Latest / Austen Chat / Jane Austen & Masculinity: A Visit with Michael Kramp
Transcript
- 0:13Breckyn Wood: Hello, Janeites, and welcome to "Austen Chat," a podcast brought to you by the Jane Austen Society of North America.
- 0:19Breckyn Wood: I'm your host, Breckyn Wood, from the Georgia Region of JASNA.
- 0:22Breckyn Wood: Listeners, we are all intimately familiar with Austen's men: the good, the bad, and the unctuous.
- 0:28Breckyn Wood: The Johns, Henries, Georges, and Fitzwilliams.
- 0:31Breckyn Wood: But how much do we understand about Regency masculinity and the varied and subtle ways Austen plays with gender expectations in her novels?
- 0:39Breckyn Wood: My guest today is here to help us examine the men of Austen's world and their complex social identities.
- 0:45Breckyn Wood: Michael Kramp is professor of English at Lehigh University.
- 0:49Breckyn Wood: He is the author of "Disciplining Love: Austen and the Modern Man" and "Patriarchy's Creative Resilience," and editor of "Jane Austen and Masculinity" and "Jane Austen and Critical Theory." In June of 2026, he gave an excellent plenary lecture at the Jane Austen Summer Program titled "Political Extremism, Difficult Dialogues, and 'Pride and Prejudice.'" He is currently working on a long-term public-facing project, Jane Austen and the Future of the Humanities.
- 1:14Breckyn Wood: Welcome to the show, Michael.
- 1:16Michael Kramp: Thank you so much.
- 1:17Michael Kramp: It's great to be here.
- 1:18Breckyn Wood: Okay, so to start, can you tell us a bit about your Austen origin story?
- 1:22Breckyn Wood: When did you first encounter her works?
- 1:25Michael Kramp: Yeah, I mean, I think I was late to the game, you know.
- 1:27Michael Kramp: I think I was late to the game.
- 1:28Michael Kramp: I don't, I don't think I'd heard of Jane Austen until my sophomore year in university.
- 1:33Michael Kramp: I saw— I think— at my university there was— I'm not sure if it was a requirement, but it was definitely encouraged for students to enroll in one what they called major author course: one course that focused explicitly and singly on one author.
- 1:46Michael Kramp: And in spring of 1993— I mean it was in the fall of '92, but registering for courses in spring of '93— I remember there was a course on Jane Austen.
- 1:54Michael Kramp: I had looked her up and found out she was this novelist from the 19th century.
- 1:58Michael Kramp: I thought I liked 19th-century novels.
- 2:00Michael Kramp: So I went ahead and registered for the class.
- 2:02Michael Kramp: And I remember it was kind of a threshold moment for me, where I was trying to decide whether I really wanted to major in English or not.
- 2:08Michael Kramp: And I thought, well, here'll be a course that'll be interesting to sort of work as a gauge for that.
- 2:11Michael Kramp: So I enrolled in this class, and I— you know, two things still stand out in my memory about this class.
- 2:17Michael Kramp: One, I was the only male student in the class.
- 2:20Breckyn Wood: Ohhh .
- 2:20Breckyn Wood: .
- 2:20Breckyn Wood: .
- 2:21Michael Kramp: Yeah, yeah.
- 2:22Breckyn Wood: Even in the '90s.
- 2:23Breckyn Wood: I'm surprised that that early the gender divide had already happened.
- 2:26Michael Kramp: Oh, yeah, even in the '90s, I was the only male student in the class, which, you know, was a really, you know, fantastic experience in many ways.
- 2:32Michael Kramp: And the— it's true.
- 2:34Michael Kramp: I mean, it's absolutely true.
- 2:35Michael Kramp: And the— but the other thing that really stands out about that class is that, you know, I had no idea who this person was at the time, but that was a class that was— that was, I believe, the last Austen class taught by Claudia Johnson at my university before she left.
- 2:47Michael Kramp: Now, I didn't know who Claudia Johnson was.
- 2:49Michael Kramp: I mean, it would have meant nothing to me as a 19-year-old college student, but it was in— it's been interesting sort of in the years since trying to think back about, you know, what did I learn in spring of 1993 from Claudia Johnson that has stayed with me?
- 3:00Michael Kramp: And it's something that— so that, that's that's a— so my origin story is very much tied to university.
- 3:05Breckyn Wood: So, it's like you accidentally stumbled into a Harold Bloom Shakespeare class and had no idea what you were getting into?
- 3:12Michael Kramp: No idea what I was getting into.
- 3:13Michael Kramp: I mean, yeah— and it was interesting because then I— again she did— my memory of this, and— well, we probably shouldn't talk about this in the podcast, but my memory of this is that is that she then— that Claudia then took a leave of absence and then took a job at Princeton.
- 3:24Michael Kramp: Um, yeah.
- 3:25Michael Kramp: When I say to people like, I— and I took a class with Claudia Johnson in university, I always want to make clear to note that I was not one of those smart people who went to Princeton.
- 3:33Michael Kramp: It was, it was at her previous institution.
- 3:35Breckyn Wood: I'm always reminding everybody that I only have a bachelor's degree, despite the fact that I'm always interviewing all these PhDs and stuff.
- 3:40Breckyn Wood: I'm like, I promise I'm not trying to lie about my credentials.
- 3:44Michael Kramp: Breckyn, you're that good.
- 3:45Breckyn Wood: Aw, thanks.
- 3:46Breckyn Wood: Okay, so well, that's really funny that you were the only male in this class full of females, because that's what we're talking about today.
- 3:52Breckyn Wood: Several of the books that you've written and edited have talked about how ideas surrounding masculinity and male identity were in flux during Austen's time because of the social and political climate.
- 4:02Breckyn Wood: So, can you just give us like a quick history course?
- 4:05Breckyn Wood: What's going on there and why are these things affecting male identity?
- 4:09Michael Kramp: Sure.
- 4:09Michael Kramp: I mean, I'm not sure how quick it is, but you know, I think that there's plenty going on, right?
- 4:12Michael Kramp: There's plenty going on.
- 4:13Michael Kramp: So the short answer might be something like this: that, you know, Austen's writing— and really coming to write— in a time of great revolutions, whether you want to think about just the French Revolution and the American Revolution, and how we are going to understand the emergence of, you know, a new British nation in the wake of those revolutionary moments.
- 4:29Michael Kramp: And so I do think it's, you know— that's where I would probably start— is that, you know, this is a time period in which how we are going to understand what a good man is, what a proper man is, what a man of England is going to be inflected by the experiences of the French Revolution and the American Revolution.
- 4:42Michael Kramp: And so that's important in a couple of ways, right?
- 4:44Michael Kramp: The first I would say is that there's a whole series of writings and discourses that emerge following the American Revolution, the French Revolution, about questions of this proper man of feeling or the proper man of sense.
- 4:55Michael Kramp: And, you know, this is something that has a long legacy, whether we go back to, you know, Lord Chesterfield's letters to his son, you know, Samuel Richardson's "Sir Charles Grandison," which is Austen's favorite novel and talks extensively about this, but also texts like Laurence Sterne's "Sentimental Journey" or Henry Mackenzie's "Man of Feeling." Um, and perhaps most prominently, for our purposes here today, we think about something like Edmund Burke's "Reflections on the Revolution in France" [sic], which really kind of bemoans and critiques what he— what Burke sees as happening with masculinity and the French Revolution.
- 5:23Michael Kramp: You know, specifically, you know, Burke makes the point that— you know, he has this famous line in the— in the— in "Reflections on the French Revolution" or "the Revolution in France," where he says, "the age of chivalry is gone." It's over, right?
- 5:33Michael Kramp: And he says, you know, that there was this time when we had noble sentiments and grace and courtesy and chivalry and gallantry, and that is now gone.
- 5:41Michael Kramp: And he writes specifically— you know, he's writing specifically about this moment, right, where the revolutionaries storm into the queen's bedroom and take her.
- 5:48Michael Kramp: And he said, "This would never have happened in an age of chivalry.
- 5:50Michael Kramp: This would never have happened in an age of men who knew how to feel properly, and knew how to behave gallantly." And then there's this other discourse that emerges in many ways directly in response to Burke, but also has a much longer legacy.
- 6:01Michael Kramp: We often talk about Wollstonecraft's "Vindication of the Rights of Woman," but her first "Vindication of the Rights of Men" is written in direct response to Burke.
- 6:09Michael Kramp: And, you know, Burke publishes the "Reflections on the Revolution in France" in 1790.
- 6:13Michael Kramp: Mary Wollstonecraft writes immediately back in almost, like, a pamphlet -war mentality— sort of critiquing that— the excessive feeling, the excessive sentimentality that she finds in Edmund Burke, and specifically thinking about it as irrational.
- 6:25Michael Kramp: And this is sort of an argument that she develops then in her "Vindications of the Rights of Woman." But other writers do as well.
- 6:31Michael Kramp: So, you know, we could think about thinkers like, you know, William Godwin, Thomas Paine, John Locke, but also, you know, perhaps more importantly, people like Mary Robinson, who are, you know, really trying to develop alternative ideas about what a rational man could look like— what a man of reason, right, who was able to sort of think through intellectual challenges, would look like.
- 6:49Michael Kramp: Now, that dialogue, I think, is really important for framing Austen's understanding of masculinity for two reasons.
- 6:55Michael Kramp: You know, one, I think it helps us appreciate the ways in which we're going to see the dynamics between men and women in Austen's fiction.
- 7:02Michael Kramp: The sort of— that legacy of Wollstonecraft, sort of defending that man of reason, also becomes a way for her to defend this physically virile, vigorous male figure.
- 7:11Michael Kramp: And she sort of openly mocks then.
- 7:13Michael Kramp: I mean, we get the sort of open critique of husbands who are too much of lovers, or the military man who has too many social acquaintances, right?
- 7:20Michael Kramp: Who's too sensitive to sensations and feeling.
- 7:23Michael Kramp: And so I think that, you know, that dialogue becomes extremely important for framing, you know, what the sort of change or shifts that we have going on.
- 7:30Michael Kramp: But I guess the last sort of, you know, notion that I'd want to raise is that I think that we're going to see the rise of what, you know, a couple of scholars have talked about as this sort of meritocracy of men.
- 7:39Michael Kramp: Um, that different kinds of men are going to be able to have access to sort of situations of power or become leaders.
- 7:46Michael Kramp: Now, later in the 19th century— a few years, you know, 10, 20 years after Austen writes, we get the more prominent development of the idea of manliness.
- 7:53Michael Kramp: Now, that's a— that's a different kind of concept that is sort of rooted in that notion of the reasonable meritocracy: that you have to be born a gentleman, but you can earn manliness.
- 8:02Michael Kramp: You can sort of develop that sense of manliness —that it's going to allow you to become a leader of the nation in different ways.
- 8:09Breckyn Wood: Well, you mentioned Wollstonecraft, and I would say one of Austen's most "Wollstonecrafty" lines is in "Emma" when Mr.
- 8:16Breckyn Wood: Knightley says, "Men of sense do not want silly wives." And that could be taken of a— I mean, almost verbatim from Wollstonecraft.
- 8:23Breckyn Wood: And I love that.
- 8:24Breckyn Wood: I'm just gonna say it right now.
- 8:25Breckyn Wood: My favorite male character in all of Austen is Mr.
- 8:28Breckyn Wood: Knightley.
- 8:28Breckyn Wood: And I used to think that that was pretty obvious, but I've, I've since found that that's kind of controversial.
- 8:33Breckyn Wood: What are what are your thoughts?
- 8:34Breckyn Wood: Do you have a favorite male character from Austen?
- 8:37Michael Kramp: I mean, I'll give you two.
- 8:38Breckyn Wood: Okay.
- 8:39Michael Kramp: One perhaps not so serious, but I think a legitimate answer, and one quite serious.
- 8:43Michael Kramp: I love Mr.
- 8:43Michael Kramp: Bingley.
- 8:44Breckyn Wood: Oh, yeah?
- 8:44Michael Kramp: I've always— I've— I mean, I've always felt like, you know, Mr.
- 8:46Michael Kramp: Bingley would be such a fun guy to spend the weekend with or, like, you know, go out to dinner with, you know.
- 8:50Michael Kramp: I mean, he just seems like— he seems determined to have a good time and you know—
- 8:54Breckyn Wood: And determined to encourage those around him to have a good time.
- 8:57Breckyn Wood: And it's, it's not a self—it's, like, a generous friendliness as opposed to a— just, like, a partier.
- 9:03Breckyn Wood: I think that that's— Bingley is like that.
- 9:05Michael Kramp: No, I love, I love your reading of that.
- 9:07Michael Kramp: No, I think that's right.
- 9:08Michael Kramp: I mean, he is such a— he's saying— so he's so gracious and welcoming and polite.
- 9:12Michael Kramp: And, you know, he always reminds me of my college roommate who was just determined to have a good time, you know.
- 9:17Michael Kramp: I tell this story all the time.
- 9:19Michael Kramp: And I mean, I mean in all sincerity, I mean, this was like my college roommate being completely innocent and honest when he makes his comment.
- 9:26Michael Kramp: But I remember being at a party with my college roommate my first year at university, and he, you know, he's this kid from suburban Chicago, and he's looking around and he says, "There are so many pretty girls here." And it wasn't, it wasn't objectifying.
- 9:38Michael Kramp: It wasn't like rude or crass.
- 9:40Michael Kramp: It was just like this, you know, 18-year-old boy being bewildered, right, by being in a college setting.
- 9:45Michael Kramp: And that's kind of how I always think about Mr.
- 9:46Michael Kramp: Bingley.
- 9:47Michael Kramp: You know, he's just, like, overwhelmed by the beauty and fun and potential in the world.
- 9:51Breckyn Wood: Yeah. He's determined to be pleased, w hereas Mr.
- 9:53Breckyn Wood: Darcy is determined to be displeased, at least in the beginning.
- 9:57Michael Kramp: Yeah, yeah.
- 9:58Michael Kramp: I mean, and there's maybe an unserious answer, but one that I'd love to explore more at some point is I think William Larkins in "Emma" is just a really fascinating character.
- 10:07Breckyn Wood: Minor, very minor character.
- 10:08Michael Kramp: Minor.
- 10:09Michael Kramp: Well, I mean, he's so minor, Breckyn, that he never actually appears, quote, unquote, on stage in the novel.
- 10:14Michael Kramp: But he's this character that everybody talks about; u m, everybody says they can't do without him.
- 10:19Michael Kramp: He's clearly vital to Mr.
- 10:20Michael Kramp: Knightley.
- 10:21Breckyn Wood: Mr.
- 10:21Breckyn Wood: Knightley's steward, right?
- 10:23Breckyn Wood: Or his. . ..
- 10:23Michael Kramp: Yeah.
- 10:24Breckyn Wood: Okay.
- 10:24Breckyn Wood: I mean, I— you said that name, and I panicked.
- 10:26Breckyn Wood: I was like, "I have never heard of this character.
- 10:28Breckyn Wood: Who is that?" No, we're good.
- 10:30Breckyn Wood: Okay.
- 10:31Michael Kramp: But anyways, I think that I like that idea.
- 10:33Michael Kramp: I think Austen's very— I think Austen's very innovative in sort of giving us a character— and he's not the only one, but he is one of the examples in Austen's fiction of a character who never shows up on stage but is clearly really important to the community.
- 10:46Michael Kramp: And I like that idea in sort of a fictional world.
- 10:49Breckyn Wood: Yeah, oh, it makes her villages seem very real.
- 10:51Breckyn Wood: People love to talk about world - building in a fantasy setting.
- 10:55Breckyn Wood: I mean, that phrase is used all the time in the fantasy genre.
- 10:58Breckyn Wood: But I think even realistic writers can do it well if they— if they've given you a sense that you could walk off the page and there would be more.
- 11:06Breckyn Wood: You know, everyone isn't just this cardboard cutout.
- 11:09Breckyn Wood: So, speaking of William Larkin being such a minor character but doing important things, I love to tell people this: when I interviewed John Mullan— he is, you know, an expert on " Emma"— on all of Austen, but I think his personal favorite is "Emma"— I had been talking to him for like 75 minutes, and we had to wrap up the interview.
- 11:25Breckyn Wood: And then I stopped recording, and then he was like, "Well, you know, the most important character in all of "Emma" is Mr.
- 11:30Breckyn Wood: Perry.
- 11:31Breckyn Wood: And I was like, "John, what?
- 11:33Breckyn Wood: I need to know more about that." That's another rather minor character who shows up in a lot— at a lot of critical plot points in the novel.
- 11:42Breckyn Wood: So, I would really love to hear John Mullan's thoughts about why Mr.
- 11:45Breckyn Wood: Perry is so important.
- 11:46Michael Kramp: I mean, I think, um, it's interesting, when I interviewed John, one of the things he mentioned to me— because we talked about Mr.
- 11:51Michael Kramp: Perry and William Larkins— you know, they're very comparable characters.
- 11:54Michael Kramp: I mean, Mr.
- 11:55Michael Kramp: Perry kind of shows up on stage in the novel.
- 11:58Michael Kramp: We don't actually engage in a conversation with him, but we see him walking by, you know? Like, that's it.
- 12:03Michael Kramp: That's as close as we get.
- 12:04Michael Kramp: But "Emma" is the novel that has the most Austenian characters who we never meet.
- 12:09Michael Kramp: They're just— they're just mentioned by name, you know.
- 12:11Michael Kramp: But anyway, that's taking us away.
- 12:14Breckyn Wood: So, let's talk about some of the different roles that Austen's men play, and then maybe you can give us some insight into what she has to say about these roles and how well or poorly her various characters are fulfilling their obligations.
- 12:27Breckyn Wood: So, first some familial roles: fathers.
- 12:30Breckyn Wood: What do you think Austen is doing with the role of "father" in her novels?
- 12:35Michael Kramp: Yeah, I mean, I think— I hope it's not obnoxious to say that I think, by and large, fathers in Austen are pretty, pretty ineffective.
- 12:42Michael Kramp: You know, they're often absent when they're present.
- 12:45Michael Kramp: They're often sort of, you know, irresponsible and chaotic— sometimes even mischievous, right?
- 12:50Michael Kramp: You know, so I mean, I think we tend to want to think about characters like Mr.
- 12:54Michael Kramp: Bennet or Mr.
- 12:55Michael Kramp: Woodhouse, who maybe aren't doing the most as parents to sort of support their daughter— especially their daughters, right?
- 13:01Michael Kramp: But it's also interesting to think about a character like General Tilney, who's this sort of parental figure who is— what— kind of intervening in the lives of his children and, you know, following machinations and coming up with narratives about his children and his children's friends, being very conniving— or maybe that's too strong of a word, I'm not sure— strategic in how he organizes relationships with his children.
- 13:24Michael Kramp: Mr.— you know, Catherine Morland's father, Mr.
- 13:26Michael Kramp: Morland, in ""Northanger Abbey," I think is a, you know, really good example of this sort of situation with a father who's, you know, who's—we're told he's not in the habit of locking up his, you know, his kids or something, right, you know?
- 13:36Michael Kramp: That he doesn't seem to be all that concerned about his young daughter going off to Bath, doesn't really seem to prepare her very well for that experience, right?
- 13:46Breckyn Wood: Oh, he gives her— he puts, like, 10 pounds in her hand or something at some point.
- 13:50Michael Kramp: Right. Yeah, no, I mean I— so I think he's a really interesting example.
- 13:53Michael Kramp: But I— what about "Sense and Sensibility"?
- 13:55Michael Kramp: I mean, I think it'd be interesting to think a little bit about both Mr.
- 13:58Michael Kramp: Henry Dashwood, who, you know, is the character who is sort of dying as the novel opens, and Mr.
- 14:04Michael Kramp: John Dashwood, who inherits that money and, you know, is a father and sort of operates, you know, uh as— is— I guess we might call him an irresponsible or ineffective father in quite a lot of ways, but also a selfish father.
- 14:18Breckyn Wood: Yeah.
- 14:19Michael Kramp: You know, and I— so I like thinking about how Austen treats fathers who oftentimes we don't get a lot of contact with.
- 14:25Michael Kramp: Like, Mr.
- 14:25Michael Kramp: Henry Dashwood— we don't really know at all.
- 14:28Breckyn Wood: Dies at the opening, yeah.
- 14:30Michael Kramp: Right, right.
- 14:30Michael Kramp: But you know, he has this really important paternal function that effectively leaves his wife and three daughters pretty much at the will of strangers for much of the novel.
- 14:38Michael Kramp: Which is— which is a, you know, a challenging, you know, situation.
- 14:42Michael Kramp: What about Mr.
- 14:43Michael Kramp: Palmer in "Sense and Sensibility"?
- 14:45Breckyn Wood: Oh, man.
- 14:45Breckyn Wood: Yeah, only becomes a father part - way through, right?
- 14:48Breckyn Wood: Yeah, it's kind of interesting.
- 14:50Michael Kramp: Yeah. And who seems to sort of be disinterested in all matters, except when his child— they fear for his child's safety; h e seems to be concerned about that.
- 14:58Michael Kramp: And the last father I was going to mention was Mr.
- 15:00Michael Kramp: Weston, who is both father and then new father, right—
- 15:04Breckyn Wood: Yeah.
- 15:04Michael Kramp: —uh, with the news of the pregnancy of his wife at the end of "Emma." And I think that's sort of— I think Mr.
- 15:09Michael Kramp: Weston becomes an interesting example of somebody who gets to be a father twice in two very different kinds of circumstances.
- 15:16Breckyn Wood: Yeah.
- 15:17Breckyn Wood: Well, and I was thinking from our modern perspective, this practice of, like, farming out your children to relatives, which, I mean, is what happens to Frank Churchill, right?
- 15:27Breckyn Wood: So, he 's virtually adopted by his— it's his mother's family, right?
- 15:31Breckyn Wood: And that's why he goes by "Churchill" instead of "Weston." And he's kind of a stranger to his own father.
- 15:37Breckyn Wood: And I think from our modern perspective, that seems like, "Oh, how could you ever do that to your child?
- 15:42Breckyn Wood: But that's what the Austens did.
- 15:43Breckyn Wood: A lot of them— I mean, they would farm them out to the countryside until they were three to a wet nurse or something like that.
- 15:48Breckyn Wood: And one of their children— um, it was Edward Knight, right?
- 15:51Breckyn Wood: —he gets adopted by other relatives and kind of raised by them to be their heir.
- 15:56Breckyn Wood: And so, in some ways, that's sort of alien to us from a modern perspective.
- 16:00Breckyn Wood: But then I love that we get that line from Isabella— contemporary— where she's saying, "I don't know who could ever do that to"— you know, because she's this, like, almost overly doting mother who's so attached to her children.
- 16:09Breckyn Wood: She has that line where she's a little bit shocked and appalled that Mr.
- 16:13Breckyn Wood: Weston could ever let his child go, which I just— I find that interesting, that that's a modern sentiment that we get from one of Austen's characters.
- 16:20Michael Kramp: Yeah.
- 16:21Michael Kramp: And I think that happens a lot with Austen and minor characters, right?
- 16:24Michael Kramp: Characters that we know we don't— who have these sort of one-off— kind of one-off comments.
- 16:28Michael Kramp: They don't appear very often in the story, but they often give us insight into, you know, the sort of cultural changes that are taking place, I think, in Austen's world.
- 16:35Breckyn Wood: Mm-hmm.
- 16:35Breckyn Wood: Well, okay, so let's talk about "brother" next.
- 16:38Breckyn Wood: There's a lot of interesting brothers.
- 16:41Breckyn Wood: Some, you know— you gave some examples.
- 16:42Breckyn Wood: I'll start out.
- 16:43Breckyn Wood: The first brother that I think of is William Price.
- 16:46Breckyn Wood: He and Fanny are so closely attached, and William is such a good brother.
- 16:49Breckyn Wood: He writes her letters, he brings her gifts, and he comes to visit.
- 16:53Breckyn Wood: And I think there's something really interesting going on there: the contrast between William Price as brother and Henry Crawford as brother.
- 16:59Breckyn Wood: And I'd like to hear your thoughts on that.
- 17:01Michael Kramp: Yeah.
- 17:01Michael Kramp: No, I mean, William seems to be such a doting brother.
- 17:04Breckyn Wood: Mm-hmm.
- 17:05Michael Kramp: Such— and such a concerned brother, right?
- 17:07Michael Kramp: You know, concerned about how his sister is doing.
- 17:10Michael Kramp: I mean, I'm not sure how much we would say that William is concerned about his other siblings, but I think that, you know, Henry Crawford seems— it's interesting.
- 17:19Michael Kramp: I once— I was talking a couple of years ago with somebody who made the argument that Austen created Mary Crawford just so we could fully understand how close to being obnoxious Elizabeth Bennet is.
- 17:32Michael Kramp: And I kind of like that idea, right?
- 17:34Michael Kramp: That, you know, that Mary Crawford— and I promise I'll come back to Henry in a second, but—
- 17:38Breckyn Wood: Sure
- 17:38Michael Kramp: Mary Crawford is sort of just on the edge, right?
- 17:41Michael Kramp: You know, where— you know, Elizabeth Bennet we adore; she pushes back on authority, but she also can sort of be, you know, proper and decorous and gracious when she needs to.
- 17:50Michael Kramp: Mary Crawford goes a step too far, right?
- 17:53Michael Kramp: Henry Crawford, it seems to me, is a really good— is a really interesting example of this sort of transactionalist.
- 18:00Breckyn Wood: Oh, that's such a good word for it.
- 18:02Breckyn Wood: I was kind of thinking it, but you just said the word that solidified my thoughts.
- 18:05Breckyn Wood: Keep going.
- 18:06Michael Kramp: No, I mean, he's just— he's really good at sort of, you know, being of service if there is a— you know, not maybe a quid pro quo, but at least a transactional relationship that is going to emerge from it.
- 18:18Michael Kramp: You know, like, he's very good at helping with sort of plans to improve people's estates or do renovations.
- 18:24Michael Kramp: He's very good at helping William Price get access to a promotion in the Navy.
- 18:28Michael Kramp: He— you know, he sort of operates as though he's engaged in a transaction or an exchange of, you know, an exchange of sorts, right?
- 18:35Michael Kramp: As if he's sort of playing a game that the rest of us maybe aren't aware of, right?
- 18:39Michael Kramp: But he's a— I think he's a fascinating figure.
- 18:41Michael Kramp: You mentioned Henry Tilney, who I think is another.
- 18:44Michael Kramp: I think I— I'm not sure, Breckyn, but I think the first paper I ever wrote on Jane Austen as a, you know, sophomore student in university was on Henry Tilney, who I still think is a really interesting character as a brother.
- 18:56Breckyn Wood: Yeah.
- 18:57Michael Kramp: You know, who's deeply concerned with his sister.
- 18:59Michael Kramp: A little bit— I mean, more than a little bit— I think, dismissive of his sister and critical of his sister at times.
- 19:05Breckyn Wood: Really?
- 19:05Michael Kramp: But well, I mean, just you know, in terms of how, you know, he— again, he wants to, you know, help Catherine and Eleanor understand each other in ""Northanger Abbey." He's a little paternalistic in the way in which that comes off.
- 19:15Michael Kramp: But he's also a really interesting character in how he, you know, he demonstrates this sort of emerging concern of brothers for their sisters and for their sisterly concerns, right?
- 19:25Michael Kramp: For what would be of interest to Eleanor, right?
- 19:28Breckyn Wood: Yeah.
- 19:28Michael Kramp: That, you know, he knows about clothing, and he knows about dresses.
- 19:31Breckyn Wood: Novels.
- 19:32Michael Kramp: Yeah, right.
- 19:33Michael Kramp: He has a— he has an awareness of this, right?
- 19:35Michael Kramp: And I think it's— I think it's interesting to kind of consider what that suggests about his brotherly relationship.
- 19:40Breckyn Wood: I do think— uh, yeah, I mean, you mentioned General Tilney back with fathers.
- 19:44Breckyn Wood: I would say within the one novel of "Northanger Abbey," you have the most terrifying view of masculinity with General Tilney and how —just his power trip and his tyranny.
- 19:55Breckyn Wood: That's what Austen calls it.
- 19:56Breckyn Wood: She calls it "parental tyranny." And then you have on the other end of this spectrum, Henry, who is a man, right?
- 20:04Breckyn Wood: He's a— he fulfills all of the expectations of his society.
- 20:07Breckyn Wood: As a man, he's a good brother, he's a good son, he's got a profession, all of this.
- 20:11Breckyn Wood: But he talks to women the way that— it's— he's kind of like— again, a modern phrase would be, like, "a man written by a woman." Obviously, they're all men written by women because Austen wrote them, but the idea of a man written by a woman is how women wish men would act.
- 20:25Breckyn Wood: And I think that that's kind of what Henry Tilney is.
- 20:28Breckyn Wood: He can talk to women about the things that interest them— and fluently, not like an outsider.
- 20:34Breckyn Wood: I've always found that really interesting about Henry Tilney.
- 20:37Breckyn Wood: And diaries too.
- 20:37Breckyn Wood: He mentions her writing in her diary— all of these things that are sort of Regency, stereotypically feminine, he can talk with facility about.
- 20:45Breckyn Wood: Yeah.
- 20:46Michael Kramp: No, I love this conversation about Henry Tilney.
- 20:47Michael Kramp: I mean, I think one of the things that strikes me most about him is that, like, he's aware of— you know, we— your first question, right, about what's happening with masculinity?
- 20:55Michael Kramp: What's happening with gender relations in this period?
- 20:57Michael Kramp: There's a sense in which Henry Tilney is, like, the ultimate example of somebody who's self-conscious about this, right?
- 21:02Michael Kramp: So, I love it when he says to Catherine, like, "I'm sure I'm, you know—I'll make some great character in your journal this evening," right?
- 21:07Michael Kramp: You know, it's like he has this understanding, like, that's part of the game, right?
- 21:10Michael Kramp: That you know, he— this is the game you should be playing.
- 21:12Michael Kramp: You should be home— going home now and writing in your journal.
- 21:15Michael Kramp: Or when he says, you know, like, you know, "We've engaged in a dance; this is an emblem of marriage," right?
- 21:19Michael Kramp: You know, like, I mean, he— there's a way in which, like, he knows the routine.
- 21:23Michael Kramp: But perhaps the most poignant example for me in that novel is when his father is sort of surveilling Catherine on the dance floor, right?
- 21:30Michael Kramp: And Henry says to [her], "You have a right to know who's looking at you," right?
- 21:33Michael Kramp: As if, like, you know, that's part of what happens here, right?
- 21:36Michael Kramp: These older men looking at these younger women in this really disturbing, right, unsettling way in "Northanger Abbey." And Henry sort of is aware of the routine.
- 21:44Michael Kramp: Like, he has a self - consciousness about the way in which men are going to behave and the way in which men expect women to behave, that I think is [unintelligible] once it's really informative.
- 21:53Michael Kramp: I mean, I think at times it's unsettling, but it's really informative, right, about this sort of game that men and women are playing in Austen's fiction.
- 22:01Breckyn Wood: Henry Tilney's meta humor is what most appealed to me as a teenager when I first read him— his self-awareness and his self-effacing humor.
- 22:10Breckyn Wood: It was really appealing to me as a teenager.
- 22:12Breckyn Wood: And I'll say I never thought about this before, b ut that is— I mean, Austen is a hyper self-aware author.
- 22:18Breckyn Wood: She's always watching herself writing and writing about writing, even in the juvenilia and also in her letters.
- 22:25Breckyn Wood: But I would say of all of the novels, "Northanger Abbey" might be the most self-aware, because she is so specifically parodying this body of Gothic literature.
- 22:34Breckyn Wood: And so, then to have a hero who is very self-aware of, like, the types and the tropes— I don't know.
- 22:39Breckyn Wood: That's an interesting parallel between the form of the novel and then Henry Tilney as a hero.
- 22:44Breckyn Wood: Does that make any sense?
- 22:45Michael Kramp: Yeah.
- 22:45Michael Kramp: No, it does.
- 22:46Michael Kramp: It does.
- 22:46Michael Kramp: Yeah.
- 22:46Michael Kramp: I know it does.
- 22:47Michael Kramp: I mean, I just may throw out a couple of other brothers that I think maybe we don't always think about, right?
- 22:51Michael Kramp: I mean, we mentioned Mr.
- 22:52Michael Kramp: John Dashwood, right, who I think, you know, in "Sense and Sensibility" is sort of neglecting, right—
- 22:56Breckyn Wood: Oh, yeah.
- 22:57Michael Kramp: Um, neglecting his family beyond his immediate wife and son, and you know, specifically neglecting the advice that his father gave to him, right, which I think is really compelling.
- 23:06Michael Kramp: I mean, we don't always think about this person as a brother in Austen's fiction, but I think maybe we should: Captain Wentworth is a brother in "Persuasion," right?
- 23:15Breckyn Wood: Yeah.
- 23:15Michael Kramp: Sophia Croft is his sister, you know, and I think we— the reason I mention that is I think Sophia Croft is— she has this wonderfully sort of sisterly— as somebody who grew up with four sisters— this wonderfully sisterly moment where she kind of calls her brother out on his nonsense, right, you know?
- 23:28Michael Kramp: And says, you know, "I hate to hear you talking that way as if women are a bunch of irrational creatures," you know.
- 23:33Michael Kramp: She sounds very much like Mary Wollstonecraft to me, you know, when she makes that comment, right?
- 23:38Michael Kramp: You know, "women are— women have this rational capacity and can, you know, can— none of us can expect to be in calm waters or smooth waters all of our days.
- 23:45Michael Kramp: What about the brotherly relationship between Colonel Brandon and his older brother?
- 23:49Breckyn Wood: Oh, so sad.
- 23:49Michael Kramp: Which seems to be like a really, a really interesting situation where like that sort of fraternity has failed— where it's become competitive.
- 23:56Michael Kramp: I'm not sure I'd present this as exact opposite, but it's sort of a corollary example— what about the brotherly relationship that we get between George and John Knightley in "Emma"?
- 24:05Breckyn Wood: I love them.
- 24:06Breckyn Wood: They're probably the happiest brothers, I would say.
- 24:09Michael Kramp: I think so.
- 24:10Michael Kramp: I think that's right.
- 24:11Michael Kramp: I think that's fair.
- 24:12Michael Kramp: I mean— and you know, one of the reasons I love that is that there's that moment near the end of "Emma" where Mr.
- 24:17Michael Kramp: Knightley goes to London, and he's got to clear his head.
- 24:20Michael Kramp: And he goes to London, and he says something like, "But, you know, things were too familiar to me there." You know, his brother's married to Emma's sister, and there's, like, there's too much familiarity there, and he has to leave.
- 24:30Michael Kramp: But I think that's a moment where, you know, you get a sense that Mr.
- 24:33Michael Kramp: George Knightley is sort of going to his brother for solace or something— you know, for comfort.
- 24:37Michael Kramp: And yeah, I've— so I think those are some of the brotherly relationships that I think we often forget about in "Emma" or in " Emma" and in Austen.
- 24:44Breckyn Wood: I was trying to look up the line— and I don't know if I'll be able to find it— but there's that wonderful line in "Emma" where John and George Knightley are just chatting about the farm and the drainage.
- 24:53Breckyn Wood: And on the surface it seems very business or transactional, but Austen says— she sort of indicates that underneath either brother would do anything for the other.
- 25:01Breckyn Wood: Do you know what I'm talking about?
- 25:02Michael Kramp: Yeah, I do.
- 25:03Michael Kramp: And aren't they like discussing a path to Donwell?
- 25:06Breckyn Wood: Yeah.
- 25:06Breckyn Wood: I see it right here where it says that they're both equally interested in where "the destination of every acre for wheat, turnips, or spring corn was entered into with as much equality of interest by John as his cooler manners rendered possible." And that isn't the line I'm thinking of.
- 25:21Breckyn Wood: I know— I'll have to go back and look, but there is a line somewhere that indicates that even though on the surface they are these sort of reserved English gentlemen, underneath there is that strong bond of brotherly love and affection for one another.
- 25:33Breckyn Wood: Okay, one more role that the men play is just that of friend.
- 25:37Breckyn Wood: I think— and you started out talking about Mr.
- 25:40Breckyn Wood: Bingley, which is great because I think he is a genuinely good friend to Darcy.
- 25:44Breckyn Wood: And even though they're kind of these opposites in a lot of ways, they complement each other.
- 25:48Breckyn Wood: We don't get a ton of examples of male friendship in Austen, since she famously never wrote any male-only scenes.
- 25:54Breckyn Wood: But I really would like to go and talk more about Wentworth and some of his sailor friends.
- 25:59Breckyn Wood: I think the picture of sort of, like, brotherly love she creates in that novel is really powerful.
- 26:04Michael Kramp: Well, can I mention two other male friendships that we can come back to if you want to?
- 26:08Michael Kramp: [Unintelligible] happy— I love talking about the Navy and "Persuasion," but, I mean, two others that— one is really famous, of course, that I think deserves more attention than it gets, and that is, of course, between Darcy and Bingley in "Pride and Prejudice": these two friends.
- 26:19Michael Kramp: I don't think we ask often enough questions about that friendship that I think is probably worth attending to.
- 26:24Michael Kramp: Another male friendship from "Northanger Abbey," right, of John Thorpe and James Morland, who are, you know, school friends, right?
- 26:30Michael Kramp: And, you know, friends in a way that maybe seems trans— again, that word "transactional," may be appropriate here, maybe not— but maybe not the closest of friends, right?
- 26:40Michael Kramp: The Navy seems different, right, for a couple of reasons.
- 26:43Michael Kramp: Just a couple of thoughts.
- 26:44Michael Kramp: One going back to what we said earlier about this kind of emergence of manliness and the man of meritocracy.
- 26:49Michael Kramp: I mean, the Navy seems to be really — the naval characters in "Persuasion" strike me as very good examples of this: characters who have sort of made their fortune, who have embraced the waters in the war and been able to sort of become these leading figures— like, these leaders.
- 27:03Michael Kramp: Wentworth is now a captain.
- 27:05Michael Kramp: Harville is now a captain.
- 27:06Michael Kramp: Uh, that they've sort of made it.
- 27:08Michael Kramp: That creates a different sense, I think, of friendship and camaraderie.
- 27:11Michael Kramp: I think some scholars have argued that, you know, there's even that sense of a family that gets created in the Navy— in that domestic setting in Lyme where they seem to operate in this very familial manner.
- 27:20Michael Kramp: But it seems to me also a way in which we understand masculinity there as weathered— a masculinity that's been marked— in contrast to, like, the masculinity that we see in that novel with, you know, Sir Elliot, who likes the smooth complexion, who likes things to be polished and neat.
- 27:34Michael Kramp: There's a way in which the naval masculinity is a rugged masculinity that's had to earn its manliness, and because of that it is marked.
- 27:41Michael Kramp: There's the famous, you know, sort of parable of sorts that Captain Wentworth shares about the chestnut, right?
- 27:46Michael Kramp: You know, here's the nut, right?
- 27:48Michael Kramp: That it's got smooth— and it's so firm, right?
- 27:51Michael Kramp: But it's interesting that the Navy, I would argue, sort of affects men in the opposite way.
- 27:55Michael Kramp: There's— there are no smooth naval officers, right?
- 27:57Michael Kramp: They've been weathered; they've been worn; they've been affected by the elements at sea.
- 28:02Michael Kramp: And I think that does affect the way in which they approach friendship and approach— and certainly approach community in the novel.
- 28:08Breckyn Wood: I think the word that Sir Elliot uses is "mahogany,"— that somebody's complexion is as dark as mahogany after they've been out in the sun and the salt, and he says it with such contempt.
- 28:18Breckyn Wood: I have a quote here.
- 28:19Breckyn Wood: I like to delve back into the text whenever possible.
- 28:22Breckyn Wood: I saved a quote from "Persuasion," and it kind of supports exactly what you said about— that this friendship is sort of elevated to a family relationship.
- 28:31Breckyn Wood: It says "There was so much attachment to Captain Wentworth in all this, and such a bewitching charm and a degree of hospitality so uncommon, so unlike the usual style of give and take invitations and dinners of formality and display, that Anne felt her spirits not likely to be benefited by an increasing acquaintance among his brother officers.
- 28:49Breckyn Wood: These would have all been my friends, was her thought." I think that's so poignant and sad and beautiful because we tend to portray "Persuasion" as, like, this lost love story.
- 28:58Breckyn Wood: And it is.
- 28:58Breckyn Wood: It's mostly a love story between Anne and Wentworth.
- 29:02Breckyn Wood: But Anne is also mourning how her entire life would be different.
- 29:05Breckyn Wood: Because she just— nobody in her own family circle understands her or cares about her or really has any of the same pleasures or interests as her.
- 29:15Breckyn Wood: And she could have had this other family— this sort of chosen, found family— if she had married Wentworth eight years previously, and that 's worth mourning just as much as the lost romance.
- 29:25Michael Kramp: Yeah.
- 29:26Michael Kramp: This quotation that you provide, I think, is— but it's always interesting to me to think about sort of these intertextual moments in Austen's fiction, because this comment Anne offers— and I'm sure that many— I'm positive that many a scholar has talked about this; I'm just not sure who they are—but this comment from Anne where she says, you know, "these would have all been my friends." It always reminds me of that moment in "Pride and Prejudice" when Elizabeth Bennet sort of is walking around Pemberley and says, like, you know, "All this," right?
- 29:52Michael Kramp: You know.
- 29:52Michael Kramp: And it's interesting that for, you know, for Elizabeth Bennet, it seems— it always strikes me as such an epiphany moment tied to materiality.
- 30:00Michael Kramp: Where for Anne Elliott here, it's an epiphany moment tied to community— tied to this sort of friendship that she observes amongst the men in the Navy.
- 30:08Breckyn Wood: Yeah.
- 30:08Breckyn Wood: I have never heard that or that echo.
- 30:11Breckyn Wood: I love it.
- 30:12Breckyn Wood: I hear it now, now that you point it out.
- 30:14Breckyn Wood: I think there's many times in the novel of "Persuasion" where Anne— where we're made to think about community and friendship and— because there's that conversation that she has with Mr.
- 30:25Breckyn Wood: Elliot about what makes good company.
- 30:28Breckyn Wood: And he says— she's, like, "I just want people who are well informed ," et cetera, et cetera.
- 30:32Breckyn Wood: And he's like, "Oh, that's not good company.
- 30:34Breckyn Wood: For good company, all you need is good breeding or whatever.
- 30:37Breckyn Wood: That is the best company." There's multiple examples of that—of, like, what does it mean to have a good circle of friends or a good community or enjoyable company to spend time with?
- 30:47Breckyn Wood: And you know, when she goes to the Musgroves, it's better company than at home because it's more lively, it's a little— it's much more friendly than her own small— her mean sister and her mean dad.
- 30:58Breckyn Wood: But it's still not great company, because everybody just talks at her.
- 31:02Breckyn Wood: She— when she moves from Kellynch Hall to the Musgroves', she becomes sort of a receptacle, and everybody's pouring all their problems and concerns into her, and she doesn't get to pour any of that back.
- 31:11Breckyn Wood: And it's only when she then moves among this naval circle that she's finally with equals— you know, not necessarily in a social sense but in an intellectual sense.
- 31:20Michael Kramp: Yeah.
- 31:20Michael Kramp: Yeah.
- 31:21Michael Kramp: No, it kind of raises an interesting question, Breckyn, which I don't know if I have a clear answer to, but, you know, there's a way in which Austen kind of invites us to evaluate men in her fiction through their ability to engage in these communities, through their ability to sort of maintain social dialogue and social conversation.
- 31:38Michael Kramp: You know, so again, I go back to someone like General Tilney, who strikes me as so manipulative about the way in which he's sort of engaging in conversation, right?
- 31:45Michael Kramp: You know, Mr.
- 31:46Michael Kramp: Darcy famously struggles with this.
- 31:48Michael Kramp: Colonel Brandon might— is very sensitive and has an understanding of taste, but he doesn't— he's often awkward trying to engage in a conversation.
- 31:56Michael Kramp: Some of the people who are so great at conversations, right—
- 31:59Breckyn Wood: Willoughby
- 31:59Michael Kramp: —you know, are people like Willoughby or Wickham, right?
- 32:02Michael Kramp: You know, who are fantastic in these sort of social settings and can sort of come in— you know, can speak off the cuff and have all kinds of fun, witty, you know, exchanges, right?
- 32:10Michael Kramp: There's a way in which I think Austen shows us that, you know, oftentimes the ability to do that is a danger.
- 32:15Michael Kramp: It's a risk, you know— that those men can be threatening.
- 32:18Michael Kramp: But that's not the case with the Navy.
- 32:20Michael Kramp: You know, the Navy in "Persuasion" seems to have a sense of brotherhood, but a brotherhood that is open— that is also elastic and sort of inviting to other people who come in.
- 32:28Michael Kramp: So, Anne brings the Musgroves and, you know, her friends, you know, with her, and the Harvilles are "Come on in.
- 32:33Michael Kramp: You should have stayed for supper." You know, so I think it is a real brotherhood, but it's a— you know, it's a way in which I think Austen helps us imagine what— if we think about Austen's study of masculinity as sort of exploring who will be the leaders of the future, who— what kinds of men are going to sort of rise and take over the future of England?
- 32:53Michael Kramp: I think Austen is sort of inviting us to think about the Navy, and, you know, putting that in dialogue with a character like Sir Walter or Mr.
- 32:59Michael Kramp: Woodhouse, who seem to be sort of crumbling, right?
- 33:02Michael Kramp: Who seem to be— you know, Sir Thomas in "Mansfield Park," who seemed to be sort of in decay or in decline or atrophy.
- 33:08Michael Kramp: But I think that's— for me, that's a very helpful way of talking about Austen's treatment of masculinity.
- 33:13Breckyn Wood: Which is really interesting because she's writing this, I mean, a hundred years before the real death— World War I, there is the final, you know, nail in the coffin for the British aristocracy in a lot of ways.
- 33:23Breckyn Wood: And that's a solid hundred years before— after Austen is writing.
- 33:27Breckyn Wood: So, it's kind of amazing— her prophetic vision there in a lot of ways.
- 33:31Breckyn Wood: So, one more sort of male archetype I want to talk about— just because it's so fun— before we wrap up, is she— Austen features the lover, the cad, but my favorite one is the dandy.
- 33:43Breckyn Wood: Do you want to talk a bit about the dandy in Austen, and what does that mean, and what are— how is she portraying this version of masculinity?
- 33:51Michael Kramp: Yeah, I mean, I don't know.
- 33:52Michael Kramp: I mean, I think I have a bad answer for you on this because—
- 33:55Breckyn Wood: Oh, okay.
- 33:56Michael Kramp: Well, no, I mean, I guess, like— so who's the dandy in Austen?
- 33:59Michael Kramp: I mean— I think that, you know, Joseph Litvak, years and years and years ago, made the argument that Henry Tilney is kind of a dandy figure in Austen, right?
- 34:06Michael Kramp: Which I think is kind of interesting.
- 34:07Michael Kramp: You know, I mean, is—
- 34:08Breckyn Wood: Robert Ferrars.
- 34:10Breckyn Wood: Robert Ferrars.
- 34:11Michael Kramp: Robert Ferrars, you know.
- 34:12Michael Kramp: I guess my point— I think I struggle with this.
- 34:14Michael Kramp: I struggle with this approach to Austen's men.
- 34:17Michael Kramp: Not because it— maybe it's true, maybe it's not— but I guess I just prefer to see Austen's men as, like, you know, less archetypal or less stereotypical.
- 34:24Michael Kramp: So Robert Ferrars, you know— maybe with his toothpick case, and, you know—
- 34:29Breckyn Wood: That is one of my favorite scenes in all of Austen.
- 34:31Breckyn Wood: I love the toothpick case.
- 34:32Michael Kramp: Yeah.
- 34:33Breckyn Wood: But you're— no, you're right.
- 34:34Breckyn Wood: And actually, I will quote you back to you, Michael, because I was reading an interview with you that they— I think that JASP did, and I really liked this line where you said one of Austen's greatest authorial gifts is giving every single character, even the ones we want to say are villainous, levels of complexity.
- 34:50Breckyn Wood: And so, I agree that Austen doesn't actually distill down into archetypes very well because one of the most enjoyable things about her writing is how complex her characters are.
- 34:59Breckyn Wood: But the historical idea of the dandy— it does pop up a little bit— like Frank Churchill riding 16 miles to go get his hair cut, right?
- 35:07Breckyn Wood: That makes— that is a juicy bit of gossip in the town for a while.
- 35:12Michael Kramp: Yeah.
- 35:12Michael Kramp: I mean, absolutely.
- 35:14Michael Kramp: I mean, correct me if I'm wrong here, Breckyn, but I mean, even, like, the Frank Churchill example is a great one— is a great example because he doesn't really do that.
- 35:20Michael Kramp: That's not really what he's doing, right?
- 35:22Breckyn Wood: Yeah, you know how long it took me to figure that out?
- 35:24Breckyn Wood: He's buying the piano, people.
- 35:26Michael Kramp: Right.
- 35:26Michael Kramp: I mean, but like, so, I mean, I think that's— I think that's exactly what I mean when I say, yes, Frank Churchill has all kinds of dandy-esque qualities to him.
- 35:33Michael Kramp: I mean, Wickham has all kinds of, you know, characteristics of the cad and the dandy, I would say.
- 35:37Michael Kramp: But I think they're also— I mean, I think Austen invites us to sort of see this emerging complexity of masculinity in the early 19th century through, you know, through these different lenses.
- 35:47Michael Kramp: Can I just say one thing about Darcy and Bingley?
- 35:50Michael Kramp: Because I think this is— I think this is another sort of large scope way of understanding masculinity in Austen's fiction.
- 35:56Michael Kramp: I still, to this day, don't think we ask enough questions or explore enough why Darcy is so concerned about Bingley.
- 36:03Michael Kramp: Like, I still think we need to sort of, you know, reflect on that, you know, more critically.
- 36:07Michael Kramp: I mean, okay, they're friends.
- 36:09Michael Kramp: I get that.
- 36:09Michael Kramp: And I guess, theoretically, we could suggest that they are sort of on different spectrums of the land— of the gentry, right?
- 36:16Michael Kramp: I mean, Darcy is sort of—
- 36:17Breckyn Wood: New money.
- 36:18Michael Kramp: Yeah, but you know, Bingley— Bingley is clearly distinct in terms of his economic, you know, heritage from Darcy.
- 36:24Michael Kramp: And the reason I want to emphasize that is I think it tells us so much about Austen's treatment of masculinity that Darcy's really concerned about what happens to Bingley.
- 36:33Michael Kramp: That I think Darcy is aware— Darcy understands that the English nation of the future is really going to need men like Mr.
- 36:42Michael Kramp: Bingley to be contributing, you know, legitimate contributing leaders and men.
- 36:47Michael Kramp: And I think, you know, Darcy's— I would argue, I mean, Darcy's legitimately concerned about who Bingley's going to— who, you know, who will Bingley marry?
- 36:54Michael Kramp: What will his future look like?
- 36:55Michael Kramp: And— but I think that tells us so much— that this sort of— this member of the, you know, higher landed gentry, who has aristocratic ties through his mother, is concerned about a man whose money comes from trade.
- 37:07Michael Kramp: And I think that— you know, again, the sort of shifting expectations of what a sort of leading man can be, what an important man to the nation could be, I think Austen encapsulates very nicely in that treatment of Darcy and Bingley.
- 37:20Breckyn Wood: I think the question you've made me ask is "What is Darcy getting out of this relationship?" Because obviously— I mean, it's just a socially beneficial relationship for Bingley and his sisters to be tying themselves to someone like Darcy, and their money has kind of opened the doors to even— metaphorically opened the doors to Pemberley for them.
- 37:36Breckyn Wood: But so, you posit that what Darcy gets out of this relationship is he's sort of, like, taking Bingley under his wing, and maybe it's an extension of his patriarchal duties as a landowner or as someone who has a vested interest in the future of Britain?
- 37:50Michael Kramp: Yeah, and you know, a future of interest— a future interest in how men will behave, right?
- 37:55Michael Kramp: I mean, one of the —you asked— one of the questions we didn't talk about but you had sent me was, you know, where do we see the shifting cultural concept of what it means to be a man reflected in Austen's novels?
- 38:04Michael Kramp: And I think this is a great— this is a great moment.
- 38:06Michael Kramp: Another moment, again in "Pride and Prejudice", when they're at Pemberley— and I'm gonna quote this because, you know, Mrs.
- 38:11Michael Kramp: Reynolds says— on Mr.
- 38:13Michael Kramp: Darcy— Mrs.
- 38:13Michael Kramp: Reynolds says, "He is the best landlord and the best master that ever lived, not like the wild young men nowadays who think of nothing but themselves," right?
- 38:22Michael Kramp: And one way to think about the relationship between Darcy and Bingley is Darcy cannot allow any more wealthy men of new money to become those wild young men who think only about themselves, right?
- 38:34Michael Kramp: Darcy can't have that.
- 38:36Michael Kramp: Darcy knows that England is going to need— especially in the wake of the French Revolution— England is going to need responsible, civil, gracious young men who are gonna sort of— who have money to, sort of, you know, establish the future of the gentry.
- 38:50Breckyn Wood: That's a very selfless reading of Darcy.
- 38:53Breckyn Wood: I think that's interesting, especially for someone who says "I've been a selfish creature all my life."
- 38:57Michael Kramp: I don't think it's selfless.
- 38:58Michael Kramp: That's interesting, because I don't think it's selfless at all.
- 38:59Michael Kramp: I think it's quite selfish of Darcy.
- 39:01Breckyn Wood: Okay.
- 39:02Michael Kramp: I think Darcy— I think Darcy —I mean, let me make it sound more crass then, Breckyn.
- 39:06Michael Kramp: I think Darcy sees Bingley as a resource.
- 39:09Breckyn Wood: Okay.
- 39:09Michael Kramp: A resource that cannot be wasted.
- 39:11Michael Kramp: And I don't think that's selfless.
- 39:14Michael Kramp: I think that's— I think Darcy has seen what's happened to Wickham, right?
- 39:18Michael Kramp: Darcy has seen what, you know, what Mrs.
- 39:19Michael Kramp: Reynolds refers to as these "wild young men." He can't— I don't— I think he's being quite selfish.
- 39:24Michael Kramp: He's being strategic and making sure that this does not happen to Bingley.
- 39:28Breckyn Wood: Preserving his interests.
- 39:30Breckyn Wood: That's interesting.
- 39:30Breckyn Wood: I'm gonna have to go back and read through that lens.
- 39:34Breckyn Wood: Okay, we're reaching the end here.
- 39:36Breckyn Wood: We didn't get to all of our questions, but I do want to hear just a little bit—can you tell us about your big project, "Jane Austen and the Future of the Humanities," for those who haven't heard about it?
- 39:45Breckyn Wood: Tell us about it.
- 39:46Michael Kramp: Thanks so much, Breckyn.
- 39:47Michael Kramp: But this is a project that really began because of my concern and fear that, you know, our discussions about the humanities have just become too elitist and too defensive.
- 39:55Michael Kramp: That we've, you know, we've become really defensive about how we talk about the value of the humanities.
- 40:00Michael Kramp: And it's a conversation that we're not very good— especially in the university— at having, you know, in ways that is accessible and open.
- 40:06Michael Kramp: And so I really want to leverage Jane Austen in a way to talk about why the humanities are important to people outside of the university as well as people inside the university.
- 40:16Michael Kramp: So to that extent, I've tried to create various public - access mediums through podcasts and YouTube films to try to help people understand, you know, how Austen really addresses some of these central issues and ideas in the humanities.
- 40:28Michael Kramp: And so, I guess the end goal for me is that if people— you know, if students and parents are not going to listen to academics or people like me about why the humanities are important, maybe they'll listen to Jane Austen.
- 40:39Michael Kramp: And I think that's— you know, Jane Austen has more cultural clout than any of us.
- 40:42Michael Kramp: I think it's— that's my attempt to kind of, you know, shamelessly leverage Jane Austen to think about the humanities.
- 40:48Breckyn Wood: Uh-huh.
- 40:48Breckyn Wood: And her social capital just keeps rising.
- 40:50Breckyn Wood: I mean, she's a good investment.
- 40:52Michael Kramp: Yeah, yeah.
- 40:53Michael Kramp: She's good money, I mean, right?
- 40:54Michael Kramp: You know, I mean, good investment, good for all of that.
- 40:57Breckyn Wood: And yeah, I would definitely encourage people to go give that podcast a listen because, I mean, pretty much all of my previous guests and all of the big names in Austen— Claudia Johnson, John Mullan, Inger Brodey, Janet Saidi— I mean, you've had everybody on, so—
- 41:12Michael Kramp: It's been a great run.
- 41:13Michael Kramp: Yeah, it's been a lot of fun.
- 41:14Breckyn Wood: Well, this has been such a great conversation, Michael.
- 41:16Breckyn Wood: Thank you so much for chatting with me today.
- 41:18Breckyn Wood: Did you mention where listeners can go to find out more about that?
- 41:21Breckyn Wood: I mean, I just google everything, but for people who want a URL or something .
- 41:26Breckyn Wood: .
- 41:26Breckyn Wood: .
- 41:26Breckyn Wood: .
- 41:26Michael Kramp: I think I do have a URL, but it probably— it'll probably take me too long to—I mean, it is—
- 41:31Breckyn Wood: It's unwieldy?
- 41:32Michael Kramp: Yeah, it's probably unwieldy, but, I mean, the podcast is available wherever you get your podcasts.
- 41:36Michael Kramp: It's called "Jane Austen and the Future of the Humanities," and that is the name of the YouTube page as well.
- 41:40Breckyn Wood: Yeah, and then your faculty bio also at Lehigh has a lot of links and explanations of all those.
- 41:46Breckyn Wood: So, go check it out.
- 41:47Breckyn Wood: All right, well, thank you so much.
- 41:49Michael Kramp: Thank you, Breckyn.
- 41:51Breckyn Wood: Dearest listeners, I am pleased to announce that Austen Chat now has over 200 five-star reviews on Apple Podcasts.
- 41:59Breckyn Wood: Thank you so much for your support.
- 42:01Breckyn Wood: If you haven't yet given us a rating, please consider leaving a five-star review on Apple Podcasts so that more Janeites can find us and join our Austen loving community.
- 42:10Breckyn Wood: Again, thank you.
- 42:12Breckyn Wood: I remain yours respectfully, Breckyn Wood.