Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Lateral Move Without Looking Like You Are Quitting
Transcript
- Lucas: A listener wrote in this week — let’s call her Priya — and she’s a commercial lender at a large regional bank. She’s been in the role for three years, she’s hitting her numbers, but she’s realized she actually wants to move into the risk analytics team. Same pay band, same title level, just a different function. Luna: So a lateral move. Which sounds simple in theory but in practice, I’ve seen people get seriously side-eyed for it. Lucas: Exactly. And that’s the core problem. A promotion is a clear signal — you’re being rewarded. A lateral move is ambiguous. Your manager might hear: ‘I’m bored’ or ‘I don’t like working for you.’ And HR might see it as you being a flight risk. Luna: Right, because if you’re willing to move sideways, you might be willing to move out entirely. Lucas: Priya’s situation is actually textbook. She’s good at lending, but she’s been volunteering on a cross-functional project building a credit risk model. She realized she likes the data side more than the client side. So she needs to ask for a transfer without making her current manager feel like she’s rejecting his team. Luna: So what’s the first move? Do you go to your manager first or to the hiring manager in the new team? Lucas: Always your current manager first. If they hear it from someone else, you’ve already created trust issues. But here’s the key — you don’t frame it as ‘I want to leave.’ You frame it as ‘I want to grow my skills in a way that also benefits this team.’ And you tie it to a specific business need. Luna: So what did Priya actually say in that first conversation? Lucas: She wrote a draft email that she showed me. The subject line was ‘Career development conversation — building on the credit risk project.’ In the body, she said: ‘I’ve really enjoyed working on the risk model and I’d like to explore how I can contribute more in that area while ensuring a smooth transition on my current portfolio.’ Luna: That’s smart. She’s not saying she’s done with lending. She’s saying she wants to add a new layer. Lucas: And she’s explicitly addressing the biggest fear a manager has: ‘What happens to my team’s work?’ By saying ‘smooth transition on my current portfolio,’ she’s signaling she’s not going to just drop everything and leave a mess. Luna: I think a lot of people skip that part. They just say ‘I’m interested in X team’ and the manager immediately goes to ‘who’s going to cover my deals?’ Lucas: Exactly. So rule one: solve the coverage problem before you ask. Priya actually mapped out her loan portfolio, identified which clients could be handed off to a junior lender she’s been mentoring, and which ones would need a more senior person. She brought that to the meeting. Luna: That’s a lot of prep. Did her manager respond well? Lucas: He was initially hesitant. He said ‘you’re our top performer, I don’t want to lose you.’ And that’s when Priya used what I call the ‘both-and’ framing. She said: ‘I want to keep contributing to this team’s success, and I want to build expertise that makes me more valuable to the bank long term.’ Luna: So she’s not choosing between the two. She’s saying they’re connected. Lucas: And she backed it up with a skills transfer grid — a simple document that lists the skills she’s built in lending that would be useful in risk, and the skills she’d gain in risk that she could bring back to the lending team if needed. It made the move look like a strategic rotation, not a resignation. Luna: I’ve never heard of a skills transfer grid. What does that actually look like? Lucas: It’s a two-column table. Left column: what I bring from my current role — things like credit analysis, client relationship management, regulatory knowledge. Right column: what I’ll learn in the new role — data modeling, stress testing, SAS programming. Then at the bottom, one row that says ‘how this benefits the bank’ and you link it to a strategic goal. Luna: So it’s basically a business case for your own career move. Lucas: Exactly. And it works because it takes the emotion out of it. You’re not asking for a favor. You’re proposing a resource allocation decision. And that’s a language managers understand. Luna: But what if your manager still says no? I mean, some managers will block a lateral move because they don’t want to lose headcount. Lucas: That’s a real risk. If that happens, you have a choice. You can escalate to HR or to a senior leader, but that’s a relationship-burner. A better move is to ask for a six-month secondment instead of a permanent transfer. It’s less threatening to the manager because you’re technically still on their books. And often, after six months, the secondment becomes permanent because everyone sees it works. Luna: That’s a great fallback. And it shows you’re flexible. Lucas: Priya actually went that route. Her manager agreed to a three-month secondment to the risk team with a check-in at the end. That was six weeks ago. She told me last week that the risk team has already asked her to stay, and her old manager is fine with it because he’s seen the handoff work. Luna: So the secondment became the bridge. That’s a really clean outcome. Lucas: The key lesson for anyone listening: a lateral move is not a career pause. It’s a career acceleration, but you have to sell it that way. And you have to do the prep work so your manager doesn’t have to wonder what happens next. Luna: Speaking of prep work — a lot of what we talk about on this show comes from questions you send in. And if you’ve ever gotten value from an episode, I’ll just say this: a couple of dollars a month genuinely makes a difference in keeping these episodes ad-free and accessible. It’s at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Lucas: Yeah, seriously. Even the price of a coffee helps cover hosting and production. And it means we can keep answering questions like Priya’s without any sponsored content. Luna: Exactly. So back to the lateral move — I think one thing we haven’t covered is timing. When is the worst time to ask for a lateral move? Lucas: Right after you’ve made a mistake or missed a deadline. You never want it to look like you’re running away from a problem. The best time is right after a win — after you’ve closed a big deal, or after you’ve delivered a project. That’s when you have the most leverage and the least suspicion. Luna: So capitalise on momentum. Priya timed hers after the risk model project got positive feedback from the chief credit officer. Lucas: Exactly. And one more thing — when you do get the transfer, don’t forget to thank your old manager publicly. Send a note to their boss, copy your manager, saying how much you appreciated their support. That kind of goodwill pays off if you ever want to go back or work with them again. Luna: It also makes you look generous, which is rare in office politics. A lot of people just disappear into the new role and the old manager feels used. Lucas: So the playbook: prepare the coverage plan, frame it as growth not escape, bring a skills transfer grid, propose a secondment if needed, and time it after a success. Follow that and you’ve got a real shot. Luna: And if you’re like Priya and you’ve done the work, the move almost sells itself. Lucas: Alright, that’s it for this episode. Priya, we’re rooting for you. And to everyone else — send us your career questions. We read every one.