Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / NCUA Pivots on Overdraft Fees and America's Credit Unions Policy Priorities 2025
Transcript
- 0:00Hey everyone, this is Mark Treichel from the Governmental Affairs Conference . I
- 0:05spent yesterday over at GAC, also known as, and had a good time catching up
- 0:13with credit union folks from around the country, some current clients,
- 0:18some former clients, some trade association folks, some ex NCUA folks
- 0:23people still at NCUA, and it was great.
- 0:26To see everybody face to face and have some good conversations about what's
- 0:31going on in the industry right now.
- 0:33And I'm going to highlight a couple of things.
- 0:36I've got America's Credit Union's 2025 Priority policy priorities here.
- 0:42I want to mention a couple of those.
- 0:45One of the things that when I was at NCUA, I always participated in and or observed,
- 0:52depending on what position I was at NCUA at the time, was the NCUA board speeches.
- 0:59In this instance Kyle Hauptman had a roundtable.
- 1:02I did not attend that roundtable but I did.
- 1:06Get an opportunity to see his press release from this morning and or
- 1:11from yesterday's speech, and it relates to Hauptman's changes to
- 1:17NCOA's overdraft and NSF fee, non sufficient fund fee collection data.
- 1:23He had hinted, now that I connect the dots to this, he had hinted that
- 1:27changes were coming relative to some of the things outlined in NCOA's priority
- 1:32letter when he attended the front end of NCOA's webinar on NCOA's priority letter.
- 1:38And this is the big reveal.
- 1:42It's good.
- 1:42The short answer is it's good for what he's changing is.
- 1:47Good for billion dollar plus credit unions in that they're
- 1:50going to have to report less data.
- 1:52So here's the press release.
- 1:54It says to help ensure credit unions can continue to support the needs of
- 1:58Americans struggling with inflation, the NCUA will no longer publish
- 2:02overdraft and non sufficient fund fee income for individual credit unions.
- 2:07Chairman Kyle Hauptman announced today, the NCUA will collect the
- 2:11data during supervisory exams.
- 2:14So it won't be in the call reports.
- 2:16They will collect the data as part of the exams.
- 2:20There's a well intentioned movement aimed at protecting consumers from
- 2:23excessive fees, which is something we all support, Helpman said.
- 2:28However, we must also consider the unintended consequences of such policies.
- 2:33In this instance, the previous data collection policy incentivized credit
- 2:37unions to avoid serving the needs of low income and underserved communities.
- 2:42These fees can be the best option in a bad situation, saving money and
- 2:47protecting individuals credit scores.
- 2:50Overdrafts also protect people from much higher costs imposed
- 2:53by their local governments.
- 2:56Of course, that's the key argument for those on the side of saying that if
- 3:03you restrict fee income, you actually hurt the people who sometimes need to
- 3:08utilize services that trigger those fees.
- 3:11And I, that is the camp that I am in.
- 3:14I believe that this is a True statement of what Kyle Houtman is saying, the
- 3:19impact is here and while not reporting, not having billion dollar credit unions
- 3:26doesn't necessarily create a huge change, it's a pivot from a pure missions.
- 3:35Point of NC way, it's a pivot from just taking the attraction off it a little bit.
- 3:41Now, they say they're still going to collect it during the exams.
- 3:44And what they previously had said what they're going to do in the exams is
- 3:50that examiners will continue to review.
- 3:53credit unit overdraft programs, including policies, procedures, disclosures, fees,
- 3:58account statements, member complaints, internal reviews, and websites.
- 4:02Now, of course, NCUA will continue to do that, but they're going to have a smaller
- 4:06footprint because they have a hiring freeze because the Trump administration's
- 4:10offered to buy people out.
- 4:12I've heard some rumblings on how many people may be expecting that, or
- 4:16excuse me, that may be accepting that.
- 4:19And so we have all this turmoil in federal agencies right now meaning
- 4:25that everybody's going to have a little bit of a smaller footprint.
- 4:28So they're not collecting this data, they'll look at it during
- 4:32exams, but the exams are going to have a lesser footprint.
- 4:35I think that's.
- 4:36Net, a good thing, meaning that they're probably not going to be digging into
- 4:39this because they're more worried about safety and soundness aspects.
- 4:43And I will always die on that hill that this overdraft fee income is
- 4:47not a safety and soundness issue.
- 4:48And that's a hat tip to previous conversations where I disagreed with
- 4:53current board member Todd Harper back when he was chair saying that
- 4:58consumer compliance is always a.
- 5:01Safety and soundness risk, and I think that's a inaccurate way
- 5:05to approach consumer compliance.
- 5:07All right.
- 5:07The rest of the press release Chairman Hauptman discussed this policy during
- 5:12a fireside chat with Jim Nussel.
- 5:15President of America's Credit Unions at the 2025 Governmental Affairs Conference.
- 5:19By the way, I did attend Jim Nussel's opening speech, very passionate about
- 5:25the difference between credit unions and banks, very passionate about
- 5:29what importance there is at this G.
- 5:33A.
- 5:33C.
- 5:33To get out and carry the mantra of credit unions.
- 5:37And I'll get into a little bit of that here in a minute.
- 5:39So back to the press release under the previous data collection policy, the N.
- 5:43C.
- 5:43U.
- 5:43A.
- 5:43required federally insured credit unions with more than one billion
- 5:46in assets to disclose separately income from overdraft and N.
- 5:49S.
- 5:50F.
- 5:50Funding fees.
- 5:51This data was available to the public on an individual basis and in aggregate.
- 5:56Under the new policy, which goes into effect with the March 31, 2025,
- 6:01Call Report Cycle, the NCUA will collect overdraft and NSF fee data
- 6:06as part of the examination process.
- 6:09The Agency will continue to publish overdraft and NSF fee income data
- 6:13in the aggregate once updates to its exam system are complete.
- 6:17They need to change their exam system in order to collect this appropriately.
- 6:22And that's a truck, that's a loophole.
- 6:24You could drive a big truck through, meaning that not anytime soon will
- 6:28they report on it, but they will report on it when that's been fixed.
- 6:31With the attack on their budget, I don't think they're going to be spending a
- 6:35lot of money on their exam program.
- 6:38Just to fix this.
- 6:39So I think it'd be a big pause on reporting it even in the aggregate
- 6:45The press release goes on to say our regulatory framework should protect
- 6:49consumers from predatory Practices without depriving them of the financial
- 6:53tools they need to navigate their lives helpman said the appropriateness of
- 6:57overdrafts and NSF fee Fees charged is a matter between the credit union
- 7:03and its member owners who ultimately determine how their credit union is run.
- 7:07Amen to that?
- 7:09100 percent behind that quote.
- 7:11And I think it's a good change for credit unions and it's a good pivot for NCUA.
- 7:15Chairman Hauptman also discussed what he calls true financial inclusion, which
- 7:20means removing barriers to de novo credit unions and removing the pain points that
- 7:25have led to fewer smaller credit unions.
- 7:28I think it's great that NCUA It appears to be making it easier to
- 7:32charter credit unions, but the reality is that 90 percent pick a number 70
- 7:37percent 80 percent 90 percent of those new credit unions that are chartered
- 7:41failed within the 1st 10 years.
- 7:43That doesn't mean they shouldn't be chartering them.
- 7:46I think it's great.
- 7:47If they could charter, 190 percent of those failed at a
- 7:51small cost to the insurance fund, but those other 10 succeeded.
- 7:54I think good stories would come from that.
- 7:55Good service would come from that.
- 7:57And so I'm very supportive of that.
- 7:59Although I think it's more of a noble mission type goal that it really isn't
- 8:04going to have a whole lot of legs, despite the fact that there has been
- 8:07a slight increase in new charters.
- 8:10All right, the last sentence of this press release, the NQA must ensure our
- 8:15regulatory burden is not a factor in a credit union's decision to merge away.
- 8:19He said, once those credit unions are gone, rarely does anyone come to
- 8:23fill their space, fill their place.
- 8:26Relieving the regulatory burden on credit unions, especially the
- 8:30small and newly formed ones posing relatively low risk to the insurance
- 8:33fund is vital to keeping those credit unions thriving now in the future.
- 8:37Again, another noble goal.
- 8:39And I think they're the pivot away from new regulations, the pivot away
- 8:45from new letters to credit unions, I think is going to be real and
- 8:50there will be some relief in that.
- 8:53All right.
- 8:53So net, that's a good thing.
- 8:55And glad to see that he took this opportunity to announce this at GAC.
- 9:00In my hands, I have a, the talking points of America's credit
- 9:05unions, 2025 policy priorities.
- 9:08They break it into three categories, protect, empower,
- 9:12and advance under protect.
- 9:15They talk about preserving the credit union's tax status.
- 9:18If you saw on LinkedIn.
- 9:21I did about a 30 second silent video, other than the cars going by, of the
- 9:26ads outside the conference center.
- 9:29A very powerful ad, the way that they approached it.
- 9:32Kudos to America's Credit Unions for that signage outside of the, and
- 9:38inside and on the handout that I have.
- 9:41But it's a very powerful approach.
- 9:42I think they did a real good job of marketing on that.
- 9:46By the way the next item is address right-sized rules and junk fees.
- 9:51The Biden administration created the term junk fees and the Trump administration is
- 9:57going away from that and GAC and America's credit unions are embracing this.
- 10:02It goes on to say, so legitimate, disclosed and highly regulated fees
- 10:06charged by depository institutions are not unfairly lumped together
- 10:10with fees in other industries.
- 10:12And that's a great differentiating point as well.
- 10:16Stop the fraud liability shift and focus efforts on protecting consumers
- 10:21and credit unions from fraudulent transactions initiated by bad actors.
- 10:25Another noble goal.
- 10:28Item to focus on.
- 10:30This one caught my eye as well.
- 10:32Prevent unlimited NCUA authority by reining in the agency's
- 10:35unnecessary spending and efforts to expand supervisory powers.
- 10:40So under the Trump administration, under the Hauptman led board, I think that
- 10:45this Pretty much takes care of itself because of the spending side of things.
- 10:52The Trump administration is going to shrink the footprint of NC way,
- 10:55which will reduce the spending and the expanded supervisory
- 11:00powers again, under a Republican administration, they tend to let.
- 11:06be less restrictive as it relates to regulating credit unions and banks.
- 11:11Reform the CFPB structure to establish stability and increased oversight.
- 11:16That's a code word for it's only got one director That leads that organization
- 11:23and that it should be a board in my mind, similar to and see way or the FDIC.
- 11:30But we could see that rolled into treasury.
- 11:33We could see it rolled into the FDIC, depending on how that all goes.
- 11:38That which leads to their next item under protect, which is support an independent
- 11:43regulatory regime to ensure credit unions unique structure and commitment
- 11:46to serve their members and communities is recognized through tailored regulation.
- 11:52So this lot of chatter with most people I saw day 1 for me day 1, which is Monday.
- 12:01Of GAC there's discussions and past podcasts, recent podcasts, one with
- 12:06John McKechnie talked about the risk of Treasury taking over OCC, Treasury taking
- 12:12over FDIC, Treasury taking over CFPB, and Treasury taking over NCUA, and I like
- 12:20the words America's Credit Unions use here tailored regulations for different
- 12:24type of inst of institutions is A good thing everybody has their own niche, and
- 12:30by collapsing these all into one agency just because it might save 10 percent
- 12:35on a budget, I think is unwise, so I disagree with where the administration
- 12:39might be wanting to go here.
- 12:40I think it's very good.
- 12:42By the way, I heard record crowds at GAC this year.
- 12:45You hear that a lot but it's good to see that, because if more people keep showing
- 12:49up, if more people hike the hill, you will continually, get those folks over
- 12:54on Capitol Hill going, wow, these folks show up, they tell us what they want
- 12:59and we don't want them voting us out.
- 13:01So we better listen to credit unions.
- 13:03So that's to me, the best part about GAC and to see so many volunteers, so many
- 13:08CEOs, so many young folks in entering the credit union movement is very positive.
- 13:15Part of this event.
- 13:16All right.
- 13:17So empower strengthening the credit union difference by highlighting
- 13:20how as not for profit financial cooperatives owned by members.
- 13:24Credit unions are consumers best option for financial services.
- 13:28Never want to lose sight of that.
- 13:29And of course, 100 percent agree with that.
- 13:32Establish federal data protection standards, protect consumers and
- 13:36small business financial data and hold negligent actors accountable.
- 13:40Accountable with a single comprehensive national data
- 13:43security and privacy standard.
- 13:46Sounds easy.
- 13:47I don't think it is.
- 13:48I think it's a good idea.
- 13:49Ensure a fair regulatory environment so all financial providers operate
- 13:53under the same rules and that supervised credit unions are not
- 13:57subject to regulatory disadvantages compared to unregulated entities.
- 14:02So that gets into FinTechs not being regulated in my mind, and I think I
- 14:07think there should be some consistency, although When you talk about nuanced
- 14:12wanting to have separate agencies, you're on a slippery slope with that one when
- 14:16you have that broader conversation.
- 14:19Seek greater fraud prevention through tools to protect credit union members
- 14:23from fraud and hold accountable entities that enable and or commit fraud.
- 14:27Another great and noble goal here on.
- 14:32I almost said QNAS on America's Credit Unions GAC priorities.
- 14:38All right, advance, build credit union opportunities, expand access to credit
- 14:42unions, great, create greater lending options and flexibility, allow new
- 14:47investment options, support innovation and emerging technology, and support
- 14:52enhanced consumer access to housing.
- 14:55There's a little bit more detail than those sound bites I just
- 14:58read you there, but again, all of those are noble and good.
- 15:01Discussions on what the industry needs to advance to enhance the wonderful
- 15:07things that credit unions do for U.
- 15:09S.
- 15:10citizens.
- 15:11The other item that I came across based on some conversations after I came back and
- 15:16I was looking at it this morning there's some guidance out there from from OPM and
- 15:21OMB relative to agency reorganizations.
- 15:25And in taking a look at that the agencies, including N.
- 15:30C.
- 15:30U.
- 15:30A.
- 15:30have until March 13th to submit a phase 1 agency rift reduction in force
- 15:36and reorganization plans due to O.
- 15:39M.
- 15:40B.
- 15:40and O.
- 15:40M.
- 15:40B.
- 15:42phase 2 of a plan is due April 15th, and then they have monthly reporting
- 15:46in May, June, and July on progress reports, and then they have a target
- 15:52implementation date for phase two plans in September 30th of 2025.
- 15:58So no doubt the NCOA senior executives are busy putting together a plan
- 16:03that shows that they are taking the administration's desire to Decrease the
- 16:09footprint of federal agencies seriously.
- 16:13And, I've heard that NCA has had a decent amount of people take the Trump
- 16:20administration, eight month buyout plan.
- 16:23It's my understanding that just because somebody.
- 16:26put a request in doesn't mean that they will get it.
- 16:29So if someone was viewed as mission critical and said, Hey, I'd like to
- 16:33get paid to work the next eight months.
- 16:35And then I agree to leave at the end of the eight months, but they
- 16:37were viewed as, if this is my terminology, mission critical, they
- 16:41might not be allowed to do that.
- 16:43and others who might have positions that are more targeted.
- 16:47Let's say they're trying to reduce the footprint of exams or a particular
- 16:50specialist group or someone who has had mediocre appraisals.
- 16:56I could see those folks getting approved to be someone who
- 17:01departs under that Trump buyout.
- 17:04But in addition to that buyout, they're saying you need to put together a
- 17:09They're saying you, the agencies need to put together a reorganization plan.
- 17:14The OPM guidance goes on to say that the identification of competitive
- 17:18areas needs to be done by March 13th.
- 17:21Competitive areas has to do with how the RIF Will actually work in practice
- 17:27and there are strategies that agents without getting into great details,
- 17:31you can make a riff area big or you can make it small and how you do that
- 17:37will determine the bumping rights that.
- 17:40People will have, and just thinking out loud and dusting off some of the
- 17:45cobwebs in my brain on this, the more competitive areas you have the harder it
- 17:50is to have a exhaustive bumping rights.
- 17:54And the bumping rights and riffs are important in what they protect.
- 17:57But it also means that sometimes when you try and put a riff in place, it just
- 18:01doesn't make sense to do so because the only thing that happens is everybody
- 18:04cascades down all the people stay.
- 18:08That are at a higher level.
- 18:09So let's say a regional director job was to go away and they bumped
- 18:14down to the lower level below that they would keep their pay.
- 18:17And then they would bump that person who would go down and bump their pay.
- 18:20So you end up having the higher people stay and riffs tend to be generally
- 18:26useless in federal government, but they need to put a plan together.
- 18:29But where it gets more interesting is that they're being encouraged to offer.
- 18:33early retirement, which is also known as VERA, V E R A.
- 18:38They're supposed to do planning and preparation relative to VERA.
- 18:43They're supposed to conduct impact assessments.
- 18:45They're supposed to review position descriptions, et cetera, et cetera.
- 18:49Then they're supposed to have a formal, a RIF notice period, which is 30 to 60
- 18:54days for people to make their decisions.
- 18:55Then they're supposed to do a RIF implementation.
- 18:59And what agencies can do, they can go to OPM and OMB to get approval
- 19:05to offer VERA and to get approval to offer what's called a VSIP, which is a
- 19:11voluntary separation incentive payment, and that allows Financial incentive,
- 19:18incentives, which are typically up to 25, 000 to employees to encourage them
- 19:23to retire or resign early, or if even if they are eligible, it can be offered.
- 19:30So there's no doubt all agencies are taking a look at this, working on
- 19:35getting their plans in and you get into this game where you want to show
- 19:40that you're responsive so that you don't, have the wrath of OMB or OPM
- 19:44or the White House turn your way.
- 19:47But if you think about it, the pressure points are the industry
- 19:51doesn't want to be taxed.
- 19:52The pressure points are NCOA doesn't want to be merged away.
- 19:56Credit unions don't want NCOA to be merged away.
- 19:59So there is a would, in my opinion, that NCOA would be a general inclination to
- 20:04say, okay, what can we do to Take action.
- 20:09So as we live to fight another day, and if you just look at, by the way,
- 20:14doge dot gov has a listing of N.
- 20:17C.
- 20:17U.
- 20:17A.
- 20:17And other agencies salaries, and they cut it based on age.
- 20:21They cut it based on averages in certain categories, but they point out that N.
- 20:26C.
- 20:27U.
- 20:27A.
- 20:27Has 1230 F.
- 20:29T.
- 20:29E.
- 20:29S.
- 20:29Full time equivalents.
- 20:32If you just look at that number, If NCUA is trying to
- 20:35get down 10%, that's 123 bodies.
- 20:39If they're trying to get down 20%, that's 246 bodies.
- 20:45They have 1, 230, so in order to get down 20%, they need to
- 20:50fall below 1, 000 employees.
- 20:54Could that be something that they say that's a good soundbite, where we
- 20:58went from over 1, 000 to under 1, 000?
- 21:01Theoretically possible.
- 21:0320 percent is a pretty deep cut and there would be ramifications of the exam.
- 21:07There would be a ramification in morale.
- 21:11The last NCUA board meeting was all about staff morale.
- 21:14When I look at this OPM guidance that's out there and think about what's going on
- 21:18at the agency and every agency to respond to it It has a chilling effect on staff.
- 21:23When we're talking about pivoting back to, to Houtman saying, we'll look at this
- 21:28during your exam, they're going to have 5, percent pick a number, less people
- 21:34doing exams which means that they're going to be going into less detail.
- 21:38In some instances, that'll be good for credit unions in
- 21:41that they'll just have to not.
- 21:43Asked so many questions.
- 21:44In other instances, when you're trying to negotiate, when NCUA is saying you
- 21:47need a document resolution, you need an examiner finding, you have an issue here.
- 21:52NCUA's going to be so worried about getting to their next exam, they
- 21:56might not be negotiating as in as good of faith as you need them to
- 22:01so that you get a fair examination.
- 22:04All right.
- 22:04I'm losing my voice because I had a lot of conversations yesterday.
- 22:07I'm about to head over for my day two, which is Tuesday.
- 22:11If you're there and you want to chat, let me know if you
- 22:14are there and want to say hi.
- 22:18Come on up to me and let's chat about what's going on at GAC, what's
- 22:21going on at your credit union.
- 22:22I really enjoyed seeing the folks I saw yesterday.
- 22:26Looking forward to seeing some folks today and meeting some new folks as well.
- 22:32All right.
- 22:32That's it.
- 22:32Mark Treichel signing off with flying colors.