Latest / Building A Zoo / Building A Zoo 4.4.2024
Transcript
- 0:19Hi, I'm Michael P. Hamans. I'm here to talk to you all
- 0:21about lawn society, lots of society. We're at w CCF fifteen eighty AM.
- 0:27It's news radio, talk radio Gone Wild. It's one hundred point nine
- 0:31on the FM dial, fifteen eighty on the AM dial. We're out across
- 0:35the Worldwide Web on an iHeart platform wccf AM dot com. You can go
- 0:42and take a look at that w CCFAM dot com and get the live show.
- 0:47You can also find the archives and so you just go to that top
- 0:53left and click on the three bars and it'll do a drop down, go
- 0:57down to partners, not live shows, but partners and UH and so those
- 1:03of us who buy time from iHeartMedia are called partners, and that's how it
- 1:08gets set up on the web page. So drop down to partners, click
- 1:12on that, go to building a Zoo and then you can go into the
- 1:15archives. And Zane says they're all up to date, so you can catch
- 1:19all of the shows right on back through. Yes, I swear, so
- 1:23take a look at him. The UH we're because of the world Wide Web.
- 1:30UH and Facebook live here at Michael P. Hayman's and Zane Scott Bickerstaff.
- 1:34Uh. You can uh listen to us all over the place, from
- 1:38Alaska where my uncle where my brother branches, to uh to uh to Taiwan
- 1:45where doctor Jeffrey McElroy is and Jeffrey is fine. We talked to him uh
- 1:49after actually during the earthquake while it was going on. It was the in
- 1:56that portition of Taipei that he's in, that was five points something on the
- 2:00scale. Other part of Taiwan seven points something on the scale. Not much
- 2:08damage right there around where he was. There was some cabinets opened, there
- 2:15was some tiles fell off the walls, there was some cracks and the stairways.
- 2:21He was on the ninth floor. He got out, got down stairs
- 2:23and outside, and we talked to him while there were aftershocks going on.
- 2:29But he's he's okay, and things are going to be mostly okay because of
- 2:36all of the building codes and the preparation for this kind of event, these
- 2:42kinds of earthquakes. Of course, that's set off tsunami warnings all around there,
- 2:49like to Okinawa such as that, But I don't think any of the
- 2:51tsunamis developed. The we'll listened to because of this world wide web not quite
- 2:58worldwide. We don't get into China. We don't get into a number of
- 3:00places, some places because of licensing, some places because of firewalls. But
- 3:05we're listening to in Hawaii with my son Dylan and his wife Jody and their
- 3:09kids. Hey, Bertie, it's Pappy. I love you, And I
- 3:15love that brother of yours, Hanker. He's a bazooka, that boy.
- 3:17These kids are deeply involved in swimming and other activities within their school. They're
- 3:23great kids, and I'm very proud of them. We're listening to in Mexico.
- 3:30We're listened to in Montana with Parks, Reese and his friends and cohorts
- 3:37Robin Hogan. There's probably a whole handful of list of them that I could
- 3:43uh list out. I hope too. I know that we're listening to every
- 3:46now and then by Scott mcmillion, editor in chief of the Montana Quarterly.
- 3:52UH. Parks is a sponsor of the show. As a matter of fact,
- 3:57he's been a sponsor since early on. Parks and I have known each
- 4:00other since nineteen seventy two at East Carolina University. We've run together, traveled
- 4:08the world together. Our families have taken vacations together. We hunt almost most
- 4:15years. For thirty years, we hunted in Montana and we've hunted elsewhere.
- 4:18But he's an artist of really great talent. He's well loved and respected in
- 4:27his hometown there of Livingston, Montana, and throughout the state of Montana and
- 4:32through the north West. He's acclaimed and for good reason. Go take a
- 4:40look at at his work. Parks P. A. R. Ks Reese
- 4:44R. E. C. Parks Reese and you can find him on Facebook.
- 4:46You can find him at his website. Take a look at his work.
- 4:54Beautiful handling of color and images. His He dwells in a surreal place
- 5:05between dreams and meditation uh in uh natural places uh and and and he makes
- 5:16social commentary and uses humor in in that. So take a look at Parks's
- 5:23work and you'll you'll want some and please buy something. He'll be appreciative.
- 5:28Uh. We'll listened to in Texas. We were just if you've listened to
- 5:31the last few shows, you know, we've been to Texas for a wedding.
- 5:36Uh. And that was beautiful and nagadocius. We flew into Austin and
- 5:42drove across the countryside for four hours to Nagadocius and beautiful drive in the springtime
- 5:48in Texas. You know, I've got friends. I've been invited to go
- 5:54back to Texas for the for the eclipse, but I think we're gonna stick
- 6:00close instead of going to that. The UH but Texas is this is a
- 6:05nice time of year to be there and UH. And so the Mazingo clan
- 6:10is there in UH in Texas and they and their friends hopefully are getting to
- 6:15tune in every now and then for us the UH Denver, Colorado. UH.
- 6:20Rob Hartung listens to us there. UH. I've just been invited to
- 6:25to make a presentation in Denver, Colorado June seventh through ninth, UH because
- 6:31the city of Pontagordas is and running for a Best Small City in the United
- 6:40States, a program national program by the League of City Cities, and so
- 6:47looking forward to maybe making a trip there and making a presentation. UH.
- 6:51I'll get back to those who invited me and let them know that, yes,
- 6:56I'm gonna make that trip with them. UH. The we'll listened to
- 7:00and we'll catch up with Rob Hartung at the time. I hope we'll listened
- 7:04to out across the northern tier of these United States, from Minnesota straight on
- 7:10across to Maine, Maine right on down the eastern seaboard through Rhode Island.
- 7:15A lot to do with the connections and friends that we've made through Chi Coula
- 7:20Smith and I have to tell you there's a lot of Rhode Island people down
- 7:25here in southwest Florida. So we've made connections through all of that. The
- 7:31we'll listened to in North Carolina from high Point to actually Raleigh, to high
- 7:38Point where doctor C. M. Kirby and his wife Jeannie lived, the
- 7:41h to Asheville, North Carolina, where Craig Atkinopoly my Judo Sinse lives.
- 7:47In Carson and Sandusky Paris. We were hoping that we would get to see
- 7:55them at Easter time here, but Sandusky's mother has passed, and so condolences
- 8:01to the family and thinking about you. She was a delightful woman we met
- 8:09at the wedding when Carson and Sandusky got married, but they're there with their
- 8:16children, little Lloy and Sabine. Carson is the daughter of another of our
- 8:22friends, Parks recent and my friend and Sam Kirby's friend from North Carolina from
- 8:30our days at East Carolina University, Lloyd Dellenger, and Lloyd's passed in a
- 8:35car wreck April first. April first, and sometimes it's a cruel joke.
- 8:41We got Lloyd died on April first. My mother passed on April first and
- 8:46twenty twenty, so I always go through that April Fool's Day with a little
- 8:54of a little bit of a heavy heart. But left the legacy of love.
- 9:01He also left Carolina cajun It's it's good on most everything. It's so
- 9:05good on chicken that there's a guarantee. What's that guarantee zing? To get
- 9:07a better piece of chicken? You got to be a rooster. That's right.
- 9:11I saw the look on your face. I knew we were going to
- 9:13do it. So ride the rooster on down through Florida, through Polk County
- 9:20with Elton, my uncle Elton and his clan, down to our local listing
- 9:24area, from Arcadia to Boka Green, from Venice to a Stero and all
- 9:30the points in between. However you got here. Thanks for being here.
- 9:33I see people are showing up on the Facebook as as watching, and so
- 9:39thanks for doing that. Hey, Rick Odom is a really long time good
- 9:43friend and he tunes in all the time. Thanks Rick very much. The
- 9:46UH. You know, here in this part of the world, we've got
- 9:52a lot of politics and it's UH and it's been driven by the Republican Party
- 10:01for a long time, and in many ways they've been very disciplined in their
- 10:09approach to imposing their control over the politics of Florida and UH, and that's
- 10:16going to be part of our discussion here this morning. UH. We're going
- 10:20to talk about the Supreme Court of Florida's opinion ruling that was handed down on
- 10:28April first, another joke, the planned parenthood of Southwest and Central Florida versus
- 10:35the State of Florida. And and so we'll get talking about that. That
- 10:41has to do with the UH, the Florida's constitutional right to privacy and enumerated
- 10:48right and what does the Supreme Court think that that means and in their review
- 10:54how that was view was affected by the rovers way and then the and then
- 11:01the rejection of Roe versus Weight in the Dobbs decision Dobbs versus Mississippi. So
- 11:09we're gonna have a big discussion about that. But here in Ponta Gorda,
- 11:13we've got music that surrounds Us in many ways. We've had We had on
- 11:22on Monday, we had the Happy Hour at Becky's Garden Shop and that was
- 11:28fabulous. I was at Judo and I wasn't there for it, but I
- 11:33understand that there was a very big crowd one hundred and fifty almost two hundred
- 11:37people to that. That will happen again May sixth, the last one of
- 11:41the season, and Becky's Garden Shop. If you haven't seen Becky's Garden Shop,
- 11:46you need to get down and see that and buy some plants and buy
- 11:50some curio from her. But on on the first Monday of the month during
- 11:56seasons, there's there's a happy hour. Music that gets played and so Coolah
- 12:05Smith is deeply involved in that. We have the Hibiscus Festival that's coming up,
- 12:11and that's three days of music. We've been really working hard to try
- 12:16to pull that together. We have the Friday night lineup, we have Saturday
- 12:20and Sunday just about nailed down. I'm sorry that it's taken me a little
- 12:24bit longer than I intended to nail down Saturday and Sunday, but that's all
- 12:28coming and a lot of that grew out of the punagorda guitar army neo beatnik
- 12:33revolutionary ensemble that's been meeting in Gilchrist Park for thirty years. And so tonight
- 12:41Thursday night at the Gazebo you can find people playing, probably in a couple
- 12:46of circles. It's gotten bigger again and so it's spinning off circles into the
- 12:50other parts of the park. But show up at Gilchris Park if you want
- 12:54to at the Gazebo if you want to hear some good music and have some
- 12:58lively social interaction with the music scene in this part of our world. One
- 13:05of the people who plays there and who's also going to play at the at
- 13:09the High Biscus Festival, Karen Cone. Karen is playing tomorrow night at Divines,
- 13:16and so at seven o'clock, I think those of you who know Divines
- 13:22is over there off of it's Peach at the intersection of Peach Linnen Veterans,
- 13:28and you can find it Divines. And so we're gonna let Karen Cohen start
- 13:35us off with the Devil and a bar Napkin number one from our CD that
- 13:41was put together JJ John Jensen at JJ's Peace River Studio, Florida, All
- 13:52vocals and guitars by Karen Cohen. Recording recorded live at JJ's Peace River Studio,
- 13:56Florida. Let's listen to Karen Cohn The Devil in the bar. Napkin.
- 14:11Take this here, napkin, honey, a perfect square of white.
- 14:16It'll soak up all your feeling, Wrap your fears up tight, Wipe down
- 14:22all your questions, blot up while you speak up, folding all your value,
- 14:28bring out all your love. Take this here, drink now. Darting
- 14:37we headed for the blind, I'll put your number in my pocket. Up
- 14:46the dreams you left behind. Take this here, nackin a perfect square of
- 15:01lies, to dap back what's hiding nesting it in your eyes. There ain't
- 15:07no pois on it. A simple baby square from a place a broken heartstide,
- 15:15a bar that's named nowhere. So take another drink now, darling,
- 15:24where another flye. I'll put your numbers in my pocket. Dreams you left
- 15:35me hide, got this one last napkin. HOI dates on it for you,
- 15:48first one with the devil and the last ones with the blues. Take
- 15:56your last drink now, darling, Really, even before the blind got your
- 16:04number in my pocket. Uh, dreams you left behind. Yeah, So
- 16:22Karen Cohen is going to be playing as I saw say it Divines tomorrow night.
- 16:26She's playing uh on Friday night at the High Biscus Festival. Uh.
- 16:33She's uh, she's she's branched out from her from her blues a little bit,
- 16:41but uh, but she's really uh become a very accomplished musician. The
- 16:48Cha Coola and I are going to be a High Biscus iteration at H at
- 16:52the Florida Americana Music Festival the weekend of April twentieth, and that's up at
- 17:03at Florida Sands Music Ranch near Brooksville, Florida. And so that's a that's
- 17:10a four day Americana Folk concert. And uh so if you there's opportunities to
- 17:18volunteer and some compensation for that. As as when I say compensation, you
- 17:26get the comped H admission and in camping space if you if you are a
- 17:33volunteer sufficiently under their their guidelines. And so take a look if you've got
- 17:41any interest in that and want to hear some great music from all over the
- 17:45state of Florida and sort of get you warmed up for the for the High
- 17:49Biscus Festival. That's the Americana Music Festival at the Florida Sands Ranch. And
- 17:59that's that we end of April twentieth. So, uh, you know,
- 18:06with that first selection there, I I thought, well, let's let's continue
- 18:15this and talk a little bit about the devil and the napkin and the and
- 18:23things that are sort of work you sideways and work your your energy into into
- 18:33some place. And so this these notions are all very private. They have
- 18:40to do with autonomy, they have to do with with belief systems and such
- 18:45as that. Well, Zora Neil Hurston was collecting folk tales for black folk
- 18:52tales from the South and and put it in a collection Mules and Men.
- 18:56And she did this as an anthropologist, uh, and so she also is
- 19:02part of that. She examined and studied and gathered information about voodoo or whodoo
- 19:10as it can be known. And in chapter seven of her book of Mules
- 19:17and Men, she says, Kitty Brown is a well known hoodoo doctor of
- 19:21New Orleans and a Catholic. She liked to make marriages and put lovers together.
- 19:26She is squat, black and benign. Often when we had leisure,
- 19:32she told funny stories. Her herb garden was pretty full, and we often
- 19:36supplied other doctors with plants. Very few raised things, since the supply houses
- 19:41carry about everything that's needed, but sometimes a thing is wanted fresh from the
- 19:45ground. That's where Kitty's garden came in. When the matter of my initiation
- 19:49came up, she said, in order for you to reach the spirit,
- 19:53somebody has got to suffer. I'll suffer for you because I'm strong. It
- 19:59might be the death of you. It was in October nineteen twenty eight,
- 20:03when I was a pupil of hers, that I shared in a hoodoo dance.
- 20:07This is not a pleasure dance, but ceremonial. In another generation,
- 20:11African dances were held in Congo Square now Beauregard Square. Those who were held
- 20:18for social purposes. Those were held for social purposes and were of the same
- 20:22type as the fire dances and jumping dances of the present in the of the
- 20:27present in the Bahamas. But the hoodoo dance is done for a specific purpose.
- 20:33It's always a case of death to the enemy that calls forth a dance.
- 20:38They are very rare even in New Orleans now, even within the most
- 20:42inner circle, and no layman as ever ever participates, nor has ever been
- 20:49allowed to witness such a ceremony. This is how the dance came to be
- 20:55held. I sat with my teacher in her front room as the very cases
- 21:00were disposed of. It was my business to assist whenever possible, such as
- 21:04running errands for materials or verifying addresses, locating materials in the various dwarfs and
- 21:11cabinets, undressing and handling patients, writing out formulas as they were dictated,
- 21:15and finally making hands, that is, manufacturing certain luck charms. Making hands.
- 21:22At last, of course, I could do all of the work while
- 21:26she looked on and made corrections where necessary. This particular day, a little
- 21:30before noon, came Rachel Rowe. She was dry with anger, hate,
- 21:36outraged confidence, and desire for revenge. John Doe had made violent love to
- 21:42her, had lain in her bed, and Bosom for the last three years
- 21:47had received of Rachel everything material and emotional a woman can give. They had
- 21:52both worked and saved, and had contributed to a joint savings account. Now
- 21:56only the day before yesterday he had married another. He had lured a young
- 22:00and pretty girl to his bed with Rachel's earnings, yes had set up housekeeping
- 22:07with Rachel's sweat and blood. She had gone to him, and he had
- 22:11laughed at her, at his former sweetheart. Yes, the police could do
- 22:15nothing. No, the bank was sorry, but they could do nothing.
- 22:18No, So Rachel had come to Kitty. Does she still love her John
- 22:22Doe? Perhaps she didn't know if he would return to her. She should
- 22:27strive to forgive. But she was certain he'd not return. How could he?
- 22:33But if he were dead, she could smile again, Yes, could
- 22:37go back to her work and save some more money. Yes, perhaps she
- 22:40might even meet a man who could restore her confidence in menfolk. Kitty appraised
- 22:47her quickly. A dance could be help for him, that would carry him
- 22:49away right now? But they cost something? How much? A whole lot?
- 22:55How much can you bring me? I got thirty seven dollars. Dad
- 22:59ain't got to pay the dancers and set at the table. One hundred dollars
- 23:03was agreed upon. It was paid by seven o'clock that same night. We
- 23:07were kept very busy, for the dance was set from ten to one the
- 23:11next day, those being bad hours. I ran to certain addresses to a
- 23:15symbol a sort of college of bishops to be present and participate the table was
- 23:21set with cake, wine, roast duck, and barbecued duck. A dance,
- 23:30a hoodoo dance that on the wrong side of that one. The so
- 23:40in our religion, in our relations with people, in our sexual desires,
- 23:48we have some expectation that that that we are a individual of soul, a
- 24:00will, a contractor with a karmic claim, and so and so decisions that
- 24:11we make we don't want the rest of the world. As a matter of
- 24:12fact, we keep the information private. Privacy does have information. You're gonna
- 24:18hear more about that. Privacy has a lot to do with information and control
- 24:21of information. But it also has to do with the autonomy of choice and
- 24:26actions about about your own body. And we're gonna talk about that some more.
- 24:30Also, well, before we get there, what's the dowt to ching
- 24:34have to say, We're gonna do a couple other things, because it's gonna
- 24:37get fairly thick into some case law. Here in just a minute. This
- 24:47is verse fourteen from the dowt to ching. Eyes look but cannot see it,
- 24:53ears, listen but cannot hear it, hands grasp can touch it.
- 25:00Beyond the senses lies the great unity invisible inaudible intangible. What rises up appears
- 25:08bright, what settles down appears dark. Yet there is neither darkness nor light,
- 25:14just an unbroken dance of shadows from nothingness to fullness and back again to
- 25:18nothingness. This formless form, this imageless image, cannot be grasped by mind
- 25:26or might try to face it. At what place will you stand? Try
- 25:30to follow it? To? What place? Will you go? Know that
- 25:33which is beyond all beginnings, and you will know everything here and now,
- 25:37know everything in this moment, and you will know the eternal dow. Always
- 25:45like to do the parody of it? What's the dow of mew have to
- 25:49say? Waldo Japussy number fourteen. We look and we do not see,
- 26:00so we assume it isn't there. We listen and we do not hear,
- 26:04so we assume it never existed. We touch, but have no feeling.
- 26:10Yet it never occurs to us that we are the one who is numb,
- 26:14dumb, and unaware. The world is filled with ten thousand things I can
- 26:19see here in touch, but it is also filled with uncountable things that neither
- 26:23you nor I can see, hear, or touch. None of these things
- 26:27have names, yet all of them know the mew. They are part of
- 26:32perfection. They are virtue. The cat's meow. I'm surrounded by nothing of
- 26:38everything, the everything of nothing. It is the form without form, the
- 26:44image without substance, the breath without sound. It arrives before you hear it
- 26:48approaching, it leaves before you have learned what to do with it. Some
- 26:52call it opportunity, but is more than opportunity. Is virtue. A door
- 26:56that swings both ways, leading from the beginning to the end and back to
- 27:00the beginning. Meowing will not open the door. The door is the meow,
- 27:06And when it opens, life kicks you out to do your business so
- 27:14well, autonomy and everybody else's business none of their business. Kind of deal.
- 27:27This is uh wilding, Why oldening, unbounded foam and drawth on a
- 28:00whipping way, holding out for a line as the edge slips away. Hope,
- 28:10hope and pray and pray. Belive the life you have to day.
- 28:15Hope, hope and pray and pray. Belive the life you have today,
- 28:33sing out, I take now, give me tomorrow. Drenching, drenching,
- 28:38down, poor, screaming, howling, excitement, dance and naked like a
- 28:45wanton oh oh and pray and pray, be live the life you have today.
- 28:53Hope, hope and pray and pray. Belive the life we have to
- 29:00day, sing out loud, Holua, fall down, riding on the full,
- 29:17screaming, howling excitement, dancing naked like a wanton Hope, hope,
- 29:23hope, pray and pray, Live the life you have to day. Hope
- 29:30and hope and pray and pray. Spirit moves us in mysterious way. When
- 29:47I fall measure your mercy. I can't afford the strings that you tie.
- 29:53Help me only if you want to screams of costly hell without them? Why
- 29:59not? And pray and pray, live the life you have today. Hope
- 30:07and hope and pray and pray be live the life you have to day you
- 30:19have to day. Yeah, So that kind of attitude, that kind of
- 30:33feeling, that kind of uh, figuring out who you are, what you
- 30:38are, what your life is about. What does the government have to do
- 30:44with that? Well, Dobbs, which is the Supreme Court's most recent pronouncement,
- 30:56and that's what where they moved away from Griswold versus Connecticut. They moved
- 31:02away from Roe versus Wade, uh and the and Dobbs says, Nah,
- 31:10there's no privacy right that that that that provides a person's control of their body
- 31:18to make a decision about terminating pregnancy. There's no as a matter of fact,
- 31:26if any such right exists, that it has to be found in the
- 31:30state. Uh, And so in our in our federal system. The Supreme
- 31:38Court said, now, the United States Constitution doesn't provide a right of privacy
- 31:45that that that goes to that And but the ruling in Roe versus Wade that
- 31:53there's been now uh derided by the court, the Supreme Court, and now
- 32:01is being used as the right to as the reason to deride any such claim
- 32:08to write at the state level in the state of Florida has just come out.
- 32:14Big picture, the question was was whether a particular legislative enactment that said
- 32:24no abortions in Florida unless the doctor determines after fifteen weeks, unless the doctor
- 32:34is determined that the fetus is not viable. And there's a lot of language
- 32:43with that, and I'm going to read the specific language to you. But
- 32:50but in the Roe versus Wade, which has had established this notion and this
- 32:55conversation about privacy being included in this idea of autonomy for medical decisions and whether
- 33:05or not to continue a pregnancy or not. That that arose in an analysis
- 33:15of the United States Constitution that basically said, it's a penumberal right, there's
- 33:20no express right to privacy or right to abortion, but you can by reading
- 33:24the whole constitution and the whole setup of what we did is that we went
- 33:30from being the king being the sovereign, to being each individual is the sovereign,
- 33:36and we've combined together through basically a social contract to say what government can
- 33:45and can't do. But basically all the rights and everything, all this notion
- 33:49of autonomy is really built into the whole concept that government only happens because of
- 33:55the consent of the governed. That there's some UH and and and in the
- 34:01court and Roe versus way, what they said was even though there's not an
- 34:06express right to privacy that includes this, that there's this it emanates the whole
- 34:10document that that the individual that it's the it's based upon the rights of individuals
- 34:17who then come together to UH into states and then into the Federal Union in
- 34:23order to express their UH their willingness to allow government to act that so so
- 34:30that there is this reserved, inalienable right that is part of what being a
- 34:36person is. That includes a right to control information about themselves, a right
- 34:42to make decisions about their their health UH, to either receive or not receive
- 34:46medical care and attention. UH. And that that that right is UH the
- 34:52strongest UH, particularly in the notion of terminating a pregnancy in the first trimester,
- 35:00because that's there's no viability. It can't in the second trimester, modern
- 35:07science might be able to save the baby, and in the third trimester,
- 35:10we know that we're going to save the baby to the best possible, and
- 35:15so and so and so. It's a at a a balancing act that starts
- 35:23with the balance on the individual and the early stages, and then the balance
- 35:30is on the side of society in the late stages. Well, to be
- 35:35to be square and honorable to the truth of the matter. The legislative enactment
- 35:43by the state of Florida that said no no abortions after fifteen weeks unless there's
- 35:51no viability for the fetus or these other exceptions that I'm gonna hopefully get to.
- 35:55There were fifteen weeks, Well, what's a trimester? That's really when
- 36:01you're talking about you're talking about how many weeks. You know, that's within
- 36:10the first trimester of a nine month You've got three months at four weeks each,
- 36:21that's twelve you know, it's four point two weeks really or whatever.
- 36:24And so it's just a little bit over twelve weeks for that first trimester.
- 36:30And really the State of Florida's legislature said fifteen weeks. But of course behind
- 36:36that is one that's coming that after Dobbs that said, you know it once
- 36:42the once the Supreme Court of the State of Florida rules on this fifteen week
- 36:47restriction, which was consistent with the analysis and Roe versus Way that the that
- 36:54it's going to go to six weeks, and so that's significantly less than than
- 37:00the time frame for the first trimester, and so that was what was in
- 37:06the balance and what the Supreme Court of the State of Florida said, Yes,
- 37:12the State of Florida has an enumerated right to privacy, the Privacy Clause
- 37:17and the Florida Constitution the right. So the right and that the language within
- 37:24it is privacy, right to privacy, right to be let alone and free
- 37:29from governmental intrusion into private life. This article one section twenty three of the
- 37:36Florida Constitution. So as I was just reading it in the newspaper and trying
- 37:45to stay up with it that way, I thought, well, this surely
- 37:50will go in favor of the right of privacy because of the analysis and how
- 37:55roversus weighed was handled and in nineteen eight when the constitutional right, I can
- 38:01remember voting in nineteen eighty for a constitutional right to privacy and it did include
- 38:07the concepts of privacy that's enumerated in row based upon the number of the United
- 38:15States Constitution. And so I thought, well, this will be pretty straightforward.
- 38:21We have an enumerated right of privacy, and so this should be upheld
- 38:28for you know, it may be not a problem with the fifteen weeks,
- 38:32but surely they'll take into account the six weeks. And they did. They
- 38:37knew that was coming, but they didn't get there. They said no,
- 38:40no, and they did in my opinion, some sophistry. I really it
- 38:45made me angry as I read the opinion, and it's a big opinion.
- 38:51It's ninety six, ninety eight pages, and they march it down but and
- 39:00it was there was only one descent. Uh So the the opinion was was
- 39:07was written by Grossian's g R. O. S. S H A N
- 39:10S. And then the it was concurred with and joined in by all the
- 39:20others except for the UH, except for one justice. And let me see
- 39:30where I have that. Yeah, at any rate, the uh they didn't
- 39:37come to that. Now, what they did at the same they didn't they
- 39:42they they found that that the words write of privacy, which is in the
- 39:46title of that article one section twenty three, that titles don't mean anything.
- 39:52That's a fairly con that's that's a common and and pretty understood and well so
- 40:00old concept. But most people don't get that part when you're doing construction language
- 40:07of construction, that the title doesn't really mean anything. It was called a
- 40:10privacy, right, and then the word private affairs and private life were was
- 40:16mentioned within the text. But they said, just because the constitution says,
- 40:22uh h, privacy doesn't mean privacy. It doesn't mean that you have the
- 40:29ability to make a decision about your own body uh uh. And in the
- 40:35that first trimester so well. But at the same time they took up a
- 40:39constitutional uh provision and and made a decision that yes, the constitutional uh language
- 40:50was not uh misleading, and the the title of that didn't h didn't misstate
- 40:58or mislead or confuse people, And so that's going to be on the ballot
- 41:02in November. So what we're going to go through is that is that the
- 41:07Supreme Court of the State of Florida says the privacy right that's already there because
- 41:10it doesn't mention abortion, doesn't include abortion. And so but if the State
- 41:16of Florida, and it's people sixty percent of them who vote in this coming
- 41:22election, decide that they want that language in there, then there will be
- 41:25a constitutional protection for the right for a woman to choose abortion under certain circumstances.
- 41:35Doesn't take away the obligation to get consent of parents before a miner can
- 41:42have an abortion, which that has its own issues and problems. I mean,
- 41:46you know, daddy impregnates the child his daughter, Why are we asking
- 41:54the daddy for permission about whether there should be an abortion or not. But
- 41:59any rate, that's a whole other set of issues that goes with it.
- 42:02But the uh so what is it says there's a conflict between the rights secured
- 42:09by the what issue they were taken up said this Florida constitutional right to privacy.
- 42:19There's a they've been asked to determine if there's a conflict between the rights
- 42:22secured by that provision and a statue that shortens the window of time in which
- 42:28a physician may perform an abortion. So the privacy Clause, they said,
- 42:32we're gonna do an analysis, says with the Privacy Claus's texts, it's context,
- 42:37and its historical evidence, and we're going to give judicial deference to legislative
- 42:43enactments. And we conclude there's no basis under the privacy clause to invalidate the
- 42:49statute. In doing so, we received from our prior decisions in which,
- 42:52relying on reasoning, the US Supreme Court is rejected, we held that the
- 42:57privacy Clause guaranteed the right to receive an abortion through the end of the second
- 43:00trimester. And they said, we're not in the petitioners are not entitled to
- 43:07a temporary injunction because we don't think they're going to be successful in the long
- 43:13run. And so within the Declaration of Rights Section twenty three, Right of
- 43:20Privacy, every national person has the right to be let alone and free from
- 43:24governmental intrusion into the person's private life, except as otherwise provided herein and this
- 43:30section shall not be construed to limit the public's right of access to public records
- 43:34and meetings as provided by law. Well Planned Parenthood claimed that it was substantially
- 43:38likely to prevail in the lawsuit because it could demonstrate that the statute violates the
- 43:43privacy clause, and after the States submitted its response, the US Supreme Court
- 43:49issued a landmark decision on abortion in a case involving the Mississippi Statute Dobbs v.
- 43:53Jackson's Women Health. It was a federal constitution, they said. The
- 43:58federal constitution does not get garantee a right to abortion. They overturned Roe versus
- 44:02Wade and Planned Parenthood of South East Pennsylvania versus Casey, and overruling those decisions.
- 44:09Dobbs turned to the people and their elected representatives returned to the people and
- 44:15their elected representatives the authority to regulate abortion. In finding a likelihood of success
- 44:21on the merits, the court relied upon our abortion jurisprudence, which they then
- 44:25tw and a Gainsville Woman Care matter, concluding the statute was subject to strict
- 44:35scrutiny, not served a compelling interest, and nor it was the least restrictive
- 44:39means of achieving that. Well, in tw they concluded the right to abortion
- 44:46was embodied within the provision. So there's already been a determination by the Florida
- 44:52Supreme Court that yes, the privacy right does include this right to abortion.
- 44:58But they revisited the question because the h and they've offered the State of Florida
- 45:06said, it really only has to do with informational privacy, and the jurisdiction
- 45:13before and after tw was understood the privacy clause to encompass certain decisional or autonomy
- 45:19rights, and today we do not revisit our our precedents outside of the abortion
- 45:23context. So they tried to limit what was going on. They said,
- 45:28yes, there's some autonomy that happens within that it's not just informational control,
- 45:34but that there's some autonomy that has to do with who you have sex with,
- 45:38those kinds of things. And they're not receding from that, but as
- 45:43concerns abortion, because we've got competing values society values of the mother's decision making
- 45:50along with their doctor versus a living thing inside her that whether it's viable or
- 45:58not, it has the potential need to be a human being, and so
- 46:04the and so rovers's Wade had gone to great links to explain how this h
- 46:13balancing act would would happen and h and this court said, because because Rovers's
- 46:22Wade has been turned over and that and that construct of a privacy for autonomy
- 46:30concerning abortion UH can't be relied upon, and so the pronouncement was flawed.
- 46:37They said they associated the language of the privacy clause with Rose understanding of privacy,
- 46:43and that they didn't justify how the concept of privacy aligned with our Constitution's
- 46:50text the right to be let alone and free of governmental intrusion and private life.
- 46:52UH. They did not ask the Florida voters UH and t W how
- 47:00they would have understood the text. And Flora's history is long of prescribing abortion,
- 47:04and so they didn't look the tw court didn't look at dictionaries, didn't
- 47:07look at contextual clues or historical sources, and it adopted Rose notions, and
- 47:15so it failed to apply long standing principles of judicial deference to legislative enactments.
- 47:21Judge Labarga, who was the descending judge, emphasized that tw was decided on
- 47:27state law grounds, and indeed tw sided Roe over twenty times had accepted Rose
- 47:36concept of privacy without analysis, and it enacted a viability transmission system that closely
- 47:42paralleled without citing any Florida precedent. That's what the majority said about the argument
- 47:50that the Labarga emphasized and said no, no, that it's doesn't work that
- 47:55way, says it's not doctrinally coherent. Rose constitutional analysis was far outside the
- 48:02bounds of any reasonable interpretation of various constitutional provisions to which it vaguely pointed,
- 48:09citing Dobbs in that. And so what's happened is that because of the packed
- 48:15court that was intentionally set up, ran the President Trump ran on the notion
- 48:27that he was going to appoint justices that would overturn Roe versus Wade, and
- 48:31then did. And now the cascading effect of that is that but the argument
- 48:37being, oh no, it really goes to the States. But now the
- 48:40States argument is because Roe was flawed, as determined by the Dobs Court,
- 48:45that anybody that relied upon the Roe analysis is not doctrinally coherent, and so
- 48:55you can't do that. But now the April fools jokes on them. And
- 49:00because this is going to incite the people who believe in privacy, that it
- 49:05includes the autonomy for decisions concerning one's own body. And you have an opportunity
- 49:10in November to vote for that constitutional amendment. And what's that Constitutional amendments full
- 49:16text, because there's going to be some uh, there's going to there's going
- 49:22to be some rhetorical a tax at it and uh. And so the ballot
- 49:29title Amendment to limit government interference with abortion, that's the ballot title that's coming
- 49:34up. Ballot summary. No law shall prohibit, penalize, delay, or
- 49:37restrict abortion before viability or when necessary to protect the patient's health, as determined
- 49:45by the patient's health care provider. The amendment does not change the legislature's constitutional
- 49:50authority to require notification to a parent or guardian before a minor has an abortion.
- 49:57So, once again, ballot type, the amendment to limit government interference
- 50:01with abortion, so that no court can come back and say later on,
- 50:07well, it's it's privacy, doesn't mention abortion, so abortion is not part
- 50:10of it. And so one of these most fundamental decisions that a person can
- 50:15make about their life moving forward, and uh, and there and the I
- 50:22mean, a pregnancy is a potentially life threatening and it's certainly life altering and
- 50:31and at some point when you say you can't make that decision, that you
- 50:36don't we not allowing you the autonomy. This constitutional amendment will say until the
- 50:43bay, until the fetus is viable, you can make a decision that that's
- 50:49that's your autonomy. And then after viability, if it's necessary to protect the
- 50:53health the patient's health as determined by the patient's health care provider. That's the
- 50:59control of information, who makes decisions about what and so the woman with her
- 51:05doctor can make these kinds of decisions. Now, let me be very clear
- 51:08with you, I am not in favor of abortion. I, however,
- 51:15am in favor of the autonomy of a woman to make a decision about whether
- 51:21to carry a fetus to term during that first trimester, as her privacy is
- 51:29more important than my opinion about what her obligation is. And so it goes
- 51:36to the very heart of this autonomy as a human being to make decisions for
- 51:42oneself and being able to balance society's right to be able to tell me that
- 51:49whether I and so there we go. So the advisory opinion of the Attorney
- 51:52General limiting government interference with abortion, they went through a big analysis to say,
- 51:58now we're not getting to the man Parritts of all this, but that
- 52:01title and the language itself are not confusing and won't miss mislead any of the
- 52:14people who are going to vote for it. And so they set it up
- 52:17so that in sixty days we're probably going to be down to a six week
- 52:22window if you want to exercise your autonomy, and come November you can broaden
- 52:30that back out at least through the first trimester and maybe into the second trimester.
- 52:37I think that I think that that's going to pass, and so ultimately
- 52:42you're going to end up having a right to an abortion in Florida, whereas
- 52:49right now it's about to disappear, about to disappear. So Zaane says,
- 52:57we've got two minutes, is that right? Yeah, So thanks for helping
- 53:05me build the zoo. We're gonna, uh, we're gonna get out of
- 53:07here on on a little bit of uh of music and then the drums coming
- 53:15up here just a second. So, uh, make sure you're registered to
- 53:20vote, get out and vote. Uh that I have to say, in
- 53:24the name of this free state of Florida. Uh, I've never seen so
- 53:29many restrictions controls by those who want to claim that they're that they are advancing
- 53:37freedom, they're advancing continuous governmental crackdown, lockdown upon people, and uh and
- 53:44it's not right and it's not fair. Let's get out of here. On
- 53:47the drums leader