Latest / Shades of Murder / 58: A Killer on Campus - Cold Case Jennifer Kairis, FL

Transcript

58: A Killer on Campus - Cold Case Jennifer Kairis, FL · Shades of Murder

0:05
On March 31st, 1998 in Winter Park, FL, when a 19 year old
0:09
girl's body was discovered inside her dorm room, responders
0:12
were puzzled at the scene before them.
0:15
The victim was lying face down on the floor in a strange and
0:19
unnatural position. This homicide investigation
0:23
would take many twists and turns that no one could predict.
0:27
Who was this young woman, and will the monster who murdered
0:31
her on a college campus ever be brought to justice?
1:09
Hello and welcome to Shades of Murder.
1:12
I am your host Alita Caldwell. In this podcast, I discuss cases
1:17
of murder from around the world and throughout history,
1:21
attempting to unravel the layers of darkness that hell make
1:25
humans Fanta monsters. Please be forewarned that each
1:32
episode contains specific and at times very graphic and
1:37
disturbing details of the case. This show is not intended for
1:41
all audiences and listener discretion is strongly advised.
1:49
Rollins College in Winter Park, FL is a lush and beautiful
1:53
liberal arts school sometimes referred to by its students as
1:57
The Country Club. Rollins College sits near the
2:00
shores of Lake Virginia. This campus is breathtaking.
2:05
A tiny private school featuring gorgeous architecture and a
2:08
Spanish Mediterranean style. Lined with palm trees and brick
2:12
paths, the campus resembles more of a sanctuary than a college.
2:17
Established in 1885 by Lucy Cross, founder of the Daytona
2:21
Institute for Young Women, it has long been considered a
2:24
premier private college and by far one of the most impressive
2:28
looking. As of 20/24, it had 3029
2:33
students enrolled. It's undergraduate tuition and
2:36
fees begin at 58,300, so Needless to say, school is not
2:41
established for the unprivileged.
2:44
Born on July 18th and 70 in beautiful San Luis Obispo, CA,
2:48
Jennifer Carris had big dreams to be on stage.
2:52
She was absolutely thrilled when she was admitted to Rollins
2:55
College in Winter Park, FL. She was excited to be pursuing a
2:59
major in theatre there and had recently been dating a new guy,
3:02
Paul, a member of the school's Tau Kappa Epsilon fraternity.
3:07
When the 19 year old Co had failed to show up for her
3:10
morning classes on Monday, her friend Shannon O'Grady felt that
3:14
something was terribly wrong. It was not in her friend's
3:17
character to be a no show at school.
3:20
Jennifer Carris was midway through her sophomore year at
3:23
Rollins College and was known for being a reliable and good
3:26
student. Shannon reached out to
3:28
Jennifer's parents, telling them that she had been able to get in
3:31
touch with her. They frantically tried to reach
3:34
their daughter, but Jennifer never answered them, nor did she
3:38
call them back. She was very close to her family
3:41
and it was not normal behavior for her to just ignore them.
3:46
That Monday evening, Shannon decided to request that their
3:49
RA, or Resident Assistant of the dorm check on Jennifer in her
3:52
room. On March 31st around 9:30 PM, an
3:55
assistant, Carlos Barcia, used his master key to open
3:59
Jennifer's dorm room. He felt in his gut that
4:03
something was wrong. When he arrived, the door was
4:06
locked. When he opened the dorm room, he
4:09
was faced with a grisly sight. His mind could barely process
4:15
what he was seen and he felt the room begin to spin.
4:19
Jennifer Karis's body was on the floor, already stiffened from
4:23
rigor mortis. The teenage girl was awkwardly
4:26
lying between the floor and the bed with one of her legs propped
4:30
up in a very unnatural and suspicious position.
4:34
She was visibly deceased, stiff and blue.
4:38
The RA caller's Marcia immediately contacted local
4:40
police to report the discovery of the young woman's death.
4:45
When first responder John Flynn arrived at the scene, he
4:47
observed that the victim was lying face down.
4:49
Some kind of fluid appeared to be oozing from her mouth, likely
4:53
blood. Her legs were visibly bruised.
4:56
The victim was fully closed, except her skirt had been hiked
4:59
up from the front. The young woman's underwear had
5:02
been pulled over to the side. There was strong suspicion of a
5:07
rape or an attempted assault. It also seemed probable that the
5:10
victim had been abusing pills. Upon entering the scene, the
5:15
head detective noticed several things that raised concern.
5:20
The college students room was in abnormal disarray.
5:23
There were piles of clothing stacked in the corners of the
5:26
room and several bottles of pills sat on the dresser.
5:30
This scene was later identified as being particularly odd
5:33
because Jennifer Carris was not known for being a messy person.
5:38
The scene was so bizarre that police officers handled the case
5:42
as a homicide from the start. At 9:37 PM, nineteen year old
5:47
Jennifer Carris was declared officially dead.
5:51
Police covered the body with a comforter that had been lying on
5:54
the girl's bed. Winter Park law enforcement were
5:57
now investigating a murder. Jennifer Carris's body was
6:01
promptly sent to the pathologist for an autopsy to be performed.
6:04
In the interim of waiting for the report, Detective Fenn
6:07
interviewed Jennifer's fellow students and friends.
6:10
When he spoke to them, he learned that she had attended A
6:12
frat gathering with her boyfriend that Sunday night.
6:15
Before heading to the party, however, according to these
6:17
witnesses, she had four mixed cocktails and a beer at a
6:21
restaurant. According to witnesses at the
6:23
frat house, Tau Kappa Epsilon, Jennifer Karis appeared to be
6:26
highly intoxicated. One key piece of the story stood
6:29
out to Jennifer's friend Shannon.
6:31
And I didn't sit right with her. Everyone whom the police
6:34
interviewed who had been at the frat party Jennifer was at spoke
6:38
of how she appeared to be more out of it than they had ever
6:41
seen her before. They described her as being
6:44
completely wasted. But this was not normal behavior
6:48
for Jennifer, as she was not particularly known for being a
6:51
party girl. Several people reported that she
6:54
and her boyfriend, frat brother Paul, got into a heated
6:57
argument. Jennifer Carris was barely able
7:00
to walk. But instead of walking her
7:02
safely back to her dorm room at Ward Hall, her boyfriend Paul
7:06
decided to have one of his pledges take her back.
7:10
When officers interviewed, this pledge was simply identified as
7:13
a student named Tim. He claimed he half carried, half
7:17
dragged Jennifer back to her dorm and he let her inside and
7:20
she fell on the bed, barely conscious.
7:23
He watched as Jennifer began to gurgle.
7:27
Tim observed some bubbles around her mouth.
7:31
But instead of making sure the young woman was OK or calling
7:34
for help, Tim left her alone with the door unlocked.
7:40
The time had been around 3:00 AM on Sunday.
7:43
It also made no sense that if the pledge Tim had dropped
7:48
Jennifer off inside her dorm room at 3:00 AM, as he said, how
7:52
was it possible that her body wasn't discovered until 9:30 PM
7:59
the following night? That left an 18 hour window with
8:04
her dorm room unlocked, and no one noticed anything strange
8:09
about that. There was no way to determine
8:12
what had happened to Jennifer Karis over those 8 teen hours in
8:18
which she live, vulnerable and highly intoxicated, alone in her
8:22
room. Police did their best to be
8:24
patient and wait for the autopsy results, which surely would
8:28
clarify the circumstances surrounding this young woman's
8:31
death and its possible 'cause, but the report only led to more
8:36
questions. Jennifer Karis's autopsy was
8:39
originally performed by medical examiner Dr. Merle Reyes.
8:43
She observed how the deceased had multiple contusions on her
8:47
body. Specifically, there was a large
8:49
area of hemorrhaging around Jennifer's neck.
8:53
What was really surprising though, was when the toxicology
8:57
results returned. Jennifer Karis was not that
9:00
drunk the night she was killed. Despite the claims made by
9:04
multiple witnesses, autopsy results revealed an abnormally
9:09
high level of heart medication Jennifer occasionally took for
9:13
migraines. It was more than twice the
9:16
amount she would have needed to ingest to be at a toxic level.
9:21
Jennifer Kerr's blood also showed two different kinds of
9:23
antidepressants, another migraine drug and over the
9:26
counter cold medicine. Two additional pathologist,
9:29
Deputy Chief Medical Examiner Dr. William Anderson and Doctor
9:33
Sarah Urgang, agreed with Doctor Merle Ray's original findings
9:37
and signed off on the girl's death being a homicide.
9:41
According to Doctor Anderson, between the assault and the high
9:44
level of drugs present in her system, her heart was sensitized
9:47
by the substances and her neck being compressed led to a lack
9:52
of oxygen for a substantial period of time.
9:55
These two factors led to cardiac arrhythmia causing her death.
10:01
Initially announced on September 1st to the press as being a
10:05
homicide, it soon became clear that someone didn't want murder
10:09
to be the official cause of Jennifer Karis's death.
10:14
At the time of the initial autopsy, 3 veteran investigators
10:18
were all in agreement that Jennifer Karis had been
10:20
murdered. The homicide investigator on the
10:23
case, mind you, was the only investigator on the case and his
10:28
very first. At the time, he also believed
10:31
that the young woman been killed.
10:34
However, within just a few days, when Sergeant King was handed
10:38
over the case, this homicide detective changed his mind.
10:42
Brought on by Winter Park Police Sergeant R King's skepticism
10:46
regarding this determination, Chief Medical Examiner Dr.
10:50
Shashi Gore was brought into the fold.
10:53
Doctor Shashi Gore had more than 40 years of experience, but he
10:57
was not board certified in pathology.
11:00
Upon his examination of Jennifer Karis's body, Doctor Shashi Gore
11:04
decided that the initial conclusion for her cause of
11:06
death being declared as a homicide was wrong.
11:10
Doctor Gore stated that it was a mistake to claim that someone
11:14
had killed a college student and there was evidence to support
11:18
this change. He stated that in all
11:20
likelihood, the young woman had died from an accidental
11:24
overdose. Doctor Stephen J Nelson as well
11:27
as his assistant agreed with this new analysis.
11:31
As to the excessive bruising, both the Chief Medical Examiner
11:35
and the detectives explained these away by falling down while
11:38
intoxicated. However, staff members of Doctor
11:43
Gore's believed there was strong evidence that Jennifer Karis's
11:47
death have resulted from homicide without Doctor Gore's
11:51
knowledge. In the fall of 1998, Doctor
11:54
Merle Reyes, the original pathologist, took autopsy photos
11:58
with her to South Florida. There, she secretly met with
12:02
several investigators and pathologists presenting her
12:04
findings. Palm Beach County Medical
12:07
Examiner Dr. Jacqueline and Martin agreed after examining
12:11
the photos and facts of the crime scene that Jennifer
12:13
Caris's death was highly suspicious.
12:16
The scene did not appear to be 1 of an accidental nor intentional
12:21
overdose. Jennifer's injuries showed
12:23
evidence of a struggle. They were consistent with the
12:26
following scenario as she kicked at her assailant, doing her best
12:31
to fight him off. He pinned her to the ground,
12:33
face down, attempting to pull her legs apart, trying to rape
12:37
her. The injuries she sustained,
12:40
including multiple bruises and scrapes, were a direct result of
12:44
this attack. Chief Medical Examiner Dr. Gore
12:48
went so far to write a letter to Jennifer's parents claiming that
12:52
Doctor Mulreys had agreed with his new determination of her
12:55
death. Their daughter, who had been
12:57
senselessly and brutally murdered, would not receive
13:01
justice. The cause of her death was now
13:04
being placed solely upon Jennifer.
13:08
Following the autopsy performed by Doctor Gore, the description
13:11
of the neck trauma was changed from being substantial to
13:14
minimal, resulting in Jennifer's death being declared and
13:18
accidental overdose. However, what was not realized
13:21
or addressed at the time was how photos that showed serious
13:26
markings on Jennifer's neck, which had been the primary
13:29
determining factor in homicide, being her cause of death, were
13:34
not found within the original autopsy file.
13:38
The only photos that proved this young woman had been brutally
13:42
murdered had since vanished. Doctor Anderson and Doctor Reyes
13:47
had taken several photographs of Jennifer's neck area to support
13:52
their decision of homicide, but now only one of the photos
13:56
remained in the file when it was passed over to Doctor Shashi
13:59
Gore to analyze. The rest of them had
14:03
disappeared. The case closed in 1999, but
14:07
thanks to an inquisitive reporter from the Orlando
14:09
Sentinel, interest in Jennifer Carris's case resurfaced.
14:13
In January 2004, they released a report addressing the gross
14:18
mishandling of Jennifer Carris's death and subsequent
14:21
investigation. This is when The Dirty little
14:23
secrets surrounding the Winter Park Police Department and its
14:26
medical Examiner's office would be exposed.
14:30
It wouldn't be until six years had passed that the original
14:33
pathologist would speak the truth.
14:35
Doctor Merle Reyes, who had performed the initial autopsy
14:38
that led to the conclusion of Jennifer's cause of death being
14:41
homicide, had been pushed aside by Chief Medical Examiner Dr.
14:46
Shashi Gore, who then reversed her decision.
14:50
Doctor Merle Reyes claimed that she was pressured to step away,
14:53
and she feared she would lose her job if she spoke up against
14:57
the Chief Medical Examiner. Ever since Doctor Reyes was
15:01
forced to leave her position as a pathologist on Jennifer
15:04
Karis's case back in 1998, she had been silent about the
15:08
reverse decision. But now she stated that she
15:12
never swayed away from her initial decision and that she
15:15
believed Jennifer Karis had been a victim of foul play.
15:19
This contradictory statement by the original pathologist led to
15:23
many questions surrounding the investigation into Jennifer
15:27
Karis's death. This new statement by the
15:29
original pathologist surfaced when the county recently hired a
15:33
board certified pathologist to replace Doctor Shashi Gore.
15:38
What was the purpose of Chief Medical Examiner Dr. Gore
15:42
suddenly intervening in the case and insisting on performing his
15:46
own autopsy unless someone had an invested interest in changing
15:52
its outcome somewhat? Or multiple persons did not want
15:55
this case to be declared A homicide and they went to
15:58
extreme but blatantly obvious links to change the results, It
16:03
would be revealed that the Winter Park Police had failed to
16:05
perform any due diligence on this poor young woman's death.
16:10
When the rape kit was performed on Jennifer Carris's body,
16:13
several perishable swabs were held by its lead investigator.
16:18
The rape kit sat at the morgue for 10 weeks before he finally
16:23
sent it to the lab for testing. A strand of hair was discovered
16:26
inside Jennifer's mouth and on her body, neither which were
16:30
ever tested. The samples were never sent to a
16:33
lab to determine whether the hair belonged to Jennifer Carris
16:36
or someone else. Perhaps even more disturbing is
16:40
how her murder was the investigators first homicide
16:43
case as aforementioned, who was then later fired from the police
16:47
force for unknown reasons. The truth was out in the open
16:51
for everyone to read. Tragically, everything,
16:54
including all case files and evidence were destroyed in 2002.
17:00
Once this report was published, Dr. Shashi Gore soon became the
17:05
center of high controversy and was severely criticized for
17:10
errors he made in other unrelated autopsies.
17:14
He would quickly and quietly disappear into retirement.
17:18
As a result of this story, which clearly illustrated the gross
17:22
neglect and lack of due diligence performed by the
17:25
Winter Park Police Department, the State Attorney of Florida
17:28
reopened Jennifer Karis case. Doctor Bruce Goldberger was
17:33
assigned to review and analyze the neck injury photos.
17:36
This resulted in yet again, a change in Jennifer Karis's
17:40
official cause of death. Doctor Goldberger now determined
17:43
that her official cause of death was suicide.
17:47
He posited, based on the evidence he was provided, that
17:51
Jennifer Carris had intentionally taken an overdose
17:53
of pills and then locked the door behind her.
17:56
Doctor Goldberger further suggested the excessive bruising
17:59
on Jennifer's body was caused by seizures.
18:02
Jennifer's parents and friend Shannon were not buying this new
18:06
version of events they were being sold.
18:09
The family requested then Governor Jeb Bush to bring in an
18:12
outside medical examiner so they could look at their daughter's
18:16
case and her autopsy results. They wanted an independent
18:20
investigation performed since there was a need for resolution
18:24
and what they deemed to be the dueling medical examiners.
18:28
Bruce Heima, Chief Medical Examiner for Miami-Dade County,
18:31
who was also an expert toxicologist, was hired by State
18:34
Attorney Lawson Lama to conduct an extensive review of the
18:38
results on March 4th, 2004, almost six years after her
18:42
murder, after Hyman now declared that their daughter had
18:45
committed suicide through the use of various prescription
18:48
drugs. Again, the critical photographs
18:52
that showed the severe hemorrhaging done to Jennifer
18:55
Carris's neck were gone, so it wasn't realistic or practical
19:00
that the findings would revert back to homicide.
19:04
Any possibility that they would receive justice for their
19:07
daughter's murder was destroyed when these pictures were
19:11
intentionally lost. Jennifer Carris's case was
19:14
officially closed on April 13th, 2005.
19:19
There are so many questions regarding Jennifer Carris's
19:22
death that remain unanswered. The investigation into this
19:25
young one's brutal and bizarre murder barely existed, and the
19:29
little that was done only supports the theory that her
19:32
homicide was covered up. The most obvious suspects were
19:37
her boyfriend Paul, who multiple witnesses saw get into an
19:40
altercation with the victim at the party, and Tim, his pledge,
19:44
whom he requested take his girlfriend Jennifer back to her
19:47
dorm. Without any known details of
19:49
their interviews with the police, it is difficult to
19:52
understand why exactly these two young men were ruled out as
19:55
suspects in her murder. Nevertheless, both of them were
19:58
soon eliminated as being the potential perpetrator.
20:02
There didn't appear to be any other leads or possible suspects
20:06
in the crime. There was always the possibility
20:08
that Paul ended up going over to Jennifer's dorm room that night
20:11
in which things became violent, except you would think there
20:15
would have been some sign or sounds made that she was in
20:19
trouble. The same applies to Tim,
20:21
although he seems to be the more likely suspect in this crime.
20:24
He had the means, motive and opportunity.
20:28
The crime may have been motivated by rage, jealousy and
20:31
or lust. This is not to blame Tim as I
20:34
have no information about this young man to believe that he is
20:37
a sexual predator who murdered a young woman.
20:40
But I can say that he lacks integrity and has questionable
20:44
morals for leaving a young woman alone in her room who was not
20:47
only visibly intoxicated from something, but was showing
20:50
possible signs of an overdose with the door unlocked.
20:54
What kind of person does that? I understand that he was a
20:58
teenager and a very scared one, but there are anonymous ways to
21:01
let someone know that a person may be in need of medical care.
21:05
Or even if it hadn't been that serious of a situation, why
21:09
would you just abandoned her and not make sure she locked the
21:12
door behind her before you left? Or knock on one of the coeds
21:16
doors and ask them to check in on her?
21:19
There is no information as to what Tim did after leaving her
21:22
dorm room. For that matter, there is no
21:25
information as to who Tim was at all outside of being her
21:30
boyfriend Paul's frat pledge. There are no last names of these
21:34
young men, which may be the key as to why this murder was not
21:39
properly investigated and subsequently covered up.
21:43
Who were Paul's parents? Who were Tim's parents?
21:46
Were they connected with law enforcement or were the major
21:49
beneficiaries of this elite private school?
21:53
I am merely speculating on who and why could be behind this
21:57
obvious conspiracy. There are questions which remain
22:01
of a practical sense that also don't add up from what is known.
22:05
Between Tim claiming that he left the door unlocked when he
22:08
left, Jennifer barely conscious on the bed that night, and the
22:10
resident assistant stating that the door was locked, we must
22:13
presume that someone inside the room locked the door.
22:17
Hypothetically, could it have been Tim or Paul who then snuck
22:20
outside the window to leave? I mean, there is no information
22:24
as to how many floors the dormitory had or what kind of
22:27
windows and doors it was equipped with.
22:29
What if the door lock was one that you can lock from inside
22:32
and then close behind you? To play the devil's advocate,
22:35
what if Jennifer Cares had been the one to ultimately lock the
22:39
door? That sure as hell doesn't
22:40
explain why her skirt was hiked up, her panties pulled to the
22:44
side, and her leg unnaturally posed on the bed.
22:48
Nothing explains the excessive bruising she had around her
22:51
neck, which indicates asphyxiation.
22:55
That is not an injury you can inflict yourself while having
22:58
convulsions. On a personal note, I
23:00
experienced multiple seizures in college and not once did I
23:03
bruise any part of my body. People don't typically stand up
23:06
while convulsing and bumping to walls.
23:09
There were also multiple bruising along her legs, which
23:12
was very unlikely to be caused by her falling down drunk.
23:16
Not unless she fell off a curb or down a stairwell.
23:20
It was also addressed by the resident assistant himself,
23:22
Carlos Barcia, in the episode Justice for Jennifer on the
23:26
series Accident, Suicide or Murder.
23:28
How he found it very odd and troubling that no one in law
23:32
enforcement had ever interviewed him.
23:34
Yes, that's right. The man who discovered a young
23:37
college girl dead in her room in a very provocative and
23:41
suspicious manner was never talked to by the police.
23:46
He had to forcefully open her door.
23:49
And yet the detective, if you can even call him that, never
23:53
asked this man questions. The first person who found her
23:56
deceased was never interviewed. Think about that for a moment.
24:01
How many cases have we all heard of where the first person at the
24:05
crime scene who claims they were the ones that found the body is
24:09
in fact the one who did it? I don't suspect that RA on any
24:13
level, but that was his point, that if the investigation had
24:17
been thorough, he should have been viewed as a potential
24:20
suspect from the start who needed to be interviewed and
24:23
eliminated. Jennifer Kerr's parents not only
24:26
refused to believe that her death was accidental, but they
24:30
were never given any legitimate explanation as to how she had
24:33
received substantial bruising around her neck and on her legs.
24:37
Jennifer Kerr's parents firmly believe that their daughter was
24:41
raped and murdered by her boyfriend, Paul.
24:44
This case doesn't only expose a major conspiracy in covering up
24:49
this young woman's homicide, but it speaks to a larger issue at
24:52
hand, being sexual violence committed against females, in
24:56
particular college students. Despite its alarmingly high
25:00
prevalence, this crisis is not given the resources and
25:04
attention it demands. CSA, also known as campus sexual
25:09
assault, comprises somewhere between 28% and 43% of all on
25:15
campus crimes that occur at secondary institutions in the
25:18
United States. Of the known recorded incidents,
25:21
the rate is approximately 8 forcible sex offenses per 10,000
25:26
students. Females are not the only ones
25:28
being victims of sexual assault on college campuses.
25:30
Research shows that one in 16 male college students will
25:34
experience sexual assault, and some studies show as high as 19%
25:40
of male students experience some kind of unwanted sexual contact.
25:45
What is deeply concerning is that according to the Bureau of
25:47
Justice Statistics, who attend college are 78% more likely to
25:52
become victims of CSA compared to men of the same age who don't
25:56
participate and secondary education.
25:59
As in most incidents of sexual assault, females are
26:02
overwhelmingly the victims of campus sexual assault.
26:05
However, interestingly, the risk goes slightly down when a female
26:08
attends a school of higher education.
26:10
They are 20% less likely to be victims compared to women who
26:14
don't attend college. The beginning of a new school
26:17
year between August and November is referred to as the Red Zone,
26:21
and there is a strong correlation between the
26:24
frequency of social gatherings that take place this time of the
26:27
year and the rate of sexual assault.
26:29
Data supported that 50% of campus sexual assaults occur
26:33
during this part of the school year, and new students are
26:36
especially vulnerable to becoming victims.
26:39
Prompted by the 1986 rape and murder of a 19 year old college
26:43
student in her dorm room. The Clary Act requires that
26:46
universities and colleges report crime statistics to the
26:50
Department of Education. The Clary Act was recently
26:54
amended in 2000 which increase the repercussions post secondary
26:59
institutions will face, including strict financial
27:02
penalties if it is discovered they have misreported these
27:06
findings. The penalty is set at $27,500
27:10
per incident not reported. However, the Clary Act does not
27:14
require that these institutions report the data to the Uniform
27:17
Crime Reporting Program every year.
27:21
When a female code embarks on a journey of higher education, she
27:24
is faced with a high risk of becoming a victim of sexual
27:28
violence. The data clearly shows that
27:30
college students are significantly more likely to be
27:33
sexually harassed, stalked, and sexually assaulted.
27:36
What is this a reflection of? Our embedded rape culture
27:39
combined with various environmental elements leads to
27:42
approximately 1 in four undergraduate college females
27:46
being a victim of rape or attempted rape.
27:48
It is estimated that of the known assaults, 4 out of five
27:52
are reported. Of those that are, they seldom
27:55
receive any justice. An investigative story published
27:58
in 2022 revealed that colleges and universities on average
28:03
suspended 1 out of 12,400 students who were accused of
28:08
sexual offenses and only one in 22,900 were expelled from the
28:14
school. The number of reported forcible
28:16
sexual offenses saw a massive increase between 2009 and 2019,
28:22
going up 363%. It is estimated that 90% of
28:31
incidents are never reported. With the many challenges
28:35
prosecutors face and therefore proving cases of rape, in
28:38
particular what is referred to as date or acquaintance assault,
28:42
in addition to the hyper protective and often defensive
28:46
behavior exhibited by institutions of higher
28:49
education, nothing much seems to change.
28:51
Although there is no exact data on the prevalence of sexual
28:54
assaults committed by members of the Greek system, multiple
28:57
studies have shown that members of fraternities are three times
29:01
more likely to commit rape. Often times, excessive alcohol
29:05
and drug use is pointed to be the culprit, the main trigger
29:09
for such violent behavior, with alcohol overwhelmingly being the
29:13
tool used by rapists. This only serves to provide
29:16
these young men with an excuse, an explanation for why they
29:20
thought or didn't care, whether or not a girl wanted to or was
29:24
even capable of saying yes. Sorority houses are not
29:27
permitted to throw their own parties with alcohol, which
29:30
means that a great majority of parties on campus and off campus
29:34
are being held at frat houses, which are male dominated and
29:37
completely controlled by them. Female members of sororities are
29:41
74% more likely to be raped than other college women.
29:47
What I find to be the most disturbing about these facts is
29:50
that individuals attending college are expected to be the
29:54
brightest and potentially most successful and powerful
29:58
individuals in our society. These are the young men who will
30:02
shape and direct the institutions that run our
30:05
communities. Yet somewhere along the way they
30:08
are being instilled with an innate lack of respect for
30:12
females and their bodies. How is it possible that within
30:15
the institutions that represent higher education and
30:18
enlightenment, and which ideally generate the best members of
30:22
society, lay the darkest and most violent of individuals?
30:26
Parents place their faith and trust and a great deal of
30:31
financial investment in these institutions.
30:33
They encourage their children to become pillars of society,
30:37
pursue higher education and become more enlightened and
30:40
well-rounded individuals. But they are something very dark
30:44
and troubling occurring at colleges and universities around
30:48
this country. And there have been many
30:49
incidents where school officials and Deans don't follow set
30:53
protocol nor did they ever pursue justice for these
30:56
victims. They are too invested in their
30:59
academic reputation to tarnish the image of the schools.
31:03
And due to this reason in itself, not enough is being done
31:06
to combat this epidemic of sexual violence being committed
31:10
against their female students. In the case of Jennifer Karis,
31:14
we may never know who was behind wanting to conceal her assault
31:18
and murder. It is evident that someone or
31:20
multiple individuals were highly invested and committed to making
31:24
sure no one paid for her death. It is asinine to me how little
31:29
was done by officials in law enforcement and the medical
31:31
examiner's office to try to convince anyone of the story
31:35
they are selling to her family and loved ones.
31:39
An accidental overdose could have been believable had it not
31:44
been for the strong physical evidence of a sexual assault and
31:47
the violence that ensued. These facts can't be erased from
31:51
the case, no matter what the one remaining photograph indicates.
31:56
It makes you wonder what level of corruption exists within the
31:59
Winter Park Police Department and potentially across all of
32:03
Florida for this kind of nonsense and injustice to take
32:07
place and almost no one his ringing conspiracy bells
32:13
screaming cover up around it. It also needs to be addressed
32:18
how Jennifer Karis takes off every box of the typical victim
32:22
who would normally be plastered across the media.
32:24
She was a young, attractive white female, in particular a
32:28
blonde from an affluent family. And yet somehow there was and
32:32
still is minimal media coverage of this case.
32:36
Jennifer Karis's death was the first recorded homicide on
32:40
Rollins campus over it's 113 years in existence.
32:45
It seems obvious that multiple persons were invested in its
32:49
prestige and danger free reputation and had too much at
32:53
stake to let this change. They had far reaching power to
32:58
silence the media and buy off the police and medical examiner.
33:02
We may never know who assaulted Jennifer Carris and caused her
33:06
brutal, senseless death. It is officially a closed case,
33:10
and the only thing that could hypothetically change this is if
33:13
someone came forward who knew something about what happened to
33:16
her that night. But even if someone did, would
33:20
the truth ever be allowed to come out?
33:23
My gut tells me that her violent perpetrator was someone who's a
33:27
wealthy and highly influential family would not allow their
33:31
male heirs future to be tarnished with the label of
33:34
rapist, much less murderer. Thank you so much for listening
33:42
to the intriguing and tragic story of Jennifer Karis.
33:45
Please let me know your thoughts on this case.
33:47
If you have any comments, questions, or ideas for future
33:50
episodes, I would love to hear from you.
33:52
Please reach out. I wanted to sincerely apologize
33:55
for the inconsistency of my releasing episodes as of late.
33:59
Within the last couple months, I upgraded my recording software,
34:03
but like any software and technology, there's a learning
34:07
curve and lots of issues have come into play.
34:10
If you enjoy the show and have not already followed or
34:13
subscribed, please make sure you are doing so on your platform of
34:16
choice. And if you would be so kind to
34:18
please make sure to just take a moment and rate the show.
34:22
It means a lot to me personally and it really helps to circulate
34:26
the show so it and get to other dear listeners.
34:29
I appreciate it very much. Until next time, stay safe and
34:34
watch over Shades of Murder happening in the streets next
34:38
door, especially inside your own home.
34:42
Shades of Murder is created, researched, written and edited
34:46
by Alito Caldwell. Original music stranger composed
34:51
by Stereo Code.