Chapter 18: We Wanted A Witch, Bro | The Witch Review

Fictionally Unstable Podcast · Nov 10, 2026 · 46m

Today on Fictionally Unstable, we review Freida McFadden's latest novel: The Witch. With a cover like that, we had high hopes that this story would give us some supernatural feels for the end of spooky season. Unfortunately, we were robbed of our witchy fantasy. But compared to some of the more recent McFaddens we've read, this was definitely a step in the right direction.

Let us know how this novel stacked up against the rest of the Freida-verse and if you'll be tuning in for her next novel, The Sleepwalker, in just a few months!