Latest / The Film Hobbyist / Klaus (2019): The Practice of Doing Good
Transcript
- 0:11Come on in and spend some time with the film
- 0:14hobbyist. My name is Lydia, and I love movies.
- 0:31We're sitting here in my attic room. It shouldn't
- 0:36surprise you to learn that I'm not much of a
- 0:39decorator. This season is an exception, but I
- 0:43don't exert much effort up here, in less trodden
- 0:47spaces. All I have is a small Christmas tree
- 0:51on my desk, hung with a selection of crocheted
- 0:55ornaments, faces about an inch and a half in
- 0:58diameter. Santa, an elf, a girl with earmuffs,
- 1:03a boy in a toboggan, and a sugarplum fairy. If
- 1:09you'll recall our conversation back in June,
- 1:11I have a small business crocheting dolls. It's
- 1:15good work that I can do on the go, and it brings
- 1:18me much joy. One of my favorite pleasures is
- 1:22the delight on kids' faces when they realize
- 1:24what I'm doing sitting in the grass by the playground
- 1:27while my children play. I often make tiny dolls
- 1:32from embroidery thread that fit in my palm, and
- 1:35I use a sewing kit to store my supplies. Sometimes,
- 1:39when a child comes to see what I'm doing, I'll
- 1:43open the box and show them the dolls. It's as
- 1:47if a golden light radiates from inside the way
- 1:51their eyes sparkle and their smiles widen. Today
- 1:56is Christmas Day, which means it's the perfect
- 2:00time to talk about a Christmas movie. And I'd
- 2:03like to talk to you about the 2019 film Klaus,
- 2:06directed by Sergio Pablos. Part of my film hobby
- 2:12is that I like to watch movie trailers online,
- 2:14especially for films I've never heard of. It's
- 2:18a great way to keep an eye out for smaller, more
- 2:21obscure movies. But sometimes, trailers aren't
- 2:26very good. And it can be easy to assume that
- 2:29the movie isn't very good either. even when that's
- 2:32incorrect. This was the case with Klaus. It was
- 2:37a mishmash of unfunny jokes strung together with
- 2:40cherry -picked dialogue set to a bad pop song.
- 2:43It looked like a cheap, lower -tier DreamWorks
- 2:47movie. And I mean cheap. The quick, choppy trailer
- 2:52edit made the animation look like it was done
- 2:54in flash. But one night, while I was out having
- 2:58an evening to myself, My husband watched the
- 3:01movie with our daughter. He hadn't seen the trailer,
- 3:04and the description looked decent enough. When
- 3:08I came home, he told me all about it and had
- 3:11me watch it the following night, despite my skepticism.
- 3:15And I'm very glad he did. That trailer did a
- 3:19terrible disservice. First, the animation is
- 3:23much better in the smooth, sustained shots of
- 3:27the actual film. It wasn't done in flash. In
- 3:31fact, the entire film was animated by hand. And
- 3:35while it was processed in a computer, that was
- 3:38to use a breakthrough technology to create amazing,
- 3:42complex lighting. This film is set almost entirely
- 3:46in winter landscapes, so what it lacks in environmental
- 3:50color, it makes up for in lighting. There are
- 3:54the soft layers you find with natural light in
- 3:58a dim room, and the golden glow of the sunlight
- 4:02shining through barren trees, long shadows cast
- 4:05over the snow. Secondly, what played as a dumb,
- 4:11contrived plot with a bad script in a trailer
- 4:14edit actually revealed itself to be a far more
- 4:17interesting story with depth and refreshing sincerity.
- 4:23While the trailer picked tropey -sounding dialogue
- 4:26reserved for cringey, faux -cool animated characters,
- 4:30the actual movie exists to challenge that cringiness
- 4:35and that posturing, to give way to genuine feelings
- 4:39and real maturity. This movie does use a few
- 4:44overdone plot points in children's animation,
- 4:47but it uses them as a springboard to more interesting
- 4:51ideas. The one flaw with this film is that it
- 4:55misunderstands its own moral, trying to spout
- 4:59one pithy thematic statement while actually portraying
- 5:04another. Klaus is a reimagining of the Santa
- 5:08Claus mythos, using an origin story for writing
- 5:11letters to Santa as the foundation for the entire
- 5:15legend. It's set in a Scandinavian country reportedly
- 5:20Norway, but the maps don't line up, where the
- 5:23postal service is taken very seriously. Postmen
- 5:28go to a special academy where they are rigorously
- 5:31trained by drill sergeants. Here, we meet Jesper
- 5:35Johansen, the spoiled rich son of the postmaster
- 5:39general, who failed the academy on purpose so
- 5:43he can return to his silk sheets. Instead of
- 5:46giving him what he wants, Jesper's father sends
- 5:50him to build a working post office in the remote
- 5:53northern island of Smirnsberg. If Jesper can
- 5:58get 6 ,000 letters delivered in the following
- 6:00year, he will be allowed to return home. If not,
- 6:05he will be cut off without a penny. With much
- 6:08whining and complaining, Jesper sets off to complete
- 6:12his task. But Smirnsburg is home to a centuries
- 6:17-old blood feud. Why would the residents want
- 6:20to send letters to their neighbors? They hate
- 6:23their neighbors. Jesper, used to scheming and
- 6:28conniving to get out of work, sets about trying
- 6:31to convince the citizens to send mail. At one
- 6:35imposing fortress of a house, a boy's drawing
- 6:38blows down to Jesper. Jesper tries to explain
- 6:43postage to him, but is chased away by the boy's
- 6:46father. In one last desperate attempt, Jesper
- 6:52makes his way to a house on a remote corner of
- 6:55the island. There, he finds a warehouse full
- 6:59of toys made by an imposing, elderly, axe -wielding
- 7:04woodsman. Jesper flees, but the boy's drawing
- 7:08falls from his satchel. The woodsman, moved by
- 7:12the picture of a sad child, intimidates Jesper
- 7:15into sneaking into the boys' house at night,
- 7:18through the chimney, incidentally, to deliver
- 7:22a toy. The following day, kids show up at the
- 7:26post office, filled with the idea that if they
- 7:29send a letter to the old woodsman Klaus, he will
- 7:32send them a toy. Jesper sees this as his way
- 7:36out and convinces the kids to write sad, pleading
- 7:40letters and convinces Klaus to send his toys.
- 7:45It works, although Klaus makes Jesper be the
- 7:49one to sneak into each house, receiving the brunt
- 7:53of suffering and booby traps. While delivering
- 7:57a toy to one house, Jesper realizes the recipient
- 8:00is a bully. and leaves coal for him instead.
- 8:05When the boy comes to the post office to tell
- 8:07the rest of the kids that Klaus never gave him
- 8:10a present, Jesper invents the idea of the naughty
- 8:14list, that Klaus would deny them presents if
- 8:18they weren't good. Hearing this, the kids go
- 8:22about trying to come up with good deeds. helping
- 8:26their feuding grown -up neighbors and parents
- 8:29instead of participating in destruction. At first,
- 8:34the grown -ups don't know what to do, trying
- 8:37to fight by out -competing their neighbors in
- 8:40goodness. But eventually, that leads to real
- 8:44goodness, and the feud begins to melt. Jesper
- 8:49still needs more letters, so he convinces Klaus
- 8:52to make toys for Christmas. In the process, though,
- 8:56he begins to change and starts to enjoy the work
- 9:00that he's doing, and even Smirnsberg itself.
- 9:03The heads of the two warring families find out
- 9:06about his scheme and connive to send letters
- 9:09themselves, some even to his father, to get Jesper
- 9:12to leave. After a bit of a contrived crisis,
- 9:16their plan fails. Jesper chooses to stay, and
- 9:20Klaus becomes Santa. The moral of this story,
- 9:25introduced by Klaus, repeated by Jesper at the
- 9:28climax, is a true selfless act always sparks
- 9:33another. This is absolute nonsense. There are
- 9:39true selfless acts in this film, but they all
- 9:42happen later in the story, after the midpoint.
- 9:45And the film knows this. At the climax, a villain
- 9:51even rejects this statement, pointing out that
- 9:54both Jesper and the kids were entirely selfish.
- 9:58I think the filmmakers felt they needed a clear
- 10:02stated theme. I also think they got it terribly
- 10:07wrong. Perhaps they might argue that while Jesper
- 10:12and the kids were acting selfishly, Klaus wasn't.
- 10:17But the thesis statement implies that selflessness
- 10:20is the driver of the action, and that's not at
- 10:25all what's happening here. Klaus is a very reluctant
- 10:30figure. He's a loner. He's cut himself off from
- 10:35community. He's not welcoming to Jesper. He scares
- 10:39him away. He's only inspired to give the toy
- 10:43because a magic wind implied to be the spirit
- 10:47of his dead wife, pulls the boy's picture from
- 10:50Jesper's bag where Klaus can find it, and later
- 10:54blows around Jesper as he tries to pitch Klaus
- 10:57on the idea of replying to the kid's letters
- 11:00with toys. It isn't Klaus's idea to help him.
- 11:06And he even forces Jesper to do the painful hard
- 11:10work. barely even speaking to him until nearly
- 11:14halfway through the film. It isn't a true selfless
- 11:19act. That doesn't mean this film doesn't have
- 11:24something coherent to say about good deeds and
- 11:27selfless acts. I actually think it does, something
- 11:32consistent that we see borne out in the real
- 11:35world. If I were to try and summarize it into
- 11:39a clear thematic statement, I'd probably put
- 11:42it, the practice of doing good sparks true selfless
- 11:48acts. Klaus doesn't want to leave his woodland
- 11:52hut. He and his wife Lydia, excellent name choice
- 11:57by the way, built it to get away from the feud.
- 12:01And she's the one who made the pithy statement,
- 12:04who believed in the impact of a true selfless
- 12:07act. Klaus decides to give the toy out of obligation
- 12:12to his wife. She would have wanted him to. And
- 12:17while he's warmed by the golden glow of wonder
- 12:20on the boy's face, it's her push, her inspiration
- 12:25that gets him to practice good by giving away
- 12:28the toys. And yes. The more he does it, the easier
- 12:33it is. Once he commits to answering the letters,
- 12:36he has also committed to practicing true selfless
- 12:41acts. And this is what happens in the town as
- 12:44well. Yes, the kids start doing good works and
- 12:49practicing pro -social behavior to be able to
- 12:52get toys, but then the work changes them, and
- 12:56they find genuine joy in the actions themselves.
- 13:01One group of kids doesn't know how to read or
- 13:03write, and thus can't send Klaus letters. They
- 13:07pester a jaded school teacher to teach them.
- 13:11But when one girl learns to write her own name,
- 13:14she's fascinated and wants to learn more. Yes,
- 13:20she has extrinsic motivations initially, but
- 13:24she finds the writing itself to be intrinsically
- 13:27valuable. The town changes, person by person,
- 13:32each in their own time. One man changes almost
- 13:37instantly. His son cleans his clarinet, and the
- 13:41joy of playing a glistening instrument moves
- 13:44him from the usual noise competition with his
- 13:47neighbors to making beautiful music. Some townspeople
- 13:52take longer. A group of kids choose to pick their
- 13:56neighbor's berries for her. instead of stealing
- 13:59them. And she, assuming this is some kind of
- 14:03new contest, makes jam with it and gives it to
- 14:07them out of spite. But then their mom bakes it
- 14:10into a cake to one -up her. And eventually, this
- 14:14routine becomes an actual genuine way their neighbor
- 14:18joins their family. They practiced doing good
- 14:22deeds, and it led to true, selfless, pro -community
- 14:27acts. Of all the members of Smirnsburg, the one
- 14:32with the longest journey is Jesper himself. His
- 14:36motivations are purely selfish. He's essentially
- 14:39running a scam. The film features his initial
- 14:43letter -writing campaign as illicit, his handing
- 14:47out sheets of paper and pencils in alleyways
- 14:50or in the lining of his coat pocket, like the
- 14:53old joke of fake watches in a man's coat. He
- 14:57ropes Klaus in by exaggerating the plight of
- 15:00the kids. He even sends the kids to school to
- 15:04learn how to write, partially as a way to get
- 15:07back at the schoolteacher with whom he has an
- 15:09early confrontation. What makes him change? Well,
- 15:15in the process of delivering these presents,
- 15:17he's in a close working relationship with Klaus
- 15:20himself. He's scared at first, then filled with
- 15:25grumbling and complaints. But the more time they
- 15:28spend delivering presents together, the more
- 15:32they build a friendly rapport. They begin to
- 15:35face danger together, even, as the clan heads
- 15:38try to ambush them. But that only leads to more
- 15:42camaraderie and shared jokes. Jesper doesn't
- 15:46realize these things are changing him. He just
- 15:50thinks it's a fun perk to the scam. But then
- 15:54he gives Klaus his Christmas pitch, trying to
- 15:57sell him on building all the toys and setting
- 15:59up a whole workshop, and Klaus begins to push
- 16:02back until Jesper literally uncovers a sad truth
- 16:07about Klaus and Lydia. All the children they
- 16:11wanted and couldn't have. Klaus, angry at this
- 16:17invasion of his privacy and out of his own deep
- 16:20grief, lashes out at Jesper. And for the first
- 16:24time, Jesper realizes that this whole scam actually
- 16:28means something to him. It was good doing the
- 16:33work with Klaus. Losing this relationship is
- 16:37painful. And with that realization, he also understands
- 16:43that he actually enjoyed the work itself. He
- 16:48chooses to try and fulfill a letter on his own.
- 16:52A girl, a member of the Sami people, indigenous
- 16:56to Norway, Sweden, and Finland, has been trying
- 16:59to write a letter to Klaus this whole movie.
- 17:01But she only speaks Sami. In a moving sequence
- 17:05that always makes me cry, Jesper takes the time
- 17:10to work with the local school teacher to help
- 17:12this girl write a letter, to help communicate
- 17:15across the language barrier. And then, with his
- 17:19own two hands, he tries to make what she has
- 17:22asked for. He fails miserably until Klaus comes
- 17:27to join him, moved by Jesper's true selfless
- 17:32act. The more Jesper joins Klaus in the toy making
- 17:37and the operation of preparing Christmas, the
- 17:41more joy he finds in the actual work itself.
- 17:44There's community to be had and genuine relationships
- 17:48in all the planning and the preparations. And
- 17:51he starts to wonder if this small life, doing
- 17:55good work and building a community, might be
- 17:59better than silk sheets and fine brandy. Though
- 18:05his transformation takes the longest, it's that
- 18:09of the clan leaders that is the starkest. They
- 18:12agree to a truce merely to take down Klaus and
- 18:16Jesper and their whole pro -community, pro -social
- 18:19deal. They plot and scheme and connive, discovering
- 18:24Jesper's secrets. They work together, making
- 18:27an assembly line of letters, thousands and thousands
- 18:31of them. But in that working together, They accidentally
- 18:36build camaraderie. Like Jasper, those close working
- 18:40relationships are transformative. Used to working
- 18:44together, one clan leader's daughter saves the
- 18:48life of the other clan leader's son. And suddenly,
- 18:52this community bond can't be denied. It's a sudden
- 18:57romantic connection. And there's no persuading
- 19:00them out of this. Jesper sees the life -saving
- 19:05effort and the sudden romantic interest and declares
- 19:08a true selfless act always sparks another. But
- 19:13the selfless act only happened because of the
- 19:16habit of working together, because of that practice
- 19:20of doing good works. Now, we're not an elf -on
- 19:26-the -shelf kind of family. I don't tell my kids
- 19:30that they have to be good because the elf, or
- 19:32Santa himself, is watching them, and they need
- 19:36to be good if they want to get presents. But
- 19:39we are talking a lot these days about the importance
- 19:42of practicing. We do homework to practice skills
- 19:46so they come more easily to us. We practiced
- 19:50our instruments so in music class we've taken
- 19:53the time to improve and are ready for the next
- 19:56step. We practice carrying on conversations with
- 20:00the toddler, even though she can't actually talk
- 20:03with us yet, because one day soon, she will.
- 20:07And we practice treating other people with respect,
- 20:10as if they are someone who matters, because when
- 20:14we act impulsively, which happens to everyone,
- 20:17we want that respect, that sense of dignity,
- 20:21to be the first thing that comes out. I want
- 20:26my kids to act selflessly, to care for others
- 20:30without expecting anything in return. And I am
- 20:33so pleased when they do. Writing unprompted birthday
- 20:37cards with encouraging messages. Taking the time
- 20:41to sit next to a younger classmate, helping them
- 20:44with their reading. A sudden tender hug when
- 20:48someone is sad. But these things don't come out
- 20:53of nowhere. These things are the fruit of practice.
- 20:59It's my husband and I standing there reminding
- 21:03them until the kids say thank you. It's repeated
- 21:08efforts of trying to get my two oldest to get
- 21:10along, walking them through each painful step
- 21:14of a negotiation and a compromise. But I walk
- 21:19them down these roads with the knowledge that
- 21:21the longer they walk it, the easier it is to
- 21:24walk. And when it's easy, true selfless acts
- 21:29will happen. And I suppose that once all that
- 21:35work is done, it isn't unusual for a true selfless
- 21:40act to spark another. Merry Christmas.