Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #🎙️109 |Public Inquiry Week Beginning 5th Oct. Land Ecology Day 4 |
Transcript
- 0:10Unknown: Welcome back. I'm Marella, your host, and I'm part of the Save Our Sperrins campaign. And this podcast is following the Coronalt public inquiry and the proposal for a gold mine in The Sperrins. If you're new to the podcast and wondering how we got here, I'd suggest going back to podcast
- 0:28number 43, the first in this public inquiry series, that will give you some of the background before joining us here. As the inquiry continues, I'll be following the evidence and the arguments and trying to make sense of what they could ultimately mean for the people, the water, and the landscapes of
- 0:50The Sperrins. There was a wonderful moment during today's public inquiry when Pat Houghty, discussing the bird surveys carried out for Dalriadians proposed gold mine, observed that the birds could be going anywhere. Well, indeed they could, Pat. And judging by the evidence we heard today, they
- 1:13might have a better idea of where they're going than some of the people being paid to assess their movements. Today we were back amongst the ecologists, working our way through badgers, bats, birds, butterflies, and a whole assortment of other creatures that have the audacity to live in The Sperrins,
- 1:29apparently without consulting the applicant's environmental management plans. There was, as usual, plenty of scientific terminology, a great deal of professional confidence, and once again, an extraordinary amount of discussion about work that could be carried out at some point in the future. I'm
- 1:49not going to take you through every species because the same issues kept cropping up: the age of the surveys, the areas covered, the methods used, and whether the information is good enough to support the conclusions being presented. What made today particularly interesting was the role of
- 2:07Northern Ireland Environmental Agency, because if you have spent the past few weeks listening to the evidence at this inquiry, you might reasonably have expected the environmental regulator to be the organisation demanding the highest possible standards of ecological assessment. Instead,
- 2:28we heard that the agency defending the overall adequacy of the applicant's information, while acknowledging that further work would be needed in certain areas, and it was during the questioning of Doctor Mark Hammond at around 20 past 10 this morning that the significance of that position
- 2:47began to emerge. Doctor Hammond was questioned about the badger surveys, and what emerged was quite revealing. Now badgers have an unfortunate habit of ignoring the red lines drawn on Dalradian's planning maps. They roam across the countryside, establish sets, forage and move around as they please, entirely
- 3:08oblivious to the proposed gold mine, which makes knowing where they live rather important when you're planning to blask, excavate and carve roads through their habitat. Doctor Hamm. acknowledged that surveys may need to extend beyond the application boundary, but when asked a fairly fundamental
- 3:31question, "When was the last comprehensive badger survey of the site actually carried out? he couldn't identify one, and this is the environmental regulator we're talking about, not somebody who has wandered in off the street. If the NIEA cannot tell us when the site was last comprehensively surveyed
- 3:53for badgers, on what basis is it satisfied that the ecological information Is adequate. The discussion then turned to planning conditions, pre-commencement surveys, and wildlife licences as mechanisms for dealing with matters requiring further attention. There's nothing unusual about
- 4:18updating wildlife surveys Before construction, species move, habit has changed, and a survey carried out several years earlier may no longer reflect conditions on the ground. The difficulty arises when information that might be essential to deciding whether a development is acceptable is
- 4:40left until after that decision has been made, and that was the point Connor Fagan, counsel for FODC, pursued. Connor referred to the Hardy and McCann cases and challenged the suggestion that shortcomings in the environmental information could be addressed. Through conditions imposed after planning
- 5:02permission, his argument was that the decision maker must have sufficient information to access the likely environmental effect before granting consent. The legal position was disputed, of course, and the commissioner will have to consider those arguments. But imagine a survey carried out after permission has
- 5:24been granted discovers an important badger set in an area earmarked for development.
- 5:32Perhaps it can be protected, or perhaps the design can be adjusted, or perhaps a licence can be obtained, but perhaps the discovery changes the assessment of the development's effects in a way that should have been considered before permission was issued, and that is the concern. When mr. Paul McDermott, Senior
- 5:58Planner, FODC, raised examples of other planning applications being delayed or refused because of inadequate ecological surveys, it introduces the uncomfortable question of whether the same standards are being applied consistently. The NIEA has a statutory role in environmental protection; its
- 6:20assessments carry weight, and that makes its willingness to accept outstanding ecological work especially significant. What is troubling is the apparent confidence that conditions and subsequent surveys would provide an adequate solution, without a clear explanation of what would
- 6:39happen if those surveys reveal something fundamentally incompatible with the proposals, as the morning progressed, the focus shifted towards the ecological baseline. To explain, that is the picture of the existing environment against which the consequences of the proposed mine are assessed, and
- 7:06it became increasingly apparent that there were serious disagreements about the quality of that picture. Also, Doctor Peter Walker questioned whether mitigation could be considered robust when some of the underlying surveys were outdated. Dr. Ruddock talked about survey coverage,
- 7:27transects, buffers, seasonal timing, and the practical limitation of recording wildlife activity. There were also challenges concerning the proportion of the site actually surveyed, although the applicants' witnesses defended their approach on the basis of species-specific methods and
- 7:50professional judgement, and whilst professional judgement certainly has its place in ecology, it is not a substitute for collecting the information necessary to understand what is happening in a particular habitat. Birds may be present at certain times of year, and absent at others. Bats can use
- 8:14different feeding routes according to weather and seasonal conditions. Badgers may occupy sets that were previously inactive. That is why the timing and extent of surveys matters. Pat Haughty reminded us of a fundamental scientific principle: absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. If
- 8:40you haven't recorded a bird, it doesn't necessarily mean there isn't one. It might simply mean you weren't looking when it was there. And Pat's observations that birds could be going anywhere captured the problem rather neatly. Their movements are part of what the survey work is supposed to establish, and
- 9:03there was another interesting issue raised by Conor Fagan concerning earlier exploratory activity associated with the mining project. He questioned whether those works might have already altered ecological conditions, potentially influencing the baseline subsequently used to assess the
- 9:26full development. One of the more encouraging parts of the day concerned the evidence being gathered by local people. We heard about wildlife cameras recording badgers, observation of birds and other species, and the considerable time residents have spent documenting what lives in their countryside. Some
- 9:48have undertaken training through Ulster Wildlife and have developed a substantial knowledge of the habitats around them. This is what we mean by citizen science. And there's something quite extraordinary about the fact that people who are volunteering their time to protect The Sperrins can find
- 10:08themselves having to establish the credibility of their observations, while the paid professionals are afforded considerable deference. Of course, local records need to be examined carefully. An observation has to be identified correctly, dated, located, and assessed for its relevance, but
- 10:31the same demand for scientific rigour must apply to the consultancy reports, which brings me to Goodwin. There is a certain awkwardness about watching a professional witness defend the ecological case for a development, while distancing himself from responsibility for particular elements of the work
- 10:52when challenged. The wider question concerns the consultancy system itself, the applicant commissions environmental assessments from professional consultants. Those assessments become part of the case supporting its application. The applicants then engage expert witnesses to explain and
- 11:13defend the conclusions. And I confess to me it is deeply dispiriting seeing highly trained ecologists applying their knowledge in defence of a proposal that will fundamentally alter the habitats they have spent their careers studying. They know that nature does not always respond according to the
- 11:37predictions written into an environmental statement. Yet here they are making the applicant's case.
- 11:46As I've said before, there are times when it fails, and when I know that some of the members of the environmental profession have wandered over to the dark side, and the consultancy fees are presumably more attractive than anything offered by Savers Sperrins, which more often than not amounts to a cup of coffee.
- 12:05The afternoon continued with more ecological evidence, including bats and the marsh frittillary butterfly. Questions were raised about bat foraging activity and the extent to which the proposed development impacts had been assessed. NIEA acknowledged that some potential effects on foraging had not been
- 12:27considered and indicated that longer monitoring would be desirable. Dr. Peter Walker also raised the loss of habitat along the Pollen Road burn, including a kilometre of affected habitat, for which he argued there was no like for like replacement. When an established habitat is lost, creating something somewhere
- 12:50else does not necessarily reproduce the ecological relationships that existed at the original site. And then we get to the marsh fertiliser butterfly. The survey work was challenged over timing, weather conditions, and methodology. The applicant acknowledged that some surveys have been conducted in
- 13:11suboptimal conditions, but defended the overall assessment and its proposals for mitigation and habitat compensation. There was also a dispute concerning whether particular survey activities required a wildlife licence, and the NIA was content with the survey information. That work content is doing quite
- 13:33a lot of heavy lifting work in this inquiry. There is a substantial difference between a regulator declaring on the basis of professional judgement that the information is sufficient, and actually demonstrating that the work meets the required legal and scientific standards. NIEA's acceptance of a survey
- 13:54does not, by itself, cure any failures to comply with an applicable legal requirement. Nor does regulatory approval settle every scientific disagreement about the reliability of the evidence, and that, to my mind, is where today's proceedings left the agency looking distinctly
- 14:15uncomfortable. Then there was the business concerning Simon Grey from Ulster Wildlife, who was speaking as an expert for Save Our Sperrins, or not speaking, as it turned out, we had genuinely understood that the requested list referred to members of Save Our Sperrins, not the independent experts
- 14:36assisting us. And I asked the commissioner to consider the question: Why on earth would we have deliberately left our own experts off a list, and perhaps should have added, when we had gone to such lengths to secure their help, because in the background was an unbelievable amount of effort in securing all
- 14:55of our experts to help throughout the inquiry. I also explained there was no attempt to circumvent the rules. We had simply misunderstood what was being asked of us. All we wanted was the opportunity to correct the list immediately and make reasonable arrangements for those experts to participate
- 15:14without causing prejudice to anyone else. Surely, in an inquiry where we have heard so much about adapting plans, managing unforeseen circumstances, and finding solutions to environmental problems, a genuine administrative misunderstanding ought not to be beyond
- 15:31mitigation. Preventing an ecologist from presenting his own evidence and responding directly to questions is a substantial limitation. Saver Sperrins are also very concerned about the other experts we have engaged for the final topics in this public inquiry. I came away from today's proceedings struck
- 15:53by the confidence with which the ecological case is presented, and the uncertainties that emerge when the evidence is examined more closely. The applicants' witnesses have defended their methods, and the NIEA has explained why it considers the information acceptable. But the challenges
- 16:12raised by Conor Fagan, Dr. Peter Walker, Pat Hawkey, and others deserves serious consideration. The consequence of a gold mine cannot be assessed on assurances that further surveys will be carried out, mitigation designed, and conditions complied with. Those promises are only as reliable as the
- 16:34evidence supporting them. And we are talking about The Sperrins, where people have lived alongside these rivers, burns, woodland, and peatland for generations, and where wildlife continues its business blissfully unaware of the planning application being argued over in Oma, local people
- 16:57are documenting what they see and asking that this landscape be properly understood before decisions are made that could change it permanently. They deserve a regulator that applies its standards consistently, and an inquiry that gives their evidence a fair hearing. When Pat Hawley said the birds could
- 17:20be going anywhere.
- 17:21He was highlighting the uncertainty surrounding the survey evidence, but I couldn't help thinking it was rather a fitting metaphor for the applicant's approach throughout this inquiry. After months of listening to shifting proposals, evolving assessments, mitigation measures still to be finalised,
- 17:39and decisions being pushed further down the road, you begin to wonder if Dalradian itself knows exactly where it's going. The birds, at least, have the excuse of being wild creatures. What's Dalradians? And I wonder where our environmental protection system is going when so much of the information
- 18:00needed to protect wildlife, may still be gathered after planning permission is granted. It feels like a race to the bottom of environmental protection, where the standards are gradually lowered to accommodate the development, and the only species guaranteed to thrive is the lesser spotted planning
- 18:17condition. And on that note, I leave it, and we see you all on Monday. You have been listening to the Save Our Sperrins podcast, Voices from the Frontline. Thank you for joining us today. All the links you'll need, from campaign updates to our social media pages, as well as links shared by today's
- 18:36guests and resources mentioned in the conversation, are available in the show notes. Please take a moment to share this podcast with friends, neighbours, or anyone who cares about protecting our land and communities. And don't forget to hit the follow button on your podcast platform. It really
- 18:54helps the algorithm spread these voices further. Together, our voices are stronger. Thanks for listening, and until next time, keep standing with the land, the water, the air, and the people who protect them.