Latest / 323 Bourbon Library Podcast / 06/09/26 EPISODE 002: BOTTLE BREAKDOWN - 2025 WILLIAM LARUE WELLER
Transcript
- 323 Bourbon Library Podcast: you Listen, folks, welcome back in to the 323 Bourbon Library podcast. And we did one episode where we did a little intro. Yep. Everybody got to know us a little bit, but we are now starting with the actual podcast episodes and you all voted on Instagram, TikTok, YouTube. We put out there three bottles as a potential bottle review for our very first episode, George T. Stagg 2025 release. ⁓ a Heaven Hill 22 year old, 26 release, and the William LaRue Weller 2025 release. And by a little bit more than a slim margin, the William- A little bit more than a slim? I'd say it was a landslide, but okay. Listen, that Heaven Hill, I was surprised that it came in a close second on Instagram. But when they tallied up all the other ⁓ votes, the William LaRue Weller, ⁓ came out on top. And frankly, I think it's the perfect bottle to start this whole journey off with. And why? And why, you ask? When I really started getting into bourbon, it was Weller. Right. And I loved Weller. And this is like the hardest to find Weller. They're expensive if you get them on the secondary. So it's a unicorn. It's definitely a unicorn. This is a unicorn bottle. that was selected by our viewers out of multiple unicorns. Yeah, we, is all rainbows and unicorns. Exactly. Exactly. So what I wanted to do here is, I know there's other podcasts out there. There's other places you can find out about William LaRue Weller. But I wanted to get a little, a little bit of a history about who was William LaRue Weller and why this bourbon, right? What is this? Why is it special, et cetera? So ⁓ let's dive in. William LaRue Weller. was born in 1825 and lived to 1899. And he was a foundational icon in the history of American whiskey, widely celebrated as the pioneer who introduced the world to weeded bourbon. ⁓ okay. Thank you. Born in, exactly, we love weeded bourbon. Born in LaRue County, Kentucky, Weller came from a family with deep roots in the early frontier distillation tradition. After serving as a lieutenant in the Mexican-American War, Weller returned to Kentucky and established a wholesale liquor company in Louisville in 1848 alongside his brother Charles. Weller's true fame came in 1849 when he decided to alter the traditional bourbon mash bill. At that time, most almost all bourbon used a rye as a secondary flavoring grain. Weller swapped the spicy rye for a soft, sweet winter wheat. creating a remarkably smoother, rounder, and gentler profile. He marketed his product with the timeless slogan, honest whiskey at an honest price. Interestingly, Weller was primarily a whiskey rectifier, merchant, and blender rather than a hands-on master distiller. He built a powerhouse brand by sourcing excellent whiskey and blending it to his standards. In 1893, As he was aging, Weller made another legendary move by hiring a young Julian Pappy Van Winkle. ⁓ that's where they came together. As a traveling salesman. Following Weller's death in 1899, Van Winkle and business partner Alex Farnsley eventually bought the W.L. Weller and Sons Company. Following prohibition, they merged it with the Arthur Stitzel Distillery to form the immortal Stitzel Weller Distillery in 1935. Today the W.L. Weller legacy belongs to Buffalo Trace, where the pinnacle of his namesake line is released annually as a crown jewel in the Buffalo Trace antique collection, also known as BTAC. So a little history about these BTAC releases, or of Weller BTAC releases. So ⁓ William LeRoux Weller expression in the Buffalo Trace antique collection is highly coveted. It's one of the most sought after bottles because it's bottled uncut, unfiltered, at natural barrel proof. And this little fact, I've been doing this for almost 15 years. I had no idea about this. fact. ⁓ I've never heard this until I started doing some research and I think it's awesome. In the very early years of the collection from when Buffalo Trace started putting out these these bottles in 2000 to 2002, the expression was known as Weller 19. And it was bottled steadily at 90 proof. The modern barrel proof powerhouse we knew, we know today started Officially launched in 2005 so from 2000 to 2005 It was just well-earned 19 there were and it was and it released and those were 19 years old at 90 proof and they released in 2000 2001 and Then in 2002 they released it in the spring and a second release in the fall in 2003 in 2004. There were no releases And then in 2005 is when they launched the William LaRue Weller at Cask Strength. And most typically, most years it's about 12 years old and some change. the highest age that's ever released was in 2006 and it came out as a 15 year, three month. And the highest proof that's ever come out was in 2014. It was a 12 year, three month, but at 140. It's the only hazmat William LaRueller that's hit the market. So generally speaking, these come out, you know, typically in the 120s, 130s, one of the lowest proofs it looks like in 2007, there was 117.9 proof. So, but they're always about, other than in 2007, wow, 2007 was a shitty year. It was the lowest proof and it was the lowest age. It was also only a 10-year three-month in 2007. Okay, and also the lowest proof And then it went up to 11 11 and ever since 2010. It's been a 12 plus years Somewhere 12 years and some change usually around six months old This this release 2025 is 12 years seven months and a hundred and twenty nine proof Okay, and the last but not least a fun fact And we also already talked about it. 2014, they released the only hazmat release at 140.2 proof. So let's get this thing poured up. was listening to your descriptions and you said something, I can't paraphrase it, but something about him being honest and stuff like that. And I'm like, okay, so this is like 20 years before honest Abe Lincoln. Like you were talking about the 1840s of his history. And now we're here all this time later and they're carrying on a legacy of stuff that he invented, he brought forward. the weeded bourbon, I'm kind of excited to try it. I don't know what it's gonna be, Honest whiskey at an honest Honest price, that's what you said. Honest whiskey at honest price. I was like, that's honest Abe Lincoln. 20 years before honest Abe Lincoln became Abe Lincoln, right? So it's like, where did Abe Lincoln get it from? William LaRue? Maybe, maybe he enjoyed the whiskey like we're about to. I mean, come Listen, I think, so this bottle, or these B-TAC collections, I think the MSRP on this bottle is $125. Good luck finding it. Yeah, if you could find it. Fun fact is this is the second bottle I've ever owned. still have the... Wait, this is the second bottle? Yes. So you've owned this bottle how long? 2017. I have the 2020, I have the 2017 release. I never opened it and I did buy it for $130. Okay. Wow. Okay. But I was like, man, I've always like, should I open it? And then I got this one. I'm like, I'm opening it. So... We're gonna open this one. But these go on the secondary 900 to $1,100. So if you can get one, I don't know. We should go digging through for some old bottles, like some 1980s bottles, see if we can get some of those and crack them open for the viewers. Let's crack this I think we can find a few things. The dusty bottles. Sitting on a shelf long enough. Let's see how good this thing is. And I hope this is as good as I remember. It's been a few minutes since I had this last. Let's get that pop on here. Let's see if this is a bum bottle. I'm gonna be very surprised Whether you like it or not, it's different story, but I just I don't think this is gonna be a bottle that Falls in that bum category. We're do something. We're gonna do healthy pores here healthy Wow, okay No, no weak ass pores. We expect this to be I don't know for the folks that are watching and listening, please Please don't do this and then go driving The best bourbon you've ever had. So I want to make sure that we all have enough. this is the best bourbon. This is your favorite. So when people ask me, what's my favorite bourbon? I historically have always said William Le Roux. And I didn't know the difference until recently between regular Weller and William LaRue weather. Yeah, so the 12 year old So this is basically Weller 12. Yeah at cask strength. Yeah instead of 90 proof and I like Weller 12. So this is gonna Knock my socks off. Yeah What do we what do you think on the nose as you've noticed it before me Man the color on this what do you guys think the color looks like? I mean, kind of cliche at this point to say red mahogany, but it is red mahogany. It is dark. It has got some long legs on it, like a really tall blonde. It's very leggy, very reddish brown. You like the nose. I love the nose. It's not as sweet as I thought it would be, but it's very good nose. The nose is elegant. It's elegant. It's not helping me to describe it to the folks that are listening to us. They're expecting us to say nutty and fruity and all these things, and I'm like, it's just elegant. I mean, there's definitely a nice fruity note. There's apple in there, there's some berries. There's some apple, it's like a spiced apple to me, like a Granny Smith or something maybe. I get like more of a red apple than a green apple. Really a red apple? All right, everybody. The vanilla, just a ton of vanilla pouring out of it. Sweetness, sugary. I think it depends on how many times you've had COVID, how you smell things. Just saying. Maybe the faintest touch of tobacco, not like pipe tobacco. No, this is like. ⁓ fresh unprocessed tobacco leaves on a farm in North Carolina. Dried or undried? Undried. Undried. This is just fresh off the tobacco plant to me. On the viscosity, extremely coating. ⁓ yeah. Legs dripping down the glass. Long legs. ⁓ You're right on the color. You said red mahogany. It's definitely got this reddish tint to it. I'm finding the more I play with it, it's opening up. It's changing a little bit in its complexity. We did just fresh crack it. Yeah, but I haven't sipped it yet. It's just swirling around in my glass and I feel like it's opened up in whatever it's been, 35 seconds. Frankly, it's what dreams are made of. I'm getting a much better aroma now than I did when I first poured. I like to... I'm diving in. You gonna drink it? You're the warm it up glass guy. am, so I like to warm it up. Oh, I like to cool it down. I want to get some air, but then I want to an ice cube in there. If you put ice cube in here, I'll kick you in the dick. I'm not gonna put an ice cube in this I promise you, we're gonna kick you in the dick if you put an ice cube in this glass. We'll take turns. Yeah. Not putting a rock in this glass, but I'm also not gonna warm it like yours. I'm gonna air it. Cool it, and guess what I'm do now? a reason why I warm up. I'm gonna take a sip of it. I'm not gonna wait for you. I can stick my entire nose down in the glass. It doesn't burn. It smells amazing. It's sweet. It's fruity. It is literally, there's a little bit of oak, the vanilla. ⁓ This is incredible on the nose. I'm gonna go ahead and say this is a banger. This is definitely a banger. I like it. the folks at home wanna hear me describe it, sorry, I don't know how to describe it. It's good. This has got a lot of warmth. It's not hitting me with the heat of its proof. It's definitely mellowed down, but it's not subdued in any way, shape, or form. This is just a... This is just punching you like it's supposed to for what it is. It's really fucking good. It's very layered. Layered flavor. it's just... It's well balanced. Yeah. Like you're not getting one too much over the other. Nice, sweet spice. No, well balanced was a very good description, because there's some complexity going on here. Oh yeah. There's a lot of aroma, there's a lot of flavors, there's heat without the hug. It's complex and layered. You hit on the nose. To me, there's a lot of baking spices, that leather that I get from a high age or higher proof barrel-aged bourbon. But in a good way. In a great way. Oh my God. All in the best way. Yeah. There's a caramel note in there, an aged vanilla. I don't think caramel is sufficient of a description because we always say caramel does caramel. This is like a deep unsalted caramel. Rich. Rich caramel. Like you put too much sugar in the batch. Yes. And it's like overly saturated caramel. But in a good way. It's not just a light tone of caramel. This is not a caramel latte from fucking Starbucks. This is a deep rich tone. No, ⁓ definitely. Okay. This is deep. This is somebody who knows how to make candy. Yeah, exactly. This is the Willy Wonka version of it. This isn't Hershey's messing around in Pennsylvania. The the nose was giving me all these like deep dark cherry black cherry leather fruit notes on it. Oh, there's definitely some dark cherry in here, And I was waiting for those to come across on the palette. I don't get as much of the fruity notes on the palette. I get more of the vanilla, the spice, the oak. The caramel. The fruit definitely hits the nose, but I'm not getting that in the front, back, middle, however you guys call it. I'm not getting that on the palette at all, the fruit, but it's there. I smell it, and then I'm getting that deeper caramel, that... kind of warm feeling, not a hug, not a Kentucky hug where it's burning anything, just that warm, rich feeling of this is a good bourbon. Yeah, the finish is, it's punchy, but it's like a saturated, it just like coats almost syrupy. Yeah. Like a Robitus, just like slowly going down your throat, coating. This is Dimetapp, this is not like a Robitussin, I would not describe that as a cough medicine. Not flavor-wise. I get what you're trying to say, because it is just flavor-wise, just way it goes down. Just as like a, or if you took a bottle of Aunt Jemima's and just squirted it in your mouth and just let it like kind of coat your throat. I don't think you're allowed to say Aunt Jemima or Uncle Ben anymore. No, they're still available. Okay. It's still called Aunt Jemima. It is. Man. You guys have you guys ever had a William Larue Weller this I don't think I know I've never had a William Larue Weller, okay, and I'm gonna say with me before You have had this not me something not you. I've never had this the first time I've opened it the other bottle Don't know it's unopened. It's unopened. I thought we had it at one point. We've tried the George C. Stagg, okay ⁓ This is the first bottle in my 15 years of William Larue Weller that I've opened that's mine We're hitting I did open my buddy Darren's out in California. We tried it at his house I think he had a 2024 Well, what I was gonna say was I think we're kind of hitting the middle of the year now in 2026 almost and I'm gonna say probably upwards of somewhere around 50 different bourbons you and I have tried this year and I'm gonna say that's the one right now right now That's the one not yet halfway, but almost halfway through 2026 if I had a vote right now favorite bottle of the year tried probably 50 of them. Right now that's sitting at number one. I like that. Yeah, I'm gonna, we didn't, so we did a 2025 best of list where you and I sampled through like 19 bourbons one night. It was just 19 bourbons in one night. Just small little sips, but I kept a list of like everything that I'd really liked in 2025 and we will do it all together this year. We definitely should. I'm keeping a list. if there's something we want on the list, did we record that? I'm gonna put that into something or We recorded it but this year we'll do it here. Yeah, let's do it again. We did it in my kitchen It was that was pre-studio. was pre-studio. Yeah, just did it in the kitchen. It was kind of shit shitty show Actually, I think we should repost that so the viewers out there can see it again before and after and yeah And then post it again when we refilm 2026 version in here Hopefully all four of us. Love you, James. Sorry you're not here, but if you don't fucking come, we're gonna replace you with somebody else. Let's get a fourth in the air, and let's do four guys going through 19 bourbons in one evening. Maybe 20, who knows. That was a lot. That was 2025. Right now, this is my 2026 favorite. This is going on the list. And we had a papi earlier this year, and I still like this better. Correct. Oh yeah, yeah, yeah. So yeah, this is stupid. The nose on this thing for me, might be a little bit, I might like the nose a little bit more than I like the palate. ⁓ the nose is phenomenal. The palate's really good. The palate's good. But you don't get, you can get more complexity in the nose. Yeah. Cause you get those fruit, those fruit notes. The nose is incredible. Like that sweetness on the nose with the fruits and the caramel, the oak, and then the palate folks that are viewing this episode don't know what we did earlier today, but we had a bottle earlier today that I, Literally called like sexual arousal on the nose And it was you heard it here a lot earlier was This I'm not gonna call this climax, but this is wait. This is more elegant. Yes. This is wait. Yeah, that was a strip club Yeah, that was a strip club and you're like, ⁓ my god, her bottle looks good. She smells good I want some right but then you flip the lights on you're like, ⁓ yes. This is way more elegant than that This is this is no launchiness at all. This is Charlie Sheen You know, this is trying to slice it Heidi Fleiss area. This is Adam's Charlie Sheen I love Charlie Sheen, but you know, he was a crackhead. Well, you know, he also I know. Yeah. High end prostitute is what you're saying. Yeah. Yeah. This was more Heidi Fleiss than Charlie Sheen. No, this is great. And maybe we're going down in a rabbit hole and listen, I don't know. We may be the first podcast that describes bourbons and levels of strippers. Hopefully not. I don't really want to go there, but because there's, we're going to do that. Then I'm going to tell you guys right now, just everybody out there knows. Okay. You've all been there. You've all done it. This is Scores in Manhattan. This is Howard Stern's favorite club. And I've been there more than once, trust me, this is good. Phenomenal, phenomenal. Listen, all I gotta say is, I think that we gotta figure out some way moving forward to try this release every year. Oh gosh, yeah, I'd love to do that. They're hard to find. We gotta figure out a way to- Can William Lerue-Reller just send it to us, Yeah, well, please William LaRue Weller get this note send us a bottle so he in 1899 I know he does but Buffalo Trace, but the buff trace guys know that I'm saying that you didn't have to point out. All right, Both trace fuck your puff buff turkey. Let's get some of this William. It's not theirs. It's not theirs. But turkeys not theirs We could trade we could put this up against a couple of buff turkeys. We should get some buff turkeys. You know, I like both turkeys I do too. like buff turkey too. You sounded like Barry White as you said that. like buff turkey is one of my favorites. The OKI 16. Yeah. OKI 16 is really good. Listen, had the viewers voted for this. Absolutely. Good job, viewers. And you guys did a great job voting for this. There were some people that said, I have FOMO, like open that bottle please. And I was like, you know, I feel the same way. Listen. I cruise Instagram, have been cruising Instagram for years. Does your wife know? ⁓ hell yeah. Okay. Looking at bourbon porn. ⁓ my God. And this is all like, this is one of the ones that I'm like, man, if I could get another, and admittedly I've got a bottle, I've had it for nine years now. Right. I have not opened it because I was like, I can't open it. I gotta have a double. I gotta have a backup. I'm kind of changing my mind in that regards. So maybe. Down the road will pop the old 2017 version. What was the 2017 version, proof-wise? Let me pull that back up, because that's, let me pull that list back up. So 2017. Yeah, while you're looking that up, all's I'm gonna say is if you happen to own a William LaRue Weller Kentucky Street Bourbon Whiskey. And have not opened it. And have not opened it. Please open. add it to your insurance policy. Because if it's not insured and I come over and drink it, you're ass out. Let's see here. No, that's pretty good That is that is definitely something where if you ever say would you like to try? Yes. Yes. Yes before you finish your sentence. Yes. Let's try that again. Yeah 2017 what I'm trying to just curious on what that pretty for like ten years. It was always pappy pappy pappy I like pappy don't get me wrong and he busted open a bottle of pappy not that long ago We've had pappy here before I'm I'm kind of liking this better Yeah, now I haven't so i've always said and I don't know I don't own a bottle i've never owned a bottle of the pappy 15 year old, okay? But I had it in a bar once And that was really good, too And i've always said this pappy 15 So maybe we got to find a bottle of pappy 15 and do a side by side with this But my 2017 is really close in proof. It's only 128.2. So this is 129 I would say write that down that this William LaRue Weller against the Pappy 15, if we ever get the opportunity, if somebody can send us a bottle of Pappy 15, we can do it. We just gotta be on it in the fall and buy Yes, come before the mean, they're kind of expensive. They're like $2,000, so that's probably 1,500 bucks maybe, 1,700 bucks, somewhere in that range on If you want to help us buy a Please like and subscribe. Buy the gear. Just We've got the water mugs. We've got the Glen Kierns. We've got the shirts, we've got the hats. We're gonna get some more gear out there soon. Please support us. Please buy some of this apparel so that we can buy some of these bottles that you want us to test, because I really do think they want us to test this against a real good Pappy 15. Absolutely. And listen, we've got some barrel picks coming out here very soon. We will let you know. I'll post how to get those bottles. We've got a couple already out, so. One of them sold out in like 36 hours. Did a barrel pick a Weller 107, gone. Can we drop a hint that there might be a barrel pick coming up in the near future? We might be taking a trip out. There's multiple barrel picks coming up in the near future. I don't know what you want. I'm just trying to Listeners, we've got some barrel picks we're going to be looking There's three. There's three different barrel picks coming. I just need to lock in the time frame because I don't know exactly when they're coming, but they're coming. So stay tuned. And thank you everybody that voted on the poll, that participated. Great choice, guys. You picked the one I wanted to pick, so don't worry. For those that did not vote for the William LaRue Weller, we will also crack the George T. Stag, and we will also crack the Heaven Hill 22, and we'll give our reviews on those here. If nothing else, we're going to crack some unicorns here. Very soon. To give everybody an opportunity to see what we think. Whether you agree with us or not, whether you like it or not, like, I admit I'm a novice, I don't know all the details, you've got a deeper sense of this, you've got a very different sense than I do. If we ever get Jimmy to show the fuck up, we're gonna have a fourth person giving you guys three honest opinions, four honest opinions of what we think this stuff is. But I'm gonna tell you right now, William LaRue Weller, if you guys can get it, get your hands on it, it's fucking awesome. We're gonna crack open some more unicorns in the future. As we wrap up. Yes. People ask me what my favorite bottle is, I say this. Today? Do you have a better bottle than this that you're in your mind, you're like, yep, no, there's something that's just a little better. No, right now, this is all I'm thinking about. That's how good this was. I've forgotten everything. And you can, like you can say, ⁓ I George Stegg better, right? Like, doesn't matter to me. I've got bottles at home we haven't cracked yet, I'm gonna bring them here in the future, we're gonna crack them open. Just because I know I have some of the bottles you have and you won't crack them, so I'm gonna crack some of them. Is that unicorns? But we'll crack some things open, we'll give them a try. You're asking me what my favorite is right now today, this is it. This is the one I like. I would have to retaste the OKI 16, the buff turkey guy. Against that. You got a good point there. I don't think that will had it against the George T. Stag and I still picked the OKI 16. Okay, fair enough. Well, stay tuned. Maybe we'll do a blind of like a unicorn blind. We'll just touch horns together and see which one's better, right? Anyway. I almost feel like we should do a unicorn as one of our brown bag banger of bums. We really need to like sneak one of those in at some point when nobody's paying attention. ⁓ yeah. Cause I think that's a really good segment. I know we've, we're kind of ahead of some of the viewers right now. They're going to see some of these brown bag banger of bums. and they're gonna start going, ⁓ my God, you guys gotta do a unicorn in there. Because you just never know what people are gonna say when they don't know what it is. Absolutely. Listen, this is fun. Thank you all. We appreciate the support. always, if you like this, follow along, like, subscribe, let us know in the comments. Feel free to email me, the 323BurbanLibrary at gmail.com if you got suggestions moving forward. We'll see you next time for another episode on the 323Burban Library. Thanks everybody. Enjoy. you