Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Zoom Depositions: The Good, The Bad, and The Unsettled
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, everyone, and welcome to today's program,
- 0:07Zoom Depositions, the good, the bad, and the
- 0:10unsettled. I'm Alapoli Castro, Director of Education
- 0:13and Professional Development at Beverly Hills
- 0:15Bar Association. And today I'm delighted to introduce
- 0:18our speakers, Adam Carlson, Andy Schwartz, as
- 0:22well as our moderator, Kondo Dike Kongsar. Condo
- 0:26is an associate attorney at Casper Meadow Schwartz
- 0:29& Cook and represents plaintiffs in complex civil
- 0:32litigation involving wrongful death, catastrophic
- 0:35personal injury, and product liability. Kondo
- 0:38earned her law degree at UC College of Law, San
- 0:41Francisco, where she was the co -founder of Law
- 0:44Empowerment and Access Project, which focuses
- 0:47on advocating accessibility to legal education
- 0:50to underrepresented minorities through diverse
- 0:52representation and mentorship to pursue higher
- 0:55education. I'm going to turn it over to her to
- 0:58introduce you to our speakers, Adam and Andy.
- 1:03Hey, hello, everyone. Hello, everyone. I just
- 1:07wanted to introduce myself again. I'm Kondo.
- 1:10I'm going to be moderating today's CLE. And I
- 1:14have the honor of introducing our panelists.
- 1:18So Mr. Adam Carlson works at Casper Meadows -Schultz
- 1:22& Cook as a managing partner. He represents individuals
- 1:26in serious personal injury cases with an emphasis
- 1:29on spinal cord injuries, traumatic brain injuries,
- 1:34permanent disability claims. including those
- 1:36arising from product defects, dangerous premises,
- 1:39and construction site incidents. Adam has been
- 1:43a co -lead for multiple trial practice series
- 1:46programs and organized the learning by doing
- 1:49deposition course and has also taught at or lectured
- 1:53at Berkeley Law School on negotiating a personal
- 1:55injury case. He's tried cases where all depositions
- 1:58in the cases were conducted in person and ones
- 2:01where they were all on Zoom. He also authored
- 2:04an article with the same title as his program
- 2:07for The Daily Journal, where the Beverly Hills
- 2:10Bar Association actually contacted him to put
- 2:12on this program. And Mr. Andy Schwartz is the
- 2:17recently retired founding partner of Casper Meadows,
- 2:20Schwartz and Cook. Andy began his career in the
- 2:23Contra Costa County Public Defender's Office
- 2:26and was certified by the California State Bar
- 2:29as a criminal law specialist in 1982. In 1979,
- 2:34along with the other founding partners, Stan
- 2:37Casper, they both founded Casper Meadows, Schwartz,
- 2:40and Cook. In 2002, Andy was certified as a civil
- 2:45trial advocate by the National Board of Trial
- 2:48Advocates. He's a member of both the American
- 2:51College of Trial Lawyers and the American Board
- 2:54of Trial Advocates. He served as a judge pro
- 2:58tem in both Alameda and Contra Costa County and
- 3:02has tried numerous cases to verdict in both state
- 3:05and federal courts for more than four years.
- 3:09And with that, I'd like to pass it on to Adam
- 3:12to kind of briefly introduce the program and
- 3:14what it's going to be about. Hi there, everyone.
- 3:18So I'll go over what this program is. It is a
- 3:23balanced examination of benefits and drawbacks
- 3:26of Zoom depositions, which obviously are prevalent
- 3:29in our practice now with there being a choice
- 3:33these days of in -person versus Zoom. And we
- 3:35are going to present both sides of it. It involves
- 3:39people who have a preference for one or the other.
- 3:43I prefer Zoom. It's nice to have this conversation
- 3:46with Andy and his perspective because he has
- 3:48a preference for in -person. So benefits and
- 3:51drawbacks of Zoom depositions, a discussion about
- 3:54how remote depositions and the unique aspects
- 3:58of it in terms of strategy, case development,
- 4:01as well as issues of fairness with potential
- 4:03witness coaching. What this program today is
- 4:07not, it is not a step -by -step how -to or technical
- 4:11training for either in -person or Zoom depositions.
- 4:16Obviously, some of the how -to's will be touched
- 4:18on, but we're not going in depth about that.
- 4:20There's other programs out there that focus more
- 4:22on that, not focusing on the granular logistics
- 4:25of things, platform -specific issues. So that's
- 4:30why we're here today. And it's been interesting,
- 4:33the response to my article. I feel like it's
- 4:36the first publication where someone other than
- 4:39my mother has had an interest in what I wrote,
- 4:41because a lot of lawyers have reached out with
- 4:44their stories. A lot of judges have read it and
- 4:48they've been curious about what I said. So it
- 4:51even led to the Beverly Hill Bars Association
- 4:54picking this up and thought that it had value
- 4:57for you all today. So welcome everyone and look
- 5:00forward to this conversation. Awesome. So we're
- 5:04gonna go ahead and get started on the CLE and
- 5:08I'm gonna ask the first question to Adam. Adam,
- 5:13what do you consider when choosing between a
- 5:16remote deposition? And why do you prefer remote
- 5:19as opposed to an in -person deposition? Yeah,
- 5:23I think really big picture sort of helicopter
- 5:28view over the trees down below. I think two things
- 5:32really come to mind. And the first one is that
- 5:35I feel as though my performance is better. And
- 5:40what I'm talking about is sort of my dealing
- 5:43with my outline as it's going on through the
- 5:47deposition. I'm in my computer. I can type as
- 5:49fast as the person speaking. It's a changing
- 5:52outline. I'm copy pasting. I'm taking things
- 5:55and putting it in later in the outline. I hear
- 5:57a witness say something. I type it exactly. I
- 6:00can read it back to him and really stay in the
- 6:04moment with all that. And I'll talk more in depth
- 6:06about that later. The other in terms of my performance
- 6:09being better is I feel like there's so many benefits
- 6:12to online Zoom depositions with exhibits. And
- 6:17I think that if there's a lot of exhibits involved
- 6:20or even not a lot of exhibits involved, it's
- 6:22a lot better through Zoom. And lastly, I think
- 6:27that it's a lower stress event for me with not
- 6:31dealing with logistics as much. I'm gonna talk
- 6:33a little bit more. about some more of that later,
- 6:36but I feel like my performance is better. I sort
- 6:38of feel like I'm in this like command center
- 6:42in my office, like launching like impeachment
- 6:45bombs and loading up the artillery cannon with
- 6:47exhibits and firing them and annihilating the
- 6:49opponent, you know, all from my gaming chair
- 6:52here. And I feel like in the comfort of my, you
- 6:55know, own room, I'm just like, you know, crushing
- 6:58the deposition. So I feel like my performance
- 7:00is better in the deposition. And the second thing
- 7:03big picture is I feel as though I get better
- 7:06content. It does relate, you know, obviously
- 7:10to my performance being better. But I feel like
- 7:13sometimes I like to get witnesses relaxed. They
- 7:16sort of forget that this is like a real deal
- 7:18proceeding. And they kind of give up the goods
- 7:21in a sense because they're not on guard. And
- 7:24I like that. So those are the two big picture
- 7:28things that come to mind about why I prefer doing
- 7:31depositions on zoom awesome thank you for that
- 7:35and andy the same question is for you kind of
- 7:39looking at the big picture why do you prefer
- 7:41in -person depositions and what are your considerations
- 7:45there well um hi everybody it's nice to be here
- 7:50First of all, I understand how technology usually
- 7:53wins and I fully understand that and I'm not
- 7:55here to make the last stand for the baby boomers
- 7:58because I know that this is inevitable and it's
- 8:00happening. But on the other hand, anybody who's
- 8:04ever tried a case and who's visited the scene
- 8:06of an accident or the scene of an incident rather,
- 8:09you know there's something that you learn from
- 8:11being there in person. It's not necessarily the
- 8:14same thing, but it's something you get perspective.
- 8:16You get to see the people involved. You see where
- 8:19the streets cross. You see where the traffic
- 8:22lights are, where the witnesses may or may not
- 8:23have been standing. And you miss that when you
- 8:27don't do it in person. And I find and I have
- 8:30found that when you're in the room with an important
- 8:34witness, regardless of the impediments to getting
- 8:37there or getting him or her there, you're gonna
- 8:40learn something and you're not gonna give your
- 8:43opponent an advantage by your not being there.
- 8:47And from my perspective, and I've done both because
- 8:49I've recently retired. I worked through the pandemic.
- 8:52I did two full -blown bonding arbitrations all
- 8:56on Zoom. So I know what they're both are like,
- 8:59but I also know that when you're doing things
- 9:02in person, there are things that you can gain
- 9:04that are unavailable when you're doing them online.
- 9:07And so from that perspective, you know, Adam's
- 9:10done a million of these. His outcomes have been
- 9:12fantastic, but there is another side to it that
- 9:16I grew up with in this practice that I think
- 9:20that advantages are to be gained by being in
- 9:22the room with the person who you're deposing.
- 9:26Thank you so much, Andy. Going back a little
- 9:29to your last answer, Adam, you mentioned the
- 9:33exhibits. I think that's a huge part of depositions,
- 9:36remote or in person. Can you expand a little
- 9:40more on how remote depositions are more efficient
- 9:43and specifically with the exhibits, you know,
- 9:46note taking, outlining your deposition? Yeah,
- 9:50I think that it's kind of one of the biggest
- 9:55advantages, I think, when I'm thinking about
- 9:58Zoom depositions, is how you can handle exhibits.
- 10:04When you're preparing for an in -person deposition,
- 10:09you're dealing a lot with printing out these
- 10:11copies. Depending on the number of lawyers at
- 10:15the deposition, you have to print that many copies.
- 10:18Some depositions that I've done involve even
- 10:23like, you know, almost over a thousand pages
- 10:25of documents. And you have to bring binders to
- 10:30this deposition. And I'm spending all this time
- 10:33prepping this deposition, like putting stickies
- 10:37in these pages and stuff like that, rather than,
- 10:40you know, crafting my outline, things like that.
- 10:44And you can, and there's also the unanticipated
- 10:48exhibit that comes up a lot with the witness.
- 10:51You're asking them questions, including even
- 10:54one of the first questions of a deposition, what
- 10:56documents have you reviewed? And they refer to
- 10:59a document you haven't printed out. Or in the
- 11:02questioning, they refer to a document. And if
- 11:07you're on Zoom, you can stay in the moment. You
- 11:10can literally pause, say, OK, that document.
- 11:13You can pause, go to the other part of your computer,
- 11:16get out the document. You can do a search in
- 11:19the document, control that, find the content
- 11:22that they were looking for, slide it over into
- 11:24your exhibit on Zoom, pull it up on the screen,
- 11:27and then you ask a question about it. And you're
- 11:30in the moment, in the flow of the deposition.
- 11:32So they refer to this thing. You've had six or
- 11:34seven questions and answers leading up to this
- 11:37moment of this exhibit, and you're in the flow,
- 11:39and it just happened. Compared to you're in this
- 11:43deposition in person, and they reference an exhibit.
- 11:47Now, you're not going to pause the deposition
- 11:51right there necessarily. You might if you think
- 11:52it's a big deal. But then during a break, you're
- 11:55going, you're getting it printed. Over a lunch
- 11:57break, you're getting it printed, whatever it
- 11:59might be. And you lose the moment where you were.
- 12:03It's really hard to get everyone back to that
- 12:07moment, the flow. And then you ask them a question.
- 12:10Well, don't you remember you said earlier this?
- 12:12And you can even read it off of the real -time
- 12:15core. You lose that moment. So I like the ability
- 12:22to have these exhibits on Zoom. It's too stressful
- 12:28dealing with these big binders and then the unanticipated
- 12:31exhibit that comes up inevitably during a lot
- 12:34of these depositions. So a consideration when
- 12:37thinking about Zoom versus in -person, is, might
- 12:41be, for you, how many exhibits are involved.
- 12:44What kind of case is it? Because not every case
- 12:46is exhibit -driven. Not every deponent is exhibit
- 12:49-driven. And so if you have a witness who has
- 12:52less exhibits involved, or you have a contained
- 12:55sort of a number of exhibits there might be for
- 12:57the witness, that's one thing to consider. If
- 13:00it's going to be a document -intensive witness
- 13:03with a lot of exhibits, if a case has a lot of
- 13:06exhibits, then maybe that's something you should
- 13:08consider. I think Adam's right. When these document
- 13:12heavy exhibit depositions, it may be better to
- 13:16do it on Zoom. A lot of my cases don't have a
- 13:19lot of documents, but some of them did. And Adam
- 13:23makes a very good point. When it's document heavy,
- 13:26it's really sort of a pain in the behind to carry
- 13:30around multiple binders and make sure everybody
- 13:32has them, make sure they're all marked properly
- 13:35and they're part of the record. On the other
- 13:37hand, I taught at Stanford at a trial advocacy
- 13:40program for one evening last fall. And a big
- 13:45part of the program that I was part of was how
- 13:49to introduce evidence at a deposition. So it
- 13:54cuts both ways. You have to know how to introduce
- 13:57the evidence at the deposition. On the other
- 13:59hand, there's multiple documents. I think Adam
- 14:02makes a real good point. It might be better under
- 14:05certain circumstances with certain witnesses,
- 14:07particularly those that are document heavy, to
- 14:10have it on Zoom, to have the documents recorded
- 14:13electronically rather than bulky six or seven
- 14:16binders of hundreds of pages of documents. And
- 14:21kind of on the same topic of efficiency, what
- 14:26about note taking? What about outline? What do
- 14:29you see the advantages and disadvantages of in
- 14:32-person versus in -person? Andy, we can start
- 14:35with you. Yeah, well, it's really not a problem
- 14:38for me. Adam does it his way. I mean, when I
- 14:42took the bar exam, I think 5 % of the people
- 14:44typed it. Now, nobody types it. It's all on a
- 14:48computer. And we hand wrote our bar exam. So
- 14:51I just learned a different way. So in terms of
- 14:54note -taking for me in a non - electronic deposition,
- 14:59I just take notes. It's not an issue for me.
- 15:01I can keep up. There's a court reporter there,
- 15:03present in the room. If you need something read
- 15:05back, it could be read back. You could do real
- 15:07time if you wanted to. It's more expensive. But
- 15:12note taking is not an issue for me. But I think
- 15:15Adam feels differently about that. Yeah. My deposition
- 15:23outline on my Word documents is just this living,
- 15:28breathing, out -of -control document that is
- 15:31continually massaged and edited as the deposition
- 15:36is ongoing. I'm copy -pasting. I have the document
- 15:42open, a Word document, and I put it right where
- 15:46the camera is. So I'm looking at the person.
- 15:51I'm actually looking at the word, but they think
- 15:53I'm looking at them. And the top half is the
- 15:56outline, the bottom half I've split view. And
- 15:59so down below I can scroll up and down the rest
- 16:02of my outline to find other things in there.
- 16:06If the witness says something I want to return
- 16:08to, I'll put it in that section later. Sometimes
- 16:12I'm then even on like, you know, looking at things
- 16:15on Google, they say a word or term I haven't
- 16:17heard of, I quickly, they're still answering,
- 16:18you know, then I put that, bring that over. So
- 16:21this outline is I'm taking notes. I'm looking
- 16:23at the person. I'm typing along. I type every
- 16:26word they say because I can type that fast. And
- 16:29I just feel very comfortable that I'm going to
- 16:31make sure I hit all of my points. And then when
- 16:33they say something I want to return to or highlight,
- 16:37it comes back into the section where I have all
- 16:40the other questions. So it's a more flow of a
- 16:44deposition. You know, you can return to issues
- 16:47and things like that, but you really want to
- 16:49stay in the moment with the witness and the question
- 16:51questioning. You know, you really want to capture
- 16:53the moment. And I find it hard to return to a
- 16:57moment. I just, with the flow of the witness,
- 16:59things kind of change, maybe a break. They talk
- 17:02with counsel and counsel's like, you know, it's
- 17:05not so great how you kind of were talking about
- 17:08that thing. And then the next time you come back
- 17:10around to it, it's a different conversation.
- 17:14I like being, I'm able to be in the moment. And
- 17:17you can be on your laptop in person. You can,
- 17:23but it is awful. I mean, it's just the, the feeling
- 17:26in the room I have seen from my perspective,
- 17:29it's awful. Maybe you do it. I don't mean to
- 17:31be judgmental. I don't think it's good, but I've
- 17:33seen lawyers take depositions on their laptops
- 17:36and the whole time in this deposition, they're
- 17:42there typing. and doing exactly what I was talking
- 17:45about doing, but I have it up where the camera
- 17:48is. And they're in there and they're doing what
- 17:50I'm doing. And it's just not a good look. It's
- 17:54just the whole feeling in the room is weird.
- 17:56And I feel self -conscious when I do it, when
- 18:00I'm looking over things like that, but the whole
- 18:04looking and find other exhibits and stuff, when
- 18:06you're on Zoom, it's sort of like... socially
- 18:09accepted to kind of look off camera at times
- 18:12and not look directly at the person. And so I
- 18:14just don't have an I don't feel self conscious
- 18:16about looking around my computer. So I just think
- 18:19this like living outline document starts off
- 18:23very robust and gets even bigger and grows on
- 18:26what the witness says. Yeah, I just I'm sure
- 18:30you agree with this. I've told I teach when I
- 18:33do teach the most important part of any deposition
- 18:36is listening to the answers. And so many people
- 18:38get stuck on their outline, they're not paying
- 18:40attention to what the answers are. And you've
- 18:43addressed this in what you previously said, Adam,
- 18:45and you make good points. I could do it my way,
- 18:49you do it your way, but I would just add that
- 18:51the most important part of any deposition is
- 18:54what the answer is, not what your question is,
- 18:56because the answer is gonna lead to more questions.
- 18:59And if you wanna do it on your laptop, that's
- 19:01fine. You wanna do it in... in person with your
- 19:05own notes and not on your laptop, that's fine
- 19:07too. But just be prepared to be facile and mobile
- 19:11on your feet because you don't always get the
- 19:13answers you expect and your outline doesn't necessarily
- 19:17carry the day as much as the answers do. So I
- 19:20would just add that to what Adam says, which
- 19:22I'm sure he would agree with what I had to say.
- 19:25Definitely, definitely. Speaking of being prepared,
- 19:30I will start with Adam. Is there a different
- 19:35way that you would prepare for remote deposition
- 19:38versus an in -person deposition? I think this
- 19:41is especially important for newer attorneys like
- 19:45myself, knowing the differences. Do you prepare
- 19:48differently? Do you prepare the same? Could you
- 19:51speak on that one? Yeah. I mean, I think the
- 19:55thing that comes to mind a lot is just like these
- 19:57exhibit things of how are you going to handle
- 20:00all these exhibits? And that's just a major part
- 20:02of the prep. getting it getting all that, you
- 20:07know, situated the outlining. So the outlining
- 20:12for me kind of gets to the point that Andy made.
- 20:19When I am in person, my outline is way more pared
- 20:26down, less written out specific questions, because
- 20:31I want to kind of be engaged with the witness.
- 20:35I mean, I'm there in person. I want to be engaged
- 20:37with the witness. I don't want to then look down
- 20:39and read an entire phrase or sentence. It's more
- 20:43along the lines of bullet points of issues. And
- 20:47then in the moment, capitalizing on what Andy
- 20:50says I agree with, which I do agree with what
- 20:52he said about being in the moment and hearing
- 20:54the answer and then going with it based on your
- 20:58outline and issues and subjects. But for me,
- 21:02when I do an outline for myself on the that I'm
- 21:06going to do a zoom deposition, it does have more
- 21:08a lot more written out because I feel like I
- 21:12can be reading it as the witness is answering
- 21:16and has all that more written out as opposed
- 21:19to like if I glance down at an outline. So that's
- 21:22kind of the difference in terms of preparing
- 21:25like the outline. But then, you know, if the
- 21:33deposition is not at your home turf, not at your
- 21:36office, you have to think about all the other
- 21:37things you have to prepare for and just make
- 21:41sure that you're logistically set up, what you're
- 21:43gonna do that morning, do all these things that
- 21:46are not involved with the Zoom deposition. And
- 21:51Andy, for you, how do you prepare for in -person
- 21:55versus remote deposition? Is it the same? I think
- 21:59for me, it's pretty much the same. Like I said,
- 22:02I haven't taken a remote deposition for quite
- 22:07a while. I did it a lot during the pandemic,
- 22:09and I retired in 2024, and I haven't done a lot
- 22:12since then. But at the end of the day, you've
- 22:15always got to keep in mind, we're in the people
- 22:17business. We're trying to convince jurors, and
- 22:19we've got to talk to them. They're our friends,
- 22:22and we're going to get them on our side. And
- 22:26you have to be comfortable talking to people
- 22:28in person. And you don't have that component
- 22:31when you're taking depositions continuously or
- 22:35remotely. You get comfortable talking to people
- 22:39face -to -face, doing face -to -face depositions.
- 22:41And I'm concerned, at least to some degree, that
- 22:45in certain circumstances you lose that. So I
- 22:48don't prepare definitely. differently, and I'm
- 22:50more than willing to take remote depositions
- 22:53under certain circumstances. You save money,
- 22:55you save time, and some depositions aren't as
- 22:58important as others. But ones that are crucial,
- 23:01like I said, I don't prepare differently, but
- 23:03I'm being more inclined to do them in person
- 23:06than remotely. And I had a comment from the audience
- 23:12in regards to the Zoom or the remote versus live
- 23:16depositions. They said, isn't stress good? Aren't
- 23:19you going to need to deal with paper and people
- 23:22at trial? Isn't litigation a social event? And
- 23:25isn't an in -person messy depo great trial prep?
- 23:30Do either of you have any comment to that? Let
- 23:34me just tell, when I teach trial practice, I
- 23:40tell people the most important thing is you don't
- 23:42spill water on your pants. So the answer is,
- 23:44yeah, it's very stressful. But stress is good.
- 23:48And I concur with the questioner or the person
- 23:50who made the comment. Zoom depots are also stressful
- 23:53for different reasons or for other reasons or
- 23:55additional reasons. But you're right, the questioner.
- 24:00It is stressful. And thinking on your feet and
- 24:03being able to think quickly is part of our job
- 24:06and the part that we really like. It comes up
- 24:09in Zoom depots, too. And Adam will talk to that.
- 24:12But I agree. It is stressful. And that's not
- 24:16bad. Part of handling stress is part of our job,
- 24:18and we like that part. Yeah, I think depending
- 24:23on what the stress is, I don't like adding unnecessary
- 24:29stress in my life. I mean, you know, this exhibit
- 24:33stuff I'm thinking about is like so stressful
- 24:36when I prep for a deposition, but getting that
- 24:38all together. If it's an away game, if I'm not
- 24:41having my home turf, I'm I'm stressed around
- 24:43like, okay, parking or where am I getting my
- 24:45morning breakfast? I'm adding all these things
- 24:47in. You know, some is referred to, I guess, as
- 24:51decision fatigue. You know, you want to limit
- 24:53your decisions. It's what it is, stress fatigue.
- 24:59And stress is good in a sense. And I think that
- 25:02raises the point of like younger attorneys. I
- 25:05do think that for younger attorneys with less
- 25:08courtroom and trial experience, there is a lot
- 25:11of value of doing the in -person depot because
- 25:15it's more similar to a hearing or trial than
- 25:21a Zoom deposition. It just is. With the anxiety
- 25:23that comes with it, with the in -person things,
- 25:26all that. So for younger attorneys who don't
- 25:28have as much trial experience, maybe you do want
- 25:30to experience that stress with just a deposition
- 25:33level, but In general, I'm trying to limit the
- 25:35stress in my life. I want to get a really good
- 25:37deposition. I'm low stress over here in my command
- 25:40center, like firing off impeachment missiles,
- 25:42and I'm chill. I go to, like, sometimes I go
- 25:44to these, you know, especially in a way game
- 25:47depo, getting through the exhibits and this whole
- 25:50thing. At the end of the deposition, it's like,
- 25:55oh, it's over. Like, I need a massage after that,
- 25:58but not a Thai massage, because those are stressful
- 26:00too, like. But when I do Zoom depositions in
- 26:03my office, I'm done. I was like, all right, I'm
- 26:05going to have a snack and get right back in it.
- 26:08And then you're talking about sometimes you have
- 26:10a week with multiple depositions, and you have
- 26:14all the stress fatigue after Monday, and you
- 26:17have four more days of it. So I think, yeah,
- 26:21stress can be good, but what stress is it? Let
- 26:25me pick up on a point that Adam just made, and
- 26:27we talked about this, the three of us getting
- 26:29ready for this webinar. Kondo brought up this
- 26:33point, and I think it's an excellent point. Younger
- 26:36lawyers really have to get out from behind their
- 26:38computer. I mean, Adam's been at it for quite
- 26:41some time. He's very experienced. This has a
- 26:43lot of success. Younger lawyers who have not
- 26:49taken a depo in person haven't been to court.
- 26:51My favorite part of being a lawyer was going
- 26:53to court and trying cases. I liked winning them
- 26:56better than losing them, but it was great being
- 26:59in court and seeing other people. And so, to
- 27:02your point, Adam, that you just made that I agree
- 27:05with, if you're younger, get out from behind
- 27:08your computer. It's a great world out there,
- 27:11and it might be a little more stressful, but...
- 27:14The whole point of this job is to connect with
- 27:16people and to help people and to convince people.
- 27:20And when you're always behind your computer,
- 27:23you're missing out on a real good part of what
- 27:25we're doing for a living, all of us. So kind
- 27:28of along those lines, Andy, what do you think
- 27:31are the disadvantages and risks to a remote deposition?
- 27:37Well, like I said, you miss out on a lot. I mean,
- 27:40some of my best friends, professionally at least,
- 27:43have been made from my opponents. I mean, I'm
- 27:45in a boat. I'm in American College of trial lawyers.
- 27:48They're very collegial organizations. And if
- 27:52we didn't agree, we'd always go to court and
- 27:53get it resolved by somebody else. But often,
- 27:56as you everybody knows, most cases don't get
- 27:58tried. I mean, I think less gets right now than
- 28:00when I was doing them. But I wasn't trying to
- 28:03case every week. I was trying to couple three
- 28:05a year at the most. But I had relationships with
- 28:09my opposing counsel. We would go to lunch. Sometimes,
- 28:12not often, but we take we take a 10 minute recess
- 28:15and we talk. We're interacting face to face.
- 28:19I don't care what anybody says. It's not the
- 28:21same than talking on Zoom. I could talk to Adam
- 28:24and Yukondo now, but we had lunch together Friday
- 28:28or last week and I see you often. you miss out
- 28:34on the relationship or go into court. I understand
- 28:36that hardly anybody goes to court anymore, which
- 28:38is a shame. I understand that most mediations
- 28:41now are done remotely. I think you're missing
- 28:45out and you're not as effective when you don't
- 28:49have a relationship with the opposing counsel.
- 28:51And sometimes not often, but occasionally it's
- 28:54bad. And at least you know what a bad relationship
- 28:57is like. I mean, I got along with most of my
- 28:59opponents. there'd be an occasional opponent
- 29:02who wasn't... I teach civility for aboda and
- 29:07I've taught it for the past 20 years. And it
- 29:10was a good part of my practice. I mean, you get
- 29:12along with other people. You meet people who
- 29:13you like, who have common interests, who have
- 29:15the same profession. Even though they're trying
- 29:18to win their case and they were really good,
- 29:21you still had a relationship with them. And you
- 29:23miss out on that when you're doing it remotely.
- 29:26I know Adam feels differently about that to some
- 29:28degree, but I think he might agree with part
- 29:30of what I have to say also. I would say, Andy,
- 29:35I agree with a lot of what you had to say. And
- 29:37I've actually, Andy and I, Andy is my most impactful
- 29:41mentor in my career. I would love to have the
- 29:44success over his career for me. He's had incredible
- 29:48trial results, all from in -person, all those
- 29:51in -person depot trials that have resulted for
- 29:54him. And I think we've had so many back and forths
- 29:58with this issue and it's great conversations
- 30:01to have. And I think that the leading factor
- 30:05weighing in favor of in -person is this interpersonal
- 30:10dynamic relationship with counsel. I've come
- 30:13to recognize that it is different. And having
- 30:19that relationship with opposing counsel goes
- 30:22such a long way for handling the and confer issues,
- 30:26things like that, or to try and resolve the case
- 30:29and get the best outcome for your client. And
- 30:32I actually had a little bit of an epiphany when
- 30:33we were kind of having even more conversations
- 30:36last week. And what I realized was that, I don't
- 30:40necessarily feel a difference with my relationship
- 30:42with opposing counsel on my end. When I when
- 30:46I meet them in person, I've made friends over
- 30:49like Zoom hangouts over during during COVID and
- 30:52then I meet them in person. I don't think that
- 30:54my relationship changed with them. I still have
- 30:56that, you know, same connection. But what I've
- 30:59looking back on and I realize that these interpersonal
- 31:02dynamic relationships, they're two way streets.
- 31:04And I think that I connected from the other person's
- 31:08perspective. because they felt more connected
- 31:10to me. Perhaps it's a generational thing where
- 31:13older attorneys feel more of a connection with
- 31:16me when they've met me in person. But looking
- 31:18back on some of my cases, I'm like, you know
- 31:19what? That case did kind of turn after we met
- 31:22in court for the MSJ hearing. And our relationship
- 31:24was different. I didn't view him any differently,
- 31:27but he viewed me differently. He must have. And
- 31:30so that is a major consideration that he gets
- 31:33to know opposing counsel, and that is just massive
- 31:35in a case. And I recognize that to be a big disadvantage,
- 31:39even though you can chat with lawyers on Zoom
- 31:41after and before, shaking someone's hand is massive.
- 31:45I recognize that. So I agree with a lot of what
- 31:48Andy says. Also, just speaking as myself as a
- 31:52newer attorney, even though I've been in the
- 31:54Zoom world and this is my current world, I also
- 31:58appreciate that in -person relationship that
- 32:01you can cultivate. The rapport that you make
- 32:03in person versus Zoom, I think is really important.
- 32:08And then kind of moving forward, I really wanted
- 32:12to ask you guys, does the deponent, the person
- 32:16that you are deposing, does that factor into
- 32:22your decision to take their remote? their deposition
- 32:25remotely or in person, like P &Qs, expert witnesses,
- 32:30or plaintiffs or defendants. And Andy, can we
- 32:34start with you? Well, yeah, the answer is of
- 32:36course. I mean, you know, typically if you're
- 32:38doing a plaintiff's personal injury case, you
- 32:40want to depose the defendant unless liability
- 32:42is not an issue. We still want to see who the
- 32:45defendant is. Is it a corporate defendant? Is
- 32:46it a person? How's the person going to react
- 32:49to be? Listen, if the jury likes the defendant
- 32:53and you have a great case, it hurts your case
- 32:55that they like the defendant. You've got to know
- 32:58that. And you find out that better in person,
- 33:00I would think, than you do online or remotely.
- 33:07Experts. I would want to depose an expert in
- 33:10person. There were times during the pandemic
- 33:12when I couldn't and I didn't. And like I said,
- 33:14I went to two hearings. One of them was a three
- 33:18day binding arbitration. It was very expert intensive
- 33:22and I never deposed the experts and I felt like
- 33:27I wanted to. The result was fine but I still
- 33:31needed to depose them in person when I couldn't.
- 33:35I have a friend who was designated as an expert
- 33:37in a legal malpractice case in San Diego and
- 33:41she was deposed remotely as an expert and she
- 33:45loved it. She felt comfortable, she was relaxed.
- 33:49And she preferred that much more than she would
- 33:51have preferred. She told me to be having to go
- 33:55somewhere to the lawyer's office or federal court.
- 33:57They would have to come to her. The case was
- 33:59in San Diego. So, yeah, you definitely care who
- 34:03you're deposing. If it's a minimal consequential
- 34:06witness who's a six hour flight away, you know,
- 34:10for a half hour, it's an easy call. But there's
- 34:13much more gray than that. I mean, that's a silly
- 34:15example that I just gave. But yeah, the answer
- 34:20to your question is an unequivocal yes, it matters.
- 34:23And there's a lot of nuances to it. And you got
- 34:26to decide. On the other hand, I've seen Adam
- 34:29take depositions in cases where I would have
- 34:31never deposed a person remotely. And he just
- 34:35did great. And the outcomes were great. And he
- 34:38got stuff that I don't know that I could have
- 34:40gotten in person. So it cuts both ways. But from
- 34:43my perspective, under the appropriate circumstances,
- 34:47in person is important. And yeah, Adam, to you,
- 34:51does the deponent who the deponent is factor
- 34:54into your decision? Yeah, I mean, it's it's so
- 34:59it's so infrequent. I really want to do in person.
- 35:02It's so great that we have these diverging opinions
- 35:05and perspectives for you all today. But I mean,
- 35:09the first thing coming to mind again is the exhibits.
- 35:11And it's interesting. And this is I agree with
- 35:13a lot of anything today, but I disagree on the
- 35:15expert one because when experts are being deposed,
- 35:19they're individuals who have reviewed a ton of
- 35:21the file compared to a lot of other witnesses,
- 35:23right? And so with any of their opinions, you
- 35:27come, you know, they share your expert file with
- 35:29you, and it's everything in the case. And if
- 35:32there's a lot of documents in the case, which
- 35:34a lot of mine do involve, maybe it's more particular
- 35:36to that, but They show up and they give them
- 35:41their opinions and you ask the question, just
- 35:43an example, like, where did you find the evidence
- 35:46of this in the file? And they say, oh, well,
- 35:49it was in the deposition of this or it was in
- 35:51this document or it was in that document. And
- 35:54then you can stay in the moment. You can go over
- 35:56to your other side of your computer. You can
- 35:58pull it up. You can get it. You can get the deposition
- 36:01line. You can control F, look for the words.
- 36:03You bring it over. You pull it up on the screen.
- 36:05You ask the expert right then and there. Okay,
- 36:09what about this supports your opinion? And that's
- 36:13massive to me, because their opinions ultimately
- 36:15have to flow back to the evidence in the case.
- 36:19All of the depositions, all of the documents,
- 36:22that's where it flows from. And so I get to really
- 36:26get granular on the exhibit part of it. So I
- 36:29guess the big thing for me is exhibit. I recognize
- 36:33that there are certain witnesses who credibility
- 36:37is more important for the outcome of the case
- 36:39than other witnesses. And that's a huge consideration
- 36:42because how somebody does in person is going
- 36:45to be different than on Zoom. But the reason
- 36:49why my preference is still on Zoom is because
- 36:51I've had, you know, I had a trial recently where
- 36:55all the depositions were on Zoom. And I don't
- 36:59feel like I really lost the ability to assess
- 37:02their credibility. from all those Zoom depositions.
- 37:05I don't feel like they were different than what
- 37:07I thought they would be. What I did think when
- 37:09I was prepping for the trial was, man, my depositions
- 37:11are really good. I know what my case theme is.
- 37:13I know what I'm going to get. And I was able
- 37:15to execute it. And I had really good depositions
- 37:18to work with. So that's where my mindset comes
- 37:22from is I think I get really good depositions
- 37:25online. My preference is that. But the witness,
- 37:28they don't have a lot of exhibits attached to
- 37:29them. Then I would consider in person. And then
- 37:34with the remote depositions, now we can record
- 37:38them all. Have you ever used a recording of a
- 37:42deposition at trial? Yes. I have too. But don't
- 37:47forget, you can also record live depositions.
- 37:49And we do that all the time. We videotape depositions
- 37:53all the time. And we often play it back. So you
- 37:56don't lose that by having it in person. videotape
- 38:02or depositions. That's good for two reasons.
- 38:05You get the videotape for trial and unruly lawyers,
- 38:08lawyers who haven't taken my civility class,
- 38:12they calm down considerably when they're on video.
- 38:16So it's a good point, Kondo, but it's available
- 38:19to both. Yeah, the rules are the same. A recorded,
- 38:21a recorded, video recorded deposition is a video
- 38:24recorded deposition. So the rules are the same.
- 38:27You can do videotapes. A video recorded zoom
- 38:30deposition played a trial the same as a in person.
- 38:35And then the last question that I have for both
- 38:38of you before I move to you know closing it out
- 38:41and getting the audience questions is do you
- 38:46have any ethical issues arise whether you are
- 38:50in person or remote? And Adam we can start with
- 38:53you. Yeah, I did recently. And it was a deposition
- 39:02where the lawyer was in the same room as the
- 39:04deponent. And I was asking questions, and I thought
- 39:09I overheard something in the background. I didn't
- 39:12know what that was. And then it happened again.
- 39:16I was like, I think that this lawyer is coaching
- 39:18the witness. I do. I didn't want to make that
- 39:21accusation there. I didn't have the goods yet.
- 39:22But I do a lot of video. amateur filmmaker, I
- 39:27also make films for my cases and splice together
- 39:30deposition clips and all this. And so I got ahold
- 39:36of the video right away and I went to the moments
- 39:40where I thought I heard something and I enhanced
- 39:42the audio and sure enough, verbatim, the lawyer
- 39:44was telling the witness what to say. And that
- 39:47was just so crazy that that had happened. And
- 39:52then you think about times where, and I'm going
- 39:54to talk in a little bit, I'm going to get to
- 39:56a case that's actually deals with this about
- 39:59lawyers not being on camera in a zoom deposition.
- 40:02So there is case on this recent to go over, but
- 40:05that happened. And, you know, obviously it's
- 40:09not going to happen in person with cause you
- 40:12can see the lawyer and all that thing, something
- 40:15like that isn't going to happen. You might still
- 40:17get some witness coaching and things like that
- 40:19with objections, but. That was unique to Zoom.
- 40:26And Andy, have there been any ethical issues
- 40:28that have arisen in prison depositions? There
- 40:31always are, but Adam didn't say this, but that
- 40:35incident that he just described was a genesis
- 40:37for his article. Because I remember it specifically
- 40:41because you told me about it, Adam. I wasn't
- 40:43there. That kind of stuff happens on Zoom. It
- 40:48doesn't happen in person. And that's another
- 40:50reason why you want to factor it in. Listen,
- 40:52most lawyers aren't dishonest. I've been doing
- 40:56this for a long time. And for the most part,
- 40:59it's a high quality group of people I've run
- 41:01into, both sides of the bar. But occasionally,
- 41:05it's going to happen. And it's easier to get
- 41:06away with when you're on Zoom than when you're
- 41:09in person. And it's never a factor for me that
- 41:12I want to do something in person. This is less
- 41:14likely the witness is going to be coached. But
- 41:16on the other hand, if there is someone who wants
- 41:18the culture witness, it's easier to do it on
- 41:21Zoom than it is in person. Thank you so much.
- 41:26And then, Adam, I'd like to pass it off to you
- 41:29to kind of give your final remarks and summary
- 41:32of the CLE before we take questions. You want
- 41:35to talk about that case, Adam? Yeah, I'm going
- 41:37to get to that in a second. First, before I get
- 41:39to that case, I'm going to go through just a
- 41:41little refresher of key considerations for whether
- 41:46to do something, whether to do a deposition,
- 41:51Zoom or in person. I talked about it a lot, obviously
- 41:56exhibit management, you know, what's the witness
- 41:58about, what's your comfort with exhibit management?
- 42:00Some people aren't comfortable with Zoom exhibits
- 42:03and electronic exhibits. You know, thinking about
- 42:07the witness comfort versus having control over
- 42:10them, things like that, like Andy talked about.
- 42:13you know, the witness might be more comfortable
- 42:15on Zoom and whether that's good or bad, think
- 42:18about that for yourself. If you think it's more
- 42:22important to be in person to assess demeanor
- 42:24and credibility, which again goes to maybe which
- 42:26witnesses this, cost factors, obviously that's
- 42:30an easy one. You got to figure out what makes
- 42:32sense for where these things are, you know, how
- 42:34much it costs to get there. Similarly, the scheduling
- 42:40efficiencies and overall workflow, if you can
- 42:42just do a Zoom deposition at 10 a .m. on a Monday
- 42:46and then also do one at 2 p .m. the same day,
- 42:49in the same case, depending on where people are,
- 42:52all those types of things you want to consider.
- 42:56What we talked about, the real -time workflow
- 42:58with the outline and notes and things like that.
- 43:03Professionalism, rapport with opposing counsel.
- 43:06likely end up with a better relationship with
- 43:09counsel if you're meeting them in person. Ethical
- 43:14concerns, witness coaching, again, deponent type,
- 43:18and then really a decision balance with all these,
- 43:22right? And you figure out what's more important
- 43:24for you. Certainly young lawyers should try doing
- 43:28more in person. I think perhaps going forward,
- 43:33if this CLA has been of any value to you, maybe
- 43:37things you hadn't thought about before, maybe,
- 43:39and you've been doing primarily Zoom depositions,
- 43:42maybe trying in -person deposition is like down
- 43:44the road and then think about these issues and
- 43:47maybe you've sort of overlooked something. So
- 43:50hopefully we've brought some value in that regard,
- 43:52pointed out some things that maybe you hadn't
- 43:54been on top of mind for making your decision
- 43:56about doing Zoom versus in -person. In -person
- 44:01depositions are a lot closer to a trial. than
- 44:04a Zoom deposition. So if your hope is to be a
- 44:08trial lawyer, and I guess a lot of you who are
- 44:10attending this webinar do have that hope, you'll
- 44:14get a lot better preparation for trial being
- 44:16in the room with the witness than being on the
- 44:18video with the witness. And that's just one of
- 44:20the many factors. Like I said, I'm not here to
- 44:23make the last stand for the baby boomers. This
- 44:26is inevitable, and what Adam's doing is great.
- 44:29But there are other factors that need to be considered.
- 44:32One of them is that. So this is a there's two
- 44:37thousand and twenty five case. These are Italian
- 44:39names, Agnone Contro Agnone versus Agnone. It
- 44:43was two thousand twenty five. And the issue was
- 44:46there was a lawyer refusing to turn on their
- 44:49camera. I can't hear you. And can anyone hear
- 44:53me? Can you guys hear me? Yes, I can hear you.
- 44:59Sorry. See if we were in person this wouldn't
- 45:10happen. Can you hear me? Can you hear me now?
- 45:24Yes, sir. Council is refusing to turn on their
- 45:31camera during a remote deposition. Now, this
- 45:36is important. We're gonna get to a little practice
- 45:38point of deposition notice explicitly stated
- 45:41counsel must be on camera. The defending attorney
- 45:46refused to put on the camera. The noticing attorney
- 45:49noted multiple times on the record that the witness
- 45:51was looking up before answering, suggesting coaching,
- 45:55repeatedly asked the attorney to turn on the
- 45:57camera and they did not. The court issued sanctions
- 46:00for discovery of use and frustrating the truth
- 46:03seeking process. and this Court of Appeal upheld
- 46:08the discovery sanction. So this is a big case.
- 46:14Attorneys have their camera on. And I'll get
- 46:17to the deposition notice specifically said in
- 46:19this case. But in case opposing counsel brings
- 46:23up, well, what about the California rule of court
- 46:26allowing telephonic appearance? Isn't this the
- 46:30same if I'm off camera? The Court of Appeal addressed
- 46:33that. Contrary to their contention, the rule
- 46:36cannot be read as a blanket authorization for
- 46:39a deponist attorney to participate by audio only
- 46:43means. While physically present with this client
- 46:46under circumstance with the attorney could surreptitiously
- 46:49coach the deponement outside opposing counsel
- 46:52view. So if you're dealing with this, just know
- 46:55that this case addresses that potential counterpoint.
- 47:00So getting to sort of the practice point, The
- 47:06notice language in Agnone specified it was going
- 47:11to be by Zoom and stated that the witness, the
- 47:16deponent, and their counsel shall participate
- 47:18using their own computer equipped with the webcam
- 47:22and with the stable landline wired ethernet connection
- 47:26to the internet. This latter part I don't know
- 47:28about, but just having in the notice that the
- 47:33attorney should appear in their own camera. I
- 47:37think should be an all notices going forward
- 47:39for zoom. And I think that, you know, I think
- 47:44that there could still be changes that would
- 47:46be better going forward with rules of court.
- 47:49This stuff needs to make it into rules of court.
- 47:52Eventually it's not there yet. It's just in that
- 47:53case. But I think that there's there are actually
- 47:56some counties that are trying to adopt these
- 47:58rules of court. I think it does need to. does
- 48:00need to happen and people that are in charge
- 48:03of those things. I don't know who does those
- 48:05things, but get these rules of court related
- 48:07to zoom depositions so that we can have some
- 48:09guidance and clarity on what's appropriate conduct
- 48:12with simple things such as whether or not a webcam
- 48:14is on. I think that counsel should not be allowed
- 48:17to be in the same room with the deponent. I think
- 48:21that they should have to be in a separate room.
- 48:24You know, but people smarter than me should think
- 48:26about that. You know, do you have Do you have
- 48:28a right to counsel this president in the room
- 48:30with you during anything? I don't know the implications
- 48:32there. You know, there's all kinds of stuff.
- 48:35You want your client to be deposed when you're
- 48:37not in the room with him or her? I mean, I do
- 48:40it now. Yeah, I absolutely. OK. You know, I understand.
- 48:46Yeah. So I think from my perspective, I think
- 48:50that my client would feel more comfortable if
- 48:52I was sitting next to him or her. But. Yeah.
- 48:58Anyway, that was an important case. Think about
- 49:01that language for your next Zoom notice. Awesome.
- 49:07So we want to be mindful of everyone's time.
- 49:09We have about 10 minutes left for questions.
- 49:14So the first question is, for newer attorneys
- 49:17like myself, do either of you just have any general
- 49:23advice in considering when to take a deposition
- 49:27remotely versus in person. Just any advice for
- 49:32like preparing and things like that for newer
- 49:34attorneys that didn't experience the world before
- 49:37Zoom depositions took over in Zoom court hearings.
- 49:42So, Adam, we can start with you. Yeah, I mean,
- 49:44I think, you know, we've been talking about the
- 49:46value for a younger attorney to do in person,
- 49:48but also try both, you know, check them out.
- 49:51I think that What might happen for people is
- 49:54ultimately they establish their preference personally.
- 50:01But with that, they should always carry forward
- 50:04being mindful that their way is not the only
- 50:07way. So I think that for younger attorneys, you
- 50:10should prep and do both. You should try the in
- 50:15-person for the reasons we talked about. And
- 50:18also do zoom depositions because you might find
- 50:21that you're doing a better deposition on zoom
- 50:23for whatever reason for you. However, it works
- 50:26So try them both but definitely yeah I think
- 50:31and my answer to that question would just be
- 50:33it's what we've been talking about. I mean, there's
- 50:34a million factors that go into it Who's the witness?
- 50:37How far is the witness? How important is the
- 50:39witness? There's something to be gained from
- 50:42taking the in -person depot if you've never taken
- 50:44one before and likewise there's something to
- 50:46be gained from taking a Zoom depot if you've
- 50:49never taken that before. I mean, I learned all
- 50:51this stuff late in my career. I didn't really
- 50:53like it, but I learned it. And, you know, and
- 50:58Adam's proved that it can be extremely effective.
- 51:02I agree. And I think that what's nice is that
- 51:06both of you have experienced in -person and Zoom
- 51:10depositions and were able to make those strategic
- 51:13decisions to determine what works best for you
- 51:16guys. And so I think that's something that newer
- 51:18attorneys can learn from and to kind of possibly
- 51:22see a hybrid situation in the future. From the
- 51:26audience, Erica Williams is asking, how do you
- 51:29make the determination to take video recordings
- 51:32of your deposition? Or rather, What factors do
- 51:36you consider when making the determination to
- 51:38video record? Adam? Well, I guess with my practice
- 51:43now, I video record them all. So it's just my
- 51:46default. I like having the video clip for a number
- 51:51of reasons. Like I mentioned, I do a bit of filmmaking.
- 51:54So having a video clip of a deponent saying something
- 51:58that I can splice into something. But I know
- 52:00that that's not everyone does those types of
- 52:02things. But I think ultimately, if you're going
- 52:06to use it at trial, a transcript, it's better
- 52:12presentation to play the video of the person
- 52:16saying something inconsistent if it's an impeachment.
- 52:20If it's a party, then you can play their deposition.
- 52:24Essentially, you can state their deposition or
- 52:26play their deposition basically anytime throughout
- 52:28your trial. And obviously, seeing the person
- 52:32saying it from their own mouth as opposed to
- 52:34a lawyer rereading it, I think is more effective.
- 52:37So my default is to video record. But in terms
- 52:40of factors, you know, costs, it's going to cost
- 52:43a little more. So does it justify it in the case?
- 52:48Yeah, I agree with that. I mean, it's obviously
- 52:50cost. If you can afford it and the case is worth
- 52:52it, you should spend the money to do it. It's
- 52:54always better to have a video than just a just
- 52:56a straight record. And then Robert Arnoff asked,
- 53:02what are the rules and strategies when you and
- 53:04your opponent differ on Zoom or in -person? Yeah,
- 53:10my understanding is the noticing attorney gets
- 53:12to set what they want and that you are allowed
- 53:14to notice a deposition by remote means. I've
- 53:17never had pushback on that. of noticing it remotely
- 53:21and then insisting on in -person or someone noticing
- 53:25it for in -person and resisting that it be remote.
- 53:28But what can happen is if people can't make it
- 53:31in -person, it's noticed for in -person, then
- 53:32there's other means that they can appear. So
- 53:35there's the telephonic appearance. I've also
- 53:40had the ability to... I've had in -person depositions
- 53:47where they set up the zoom Capabilities and sometimes
- 53:53that can be the court reporting service Or it
- 53:57can be working with opposing counsel Depending
- 54:00on how they're gonna take the deposition For
- 54:03example, I had counsel notice in person and it
- 54:06was far away from where I was he was living near
- 54:09he lived near where the deponent was and he agreed
- 54:11to have Him on a laptop and the other person
- 54:15on a laptop there in the same room all the other
- 54:18lawyers were on zoom he was in the room with
- 54:20the deponent and we were all appearing remotely
- 54:23by zoom and uh shannon burns is asking in zoom
- 54:31depots how do you determine whether or not the
- 54:35deponent has a cheat sheet or is looking at documents
- 54:38outside the video to help in responding to potential
- 54:41questions so this kind of goes to the witness
- 54:44coaching i think yeah um so i Given admonition
- 54:50part of my admonitions, you know, there's the
- 54:52deposition admonitions that you give you know,
- 54:56don't guess you know We're entitled to the best
- 54:59estimate recording rules all that I also give
- 55:02the admonition that they are not to refer to
- 55:05or review any documents off -screen and that
- 55:09we may ask at any point to view what's in the
- 55:13room and See what's there if there is a document
- 55:17in the room then you should turn it over if you
- 55:21need to refer to it or look at it later on. You
- 55:25can let us know, but we are entitled to your
- 55:28testimony from what you recall, not from reviewing
- 55:31any document. Now, you can't fully enforce that.
- 55:38There could be things off camera. And I have
- 55:42heard one of the judges that reached out after
- 55:45the article came out told me a story about how
- 55:48you know the the person like bumped the laptop
- 55:53and it knocked it and then saw like a giant whiteboard
- 55:59with like the bullet points for the deponent
- 56:02to make during the depot and then they're like
- 56:07ma 'am can you turn that thing around and it
- 56:10was like a war room with all this stuff up there
- 56:13so I I just gave an admonition at the beginning.
- 56:18It's just that, you know, it's the best you can
- 56:19do. And it's a risk associated with doing a Zoom
- 56:22deposition, I acknowledge. And you gotta remember
- 56:25this, they were all court officers. At least
- 56:27that's what I was told I was when I was sworn
- 56:29into the bar a while ago. And we have to have
- 56:32our integrity. And, you know, you can't suspect
- 56:36everybody's gonna be dishonest. I sort of make
- 56:38the other presumption. And that people are going
- 56:41to be honest and have integrity. It's not always
- 56:43the case, but for the most part, it is. And if
- 56:46things like that happen, they're going to happen.
- 56:48And they're going to happen both in remote and
- 56:50in -person depots as well. Sometimes kind of
- 56:54depending. I will say you may be subject to sanctions
- 56:56if we learn that you're using an aid. But it's
- 57:00not standard for me. Maybe I'll make it standard.
- 57:02I don't know. It kind of depends on how the case
- 57:05has been going. And David Azar asked if you have
- 57:10used electronic exhibits with screens for an
- 57:13in -person deposition, and his impression is
- 57:16that some live exhibit companies have that as
- 57:18an option. Have you guys ever done that? All
- 57:21the time, like just playing on a TV, I assume,
- 57:24yeah, or on a laptop. All the time in person,
- 57:28yeah. You know, we have a TV in our conference
- 57:30room. and can load some things up because we
- 57:34have access to our computer database on our TV
- 57:37screen. And so I'll put it up there. Or you can
- 57:41have it on your laptop or something and show
- 57:46it. And that comes up. Sometimes you're trying
- 57:52to drill down on where on a map or something
- 57:55it occurred, where they were standing at a scene.
- 57:59And on Zoom, What I do is I just, I'll share
- 58:02screen, pull up Google Maps, go to the scene
- 58:04and I'll click around and I'll kind of talk through
- 58:07narrate for the record and say, okay, I want
- 58:09to drill down to where you're standing. And they're
- 58:11like, okay, we're on this corner. No, that corner.
- 58:13No. And then they give me the corner. I'll screenshot
- 58:17it. Save that screenshot as a, as a document
- 58:23PDF or make that an exhibit and then load it
- 58:28up. And in person. might do something similar
- 58:31with the TV conference room, where I have Google
- 58:34Maps up and I'm scrolling around, tell me when
- 58:37I get to where you are, and then you screenshot
- 58:39it, and then you send that to a printer, print
- 58:44that out, and make it an exhibit. It becomes
- 58:47difficult when you're having this electronic
- 58:49stuff that's also, I mean, depending on which
- 58:51file it is, but that's just an example. And then
- 58:56the last question before we hit 130 is from RJ
- 59:01Hendrix. How do you deal with a situation where,
- 59:04in a remote deposition, the witness produces
- 59:07additional documents? You always find a way to
- 59:13get it. It happens. If they have a lawyer, the
- 59:17lawyer will make do. They'll scan it. I've always
- 59:23ended up when that happens, being able to get
- 59:27a digital copy of it and emails and make it a
- 59:29part of the record. I suppose if it's someone
- 59:33who doesn't have fully those capabilities, it
- 59:35just would figure it out, make a way to set those
- 59:39aside. We can recess the deposition and get the
- 59:42documents and come back some other day. That's
- 59:44not a problem. Yeah, you just I've typically
- 59:49had the witness with a counsel. It's often with
- 59:52counsel and counsel will get you the documents.
- 59:55I've also seen like with PMQs where when you
- 59:59ask what documents have you reviewed in preparation
- 1:00:02and they give it to you right there. I've seen
- 1:00:06where attorneys have been like, let's take a
- 1:00:0810 minute break so I can review this and then
- 1:00:10move along. And that's something that's advantageous
- 1:00:13in zoom depositions. because you can quickly
- 1:00:15kind of go back and forth and add that later
- 1:00:18on to your outline as well. And I believe we're
- 1:00:21at the 1 .30 mark. I'm sure people would like
- 1:00:25to leave if they could, but we have some more
- 1:00:27questions. I don't know, Adam and Andy, if you
- 1:00:30would like to answer now or if you would like
- 1:00:34to make a challenge. I've got a couple more minutes.
- 1:00:35Couple more minutes. Couple more minutes if people
- 1:00:37want to stay, but if not, you're taking off.
- 1:00:39Thank you for appearing. Hopefully this was a
- 1:00:41value to you and your consideration of doing
- 1:00:44zoom or in person. Yeah, thanks for coming. So
- 1:00:48much OK, so then as people are leaving, I'll
- 1:00:51ask some more questions to you guys. One person
- 1:00:55James Warren asked, do you ask a deponent if
- 1:00:59they have any other electronic devices present
- 1:01:02during the zoom deposition? I have not. No, I
- 1:01:08think I have not asked that. Would bringing a
- 1:01:13thumb drive this from John Holly, would bringing
- 1:01:17a thumb drive with exhibits be efficient in an
- 1:01:19in -person depot? Sure. Yeah, we get that. You
- 1:01:23get that a lot. I've had certainly expert witnesses.
- 1:01:28They show up. You know, used to be kind of they're
- 1:01:31showing up with. Well, now they have to reduce
- 1:01:34their files to a certain number of days. Yeah,
- 1:01:38the three -day rule, that's good. You can bring
- 1:01:45a thumb drive with documents. If you're asked,
- 1:01:51the depo notice asks for documents. Stuart Wolf
- 1:01:55asked, how do the rules work about recording
- 1:01:58a Zoom deposition? The general rule in California
- 1:02:01is you can't video or audio record without consent.
- 1:02:06You notice it saying it's going to be video recorded
- 1:02:09and then in the beginning the people it says
- 1:02:11the at the top says this meeting is being recorded
- 1:02:14and everyone has to click OK. So that's the consent.
- 1:02:19And Cedar Boshua. Apologies if I mispronounced
- 1:02:23that. This was more on the line of the question
- 1:02:27that we had earlier about whether deponent factors
- 1:02:29into your decision. Cedar asked, how does the
- 1:02:33question of in -person versus virtual depositions
- 1:02:35apply to expert depositions? And what should
- 1:02:38experts consider? Well, I think we talked about
- 1:02:42that already. I mean, I prefer to depose experts
- 1:02:45in person because you really get a feel for who
- 1:02:48they are. And you get there, in state court at
- 1:02:52least, you get your files 72 hours in advance.
- 1:02:55I think maybe 48. I forget the rule. And in California,
- 1:03:02they have to come to you. In federal court, you've
- 1:03:06got to go to them. So that's an issue. But I
- 1:03:10just refer in person in general and for experts
- 1:03:11in particular. But that's just my preference.
- 1:03:14And I think Adam has a different one. Yeah, I
- 1:03:19mean I got it's just like those documents all
- 1:03:21these experts are gonna have like refer to some
- 1:03:24Some minute fact that is a foundation for something
- 1:03:28they're trying to use to crush your case I want
- 1:03:31to make sure that I can drill down on that fact
- 1:03:33so then when they hit the stand I'm like prepared
- 1:03:36to just Know what's coming because ultimately
- 1:03:39they can get up there and say what they want,
- 1:03:41but I think the jury understands when you rein
- 1:03:44everything back in and the foundation of what
- 1:03:47they said that is so good for their side is weak.
- 1:03:50And you've really, a deposition to me is discovery.
- 1:03:54You're discovering what the, and then with an
- 1:03:56expert, you're discovering what their opinions
- 1:03:58are and what they're based on. The best way to
- 1:04:00test that I think is being prepared to get into
- 1:04:04the documents. That's great. Okay. Another question
- 1:04:10kind of on the topic of comfortability of the
- 1:04:13deponent. Does that matter to either of you about
- 1:04:18how comfortable the opponent is during the deposition?
- 1:04:23Yeah, some people like them comfortable. Some
- 1:04:26people don't like them comfortable. It's a matter
- 1:04:29of personal preference. And I find that they're
- 1:04:33often less comfortable when they're in person.
- 1:04:35than not, but some people prefer to have the
- 1:04:38witness more comfortable than others. Yeah, I
- 1:04:42think it's interesting. Andy and I both see one
- 1:04:45aspect of this the same, that the witness is
- 1:04:47more likely to be comfortable on Zoom than in
- 1:04:51person. They're likely to be uncomfortable in
- 1:04:53person. But we see it differently about how that
- 1:04:56plays out, what that means to us, because Andy
- 1:04:59prefers the in -person witness being a little
- 1:05:02uncomfortable and seizing on that. assessing
- 1:05:05them out and all that. And I think that what
- 1:05:08I've seen since I've started doing the Zoom depositions
- 1:05:11is these witnesses super comfortable just give
- 1:05:14up the goods. They just don't, they're not on
- 1:05:16guard and they slip. They're not thinking. They
- 1:05:21say ridiculous things because they're on Zoom
- 1:05:23in their own room. And I've liked that. And so
- 1:05:27we kind of, we agree that they're probably more
- 1:05:30comfortable on Zoom. And you have to figure out
- 1:05:33a thing with your practice. And also that's a
- 1:05:35style thing. Andy has a much different style
- 1:05:37with how he would do every trial than my style
- 1:05:40with all of my trials. Andy is stylistic. It's
- 1:05:45personal. I see how when Andy talks about how
- 1:05:48he likes to witness uncomfortable and ask him
- 1:05:51questions, how that's for Andy. But I also see
- 1:05:54like who I am and my vibe and what I like to
- 1:05:57do and how I approach people and converse and
- 1:06:00all that. that the Zoom comfort person for the
- 1:06:03witness is my style. I think we're sort of at
- 1:06:08the end of our time limit here, Kondo. Yeah,
- 1:06:11definitely. Thank you guys so much for speaking
- 1:06:16and answering all of our questions. There's a
- 1:06:19few questions left over, but I'm sure we can
- 1:06:22find a way to get us all connected. Yeah, our
- 1:06:26email address is available to the... Participants?
- 1:06:31There must be. I'm sure there are. I'm sure we
- 1:06:34can make it so. Is anyone going to come on and
- 1:06:39sign us out? All righty. This concludes today's
- 1:06:43presentation. Thank you so much Condo Adam and
- 1:06:46Andy for joining us today and educating our members.
- 1:06:49And thank you so much to our audience. Have a
- 1:06:51great day, everybody. Thank you. Thank you. Have
- 1:06:54a great day.