Latest / Culture Alchemy / Ep. 86: Why YOU CAN SEE EVERYTHING Deserves a Best Picture Oscar Nomination
Transcript
- Why YOU CAN SEE EVERYTHING Deserves a Best Picture: What's brilliant is this movie doesn't simply tell us we're living in an age of uncertainty. It makes us feel that uncertainty. What if I told you one of the best movies of 2026 is a documentary about a convicted con artist made by a comedian who's built his career on deception. And together, they've made a movie about something neither of them is particularly famous for the truth. And somehow, after nearly three hours, you leave the theater less certain about who you trust than when you walked in. That film is You Can See Everything. I saw it twice last week and it's still living rent-free in my head, and I think it deserves a Best Picture Oscar nomination. Yes, best picture for a documentary. And here's why we're having this conversation right now. Because according to Forbes, you can see everything just pulled in an estimated 19.5 million in its second week at the North American box office. That's bringing its total to more than 45 million. And here's what's remarkable: it actually made more money in the second weekend than its first. A nearly three-hour documentary about Elizabeth Holmes is becoming a box office phenomenon. And now it has the potential to make Oscar history. Because if you can see everything receives a best picture nomination, it would be the first documentary ever nominated in that category. And I don't think that possibility is nearly as wild as it sounds. Welcome to Culture Alchemy, I'm Antoinette. And before I go any further, don't worry, I am not gonna spoil this film because Part of the joy is genuinely not knowing where it's taking you. But I do need to tell you why I went back. Because the first time I saw it, it was in a packed evening screening. People were laughing and gasping, reacting out loud, and that's when it hit me. This is a movie you experience with other people. The room becomes part of the film. So I went back for matinee. Different crowd, different energy, different moments getting laughs. There were jokes that landed differently. There are moments where I caught myself. Watching the audience almost as closely as a screen. And for a documentary about the truth, that feels oddly appropriate. We can watch the same thing and all come away convinced we saw something different. Part of what makes this so fascinating is the creative collision behind it. You have Nathan Fielder, whose comedy often lives in that space between awkward reality and elaborate manipulation. Then there's Lance Oppenheim, a filmmaker who knows how to make real life look impossibly cinematic. Earlier this year, he explored our fascination with catching people in the act of deception through primetime, his film about Chris Hansen and the world of To Catch a Predator. So think about that for a second. Hansen built a television phenomenon around exposing people who are hiding their true intentions. Nathan Fielder has built a career around elaborate setups that blur reality and performance. And then Elizabeth Holmes became one of the most notorious figures in Silicon Valley because of the enormous gap between What she promised and what was actually true. There is a fascinating thread connecting all of them. It's our obsession with uncovering what people are hiding. And together, they're making a movie about Elizabeth Holmes, the former Silicon Valley darling who founded Theranos, a company that promised to revolutionize blood testing, with just a few drops of blood. Except, the technology didn't exactly work as promised. And so Holmes was eventually convicted of defrauding investors. This is a woman who persuaded. Some extraordinarily powerful and wealthy people to believe in her vision. And that, in and of itself, is fascinating. Because how did she do it? And maybe more importantly, why did so many people believe her? So here's what makes this premise so fascinating to me. You have two people who, in very different ways, are known for deception. Holmes persuaded investors to believe in a technology that couldn't deliver on its promises, and Fielder Has practically made an art form of blurring reality and performance and injecting cringe directly into our collective bloodstream. And now they're at the center of a movie, trying to get to an objective truth. I mean, the premise alone is really brilliant. I mean, who exactly are we supposed to trust? And what if we're not particularly reliable judge of the truth anyway? I mean, Fielder is a remarkable interviewer because he asked those questions that most of us would be too embarrassed to say out loud. He notices something strange. And instead of politely moving on, he stays there. He barks. He lets the awkwardness breathe. It's funny. It's unnerving. And it's often much more revealing than a conventional celebrity interview. So here's the question I kept coming back to What is subjective truth? We like to imagine that if we pay close enough attention, we'll spot the lie, we'll notice the inconsistency, the strange expression, the pause that lasts a little too long. Look at the show like The Traitors. Part of the fun is sitting at home watching these people try to figure out who's lying and who's Thinking, come on, how can you not see it? It's so obvious. We love believing we're good judges of character. We love believing we'd recognize a manipulator. But would we? Human beings are not lie detectors. We're meaning makers. We build stories out of tone, body language, and what we already believe. And the film keeps putting us in that uncomfortable position. You think you figured somebody out, and then you're not sure sure. It's like, not just with homes. Everybody, even Fielder. And then there's the relationship material. my god, the relationship material. There's a scene involving Elizabeth Holmes, her partner Billy, and some eggs. Fielder notices the way that Billy takes over the whisking and actually asks him about it. And I loved it because this is exactly the kind of tiny domestic interaction you could spend an entire session on packing in couples' therapy. Who takes charge? Who gives way? What does helping mean to one person and what does it feel like to the other? And that's what I really appreciated about this movie. Doesn't need to diagnose anybody or pretend it can know the private truth of a relationship. It just notices a detail, asks the question, and lets us sit with the possibilities. So sometimes the question is actually more interesting than the answer. There's also a sequence involving Abbott and Costello's famous Who's On First Comedy Routine that I I can't stop thinking about. It becomes a fascinating little experiment in language. How do we know when someone understands what we mean? What happens when two people use the same words but seem to be having completely different conversations? And at what point do we start wondering whether the misunderstanding is genuine or something else? Now, let me lay out the best picture argument because I'm not saying this movie is going to win Best Picture, but I'm definitely saying that it deserves to be nominated. It deserves to be in the conversation. And here's why. First, this is extraordinary filmmaking. It moves between documentary, dark comedy, and psychological thriller without ever feeling like it's checking off genres. The cinematography is gorgeous. The music creates this constant feeling that something is just slightly off. And then the editing knows exactly when to let a moment stretch past the point of comfort. Second, it does something I think the very best movies do. It changes the way you experience the world while you're watching it. You're not simply observing people trying to get to the truth. You're actively questioning your own ability to recognize it. And third, it captures something essential about the cultural moment we're living through. Our obsession with authenticity. Our fascination with deception and our growing uncertainty about what and whom we can believe. There are times that I actually forgot I was watching a documentary, not because it was fictional, but because it has the tension, the visual imagination, and sense of surprise that I want from great cinema. Full stop. And the fact that it works in a theater with a room full of people reacting together, that matters. In an era When so much of what we watch is designed to be consumed alone, half distracted on a phone, this movie demands your attention. That's not just a great documentary, that's great cinema. And if Best Picture is supposed to recognize the year's most accomplished, ambitious, and culturally significant filmmaking, I don't see why a documentary shouldn't be part of a conversation. And I genuinely cannot imagine a more appropriate film for 2026. we're living in a time of AI-generated images and deep fakes, curated identities, and people building entire public personas online. We have access to more information than ever before. You can see everything captures the collective heartbeat. It catches us wanting a neat answer, wanting a clear villain, wanting the person on screen to finally reveal who they really are. And what's brilliant is this movie doesn't simply tell us we're living in an age of uncertainty. It makes us feel That uncertainty. You can see everything deserves a best picture nomination because it captures something about the moment we're living in. Days later, I'm still thinking about it. For me, that's what great movies do. It doesn't always give you the answers. Sometimes it leaves you with better questions. And you can see everything might just be one of the best examples of that I've seen in years. So have you seen it? And if you have, I'm curious. Did you leave the theater feeling like you understood Elizabeth Holmes better? Or were you more confused than when you walked in? Let me know in the comments and subscribe for more pop culture psychology. And until next time, stay curious.