Latest / Chatter that Matters / A tribute to Canada - J.D.M. Stewart
Transcript
- 0:04On july first, eighteen sixty seven, this beautiful country was born.
- 0:11Not because it was inevitable or because geography demanded it.
- 0:14Not because everyone was in agreement on what it should become.
- 0:19It happened because it was an act of imagination.
- 0:23Handful of colonies, divided by language, religion, region, interest, and identity, they decided to attempt something larger than themselves.
- 0:33What they chose was union over drift, compromise over collapse, a country over a collection of colonies.
- 0:40And from that first day, Canada has required prime ministers who could do more than win elections.
- 0:47They had to hold together a country that often seemed easier to pull apart.
- 0:52They had to build railways and institutions, navigate war and depressions, manage Quebec in the West, share a border with the world's greatest economy, welcome newcomers.
- 1:03Expand rights.
- 1:05They made decisions that lifted Canada and decisions that in fact harmed Canadians for generations.
- 1:12And that is why this Canada Day conversation matters to you and me.
- 1:16I hope they walk away with a few things.
- 1:19One of them would be that Canadian history is quite fascinating, pleasantly surprised about some of the achievements of the country, and I hope that they would come away
- 1:29understanding that leadership matters.
- 1:33My guest today is JDM Stewart.
- 1:35He's the author of the Prime Minister's Canada's Leaders and the Nation they shape.
- 1:40This is personal for me.
- 1:41Before James was an author, historian, commentator, and one of Canada's most thoughtful voices on her political history, he was a teacher at Bishop Strong School.
- 1:52Both of my daughters were blessed to have him as their history teacher.
- 1:56They did not just learn history from James, they fell in love with him.
- 2:00And that's a rare gift.
- 2:02See, he could take a date and turn it into a decision.
- 2:05He could take a name in a textbook and turn it into a moment of time.
- 2:10He could tell you why that happened and why it still matters today.
- 2:15The country itself was small, but the vision was big.
- 2:19And in his book, James opens with a story that should stop every Canadian in their tracks.
- 2:24He's speaking to a group of high school students at the United Nations, showed him a photograph of Lester B.
- 2:30Pearson, our Nobel Peace Prize winner, former Prime Minister, some would say the architect of modern Canada, and no one knew who he was.
- 2:39Well, nobody really teaches about prime ministers anymore.
- 2:42And that's the comment that really got me going.
- 2:45Just think about that.
- 2:46We live in a country where many young Canadians know more about American presidents, the founding fathers, politics, and culture than they know about the people who built, broke,
- 2:54repaired, defended, and reimagined Canada.
- 2:58And I'm launching this conversation on Canada Day 2026 at a time when Canada is once again being tested.
- 3:06The world order we relied on is shifting.
- 3:09Our relationship with the United States is under pressure.
- 3:12The economy is anxious.
- 3:14Artificial intelligence is reshaping work and truth.
- 3:17Quebec feels ignored, the West feels alienated.
- 3:20Young people are questioning whether Canada still offers them a future.
- 3:24A significant majority would choose to join the United States if the financial deal made sense.
- 3:30And this very idea of sovereignty, the right to decide our own destiny, is no longer something we can take for granted.
- 3:37We need to get more people on the same page more often than we do currently so that we can get some of these things done.
- 3:43You can just imagine how hard it is to be a prime minister.
- 3:46I want to get X, Y, and Z done and then a bureaucrat says, Well we gotta line up this, this, this and this.
- 3:53It's incredibly hard, but we have to keep trying.
- 3:56So this is not a history lesson.
- 3:58This is a reckoning with memory.
- 4:00Because if we do not know how Canada was made, how can we understand what's at risk?
- 4:05If we do not know that leaders who shaped us, how can we judge the leaders who will shape what comes next?
- 4:10And James does not see our prime ministers as saints.
- 4:13At the same time, he doesn't reduce them to villains.
- 4:17He asks us to see them as human beings, ambitious, flawed, visionary, limited, courageous, cautious, sometimes wrong, sometimes remarkable.
- 4:25But always consequential.
- 4:26An hour in the office of the prime minister is an hour in the office of the history of the country.
- 4:32What can the prime ministers of our past teach us about the Canada we need to become?
- 4:42It's Tony Chapman.
- 4:43Thank you for listening to Chatter That Matters presented by RBC.
- 4:46If you can, please subscribe to the podcast and ratings and reviews, while they're always welcome and they're always appreciated.
- 4:57JDM Stewart, author of the Prime Minister's Canada's Leaders and the Nation They Shaped.
- 5:01Welcome to Chatter that Matters.
- 5:03Great to be here, Tony.
- 5:05So Jace, I want to begin with you as a teacher.
- 5:07As I said in my opening, both of my daughters had you for history and they fell in love with the subject.
- 5:14What did you understand about teaching history that allowed you to make young people care?
- 5:20It comes down to uh caring about your students, but also being really authentic and meaningful in your enthusiasm for the subject at hand.
- 5:29And in this particular case, we're talking about mostly Canadian history, which is what I spent a good part of my career teaching and and that was always a real calling for me to
- 5:40be in the classroom with young people trying to teach them about the importance of the past.
- 5:44The reason you wrote this incredible book, Students Not Recognizing Lester B.
- 5:49Pearson, why did that moment hit you so hard?
- 5:53And more importantly, what do you feel it says about Canada and our understanding of what our roots are and what it took to build this country?
- 6:01So I was at a meeting of model United Nations students at the high school level when this happened and I had a picture of Lester B.
- 6:09Pearson on the screen.
- 6:11I asked this collection of students who who we had in front of us and nobody knew.
- 6:15And then I spoke to the teacher afterwards and said, Hey, can you believe that?
- 6:19The kids didn't know who Lester B.
- 6:21Pearson was and she said, Well, nobody really teaches about prime ministers anymore and that's the comment that really got me going.
- 6:28And I decided I've got to get a book out there.
- 6:31to have uh an opportunity to reach more kids and students and and even people beyond the classroom with this book because um there hadn't been one for such a long time.
- 6:41You've written it and people have read it, do you still have that same feeling that understanding our Prime Minister is a connective tissue to understanding our country?
- 6:52There are a number of of approaches to seeing the connective tissue of Canadian history.
- 6:58You could do it through immigration.
- 7:00You could do it through Canada's military experiences.
- 7:04You could do it through changes in the relationship between the government and its people through government programs.
- 7:12But the lens that I chose was this lens through Canadian prime ministers, which I still think is very important because
- 7:19It's the Prime Ministers who are making the decisions that affect everybody else.
- 7:24I quote Peter C.
- 7:25Newman in the opening.
- 7:27And Peter says, An hour in the office of the Prime Minister is an hour in the office of the history of the country.
- 7:34And let's wind the clock back to the july first, eighteen sixty seven, Canada becoming a country.
- 7:39What was most improbable about the idea that this crazy size of land and different beliefs and everything that went into this melting pot could become a country?
- 7:50Well, in eighteen sixty seven, of course, Canada wasn't very big at all.
- 7:54It was just uh this strip of of Ontario and Quebec plus New Brunswick and and Nova Scotia.
- 8:00So the country itself was small, but the vision was big.
- 8:06One province is French speaking and Catholic, and the other provinces are primarily Protestant and English speaking.
- 8:14So that was something kind of novel from the very beginning and was obviously going to
- 8:20cause friction uh down the road.
- 8:22In fact it still causes friction.
- 8:23So it was an improbable country, that's the way you put it.
- 8:26But it I think it would become even more probable improbable as we expand it.
- 8:30Let's talk about McDonald because, you know, his concept of C to C, the railway.
- 8:36I mean, right now we're tearing down his statues.
- 8:39We're not really recognizing what he did that was positive and what he made possible.
- 8:44This is one of my problems with people taking down the McDonald statues and and much of the debate about Sir Johnny McDonald to begin with is that it has become very one track,
- 8:54not a thorough evaluation of someone's legacy.
- 8:59The critics are taking one issue and saying Johnny McDonald, his indigenous policy was terrible and and started residential schools, therefore he must be a terrible person.
- 9:10And then we're just throwing everything out.
- 9:12And that that's not really a good historical perspective or any way to evaluate any any person, both living and dead.
- 9:20You know, I look at United States, their founding fathers, and how well they've been championed and celebrated, and all of them had flaws.
- 9:29All of them had why do the Americans establish their founding fathers as really heroes and yet we as a country seem to be more concerned about what they did wrong versus the the
- 9:44magistry of what they did right?
- 9:45Maybe that the Americans have a culture that is more ready to exalt and have heroes, whereas Canada is less content with heroes, doesn't think it needs them as much, will
- 9:59sometimes try to knock them down if they if they have them.
- 10:02It'd be interesting to see the study of what why Americans seem to be able to um look at someone like Thomas Jefferson or George Washington and say, yeah, we don't like the fact
- 10:10that he had slaves on one side, but on the other side we like the fact that
- 10:14He uh was president or the first president, or in Jefferson's case, the man who wrote the Declaration of Independence.
- 10:22So this is the whole idea that two things about a person can be true at the same time.
- 10:28With Sir John MacDonald, it can be true that he had the vision and the courage to try to build a nation out of something pretty small and see uh far enough ahead that a railway to
- 10:40the West Coast would be appropriate.
- 10:42And then at the same time we can say, yeah, there was a lot of skullduggery.
- 10:46We don't like his treatment of indigenous people, and we regret that.
- 10:49You know, we can have a uh a more balanced understanding of what what makes um a hero or someone worthy of a statue.
- 10:56But Canadians seem very reticent actually to really put anyone up on a pedestal.
- 11:02And in some degrees uh that's okay because that shows a certain amount of humility and modesty.
- 11:07But on the other hand, it sometimes leads to a lack of
- 11:11Ambition or aspiration and appreciation for your past.
- 11:15So let's move it on to talking about uh Laurier.
- 11:19I've studied a lot of Canadian history, but I didn't really understand Laurier's role the way you frame it.
- 11:24Moderation, conciliation, what do you call the sunny way?
- 11:28So in today's angry polarized world where it seems that everybody's sitting in their social media castles, uh liking each other's like minded content and then firing spitballs
- 11:39at the other side.
- 11:40Bring us back to the time where maybe there was a sense of civility and positivity that roared through politics.
- 11:47I loved his approach, which was devoid of hard edges.
- 11:53It was devoid of take it or leave it.
- 11:56It was about talking, dialogue, finding a solution always.
- 12:00So whether this was, you know, how are we going to solve the issue of sending troops to the South African War in 1899?
- 12:07Because I don't know if we really want to do it, he said, but I know there's a a lot of Canadians who still feel strong.
- 12:15feelings for the Empire, they probably want to do it.
- 12:17French Canadians not so much, but we do want to be able to help the British Empire.
- 12:21How do we do it?
- 12:22And so the end they he worked out a compromise where Canadian soldiers who volunteered to go would be able to go, but it would be paid for by the British.
- 12:31So he was always looking for a solution.
- 12:33Laurier was another visionary who believed in Canada itself and he added Alberta and Saskatchewan as two new provinces to the country.
- 12:43He traveled the country by rail and in one of my fate favorite stories about Sir Wilfrid Laurier is he took the railway out to Vancouver and back.
- 12:53At the end of the trip, he said, I went out west as a Canadian, but I've returned ten times more Canadian after breathing in the air and taking in the scenery of Western
- 13:03Canada.
- 13:04So that idea of how great Canada can be and that traveling it can inculcate with you the beauty of the country.
- 13:11He was always such a positive force.
- 13:15Would he survive today's politics?
- 13:17You know, I I think we could use people who who can try to show that there is a different way and that you don't have to be sinking down as everyone else sinks down.
- 13:26You know, you can still go high.
- 13:28And it's important for leaders to show that leaders can still go high.
- 13:33Mark Carney's doing a pretty good job of trying to avoid getting into the into the sandbox with President Trump.
- 13:41You know, you talk about whether they wanted to fight or not, but First World War comes along.
- 13:46Prime Minister Borden, there's no choice.
- 13:48We're signing up.
- 13:49You know, obviously national sacrifice, conscription, deep division.
- 13:53Tell me a little bit about his leadership that found a way through one of the real fractures of of what Canada stood for.
- 14:02I think one of Borden's successes was the personal.
- 14:05And I've always liked looking at the personal in leadership.
- 14:08And in nineteen fifteen, Borden makes a trip overseas and visits a number of hospitals where Canadian soldiers are are stationed and recovering.
- 14:19And he is blown away by their courage, by their attitudes.
- 14:23And and at that point he decided that I will make sure that we fight this war to the end.
- 14:29So that the sacrifice of these men who are wounded or already dead won't be in vain.
- 14:35As well as keeping the eye on Canadian sovereignty.
- 14:40This is not to say that there weren't mistakes made, because Tony, there were mistakes made by the Borden government.
- 14:45They gerrymandered the 1917 election to some degree, and they closed down some some rights of of different people as as often happens in wartime.
- 14:55So it's it's not like these guys were saints, and you you set off the top.
- 14:58I'm not trying to make prime ministers into saints.
- 15:01The real driving force here is leaders who are trying to make a positive difference for the country.
- 15:05You're always fascinated by their personalities.
- 15:08And when you write about Mackenzie King, you see what a contradiction.
- 15:11Odd, cautious, morally complicated.
- 15:14Yet he was incredibly successful.
- 15:16What did you learn about that melting pot between inspiring leadership, effective leadership, and if you looked at the book from its cover, you'd say not capable of
- 15:25leadership?
- 15:26I'm still a bit confounded by Mackenzie King, because he wasn't the nicest guy.
- 15:31He wasn't the per sort of person that you want to spend extra time with.
- 15:35He was always working.
- 15:36He never married, and in some ways, I think his marriage was was Canada itself.
- 15:42He surrounded himself with with good people.
- 15:45He let them do their jobs unless he thinks thought they were no longer capable of it, dedicated to the country, its sovereignty, definitely believed in the potential of what
- 15:54what Canada could bring to the world.
- 15:56But sometimes caution is is a virtue.
- 15:59And for King he used that skillfully and that pragmatism, I think I'll throw that word in in there as well, which which may come up again later.
- 16:07Pragmatism and caution, King had that in spades.
- 16:10And he also had strong cabinets.
- 16:12So let's now move to the individual that motivated the book, Left to be Pearson, governing office in from, you know, position of weakness, often with a minority government.
- 16:21But that was the days of Canada where Flag, Medicare, Canada pension planning won the Nobel Peace Prize, the St.
- 16:27Lawrence Seaway, Trans Canada Highway.
- 16:29I mean, we were really good at getting stuff done.
- 16:32Talk w how much of that would you put on Pearson's shoulders?
- 16:36Some of it was Louis Saint-Laurent, and some of this was was Pearson.
- 16:40So Saint Laurent was the infrastructure guy who brought forward the St.
- 16:44Lawrence Seaway and and got us in NATO and things like that.
- 16:48But Lester B.
- 16:48Pearson, as you were saying, just running through minority governments from 1963 to 1968, but got these big jobs done.
- 16:56You know, Medicare being uh one of the biggest ones on the Canadian flag, the most divisive debate in parliamentary history.
- 17:03Perhaps it was his skills.
- 17:05as a conciliator, as a diplomat that helped with that.
- 17:09But a lot of people were looking at Pearson with eyes wide open, saying, How are you actually doing that?
- 17:15Because this flag debate is going to be a disaster.
- 17:18In some ways, they were right, because it was such a a vociferous debate.
- 17:23But he had a vision.
- 17:25We needed a flag like this.
- 17:27Now he wasn't the one that invented that idea.
- 17:29Mackenzie King was talking about it in the 1945 lead up to the to that election.
- 17:34Push came to shove and Pearson saw what the need of it would be responding to, you know, there were still uprisings in Quebec now in the nineteen sixties.
- 17:42A flag that had that didn't have British colonial symbols on it would be necessary for Canada to move forward.
- 17:50he was a nice guy.
- 17:51He would listen.
- 17:52He was a diplomat.
- 17:53And also he was good at letting people who knew how to do something a little bit better in terms of negotiations.
- 18:00He let let them do it, and then people could report back to him and see what the prime minister thought.
- 18:04You know, we can't obviously go through every prime ministry, but I'm curious after you've done so much work with it, who do you feel is most misunderstood by Canadians?
- 18:15Writ large, a lot of people think prime ministers are just trying to build their their egos.
- 18:22But I would say all of the prime ministers have been trying to get something done good for the country, as I saying.
- 18:27But look at somebody like Brian Mulrooney.
- 18:29A lot of people didn't like Brian Mulrooney's personality when he was prime minister.
- 18:34But then when he died, people were appreciating a lot of the bold government initiatives that he took and that he was kind of a from a bygamon era, it almost seemed, because in
- 18:44the twenty twenties
- 18:45Politicians weren't making bold strokes anymore.
- 18:47It was it was not the same.
- 18:49The other person who I think was somewhat misunderstood is Stephen Harper.
- 18:52Because Stephen Harper, he gives off a bit of a remote vibe as a leader.
- 18:57Doesn't really let you in and seems like he's always calculating, but behind the scenes he's he's quite a different fellow.
- 19:04He he has a great sense of humor, he uh is enjoys camaraderie.
- 19:09And so there's often a a disconnect between the private prime minister and the public prime minister.
- 19:15I think it's important for people to understand that.
- 19:17And it's useful if prime ministers try to reveal a little bit more of the personal side to the public.
- 19:23So if you were a sports broadcaster, instead of talking about prime ministers, we're talking about athletes, I'd say who's the most underrated?
- 19:29You'd everybody has that argument.
- 19:31But when it comes to prime ministers, I'm curious from your point of view, who's the most underrated for the Canada we live in today that really set up sort of the bedrock or the
- 19:41foundation of this country, but really isn't recognized for it?
- 19:45To me, that answer is Louis Saint Laurent.
- 19:47Louis Saint Laurent was prime minister from nineteen forty-nine to fifty-seven.
- 19:51And this was at a critical time.
- 19:52It was the end of the McKenzie King era.
- 19:55How are we going to respond to the new world order that's being created out there with uh a communist bloc settling in?
- 20:02Saint Laurent did these things, signed Canada on Tonato, developed the the NORAD agreement, which uh the Diefenbaker government ended up signing, built the great
- 20:10infrastructure projects.
- 20:12The Saint Lawrence Seaway, I think you were alluding to earlier.
- 20:15The Trans Canada Highway.
- 20:16These were done in years, not decades upon decades, for a country of what, twenty million at that time.
- 20:22That was exceptional infrastructure building.
- 20:24And defense spending was often several points of of GDP or GNP as they measured it then.
- 20:31So he was spending money on defense.
- 20:34At the same time, also he was trying to move Canada away from its relationship with Great Britain slowly by doing things like um removing the word dominion from government
- 20:46correspondence.
- 20:47It would just be government of Canada rather than Dominion of Canada.
- 20:50He was doing these little things.
- 20:51He also appointed the first Canadian Governor General.
- 20:54In Vincent Massey.
- 20:55So he was making these little moves towards being more sovereign in the way we talk about ourselves and think about ourselves.
- 21:04uh
- 21:05historian, as I'm listening to you, it must frustrate you at times when people dismiss accomplishments of the past by just saying that was a different time or it back then
- 21:14everything was simple, easy to get done.
- 21:16I have to believe they had I mean, it might be different challenges, but the complexity and chaos of running a country is no different today than it was back then.
- 21:24Yeah, I don't know if I agree with you one hundred percent on that, uh Tony.
- 21:28Like the some of these projects would be really challenging and you'd need to marshal great resources, but the whole legal landscape and the treaty landscape and the rights and
- 21:42the environment, like a lot has changed in terms of what you have to be considering before you do any project.
- 21:48That's fair.
- 21:49We need to get more people on the same page more often than we do currently so that we can get some of these things done.
- 21:56You can just imagine how hard it is to be a prime minister.
- 21:59When you say, I want to get X, Y, and Z done and then a bureaucrat says, Well, we gotta line up this, this, this and this it's not the easiest thing to do.
- 22:07It's very it's incredibly hard, but we have to keep trying.
- 22:12When we come back, James and I are going to continue our conversation and pay particular note to his thoughts on the referendums and the separation moves that seem to be happening
- 22:22in this country and why that in fact they go back a half a century.
- 22:27And then I'm going to close the show with my love for Canada and some of the things I think we can do to make this beautiful country dream and do.
- 22:41It's Tony Chapman.
- 22:42Investing in Canada, while that matters to RBC.
- 22:46$500 billion in sustainable financing to combat climate change.
- 22:50$500 million for future launch.
- 22:52A 10-year program to prepare youth for the jobs of tomorrow.
- 22:55Helping to discover the next generation of Olympians, artists monetizing their talents, women entrepreneurs pursuing their dreams, supporting mental health, and so much more.
- 23:05Investing in Canada, while that matters to RBC.
- 23:13Canada prepares to fly its new flag that will make the maple leaf the popular symbol of the country.
- 23:19At a textile plant in Toronto, mass production is underway to have the first order ready when Queen Elizabeth proclaims it officially.
- 23:26And at verbal sanction on Christmas Eve.
- 23:28Thus, until now, there had been no official Canadian flag.
- 23:32But in a short while, all Canadians will salute their maple leaf forever.
- 23:43Our guest today is JDM Stewart.
- 23:44He's the author of an extraordinary book, The Prime Minister's Canada's Leaders and the Nation They Shaped, and what he has to say I hope will shape your views on this great
- 23:54country we live in and the leaders that helped make it happen.
- 24:00You think we've put so much bureaucracy and layers upon layers of wet cement that we can't even get the littlest things done, let alone having the imagination of building a railway
- 24:12coast to coast or the St.
- 24:14Lawrence Seaway.
- 24:15Have we put ourselves in a position that mediocrity is the way forward because we just haven't got permission and an appetite to get things done?
- 24:25I think there is an appetite, but I also think there has to be a bit more recognition or admitting that these things aren't as easy as we think they are.
- 24:35And maybe a bit more transparency to say, look, if we want to build a pipeline from Alberta to British Columbia, we have to uh do this kind of environmental assessment, we
- 24:44have this number of First Nations, we have to get on board.
- 24:46It's gonna cost this kind of money, but also some drive to make sure that it happens too.
- 24:51You know, I understand yes, you need to talk about environmental and the indigenous.
- 24:55You all of these things have to be factored in, but if they're simply used as a toll booth or a reason why not, it paints a very different picture.
- 25:04It's almost like the rest of the world must be raising their eyebrows going, You're sitting on more resources than almost any other country on the planet, and yet you got
- 25:13eleven million, one quarter of your population has stepped into a food bank last year.
- 25:17There's a of pockets of things that aren't working well in the country.
- 25:20I think that's that's for sure.
- 25:22It does get a bit discouraging to think about how long it's been since we've really done something incredible that we can all rally behind.
- 25:30And a lot of Canadians are starting to believe it too, because I would say that, you know, we had a government under Justin Trudeau that for a number of years was kinda saying that
- 25:40we're not a great country, i even if it wasn't explicit.
- 25:44it didn't seem to be ambitious that way, except in the area of climate change.
- 25:48I would encourage Prime Minister Mark Carney to continue to kind of dream for Canadians, set the bar high, and get some of the best minds to say, here's things that we can do.
- 25:59And some of them don't have to be infrastructure projects.
- 26:02We could be doing it by promoting other things like promoting Canadian sovereignty through Canadian books and and talking about arts projects and things like this that build a a bit
- 26:11of cohesion.
- 26:12But
- 26:13You know, he's holding that big summit economic summit in the fall of people gathering in Toronto to talk about world economics and and projects.
- 26:20So it's not easy and I think it is a lot harder than it used to be.
- 26:25I wasn't really gonna touch on this, but let's talk about the two Trudos, arguably the most polarizing prime ministers in our history.
- 26:31So let's start with the dad, Pierre.
- 26:34When we first walked off the airplane in Bonn with his rose and his lapel and his long hair, we thought we had a rock star.
- 26:40Canada had an identity, a personality.
- 26:43But I would say that during his tenure w we saw a country that was becoming more and more divided in terms of East and West and French and English.
- 26:52It was an exciting time when Pierre Trudeau became prime minister in in 68, and that was the the period of Trudeau Mania, which some of your listeners will remember.
- 27:01Uh, but the the bloom fell off that rose pretty quickly because in the nineteen seventy-two election, the Trudeau Liberals just won a minority government.
- 27:13You knew where he stood on most issues.
- 27:16And if you didn't like it, he was willing to spar with you or
- 27:20Take an issue the ballot box and and see what happens.
- 27:24So he did have hit the courage of his convictions.
- 27:27And the country was divided for sure, particularly from the West, with oil-producing resource-oriented provinces and the rest of Canada.
- 27:35And plus the whole idea of bringing in official bilingualism that created its own record of of division.
- 27:41But the one thing people did appreciate about Pierre Trudeau is that he at least spoke his mind and wasn't trying to speak out of two sides of his mouth.
- 27:49When Pierre Trudeau passed away in two thousand, there were hundreds of thousands of people that went to Ottawa to pay respects to his casket lying in state at the center of
- 28:00the Parliament building.
- 28:01So there was an appreciation, if not a love for him as well.
- 28:07You know, his son comes along carrying the Trudeau name and gets fast tracked into the leadership.
- 28:12How would you mark his time as a prime minister?
- 28:16You know, as a historian, Tony, the first thing I have to say is that it's a little bit early to be putting the stamp on his prime ministership.
- 28:23We're still trying to figure out what we think of uh Brian Mulrooney's prime ministership thirty years after it ended.
- 28:29But we can talk about some of the early the early tracks and he was also a prime minister that left office very unpopular.
- 28:37Uh we talked about the divisions that Pierre Trudeau created.
- 28:42And even Brian Mulrooney was divisive too.
- 28:44And there's some similarities between Trudeau Justin and Brian Mulrooney because they were both big personalities, personalities that kind of liked the adulation of the masses.
- 28:54And this, I think, was part of the reason why Trudeau fell out of favor, is people were tired of listening to him because he did do a bit of preaching and moralizing.
- 29:03He was apologizing a lot for things that happened in Canadian history, or he was saying Canada was great, but there would always be an asterisk.
- 29:10And he said famously,
- 29:11You know, Canada has no core identity.
- 29:15And I think that really ticked a lot of people off.
- 29:17And he's never been able to live it down or try to correct that statement.
- 29:22So he's not been a successful prime minister.
- 29:26I think that could change over time as we look at the issue of climate change isn't going anywhere.
- 29:31And Justin Trudeau staked a lot of his political capital on climate change.
- 29:36The issue of reconciliation with indigenous peoples, that's not going anywhere.
- 29:41Justin Trudeau staked a lot of his political capital on that issue.
- 29:46So there's uh a lot to sift through over the next twenty to thirty years to see what we think of the Justin Trudeau years.
- 29:53James, I was born in Quebec.
- 29:54I was part of the English exodus out of Quebec in nineteen seventy-nine.
- 29:58I had a lot of empathy for the French.
- 30:00I mean, the old expression was the English own the breweries, we drink the beer.
- 30:04I'd often painted it towards how powerful the church was in Quebec for many years as a reason why a lot of Quebecers weren't encouraged to do more.
- 30:12And I and I think a dupless with the separating the church and state, but we still had separation.
- 30:17We came very close to losing Quebec.
- 30:20And I'd say now in twenty
- 30:21twenty six, we cannot deny four hundred thousand people from Alberta have signed a petition to debate their referendum and independence.
- 30:29So talk to me about first Quebec.
- 30:31What can we learn from that and how can we take some of that learning to make sure that both Quebec and Alberta continue to be part of this great country?
- 30:40One thing that underlines both of these questions is the importance of understanding your country and understanding your history.
- 30:46Because that Quebec referendum, the second one, is over thirty years ago, and the first one is almost fifty years ago.
- 30:53So most of the younger population uh doesn't have any recollection of this at all.
- 31:00And so this is why another reason why I think it's important for people to read books like mine, uh, is to have an understanding that there are roots to this and the roots go back
- 31:10To before Confederation.
- 31:12And the same thing with Western separatist feelings.
- 31:16Western alienation it didn't just get invented under Jason Kenny or Danielle Smith.
- 31:22This goes back to um the 1920s.
- 31:25And some of the early third parties that were in Parliament, like the Progressive Party, won the second most seats in the 1921 election.
- 31:34And they were a collection of Western farmers and Ontario farmers who were unhappy.
- 31:38with the decisions of coming out of Central Canada.
- 31:42So we have to have a patience and an understanding for these issues.
- 31:47And we also need to be able to debate them on their on their merits, because I I don't think there is a strong case for Quebec or Alberta to leave Confederation, the
- 31:57Confederation of one of the greatest countries in the world.
- 31:59Is there room to try to make the Confederation better?
- 32:02Yes.
- 32:03But I think it's really important that people walking around saying, I wonder what's going on in this debate.
- 32:08Well, y you kinda have to educate yourself a little bit on some of the historical issues that have plagued both of these provinces.
- 32:16They're two quite different ones as well.
- 32:18Quebec, very much a cultural and linguistically based movement and trying to control their own cultural destiny in a on a continent of uh four or five hundred million people.
- 32:30Alberta, it's very much more a grievance between
- 32:34Alberta separatists and and not just separatists, the Alberta government and the relationship with the federal government in Ottawa, which really deteriorated under the
- 32:44the leadership of Justin Trudeau.
- 32:46A striking number of young Canadians, striking number, would consider becoming American if the price was right.
- 32:53So in other words, my future is no longer guaranteed.
- 32:56This Canadian dream has disappeared.
- 32:59Access to jobs, affordable housing, this great negative cloud that social media has put over all of us.
- 33:07How do we get them to believe in this country again?
- 33:09One of the things that teaches this is that economics are extremely important.
- 33:13And the economic agenda hasn't really focused on young people for a long time, if ever, because it's always seems to be focused on on the older set of demographics.
- 33:24And I think younger people have finally realized that they're kind of getting the short end of the stick, which which I would say they probably are.
- 33:31I would spend some political capital addressing their needs, which are significant.
- 33:36At the same time,
- 33:37We haven't done a great job of showing young people how dynamic the country is historically and culturally.
- 33:46We ha we live next door to the biggest cultural juggernaut in the United States.
- 33:50It dominates a lot of what comes across a a young person's phone.
- 33:55In schools, I think we need to do a better job of telling the story of of Canada through not just history class, but also, you know, in your English class.
- 34:03Are you
- 34:04Reading English uh Canadian novels or French Canadian novel in translation and celebrate the country.
- 34:10We just spent the last ten years.
- 34:12In the ten years after the Truth and Reconciliation Commission, there was a lot of newspaper stories and political commentary about Canada not being a great country.
- 34:22We can still recognize the wrongs, but we can still say this is one of the greatest countries in the world.
- 34:28We'd I'd like to hear a little bit more of that kind of talk coming from various leaders across the country.
- 34:33So if young Canadians read your book, what do you hope they walk away?
- 34:40A few things.
- 34:40One of them would be that Canadian history is quite fascinating, pleasantly surprised about some of the achievements of the country.
- 34:49And I hope that they would come afr come away understanding that leadership matters.
- 34:55I would hope they say, Oh, I I want to pick up another book on Canadian history and I want to delve deeper into that that topic there on Expo sixty seven, or I want to read more
- 35:04about what happened with um
- 35:07some of the the environmental water treaties or some of the arts groups that were formed.
- 35:12Or I just want to dig further into a biography of somebody like Wilfred Laurier.
- 35:16So a nice springboard into a further interest in Canadian history would be my hope.
- 35:22James, I always end my podcast with my three takeaways.
- 35:25And the first is I help a lot of people take away what you talked about today.
- 35:30And that is we look at our prime ministers and we tend to frame them and label them, even more so now.
- 35:36I love Carney or I hate Carney.
- 35:38But the reality is they're human beings, and as you said, most of them stepped up to serve and build a better Canada.
- 35:45They often had to do it wading through the cement of the days, whether that was Britain.
- 35:50United States, tariffs, Quebec seeking i independence.
- 35:54Many of them found a way to keep moving forward.
- 35:56Some even ran through that cement.
- 35:59And certainly when you look at how Canada was created, we've done some remarkable things.
- 36:05The second thing is the interesting is the attributes of a leader.
- 36:08And I wonder if they have changed over time.
- 36:11I think that time has changed in terms of we talked about is the you know, the bureaucracy and the many things you have to check off before you get things going.
- 36:18But
- 36:19You know, you need courage, you need conviction, you need capability, you need your ability to compromise, collaborate, and you need to have this, you know, these shining
- 36:28eyes in the sense that we can dream and we can do it.
- 36:31And let's hope that as we vote for our leaders in in the future, we look for those attributes in them.
- 36:37I guess the final thing is, you know, the word history almost tends to timestamp things and and make people go, Do I really need to learn that?
- 36:47Hearing the passion in your voice, and I am a lover of history as well, I think the more we can learn about where we came from, to understand that the rings on the tree called
- 36:57Canada that began in eighteen sixty seven, and each of those rings represents a year, and within those years a lot went on.
- 37:05And the more we understand that, I think the more we can appreciate why there is really no country like Canada, that it is our time to seek possibility and positivity and to create
- 37:16a country where
- 37:17We're less dependent on boring money to make our way forward and much more focused on growing our way forward and as you said, with culture and creativity and commerce and
- 37:28enterprise and all the magical things that give a country and the people who live their purpose.
- 37:33So I I really appreciate you joining me on Chatter That Matters.
- 37:37My pleasure to be here, Tony.
- 37:38Thanks for the great conversation.
- 37:43What I now want to talk about is Canada.
- 37:46I'm not happy where we are as a country.
- 37:48We seem divided and distracted.
- 37:51Too many are living paycheck to paycheck.
- 37:53For them and many others, Canada is no longer affordable or a place to dream and do.
- 38:00I mean, we all love to hear that we're the best place to live and we're wrapped and protected by a blanket of care.
- 38:06But is it fair to say that it's our borrowed dollars in excessive taxation?
- 38:11That have been woven together to create this blanket.
- 38:14Next year, our interest payments for the debt owed by our federal and provincial governments will be over $68 billion.
- 38:21This is money that should go to health care and education and our defense.
- 38:25And each year more debt is piled on and more interest is paid.
- 38:29Canada needs to grow, not bore our way forward.
- 38:32We need to drastically reduce the number of dollars that go into running our many levels of government.
- 38:37We need to free up more dollars working for Canadians in Canada.
- 38:41We need to improve our productivity and foster and fuel a made in Canada economy versus subsidizing our branch plant mentality.
- 38:49And with so much commerce happening in the clouds, we need to invest in our innovators and keep them in Canada versus having them drain into other countries.
- 38:57We need to maintain our leadership in AI, be the leaders in tech for nature.
- 39:01Why not own longevity and become the country where research and commercialization is done to keep people living healthier and longer?
- 39:08We need to pick the lanes where we can be a superpower.
- 39:11Can we not become the country that our allies look to for ethically sourced food and the environmentally forward harvesting of our resources?
- 39:19Canadians populate Hollywood.
- 39:21Can we not tap into our creativity to create content and gaming for the world?
- 39:24And Canada must treat immigration as our strategic advantage, not some random number.
- 39:30We need to understand how many people will we need given our job losses and the automation of task work and our infrastructure and social services.
- 39:37Are they set up to support them?
- 39:39What can best serve our calling for a growth-oriented economy while preserving our democracy and values?
- 39:46We only have 40 million people to feed and vast intellectual, emotional, and natural resources to harness and harvest.
- 39:53Let's work to earn our way forward and to create the next chapter of Canada, one that's tolerant, democratic, resourceful, and productive.
- 40:01Because the future Canada and the future of our youth, and your and my future, deserve this.
- 40:08Once again, a special thanks to RBC for supporting Chatter That Matters.
- 40:12It's Tony Chapman.
- 40:13Thanks for listening, and let's chat soon.