54:57if anybody's interested in this stuff, reach out, sign up.
- 55:01There's this notion, I don't want to call it magic, but I'll
- 55:03use it as like that term. Any sufficient technology is
- 55:06indistinguishable from magic. There is something very
- 55:08incredible about setting up an account and having a video
- 55:11verify with multiple institutions and know that
- 55:12people with armed guards and security are in different
- 55:16entities in different locations signing transactions on your
- 55:18behalf like that's never existed.
- 55:20A bunch of people are working on this stuff.
- 55:22We're excited for other people to have multi institution in the
- 55:24space. There's a lot of operational
- 55:26there's a lot of things that go into it and the keys are yours.
- 55:29It's merely misunderstood. But these keys are offline bit
- 55:33goes Trust Company the only time they've ever taken a key offline
- 55:36that houses the ETF's on ramp now Tetra and then coin cover.
- 55:42So I would encourage anybody to try that out.
- 55:44The keys are yours, you direct control, you have legal
- 55:46relationships. But the thing that I think is
- 55:49outside of on ramp, just a market structure thing I want to
- 55:51share because nobody talks about this and this is just like
- 55:54important if anybody cares about the asset.
- 55:57Is. Ultimately, you know, we said
- 56:00that people aren't comfortable with their their self custody.
- 56:02There's this like grander notion that's even just as kind of like
- 56:05wild of a statement I believe to be true is that both sides of
- 56:10custody that exists that house majority of the Bitcoin take
- 56:12insane trade-offs and nobody ever talks about how Bitcoin can
- 56:16monetize and we all believe it to, you know, be worth 10s of
- 56:19trillions of dollars and nobody ever brings up that both models
- 56:23here are not feasible. It is there's no way it can
- 56:26happen. Self custody.
- 56:28There's no way institutions are going to be able from a
- 56:30fiduciary perspective hold their own keys.
- 56:32Why on earth exists? We saw it time and time again
- 56:34where those high net worth individuals to businesses,
- 56:36institutions, they cannot just get around the fact that
- 56:39somebody can move with hardware devices outside of the platform
- 56:41or wallet config file and then third party custody.
- 56:45I mean this is ultimately why gold failed.
- 56:47You cannot have a centralization of an asset that competes with
- 56:50money and have the ability with somebody with firearms and in
- 56:53government agencies to take the asset.
- 56:56So nobody has was talking about this.
- 56:58And we saw in 22 this notion of the smartest people in the room,
- 57:04you know, weren't the smartest people, whether it was
- 57:05grayscale, whether it was the exchanges that blew up.
- 57:08And ultimately nothing else came from that other than a few
- 57:11people got slaps on the wrist. But everybody's still leveraging
- 57:14the same third party custody. Coinbase is even bigger now.
- 57:17So I think that's just a more important thing outside of honor
- 57:19is really doing a hard look of like how does this asset really
- 57:22scale to be the asset everybody wants it to be?
- 57:24If there's the two options that exist is third party custody or
- 57:27self custody. And I don't think that gets
- 57:29talked about enough because it's a little bit less of like a
- 57:31shell in the solution and more of just like there's an actual
- 57:33fundamental problem that if it doesn't get fixed, I don't know
- 57:36how that coin can actually win. Yeah.
- 57:38And Speaking of trade-offs too, Michael, and all the different
- 57:41personas that we've discussed today, one thing that's often
- 57:45overlooked is inheritance, right?
- 57:47Because Michael, even the persona you describe where it's
- 57:50a technical user, maybe on that scale of one to 10 in terms of
- 57:54the amount of pain or discomfort they experience managing their
- 57:57own keys, maybe there are one A2 or a three.
- 58:00They have a very low amount of discomfort managing their own
- 58:03keys. But often what we find in
- 58:05conversations with clients, one of the main things that concerns
- 58:09them is they all view Bitcoin as a multi generational pursuit as
- 58:13the four of us do as well. And to take a trade off and have
- 58:19a gap in your financial plan where if something happens to me
- 58:23or something happens to client and there's not a seamless way
- 58:28for their family to access that wealth.
- 58:30That's that is a massive trade off.
- 58:31That's essentially accepting that all of the work that you've
- 58:35done to understand Bitcoin, which is often hundreds or
- 58:37thousands of hours for an individual, and then all of the
- 58:41capital and choice they've made to use Bitcoin as their
- 58:45preferred savings vehicle could all be lost in a transition of
- 58:50that wealth. And that's really, in my
- 58:52opinion, a very unacceptable and irresponsible trade off to make.
- 58:56So unless someone feels like really bulletproof that their
- 58:59spouse or their children will actually be able to access that
- 59:03wealth. And they've also addressed the
- 59:04legal title issue, which a lot of people haven't done with self
- 59:07custody. Then they're really taking a ton
- 59:09of risk there, which. Could.
- 59:12Unfortunately, like people don't like to talk about it, but it
- 59:13could really put someone's family in a terrible situation
- 59:17financially. It's a it's a great call out
- 59:19because again, thousands of conversations have come into
- 59:23the, this, these products and how we think about them.
- 59:26And there's these two overarching themes that I think
- 59:28the audience a lot will resonate is generally it's a male that's
- 59:30the the allocator, the one holding BTC.
- 59:34And generally what I'm finding is they, they say it to me.
- 59:37I've never heard it out loud. It's just like my wife wants is
- 59:39fine with the allocation, but it's not fine with wants nothing
- 59:42to do with the asset. So it's like it's on you and
- 59:44it's a difficult spot to be in because again, if you go back to
- 59:47that last image that showed third party custody or self
- 59:50custody, you can't leave. We all know you can't leave it
- 59:53on a third party custodian. You'll more than likely outlive
- 59:55the third party custodian historically.
- 59:57But then the alternative is what Jackson's referring to as you're
- 1:00:00effectively leaving a treasure map and hoping your family can
- 1:00:03find the asset, which I guess made sense because it was the
- 1:00:071st 15 years, but there's other there needed to be market
- 1:00:10structure that developed the other thing.
- 1:00:13That's worth referencing. And it's just, it reminds me of
- 1:00:15trust, revocable and irrevocable trust and how we put them off in
- 1:00:19the same way that we think if we put off inheritance is mortality
- 1:00:22becomes real. As we get older, people get
- 1:00:25sicker. And I remember this from clients
- 1:00:28previously. And here where somebody I was
- 1:00:29just on the phone with, somebody whose father passed away this
- 1:00:31morning, didn't pass away this morning.
- 1:00:33I was talking with the gentleman, this father passed
- 1:00:35away and, you know, he was down but also understood he needed to
- 1:00:38get set up because it's like he stored all his value.
- 1:00:41This is significant wealth. And it's like, I can't be in a
- 1:00:43position when you go through that.
- 1:00:45So mortality starts to become increasing real.
- 1:00:47And it's just like, well, what am I doing here?
- 1:00:50And so, yeah, those are two good call outs actually.
- 1:00:53And that's, that speaks to making Bitcoin a more reliable,
- 1:00:59a more robust part of your financial planning and, and
- 1:01:05financial reality. Because you know, in, in 2011,
- 1:01:09it was the cypherpunks and anarchists and who were young
- 1:01:14single males who had some, you know, Bitcoin allocation.
- 1:01:20Fast forward Bitcoin now is held by family men, you know and and
- 1:01:27and millennials who are starting families.
- 1:01:30I've I've gone through this journey recently, Michael has
- 1:01:33recently and and you're what you need to to have in your Bitcoin
- 1:01:40custody set up shifts. I think as, as part of that,
- 1:01:44you, you need to know that your family is going to be protected,
- 1:01:49protected against Fiat debasement, yes, but also
- 1:01:53protected in the event that, that you get hit by a bus
- 1:01:57because the treasure map set up is pretty uncomfortable.
- 1:02:02You can get it to a place where you're pretty sure it can it,
- 1:02:05it'll work, but you never know. And that, that one, two 5%
- 1:02:10chance is, is pretty awful. And, and so I think that that is
- 1:02:16also part of the story of, of Bitcoin.
- 1:02:19Bitcoin custody evolves into being a part of society and the
- 1:02:25fabric of society is, is reliable financial trust, you
- 1:02:30know, in in financial planning. And that's where Bitcoin, you
- 1:02:35know, has to emerge from the wilderness and, and become a
- 1:02:38part of, of, of that fabric of society and allow for family
- 1:02:44planning really and, and family confidence and multi institution
- 1:02:49custody does that in a way that no prior form of custody has
- 1:02:53been able to do, Especially when it comes to like, you know, the,
- 1:02:56the wrench attack possibilities of taking all that
- 1:02:59responsibility and putting it on yourself and storing it in your
- 1:03:03house, you know, in various places that that now you're just
- 1:03:07opening yourself up to a form of barbarism that we haven't had to
- 1:03:12deal with as a, as a society in hundreds of years.
- 1:03:15And so let's quickly get to a place where we no longer have
- 1:03:18that risk reintroduced. It it's it's looking at to it.
- 1:03:24People want solutions. They don't want to to, you know,
- 1:03:28buy pieces together. So it's kind of like, you know,
- 1:03:31somebody in the 90s when they wanted a computer, they would go
- 1:03:33out and they would build their computer and they'd buy pieces
- 1:03:36off the shelf and they'd go and they'd put it all together and
- 1:03:38say, oh, we're going to make this work.
- 1:03:39If we still had to use computers that way today, a lot fewer
- 1:03:43people would have computers. So people just like I, I want to
- 1:03:45go to the, I'm going to Best Buy, I want to go to the Apple
- 1:03:47Store. I just want to buy the computer
- 1:03:48and it work and I want to tinker with it.
- 1:03:50All the same pieces are in there, but they if somebody else
- 1:03:52has sold them a solution. So we we built the technology
- 1:03:57over the last 15 years. Now the solutions are being
- 1:03:59built and multi institution custody is a solution that
- 1:04:02scales Bitcoin custody to the masses.
- 1:04:04It is safe and secure and I would argue it has the no there
- 1:04:08is no perfect way to do anything in technology.
- 1:04:11There are always trade-offs. I would argue that multi
- 1:04:15institution custody has the the, the best, you know, if you're
- 1:04:18looking at pros and cons list, it has the most in the pros list
- 1:04:21of any, of any custody model. And I think it's the one that
- 1:04:24scales from, you know, somebody that's that's 80 and that just
- 1:04:27knows they need some Bitcoin, but don't they don't want to
- 1:04:29deal with it. Or someone that's 20 and they
- 1:04:31travel around a lot. Like I don't want to hold these
- 1:04:33keys. It scales for everybody just as
- 1:04:35in the same way like the iPhone was a great smartphone for
- 1:04:38everybody regardless of your of your tech savviness.
- 1:04:42Bitcoin and multi institution custody is the way that scales
- 1:04:45the same way it really is to me, the iPhone of Bitcoin custody.
- 1:04:49Yeah, Maybe one thing we could do now is I kind of want to zoom
- 1:04:53out for a second outside of just multi institution and talk about
- 1:04:58risks, right. Because Jesse, one thing that
- 1:05:00you mentioned and really the entire topic of this
- 1:05:03conversation is evolution of custody, right?
- 1:05:06Custody is a solution that evolves as the market and risk
- 1:05:10structure evolves, right? So I'm curious to hear the
- 1:05:14group's thoughts on thinking through 2024, this next cycle
- 1:05:19and a cycle from now, right? Like let's think about the next
- 1:05:22five years for Bitcoin custody. What are some risks that maybe
- 1:05:27are increasing in your opinion or decreasing, right?
- 1:05:30Because risk is always going to be a vector.
- 1:05:32These risks are never static. Things change on a daily basis,
- 1:05:36monthly basis or yearly basis. So I'm curious to hear the
- 1:05:38group's thoughts, whether it's just in conversations, building
- 1:05:41the business or maybe paying attention to other developments
- 1:05:44within the industry. What do you guys see as risks
- 1:05:47that maybe people are under appreciating versus over
- 1:05:51appreciating in the market? And how do people think about,
- 1:05:54you know, mitigating some of these risks and as they develop?
- 1:05:58I mean, the first thing that comes to mind is I'll throw it
- 1:06:02back after sharing the statement to you Jackson, because you have
- 1:06:04a lot of these conversations is more institutions don't catch up
- 1:06:08on this cycle and we have orders of magnitude of liquidity
- 1:06:15issues, right? Because at the end of the day,
- 1:06:17the volatile asset and it's, it's, it's the most volatile
- 1:06:20asset we've probably ever seen, specifically if you're coming
- 1:06:23from Tri Phi. And so if you get caught off
- 1:06:24sides, it's unfriendly and people end up insolvent.
- 1:06:28You know, people custodial losses, exit scans, there's all
- 1:06:30these things that happen. And it's been very positive to
- 1:06:33see folks from Schwab joined the firm pensions that we're working
- 1:06:37with in the UK. So it's good to see
- 1:06:39institutional investors grok this because we've seen carnage
- 1:06:42the past 15 years, but it's still very, we're still very
- 1:06:46early in my fear. The risk is that more capital is
- 1:06:51going to come in orders of magnitude more capital this next
- 1:06:54cycle and that there's just going to be losses.
- 1:06:56Again, it's going to be another, you know, I don't know exact
- 1:06:59time frame obviously, but curious like Jackson on your
- 1:07:02side because you have a lot of these conversations, where do
- 1:07:04you do you agree with that or where do you see risks outside
- 1:07:07of that? Yeah, one area that it's
- 1:07:12probably not a surprise to any of you and won't be as surprised
- 1:07:14to the audience because they're thinking about it in many cases
- 1:07:17is I think people tend to over index against hypothetical
- 1:07:22future kind of tail risk events. One example of that being a
- 1:07:2761O2, right? Everyone likes to think about
- 1:07:30what happened 100 years ago is related to the US government's
- 1:07:35actions and confiscation of gold from private citizens within the
- 1:07:40country, right? And there's a couple things to
- 1:07:43call out there first and foremost.
- 1:07:45But think only about 25% of private ownership of gold was
- 1:07:48actually successfully confiscated.
- 1:07:50So now you kind of think about that and extrapolate to a
- 1:07:53digital bear asset that doesn't. It's kind of weird, right?
- 1:07:56It lives somewhere and nowhere at the same time.
- 1:07:59And what I think people often times fall into is they over
- 1:08:05index to these things that don't really they don't exist today.
- 1:08:08It's good to be aware of them. And I wouldn't discount it
- 1:08:11personally, but you're, you're in many cases over indexing to
- 1:08:15something that could happen, but it doesn't happen right now.
- 1:08:20But what could happen today and and things that we face,
- 1:08:23Bradley, an example you pointed out is travelling, right?
- 1:08:26People travel very frequently personally for business, How do
- 1:08:31you manage keys if you're leaving for a week for a
- 1:08:34vacation or you're leaving for two weeks for a business trip,
- 1:08:37right? Do you bring the keys with you?
- 1:08:38Are they secured within your home?
- 1:08:40Are they secured in another location?
- 1:08:42How do you perform any sort of key checks while you're away?
- 1:08:47Another thing we already talked about is inheritance.
- 1:08:50This is if you're using Bitcoin as your primary store of value
- 1:08:54and it's a very much a bedrock of your financial plan, you need
- 1:08:59to absolutely have a way to pass those assets down.
- 1:09:02And that is, in my opinion, much more important than thinking
- 1:09:06about what could happen if the US government or some people
- 1:09:10even go as far as to say governments globally will
- 1:09:12coordinate attack on Bitcoin, which we can unpack that.
- 1:09:15I think it's a very, very low risk and it would be extremely
- 1:09:17hard to pull off. But there's of course ways to
- 1:09:19mitigate that, right, right. Like multi jurisdiction, multi
- 1:09:25institution custody is a form of third party custody that
- 1:09:29mitigates these risks. So a, you're not trusting
- 1:09:31yourself with all of your Bitcoin and opening up
- 1:09:34trade-offs as it relates to human error and travelling and
- 1:09:37inheritance, but you're also not trusting 1 institution that if
- 1:09:41the government did, you know, on a dime, change their entire
- 1:09:44position, which would be unlikely, there'd probably be a
- 1:09:47lot of messaging and you'd kind of be able to anticipate
- 1:09:50something like that happening. But if it did happen on a dime,
- 1:09:53you would be in a pretty tough spot if you had all of your
- 1:09:55Bitcoin and one omnibus account at, you know, AUS regulated
- 1:09:59exchange. But if your Bitcoin is held and
- 1:10:01not controlled by one independent institution, but
- 1:10:04it's but there's governance and decentralization baked into how
- 1:10:09the keys are managed and they're in multiple jurisdictions and no
- 1:10:13institution can turn keys over to the government, then you've
- 1:10:15effectively removed or or really mitigated that risk.
- 1:10:19So hopefully that helps this context.
- 1:10:22I think these are typically the converse, these are typically
- 1:10:25the conversations that I'm having with folks is how do you
- 1:10:27actually approach this personally at an individual
- 1:10:30level or if you're a business, how do you think about this as
- 1:10:32well? And I try to anchor back to what
- 1:10:36actually this, what are actually the circumstances today and what
- 1:10:39are the higher probability risks and what are increasing versus
- 1:10:43what might be decreasing in the market?
- 1:10:48Yeah, I think about, I, I think there's the, the potential for
- 1:10:52personal tragedy that I, I think is, is probably acute, acute
- 1:10:59risk for the individual. I don't think Bitcoin has a ton
- 1:11:02of risk in terms of its continued success and and
- 1:11:08growth, but the individual can screw up along the way.
- 1:11:13And, and I think we're, I think there are discrete risks for the
- 1:11:21the individual and how they custody, whether they choose
- 1:11:23self custody or third party custody that are higher than
- 1:11:27people generally think. I think a great example of this
- 1:11:32is right now there are there's some network, probably several
- 1:11:37networks of hackers who are really social engineering
- 1:11:42hackers who are through a variety of of methods are
- 1:11:47gaining people's cell phone numbers because you're on some,
- 1:11:52you know, Ledger hardware contact info leak from three
- 1:11:57years ago or other personal information leaks.
- 1:12:04And people are getting contacted by these these hackers who sound
- 1:12:08who are making themselves sound like customer service tech
- 1:12:12support for various crypto platforms.
- 1:12:17Maybe it's Coinbase, maybe it's Ledger, and these guys are
- 1:12:21really good. There's a interview that John
- 1:12:25Seth did, the impromptu interview he he got with one of
- 1:12:30these hackers who called him. And then he managed to get this
- 1:12:33guy to talk about everything they do.
- 1:12:35And the first, you know, 5-10 minutes of that call was this
- 1:12:39guy thinking he was making headway on effectively social
- 1:12:43engineering John Seth while John Seth was playing along.
- 1:12:46But it was really good. It sounded right.
- 1:12:48It sounded like the real deal. And who knows how many
- 1:12:52individuals will fall for that or have already fallen for that
- 1:12:57and could going forward, accidentally hand over their
- 1:13:01Coinbase login credentials and have those hackers sweep their
- 1:13:06the account. That happens every day.
- 1:13:10And we don't think about it because because Coinbase isn't
- 1:13:13hacked. And I think that's a, you know,
- 1:13:16why we don't think about that as a risk, because Coinbase's
- 1:13:19security has never been hacked, at least that I'm aware of.
- 1:13:24And it's a it, you know, from a, from a pure security point of
- 1:13:28view, it is sound. However you can, you can be
- 1:13:32social engineered to give up your credentials and then your
- 1:13:35account gets swept. And Coinbase didn't do anything
- 1:13:38wrong. You screwed up.
- 1:13:40So I think that's the, the risk to the individual.
- 1:13:42And of course, there's also the, the wrench attack risk.
- 1:13:45And we're starting to see more sophisticated criminal networks
- 1:13:50targeting people who have wealth.
- 1:13:55And it's, you know, there, there are some who are doing this
- 1:13:58with, with crypto. I think I, you know, you can
- 1:14:01only imagine how the price of Bitcoin 5-10 X is.
- 1:14:06There's going to be a lot more of that targeting wrench
- 1:14:09attacks, targeting the individual who are, who's
- 1:14:11keeping their keys at home. And then I think the, the, the
- 1:14:16big hidden risk for individuals and institutions is that people
- 1:14:23are keeping themselves from a larger Bitcoin allocation
- 1:14:26because they're uncomfortable with the their options of self
- 1:14:30custody or third party custody. And so that's a big risk that
- 1:14:34you are, you are keeping yourself out of the game, even
- 1:14:37though you know where this is going because it's
- 1:14:41uncomfortable, because you don't want to lose the farm, because
- 1:14:45it's just psychologically untenable to take that risk on
- 1:14:49of, of self custody or or third party custody.
- 1:14:52And so in doing that, you're running this risk of missing
- 1:14:55out. You are you have put yourself on
- 1:14:57the sideline at least partly. Maybe you have a 5% allocation,
- 1:15:00but you would have a 20% if you if you felt more comfortable
- 1:15:04about custody. Well, you're missing out on a
- 1:15:0615% allocation right there. And so I think that's AI think
- 1:15:11that's a epidemic of, of fear out there about Bitcoin.
- 1:15:18That is probably the single biggest risk that that people
- 1:15:21run with regard to custody. It's nobody feeling really
- 1:15:23comfortable. And so they're counting
- 1:15:25themselves out of the game. That's a great like working
- 1:15:27backwards really quick. There's you hit on two really
- 1:15:30important things I think for, for listeners and as we share
- 1:15:33this is, it's, I always thought about on ramp as like the price
- 1:15:37appreciates is less for the hardcore bit pointer like our
- 1:15:39friend, it's for their family member that has, I always think
- 1:15:42like somebody that has whatever their percentage is, unless
- 1:15:46they've gone very deep and figured out how to make it as
- 1:15:48close to bulletproof as possible, they want 10X the
- 1:15:51version. So if they have 1%, they want
- 1:15:5210%. If they got all the way to
- 1:15:53double digit percentage of their net worth, they really want
- 1:15:56100%, but they haven't figured out to Jesse's point, how to
- 1:15:59make it bulletproof. And that's where those numbers
- 1:16:02you hear about 200 million people home Bitcoin, it's
- 1:16:05reality. It's like .01% of that.
- 1:16:07It's just people have $5 on Coinbase or $1000 in the ETF on
- 1:16:11their IRA or whatever. So I think sharing this, always
- 1:16:14want to work with them. The other one is honestly, I
- 1:16:18think the biggest blind spot in this whole setup from the
- 1:16:22smartest, most educated people in the space of the, the notion
- 1:16:26that we're all going to hold our keys in the same way that like
- 1:16:31there's a reason why we don't hold gold underneath our
- 1:16:33mattress. And for thousands of years,
- 1:16:35institutions that have existed and we had to build trust
- 1:16:37circles around them. And it's not to say it has to
- 1:16:39look exactly the same, but there's these two things that
- 1:16:42are happening currently that everybody I think would agree
- 1:16:44on. You have the right side, which
- 1:16:46is the digital sphere. And everybody that's
- 1:16:47sophisticated online is trying to get your Bitcoin.
- 1:16:49Jesse called out Coinbase. There's all the different, you
- 1:16:52know, North Korean hack. There's all these groups that
- 1:16:54are all day online, like to the point we don't even use our
- 1:16:56phones anymore. And then and there's always a
- 1:17:00connection between your phone and your Exchange Server.
- 1:17:02So I think ideally, most folks that are listening to this would
- 1:17:04know to keep their Bitcoin off of an exchange.
- 1:17:07The other side that I think gets discounted and not brought up
- 1:17:10enough is I can't imagine any city that anybody's living in
- 1:17:13where crime has gone down just full stop.
- 1:17:17Maybe across the world, there's probably like top 510 cities.
- 1:17:20Everything else is up and to the right.
- 1:17:22We're in a bull market for whatever's happening from a
- 1:17:25defunding, from a societal situation.
- 1:17:27But those are generally been pretty segregated, right?
- 1:17:29So you have the digital folks online trying to get your
- 1:17:32Bitcoin. You have physical people, you
- 1:17:33know, mugging, doing, breaking into houses.
- 1:17:36Those haven't merged together. And what Jesse called out was
- 1:17:39that as the price goes to two 5-10 X, those things will
- 1:17:42naturally converge where you're going to have physical people
- 1:17:45that are physical harm that's generally done maps to the
- 1:17:49digital world and understanding people hold Bitcoin because
- 1:17:52there's not many places you can fold your private keys other
- 1:17:54than your home. You leave it in a bank.
- 1:17:56Well, they're not open, you know, after 5:00 and on
- 1:17:58weekends. So good luck with that.
- 1:18:00Like multiple houses maybe. So this notion of like all of
- 1:18:05our data is out there, whether it's all the CRM leaks from
- 1:18:07every exchange, collaborative custody providers been hacked,
- 1:18:10it'll be hacked, you know, God forbid ours will probably one
- 1:18:13day. It's just this is what happens
- 1:18:14with data. It doesn't want to be
- 1:18:16centralized, so it ends up somewhere.
- 1:18:19You map that with all the AI tools that are out there, you
- 1:18:21can pretty much discern how much Bitcoin almost everybody owns.
- 1:18:25So now what happens when the price is 100K150K350K?
- 1:18:30And now you can figure out that somebody's holding $4.5 million
- 1:18:34in BTC, $35.7 million in Bitcoin.
- 1:18:37And now you have kids at home and you go to work and you go on
- 1:18:40vacation. Like what is the the end game?
- 1:18:43What is the plan? And then you need to access a
- 1:18:45Bitcoin because you got to pay for the doctor bill.
- 1:18:46Or are you going to like show because the logic of violence
- 1:18:49changes in that scenario because now people are watching where
- 1:18:51you go right now it doesn't matter because it's $350,000 in
- 1:18:54multi state custody. But what happens when it's 3.5
- 1:18:58million? Like it all changes.
- 1:19:00And so it just doesn't get talked about because I don't
- 1:19:01think people have had to go through that.
- 1:19:03And it's just like Anchor 2, not your keys, not your coin, don't
- 1:19:06trust anyone. Well, I mean, that only works
- 1:19:09until kind of you hit that inflection point.
- 1:19:11And I think this is kind of what we're talking about here.
- 1:19:14I think the risk to the individual.
- 1:19:17I would echo what both of you all said.
- 1:19:19Specifically run inheritance. Security inheritance are to me
- 1:19:21the two biggest ones and that to me is where multi and social
- 1:19:25custody, it really solves that. I think that the risk of the
- 1:19:29industry is something that I've not heard anybody talk about is
- 1:19:32that we get frustrated that people want solutions instead of
- 1:19:37buying parts. And just as like it's kind of
- 1:19:40like that that Jeff Bezos quote you like your margin is my
- 1:19:42opportunity. There is a lot of opportunity in
- 1:19:45selling solutions here. And that's why I think on ramp
- 1:19:48is, is is really set up very well in the coming years because
- 1:19:52it's selling a solution. And it's okay if people don't
- 1:19:56want to physically hold keys. And it's okay if people don't
- 1:19:59care about the latest roll ups and it's okay if they actually
- 1:20:02don't care about Bitcoin at all. They just want their money to
- 1:20:04stop. Being worse and like, I think,
- 1:20:07you know, it'll be there are people out there that like if
- 1:20:09they went to their bank and their bank was the only place
- 1:20:11that like, you know, again, let's say their bank had a multi
- 1:20:13institutional custody and then but they just like went to the
- 1:20:15local bank and it's like, Hey, we can reverge your dollars to
- 1:20:18Bitcoin and we have this this custody agreements like OK, like
- 1:20:21the people don't care and like that.
- 1:20:23And I think we had often forget about that.
- 1:20:24Like generally people just don't care about this.
- 1:20:26Like if you're, you know, a plumber, you just like want to
- 1:20:29go do your job, help your customers and make money and you
- 1:20:33want your money to work for you. That's who the industry needs to
- 1:20:36be focusing building on is the people that actually don't care
- 1:20:38about Bitcoin, just as in same ways like people can like not
- 1:20:42care about SSL and HTTPS and like the latest enhancements in
- 1:20:47like security. They just want their phone and
- 1:20:49their apps to work. They just, they just wanted to
- 1:20:51go about their lives. And so as an industry, like we
- 1:20:53need to keep building solutions for people that absolutely do
- 1:20:56not care about Bitcoin because those are the people when they
- 1:20:59come to Bitcoin because it's just like what everybody's
- 1:21:01doing. Just in the same way everybody
- 1:21:02came to smartphones, everybody came to the Internet, like we
- 1:21:05need solutions that are turnkey for them.
- 1:21:06And that's to me why I'm so passionate about multi
- 1:21:09institutional custody. Yeah, there's a It's funny, we
- 1:21:12forgot. Like there's a reason why the
- 1:21:13division of Labor exists and it's like it anchors to the one
- 1:21:16that's like, it's not hard to, you know, hold 12 words or self
- 1:21:20custody. It's like it's not hard for to
- 1:21:22do $10. Try doing 50% of your net worth
- 1:21:25and let's see how easy it is. It's just like, it's just the
- 1:21:27notion of it's, it's not the same thing and it's just treated
- 1:21:32as the same. Yeah, and, and I remember years
- 1:21:35ago listening to podcasts about collaborative custody, about
- 1:21:40multi sig in general. And the talk then was, you know,
- 1:21:44eventually you'll have like your accountant hold a key in his
- 1:21:47office and maybe your lawyer will hold a key in their office
- 1:21:51and then you'll have one at home.
- 1:21:52And then you've got some geographic distribution there.
- 1:21:57And that'll be that'll be how people do this.
- 1:21:59But that doesn't really make sense because they're not
- 1:22:03experts and they don't quite have the right incentives.
- 1:22:07Really what you want to do is you want to hire a key holder
- 1:22:10whose, whose business is doing this, who, who's best in class
- 1:22:14at holding a key and keeping it safe and signing when the
- 1:22:17appropriate, you know, conditions are met.
- 1:22:22And that's what multi institution custody actually is.
- 1:22:25And so it's, it's funny, there was this sort of half baked
- 1:22:28notion of how you'd eventually have some distribution of who's
- 1:22:32holding the key and, and geographic separation of the
- 1:22:35keys, but there was always half baked.
- 1:22:38And here is the the baked version of it where you you have
- 1:22:45a a marketplace for key holders. You know, you, you're when you
- 1:22:49come to on ramp, you're hiring the best in the world at holding
- 1:22:53keys on your behalf because we've partnered with the best in
- 1:22:57the world to hold keys in a multi state quorum and sign when
- 1:23:01the appropriate conditions are met on your behalf.
- 1:23:05And so, you know, it's, it's a natural evolution of this entire
- 1:23:09journey of Bitcoin custody over the last 15 years.
- 1:23:13And it's really at the dawn of a new era of a format of custody
- 1:23:18that's simply not possible with with the traditional assets.
- 1:23:22You can't do this with stocks, bonds, gold, real estate.
- 1:23:27And it's going to open up a a lot of new capital to Bitcoin
- 1:23:34because it's going to lower the risks inherent in in holding
- 1:23:38Bitcoin and it's going to secure a lot of families, financial
- 1:23:45worlds and, and enable them to have the kind of freedom that
- 1:23:50Bitcoin has always promised. And the security side of custody
- 1:23:55has always been that nagging requirement that that weighs
- 1:24:02heavily on on the individual and and on the person.
- 1:24:06Usually the guy in the family who thinks of this is a great
- 1:24:10asset to hold, but it comes with some some nerves holding it at
- 1:24:16home or wherever you do. And so you know, this is, I
- 1:24:20think I guess to bring it full circle, this is this is that
- 1:24:22next step in the technological progression of Bitcoin custody
- 1:24:31where we go from highly technical, less user friendly
- 1:24:36forms of custody to more user friendly, less technical, more
- 1:24:41professionalized forms of Bitcoin custody.
- 1:24:44Yeah, and that's a really key point.
- 1:24:46Professionalized because these concepts, they don't get talked
- 1:24:50about enough. It's less about because the
- 1:24:52incentives aren't there. It's just because most people
- 1:24:54haven't had the background and experiences because there's two
- 1:24:57sides. It's one understanding Bitcoin
- 1:24:58deeply, but even more than that, it's understanding the world and
- 1:25:01commercialization of technology and how it's going to be
- 1:25:03introduced. And so coming on room, it's
- 1:25:07there's a technology component, but then there's a professional
- 1:25:11experience with historically, like going back to Bradleys
- 1:25:14point, people want solutions and historically people have only
- 1:25:17had problems when they allocate to Bitcoin because you've played
- 1:25:19hot potato with the asset. You're basically just going from
- 1:25:22exchange to this next one's Trust Company just got hacked
- 1:25:25and now I don't know if they're gonna let me take my Bitcoin or
- 1:25:27my IRA like it's just hot potato.
- 1:25:29Now my collaborative custody doesn't work.
- 1:25:31It's it's called honor it for a lot of reasons.
- 1:25:33They're one of them is you start with this custody format.
- 1:25:35But as we grow, whether it's multi jurisdictional, if you
- 1:25:37want to hold a percentage potential in the future with the
- 1:25:40keys just so you can always have control.
- 1:25:42There's a lot of things we're talking about.
- 1:25:44There is a world though that in multi institution custody you
- 1:25:48can open up a whole new like dawn of financial products that
- 1:25:52reduce counterparty risk, but allow you to still have this
- 1:25:55notion that one single entity doesn't hold unilateral control.
- 1:25:58Insurance is just an easy example, right, because you
- 1:26:00can't historically insure all of coin bases assets and you also
- 1:26:03can't insure your assets if you're holding them by yourself.
- 1:26:06There's no shortage of other things that we have planned in
- 1:26:08the market. We're working again.
- 1:26:10We mentioned the pensions, the UK, we think that in the future
- 1:26:12state publicly traded funds, you know, i.e.
- 1:26:16TFs will be held in this format. They've, they've called it
- 1:26:18bulletproof. It makes complete sense why you
- 1:26:21would not want 10s of thousands, if not hundreds of thousands of
- 1:26:24Bitcoin sitting with a single custodian that can lose it all.
- 1:26:28So I think that's the second part.
- 1:26:29It's technology mixed with humans are really where we're
- 1:26:32driving this kind of forward when it comes to financial
- 1:26:35services built on it. Yeah.
- 1:26:36And on the technology piece too, maybe just one final thought
- 1:26:40before we get to wrapping here is for the folks that are a
- 1:26:45little bit more technical and more savvy and want additional
- 1:26:49assurances. You may want to know that while
- 1:26:53you are providing, while you are allowing third parties to manage
- 1:27:00keys on your behalf, again, it is multi institution.
- 1:27:04None of them control it and they only sign in your direction.
- 1:27:07And the kicker here is that when you log in to your client
- 1:27:11dashboard, you can take your address and you can plug it into
- 1:27:14a public block explorer node and you can, you can verify this on
- 1:27:17chain, right? So, so Bradley's point earlier
- 1:27:20in the episode, we want to live in a world where you still trust
- 1:27:23institutions. But in that same vein, this is
- 1:27:26still a trust minimize solution because you're not trusting 1
- 1:27:29institution and you can always verify it yourself as well.
- 1:27:32So I think that's something that I often overlooked in the past.
- 1:27:36And now I really do make it a point to share with folks in
- 1:27:38conversation because it is important.
- 1:27:40It's not going to be important to the net new a buyer of
- 1:27:43Bitcoin, but it will be important to someone who's owned
- 1:27:45it since 2017 and has a sizable portion of once that additional
- 1:27:50transparency and visibility into how the assets are held.
- 1:27:56So with that, any final thoughts here before we close it down?
- 1:28:01You know, I think for me, if anybody's listening to this and
- 1:28:04say, well, I don't have enough Bitcoin to, to, to need a
- 1:28:07solution like this. Book a consultation, chat, chat
- 1:28:10with the honor team. I promise you, you'll be blown
- 1:28:13away by it. And even if it's not the right
- 1:28:15solution for you today, you want to learn about it.
- 1:28:19Because to me, again, this is the model that scales up.
- 1:28:22You know, Jackson, you're talking about like you know
- 1:28:24trust. You know there is trust
- 1:28:26everywhere. Even if you manage your own keys
- 1:28:29yourself. You're still trusting Apple,
- 1:28:31you're still trusting Dell. You're still trusting your
- 1:28:33Internet provider. You're still trusting the maker
- 1:28:35of the USB cord. You're still trusting all these
- 1:28:37things. And one of the things that I
- 1:28:39would I would kind of leave you to think about is again, the
- 1:28:42inheritance was huge for me. And you know, we've seen, you
- 1:28:45know, I've seen so many connectors and things and
- 1:28:48protocols come in my life for communication.
- 1:28:50You know, imagine if you just put, if you have your Bitcoin
- 1:28:54hardware signed device and put it in a drawer and it sits in
- 1:28:57there for 30 years. You know, do you think that how
- 1:29:01are you going to connect that particular device to your
- 1:29:04computer 30 years from now? It's probably going to have the
- 1:29:06same cord. And those are the things you
- 1:29:07have to think about when you take and physically hold keys.
- 1:29:11You're having a technical burden that you're going to have to
- 1:29:13think through over the years as technology evolves.
- 1:29:16You're going to think through that when you come to on ramp
- 1:29:18and multi institution custody. You don't have to think about
- 1:29:21that. You're you're getting to enjoy
- 1:29:23the the benefits of bitcoins adoption without having to you
- 1:29:28know, hang on on the bumpy ride along the way as that technology
- 1:29:31evolves as as as Bitcoin evolves as a protocol on ramp and its
- 1:29:34key providers will be right there along with it always
- 1:29:38having the best in class security, always having the best
- 1:29:41in class way to interact with the protocol.
- 1:29:43And again to me, it was very when I came to honor.
- 1:29:45It was very big to me that I could I run my own node.
- 1:29:48I can view my wallet on my own node trust but verify.
- 1:29:52And again, I even if you start slowly with your multi
- 1:29:55institution custody vault, I promise you as bitcoins price
- 1:29:58rises, you will find yourself more and more feeling less
- 1:30:01confident technically and physically, you know, managing
- 1:30:04your own keys and you'll want to you'll want to partner with on
- 1:30:07ramp and it's key providers. I promise you that, yeah.
- 1:30:12Well, thanks, Bradley. Michael, I think.
- 1:30:15Yeah. Only thing to call out because I
- 1:30:16think maybe we didn't fully specify is that, you know, multi
- 1:30:21sig is only native to the Bitcoin protocol, which is
- 1:30:24important because it's effectively interoperable with
- 1:30:27any other, you know, public private key pair in the sense
- 1:30:30that this is technology that the largest custodians in the world
- 1:30:33specifically like Coinbase and Bitco use.
- 1:30:35So there's nothing different here out from a technical
- 1:30:38perspective. What's different is really from
- 1:30:40a legal and social construct perspective.
- 1:30:43So you have relationships with multiple custodians and they
- 1:30:45move at the direction of you and we provide financial services,
- 1:30:48client services around it. I think it's just important to
- 1:30:51call out because ultimately we say this scales and helps
- 1:30:54Bitcoins adoption. Some folks may not fully grok
- 1:30:57that this technology is interoperable and allows for
- 1:31:01different levels from different places all over around the world
- 1:31:04to participate where other technologies don't that
- 1:31:07generally use crypto assets. And that's why you don't see
- 1:31:09this approach very often. But as Bitcoins price arises and
- 1:31:12I think we were recently a 60% dominance in the crypto sphere,
- 1:31:15more and more people will wake up to Bitcoin significance and
- 1:31:18why you would want to custody in a different way.
- 1:31:22Yeah, well said. Well, Bradley, thanks for
- 1:31:25joining us this week. Really appreciate your
- 1:31:27generosity with your time. Michael and Jesse, good
- 1:31:30conversation as always. And Brian had to jump early, but
- 1:31:33Brian did a great job with the report and sharing some thoughts
- 1:31:36earlier. So for folks that want to find
- 1:31:39the report, just check out our website on rampthisone.com.
- 1:31:43You'll see it right there on the homepage.
- 1:31:44You'll be able to download the report, read it through it
- 1:31:47yourself, and share with any friends, family, colleagues.
- 1:31:50We'll also be hosting the webinar on the evolution of
- 1:31:53Bitcoin custody. That'll be on September 10th.
- 1:31:56We'll include the information in the show notes to find more
- 1:32:00details there and register. And now we look forward to
- 1:32:04speaking with you. If you want to reach out and
- 1:32:06discuss any of the things we talked about today, we're always
- 1:32:10welcome. Welcoming a new conversations
- 1:32:12opportunity to jump on a call. So just go to our website and
- 1:32:14you can schedule a consultation right there and connect with any
- 1:32:17of us. Awesome.
- 1:32:23Thanks for listening to this week's episode of the show.
- 1:32:25If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 1:32:27episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 1:32:30app. All the links we discussed in
- 1:32:32today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 1:32:35Before we finish, a quick reminder that On Rat Media is
- 1:32:37for informational and entertainment purposes only, and
- 1:32:40nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 1:32:43Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:32:46to hear from you. Visit onrampbitcoin.com contact
- 1:32:49to schedule a consultation with one of our private client
- 1:32:52advisors.