Latest / Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques / 278. How Do You Mean? It’s Not What You Say, It’s How You Say It
Transcript
- 0:03Matt Abrahams: Your tone is your trademark.
- 0:05It's not just what you say and how you say it, it's the tone in which you deliver it.
- 0:10My name is Matt Abrahams, and I teach Strategic Communication at
- 0:13Stanford Graduate School of Business.
- 0:15Welcome to Think Fast Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 0:19Today, I look forward to speaking with Jefferson Fisher.
- 0:22Jefferson is a Texas Board certified trial attorney and
- 0:25the founder of the Fisher Firm.
- 0:27Jefferson teaches people how to navigate high stakes conversations by prioritizing
- 0:31connection and clarity over winning.
- 0:34As a compliment to his New York Times bestselling book, The Next
- 0:38Conversation, he's now releasing The Next Conversation Workbook to further
- 0:42help people apply his principles.
- 0:44Welcome Jefferson.
- 0:45I am really excited for this conversation.
- 0:48It's rare that I get a chance to geek out with somebody on all things
- 0:51communication, so thanks for being here.
- 0:53Jefferson Fisher: Absolutely.
- 0:54Thanks for having me.
- 0:55I mean, come on a conversation about conversations.
- 0:57Let's go.
- 0:58Matt Abrahams: So shall we get started?
- 0:59Jefferson Fisher: Yeah, let's do it.
- 1:00Matt Abrahams: Alright.
- 1:00So you're a trial lawyer by training, yet you've famously said that we
- 1:05should stop trying to win arguments.
- 1:08What's the approach we should take instead and why?
- 1:12Jefferson Fisher: As soon as you try to start winning arguments, you're losing.
- 1:15People think that in litigation, in the trial world, that's all
- 1:18you do is win arguments, but that's really not what you do.
- 1:22You only have so much limited information to go off of, and so a
- 1:25lot of the times what you're left with is saying, okay, instead of trying to
- 1:29win an argument, what can I do, what I say is arguments are not something
- 1:33to win, they're something to unravel.
- 1:36It's like a line, a piece of thread, or a water hose.
- 1:38You get knots in it, you get kinks in it, and the better and more efficient
- 1:42you get, the faster you get at identifying and undoing the knot, the
- 1:46better the conversation's going to be.
- 1:48So instead of having to win, it's this mentality of having something to learn.
- 1:52So I say, rather than having something to prove, have something to learn.
- 1:56Matt Abrahams: So it has to do with the overall approach, right?
- 1:58Take this approach of learning, and it's not a competition, it's more about
- 2:01connection and really understanding the other person's perspective.
- 2:05Is that a fair way to characterize it?
- 2:07Jefferson Fisher: Yeah.
- 2:07I mean, who wants to be around the person who always has to be right?
- 2:10The person who always has to have the last word, the person who is just
- 2:13the brick wall that can never hear another person's opinion, who wants
- 2:18to live in their own echo chamber.
- 2:20It does not build anything.
- 2:22It only decreases everything.
- 2:24That the only thing you've won with that kind of person is contempt.
- 2:27You've won resentment.
- 2:29You've won awkward silence.
- 2:31There's nothing good that comes from winning an argument.
- 2:34Matt Abrahams: So how best does one approach a conversation to learn?
- 2:38Is it inquiry through questions?
- 2:40Is it storytelling?
- 2:42How can we actually execute on that idea?
- 2:45Jefferson Fisher: Yeah, you ask more and talk less.
- 2:48A lot of the times it's using clarifying questions to be able to probe and to get
- 2:53somebody else to share their perspective.
- 2:55It's setting the standard at not winning, not setting the standard at
- 2:59changing their mind, setting the standard to understanding their perspective.
- 3:05Matt Abrahams: And there's a big distinction between
- 3:06understanding and agreeing, right?
- 3:08We listen for understanding, and that allows us to then begin
- 3:12to foster that communication to perhaps move towards agreement.
- 3:16I particularly like asking open questions, help me understand why,
- 3:21what's going on for you there?
- 3:23Do you have specific questions you like to lean into to help with that understanding?
- 3:27Jefferson Fisher: Depends on the context.
- 3:29If I can tell I'm in a conversation that seems to be getting friction and
- 3:33I can tell that the other person is starting to get frustrated and things
- 3:37are starting to get bogged down, I'll usually ask, what's coming up for you?
- 3:42It's a way of making sure that I'm communicating in that moment
- 3:46that I can tell something else is bubbling up underneath.
- 3:48That something is happening deeper than what's on the surface, and I've
- 3:52always got an answer back from it.
- 3:54It's far better than what's wrong with you, but if I say, what's coming
- 3:57up for you that's indicating, hey, I can see something rising within
- 4:01you that's causing friction here, so why don't we talk about it?
- 4:04But the key here is not to use questions that begin with why.
- 4:09Why it's a lot more accusatory.
- 4:12Matt Abrahams: Absolutely.
- 4:13Why questions can really put somebody on the spot.
- 4:16And I like your idea of what's bubbling up for you.
- 4:18It strikes me that what you're doing in those moments though, is you're
- 4:21really observing, not only the communication, but how it's being said.
- 4:27So a lot of us struggle with taking that step back to be monitoring the
- 4:32communication that's going on while we're in the midst of having the communication.
- 4:36You know, those of us who study this talk about meta awareness, the awareness of
- 4:40our communication as we're having it.
- 4:42Are there certain cues and clues that you look for?
- 4:45Is it faster speaking, more emotional language?
- 4:49What are some of the things that you're looking for to show that there's some
- 4:52tension building up, some friction?
- 4:54Jefferson Fisher: I pay attention to pace a lot.
- 4:56How fast are they pushing the conversation?
- 4:59Faster they push it, the more they typically want it over with.
- 5:02You know, if I can pause, have that kind of, what's coming up for you?
- 5:06What am I missing?
- 5:07How's that hitting you?
- 5:08These open-ended questions that breed space, because sometimes that's
- 5:12what I'm most trying to pick up on.
- 5:15What's the rhythm of the conversation?
- 5:17That's what I'm looking for and that tends to tell me if the person I'm talking
- 5:22to is, are we in the pocket together?
- 5:25Are we connecting, or are we on different frequencies?
- 5:28Like they're on FM and I'm still on AM.
- 5:30There's no way we're gonna be able to reach each other, we're
- 5:32not gonna connect, you know?
- 5:34Matt Abrahams: Yeah.
- 5:34I really like the idea of pace, because you're talking about it,
- 5:37I think, at two different levels.
- 5:39There's the pace at which somebody is speaking, speaking quickly,
- 5:42but then there's the pace of pushing the content forward.
- 5:45There's, as you said, a rhythm to communication and conversation, and
- 5:49you can feel when somebody's really trying to drive and push it forward.
- 5:53And both levels, both types of pace, I think are insightful to see if
- 5:58the person is agitated, concerned if there's friction building up.
- 6:01So you need to be cognizant and focusing on that as well as just being
- 6:05engaged in the communication itself.
- 6:08You know, I've read that you have a mantra you like to say, observe, don't absorb.
- 6:12Many of our listeners have a tendency, especially when constructive feedback
- 6:18is sent their way, to really feel it, to take it on and perhaps get defensive.
- 6:23What advice and guidance do you have to help us really be present and observe
- 6:28without absorbing something and perhaps reacting too soon or too negatively?
- 6:33Jefferson Fisher: What I mean is you get to watch a conversation happen without
- 6:37absorbing all of it and deciding that, well, what they say is just who I am.
- 6:41So if you were to have the mindset of there is something for me
- 6:45here if I'm willing to listen, then things tend to go better.
- 6:49I know that when you get feedback from somebody, they say, don't
- 6:54take criticism from somebody you wouldn't take advice from.
- 6:57It's a balance between hearing what they say and knowing are they meaning it for
- 7:01your good or ultimately for your peril.
- 7:04Are they wanting to actually try and build you up?
- 7:07Is it something that you just feel sensitive about?
- 7:09Did they hit something on a nerve or are you actually interested
- 7:13in trying to build on with it?
- 7:15So it's, it's all contextual.
- 7:17Matt Abrahams: I really like everything you said, but the thing
- 7:20that really stood out to me was there's something to learn here.
- 7:23And when you look for the learning, especially if it's coming from a source
- 7:27you respect, it can be very helpful.
- 7:29And that can help take away perhaps some of the initial defensiveness that
- 7:32one feels, and approaching it from a place of gratitude and expressing
- 7:37your gratitude and saying thanks can really help with some of that.
- 7:40I wanna move to a different topic.
- 7:43Often our meetings and conversations can go off the rails.
- 7:46They don't go the way we expected.
- 7:48You have a framework you call one frame, one issue.
- 7:52How can we set appropriate conversational frames at the beginning, or even before
- 7:57we begin the conversation, so that we can manage this and keep it on track in a
- 8:03way that we want, so we don't have scope creep or anxiety that comes from that?
- 8:07Jefferson Fisher: I cannot stand meetings where you get in, they go, okay,
- 8:11everybody, we have a lot to cover today.
- 8:13You never get outta it feeling like you covered really anything.
- 8:16You know, because you're too spread thin rather than going deep on a few issues.
- 8:20It's applying that same kind of idea, when you talk about everything, you
- 8:24talk about nothing at the same time.
- 8:25So what does a frame do?
- 8:27Like a picture, it enhances what's in it.
- 8:30If I can put a frame around the conversation, it does two things.
- 8:33One, it enhances the conversation, it highlights it, it makes it very clear.
- 8:38Second, what it does is it gets rid of all the anxiety of the stuff that you
- 8:42might think we're gonna be talking about.
- 8:44So if I text you and I say, we need to talk, and nobody gets that
- 8:48text and goes, oh, high five, yes.
- 8:51I can't wait.
- 8:52Do you see that they need to talk?
- 8:53It's always terrible, that feeling.
- 8:55Why?
- 8:55Because you have all that anxiety about what are we gonna talk about.
- 8:59Well, you can remove that anxiety by using a frame, and I really have it
- 9:03in three steps is, one, that I tell somebody what I want to talk about.
- 9:06Give them the gift of telling them what you want to talk about.
- 9:10Don't make them have to ask, tell them the topic, the subject, whatever it is.
- 9:13Number two, tell them how you want the conversation to end.
- 9:18What's the checkered flag?
- 9:19Where are you going?
- 9:20What I like to use is, what I want to take away from, what do I want
- 9:23to walk away from the conversation.
- 9:25And the three I get their buy-in into it.
- 9:27That's as simple as, sound good?
- 9:29Does that work?
- 9:30Can we do that?
- 9:31'cause once you get that little nod of, yeah, I'll talk to you about that.
- 9:35It's like an implicit contract.
- 9:37They now are bought into what I committed to talking to this about you.
- 9:41Now they know I don't talk about anything else.
- 9:43There's no other collateral issues.
- 9:44You have a straight path A to B. I know exactly what we're gonna talk about.
- 9:47So it's a way of removing the difficult from difficult conversations,
- 9:52and now it's just talking.
- 9:53Matt Abrahams: It sets expectations, certainly, and it sets your
- 9:57vision of what success looks like, and that can be helpful.
- 10:00It does require that your conversation partner or partners go along with it and
- 10:05have the same ability to focus as you do.
- 10:07I wanna flip to talking about digital communication.
- 10:11You like me, have a digital presence in your communication and you distinguish
- 10:15between transmission and connection.
- 10:17I think many people today, especially in the world of social media and digital
- 10:21communication, confuse sending a message with actually communicating a message.
- 10:27How does transmission fail us and how can we create or increase the connective
- 10:33nature of our communication, especially in a world where most of our communication
- 10:39is intermediated by some technology?
- 10:41Jefferson Fisher: Technology has allowed us to communicate
- 10:44with people all over the world.
- 10:46People you and I would never come in contact with our entire life.
- 10:49And so it is pivotal and it's crucial to still have that technology.
- 10:53What I would want to see is the ability to increase the mediums.
- 10:57So if it's something that somebody really matters to you, it's not just
- 11:01communicating digitally on a text or an email, it's to see them in person.
- 11:06It's to make a phone call.
- 11:07It's to write a letter.
- 11:08Like, diversify communication mediums.
- 11:12It provides a different touchpoint in a way that's not gonna be like anything
- 11:16anybody else can do that's unique to you.
- 11:19My handwriting's different than your handwriting, but yet you
- 11:21can see my personality in the handwriting, same as yours.
- 11:24And I know that if you want to increase what's good about digital
- 11:28communication is using it to aid and support rather than using it to detract.
- 11:33Matt Abrahams: So the take home message there is if it's
- 11:35significant and important reach out.
- 11:38I like your notion of diversify your channels of communication.
- 11:41I think there's a lot of pressure to be efficient and
- 11:44that efficiency gets in the way.
- 11:46Your tone is your trademark.
- 11:48I think that's a very powerful statement that you make.
- 11:52And I agree.
- 11:53Many of us though, are unaware of the tone of our messages.
- 11:56We are so fixated on what we're saying and are we saying it appropriately?
- 11:59And did I use the right words?
- 12:01How can you audit your tone to be aware of how you're coming across?
- 12:07Jefferson Fisher: Well, you can say from the practical side, you
- 12:09record it and you listen to it.
- 12:10You get comfortable with hearing it.
- 12:12Many of us are not used to that.
- 12:14And we'll hear our voice for the first time and we'll be like,
- 12:16is that how I really sound?
- 12:17So you could practically record it, try to improve it as you want.
- 12:21You could take coaching, so you have ways you wanna do that.
- 12:24I like to apply my tone to or compare it to music.
- 12:29So you think about like what band would match your style of communication.
- 12:35There are times like if I want you to listen to me and to slow down, and
- 12:39if I want to make you uncomfortable, I'm not going to blast AC/DC.
- 12:45Or I'm not gonna blast Eminem.
- 12:48Like I'm not going to do that if I want you to be comfortable
- 12:52and ugh, lower your shoulders.
- 12:54What, I'm gonna put on some easy listening, I'm gonna put on some singer
- 12:58songwriter James Taylor type stuff.
- 13:01And so that's the kind of tone of like, am I giving you a voice?
- 13:07So it's trying to find what song does your voice give?
- 13:12Because if I want you to be calm, I'm gonna talk a little bit calmer.
- 13:16That's the tone is your trademark.
- 13:18If you're somebody who's brash and angry and mad all the time,
- 13:21that's who you're going to become.
- 13:24Your tone controls everything.
- 13:26And there's plenty of times you know it's not your words, it's your tone.
- 13:29Like how many times have you probably heard from your mom or
- 13:31somebody go, I don't like your tone.
- 13:34It's something within us, or we hear somebody say something, and the words
- 13:37might be right, but we go, you know what?
- 13:39I don't like the way you said that.
- 13:40That's what ends up controlling the day.
- 13:42So yeah, tone is absolutely your trademark.
- 13:45Matt Abrahams: I really do like that saying and tone, again, I
- 13:48think there are two levels here.
- 13:49There's finding your authentic natural tone, that's who you are, and that's
- 13:52where coaching and recording can help you.
- 13:55But you also were talking about using tone strategically to
- 13:59help you reinforce your message.
- 14:01So if we're having a really serious conversation I need to reflect on,
- 14:05what tone do I want to bring to this conversation or have this conversation
- 14:10have, and are there ways I can leverage tone to really reinforce what I'm saying?
- 14:14And I do think at both levels it's really important.
- 14:18Using Tone as a tool is a very creative and strategic way to help you.
- 14:23And I appreciate that.
- 14:25Congratulations on your new workbook.
- 14:28People who know my work know that I'm all about practical, tactical
- 14:31advice and guidance, and a workbook's a great way to bring that about.
- 14:34In your new workbook, you have lots of assessments.
- 14:36Your initial assessment has you asking readers if they struggle
- 14:40with stopping myself from protecting other people's feelings.
- 14:45Why do you believe we have this instinct?
- 14:47And why is this the first self-assessment in your book?
- 14:51I could imagine others things could have come first.
- 14:53Jefferson Fisher: As a society, we're afraid to disappoint other people.
- 14:57We're afraid of their reaction.
- 14:59So what do you turn to?
- 15:00You turn to people pleasing and you turn to making sure that you're always last.
- 15:07And you give and you give, and you, you say, I'm not worth anything
- 15:11unless you think I'm worth anything.
- 15:13And we tie our identity to how much we serve is how much we
- 15:18can be okay with ourselves.
- 15:20And so that's why I wanted to start with it.
- 15:23Is, Hey, let's take a hard look.
- 15:24Let's have a cold shower for a second.
- 15:26Are you so focused and so afraid to disappoint somebody that you'd
- 15:32be willing to lower the way you see yourself even just a little bit?
- 15:37Is that okay with you?
- 15:39And to kind of have that self-reflective moment because if you want to improve
- 15:44how you communicate, I'd say skill number one is you have to learn to
- 15:47be okay disappointing some people.
- 15:50Matt Abrahams: I like that you start with the internal conversation first.
- 15:53I think that's a really important place for people to start.
- 15:56You know, if you're working on your communication, working on having
- 15:58better conversations, start with that conversation you have yourself,
- 16:01and look at your motivations.
- 16:03Are they truly your motivations or these societal pressures
- 16:07that you're conforming to?
- 16:08I like that, and I, and I spent some time doing the assessment myself, so thank you.
- 16:12In your workbook, you ask readers to write an internal manual.
- 16:17Can you share with us what this internal manual is?
- 16:19I don't know that I'd want other people having my internal manual, but talk
- 16:23to me about what it is and how it can help us identify sort of the rules and
- 16:28procedures that we leverage and use.
- 16:30Jefferson Fisher: I'd be willing to bet that most people don't really take an
- 16:34objective view about how they communicate, how they choose to communicate.
- 16:38They invest in a lot of things.
- 16:40They know how they make their coffee.
- 16:42They know what goes into X, Y, and Z, but they don't know how they communicate.
- 16:46So the idea of a manual is to write down what you allow and what you don't allow.
- 16:51Because if you don't, otherwise people just have a remote control to you.
- 16:54They have a remote control to your emotions, to your fears, and to
- 16:58your insecurities, where they always know how to what, push your buttons.
- 17:02But a manual says, no, no, hey, if you wanna communicate with me,
- 17:05this is how we're going to do it.
- 17:07So instead of this idea, like a remote control would say, you can't talk to
- 17:12me that way, a manual has this idea of like, hey, look, if you turn to
- 17:17page 74, paragraph D, you'll see, yeah, I don't respond to that volume.
- 17:21I don't respond to that tone.
- 17:23That's below my standard of respect.
- 17:25It's this idea of do you have written out, for yourself, how I will be
- 17:30communicated, how I'll be talked to and how I'm going to communicate.
- 17:34Do you have any idea at all?
- 17:35And maybe it's okay to like write it out and, yeah, it's hard 'cause life happens
- 17:38and maybe you don't follow it all the time and there's exceptions and whatnot, but
- 17:42you need to have some kind of rough idea of what you will choose to have allowed,
- 17:47be permitted, who has access to you in a way that can communicate that matters.
- 17:53Matt Abrahams: I like this idea of reflecting on your communication
- 17:57and thinking about what's acceptable and unacceptable.
- 18:00I think in my manual, I'd have to have several appendices because
- 18:03different contexts require different operating procedures.
- 18:07But I do like the idea of self-reflection and using the analogy
- 18:10of a manual makes a lot of sense.
- 18:13So before we end, I like to ask three questions of everybody I interview.
- 18:16One I create just for you, and two are similar for everybody.
- 18:19Are you up for that?
- 18:20Jefferson Fisher: Yeah, let's do it.
- 18:20Matt Abrahams: All right.
- 18:21So like me, you host a podcast, you write books, you deliver keynote speeches.
- 18:26All of this allows us privilege to interacting with lots of amazing people.
- 18:30What's one lesson you've learned from these different situations,
- 18:34your podcast, your writing, your keynoting, that's changed the way you
- 18:37communicate something you've learned?
- 18:39Jefferson Fisher: We're all still figuring it out, and I find that no matter who
- 18:42I'm talking to or where I am, it's easy to think that they got it all figured
- 18:46out, and once you really start to scratch beneath the surface, they don't
- 18:50really know what they're doing either.
- 18:51And so you just have to fail enough to kind of create a pattern of what kind
- 18:57of works and that's what you go with.
- 18:59That's what I've learned.
- 19:00Matt Abrahams: Yeah, I think that's right.
- 19:02We make this assumption that everybody else has got this figured
- 19:04out and we don't, and in fact, we're all figuring it out together.
- 19:08I appreciate you sharing.
- 19:09Question number two, who is a communicator that you admire and why?
- 19:14Jefferson Fisher: I have a friend whom you probably know, Chris Voss.
- 19:18And the reason I admire him is because we did a thing on stage
- 19:21once and somebody said afterwards, y'all are kind of like fire and ice.
- 19:24Like I'm the more softer side.
- 19:27Chris is not, you know, he, he is, let's get the deal done and
- 19:30negotiation and that balances me.
- 19:33And so I always appreciate that he'll say something, I go, yeah,
- 19:37I think that makes a lot of sense.
- 19:39But in terms of kinda always walking away with something practical,
- 19:42that is something that challenges me, I'd probably say Chris.
- 19:46Matt Abrahams: Chris is a great guy.
- 19:47We've had him on the show and both of you provide really practical, tactical
- 19:52advice and ways of getting into and out of communicative situations
- 19:56that I appreciate, so thank you.
- 19:58Final question.
- 19:59What are the first three ingredients that go into a successful communication recipe?
- 20:05Jefferson Fisher: One, regulation.
- 20:07You have to be able to say things with control, and you do that not
- 20:10by controlling the other person, you do that by controlling yourself.
- 20:13Two would be discernment, being able to know what is true and to
- 20:19speak what is true, to be assertive, to say things with confidence.
- 20:23And number three would be setting direction.
- 20:27Having a, a goal, setting your intention of the destination and to create
- 20:32connection with the other person.
- 20:34So when you're able to say it with control, say it with confidence and say
- 20:38it to connect, I think that's a, a pretty good recipe for a good conversation.
- 20:43Matt Abrahams: I agree.
- 20:44Regulation, discernment, direction, absolutely key ingredients.
- 20:48All predicated on what we've talked a lot about, which is self-reflection,
- 20:52understanding yourself, being able to determine where you're coming
- 20:55from before you try to engage others.
- 20:58Jefferson, I knew this would be a really great conversation.
- 21:01I knew we'd have an opportunity to really engage in ideas.
- 21:04I appreciate your input, your insights.
- 21:07Thank you for the time and congratulations on the new workbook.
- 21:10Jefferson Fisher: Thank you so much.
- 21:10Thanks for having me.
- 21:11It was great.
- 21:14Matt Abrahams: Thank you for joining us for another episode of
- 21:16Think Fast Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 21:18To learn more about communication and negotiation, please listen
- 21:22to episode 228 with Chris Voss.
- 21:25This episode was produced by Katherine Reed, Ryan Campos, and me, Matt Abrahams.
- 21:30Our music is from Floyd Wonder.
- 21:31With thanks to the Podium Podcast Company.
- 21:34Please find us on YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts.
- 21:37Be sure to subscribe and rate us.
- 21:39Also follow us on LinkedIn and TikTok.
- 21:42And check out fastersmarter.io for deep dive videos, English language
- 21:46Learning content, and our newsletter.
- 21:49Please consider joining our Think Fast Talk Smart Learning community
- 21:52at fastersmarter.io/learning.
- 21:55You'll find video lessons, learning quests, discussion boards, an AI
- 21:59tool, and book club opportunities.
- 22:01Again, that's fastersmarter.io/learning to become part of our Think Fast
- 22:06Talk Smart Learning community.