Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / California’s Brave New World of A.I. Legislation
Transcript
- 0:00California's Brave New World of AI legislation. I'm Randy Bandman, chair of the Entertainment
- 0:12Laws section of the Beverly Hills Bar Association. Our Entertainment Laws section is sponsored
- 0:18by Lawyers Mutual Insurance Company. I wanted to point out that if any of our attendees
- 0:24have any questions, they can post them in the Q&A box in the Zoom and our panelists will
- 0:28do their best to get to them as the program proceeds. Today's program will be led by
- 0:36Douglas Morel, Beverly Grossman Palmer, and Peter Jackson. Douglas Morel is a partner
- 0:43at Greenberg Lusker LLP. Douglas represents celebrities, entertainers, companies, guilds,
- 0:50media concerns, and others in litigation over the course of several decades and counting.
- 0:57His imprint can be found on hundreds of important entertainment-related issues that were resolved
- 1:01in the courts for that required legislative action. Beverly Grossman Palmer is a partner
- 1:08at Stormwasser and Wichir. Beverly joined her firm after serving as a law clerk for
- 1:13the honorable Dorothy W. Nelson of the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. Ms. Grossman Palmer
- 1:19represents clients in the fields of election law, land use, and environmental law, economic
- 1:24regulation, and education law. She has appeared in both state court and administrative proceedings
- 1:29and before local governments. She also advises clients on compliance with campaign finance
- 1:34and reporting laws, as well as provides guidance and analysis on the initiative process.
- 1:41Last we have Peter Jackson. Peter is counsel at Greenberg Lusker LLP. Peter helps businesses
- 1:47with broad aspects of technology-related operations to focus on complex contracts involving
- 1:53IP, data, security, and privacy issues. He advises on emerging issues like rights and
- 2:00output from generative AI tools, on-chain contracts, and data strategy, as well as nimble
- 2:05compliance under state and federal privacy laws like CCPA and HIPAA. His clients include
- 2:11content companies, AI developers, and Web3 organizations, as well as SaaS providers and
- 2:16consumer products brands for both B2C and B2B purposes. Thank you, panelists.
- 2:23Thank you.
- 2:26Thank you, Brandy.
- 2:28Thank you, Dad.
- 2:30So we will start screen sharing now, and if we can page ahead to the agenda, you'll see
- 2:37where we're going ahead. I've got the first four measures, and Beverly will be dealing
- 2:47with the next four, including one that is currently inoperative because of an injunction
- 2:54that was issued. And Peter will be batting cleanup and dealing with another four bills
- 3:04and one. And we are all, I think, going to chime in a little bit to talk about SB 1047,
- 3:12which was vetoed by Governor Newsom, but was a significant AI piece of legislation. So
- 3:21let's move on. The first two bills I'm going to address focus mostly on the ways in which
- 3:27artificial intelligence impacts the entertainment industry, AB 1836 and 2602, turning first
- 3:36to AB 1836. California has had a postmortem right of publicity since 1985 and is currently
- 3:45one of 27 states recently including New York to recognize such a right. In 1999, the legislature
- 3:54amended our civil code section 3344.1 to add broad exemptions for essentially all expressive
- 4:02works, including plays, books, music, magazines, newspapers, radio, TV, audio visual works,
- 4:10and advertisements for all such works, so long as they were, quote, fictional or non-fictional,
- 4:16entertainment, or a dramatic literary or musical work, close quote. Now, in light of these
- 4:23exemptions and in this brave new era of artificial intelligence, it was obvious that deceased
- 4:29performers would be unable to prevent the postmortem digital exploitation of their voices
- 4:35and likenesses in movies, TV, video games, and sound recordings by means of the postmortem
- 4:43right of publicity statute. Consequently, with the Screen Actors Guild, American Federation
- 4:49of Television and Radio Artists, otherwise known as SAG-AFTRA, as its sponsor, the legislature
- 4:56passed and Governor Newsome signed AB 1836. I should add that in the interest of full
- 5:02disclosure, I served as a technical legal expert who testified in Sacramento on behalf
- 5:09of SAG-AFTRA in support of this legislation before three separate legislative committees.
- 5:15Now, AB 1836 precludes the production or distribution of a digital replica, quote, unquote, of a
- 5:23deceased personality's voice or likeness in expressive works without the prior consent
- 5:29of the decedent's heirs or other representatives. For purposes of this legislation, as well
- 5:35as 2602, the next bill I'm going to address, digital replicas are defined as, quote, a
- 5:41computer-generated, highly realistic electronic representation that is readily identifiable
- 5:48as the voice or visual likeness of an individual in a work in which the actual individual did
- 5:55not actually perform or appear, or the actual individual did perform or appear, but the fundamental
- 6:04character of the performance or appearance has been materially altered, close quote.
- 6:11That's the definition of a digital replica. Confronted initially with opposition from
- 6:16the studios and the motion picture association, AB 1836 was eventually amended to include
- 6:24a significant number of exemptions for uses such as news, sports broadcasts, commentary,
- 6:30criticism, scholarship, satire, and parody. Also exempt from liability is what has been
- 6:37colloquially characterized as the forest gump exemption, namely the representation of an
- 6:44individual in a somewhat fictionalized historical work, quote, unless the use is intended to
- 6:50create and does create the false impression that the work is an authentic recording in
- 6:55which the individual participated. So think Tom Hanks' characters and counters with
- 7:01presidents Kennedy Johnson and Nixon in forest gump. A civil action can be brought for violation
- 7:07of this digital replica right with available statutory damages of $10,000 or the actual
- 7:14damages suffered by the person controlling the deceased person's voice or likeness rights.
- 7:19This law becomes effective on January 1st of 2025. So now let's next look at AB 2602.
- 7:28As many of you will doubtless recall, the topic of artificial intelligence was a significant
- 7:36aspect of the strike that lasted from July to November of 2023 by SAG-AFTRA against
- 7:42the Alliance of Motion Picture and Television Producers, the AMPTP. As part of the deal
- 7:48that ended that strike, two categories of digital replicas were created, employment-based
- 7:54and independently created. For employment-based digital replicas, producers must provide advance
- 8:00notice and obtain the performer's clear and conspicuous consent in a signed writing separate
- 8:07from the employment contract. And this applies to both sequels and prequels. And for independently
- 8:13created digital replicas, producers must likewise negotiate with performers or their authorized
- 8:20representatives. But what happens if performers or employers are not SAG-AFTRA members or
- 8:25signatories? And that's where AB 2602 kicks in. As I indicated before, the two use the
- 8:34term digital replica in precisely the same way. But AB 2602 creates a new labor code
- 8:41section that renders unenforceable any provision in an agreement for the performance of new
- 8:49personal or professional services by such a digital replica unless three conditions
- 8:55are met. First, specific permission must be given to create a digital replica of the individual's
- 9:02voice or likeness. Second, with certain exceptions, there must be a reasonably specific description
- 9:09of the intended use. And third, the individual must have been represented by legal counsel
- 9:15who negotiated the provision and whose commercial terms are stated clearly and conspicuously
- 9:21in a writing signed by the individual. Or that individual must have been represented
- 9:27by a labor union that represents workers who do the proposed work under terms of a collective
- 9:33bargaining agreement that expressly addresses use of digital replicas, such as the 2023
- 9:39SAG-AFTRA Memorandum of Agreement that ended the AMPTP strike. The apparent remedy for
- 9:45a violation of this labor code section would involve a declaration voiding the non-conforming
- 9:51provisions of any such agreement. And AB 2602 is effective for newly created performances
- 9:59that are fixed on or after January 1. So moving beyond bills whose impact will be felt most
- 10:05acutely by the entertainment community, AB 2013 requires us to explore the world of
- 10:13generative artificial intelligence, which it defines as artificial intelligence that
- 10:18can generate derived synthetic content, such as text, images, videos, and audio, that emulate
- 10:27the structure and characteristics of an AI training set. AB 2013 obligates a developer
- 10:35of GenAI, as I'll call it, systems or services to post on that developer's internet website
- 10:43extensive documentation by means of a high level summary identifying the data sets used
- 10:50for GenAI training. And this information must include, among other things, the sources or
- 10:56owners of the data sets, a description of how those data sets further the intended purpose
- 11:02of the GenAI, whether the data sets include any data protected by copyright, trademark,
- 11:08or patent, or are entirely within the public domain, whether the data sets contain any
- 11:13personal information and eight additional categories of information. These website posting
- 11:20obligations apply to newly created or substantially modified GenAI that is released on or after
- 11:27January 1, 2022, but that posting need not take place under this legislation until January
- 11:351 of 2026 at the very latest. And for any GenAI that is newly created or modified after
- 11:44that date, the required postings must precede their release. And these obligations I should
- 11:50apply only to GenAI that is made publicly available or used by Californians, which,
- 11:56of course, if it's on the internet, it's going to be available. The developers who use data
- 12:01to train GenAI are exempt from these disclosure requirements if any of three conditions exist.
- 12:08One, the sole purpose of the GenAI is to help ensure security and integrity involving data
- 12:15breach and similar incidents. Two, the sole purpose of the GenAI is the operation of aircraft
- 12:22in national airspace. Or three, the GenAI was developed for national security, military
- 12:27or defense purposes, and is made available exclusively to a federal entity. Though the
- 12:33bill doesn't contain any specifically identified penalties, developers who disclose that they've
- 12:39used unauthorized training data would presumably be exposed to liability for the misuse of
- 12:44that data under preexisting laws, such as, for example, California's consumer records
- 12:50law. So the final bill I'm going to discuss is SB 942. Effective January 1, 2026, this
- 13:01legislation obligates a quote unquote, covered provider to make available at no cost an AI
- 13:08detection tool that meets specified criteria, including public accessibility. Now, content
- 13:16providers are defined to mean someone who creates codes or otherwise produces a GenAI
- 13:22system that has over one million monthly visitors or users and is publicly accessible
- 13:27to anyone within California. The detection tool that such covered providers must make
- 13:33freely available has to meet six specified criteria, the most significant of which are
- 13:39that it must allow a user to assess whether the image, video, and or audio content was
- 13:45created or altered by that covered providers own GenAI system. And it must identify the
- 13:52provenance of any other data detected in that content. Beyond this information, SB 942 obligates
- 14:00covered providers to also offer their users the option to include a manifest disclosure,
- 14:06quote unquote, of GenAI content that is clear, conspicuous, appropriate for the medium and
- 14:13understandable to a reasonable person. Covered providers are further required to include a
- 14:19latent disclosure of GenAI related information. It includes the name of the content provider,
- 14:26the name and version of the GenAI system that created or altered the content, as well as
- 14:30its time and date of creation or alteration. SB 942 contains an exception for quote any
- 14:38product service, internet website or application that provides exclusively non user generated
- 14:45video game, television, streaming movie or interactive experiences. Violations of these
- 14:52GenAI detection and tool detection tool disclosure requirements expose a covered provider to
- 14:59a civil penalty of $5,000 per violation in a civil action that can be brought only by
- 15:06the Attorney General, a county council or a city attorney. Significantly and in order
- 15:11to encourage prompt compliance, every day of non disclosure is deemed to be a separate
- 15:18discrete violation. So in an action against a covered provider, a prevailing plaintiff
- 15:25but not a prevailing defendant is entitled to recover its reasonable attorney's fees
- 15:30and costs. Finally, civil actions may also be brought by the same governmental plaintiffs
- 15:36against third party licensees that have either modified a licensed GenAI system in a manner
- 15:43that makes it incapable of providing these required disclosures or if that licensee fails
- 15:49to cease using a licensed GenAI system after that system's license has been revoked. The
- 15:56penalties for such violations by third party licensees are injunctive relief and reasonable
- 16:01attorney's fees and costs. With that, I turn the program over to Beverly Palmer.
- 16:08Hi, thank you. And it's nice to speak to the entertainment lawyers. I don't get to meet
- 16:14you all very often as an elections attorney. I will be speaking about three bills, AB 2355,
- 16:22and AB 2839, all of which went through the legislative process together and were heard
- 16:31by the same committees at roughly the same times. All of these bills attempt to address
- 16:37the legislature's concerns about the use of artificial intelligence to generate extremely
- 16:42realistic looking materials that are deceptive in the context of election materials. The
- 16:49concern was that one of the legislative analyses of these bills pointed out, generative AI
- 16:58can provide what seems like dispositive evidence of truth or falsity. And so the legislature
- 17:03attempted to address that concern in these three bills by both requiring disclosures
- 17:09on communications and in some instances outright prohibiting certain speech and requiring content
- 17:16providers to remove certain speech. So to turn to, and this is not, some of it is new,
- 17:23but it builds on existing state laws. So even since the founding of California in the first
- 17:28legislative session, the state enacted a penalty for deceiving a voter and causing the voter
- 17:34to elect to choose a different candidate than the voter had intended. But at the same time,
- 17:41the constitution and the California constitution both contain speech rights and protect large
- 17:46categories of speech, especially political speech. And so what the legislature is doing
- 17:51in these three bills is balancing these speech rights against the governmental interest in
- 17:57ensuring election integrity and in information disclosure to the public. And there is a bit
- 18:04of a tightrope as you will see. So AI certainly heightened the legislature's concern about
- 18:12misinformation in elections. So there were already existing laws addressing that topic.
- 18:18But some of the concerns that the legislature was, but was reporting in its analyses were
- 18:24things like in Slovakia, there was a fake audio recording of a candidate that spread online
- 18:29in the days before an election and put him in a very bad light. And he lost the election.
- 18:36In the US, voters in New Hampshire, thousands of voters got calls from an AI generated Joe Biden,
- 18:41telling them not to vote in the primary election and save their vote for November.
- 18:46There were fake images used in ads for DeSantis. There were fake images used in RNC ads. There
- 18:52was a fake image of a manipulated Anderson Cooper image in a Trump campaign ad. And so all of these,
- 19:00all of these alarm the legislature, though it got particularly alarmed when Governor Newsom
- 19:06reacted to a particular parody video that I'll discuss as we move through this content. But
- 19:13before all of these bills were passed, pre AI, back in 2019, the legislature enacted elections
- 19:20code 2000, 0010, which prohibited within 60 days of an election, materially deceptive audio or
- 19:29visual manipulations of candidate images that were conveyed with distributed with actual malice.
- 19:37So I think if you manipulate an image of a candidate to make that candidate appear to do
- 19:43something they didn't do, malice is probably not that difficult to show. But the material could be
- 19:49distributed as long as it had the disclaimer that this video or photo or audio has been manipulated.
- 19:56And notably, this did not apply to satire or parody. So satirical and parody content could be
- 20:04continued to just be distributed without any disclaimer or any restrictions. So turning
- 20:10first to AB 2355, which I think is the most straightforward of the bills, this was an amendment
- 20:18to the political reform act, the political reform act governs electoral campaigns,
- 20:23and highly regulates political committees that are engaged in those campaigns. So you've probably
- 20:29received election mail or seen TV ads during an election and noticed that there is a disclaimer on
- 20:36that mail or at the end of those ads. And those disclaimers tell you who paid for the ad,
- 20:42who are maybe who are the top funders of the ad, and all of those disclaimers are a form of
- 20:46compelled speech. But the Supreme Court of the US has upheld those kind of disclaimers as
- 20:52you're sufficiently narrowly tailored to serve an important governmental interest in
- 20:57telling people where the source of money in politics is. And there is little chance,
- 21:06I think, in the future of disclaimers being held to violate the first amendment. So this
- 21:1120 AB 2035 adds a disclaimer requirement to our already numerous disclaimers,
- 21:18ad generated or substantially altered using AI. Now in the course of considering this bill,
- 21:24the legislature had to confront what they meant by AI. The originally version of this bill was so
- 21:29broad that just even using Photoshop to edit an image would likely have required the disclaimer.
- 21:35So they wound up narrowing the definition down to AI is an engineered or machine based system
- 21:42that varies in its level of autonomy and that can from explicit or implicit objectives infer
- 21:48from the input it receives how to generate outputs that can influence physical or virtual
- 21:53environments. Now this law applies to both candidates and ballot measures, which is a little
- 22:00broader than our previous restrictions. And there's no malice or defamatory intent required.
- 22:05There's no time limit. It applies to any time and any to any election material that is generated
- 22:10using AI. I think that that presents a challenge for compliance because I don't,
- 22:17as an elections attorney, I don't know how an ad is created and it will require me to understand
- 22:23how an ad might have been created, what tools were used, do those tools constitute AI. I think
- 22:29it creates some ambiguities and challenges that way. It can be enforced. It will be enforced by
- 22:34the Fair Political Practices Commission, which enforces other parts of the Political Reform Act,
- 22:39who can seek injunctive relief or penalties. Typically they seek penalties. The maximum
- 22:46is 5,000 per violation, which is like 5,000 per missing disclaimer, though that is a maximum that
- 22:53is not typically imposed. But this will be interesting to see how that plays out in future
- 22:59elections where attorneys and other advisors of candidates and campaigns are required to discern
- 23:05how an ad was created. They'll turn now to AB 2839, which is, it has a straight through on it because
- 23:13it was overturned by, or not overturned, but is preliminarily enjoined. And this is a,
- 23:18definitely a broader bill. It goes from regulating advertisements paid for by political committees
- 23:24who are already subject to significant regulation, to regulating content by anybody and specific
- 23:32types of content. And it builds on elections code 20010 from 2019, which applied to ads in the 60
- 23:43days before an election with intent to deceive an actual malice. Now this regulates a much broader
- 23:49category of communications within a longer period, 120 days of the election. The legislature tried to
- 23:57use the standard that the Supreme Court set forth quite some years ago in New York Times versus
- 24:02Sullivan about speech that is, so a protecting speech that is maybe false speech, but that is not
- 24:12made with actual malice. But the way they did so may have caused, it may have been a little
- 24:18broader than what New York Times versus Sullivan would apply to. So normally actual malice would be
- 24:23demonstrated if somebody knowingly or without a reasonable investigation made false or,
- 24:31made false factual false statements. Now here, this statute prohibits speech that portrays a
- 24:39candidate as doing or saying something they did not do or say, and the content is reasonably
- 24:44likely to harm the reputation or electoral prospects of the candidate. Now this also expressly
- 24:50included candidates for president or vice president, which given the internet would basically make
- 24:57California a nationwide standard for content of speech about presidential candidates. And I
- 25:05don't think the legislature really discussed or considered that implication of that law.
- 25:09And it also prohibits really interestingly speech about elections officials or elected officials
- 25:17portray doing something they did or did not do or say if the content is reasonably likely to falsely
- 25:24undermine confidence in the outcome of one or more election contests. And it prohibits manipulated
- 25:30speech showing voting machines, ballots, voting sites, or property or equipment related to elections
- 25:36in a materially false way if the content is likely to undermine falsely undermined confidence
- 25:42in the outcome of an election contest. So as originally proposed, the legislation exempted satire
- 25:49entirely satire and parody. But as it was ultimately enacted, it required a disclaimer on satire and
- 25:57parody. So it did not, it now regulates it and requires a disclaimer that states, you know, this
- 26:04video has been manipulated for purposes of satire or parody. And not only does it require a disclaimer,
- 26:10it requires a disclaimer that is the size of the largest font used in the media. And as we will see,
- 26:18sometimes this font can, that can actually make it impossible to even employ the disclaimer
- 26:23effectively on the ad. It is broad in that it allows any person who receives the communication to
- 26:30sue for injunctive relief and recover damages and attorney's fees. And it had an urgency clause,
- 26:36so it would immediately apply. So AB 2355, the one we just talked about said, you just tell us if
- 26:42you manipulated an ad. But here now the legislature is saying you can't even engage in certain
- 26:48categories of speech at all. And if you do engage in that speech for the purposes of satire, you
- 26:56need to include a disclaimer. There's also, I didn't discuss this too much in the slide, but there's
- 27:02also an exemption for candidates. They can portray themselves doing something they didn't do if they
- 27:08want, which sometimes they may wish to do, but they have to use a disclaimer as well. So you can't
- 27:14kind of pump yourself up as a candidate falsely without a disclaimer. So this law was immediately
- 27:22put to the test and the legislature seems to have anticipated some First Amendment issues if you read the analyses of the bill.
- 27:30It's put to the test in Coles versus Bonta, which is on our next slide, a little summary of the holding. So Coles
- 27:38is an internet content creator who is known as Mr. Reagan. Coles created a number of parody ads of, well, he creates
- 27:48a bunch of parodies, but in particular of Kamala Harris. And there was one that he, the first one he did, shortly after
- 27:56she became the candidate for president, where he used a pretty accurate sounding voice of Kamala Harris
- 28:04and clipped it with a bunch of images of her and made a thing labeled Kamala Harris ad parody. So it was called a parody
- 28:14ad where he had her say things like, I'm the ultimate diversity hire and I was trained by the ultimate deep state
- 28:22puppet, Joe Biden. I watched the ad. I found it to be obviously parody, but Newsome saw this ad and was quite offended and posted
- 28:32on Twitter that such an ad should be illegal and it would soon be made illegal in California.
- 28:38That is when AB 2839 went from exempting satire and parody to requiring the big disclaimer, which in the case of these
- 28:48videos, because the font sizes used were so large that it would have basically covered the entire screen of the video.
- 28:56So Coles filed his suit, basically the day the governor signed the bill into law and it was enjoined shortly
- 29:07thereafter by October 2nd. The court found two major issues with the bill and I think one of them is a lot harder to deal with
- 29:16than the other. So just to talk about the easy one first, that disclaimer, the giant disclaimer, he said that A, that was too burdensome
- 29:24to use such a giant disclaimer and obviously it was compelling a speech that was impossible to engage in.
- 29:34But at the same time, he found that a disclaimer requirement might be a reasonable one if it was narrowly tailored enough.
- 29:42But really the biggest problem that the court had with this, which I think is going to make it a little challenging for the legislature
- 29:49if this is upheld, is that it used, it addressed such a broad amount of speech because it prohibited speech affecting things that were really
- 30:00kind of ineluctable, like something that suppressed candidates affected the electoral prospects of a candidate.
- 30:08I mean, how do we know what kind of speech is or isn't going to do that or that undermined confidence in election results?
- 30:14And his example, the judge's example on that was an image showing AI generated numbers of voter turnout could undermine confidence in an election.
- 30:24And that could be true. So the court found that that really suppressed such a broad amount of speech.
- 30:30It really wasn't just speech that classically would have caused harm in previous cases.
- 30:37This was kind of going and plowing a new field of potential harm that courts had not yet found to be speech that could be suppressed.
- 30:46And the court also said, you know, this is a strict scrutiny applies to the speech because this is content based regulation.
- 30:55And so you must use the least restrictive means to further your interest.
- 30:59And the court did agree that the government has a compelling interest in ensuring election integrity and thought that a disclaimer could be appropriate,
- 31:08but it needed to be more narrowly tailored.
- 31:10And it was difficult to tell whether the court would have upheld, say, a requirement that all of the material had a disclaimer, you know, something that didn't prohibit the speech entirely,
- 31:20but that required a disclaimer on any manipulated material like AB 2355 does.
- 31:26But I will note that there is another lawsuit that has been stayed, but depending how Coles v Bonta is resolved, it's by Babylon B, which is seemingly some sort of satirical publication.
- 31:38And we have argued that even requiring a disclaimer on satire or parody is unconstitutional because it kills the joke.
- 31:46Maybe that is something that entertainment lawyers will appreciate as an election lawyer we're so used to disclaimers it's hard to imagine objecting.
- 31:55But so stay tuned on Coles versus Bonta. That's just a preliminary injunction but it does point to some potential problems regulating this material in the political sphere.
- 32:05And so finally, AB 2655, which is the most different of the laws, then kind of newest thing it imposes new obligations on large online platforms to actually take down content.
- 32:19I'm pretty sure that this will face a First Amendment challenge as well, though it has not yet because it's not in effect immediately, but it will go in effect soon.
- 32:29It applies in the 120 day pre election period and 60 day post election to large online platforms, which have at least one million California users.
- 32:40And it applies to material about certain candidates, including presidential candidates and candidates for statewide office state legislature and House of Representatives.
- 32:54It does not apply at all to satire or parody even if it's materially deceptive so the legislature did carve out satire and parody here.
- 33:03But it requires the online providers, the online platforms to actually remove material that contains materially deceptive content, which is audio or visual media that is digitally created or modified and that includes but is not limited to deep fakes and the output of chat box,
- 33:23but it would falsely appear to a reasonable person to be an authentic record of the content depicted in the media. Deep fake is audio visual audio or visual media that is digitally created and modified such that it would falsely appear to a reasonable person to be an authentic record of the actual
- 33:40actual speech or conduct of the individual depicted in the media. So there were definitely some concerns raised about a lot of this legislation.
- 33:53I mean it's required to remove the materially deceptive content only if it's reasonably likely to harm the reputation or electoral prospects of a candidate or falsely undermine confidence in the outcome of election.
- 34:04Otherwise, it just has to be labeled that the content has been manipulated and is not authentic. And it creates a reporting regime for residents to report content that should be removed or labeled.
- 34:15Now, the, it was pointed out that, especially it used to have a broader definition of candidates but even with this, it's very difficult for these companies to know what needs to be removed.
- 34:28It would need to determine not only that the person portrayed is a candidate when that election is going to be what if the candidate actually did the thing that is portrayed.
- 34:38In some cases that's easy to figure out but sometimes with a less obviously state assembly or state legislature races we might not know as much about these candidates harder to figure it out.
- 34:50There are also lots of special local elections to replace smaller elections when candidates need to be replaced so they would apply in those contexts as well.
- 35:00It just creates a real challenge for those companies to detect that material and opponents should click the ACLU and industry groups found that the measure was not narrowly tailored enough and even though as Doug indicated talking about SB 942 I think it was that
- 35:18there may be tools to allow detection of digital modification.
- 35:23There is not technology to detect whether something is materially deceptive so that it appears authentic but has a force false portrayal relating to, you know, that will give a reasonable likelihood of harming the reputation or electoral prospects,
- 35:40or undermining confidence in the election and so the ACLU and the industry groups who were concerned that platforms would err on the side of blocking content and burdening speech.
- 35:52As an elections attorney I'm also concerned.
- 35:55I see that political compliance is a tool used by adversaries frequently to report on potential issues that their opponent may have to generate a story saying oh there's an investigation of this person because they made like one mistake on a whatever.
- 36:14So it's, there is a lot of potential for abuse here where I could see potentially reports being submitted. If the media platforms are airing on the side of taking down things it could really massively magnify these problems and you know if there's no
- 36:33requirement that the candidates, the other side of the issue be notified and given the opportunity to defend the materials so I understand what the objectives are here, but it is challenging and I think the reliance on the same con same idea of you
- 36:51is incredibly likely to harm the reputation or electoral prospects or falsely undermined confidence is going to make this bill challenging to defend the when it is invariably subjected to strict scrutiny.
- 37:06So that is that the agenda had me covering the next bill but actually Peter is going to hit it. Yeah, so I'll toss the ball over to him.
- 37:16And then we'll come to some more difficult, difficult implementation rules and some of these other laws as well. Unlike, I'm not a subject matter expert in the criminal laws that will come up later but we'll talk about what they, what they do pretty general sense.
- 37:34So the law 85 which you see here is kind of an everything else bill does a bunch of different things that are not necessarily interrelated but for the most part have to do with public sector implementation use of generative AI or a more broadly.
- 37:51First, it makes a very slight modification to existing law that applies to social media platforms. Basically, social media platforms already at the Arab a certain size, have to disclose in a semi annual reports to the California attorney general certain information about how they operate,
- 38:10including content moderation policies, and those disclosures are now required to encompass more particularly decisions about content or the use of artificial intelligence in making those decisions with respect to anything that users are posting or doing on their platform.
- 38:29So that's a slightly smaller change the rest of them are related pretty much to government activity.
- 38:36And most substantially, there is a section of the bill that essentially imports the pending California privacy protection agency regulations around what it calls automated decision making technology into and against public institutions and they're obligated to report that information.
- 38:57So in the same way that private business would kind of to the, the legislature and other bodies within the California government. In addition, the public sector institutions have to follow some compliance guidance.
- 39:12And that builds upon a pre existing executive order from Governor Newsom from 2023 that already had the California Department of Technology promulgating some guidelines. Those are going to have the force of law to a greater extent than they did previously.
- 39:30Also, in the education space, there are a couple of changes that require California Community Colleges to to follow that and also to a lesser extent the UCs in terms of procurement of AI technology and to a lesser extent with the educational institutions some some reporting around usage.
- 39:51Finally, there is why am I blanking on number four.
- 39:58I don't know. What is number four.
- 40:02Ah, yes.
- 40:04The, again, at the everything bill so these are kind of unrelated.
- 40:09Economic subsidies for certain types of public.
- 40:14I guess economic subsidies for private sector businesses in certain spaces now have to take into account in assessing the appropriateness of the subsidy, the extent to which the business that is receiving the subsidy would be using artificial intelligence to automate work or displace workers.
- 40:31It's pretty narrowly tailored to what I think is best described for purposes of today's presentation as warehouses.
- 40:37It's kind of long and short of 2885. I'm not sure how many government practitioners we have in here today in terms of people who advise public sector institution but the extent you do that 2885 may have more balance for you.
- 40:52And I think we thought we can move on.
- 40:56Okay, so this is the first of three.
- 40:59I guess the third one is not criminal in nature, but they're related to the same overarching concept, which is sexually explicit.
- 41:06So, this is a very different concept.
- 41:09Digitally altered or artificial intelligence generated content. The definitions vary a little bit across the three bills, but they're all driving kind of at the same thing.
- 41:17This one is the most perhaps interesting with perhaps most problematic.
- 41:21Although again, it's not a criminal error. I'm not going to be the one to tell you.
- 41:25There are some existing child pornography prohibitions under law, which carry some recent penalties to also criminalize the distribution or possession of what looks like child pornography, but isn't because it was created through artificial intelligence.
- 41:43So, if it appears to be a person under the age of 18, it shall be.
- 41:50I don't really have a whole lot else to say about that just because I'm not an expert in this area. And I think that it probably faces some constitutional hurdles of a different nature than the ones that Beverly was talking about.
- 42:01But there's back to speech, which I'm more familiar with.
- 42:03But I would imagine that this is really in the eye of the beholder, although I'm sure there will be some very bright line instances of things that are quite terrible and the legislative findings for this bill illustrate that very well.
- 42:16I think it remains to be seen how much this will actually change the scope of liability for what is called typically CISM child abuse sexual child, yeah, child abuse sexual material.
- 42:32And I would guess that if it appears to be someone under the age of 18, it is going to be someone under the age of 18, remember this, but nevertheless, we have now amended this law to encompass explicitly, usually altered or artificial intelligence generated
- 42:52depictions of underage people.
- 42:56Okay, let's move on to the next one.
- 43:00Alright, so this is a slightly more interesting lower scope of liability here it's just misdemeanor disorderly conduct, but again we're talking about nudity or sexually explicit imagery and distribution of it, not limited to children.
- 43:17That is essentially akin to a deep fake.
- 43:21Someone who appears to be in a state of undress revealing.
- 43:28Intimate areas of their body or engaged in sex.
- 43:32And if a reasonable person would believe that it is an authentic image of the person in question, then it is treated in the same way that a, I think the statute actually mentioned the word people, sort of, cameras that were sort of we hidden in bathrooms, kind of in yesterday
- 43:48and I don't know if that still happens, but that kind of videotaping or sort of looking into someone's space, where they're privately doing something that is sexual in nature, you know, it's going to be treated the same way that if the material that is being captured is
- 44:10seems to be an authentic image of a person.
- 44:15Statute basically built in this definition doesn't require that the person actually have engaged in viewing, but the recording activity is basically going to be analogous to the creation of that content.
- 44:28Now, whether anyone would know about it was presumably a question about distribution.
- 44:32But we can all imagine some scenarios when this would come into play.
- 44:37Again, it's a misdemeanor and it goes into effect on January 1 next year.
- 44:42And then finally, an interesting one about social networks so we can move on to the next slide.
- 44:50I'm just powering through these.
- 44:52So, the same sort of rubric that we just talked about with respect to non child images, where it's an intimate body part for the engaged or a person engaging in sex, what appears to be that person engaging in sex or in the nude.
- 45:08It's going to be applied against social media platforms of a certain the same threshold that applies throughout this, this bill.
- 45:15Sorry, throughout the statute in the business and professions code that says what a social media platform is and the thresholds that are required.
- 45:25If this would make them responsible for removing those types of images or content to the extent a user, which does not have to be the person who is depicted complaints and during the dependency of an investigation of such a complaint, the content must be restricted from access.
- 45:44The statute does not get into these are detailed about what happens if the content, if the platforms concludes that the complained about content is not subject to this, the definitions in SB 981.
- 45:59But if it is there to issue, they are I guess in any, an either scenario to issue a statement to the complainant within 30 days, extendable to 60 if they need extra time.
- 46:14And I think it's important to remember that for the most part, the social media platforms that we all use have content moderation policies that already prohibit anything of this nature to be in with.
- 46:27And it pretty closely adheres to if anyone's familiar with, for example, Instagram's guidelines where you know female nipple is not allowed male nipple is the statute tracks that pretty, pretty, pretty tightly.
- 46:42This is probably aligns pretty well with large social media platforms practices around content moderation already and thus the, the penalties and the scope of its application in practice may be somewhat limited just because there are so many social media platforms that already do this.
- 47:02And it will be interesting to see whether the definition of a social media platform could be extended to what I'll just call pornography services or websites, because to some extent they, some of them involve features that might subject them to the definition of social media platform.
- 47:23I think that remains to be seen. And it certainly doesn't, it's certainly not an intent of the bill to target that I think it's more intended to be true social media platforms, it's just the definitional slippage as possible.
- 47:36And of course, pornography sites may change and evolve over time to have more social features. Many of them already do have to some extent some of the things that would bring even to scope which is connecting users to communicate and have profiles on the service.
- 47:51So for the most part, that's a general idea of what it says.
- 47:55I think with that we just have one left which kind of is a nice bow tie on a lot of the threats that we've talked about.
- 48:02Overall today, it's a veto bill Senate bill 1047. I don't know if Doug or Beverly you want to sort of introduce this. I think it's, it's got a little bit for everyone, because it covers a lot of the sort of issues that we've been discussing earlier.
- 48:18You know, from a 40,000 foot level, what it sought to do was to require safety testing of AI systems or models before they were released to the public.
- 48:31It would have given the state attorney general the right to sue companies over serious harms caused by those technologies, including death or property damage.
- 48:45It also mandated a kill switch to turn off AI systems in case of potential by a warfare or mass casualties or property damage.
- 48:59And Newsom Governor Newsom vetoed the bill for reasons that are interesting.
- 49:11He said it was flawed because it focused too much on regulating the biggest AI systems.
- 49:19Those are known as frontier models without considering potential risks and harms from the technology.
- 49:27And what's also interesting is that support for the legislation was brought together a couple of strange bedfellows. Elon Musk, of all people, supported it.
- 49:43As did a group of entertainers, including Jane Fonda, Mark Ruffalo, Shonda Rhimes, Joseph Gordon Levitt, all of whom urged Governor Newsom to sign the bill, but he elected not to.
- 49:59And really said, yeah, go ahead.
- 50:03No, go ahead.
- 50:04I mean, I think that there is a lot of, I can understand why there was a lot of support for this in theory. I think that in practice, it kind of broke down.
- 50:12Newsom's message is a little bit of, is a very polite way of saying this doesn't seem to work the way that you think it does.
- 50:19For one thing, it's the definitional sort of crux of this bill is the idea of a covered model.
- 50:26And just to be a little bit technological for a moment, a model is a file of math.
- 50:34I mean, really, if you, if you wanted to ask someone in the space what what you're actually talking about, you can go on huggingspace.co and you can see tons of them.
- 50:42It's a very large file that contains math equations.
- 50:45So we'll get to why that's problematic for implementing a kill switch, because it's not a system.
- 50:51But the first problem is that just before development, you have to decide whether you're going to reach certain thresholds at which you have to make certain other discretionary sort of non discretionary decisions about the way
- 51:03that you'll operationalize this later.
- 51:05They can't really be undone.
- 51:08So, I think that's been part of the pushback from the technology space, just that these don't necessarily change over time, although there was a mechanism by which a new regulatory body could update these thresholds.
- 51:21But it's not going to be entirely clear to people at the beginning of embarking on creation of something, whether it's going to, you know, be under or above these particular thresholds.
- 51:33And I think it's also important to remember that it wouldn't, it was not just about the largest frontier models, it's also any fine tuning or sort of augmentation of something that already exists, for example, like an open source model of stable diffusion, if you will, for generating images,
- 51:50which a lot of businesses, because it's open source, used to build upon and customize and make a little bit better for their particular, you know, technology that they're using to deploy it.
- 52:02They're also going to be subject to this rule, even though they had nothing to do with the original training and may not know that much about it, because they may be fine tuning to a degree that exceeds those thresholds.
- 52:12So, I think that's part of the problem that people encountered and then also the definitional craziness of whether something is reasonably capable of creating, you know, a chemical weapon or causing mass casualties.
- 52:27I think it's entirely dependent on you. So it's a little bit hard for anyone to know how to implement those things. And then finally, there's the problem of a covered model not being subject to, I mean, how a model would implement a kill switch when it's something that's designed to be.
- 52:41Compatible with any number of systems. It's kind of hard to imagine how that would be technologically feasible under the way that anyone would interpret the actual term.
- 52:56Just talked a lot. So, Doug, do you want to go back to the veto message? I mean, I think the veto message was this probably overkill.
- 53:05And we may see it. We may see a version of 1047 surface here or the federal level or in another state that is a little bit more.
- 53:17I think thoughtful and it's scope and application. But the idea of regulating something based on what it could possibly be used to do by someone else is kind of an inherent possibility when we're talking about.
- 53:32A model that's designed to produce output that's tailored to human input or the input that it receives as the OECD definition would have it.
- 53:44Yeah, if you can put up the final substantive slide that has the veto message on it.
- 53:52You know, you'll see that Governor Newsom suggested that he's got things. I've got one more slide after that. There we go.
- 54:03You'll see that he's sympathetic to the aims of the bill, but has said that it needs more work.
- 54:14And, you know, this really would have put California in the forefront of this issue. And I think he wanted to be, or at least he says he wanted to be a little more careful about this and a little more comprehensive and, you know, not essentially impose obligations that weren't to be imposed across the board to all who might.
- 54:43For whom this technology might be relevant. So, you know, whether we whether that's to be believed or not, that's, that is kind of what he said and and we'll see, I think, whether in the next session, this all of this gets revisited.
- 55:00One of the things that the author complained about Scott Wiener from San Francisco was that the governor's office didn't intervene early on to, you know, what its concerns were.
- 55:15And so the veto came kind of kind of out of the blue. So he says, so, so we will see.
- 55:23But yeah, we may see something work into the European unions, AI act, which is a little bit, a little bit. It's a sweeping bribe, but on the important issues of when certain things are going to be high risk as it's termed there.
- 55:36It's a little bit easier to understand how something could lead to those particular effects because it's not focused on the nature of the output but intended use cases and where deployments occur.
- 55:49So, I definitely think that that's worth paying attention to should this be reintroduced.
- 55:54We've seen California adopt European style regulations in the past CCPA is effectively a clone with some important modifications of the general data protection or regulation.
- 56:05And of course, past four years after that went into effect. The EU AI act is in effect to some extent to a limited extent right now and we'll go further into effect over the coming years.
- 56:16So we may see something work into that in the future. It's getting at the same problem.
- 56:24No, with that, I think we're, we're open for questions. If Randy, do you want to be our gatekeeper.
- 56:34Sure. Yeah, thank you very much. That was so informative and a lot to take in. So thank you for walking us through that.
- 56:40There's a lot of us who are entertainment lawyers as you know, on this meeting. One question touched upon.
- 56:47Since we represent a number of celebrities.
- 56:50Maybe you could tell us, are there any specific rules attached to a celebrity endorsement of a particular political candidate. Maybe that's something for Beverly to address.
- 57:01Sure. And there are not unless the celebrity is paid to appear in a campaign communication. So celebrities are, you know, like any people have the right to, to make an endorsement.
- 57:18And if a celebrity is paid to appear in an ad, then that is something that must be put on the disclaimer and use a report that is filed that says, you know, so and so was paid and here's how much they were paid but strictly strictly for endorsements.
- 57:36I mean, also I'm not aware personally of any celebrity, like, hey, being paid by a candidate for an endorsement that is not something that I actually have knowledge of happening. I may, but I don't at the premise that a celebrity celebrity is paid to endorse is not
- 57:58necessarily one that I am saying is taking place.
- 58:03I guess allowing the similar vein if there's a particular, let's say, television show that is an effect talking about a particular candidate is there specific disclosures for the television series or something of that nature.
- 58:19Are we talking about perhaps a satirical or a parody type show then. No, I mean, and these laws that we were discussing here are all ones that wouldn't really apply to like a show where there's somebody who's obviously fictitiously portraying a candidate it would
- 58:38apply to something where you can't really detect it would appear to a reasonable person that it is likely to be an authentic image. And so it doesn't apply to Alec Baldwin impersonating Donald Trump, like we all know he does a great
- 58:53version, but we know it's not Donald Trump. This is what the things we're talking about in these bills are much more nuanced and like harder to detect impersonation so and and there are also I should have mentioned this or exemptions for broadcast stations from these bills for covering
- 59:12these kind of communications or they can also put a disclaimer saying that things don't actually accurately represent any actual event, but I don't think there's any danger that like a parody show would have to include a disclaimer saying like that this is not an actual event because
- 59:28it's obvious to the viewer that it is not an actual event. And are there rules with respect to equal time for the various candidates and distinction between a new show or parody show is that something that you handle or there are equal time rules for advertising for
- 59:46federal candidates but that doesn't apply to parody type shows I mean I don't I don't advise on this issue but it is. There's nothing regulating how much time you have to give to a candidate on on a parody show that's kind of up to the, that's like their
- 1:00:02first amendment right to artistic and free speech and maybe Doug has more. Well, although we know that in this last cycle. The appearance by Kamala Harris on SNL was met with an equal time complaint by the Trump campaign and in fact NBC gave
- 1:00:23Trump twice as much time as Kamala Harris had on air by way of commercial time following sporting events I'm not sure I recall exactly which it may have been an NFL game or may have been something along those lines.
- 1:00:44And so, you know, that's, and that decision that was made to do that was somewhat controversial and and you know I don't know whether in fact the equal time rules would have mandated that but out of abundance of caution I think NBC decided let's let's give him the time.
- 1:01:06Yeah, and I think there's a difference between also like featuring the candidate versus like a act of parodying the candidate to is like somewhat those would be handled differently but yeah that's a good point that and I hadn't I had not been aware of the NBC decision to do that so
- 1:01:26interesting concerns.
- 1:01:29Does California have a deep fake law for living personalities like the Elvis act.
- 1:01:36So, the Elvis act is an interesting piece of legislation that was recently enacted in Tennessee.
- 1:01:46It is intended to effectively augment what had not been a particularly robust writer publicity statute in that state.
- 1:02:00Elvis by the way stands for ensuring likeness voice and image security so in addition to it being protective of you know who.
- 1:02:09So, that's what that's what the acronym stands for. But to answer the question more specifically, California is interesting in that the statute governing the writer publicity for living individuals, which is civil code 3344, as opposed to 3344.1, which is the one that
- 1:02:32concerns deceased personalities 3344 doesn't contain the same expressive works exemption.
- 1:02:41And so a lot of the cases that have been decided under it, starting with comedy three the case involving the three stuges is a case where, you know the courts have essentially applied the law outside of the commercial context outside of goods and services.
- 1:03:01And applied it in that case to lithographs, which are sort of an expressive medium and subsequently video game cases involving NCAA football players and professional football players have likewise taken advantage of the statute.
- 1:03:18But in terms of the way California law has developed. There's also another line of authority involving the common law writer publicity. And that's what's been invoked in other look alike and sound alike cases.
- 1:03:36So cases involving for example, a robotic Vanna white cases involving a unique pitching stance by a former Dodger non Don Newcomb sound like voices of bet middler have all been actionable under California's common law writer publicity.
- 1:03:57And that common law writer publicity will, in my view, likely be applicable to to digital replica.
- 1:04:09Is there does that one.
- 1:04:11I think there's case law to support the idea that that has to be a commercial use is that right. No, there's not.
- 1:04:17Not really. I mean, you know, the, the comedy three case establishes that that's that that's not the case and whether you want to view. I don't know how you want to video games but they are, you know, at least according to the Supreme Court.
- 1:04:33They are expressive works to that are equally protected so doesn't apply to necessarily just good services.
- 1:04:44Okay, well, I think it's about time we wrap up. I know that we keep talking about all of this forever and we definitely look forward to reaching back out to you all as we know that the legislation will continue to evolve as AI does.
- 1:05:00And so, thank you very much. And have a great rest of the afternoon.
- 1:05:08Thank you.
- 1:05:10You may be eligible for CLE credit in your state. Visit bhba.org slash podcasts for more information.