Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / The Price of the Electric Mile
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome to the Deep Dive. Today we're cutting through one
- 0:13of the biggest economic questions facing drivers right
- 0:17now, the real cost of going electric.
- 0:20We always hear that EVs are cheaper to run.
- 0:23That's really only half the story, isn't.
- 0:24It it is, to really get it, you need the whole financial
- 0:27picture, the total cost of ownership or TCO from, you know,
- 0:31what you pay per mile all the way back to that big number on
- 0:33the sticker. Exactly.
- 0:34So to get that full picture, we've pulled together a really
- 0:37focused stack of sources for this deep dive.
- 0:40We've got a detailed analysis from Zeta on US operating costs,
- 0:44a look at international efficiency metrics, specifically
- 0:47from the UK, and a huge report from the IEA, the International
- 0:50Energy Agency, which covers global affordability trends and
- 0:55crucially, those initial purchase prices.
- 0:57And our mission here is to basically take all that data and
- 1:00just distill it for you. We want to give you a clear side
- 1:02by side understanding of that TCO.
- 1:04So separating the daily running costs from that, well that
- 1:07initial price barrier. Precisely because we're going to
- 1:10see that barrier is still the main gatekeeper to mass
- 1:13adoption, and it looks very different depending on where you
- 1:16are in the world. OK, let's unpack this.
- 1:18Let's jump straight into those immediate costs, starting with
- 1:20fueling the Zeta report on the US market.
- 1:24It hits you right away with this just an astonishing number.
- 1:28It says that nationally, gas powered cars can cost up to four
- 1:31and 1/2 times more to drive per mile than EVs. 4 1/2 times.
- 1:36It's a staggering figure. It really is.
- 1:38That suggests the daily savings are just.
- 1:42They are. And you know, the reason for
- 1:44that massive saving goes beyond just comparing gas and
- 1:47electricity prices. What's really fascinating here
- 1:49is the issue of price stability. OK, gasoline prices are, well,
- 1:53they're fundamentally volatile. They're tied to global oil
- 1:56markets, geopolitical events. When the price of oil spikes,
- 1:59you feel it at the pump instantly.
- 2:02But EVs run on domestically produced electricity.
- 2:05And if you look at the Zeta data, especially that 12 month
- 2:08period between March 2022 and 2023, you see it so clearly.
- 2:12What did? They find gas prices were all
- 2:14over the place, spiking up. Meanwhile, the average cost of
- 2:18electricity remarkably stable. It gives you a predictable
- 2:22expense you can budget for. And that predictability is
- 2:25almost as valuable as the saving itself for a household or a
- 2:29business. It really is.
- 2:30And it doesn't stop there. The savings go beyond the plug,
- 2:33right? Well, I'm thinking about
- 2:34maintenance. We saw data from Consumer
- 2:36Reports suggesting EV drivers can save between what, 1800 and
- 2:40$2600 a year? Per year.
- 2:42And that saving is well, it's structural.
- 2:45An EV motor might have, say, 20 moving parts.
- 2:48An internal combustion engine has thousands.
- 2:50Thousands. So you just eliminate oil
- 2:52changes, transmission fluid, spark plugs, belts, even your
- 2:56brakes last longer because of regenerative braking.
- 2:58And to make that tangible, the Zeta report had a great real
- 3:01world example for the US market, the Ford F-150.
- 3:05A perfect comparison. The gas powered F-150's
- 3:07operating cost per mile is about $0.15, So dollar 0.1496.
- 3:13Now compare that to the electric F-150 Lightning.
- 3:16It cost just over six cents a mile.
- 3:18Wow, so less than half the cost to run every single day?
- 3:22Exactly. But that that figure, just over
- 3:25six cents a mile, it sounds incredible, but we have to talk
- 3:29about the TCO, the total cost of ownership.
- 3:31Big picture. Right.
- 3:33If that F-150 Lightning has a much higher sticker price, how
- 3:36long does it actually take for those savings to pay off that
- 3:40initial premium? Are you waiting five years just
- 3:42to break even? That is the critical question
- 3:44and you know it complicates the calculation because it's
- 3:47different for every buyer, every region, what incentives are
- 3:50available. But that daily running cost
- 3:52difference is so huge that the break even point is moving
- 3:56forward really, really fast. Most analysis now put the EV
- 4:01ahead on TCO within the first few years, sometimes as little
- 4:04as three years. So the fuel and maintenance
- 4:07savings just accelerate that break even point dramatically.
- 4:10And that pattern holds up even when you look at different parts
- 4:13of the country, which is fascinating because, you know,
- 4:15energy prices are all over the map in the US.
- 4:17The report looked at the Tesla Model 3 in a high cost state
- 4:21like California. It's about $0.10 a mile.
- 4:24OK, still pretty good. But then you go to a state with
- 4:26cheaper gas like Missouri. The Tesla still way way cheaper
- 4:30at under $0.05 a mile right? The efficiency advantage is just
- 4:33so massive it outweighs those local price fluctuations.
- 4:36So the evidence for lower running costs is just it's
- 4:39overwhelming. The magnitude of the savings
- 4:42might change state to state, but the saving is always there.
- 4:45Always there. OK.
- 4:46So the US cost savings are clear, but that cost per mile is
- 4:50obviously tied to efficiency. Now, if we look over at our UK
- 4:54source, it gives us a really helpful way to think about EV
- 4:58efficiency if you're used to, you know, miles per gallon.
- 5:01We need to do that because comparing electricity usage can
- 5:04be confusing. The key metric you need to know
- 5:06is miles per kWh or MPKWH. The electric version of MPG.
- 5:11Exactly. Just think of it that way.
- 5:12The higher the number the better.
- 5:14And once you know that you can figure out your true cost per
- 5:17mile. You just take what you pay for a
- 5:19kWh of electricity and divide it by your car MPKWH.
- 5:24Simple enough, but it gets complicated when you look at how
- 5:27they even get those efficiency numbers right.
- 5:29They're using this European WLTP test data.
- 5:33Right. And that data can look a bit
- 5:35technical. The example in our source was an
- 5:37Audi E Tron. It uses 234 Watt hours per
- 5:41kilometer. Which means nothing to me.
- 5:43To most people, but they use a formula to convert that into
- 5:47something useful, which in this case was about 2.6 MPKREWH.
- 5:51OK. But what's fascinating is that
- 5:53even those clinical looking WLTP numbers include two factors that
- 5:58affect the real cost you pay. Oh, this is interesting.
- 6:01What are they? First, they factor in energy
- 6:03loss during charging. When you plug your car in, some
- 6:06energy is just lost. His heat maybe 5 up to 15%.
- 6:10It never even makes it into the battery.
- 6:11Wait so if I'm charging in my garage I'm literally paying for
- 6:14heat that doesn't move my car? Exactly.
- 6:16You are paying for the process of charging, not just the energy
- 6:19that gets stored. Wow.
- 6:21OK. What's the second factor?
- 6:22It's the difference between the gross battery capacity, the
- 6:25advertised size, say 95 kilowatt hours, and the actual usable
- 6:30capacity, which might be a bit lower, like 86.5 for that E
- 6:33Tron. So you pay to charge the whole
- 6:35thing, but you only get the range from the smaller usable
- 6:39part. Precisely.
- 6:40The inefficiency is baked in, and yet the savings still hold
- 6:44up. Right.
- 6:45Despite all those variables, the UK data still confirms that EV
- 6:48fuel costs are generally 2 to 4 times lower than gas or diesel.
- 6:54So the daily savings argument is absolutely settled globally.
- 6:57It is. But, and this is the big one,
- 7:00here's where it gets really interesting, We have to pivot
- 7:03from that low daily cost to the massive initial hit.
- 7:06The sticker price, the sticker price, that initial purchase
- 7:08price is still the single biggest barrier.
- 7:11A 2023 European Commission survey identified it as the key
- 7:15obstacle. I mean if you can't afford the
- 7:17down payment, TCO doesn't matter.
- 7:18It's totally irrelevant at that point, but globally
- 7:20affordability is improving and it's driven by two big things.
- 7:24First, battery pack prices. They fell by more than 25% in
- 7:282024 alone. That is huge.
- 7:31Second, you have intense specifying market competition,
- 7:33finally forcing some real economies of scale.
- 7:36And this is where we see those stark regional differences.
- 7:38You mentioned it's not happening evenly everywhere.
- 7:41Not at all. Let's start with the China case
- 7:42study. I mean it's just mind blowing
- 7:44they are the a global leader here.
- 7:46What's happening there? In 2024, the median price
- 7:49someone paid for a brand new battery electric car was
- 7:53actually less than what they paid for a conventional gas
- 7:56powered car. Hold on, cheaper to buy
- 7:58outright, not just cheaper to run overtime.
- 8:00Cheaper to buy on day one. That changes the entire
- 8:03conversation. There is no break even period to
- 8:06worry about. That's a total game changer.
- 8:08It is, and that affordability is driving saturation.
- 8:11Get this nearly 95% of all small car sales in China are now
- 8:16electric. The entry barrier is gone.
- 8:18Unbelievable. So let's contrast that with,
- 8:20well, with US, Europe and the US, the premium gap.
- 8:24Why are Western automakers so far behind China's model?
- 8:27It seems to be a mix of things, but the main driver is legacy
- 8:30automakers protecting their high profit margins in Germany and
- 8:34the UK. Affordability has stalled car
- 8:36makers focused on high end premium EVs to get their
- 8:39development costs back. In Germany, a small Bev still
- 8:43had a 45% price premium over its gas equivalent in 2024. 45%,
- 8:49that's a huge hurdle. It's a wall, and part of it is
- 8:52that US and European brands have these massive existing profit
- 8:55streams from gas trucks and SUV. They're hesitant to undercut
- 8:59their own bestsellers. But that's going to have to
- 9:01change, right it? Is new EU CO2 standards are
- 9:05coming and they're expected to force the launch of models under
- 9:07€25,000 by 2026, so a pivot is coming to Europe.
- 9:11And the US situation looks pretty similar to Europe's, very
- 9:14focused on high end trucks and SUV's.
- 9:17Even with things like the Tesla price cuts, the market is still
- 9:20so skewed. Heavily skewed Our sources show
- 9:23that in 2024 there were only two Bev models priced below $30,000.
- 9:28Only two. Compared to more than 50 gas
- 9:30powered models in that same affordable range.
- 9:33And the pipeline doesn't look much better.
- 9:35Most announced American Bevs coming by 2026 are still priced
- 9:40over $50,000. It's a huge affordability chasm,
- 9:44and that gap is creating an opportunity for disruption in
- 9:46other markets. Let's look at Thailand.
- 9:48What's the story there? Chinese car makers are moving in
- 9:51aggressively. In 2024, the average price of a
- 9:54Chinese EV in Thailand was already lower than the average
- 9:58price of a conventional car. So they're just repeating their
- 10:01strategy from home. Exactly, and that competition
- 10:04immediately shrank the Bev price premium for the entire Thai
- 10:07market down to below 5%. Competition is forcing the
- 10:11change. Which brings us to the future.
- 10:13What about things like taxes? Governments are going to lose
- 10:16all that fuel tax revenue. A great point, and we have a
- 10:19source on that referencing the UK's proposed paper mile charge
- 10:22for EVs. It's set to start in April 2028.
- 10:25A road use tax, essentially. Right.
- 10:27And the proposal is for about 3 pence per mile for electric
- 10:30vehicles. Now, it's important to put that
- 10:32number in context for you. A new tax sounds bad, but let's
- 10:35compare. Based on average mileage, that
- 10:38new tax would cost an EV driver about £243 a year.
- 10:43OK, crucially, that's still less than half of the £600 a typical
- 10:48gas or diesel driver pays in fuel duty right now.
- 10:52So even with future taxes factored in, the operating cost
- 10:55advantage for EVs remains significant.
- 10:57It seems baked in. The mechanism might shift, but
- 11:00the savings for the driver are projected to stay substantial.
- 11:03Which really brings us to the final provocative thought for
- 11:05you to consider. After all this, the economic
- 11:08case for EVs based on TCO and running costs is pretty much
- 11:12settled. The only real barrier left is
- 11:14that upfront price, right? So given what we see in China
- 11:17where EVs are already cheaper, and with regulations forcing a
- 11:20change in Europe, will that global market pressure finally
- 11:24force American and European automakers to pivot away from
- 11:27the high profit luxury models and finally prioritize the mass
- 11:31market affordability that truly unlocks full adoption?
- 11:34That is the perfect thought to chew on.
- 11:37The data shows the path is through that affordable entry
- 11:40point. It's just a question of who gets
- 11:42there first. Thank you for sharing these
- 11:45sources and helping us pull out these insights in this deep
- 11:48dive. My.
- 11:48Pleasure. And if you want more curated
- 11:50knowledge shortcuts just like this one, be sure to follow the
- 11:53channel. We'll see you on the next deep
- 11:55dive.