Latest / Film And Whiskey / Forrest Gump (1994) / Glenmorangie Nectar D'or Single Malt Scotch
Transcript
- 0:00In 1994, director Robert Zemeckis and star Tom Hanks gave
- 0:05the world a rambling exploration of what it was like to live
- 0:09through one of the most tumultuous periods in American
- 0:11history. In 2024, we matched this movie's
- 0:16Oscar gold with some nectar gold.
- 0:19The film is Forrest Forrest Gump.
- 0:22The whiskey is Glenn Moringey nectar.
- 0:30We'll review them both. This is the Film and Whiskey
- 0:34podcast. Welcome to the Film and Whiskey
- 0:54podcast, where each week we review a classic movie and a
- 0:57glass of whiskey. I'm Bob Book.
- 1:01How many times do you think we're going to do that this
- 1:07episode? Oh, at least 47.
- 1:13I still don't know how we didn't pair originally Nectar D or with
- 1:19a Denny Villeneuve movie. Well, I think this was this
- 1:22pairing happened before we ever got around to Denny Villeneuve.
- 1:26So maybe next time we can do it because we'll get into talking
- 1:30about our whiskey for the day. But they've released a new
- 1:32expression of this, Brad. It's a 16 year age stated
- 1:35version now. So perhaps our next Denny
- 1:37Villeneuve film can be paired with Nectar.
- 1:43But let me go back to my original prompt here.
- 1:46My name is Bob Book. Who are you?
- 1:49Oh, I'm Brad G It's great. Great to meet you, Bob.
- 1:52This week on Film and Whiskey we are looking at the 1994 Best
- 1:56Picture winner, Forrest Gump. Or, as the guy dressed like Abby
- 2:02Hoffman says in this movie, Forrest Gump.
- 2:06Bro it's my favorite part of the whole movie.
- 2:09I've never noticed the way he says it before, but this time
- 2:12through I was like, what did he just say?
- 2:16My name, My name is Florence Gump.
- 2:17Florence Gump. Then everybody in the crowd
- 2:19goes. Gump, what a great moment.
- 2:25I don't know just how to moderate the two poles of
- 2:32thought that I have on this film, Brad, because I really
- 2:35want to talk about the movie as a piece of cinema and and
- 2:40evaluate it as a work of art, talk about my issues with it.
- 2:43I also just want to sit here and quote Forrest Gump for an hour
- 2:47because I'm sure I said this on our first episode.
- 2:51This was probably my most quoted film for a long, long time.
- 2:54Like I remember we were in college once and I just remember
- 2:59for some reason there was like, you know, we were, we were on a
- 3:02retreat or something and there were like 8 guys sleeping in
- 3:05bunk beds in this room and two of us kept the other six up all
- 3:11night just saying Forrest Gump quotes.
- 3:16It would get real quiet and people would start drifting and
- 3:19then somebody would go, her dream had come true, she was a
- 3:23folk singer. And then everyone would start
- 3:25laughing again. There was just just so many
- 3:28stupid quotes in this dumb movie, Brad.
- 3:32Yeah, I I would put it up there with Anchorman, The Legend of
- 3:35Ron Burgundy for like top most quotable films.
- 3:40Maybe, maybe we need to get back and do a top five bonus episode,
- 3:43Bob. Most quote.
- 3:44Sometime most quotable films. This falls into a really
- 3:47specific quotable movie category though, which is that the
- 3:52quotes, when understood in context, are not that great.
- 3:55It's only when you say them completely divorced from the
- 3:58context that the quotes are funny.
- 4:01Yeah, 100%. There are so many moments in
- 4:04this film where the script is so tight and keeps you moving
- 4:11through scene by scene that you just get these little funny 1
- 4:15liners that because Zemeckis is trying to get through such a
- 4:20large swath of history, like he doesn't have time to linger on
- 4:23these scenes. And you get a lot of really fun,
- 4:26funny 1 liners because of it. So Brad, our first time around,
- 4:30I had brought up that this is a really polarizing movie among
- 4:34critics. It was like it was respected for
- 4:38what it was. But I think similarly to a movie
- 4:40like Green Book, like once it wins the Oscar, then everybody
- 4:44turns on it and it becomes I can't believe this movie won the
- 4:47Academy Award for a long, long time.
- 4:49We. All liked it, but.
- 4:51But now we don't. For a long time, this became
- 4:55reviled by critics. And so I think people are
- 4:59starting to come back around on it, but in a much more, I don't
- 5:03know, level headed sense, which is like, this is not a perfect
- 5:06film. It's good for what it is.
- 5:08We can debate if it won the Oscar or not.
- 5:11But I remember when I first brought this up to you, you
- 5:13know, in our first episode in Season 1 on this, you were kind
- 5:17of surprised that this had been polarizing at all.
- 5:20And now having dealt with movie critics as much as we have,
- 5:23Brad, and also having reviewed, what, 300 movies or something
- 5:26like that at this point, I guess let's check back in on that
- 5:29debate. Can you see why critics would
- 5:32have been divided on this movie, whether or not you agree with
- 5:35that? I think that I can understand it
- 5:38when I look at particularly one other film in the Best Picture
- 5:44race. Pulp Fiction is the obvious
- 5:47critic darling here. Like like you're talking about
- 5:52Tarantino's big coming out party?
- 5:54Like everybody loved Reservoir Dogs in what, 9192?
- 5:5892, yeah. Yeah, so a few years later, you
- 6:02know, he makes this masterpiece of a film.
- 6:05And then you have the the pop sensation that is Forrest Gump.
- 6:11And I, I can understand why critics would be annoyed that it
- 6:14would win. I, I think I'm curious if
- 6:17there's a difference between critical reception before the
- 6:21Oscars and then critical reaction to the Oscar win.
- 6:26Like, did critics like the movie just plain and simple, you know,
- 6:30on their review? Were critics a fan of this film
- 6:33before it got caught up in the politics of Hollywood?
- 6:37I think critics were like, you know, when you look up a movie
- 6:41on on Metacritic, if it's like under an 80 or 85, it doesn't
- 6:45say universal acclaim. It says like generally positive
- 6:49reviews. And I think that's a good way to
- 6:51sum it up. They were like lukewarm on this
- 6:54movie. Like, hey, it's a pretty good
- 6:56movie. It's got great visual effects.
- 6:58It's a fantastic summer movie to go see.
- 7:01Obviously, they had its detractors as well.
- 7:03But again, this is when the Oscars had a lot more cachet in
- 7:07our society. And so even though a lot of
- 7:09movie critics have never put too much emphasis on the Oscars, it
- 7:14was still like the popular mechanism for saying, hey,
- 7:18history, This is the movie from this year that we think
- 7:22represents the year in film. And when you have a movie like
- 7:26Pulp Fiction break into that five nominee category, it's
- 7:31almost like, Oh my gosh, like this movie could really do it.
- 7:33This is a revolutionary film in American history.
- 7:37And then to lose, but not just to lose, but to lose the Forrest
- 7:40Gump is kind of, I think the turning point with a lot of
- 7:43critics. And it's not necessarily that
- 7:45they hated the movie. It's just like you gave a three
- 7:49star movie The Oscar in a year where we really could have like
- 7:55coronated something new and exciting in American cinema.
- 7:58And again, now if that's fair or not, I think that's what
- 8:01happened there. You say 3 star, but famed
- 8:05reviewer and I would say the favorite of this podcast, Roger
- 8:08Ebert, gave it a four-star review.
- 8:10We sure did. I must call him Forrest Gump.
- 8:14Roger Ebert loved a good time at the movies, you know what I
- 8:18mean? And and Roger Hebert was also
- 8:20like much more than his peers, I think, susceptible to exciting
- 8:24visual effects in movies. And at the time the VFX and
- 8:28Forrest Gump were. Cutting.
- 8:30Incredible. Yeah.
- 8:31Yes, and I think that the spectacle of it definitely
- 8:33tipped his hand. He also gave like the first
- 8:35Harry Potter movie 4 stars. And yeah, which I think is like
- 8:40kind of a good comparison here, 'cause I wouldn't call that a
- 8:42perfect movie, but it was something that was new.
- 8:45It was something that was exciting.
- 8:46It was at the cutting edge of what we could do with technology
- 8:49at the time. And so, yeah, I see why Rodger
- 8:52Ebert gave it four stars. I also see why Bob Book is not
- 8:55going to give it four stars. So.
- 8:58Can I read you one line from the Ebert review that just made me
- 9:02laugh really hard? Yeah, sure.
- 9:04So he's talking about how Forrest IQ is 75, and you might
- 9:08be able to argue that Forrest can't understand everything
- 9:11that's happening to him, but Ebert is saying that he does.
- 9:15And he says he even understands everything that's important
- 9:17about love. Although Jenny, the girl he
- 9:20falls in love with in grade school and never falls out of
- 9:22love with, tells him Forrest, you don't know what love is.
- 9:26She is a stripper by that time. Like it's, it's, it's little
- 9:35lies like that where I'm like, man, Ebert is the goat.
- 9:39He's so funny, man, That's great.
- 9:41All right, on that note, on the note of Jenny stripping, let's
- 9:43get into talking about this movie now.
- 9:45Again, this is season 10 of our podcast where we are revisiting
- 9:48all the films from our very first season of the podcast
- 9:51because I think we've improved in our ability to review both
- 9:54movies and whiskey. If you'd like to listen to our
- 9:57original review, you can check us out on Patreon.
- 10:00We've put season one behind a pay wall.
- 10:02You can't get it publicly anymore, but if you really want
- 10:05to hear us stumble through, check us out on patreon.com/film
- 10:08Whiskey where you can support us at three different tiers, A-35
- 10:12and $7.00 a month tier. Each tier comes with exclusive
- 10:15perks, including access to a special Discord channel that
- 10:18Brad and I are on pretty much every single day talking to
- 10:21people from Film and Whiskey Nation.
- 10:24Brad, it's time for us to get into, Brad explains.
- 10:27Brad's going to give us the movie plots with only 60 seconds
- 10:30taken on the clock, so let's go ahead and do your take with this
- 10:34little segment that we call, Brad explains.
- 10:37Brad Explains is the part of the show where Brad breaks down the
- 10:40plot of the film that he has just seen, often for the first
- 10:43time. This is at least Brad's second
- 10:46time seeing Forrest Gump. I have to imagine that even in
- 10:49the G household, you probably saw this at some point growing
- 10:54up, right? Like this is not just time #2
- 10:56for you. I don't think I saw this movie
- 11:00until college. Wow.
- 11:03Yeah yeah. Fourscope was not a staple of
- 11:05the G household. I it was probably like 18/19/20
- 11:11when I saw it for the first time.
- 11:13Man, that's wow. Yeah, dude, I, I feel like this
- 11:18movie was so ubiquitous in the late 90s, like it was on some
- 11:24channel on TV at every moment of the day for a solid 8 years, I
- 11:30would say. And now I know you didn't have
- 11:31cable. I, I understand you don't have
- 11:33to tell me, you freaking Amish person you.
- 11:37But like, you know, it was the second highest grossing film of
- 11:401994. And then it hit video and the
- 11:43soundtrack became, I think for a time, either the best or the
- 11:46second best selling soundtrack of all time.
- 11:48Like, this movie was freaking everywhere.
- 11:50I saw this movie at a way too young age.
- 11:53Didn't really understand what was going on with Forrest and
- 11:56Jenny in that dorm room for a while.
- 11:57But man, man, my parents, what were you letting me watch back
- 12:01then? See.
- 12:02You were on the same level as Forrest, Yeah.
- 12:03Pretty much, Pretty much, man. All right, dude, You have one
- 12:08minute on the clock to break down the plot of Forrest Gump.
- 12:11Folks, we're going into full spoilers.
- 12:13So if you have not seen this 30 plus year old film, go ahead and
- 12:16hit pause here. Go watch Forrest Gump because
- 12:19you're one of the few that has not seen it.
- 12:20And then come back and rejoin the episode.
- 12:23Brad 60 seconds and go. Forrest Gump is a film that
- 12:27follows its titular character, Forrest Gump as he grows up in
- 12:32the Deep South. That's a capital D Capital S
- 12:36Deep South, for those who are wondering, back in the 1950s.
- 12:41It follows him through the, as I said earlier, tumultuous
- 12:45sixties, 70s and 80s as he finds himself in various extraordinary
- 12:53circumstances in his ultimate pursuit of being a good person,
- 12:58honoring his friends and pursuing his one true love,
- 13:03Jenny. He's also the father of Hailey
- 13:07Joel Osmond. He sure is.
- 13:10Dude literally every single time I've ever seen this movie I'm
- 13:15like completely blindsided when the child comes out and it's
- 13:20Hailey Joel Osman and I have the exact same reaction.
- 13:23I'm like, oh wow, it's Hailey Joel Osman.
- 13:25And the way he says hello there, Mr. Gump, is the most perfect
- 13:29line reading of the whole film. There are so many great line
- 13:32readings in this film. It is like Robert Zemeckis wins
- 13:36the Best Director Oscar for this film, which I think of all of
- 13:40Forrest Gump's Oscar wins, I probably have the biggest issue
- 13:44with that. And we can talk about that
- 13:45later. But if there is ever going to be
- 13:48a reason to justify him winning best director, it is getting
- 13:52these line readings out of tiny, tiny characters in this movie.
- 13:55Whether it's the literally tiny Hailey, Joel Osmond or every
- 14:00time Dorothy Harris, the bus driver shows up, there's so
- 14:05dude, there's so much disdain in her voice when he goes, Mama
- 14:10said I shouldn't be talking to strangers and she goes, this is
- 14:13the bus to. School.
- 14:16It makes me laugh. She's got a cigarette hanging
- 14:18out of her mouth. I freaking love the way the line
- 14:21readings in this movie go. Oh man, and who who plays his
- 14:26friend Bubba Gump or Bubba? Bubba is played by an actor
- 14:30named Michael T Williamson. Yeah, Michael T Williamson
- 14:34freaking knocks it out of the park.
- 14:36Like every moment he is on screen, I just want to be his
- 14:41best friend. And the way he sucks his lip in
- 14:44when Gary Sinise is yelling at me, it's just, it's like a
- 14:49perfect little moment of physical humor in the movie.
- 14:53Dude, where where he goes? My name is Forrest Gump.
- 14:58People called me Forrest Gump. I'm going to do this all
- 15:02episode. It's it's so good.
- 15:07OK, where do you want to start talking about the movie?
- 15:10Because I think we could we could start with the movie
- 15:12itself and then broaden it out into the discussion around the
- 15:17movie. Or we could do the reverse of
- 15:19that. I I don't know if I really want
- 15:21to talk about the discussion around the movie, unless it's
- 15:24like a major point of the episode.
- 15:27Like, I don't know, this movie has stuck in the cultural
- 15:30consciousness, but, and there's a reason for that.
- 15:34And I don't know, is there, is there any argument there?
- 15:38What, what, what are your thoughts, Bob?
- 15:39Let's start there, I suppose. What's going to say?
- 15:42I clearly intended it to be a big part of the episode, or I
- 15:44wouldn't have presented you with two options.
- 15:47Brad. Yes, we can start here and end
- 15:49here, or we can end here and start here.
- 15:52And you're like, no, let's just knock one of those two things
- 15:54completely off the docket for today.
- 15:57Cool. Yeah, I mean, I just want Film
- 16:00and Whiskey Nation to know how dismissive I am of your takes on
- 16:04this podcast. Believe me, they know Brad.
- 16:09They've had ten seasons to figure that one out.
- 16:13I guess I want to revisit, if we're going to start there, I
- 16:15want to revisit this conversation around like, why is
- 16:19there such a disconnect between certain people and the general
- 16:23public on this movie? And, and like, it's sometimes
- 16:27hard to explain. Like if you're just talking to
- 16:29like your average moviegoer, I don't really know anybody that's
- 16:33like the average moviegoer that has ever been like Forrest Gump
- 16:35bad movie. It is a it is a purely enjoyable
- 16:39film. Even the average movie goer
- 16:42could probably say, yeah, this movie goes about two inches deep
- 16:46on any subject. Like, it's it's certainly not
- 16:50some insanely detailed exploration of America's history
- 16:54and geopolitical climate and everything else.
- 16:57Like, it's just, it's like a greatest hits album of things
- 17:00that happened in the 60s and 70s in America.
- 17:03And you know what, sometimes you like to put a greatest hits
- 17:05album on. I don't want to dig through all
- 17:07my favorite artists, 10 best albums to find the songs I want.
- 17:11Just compile them on a disc for me.
- 17:13And then I can just play the hits.
- 17:15And I think that if you approach the movie with the understanding
- 17:19that this is a greatest hits album of America, I think it
- 17:23becomes a much more easygoing experience.
- 17:26I, I think that for me, this is far and away the, the setting of
- 17:34the film, the like, let's go through America's greatest hits.
- 17:38For me, that's the backdrop that like, that has nothing to do
- 17:43with what this movie is trying to say.
- 17:46And, you know, to look at the IMDb score, Bob, this isn't just
- 17:50a movie that most people are like, oh, yeah, Forrest Gump.
- 17:52This is an 8.8 out of 10. Yeah. 100%.
- 17:56That is a massively high. Score.
- 17:59Like, yeah. And perhaps I understated it.
- 18:02If we're talking about popular films in America in the last
- 18:0650-60 years, there are very few movies that I feel like the
- 18:11critical consensus on and the general population's consensus
- 18:15are more divergent. Like I just, I really think that
- 18:19at best, you'll get a critic to say this is a pretty good movie
- 18:23for what it is, But then you look at IMDb and it's like, this
- 18:26is, is this still top ten? It might still be top 10.
- 18:28It is the 11th. 11th. Yeah, but Oppenheimer, Yeah,
- 18:34Yeah. I mean, Rotten Tomatoes, 76% for
- 18:38critics and 95% for audience. So like, yeah, there, there's
- 18:42definitely a disconnect here. And I I think it's because
- 18:46critics don't have a soul. If I.
- 18:49If I had to guess, because like when I when I watched this
- 18:53movie, I think this time around I finally understood why this
- 19:00hit so deep for people. And I I, I think it's because
- 19:04Zemeckis has this talent for painting and really broad
- 19:08strokes across a massive time period in American history.
- 19:14And yet somehow he like catches many of like the deep desires
- 19:21and longings of humanity all in this one character of Forrest
- 19:26Gump. And like any human being
- 19:30watching this movie can find a little bit of them self and his
- 19:33character. Like if you've ever had a desire
- 19:36to see something beautiful in the world, Forrest also has that
- 19:39desire. If you have a desire, if you
- 19:42have a desire to experience love and belonging and relationships
- 19:45that matter to you, you got Forrest Gump wanting the exact
- 19:48same thing. Dude.
- 19:49The moment where he's worried about passing on his lack of
- 19:54intelligence to his son, Oh yeah is heart wrenching.
- 19:58And like who? Who can't, once you've had a
- 20:01child, relate with that fear of like, oh man, like what if I
- 20:05passed down one of the worst parts of myself to my child?
- 20:09Like, and, and there's like, I could go on and on and on.
- 20:12Like I, I want to be the kind of person that doesn't let money
- 20:15and fame change me. Oh, guess what?
- 20:17Forrest Gump is also that and, and the The thing is, you could
- 20:24read all of those things and be like, well, there's your
- 20:27problem. He made a perfect character that
- 20:29doesn't have any flaws. But the beautiful thing about
- 20:33Forrest Gump is that he doesn't stand emotionally distant from
- 20:39the world around him. Like the way he shows terror
- 20:44when he is trying to save Bubba, when he thinks he's passing down
- 20:50his lack of intelligence to his son.
- 20:52The joy that he has when he sees Jenny in Washington DC.
- 20:58Like he engages with the world around him in such a emotionally
- 21:03vulnerable way that he's not just this blank slate of a
- 21:08character. He is somebody who has
- 21:10motivations and has desires. And I just like, I don't know
- 21:14how Zemeckis does it because I'm with you.
- 21:16I know you. I know that one of your main
- 21:18points on this is that the broad strokes are, are tough to
- 21:22swallow at times. I just, I think he nails it,
- 21:25man. Man, how do I want to respond to
- 21:28this? I think maybe let's let's try to
- 21:32arrive at the end of framing the debate around Forrest Gump and
- 21:36I'll I'll answer your points with what I would assume to be
- 21:41the push back. Now, I don't necessarily agree
- 21:42with all this, but I think for me watching it this time, the
- 21:47biggest flaw with this movie is that it it kind of wants to have
- 21:53its cake and eat it too, when it comes to how it presents its
- 21:56characters as metaphors for a tumultuous time in American
- 22:02history. And I what I mean by that is
- 22:04like it wants you to understand at the most basic level that
- 22:11Forrest Gump is a simple man who has simple American values, and
- 22:20perhaps not as a result of those values, but and also Forrest
- 22:25Gump winds up wildly successful at the at the same time, his
- 22:31best friend Jenny is really representative of the sort of
- 22:35lostness of a generation of the baby boomers who went off
- 22:41seeking something fulfilling for a really long time.
- 22:44And perhaps not as a result of that seeking, but just and also
- 22:51they got themselves into some really deep shit.
- 22:54Do you know what I mean? And I think that I think that
- 22:57where critics really started to dislike what they felt the movie
- 23:01was saying was like, you want to make that metaphor, but then you
- 23:04want it to stop right there. And you don't want us to trace
- 23:07it to it's it's logical conclusion, right?
- 23:10Like you have to kind of put yourself back in the historical
- 23:13context of this movie coming out.
- 23:14It's like smack dab in the middle of Clinton's first term.
- 23:19You're coming off of a decade plus of Reagan and then George
- 23:23HW Bush, where America like very loudly declared like, we are
- 23:28returning to conservative values in America, whether that is
- 23:33social or economic. Like this is where we have
- 23:36arrived as a nation. And I think that a lot of
- 23:41critics read this movie as, like, whether or not Zemeckis is
- 23:45trying to make this an apology for, you know, baby boomers kind
- 23:50of coming back into traditional American values.
- 23:53It certainly seems to espouse that.
- 23:55And that Jenny as an extension is, you know, a portrayal of we
- 24:01went and sold our Wild oats as a generation, but now we're kind
- 24:04of coming back to conservatism. Now, again, I don't even know if
- 24:08I want to say that I see all that in this movie.
- 24:09I just think that that's kind of what the pushback on the movie
- 24:12is. Not that it is a conservative
- 24:13movie, but that it wants to paint Forrest and Jenny as these
- 24:18really kind of broad strokes metaphors, but then it never
- 24:22really wants to examine the implications of painting them in
- 24:26those metaphors. Like, what does it mean that
- 24:28Forrest Gump is your simple American values representative
- 24:34because he's also developmentally disabled.
- 24:36You know what I mean? Like, he, you can't really take
- 24:39that metaphor too hard because then what are you saying about
- 24:41America? And on the flip side, it's like,
- 24:44you know, is Jenny's only redemption when she becomes
- 24:48quote, UN quote conservative at the end of the movie.
- 24:50I think that there are a lot of thorny things that come up as a
- 24:55result of those metaphors being introduced.
- 24:57And I will say I don't think the movie intends to go any farther
- 25:02than it does, but I think that's what a lot of people's problem
- 25:05with it is. Does that make sense?
- 25:07Yeah, yeah, it makes sense. I I guess when I look at this
- 25:12film, I, I don't see it as a broad strokes representation of
- 25:19entire generations. For me, it it's two individual
- 25:23characters who see the world in a certain way, who choose to act
- 25:31in a certain way because of how they see the world and there's
- 25:34consequences based on those actions.
- 25:38Like for me, it's as simple as that.
- 25:41And you know, to get back to the themes of human desire and what
- 25:46we would all want, I think Jenny represents the part of us that
- 25:50hopes that no matter what we do in this world, somebody will
- 25:54still love us. Like, like to me that like
- 25:57that's the entire character of Jenny is like no matter what I
- 26:01do, I really deeply hope that there would be a Forrest Gump
- 26:06character to love me no matter the decisions I've made.
- 26:10And the moment where Robin Wright looks at him and and
- 26:12they're at the house and he asks her to marry him and she says,
- 26:17like, you would never want to marry me.
- 26:20Like it's a heartbreaking moment.
- 26:22And it speaks once again to that deep fear that we all have is
- 26:27man, if somebody really knew me, they would never want to be my
- 26:31friends, my lover, my spouse, like they would never want me to
- 26:35be their mother, father like I. Once again, it's an example of I
- 26:41think Zemeckis is diving deep into the human experience.
- 26:46I will say, and let's move out of that whole debate thing
- 26:49because I want to get back to a thing you were saying about the
- 26:52kind of one-on-one interactions. Where this movie really succeeds
- 26:56is when it kind of drops all of the stuff about America and the
- 26:59pop culture references and Forrest Gump weaving in and out
- 27:03of these random historic events. And when you just get like
- 27:06Forest and Sally Field in a room together or Forest and Robin
- 27:10Wright in a room together or Forest and Bubba like by a river
- 27:13in Vietnam for 10 seconds, the, the actual human relationships
- 27:18within the movie are incredibly well acted.
- 27:21They're really well written for the most part, I would say, you
- 27:24know, like Sally Field gets nominated for an Oscar for
- 27:29portraying Mama in this movie. And she's in the movie for like
- 27:328 minutes. Like she's I I forgot how little
- 27:35she's in this movie, but that very last interaction, she just
- 27:41dude, they they leave the camera on her for a minute and she kind
- 27:45of collects herself before saying this line.
- 27:47And and you know, she starts kind of smiling and while
- 27:51tearing up and it's this brilliant portrayal of like a
- 27:54mom comforting a son while also grieving.
- 27:59And she you know, she's talking about dying.
- 28:01She brings back up the life is like a box of chocolates.
- 28:03And then she just says, I will miss you, Forrest.
- 28:06And my God, dude was IA puddle on the floor in that moment.
- 28:10Like when this movie goes for the waterworks.
- 28:14I do appreciate that it doesn't happen in the like broad
- 28:18strokes, talking about America stuff.
- 28:21It happens in the interpersonal relationships, and I think
- 28:24that's where it succeeds. Yeah, and you know, you have
- 28:28things like the Vietnam War, which everyone has strong
- 28:32opinions on. And yet, in the moments when
- 28:35Forest is running back and forth trying to save his squad
- 28:39members, it all of a sudden, it doesn't matter what political
- 28:43affiliation you have. You understand the pain and the
- 28:47suffering and the desire to be helpful in an unwinnable
- 28:54situation that Forrest has. And as he's holding Bubba, it's
- 29:00that moment where the narration of the film works like a charm,
- 29:04that there's this counterpoint of Forest in the memory who
- 29:08doesn't know what's going to happen, and Forest narrating the
- 29:11memory who is diving into the regret that he has of like,
- 29:17yeah, if I had known that this was the last thing I'd ever say
- 29:20to my best good friend, I would have said something different.
- 29:23And it's just, dude, it's Waterworks.
- 29:27It's incredible. Yeah, and it's, again, I think
- 29:31that a lot of people, a lot of critics thought that this movie
- 29:34was really emotionally manipulative.
- 29:36And I can see why they would think that.
- 29:38But I think that there's enough attention given to each of these
- 29:42relationships that he has with Mama, with Bubba, with Jenny,
- 29:45with Lieutenant Dan, that they each have their own unique
- 29:49rhythm and dialogue to them. And then they each have their
- 29:53own arc and emotional payoff. And I don't feel like they were,
- 29:57you know, manipulating US by pulling a string in a way that
- 30:01seemed false, especially on those fronts.
- 30:03Yeah, man, I, I mean, I, I feel like there's so many directions
- 30:07we could go with this. But what what do you think when
- 30:11it comes to Zemeckis as a director in this movie?
- 30:15What are some elements of the cinematography of the acting
- 30:19performances of of the different things you see on the screen
- 30:23that that drew you in this time? So Zemeckis kind of made his
- 30:27bones as a Steven Spielberg protege.
- 30:30And then he, you know, he gets deployed by Spielberg in his
- 30:33first few films, and then he makes it big with Back to the
- 30:35Future. And ever since Back to the
- 30:37Future, Zemeckis has been known as a guy who even more than
- 30:40Spielberg, like, he loves him some special effects.
- 30:44He loves kind of pushing the boundaries on what you can do
- 30:47with computer imagery. You know, he's very similar to a
- 30:50James Cameron or a George Lucas in that regard.
- 30:54I think that. Just as successful in all his
- 30:57films. Yeah, I mean, he's he's never
- 30:59made a bad movie and neither is George Lucas.
- 31:01What are you talking about? So, and I don't mean anything
- 31:05disparaging to Zemeckis in that regard, because I think that
- 31:08he's a good director. I also just think that like when
- 31:11you look at how Steven Spielberg maps out a shot in his mind and
- 31:15the Spielberg wonders and, and the way that he is just like
- 31:18mentally storyboarded every shot, it's insane what that guy
- 31:23can do. Zemeckis, I feel like is a
- 31:26really good copycat of Spielberg in that like the camera is
- 31:30moving around a lot in this movie.
- 31:32And I think the actual like the lighting of the movie, the
- 31:35blocking of the movie. It looks like a movie.
- 31:37It's a beautiful film to look at in parts.
- 31:40I don't think that I would look at the majority of the shots in
- 31:42this movie as like artfully composed.
- 31:45There's a lot of shots of like, that's a beautiful mountain, but
- 31:50the mountain's beautiful. Like the the camera work in this
- 31:52movie is very Workman like. It's it's you know, it gets the
- 31:55job done, but it's not on the level of like a Spielberg.
- 32:00Does that make sense? 100% I think there's a few
- 32:04moments that stand out to me. One being when when Forrest is
- 32:08in the the hospital and he's narrating something and all of a
- 32:13sudden you see Lieutenant Dan's hand like reach up behind him
- 32:17and grab him and pull him down. Like, like there's little
- 32:21moments like that. Or even when when he's walking
- 32:24out from being on television in New York and the door closes and
- 32:29Lieutenant Dan is waiting there for him.
- 32:32I think there are some great moments where the camera almost
- 32:37hides something and gives you a bit of a surprise.
- 32:40Even when he's in Vietnam and it's raining.
- 32:45And then there's the moment where the rain stops and then
- 32:47immediately the bullets start flying.
- 32:50Like there. There's a moment where Zemeckis
- 32:52likes to try to surprise the viewer.
- 32:54But I'm with you. Like he's not a Hall of Fame
- 33:00camera usage type director. And I think like similarly, I
- 33:05wouldn't call him a great director of actors.
- 33:08That's not to say that everybody in this movie isn't very good,
- 33:11but we don't we don't think about like, man, Robert Zemeckis
- 33:15really directed Tom Hanks to that Oscar.
- 33:18It's like, no, Tom Hanks went and studied the speech patterns
- 33:21of the kid that plays Forrest Gump.
- 33:23Tom Hanks was leading into like he was at the height of his
- 33:26powers here and and Robert Zemeckis is a competent enough
- 33:30director that he knows when to leave the camera on Sally Field
- 33:33for an extra 5 seconds to get her her Oscar nomination.
- 33:37But I feel like it's more a function of working with really
- 33:40good actors than it is that he brought something out in these
- 33:42actors. Yeah.
- 33:44I mean, that's, that's like always, I don't know, I, I feel
- 33:48like your distaste overall for the film in my mind, like, I
- 33:56don't know why isn't it a boon to to Zemeckis that he knew to
- 34:00do that for five more seconds on Sally Fields and he knew how to
- 34:05let Tom Hanks be Tom Hanks like. Oh yeah, I don't.
- 34:08I don't. Know if it's a a good or a bad
- 34:10thing, but I think we can say that he was in charge of that
- 34:14final product and put together a film where people were getting
- 34:18nominated for best acting performances and he was under he
- 34:23was under it he received a nomination and won for best
- 34:26director like I I think he was kind of doing something right
- 34:30for most of the. Yeah, and I feel like you, I
- 34:32don't, I don't want you to misconstrue what I'm saying
- 34:34either. Like, you can absolutely be a
- 34:37Workman, like director and like that is a compliment in itself.
- 34:40Hollywood history is full of guys like this.
- 34:42Michael Cortese is like one of the best directors of classic
- 34:46Hollywood when he directed freaking Casablanca, but he was
- 34:49the guy that they called when you just needed a guy to plug
- 34:52into a movie. You know what I mean?
- 34:53He's not like an he's not considered an auteur because he
- 34:55doesn't have a style of his own. And I guess that's what I'm
- 34:58saying about Zemeckis. Like dude's a good director.
- 35:00You know, I don't we don't talk about him like we talked about a
- 35:03Coppola or a Scorsese or something, but that doesn't
- 35:07necessarily mean that he's bad. I'm just saying, we look at like
- 35:10Paul Thomas Anderson and every PTA movie.
- 35:13We say somebody gave the best performance of their career.
- 35:16That's not really what you get with Zemeckis.
- 35:17That doesn't mean that he can't direct an actor to an Oscar
- 35:21nomination. I like, I think you hit the nail
- 35:23on the head. You just might have misconstrued
- 35:25me a little bit. Sure, that's my favorite thing
- 35:27to do. Well hey man, why don't we
- 35:30misconstrue each other for a little bit and let's start
- 35:33speaking in French nonsense at each other while we look at our
- 35:36whiskey for the day, the Glen Moringey Nectar.
- 35:50All right, everybody, today we are going to be drinking from
- 35:54one of our favorite brands. We absolutely love Glenmorengy
- 35:59and we're going to be drinking the most famous of their brands
- 36:03in our minds simply for the fact that it is called Nectar.
- 36:13The Glenn Moringy Nectar Door. This is man.
- 36:18This is legendary in film. The annals of film and whiskey.
- 36:24And I'm, I'm curious like is it going to stand up to the amount
- 36:28of attention we've paid to it over the?
- 36:30Years. I don't know, man, because even
- 36:32at the time we reviewed it. And let's back up a minute.
- 36:35We first tried the Glenn Moringy brand when we picked up a
- 36:39sampler of 100ML samples of four of their different products.
- 36:45And I think back then this was like 25 bucks.
- 36:48It was like the best possible deal you could get in Scotch.
- 36:50I think they've since discontinued this sampler
- 36:53because so many of the whiskeys in here have undergone a little
- 36:56bit of a renovation. But it it included their
- 36:59standard 10 year, it included the Quinta Reuben, it included
- 37:03the La Santa and then like the big dog in the box was supposed
- 37:07to be this Nectar door. And Brad, we really liked the La
- 37:11Santa and we especially liked the Quinta Reuben and the nectar
- 37:14door was like, this is good. This is still better than the
- 37:16standard 10 year, but we didn't think it was worth the what we
- 37:21consider to be astronomical price hike over the other three
- 37:25in the box. So I'm excited to revisit this
- 37:29because again, I feel like this is supposed to be the big
- 37:31selling point of the box. It's the most expensive of the
- 37:33four, or at least it was at the time we purchased this.
- 37:36The version that we have in the box is actually now an outdated
- 37:40version of nectar door. It was 12 years old at the time
- 37:44of this bottling and it was finished in so turn casks, which
- 37:47we've talked about many, many times through the history of
- 37:50film and whiskey. It gives it's a French wine.
- 37:53It gives really sweet character. Now this is a 16 year age stated
- 37:58product. It's finished in at least three
- 38:00different types of casks. I think one of them being Tokai
- 38:03casks from Hungary. So we'll have to try that new
- 38:06version, but we're kind of paying homage to Season 1 by
- 38:10revisiting what we tried back then in this 12 year expression.
- 38:14Now I will tell you Bob, the Glenmorengy Taster pack is still
- 38:19available. It is still for 100ML bottles of
- 38:25the original, which is the 10 year, the La Santa 12 year, the
- 38:29Kintorubin 12 year and the Nectar Dor.
- 38:32So you can still get this. It will cost you $32 which for
- 38:37400 MLS of Scotch I would say is a very good price.
- 38:42I am really surprised you can still buy it anywhere.
- 38:44I would have assumed that this, like the skew would be dead by
- 38:47now because the Quinta Reuben is not 12 year anymore and it
- 38:51hasn't been for five years now. The Nectar door is not 12 years
- 38:54anymore. I don't know about the Lasanta,
- 38:56but like, this seems like they're just trying to burn
- 38:58through old stock of stuff, which is totally fine.
- 39:02I still think it can benefit. Yeah, I I think it's worth
- 39:04picking up for sure. Well, let's get into the review
- 39:07here. Bob.
- 39:08I have drank this already. I, I've taken my notes, so I'll
- 39:12jump in on the nose while you get started.
- 39:16I think this is one of the best noses we've had in a while.
- 39:20It's pretty delightful. Oh my gosh, dude.
- 39:22There's like almost like a toasted candied almonds note on
- 39:28the nose. There's a ton of honey, almost
- 39:31like a honeycomb. There's some prosciutto and it
- 39:34it got citrusy for me, but all the, the, the word that came to
- 39:40my mind was like a lemon meringue, like a little bit
- 39:43creamy, a little bit zesty. This is an incredible nose Bob.
- 39:48I give it a nine out of 10. I'm going to be just a little
- 39:51bit beneath you. I'm going to be in an 8 1/2 on
- 39:53the nose. There's a lot of different
- 39:55directions this one can go and you know, we never mean to
- 39:58punish a nose as a result, but I can't quite pinpoint where this
- 40:02is going to go flavor wise. It's really creamy.
- 40:05You, you absolutely nailed that. I get a little bit of melon on
- 40:07this. I get.
- 40:09Quite a bit of spicy like like black pepper as well, but then
- 40:13there's a lot of lemon and it's for me it's more lemon zest or
- 40:16even like the pith of a lemon. It's like a a more aggressive
- 40:20lemon. I do definitely get the
- 40:23influence of the wine casks here.
- 40:25This has a really dark grapey nose similar to I don't know
- 40:29like a pinot noir for me and and I would even call it almost
- 40:33raisiny really, really good. But again, like, is it going to
- 40:37taste like wine? Is it going to taste like melon?
- 40:39It has those kind of bright, almost Irish whiskey notes at
- 40:42the top of it. So I'm at an 8 1/2, but let's
- 40:45dive into the taste. I think when you move into the
- 40:48pallet you get just this bomb of honey.
- 40:52The lemon meringue really sticks around for me.
- 40:55It's a really creamy whiskey experience.
- 40:58You get a bit of an orange zest that pops at you, and I thought
- 41:03it got almost into the territory of like a Maple syrup.
- 41:07The palate is a little bit less impressive than the nose for me,
- 41:12but just barely. I'm going to give it an 8 1/2
- 41:14here. I'm going to say this in the
- 41:16nicest way I can think to say it.
- 41:18Brad, I feel like we've always plugged the Quinta Reuben as you
- 41:24should buy this whiskey if you're starting to get serious
- 41:27about Scotch because it's mind blowingly good at a really good
- 41:31price. I almost want to transfer that
- 41:34title to this, but has nothing to do with the price and it also
- 41:38has nothing to do with the taste.
- 41:40I just think that like from the moment I sipped it, I could tell
- 41:43this was an incredibly well made Scotch.
- 41:46It's really creamy. There are some almost
- 41:49nondescript fruity notes going on here.
- 41:52It has almost an ashy sort of burnt taste at the back, in a
- 41:56good way. Like you, you get that on a lot
- 41:58of scotches, even on non peated scotches, but it's not complex,
- 42:05you know what I mean? Like I, I'm not going to sit
- 42:07here and pull notes out of this for the next 10 minutes.
- 42:09Like it just tastes like a really creamy, really good wine
- 42:15cask finished Scotch. And I think that I would almost
- 42:18want to offer this to a person who has only ever had J&B or you
- 42:24know what I mean, or like Cutty Sark and be like, this is what a
- 42:27$90.00 bottle of Scotch tastes like.
- 42:30Because if I'm telling someone, Oh yeah, like, do you taste the
- 42:34figgy pudding in this? And they're going to be like,
- 42:36no, I don't know what that I don't know how to look for figgy
- 42:38pudding. I don't think you can really
- 42:40look for anything in this. It's just a very generically
- 42:43good Scotch. And I like it because of that.
- 42:47And I'm I sound like I'm insulting it, but.
- 42:50You certainly do. I I I'm going to give it an 8 on
- 42:52the taste. It's just like I I don't have
- 42:55any notes to give on it other than that.
- 42:57Where you at on the finish? I'll give it a 7 1/2 on the
- 43:00finish. I think that it it has a really
- 43:02nice kind of fade out on the finish.
- 43:04It doesn't drop off a Cliff, but it also, I haven't been thinking
- 43:08about the finish at all. You know what I mean?
- 43:09Like it's just a really good barley heavy creamy Scotch
- 43:14finish and I sound like a broken record.
- 43:17Yeah, I, I am getting a lot more here than you are, Bob.
- 43:21Like I think that the finish is incredible.
- 43:24I, I think it's the best part of this experience for me.
- 43:28The flavors sat on my palate for a long time after I was done.
- 43:33And it's this, this fresh lemon zest.
- 43:36It gets into those kind of almost like a Cream of wheat
- 43:41sourdough bread kind of territory.
- 43:44And the honey sticks around for the long run.
- 43:47I think it's a 9 1/2 on the finish and I think for me, I'm
- 43:51going to give it a 9 1/2 on balance as well.
- 43:54Like the I, I would agree with you that this is not the most
- 43:58complex whiskey I've ever had, but I think that that mixture of
- 44:03the grainy notes with the honey, with the fruit, with the citrus
- 44:09zestiness, that there is a lot going on here and it's executed
- 44:13at a really high level. Yeah, I I won't disagree with
- 44:17any of that. I I think that on the finish,
- 44:19for me, if I can revisit my finish for a hot second, I won't
- 44:22change my score. 2nd and 3rd sip definitely improved the
- 44:25experience. It's much thicker, much more
- 44:27viscous and, and I think for one of the first times ever, I
- 44:31really am getting true notes of butterscotch on this.
- 44:34It's not quite caramel and it's not quite Maple and it's right
- 44:37in between that it reminds me a lot of like a butterscotch ice
- 44:40cream topping. I really, really like this a
- 44:43lot. I again, I still don't think
- 44:44it's complex, but I'm going to give it a nine out of 10 on the
- 44:47balance because everything that it does, it's doing at a high
- 44:51level, even if I'm not pulling 50 different tasting notes out
- 44:54of it. Now Bob, this is going to set
- 44:57you back $82 in the state of Ohio for a bottle.
- 45:03I think that's a still a pretty good value.
- 45:07Let me ask you this, is that for the 12 year expression or the
- 45:09new 16? Let me pull it back up and check
- 45:14Bob. It looks on the OHLQ website
- 45:17like it's a picture of the older whiskey.
- 45:20But I, I don't know if they've like started to transition what
- 45:24they are shipping to the US. I don't know if you're like
- 45:26finishing out the old batch. What I do know is that in 2022,
- 45:32just two years ago, it won double gold at the San Francisco
- 45:37World Wine and Spirits Competition in the single malt
- 45:43non age stated category. So as of two years ago it was an
- 45:48nasi don't. I don't imagine that the price
- 45:51is going to shoot up if it's a 16 year all of a sudden.
- 45:54No, I was more worried that we were, we would be accidentally
- 45:58harming our scores on this one if they were pricing it out for
- 46:0116 and we were only reviewing the 12 year, you know, So I
- 46:06don't know, at $82, I think this is overpriced, Brad.
- 46:08But it's also like, you know, we have that principle of $10.00
- 46:13for every year that it's aged. And Glen Moringy has always,
- 46:16always been almost cutting that in half.
- 46:19You know, like we had the Quinto Rubin 14 year that was selling
- 46:23for 50 something dollars and now it's up into $70 territory and
- 46:27we're still like, oh, it's overpriced now.
- 46:29We've been really spoiled by Glen Moringy, I guess is what
- 46:32I'm saying. I think in a vacuum, $82 for
- 46:35this is not a bad value. I just think that I can get
- 46:39better $82 whiskey than this. So I'm going to give it a six,
- 46:45just a six out of 10 on value. Man, yeah, we're, we're far
- 46:48apart here, Bob. I, I think that this is a really
- 46:51good value. I think that there is enough
- 46:54Scotch out there at a higher price that $82 for a really
- 47:01beautiful expression of Scotch. I I'm willing to pay it.
- 47:06I I think I'm at an 8 1/2 year on value.
- 47:10Before we give our final scores, let me ask you this When was the
- 47:13last time you revisited Quinta Reuben?
- 47:16Just a few months ago. Which is better?
- 47:21I think this is better. Wow.
- 47:23Yeah, see, I still prefer Quinta Reuben.
- 47:24It's got a little bit more kick to it.
- 47:27Like I I just, I think it's more of a bourbon drinker.
- 47:29Scotch, which is not. That doesn't inherently make it
- 47:32better. I just like it better.
- 47:34It's a nice change of pace for me.
- 47:36This is really, really good. I just don't quite get as much
- 47:39on it as you do. So I'm coming out to a 39 out of
- 47:4250, which is still a damn good score.
- 47:44I'm almost at the 40 mark. Yeah, we are farther apart than
- 47:49normal, Bob. Usually we're somewhat close.
- 47:52I'm at a 45 out of 50. Wow, the 90 out of 100 mark for
- 47:57Brad. This is rarefied error.
- 47:59It is. I can probably count on both
- 48:02hands the amount of times either of us have gone at or above 45.
- 48:08I mean, I don't know, have we done 10 whiskeys at or above 45
- 48:12out of 100? I don't know man.
- 48:15I don't think we have. It's it's been close, but yeah,
- 48:18I mean, you're talking about getting a nine in every single
- 48:21category. That's hard to do.
- 48:23It is we're coming out on average to a 42 out of 50 or an
- 48:2684 out of 100. This is like it even hitting 42.
- 48:31We're going to be approaching best whiskey of the season
- 48:34territory here. Yep.
- 48:37Much like the movie, I really like this, but because I am not
- 48:41as effusive in my praise as Brad, he thinks that I don't
- 48:44like it at all. I mean, you know, you're you're
- 48:48a trash person, so. I guess so.
- 48:51This whiskey and film were wasted on me.
- 48:56All right, man, let's get back into talking about Forrest Gump.
- 48:58What do you say? Yeah, let's get to it, man.
- 49:04All right. That was the Glenn Moringy the
- 49:07Nectar Single Malt Scotch Whiskey.
- 49:12Brad, we're talking about Forrest Gump.
- 49:14But in order to do that, we have to get to our next segment,
- 49:17which we call 2 Facts and a falsehood.
- 49:19Brad is going to try to stump your ball to our right and what
- 49:26is wrong? 2 facts and a falsehood. 2 Facts
- 49:30and a Falsehood is the part of the show where Brad presents me
- 49:33with three items as fact about the making of this movie, one of
- 49:37which is a complete lie. Brad, I've done no research yet
- 49:41again today. I feel like I've really
- 49:43liberated myself from doing research this season.
- 49:46Yeah, you're you're so lazy, Bob.
- 49:48I know. Why would you not?
- 49:49Why did you not do research on the movies for the spot?
- 49:51I learned from the best man. Brad, hit me with your two facts
- 49:56and a falsehood. In fact #1 when the studio
- 49:59imposed budget cuts on the film, both director Robert Zemeckis
- 50:03and star Tom Hanks waved a large part of their fee in exchange
- 50:07for percentage points, which ultimately netted Hanks in the
- 50:10region of $70 million. That was almost a Michael
- 50:17Jackson. Fact #2 In all the scenes of
- 50:24Forrest unloading his empty Nets onto the deck of the Jenny,
- 50:29there is some sort of war paraphernalia contained in the
- 50:32net, from a military helmet to military boots.
- 50:37Fact #3 Robert Zemeckis used the paintings of Norman Rockwell as
- 50:41the design inspiration for the town of Greenville, AL.
- 50:45The scene where Forrest sits in the hallway of his school where
- 50:47his while his mother talks to the principal, is a direct
- 50:50recreation of Rockwell's painting Girl with a Black Eye
- 50:54All. Right.
- 50:59Let me let me make sure I understand.
- 51:01Number two, it was that there was some sort of military
- 51:04paraphernalia in. Was it in every scene or in just
- 51:08that scene? It's because he, he drops an
- 51:12empty net like four or five times before, you know, they go
- 51:16into the storm and there's billions of shrimp and each time
- 51:20he drops an empty net, there's some sort of war.
- 51:24You know, there's a helmet, there's boots there.
- 51:26There's a few other things. Well, I don't know.
- 51:31I think number one's true #2 might be true, but like to what
- 51:37end? Like why did they do that?
- 51:40Or is it just a cool little fact like there's a boot there?
- 51:44Yeah, I mean, I, I think it, it kind of represents the idea that
- 51:49that Gump's eventual fortune came out of war.
- 51:53Yeah. Who?
- 51:54Knows there's there's not reading there.
- 51:56Sure it's a Mechus. The man is an enigma.
- 52:00Man, these are good. Brad #3 sounds right.
- 52:03That looked very Norman Rockwelly.
- 52:07I think you made-up #3 but it you did such a good job making
- 52:11it up that I'm going to say it's true and I'm going to say #2 is
- 52:15the falsehood. Bob, you, I don't know if your
- 52:19gut is right or wrong here, because you did choose the
- 52:22falsehood. Yeah, nailed it.
- 52:26All right. Yeah, cool.
- 52:27Good job. You know, Vito burrito.
- 52:31All right, man, let's dive back into talking about the movie
- 52:34itself. We've touched on the
- 52:36performances a little bit. We've talked in depth about the
- 52:39conversation around it. Brad, there are, I mean, 1994 is
- 52:44a huge year in the history of movies and it's it's been a very
- 52:47big year in film and whiskey history as well.
- 52:49I mean, we've done just this season.
- 52:52We did Forrest Gump, Pulp Fiction, Shawshank and The Lion
- 52:57King. Like, I mean, what a year.
- 53:00Yeah, this is a heck of a year, man.
- 53:03Like what was in the water in this year that directors were
- 53:09just knocking it out of the park with their films?
- 53:11Yeah. You know, oddly enough, I do
- 53:14kind of feel like of all the things that could be named Best
- 53:17Picture in 1994, I do kind of feel like Forrest Gump is the
- 53:21best choice. Not because it's the best movie,
- 53:25but because it really is like a time capsule of what we cared
- 53:28about as America in 1994. And I think what we cared about
- 53:33was like, we Americans have really become jaded by arguing
- 53:43about things. And we don't want to talk about
- 53:45the causes of the Vietnam War anymore.
- 53:47And we don't want to talk about how much of A crook Nixon was.
- 53:50And we don't want to talk about our sordid history with drugs
- 53:53and free sex and everything else.
- 53:55Let's just kind of try to come back to what we think are the
- 53:59principles of America and let's focus on that.
- 54:02And, and I see why people didn't like that.
- 54:05I see why people think that America was putting its own head
- 54:08in the sand. But regardless of where you
- 54:11think America was at the time, this movie captured it that I
- 54:15guess it's a perfect encapsulation of however you
- 54:18interpret that part of history. And yes, I think Pulp Fiction's
- 54:21a better movie and probably would have been a better Best
- 54:23Picture winner. But I mean, that's just talking
- 54:27about the quality of the film. I think this movie really
- 54:30captures a moment in history and a lens through which to view the
- 54:36year. So you would say that this this
- 54:39year is an example of the populist approach winning the
- 54:44Oscars? When When has that happened?
- 54:47Yeah, the Academy didn't have its head up its own butt.
- 54:50Yeah, I know, man. Look at that.
- 54:53I don't know man, you've seen all four of those movies.
- 54:55Obviously The Lion King, not nominated for best picture, but
- 54:59Shawshank, I think you know, if they, if they redid it now, I
- 55:02almost feel like Shawshank would win cause if they redid it now,
- 55:05Forrest Gump's not winning. It's it's had 30 years of bad
- 55:08publicity because of that. I also don't know if Pulp
- 55:11Fiction is ever going to be palatable enough for a large
- 55:15chunk of the voting membership. Yes.
- 55:18And I think Shawshank's kind of like the the middle ground
- 55:21there. Yeah, I, I mean, at the end of
- 55:23the day, one of the reasons I think Forrest Gump has stood the
- 55:28test of the time is because of how sincere it is.
- 55:31Like, and it wouldn't win today because of that.
- 55:34Like, we're so much more cynical as a nation.
- 55:38And I, I don't think that the sincerity of the character of
- 55:42Forrest Gump, let alone the whole film, I just don't think
- 55:46it would work nowadays. Not not in the same way.
- 55:49I would still like it because I, I think the cynicism is tiring
- 55:55and overrated. It's not fun to be cynical, Bob.
- 55:58I think that's what I'm trying to say.
- 56:01It's fun for a time, but you have to come back to reality
- 56:04like Jenny. Yeah.
- 56:06Well, and that's, I think that's another reality of the human
- 56:09experience that we all have had over the last 80 years in
- 56:14America is that it is a very difficult journey to go on to
- 56:23figure out who you are, what you're all about.
- 56:26In a world where we have so much more awareness of what's going
- 56:30on in the wider realm of human existence and trying to figure
- 56:35out who we are and the journey we go on in our late teens into
- 56:39our 20s. And then we arrive into our 30s
- 56:42and, and suddenly we have different viewpoints on the
- 56:45world. Like, I think it captures that
- 56:47the tumult of growing up in a very different world than
- 56:52humanity has ever had in in its history.
- 56:56Yeah, man, Well said. I think that we've we've kind of
- 56:59captured most of what we have to say around the movie.
- 57:01And I I feel badly because I don't feel like we reviewed much
- 57:04of the movie itself today. So before we get into, let's
- 57:07make it a double. I have many notes on this movie,
- 57:11Brad, but let's just try to condense it down into a few
- 57:13quick observations. Is there anything that you want
- 57:15to make sure we touch on before we get out of here today?
- 57:19You texted me this, so it's your point, but I love the idea of
- 57:23watching this film and maybe like cutting out every single
- 57:27part that's not the bus stop and like just imagining this movie
- 57:32through the eyes of the people sitting at the bus stop.
- 57:36That poor woman at the start of the movie, the nurse that sits
- 57:39down like she's just like I had a hard day, leave me the F
- 57:43alone. And this guy you know, do you
- 57:46want a chocolate? He's just like putting a box in
- 57:48her face. Those must be comfortable shoes.
- 57:52My feet hurt. Like how many more signals could
- 57:56she be giving this guy? This dude will not shut up.
- 58:00I also took a note that he is just in general just a horrific
- 58:04listener because there's a point where you think he's like going
- 58:08to genuinely engage someone in dialogue.
- 58:10And he says, did you go to an all girls school or a girls and
- 58:14boys together school? And she goes, oh, it's Coed.
- 58:16And he goes, OK, cool, because Jenny went to a school that was
- 58:19only. And then he dives right back in
- 58:21and it's like forest. This is not how you're supposed
- 58:23to be an active listener, man. It's not all about you.
- 58:30Yeah, the if you made it a a cut of this movie that was the exact
- 58:34same length, but the first 90% of the film, the camera just sat
- 58:39there on the bus stop as he told the story.
- 58:42That would be a hell of a movie. I had a couple questions that
- 58:47are a rhetorical questions, but I was thinking about this movie
- 58:50in the history of PG13 movies because like this movie is
- 58:54significantly less violent than a movie like The Avengers, but
- 58:59they show blood. And so then you're like, Oh my
- 59:01gosh, like this is a real war movie, You know what I mean?
- 59:04Like it's not horribly violent, but it seems it seems extreme by
- 59:09what we have come to understand APG 13 movie to be.
- 59:14And perhaps in no way more than in the sexual way.
- 59:17You could just do a whole lot more sexy stuff back in 1994 and
- 59:21get away with the PG13. This is only a couple years
- 59:24before Titanic just showed boobs for 7 minutes straight and
- 59:30there's a couple boobs in this movie in a in a Playboy
- 59:32magazine, but for the most part there's no nudity.
- 59:36But I did write down the question.
- 59:38Is this the only film ever to get APG 13 rating and also
- 59:43feature a guy jizzing on someone's bathrobe?
- 59:48Wait what? When they're in the dorm
- 59:50together and she she takes off her top and then she has forest
- 59:54Hutcher boobs and then he ejaculates.
- 59:57Oh, I've never interpreted it that way.
- 59:59Oh, he literally says right after that I think I ruined your
- 1:00:02roommate's bathrobe. And she says that's OK, I don't
- 1:00:05like her anyway. You've never got that before.
- 1:00:11Nope. Oh, and then he goes I'm dizzy.
- 1:00:16How did you interpret it? I don't know.
- 1:00:20I didn't really think about it. Wow.
- 1:00:22Yeah, man, that's why I was saying like as a kid, I had no
- 1:00:25idea what was going on in that scene, but.
- 1:00:27Apparently as an adult, as an. Adult.
- 1:00:29I'm like how? How on earth did they get away
- 1:00:32with this in APG 13 movie? Now I think you're starting to
- 1:00:36understand why this was not shown in the G household growing
- 1:00:40up. I just I guess what I'm saying
- 1:00:45is the list of PG13 movies featuring ejaculation scenes
- 1:00:49probably not very long. Yeah, I mean, by 99 we have
- 1:00:53Kevin Spacey masturbating in the shower.
- 1:00:56Yeah, but and that gets that gets an R.
- 1:00:58That's a hard R, Yeah. OK.
- 1:01:03Second question much less of a hot topic.
- 1:01:06Forrest got no interest from the NFL after graduating from
- 1:01:10Alabama and being an All American.
- 1:01:13OK, so that you're, you're, you're catching on to my main
- 1:01:17critique of the, the story, like within the world of the film of
- 1:01:22Forrest Gump, they keep acting like this guy is a nobody.
- 1:01:27Like I, I, I feel like they're, they're doing it as a joke.
- 1:01:31But whenever they're talking about Forrest Gump, the man
- 1:01:33running across America, they're they literally refer to him as
- 1:01:37the farmer from Greenbow, Alabama, right.
- 1:01:41And I'm like, hold on a second. This dude was an all American
- 1:01:44for four years, five years at Alabama during the Bear girls
- 1:01:48era. He received Bear Bryant.
- 1:01:51Sorry, the guy that. Goes out in the wilderness and
- 1:01:54eats. Shit bears.
- 1:01:56Bears something. He wins the Congressional Medal
- 1:02:00of Honor. He gives a speech at one of the
- 1:02:02largest peace rallies in the history of peace rallies.
- 1:02:07He like. He does a million famous things.
- 1:02:10He goes to China and beats the Chinese in ping pong like.
- 1:02:14He's the founder of the Bubba Gump Shrimp Corporation.
- 1:02:16At that point, yeah, He's not a nobody.
- 1:02:19Yes, like at this point it's like, man, this guy who has done
- 1:02:23all these things is running. Why are you running, Mr. Gump?
- 1:02:28Yeah, I mean, he's like AAI, don't know what you call 100
- 1:02:31millionaire, but he's got to have hundreds of millions of
- 1:02:33dollars in the bank. Does he call himself a a
- 1:02:37gazillionaire? A gazillionaire?
- 1:02:38Yeah, gazillionaire. Yes, Sir, we have more money
- 1:02:41than Davy Crockett. Such a great line.
- 1:02:47But yes, like I just, you know, and, and he's at his graduation,
- 1:02:52apparently no NFL interest as a returner.
- 1:02:55But an Army recruiter? An Army recruiter and the thing
- 1:02:58I love the most about that scene is that the guy goes have you
- 1:03:01given any thought to your future and he takes the thing and he
- 1:03:04doesn't like the the natural thing for a person to echo would
- 1:03:07be like my future. But he doesn't say that he goes
- 1:03:12thought like the the foreign concept here isn't the future.
- 1:03:17It's thinking yes. Oh, man, I mean, he, he's good
- 1:03:22at running Bob. He he ain't so good at thinking.
- 1:03:25He must be the stupidest son of a bitch alive, but he sure is
- 1:03:29fast he. Sure is fast.
- 1:03:35All right, one more quote and then we'll get to let's make it
- 1:03:37a double. I don't know where else to fit
- 1:03:39this in to the podcast today, but I just had to say at some
- 1:03:43point, sorry I had a fight in the middle of your Black Panther
- 1:03:46Party. What a great line man.
- 1:03:51That should be. That should be the actual name
- 1:03:53of this movie. Black Panther Party.
- 1:03:57The whole sentence. Sorry, I had a fight in the
- 1:04:00middle of your Black Panther Party.
- 1:04:04As they're all standing there with guns.
- 1:04:06Drawn. All right, man, let's get into.
- 1:04:10Let's make it a double. We're near the end of the
- 1:04:12episodes of Things, listening to the film and Whiskey Show.
- 1:04:16Let's have another film with this one, even if it's
- 1:04:18struggling. It's the final segment of the
- 1:04:20day. Now let's make it a double.
- 1:04:22Let's Make It a double is the part of the show where we pick a
- 1:04:24movie to pair up with this one to make the perfect double
- 1:04:27feature. Brad, since you think I hate
- 1:04:30this movie, I will defer to you on this front.
- 1:04:32I'll let you go first here. I'm going to pair this with a
- 1:04:35film that came out 14 years later.
- 1:04:38It is a 2008 movie that has a similar vibe of like traversing
- 1:04:44a large historical period. And you know where you're going.
- 1:04:48Yeah, having a bit of an introspective take on it, I'm
- 1:04:51going to go with The Curious Case of Benjamin Button.
- 1:04:53Oh, that's not where I thought you were going, I am 99% sure.
- 1:04:58Where do you think I was going? I thought you were going to say
- 1:05:00Slumdog Millionaire. I was thinking about No Country
- 1:05:05for Gary Oldman, but. I'm pretty positive that
- 1:05:11Benjamin Button was written by the same guy that wrote Forrest
- 1:05:13Gump, which is probably why it feels so.
- 1:05:15Similar. Yeah.
- 1:05:17There you go. Yep.
- 1:05:18Yeah. Good movie.
- 1:05:20Oh yeah, Very good movie. I remember walking out of it in
- 1:05:22the theaters. Like that was one of those weird
- 1:05:25movies that my dad and I were like, yeah, you want to go watch
- 1:05:27a movie? And like, we picked while we
- 1:05:29were at the theatre and I was like, I don't know, Benjamin
- 1:05:32Button sounds curious. Let's go watch it.
- 1:05:35And I remember as like a 17 year old walking out of the theater
- 1:05:39and being like, man, that was really nihilistic.
- 1:05:43Oh man, I don't know if I enjoyed that.
- 1:05:46This was prior to before you knew anything about David
- 1:05:49Fincher. And now it's like, Oh yeah, it's
- 1:05:51a Fincher movie, of course. Yeah, exactly, Brad, for my
- 1:05:56Let's Make it a double. I think I'm going to throw back
- 1:05:58to a few seasons ago, we had the author, Noah Gettel on the
- 1:06:01podcast to talk about his book Baseball the Movie.
- 1:06:05And Noah and I talked a little bit about the movie Field of
- 1:06:08Dreams and how Field of Dreams is remembered as this movie
- 1:06:12about baseball. I think much like Forrest Gump
- 1:06:14is remembered as a movie about America, but it's also like it's
- 1:06:18a movie that's very obviously made by the baby boomer
- 1:06:21generation that deals with, you know, their own political
- 1:06:25progressiveness and like their their ability to go out and
- 1:06:29protest and like fight the power, but also their desire to
- 1:06:33cling to all the values they had in the 50s, like baseball, like
- 1:06:37whatever it would be in Forrest Gump.
- 1:06:39And I don't know that either of these movies it like it's
- 1:06:42completely successful in holding both of those things together.
- 1:06:45But they so remind me of each other.
- 1:06:47They're like, they're just these big weird movies that like, if
- 1:06:50you said something on paper, like if if you go into a pitch
- 1:06:54meeting and bring either Field of Dreams or Forrest Gump into
- 1:06:57the pitch meeting, you're like, I'm sorry, what is this movie
- 1:07:00about? But yeah, but they're just
- 1:07:02American classics now. And I think that you could do a
- 1:07:05lot worse than Field of Dreams here.
- 1:07:07Yeah, I mean, I mean, Field of Dreams is like the ubiquitous,
- 1:07:11if you ask any commoner what's your favorite baseball movie,
- 1:07:15It's like, I don't know, Field of Dreams.
- 1:07:18I I saw like half of it once in an afternoon.
- 1:07:22You know the peasants. Oh man.
- 1:07:28OK, so have you seen Field of Dreams?
- 1:07:30I have. I think I saw it when I was in
- 1:07:34like 7th or 8th grade and I literally have no memory of that
- 1:07:38movie. Whatever you might remember
- 1:07:40about that movie, if you revisit it, I promise you, you'll be
- 1:07:44like, I don't remember this, I don't remember this.
- 1:07:47What's this movie about? Where's the baseball?
- 1:07:49The baseball doesn't show up until like the last five minutes
- 1:07:52of the movie. It's kind of like aliens and
- 1:07:57signs, yes, it's like, it's like, yeah, they just show up
- 1:07:59for the last 5 minutes. All right, man, let's give this
- 1:08:03movie some final scores. I'll get mine out of the way
- 1:08:06here. I think this is a good movie.
- 1:08:09It's a very enjoyable movie. I don't think it goes very deep.
- 1:08:13I think at its best, it's like an 8 1/2.
- 1:08:15I think at its worst it's like a six.
- 1:08:16So I'm going to fall kind of right in the middle here.
- 1:08:18I think this is a somewhere between A7 and a 7 1/2 film for
- 1:08:22me. I'm going to give it a 7 out of
- 1:08:2410, Brad. Come on, Bob.
- 1:08:27Good movie. Have a soul.
- 1:08:29Good movie. I think that this is a nine out
- 1:08:32of 10 movie, Bob, like I I think that your qualifier of it was
- 1:08:37that this movie is like good but shallow.
- 1:08:41I think this movie is good and the depth of it is what draws me
- 1:08:46up to A9 like overall, for me, it's like an eight 8 1/2 out of
- 1:08:5010. But the emotional depth that you
- 1:08:53find in the character of Forrest Gump, in the relationships and
- 1:08:56Jenny, like, I think that it speaks to the core of human
- 1:09:01desire in a really powerful way. And I, I, yeah, I, I think that
- 1:09:06this movie is way deeper than people give it credit for.
- 1:09:11All right, so it's a 7 for me. It's a nine from Brad, taking us
- 1:09:14to a very easy to average 8 out of 10.
- 1:09:17But I'd like to know what you think, which one of us is wrong?
- 1:09:20Because it's got to be one of us, folks.
- 1:09:22Is it me or is it Brad? You can tell us on any of our
- 1:09:24social medias, Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, Tiktok,
- 1:09:28YouTube at Film Whiskey. Or if you want to join the
- 1:09:32conversation, we are live on our Discord talking to you all fans
- 1:09:37of the Film and Whiskey podcast every single day.
- 1:09:40So if you'd like to join the conversation, you can find a
- 1:09:42link to our Discord at the end of every single one of our show
- 1:09:45notes. Next week we are going to be
- 1:09:47wrapping up our Season 10 revisit with a movie that never
- 1:09:51ceases to make me feel like it's freaking perfect, Alfred
- 1:09:54Hitchcock's Rear Window. So join us next week for some
- 1:09:59Hitchcock, but until then, I'm Bob Book.
- 1:10:02I'm Brad Gee. And we'll see you next time.