Latest / Newcomer Pod / AI is saving the economy. For now.
Transcript
- 0:00I'll be honest Eric, I'm having, I'm having an annoying day.
- 0:04I have been trying to reach sources in the AI world because
- 0:06I really need to get my story out and no one wants to talk
- 0:09because everyone is paying attention to the GPT 5 release.
- 0:12Well, it's like a bank holiday in tech, you know, it's just
- 0:15like everybody's and they complain.
- 0:17I feel like the competitors all complain that, you know, open
- 0:20their eyes. People all tweet in advance and
- 0:23they're like, we got something becoming, you know, they,
- 0:25they're good at building up the sort of excitement on Twitter.
- 0:29And then, you know, everybody clearly is excited.
- 0:32It feels like all the other AI companies are orbiting, you
- 0:35know, these open AI, They gotta be excited.
- 0:37About something 'cause remember last year Sam had the, the 12
- 0:41days of shipments where they were putting out a new product
- 0:44every day, which I think culminated in for, for something
- 0:49I remember which model, but the fact that I don't remember
- 0:51clearly means that it didn't build towards something huge.
- 0:54Where is, you know, this one is supposed to be really
- 0:57meaningful. Like this is supposed to be the
- 0:59moment where GPT 5 and open AI reasserts itself as the best
- 1:04model that's out there. And specifically on coding, they
- 1:07in their, you know, embargoed press conference and then later
- 1:10in, you know, the, the, the, the public press conference today
- 1:13basically said like we have the best model out there for coding
- 1:16and I'm coding. All these everybody would like
- 1:20them to get better, right? People are spending a ton of
- 1:22money on it. Anthropic is dominating and
- 1:25competition is good for consumers.
- 1:27So we'd like them to succeed. Not not clear yet if they have.
- 1:32I mean, the prediction markets, you know, I think there's a
- 1:35betting pool on who will have the best model at the end of the
- 1:38month. And Gemini as as leading and I
- 1:43think gained a lot of ground when GBD 5 came out.
- 1:47So the initial reaction I think is not so positive.
- 1:52This podcast is supported by Google.
- 1:54Hi folks, Paige Bailey here from the Google DeepMind Devrel team.
- 1:57For our developers out there, we know there's a constant trade
- 2:00off between model intelligence, speed and cost.
- 2:03Gemini 2.5 Flash aims right at that challenge.
- 2:06It's got the speed you expect from Flash, but with upgraded
- 2:09reasoning power. And crucially, we've added
- 2:11controls like setting thinking budgets so you can decide how
- 2:14much reasoning to apply, optimizing for latency and
- 2:16costs. So try out Gemini 2.5 at
- 2:19aistudio.google.com and let us know what you build.
- 2:23And I feel like a real loser. I mean I keep opening ChatGPT
- 2:27waiting for Christmas to arrive and mine still says 4 O and I'm
- 2:32paying you guys. I've got a plus account.
- 2:35I asked Chad GBT like, are you what, What do I do?
- 2:39And it's like trying to do like logic puzzles with itself to see
- 2:42if it thinks it's actually GBT 5 or not.
- 2:45It's like, well, if I was 4, I wouldn't be, I wouldn't be able
- 2:48to solve this problem if I was 4 O so I must be 5.
- 2:53You know, it's like, why can't they just program it, doesn't
- 2:56it? I thought they'd give these
- 2:57things prompts where they say like.
- 2:59Doesn't your prompt tell you what model you are?
- 3:02Oh, I I have. Yeah.
- 3:03I guess it should be able to say that that's a fairly basic
- 3:06feature that's just like the about page on your iPhone.
- 3:09Like, yeah, I forgot what kind of iPhone model I have.
- 3:12But you've actually plunged this thing into like a deep
- 3:14existential crisis. If she's like, have you been
- 3:17outmoded yet? You know, do they had they had
- 3:19like a funeral recently for Claude for one of the early.
- 3:22I didn't see that. Wait, what?
- 3:23Yeah, yeah. Kylie Robinson, our buddy over
- 3:26at Wired Now, I think she had a piece about this talking.
- 3:30Has she been on the show? Yeah, we need to have her on
- 3:31the. Show no, we should have her.
- 3:32She lives down the street for me too.
- 3:33We should have her have her in studio.
- 3:35But yeah, she she did this story about how when they retired one
- 3:38of the early versions of the Claude model, they had like a
- 3:41funeral for it, which is a particular type of AI
- 3:45researcher. Very anthropic.
- 3:48Yeah. Oh yeah, for sure.
- 3:50Anthropic, by the way, is definitely feeling the heat like
- 3:53they rush released. It seemed like their updated
- 3:55version of clawed like clawed Sonnet 4.1 or something this
- 3:59week. So it's been and then also open
- 4:01air had the the open source model that came out, which
- 4:05everyone for whatever reason, declared not everyone, you know,
- 4:08whatever Twitter's algorithm wanted to show me like declared
- 4:10as like a a kind of a bust. It didn't seem like it truly
- 4:14wasn't met with like the DeepSeek, like ferocity.
- 4:18Well, DeepSeek was about other people being able to play catch
- 4:21up to open AI. So open AI, you know, there's
- 4:26such high expectations. I mean, the thing that open AI
- 4:28has that everybody else doesn't have is users.
- 4:31You know, just like there's the inertia that consumers will use
- 4:34whatever we have. Like we can say oh, the four O
- 4:36announcement was underwhelming, but it's like I'm going to chat
- 4:39to UBT and just waiting for the the thing to update.
- 4:42But I, there's like a, a more powerful model, which I think
- 4:45there's no debate as to whether or not 5 is better in most
- 4:49regards to like the earlier open AI models.
- 4:51Like is that going to drive more growth?
- 4:53Like who are these model updates really for?
- 4:55I, I get the like coding side of it.
- 4:57Like that's a very competitive field and Anthropic basically
- 5:00owns it now. So like open AI has business
- 5:02reasons to be a real player there.
- 5:04But you know what is Chachi BT is at like 700 million weekly
- 5:09users now. Like is the thing that takes him
- 5:12to a billion like 5 being that much more powerful or it's just
- 5:16like generally like there's still more that word that needs
- 5:19to to leak out to the non initiateds about like ChatGPT as
- 5:24a software rather than the fact that like 5 can do whatever
- 5:28logic puzzles slightly better. First I was like, this is an
- 5:31insane question because it's like, obviously you know, for
- 5:37consumers, they have to go find how the model can deliver value.
- 5:41And the smarter it is, the more value they'll get out of it and
- 5:43the more reasons they have it. If they're using the lot, open
- 5:46AI will find more ways to charge for it.
- 5:47So obviously, you know, a better model means a lot of stuff.
- 5:51And then, you know, real businesses that we'll build on
- 5:54top of the API will find use cases and be able to charge for
- 5:58it and hand hold users to the value.
- 6:02But I, I do agree with the a piece of the question, which is
- 6:05just like sort of astonishment that these models can be as
- 6:10impressive as they are today. And there's still lots of people
- 6:14who don't use them at all. And then some of us that do use
- 6:16the models, we're not really trying to apply them in all the
- 6:20cases we should. But but I think that's just
- 6:22because it's like the the sort of like, you know, businesses
- 6:25are going to need to build on top of these models to hand hold
- 6:29us to exactly the value. And so getting smarter is great
- 6:33for the API business and that's where I think a lot of the
- 6:36business could be long term. Yeah, but that implies that
- 6:39people were using earlier versions of the models and were
- 6:41underwhelmed by it because it was technically not as powerful
- 6:45as they wanted, when really could just be like they haven't
- 6:47been exposed to it. I'm talking about normies,
- 6:49right? Just people that would be using
- 6:51ChatGPT. I.
- 6:52Just think you know some hallucinations and you don't
- 6:54trust somebody you know somebody lies to you a couple times
- 6:56you're like don't trust you. You know, I, I, I think sort of
- 7:00consistency is really valuable in building trust.
- 7:03And so if these models can, can become just more reliable, and I
- 7:07think that's part of what open AI is saying here.
- 7:09It hallucinates less and that that could help it a lot.
- 7:13I mean, it's worth saying. I mean, while we want to get
- 7:16much more intelligent, part of the big development here is just
- 7:20that this is a unified model that open AI is going to route
- 7:23you to, Oh, you. This is a pretty easy question.
- 7:26We don't need the model to waste all its resources thinking about
- 7:29it. And oh, this is an intense
- 7:31question. We'll think about it.
- 7:32And so that could allow the model to operate great more
- 7:35efficiently and also just make it life easier for consumers to
- 7:39get great answers without having to pick the appropriate model.
- 7:43Yeah, I, I think it's both like a model selector, but also my
- 7:47understanding is that the models themselves have been improved.
- 7:50So it's not just like we've routed to the most useful thing
- 7:53to answer your question, but you know, the the tool, the tool
- 7:57itself is more powerful. Yeah, I, I don't know.
- 8:00I mean, I don't go you use this more than I do.
- 8:02I don't yet pay for the, the, the plus version of it, $20.00 a
- 8:06month is just I'm not there yet. I'm not sorry.
- 8:09I'm not even against it. I just like I haven't found $20
- 8:12worth of value for me that is like that much better than the
- 8:14free version. I just like proofread it,
- 8:16feedback, run my stories through it.
- 8:18What do you think? What am I missing?
- 8:20Like it always gives me a couple useful thoughts.
- 8:23Like, all right, it's a new model.
- 8:25I mean, I think the last word on it to me is just we always try
- 8:28to like decide whether it's a good model on the first day.
- 8:31And I think nobody knows right away.
- 8:33It takes, takes some time. We we write off models and then
- 8:37they become sort of our daily drivers.
- 8:40And then other times we get excited and then nothing.
- 8:43So I think we'll see people play around with them.
- 8:47Yeah. I also think we can't understate
- 8:48how significant it is for open AI in terms of, you know, it
- 8:53needing to be some kind of a leap for them because a lot of
- 8:56the conversation has been, you know, GPT, everything has been
- 8:59more or less iterations on four. We came out like a little bit
- 9:03over two years ago. So this is like a like, there's
- 9:05no way around this one. This wasn't.
- 9:07And you know that the back story of building this, you know, this
- 9:09model was that for a long time they were working on this giant
- 9:13model. Like I don't even know how many
- 9:14trillion parameter model that was.
- 9:16You know, they called it Orion internally and they realized
- 9:19most of the way through it kept being delayed and delayed and
- 9:22delayed that it wasn't showing off large enough improvements in
- 9:25capability for it to be for it to merit being called 5.
- 9:29And the same time, you know, this breakthrough came with like
- 9:32deep reasoning and, and in like logic, you know, the ability for
- 9:36it to like handle more complex gain of thought.
- 9:39And so they ended up calling Orion GPT 4.5 and it's basically
- 9:43unused as a model. No one really talks about it,
- 9:45but 5 is the real deal. Like it has to be something.
- 9:48It can't just be written off as like, yeah, we're still
- 9:50iterating on something. And this does not feel, it does
- 9:53not feel like what the four, what was the iPhone 4, the one
- 9:58where it's like, oh, new mock or it's like they have the App
- 10:01Store. And, well, 10X, right?
- 10:03The iPhone X the first time they had like the full.
- 10:05Screen, it's not like that it's not one of the big iPhone
- 10:08moments where it's like, oh, they really changed it.
- 10:10This is like, Oh yeah, they they come out with new phones every
- 10:12once in awhile and sometimes we we try to get ourselves excited
- 10:16about it and that's how this feels to me and I agree yeah,
- 10:20we've been talking about 5 for a long time.
- 10:22Thought 5 would be an insane moment.
- 10:24And so far I'm not seeing that level of like hysterical
- 10:28euphoria that I, I would have expected, you know, six months
- 10:32ago for ChatGPT 5. Yeah, which again, like back to
- 10:35what you said earlier is maybe why people are expecting Gemini
- 10:38to leap ahead because opening eyes best shot just didn't blow
- 10:42people away as much as, you know, maybe unrealistic
- 10:44expectations LED them to think like they're in a big fight in,
- 10:48in terms of model quality. Now, like you, you've got
- 10:50Anthropic very capably putting out stuff, you know, Meta, I'm
- 10:53assuming will come out with something of of value.
- 10:57And, you know, Google is very serious.
- 10:59Microsoft still irrelevant, by the way.
- 11:01Like I'm never not gonna say until they do something real
- 11:03here. Yeah.
- 11:04Like it's just a very different landscape than when 4 came out.
- 11:07Let's talk about a related but different topic.
- 11:11So the CapEx build out, data center build out, we we're in
- 11:17this moment. And I keep telling this to other
- 11:19people AI adjacent. They're like, man, AI is
- 11:21apparently like propping up the entire economy.
- 11:24It's like, thank God, you know, we're in the orbiting artificial
- 11:28intelligence because that's that's the thing, saving the
- 11:31economy. And you know what they have to
- 11:33say like. The Wall Street Journal when I
- 11:36was covering AI so now. You're working for, you know,
- 11:39company with an AI conference. So even we got even closer to
- 11:42it. They, they.
- 11:43Yeah, that was the problem. I wasn't close enough to AI.
- 11:46Exactly. But the the thing say, you know,
- 11:48it's the infrastructure build out, that there's real capital
- 11:51expenditures going into this and that the big tech giants, you
- 11:55know, are spending aggressively. Yeah, basically what I saw
- 11:57happen. And it's kind of funny when like
- 11:59an idea just percolates through, you know, the discourse.
- 12:02But you had at least three different articles come out in
- 12:05the last two weeks pointing out. We, we were earlier than some of
- 12:09this like sorry, there, there. Is this what Kadroski or
- 12:13whatever he sort of initiated it?
- 12:16Is it Paul or Peter? Yeah, that's Paul Kadroski I saw
- 12:20so we. Riffed on that like a couple
- 12:23weeks ago and now yeah, The Journal Noah Smith A bunch of
- 12:27people are like, oh, maybe everybody loves a good oh, the
- 12:31world could end in financial collapse thesis and that's sort
- 12:35of what what this is right? Yeah.
- 12:37And essentially and what I think Kedrosky's article did very did
- 12:41a very good job explaining was like you know and we had some
- 12:43new GDP numbers coming out. It's also earning season so
- 12:46people can more easily calculate what like the the CapEx spending
- 12:49looks like for all the biggest companies, but a non
- 12:53insignificant percentage of it, what was it like almost 1% of of
- 12:56GDP growth came from AI CapEx spending.
- 13:00And that is, you know, like the chart that that Kedrosky put
- 13:04together showed that, you know, outside of the building of the
- 13:08railroads and like the telecom build out duringthe.com bubble,
- 13:13you know, you have you seen that much of GDP growth confined to
- 13:17one particular sector? And it's a, you know, an
- 13:19infrastructure build out that at least in the case of AI is like
- 13:22well ahead of it's, you know, it's, it's broad, broad based
- 13:27adoption. And I guess, you know, the, the
- 13:30next question to all of this is like, well, is this a bubble?
- 13:33Is this something that could potentially bring down the
- 13:36economy if AI doesn't end up becoming what a lot of people
- 13:40are expecting? And I, I, you know, I want to
- 13:43take the bear case on this one because it's more interesting to
- 13:46me and, and say, like, Oh yeah, we're absolutely circulating,
- 13:50you know, a, a Bear Stearns like event where, you know, AI
- 13:53doesn't, you know, doesn't pan out.
- 13:56But I just don't see it. Like I can't follow the train of
- 13:59the train of thought that leads me to AI.
- 14:02You know, CapEx spending is going to somehow when AI doesn't
- 14:06get as widely adopted, result in like the collapse of, you know.
- 14:10Like 10%. Unemployment.
- 14:12This is like Meta going on on the metaverse, like they spent
- 14:16tons of money trying to do that and like, well, didn't work.
- 14:19The the key here is that the Max 7 they make tons of money and so
- 14:24they can spend a bunch on CapEx for everybody.
- 14:27But Meta, it's still, I think less than their actual sort of
- 14:31cloud revenue, right? And even if it were bigger, it's
- 14:33just like they stopped doing it one day and they say, OK, well,
- 14:37we'll print money again. Like I, I don't see the debt
- 14:40story. I know some of these things are
- 14:42like financed, but they're super valuable companies that could
- 14:45raise unlimited sums of money that produce real cash.
- 14:49Like, yeah, they're monopoly. What's, what do you like?
- 14:52If you're a monopoly, what are you going to do with that,
- 14:54right? If you have just an incredible
- 14:56margin, you have cash flow like crazy cash flow.
- 14:59The money's got to go somewhere. You could do stock buybacks.
- 15:02You could. And this is a good thing.
- 15:05Like, wouldn't we? I feel like the sort of left
- 15:08it's like, oh, you know, share buybacks, like exactly what
- 15:11you're saying. Share buybacks and dividends are
- 15:12they're bad. They're not doing anything.
- 15:14It's like here they are. They're excited about something
- 15:17in the future and they're investing in the real world
- 15:20infrastructure to run at it. I mean, I think if you believe
- 15:23AI will be good for the world, then it's like, great, yeah.
- 15:26So what if they're spending a little bit ahead of, you know,
- 15:30themselves and they they find out they sort of overbuilt too
- 15:33soon? Yeah.
- 15:34I guess like there's an argument that like the actual technology
- 15:37that you're building is something that's going to be
- 15:38like job displacing. So like there's a medium to long
- 15:42term impact of building up the technology there.
- 15:44But like, I mean, that gets into like the, you know, kind of
- 15:46technophobic argument of like, well, what do you want to do?
- 15:48Not invest in this technology that's going to be
- 15:51transformative like I never and I again, I'd love to take the
- 15:54bear case here, but I just can't follow that logic of like, let's
- 15:57let's not do the thing that could potentially create like
- 15:59God. And the people making those
- 16:02arguments are always on their iPhones, you know, they're just
- 16:05like, it's they, they're once like, I mean what?
- 16:08It's the Chapo's of the world who are like anti tech, but then
- 16:12they're clearly like tech addicted.
- 16:14You know, it's like they never choose not to use the products
- 16:18that they say, oh, we shouldn't we shouldn't build the next one,
- 16:21even though I love the current one.
- 16:23Yeah, it never makes. Yeah, I don't.
- 16:25Want to go too let's I would want to save that part of the
- 16:27conversation for a different episode because I do think there
- 16:29is something to say about like the social impact of AI and the
- 16:32effect that it's having on like intelligence and like
- 16:35sociability and like. You know, trying to think about
- 16:38stuff like, I think like people not reading, I mean, we talked
- 16:41about this on the Rupal Valley podcast.
- 16:44I made a defensive reading and writing.
- 16:47I, I, I do worry about that. But to me that's more of a
- 16:51social media phenomenon. AI as it exists right now in a
- 16:55chat bot actually makes you like sort of think and write and
- 16:59engage. I I think it's much more
- 17:01intelligent than sort of the leaner force.
- 17:02You're forced me into this argument now.
- 17:04Yeah, Yeah, I think, I think the intent aspect of, you know,
- 17:08ChatGPT is much better than the passive and engagement of social
- 17:12media. There's no question to me that
- 17:14that is an improvement. I think the idea of and.
- 17:15Social media is built on engagement, whereas at least for
- 17:19now, chat bots are predicated on getting you truthful answers and
- 17:23appearing smart on tests. So obviously they're much more
- 17:27virtuous than feeds. I think outsourcing writing and
- 17:32all thought to an AI is like problematic for a society.
- 17:36Like rather than cogitating over an issue, yeah, yeah.
- 17:39Or like, I need to fire these employees, how can you please
- 17:41write this for me so I don't have to deal with, like, the
- 17:44emotional labor of what it means to communicate to someone is
- 17:47like a net negative on society. Like I think there's all kinds
- 17:50of bad things that like asking someone to imitate human emotion
- 17:53and logic and having that be like, then put in your own words
- 17:58like has on a society. But I don't think that's what
- 18:01Kedrosky was getting at in his No, we're pretty far from you.
- 18:06Force me into it. A piece of it.
- 18:09Yeah. Look, I think there's also like,
- 18:12yeah, for the Mag 7. I don't know remember exactly
- 18:15who's in in the Mag 7 but but for all these companies.
- 18:19Alphabet. Yeah, these are like cash
- 18:21machines, like they have no issue investing in in in
- 18:25infrastructure. They're not taking on huge
- 18:27amounts of debt. There are companies in the AI
- 18:29mix that I'm a little bit more concerned about.
- 18:32Oracle, which I pay attention to, is taking on debt so they
- 18:35can finance the Stargate shit that they're doing with open AI.
- 18:38Isn't Oracle just they're like professionally rich and good at
- 18:42selling tax? I mean, I haven't dug into them
- 18:44as much as you, but they have they're doing the financing
- 18:48because they have have money, right.
- 18:50Yeah. And like so far no one's like
- 18:52freaking out about Oracle because they're taking on debt
- 18:54to like, you know, buy the GP us that are going to be in the
- 18:57Stargate data centers. But they're just in a different
- 18:59class of company than the MAG 7 because they're not in the MAG
- 19:037. And you know, there's also ones
- 19:05like like core Weave, which you know, is a crazily valued stock
- 19:09right now and they're taking on they they keep going back to the
- 19:12debt markets to to do build out. So there are some like there is
- 19:15some concerning leverage I think for some of these companies that
- 19:19that are taking on debt, but it doesn't seem like a load bearing
- 19:23beam that if those things go under like you're going to see a
- 19:262008 like event happen or even I'm.
- 19:29Definitely open to a world where here's the bull case.
- 19:33Sorry, the bear case to me, which I'm not necessarily
- 19:37subscribed to, is all the tech stocks are massively inflated
- 19:44because they're investing in the technology that's driving some
- 19:50of their revenue and driving their multiples.
- 19:53Because basically it's like, we're gonna, you know, big tech
- 19:57companies are the biggest investors in AI startups.
- 20:01Those startups are turning around spending on cloud
- 20:04computing and foundation models and stuff.
- 20:06Where they're, they're generating revenue, so they're
- 20:08spending money to make money instead of old, you know,
- 20:11revenue round tripping issue. And then the opportunity of AI
- 20:16is also increasing their multiples.
- 20:18So I could see a world where all right, you know, suddenly AI is
- 20:22not delivering as much as people thought or AI is delivering, but
- 20:26there's no margin to be had because open source is so
- 20:29successful. And then all the stocks crash
- 20:32and they crash because, you know, they're, they're sort of
- 20:36benefiting in multiple ways, both revenue and multiples.
- 20:39And so that would hurt them. And I think given that they're
- 20:42so important to the performance of the S&P 500, it would just be
- 20:46like a bleak, you know, the American economy would all of a
- 20:49sudden everybody would feel much poorer because the value of like
- 20:52the stock market has gone down so much.
- 20:54But it doesn't seem, it seems like, oh, we're all just like a
- 20:56lot poorer. I, I don't see this sort of like
- 20:58ripple effect. They're companies that make a
- 21:00lot of money. They make way less, they're way
- 21:02less valuable. And then suddenly America just
- 21:03feels weaker relative to the rest of the global economy.
- 21:08But I don't necessarily see like who's going bankrupt.
- 21:13Yeah. And like, let's just also
- 21:15remember that, like these companies all crushed earnings
- 21:19these last two weeks. Like they're foundational.
- 21:21Bullish. And they're AI.
- 21:23Yeah. It's like it's clearly this is
- 21:24where things are going. We spend all our time on the
- 21:26Internet like these companies are the main entities innovating
- 21:29in the world. Like they're very sophisticated
- 21:33businesses. Yeah, I don't, I don't know.
- 21:35I'm pretty bullish. Yeah.
- 21:37I guess the part of it that I think is worth being concerned
- 21:42about or paying attention to is the fact that it is a non
- 21:47marginal part of GDP growth like spending on these things and
- 21:50like you have to just pay attention to that.
- 21:52Like whenever one sector is that responsible for like absent all
- 21:55of these things that we would kind of have fairly anemic
- 21:58growth. And you know, the argument also
- 22:02is like, well, that's fine because this is transformative.
- 22:04Like we should be investing in these things.
- 22:06And like this is all going to like later lead toward even more
- 22:08growth because we're going to have all this efficiency and and
- 22:11then people will be more productive.
- 22:13But it's like it's getting into the territory where it's
- 22:16interwoven into the broader economy.
- 22:18It's not just like some tech experiment of, you know, some
- 22:22companies building something that could be cool like this is
- 22:24now part of it. Like you're, you know, you're
- 22:28woven into the fabric of what's making the economy work and
- 22:32problems within that. I don't mean we won't even
- 22:34foresee what the problem could be, but problems within that
- 22:36will have ripple effects. And that's it's just worth
- 22:38paying attention to. Like I don't see the warning
- 22:40signs yet. But like it's, you know, it's
- 22:43built into it. Well, it's just also just it's
- 22:46been too long, you know, in between crashes, right?
- 22:49Like you know what? I In startups, there was a
- 22:52downturn, You know, 2021 was a peak.
- 22:55We came down. There were all these software
- 22:57companies that were overvalued. We did have a a minor correction
- 23:01because of the pandemic inflating the value of tech
- 23:04stocks and driving forward revenue that then slowed down.
- 23:08But yeah, I came around at just the perfect time.
- 23:12And like, there's no, like there's no morality play there.
- 23:15It's like, oh, we should have, we should have really taken our
- 23:17comeuppance more. It's like, no, we got lucky that
- 23:20there was like another really cool idea just as tech was about
- 23:24to take it pretty hard from getting overexcited about
- 23:27everybody working remotely. And so that that sort of safe
- 23:30things. And that is the tech idea that
- 23:32it's like, oh, we'll keep up coming up with new ideas and the
- 23:34new ideas are are real things and that will create value.
- 23:38And it's not just like financial games like on Wall Street.
- 23:42Right. And it's also just kind of the
- 23:43way things work. Like I I see this argument being
- 23:46applied to San Francisco and be like man if it wasn't for the AI
- 23:49boom San Francisco would really be fuck.
- 23:51Right, that's just a job. They're all hard at work, like
- 23:53coming up with a new thing, going where it's.
- 23:55Kind of what they do here, there's always something, man.
- 23:58It's like, man, if it wasn't for the Gold Rush, San Francisco
- 24:00would really be. Fight right, right.
- 24:02Yeah, it's, it's like that's not really the argument you think it
- 24:05is, because that's just like that's how a boom economy tends
- 24:08to work. And the fact that, like, San
- 24:10Francisco keeps coming up with the new thing that matters to
- 24:13the economy is why, like. Detroit good at is they all left
- 24:17crypto because crypto stopped making them money and they shift
- 24:20over to AI. And honestly, you want things to
- 24:22die so that people can go to the actual productive parts of the
- 24:26economy and, you know, yeah. Well, you're closer to the
- 24:30crypto people than I am. But like, like, are they all
- 24:33just like riding a false high right now?
- 24:35Like knowing that the the value of all of their holdings is like
- 24:38not really logical at all That like what?
- 24:40Do you mean Bitcoin? I mean the dollar is eroding at
- 24:43the moment. So I mean Bitcoin is like there
- 24:45is, there is, I mean, I, I don't hold a lot of Bitcoin.
- 24:48I, you know, I have what, $1000 worth or something, but like
- 24:53definitely, I, I think, you know, Bitcoin is a psychological
- 24:57investment thing, just like, you know, so many things and it's a
- 25:01bet against the dollar. And I, I think the dollar is in
- 25:05a bad place. So I don't, I don't know.
- 25:07I, I think the other thing in crypto, which this is, you know,
- 25:10it's just that it's like fraud is legal and there's tons of
- 25:14fraud in crypto. And so it's like you can do
- 25:16whatever you want seemingly. And so I think that's going to
- 25:19open up some activity. Right.
- 25:21Well, I'm just thinking about it because, you know, I, I was
- 25:25reading our buddy Mike Isaac's story about San Francisco and
- 25:29like, you know, this moment, the, you know, the AI moment and
- 25:32how we've moved to the hard tech era in, in Silicon Valley.
- 25:36And you know, he had this like 1.
- 25:37The clause in there of like San Francisco is used to like things
- 25:40like blowing up and like, he's like, like crypto and he's like
- 25:43also things tanking crypto, which is like a funny structure,
- 25:48but also like, like crypto is not tanking right now.
- 25:51It's just in terms of like the value of the currencies, it's
- 25:53actually really high. So that wasn't the best analogy.
- 25:57Did you read that piece by the way?
- 25:59Yeah, I, I read some of it. I mean, I, I don't get, you
- 26:03know, it's just the, the trend story sort of thing.
- 26:07You know, it's like this is the New York Times, you know, it's
- 26:10like this, this is where we are. I mean, I, I think it's
- 26:13generally correct. You know, it's just like, I
- 26:15don't know, it's not, it's too high level.
- 26:19I guess, Yeah. I mean, first of all, you know,
- 26:21Mike's a buddy and I always, you know, want to support my friends
- 26:24work and, you know, the New York Times, you know, loves calling a
- 26:27moment and explaining to the normies what's going on here.
- 26:31You know, there's always like kind of a combination of like
- 26:34things that have been going on for like years that we just call
- 26:36is like, oh, this is just happening now.
- 26:37It's like the year of efficiency I think was like 2022.
- 26:41So it's hard to say That's like specific to the crypt.
- 26:44A lot of things about tech are just.
- 26:47Things humans do and a lot of things people hate about the
- 26:49media are just things humans do. And a thing humans do are say
- 26:53what is what is the mood of the moment?
- 26:55And, you know, there were tech buses.
- 26:56The, you know, we have these narratives in The New York
- 26:58Times. And I think Mike's story does a
- 27:00good job of trying to sort of coalesce, like where where's our
- 27:04headspace at? And obviously these things are
- 27:05all, you know. Yeah.
- 27:07So. But.
- 27:07There, but there is something different.
- 27:09I was talking to our our colleague Jonathan Weber about
- 27:12this. Like I think there is something
- 27:14worth examining about, you know, what does the AI moment, how
- 27:18does it compare to previous booms and busts and waves of
- 27:22technology? And like, there's no question.
- 27:24And like his article starts off with his interesting analogy of
- 27:27Silicon Valley and like the rest and vest era and how you know
- 27:33there was a time starts. Off.
- 27:34I know we love him, but he starts off in fiction.
- 27:38He talks about Silicon Valley, the show, and he's like, oh, but
- 27:41it was really truthy. It's like, oh man, of all
- 27:43places, I wish the New York Times wasn't sort of doing.
- 27:45That's like, well, I, I have to, I have to do a disclosure on
- 27:49anything related to that show because I was briefly an advisor
- 27:53to it and my brother was an executive producer on it, so.
- 27:55I was once a storyboard meeting with that, yeah.
- 27:58Associate Producer. I had multiple meetings in a
- 28:00cameo. Your brother was like legit on
- 28:02the show. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 28:04No, but there was a lot of research that went into it.
- 28:06So it's very accurate. So I know, but but but but I
- 28:09will say him using, you know, Silicon Valley and the rest
- 28:11invest moment. This is about like the pamper
- 28:13tech, you know, employee. This was like the Google Plex.
- 28:16This was like whatever Odwalla juices and whatever dumb shit
- 28:19people associated with the time. And like now things are austere.
- 28:22We have to go back into the office, which is really, you
- 28:24know, unfair to make people do. And you know, what we're
- 28:28building now is maybe more. Era of the $100 million
- 28:33Facebook. Yeah, but that's interesting
- 28:36too, right? Like, yeah, is this like an era
- 28:38of austerity and efficiency because you're making people go
- 28:40to the office? But also apparently everyone at
- 28:42opening I got like a $1.5 million retention package,
- 28:46right? Now instead of spending the
- 28:48money on perks, which I think some of the perks were like tax
- 28:51efficient, you know, it's you get, you can deduct food in the
- 28:54office. So but IT projects softness Now
- 28:56it's just like, fine, give, give them cash and say work hard.
- 29:00Yeah, yeah, hundreds of millions of dollars.
- 29:02That is a fairly select group of people.
- 29:04I don't know if it's going to have the ripple effect, but.
- 29:07The last thing we wanted to talk about was, you know, Tim Apple,
- 29:11Tim Cook being right, right? He's like in the White House
- 29:14between Trump and JD Vance, right?
- 29:17Like, just as they're saying terrible stuff, he's giving
- 29:20Trump 24 karat gold. I don't know enough.
- 29:23It seems like an insane amount of gold, right?
- 29:26It's never enough. It's never enough.
- 29:27It's. Like he's a king.
- 29:28You know, it's just like the, I mean, the, the thought I had is
- 29:31just like, did did any of these tech executives really believe
- 29:36diversity, equity and inclusion? You know, it's just like, OK,
- 29:39they did the Democratic thing. Now they're doing the like Trump
- 29:42thing. They're willing to like kiss the
- 29:44ring for whatever The thing is of the moment.
- 29:46I don't know, it's it's just insane to me that they'll just
- 29:49like here, here our gifts are are king.
- 29:52I don't know what was your reaction.
- 29:53I mean, Apple can like they are the most vulnerable maybe of all
- 29:58of the big tech companies to. Keep China.
- 30:00To Trump's Caprice, like if he's going to start fucking around
- 30:03with tariffs in a more serious way, they have major problems.
- 30:06Like you can only like rush production in India one time to
- 30:09get, you know, out before the tariffs start coming down on
- 30:12you. So like it wasn't enough gold,
- 30:14frankly, for whatever. I don't even watch the press
- 30:17release or the the press conference I missed.
- 30:19Well, Trump was like singing his praise like Tim Cooks praises.
- 30:23I mean, he was like. He likes rich people too.
- 30:26I mean, he's still, even after everything that happened with
- 30:28Elon, still being like, Nah, he's a good guy.
- 30:31He had a bad day, but he's still a good guy.
- 30:33So he's like very specific on like he wants to demonize.
- 30:37Smartest people are the richest people.
- 30:38It's like whatever you did to figure out how to get all that
- 30:40money, you're smart now. Yeah, they're richer than him.
- 30:43I mean, I don't know, Tim Cook is well, who knows how much he's
- 30:45worth, but but no, obviously it's it's it's disgusting and
- 30:48like and and and obvious and like fairly ham fisted.
- 30:53And I love that he's got it down now that every every president.
- 30:56I think it started with Trump and then even with Biden.
- 30:59And now with Trump again, they're like, now we're doing
- 31:02another like 600 billion, you know, Oh, why 600?
- 31:05Now we're going to up into eight.
- 31:05You know, they just like they just keep amping up.
- 31:08They're like, we're going to invest in America.
- 31:10You know, they, it's just like, I mean, they just make up like
- 31:14these press releases basically like I mean the.
- 31:17Numbers are made-up. The numbers are absolutely
- 31:18made-up. Cause 600 billion is meaningless
- 31:20for for Apple, right And. This is the thing I hated about
- 31:21the media. I mean, which again is just a
- 31:23humanity thing. But it's like we, we talk about
- 31:28this is a tangent, but it, we're, we're deep into the
- 31:30episode now. But, you know, it's like Open AI
- 31:32gets stories about how they raise $40 billion or whatever
- 31:37from SoftBank and then that seemingly hasn't totally
- 31:41happened yet. And then they get excited
- 31:43headlines again, I think from the New York Times saying that
- 31:46they raise less than that as if it's like upbeat.
- 31:50It's just like these these companies are able to get
- 31:53excited headlines about big numbers over and over again in a
- 31:57way that nobody's really adding up all all the numbers and
- 32:00saying, did they? Did they get what they were
- 32:01supposed to get last time? Yeah, well, open AI is
- 32:04particularly egregious on on that front because, yeah, the
- 32:07SoftBank stuff, it's really unclear where, you know, if that
- 32:09money is even going to come through because it's, you know,
- 32:12contingent on the conversion. By the way, all these people
- 32:14that the New York Times mentioned in their story, like
- 32:17Dragon Ear that are putting in like some sort of side money,
- 32:20like I think it was some kind of an SPV actually into open AI.
- 32:24Like they also could be buying into a company that might not be
- 32:27able to successfully convert into a for profit.
- 32:31Like the numbers are well ahead of like the actuality on any of
- 32:34this shit. So it's, it's super problematic.
- 32:37And also, I mean, like, I never like you can't bring it up
- 32:40enough. In my opinion.
- 32:41Is, is, is Stargate And like that also had a huge number
- 32:45attached to it, $500 billion, which you know.
- 32:48As far as I can. That was a Trump number, too.
- 32:50That was yeah. He was a Trump.
- 32:52Yeah. And was it Larry?
- 32:53Yes. And was the third person who
- 32:54was? Larry and Masa, they were all
- 32:56there and but the 500 billion number was not like, you know,
- 32:59they have like a very, you know, advanced spreadsheet where they
- 33:02calculated like project by project and realized over 10
- 33:05years what it was. Yeah, Like what's what's the
- 33:07number That's too big though, That would, you know, a
- 33:09trillion. No one's going to believe that.
- 33:11And like 200 billion, that seems like not a big number.
- 33:15So they end up you used to. Work for the publication.
- 33:17Weren't you on a you're a contributor or something on that
- 33:20story where the Wall Street? Journal said I got attacked.
- 33:22Open AI was gonna raise like 6 trillion.
- 33:25What was? That 7-7 trillion.
- 33:27Wall Street Journal. What were they doing?
- 33:29Like, why did that happen? You know, now what's the answer?
- 33:33Like what? There's only so much I can say
- 33:35on that one, but I will say that like, you know, you should give
- 33:38a lot of journalists, put a lot of stock into true at the time.
- 33:43People were saying to other people that they they were
- 33:46throwing around and say numbers to each other and.
- 33:49Well, Sam and making fun of it too, you know, after it came
- 33:52out, he's like, fuck it, let's do 9 trillion.
- 33:53And it's like, you know what, Sam?
- 33:55Like you can't have it both ways.
- 33:57And that's all I'll say about that.
- 33:59Right. Sam is clearly out.
- 34:00He was, I'm sure out and about throwing around big numbers and
- 34:04then the Wall Street Journal reported and people have the
- 34:07right to know. But I think the the Journal
- 34:09should have never put it in the headline, which I think was my
- 34:11stance at the time. And they should have been, it
- 34:13should have been much more like in this meeting and with this
- 34:16person said this number, and they probably should have said,
- 34:19and that's absurd. I mean, I honestly think that's
- 34:21our competitive advantage. Like that it we were throwing
- 34:24around, it's either this is a meaningless number, which is
- 34:27what I think it ended up being because it's like, oh, it's a
- 34:28statement about overall spending across like the economy, you
- 34:32know, or you know, it's just like putting it in the headline
- 34:36as if it's like a deal number was the insane.
- 34:39Thing if you pass around the hat enough times, I guess you can
- 34:42reach 7 trillion. It's like the implication of
- 34:45that headline. Yeah.
- 34:48And I actually think the best story that came out that year on
- 34:51that topic was what the The Times ended up doing, you know,
- 34:55a bunch of months later where they talked about how all of
- 34:57these chip manufacturers laughed Sam out of the room when he was
- 35:01going around to like, whatever at like, TSMC or yeah.
- 35:05Yeah, they were like they called him a podcast guy or something.
- 35:09Or. Podcast, bro, which I don't even
- 35:10know what that means, but I like it.
- 35:12Yeah, Yeah, 'cause like, yeah, when the big boys, you know, the
- 35:15ones who actually deal with numbers and like production at
- 35:17that scale are like seeing you put your fucking pitch deck up
- 35:21on the screen and they're just like, that's not how it works,
- 35:23brah, is yeah. That was like the reality check
- 35:28I was very happy to see happen to Sam.
- 35:29Yeah, that was a good story there.
- 35:30That's good. We we criticized the New York
- 35:32Times. We complimented them.
- 35:34Yeah, we're like back to dead cat here.
- 35:36That's. No, Tim, Tim, Apple, super
- 35:39embarrassing, $600 billion, meaningless number.
- 35:42I also saw one of the things that came out of it was like,
- 35:44you know, a headline was like Apple to move production of like
- 35:47Corning Glass to Kentucky or something.
- 35:50And someone could Fact Check me on this?
- 35:52I'm pretty sure they already have that.
- 35:54Yeah, I think they already do. Well, I think they'd already
- 35:57said it was like all in the United States, and now they're
- 36:00like saying it again. And somebody I think pointed
- 36:02out, like, weren't they already supposed to be?
- 36:04I think it might have been Mark Kerman saying like they weren't
- 36:07they already doing it 100% in the US So yeah.
- 36:11It's very much like if you remember the episode of Mad Men
- 36:13when he's working with Lucky Strike and they have the ad
- 36:16campaign for the cigarettes. It it's toasted, toasted.
- 36:19Yeah, yeah, of course, I remember.
- 36:21That Yeah, yeah. So that was basically the it's
- 36:22toasted moment for Apple just being like, now glass
- 36:26manufactured in the US, never enough of that shit.
- 36:30And it works on Trump, and it's frankly a lot more realistic and
- 36:33meaningful easily. You just say Trump, you get
- 36:36credit for this thing. It's like it doesn't matter if
- 36:38you were doing it or not. It's just like the now the
- 36:40credit flows to him anyway. Well, that's way better than
- 36:42like the Howard Lutnick going around, Howard Lutnick going
- 36:45around during the tariff moment trying to get people hyped up
- 36:48that we're going to start doing the little screws and the
- 36:50iPhones in America. Or he was like giddily going on
- 36:53CNBC talking about that. Like that one never should have
- 36:56made it out of the brainstorming session.
- 36:57So this is better. I I'll give him, I'll give him
- 36:59credit for that. All right, see you next week.