Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How to Use the Reciprocity Principle for Office Influence
Transcript
- Lucas: So there's this classic psychological principle — reciprocity — that basically says if someone does something for you, you feel a subconscious obligation to return the favor. And in an office setting, it's one of the most reliable ways to build influence without ever asking for it directly. Luna: Right, it's the 'I scratch your back, you scratch mine' idea. But I think a lot of people screw it up because they make it too transactional — like they're keeping a ledger. Lucas: Exactly. The moment it feels like a quid pro quo, you lose the effect. The principle works best when the favor is genuine, unexpected, and not tied to an immediate ask. I saw this play out beautifully in a marketing team a few years ago. There was a mid-level manager, Sarah, who wanted to push through a new campaign strategy — but she knew the head of product was skeptical. Luna: So what did she do? Did she start with a big presentation? Lucas: No, she did the opposite. She spent two weeks sending the product head relevant data she'd found — market insights that would help his own roadmap — without ever mentioning her campaign. No strings attached. Then she offered to let his team use her design resources for a deadline they were struggling with. Luna: So she built a debt of goodwill before making her move. That's smart. Lucas: Exactly. When she finally asked for a thirty-minute meeting to discuss her campaign idea, the product head not only showed up — he was already primed to say yes. He later told her, 'You've been so helpful, of course I'll hear you out.' That's reciprocity in action. Luna: And it's not just about favors. I've seen it work with simple things like acknowledging someone's contribution publicly. If you give them credit in a meeting, they're more likely to support your idea later. Lucas: That's a great point. Credit is a form of currency in the office. And the key is, you have to give first. Most people wait until they need something, then scramble to offer something. That's too late. The principle only works if the giving precedes the asking. Luna: But what about people who abuse it? Like, someone who gives you a tiny favor and then expects a huge return? That feels manipulative. Lucas: It is manipulative, and it usually backfires. Genuine reciprocity is about creating a relationship, not a transaction. If you give a $5 coffee and then ask for a $5,000 project sign-off, people see right through it. The principle works best when both sides perceive the exchange as fair over time. Luna: So the size of the initial gift matters. It should be proportional to what you might eventually ask for. Lucas: Right, but not too proportional. If it looks like a setup, you lose authenticity. There's a famous study — the one where researchers sent Christmas cards to strangers. Most recipients sent one back without even knowing who the sender was. That's how hardwired reciprocity is. Luna: So in an office context, what are some low-effort, high-impact giving moves? I'm thinking like sharing an article that's relevant to someone's project, or offering to grab coffee just to listen. Lucas: Those are perfect. Also, being the person who introduces two colleagues who could benefit from knowing each other — that's a classic. It costs you nothing, but both parties feel indebted to you. Another one: volunteering to take notes in a meeting no one wants to document. Small things. Luna: And you have to do it consistently, not just before a big ask. Otherwise, it's too transparent. Lucas: Yeah, consistency builds a reputation as a giver, not a taker. And that reputation itself becomes a form of influence. People want to help you because they see you as someone who helps others. Luna: There's a flip side, though — the obligation can feel heavy. If someone does you a big favor, you might feel pressured to reciprocate in a way that's not genuine. Lucas: That's true. And that's where self-awareness comes in. If you're the receiver, it's okay to acknowledge the favor and say, 'I'd love to help you in return when I can.' That releases some pressure. And if you're the giver, you should never expect or demand repayment. That would poison the well. Luna: You know, this ties into something I've been thinking about with the podcast itself. We put out episodes every day, no ads, and it's because a small group of listeners chips in monthly. Lucas: Yeah, it's a similar dynamic — people give first, and that support is what allows us to keep this going. If you've found these career strategies useful, there's a way to help us keep making them ad-free. It's buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Luna: And we really mean it when we say no pressure. It's just an honest thing — we love making the show, and listener support is what makes that possible. Lucas: Exactly. So back to office politics — one mistake people make with reciprocity is they only give to people above them. But influence works sideways and downward too. Helping a junior colleague with a task can create an ally who later champions your idea to their manager. Luna: That's a good reminder. The favor network is broader than just your boss or your stakeholders. Lucas: Right. And another mistake is forgetting that reciprocity also applies to negative actions. If you slight someone, they'll feel compelled to slight you back. So it's actually more important to avoid creating negative debts than to accumulate positive ones. Luna: So being careful not to burn bridges is part of the same principle. If you mess up, apologize sincerely — that can also trigger a reciprocal response of forgiveness. Lucas: Exactly. A genuine apology is a form of giving — you're giving them respect and admission of fault. That often elicits a reciprocal gesture of acceptance. I've seen teams repair trust just by one person saying, 'I was wrong, and I'm sorry.' Luna: Let's talk about timing. When is the best moment to deploy reciprocity in a project cycle? At the beginning, when you're building relationships? Lucas: Ideally, yes. The beginning of a project or a new working relationship is prime time because there's no history yet. You can set the tone. But it's never too late — even in a strained relationship, a small unsolicited help can reset the dynamic. Luna: I think the hardest part is making it feel natural. How do you give without looking like you're angling for something? Lucas: The key is to give in areas that are genuinely useful to the other person and that you enjoy giving. If you're good at data analysis and someone's struggling with a spreadsheet, offer to help because you like solving those puzzles. Your enjoyment makes it authentic. If you're forcing yourself to do favors you hate, it'll show. Luna: So align your giving with your strengths. That way it's sustainable and sincere. Lucas: Right. And don't keep score. Once you start mentally tallying who owes you what, you've already lost the spirit of reciprocity. The goal is to build a culture of generosity around you, not a ledger of IOUs. Luna: I've heard some people say that over-giving can make you look weak or desperate. Is there a risk there? Lucas: There is, if your giving is always one-way and you never ask for anything. But that's actually a different problem — it's about boundaries, not about reciprocity. You should still advocate for your own interests. Reciprocity works best when it's a two-way street over time, not when you're a doormat. Luna: So the sweet spot is being known as someone who helps, but also knows when to ask for help in return. Lucas: Exactly. And that ask itself can be a form of giving — it makes the other person feel needed and valued. There's research showing that asking for advice actually makes the advisor like you more. It's called the 'Benjamin Franklin effect' — and we covered that in a previous episode. Luna: Right, that's the idea that doing a favor for someone makes you like them more. So reciprocity loops back on itself. Lucas: It does. The whole system is circular. You give, they give, you both feel good, and relationships strengthen. That's the foundation of office influence that doesn't feel slimy. Luna: So if someone wants to start applying this tomorrow, what's one concrete action they can take? Lucas: Pick one person you want to build a better relationship with. Think of something small they're working on — a report, a presentation, a problem — and offer one specific piece of help. Not a vague 'let me know if you need anything.' Like, 'I saw you're working on the Q3 forecast. I have some historical data that might save you time. Want me to send it over?' Luna: That's actionable. And then don't mention it again. Just let the reciprocity do its work. Lucas: Exactly. And if they reciprocate, great. If not, that's okay too — you've planted a seed. Over time, these small gestures compound, and you become the person people want to help. Luna: It's almost like a long-term investment in social capital. Lucas: That's exactly what it is. And like any investment, the best time to start was yesterday. The second best time is today.