Latest / Newcomer Pod / The Musk Bubble in Tech Is Going to Pop (w/Alex Stamos)
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome, silicon salad. Hello everybody.
- 0:13Welcome to Dead cat Tom dote on from Insider joined by Eric
- 0:17newcomer newcomer thanks for joining us in the chat today so
- 0:20today we're going to do it. We're going to talk about
- 0:23Twitter content moderation and the internal documents released
- 0:26by Elon Musk maybe is the only reason he bought Twitter, it's
- 0:29not Clear. So we're going to talk about how
- 0:32content moderation is done, and we're going to like it.
- 0:35So joining us to talk us through.
- 0:36This is Alex Stamos for mercy. So at Facebook, he is also the
- 0:40director of the Stanford internet Observatory.
- 0:44And he is now, apparently, an Elon Musk Nemesis where he runs
- 0:47a propaganda platform so says Ilan.
- 0:50But first of all, Alex, welcome back to dead cat.
- 0:52Thank you so much for joining us to talk about all this.
- 0:54Thanks for having me guys. Returning, guest always loved
- 0:57it. Yeah.
- 0:58Okay. So we're going to need a jacket.
- 0:59How many? I have to do this before, I get
- 1:01that the Masters jacket, you're behind Aaron Griffith.
- 1:04And who else is? Like attack petty shit like
- 1:05that. Yeah, so whoever gets the five
- 1:07first definitely get some swag. So we're going to do this, we're
- 1:10going to do it in good faith and I'm even, I'm even going to call
- 1:13it the Twitter files which is what Elon wants us to call it.
- 1:16So basically, let me just summarize what has happened.
- 1:18So far there have been two stories.
- 1:21All of which have been posted on Twitter, which as a side point,
- 1:24I think is really lame as a journalist, these stories exist
- 1:26entirely on Twitter, and it's all because Elon is controlling
- 1:29these documents. And I think, as part of his, you
- 1:31know. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:33With internal agreed to publish them, on Twitter.
- 1:35Yeah, but these are good journalist independent
- 1:37journalists who have done it but I think that particular
- 1:39concession is lame. But anyway, here are the two
- 1:42tweet storms that have come out so far.
- 1:44The first one is from Matt, Taibbi, who is a sub stacker
- 1:47and, you know, long time investigative journalist and
- 1:50he's writing about Hunter Biden and in the tweets and, you know,
- 1:54from the internal documents, he showed the internal
- 1:56deliberations around, pulling down the content that came from
- 1:59Hunter. Laptop that were initially leaks
- 2:02in your post via Rudy Giuliani. Some of this word deliberations,
- 2:06insights, Witter, about the decision to block all the links
- 2:09from the New York Post, which was a pretty big deal at the
- 2:12time. And I still think kind of crazy
- 2:15and some of it was just about pulling down pictures of Hunter,
- 2:17Biden stick. So that's why we didn't make
- 2:20that clear, but yeah, yeah. So so part one was all about
- 2:23Hunter Biden and that whole story that turned out not to
- 2:26push the election towards Trump and in the second one, which
- 2:29came out yesterday. Day or last week, when you guys
- 2:31all hear this, that one is from Barry Weiss also at sub stack
- 2:35and she's dealing with the topic of Shadow Banning which is a
- 2:38basically the curtailing of the reach of certain users and her
- 2:42tweets. She showed that Twitter had
- 2:44flagged and D boosted certain accounts like Dan, bungee know a
- 2:48bunch, I know. And once you know that guy a
- 2:51Stanford Professor, Jay about a Chara none of us know which
- 2:55speaks where it's your bar. I just don't spend enough time
- 2:58on Facebook to get the full bunch.
- 3:00No, George. I know, it's so.
- 3:02So then they're also a Stanford, Professor Jay bhattacharya.
- 3:05Who had some anti lock down content.
- 3:07It appeared that he had also been D boosted in certain ways
- 3:10and then there is high righteous akka lives of tick tock and it
- 3:14showed that all of these accounts have been flagged and
- 3:16in some way, kind of D distributed in a way that they
- 3:20had been expecting removed from trending topics and search.
- 3:24And then also in Barry's tweets, there were internal debates
- 3:28about the use of spam enforcement policies.
- 3:30As a trust and safety cudgel. And there's also this question
- 3:33about whether Twitter was being genuine in.
- 3:36Its previous claims that, it did not Shadow ban people, which
- 3:39then of course, gets into very exciting semantics of what
- 3:42shadow Banning means. All right.
- 3:44So we want to bend over backwards, to be fair to these
- 3:48people. I think that's all all our
- 3:49inclination, Alex. I've seen you trying to steal,
- 3:51man. The argument of these tweets
- 3:53storms, is there a piece out of it that you would say, is the
- 3:57best critique or The most substantive piece to come out of
- 4:03these to tweet storms in your view.
- 4:06So I feel like the first tweet storm, the tabi one which
- 4:10focused on specifically the hunter Biden situation has a
- 4:15kernel of Truth in the recognition that there is a
- 4:17problem with government and political interference on these
- 4:22big platforms. The truth is, when you work at
- 4:24Wendy's companies, everybody is constantly trying to work the
- 4:27rafts to get you to change their content.
- 4:29Moderation, Strategies in a way, they like, everybody wants their
- 4:32enemies taken down. And everybody wants their
- 4:35political friends, and fellow travelers to stay up, no matter
- 4:39what they do. And so that is a problem that
- 4:42companies are always dealing with, and it is true that if you
- 4:45have a officials in the US, government pushing for content
- 4:49to be taken down, then that would be in the United States.
- 4:52Possibly a First Amendment violation in the specific
- 4:56hundred biting case. There's absolutely no evidence
- 4:59in his threat. That anybody who is a actual
- 5:02employee of the US government and therefore covered by the
- 5:04First Amendment did anything. The one example was the Biden
- 5:08team that they could find saying, take down these nude
- 5:11pictures of Hunter, they didn't even say anything about the New
- 5:14York Post story itself was subsequent tweets that had
- 5:18specific nude videos and photos, which Twitter has a policy that
- 5:22you cannot put naked photos up on somebody without their
- 5:24permission. We call this ncii in the
- 5:27industry non-consensual intimate imagery but your Especially
- 5:30revenge porn, right? Revenge porn is like the term
- 5:33that people use. We try not to use in the
- 5:35industry because it Revenge implies that the victim did
- 5:37something wrong. The majority of the time it is
- 5:39not the 40 year old son of a presidential candidate.
- 5:42It is a 19 year old girl who ran whose boyfriend did something
- 5:46bad, right? So like we try not to use
- 5:47revenge porn because the median victim here is absolutely
- 5:50innocent of doing anything. And in terms of the government,
- 5:53meddling to take something down. A lot of people forgot that
- 5:57Trump was in the White House. When The Biden team was asking
- 6:01us to these. There were people just saying
- 6:03the Biden Administration, when it's like the Trump
- 6:06Administration was in office. So there isn't even a question
- 6:10there of whether, you know, the right people within Biden world
- 6:13were making this question or not.
- 6:15There were no idea was unemployed history of time,
- 6:18right? The DMC is not a government
- 6:20actor. There's no First Amendment
- 6:21analysis. That covers the dnc's actions
- 6:25and tidy, admits that, he could not find any evidence of the
- 6:30Kermit being involved and then also hints towards that.
- 6:32There were emails from the Trump Administration which actually
- 6:36could be a First Amendment violation.
- 6:37We want does not address any of those up, right?
- 6:39So if we want to steal me on this, if we wanted opposite
- 6:42strawman, if we want to take it seriously, government
- 6:44interference and platforms is a real deal.
- 6:47But Taibbi, one did not show that and to specifically ignore
- 6:51the possibility of actual government interference and musk
- 6:55giving very selective data to a couple of very Medically biased
- 7:01journalists is not the kind of transparency, we would need if
- 7:03we want to be confident that there was not interference on
- 7:07this platform by government. All right, so tweet storm one,
- 7:10pretty weak. I think that's sort of its weak,
- 7:13but there's a fundamental, I think there is a real kernel of
- 7:16Truth there. And from my perspective, the
- 7:18kernel of Truth, is that every government on the planet
- 7:21including ours, in the United States of America, is trying to
- 7:23manipulate Twitter and all of the other major platforms.
- 7:26And so, I proposed here things you can do, if your musk, you
- 7:29could have an open Open database of moderation decisions.
- 7:31There are some interesting, Privacy Law issues there, but
- 7:34you can work around those. You can commit to releasing you
- 7:38instead of just releasing emails from the Biden and team, the DNC
- 7:42not government actors. You can release all
- 7:44Communications, from all government actors globally.
- 7:47So the Modi campaign, the Indian government, I think really
- 7:51important for somebody whose net worth is tied up in China, like
- 7:55musk Communications, with the Chinese Communist party is the
- 7:58kind of thing that if Really cared about this, you could
- 8:01release but musk apparently doesn't like that idea, right?
- 8:04We want to talk about that more. Certainly, what?
- 8:06We still on this topic, what you're saying is maybe the most
- 8:08legitimate criticism or insightful Revelation from the
- 8:12Taibbi thread. When you were at Facebook and
- 8:15you were probably in the middle of a lot of these discussions,
- 8:17generally, do you think internet platforms handle it?
- 8:19Well, we have the internal discussions or at least some of
- 8:22the internal discussions around what was happening around Hunter
- 8:25Biden. It all seems fairly chaotic.
- 8:27It feels a little bit arbitrary. And you know, there is A certain
- 8:30amount of well I guess within the arbitrariness people's
- 8:33inherent biases and maybe what they would prefer to see happen
- 8:36if they are you know donors to the Democratic party or
- 8:39whatever, informing some of their decisions.
- 8:41So like generally how good of an actor do you think the platforms
- 8:44are in these situations and is there anything from the Twitter
- 8:47specifically that you thought that kind of stock a little bit?
- 8:51So in this specific situation and parallel Facebook made a
- 8:55lesser mistake, but I think Twitter and Facebook did make a
- 8:58mistake here and that They took on responsibility for something
- 9:02that should not be their responsibility.
- 9:04If we go back to 2016, they're two totally different propaganda
- 9:08campaigns by Russia and Russian Affiliated groups against the
- 9:12campaign. There is the campaign on the
- 9:15platforms which was mostly private actors in Russia,
- 9:18internet research, agency and other firms owned by.
- 9:21You've any provision mostly in which they were trolling on the
- 9:24platforms that I think is absolutely responsibility.
- 9:28The company's Facebook and Twitter should not allow a
- 9:30handful of people in a building st.
- 9:32Petersburg to run a thousand accounts that pretend to be Real
- 9:35Americans and get hundreds of millions of views that should
- 9:38not be allowed, but it was relatively small next.
- 9:42The next one you're going to say, right, but that was a
- 9:44relatively small impact, I think versus the hacken Lee Campaign
- 9:47which was actually the government itself, Gru Russian,
- 9:50military intelligence break into DNC breaking to jump addresses,
- 9:53email, bunch of other people's email and then leaked
- 9:56information to change the overall media environment.
- 9:59Now, Target of that. While there are online
- 10:01components here. The target of that is the US
- 10:04media and in the reaction to 2016 and with all the pressure,
- 10:08as you know, we have all discussed about.
- 10:11This was the tickets go back. And listen, we dug into this.
- 10:14Yeah. Well, we dug into this.
- 10:16I think it's a little unfair to completely blame social media
- 10:18companies for Trump, but that is effectively.
- 10:21I think the feeling that the company's was the entire Center
- 10:24left media, and I think that there is a kernel of Truth in
- 10:27all of this criticism of that is That we kind of the New York
- 10:30Times consensus is Facebook created Trump and if you push
- 10:34companies that they are responsible for something like
- 10:35that, then maybe they'll take on responsibility, did it.
- 10:38And I do think the company should not have taken on
- 10:40responsibility for that second class that hacking leak because
- 10:43basically everybody else primed from the last election, we're
- 10:48sort of late-breaking information, helped tilt things
- 10:52for Trump and social media. Companies have been blamed for
- 10:57fueling pro-trump message. So then we get towards The end
- 11:01of the second Trump election and all of a sudden we have this New
- 11:04York Post story about Divine laptop.
- 11:06It might be hacking. Leaked material.
- 11:09And so Twitter, decides, I think we all think that's wrong now
- 11:13but Twitter, decides for reasons that we can all understand to
- 11:17try and block the story. Now, the story still rent,
- 11:20plenty wide. It went wider, right?
- 11:22There's a massive Streisand effect here, right?
- 11:24Where? Because of Twitter's action, and
- 11:26to be fair, Facebook also did a thing where they Kind of down
- 11:30rigged to a little bit. So it didn't show up and
- 11:32recommendations and such until is fact checked and then they
- 11:34release that as well, but it was allowed to be posted on
- 11:37Facebook. But because of that action,
- 11:39there's a massive Streisand effect and people pay way more
- 11:41attention to it and it completely dominates.
- 11:43The discussion in the last week's of the campaign and
- 11:45Democrats were somewhat dishonest about this whole thing
- 11:49and try to make it seem. Like the laptop was like,
- 11:52probably fake when it seems like clearly.
- 11:55It was truly a core russian, right?
- 11:56And I think that figured also into, I imagine some of faith.
- 12:00It's distorted. Sorry.
- 12:00Twitter's decision making was that we don't want to be seen
- 12:03disseminating. Something that could have been,
- 12:05you know, Russian and origin, or have some kind of Russian
- 12:07involvement and we've got a retread of everything in 2016,
- 12:10right. What any, I think these
- 12:12companies did not want to spend another four years of being
- 12:14blamed for being probably a. But I think this is where
- 12:17Twitter did not have the fortitude to stand up and say,
- 12:20look, if the New York Post, publishes something that is
- 12:23hacked, or obtained illegally that is on them, right?
- 12:27Like I don't think that Facebook and Twitter should substitute
- 12:30their editorial discretion for the editorial discretion of
- 12:33journalistic outlets. Even as those journalistic
- 12:35outfits, don't have necessarily great ethics, right?
- 12:37But I do understand how they got here because it was incredibly
- 12:39sketchy, right? Like the post is the only outlet
- 12:42that has it, right? They do not share the hard drive
- 12:44with anybody else. So, no other journalists, I
- 12:45mean, the entire journalism world had this huge problem of
- 12:48how do you cover this? When you cannot authenticate,
- 12:51the documents or authenticate? The drive, it took months and
- 12:54months and months for the Washington Post to get a copy
- 12:56later. The Washington Post had
- 12:58forensic, experts who I really trust.
- 13:00Get it. And they find that the hard
- 13:01drive has been modified, but none of this comes out in that
- 13:05time. The other media Outlets are know
- 13:07how to handle it. Twitter doesn't know again.
- 13:08I think Twitter made a mistake. And so, if you want to say the
- 13:11outcome of this whole thing is Twitter should not take
- 13:12responsibility for stuff. That might be a hacking leak.
- 13:15I think that's true because just, this is just the reality
- 13:18of living in a free Society is we have a free media.
- 13:22We do not have a national secrets, we don't have like a
- 13:24Secrets act and official Secrets act, there are free societies
- 13:28that say before an election. Section you can't release a
- 13:31bunch of like traumatic new information and even if the
- 13:35federal government doesn't have that principle, it's not crazy.
- 13:39That social media companies would say listen we're not doing
- 13:43a great job, sorting truth from falsity and we don't invest
- 13:47enough in it were bad at it. We don't want to be the vehicle
- 13:51for a bunch of false information right before the election.
- 13:54So we're basically going to say we don't moderate enough, we
- 13:56don't want to create this sort of like chaos, right?
- 14:00Election like that to me would be a reasonable stance.
- 14:02I don't know if it's the one. I would have to know what you're
- 14:04talking about. Are they taking down a link from
- 14:07The New York Times or the Wall Street Journal, or the what New
- 14:09York Post that? That's where the problem is.
- 14:12There's a difference between them.
- 14:13Being responsible for the organic content that is on their
- 14:16platform where people are using. If you're on Facebook and you
- 14:19say, I'm Joe, Schmo actually live in Wyoming and you really
- 14:23live in Beijing. That Facebook has some
- 14:25responsibility there. If somebody's posting the link
- 14:28from the Washington Times, Is that I think the Washington
- 14:30Times is responsible for that and let you write other
- 14:33societies. Have this in France, there's a
- 14:35news blackout. I believe it's 48 hours before
- 14:37the election. In this exact thing came up and
- 14:39that there was a Russian campaign called mccrum leaks,
- 14:43where they had real stolen documents and then they inserted
- 14:45fake documents into the real ones to try to confuse people.
- 14:49And they released it hours before the deadline because
- 14:52their goal was to get online sources to cover the
- 14:56quote-unquote macron leaks and then not allow the mainstream To
- 15:00rebut it failed in France, right?
- 15:03But we don't have anything like you will never have anything
- 15:05like that in the US. And so as long as the poet, you
- 15:07know, there's not a rule around the actual media.
- 15:09I don't think Facebook or Twitter, can invent that rule
- 15:11themselves, I want to move on to the very wise thing soon, but
- 15:14like to structure the hunter Biden laptop argument, I think
- 15:19the liberal position would be okay, maybe Twitter, mishandled
- 15:22it, but it doesn't undermine all top down decision making.
- 15:26They should still have processes for deciding what to put out.
- 15:29Out. And then there's sort of a
- 15:30conservative position, which is just look how much the experts
- 15:34fail. Whether it's the laptop, whether
- 15:36it's covid. Disinformation, every time you
- 15:39have a top-down censorship model, there are major failures
- 15:43and so we should insert of abandon, the exercise
- 15:46altogether. So that is like musk kind of
- 15:51vibrates between these two states of there should be no
- 15:55content, moderation and then we're going to do lots of
- 15:57content, moderation. But based upon Opinion because
- 16:01the truth is is he's he's really wrapped around the axle by like
- 16:04three or four decisions, the hunter by and laptop, the D
- 16:07platforming of Babylon. Be lives of tick-tock, probably
- 16:10lives of tip, talk. Those are like for things that
- 16:14are very public, that happened in the United States.
- 16:18They do not represent 99.99% of what you have to do, every day
- 16:22to keep a platform like Twitter actually useful, right?
- 16:25And that is where things are starting to fall apart at
- 16:28Twitter, is that Their basic ability to stop spam.
- 16:31For example, is really getting bad, we're actually publishing a
- 16:35blog post, the next couple of days on this on in China like
- 16:39knowledge about the protests in China have been buried by spam
- 16:42and it looks like it might not really be the Chinese government
- 16:44looks like it's just spammers take advantage of the fact that
- 16:47there's almost no anti spam team left at Twitter now, right?
- 16:49Like and so if you decide we're just not going to do content
- 16:52moderation at all, you will end up with eight Chan.
- 16:54You'll end up with something that is unusable at the scale at
- 16:57which Twitter wants to operate. Yeah.
- 16:59And what, I will link that blog post in the episode description
- 17:01because there's been a lot of talk about that last thing on
- 17:04this side. Before we move on to the Barry
- 17:06Weiss thread in terms of New Revelations that came out of
- 17:09what Taibbi had posted, it seems fairly thin to me.
- 17:13I mean, even on the topic of, you know, not linking store not
- 17:17allowing links to the New York Post story, I believe Jack even
- 17:20came out while he was CEO of Twitter to say in hindsight,
- 17:23that was an extreme decision. That was the wrong decision.
- 17:26There's already been some level of Maiya culpa on the part of
- 17:29Twitter leadership. To say, we don't agree with the
- 17:31way this played out in the end. We would take a different tactic
- 17:34that happen this way. And so the idea of this was a
- 17:36huge gotcha, or at least some kind of like confirmation of
- 17:40Suspicion on the part of conservatives, and Elon Musk.
- 17:43I don't think it was really their right?
- 17:44Anyone who's been following us, right?
- 17:46Nothing he said was different than what you all Roth said on
- 17:49stage with Kara Swisher, right? You well who was in charge of
- 17:52the trust and safety team. Straight up said we made a
- 17:55mistake. Here's how the mistake was made.
- 17:57This is what I do differently and everything.
- 18:00Tell you be posted back that up. And most importantly, Taibbi
- 18:04said, there's no evidence of government intervention in
- 18:07Hunter by his laptop. And there is evidence of the
- 18:09Trump campaign sending other stuff.
- 18:11And then just kind of left that dangling out there, but does it
- 18:13matter. Because what's happening is,
- 18:14people are framing it up and saying this proves something,
- 18:18and having all this anger and rage, you know, all those
- 18:22liberals at Twitter without any real evidence.
- 18:25It's honestly, I mean, I used to be a big tiny beef and back in,
- 18:28like, the Rolling Stone day. I I loved the phrase.
- 18:30The like you know this vampire squid on the face empire squid
- 18:34face of the human about Goldman Sachs.
- 18:35Yeah right and I mean obviously he should be pretty embarrassed
- 18:39by this. I don't see how you come back.
- 18:41I mean one the fact that he's like doing all this work on
- 18:43behalf of this, incredibly rich and powerful person, I feel like
- 18:46it's incompatible. It's like, it's in the musical
- 18:48for Tucker Carlson just to get mad.
- 18:50I mean, it's sort of feels like all a pretense.
- 18:52There's no evidence to back what he's saying?
- 18:54It's crazy. It's just like it from a basic
- 18:56journalistic perspective. You can't have like, 60 tweets
- 18:59that are all brethren. Worthless.
- 19:00And then the actual evidence you show doesn't demonstrate easier
- 19:03than what the governor. He didn't see any evidence that
- 19:06the government interfered. Even though everybody around him
- 19:09wants, basically keeps suggesting that it did and he
- 19:12does nothing to clean up that record at all.
- 19:15No, no. He in fact, his thread is
- 19:17inconsistent on this, right? Of like making claims that he
- 19:21can't back up later in the thread.
- 19:22Let's talk about Barry. So, this one, tell us a little
- 19:25bit meteor to me, in terms of showing off, What could arguably
- 19:30be a disingenuous stance on the part of Twitter when it comes to
- 19:34Shadow Banning? So like I kind of summarize at
- 19:37the outset there were internal looks like screenshots really of
- 19:41certain accounts you mentioned lives of tick-tock events.
- 19:43Bungee know we mentioned J bought a Chara from Stanford
- 19:47where it did show that they had tags affixed to their accounts
- 19:50saying they were to be penalized, eboost, 2, whatever
- 19:53term you want to use and not made as you know, their content
- 19:56not made as distributed. I mean, I don't No, what do you
- 19:59think about everything that came through berries tweets?
- 20:02So I think the, if we're once again going to take the best
- 20:06possible version their commitment, I think this is a
- 20:09situation where Twitter's Executives were not very
- 20:11specific in their language, right?
- 20:13Everything she is talking about is both in the terms of service
- 20:16and I've been in multiple blog post on Twitter that Twitter
- 20:19will allow certain speech to exist, but we'll decide that
- 20:22they will not amplify it themselves.
- 20:24I think this is a good thing. In fact you know who agrees with
- 20:26me on that? Yeah, I'm a guy named you.
- 20:29Musk agrees with me and that he specifically talked about
- 20:33freedom of reach is not freedom of speech, right?
- 20:35So that is a, that is a paraphrase of my colleague,
- 20:37Grenada, resta of what people have talked about, for years,
- 20:40which is a middle ground. For these platforms is allowing
- 20:43certain speech to exist, and to be findable by people who
- 20:46specifically search it out. But not to use the features of
- 20:50the platform that recommend stuff or provide amplification
- 20:53to push that stuff out, right? That basically Twitter is saying
- 20:56there's some Middle Ground if you're Really, really bad over
- 20:59here. You're just off if your speech
- 21:01is just find your over here and we're going to have to deal with
- 21:03the middle ground where we will allow you to exist.
- 21:06But we're not going to have a recommend you and we're not
- 21:08going to push you on other people and that is effectively
- 21:11what these different settings do is that people who are multiple
- 21:14repeat offenders that instead of taking them completely off, they
- 21:18allow them to exist. They allow their followers to
- 21:20see all their content but they don't recommend them.
- 21:23Just like some of the debate on the very wise threat is
- 21:26semantic. It is what Is all semantics.
- 21:30What is Shadow Banning? Because Twitter basically said
- 21:33we don't Shadow band but then Twitter defined Shadow Banning
- 21:35as no one but you can see what you do.
- 21:39And other people clearly. See Shadow Banning is I'm not
- 21:42getting as much reaches. I thought I should.
- 21:44But Twitter was very clear that they were fiddling with reach of
- 21:48accounts that violated their policies.
- 21:51So it feels like there's just like a total semantic war going
- 21:54on here, right? There's a 20-18 blog post, where
- 21:57the people in charge at Twitter said, Ed, what is Shadow?
- 22:00Banning the best definition we found, is deliberately making
- 22:02someone's content undiscoverable to everyone except the person
- 22:05who posted it, unbeknownst the original poster, right?
- 22:07So they are taking the most extreme version of what people
- 22:11talk about Shadow Banning, where somebody's effectively in a
- 22:14complete jail where they think they're on the platform but
- 22:17nobody sees it, right? They then say in that post, what
- 22:20we do do is we take people out a search and we down rank stuff
- 22:23and so, yes, it is all done on recovery.
- 22:26Let's get into the definition of that.
- 22:27I mean down rank. He means if you're looking at
- 22:30trending topics, it won't appear.
- 22:32If you have the algorithmic feed that puts in accounts that you
- 22:35don't normally follow, but it just wants to highlight
- 22:37something of, you know, Trend and excitement and people are
- 22:41talking about. They'll put that in there even
- 22:42if you don't follow it. So that is like a kind of
- 22:44algorithmic boosting that Twitter engages with that.
- 22:47They basically push these people out of, right?
- 22:49They effectively say the places where we are putting content to
- 22:53you. That you did not explicitly ask
- 22:55for, we consider that our editorial responsibility, and we
- 22:57will make editorial Visions for than that.
- 22:59And that includes both the algorithmic feed.
- 23:01Like you said, as well as trending topics and other kinds
- 23:03of recommended you should follow this account because there's
- 23:05three or four interfaces at Twitter that will recommend
- 23:08content to you. I'm sort of conflicted.
- 23:11There's sort of the covid case study where Twitter seems to be
- 23:15going after somebody for saying oh covid.
- 23:17Lockdowns Are Gonna Hurt our children because learning loss
- 23:22or whatever, with the benefit of hindsight, to me does seem like
- 23:26some you know censorship around this sort of Veiling ideology.
- 23:30On the other hand, down voting or whatever, they did to lives
- 23:34of tick-tock. I don't know if I ran a
- 23:35platform. I did all this hard work.
- 23:37I founded, like tech company. I built it up and I'm like,
- 23:41Distributing it to the world. I don't know if I'd want to look
- 23:43back at my work product and see that like this account, like
- 23:47harassing sort of the most marginal people in our society
- 23:51and just sort of making fun of them.
- 23:53Even if it doesn't, violate sort of, I don't know, Red Line rule
- 23:56as I Can Dream up. Why am I Using this great tool
- 24:00that I created to distribute that.
- 24:01Like what's my obligation which is white this kind of feature
- 24:04exists to allow that account to exist.
- 24:07Like if you want it to be able to be there then you need to
- 24:11have some kind of mechanism where you're not making things
- 24:13worse. And the thing goes have to
- 24:15remember that is that all of trust and safety is adversarial.
- 24:18Any decision you make, the person who you're making
- 24:21decisions about their content will adjust.
- 24:24And what has happened is you have these effectively, these
- 24:27kind of professional. Trolls.
- 24:30Like legit Tick-Tock who understand exactly where the
- 24:32line is and they'll go up to a millimeter of that line and the
- 24:35outcome is Children's Hospital's get bomb threats, right?
- 24:39And so, if your Twitter interact, the real-life impact
- 24:42of this account is that people are getting death threats but
- 24:46they are super careful. Not to violate one, you might
- 24:48just make it go away totally and see like we're just going to
- 24:51take this risk or you might do something like this.
- 24:54We're like okay you can exist but we're not making it, we're
- 24:56not going to try it, you know, or whatever.
- 24:58Right. Let's go.
- 24:58The argument a number of people are making is that lipstick cock
- 25:00probably got actually a good deal here and that they violated
- 25:03multiple times right? And they got customers floppy
- 25:05letters, right? They ifs writing was adjudicated
- 25:08against them. It needed to go to the highest
- 25:10levels. The effectively got, what was
- 25:12then a scandal when Facebook had a called cross check?
- 25:14Which is, which is, this is actually pretty common in
- 25:16something you have to do with these companies.
- 25:18Is when you have a very large account, you end up marking it.
- 25:21So that just a normal day to day, content, moderation worker
- 25:24can take it down like you, you can't run a social network where
- 25:27the president United States can have their Reset any contract.
- 25:30Right right. Right.
- 25:31But nasty protected they protected the account that
- 25:34normal content operations people could not take impact on it.
- 25:37So certainly it looks like Twitter went out of their way to
- 25:40allow two lives. A tick tock to continue to
- 25:42exist. Do you think there is any
- 25:44positive outcome to the broader public in?
- 25:46Showing the way internal deliberations happen at social
- 25:49media platforms? Because, you know, it, I do
- 25:51think there's something interesting about the fact that
- 25:54these were big stories at the time or there was like a lot of
- 25:56attention paid to the claims by conservatives.
- 25:58A shadow Banning and reporters did not manage to get these
- 26:01documents. And right.
- 26:02Kind of the, you know, whatever mainstream media reporters, did
- 26:05not get these documents and write the stories that you know,
- 26:08are coming out now because of Ilan.
- 26:09I mean, you think there's some positive aspects to at least
- 26:12that happening? Yes.
- 26:14I mean, I think one is this is something I've actually been
- 26:16saying for years. I have a talk in which I talk
- 26:18about how these companies act in a quasi-governmental manner by,
- 26:22they just do, and they are making decisions about people's
- 26:25political speech, they have to if they want to.
- 26:29Run these kinds of platforms and they the platform's be usable.
- 26:31And they do not want like really bad outcomes, like, people dying
- 26:35then, they have to act in the quasi-governmental manner, but
- 26:37they do so without Democratic legitimacy or transparency.
- 26:40And so for years, I've been talking about these companies to
- 26:42be more transparent in their decisions.
- 26:44One of the ways you could do that, maybe a positive outcome
- 26:46and something I proposed to musk before we call.
- 26:48Yo, attacked me for it was they could run a database for the
- 26:52last 30 days. These are all the content.
- 26:54Moderation decisions we've made and you could, they're
- 26:57interesting privacy issues, but You could provide that for
- 26:59people so that you can see whether or not there's a bias
- 27:02because he's he's making the assertion that these decisions
- 27:05were politically biased but he's not providing any evidence of
- 27:07that. All he's doing is its allowing
- 27:10me to Miriam the Trump people ask for you know it's just like
- 27:13look at these case studies and we won't tell you about any of
- 27:16the other case studies let alone.
- 27:18Actually provide you data that would allow you to sort of
- 27:21analyze it right now and I guarantee you've got like,
- 27:24maybe, you know, BLM protesters who say things that could be
- 27:28considered Violet and gets police officers getting the same
- 27:30kind of limit. I totally expect.
- 27:32You have antifa. Another kind of like far left
- 27:34folks. Anarchists there have been tons
- 27:36of complaints by pro-palestinian, protesters that
- 27:38a claim that they are constantly getting, you know, whatever, D
- 27:41boosted, Shadow band. And I mean, that would be really
- 27:43frustrating thing about the take that came after, you know,
- 27:47Barry's tweets was like, this is only happening on one side and
- 27:50it's like, well, you're going to say it's only happening on one
- 27:52side when it's reported by someone whose goal as a reporter
- 27:55right now, is to show that the left is censorious and that the
- 27:58It's goal, is to make sure that conservatives do not get the
- 28:01read-through main stream channels.
- 28:02You're not going to get an even-handed hearing from Barry
- 28:04Weiss when it comes to, you know, leftist true leftist not
- 28:07like center-left, but like actual antifa, or I don't say
- 28:11auntie because that's loaded. But you know, like Palestinian
- 28:13rights any any sort of? It's also a Muslim.
- 28:15He's bad news. Your can be asymmetrical.
- 28:18Like these people just assume that there's necessarily
- 28:22symmetrical bad behavior and I just find it, right?
- 28:24The totally absurd claim, which if you had a database here, You
- 28:28could get different groups analyzing that data and then
- 28:32publishing their methodology and doing peer reviewed work on we
- 28:35think they're biased or not it in you're totally right time.
- 28:37Like there are other groups that have a lot of complaints here.
- 28:39I think the Palestinian you'll pro-palestinian groups have
- 28:42pretty legitimate complaints and it goes exactly to the first
- 28:44thread. The state of Israel runs what's
- 28:47called an internet referral unit.
- 28:49They have a full-time employees of the state of Israel, whose
- 28:52entire job. It is to tell Twitter and
- 28:54Facebook to take content down under Israeli law.
- 28:56Is that Brad and well. Well, I think that is something
- 28:59that is going to exist. And so, what we should have, is
- 29:02complete and total transparency, and what content was taken down,
- 29:05because a sovereign state said, it should be taken down, right?
- 29:09And that's the kind of transparency that if they want
- 29:11to provide would be great. I'm not sure Barry Weiss
- 29:13believes that, that would be appropriate, but if she really
- 29:15cared about the things she thinks she's caring about then
- 29:18complete transparency of what is being moderated and in what
- 29:21situations that was because of an external requests, I think is
- 29:24required. And this is what is lost.
- 29:25And I think the bad faith nature of these debates because Is so
- 29:29hard to differentiate, you know, a supposed absolutist stance on
- 29:33free speech. And the particular political
- 29:35viewpoints that you had that you feel are being, you know,
- 29:38kneecapped by the people that are in charge, because if you
- 29:41truly did believe in these things, you being, you know, the
- 29:44Free Speech, absolutist, Elon Musk, David sacks.
- 29:46All these people that are bitching and moaning on Twitter,
- 29:48they would not have released it to specific journalists who were
- 29:51given specific instructions on how to disseminate this
- 29:54information Jack, Dorsey even publicly a steal on you.
- 29:58Should release all of these documents to all the journalists
- 30:01who had to provide full transparency.
- 30:03Which you were saying at the outset would be the only way
- 30:05that you could have like, a true.
- 30:07And fair, Reckoning of what was going on inside sweater during
- 30:09this period, right? These guys are definitionally
- 30:12useful, idiots, here they are targeting reporters.
- 30:15Who want to see the world a certain way really want to
- 30:19Professor Independence but are clearly aligned with delivering
- 30:23the message that Elon Musk wants.
- 30:25I mean, it's very similar to some of the Iraq War report.
- 30:29And, you know, you would think Tybee would be sort of terrified
- 30:32of becoming that person. I just find it ridiculous.
- 30:36And the other thing I wanted flag is just and I think we've
- 30:38all into that. This is just the sort of
- 30:41American narcissism they like the great sort of political
- 30:46speech challenge of our time is going to revolve around Libs of
- 30:49tick-tock rather than China nation-states fascism like the
- 30:54big questions like just the narcissism of it is mine.
- 30:58Mind-boggling to me. Well, but this is okay, so if
- 31:01you want to take their argument seriously, that has been true of
- 31:04kind of the American Center left as well is that all of the
- 31:07discussions were about Trump and not about the fact that 95% of
- 31:11Facebook's users are outside the United States 80% of Twitter's
- 31:14users outside the United States but those people are facing much
- 31:18worse because one they live in states that have massive
- 31:21censorship and propaganda outlets and to their countries
- 31:24that don't have a First Amendment and so if you live in
- 31:26India Hunter by his laptop, Seems quaint because right now
- 31:30the Indian state is the most censorious democratic State on
- 31:33the planet. They said more requests than any
- 31:36other government to take down stuff on Twitter.
- 31:39A lot of that. Yeah, it's on Twitter and face
- 31:40of how much warranted, how much is Twitch India and then get to
- 31:44China. Like, what?
- 31:45How much is Twitter dealing with India and China right now?
- 31:47Like how important are those platforms in those countries?
- 31:50Right. So Twitter is blocked in China,
- 31:53right? When you think about the risk
- 31:55from China, it is that the People's Republic of China has a
- 31:58A very large and growing propaganda capability.
- 32:01That targets, Twitter traditionally, the Chinese
- 32:04propaganda capability was focused on Chinese and
- 32:06non-chinese platforms, and two incidents has changed over the
- 32:10last five years. First of the series of
- 32:12uprisings, in Hong Kong, the PRC found themselves.
- 32:15Totally at a disadvantage versus these highly online.
- 32:19Very good English. Speaking Hong Kong students who
- 32:21were able to get their side of the story out.
- 32:24And then the second was coated, was that, you know, with
- 32:26everybody blaming China At some level, whatever you believe
- 32:30about Wuhan. I think you could say, you know,
- 32:32obviously covid came from China, whether it was natural or not
- 32:35that they wanted to distract from that.
- 32:38And also push the idea that China's response to covid-19.
- 32:58About China, right eye. Has he said anything about it?
- 33:01People are directly asking about it.
- 33:04He has no stream sensitivity like he has factories in China.
- 33:08Right there are obvious pressure points that he's sensitive to
- 33:11any won't say a word about almost.
- 33:13All of his net worth is in Tesla.
- 33:15Stock Tesla has a massive gigafactory in Shanghai from,
- 33:19which they will be producing cars to be shipped around the
- 33:21world, but especially in Asia, I believe.
- 33:24And China is already 25 percent of the revenue.
- 33:27Clearly, if you look at like, Counted cash flows for the
- 33:29future. China is going to be more than
- 33:3150% right of their stock price. And so yes, the PRC has huge.
- 33:35Leverage over him. It's like, if Mark Zuckerberg,
- 33:37instead of having all his money in Facebook stock is money, was
- 33:40like in a Chinese pharmaceutical company, right?
- 33:42And it's like this is how this is something.
- 33:44I've never really faced. Republicans were sincere.
- 33:46They would be going insane over this.
- 33:48I mean, this is any national security.
- 33:51Serious person would be terrified of this situation.
- 33:54Yes. Yeah.
- 33:56Right. Because the team, so, right
- 33:58before For the election, this got very little play but we
- 34:00wrote this up a TI Partnership dotnet.
- 34:02If you look at our blog for 2022, right?
- 34:05Before the election, there were five disinformation networks
- 34:08taken down in a coordinated work by Twitter and Facebook.
- 34:12We did the right up in the analysis of who they were and it
- 34:15was the Iranians in the Chinese most of it was anti-republican.
- 34:19In fact, one of the group's was a, they created an entire fake
- 34:22anti Rubio group in Florida fasten the Chinese did.
- 34:25And so what end this? Because they think Republicans
- 34:28on door. Sort of China or yes?
- 34:30Right. And I think I think actually,
- 34:32you are starting the the idea that foreign influence is
- 34:35something that is only pro-republican is a very 2016
- 34:39idea. What's happened is American,
- 34:42democracy has become the World Cup of disinformation, where
- 34:46everybody cares about our elections, even Our House and
- 34:49Senate election of Iraq, where they don't get to vote in them.
- 34:51It impacts every with, right, right.
- 34:54And so, if you are a government, you've got your political leader
- 34:57saying, Hey, why are we not playing here to if the Russians
- 35:01are playing there and the Chinese.
- 35:02And so you'll Iran and China were running.
- 35:04Disinformation campaigns are talking about Twitter, that
- 35:06entire team at Twitter that did that work is gone.
- 35:09Every single one of them, not a single person that we used to
- 35:11email to work on this stuff together is still there and
- 35:15Republicans should care about that because a bunch of
- 35:17disinformation on Twitter is anti-republican, right?
- 35:20Is anti GOP is sometimes anti-trump.
- 35:22But in many cases targeting in this case, like Rubio, very
- 35:25specific kind of mainstream Republican politicians.
- 35:28They see them as not beneficial to array on door China and so,
- 35:31yes, I do think like we're stuck in this weird 2017 moment where
- 35:37Republicans don't care about foreign influence and Democrats
- 35:39do and therefore you can play to the right of saying that none of
- 35:43this stuff is real but that just does not match the facts on the
- 35:45ground as documented and that we will not be able to document
- 35:48very much anymore. If nobody had Twitter is minding
- 35:51the store so this is kind of a soft target but I feel like we
- 35:54have to deal with it to an extent we've seen as Elon.
- 35:58Has, you know, spent a little more time on Twitter.
- 36:01There is a creeping arbitrariness behind his own,
- 36:03moderation decisions. He has banned Kanye from the
- 36:06platform for posting a swastika which is actually fine.
- 36:10I would think like it's and you could release the process behind
- 36:12that. I mean like shit.
- 36:14There's simple dare. He is not a lot, Alex Jones back
- 36:16on the platform Because he believes that, you know,
- 36:19everything that he's said about Sandy Hook was, you know,
- 36:21disgusting and harmful. And he doesn't want to be
- 36:24running a platform that's like that.
- 36:25So there's obviously a huge amount of hypocrisy blatant.
- 36:28In the way that he is approaching content.
- 36:30Moderation decisions. Where do you see this going with
- 36:33him? Like, if he's still in this kind
- 36:35of 2017 mindset, he's starting to come to terms with the fact
- 36:38that a free-for-all absolute a stance on free speech is not
- 36:41actually what he wants. Let's even take the economic
- 36:43pressures from what advertisers want off the table.
- 36:46Where do you see you on progressing?
- 36:49In terms of building up or rebuilding some of the content?
- 36:52Moderation structures that he took down?
- 36:54I really don't know other than the thing I said, the day, he
- 36:58closed the door. Deal.
- 36:58Was he kind of bought himself into a world of pain here
- 37:01because one he is exposed to all these countries.
- 37:04He sells products all around the world.
- 37:06He is somebody who is until this moment maintained a kind of
- 37:09bipartisan respect for him. Another company.
- 37:12He owns SpaceX I believe 80 90 % of the revenue comes from the US
- 37:16government. They are effectively a defense
- 37:17contractor to NASA and DOD and so he's kind of ruining his
- 37:21reputation. With half the people who vote on
- 37:23budgets, that give him billions of dollars.
- 37:25And then by saying, I am the decider, there is no Policy
- 37:29mechanisms. There's no counsel, there's no
- 37:32discussion. You only have to Lobby me.
- 37:34He has made himself kind of personally, if not legally
- 37:38morally, responsible for everything happens on Twitter.
- 37:40And I think one, he seems to be kind of spinning out of control
- 37:43a little bit in his own interactions.
- 37:45Like it's getting with more and more like he just called the
- 37:48only bar. Yeah, he said I run up, right?
- 37:52And so like I proposed to him, you know, that they should have
- 37:54these transparency mechanisms, which is a totally nonpartisan,
- 37:58you know, No idea. And he said I run a propaganda
- 38:00platform, which, you know, we've got a couple of grad students.
- 38:03I've got like four full-time employees at a bunch of real
- 38:05smart kids who work for me. I'm not sure I'd call that a
- 38:07platform but that's cool. Like if you want to say that but
- 38:10like he's kind of spinning out of control and his interactions
- 38:12with people and I think he's going to find.
- 38:15This is not fun. It's also really affecting the
- 38:17stock price Tesla stock has plummeted even worse than all
- 38:21these other companies. I think part of it is he is
- 38:24destroying the brand of Tesla and he is going to find that
- 38:27doing this for the Lord. Jules is gonna have real
- 38:29long-term economic impact on him.
- 38:31I think in a year he's not going to own Twitter because I think
- 38:34it's not going to be fun dealing with these issues.
- 38:36They never stop. They will never not be a
- 38:38moderation controversy on Twitter.
- 38:41It is going to massively distract him and it's destroying
- 38:43his brand and I say this is like I drive a Tesla.
- 38:46I have a Tesla roof, I have power walls behind me back here.
- 38:49So I I think Tesla has built incredible things and I don't
- 38:53think I'd ever by Tesla product. Again, I've got 20 years of
- 38:55depreciation, now on the roof that would have to live with but
- 38:58I'm never buying In a car again and that's true for like, you
- 39:00know, when you think about the people who by Tesla's, you're
- 39:02talking about kind of urban and Suburban college educated people
- 39:05with high incomes, he's not playing to that base.
- 39:09Right, right, right. And I mean, yes, I've heard this
- 39:11this argument from a lot of other people that it's like, if
- 39:14you are and this is just the general issue, I think the
- 39:16Republican party is maybe running into is as you fight
- 39:19entirely on culture, War it matters but you are yourselves
- 39:21you know a well-off group of people you kind of got to think
- 39:25about who your audience is at a certain point and that's fine if
- 39:28you feel like You were the voice for, you know, Middle America,
- 39:30but you're also selling hell of expensive cars that.
- 39:33I mean, good for you, if you can make cars for those people, but
- 39:35by and large you really aren't, I know this is getting
- 39:38psychological. But like, what do you think is
- 39:40going on? Sometimes I'm like, it's their
- 39:42children, their children are all, like, so left that they
- 39:44can't even understand it and the culture that they're facing with
- 39:47their children is alienating to them.
- 39:50Why is he, like, huffing this sort of like, Libs of tick-tock
- 39:54content to such a degree that he has been?
- 39:56So, Radicalized a totally vacillates between saying that
- 40:02he wants to like be on the side of the middle 80% and then he
- 40:07says he's going to support Ron DeSantis and every every
- 40:10account, he's validating is some weird right wing account.
- 40:14Well that's where the business side gets really interesting too
- 40:16because you can see the rationalization starting to come
- 40:19together over there. That because they are taking
- 40:21this quote-unquote absolutist. Free speech stance.
- 40:24They're starting to lose advertisers and now they're
- 40:26blaming. Whoa.
- 40:27Mmm for all of this because the, you know, these advertisers
- 40:31don't want to be associated with the platform that is, you know,
- 40:33Riven with hate speech. But if you are an Advertiser,
- 40:36you know, or a Big Brand, you are trying to sell the most
- 40:39amount of products as possible, and you see like the sentiment
- 40:42that most of the country has, which is most people don't like
- 40:45seeing these things on their timeline.
- 40:46And most people don't want to be surrounded by, you know, this
- 40:49level of hate speech and so you do it, they can't even like rely
- 40:53on the free market argument in order to prove that what they're
- 40:56fighting for is like what the You know, most of the country
- 40:59wants. Yeah, he is definitely Twitter
- 41:02is definitely cash flow negative at this point, right?
- 41:05Like there's never been a great business, it is over the last 10
- 41:07years, you know. It's only had a couple of
- 41:08quarters of profitability but effectively it was making as
- 41:11much revenue as it spent. So it was going to be an ongoing
- 41:14concern for the foreseeable future.
- 41:16And what he did was he did reduce his costs by laying off
- 41:19all these people but he also is massively destroyed as Revenue.
- 41:22I'm sure he's increased engagement with all this
- 41:24craziness but that is the supply of Advertising.
- 41:28Right? So he's increase the supply in
- 41:29the market place. Every time you see an ad on
- 41:32Twitter or any other platform, that is the outcome of a
- 41:35real-time bidding war between advertisers and I guarantee the
- 41:39price of those Twitter ads have gone through the floor, because
- 41:42the Big Brand advertisers who are willing to spend the big
- 41:45money on. Those cpcs are cpms are not are
- 41:49mostly gone, a couple or left like Amazon.
- 41:51And then you saw that the daily Stormer guy.
- 41:54When you go through his feed, the Amazon ads are on there.
- 41:56So we just saw, you know, Quiet letter to advertisers from
- 41:59Twitter saying, we're coming up with more brand safety stuff so
- 42:02you can block certain accounts and such.
- 42:05I don't know if that's going to be good enough, but I am sure
- 42:07they're losing money and that doesn't only include the fact
- 42:10that he, he borrowed a huge amount of money.
- 42:13He attached to the new Twitter Corporation over a billion
- 42:16dollars in interest payments per year.
- 42:18And so, yes, he could massively, cut the staff and keep Twitter
- 42:21running because all a lot of the hard engineering has been done,
- 42:23and it's now in like a sustained engineering mode, but he's not
- 42:26going to be able to make serious.
- 42:27As changes in. So we talked about these big
- 42:29ambitious things about building the everything app building
- 42:31payments. Building this building that you
- 42:33can't do that on a skeleton crew.
- 42:35At least not safely. Once you already have a base of
- 42:37hundreds of millions of users and so I think he's he's going
- 42:40to find himself in this weird trap where he's going to have to
- 42:44continue to subsidize it out of his personal net, worth which
- 42:46again because of his actions is dropping right?
- 42:49And so like the people who are really should be angry here,
- 42:51probably Tesla shareholders because his continued sale of
- 42:54Tesla stock plus his erratic behavior is Tanking Tesla stock
- 42:58in a way that is great for the shorts of which I'm not.
- 43:03And they have made the shorts and made billions.
- 43:05But for normal Tesla stockholders they're the ones
- 43:07holding the bag. You think liberals have said too
- 43:09low of a bar for you on Twitter. Like do you think this whole
- 43:13thing that website is just going to start like going down, or it
- 43:17felt like there was a moment where I don't know, there was
- 43:20just like a panic over, like, oh, this could all end, like
- 43:23tomorrow, or how do you see that playing out?
- 43:26I mean, he's just running more risk, right?
- 43:28Like you could run Twitter with 300-400 people.
- 43:30So you know, Twitter has about 500,000 servers in three main
- 43:33data centers, as well as in a couple dozen pops, right?
- 43:36So you need your data center operations people.
- 43:38You need your infra people who manage the hardware and software
- 43:42remotely and then you need your devops people, who keep it
- 43:45running, that's your minimum right?
- 43:47So you know, probably maybe 400 people.
- 43:49And people you can keep it up and running in definitely if you
- 43:52want to actually build this incredibly complicated app that
- 43:55is effectively the American version of we chat.
- 43:57Then you going to need hundreds and thousands of Engineers
- 44:00designers product managers in the like and so is it just going
- 44:04to go down? I think he's taking more risk
- 44:06because the depth of their engineering Talent has
- 44:09decreased. And I think one of the crazy
- 44:10things he's done is he's done the layoffs in a way that is
- 44:14incentivized people who have other options to lead the
- 44:17craziest from like it just a Fleet take the politics out from
- 44:21a Harvard, Business Review organizational management
- 44:23perspective. Sending an email that says click
- 44:27this button if you're so hardcore you want to have a
- 44:29horrible life. If you don't, I will
- 44:32automatically pay you. 90 days of severance going into the
- 44:34holidays is just selecting, for people who don't think they can
- 44:38get a job by January and people who have like H-1B visas and
- 44:42such. And so, a bunch of people who
- 44:44believe or people who believe, in whatever, you know, political
- 44:47project, he is trying to advance through.
- 44:49Yes. Fleur, which is I don't think is
- 44:51a majority of the of the L7 engineers at Twitter.
- 44:56I guarantee that the majority of them do not think he's doing a
- 44:59good job and and and they those people there have been a lot of
- 45:02layoffs and Tech but if you're at like an LS7 at Twitter and
- 45:04you have operated at the scale, you will have a job in two weeks
- 45:07and his vision isn't even clear. Like, even if you're a die-hard,
- 45:11he alternates. So it's harder, you're really
- 45:13sort of going with the, I don't know dear leader sensibility,
- 45:17where you're supporting, right? Every Lon.
- 45:19Capriciously wants to do, I mean it's worked from the past
- 45:23because Tesla had a mission, we're going to make electric
- 45:25cars real. We're going to save the Earth
- 45:27SpaceX. We're getting Humanity off this
- 45:29planet where reinvigorating American.
- 45:31Those are incredible missions. Their missions of people will
- 45:33take less money and work 80 hour weeks for.
- 45:36There's no. What is the elevator pitch of
- 45:38musk's Twitter? It's we're going to run this for
- 45:41the personal gratification of musk.
- 45:43That is not the kind of thing. You're like, oh, I'll never see
- 45:45my kids and I'm fine with it. That's yeah.
- 45:48That's gonna motivate You for that.
- 45:49So this gets to the kind of interesting question, at least
- 45:52interesting to us. And maybe question about the
- 45:53journalist that are at the center of all of these
- 45:56quote-unquote Revelations because, you know, we have with
- 45:59Barry Weiss. Well, she's more or less just,
- 46:00you know, become a partisan to the certain types of people that
- 46:04believe that the left is an anti Free Speech group and they're,
- 46:07you know, they are out there to cater to the whims of the
- 46:12blue-haired pronoun people. And you have people like Matt
- 46:15Taibbi, who I think is a great journalist.
- 46:17I'd love to have him on Matt. If you hear this, we're down to
- 46:21chat, but I think there is something very strange and
- 46:23almost Insidious happening with the non mainstream journalists,
- 46:27the ones that are contrarian basically by nature and that
- 46:30they are trying to rebel against, you know, the
- 46:33mainstream argument that's been pushed forward over the last
- 46:36couple of years and the over reaction I would say over
- 46:39reaction by the New York Times, the things like Russia gate or,
- 46:42you know, Facebook content, moderation, all this other stuff
- 46:45and they have ended up in a place like Eric mentioned
- 46:47earlier in which they are willing.
- 46:49NG to be mouthpieces and there's really no other word for it,
- 46:52mouthpieces for the richest person in the world in which he
- 46:54can, you know, release selectively, release documents
- 46:57that are being pushed through the platform that he owns that
- 47:00if nothing else is going to bring like it, did sit this
- 47:02fucking thing. But from a journalistic aspect
- 47:04here, how did we end up here? Is there anything positive to
- 47:07say about deciding to carry water for Elon Musk in an
- 47:12extremely untransparent way? My personal view on this is I'm
- 47:16just very skeptical of like Conservative media project.
- 47:21My first job out of college, I worked for the Washington
- 47:24examiner, which was sort of a republican, billionaire funded
- 47:29outlet. But I, you know, I took the job
- 47:31as I was covering TC City Hall and you know, it was fairly
- 47:36straight news sensibility. But ultimately like I found who
- 47:41think the conservative impulse to be like pretty sloppy willing
- 47:44to like throw up, you know, headline numbers of like budget
- 47:48deficits. Without sort of much thinking
- 47:50about the context and it was very similar to like what we're
- 47:53seeing now. Where it's can it be truthful
- 47:55enough that it's something that we can all get like angry about
- 47:59and score points on and I don't quite know, culturally why I
- 48:03like the right hasn't been able to build up great, conservative
- 48:07media like disposition Ali, but I just, I've never seen them
- 48:11successful and that's part of why I sort of have cheered for
- 48:14like a musk Twitter. It's like okay, make the right
- 48:17actually governed as they Say they want to but I mean I think
- 48:21as we've all sort of said they I've seen no evidence that they
- 48:25can I don't know our Alex are you as cynical as I am?
- 48:28Why can't the right wing to liver sort of a coherent
- 48:32argument here? What it's interesting when you
- 48:35talk about Taibbi, I think unfortunately he's trending
- 48:38towards Greenwald who the biggest enemy for Glenn
- 48:41Greenwald is Westwind normally Democrats, right?
- 48:44Right, like right West Wing watching, Obama voters, even
- 48:48though he is. Moved to a country that has a
- 48:50semi fascist dictator. Who is now fighting against yo,
- 48:54Paulson roo-hoo Glenn Greenwald hates is now fighting against
- 48:58being democratically-elected out and you know who's going to
- 49:01support him in that, it looks like musk musk has been tweeting
- 49:03things positively saying about, he's looking into whether bowls
- 49:07in, Ro was improperly treated by Twitter that no matter what the
- 49:11facts are that the worst people are just Normie.
- 49:15Democrats it. I feel the same way about Ed
- 49:17Snowden is like if One day, Ed Snowden is going when he is no
- 49:21longer useful, something. Horrible is going to happen to
- 49:24him in Moscow by the FSB and his last thoughts going to be the
- 49:29real. Enemy is Barack Obama, right?
- 49:31Like it's just you you have these people words.
- 49:34They've got such anger that they have to then realign everything
- 49:38else around the these like basic ideas of you know, basic
- 49:42center-left kind of normal yo government in the United States
- 49:46is the worst thing ever. So somehow either Trump is
- 49:49President or, you know, populists around the world are
- 49:53really the representatives of the people.
- 49:55I do. Sadly think that the common
- 49:56denominator in a lot of this ironically is Twitter that the
- 50:00Twitter engagement mechanism. For a lot of people, especially
- 50:04contrarians is just to get into fights with people.
- 50:07Is it to score points in the midst of some sort of Twitter
- 50:09argument. And that by definition is going
- 50:12to push you into taking very bizarre stances and, and into
- 50:16strange corners. And I see someone like Greenwald
- 50:19you Journalistically at the stuff that he's pushing out
- 50:21through his sub stack and you know, if he still publishing
- 50:24articles anywhere else still pretty strong stuff.
- 50:26I mean, you mentioned Brazil, you know, he was responsible for
- 50:29the dissemination of a lot of files that were leaked in
- 50:32Brazil, that helped exonerate Lula, who is now?
- 50:35Maybe going to be the president there.
- 50:36So I again, like when it gets to the moral compass, I still think
- 50:40it's point in the right direction, but because Twitter
- 50:42has dominated so much of the way journalists view their job and
- 50:47and the way to establish their brand.
- 50:49That it's just going to end up in this place.
- 50:50We're really good. Journalists are willing to make
- 50:53concessions to some of the least, good faith, actors out
- 50:57there and ones that at every other way.
- 50:58They do not agree with them politically just that they can
- 51:01get, you know, score points against Normie Democrats.
- 51:03And it's super depressing. There's no other word for it.
- 51:06I cuz I do respect these people but this is not the answer, I
- 51:09think. Yeah, the interesting thing is
- 51:11talked about yesterday to is this strategy of bringing these
- 51:14people into look through your files.
- 51:16It's okay. To let you know, I don't It's
- 51:19journalistically appropriate to only do it for two, but if
- 51:21you're going to let people look through your internal
- 51:22Communications but musk has a legal responsibility to protect
- 51:26user data. So if we continue down this path
- 51:29where now Taibbi and Weiss and they're kind of political those
- 51:34kinds of political actors are able to go look through user
- 51:37data than musk is in the world of hurt and adjust.
- 51:39While we're recording this, it was announced something I
- 51:41predicted yesterday has happened which is Irish data protection
- 51:44commission, is now looking into what kind of access Barry Weiss
- 51:46had because having access to these Internal interfaces is
- 51:50exactly the thing that got Twitter and trouble over and
- 51:53over again because outside hackers or people who are
- 51:56working for the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, had access to user data.
- 52:00And so Twitter has agreements with the FTC to not allow random
- 52:04people to get access to Twitter user data.
- 52:07And they have such agreements with the Irish TPC, which is the
- 52:10most important regulator for them and what sort of data in
- 52:12specific is the most sensitive. I mean, DMS obviously, but, like
- 52:16outside of that, what do you think is of major concern to
- 52:18regulators? So in the u.s.
- 52:20DMS for sure because that is the only data for which there's like
- 52:24a straight black letter law. That Twitter is responsible for
- 52:27something called the stored Communications act, which is a
- 52:29pretty old law was signed by Ronald Reagan, it really was
- 52:33meant to apply to the phone companies and very early email
- 52:36systems but the stored Communications act 18, USC 2702,
- 52:40specifically says that if you have, if you're a holder of
- 52:44stored Communications of people, you cannot release it to anybody
- 52:47except under certain In circumstances, and we're having
- 52:51a lot of fun for the LOLs is not turns out, not in the law,
- 52:54Ronald Reagan signed that you can't, you can't release SCA
- 52:57cover material for trolling for the FTC is going to be a much
- 53:01broader set of IP address phone number.
- 53:04Anything that is non-public information is covered by the
- 53:06FTC consent decree, which already some of the stuff that's
- 53:09in the interfaces that Weiss looked at that.
- 53:12It's not clear. Whether Weiss was actually hands
- 53:14on keyboard or whether she was just looking over the shoulder.
- 53:17But in either case, Probably that was a violation.
- 53:20The FTC consent decree. This can put journalists on a
- 53:23weird side here where we're going to be rooting or at least
- 53:26some of us are going to be rooting for reporters.
- 53:29Quote on quote, to get in trouble for violating Twitter's
- 53:32data security. So, there's a difference between
- 53:35Elite email between employees or a document inside and user data,
- 53:39right? And for the most part, when you
- 53:40talk about like the Facebook files and such of situations
- 53:43where journalists have cheered leaks, those are generally
- 53:47internal correspondence between Tween employees.
- 53:50That at least, where I saw were generally, those journalists
- 53:53were then, very careful to take out any pii.
- 53:57But in this case like I think like, the fear is that the next
- 54:01step of like musk on this path is, he's just going to let these
- 54:04people get access to DMS and he does.
- 54:06So he is just straight black letter, not only be federal law,
- 54:09lunacy, I mean we yeah, I mean I love the stuff that's happening
- 54:13today. We would say was a month, right?
- 54:15Well I mean, you know, the legal parameters around what Twitter
- 54:19Be doing is already getting brittle because we saw Elon very
- 54:24publicly fire was named James Baker.
- 54:26The, the company's was it associate general counsel or
- 54:29when I like the high up treating, sorry.
- 54:31Deputy general counsel who I believe was vetting these
- 54:33documents around the time that, you know, Barry Weiss was
- 54:36looking at them. And this was depicted as some
- 54:38sort of Nefarious act where I imagine imagine his argument
- 54:42this is James Baker's argument is like we're about to dump a
- 54:44whole bunch of internal shit here.
- 54:46I think I'd want to know whether or not this is going to be in
- 54:48violation. Of federal statutory lines.
- 54:50Just like, I didn't know you worked for me like, you know,
- 54:52like that's sort of builds his credibility.
- 54:56It's I mean, it was that it's one of his top Warriors if not
- 54:59top lawyer and the and Elon doesn't know who they might have
- 55:02been, what did I mean? There's no general counsel.
- 55:04So, apparently his personal lawyer who I am.
- 55:07Shocked Quinn Emanuel still has him as an employee, but I guess
- 55:10he's created a huge amount of litigation business 4qe, but
- 55:13apparently his personal lawyers, effectively the GC now and I
- 55:17don't know how the GC would not know who their deputy.
- 55:19Don't councils were generally expect considering Baker's
- 55:22background. I don't know him.
- 55:23I don't know exactly what he did, but every tech companies
- 55:26got somebody like that who came from either like the National
- 55:28Security division of doj or FBI because when you operate the
- 55:33scale you get legal requests from governments around the
- 55:36world continuously. And so you need an entire legal
- 55:38department, the thinks about those things.
- 55:40And so, yes, I guarantee. One of the things in baker's,
- 55:42internal analysis would be. We have sca ekkuva, as well as
- 55:47FTC and Irish. And protection commission
- 55:50commitments that we need to follow when doing this and like
- 55:53oh that's a bunch of legal gobbledygook, you're fired
- 55:55right? So I mean, you can YOLO through
- 55:57this, but the truth is when he bought Twitter, Twitter was
- 56:00already had already twice made a deal with the FTC so he
- 56:05purchased a company that is already kind of under consent.
- 56:09Decree that has been looked over by a federal judge, his ability
- 56:12to fight any of this was effectively already given away
- 56:15by previous administrations of Twitter that's part of the
- 56:18liability. He purchased so if he thinks he
- 56:21can just be like, oh, it's a reset because I bought it.
- 56:24That's not how any of this works.
- 56:25And more importantly, the baker is on the same day.
- 56:28His chief information security officer Chief compliance
- 56:31officer, and Chief privacy officer all resigned, and that
- 56:34happened to be the day that they were supposed to sign a letter
- 56:37to the FTC. So, I think it is highly likely.
- 56:40There's already a quiet FTC investigation going on because
- 56:43Twitter already missed a deadline, under their consent
- 56:45decree and all of the people that the FTC used to integrate
- 56:48used to work, With to make sure that Twitter was protecting user
- 56:51data are gone and if you violate the terms of your consent,
- 56:55decree, I mean, what are the penalties for that?
- 56:57Is it a fine? Is it, you know, you lose your
- 57:00you're tweeting license? Like what exactly happens.
- 57:03I mean, believe the only things I've ever heard of is FTC can
- 57:05find you, but the amount they can do.
- 57:07So could be pretty significant. Yo, the largest right now is 5
- 57:10billion to Facebook to Facebook, that was nothing five billion
- 57:13dollars to Twitter, which is now losing two to three billion
- 57:15dollars a year. Probably would be disaster
- 57:17illness. That would that would be More
- 57:19than that. I mean, five billion dollars
- 57:20would be more than all the cash equivalents.
- 57:22All the liquid wealth of Twitter.
- 57:24So if like the FTC matched, the Facebook fine musk would have to
- 57:27go sell Tesla stock. And then recapitalize the
- 57:30company to keep it a going concern are fines based on the
- 57:33value of the company or fines based purely on sort of how
- 57:37egregious the infraction was. It is based upon the politics
- 57:41and the negotiation and the judge and it is where it is
- 57:45based on the size of the companies in Europe.
- 57:47And there are limits to how much you can.
- 57:49Fine. But also, they could be ordered
- 57:50to cease operations in Europe. That would be a possibility to
- 57:53get super reflective on this. I mean, I premise of the
- 57:56conversation going in is like, okay, we want to take them as
- 58:01seriously as possible. I mean, it's amazingly hard to
- 58:04actually engage with like the Elon Musk Camp directly.
- 58:08I'm elon's not out there, giving tough interviews and even like
- 58:11getting proxies for him is very difficult.
- 58:15You know we had Jason calacanis on, he wouldn't talk about it.
- 58:19So anyway, we started this conversation off with the
- 58:21premise that you know, we wanted to sort of take them seriously.
- 58:25I wanted to just raise like is that a mistake?
- 58:27Like do you think there's a point where we just need to sort
- 58:30of just stop taking them? So seriously if these arguments
- 58:34are so sloppy, yeah, I think you have to take must seriously
- 58:38because he has incredible power now, like his ability to shape
- 58:41the conversation in the middle American political class.
- 58:44He is now the most important person.
- 58:45Well, you don't have to take him as sincere.
- 58:47In fact, he gives a lot Of evidence.
- 58:49These not, he contradicts himself every other day.
- 58:52And yet, you see reporters sort of constantly taking him at his
- 58:56word. I don't know.
- 58:57At some level we have to say, somebody's not trustworthy,
- 59:01they're not straight forward. I think you're right musk, like
- 59:03it's hard to take him completely seriously.
- 59:05Now, even though he's got this girl power of more interesting
- 59:08to see mentioned calacanis, not being willing to engage on this.
- 59:12I'm putting down a marker. Now, the musk bubble in Tech is
- 59:15going to pop, right? That right now, it has become
- 59:18trendy Seen as counterculture to be seen on team musk and there's
- 59:21a bunch of people who people who I used to work with people who
- 59:24I've interacted with socially, who are smart serious, people
- 59:28who are now kind of waving the musk flag and just like with
- 59:32Trump, just like with FTX that bubble is going to pop and
- 59:35you're going to see all these people.
- 59:37All of a sudden try to rewrite history that they were just oh,
- 59:40you know. Yeah, I invested a little bit
- 59:41money or I gave him some suggestions because like musk is
- 59:44accelerating his kind of break down here and if you end up with
- 59:48Twitter, going out of business. Business him, having to give up
- 59:51the Twitter to the bond holders or that the debt holders.
- 59:55If you see him having to step down, as CEO as Tesla, if you
- 59:58see some kind of massive moment or, you know, if there's like a
- 1:00:02horrible violent act, that happens publicly.
- 1:00:04If there is God forbid, something of the level of a
- 1:00:07Christ Church shooting or something that gets attached
- 1:00:09back to musk's moderation decisions.
- 1:00:12All the sudden, all these people who thought it was really cool
- 1:00:15to be on team, musk are going to reverse themselves and so I hope
- 1:00:18people are taking Screenshots because you're right, it's just
- 1:00:21a very scary. Like, there's just scary impulse
- 1:00:24in the valley right now. Like a lot of what the New York
- 1:00:26Times wrote about people in Silicon Valley, in 2018 was, not
- 1:00:29that correct. But now, a bunch of things they
- 1:00:31said, then are now applying to 2022, right?
- 1:00:33About the politics of individuals, and the fact that
- 1:00:36he has become this Pied Piper for otherwise, serious people
- 1:00:40whose I've been to their house. I've had dinner with their
- 1:00:42family and now they've turned into, it feels in Silicon
- 1:00:45Valley, a little bit like in the, you know, after Trump was
- 1:00:48elected. The family's got kind of rivet
- 1:00:50right? It feels a little bit like that
- 1:00:51in the valley in that a bunch of otherwise, serious.
- 1:00:54Smart people are now in this kind of orbit and are going to
- 1:00:58have to it will be interesting to see when like calacanis being
- 1:01:02that quiet about it. I thought was the start like
- 1:01:04his, he's very smart about his Public Image and I think that is
- 1:01:07the start of an indication that people are going to start off.
- 1:01:10I took him as being quiet because anything he says gets
- 1:01:13the tribute to Ilan and then Eli gets mad at him.
- 1:01:15I always sort of saw it in the DMS, the text.
- 1:01:19Is yeah. Sorry the text messages were
- 1:01:21calcaneus is getting chided for being too loud.
- 1:01:23So I took it that way honestly, as much as we enjoy Jason I mean
- 1:01:28I feel like he's pretty much rolling over.
- 1:01:30I mean if you listen on all in he's not sort of Defending sort
- 1:01:34of the democratic line he's just sort of letting he's pretty Pro
- 1:01:38you oniy. I yeah I think he's he's very
- 1:01:40much sort of capitulated to his co-hosts who love sort of the
- 1:01:44musk party and love to shit on Democrats right now.
- 1:01:48I mean, By the way, if I were an editor, the idea that, you know,
- 1:01:52Ilan is the new Trump when it comes to dividing families and
- 1:01:54Silicon Valley, and the uncomfortable conversation have
- 1:01:56the table. Excellent story.
- 1:01:59Yeah, just threw that smart. That's very smart.
- 1:02:02The New York Times wasn't on a strike.
- 1:02:03They could write that it's the perfect New York Times style
- 1:02:06section story. These always want to be
- 1:02:08Optimist. I mean that's they feel like I
- 1:02:10mean it's been a winner to be Pro.
- 1:02:12He Lon, you know I mean I'm Marc Andreessen was somewhat
- 1:02:15defensive role of Elizabeth Holmes for a period like If you
- 1:02:19like the positioning over and over again has just been defend
- 1:02:22sort of crazy Optimist. Well in in driessen's, one of
- 1:02:26those guys, I'm very distant, very sad about because I used to
- 1:02:28work for him at loud Cloud. I reported to him on the board.
- 1:02:32I'm an LP and Andreessen Horowitz.
- 1:02:33I get a K1 every year from him and he blocked me on Twitter and
- 1:02:37then was subtweeting me last night and is gone.
- 1:02:40Kind of full. What's the deal?
- 1:02:41I mean, we're a difference. Is that with Marc Andreessen?
- 1:02:44What's the deal? I mean he's never been the most
- 1:02:47kind of empathetic guy like one of my first - Marc Andreessen
- 1:02:51moments was after I joined loud Cloud.
- 1:02:53It was during the dot bomb and we were doing a layoff and Ben
- 1:02:56Horowitz who actually is, like, who he says he is, was up there
- 1:03:01in tears talking to the company about how he had to lay people
- 1:03:04off. And how horrible was to do this
- 1:03:06to the family, but it was necessary to move forward.
- 1:03:09And Mark was over on the side on his BlackBerry typing out, an
- 1:03:12email like, not even paying attention, right?
- 1:03:14And I was like, that's the difference between bedded Mark
- 1:03:17and so, yeah. I mean, he's never He's I think
- 1:03:19he's one of the things is that money is disconnected from the
- 1:03:22world. Like he lives in like a palace
- 1:03:24and Atherton with high walls. And I don't know if you saw but
- 1:03:27you know, he was part of the group trying to keep a yeah.
- 1:03:30The whole episode about that. Yeah.
- 1:03:32We're we were very interested about house.
- 1:03:33Yeah. Three million dollars per condo
- 1:03:35right like cheap housing which is they have to have to hire
- 1:03:39round-the-clock security now because there are, you know,
- 1:03:41people moving in low-rent people moving into Atherton.
- 1:03:44It's pretty dangerous. Hell yeah.
- 1:03:45And so he's I think like, you know, there's these people in
- 1:03:47the valley to me that The moment at which you start to completely
- 1:03:50lose touch is when you have enough money to fly private,
- 1:03:53that that's like the last situation in which you ever have
- 1:03:56to mix with normal people is like an airport and so if you're
- 1:03:59like going in a armored SUV to the airport and you're flying
- 1:04:03private and you're going to Davos and you never have to kind
- 1:04:06of interact in normal people. There's a bunch of people in the
- 1:04:08valley who are at that level and they're making that their
- 1:04:11ideology. You know, Balaji is out there.
- 1:04:13Don't give interviews don't reply to comment, you know,
- 1:04:15they, they sort of convince themselves that not engagement.
- 1:04:19It's sort of principled. And so, then they make their
- 1:04:22sort of self-isolation complete. I don't know, I just wish they'd
- 1:04:27communicate an essay format. Like, I feel like for people who
- 1:04:30claim to be so smart that all their arguments emerge in like,
- 1:04:34tweets is just there's also like an inability to like accept the
- 1:04:38L. I mean, you saw that after the
- 1:04:40midterms, you know, the people that were the loudest in terms
- 1:04:43of you know woke people are destroying America that campaign
- 1:04:46tactic didn't work nearly as well as you would have expected
- 1:04:48it. To and instead of saying, hey,
- 1:04:50maybe we should recalibrate because our viewpoints aren't as
- 1:04:52popular as we thought they were you know they just avoid the
- 1:04:55topic right? I know the midterms, it felt
- 1:04:57like a moment where ya in Silicon Valley, sort of the
- 1:05:00sense that the based crowd or the you know these meme warriors
- 1:05:05were going to like win. It just seemed totally out of
- 1:05:07touch with an America that clearly was very worried about
- 1:05:11Normie lib stuff. Yeah, to zoom back at the
- 1:05:14midterms. I think the positive thing here
- 1:05:15is that, finally, a significant part of the profession Holcomb
- 1:05:19party is starting to understand that telling your voters that
- 1:05:24voting is rigged that voting early is a bad idea that they
- 1:05:27should not. You know, Kerry Lake was telling
- 1:05:29people not to put their ballot in the backup box if the local
- 1:05:33scanner that kind of stuff is going to become dispositive in
- 1:05:36these elections where it's 15 or 20,000 rights.
- 1:05:39And so that is the what I think that positive thing that came
- 1:05:42out of the midterms was that finally people are figured out
- 1:05:46election denialism is actually in a democracy.
- 1:05:48Is a losing, you can fight it but in the long run it is a
- 1:05:51losing battle because you're telling people to be politically
- 1:05:54disconnect and also you know just to bring this back to the
- 1:05:57Twitter files, you know. I think if these stories you
- 1:06:00know or the revelations do not end up getting the purchase and
- 1:06:03reach that they were hoping to because they decided to they
- 1:06:06being Elon Musk and that whole crowd decided to completely
- 1:06:09circumvent, you know, the mainstream media's role in, you
- 1:06:12know, the national discussion, then maybe you should think, you
- 1:06:15know, they're not exactly, always going to be the enemy and
- 1:06:19You have to at least position this in a somewhat neutral way
- 1:06:22that you know the broader public at least as far as the broader
- 1:06:25public, that reads the mainstream media will want to
- 1:06:27engage in this stuff. So you know, if you guys didn't
- 1:06:29end up getting what you wanted, through all of this, maybe some
- 1:06:32self-reflection would be in order.
- 1:06:33Are you surprised the Marc Andreessen still on the Facebook
- 1:06:36or I am but you'll Peter teal made it to do.
- 1:06:41You think it's just being a loyalist is great and why we
- 1:06:44must get rid of somebody else just like even though like
- 1:06:47clearly and Driessen disagrees with Zuckerberg on how he's
- 1:06:50governing that at least he's like super differential, right?
- 1:06:54Like is up, I think in the situations in which the board
- 1:06:59could have put some controls on zaku.
- 1:07:01There, been multiple situations in which such as ask the board
- 1:07:04to kind of stamp his corporate here.
- 1:07:06The creation of ultra voting shares, like that, after such an
- 1:07:10incident. Yes.
- 1:07:12Yeah. So in whatever they disagree
- 1:07:14with politically, you're right, and every situation were duck
- 1:07:18needed. His vote.
- 1:07:18Vote. He got his vote.
- 1:07:20So yeah, I think at this point, he never sucked isn't get rid of
- 1:07:24him unless he does something like, teal, go.
- 1:07:26So politically outside. But what what's happened is?
- 1:07:29Unfortunately, the board is much more subservient to suck than it
- 1:07:32was during my day. Like there were really
- 1:07:34independent directors Erskine Bowles, you know, for example
- 1:07:39who ask lots of questions and such and I feel like the
- 1:07:42Facebook board has become a rubber stamp which is, you know,
- 1:07:45I mean the upside for Zack is He'll see looks incredible in
- 1:07:51the fuck compared to like, like the bar has been set, low solo
- 1:07:54bike, like the fact that he is not, you know, personally,
- 1:07:57trolling people that he has structural kind of is an
- 1:08:02oversight board. Suck has has an oversight board
- 1:08:05and other internal structures for making decisions that he
- 1:08:08isn't out there personally going back and forth, back and forth
- 1:08:10on things, makes it look really good and it makes the, you know,
- 1:08:13people thought the oversight board was a crazy idea.
- 1:08:15He duck hated being the guy that was just Possible for Content
- 1:08:18moderation so much. He spent two hundred million
- 1:08:20dollars to build this oversight board, and then musk spent forty
- 1:08:24four billion dollars to become the guy that tried to get out of
- 1:08:27right. Very well, here's my last
- 1:08:29question and we can, you know, try to spin it forward or at
- 1:08:32least as broadly as possible. Is there anything that can be
- 1:08:36learned about concept moderation, by the other
- 1:08:38platforms by the debacle that has been playing out here in
- 1:08:42terms of elon's approach to moderation, is there something
- 1:08:45that can be said at least reaffirming those?
- 1:08:46Who felt that? Linking content.
- 1:08:49Oversight board is Meaningful. You know the dialogue between
- 1:08:52platforms and countries which, you know, I think that's a
- 1:08:54fascinating thing that not enough people have written
- 1:08:56about, I don't know, just try to give me some sort of optimism
- 1:08:59about a positive outcome from, you know, the implosion that
- 1:09:03we're witnessing here, I think. I think the lesson has been that
- 1:09:08having procedural mechanisms around content moderation, where
- 1:09:12you set a standard and then you have a bunch of smart people
- 1:09:15argue about whether certain content violates that standard
- 1:09:17or not. Not while that seems like the
- 1:09:20worst way to do it is the worst way to do content moderation,
- 1:09:23except all the others, right? It has demonstrated, that there
- 1:09:25is a real value to not create a situation where lobbying one
- 1:09:29person is responsible at traditionally, Twitter's smear
- 1:09:33this responsibility over dozens of folks, none of whom could
- 1:09:36that be said. This person is responsible for
- 1:09:38what happens because I don't think musk understands the
- 1:09:41people. He's dealing with our there's
- 1:09:43going to be violence right. There is going to be violence,
- 1:09:46tied to the speech that is happening on.
- 1:09:48Litter. That is a constant challenge of
- 1:09:50balancing, real world, violent Impact versus trying to protect
- 1:09:54political speech. And he's gone very hard to one
- 1:09:56side and that violence will be personally if not legally
- 1:09:59attached to him morally attached and it might be legally to Ask
- 1:10:02Resources case Gonzalez in the Supreme Court, where effectively
- 1:10:05section 230 protections around certain kind of violent acts,
- 1:10:09that are encouraged by platforms, would be attached to
- 1:10:12the platforms, as a responsibility.
- 1:10:14And so like he right now, he's got some section 230 protections
- 1:10:17but it might not make it past the Supreme Court especially
- 1:10:20when Republicans are in favor of repealing section.
- 1:10:22Well, as the nuclear option about the, do you think, do you
- 1:10:27think we will see any legislation?
- 1:10:29I mean, do you think I mean we could solve this transparency
- 1:10:32problem instead of just leak, you know, selectively leaking
- 1:10:35then? Yes.
- 1:10:36Yeah. Do you think they'll be a
- 1:10:37legislation, right? So my, I mean, my colleague make
- 1:10:39personally has put out a platform transparency, act that
- 1:10:42has gotten bipartisan co-sponsors, so I'd love maybe.
- 1:10:46This is an opportunity. I'd love to see.
- 1:10:48Support required transparency. That he could, he could
- 1:10:51voluntarily do it but then it gets back stopped by law that
- 1:10:54his competitors have to have transparency for the most part.
- 1:10:56I don't think they'll be regulation in the US.
- 1:10:58This will be what we most important for Twitter is going
- 1:11:00to be FTC now, right? Like they're pretty clearly in
- 1:11:03violation of their consent decree, whether they can cure
- 1:11:05that or end up getting fine, will be an interesting question.
- 1:11:08And then in Europe, Twitter is now the number one target of the
- 1:11:11general Services act. The Europeans are so happy
- 1:11:14because they wanted. What would happen would fail to
- 1:11:17GDP are They didn't beat somebody up on the first day of
- 1:11:19prison, right? So like GPR was this real slow
- 1:11:22burn where they tried to make, they wanted to punish a Facebook
- 1:11:26or Google, but for a bunch of procedural reasons, they weren't
- 1:11:29able to do so quickly, but DSA I think now that he is acting.
- 1:11:33So kind of out of the norm and he's also fired all the people
- 1:11:37that would normally fight the TSA for him.
- 1:11:39I know everybody wants to make this about the Democratic party
- 1:11:42but then we've got the Europeans over there who are you to the
- 1:11:45left of the Democrats, right? Right?
- 1:11:48Well as easy as Elon would say popcorn Emoji popcorn Emoji.
- 1:11:51Anyway Alex, thank you so much for coming on.
- 1:11:54Yeah, thanks this is great. Thanks for doing this, Alex,
- 1:11:56thanks guys, have the right? Goodbye, goodbye.
- 1:12:11Goodbye goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye.