Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / The old man trader options strategy explained
Transcript
- 0:00So imagine a master trader just hands you this highly
- 0:03engineered, theoretically foolproof trade setup.
- 0:06Right, like the Holy Grail of trades.
- 0:08Exactly, You look at the math, you run the probability software
- 0:12and the screen just flashes the stark reality.
- 0:15There isn't almost 60% chance you will actually lose money on
- 0:18this trade. So I mean, would you still take
- 0:20it? Well, most people would just run
- 0:22for the hills. We are so conditioned to look
- 0:25for the sure thing. You know, like that 90% win
- 0:28rate. Taking a trade where the math
- 0:31literally says you'll probably strike out It sounds like
- 0:34financial suicide. It really does.
- 0:36But today we are jumping into a deep dive on a framework from a
- 0:4029 year market veteran, Noah Davidson, and he argues that
- 0:44taking that exact trade is the absolute secret to massive
- 0:48longevity in the market. Yeah, it's this fascinating
- 0:51concept he calls the Lazy Old Traders Guide to crushing it
- 0:54with options. Right.
- 0:56And the whole mission of this deep dive is to rescue you from
- 0:58that hyperactive, incredibly stressful style of modern
- 1:02trading. We want to equip you with what
- 1:04he calls the old man trader mindset.
- 1:07We're essentially swapping out that adrenaline fueled casino
- 1:10mentality for, well, a master class in patients, asymmetric
- 1:14risk and strict structural defense.
- 1:16Because he identifies this core rot at the center of modern
- 1:20retail trading, Somewhere along the line, the really
- 1:23sophisticated architecture of options trading just devolved
- 1:27into pure gambling. Oh totally, You picture these
- 1:31young impulsive traders staring at like 6 glowing monitors,
- 1:34right? Exactly.
- 1:35Just aggressively buying these zero days to expiration options.
- 1:39They're treating these complex derivative contracts like
- 1:42they're scratch off lottery tickets.
- 1:45And the result isn't just terrible portfolio performance.
- 1:48I mean, it's chronic psychological burnout.
- 1:52Yeah, it's exhausting just thinking about it.
- 1:54Right. So the old man mindset is the
- 1:57antidote to that. It operates on the premise that
- 2:00trading should be methodical, boring and fundamentally
- 2:04protective. But before we can even look at a
- 2:06stock chart or, you know, build that paradoxical trade we
- 2:09mentioned earlier, we really have to rebuild the foundation.
- 2:12Noah insists that the prerequisite to any trading is
- 2:15mechanical fluency. You have to know your strategies
- 2:18and you have to know your Greeks.
- 2:19Oh, the Greeks? Yeah.
- 2:21Delta, gamma, Theta, Vega. These are the mathematical
- 2:25variables that basically dictate how an option's price changes.
- 2:29Which sounds intimidating for a lot of people.
- 2:32It does, but the fatal mistake amateurs make is trying to learn
- 2:36these concepts while real money is actually on the line.
- 2:40Noah is so adamant about this. You must paper trade first,
- 2:44right? You have to make your
- 2:45foundational mistakes in a simulator because the market is
- 2:48just utterly unforgiving if you don't understand the physical
- 2:51laws governing your contracts. Let's ground this in a car
- 2:55analogy, because I think that helps.
- 2:56Learning the Greeks is essentially understanding how
- 2:59the vehicle you're driving interacts with the physical
- 3:01world. So delta is your speed, how fast
- 3:04your option price moves when the stock moves.
- 3:06That's a great way to look at it.
- 3:08And Theta is like the slow persistent leak in your tire.
- 3:12Every single day that passes your option loses a bit of time
- 3:15value and that leak accelerates as you get closer to your
- 3:18destination or expiration. And then Vega is the weather
- 3:22condition. If implied volatility spikes,
- 3:25it's like suddenly driving through a severe storm, which
- 3:28wildly inflates the premiums. You have to know how the car
- 3:32handles in that. Exactly, you have to know the
- 3:35car. But that car analogy also
- 3:37highlights the exact limitation of just having mechanical
- 3:40knowledge. I mean, you can understand the
- 3:42steering, you could account for the slow leak in the tire, and
- 3:45you can know the route perfectly sure.
- 3:47But none of that prevents you from, say, entering in the legal
- 3:50street race and wrapping that car around a telephone pole.
- 3:53Right, knowing how to drive doesn't make you a professional
- 3:55racer. Precisely.
- 3:56Mechanical fluency is just a prerequisite to actually
- 4:00survive. You have to shift from
- 4:02understanding those external mechanics to building an
- 4:05internal architecture of risk. And Noah uses this whole
- 4:08alphabet soup of rules for this. He talks a lot about minding
- 4:11your PS and QS, but looking closely at the source material,
- 4:14what he's really doing with the PS is building an internal
- 4:18psychological fortress. Let's dissect that fortress a
- 4:21bit. It starts with probabilities and
- 4:24potential. The young impulsive trader looks
- 4:27at an options chain and asks one single question.
- 4:30How much can I make? It's all about the upside.
- 4:34All about the ceiling. Yeah, but the old man trader
- 4:36looks at the exact same screen and asks how likely is this to
- 4:40actually happen and how much is it going to hurt me if it
- 4:43doesn't. It is a total reversal from
- 4:46fantasy to reality. I love that framing.
- 4:50How much can it hurt? That fundamentally changes your
- 4:53entire relationship with the trade.
- 4:55It forces you into the next phase, which is process and
- 4:57plan. Right, because you are deciding
- 5:00before a single dollar is even deployed exactly what you'll do
- 5:04if the stock goes up, and exactly what you'll do if it
- 5:07completely tanks. Which leads to what I think is
- 5:10the most critical P in the entire framework position size.
- 5:13Because most retail traders, they operate under this illusion
- 5:16that a stop loss order is their primary risk management tool.
- 5:20Oh yeah, they buy a massive position and just slap a tight
- 5:24stop on it hoping for the best. Right, but Noah argues that
- 5:27position size is your actual first line of defense.
- 5:30The young buck uses maximum margin asking how big can I go,
- 5:34while the old man trader sizes the position by asking how wrong
- 5:37can I afford to be. It's brilliant.
- 5:40But I do want to push back on this defensive posture just for
- 5:42a second. If you look at this philosophy,
- 5:45you know, focusing on how much it can hurt, basically assuming
- 5:47you're going to be wrong, rigidly capping your size, it
- 5:50sounds incredibly pessimistic. I can see why you'd say that.
- 5:54I mean, isn't the whole point of trading options the ability to
- 5:57leverage a small amount of capital for outsized gains?
- 6:01Why is a 29 year veteran so obsessed with playing defense?
- 6:04Well, it looks like pessimism to an amateur, but it's actually
- 6:08the mathematical reality of survival.
- 6:11The market functions as an incredibly efficient machine for
- 6:14transferring capital from the inpatient to the patient.
- 6:17That's a hard truth. It is.
- 6:20If you over leverage to capture massive gains, you will
- 6:23eventually, inevitably encounter a market event that blows right
- 6:27past your stop loss and wipes out your entire account.
- 6:31You can't leverage your capital if you don't have any chips left
- 6:33to play with. Right, game over.
- 6:35Exactly so the old man traders rigid defense is precisely what
- 6:41actually enables him to capture those outsize gains over a
- 6:44decade rather than just burning out in a month.
- 6:47And part of that defense is recognizing that you don't
- 6:50always have to be in the market. Noah highlights patients as a
- 6:53core virtue. Sometimes the actual job
- 6:55requirement is to just sit on your hands and do absolutely
- 6:58nothing. Which is agonizing for someone
- 7:01addicted to the action. And this touches on Noah's final
- 7:04internal pillar, personal psychology.
- 7:07He issues a really stark warning in the material.
- 7:10What's that? He says?
- 7:11You can be a mathematical genius.
- 7:13You can know every Greek backward and forward, but if you
- 7:16don't manage your own temperament, you will fail.
- 7:20If a position size is too large. Panic sets in, and the moment
- 7:23you were trading with scared money, your mechanics just go
- 7:26right out the window. You become your own worst enemy.
- 7:29You really do. So if the peas represent this
- 7:32internal psychological fortress, how do we actually engage with
- 7:35the external market? Because there's endless noise
- 7:38out there, thousands of stocks, breaking news, talking heads
- 7:41screaming on TV. How does the old man trader
- 7:44filter the noise to actually find a trade?
- 7:46Well, that is where the queues come in.
- 7:49If the PS look inward, the queues look outward.
- 7:52The first filter is quality and qualification.
- 7:55Does the setup actually meet your strict predetermined
- 7:58criteria? Right.
- 8:00Like is the stock highly liquid, meaning you can easily buy and
- 8:03sell without radically moving the price?
- 8:05Exactly. If it's illiquid or the setup is
- 8:08messy, you don't force it, you simply move on.
- 8:11Then you have to quantify. This means stripping away all
- 8:14that vague emotional language. You don't just look at a chart
- 8:18and say, oh, the upside looks huge.
- 8:20You put exact mathematical parameters around your profit
- 8:23targets and your maximum acceptable loss based on
- 8:26historical data. And once it's quantified, you
- 8:28seek the quiet trade. This is probably the starkest
- 8:31contrast to modern trading culture.
- 8:33Oh, for sure. The adrenaline junkie wants the
- 8:36earnings announcements. You know, the volatile biotech
- 8:38news, the chaotic moonshots. The old man trader actively
- 8:42avoids that noise. He wants a boring chart,
- 8:45reasonable volatility, and plenty of time on the clock.
- 8:48Noah explicitly says that you put the quiet trade on and then
- 8:52you literally go play golf. I love that it's like the
- 8:55difference between a microwave and a slow cooker.
- 8:57The young buck trader wants the microwave.
- 8:59They want the sparks flying. The food is piping hot in 30
- 9:01seconds, but there is a very real chance the entire thing
- 9:04just explodes in their face. That's a perfect analogy.
- 9:07The Old Man Trader uses the slow cooker.
- 9:10You prep the ingredients, you set the parameters, you walk
- 9:13away to enjoy your day, and you just let the market do the heavy
- 9:16lifting over time. But to let that slow cooker
- 9:18work, you have to apply the final cue quash.
- 9:22You have to ruthlessly quash your impulses like.
- 9:25FOMO. Exactly.
- 9:27You quash FOMO, you quash the urge to revenge trade
- 9:30immediately after taking a loss, and most importantly, you quash
- 9:34the urge to put on a trade simply because you're bored.
- 9:37Experience teaches you how to trade.
- 9:39Wisdom teaches you when to stay completely out of the market.
- 9:43Which brings us to the culmination of all this theory.
- 9:46You wait for the right pitch. The market is throwing thousands
- 9:49of pitches at you every single day.
- 9:51You don't have to swing right. You only step up to the plate
- 9:54when the context, the charts, the catalyst, and the
- 9:56confirmation all align perfectly.
- 9:59So let's actually take all of this abstract architecture and
- 10:02apply it to a real world pitch. In the source material, NOAA
- 10:06breaks down a specific setup for Freeport Mcmoran, ticker symbol
- 10:09FCX. It's a massive copper mining
- 10:12company. OK.
- 10:13So we start by looking for the catalyst.
- 10:15Why are we interested in copper right now?
- 10:17The macro context here is that there's a colossal wave of
- 10:20capital expenditure flowing into the construction of global data
- 10:23centers. Right, the AI boom.
- 10:25Exactly. And those data centers require
- 10:27astronomical amounts of copper for power and infrastructure.
- 10:31So the fundamental demand story is incredibly strong.
- 10:34So with that context set, we move to the chart and we apply
- 10:37our rule to quantify. We are looking for a highly
- 10:41specific technical setup here. NOAA identifies that FCX is in a
- 10:45broad trend zone, but more importantly, it is resting right
- 10:49at its twenty period simple moving average while sitting
- 10:52just below its 13 period exponential moving average.
- 10:56Let's unpack why the intersection of those specific
- 10:58moving averages actually matters, rather than just waving
- 11:01our hands and calling it a bullish area.
- 11:03Good idea. The 20 period simple moving
- 11:06average is essentially the stock's recent baseline health,
- 11:09right? It gives equal weight to the
- 11:10last 20 days. But the 13 period exponential
- 11:13moving average hugs the price much closer, reacting to the
- 11:17most recent days a lot faster, yeah.
- 11:19So when the stock is fundamentally strong but the
- 11:22price dips down to touch that 20 day baseline without crashing
- 11:24through it, it indicates that the medium term foundation is
- 11:28rock solid even if the short term momentum cooled off.
- 11:31It's the visual equivalent of a sprinter catching their breath
- 11:35before the next. Dash.
- 11:36Exactly. Noah calls it a textbook bullish
- 11:39retracement. But the Old Man trader doesn't
- 11:41just guess where it will Sprint next, he quantifies the target.
- 11:45Noah looks at the historical repeating swing cycles for FCX.
- 11:48Historically, when the specific stock catches its breath and
- 11:51swings upward, it runs between 10 to 20 points, with the
- 11:54average historical swing being about 15 points, right?
- 11:58So by applying that 15 point average to the current chart, he
- 12:02pinpoints a highly specific target sweet spot at a price of
- 12:0585. And he expects the move to take
- 12:08a few weeks to a month and 1/2. OK, so we have the catalyst, the
- 12:12chart and the quantified target. But to build an options trade we
- 12:16need the final puzzle piece, which is volatility,
- 12:19specifically implied volatility or IV for FCX.
- 12:24At this exact moment, the IV is sitting at 48.89%.
- 12:29So why does that exact percentage dictate the entire
- 12:32strategy? Because implied volatility
- 12:35basically tells you how expensive the insurance premiums
- 12:38on the options contracts are right now.
- 12:40At almost 49%, IV is in this tricky middle ground.
- 12:45Meaning. Meaning the options are too
- 12:47expensive to simply buy a long call.
- 12:50You'd be overpaying for the premium, which means the stock
- 12:53has to make a massive move just for you to break even.
- 12:56Conversely, the Ivy isn't high enough to just sell options and
- 12:59collect a massive payout. So the environment itself forces
- 13:03a structural approach because we have a specific target of 805A
- 13:07timeline of a month and a half and middle tier volatility.
- 13:10We have to construct a multi leg strategy.
- 13:13Right, a targeted butterfly. Exactly, we are looking at
- 13:17October options with 43 days until expiration.
- 13:20The stock is currently trading around $74.00.
- 13:22So let's walk through the exact mechanics of how you build an
- 13:26old man trade. OK, leg one is our directional
- 13:30bet. We buy one out of the money call
- 13:33option at the $75 strike price. This basically establishes our
- 13:37position that the stock is going up.
- 13:39This single leg costs about $440 out of pocket.
- 13:43OK. If we stopped right there, we
- 13:45are risking $440. But as you noted, because
- 13:49volatility is at 49%, we are slightly overpaying for that
- 13:52contract. We need to finance it somehow.
- 13:55And we finance it by basically becoming the insurance company
- 13:58for someone else. Nice.
- 14:00This is leg two. We go out to our quantified
- 14:03sweet spot, the 8250 strike price.
- 14:06We are going to actually sell two call options at this level
- 14:10because we are selling them. The market pays us the premium.
- 14:14We collect about $195 per contract, which brings in
- 14:18roughly $390.00 total. Wow.
- 14:20So look at that math. We paid $440 for our directional
- 14:24bet, but we immediately collected $390.00 by selling the
- 14:28two calls at our Target. We have financed almost the
- 14:31entire cost of the trade using the market's own money.
- 14:34Exactly. But, and this is a huge but,
- 14:37selling those two calls introduces A structural flaw.
- 14:41We bought one call, but we sold two.
- 14:44That means we have one naked short call.
- 14:47And Noah explicitly jokes on the source material.
- 14:49Nobody wants to see an old man naked.
- 14:52Yeah, it's a funny line, but the financial reality behind it is
- 14:56terrifying If you have a naked short call and some massive news
- 15:00breaks causing the stock to gap up to say, $150.00 a share, Aw.
- 15:05Man. You are on the hook to deliver
- 15:08those shares at 8250. Your risk is theoretically
- 15:12infinite. And an old man trader never
- 15:15accepts infinite risk. The entire philosophy is built
- 15:18on how much can it hurt. We must cap the risk right?
- 15:22So we move to leg three, We go further out of the money past
- 15:25our target and we buy one call option at the $90.00 strike
- 15:29price. And this leg only costs about
- 15:32$75.00 because it's so far away from the current price.
- 15:36Amateurs buy these $90.00 calls as cheap lottery tickets.
- 15:40Just praying for a miracle moon shot but we are buying it for a
- 15:44completely different reason. We are buying it purely as an
- 15:47insurance policy against our own naked position.
- 15:50Exactly. By owning the $90.00 call, we
- 15:53cap our infinite risk. The absolute maximum we can lose
- 15:57on that short side is now mathematically restricted to the
- 16:00distance between the 8250 calls we sold and the $90.00 call we
- 16:04bought. So let's synthesize the final
- 16:07architecture of this trade. We paid $440 for the first leg,
- 16:10collected $390.00 from the second leg, and paid $75.00 for
- 16:15the defensive third leg. That brings our total absolute
- 16:19maximum out of pocket cost to a mere 125 dollars.
- 16:22Yep, if the entire market crashes tomorrow or the stock
- 16:26drops to absolute 0, the absolute worst case scenario is
- 16:30that you lose exactly $125.00. Your downside is an impenetrable
- 16:35fortress. That's incredible.
- 16:37But if the slow cooker works and the stock glides up to our
- 16:41quantified sweet spot of 8250 at expiration, the maximum
- 16:46potential reward is up to $600. You are risking $125.00 to
- 16:52potentially make $600. Which brings us all the way back
- 16:55to the paradox we open the show with.
- 16:57When NOAA plugs this exact targeted butterfly into the
- 17:00probability software, it reveals that there is only a 27.88%
- 17:05chance the stock lands in the target profit zone.
- 17:08Right? And there is an almost 60%
- 17:10chance the trade lands below break even.
- 17:13The math literally says you will probably lose this trade.
- 17:17And this is the brilliant, completely counterintuitive
- 17:20essence of asymmetric risk. The old man trader does not care
- 17:25that he has a 60% chance of losing because he asked the
- 17:28right question at the start. How wrong can I afford to be
- 17:32right? He can easily afford to be wrong
- 17:34for $125. If the trade fails, it is a non
- 17:38event, It doesn't trigger panic, it doesn't induce revenge
- 17:42trading, and it doesn't dent his portfolio.
- 17:45But when he is right, he makes 600 bucks.
- 17:48I mean he can literally afford to lose this exact same trade 3
- 17:51or 4 times in a row and a single win makes his entire month
- 17:55profitable. Furthermore, his plan is totally
- 17:58emotionless if the trade loses 50% of its initial $125.00
- 18:02value. So you know if it drops by about
- 18:04$62.00, he doesn't wait and hope, he just cuts it and walks
- 18:08away. It's.
- 18:08Beautiful and it's simplicity. We've really journeyed from the
- 18:12adrenaline soaked chaotic reality of the modern zero day
- 18:15trader just burning out on infinite risk and high stress,
- 18:19to the calm surgical precision of the old man trader.
- 18:23It's quite the shift. It requires the discipline to
- 18:25learn your Greeks mechanically, the patience to build a
- 18:28psychological fortress with your peas, and the wisdom to filter
- 18:32the noise with your cues until the perfect pitch arrives.
- 18:36And when you finally swing, you structure the trades so that
- 18:38time is working for you. Your downside is strictly capped
- 18:42and your position size ensures you can just sleep soundly at
- 18:45night. You know, the principles of
- 18:47asymmetric risk and capping your downside don't just apply to
- 18:51copper stocks and options chains.
- 18:53They provide a really fascinating framework for
- 18:56looking at your broader life. Oh, that's interesting.
- 18:58Yeah. Think about it, where else are
- 19:00you operating? Like the impulsive young buck,
- 19:03where are you taking on naked infinite risk for a relatively
- 19:07small reward. It's a profound question to
- 19:09leave on. The Old Man Trader mindset is
- 19:12fundamentally about architecting your life so that your downside
- 19:15is strictly capped. Whether it's in your career,
- 19:18your financial habits, or just how you spend your daily energy,
- 19:21If you manage your downside and eliminate the catastrophic
- 19:25risks, you give yourself the longevity to patiently wait for
- 19:28the pitches that actually matter.
- 19:30Thanks for joining us on this deep dive.
- 19:31Keep seeking the signal in the noise.