Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / How New Fire Risk Policies Are Reshaping California Land Use and Construction with Don Schmitz, Michael Lynch, Joseph Cobert, Laurence Hummer
Transcript
- 0:02Hello, welcome to the Beverly Hills Bar Association
- 0:08real estate sections program for July. We've
- 0:13entitled it how new fire risk policies are shaping
- 0:19land use and construction. The truth of the matter
- 0:24is it's probably also reciprocal because I think
- 0:27what's going on in land use and construction
- 0:30is influencing what is happening on the insurance
- 0:34policies. I'm Joe Cobart. I am the past chairman
- 0:41of the real estate section and on the executive
- 0:45committee now. I am one of the moderators. The
- 0:48other moderator is Larry or Lawrence Hummer.
- 0:51You can see his him smiling. He's on the executive
- 0:56committee as well. Both Larry and I are longtime
- 0:59real estate lawyers. And we came up with the
- 1:06idea of this particular program because we both
- 1:11were made aware of the fire hazard severity maps
- 1:17that have been generated by the Cal Fire, the
- 1:23state agency, sent to the cities to make sure
- 1:26that every city designates what areas they think
- 1:31are ones that are susceptible to fires. In fact,
- 1:36the parts that are would either get classified
- 1:39as moderate, high risk, or very high risk. What
- 1:45that also does, though, is gives information
- 1:49to the insurance companies and they make their
- 1:51own risk analysis, but they take those items
- 1:54into consideration. Now, we have two really terrific
- 2:00speakers that are going to be sharing their thoughts
- 2:05with you. First one is Don Schmitz. Don is the
- 2:11president and principal of Don Schmitz and Associates.
- 2:15He's been in the land use consulting business
- 2:17for about 37 years, even though he looks too
- 2:20young to be doing that. He has a firm that has
- 2:26offices in Malibu and Agoura Hills. And I think
- 2:30I saw in the picture about 18 people employed
- 2:34there. So they're very busy practice. What do
- 2:37they do in that area? Well, they consult. and
- 2:43specializing in land development, entitlements,
- 2:49strategic planning, project management, dealing
- 2:53with government entities, and advocating for
- 2:58their clients before those entities. Besides
- 3:04consulting in land use per se, Don has been recognized
- 3:10as one of the preeminent experts in coastal land
- 3:14use planning. Very knowledgeable about coastal
- 3:19commission and all of that. Our second speaker
- 3:22is Michael Lynch. Michael will talk about things
- 3:28from the insurance side perspective. Michael
- 3:32has been in the casualty insurance business for
- 3:36about 30 years. Currently, he's with Marsh and
- 3:40McLennan, a large insurance company, where he
- 3:43is the president of the private client services
- 3:50West Coast region. And he's going to be talking
- 3:55to us about what's going on in the insurance
- 4:02sector. We've got a lot of things changing. He's
- 4:05going to talk about those items. He's also going
- 4:09to be focusing on, in part at least, California
- 4:15Fair Plan. What was its origin? What's happened?
- 4:21What will be its future? And those of us who
- 4:24are California taxpayers are interested in knowing
- 4:28about that because we subsidize it. He'll also
- 4:32talk about the difference between the admitted
- 4:35insurance carriers and non -admitted carriers.
- 4:41He will also let us get an insight into how the
- 4:47insurance companies are going to be calculating
- 4:50premiums these days, what they're going to require
- 4:53in terms of steps that you might take on your
- 4:57property if you're going to do construction.
- 5:00and cutting back on the land area that's got
- 5:10a lot of shrubs and also what's called defensible
- 5:17space. And so Michael will do that. Before we
- 5:22go to our speakers, just a couple of housekeeping
- 5:25things that I think we need to know. If you have
- 5:29any questions, and we hope you do, please set
- 5:32them out in the Q &A. Larry will be monitoring
- 5:37that. We hope to be able to get to a lot of them,
- 5:42time permitting. If we go over a little bit past
- 5:455 o 'clock, we may have a few minutes to answer
- 5:50some final questions. And I know it's been put
- 5:55on the screen, but if you haven't, notice that
- 5:59you'll get, if you're a lawyer and you attend,
- 6:02you'll get MCLA credit certificates in a couple
- 6:05of days, probably. And we, you know, we in the
- 6:11executive committee of the real estate section
- 6:14are really looking for contributions from other
- 6:17people who have ideas. And if you have an interest
- 6:22in making a presentation or coming up with a
- 6:26topic to help others, do so, we'd love to have
- 6:29you join. And that's now time to turn it over
- 6:33to Don Schmitz. Can I interrupt? I'm sorry, Joe,
- 6:36for just one thing. Those of you who haven't
- 6:39seen the materials that the Beverly Hills Bar
- 6:41Association sent you earlier, if you look in
- 6:44the chat, you'll see that there's a link there
- 6:48to the materials. You can download them and have
- 6:51them available that way. And some of the materials
- 6:55are going to be in Don's PowerPoint, so you'll
- 6:59have a chance to see them that way as well. Don?
- 7:04Well, thank you, Joseph. I appreciate it. I am
- 7:07the aforementioned Don Schmitz. If you can start
- 7:10a PowerPoint presentation, go to the next slide.
- 7:14So the AICP stands for American Institute of
- 7:17Certified Planners. Contend that means any idiot
- 7:21can plan, but I'll allow you to come to your
- 7:25own conclusions after listening to our presentation.
- 7:27Next slide, please. I am a point man for my firm.
- 7:32There's about 20 of us. As you can see, they're
- 7:35all younger, better looking, better dressed,
- 7:38smarter. But they really are the heart and soul
- 7:42of the firm. And I'm just the sharp end of the
- 7:45spear here. We work all up and down the state
- 7:48of California, not just in the coastal zone.
- 7:50But the fact of the matter is, is that our consulting
- 7:52practice on entitlements of individual projects,
- 7:56as well as representing counties and cities in
- 7:58front of the Coastal Commission and dealing with
- 8:00state and federal agencies have a tremendous
- 8:02amount of experience in the issue as it pertains
- 8:05to fire safety, fire safe development, and protection
- 8:09of communities. Next slide, please. So we're
- 8:14gonna discuss several things here. The fire severity
- 8:17zones and what the implications are for local
- 8:20laws and regulations. I was asked to focus in
- 8:22a little bit on Beverly Hills and Santa Monica,
- 8:25what wildfire impacts are and solutions to extreme
- 8:28wildfires. I think that the cataclysm that we
- 8:32have experienced here in Southern California
- 8:34very recently, still very fresh, but. Sadly,
- 8:39not completely atypical is why this is, if you'll
- 8:42pardon the pun, a very hot topic, and a lot of
- 8:44this is going to be germane to what Michael is
- 8:46going to be speaking with you this afternoon
- 8:49as well. Next slide, please. So the fire hazard
- 8:53severity zones are in the state responsibility
- 8:56areas. These are not new. These have been around
- 8:59for a long time. You've got moderate, high, and
- 9:02very high. The very high is class four, and high
- 9:07is class three. very high would be called a very
- 9:13high fire hazard severity zone. So say that quickly
- 9:17and I promise that you will get time time. This
- 9:19has some pretty important implications in regards
- 9:22to property owners, municipalities and counties
- 9:25in regards to their land use planning and their
- 9:27construction practices. Next slide, please. So
- 9:34this is the city of Beverly Hills. The state
- 9:40Mapping for the severity zones did not change.
- 9:44The very high fire hazard severity zone, as you
- 9:47can see on the slide, did not change from that
- 9:50which was mapped before. Now, it obviously comes
- 9:53down into the urban area. So there's a couple
- 9:56things which are relevant in regards to that
- 9:59that you got to be aware of. First of all, before
- 10:02Beverly Hills was built, before Los Angeles was
- 10:05built. These wildfires that would start either
- 10:10through spontaneous combustion from piled up
- 10:12biomass or lightning strikes. They would burn
- 10:15and burn and burn. They would come down out of
- 10:17the hills and they would burn right down through
- 10:19the flatline areas into the grasslands. We've
- 10:21built our communities and our cities in in the
- 10:25in the path of these things. It's a bit of a
- 10:28misnomer that they just are were ever confined
- 10:32to the hills. In fact, when they the Spanish
- 10:34were. coming up through California and under
- 10:38explorations, they called Los Angeles the Valley
- 10:41of the Smokes. And that was because of all the
- 10:45fires that were burning on an ongoing basis.
- 10:48There was nothing to stop them, and they would
- 10:50burn for days and weeks and months. And that
- 10:53means fire is part of the natural cycle for the
- 10:56sclerophyll vegetation you have here in the Mediterranean
- 10:59climate. Next slide, please. And if you'll just
- 11:03go to the next slide. So basically both the city
- 11:08of Beverly Hills and the city of Santa Monica
- 11:11have passed local ordinances. More on that in
- 11:14a second. Unlike Beverly Hills, Santa Monica
- 11:17did. and see some modifications to the state
- 11:22classifications for the very high fire hazard
- 11:25and high fire hazard severity zones as a state
- 11:28map in which they actually came down to the periphery
- 11:32of the city of Santa Monica. This is actually
- 11:36logical. If you take a look at the Eaton fire,
- 11:41that monster came down out of the San Gabriel
- 11:43Mountains and burned models. Into the community.
- 11:48Once it got a full head of steam, there was.
- 11:51There was no stopping it, and so the states modified
- 11:54their their mapping in regards to that, and they
- 11:57have. In fact, the city has adopted these maps
- 12:01pursuant to the ordinance, which you see here
- 12:04on the screen. This does have implications, not
- 12:08just on the the micro scale, but on the macro
- 12:12scale in one of the. Biggest examples of that
- 12:16is, as you may well be aware, the state has been
- 12:20passing a lot of laws to to promote higher density
- 12:27housing to address the housing crisis in the
- 12:29state of California. One of the most important
- 12:33ones is Assembly Bill 130, which became law immediately
- 12:36because it was incorporated into the budget bill
- 12:39that was passed up there in Sacramento, removes
- 12:42a lot of the CEQA obstacles and such as it pertains
- 12:46towards doing higher intensity development. One
- 12:49of the caveats to that. is in areas that are
- 12:53a very high fire hazard severity zone. That law
- 12:56and the waiver of a lot of the environmental
- 12:58regulations does not apply within these mapped
- 13:01areas. When you go back to the existing development,
- 13:05it's more of a reaction on the micro scale, which
- 13:09I'll discuss next. Next slide, please. There
- 13:13are some important key numbers that you should
- 13:16be aware of. It is only July. But we've already
- 13:22had 44 large wildfires this year. There's been
- 13:25over 219 ,000 acres. These numbers are from the
- 13:30Watch Duty, which is a 501C3 nonprofit organization.
- 13:36219 ,000 acres is probably a higher number now.
- 13:3929 fire -related fatalities. I know that that
- 13:43number is antiquated because they just discovered
- 13:45another fatality or two from the Palisades and
- 13:48the Eaton fires. There's been over 16 ,255 structures
- 13:54damaged and destroyed by wildfires this year.
- 13:57These numbers just keep going up. But this was
- 14:02not the worst year in regards to acreages. I
- 14:06believe that was 2018, 2019. Next slide, please.
- 14:13So these numbers here are the costs of fighting
- 14:16the fires. These aren't the losses. These are
- 14:19not the damages to real estate, to businesses,
- 14:22to homes, to infrastructure. This is just the
- 14:25cost of fighting the fires. And so from 1981
- 14:28to 84, 85, the state spent about $14 million.
- 14:34In 2021 to 2025, they spent $868 million. And
- 14:40remember, we are nowhere near done. with 2025,
- 14:45and depending on what the climatic conditions
- 14:48will be going through the end of the year, this
- 14:52could get much, much worse. So we are approaching
- 14:55a billion dollars in fire suppression expenses.
- 15:01Those helicopters, the bulldozers, the thousands
- 15:06and thousands of firefighters that are out there,
- 15:10and they are the best in the world. which is
- 15:13a bit of a depressing side note because the best
- 15:16in the world is getting rolled up by these cataclysms.
- 15:19But we're getting close to a billion dollars.
- 15:22The estimates are still rolling in, in regards
- 15:24to the property damage from the palisades and
- 15:28the Eaton fire. But I'm hearing numbers of upwards
- 15:32to a quarter of a trillion dollars, just many
- 15:35tens, hundreds of billions of dollars of real
- 15:39estate damages. that had been lost. So that of
- 15:43course doesn't include the absolutely irreplaceable
- 15:50loss of human life. Next slide please. So there's
- 15:53a number of solutions to extreme wildfires and
- 15:56includes home hardening, developing fire resistant
- 16:00homes and buildings, wet defensible fire breaks,
- 16:02which all embellish your pond, first fire defense
- 16:04systems, overlapping sprinkler systems, and prescribed
- 16:07burns. Next slide. This next slide is fuel modification.
- 16:13That's a fancy way of saying clear, not the stuff
- 16:15that burns around the structure. So combustible
- 16:19vegetation needs to be removed, thinned, or modified
- 16:22with drought -tolerant fire -resistant plants.
- 16:26And the state law requires 100 feet. County of
- 16:30Los Angeles requires 200 feet. City of Beverly
- 16:33Hills requires 200 feet. County of Ventura requires
- 16:36100 feet. So 100 feet is sort of your baseline.
- 16:40And so these different fuel modification zones,
- 16:43it depends on how close you are to the structure.
- 16:47Within the first 100 foot of the structure is
- 16:50where you want to see your irrigated landscaping.
- 16:54You don't want to have any native vegetation.
- 16:56And within 30 feet of the structure, you don't
- 16:58want to have any specimen trees which could act
- 17:01as ladder fuels to convey the fire up onto the
- 17:04roof of the house. When you go out in these areas
- 17:07that require 200 foot of clearance, What LA County
- 17:11refers to as zone C, it's selective thinning
- 17:14of the native vegetation. You take out the really
- 17:16hazardous species like sage and sumac, and you
- 17:19thin out the more resistant ones like mountain
- 17:22mahogany and cyanothus. It's more of a natural
- 17:25transition. This is to slow down the fire as
- 17:29it approaches the structures, and it is to reduce
- 17:33the radiant heat. Next slide, please. So home
- 17:37hardening is something that is a code for all
- 17:42new development in these fire hazard severity
- 17:45areas. One of the things that I think that you
- 17:47ought to be looking for is existing homes in
- 17:52regards to home hardening, where there's not
- 17:54a entitlement hook, a permit hook for the jurisdictions
- 17:58to require it. Nonetheless, Michael and other
- 18:03insurers are going to want to see these things
- 18:05done. a class A fire resistant roof, the eaves
- 18:08boxed in, siding also class A fire resistant,
- 18:13dual pane tempered glass windows. One of the
- 18:17things I didn't mention in the zones of clearance
- 18:19is within five feet of the structures, the state's
- 18:22now adopted. Zone O, I refuse to call it the
- 18:28O Zone. Immediately adjacent to the house to
- 18:31where you're not allowed to have any bushes,
- 18:34let alone any trees, just gravel or sod or succulents.
- 18:40They have learned that having the bushes planted
- 18:42right up next to the house will convey fire and
- 18:45can take the home. Openings need to be metal
- 18:48screen and decks need to be, decks act as wicks.
- 18:53very often. And so those decks need to be constructed
- 18:57in a fire hardened fashion as well. So next slide,
- 18:59please. This is just a couple examples of what
- 19:03you're looking at. You can see on the right,
- 19:06you've got stucco siding. You've got a tile roof.
- 19:09I used to think these pots and pans, Spanish
- 19:11tile roofs were great. They're not. I mean, you
- 19:15can build a campfire on them and it's not gonna
- 19:17catch a house on fire, but those embers, which
- 19:20flow like lava, get up underneath them and can
- 19:23get the underlayment burning. Screening the vents,
- 19:27but also a screen over the chimney. A lot of
- 19:29people don't think about this. I've seen homes
- 19:31taken where just you have copious amounts of
- 19:34embers which rain down into the fireplace, which
- 19:36is fine within the fireplace, but then it spreads
- 19:40out over the living room floor. floor and takes
- 19:42the house from the inside. Next slide, please.
- 19:46So this is what's happening now. I actually built
- 19:52this on my house. from scratch before you started
- 19:56getting these contractors can do it. And it wasn't
- 19:58until I took a close look at the slide, I realized
- 20:01this house is right up by my ranch home up in
- 20:04the Santa Monica Mountains. In fact, I permitted
- 20:06this house through the County and the Coastal
- 20:09Commission many years ago, and it did burn down
- 20:11in the Woolsey fire. And as you can see, it's
- 20:13a great house with a tile roof and stucco siding
- 20:16and all that. But when the gentleman rebuilt,
- 20:19he hired this company, Hotshot, and they incorporated
- 20:23this. fire suppression system. It's linked in
- 20:26with satellite comms. It has ember detection,
- 20:29auto activation, full perimeter defense. As you
- 20:32can see, he has a vineyard. Those have been outlawed
- 20:35in the Santa Monica Mountains by the Coastal
- 20:37Commission in the County of Los Angeles, by the
- 20:38way, but they make a great fire break. So this
- 20:43house is a very safe house, except you got those
- 20:46blowing embers and it just needs to find one
- 20:48weak chink in the armor and it can take the whole
- 20:51house. That's exactly what happened. So these
- 20:54systems are not cheap, but they are very, very
- 20:57effective. Next slide, please. On the macro scale,
- 21:02our government needs to do more. And that starts
- 21:05with good old fashioned fire breaks. They're
- 21:08proven, they work. They're done now in the middle
- 21:12of a firestorm where the bulldozers and the crews
- 21:15come out and they grade these in. They're a necessary
- 21:18component to fighting wildfires. The counties
- 21:23and the cities used to do these regularly. The
- 21:25environmental movement shut that down and they
- 21:29stopped doing it. I would contend that the tragedy
- 21:32of the Palisades fire, for instance, is a result
- 21:35of a failed 50 -year experiment in land use.
- 21:39We need to start doing these fire breaks again.
- 21:42Next slide. But they can be done a lot more sensitively.
- 21:45Those who argue that fire breaks don't work,
- 21:48by the way, I don't think they've got a leg to
- 21:50stand on. That's the case. Why is it the fire
- 21:53department rushes around in the middle of an
- 21:55outbreak of a firestorm in the middle of the
- 21:57night, putting their lives on the line to get
- 21:59out there with the 200 foot tall wall of flame
- 22:03coming at them to cut in these fire breaks? I
- 22:06think what we ought to do is make them wet defensible
- 22:08fire breaks. If you go to the next slide, please,
- 22:10you cut in the fire breaks. And then you provide
- 22:13a more sensitive way to do them if you're prepositioning
- 22:17them is you use goats. So you're not getting
- 22:20all the environmental damage. In fact, using
- 22:22the goats is something that has been endorsed
- 22:23by the Sierra Club. And the picture on the right
- 22:26is now become a cultural cherished phenomenon
- 22:30in Malibu West. They call it the running of the
- 22:32goats. It's a... It's a subdivision in western
- 22:35Malibu, and the goat herder brings out all these
- 22:39goats, and they go running down the street, and
- 22:41the kids laugh, and then they spend all their
- 22:43time in the surrounding hills munching down all
- 22:46the fuel, which makes a huge difference when
- 22:49the inevitable firestorm comes. Next slide, please.
- 22:54So establishing a fire defensive system would
- 22:57be a really good thing to do for Beverly Hills.
- 23:00You do have the Hollywood Hills back behind it.
- 23:03The fires do not have as much time to gain up
- 23:05a full head of steam. Unlike the Pacific Palisades
- 23:10and Malibu where it can start miles inland and
- 23:13fan out to a three to 10 mile wide fire front
- 23:17driven by 50 mile an hour winds, but it's still
- 23:20there. And so establishing some fire. Next slide.
- 23:54The reason I call them wet defensible fire breaks
- 23:56is because I think that we should pre -position
- 23:59large municipal water tanks, agricultural lines,
- 24:02and put these large sprinklers out there. Each
- 24:04one of these sprinklers would have a 30 to 50
- 24:06-yard range. It basically would rain along the
- 24:11fire breaks. And when you think about what the
- 24:13fire department does currently, they grade in
- 24:15those fire breaks, pre -positioned or otherwise,
- 24:18and then when the fire gets up to the fire break,
- 24:20they hit it like hell with all their aerial assets.
- 24:23With a system like this, pre -constructed, you
- 24:27could literally have one fireman who opens up
- 24:29a valve and puts a tremendous amount of water
- 24:33on the fire breaks. Next slide, please. Another
- 24:36thing to consider, as was viewed in the Palisades
- 24:40and also in the Eaton Fire, if there was a municipal
- 24:43effort in these, what they call the Wadland Urban
- 24:47Interface areas, where they put these sprinkler
- 24:50systems up on risers, even on top of utility
- 24:53poles, they could, again, they could turn those
- 24:56on and it would wet down the entire community
- 24:58as the fire front approaches and keep those embers
- 25:01from taking the homes and hopscotching all the
- 25:03way through those communities with the loss of
- 25:06life. tremendous damage. Next slide, please.
- 25:11Now I'm hoping that what we are viewing is a
- 25:15change in the ethos in the state of California
- 25:17as far as this goes. This will take a municipal,
- 25:22county, and statewide effort to take these more
- 25:24macro solutions and make those happen. Now, lots
- 25:28of folks are aware of the governor's executive
- 25:30order setting aside CEQA and the Coastal Act
- 25:32to allow people that were destroyed in the Palo
- 25:35Stades and eaten fire from permitting requirements.
- 25:39Not everybody is aware that there was a proclamation
- 25:41of a state of emergency, which is a slightly
- 25:44different animal. As you can see here, it allows
- 25:47Free of CEQA and Free of the Coastal Act, the
- 25:50fire marshal to create a plan for the removal
- 25:53of vegetation for the creation of strategic fuel
- 25:56breaks as identified by approved fire prevention
- 25:59plans. That's CAL FIRE and the local fire marshal.
- 26:03And it also talks about removal of vegetation
- 26:05using cultural traditional ecological knowledge
- 26:08for cultural burning and or prescribed fire treatments.
- 26:12That's a fancy way of saying prescribed burns.
- 26:15And we stopped doing prescribed burns. They're
- 26:17very difficult to get permits for. The AQMD is
- 26:22the one that fights them the most, but it's also
- 26:26political. The last prescribed burn that the
- 26:28fire department I know was approved in 2018 around
- 26:33the community of Big Rock in Malibu and pursuant
- 26:37to the urging of anti -development folks in environmental
- 26:40organizations. The community of Big Rock is now,
- 26:47for all intents and purposes, destroyed. So I
- 26:51think the proof's in the pudding in regards to
- 26:54what we need to do to change our approaches on
- 26:58these things. Next slide, and I'll wrap it up
- 27:01with this. One of the things that I also recommend
- 27:05for our clients is that they, now, this is a
- 27:08ham -handed picture. You see some tanks here.
- 27:11They don't have to be ugly. They don't have to
- 27:13fill up your backyard. They can be subterranean.
- 27:15If you have a pool, this is great. On -site water
- 27:19storage, I think, is very, very important for
- 27:21the survivability of people's homes. And I'm
- 27:23wondering if Michael's going to comment on whether
- 27:25or not this is the type of thing that an insurance
- 27:28carrier could take into account when they are
- 27:31deciding whether or not to insure a home and
- 27:35what it's going to cost a homeowner or a business
- 27:37owner. If you've been paying attention, you know
- 27:40that the hydrants went dry in the Pacific Palisades.
- 27:44You may not have seen much press in regards to
- 27:47the hydrants going dry in parts of Malibu. They
- 27:50usually do. This is something which is sadly
- 27:55ongoing, but if you have on -site water storage
- 27:58and if you have one of those fire suppression
- 28:00systems with the pumps, maybe even a backup generator
- 28:03so that if the municipal system breaks down,
- 28:09that you will have the ability still to protect
- 28:11your home and it can in actuality all be done
- 28:14remotely in computer control. And I'm confident
- 28:17that if there was a lot more of this, we would
- 28:19have whole different scenarios in regards to
- 28:21these inevitable wildfires. So with that, go
- 28:23to the next slide. And I will wrap up my presentation.
- 28:27I don't want to dominate the airwaves. I think
- 28:29it's Michael's turn. And after everybody's done,
- 28:32I will be available for any questions that you
- 28:34may have. Thank you, Don. Wow. If what you're
- 28:41doing today gets boring, Don, we have some risk
- 28:45management jobs that I would love to talk to
- 28:47you about because you really touched upon some
- 28:51amazing things and it's the kind of thing that
- 28:54we're out talking about on a daily basis with
- 28:58clients, with communities, with the centers of
- 29:02influence that we might work with. perhaps for
- 29:07the first time in my career, that message is
- 29:13being heard and people are asking for more information
- 29:16on how do we better protect ourselves, better
- 29:18protect our communities. It's a shame and it's
- 29:22quite sad that it takes an event like the Palisades
- 29:24and Altadena fires to perhaps prompt those questions,
- 29:28but we are where we are and I think it's an important
- 29:31inflection point in our. state's history as to
- 29:35how we're going to address these things. And
- 29:38from my perspective, maintain an insurance market
- 29:42that is affordable for all. You know, if you
- 29:49would have told me that five years ago that I'd
- 29:52be sitting here talking to the Beverly Hills
- 29:55Bar Association about insurance, I would have
- 29:57thought you're crazy. But it's become such a
- 30:00prominent issue. and such an important issue
- 30:04that I'm glad that I've been able to join you
- 30:08today and I thank you for the invite. I'll start
- 30:13with a question. What if I told you that if we
- 30:18don't get a handle on this insurance crisis,
- 30:21it could turn into a financial contagion? we're
- 30:26beyond insurance crisis at this point. We're
- 30:29in a place and time where if this thing starts
- 30:33to spread, and maybe that's not a great word
- 30:35to use, but if it starts to spread, we could
- 30:38have some serious economic issues in the state
- 30:40of California. As mentioned earlier, I've been
- 30:44in a high net worth personal insurance space
- 30:46for 30 years. I spent 27 years on the carrier
- 30:50side of the business with Chubb AIG and Pure.
- 30:54in the past three with Marsh -McClennan agency
- 30:58here in the Western US. And I have never seen
- 31:02a market this bad. And I would suggest that if
- 31:08you have someone that tells you they've seen
- 31:10a market this bad, please introduce them to me.
- 31:13And I'd love to have a conversation with them
- 31:16because we're dealing with some forces that are
- 31:20different than any other. time and place in our
- 31:27history. If you can pull up the slide, I'll hit
- 31:31on a couple of things that I'll plan on talking
- 31:33to you about today. One more slide for it, please.
- 31:37I'm gonna give a market update, talk a little
- 31:40bit about the history of the California Fair
- 31:42Plan, the regulatory environment, and then the
- 31:45admitted versus not admitted insurance. One of
- 31:53the unique things about what we're dealing with
- 31:55is we're dealing with something that quite frankly,
- 31:59a big piece of it started in 1968. In 1968, the
- 32:05California Fair Plan was created as an insurer
- 32:09of last resort. We were coming out of a very
- 32:13difficult time in many ways in inner cities.
- 32:17The Watts Riots had recently taken place. And
- 32:20as a result, people were having a hard time finding
- 32:23insurance. And so a plan was developed and to
- 32:28provide protection to those people who otherwise
- 32:31could not find insurance. You fast forward to
- 32:352020 and there was $150 billion in exposure sitting
- 32:41in the California Fair Plan. When the Palisades
- 32:47Fire and the Altadena Fire started, there was
- 32:49about $500 billion in exposure sitting in the
- 32:54California Fair Plan. And here we are six months,
- 32:57a little over six months later, and there's now
- 32:59$600 billion in exposure in the California Fair
- 33:03Plan. When the Palisades Fire started, the California
- 33:09Fair Plan had less than $400 million in cash
- 33:13on hand to pay claims. I'm not a mathematician,
- 33:18but I can tell you that math doesn't work. And
- 33:21not only does it not work, the retention on their
- 33:24reinsurance was $900 million. So they didn't
- 33:27even have enough cash on hand to meet the retention
- 33:31point on their reinsurance. Now, if you think
- 33:38about what that means, and I wanna talk about
- 33:41something I think is often, misconstrued, the
- 33:44California Fair Plan is not backed by the state
- 33:48of California. And as such, us as taxpayers,
- 33:52it's actually backed by the insurance carriers
- 33:55that write business here in the state of California.
- 33:58So what does that mean? As the California Fair
- 34:01Plan continues to grow, the exposure of the carriers
- 34:05that write business here has grown as well. So
- 34:08in addition to the book of business that they
- 34:10underwrite, and they collect premium for, they
- 34:14now have exposure to this monster that is the
- 34:17California Fair Plan. And because there wasn't
- 34:20enough money to pay the claims associated with
- 34:23the most recent fires, for the second time in
- 34:27our history, an assessment was done for a billion
- 34:32dollars. So any admitted carrier who writes business
- 34:35in California received the bill. In the case
- 34:39of State Farm, and I'll use them because they're
- 34:40the largest provider of homeowners insurance
- 34:42in the state, they received a bill for over $200
- 34:46million. Again, for business that they don't
- 34:49underwrite, they don't have on the books, and
- 34:51they don't collect premium for. So as a result
- 34:54of that, what we've seen is carriers, in some
- 34:58cases, start to exit the state. In other cases,
- 35:02in many cases, we're seeing mass renewals across
- 35:05the state. And it's all to lower their exposure
- 35:12to the California fair plan, knowing that they
- 35:15financially cannot support the exposure that's
- 35:17on their books. It's a difficult place to be
- 35:21in. And I would tell you that I think we probably
- 35:25have another billion dollar assessment that's
- 35:27likely to take place next year as a result of
- 35:29these same fires. And ultimately where this comes
- 35:33back around is Half of that exposure can be put
- 35:39back towards us. Anybody that has a state farm
- 35:44policy can get a surcharge on their policy as
- 35:47a result of what they've had to pay as a result
- 35:50to the California Fair Plan. The next big event
- 35:56that is creating massive issues and perhaps the
- 36:00biggest issue is the passage of Prop 103 in 1988.
- 36:05And it did a few key things. It turned the elected,
- 36:09excuse me, the commissioner of the Department
- 36:11of Insurance became an elected position. All
- 36:17the rate filings had to flow through the department.
- 36:21And any rate filing over a certain percentage,
- 36:25the consumer watchdog could come in, the intervener,
- 36:29consumer watchdog, one in the same, and do a
- 36:32review. And what happens is it then takes forever
- 36:37to get approval on a rate increase. It also costs
- 36:42money because the intervener charges in bills
- 36:44for the hours that they spend reviewing these
- 36:48filings. So historically what carriers have done,
- 36:51the magic number is 7%. If you're below that,
- 36:55it doesn't typically go to an intervener. If
- 36:59you're above that, you're almost rest assured
- 37:01that's what's gonna take place. Interrupt for
- 37:04a second there, Mike. When you say seven percent,
- 37:08seven percent of what? Seven percent rate increase.
- 37:11So if I have a rate and I try to increase it
- 37:15seven percent or more, what happens? Ultimately,
- 37:18that filing that has to go through the state,
- 37:20the third party will come in and they want to
- 37:22take a look at that same file. So it's another
- 37:25layer in the process that creates time delays.
- 37:29These things are supposed to be approved in 180
- 37:31days and I've seen them go as long as two years.
- 37:35Thank you. Yeah, no problem. So what that does
- 37:39is it creates another inflection point for the
- 37:42carriers is, okay, we take 6 .9, we take 6 .9,
- 37:46but if our need is 40%, I can't take that. And
- 37:50the game of catch -up has just gotten too, the
- 37:55Delta is too large to close the gap. So now in
- 37:59addition to the exposure to the California fair
- 38:01plan, the business that they have on the books
- 38:04is underinsured, is underpriced. And so you have
- 38:13massive... portfolios of business that need need
- 38:17more rate. The easiest way I can say it is let's
- 38:19say I'm selling something or building something
- 38:22for 90 cents. I'm selling it for $1. 10 % margin.
- 38:27That's a fantastic year for an insurance carrier.
- 38:30My rates go up as a result of losses that have
- 38:34happened. I mean, there's any number of factors,
- 38:38but if the rates go up. And now it cost me $1
- 38:43.30. to build my product and I'm being forced
- 38:47by the Department of Insurance to sell it for
- 38:50a dollar. Again, the math doesn't work. You see
- 38:54carriers leave the state. You see more mass renewal,
- 38:57non -renewals. And it creates a logjam as to
- 39:03where do we consumers in the state of California
- 39:06find our insurance. The other thing that I would
- 39:14include in this is up until recently, we were
- 39:17the only carrier, excuse me, the only state that
- 39:20didn't allow reinsurance to be a factor into
- 39:24rate making for carriers. Now those rates in
- 39:272023 went up between 30 and 50%. So many of you
- 39:31may know that carriers don't keep all the exposure
- 39:34they have in any one place on their books. It's
- 39:39insurance for insurance. Those costs went up
- 39:4130 % or more, but they're not allowed to build
- 39:44that into their rate making. It's a no win proposition
- 39:47for carriers if you're gonna limit how much they
- 39:51can charge for the products that they sell here.
- 39:58So that leads to the fourth bullet point here
- 40:01is, historically I would suggest that 95 % of
- 40:06the California homeowners market was insured
- 40:09with an admitted carrier. The admitted carriers
- 40:12are those carriers who have to file their rates
- 40:14with the Department of Insurance for review.
- 40:18They're filing their policy coverage language.
- 40:20They're filing their underwriting appetite. The
- 40:26other option is the non -admitted option. And
- 40:29I would tell you today that probably 80 to 85
- 40:33% of what we are doing is in the non -admitted
- 40:37market. The rates don't need to be filed with
- 40:40the state. There's a heck of a lot more flexibility
- 40:43and not just price, but in coverage limits. And
- 40:48so carriers can limit their exposure and charge
- 40:51what they feel is necessary to charge for an
- 40:56exposure. I gave you one example and it's mine.
- 40:59I live in an area where I am exposed to some
- 41:03native brush that can't be cleared. It's not
- 41:06private property. state property. I was insured
- 41:11with a carrier paying $5 ,000 a year for my homeowners
- 41:14insurance. They filed a 49 % rate increase, let's
- 41:19just say 50 % rate increase. So my insurance
- 41:23would have gone up to $7 ,500. Sounds like a
- 41:27lot, 50%, holy mackerel. They didn't get it approved.
- 41:32They left the state and the two best options
- 41:34I was able to find And I've been doing this for
- 41:37a long time with a lot of friends in the industry,
- 41:39but the two best options I was able to find,
- 41:42$25 ,000. So instead of going up 50%, it went
- 41:46up five times. And we're seeing numbers well
- 41:49beyond that in places like Beverly Hills, because
- 41:53the numbers instead of five to 25 are 50 to 400
- 42:00or $500 ,000 a year for some of these homes.
- 42:08So we're stuck at a point where, what's gonna
- 42:15happen next? Well, the insurance commissioner's
- 42:19term is up in 26. Personally, I don't think we
- 42:25can wait that long, but to me, it seems like
- 42:29we're slow playing the results. The fact of the
- 42:32matter is that all of us, have to pay more for
- 42:35our insurance in California. And I'm not talking
- 42:37those of us that have gone from an admitted product
- 42:40to a non -admitted product. I'm talking about
- 42:43the general market, the admitted market. We have
- 42:46to allow rate to flow through that market. And
- 42:50if we do, it will bring back options, which brings
- 42:54back competition, which brings back the choice
- 42:58that we need when we're making a buying decision.
- 43:01on where we're going to go. It is not uncommon
- 43:03today to have situations where we only have one
- 43:10option for a client. And that's it. And it's
- 43:13not a pretty option. And we're giving you something
- 43:15that has got less coverage for a lot more money.
- 43:20And it's a difficult conversation to have, as
- 43:22you might imagine. It's not fun. But I would
- 43:26suggest to you that that if you have clients
- 43:28that are falling into this kind of situation
- 43:30or if you yourself are falling into this situation
- 43:32Please connect them with a good broker who can
- 43:36walk them through this process Havoc has access
- 43:39to markets And make them aware of what's going
- 43:43on because ultimately it's going to come back
- 43:45to we as homeowners We as communities to do it
- 43:50on doing a lot of the things that Don was speaking
- 43:52to hardening our homes, hardening our communities.
- 43:57Unfortunately, a lot of that responsibility is
- 43:59gonna fall on us and that's just where we are.
- 44:06You know, the fact that this part of the issue
- 44:10dates back upwards of 57 years is pretty amazing
- 44:16thing. And it's also... perhaps more amazing
- 44:20that we couldn't see this coming. I can tell
- 44:22you for one, anybody that was paying attention
- 44:24could see what was happening to the market starting
- 44:28back in 2017 with the Woolsey fire. And then
- 44:32going forward when inflation kicked in in 22,
- 44:36reinsurance rates went up in 23. The regulatory
- 44:41market and what was happening there. the writing
- 44:45was on the wall and it was like the perfect storm.
- 44:47And the market has since fallen apart and it's
- 44:51gonna take some time to get back to any sense
- 44:53of normalcy. And the last thing I'll point out
- 45:00and this is where we're gonna get into this whole
- 45:02financial contagion thing and I don't wanna scare
- 45:04anybody, but California homeowners have about
- 45:07$2 trillion in equity in their homes. And if
- 45:11all of a sudden, They can't sell their house
- 45:14because the cost of insurance or because they
- 45:21can't find insurance. Now we're impacting the
- 45:24real estate market. We start to see some pressure
- 45:27on values and we're seeing that already. It starts
- 45:31to impact a lot of different aspects of our economy.
- 45:35Builders, I can go down the list, but that's
- 45:39where it gets a little scary. Again, it's a lot
- 45:43of information to share with you in 15 minutes,
- 45:47but I'd be happy to answer any questions you
- 45:52may have about this topic or anything else associated
- 45:57with the insurance piece of this. Thank you,
- 46:01Mike. If I may raise a question, we've gotten
- 46:06a very good perspective from Don from the planning
- 46:11background that he has and you're getting a background
- 46:14from your insurance situation. How, if at all,
- 46:21do the fire maps and their extension or non -extension
- 46:25to high severity or low severity impact or have
- 46:31an effect on insurance? Are these two different
- 46:33tracks that are irrelevant to each other. Among
- 46:37our materials, we provided the statement of the
- 46:40insurance commissioner about the new fire hazard
- 46:42maps. But do those fire hazard maps really have
- 46:46an impact on how the insurance companies assess
- 46:50their risks and decide what to charge? Yeah,
- 46:53it's a great question. And what I would tell
- 46:58you is they are a factor. they are not the only
- 47:03factor. And I point back to the fact that carriers
- 47:07already, their actuarial data is telling them
- 47:10that their books of business are already under
- 47:13priced in California. So they need rate there.
- 47:17But the second part of that is there was a carrier
- 47:21that I won't name that at the time of the Woolsey
- 47:26fire, In 90210, they had $15 billion worth of
- 47:31exposure. The only way they found that out was
- 47:35because that fire was ripping from Thousand Oaks
- 47:37over to Malibu. The maps that carriers are using
- 47:44today internally are better in that they can
- 47:47get down to street level mapping to know what
- 47:51their exposure is. These carriers have hundreds,
- 47:54thousands of underwriters and it's very easy
- 47:56for The underwriter over on in this cubicle to
- 48:00say yes to a large account in Beverly Hills,
- 48:02the one over here saying yes to another account
- 48:05that happens to be the neighbor and not know
- 48:07what that's doing as you're going down the block.
- 48:09And next thing you know, you got a billion dollars
- 48:11in exposure and houses and art and cars and jewelry
- 48:15and things of that nature. So aggregates and
- 48:18exposure plays a role and mapping certainly has
- 48:22a role in that as well. If I understand it correctly,
- 48:26the insurance companies have their own way of
- 48:28doing it, and it can be a house -to -house thing.
- 48:33Absolutely. We have an example in the handout.
- 48:37I guess it's number two of that. People want
- 48:41to look at that of an all -state insurance, looking
- 48:45at particular characteristics of a property.
- 48:49It seems to me, if I understand it correctly
- 48:52and I'm listening to both, Don and Mike on this,
- 48:55you're both saying that we need to spend more
- 48:57money on stuff we're not spending money on. Don,
- 49:00is that right? We're just not doing enough to
- 49:03protect ourselves? And Mike, we're not paying
- 49:06enough for insurance. Well, if I could address
- 49:11it first, yes, we're not doing enough. Folks
- 49:14ought to be more proactive in regards to hardening
- 49:18their homes. Look, it's easy for us to pontificate,
- 49:22right? Some folks, they're worried about putting
- 49:27groceries on the table and paying their taxes.
- 49:31And so we tend to think about these areas as
- 49:34being very affluent because that makes the news
- 49:37a lot. Pacific Palisades, Malibu, of course,
- 49:41over and over. This is the Beverly Hills Bar
- 49:44Association meeting. But I think the Eden Altadena
- 49:48Fire really was somewhat jarring, much more of
- 49:52a middle class neighborhood. The biggest loss
- 49:55of life in California from a wildfire was the
- 49:59Paradise Fire, where something like 88 people
- 50:03perished. The city fathers thought it would be
- 50:06a great idea to have traffic calming and created
- 50:11a choke point for people to evacuate. And they
- 50:15were emulated. So they're trying to rebuild that
- 50:18community. But these are not affluent areas.
- 50:20But look, here's the harsh reality. We live in
- 50:24earthquake country. We are requiring certain
- 50:27commercial property owners to engage in seismic
- 50:31retrofitting and upgrades. Otherwise, those buildings
- 50:34are going to kill a lot of people in the next
- 50:37earthquake. And I think the fires are getting
- 50:41right up there with them as it pertains to the
- 50:45potential loss of life and damage to property.
- 50:51So even though I'm an ardent property rights
- 50:55advocate and libertarian, I shave over too much
- 50:58government regulation. We have way too much in
- 51:01California. That being said, I think that there
- 51:03needs to be a concerted effort to identify these
- 51:07areas and see what can be done to proactively
- 51:10educate people. Malibu is doing that. They have
- 51:14two or three specials which go out to these neighborhoods
- 51:16and tell people, look, you really ought not to
- 51:19have that pine tree right there next to the house.
- 51:22And you shouldn't have firewood stacked up here
- 51:25next to the side. You need to box in that deck
- 51:27and get on top of your brush clearance, put the
- 51:30vents screen and get that done. But also on the
- 51:34macro scale, we need to invest in this and especially
- 51:38in the wildland urban interface areas. We need
- 51:41to do those fire breaks. We need to pre -position
- 51:45water. We need to do those prescribed burns.
- 51:49I think that that's something that's going to
- 51:51take a lot of leadership from our elected officials.
- 51:55Yeah. If I understand it quickly, you think we
- 51:59need to pay more for insurance, but we could
- 52:02achieve something less than the things we're
- 52:06getting now if we had a better regulatory environment?
- 52:10Is that right? I think it brings, it takes away
- 52:14the extremes. Okay. So instead of having to go
- 52:18from $5 ,000 to $25 ,000, the rate is 7 ,500.
- 52:23I'm just making those numbers up at $7 ,500 because
- 52:26the home has been hard in the right way. I've
- 52:29done everything that I can possibly do to better
- 52:31protect my house. It's going to cost me to do
- 52:34that, but it's better than paying $25 ,000 every
- 52:37year for my homeowners renewal. And so until
- 52:40we get to a place where we start to recognize
- 52:42that these are the things that we can do, and
- 52:45I agree 100 % with Don, it's not just us as individuals,
- 52:49but from a government standpoint, to allow some
- 52:52of this to happen is an absolute must. The scary
- 52:56part to me is, for the longest time in my career,
- 53:01California conversations were all about earthquake.
- 53:04We talked about earthquake very little anymore.
- 53:06It is all wildfire and that's what reinsurers
- 53:10are looking at. That's what the industry is looking
- 53:12at because they have had such a massive impact
- 53:15over the last handful of years. And so we're,
- 53:18yeah, we're all gonna have to play a part. I
- 53:22share with you one story if I could. after the
- 53:25Woolsey fire, we went out into some communities
- 53:27and tried to have some conversations with different
- 53:31associations. And we're in one of them, and there
- 53:34was a lady in there who was an ardent, we need
- 53:38to do this as a community, we need to do this
- 53:39community. When we got to her house, she had
- 53:41these massive Italian Cypress, which if you've
- 53:45ever seen an Italian Cypress burn, it is like
- 53:48a Roman candle. And when we said they should
- 53:51come down, she's like, no, I like it, right?
- 53:53these privacy, I said, I can't take these down.
- 53:57So there's a psychological element to this, too,
- 54:00that we have to recognize and make sure that
- 54:05we're playing our part. There's a question from
- 54:09Elizabeth Rafidi for you, Mike. which is in light
- 54:14of the fires and the expected outlies by the
- 54:17insurance companies, not to mention potential
- 54:21lawsuits against insurers and government agencies.
- 54:23You know, this is California, the United States,
- 54:25we generally sue everybody anytime we can think
- 54:28of it. Do you see any hope for addressing your
- 54:31concerns on a governmental level? The last part
- 54:35broke up a little bit. Do you see any hope for
- 54:37addressing your concerns at the governmental
- 54:39level? Well, I would tell you that there's a
- 54:44lot of lobbying going on. I think that the challenge
- 54:48we have is I think there's individuals that understand
- 54:51it. And so the association that represents independent
- 54:56agents and brokers across the state was lobbying
- 54:59on their own behalf. And then they joined hands
- 55:01with the Contractors Association and the Builders
- 55:05Association and the Wine Makers Associations.
- 55:07And they've come together as one voice. to put
- 55:10some pressure on our legislators to address this
- 55:16issue and to recognize that this isn't something
- 55:18that's going away. And until we do such thing,
- 55:22we're going to be stuck. Because the point about
- 55:26people not living in Beverly Hills who are on
- 55:29a fixed income, they're the ones that are impacted
- 55:32the most. Someone living in Beverly Hills, yeah,
- 55:35their rate's going to go up. In many cases, they
- 55:37can afford it. They might not like it. But they
- 55:39can afford it. But if I'm going to fix budget
- 55:41and all of a sudden, the rates go up to where
- 55:45now you're talking about a whole different decision
- 55:48you have to make. Unfortunately, with the Palisades
- 55:50fire, probably true in Altadena, some of those
- 55:54people whose home had been handed down from grandma
- 55:56and grandpa to mom and dad to now the children,
- 56:02they just said, the heck with it. I'm not going
- 56:04to insure it. I'm going to roll the dice. It's
- 56:06too expensive. And now they've lost. all that
- 56:09equity in that house because they were forced
- 56:12into making a decision that impacted them in
- 56:18the way that it ultimately did. There's some
- 56:20really sad stories as you might imagine around.
- 56:22I've been hearing some of them. We have a question
- 56:24from Martin Murphy and another one from Howard
- 56:27Gould who happens to be the co -chair of the
- 56:29real property section. They deal with economics.
- 56:35Mr. Murphy is asking really a question. It's
- 56:38more of an economic thing for Don in terms of
- 56:41practical questions. How do you make a decision
- 56:47about what cost real? He's asking whether I could
- 56:50buy thicker glass and that would be X dollars
- 56:53more expensive. He says 60 ,000 for one. He's
- 56:58thinking of a 2 ,000 square foot house. rather
- 57:02than other glass, how do you make that economic
- 57:04decision of how much I'm going to put into this?
- 57:07And Howard Gould, who's the chair of this section,
- 57:10is saying, how about, Don, you mentioned sprinklers
- 57:13along ridge lines and elsewhere. Don, Howard
- 57:16is asking, how about putting sprinklers on top
- 57:19of your house? Does that make sense? Yes, it
- 57:22does. Let's start with the glass, first of all.
- 57:24The default, of course, is the fire codes that
- 57:29have been adopted for home hardening to get a
- 57:33permit in these designated areas. And that is
- 57:37the dual pane glass. And that is not something
- 57:42which is negotiable. You will do that. And so
- 57:47it's really not, can I afford it? If you are
- 57:50rebuilding your house, that is what you need
- 57:53to do. Now I've read the question and there are
- 57:56other alternatives for thicker single pane tempered
- 57:59glass. I do have some clients where we are, they
- 58:03wanna go that route, especially with very large.
- 58:07picture windows because you get less distortion,
- 58:10but it's very expensive. And I'm now in the process,
- 58:13my building and safety group, of negotiating
- 58:15with the building departments and the fire department
- 58:18to see if that will pass muster as far as that
- 58:20goes. So that's an economic decision, which is
- 58:25personal, and somebody can decide what it is
- 58:27that they want to do. But if they're rebuilding
- 58:30a home in one of these designated fire zones,
- 58:35they are going to have to do the pain glass and
- 58:37they work. They definitely work. I've seen it
- 58:40firsthand many times. The outer pain can crack
- 58:44from the radiant heat, but the inner pain survives
- 58:49and that prevents the penetration of the embers
- 58:52into the house, which is even a very stout home
- 58:56or business can be lost. I've seen that happen
- 59:00many a time. In regards to the sprinklers, look,
- 59:05we're all doing what we can, right? And so an
- 59:08individual property owner or anybody's clients,
- 59:11they can't really sit back and say, city of,
- 59:15county of, get your butt up there and start doing
- 59:18the fire breaks and put big ag sprinklers on.
- 59:22Oh, they could and they should. They should lobby
- 59:24their local elected officials to do that. But
- 59:27you have to start at home. And that's something
- 59:30that you can control. Now, be advised, when we're
- 59:34talking about these fire suppression systems
- 59:36for an individual building, the fire department
- 59:39and the forestry divisions which handle the brush
- 59:42clearance will not allow you to do that in lieu
- 59:46of the proper fuel management. Okay, but they
- 59:50will allow you to do it and that's something
- 59:52you can control your own destiny on. So if you
- 59:56do the fire hardening of the structure, maintain
- 59:58the fuel management reduction and put one of
- 1:00:02these systems on your house, you're going to
- 1:00:04be in an exponentially better position as it
- 1:00:07pertains to survivability. I have a question
- 1:00:10and that is I can drive around the West Side.
- 1:00:13I can look at the Beverly Hills fire hazard map
- 1:00:16and I can say, wow, I've been right near the
- 1:00:18Beverly Hills Hotel. I've been in that we now
- 1:00:23see very severe fire hazard area. I don't see
- 1:00:26any 100 foot clearances around those houses up
- 1:00:30there. I see a lot of really nice tasty vegetation
- 1:00:35for a fire. How is it that we can have all these
- 1:00:38restrictions and still have such dense foliage
- 1:00:42and close together housing in that area? Changing
- 1:00:45rules, lack of proactive enforcement. Now, in
- 1:00:51other areas that people traditionally think of,
- 1:00:54say if you had a house up in the Hollywood Hills
- 1:00:56and Santa Monica Mountains and somebody's got
- 1:00:58a large parcel, an acre larger, and they're plucking
- 1:01:00a house down in the Chaparral, it's... it's readily
- 1:01:05transparent in regards to getting that 200 foot
- 1:01:08of brush clearance around it. And if they don't
- 1:01:11have it, then another arm of the government called
- 1:01:13the Weed Abatement District, they come out and
- 1:01:16they will take a look at it. The fire department
- 1:01:19will make sure for the brush clearance on your
- 1:01:21subject property that you are maintaining it
- 1:01:23as you are supposed to. And if the radius of
- 1:01:26your brush clearance goes onto a neighbor's property,
- 1:01:29they will send a notice to that neighbor. They're
- 1:01:32actually obliged to clear the Haster's brush
- 1:01:35off of their property to maintain the 200 -foot
- 1:01:38radius around your home. And if they don't do
- 1:01:42it, they will send out a crew that charges you
- 1:01:45by the square foot. I swear, I think it's a team
- 1:01:47of attorneys with weed -whackers because it's
- 1:01:49really expensive. And they will clear it on your
- 1:01:52property and they will put it on your tax bill.
- 1:01:55Now, when you get these urban areas, it's much
- 1:01:58more complicated. You have sometimes very affluent
- 1:02:01people that are very fond of their cypress trees.
- 1:02:03And Michael, I can tell you I've watched film
- 1:02:05clips of homes being lost because of cypress
- 1:02:08trees and things of that nature. And it gets
- 1:02:11real complicated when not only on the existing
- 1:02:15home where the government comes in and say, let's
- 1:02:19cut down those trees. Pull the bushes back five
- 1:02:22feet from the house, but also it's going to the
- 1:02:24neighbor and saying you got to do some major
- 1:02:27clearance of your very expensive landscape that
- 1:02:29you've invested in over the last 20 years. It
- 1:02:32gets very complicated. It can get very litigious,
- 1:02:36and therein lies the answer on why we have not
- 1:02:40proactively address this problem in these urban
- 1:02:43wildland interface areas. Well, it sounds like
- 1:02:46a good answer to give to. group of lawyers that
- 1:02:49they might need to get involved and deal with
- 1:02:53people like Don and help people deal with Mike.
- 1:02:56I think, Joe, we have achieved our hour and a
- 1:02:59little bit over and maybe we should turn it over
- 1:03:01to you. I just want to add one thing that within
- 1:03:05the last 10 days, there was a trial level decision
- 1:03:08in a case which supports what Mike said about
- 1:03:14the surcharge. It was an attempt to have a judge
- 1:03:21decide, and the judge did decide that it was
- 1:03:24lawful for the insurance companies as a group
- 1:03:28to pass through in their upcoming policies, two
- 1:03:32policyholders, 50 % of what their losses were.
- 1:03:37And there was testimony that, talking about it,
- 1:03:40a billion dollars of losses, that means $500
- 1:03:42million have to be pass through in the upcoming
- 1:03:46period. That's a lot of money. Well, thank you,
- 1:03:52everybody, for being with us. And we really,
- 1:03:57I think, have learned an awful lot about the
- 1:04:00challenges that we face. They're not going to
- 1:04:03be decided quickly. And I do think that something
- 1:04:08has to be done governmentally. And just who's
- 1:04:12got the ability to effectuate that, I don't know.
- 1:04:16But thank you, Don. Thank you, Mike. And Larry,
- 1:04:20let's, I think, close up. Was there any other
- 1:04:24question that you thought we should answer? No,
- 1:04:26there's only one quick thing. I've noticed that
- 1:04:28this is not the only state with terrible insurance
- 1:04:31problems. I'm told that for completely different
- 1:04:34reasons, Florida has the worst insurance market
- 1:04:38in the country. We don't have their hurricanes.
- 1:04:41We don't have their tornadoes. We don't quite
- 1:04:45have this much torrential rain. So I wonder to
- 1:04:48the extent we can learn something from other
- 1:04:50places that have to deal with this. It could
- 1:04:51be interesting. I'm not sure the answer is always
- 1:04:54in the California legislature. Texas is a big
- 1:04:57problem. A number of Western states because of
- 1:05:00brush exposure. Yeah, this isn't just a California
- 1:05:03thing. California happens to be one of the nastiest.
- 1:05:07Yeah, okay, this has been fun. Thank you everybody.
- 1:05:10Thank you all