Latest / The Vegan Report / Vegan Witchcraft. With Corey Lee Wrenn | Ep. 103
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone, my name is Ryan and you are listening
- 0:03to The Vegan Report. Today we discuss the topic
- 0:07of witchcraft with Dr. Carly Wren, the author
- 0:11of the book The Vegan Witchcraft. Dr. Wren is
- 0:15an American sociologist specializing in animals
- 0:19and society, the animal rights movement, ecofeminism,
- 0:23and vegan studies. We talked about witches using
- 0:27human remains for spells, the witchy argument
- 0:32for veganism, how the animal movement fails women,
- 0:37the taboo of being a witch in society, what being
- 0:41spiritual means for an atheist, and much more.
- 0:45Get the vegan witchcraft now, it's a fascinating
- 0:49read, I highly recommend it. Link to order the
- 0:53book in the episode's notes and Share this episode
- 0:57with the witches and vegans, you know Let's spread
- 1:01Corey's message to the world Leave a good review
- 1:05and for more interesting conversations Make sure
- 1:08to follow the show Thank you Corey you welcome
- 1:13to the vegan report. Thank you so much for being
- 1:15here. Thank you for having me I'm very excited
- 1:18to talk about this topic And book. Let me start
- 1:23with this kind of out there question. So I was
- 1:28born in North Africa. Whoa. Yes. And there, witchcraft
- 1:34has another meaning than in the West. And your
- 1:39book gave me an opportunity to think about the
- 1:43kind of witchcraft that is practiced in Asia,
- 1:47in the Middle East, in North Africa. And I feel
- 1:51like, you know, and you mentioned that in the
- 1:55book, you touch on that. I feel like in the West,
- 1:58whatever has to do with human beings, so using
- 2:03witchcraft with human parts or things of the
- 2:07sort is very taboo, is not really practiced or
- 2:12promoted. But in, you know, Africa or in the
- 2:18country, like in my country where I was born,
- 2:23witchcraft practitioners do use human parts.
- 2:29We'll go in cemeteries and dig up corpses or
- 2:32things like that. We keep our cemeteries guarded
- 2:35for that reason. And so, weirdly enough, there
- 2:40isn't that speciesism aspect to witchcraft in
- 2:45some other parts of the world. Yes, they will
- 2:49use animals, but also human beings. Of course,
- 2:54if you Google some of what I'm saying, you'll
- 2:58see cases of people getting abducted and having
- 3:03all sorts of bad things happening to them in
- 3:06the name of witchcraft. By the way, all of that
- 3:09is illegal in those places. We'll talk about
- 3:13it later. What do you make of that, of that difference
- 3:17of witchcraft in the West versus Africa and Middle
- 3:22East and so on? That is actually a very, very
- 3:25excellent point. I had a lot of difficulty when
- 3:28I was writing this book, narrowing it down, because
- 3:31even if I were to look, say, in Ireland, Ireland
- 3:35does not even have a similar relationship to
- 3:37witchcraft that say we do in Britain and the
- 3:39United States. So much of my book actually just
- 3:42focuses on The uk and the united states because
- 3:46if we start to look global witchcraft is. Believe
- 3:50it or not listeners a global phenomenon and it's
- 3:52still with us today it's still actively practice
- 3:55by people all over the world and i wish that
- 3:58i could have more. More space really and bandwidth
- 4:03if you will to look into other parts of the world
- 4:06this is. A major aspect that would say of twenty
- 4:10first century vegan feminist theory which is
- 4:12part which is the theory i use for this book.
- 4:15is that we need to start pushing back on white
- 4:17-centric approaches, Euro -centric approaches,
- 4:21because if we start expanding to looking at other
- 4:23ways of being, other ways of knowing, we can
- 4:26really expand our theory, and it can be a lot
- 4:29more fit for purpose, if you will. So I think
- 4:32if someone is out there, maybe it's you, but
- 4:34maybe it's one of our listeners who would like
- 4:36to do that research, I think there can be really
- 4:39some interesting Challenges to the theory just
- 4:43for an example this is not witchcraft but one
- 4:45of them such a fascinating and very important
- 4:47example of how. The same criticism works elsewhere
- 4:51in vegan feminism so we may be familiar maybe
- 4:54familiar with carol adams's theory the sexual
- 4:57politics of meat and the idea is that. Consuming
- 5:00meat is very much so an act of patriarchal dominance.
- 5:05Women's bodies are animalized and they're also
- 5:07treated like meat just like animals are. However,
- 5:10there's been criticism or pushback rather. From
- 5:13a psychologist her name is Rama Ganesan. I think
- 5:16she's in Canada I'm not quite sure but she's
- 5:19done quite a lot of work on how that actually
- 5:21doesn't really make sense in the Hindu context
- 5:24because actually Meat eating there is much more
- 5:27or lack of meat eating there. It's much more
- 5:30of a caste issue where the people who are Dalits
- 5:32who are further down in the caste system are
- 5:34more likely to be consuming flesh, and then the
- 5:36people who are higher up in the caste system
- 5:38are less likely to be consuming flesh, and yet
- 5:40it's a deeply patriarchal system. So how does
- 5:42that work with the very popular theory of Carol
- 5:46Adams, which is, we have to admit, in a Western
- 5:49European... cultural context. So that is I think
- 5:53a great criticism you've raised that if we can
- 5:56start to open up and expand to other parts of
- 5:58the world and how they interact with other animals.
- 6:01and these different value systems, we can learn
- 6:03quite a lot. So yeah, that would be my thoughts
- 6:05on that. I don't know enough about it. I do know
- 6:07that it's widely practiced. I do know also that
- 6:10our parts of Africa, where certain non -human
- 6:12animals are in fact used and are targeted, because
- 6:16there has been some charity work in that region,
- 6:18a part of the world rather, to advocate for them.
- 6:23What do you think though? About what exactly?
- 6:30Well, what do you think, like, how could maybe
- 6:31witchcraft from where you're from challenge?
- 6:33Because I think one of the premises of my book
- 6:35is the theology, if you will, of modern witchcraft
- 6:40is supposed to be about finding power in relationships
- 6:44with nature and fellow animals, embodying the
- 6:47feminine power, all these things that have been
- 6:49kind of made evil or uncivilized or barbaric
- 6:51over the years through the through the church's
- 6:55different efforts to clamp out, start to stamp
- 6:58out paganism or the Industrial Revolution, the
- 7:00Enlightenment period, all these things have kind
- 7:02of denigrated nature, animals. femininity all
- 7:07these things but witchcraft is basically saying
- 7:09no actually let's reclaim that as a source of
- 7:13power a birthright if you will unfortunately
- 7:15what happens in western witchcraft in the in
- 7:18the uk in the us at least is that is a lot of
- 7:20talk and when you actually look at the practices
- 7:23that they're engaging with non -human animals
- 7:25are very much so objectified in a lot of ways
- 7:28so if you're saying that in your part of the
- 7:30world uh humans are used more in witchcraft and
- 7:34maybe not so much non -human animals. Do you
- 7:36think maybe that could challenge witchcraft as
- 7:40maybe a new... Do you think that there's a feminist
- 7:42element to it as well? Like maybe you know more
- 7:44than I do about that part of the world. Is there
- 7:47a feminist element? I'm not sure I know more
- 7:52than you do because you know it's such a taboo.
- 7:55in yes in those societies and not just that it's
- 7:59illegal you know I came across a post on social
- 8:03media and it was a document from the Iraqi government
- 8:10and they were congratulating themselves for having
- 8:14arrested a hundred witchcraft practitioners and
- 8:19people were mocking that you know they were mocking
- 8:21that as if you know or they call it Harry Potter
- 8:25or something. But it's real, you know. They do,
- 8:31you know, practice witchcraft. You might not
- 8:34believe in that, but they do believe in it. And
- 8:38it is illegal. And the sentences for doing that
- 8:42are quite harsh. And then the social taboo that
- 8:48is attached to you Is also quite something, you
- 8:52know, you're marginalized in society So it's
- 8:56quite, you know Sorry to interrupt, but what's
- 8:59it based on? Why is it illegal? What is the threat
- 9:01that these people are posing? Religious reasons
- 9:03so Muslim majority countries, you know, it's
- 9:06explicit but also, you know Christian majority
- 9:08countries in Africa on the African continent
- 9:12Witchcraft is considered sinful Going against
- 9:16God. Yeah way it's not very different than from
- 9:21the way it's treated here in the UK, well has
- 9:23been anyway. Let's not forget that witchcraft
- 9:26was illegal in this country where I'm recording
- 9:28from the UK until 1951. So it's, I mean, there
- 9:33was also penalties. I mean, maybe not the death
- 9:35penalty. The last person who was executed for
- 9:37witchcraft, I think it was in the 1700s here
- 9:39in the UK. But we do know that many, many people
- 9:41were executed in the US, the UK, Europe and elsewhere.
- 9:45So I think it's a similar thing there that What
- 9:49are what are these folks but i guess the idea
- 9:51here is what are they representing then and what
- 9:53can be gained and if we sort of sit with the
- 9:56people on the margins if you will because what
- 9:58are they representing their representing a challenge
- 10:00the status quo and i'm willing to bet they probably
- 10:03also. Guessing I don't really have a lot of experience
- 10:07in this I'm willing to bet that they're also
- 10:09a challenged patriarchy They're a challenge to
- 10:12this idea that nature is something to be controlled
- 10:15or even feared and so witchcraft at least as
- 10:19I understand it is about reclaiming that as Not
- 10:23sinful not something to be afraid of not something
- 10:26to be controlled and it's not just nature as
- 10:29other but nature is ourselves as well And so
- 10:31especially people who have been marginalized
- 10:33women non human animals colonize people excited
- 10:36there's something to be gained there by reclaiming
- 10:39that and kind of doing away with these categories
- 10:41of who is civilized who is not who is pagan who
- 10:43is not. I also say that even in the u .k. we
- 10:47can't get a blanket of everything is hunky dory
- 10:50here my partner's mother is a jehovah's witness
- 10:53and she. She canceled Christmas this year because
- 10:57she thinks it's pagan and that would offend God
- 11:00and so you better believe she doesn't know She
- 11:03doesn't know about this book that I've written
- 11:05or any of the other witchcraft stuff that I do
- 11:07because that would be the end of it, buddy Like
- 11:09it would be very awkward when I go to visit with
- 11:11her So there's still persistence of that in the
- 11:14West as well and and we're not even getting into
- 11:17the United States where it is such a hyper Christian
- 11:19country that you know, it's it's very scary not
- 11:23even to to identify as a witch, but also as I
- 11:26was talking to you earlier about even identifying
- 11:28as an atheist can be very dangerous in the United
- 11:31States. Yes, I want to discuss this, but first,
- 11:37you know, going back to that point of, you know,
- 11:41witchcraft outside of the West. You know, I also
- 11:47I'm also a native of North Africa. We were called
- 11:51the Emezer and the Emezer people. And we always
- 11:57had a spirituality, kind of a animistic spirituality,
- 12:03which is deteriorating. And, you know, the question
- 12:08rises every time, you know, what is exactly witchcraft
- 12:13versus what is religion or spiritual practice,
- 12:17at least in those societies, you know, and you
- 12:22know, old traditions from native people of the
- 12:26land, for instance, honoring a tree. Is that
- 12:31witchcraft or is that, you know, something religious
- 12:36and spiritual? And sometimes, you know, I see
- 12:41the mainstream religion getting mixed with the
- 12:45animist practices. And so, you know, you go and
- 12:50climb a mountain to go and see the tomb of a
- 12:55great seer and You do it, you know while Reciting
- 13:02verses of the Quran and You think oh well that
- 13:07doesn't make sense much with you know, the the
- 13:10tenets of Islam, but You know it went and mixed
- 13:16with the original practice of honoring the dead
- 13:21and your ancestors, which has been in place for
- 13:26maybe centuries, if not thousands of years. So
- 13:30what do you make of that? You're pointing out
- 13:34some really important conceptual issues here.
- 13:38Absolutely. Well, I think it just goes to show
- 13:40that any religious or spiritual practice is really
- 13:43what you make of it. And I think ultimately what
- 13:45For me anyway, what would define something as
- 13:48religious is that it has to have this sort of
- 13:50supernatural element to it, a belief in a higher
- 13:53sort of cosmic order even. So you could really
- 13:57call, see witchcraft in all kinds of religions.
- 14:00If you look at Christianity, Judaism, there's
- 14:02a whole lot of that in there as well. So not
- 14:04just in Islam. And as you said, also in animus
- 14:08sort of belief systems. So for me, when I've
- 14:11tried to figure out, well, what actually is witchcraft?
- 14:15witchcraft for people who are aware that the
- 14:17origin of the word i believe it's an anglo -saxon
- 14:19origin but basically it comes from the word wicca
- 14:22which basically means wise wise person flexible
- 14:26and also went on to be the word for like what
- 14:29we use for wicker wicker chairs and things like
- 14:32that flexible so this idea that one is sort of
- 14:36flexible with nature -wise and all this sort
- 14:38of thing. It's just a term. It's just a term
- 14:40we use in the West, but basically the idea being
- 14:43that you are, I would say, seeing power in nature.
- 14:48Whereas for a lot of these institutionalized
- 14:50religions, the idea is not to see power in nature,
- 14:53but see power in this overarching God -like Being
- 14:59whichever religion we're talking about and usually
- 15:02what we see there is a divorce from nature in
- 15:05some way so religion being used in to uplift
- 15:08humanity from fellow animals and the environment
- 15:12more broadly Witchcraft more contemporarily at
- 15:16least in the West is very hard to define because
- 15:20it's We can say yeah, it's a nature -based religion.
- 15:23It's a nature -based spirituality, but some people
- 15:26also as you mentioned interweave other religions
- 15:29with that. So I know, personally, I know some
- 15:31people who identify as Christian, but also witches.
- 15:35There's some people like me, I identify as an
- 15:37atheist, but I also identify as a witch. I don't
- 15:39believe that there's some higher power governing
- 15:41the cosmos and all that. I just see magic in
- 15:44nature. And one of the, so if I had to define
- 15:47witchcraft, then at least from a Western UK perspective,
- 15:51it tends to be, it's a nature -based spiritual
- 15:54practice. And it is very much so, unfortunately,
- 16:00well, fortunately, it depends on how you look
- 16:01at it in relation to institutionalized religion.
- 16:04And therefore, it says unlike institutionalized
- 16:09religions, you determine your spiritual practice.
- 16:12This is individually driven. Whatever Satisfies
- 16:16you spiritually is witchcraft versus all these
- 16:19doctrines and rules and tenets that you need
- 16:21to follow in other spiritual practices institutionalized
- 16:24religions. We don't have that in witchcraft which
- 16:27is something that I pick up in the towards the
- 16:30end of my book actually because it becomes quite
- 16:32difficult when we're looking at non -human animals
- 16:34if we don't have any rules about what witchcraft
- 16:36is it kind of unfortunately. becomes a free for
- 16:41all and that will anything goes and becomes quite
- 16:43hedonistic because it's in relation to institutionalized
- 16:46religions it's about pleasure seeking it's about
- 16:48individual libertarian libertarianism all these
- 16:51sorts of things. Which can unfortunately then
- 16:53replicate some of the inequalities that institutionalized
- 16:56religions have an imposed on society. Yes, this
- 17:01is why I love your book so much. Again, The Vegan
- 17:05Witchcraft, go get it. It offers that framework
- 17:09which clarifies a lot of things for me and helps
- 17:13me think about this phenomenon, which is really
- 17:17pertinent. Okay, let's talk about the taboo associated
- 17:21with witchcraft. So let me tell you a story.
- 17:27I had the conversation... recently with an animal
- 17:31advocate. She was invited to give a speech about
- 17:35her practice of witchcraft and her spirituality
- 17:38and the problem was that she's a lawyer and she
- 17:43thought, you know, if I go and open up about
- 17:47this part of my life, clients will not take me
- 17:50seriously anymore. They won't hire me. And so
- 17:54it was a difficult decision for her to make,
- 17:58you know, to be open about her spirituality and
- 18:02to be honest about who she is and how she is
- 18:05you know a pagan and a witch and all of that.
- 18:11I was really saddened by to see that because
- 18:16you know what's the big deal you know she's a
- 18:18lawyer she's also witchcraft so explain that
- 18:22to me. What country is she living in? The U .S.
- 18:30It's a very very Christian dominant country and
- 18:34although the whole the whole purpose of the United
- 18:36States is religious freedom We are one of the
- 18:39least religiously free countries that I know
- 18:41of like we were talking before the recording
- 18:45about how I actually I didn't mention this but
- 18:49I have really Been into witchcraft since i was
- 18:52a young teenager and i think there's something
- 18:54quite telling that i got into witchcraft about
- 18:57the same time that i got into animal rights became
- 19:00vegan vegetarian at thirteen and that's about
- 19:02the time i started really getting into witchcraft.
- 19:08I kind of lost, I lost that when I got into the
- 19:11university and I think it's because I was picking
- 19:13up on, I was getting up, becoming a late teen
- 19:16and then going into university. It's like, this
- 19:18is not what serious grownups do. And it wasn't
- 19:20until I really, I got really settled into my
- 19:23first academic position and I was living alone
- 19:26at the time and I could just do what I want when
- 19:27I got home and no one was there to judge me.
- 19:30And so I started to dabble into it a little bit
- 19:32more, then moved to the UK and all of a sudden
- 19:35It was okay to talk about openly as i remember
- 19:39even in the us like you had to be careful i mentioned
- 19:42being an atheist and and a lecture i was giving
- 19:46which i thought was a totally normal thing to
- 19:48do i'm not preaching atheism i was just mentioned
- 19:50it because we're talking about stigma and deviance
- 19:53and my sociology class and my. it just happened
- 19:57to be one of the, a class that I was being observed
- 19:59on for one of my superiors. And they, they said,
- 20:02you can't talk about that. You got to leave that
- 20:04out and talk about being an atheist. It's like,
- 20:06Whoa, it was just one example. But the fact that
- 20:09she got so weirded out by that and like caught
- 20:11me on it, I was like, geez, there's actually
- 20:13quite a lot of research on atheism and stigma.
- 20:15And I've done research on that, by the way, and
- 20:18the vegan community, if people are interested,
- 20:20you can go find that it's on my website. So We
- 20:24can't even talk about atheism, which is not believing
- 20:26in anything really. We're surely going to have
- 20:28difficulty talking about witchcraft when we're
- 20:30talking about a serious, like we're talking about
- 20:32magic. We're talking about this whole history
- 20:35of religions trying to clamp down on witches
- 20:39and burning people and torturing people. So that's
- 20:43still around. Like that's still around. But when
- 20:45I came to the UK, there was a sort of relaxation
- 20:47about that. I think because paganism is still
- 20:49very much so incorporated into British culture.
- 20:54So I do think that her being American has a lot
- 20:56to do with it. But ultimately, what are you doing?
- 20:58Why does it matter that she's an American? Because
- 21:00what is she doing ultimately? She's challenging
- 21:02the status quo. Because Christianity in the United
- 21:05States, hopefully this doesn't offend anybody,
- 21:07but this is like my sociology speaking here,
- 21:10Christianity in the United States is not simply
- 21:11a belief system. It's a system of control. And
- 21:15many religions have operated in that way as systems
- 21:18of control. But in the United States has become
- 21:20so intertwined with nationalism, there's a reason
- 21:23why the republicans and donald trump are always
- 21:25donald trump came out with his own version of
- 21:27the bible for people who didn't know that it
- 21:29was charging like eighty quid for it but it's
- 21:32wrapped up in power and so to identify as a witch
- 21:35is there's an element there maybe you're not
- 21:38being taken seriously people think you're a bit
- 21:39kind of woo woo and off the wall fine but i think
- 21:42you're challenging power and there's a deep stigma
- 21:45associated with that and also there could be
- 21:48serious professional consequences I do worry
- 21:51actually thinking about it like as part of just
- 21:54doing this book but also i've been doing a lot
- 21:56of youtube work with this book as well. If i
- 21:59wanted to apply in the united states go back
- 22:01to the us to work i would i'm not sure if anyone
- 22:04want to hire me now because i'm open about it
- 22:06but you'd really be surprised here in the UK
- 22:08how more open -minded people are about it. Yes,
- 22:14definitely. I follow the work of, I think they're
- 22:17called the Church of Satan. They're great. They're
- 22:22hilarious at, you know, showing that double standard
- 22:26how, you know, Christianity is put on a pedestal
- 22:30versus other religions. So, for instance, they
- 22:33will petition to have a behemoth statue in the
- 22:39capital of the state where there are there is
- 22:42also you know the 10 commitments and they will
- 22:44say you know it's a it's a public building why
- 22:47not represent every religion including satanism
- 22:50yeah we also have to like i mean i love the work
- 22:54that they do it's brilliant it just holds a mirror
- 22:56doesn't it but i think we also need to be cognizant
- 22:59of the fact that especially with witchcraft this
- 23:02is a this is one of the few Yeah, one of the
- 23:05very few feminist focused or feminine focused
- 23:09religions mainstream mainstream if you will and
- 23:13also it is explicitly asking folks to Recognize
- 23:18nature our relationship to nature fund power
- 23:20and solidarity with nature and power and solidarity
- 23:22with fellow animals that's quite I mean that
- 23:25challenges a system and in the state patriarchy
- 23:30religion has worked for over a thousand years
- 23:33to stamp out that solidarity, because the whole
- 23:36point is divide and conquer. There's a reason
- 23:38why there's so much emphasis on these rules and
- 23:42hierarchies in these religions. And that's the
- 23:44idea is to separate us so that we can be more
- 23:47easily controlled. That's my sociological take
- 23:49anyway. I'm realizing how much of an explosive
- 23:54combination this all is, you know, even the animal
- 23:58advocates Label is kind of a stigma that we have
- 24:03to worry about with authorities. Let's talk about
- 24:09feminism, because you contributed to the Science
- 24:13of Activism initiative with a podcast and episode
- 24:19called Vegan Feminism in a nutshell. So I guess
- 24:24my first question for you about that is... What
- 24:27is your diagnosis of, you know, the state of
- 24:32feminism in the animal advocate community, in
- 24:36the animal rights movement? Yeah, not great.
- 24:43Not great. I've been doing this work since. Yeah,
- 24:46so I first started Vegan Feminist Network, which
- 24:48is a website where I host a lot of my blogs,
- 24:51but blogs of other women and people on the margins.
- 24:53back in 2013 and I started that out of a lot
- 24:58of frustrated conversations with fellow activists.
- 25:01So at that time I was in my twenties and I was
- 25:04more engaged in the online activism community,
- 25:07which now I just don't have the patience for
- 25:09a lot of that is because of sexism. But it was
- 25:12really, it was really irritating me how little
- 25:15people understood why gender mattered. and why
- 25:19feminism could actually enlighten us and strengthen
- 25:22us in a lot of ways. And so I started Vegan Feminist
- 25:25Network. And I'm really sorry to say that here
- 25:28we are over 10 years later, and this is my new
- 25:31book project, by the way, which is what, well,
- 25:33in that podcast I was summarizing. I'm really
- 25:37sorry to say that here we are over 10 years later,
- 25:39and I'm just still writing about these things.
- 25:43Just for instance, Vegan Campout. This is like
- 25:47one of my favorite things to pick on because
- 25:49it's just like so ridiculous A vegan camp out
- 25:52here in the UK. They have like this big lineup
- 25:54of people every year They've been going on for
- 25:56like 10 years now and every single year It's
- 25:59just men men men men men at the top of the lineup
- 26:02and you have to really squint to find women down
- 26:04at the bottom somewhere and and a couple of years
- 26:07ago I posted on vegan feminist network about
- 26:09it and the organizers came back and just like
- 26:12reamed me basically letting me know that my feminist
- 26:16critique had no validity and I was making it
- 26:19up and actually women voted for no women to be
- 26:22here. So that makes it okay. Well, whatever.
- 26:25Like these kind of nonsensical things. And then
- 26:28more recently this year, the Vegan Society, which
- 26:31has its own history with sexism, unfortunately,
- 26:34has been trying to come back from that and posted
- 26:36a short essay from this Taiwanese American person
- 26:41who I think was non -binary. And it was basically
- 26:45exploring feminism and how bio -essentialism
- 26:48can teach us quite a lot in the animal rights
- 26:50movement about not equating worth with the body
- 26:53you were born in. And that person got so much
- 26:57vitriol in response to that that the vegan society
- 27:00had to shut down the social media surrounding
- 27:03that post. So this is happening right now. So
- 27:07unfortunately, while I would advocate as a sociologist,
- 27:10we look at feminism and critical race theory
- 27:12and queer or vegan theory as well, and theory
- 27:16from people who are doing disability studies.
- 27:19I think there's so much to be learned from that.
- 27:21It's a very divisive. Topic and a lot of people
- 27:24are unconvinced that it's useful some people
- 27:27think that this is detracting from non human
- 27:29animals which i think is incorrect but i think
- 27:32really at the heart of a lot of this is that
- 27:34people just. Unfortunately just because you're
- 27:36vegan doesn't mean you aren't bigoted so there's
- 27:38a lot of challenge of challenging work we need
- 27:40to do to get people to recognize yeah women matter
- 27:44and. people of color also matter and their causes
- 27:47matter. It's not just about non -human animals
- 27:49on their own, because the same systems that are
- 27:51shaping speciesism are also at work with these
- 27:54other human groups. So it's definitely an intersectional
- 27:58argument, but it's unfortunately not well received,
- 28:03if I may say so. Yeah, I think people's first
- 28:07instinct is to think, well, the vegan community
- 28:11is mostly made up of women. So how can there
- 28:15be any sexism? And, you know, I understand that,
- 28:21you know, that reaction. But if I look at other
- 28:25situations, like I'm a fundraiser, my work, you
- 28:30know, is mostly dominated by women, you know,
- 28:33most fundraisers are women. But, you know, work
- 28:37where that is higher paid jobs in the fundraiser
- 28:42space are usually given to men. If you want to
- 28:48do admin work or more like stewardship with donors,
- 28:54that will be a task given to women. But if you
- 28:58want to acquire new donors and launch a campaign
- 29:03or something more ambitious, employers will favor
- 29:09men for that task. And so even if it's a woman
- 29:14dominated profession, there is this level of
- 29:17bias. Yes, that's actually a very good point.
- 29:22So there's, when we look at sexism in the animal
- 29:24rights movement, there's a variety of different
- 29:26ways it manifests. And yes, the gender pay gap
- 29:28is a major one. I've not looked into this recently,
- 29:31but some years back, I went and for people who
- 29:34are interested, If a charity is registered, they
- 29:37have to release every single year where the money
- 29:41goes for transparency. And so you can go and
- 29:43look, where's my money going? Where's the people's
- 29:45money going? And so you could actually see, I
- 29:47mean, I'm taking guesses here about male names
- 29:49and female names, but I think we can be reasonably
- 29:51accurate when I see. more higher salaries going
- 29:55to male names that this is probably a sexist
- 29:58issue. And you're right, also we have research
- 30:00in social movement theory, not just in the animal
- 30:02rights movement, but in other movements where
- 30:04women are more likely to be relegated to the
- 30:06organizational stuff, the more drudgery of social
- 30:09movement mobilization, if you will. And what's
- 30:13unique, I think, to the animal rights movement
- 30:15is that yes, four out of five activists, four
- 30:18out of five people who are vegan are women. So
- 30:21you would think, whoa, Women in the majority
- 30:23women are all good to go. But actually what we
- 30:26have here is not just a female majority But we
- 30:29also have a majority of people who, why do people
- 30:31come to the animal rights movement? Most of them
- 30:33are coming here because they're deeply empathetic
- 30:35and they're really, their hearts are out on their
- 30:38sleeve and they want to do what they can to help
- 30:40animals. That unfortunately creates a vulnerability
- 30:43and women are more easily preyed upon. It's basically
- 30:46a pool of highly empathetic, sensitive women.
- 30:49And so it's very easy, sadly, for abusive, predatory
- 30:54men, some narcissistic, abusive people as well,
- 30:56to come in and exploit women, and we do have
- 31:00a systemic problem with sexual harassment and
- 31:04worse. And that's been documented now. We have
- 31:06research to back that up. So that's not the kind
- 31:10of vegan world I'm advocating for. And the idea
- 31:12is if we cannot get our own ship in order, how
- 31:17in the hell can we actually be thinking we can
- 31:19put together a prescription for change? We haven't
- 31:22even got our own stuff sorted out yet. Because
- 31:25if we still can't take women seriously, and recognize
- 31:27women's personhood and right to bodily autonomy.
- 31:31What makes us think we can get that figured out
- 31:33with other animals? It seems quite silly. So
- 31:36we need to be thinking also about the way we
- 31:38organize, as you said, how we organize our advocacy,
- 31:42our charity organization, even down to the grassroots
- 31:47level. I get very suspicious when we introduce
- 31:49a hierarchical means of organizing our movement
- 31:53because invariably This is a sociologist speaking
- 31:57here invariably when we introduce a rigid hierarchical
- 32:00system in organizational system a hierarchy of
- 32:03command whatever you want to call it where power
- 32:05is concentrated at the top. We have the further
- 32:09far down you go more and more volunteer people
- 32:12women who are not making money who are doing
- 32:14the grunt work who are not getting any remuneration
- 32:18for that who are more vulnerable to being exploited.
- 32:20sometimes even sexually. And then the higher
- 32:23up you go, it's going to be more men, not just
- 32:25more men, but more white men, more middle -class
- 32:28men, men from privileged backgrounds. And again,
- 32:32how can we then envision a society that prioritizes
- 32:38the well -being of everyone and recognizes the
- 32:40personhood of everyone and really truly believe
- 32:43that has a system put into, have a system where
- 32:46we can Realize equality is what I'm trying to
- 32:49say. If in our own movement, we're still relying
- 32:52on these old unequal systems that invite abuses
- 32:55of power and are not democratic in how we make
- 32:59decisions. Very well said. And about your point
- 33:04on, you know, how this movement attracts empathetic
- 33:09people. You know, when I started working in the
- 33:13nonprofit world, I thought I was going to work
- 33:15with angels. But no, I discovered that lots of
- 33:21people will look for or seek proximity with vulnerable
- 33:26populations in order to predate on them. It is
- 33:32quite common in leadership. So yeah, it's quite
- 33:39distressing. And we see the same thing in the
- 33:42animal movement. we've all come across stories
- 33:47of shelters being managed by just the most cruel
- 33:52of people. And again, it's that it's the fact
- 33:56that we put, you know, those predatory people
- 34:00in proximity with vulnerable populations. So
- 34:05the challenge then becomes how do we make accountability
- 34:08and power sharing normative? In our movement
- 34:12is basically what we're doing is replicating
- 34:14the same systems of oppression and inequality
- 34:17that we are all raised with socialize with a
- 34:20very unequal conflict based society. That were
- 34:23existing in what we need to i think foster an
- 34:27imagination for alternatives and it's not easy.
- 34:31Takes a lot of hard work and a lot of hard critical
- 34:34thinking and that's why unfortunately I think
- 34:36a lot of the times we just divert back to what
- 34:38we're familiar with which by the way I think
- 34:40is also a major reason why we see a lot of sexist
- 34:43campaigning. I'd rather go naked than stuff which
- 34:46although I'm someone recently asked me and we
- 34:49still do that yes we still do that I was on the
- 34:52high street here in Canterbury. This earlier
- 34:55this summer and there was people and their underwear
- 34:58women sorry women in their underwear because
- 35:00that's supposed to make people think about. I
- 35:03don't know the milk industry or something what
- 35:06why why are we doing that just because in our
- 35:08mind we live in a very sexist misogynistic sex
- 35:12saturated society where we're used to we don't
- 35:15even think about. not done doing it this way
- 35:19we're used to seeing women in their underwear
- 35:21on full display in public spaces like that's
- 35:23just a normal thing that's what female bodies
- 35:25are for like. And it's like the honor of the
- 35:28capacity of our imagination to think of other
- 35:30ways to use female body activists that's not
- 35:33gonna reduce them down to sex objects because
- 35:35that's what that is it's not challenging anything
- 35:37it's only sitting with the status quo. You're
- 35:41surrounded by women in your underwear and all
- 35:43over the public space and all these advertisements
- 35:45and programs and Netflix and whatever else. There's
- 35:48nothing radical here. So there's really an erosion,
- 35:51if you will, of the possibilities. The imagination,
- 35:56the creative possibilities, the activist mind,
- 35:58I think has been really eroded just by being
- 36:02saturated in an oppressive society. So that's
- 36:05something I would like to see. I think feminism
- 36:07can offer that. If people Incidentally we're
- 36:11off the topic now but in the vegan witchcraft
- 36:12book as well i go into some of that where people
- 36:15are starting to use creativity creativity is
- 36:17thought to be fundamental to social justice work
- 36:21and feminism in witchcraft. How do we tap into
- 36:25that creativity to envision alternatives. Not
- 36:28just replicate the status quo because especially
- 36:30when you're talking about in these nonprofit
- 36:32charities risk reduction and predictability is
- 36:36the name of the game because. These are organizations
- 36:38that are working within a neoliberalized capitalist
- 36:40system. But that's not going to create social
- 36:43change. It's only working within the system and
- 36:45replicating the systems of inequality. I agree
- 36:49with that. I always say, you know, not being
- 36:53creative is a luxury here in this movement. Quickly
- 37:00to close this conversation on feminism in the
- 37:05animal space. What do you make of the fact that
- 37:10Being vegan and caring for animals is in society
- 37:15mostly seen as something feminine and Yeah sad
- 37:21It's sad that we think and I'm saying this out
- 37:28having like Right now I'm working on revisions
- 37:31for that book on vegan feminism and I'm just
- 37:33last night. I was working on the chapter on The
- 37:37first wave of vegan feminist activism of the
- 37:3919th century and even back then the word they
- 37:42would use back then is sentimentalism. And even
- 37:45in the 19th century it was it was starting to
- 37:48be this association was starting to become codified
- 37:50in the public imagination that women do the caring
- 37:54especially and this holds true today especially
- 37:58we're now in moving into this industrial revolutionary
- 38:01period. Capitalism rationality. Efficiency, predictability,
- 38:09separation of mind and body, separation of civilization
- 38:13and nature. All these things are starting to
- 38:14now become normal and normative. And so women
- 38:18who were saying, hey, wait a minute, actually,
- 38:20this is not the human condition to turn off our
- 38:23emotions and to turn off our compassion for other
- 38:26beings. But they would be pushed back and say,
- 38:29well, you're just being sentimentalist. In fact,
- 38:31not. That was like the least of their worries
- 38:34and worst cases People like me who are so like
- 38:38life -driven compassionate to help other animals
- 38:40in whatever way I can and like I mean really
- 38:43out there with it We'd be considered mentally
- 38:46ill and still to this day I think a lot of people
- 38:48do consider us mentally ill but they actually
- 38:50had a Diagnostic sort of category for it back
- 38:54in the 19th century. I think it's called like
- 38:56a zoo of zoophilia or something but basically
- 38:58trying to stigmatize and pathologize what is
- 39:01a basic human functionality to see personhood
- 39:06in other animals and want to help and to want
- 39:09to respect them and not hurt them. So this idea
- 39:13that veganism or caring about animals is a thing
- 39:16for women actually goes back over well over a
- 39:19hundred years. And it was because a lot of the
- 39:21women who were advocating for non -human animals
- 39:24and a lot of the early vegetarian advocates as
- 39:26well We're also suffragettes. We're also advocating
- 39:30for marriage rights for women. And by the way,
- 39:32it wasn't just women's rights. They were involved
- 39:34in abolitionism, anti -colonialism, prison reform,
- 39:40trying to combat child abuse and public health,
- 39:43da da da da da. But because a lot of women were
- 39:45doing it even back then, there's this sort of
- 39:47cultural legacy that this is something that women
- 39:49do. And that is really sad because We think about
- 39:54patriarchy here in the 21st century and all the
- 39:57toxic effects it has on has on men So think about
- 40:00like it's not fair to penalize women and try
- 40:02to pathologize women and alienate women for caring
- 40:04like that stinks Yes, but also what? What impact
- 40:07is this having on men? We're having an emotional
- 40:11response to having a heart, caring is something
- 40:13that has to be stamped down. And that happens
- 40:16because masculinity is defined in relation to
- 40:19femininity. So if that's what women do, men have
- 40:22to do the opposite, no matter how irrational
- 40:25and silly and inhuman it is. this so -called
- 40:29male loneliness epidemic. Well, what is that
- 40:31about? It's about really embodying this, I don't
- 40:34need anyone. I'm independent macho dude and caring
- 40:37about other people is for girls. Well, now we
- 40:40have men who are isolated and suicide rates for
- 40:44men are much higher. Depression rates are very
- 40:46difficult for men as well. Men who are in their
- 40:49twenties even and thirties are becoming isolated.
- 40:52So, Not caring, this idea of not caring is actually
- 40:56toxic for men. And so I think that's a very important
- 40:59new realm for vegan feminism is to reach out
- 41:03across the gender binary and normalize caring
- 41:07for men as well. I don't like, there's this idea,
- 41:10well, we can do the dude bro version of veganism
- 41:12for men. I think that only replicates toxic masculine
- 41:16norms. I think instead we need to start querying
- 41:19gender. And do away with this idea that to be
- 41:22masculine is the opposite of feminine because
- 41:24as long as we have that duality, we're always
- 41:27going to have a conflict system where women are
- 41:29going to be disadvantaged and men are going to
- 41:30get alienated in this non caring isolated kind
- 41:33of anti human way of existence. And that's a
- 41:38cold place to be. Let's go back to your book
- 41:42and talk about, you know, the way that modern
- 41:47witches are perceiving animals, which is so interesting
- 41:52on so many levels. I guess as a segue, I could
- 41:59mention that, you know, I know that in my native
- 42:02culture, some ways of exploiting animals were,
- 42:08you know, attributed to... Well, let's not go
- 42:12there. Let's... But yeah, so let's talk about,
- 42:18you know, how modern witches perceive, interact
- 42:25with the vegan movement and animals. Very good
- 42:29question. But first off, I think for people listening,
- 42:32we should go there. We do need more multicultural
- 42:35analyses of these things. The more that the stronger
- 42:37our theory is going to be. So I will validate
- 42:39you there. As far as what a witchcraft, what
- 42:43the modern witchcraft movement think about veganism,
- 42:46not much. That is what infuriates me the most.
- 42:49I think that was a main drive for me to write
- 42:51this book is because I'm into it. I'm reading
- 42:54this stuff and I'm having to skip through the
- 42:57books or skip through the videos on YouTube because
- 43:00they're saying offensive stuff about animals
- 43:03or objectifying animals. What is going on? Because
- 43:06the whole premise. Modern witchcraft so maybe
- 43:10i should clarify very quickly for people listening.
- 43:14I'm focusing just on the united kingdom and the
- 43:17united states everywhere else in the world we
- 43:19talked about this early about it's very there's
- 43:21infinitely variable. But in the united kingdom.
- 43:24Witchcraft is rooted in this longer pagan history
- 43:27so it's sort of this long legacy that exists
- 43:30here we've always kind of had paganism okay and
- 43:33it's nature based right that even the word pagan
- 43:36simply means person lived out in the country.
- 43:39Person without nature. So it wasn't necessarily
- 43:42very feminist. Witchcraft in the UK when it was
- 43:46sort of regenerated in the in the twentieth century
- 43:49it was just more it was nature based it wasn't
- 43:52very political. Whereas in the United States,
- 43:56witchcraft as it re -emerged really did emerge
- 43:59out of the environmental movement and out of
- 44:01the feminist movement. And it's sort of, if you
- 44:04look at some of the writings of the main witches
- 44:06from the United States, like Starhawk, they'll
- 44:09actually say that I wasn't even really aware
- 44:12about the witchcraft revival in the UK. I just
- 44:15kind of intuitively knew that witch, to be a
- 44:19witch, is like the epitome. of like the archetype
- 44:23of the evil woman and we're in the depths of
- 44:26the feminist kind of fight against patriarchy.
- 44:28We're talking about the 1960s, 70s, 80s. Let's
- 44:31embody that ultimate evil symbol of woman and
- 44:36become that and actually create it and turn it
- 44:40from a point of stigma and marginalization into
- 44:43a point of power. so the american version of
- 44:47witchcraft has always been rooted in feminism
- 44:49and environmentalism and in fact later in the
- 44:53movement by the 20th century by the 21st century
- 44:56for sure the uk version of witchcraft as they
- 44:59had reclaimed it was now much more political
- 45:01as well now okay so i'll let the uk off the hook
- 45:05a little bit because they were really kind of
- 45:08trying to recreate folk histories. And Gerald
- 45:12Gardner, by the way, who invented Wicca in the
- 45:15early 20th century, he openly plagiarized from
- 45:18lots of different European folk ways and a lot
- 45:20of Italian witchcraft and what he thought, what
- 45:23he interpreted out of anthropology here in the
- 45:26UK. It was an act of creation, fine. And it really
- 45:30wasn't about anything political, but in the UK,
- 45:32in the US, it certainly was. And if the idea
- 45:36was let's get environmental let's get feminist
- 45:38with it you would think that the animal rights
- 45:40thing would be there and this is something i
- 45:41explore in the third chapter of the book because
- 45:43actually star hawk. If i may take a leap here
- 45:47i was a star hawk is probably one of the most
- 45:49influential american witches of that time she's
- 45:52still active today by the way. She was what she
- 45:55was writing in the san francisco bay area in
- 45:57the berkeley area. She's writing in the nineteen
- 46:00seventies in the early eighties she still working
- 46:02there today and. The heart of modern vegan feminism
- 46:06also comes out of that very same spot. The Berkeley
- 46:11space, the San Francisco Bay space. We're looking
- 46:14at Marty Keel, who I would consider really the
- 46:17mother of vegan feminist thought. We all think
- 46:18about Carol Adams, but Marty Keel is also doing
- 46:21this work, and she founded the organization Feminist
- 46:24for Animal Rights in Berkeley. And I know that
- 46:28she and Starhawk had to have had some kind of...
- 46:31some kind of communication. They both had a chapter
- 46:34published in a book together on ecofeminism.
- 46:37I'm looking through Marty Keel's archives. She
- 46:39has mentions of Starhawk doing rituals at a feminist
- 46:43conference. So what really frustrates me is that
- 46:46Starhawk is in the midst of this vegan feminism
- 46:49and she's not, there's no cross -pollination.
- 46:54And in fact she makes all kinds of nonsense about
- 46:57how veganism is actually bad for the environment
- 46:59which is ridiculous but her whole point is that
- 47:01she's an ecofeminist and she wants to use witchcraft
- 47:04as a means of empowering marginalized communities
- 47:07and empowering nature. And yet she has this complete
- 47:11block when it comes to non -human animals and
- 47:14i would say that that's continues to be pretty
- 47:15normative of the witchcraft movement today although
- 47:18it's now much more political. It's still not
- 47:21very vegan. And I have people email me and ask
- 47:25like what is a vegan which like a practical vegan
- 47:27which book that you can recommend and I don't
- 47:29have any that I can recommend. I'm working on
- 47:31a book like that myself because there aren't
- 47:35any. Well, there's this one. Uh, theory book,
- 47:39right? But people want to like, give me some
- 47:41spells, give me some rituals. And that is by
- 47:44the way, one of the reasons why I've started
- 47:46doing the YouTube channel, uh, I'm now doing,
- 47:48um, in -person community events as well. I just
- 47:51had a solstice ritual on Saturday here in Canterbury.
- 47:54I did one for a salwin, um, and, uh, a neighboring
- 47:58city for an animal rights group back in October,
- 48:02because I think it's, it's one thing to just
- 48:03do the theory, but like we were talking about
- 48:05earlier. The creativity is important. How do
- 48:07we actually do and imagine different ways of
- 48:10being? So that's what I'm hoping to do in the
- 48:13future is continue to do the in -person stuff,
- 48:15the YouTube stuff, and perhaps even write a book.
- 48:18I'm working on a book actually to guide people
- 48:21on everyday practice and encourage their own
- 48:23creative ritual making and spell work, if you
- 48:27will. And thank you for doing that. You know,
- 48:32let me add this. believe that spirituality is
- 48:38important for this movement, that it is lacking,
- 48:41that people need it because, you know, they're
- 48:45suffering from, you know, burnouts and being
- 48:48close to this evil of animal exploitation. So
- 48:51they need some form of spirituality. I'm not
- 48:54going to say which form, you know, I'm personally
- 48:57a Buddhist, some choose Christianity, others,
- 49:00witchcraft. Why not? But let's promote it that
- 49:03there are ways of coping with that pain. There
- 49:06are ways of interacting with the world that enriches
- 49:09your life experience. And also, you know, let's
- 49:15use witchcraft to be successful in this movement.
- 49:18Why not? You mentioned being, you know, the interaction
- 49:23with the link with the political sphere. I've
- 49:28come across so many stories of witches, you know,
- 49:30opposing Trump or opposing, you know, right -wing
- 49:34political movements or whatever. But also in
- 49:39my personal life, you would be surprised at how
- 49:41many business people like very serious people
- 49:44are also, you know, have their personal witch
- 49:48person, you know, who they go to to do spells
- 49:52and stuff. And people laugh at that. But, you
- 49:55know, the serious people out there who are building
- 50:00this mask of seriousness and being official and
- 50:03all of that, they don't hesitate to use whatever
- 50:06means necessary to get what they want, including
- 50:09witchcraft. So why wouldn't we do the same? Let's
- 50:13do a pick spell for making this animal movement
- 50:18successful. What do we have to lose from entertaining
- 50:21that idea? Yeah. Now I have to say, My very first
- 50:26book is called a rational approach to animal
- 50:28rights, and I do tackle quite a lot of this spiritualistic
- 50:31stuff and religion. I have a whole chapter on
- 50:34why I think religion is very problematic for
- 50:36shaping veganism. I've had to return to that
- 50:39in this new book because obviously now I'm arguing
- 50:42a much different position. But I think there's
- 50:46a difference from I'm going to cast a spell to
- 50:50end speciesism versus I'm going to organize this
- 50:54ritual for fellow vegans to come together and
- 50:56imagine a possibility of something different
- 50:58or to take a moment to the seasons are changing.
- 51:02Let's ground ourselves in that and focus on some
- 51:04of the positive things. or let's cast a spell
- 51:08to end speciesism, but really what we're doing
- 51:10is setting intention and thinking about how we
- 51:12can do real things in the real world beyond this
- 51:15kind of liminal space of the ritual to make that
- 51:18happen. So I think what you said earlier is so
- 51:22important. When I wrote that first book in, gosh,
- 51:272015 or 16, I was in my 20s, and still full of
- 51:32Spitfire, still full of spitfire, but now I'm
- 51:34like in my 40s and I always say this and it sounds
- 51:38really depressing and it is. Almost every single
- 51:41night I go to bed I have to actively train my
- 51:43brain not to start wandering off and thinking
- 51:46about some horrible video I saw or what's happening
- 51:49right now in the slaughterhouses or the bears
- 51:51who are being having bio extracted like or the
- 51:54lobster in the tank that I saw the other. I have
- 51:57to actively stop doing that and it gets harder
- 52:00and harder I think as you become an older vegan
- 52:02to manage that because it accumulates all these
- 52:06images accumulate this knowledge accumulates
- 52:09and it doesn't really go away it builds up and
- 52:13you can't just always be this receptacle you
- 52:16need to have ways of letting it out and and harnessing
- 52:19that energy and getting it go somewhere with
- 52:22it and retrain ourselves be that through meditation
- 52:27in a completely atheistic way or be it through
- 52:31institutionalized religion. Yeah, Christianity,
- 52:33whatever it may be. But for me, I'm advocating
- 52:36witchcraft as someone who's on the fence here.
- 52:39I was raised atheist, never been into the institutionalized
- 52:42stuff, but I also see a value in going out into
- 52:47nature and saying, ah, it's winter solstice,
- 52:51it's very dark and that's very depressing, but
- 52:54the sun is returning and all the amazing symbolism
- 52:57with that. And so when I led the ritual, Last
- 53:01Saturday and we opened it up to the public. I
- 53:03didn't know who would come and you just be surprised
- 53:05people come When I did the Saman event back in
- 53:09October I had a huge turnout and people were
- 53:12all open -minded because they're all hungry for
- 53:14that same thing Like how to manage these horrible
- 53:17negative feelings and the sense of helplessness.
- 53:19I can't fix that I'm not going to be able to
- 53:21end speciesism, but what I can do is invite us
- 53:24to Grounded nature for a minute and pay attention
- 53:29to the fact that the sun is still turning, the
- 53:32planets are still turning, the stars are still
- 53:33turning, we're still turning, the seasons are
- 53:35still turning. And we can connect to that and
- 53:39focus on that life regenerating. And actually
- 53:43just spending time in nature, we know that we
- 53:45have science on that, that that's good for us.
- 53:47But it's also the community building, coming
- 53:49together in ritual. And being creative, like
- 53:53every time I do one, it's different. And it's
- 53:55always, it's very much so interactive. So people
- 53:58who come contribute in their own ways. And you
- 54:01just have a sense of, ah, at the end of it, right?
- 54:05So some of it, I'm advocating that we can do
- 54:07this as a sort of self -care, community self
- 54:09-care, if you will, but also we can use this
- 54:12more strategically. And this is what Starhawk
- 54:14has done, and if people are interested in how
- 54:16to use it more strategically, I would advocate
- 54:18going, checking out some of her work because
- 54:20she actually spells out how to do this. But we
- 54:22can actually use it to organize campaigns because
- 54:27one of the things is that when you get together
- 54:29for, say, an activist campaign, it may not be
- 54:33successful. And you may go home and think, well,
- 54:35I just wasted two hours. But there's other things
- 54:38going on there, isn't there? Like you got out
- 54:40in community, you're interacting with people,
- 54:42you're getting to know, you're bonding with other
- 54:44activists, you're making yourself feel better
- 54:46because really when you go out into a protest,
- 54:48for instance, isn't that a sort of ritual? You're
- 54:50not going to stop that incident, that oppression
- 54:53from happening, but it's a ritual in a way. But
- 54:55what if we can just add to that then and tinker
- 54:57with it so that we are being more conscious of
- 55:00it and we're able to structure it a little bit
- 55:03more to where we manage people's energy and emotions
- 55:05in a more compassionate way. And how do we do
- 55:09that? There's infinite ways to do it. And I'm
- 55:11hoping to explore that more through doing the
- 55:12in -person stuff and the book that I hope to
- 55:15do one day in the future. Yes, that's beautifully
- 55:18said. Let me continue on, you know, the non -vegan
- 55:25witches out there. What is their reaction when
- 55:29they're confronted with what you're saying, you
- 55:32know, that they should consider veganism and
- 55:35animal rights more seriously? I've not really
- 55:39had much interaction with them. The only witches
- 55:42I've really interacted with are ones I know in
- 55:44real life. For the most part, they're already
- 55:48either vegan or vegan leaning. I think I mentioned
- 55:54this to you before we started recording, but
- 55:57one of the reviewers for this book, I'm pretty
- 55:59sure was chosen because she was... Um expert
- 56:03in witchcraft theory, but not a vegan because
- 56:06the response I got from that was actually I could
- 56:10I won't have time to pull it up now, but it's
- 56:12so funny that I sent it to all my friends because
- 56:15it was like one of the most nastiest nastiest
- 56:19reviews responses to my work I've ever received
- 56:22and I knew what it was is because I'm actually
- 56:25holding up a mirror to this person like here's
- 56:27the theory that you're promoting and actually
- 56:29false completely flat because the way we're treating
- 56:32on human animals is not mashup with this approach
- 56:35to witchcraft it just doesn't and so i was accused
- 56:38of just being like having a diet tribe and thinking
- 56:41i'm gonna become some great witchcraft guru and
- 56:44start a new movement and well maybe i will. But
- 56:48really, they were trying to dismiss me and it
- 56:50was basically they were trying to say that I
- 56:52was deeply biased and that we are biased. I'm
- 56:55a vegan. I'm advocating for animals. And it really
- 56:58gets on my nerves when people accuse me of being
- 56:59biased. Like I've never said I wasn't vegan.
- 57:01Like the book is called Vegan Witch for Pete's
- 57:03sake. The whole point is to come at it from a
- 57:07vegan standpoint. But almost every time I do
- 57:10anything on veganism or animal rights in a non
- 57:12-vegan space. I'm always told I have to explain
- 57:15why this is relevant or why it's not biased.
- 57:19I would like to think that if you were writing
- 57:22on racism or feminism and non feminist or non
- 57:25racist spaces, you wouldn't have to stop and
- 57:26say, well, why this is this is why it's not biased
- 57:30or blah, blah, blah. But because it's about animals,
- 57:32I'm accused of being biased. But I can talk all
- 57:35day long about feminism. And that's just considered
- 57:37a perfectly legitimate critique, at least in
- 57:40these, you know, academic spaces. So yeah, I
- 57:43don't know, I haven't really gotten much feedback
- 57:45on that. I've only gotten positive feedback thus
- 57:48far, which has been very, very encouraging. I'm
- 57:51sure that there are negative responses, but they're
- 57:53just keeping it to themselves. So thank you for
- 57:54that. Yes, I always say I've had these conversations
- 58:01too many times to for my taste. But I always
- 58:05say this podcast, you know, it's not objective.
- 58:08I'm independent, but I'm not objective and I'm
- 58:11not trying to be because it's impossible. I come
- 58:14with my biases. I'm transparent about them. But
- 58:19yeah, I'm not aiming at that. I'm aiming to be
- 58:23independent. That's it. Yeah. Yes. One more point
- 58:31about those witches. Why do they consider using,
- 58:39you know, humans as taboo. We talked about that
- 58:45in the beginning. It's something a bit morbid,
- 58:48so sorry for bringing this up again. But I feel,
- 58:52you know, it's a conversation starter for, you
- 58:56know, doing animal advocacy work with them. Like,
- 59:00you're not using humans. Why is that explained?
- 59:03Oh, there's a difference. But what about, you
- 59:06know, animals then? Yeah, so that is a very very
- 59:10good observation I did pick up on that quite
- 59:12a bit and by the way I didn't mention like what
- 59:14this book is kind of what the methodology was
- 59:17but I I wanted to start from the beginning so
- 59:20I just went to Find every single major contribution
- 59:25to witchcraft modern witchcraft theory that I
- 59:27could on the contemporary by the way I don't
- 59:29really talk too much in the book about the witchcraft
- 59:32trials and medieval times and so it's just too
- 59:34much to take on but looking at the publications
- 59:37from the 60s, 70s, 80s, 90s, etc. So I went straight
- 59:40to the source basically to see what are people
- 59:42saying. And this is one of the things I did in
- 59:45fact see is that they would make all these claims
- 59:48about practicing respect for others, but it would
- 59:53not go to other animals. So one of the things
- 59:57that the modern witchcraft movement did in order
- 1:00:00to de -stigmatize itself and to legitimate itself
- 1:00:02was to focus on healing. So it's quite a lot
- 1:00:06of healing work. So they, especially in the UK,
- 1:00:09after it was decriminalized, witchcraft was decriminalized,
- 1:00:12there was a lot of active work for the major
- 1:00:14witchcraft leaders in the media to basically
- 1:00:17say, we don't do black magic, we don't do norc
- 1:00:19magic, we don't sacrifice animals, we don't eat
- 1:00:22little children, we are healers, we're community
- 1:00:25healers, you know, which is kind of what I'm
- 1:00:27doing with vegan witchcraft. I'm trying to do
- 1:00:29like healing work in the vegan community. Okay,
- 1:00:31fine. But when we look into actually the practices
- 1:00:36that folks are doing, there's healing work for
- 1:00:38some, but not for others. In a few books, you'll
- 1:00:40see spells or rituals that are geared towards
- 1:00:42companion animals. In a very rare case or two,
- 1:00:45you'll see that directed towards free -living
- 1:00:47animals. I was only actually able to find one
- 1:00:51witch who, she's an ex -vegan, Tess Whitehurst,
- 1:00:55who had some spells that were for animals in
- 1:00:57labs and slaughterhouses and such. But for the
- 1:01:02most part, they're not included at all. I think
- 1:01:04the silence there is very important. When there's
- 1:01:06silence, that means that they're not even worth
- 1:01:09acknowledgement. That's a power flex. But there
- 1:01:13are cases where, yes, they explicitly say, you
- 1:01:16don't fool with, for instance, cemetery magic.
- 1:01:18We were talking about that earlier. So I think
- 1:01:21Rachel Patterson, I believe, is the name of the
- 1:01:25witch. I can't remember exactly what her name
- 1:01:27was. I think her last name was Patterson. arguing
- 1:01:31that cemetery magic should not be done unless
- 1:01:34it's someone that you know and you ask permission
- 1:01:37and you don't fall with strangers graves that's
- 1:01:39just bad but then later in the book she's like
- 1:01:41okay so if you come across roadkill then here's
- 1:01:45here's some ways you can strip their bones and
- 1:01:46use the bones in the rituals or if you have your
- 1:01:50sunday roast you should save the bones from your
- 1:01:52sunday roast and here's some of the cool things
- 1:01:53you can do in your rituals but it's like whoa
- 1:01:56okay So you have all these rules about going
- 1:01:59to cemeteries and by the way not even digging
- 1:02:01up human body parts just basically in modern
- 1:02:04witchcraft when they do cemetery magic it's usually
- 1:02:06just working with cemetery dirt. But then when
- 1:02:08it comes in on human animals okay well let's
- 1:02:11just actually use their corpses and what you
- 1:02:14see time and time again and there by the way
- 1:02:16there's whole books on using dead animal bodies.
- 1:02:21Horns and bones and skulls and all that kind
- 1:02:23of stuff and they also explain how to take the
- 1:02:26flesh off very Jeffrey Dahmer stuff. But what
- 1:02:29was very interesting about that is the rationale
- 1:02:31that they give because they know that it's a
- 1:02:33bit contentious to work with dead bodies because
- 1:02:36it's stigmatized to work with dead bodies. Animal
- 1:02:39bodies included because yeah Jeffrey Dahmer one
- 1:02:42of the first things he did before we went off
- 1:02:44to start killing people human being people it
- 1:02:46was killing animal people. So which is know that
- 1:02:48there's a bit of a stigma there but what they'll
- 1:02:50do to rationalize it you see this over and over
- 1:02:52again as I'll say. Well the animal would go to
- 1:02:56waste otherwise and we're honoring the animal
- 1:02:59by using their bodies so what okay first off
- 1:03:03it wouldn't go to waste if an animal is dies
- 1:03:05in the woods just killed on the road it wouldn't
- 1:03:07go to waste. They wouldn't go to waste. Other
- 1:03:10animals would, ants would eat them and move back
- 1:03:12into the dirt and it would go back into nature
- 1:03:14and have a perfectly good use in the ecosystem.
- 1:03:17It's not going to waste. When they're saying
- 1:03:19it's going to waste, it's like we aren't exploiting
- 1:03:22this animal to our full benefit. That's what
- 1:03:25they're saying. And they're using a capitalist
- 1:03:26framework. They may harken back to some indigenous
- 1:03:29stuff. Oh, indigenous people. There's a lot of
- 1:03:31that romanticization of indigenous people by
- 1:03:33white witches, by the way, white race witches.
- 1:03:36But this idea that, well, if we're not using
- 1:03:39it to its full capacity, then it's not morally
- 1:03:41good. Using the morality, the moral framework
- 1:03:44of capitalism and putting it into witchcraft,
- 1:03:46which is really problematic. And a lot of modern
- 1:03:49witchcraft, by the way, is very critical of capitalism
- 1:03:52because it's nature -based and sustainable and
- 1:03:54all this sort of stuff. So when it comes to non
- 1:03:56-human animals, there remains this complete block
- 1:03:58about how non -human animals aren't objects that
- 1:04:01need to be exploited, resources that need to
- 1:04:03be made good on. They're persons! And if we want
- 1:04:07to respect human beings in cemeteries, why aren't
- 1:04:09we respecting non -human animals that we find
- 1:04:12dead, or worse, that they're killing? So there's
- 1:04:15no honoring of the non -human animals when you're
- 1:04:18eating them just because it's for pleasure or
- 1:04:20whatever, and then you're flushing them down
- 1:04:21the toilet down into the magical sewer system
- 1:04:24like, okay, we'll do a little ritual over the
- 1:04:26toilet. Like, that's not happening. It's not
- 1:04:28honoring them. Yeah, they're very true. Beautiful
- 1:04:34way to say it. No, it's, it's a compelling argument,
- 1:04:40you know, taking the corpse of living beings
- 1:04:42and then I'm sorry for my language, but shitting
- 1:04:46that being in the toilet. This is, this is like
- 1:04:49peak. Yes, I mean, this is a blasphemy and desecration
- 1:04:55of nature at the highest level, but I feel the
- 1:05:01same way about witches as I feel about Buddhists
- 1:05:04in the sense that you would expect Buddhists
- 1:05:08and witches to be the first on the front line
- 1:05:12of defending animals and being vegan and all
- 1:05:15of that, but they're not. The witches, when I
- 1:05:20think about witches, I think about the familiars,
- 1:05:23I think about... um again the connection with
- 1:05:26nature like you described very well in the book
- 1:05:29and um so you know it's it's like for me it's
- 1:05:34natural for them to be vegan yet they're not
- 1:05:36so i think that's the ultimate this is where
- 1:05:38i come back to with that we were talking about
- 1:05:40earlier with the the first book that i wrote
- 1:05:42on the rational approach to animal rights and
- 1:05:44how it's very critical of religion because at
- 1:05:45the end of the day and kim socha by the way has
- 1:05:47written a whole book on atheism and animal rights
- 1:05:49where she goes through all the different religions
- 1:05:51wicca and witchcraft included And says why this
- 1:05:55is a problematic way of advocating for animal
- 1:05:58rights and that's what that's what it comes down
- 1:05:59to because it's beyond religion religion is just
- 1:06:01used. Another ideological framework right so
- 1:06:05we have to really get the root of it and this
- 1:06:07is where my feminism comes in i think we need
- 1:06:09to be thinking intersectional and. If we just
- 1:06:12relying on religion to kind of save us from oppression.
- 1:06:16I think historically religion unfortunately is
- 1:06:18just been another system of an ideological system
- 1:06:21so i'm really hesitant to use in that way. In
- 1:06:24the book i'm hoping i'm hoping that which is
- 1:06:26will read that and say okay i do see power in
- 1:06:29nature and solidarity with other animals and
- 1:06:31i don't want to participate hurting them anymore.
- 1:06:34But on the other hand, I think probably more
- 1:06:36realistic, the outcome of this book is that I'm
- 1:06:38going to be encouraging more already vegan or
- 1:06:40people all sort of vegan on the fence vegans
- 1:06:43to think about how to use the power of witchcraft
- 1:06:45to help manage compassion fatigue and things
- 1:06:47like that. Sadly. Wonderful. So, Corey, I think
- 1:06:52I covered, we covered a lot. Great conversation.
- 1:06:56Yes. Stop provoking. Did you want to add something
- 1:07:00before I stopped the recording? No, I guess okay.
- 1:07:03How about this for people who are like what the
- 1:07:05hell is this woman talking about? You know what?
- 1:07:07I read the book or don't but maybe if we can
- 1:07:10just take a moment and Where's the moon look
- 1:07:15for the moon check out the moon? Where's the
- 1:07:17Sun? Where are we in the season right now? And
- 1:07:19even if you start to attune your body To your
- 1:07:22consciousness to paying attention where you are
- 1:07:24in the larger scheme of the seasonal changes
- 1:07:26and the cosmic changes lunar phases I think that
- 1:07:29you'll start to you'll start to sense a bit of
- 1:07:31a change and a change in your inner world. And
- 1:07:34that's a good place to start. Thank you for that.
- 1:07:38Yes, great advice. It's difficult to describe
- 1:07:43such, you know, profound practices and feelings.
- 1:07:48It takes away from them. But trust us and try
- 1:07:52it. And it's beyond words. So yes. Corey, this
- 1:07:58has been a lovely conversation. Thank you so
- 1:08:01much for having answered my questions. Thank
- 1:08:04you so much for the book and for all that you
- 1:08:07do for the animals. Thank you as well. It's not
- 1:08:11easy work what you do. Thank you everyone for
- 1:08:14listening. I kindly invite you to share this
- 1:08:17podcast with the vegans you know. Let's encourage
- 1:08:20more people to take action. Again, thank you
- 1:08:24so much for caring, and I will see you next Tuesday
- 1:08:27for a new episode.