Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Why Microsoft stock crashed 30%?
Transcript
- 0:00Imagine walking through like an incredibly high end luxury
- 0:04boutique. Oh yeah, the kind where
- 0:07absolutely nothing is ever on sale, right?
- 0:09Exactly. You are looking at items that
- 0:12rarely, if ever get a discount and suddenly right in the middle
- 0:17of the floor you see their absolute flagship product.
- 0:20The one everyone wants. Yeah, the gold standard, but
- 0:22it's just tossed into a clearance bin with a giant red
- 0:25sticker that says 30% off I. Mean your first thought probably
- 0:29isn't. Wow, what a lucky break for me.
- 0:31No, not at all. Your first thought is, wait,
- 0:34what is wrong with it? Is there a giant scratch I'm not
- 0:36seeing? You immediately suspect that
- 0:38something fundamental has broken.
- 0:40Right, because things like that just don't happen for no reason.
- 0:42Exactly. And for you, the listener, that
- 0:45is exactly the scenario we are exploring today, but instead of
- 0:47a designer watch, we are talking about one of the most premium
- 0:51blue chip tech giants in the world, which is Microsoft.
- 0:55It is the perfect framing because you know when a company
- 0:58with that kind of scale and reputation suddenly trades at a
- 1:01massive discount, it demands a really serious, objective
- 1:04investigation. And that is our mission for this
- 1:07deep dives. We are trying to answer a multi
- 1:10billion or maybe even multi trillion dollar question.
- 1:14Is Microsoft's recent 30% share price crash a dangerous value
- 1:18trap, or is this actually a generational buying opportunity?
- 1:22Which is a massive debate right now.
- 1:24It really is. So to figure this out, we are
- 1:26drawing heavily from a really thorough breakdown by the German
- 1:31Value Investor YouTube channel. They deconstruct Microsoft's
- 1:34current valuation, their underlying financial engine, and
- 1:38the massive risks they're taking right now.
- 1:39Yeah, they really dig into the raw numbers.
- 1:41They do, but before we get into the weeds of those numbers, just
- 1:44a quick reminder for everyone. Disclaimer All analysis is based
- 1:48on publicly available sources and may be subject to revisions
- 1:51or differing interpretations. All contents from this channel
- 1:54is for educational and research purposes only and does not
- 1:57constitute investment advice. Conduct your own due diligence
- 2:01before making investment decisions.
- 2:03Always important to keep in mind when we talk about these kinds
- 2:05of market shifts. Absolutely also to access more
- 2:08advanced researches, applications and our latest
- 2:10published personal Intelligent Multi Agent Deep value
- 2:13intelligence. Welcome to explore and join deep
- 2:16values dot AI community to track total market temperature.
- 2:20Welcome to search and download the iOS App Buffett Indicator
- 2:23from the Apple App Store All. Right, so where do we start with
- 2:26the Microsoft situation? OK, let's unpack this, starting
- 2:29with the raw math of the recent pullback, because it is jarring.
- 2:33We are looking at a share price that dropped from a high of $556
- 2:37down to $373. And it even briefly touched
- 2:41around $350.00. Right.
- 2:43Yeah, exactly. Which I mean, that represents
- 2:45hundreds of billions of dollars in market capitalization
- 2:48completely wiped out over a relatively short window.
- 2:50It's staggering when you look at the absolute dollar amount.
- 2:53Right. And because of that drop, the
- 2:55valuation metrics have just shifted dramatically.
- 2:57The price to earnings ratio, the PE ratio dropped from a very
- 3:01lofty 37 down to 23. Wow.
- 3:03And for anyone tracking this stock, you know that over the
- 3:05last 10 years, Microsoft's PE rarely ever dipped below 24.
- 3:10No, it usually commands a total premium price tag for every
- 3:14single dollar of earnings it generates.
- 3:16And if you project those earnings forward, the current
- 3:19valuation actually looks even more unusual.
- 3:21How so? Well, analysts are projecting
- 3:242026 earnings to land somewhere around 18 or $19.00 per share.
- 3:29If they hit that, the forward PE ratio drops closer to 19 or 20.
- 3:33OK. Wait 19 or 20?
- 3:34The last time Microsoft was trading this cheaply relative to
- 3:38its earnings was way back in 20, 17.
- 3:40Exactly. The PE ratio was just under 20
- 3:43then the share price was around $67 and if you had bought in
- 3:47then you would have achieved a $450 return per share up to
- 3:50today. It sounds like the ultimate
- 3:52value investors dream scenario, right?
- 3:54Catching a legendary compounder at a historical discount.
- 3:58It does sound like a dream, but I have to push back on that
- 4:00initial premise because, you know, a stock dropping 30%
- 4:03usually means the broader market sees a real crack in the
- 4:06foundation. Are we looking at a declining
- 4:08empire here? What's fascinating here is that
- 4:10if you examine the actual operational health of the
- 4:12company, the answer is a resounding no.
- 4:15Really. A resounding no.
- 4:17Yeah. I mean, the market's reaction
- 4:19isn't pricing and past failure or present decay.
- 4:22It is entirely about future uncertainty.
- 4:25Operationally, Microsoft is not declining.
- 4:28Counter intuitively, their core financial engine is stronger
- 4:31than it has almost ever been. OK, I'm going to need you to
- 4:33walk through how a company loses a third of its value while
- 4:38simultaneously being financially stronger than ever.
- 4:41The natural assumption is that they must be losing market share
- 4:45or seeing revenues shrink. Right.
- 4:47But to understand the disconnect, you have to look at
- 4:49their long term growth trajectory versus how they
- 4:51operate today. Since 2013, the consistency has
- 4:55been remarkable. So what do those numbers look
- 4:56like? Well, revenue grew from $78
- 4:58billion up to over $300 billion, and net profit over that same
- 5:03period jumped from nearly $22 billion to over $119 billion.
- 5:07OK. So they essentially quintupled
- 5:09their profit in just over a decade.
- 5:11Exactly. While also, I assume, paying out
- 5:13steady dividends and buying back stock.
- 5:14Right, They actually reduced outstanding shares from 8.4
- 5:18billion down to about 7.4 billion.
- 5:20Oh wow, so every remaining share now holds a much larger slice of
- 5:23a much bigger profit pie. Yeah, exactly.
- 5:26But the market is always forward-looking.
- 5:27So we have to ask if they've hit a wall recently and the data for
- 5:31the current half year ending December 31st 2025 shows that
- 5:36they absolutely haven't. They're still growing.
- 5:38In just that six month period, revenue jumped from $135 billion
- 5:43to $158.9 billion. That is nearly $24 billion in
- 5:49new top line revenue generated in half a year.
- 5:52That level of growth at that scale is just hard to wrap your
- 5:55head around, but I think, you know, it comes down to the
- 5:57nature of what they sell. The software.
- 5:59Yeah, Microsoft's enterprise software, things like Windows,
- 6:02Office 365, Azure, it basically operates as the plumbing of the
- 6:06global corporate world. That's a great way to put.
- 6:08It, once a multinational company, integrates Microsoft
- 6:10across, say, 50,000 employees, the switching costs to move to a
- 6:14competitor become an absolute nightmare.
- 6:16Nobody wants to RIP that plumbing out.
- 6:18It creates an incredibly wide economic Moat.
- 6:21And that Moat is the absolute, absolute key to understanding
- 6:23their profitability, specifically because of a
- 6:26concept called operating leverage.
- 6:27Right, because software scales. So, well, precisely because they
- 6:31have that locked in customer base, expanding their revenue
- 6:34doesn't require a proportional expansion in costs.
- 6:37We just established that revenue grew by nearly $24 billion in
- 6:41the half year, but to generate that new revenue, their
- 6:45operating expenses only increased by $8 billion.
- 6:48See, that is the magic of operating leverage right there.
- 6:51It costs almost nothing to manufacture and distribute an
- 6:53additional digital software license.
- 6:56You bring in $24 billion in new money and it only cost $8
- 7:00billion to make it happen. The rest just flows straight
- 7:03down the income statement into pure profit.
- 7:05As a result, net profit for that half year grew from $49 billion
- 7:09to $66 billion. And because they generate so
- 7:12much cash so efficiently, they've built a balance sheet
- 7:14that acts as an incredible defensive shield.
- 7:17What are we talking about in terms of cash?
- 7:18They currently hold about $90 billion in cash and short term
- 7:22investments plus another $20 billion in long term
- 7:25investments, so $110 billion in highly liquid assets that's.
- 7:30Insane. Against what kind of debt?
- 7:33Only about $5 billion in short term debt and $35 billion in
- 7:37long term debt. So total financial liabilities
- 7:40sit at just $40 billion. So you have $110 billion in
- 7:45liquid assets against $40 billion in debt, leaving a net
- 7:49cash potion of $70 billion. It's just a fortress of capital.
- 7:52OK. So we've clearly established
- 7:54that the core business is thriving, the Moat is completely
- 7:57intact, the cash is flowing. But this brings us to the crux
- 8:02of the problem, right? The actual reason the market is
- 8:04hitting the sell button. Yep, the big pivot.
- 8:06Because that massive cash generation we just detailed is
- 8:09currently being funneled at breathtaking speeds into a very
- 8:13expensive, very unproven unknown.
- 8:16We are talking about the artificial intelligence elephant
- 8:18in the room and to understand why the market is spooked, we
- 8:21need to shift our focus from the income statement over to the
- 8:24cash flow statement. OK, be the way.
- 8:26Specifically, we need to examine capital expenditures or CapEx.
- 8:30Which historically for a software company, CapEx is
- 8:32relatively low. I mean, you pay developers, you
- 8:34pay for marketing, but you aren't building massive steel
- 8:37factories to sell more digital downloads.
- 8:40Exactly. But the race for AI dominance
- 8:43changes the entire physical footprint of a tech company.
- 8:46You can't just write brilliant algorithms you.
- 8:49Actually have to run them. Right, and that requires immense
- 8:52physical infrastructure. You need sprawling data centers,
- 8:5510s of thousands of highly expensive GPU chips, massive
- 8:59cooling systems, and, well, the power grid capacity to run it
- 9:03all. And the price tag for that
- 9:04hardware is just staggering. Let's do the math on that for
- 9:07the listener. Because the sheer scale of the
- 9:09spending is what triggered this entire valuation debate.
- 9:12Yeah, let's break it down. If we look at the first six
- 9:14months of the fiscal year, Microsoft SCORE operations
- 9:17generated $80 billion in cash flow, right?
- 9:21If we subtract about $6 billion for stock based compensation, we
- 9:25are left with a very clean $74 billion in operating cash flow.
- 9:30Which is an incredible starting point, but then you look at what
- 9:32they spent on property, plant and equipment that AI
- 9:35infrastructure build out. OK, Becks.
- 9:37Yeah, for this half year period, their capital skyrocketed to $50
- 9:42billion. That is up from $30 billion the
- 9:45previous year. Just think about what that does
- 9:47to the actual cash the company gets to keep.
- 9:50You take that $74 billion they made, subtract the $50 billion
- 9:54they had to sink into physical data centers, and you are left
- 9:58with a free cash flow of about $24 billion for the half year.
- 10:02It shrinks really fast. It does if we annualize that.
- 10:05Just multiply by two. We are looking at roughly $50
- 10:08billion in free cash flow for the entire year.
- 10:11And this is the pressure. Point Here's where it gets
- 10:13really interesting, $50 billion sounds like infinite money, but
- 10:17you have to weigh it against the price tag of the entire company.
- 10:20Right, because Microsoft is a $3 trillion enterprise.
- 10:22Exactly. If you were paying $3 trillion
- 10:25for a business that only leaves you with $50 billion in free
- 10:27cash at the end of the year, your price to free cash flow
- 10:30ratio is 60. And in the investing world, a
- 10:33multiple of 60 is entirely unforgiving.
- 10:36It leaves no room for error. It assumes absolutely flawless
- 10:40execution, 0 roadblocks, and massive guaranteed future
- 10:44growth. It is anything but a bargain.
- 10:47Naturally, a listener might think, well they won't spend $50
- 10:49billion every six months forever.
- 10:52This is just an initial build out phase for AI.
- 10:55Which is a fair assumption, so. Let's run a hypothetical
- 10:58scenario. What if Microsoft scales back?
- 11:02What if they decide they've built enough infrastructure and
- 11:05they drop their CapEx back down to last year's level of $30
- 11:09billion per half year? Well, the math improves, but it
- 11:12still highlights the overarching valuation issue.
- 11:15Let's say they still generate that $80 billion in operating
- 11:18cash flow. Subtract the reduced $30 billion
- 11:21in CapEx and you have $50 billion.
- 11:24OK. Take out the $6 billion in stock
- 11:26based compensation and you are left with $44 billion for the
- 11:29half year. Got it.
- 11:30So we multiply that by two, maybe assume a slightly stronger
- 11:33second-half, and you get an annualized free cash flow of
- 11:35roughly $90 billion, right? That is a huge improvement over
- 11:39$50 billion. But even in this highly
- 11:41optimistic scenario where they drastically slash their AI
- 11:44spending, dividing a $3 trillion market cap by $90 billion in
- 11:48free cash flow still gives you a multiple of 33, and 33 is still
- 11:52a very premium valuation. It is not the kind of number
- 11:56that makes a value investor rush to hit the buy button.
- 11:59If we connect this to the bigger picture, this calculation
- 12:02perfectly illustrates the market's current fear.
- 12:05The stock market fundamentally hates uncertainty.
- 12:08Oh, absolutely. Microsoft is taking 10s of
- 12:11billions of dollars of guaranteed highly predictable
- 12:14software profits and sinking them into physical hardware for
- 12:18AI, but there is absolutely zero guarantee on the return on
- 12:21investment for that capital. And that is the core debate.
- 12:25Will AI create entirely new multibillion dollar revenue
- 12:29streams that actually justify spending $100 billion a year on
- 12:33hardware? Or will AI just become a
- 12:35baseline feature that customers expect for free?
- 12:37Right, because if it's the latter, Microsoft is spending a
- 12:40fortune just to maintain the market share they already had.
- 12:43Exactly. Are they building a new, highly
- 12:45profitable empire, or are they just running incredibly fast on
- 12:48a very expensive treadmill just to stay in the exact same place?
- 12:52The treadmill scenario is scary. It is.
- 12:54If those massive hardware investments don't yield massive
- 12:57new software profits, a price to free cash flow ratio of 60 or
- 13:01even 33 is going to look dangerously high.
- 13:04Which brings us to the final piece of the puzzle.
- 13:07We have the historical context. We have the CapEx math.
- 13:10Now we have to figure out how to interpret the future by looking
- 13:13at the battle of signals, the people inside the company versus
- 13:17the analysts on Wall Street. And the contrast between the two
- 13:20camps right now is incredibly sharp.
- 13:22Let's. Examine the internal perspective
- 13:24first. When you come through the SEC
- 13:26filings, there is a consistent pattern of insider selling by
- 13:29board members and executives. And they aren't just taking
- 13:32profits at the peak. They're continuing to unload
- 13:35shares even as the prices drop down to levels like $392.
- 13:39The sheer volume and frequency of the selling is what really
- 13:42stands out in the financial filings.
- 13:44Just looking at the data from March alone, there is a steady
- 13:47stream of sales. 1 Executive offloading $2,000,000 with the
- 13:50stock, another $1.3 million than $5,000,000, a $24 million block,
- 13:55and even a $62 million dump involving various board and
- 13:59supervisory members. That's a lot of equity changing
- 14:02hands. It is page after page of
- 14:03internal leaders reducing their exposure.
- 14:06To maintain objectivity, the research does point out two loan
- 14:09instances of buying. There was a purchase in February
- 14:13by director John Stanton for about $2,000,000.
- 14:17OK, so someone is buying. Right.
- 14:18And there is a noted April 2025 purchase by Bradford Smith for
- 14:24€1.45 million. But when you aggregate the data,
- 14:27those purchases are microscopic drops in a massive ocean of
- 14:32selling. Now contrast that internal
- 14:34behavior with the view from Wall Street, because the analysts are
- 14:38painting a completely different, incredibly rosy picture.
- 14:40They really are. They're projecting Microsoft's
- 14:42total revenue to grow from $300 billion to over $500 billion,
- 14:46and they expect earnings per share to climb steadily to
- 14:49$27.00 in the coming years. And if those projections hold
- 14:52true, the fundamental math changes drastically in favor of
- 14:55the investor. Yeah, the theoretical model
- 14:57suggests that if Microsoft actually hits $27.00 in earnings
- 15:00per share and the broader market calms down and rewards them with
- 15:03a normalized PE ratio of 30 again, the stock price would hit
- 15:07$810. That would be 117% increase for
- 15:11the current 373 taller level. A chance to more than double
- 15:15your money on one of the safest companies in the world.
- 15:18It sounds incredibly tempting. It does.
- 15:21But here is where I struggle to reconcile these two realities.
- 15:25We have Wall Street analysts saying by now it's a guaranteed
- 15:27path to $810, right? But at the exact same time, the
- 15:32people sitting in the Microsoft boardrooms are eagerly cashing
- 15:36out 10s of millions of dollars of their own stock at under
- 15:39$400. It's a huge disconnect, yeah.
- 15:42If this AI transition is a guaranteed home run, why are the
- 15:45people steering the ship quietly packing their parachutes?
- 15:48This raises an important question about how we weight
- 15:50different types of market information.
- 15:52There is a classic adage that insiders might sell stock for a
- 15:55dozen personal reasons, paying a tax bill, buying a house,
- 15:58diversifying their personal portfolio.
- 16:00But they usually only buy for one reason.
- 16:03Which is that they genuinely believe the price is going up.
- 16:05Exactly. Right, so you can't always
- 16:07assume a sale is a boat of no confidence.
- 16:09However, context is everything. When you see the sheer volume of
- 16:14selling, heavily concentrated across multiple executives,
- 16:17happening simultaneously with the largest, most expensive
- 16:20infrastructure pivot in the company's history, it suggests
- 16:24an acute awareness of elevated risk.
- 16:27That makes a lot of sense. Analysts build their price
- 16:29targets based on spreadsheet models and optimistic adoption
- 16:32curves, but the insiders are the ones who actually have to
- 16:35execute that pivot. They are in the trenches.
- 16:38Right. They are the ones managing the
- 16:40soaring CapEx, securing the energy contracts and trying to
- 16:43figure out how to extract profit from a wildly expensive new
- 16:46technology. The heavy selling suggests that
- 16:49even the leadership views the upcoming waters as incredibly
- 16:52choppy. They clearly don't view the
- 16:54current valuation as a guaranteed unbreakable floor.
- 16:57No, they don't. It really puts you, the
- 16:59listener, in a fascinating dilemma.
- 17:01As an investor, you have have to decide whose conviction is
- 17:04stronger, the optimistic models of Wall Street or the heavy
- 17:08wallets of the internal executives.
- 17:10Exactly, and it explains why that 30% drop isn't just a
- 17:14simple clearance rack discount, it is the collective market
- 17:17struggling to reprice the immense risk of this entire AI
- 17:21transition. Let's zoom out and recap the
- 17:23journey we've just been on because there is a serious tug
- 17:26of war happening with this valuation.
- 17:28Let's do it on one side. We are looking at a historically
- 17:31cheap PE ratio for Microsoft. We have an undisputed world
- 17:35class economic Moat, incredible operating leverage that
- 17:38practically prints money, and a $70 billion net cash fortress.
- 17:43It is the absolute definition of an unshakable financial engine.
- 17:46But on the other side, that engine is being heavily taxed to
- 17:50fund a massive, unproven endeavor.
- 17:52Capital expenditures have exploded to $50 billion in a
- 17:55single half year just to build physical AI data centers.
- 17:59That spending is absolutely crushing their free cash flow,
- 18:01pushing their multiple up to a very forgiving 60, right?
- 18:04And all the while, the people who know the company best, the
- 18:06insiders, are aggressively selling off their own shares.
- 18:09It's a lot to weigh. O what does this all mean for
- 18:11you? It means that finding a premium
- 18:14asset at a steep discount always requires asking why the discount
- 18:18exists. The fundamental business isn't
- 18:20broken, but the cost required to maintain its global dominance
- 18:23has drastically changed. And that leads me to a final
- 18:27thought. I want to leave you with a
- 18:28broader shift in how we might need to view the tech sector
- 18:31moving forward. Yeah, what's that?
- 18:32Well, for decades the magic of the software industry was its
- 18:35zero marginal cost. You build a program once and you
- 18:38sell it a billion times for nearly pure profit, right?
- 18:42But if maintaining a software mode in the modern era now
- 18:45requires dropping $100 billion a year into physical real estate,
- 18:48cooling towers, power grids and hardware, is the golden age of
- 18:52high margin, low cost software over?
- 18:55Are we watching these nimble, infinitely scalable tech giants
- 18:58slowly morph into capital intensive heavy industry?
- 19:01Wow, that is a fascinating and slightly terrifying paradigm
- 19:07shift to ponder as you look at your own portfolio.
- 19:09Thank you so much for joining us on this deep dive.
- 19:11If you like to access wider topics, including life and
- 19:14investing philosophy, please subscribe to our scissor
- 19:16channel, Deep Values. Don't forget to like this video.
- 19:18Much appreciated.