Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / 2026 Annuities: Why Young Savers Should Say No?
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Deep Dive. Today we're tackling a product
- 0:03that lives right at that intersection of, well, powerful
- 0:07salesmanship and almost impenetrable complexity.
- 0:11The annuity. Oh yes.
- 0:13If you've ever even looked into buying 1, you know the pitch is
- 0:16compelling. Guaranteed income for life.
- 0:19But then you see the contract and it.
- 0:21Reads like a financial puzzle. It almost feels deliberately
- 0:23designed to hide the costs and, you know, the real consequences.
- 0:27Exactly. Annuities are, I think, easily
- 0:29one of the most misunderstood instruments in retirement
- 0:32planning. So our goal today is to cut
- 0:34through all of that complexity. We're going to dissect the
- 0:37contracts, the layered costs, and most importantly, figure out
- 0:41if this is even a suitable tool for you, the young working
- 0:45professional in the accumulation phase of your career.
- 0:48We're going to expose the fine print.
- 0:49That's the plan. And to do that, we've stacked up
- 0:52an expert analysis. It details everything from the
- 0:55basic contract structure to 4 tangible case studies that put
- 0:59real dollar figures on all the trade-offs.
- 1:01It's the shortcut you need to really understand this thing.
- 1:04OK, let's unpack this. And before we jump in, we just
- 1:07need to acknowledge a couple of important points.
- 1:10All of the analysis we present is strictly based on publicly
- 1:13available sources. It's for educational purposes
- 1:16only. This is not investment advice,
- 1:18so please conduct your own due diligence.
- 1:21Absolutely. And while we're on the topic of
- 1:23due diligence and you know, having context, understanding
- 1:27the market temperature is really key to any long term savings
- 1:30decision. We actually recommend checking
- 1:32out the iOS app Buffett Indicator on the Apple App
- 1:35Store. It's a great little tool that
- 1:37helps you track the total market climate.
- 1:39It's a useful data point for sure.
- 1:41So let's strip away all the marketing material.
- 1:44When you buy an annuity, what are we actually talking about?
- 1:47What is the simple foundational definition an?
- 1:49Annuity is fundamentally a contract.
- 1:51It's a contract between you, the annuitant, and an insurance
- 1:54company. OK, you pay the company money,
- 1:56either a lump sum or, you know, periodic premiums, and they in
- 2:00turn contractually promise to give you a regular stream of
- 2:03income later, typically for the rest of your life.
- 2:05So it's not life insurance and it's definitely not a savings
- 2:08account or ACD. What really sets it apart?
- 2:11It's unique. Its primary function is
- 2:14systematic liquidation and distribution liquidation.
- 2:17Exactly. It's not designed to grow your
- 2:19capital forever. It's designed to turn a pile of
- 2:22capital into a guaranteed paycheck.
- 2:24And this gets us right to the moment, right?
- 2:27The core value, because in retirement we basically face two
- 2:31big threats to our money. There's investment risk.
- 2:34Meaning the market drops and you lose your principal.
- 2:37And then there's longevity risk. Longevity risk is the big one.
- 2:40It's the risk of living too long and outliving your savings, and
- 2:45the annuities central function is to transfer that specific
- 2:49risk. Transfer to the insurance
- 2:50company. Precisely when you annuitize,
- 2:52you hand over a sum of principle and the insurance company takes
- 2:56on that obligation. They now bear the risk that you
- 2:58might live to be 110. They ensure that your
- 3:00contractual income stream just never ceases.
- 3:03You're paying for certainty. So you're exchanging control and
- 3:06liquidity for an ironclad guarantee?
- 3:09That's the trait, and it's achieved over 2 distinct phases.
- 3:12First you have the accumulation phase.
- 3:14That's for the money you put in grows tax deferred, you're just
- 3:17saving up. Second is the annuitization
- 3:20phase or the payout phase, and this is a critical point.
- 3:23It's an irrevocable decision where you trade that accumulated
- 3:27capital for the guaranteed lifetime income stream.
- 3:30Irrevocable. That's a big word.
- 3:32It is. Once you flip that switch,
- 3:33there's no going back. OK, so let's start classifying
- 3:36these things. It seems like there are a few
- 3:38different types. Right.
- 3:39We need to classify them in two ways.
- 3:41First, by timing, we have the immediate annuity or SBIA with a
- 3:46SPIA payment start almost right away, within a year.
- 3:50It's simple, and it's really only for someone who is already
- 3:53at retirement and wants to turn a lump sum into an immediate
- 3:55paycheck. But for you listening, the long
- 3:58term saver, we're almost always talking about the other kind,
- 4:01the deferred annuity. That's where the payout is
- 4:02delayed, right, To allow for years, maybe decades of tax
- 4:07deferred growth? Exactly.
- 4:10And now we dive into the most complex part, how they're
- 4:14classified by the growth mechanism.
- 4:17This tells you exactly where your money is invested and,
- 4:21crucially, who is bearing the investment risk.
- 4:23OK. And this is where it gets really
- 4:25interesting because I feel like the complexity is where the risk
- 4:29can subtly shift back to you, the investor, even when the
- 4:33product is advertised as safe. That's the perfect way to put
- 4:36it. The simplest structure is the
- 4:38fixed annuity. This is the conservative option.
- 4:40The insurer just sets a guaranteed interest rate and
- 4:43they bear all the risk. It's very low risk, but your
- 4:45growth potential is also, you know, quite low, similar to a
- 4:48high yield CD all. Right.
- 4:49So moving up that risk spectrum, we hit the variable annuity.
- 4:52Yes, and this is essentially an investment wrapper.
- 4:56Your money is placed into something called sub accounts,
- 4:58which for all intents and purposes function just like
- 5:00mutual funds. So in a variable annuity you
- 5:03bear the risk. You bear 100% of the investment
- 5:05risk. The account value fluctuates
- 5:07directly with the market. If those sub accounts perform
- 5:10poorly, you absolutely can and will lose principal.
- 5:14And finally, the beast, the indexed annuity.
- 5:18The complex hybrid. These are marketed so heavily,
- 5:21the idea is that the returns are linked to an index like the S&P
- 5:25500, but your money isn't actually invested in the index.
- 5:28Right. And the primary marketing law
- 5:30here, which our source material really confirms is the zero
- 5:33floor. The zero floor if.
- 5:35The S&P 500 drops, say, 30%. Your principal is protected.
- 5:39The floor is typically 0% and that sounds like a really
- 5:43powerful hedge against a market crash.
- 5:45But that safety is not free. You pay for it by giving up
- 5:48almost all of the markets upside.
- 5:50The investor you you never get the full market gain and this is
- 5:53engineered through the subtle mechanisms that are so easy to
- 5:56miss. Exactly.
- 5:57The first one is the cap rate. So if the S and T500 returns 9%
- 6:01in a great year, but your annuity has a 6% cap, you only
- 6:05get 6%. And that 3% difference just goes
- 6:07to the insurer. That's their profit for
- 6:09protecting your principal. The second mechanism is the
- 6:12participation rate. If the market gains 10% and your
- 6:16participation rate is set at, say, 75%, you only receive a 7
- 6:201/2% credit. The insurer keeps the other 2
- 6:231/2 percent. So you're sacrificing returns on
- 6:26the way up to protect yourself on the way down, every single
- 6:29time. Every time.
- 6:30And here is the really critical detail.
- 6:32And it's almost always buried deep in the contract.
- 6:36The performance calculation for an indexed annuity almost always
- 6:40excludes dividends. Wow.
- 6:42Since dividends historically contribute such a huge portion
- 6:45of the total return of major indexes, that omission creates a
- 6:49performance drag from the very beginning.
- 6:51It basically guarantees you will lag a simple index fund
- 6:54investment over time. OK.
- 6:55Let's talk about the sales pitch then, the advantages that make
- 6:58people consider these things in the first place.
- 7:00Well, the three main advantages are pretty clear.
- 7:02First, the guaranteed lifetime income.
- 7:05That's the feature you can't really replicate anywhere else.
- 7:08Your own personal pension. Sort of.
- 7:09Second is tax deferred growth. Your compounding is friction
- 7:13free until you take it out. And third, they have no IRS
- 7:17contribution limits. So if you're a high income
- 7:19earner and you've already maxed out your 4O1K and your IRA, this
- 7:23can serve as a third pillar for really large deferred savings.
- 7:27Got it. Now for the downsides, which for
- 7:29most young accumulators probably outweigh those benefits.
- 7:33And the first major hurdle is crippling illiquidity.
- 7:37Annuities are deliberately illiquid.
- 7:39They enforce this through really steep surrender charges if you
- 7:42try to withdraw money early. How steep are we talking?
- 7:45Well, the surrender periods usually run 6 to 10 years and
- 7:48the initial penalties can be as high as 9%.
- 7:51This money is locked away. And on top of that, if you
- 7:53access the earnings before age 59 1/2, the IRS slaps on a 10%
- 7:58penalty on top of the surrender charges, right?
- 8:00It is financially dangerous to tie up money that you might need
- 8:03in the near future. OK, what's next?
- 8:05Then there is the issue of high layered fees, especially in the
- 8:08variable products and we need to define the big one, the
- 8:12mortality and expense charge or the M&E charge.
- 8:16These are annual fees, often 1.25 to 1.5% of your account
- 8:20value paid to the insurer every year.
- 8:23Wait. Why are you paying 1 1/2%
- 8:25annually just in M&E? What?
- 8:27What is that for? You're paying for the core
- 8:30insurance guarantees, primarily the mortality guarantee, the
- 8:34promise of that lifelong payout. Plus you pay administrative
- 8:37costs, underlying sub account fees, and then if you buy any
- 8:41optional guarantees, you pay hefty annual rider fees on top
- 8:44of all of that. This constant fee drag is one of
- 8:47the biggest reasons they so often underperform.
- 8:50But the single most critical disadvantage, the one that can
- 8:52really sabotage long term growth, is the tax deferral
- 8:56trap. This is the most critical take
- 8:58away. It sounds like it negates a lot
- 8:59of the supposed benefit for a younger investor.
- 9:02It can. So think about it this way.
- 9:04If you invest in low cost index funds in a standard taxable
- 9:07brokerage account, you pay taxes on the gains at the end.
- 9:11Those long term gains are currently taxed at the
- 9:13preferential long term capital gains rate.
- 9:15For most people, that's 15 or maybe 20%.
- 9:18OK. A lower rate, but the annuity is
- 9:21different because it's an insurance wrapper.
- 9:23When you finally pull out that deferred growth, all of it.
- 9:27All of it is taxed as ordinary income, which means your gains
- 9:31could be taxed at 24 percent, 32% or even higher, depending on
- 9:34your tax bracket and retirement. The math is simple.
- 9:39For the annuity to win, the benefit of compounding tax free
- 9:42has to be enormous. Enormous enough to overcome that
- 9:45much higher tax rate on the back end.
- 9:46Exactly. And for many savers, especially
- 9:49those who start young, the ordinary income taxation makes
- 9:52the annuity a less tax efficient choice than just a simple
- 9:56brokerage account, despite the deferral.
- 9:58Let's put some real numbers on that.
- 9:59Using the case studies from the source material, we're comparing
- 10:02outcomes based on $100,000 lump sum.
- 10:05OK, look at case one. A 65 year old male buys an
- 10:08immediate fixed annuity income starts now that pays
- 10:12approximately $652 per month for life.
- 10:15That's the baseline, the pure cost of buying longevity risk
- 10:18transfer now. Compare that to case 2, which
- 10:21shows the power of time. A50 year old buys that same
- 10:24$100,000 annuity but waits 15 years, starting payments at 65
- 10:29and the payout jumps significantly.
- 10:32It's paying between 12107 dollars and $14139 a month.
- 10:36It more than double S the income time and deferral matter hugely
- 10:40here, OK. But look at the cost of the
- 10:42safety net. Case 3 involves a 65 year old
- 10:45buying a variable annuity but with a guaranteed lifetime
- 10:48withdrawal benefit Rider, the GLWB.
- 10:52Right. So this rider guarantees a
- 10:53minimum stream of income no matter how the market performs.
- 10:56But that guaranteed minimum payout is only about $458 a
- 11:00month. Wait a minute.
- 11:01That's way less than the 652 from the Simple No Frills Fixed
- 11:05annuity. It's a huge difference, and it
- 11:08perfectly illustrates the high cost of that GLWB writer and the
- 11:11ongoing M&E charges. You are paying significant
- 11:15annual fees for the potential of market upside, but the safety
- 11:18net you are actually guaranteed is substantially smaller than
- 11:22what you could have just bought with a simple fixed product.
- 11:25The cost of complexity is massive.
- 11:28So after this deep dissection of mechanics, fees, tax traps, what
- 11:32is the final verdict? Is this suitable for you, the 35
- 11:35year old working professional whose main goal is just wealth
- 11:37accumulation? The verdict is unequivocally
- 11:41clear. Annuities are not suitable or
- 11:43financially efficient for a 35 year old in the accumulation
- 11:46phase. A hard no.
- 11:47A hard no Your longtime horizon demands liquidity and maximum
- 11:50growth potential, neither of which a high cost illiquid
- 11:53deferred annuity provides. So we have to review the
- 11:56retirement savings hierarchy. If we have decades to invest,
- 11:59where does the money go first? Always, always start with the
- 12:02401K match. It's free money.
- 12:04Then you maximize your IRA, whether it's Roth or
- 12:07traditional. Then you go back and you
- 12:08maximize the rest of your 4O1K. Those vehicles offer the exact
- 12:12same tax deferral as the annuity, but with lower fees,
- 12:15better liquidity, and in the case of a Roth, completely tax
- 12:19free withdrawals. And this brings us to what you
- 12:21call the redundant annuity error, which is a mistake we see
- 12:24way too often. This happens when an investor,
- 12:27usually misled by a sales pitch, buys an annuity inside an
- 12:31already tax advantage account like an IRA.
- 12:34In an IRA. Exactly.
- 12:35The IRA already gives you the tax deferral for free.
- 12:38By layering an annuity inside it, you are simply paying those
- 12:42high M&E fees, that 1 1/2 percent a year for a tax benefit
- 12:46you already have. It is financially irrational.
- 12:48It just guarantees A substantial long term reduction in your
- 12:51wealth. So the immediate strategy is
- 12:52simple. Low cost index funds inside your
- 12:55qualified accounts. The time to even have this
- 12:57conversation is not now. The correct time to consider an
- 13:00annuity is much later when you reach, say, age 60 or 65 and
- 13:06you're ready to transition from accumulation to distribution.
- 13:09At that point, a simple low cost immediate fixed annuity might be
- 13:14appropriate for a small fraction of your portfolio.
- 13:16For what purpose specifically? Specifically for income flooring
- 13:20covering your essential non negotiable monthly expenses like
- 13:23housing, food, utilities. So what does this all mean?
- 13:27The annuity is a specialized tool designed to solve a very
- 13:31specific problem, launch risk. But for the young accumulator,
- 13:34it's high costs, crippling A liquidity and that unfavorable
- 13:38tax treatment make it a vastly inferior choice.
- 13:41Absolutely, and here's a provocative thought for you to
- 13:44explore as you continue on your savings journey.
- 13:46Considering the higher tax rate imposed on annuity gains is a
- 13:50standard taxable brokerage account which offers you
- 13:52superior liquidity, lower fees and the benefit of lower long
- 13:56term capital gains tax rates, is that actually a more efficient
- 13:59vehicle for building wealth during your prime earning years
- 14:02than on a high cost of furred annuity?
- 14:04Think about that critical trade off deferral versus the final
- 14:07tax rate. It's a really important
- 14:09calculation to make. To track total market
- 14:11temperature. Welcome to Search and download
- 14:13iOS App Buffett Indicator from Apple App Store.
- 14:17Remember, this analysis is based on publicly available sources
- 14:20and is strictly for educational purposes only.
- 14:23It does not constitute investment advice.
- 14:26Conduct your own due diligence before making investment
- 14:29decisions. If you want to listen to our
- 14:31full deep dive about this topic or access more advanced
- 14:34contents, welcome to join Deep Value Club membership or
- 14:38subscribe us on Apple Spotify Podcasts channel Deep Value
- 14:42Investing. Apple Store stron John Don Don
- 14:50Tango we Apple stored.