Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul #18: Expansion of Presidential Power and Controversies
Transcript
- 0:02Welcome back to the Politics with Paul podcast with your host, Paul Reeder.
- 0:08Today, we're gonna talk about expansion of US presidential power over the years and
- 0:14controversy surrounding it.
- 0:16So with Donald Trump soon to return to the presidency, one of his policies that he has
- 0:23indicate indicated he plans to institute as his first orders of business is the imposition of
- 0:30stricter tariffs on the likes of countries such as China, Canada, and Mexico.
- 0:36And there's also been speculation that Trump could try to appoint key cabinet posts during a
- 0:42US senate recess, and the recesses were the US senate is out of session and back in their home
- 0:49districts.
- 0:50It can happen during a session.
- 0:51It can happen between sessions as well.
- 0:54And the significance of that is that the US senate provides advice and consent, as the
- 1:00constitution puts it, on various appointments the president makes, ultimately having final
- 1:06say on whether these appointees are confirmed.
- 1:09But during a recess, a president would be making this appointment without advice and
- 1:14consent from the US Senate.
- 1:17Now discussions like these ultimately highlight an ongoing debate about how much power the
- 1:24president can and should have to act unilaterally in various situations.
- 1:30That is whether he can bypass congress to enact certain policies or appoint certain people, and
- 1:36that has a lot of implications for checks and balances and separation of powers, which are
- 1:41hallmarks of the American system of government.
- 1:45So today, we're going to cover how presidential power has expanded over time and the
- 1:51controversies that surround said expansion.
- 1:54So let's dive into it.
- 1:57Now first, it makes sense to start with the framers and how they debated the presidency.
- 2:04Sometimes the framers of the constitution are erroneously assumes that they came together for
- 2:10the good of all, and they put aside all their differences and and debated everything like
- 2:15gentlemen and and and put their political biases aside, and that's that's not what
- 2:21happened at all.
- 2:22In fact, the constitutional convention threatened to fold several times due to intense
- 2:26bickering, and not every founding father was a framer of the constitution.
- 2:30Some were adamantly opposed to it and wanted to stick with the articles of confederation.
- 2:35In fact, there's a lot of them thought the constitution was illegal, illegal, shredding
- 2:44basically of the articles of confederation, but that's a whole other thing for another day.
- 2:51But the presidency was perhaps the biggest source of debates when the framers of the
- 2:57constitution got together to debate the new form of government.
- 3:00Not necessarily that they had given a whole lot of thought beforehand.
- 3:02Even James Madison, who is often considered the father of the constitution when he roached
- 3:08George Washington, one time, there was he even admitted that he hadn't thought a whole lot
- 3:15about it.
- 3:16But during the debates, it was a very, it was one of the bigger debates within the whole
- 3:26debate about the US constitution.
- 3:28Not not just about how much power should be divided between federal and state governments,
- 3:33which was a very key overall issue with the constitution, but how much power should be
- 3:39invested in this new chief executive.
- 3:43And, of course, there was some hesitation to provide a certain amount of power to one person
- 3:48due to American experiences under British rule with King George the 3rd.
- 3:54Even those who supported having a vigorous executive much more than what they had under
- 3:59the articles of Confederation, they didn't agree on what exactly a vigorous executive
- 4:05would look like.
- 4:06And some of the proposals that were discussed were, should there be 1 president or should
- 4:10there be 3 presidents, sort of like a triumvirate, sort of like with, Roman history
- 4:16during the time of Julius Caesar or Caesar, depending on who you ask.
- 4:22For 1 president, the idea the general idea was more decisive action.
- 4:27When 3 presidents, the idea was more deliberative action.
- 4:31Obviously, we ended up with 1 president.
- 4:34Should the president be directly or indirectly related, Some of the framers argued for direct
- 4:40election, which some people today also argue for.
- 4:44Some felt that that direct election was excessive democracy, not necessarily because
- 4:48people were stupid or easily given to, local biases or anything like that.
- 4:58So some some of them felt that way, but some of the framers were also concerned about, you
- 5:03know, back in that time, information flowed very, very, very slowly, and they were some of
- 5:12them were just concerned that there wouldn't be informed decision about a chief executive who
- 5:19was going to be so far away from the people, whereas the more local and state level
- 5:24representatives, there are closer information about them came more quickly, and they can make
- 5:30more informed decisions about that.
- 5:33And then there was discussions about whether a president should be elected by the people,
- 5:37period, not even indirectly.
- 5:39Now, obviously, it led to the electoral college where people decide through the states on a
- 5:45form of indirect election.
- 5:47And then, also, what should the executive even be named?
- 5:51Obviously, became president of the United States.
- 5:55Now, ultimately, what they came up with was article 2 of the constitution.
- 6:00So the presidency heads the executive branch of the government, and the executive branch, it
- 6:05executes laws.
- 6:06It enforces laws whereas legislative branch legislative branch, excuse me, which is where
- 6:12congress is, they write the laws, and then the Supreme Court interprets the laws.
- 6:18The federal courts that in overall interpret the laws.
- 6:22So article 2 focuses on the executive branch, and section 1 talks about presidency b
- 6:28presidency being 4 years.
- 6:29The 12th amendment was later on added, which made the president and vice president the same
- 6:35ticket, sets the eligibility requirements for presidents, and then also the 25th amendment
- 6:41got added later to clearly denote the succession to the presidency if the president
- 6:47dies or resigns or is impeached.
- 6:51Section 2 makes them the commander in chief.
- 6:54They they can make treaties with 2 thirds of support or 2 thirds of the US senate present.
- 7:01They can also employ ambassadors, supreme court judges, and other officers of the u US and fill
- 7:09vacancies during senate recess under the end of their next session.
- 7:14And that's going to be, a big part of what we talk about today because we're just talking
- 7:19about appointments during the recess of the US senate.
- 7:24Section 3 talks about state of the union and how the president delivers 1.
- 7:28And then section 4 just prescribes how a president can be removed from office on
- 7:35impeachment for and conviction of treason, bribery, or other high crimes and misdemeanors.
- 7:42Now as with many provisions of the constitution, though, there has been some
- 7:47debate over time of what powers fell under these provisions, and we'll be talking about
- 7:52those in a little bit later on later on during this episode.
- 7:59Some of the presidents who have expanded the power and prestige of the presidency, Probably
- 8:06most presidents have wielded power and the prestige of the presidency in some meaningful
- 8:11way, but there are some presidents in particular that are highlighted by a consensus
- 8:16of history and political scholars, and we'll cover some of those here.
- 8:22But examples of presidents who are considered to have expanded presidential power and
- 8:27prestige in a considerable way, really, the first one to be credited as that kind of
- 8:34president was Andrew Jackson, who served from 18/29 to 18/37.
- 8:40He was the you could argue he was the first one to really make use of vetoes during his
- 8:46presidency where congress passes a law, president doesn't like it and says, nope.
- 8:50We're not doing that.
- 8:52He had 12 vetoes during his pres presidency more than his 6 predecessors combined.
- 8:57James Madison had, the most before then with 7.
- 9:01I believe it's James Madison.
- 9:03In particular, he thwarted infrastructure and national bank bills that were against his
- 9:09political philosophy.
- 9:10And he was really the first major example of a populist in American history casting himself as
- 9:17a champion of the people against congress and special interests.
- 9:21He was also very much a dominant figure over his cabinet, often forced out those who did not
- 9:29go along with what he wanted, and he also, challenged the Supreme Court's authority in
- 9:36particular by defying their ruling on Native Americans.
- 9:40He want to forcibly remove them from the lands they were on.
- 9:43Supreme court actually back then told him that he sort of do it, at least not the way he was
- 9:49going to do it, and he decided that he didn't need to listen to the supreme court and
- 9:54forcibly moved these Native Americans on what was known as the Trail of Tears.
- 9:59So, interjection, not not exactly a nice guy.
- 10:05But in any case, for the purposes of this podcast, he is really the first major example
- 10:12of a president who wielded the power of the office.
- 10:18Abraham Lincoln from 1861 to 1865, he during the civil war, he declared martial law and
- 10:29suspended habeas corpus in several states to try to stymie potential Confederate support
- 10:34during the civil war in places like Maryland, for example.
- 10:38Habeas corpus is the right of a person under arrest to appear in person before the courts to
- 10:45ensure they have not been falsely accused.
- 10:47And article 1, section 9 of the constitution says, privilege of the writ of habeas corpus
- 10:53shall not be suspended unless when in cases of rebellion or invasion, the public safety may
- 10:59require it.
- 11:01With the Civil War and the Confederate States in rebellion, Abraham Lincoln, in his view,
- 11:07that was the time to suspend habeas corpus.
- 11:10Now in retrospect, some people view that controversially, but for Lincoln, he saw the
- 11:18states at the the confederate states as in rebellion as opposed to being a separate
- 11:23country even though they had technically actually succeeded from the country.
- 11:29He saw them as still part of the country, but just rebellious.
- 11:33And some argued that Lincoln subverted the constitution, while others argued it was
- 11:38necessary during a rebellion when the nation's survival was at stake.
- 11:44Part of, you'll see a similar argument for a couple of the debates over presidential power
- 11:50that we're gonna highlight later on.
- 11:52But he also authorized a major expansion of the US military to combat the confederacy through
- 11:58proclamation 83.
- 12:00He also passed the executive order known as the Emancipation Proclamation and which freed
- 12:08slaves in the states that were in rebellion aka the South.
- 12:14Now it didn't really have all that much teeth, but it did help eventually lead to the 13th
- 12:20amendment, which actually did abolish slavery outright.
- 12:25And then after defeating the Confederacy in the civil war and while bringing them back into the
- 12:29union, the federal government was, used to carefully watch the South and influence their
- 12:35governments, and they ensured expansion of black suffrage.
- 12:39And a lot more Republicans got into federal, state, and local offices in the South.
- 12:43And back then, the South was extremely democratic.
- 12:47It was a very, very deep blue normally.
- 12:51And not long after Reconstruction ended, Republicans were kicked out of office, and over
- 12:5990% of offices would be won by by Democrats.
- 13:02Now Abraham Lincoln didn't live long into that time to see Reconstruction because he was
- 13:10assassinated shortly into the Reconstruction era by John Wilkes Booth.
- 13:15But Abraham Lincoln is another example of a president who really is highlighted as a
- 13:22president who expanded the power of the presidency or at least wielded power of their
- 13:27presidency in a very significant way.
- 13:30Then we've also got Teddy Roosevelt from 1901 to 1909.
- 13:35He really highlighted the presidency as a bully pulpit to speak directly to the people and
- 13:40influence congress to push an agenda.
- 13:42And he was also famous for his phrase, speak softly and carry a big stick.
- 13:48You will go far, which described his foreign policy where he directly engaged with foreign
- 13:53nations arguably much more than most previous presidents.
- 13:58But in short, you negotiate peacefully, but pose the threat of a large military.
- 14:04Woodrow Wilson, not long after him, 1913 to 1921.
- 14:09Woodrow Wilson was a Democrat, but he was a progressive activist like Republicans William
- 14:14Taft before him and Teddy Roosevelt before William Taft.
- 14:19Woodrow Wilson, a lot of one of the things he's really known for is he led the charge for the
- 14:23creation of the Federal Reserve, which we still have today, and they adjust interest rates and
- 14:29the nation's money supply.
- 14:31He also supported the Clayton Antitrust Act that was passed in 1914, which was stronger
- 14:38than the previously passed Sherman antitrust act and several other labor reform bills that
- 14:43he pushed for that also passed.
- 14:45Now he's also known for centralizing power during World War 1 as well.
- 14:50He established the war industries board in 1917 to coordinate industrial production, quelled
- 14:57anti war sentiments through the passage of the espionage and sedition acts that prohibited
- 15:02interference with the draft and criticism of government, and also took a leading role in
- 15:08international affairs post war, though he was ultimately unsuccessful in getting the country
- 15:14to enter the League of Nations that that crumbled not too long after the US would not
- 15:24enter it.
- 15:25US senator Henry Cabot Lodge was a big factor in preventing the US from entering that because
- 15:32at the time, there's still a lot of isolationist sentiment in the US.
- 15:36It's not like today where it's a lot more of a globalized interconnected community across the
- 15:43world.
- 15:44The League of Nations was a precursor to the United Nations.
- 15:48We'll get to that in just a moment.
- 15:50And then the last president will highlight, though, not necessarily the last president that
- 15:55really wielded power of the president.
- 15:57Certainly not the last example of 1, but Franklin Roosevelt or FDR for short, Franklin
- 16:03Delano Roosevelt, 1933 of 1945.
- 16:06And his agenda was helped in large part by sweeping democratic gains in federal and state
- 16:11governments in the early years of the great depression base.
- 16:14Just about everywhere in the country, democrats made huge gains.
- 16:17Not necessarily taking over every single state government, but a ton of congressional seats
- 16:24were flipped to Democrats and a lot of state governments, at least for a little while.
- 16:31Not necessarily for a very long time, but for a little while, they became democratic majorities
- 16:36too.
- 16:36You started to see towards the end of 19 thirties, a lot of those states started to
- 16:41become a bit more Republican again.
- 16:44But he was famous for his new deal programs that he pushed for that fundamentally changed
- 16:49much of the federal government's structure and function.
- 16:52And among a few of those, there there's still many of those lasting programs from that time,
- 16:58and a few of those include Social Security, the Securities and Exchange Commission, the Federal
- 17:03Housing Administration, and the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation.
- 17:07So a lot of impact that FDR had then and that we still feel today.
- 17:13And, also, with the with the couple of war powers act, he reorganized much of the
- 17:18executive branch and independent government agencies to support the war effort when the US
- 17:23entered World War 2.
- 17:24The US wasn't in it from the very beginning.
- 17:27They entered relatively late.
- 17:29And he also led the charge to bring the US into the newly formed United Nations, which I just
- 17:34mentioned a little bit ago.
- 17:36So Woodrow Wilson not able to bring the US into the League of Nations.
- 17:40FDR was able to do that, though, following World War 2 when the United Nations became a
- 17:48came into existence.
- 17:50And, really, since World War 2, every president has taken a leading role to some degree on
- 17:56world affairs as the US becomes a superpower and the world becomes increasingly globalized.
- 18:02Now today, presidents definitely have more power than the framers of the constitution
- 18:07envision.
- 18:08The question is just whether they have too much power and whether said power is
- 18:13unconstitutional.
- 18:14Definitely some heated debates in that regard.
- 18:20Now moving on to presidential power and relations with congress.
- 18:25So we have a series of checks and balances between all three branches of government.
- 18:30And in the case of president with congress, president can veto bills by congress.
- 18:36Congress, if they can get enough support, can override vetoes, but they have had a lot of
- 18:41support.
- 18:41It can't just be one party.
- 18:43It has to be 2 thirds of both chambers of congress.
- 18:47The president can nominate heads of various government departments.
- 18:51Congress confirms or opposes them.
- 18:54And then congress declares war, but the president is the commander in chief.
- 18:58And those last two points in particular about nominating government agency heads and
- 19:06declaring war.
- 19:08Couple of the debates we're gonna highlight here as to whether president has usurped
- 19:14congress' war powers and whether the president can or how far the the president can go in
- 19:20nominating or or making recess appointments and and establishing somebody in a cabinet post
- 19:28without the advice and consent of the senate.
- 19:30But from the 19 sixties, there was a study done by political science, Aaron Waldavsky, that
- 19:36pause that posited there was 2 presidencies.
- 19:40And the idea behind it is there's not obviously actually 2 presidencies, but how the president
- 19:46operates and interacts with congress on domestic policy is much different than on
- 19:52foreign policy.
- 19:53The chief difference is the president gets his way much more on foreign policy than on
- 19:58domestic policy.
- 19:59There hasn't been a whole lot of reexamination of that theory in more recent times, though
- 20:04some argue that the president still has too much influence over poll foreign policy and war
- 20:11powers.
- 20:12So the 2 presidency's thesis may still be alive and well in that regard, but the controversy
- 20:20over whether the power to declare war was usurped by the president with, for example, US
- 20:27military involvement in Korea and Vietnam where congress did not declare war initially.
- 20:33We got into those wars, and then congress later on gave support for the wars.
- 20:39There's a lot of controversy over those.
- 20:41And then congress in 1973, they passed the war powers resolution of 1973 after Richard Nixon
- 20:49had secretly bombed Cambodia without congressional approval, and Nixon tried to veto
- 20:57that, that that bill.
- 21:01Congress overrode that bill, and some would still argue that subsequent presidents have,
- 21:08again, taken a lot of the war powers of congress and that congress has more or less let
- 21:14them.
- 21:14Again, a little bit more on this later, but there's even arguments about whether the war
- 21:19powers resolution was even constitutional as well.
- 21:24Now when it comes to presidential power and relations with the supreme court, checks and
- 21:29balances between the two branches, in particular, the president can appoint judges
- 21:34confirmed by the US Senate, and judges can rule acts by the president as unconstitutional and
- 21:41are insulated from presidents deciding to remove them.
- 21:43Once you appoint a judge to supreme court or other federal courts, they are they have
- 21:52lifetime appointments unless they get impeached or obvious obviously, if they pass away or
- 21:57resign.
- 21:58But other than that, though, they are in for as long as they want to be.
- 22:03Now usually, presidents do acquiesce to supreme court rulings, but there are several major
- 22:10instances where they decided, I'm I'm not listening to the courts.
- 22:14Mentioned earlier, Andrew Jackson Cohen, yeah.
- 22:17No.
- 22:17We're I'm I'm not listening to you when they try to stop it from forcibly moving Native
- 22:22Americans.
- 22:24But there's also a political question doctrine that's that SCOTUS has where they won't rule on
- 22:30cases that they feel are too politically charged.
- 22:33And in particular, if it's a spat between the executive and legislative branches regarding
- 22:38which powers one or the other has.
- 22:42Basically, the concern is that the judicial branch could be seen as too political when they
- 22:46are theoretically supposed to be the apolitical branch of government.
- 22:51Although, obviously, a lot of questions that people have over the years, regardless of
- 22:56whether the court has leaned left or right, whether the the branch is actually apolitical,
- 23:03but the selection of judges has also become a lot more partisan over the last 40 years or so.
- 23:10You have these unofficial litmus tests that presidents have to make sure a judge has a
- 23:16similar similar ideology to said president.
- 23:20And you really saw it in particular with not not necessarily the first partisan confirmation
- 23:28process, but is the one that really started this era of very partisan confirmation
- 23:34processes was Robert Bork in 1987.
- 23:37Reagan nominated him.
- 23:38The Democratic US Senate voted it down.
- 23:41Ultimately, his name was withdrawn, and he had Clarence Thomas who's still on the court today.
- 23:46In 1991, George h w Bush, George w Bush's father, nominated him.
- 23:53Clarence Thomas was accused of sexual harassment by law professor and former employee
- 23:57Anita Hill, but he would eventually be confirmed by what was then the narrowest margin
- 24:04in history for a confirmation of a US or a Supreme Court judge, which was 52 to 48.
- 24:12You also had Merrick Garland, who's the current attorney general until Trump takes office.
- 24:18He was nominated for the Supreme Court in 2016.
- 24:22The US Senate, controlled by Republicans at that time, decided they would not vote on the
- 24:29nomination until after the election, then Donald Trump won in 2016.
- 24:33So Garland's nomination was returned in early 2017 with out of votes.
- 24:38And then you had Brett Kavanaugh in 2018 was nominated by Trump in Trump's first term.
- 24:45Kavanaugh also accused of sexual assault and was eventually confirmed 50 to 48 to 1.
- 24:541, there was a US senator that was not, there to vote at the time, and there was another
- 25:02senator that said that they were present, but they decided not to vote yes or no.
- 25:07Hence, 50 to 48 to 1.
- 25:10Now onto executive orders, which are a particular source of controversy.
- 25:18An executive order is a directive by the president that manages the operations of the
- 25:23federal government.
- 25:24That's just the basic definition of what an executive order is.
- 25:28Now these usually get panned as the president trying to make laws, which is what congress is
- 25:33supposed to do, but not every executive order is some major controversy or some sort of it
- 25:39they don't always have some major impact or impose some sort of major policy, but,
- 25:46obviously, we do have a lot of, instances of very prominent and impactful executive orders.
- 25:55So you have ones like the Emancipation Proclamation and the desegregation of public
- 26:00schools following the Brown versus Board of Education decision in the late 19 fifties and
- 26:06also the desegregation in the military in the late 19 forties.
- 26:11But you also have internment camps for Japanese Americans during World War 2 and the barring of
- 26:17LGBTQ workers from government jobs, which was only I could leave 2017 lifted.
- 26:26So some major executive orders that are unequivocally good, some of them that are
- 26:34unequivocally bad, and some of them that are a little bit more of a gray area.
- 26:38And every president, except for William Henry Harrison, has passed at least one executive
- 26:43order.
- 26:44Only reason William Henry Harrison doomed is because he only lived into office for 1 month
- 26:49before he passed away.
- 26:52But as a just a basic overview of how the use of executive orders has expanded over time, the
- 27:00first one to break 10 executive orders was Andrew Jackson who had 12 from 18/29 to 18/37.
- 27:091st one to go over a 100 executive orders was 217 by Ulysses s Grant, who was president,
- 27:1618/69 to 18/77.
- 27:18First one to go over a thousand was 1081 by Teddy Roosevelt in 1901 who or who served from
- 27:2519 01 to 19 0 9.
- 27:27And then the first half of 1900 saw by far the highest number of executive orders.
- 27:33Woodrow Wilson had 1800.
- 27:35Warren Harding had 522.
- 27:37We only served for a couple years.
- 27:39Calvin Coolidge had over 1200.
- 27:42Herbert Hoover had close to a 1,000, and then Franklin Roosevelt by far had the most
- 27:47executive orders partially because he was the office the longest, but he also had the highest
- 27:53average per year.
- 27:54But he had 3,721, and then Harry Truman had a little over 900 after him.
- 28:01And so the use of executive orders is not as high as it was back then, but you still see
- 28:07them pretty often, since the first half of the 1900.
- 28:15So before we close out here, let's go over this final section of this episode here.
- 28:20We're gonna talk about debates over the powers of the presidency.
- 28:25In particular, we're gonna highlight this book right here.
- 28:31The debating the presidency is a textbook I've had back from my undergraduate days at the
- 28:35University of South Florida, Goebbels, but they lay out several big debates regarding
- 28:42presidential power very well.
- 28:44And this this was back in, say, 2013.
- 28:48Jeez.
- 28:48Yeah.
- 28:48It was at least 10 years ago.
- 28:50Boy, time flies.
- 28:53But here's a quick just a quick look at several of these debates from this book and also from
- 29:00outside the book.
- 29:01But, from from the book, I'll highlight just a few of the debates and what people who say yes
- 29:10on one side of debate.
- 29:11The the the the way the the book is is laid out is it poses a question.
- 29:15It says, it was the president's blah blah blah.
- 29:19Yes or no?
- 29:20And the way it it does it is that each one of those debates has one person saying yes and has
- 29:29a a an essay about it, and then the no side has a person writing an essay about it.
- 29:36And a bun they're all professors and scholars that are are are writing on it.
- 29:42Very, very interesting, book, and there's been a at least a couple of editions since then.
- 29:48But from the book, highlight a few of the debates here.
- 29:53One of them is about mentioned it several times already.
- 29:56Has the president you served congress' war powers, the war powers that rightfully belong
- 30:02to congress?
- 30:03So the person who argued for the yes side, and you'll hear this from other, people who would
- 30:11make that argument.
- 30:13A lot of them would say there's a clear demarcation of power to declare war that
- 30:17belongs to congress, and the president is just a commander in chief.
- 30:20So the fact that president is taking the lead on declaring war is a clear violation of the
- 30:28constitution, and they had also argued that the power to unilaterally declare war is an abuse
- 30:33of power that just shouldn't belong to one person in the first place, and also that courts
- 30:38have not stopped the president like they should.
- 30:42Partially goes back to that political doctrine question.
- 30:45Some sometimes courts feel that it's too politically charged, whereas people who are
- 30:50arguing that presidents have usurped congress' war powers would say, the courts should not be
- 30:55doing that.
- 30:56They should be stepping in on these questions.
- 31:00Whether they're too politically charged or not, they should be stepping in and saying that the
- 31:03president can't do this.
- 31:05Now people who say that presidents have not usurped congress's war powers, they argue that
- 31:11the constitution constitution actually leaves war powers responsibility ambiguous and that it
- 31:18allows presidents to repel invasions on their own authority and thus leaves power to make war
- 31:25a concurrent responsibility of both branches.
- 31:29And, also, in their view, a lot of people would say that the president hasn't just taken it
- 31:37from congress, but that congress has willingly ceded war powers without sufficiently pushing
- 31:43back.
- 31:44So that's a look at that debate.
- 31:48Another debate that is highlighted in the book is whether the war on terrorism requires
- 31:53relaxing checks on presidential power.
- 31:56Those who feel that checks on presidential power should be relaxed in a time like the war
- 32:02on terror, they would argue that congress often hamstrings presidents from acting to protect
- 32:08national security.
- 32:09It's that kinda goes back to that argument of the do nothing congress or congress that just
- 32:15deliberately stonewalls a president is if if the president and the congress are of 2
- 32:22different parties.
- 32:24They'd all they also argue that the framers of the constitution gave the chief executive, the
- 32:29president, authority to respond to the demands of war.
- 32:34Basically, that as one person, they need to be able to respond swiftly and decisively when war
- 32:42demands it because there's only so much deliberation that you can have when it comes to
- 32:49war.
- 32:50And then they've also argued that presidents that have been more willing to exercise power
- 32:55in the name of national security have brought a lot of benefit to the nation, and they
- 32:58highlight ones like George Washington or Abraham Lincoln and how he addressed wartime
- 33:07powers during the civil war or FDR during World War 2.
- 33:12Now people who think that's the war on terrorism does not require relaxing checks on
- 33:19presidential power.
- 33:20Some of their arguments are that presidential action has been more dangerous, ineffective,
- 33:27costly, etcetera, etcetera with fewer checks on his power.
- 33:32It's done a lot more harm than good.
- 33:34They've also argued that the freedoms of speech and press, which we have from the first
- 33:38amendment, have been subordinated in the name of national security.
- 33:42Basically, it's saying the idea that people can't speak out against war is is unjust.
- 33:49It's a violation of first amendment rights.
- 33:51It's not about national security.
- 33:53And they also then people who don't think that presidential powers or checks on presidential
- 33:59power should be relaxed.
- 34:00They would say that the national interest is often just a euphemism for the political
- 34:04interest of a president and their party.
- 34:09And one more debate from this book and then cover a couple of the ones that were brought up
- 34:17at the very beginning of this episode.
- 34:20Whether the president has too much power in the selection of judges, so people who think that
- 34:25the president does has does have too much power in the selection of judges, the yes side, a lot
- 34:31of them argue that the US senate advice function on judges has largely been reduced
- 34:37when they are supposed to provide both advice and consent on, judges.
- 34:43It's not just about, yes.
- 34:45We we we support this the confirmation of this judge.
- 34:48Sometimes they say, well, you know, the the idea is that they would say, hey.
- 34:53I think this person should be nominated.
- 34:56Or the idea of senatorial courtesy, which is basically if a judge comes from a certain US
- 35:04senators from state especially the senior senator of the u of that state.
- 35:09So let's say a a judicial nominee comes from Michigan and, senior senators the either the
- 35:18junior or the senior senator.
- 35:20Junior just meaning the US senator had that has been in has been a senator for that state a
- 35:27shorter time, and, senior senator for that state has been there a longer time.
- 35:31So if we had a Michigan senator this is not the actual numbers.
- 35:35But let's just say that the one senator for Michigan has been there for 10 years, and then
- 35:41the other one has been there for 6 years.
- 35:43The one that's been there for 10 years is considered the senior senator, and the one
- 35:46that's been there for 6 years is the junior senator.
- 35:49Doesn't matter their actual ages.
- 35:51It matters how long they've been in the office.
- 35:53But in any case, senatorial courtesy says if a judge or really a a nominee from that state in
- 36:04particular, but a lot of times specifically for judges.
- 36:07If a senator does not approve of that nominee, then that president won't even nominate them in
- 36:14the first place.
- 36:17Now then doesn't that still happens sometimes, but probably doesn't happen nearly as much as
- 36:22it used to.
- 36:23So the idea for people who think that the president has too much power and the selection
- 36:28judges would say that advice, not just for senatorial courtesy, but advice function in
- 36:33general of the US Senate saying, well, maybe we should consider these people or or, hey.
- 36:38Nominate this person or, I'm not sure that this one's a good idea.
- 36:43They say that advice function has been diminished all in a lot in recent years.
- 36:49Some of them would argue that the threshold for confirmation of justice needs to be raised from
- 36:53a simple majority where it's not just 50% plus 1.
- 36:58Yeah.
- 36:58And some they might argue that 60% should do it or or 2 thirds.
- 37:04It it but in any case that the simple majority is too low a threshold and is too given to
- 37:10political and partisan considerations.
- 37:16And then one of the other arguments they have is that percent presidents are far too
- 37:22political and making appointments to what is supposed to be the a political branch.
- 37:28On the no side for people who think that the president does not have too much power in the
- 37:33selection of judges, a lot of them would say, well, the president only has the power to
- 37:37nominate.
- 37:37They can't just fill them into the office that they want.
- 37:40It's not like a like a normal recess appointment, but that the president only has
- 37:46the power to to nominate the judge.
- 37:49They can't confirm it on their own.
- 37:51They still need the US senate to do that.
- 37:53They also would argue that bringing congress into more of a role in the nomination process
- 37:59invites more political factionalism into the process, and it also kinda blurs a little bit
- 38:06more of the line of of, separation of powers and checks and balances in that regard.
- 38:12And some of them would argue it's actually the US senate that actually exercises too much
- 38:18power by obstructing the confirmation process on partisan and ideological grounds.
- 38:23You have, for example, the filibuster, which is a whole other debate, whether senators should
- 38:29be able to basically hold up a judicial nomination just by hawking as long as they want
- 38:35until they have enough US senators to say, okay.
- 38:39You need to shut up.
- 38:40We're we're gonna move forward one way or another on on an issue.
- 38:46So filibuster being one of those ways that at least in the views of people who who think that
- 38:55the president is not the one that has too much power in the selection of judges.
- 38:59Some of them would argue that the filibuster would is something that needs to be severely
- 39:05curbed or eliminated, in general.
- 39:08But because the US senate is the one that actually confirms the appointment, in their
- 39:13eyes, a lot of in the eyes of people who think that the president is not the one that has too
- 39:18much power in judge selection, they would say that the US senate is just very obstructionist.
- 39:26So, obviously, what you think about all those arguments, that's up for you to decide.
- 39:32Like, as as as always, and I'm not putting forth my opinion on any of them, but that's
- 39:39just some of the the arguments laid out for those debates.
- 39:44But a couple of the last debates we'll cover before we wrap things up, and not that are not
- 39:50necessarily from this book.
- 39:51Go back to executive orders.
- 39:53So controversies around these executive orders.
- 39:56Again, they're not all sweeping policies or anything like that, but when they are more
- 40:04impactful, a lot of the controversies often revolve around whether in order bypasses
- 40:09congress's power to make laws or whether it oversteps the boundaries of presidential power
- 40:14given by the constitution, not necessarily that it circumvents congress's, role in the process,
- 40:20but that it's simply not something granted to a president in the first place and or the general
- 40:26impact of the executive order, whether it's as good or bad.
- 40:32So some of the reasons that somebody would support an executive order or oppose an
- 40:37executive order, It a lot of it resembles those for the aforementioned debate over relaxing
- 40:43checks on presidential power during the war on terrorism.
- 40:48So support reasons include they might need to bypass a do nothing congress or congress that
- 40:54just simply just stonewalls them over partisan reasons.
- 41:00You you an argument for on several of those previous debates that we were just talking
- 41:06about or that there's an ultimately pressing need that requires swift action into the
- 41:10president needs to just do something about it, regardless of whether the congress is is is
- 41:17stonewalling them or not.
- 41:18They just the president needs to be able to act swiftly.
- 41:21And then opposition reasons would include the potential for presidents to take power to make
- 41:26laws from congress or that a president can't be trusted to not overstep their boundaries, or
- 41:33they might use the national interest as a cover for simply what is their own interest or their
- 41:39party's interest.
- 41:41And then in the case of recess appointments, there's been some argument about whether the
- 41:47recess of the US Senate they're they're for when it comes to presidents appointing, US or
- 41:55not, excuse me, not US senators.
- 41:57When they come to appoint whatever government had and need the US senate to, con confirm.
- 42:05If it's during a recess, the president does not need congress's, confirmation on that.
- 42:14But does the recess of the US senate as prescribed in the constitution, does it include
- 42:19recesses during a session, or is it just recesses between sessions?
- 42:27Big difference there.
- 42:29So it is there's a bit of a debate about whether it's just one or the other, or both of
- 42:36those kinds of recesses, are allowed if appointments during either one of those kinds
- 42:42of recesses are allowed or or only during one of those recesses.
- 42:46How long does the recess have to be for a president to make appointment during it?
- 42:51That's also been the subject of supreme court cases.
- 42:55And is the constitutional provision allowing presidents to make recess appointments?
- 43:01Is it going to be abused in a way where the president can circumvent congress's ability to
- 43:06confirm the appointment at will, similar to arguments about whether the president has too
- 43:11much power regarding the selection of judges.
- 43:13So a lot of those are just a few of the debates, regarding presidential power and how
- 43:21much it's it's expanded.
- 43:22It's it's obviously considerably expanded since the time of the framers of the constitution,
- 43:28but it's a matter of whether it's expanded too much and whether it's it's violated the
- 43:34constitution, in previous instances.
- 43:38So, obviously, that's that's all for you to decide.
- 43:42I'm just trying to lay out the arguments as best I can, try to give equal time to both
- 43:48sides of those arguments.
- 43:49So those those are just a few of the debates that, that are had about presidential power,
- 43:57but that's gonna wrap it up for today's episode.
- 44:00As always, thank you so much for listening.
- 44:02Let's end you off on a random question.
- 44:07Today's random question is, what is a word that is grossly overused and needs to be severely
- 44:14curbed?
- 44:19We need to stop using the word literally so much.
- 44:26We literally use the word literally, literally all the time.
- 44:30It's not when people use it hyperbolically or like when people say, oh, you do use literally
- 44:37wrong.
- 44:37No, Literally is often used in a very just even describing this and having to use the word
- 44:44drives me up a wall.
- 44:47It's not when it's used hyperbolically.
- 44:48It's when it's just when it's used correctly, but it's just completely unnecessary.
- 44:53I'm literally looking at my camera.
- 44:55Sorry to really screamed in the camera, microphone there.
- 44:58I'm literally looking into my camera.
- 45:01I'm literally typing it up right now.
- 45:03I'm literally looking to my right.
- 45:05We don't need to say literally for every freaking we don't need to use the word all the
- 45:12time.
- 45:13And if I were gonna be a dictator, one of my first orders of business would be to put a
- 45:18quota on the number of times that the word literally is used.
- 45:23Obviously, it's not a legitimate policy.
- 45:25You can't actually enforce it, but I hate it.
- 45:29I that's why I try to use the words actually or legitimately.
- 45:33Basically, it gets the same point across.
- 45:35Try not to use those too much because I know then that starts to be used the amount of times
- 45:40that literally is.
- 45:41I I I just I can't I can't stand how often the word literally is used.
- 45:47It literally makes me insane.
- 45:52But but, you know, there's at the same time, there's a lot more important things to be
- 45:57annoyed about in in today's world.
- 46:00But in any case, let me know what a word that you cannot stand is or if if you agree with me
- 46:06on the whole literally thing because it's literally ridiculous.
- 46:13But in any case, once again, thank you so much for listening.
- 46:17Links in the show notes for Facebook, LinkedIn, Matchmaker FM profile, my book on Amazon, why
- 46:24independence rarely win elections, and how they could become more competitive.
- 46:28Also, my email, paulraderwrites atgmail.com.
- 46:32Raider spelled r a d e r.
- 46:36And with that, I will talk to you in the next episode.
- 46:40So until then, take care.