Latest / Inside Automotive with Jim Fitzpatrick, powered by CBT News / Navigating Auto Industry Challenges: A Conversation with Doug Eroh of Longo Toyota
Transcript
- 0:09Jim Fitzpatrick: Welcome to Inside Automotive with Jim Fitzpatrick.
- 0:12Jim Fitzpatrick: Hey everyone, Jim Fitzpatrick, thanks so much for joining me this morning.
- 0:17Jim Fitzpatrick: Today we are joined by Doug Eroh.
- 0:18Jim Fitzpatrick: You've seen him here before on CBT News.
- 0:20Jim Fitzpatrick: He's the president and GM of Longo Toyota, the world's largest Toyota dealership.
- 0:25Jim Fitzpatrick: He's also the president of the Penske Motor Group.
- 0:28Jim Fitzpatrick: So, Doug, thank you so much for joining us out of your very busy schedule, taking the time with us.
- 0:33Jim Fitzpatrick: We really appreciate that.
- 0:34Jim Fitzpatrick: I think you guys sell in excess of 25,000 vehicles a year, right.
- 0:41Doug Eroh: Yeah, good morning, Jim.
- 0:41Doug Eroh: Great to see you again.
- 0:42Doug Eroh: That's right, Toyota and Lexus sell about 25,000 new and used here at Longo every year and we're on track to do that again this year, in spite of all the challenges and the things happening in the world around us.
- 0:53Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, which is what we want to talk to you about.
- 0:55Jim Fitzpatrick: So thank you again for joining us.
- 0:56Jim Fitzpatrick: First and foremost, how are sales, both new and used?
- 1:00Jim Fitzpatrick: How are they going right now?
- 1:02Doug Eroh: You know, if you look at the first half of the year it's actually been pretty good.
- 1:05Doug Eroh: We're up almost 10% year over year in sales volume.
- 1:09Doug Eroh: New car sales volume, used is flat.
- 1:11Doug Eroh: We've seen a little bit of a pullback on the used side.
- 1:16Doug Eroh: A year ago we had a lot lower inventory.
- 1:18Doug Eroh: So a lot of our business is driven, of course, by availability and the products that we have to sell and fortunately the summer of 25, from an availability perspective, is looking a lot better than the summer of 24.
- 1:35Doug Eroh: And that's driving certainly some more interest in our cars and more volume.
- 1:37Jim Fitzpatrick: So let's talk about the rollback that you guys started there in California.
- 1:41Jim Fitzpatrick: But the rollback of the EV tax credits is still making headlines.
- 1:44Jim Fitzpatrick: What kind of an impact has that had on your business, or do you think it will have on your business?
- 1:52Doug Eroh: Yeah, I think, Jim, if you go back a couple months, there's really two things that have happened with respect to EVs.
- 1:57Doug Eroh: The first one was the Senate and the House actually voted to use the Congressional Review Act to actually remove the right of California and 12 other states to set their own emission standards.
- 2:11Doug Eroh: So what that did is basically eliminated what you and I would call the EV mandate right.
- 2:18Doug Eroh: It was a little bit frightening, frankly, that the industry in those 12 states was going to have to sell 35% EVs starting this fall and we're nowhere near that.
- 2:27Doug Eroh: So I think that was a huge win for consumers, right?
- 2:30Doug Eroh: Because in those states I mean you're going to we were not going to have the availability of the gas and hybrid models, as manufacturers had to, you know, meet this mandate.
- 2:39Doug Eroh: So that would have been a real problem for all of us.
- 2:41Doug Eroh: So that was a big win, I think, from both a consumer standpoint, from a dealer standpoint.
- 2:46Doug Eroh: Then you saw, and most recently in the bill that was passed, the elimination of the EV tax credits.
- 2:53Doug Eroh: Obviously that does have an impact on consumers.
- 2:55Doug Eroh: I look at the EV tax credits really in three buckets.
- 2:58Doug Eroh: One is the one that's on new cars.
- 3:01Doug Eroh: Certain models qualify.
- 3:03Doug Eroh: It depends on the country of origin or country of assembly, some other factors.
- 3:07Doug Eroh: Not all vehicles qualify for that right, so that's going to affect some and not others.
- 3:11Doug Eroh: Our vehicles didn't qualify for that incentive incentive so, frankly, won't have an impact.
- 3:19Doug Eroh: Second thing that I think will impact most uh dealers, most manufacturers, is the tax credit that went to the lessor of these vehicles and essentially was passed along to the consumer.
- 3:28Doug Eroh: If you look at that, you know I I the latest stat I think I saw was that 70% of EVs are leased, so that I think, from a tax credit perspective, that was being passed on and probably even subsidized further by manufacturers.
- 3:44Doug Eroh: So I think that's the one that will be the challenge.
- 3:47Doug Eroh: I think we're going to continue to sell EVs.
- 3:48Doug Eroh: You know, frankly, we're going to sell every powertrain right, Hybrids are in highest demand.
- 3:54Doug Eroh: We sell here about 58% hybrids at 700 cars a month.
- 4:00Doug Eroh: Wow, when you think about it.
- 4:02Doug Eroh: So EVs is a relatively small part of our business at our brand, but I think it will continue to be a part.
- 4:08Doug Eroh: The products are getting better and I think in the future, frankly, everybody's going to compete on product, not on you know who has the higher tax credit or who qualifies or where you build the car.
- 4:17Doug Eroh: So I think long-term, that's a positive right.
- 4:20Doug Eroh: We've got to kind of get through this.
- 4:21Doug Eroh: You know, transition period.
- 4:23Doug Eroh: I expect a very brisk sales opportunity in the next you know, 60 to 90 days as these things phase out at the end of September.
- 4:32Doug Eroh: In the next 60 to 90 days, as these things phase out at the end of September.
- 4:34Jim Fitzpatrick: We've already seen a lift in our EV sales this month.
- 4:36Doug Eroh: Oh, I bet, yeah, in fact, we've already sold more EVs this month, in July, than we did in June, so it's only halfway through the month, so I think that will continue.
- 4:43Doug Eroh: Then we'll have to deal with frankly what life looks like after that and the auto industry we all figure out a way to adapt and I know we'll adapt to this and ultimately long-term products will win, based on the product attributes and how good of a product they are and how well they meet consumers' needs.
- 5:00Doug Eroh: Right, as the range gets better and these products get better, they'll be more in demand, but it'll happen more naturally.
- 5:06Jim Fitzpatrick: Sure sure.
- 5:16Doug Eroh: And with the price of gas.
- 5:17Doug Eroh: I mean, you guys in California, I think you're probably paying the highest gas prices of anywhere in the country, right?
- 5:19Doug Eroh: Yeah, unfortunately, you're correct.
- 5:20Doug Eroh: I mean, gas is probably $4.75 a gallon here, which is a whole other story, but it does, you know, drive demand for more fuel-efficient vehicles and, frankly, I think that's why it's one of the reasons that we do so well with hybrids.
- 5:29Doug Eroh: Yeah, because people want, you know.
- 5:31Doug Eroh: Hey, I can get a, I can get.
- 5:32Doug Eroh: You know, every Camry's a hybrid today.
- 5:34Doug Eroh: You know, the majority of the RAV4s we sell are hybrids.
- 5:37Doug Eroh: You know, we have really a hybrid almost every model we sell.
- 5:41Doug Eroh: So people are opting to that more, right, 40 miles per gallon, 50 miles per gallon, yep, you know, ultimately, people are looking at cost of ownership, right?
- 5:48Doug Eroh: Which includes gas, which includes insurance.
- 5:51Doug Eroh: Insurance is, of course, a challenge as well, and overall affordability is a challenge.
- 5:55Doug Eroh: So it's just part of that and fortunately we have products that can help mitigate it.
- 6:00Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah, affordability is a real issue.
- 6:02Jim Fitzpatrick: That's got everybody concerned consumers, oem executives, as well as car dealers.
- 6:06Jim Fitzpatrick: And where is this headed?
- 6:09Jim Fitzpatrick: I mean, you know, to have the average price of a new vehicle heading almost $49,000, it's just, it's unacceptable, right.
- 6:17Doug Eroh: Yeah, I would say our number one concern, right, you look at the affordability for all consumers and this doesn't just affect us, it affects every brand, every consumer, and you know it's definitely an issue.
- 6:29Doug Eroh: Right, and again to your point, it's not just the car, right, it's going to be the other things that go along with it, the cost of ownership.
- 6:34Doug Eroh: You know we're really focused on leasing.
- 6:37Doug Eroh: We're trying to get our lease penetration back up to where it was kind of in the pre-COVID days, which was, you know, in the Toyota world, 25%, 30% and in the Lexus world, 60-plus percent.
- 6:49Doug Eroh: We're not quite there, we're working on that, but that is kind of be.
- 6:52Doug Eroh: I see our ticket, you know, to sort of getting through this affordability crisis, at least having a different means.
- 7:01Doug Eroh: We've got to get interest rates down.
- 7:02Doug Eroh: You know that is a structural issue that's affecting our business.
- 7:05Doug Eroh: I'm hopeful that as we get into the second half of the year we'll start to see some cuts in that area, because that's another huge driver of our business and certainly, you know, the high rate environment we're in doesn't help.
- 7:17Jim Fitzpatrick: Sure, sure, and I know that we went almost the whole interview without mentioning the T word, which is tariffs.
- 7:23Jim Fitzpatrick: But I'll ask you now what impact is that having on your business?
- 7:28Jim Fitzpatrick: If any?
- 7:28Jim Fitzpatrick: Are consumers bringing it up?
- 7:30Jim Fitzpatrick: What's your viewpoint on this?
- 7:32Jim Fitzpatrick: Obviously, as we coming into this interview today, the president just announced another 30% tariffs, and it's just.
- 7:40Jim Fitzpatrick: I mean every single time you turn on the TV or you go to your phone, it's a different story.
- 7:45Jim Fitzpatrick: On the tariffs, has it got consumers tied up out there?
- 7:51Doug Eroh: It's definitely in the air, as you said.
- 7:52Doug Eroh: I don't think you can go anywhere without talking about it.
- 7:55Doug Eroh: I don't think there's a consumer that isn't talking about it.
- 7:58Doug Eroh: I think there's not a full understanding yet of where it's going to land, where we're going to land with tariffs.
- 8:07Doug Eroh: You know, quite frankly, I think it's helped our business in the short term.
- 8:14Doug Eroh: You know, if you look at March and April, even May, we saw big increases in traffic.
- 8:19Doug Eroh: You know, I would almost call it a frenzy in those first few weeks following those announcements.
- 8:24Doug Eroh: But of course, you know, when you have a frenzy like that, there's also a give back to that.
- 8:28Doug Eroh: Right, right, you pull those deals ahead, right yeah, there's only so many, so much business out there.
- 8:33Doug Eroh: So I think we pulled a little ahead.
- 8:35Doug Eroh: We're probably feeling that a little bit.
- 8:37Doug Eroh: We probably felt a little bit in June.
- 8:38Doug Eroh: And I say we I'll use the collective we as an industry.
- 8:41Jim Fitzpatrick: Yes, yeah, everybody I talked to felt the same way.
- 8:44Doug Eroh: Yeah, I think it's common, I think it's not certainly not worrisome, I don't.
- 8:51Doug Eroh: I mean at least in terms of where the business is currently.
- 8:53Doug Eroh: You know, we were in a meeting yesterday and really if we look at our traffic and we look at, you know what we're selling.
- 8:59Doug Eroh: We're sort of back to the level we were at I would call it in the first half of March, right before there were tariffs, sort of almost a normalized like this is sort of the business.
- 9:08Doug Eroh: Now, of course, there are some, you know, certainly some storm clouds on the horizon.
- 9:14Doug Eroh: You know, if these things were to continue, I think, if you look at it, the manufacturers and Toyota has done a great job.
- 9:21Jim Fitzpatrick: We're fortunate to work with them to hold the price.
- 9:24Doug Eroh: They're getting.
- 9:25Doug Eroh: I mean, you think about it?
- 9:26Doug Eroh: These manufacturers are paying an exorbitant amount of money, and it's even an unfathomable amount of money, in tariffs right now and that has not been passed along in a meaningful way to the dealers, and we're fortunate to work with Toyota, who's done that.
- 9:39Doug Eroh: I mean, the average price of a car just went up $270.
- 9:42Doug Eroh: So I mean we're talking about less than $5 a month on a normal contract.
- 9:46Doug Eroh: It's not immaterial, but of course everybody's not going to be able to hold their breath forever.
- 9:52Doug Eroh: So we're hopeful that there's a deal, that there's some.
- 9:55Doug Eroh: I think what the industry craves is certainty, and right now there's a lot of uncertainty.
- 10:01Doug Eroh: I think certainty, whatever that tariff might be of course I think everybody would love a lower one, I think would be, you know would provide the certainty that's needed for the industry to move forward and have plans and let us plan our business appropriately.
- 10:15Doug Eroh: So we're hopeful to see that.
- 10:17Doug Eroh: Again, I don't think the whole story has been told yet and we'll see where we're at in a few months.
- 10:21Jim Fitzpatrick: Yeah for sure.
- 10:22Jim Fitzpatrick: Other than the tariff situation, is there anything that keeps you up at night, as you look to the end of the year, that you say no?
- 10:32Jim Fitzpatrick: That might be an issue lurking around the corner there.
- 10:33Jim Fitzpatrick: We got to keep our eye on.
- 10:35Doug Eroh: Yeah, I think we just got to keep.
- 10:36Doug Eroh: I think we talked about it.
- 10:38Doug Eroh: But affordability right, it's just how many people are priced out of the market right now.
- 10:41Doug Eroh: I think that is something that we've got to really as an industry and really economically find a solution for.
- 10:48Doug Eroh: I think interest rates, of course, is going to be part of that.
- 10:50Doug Eroh: Leasing's part of that um, leasing's part of that.
- 10:56Doug Eroh: You know there's other things.
- 10:57Doug Eroh: You know getting material costs down, these things that have driven up over the last few years, that have caused the rise.
- 10:59Doug Eroh: And you know you look at the regulatory environment.
- 11:01Doug Eroh: You know there's a lot of things that have been added to cars.
- 11:04Doug Eroh: Yeah, you put a car through a collision center today you know we've got a big collision center here and you look at the cost of repair and severity on that car and it's it just costs.
- 11:13Doug Eroh: I mean, I can imagine it's a safer car, which is great, but there's a lot of cost in that vehicle.
- 11:19Doug Eroh: Fixing a bumper isn't $400 anymore.
- 11:22Doug Eroh: It's $2,000, depending on what the car has.
- 11:25Doug Eroh: There's a lot of pieces to it.
- 11:27Doug Eroh: It's not a simple solution, but you know, I think that you know there's some short-term things that can happen, but that's the biggest thing.
- 11:32Doug Eroh: That's really.
- 11:33Doug Eroh: You know that we're keeping an eye on beyond our business, and you know we just had a mid-year planning meeting with all of our managers and we just said, hey, you know what?
- 11:40Doug Eroh: The best thing we can do is control the controllables, right, we can't control tariffs, we can't control interest rates, we can't control these macroeconomic things.
- 11:49Doug Eroh: So the best thing we can do is just continue to get better at all the processes and the things that we do in our business and, you know, most importantly, continue to provide an exceptional guest experience and be better than everybody else at that.
- 12:03Doug Eroh: And you know we'll continue to win, no matter what the size of the market is.
- 12:06Jim Fitzpatrick: I love it.
- 12:07Jim Fitzpatrick: Great attitude, Doug Eroh, president and GM of Longo Toyota, the world's largest Toyota dealership.
- 12:12Jim Fitzpatrick: Man, you guys have been number one for how many years?
- 12:14Jim Fitzpatrick: When I sold Toyotas back in the 80s, you were number one.
- 12:18Jim Fitzpatrick: It's been going on now a little too long, Doug.
- 12:20Jim Fitzpatrick: I mean, come on, give somebody else another, give somebody else a chance.
- 12:25Jim Fitzpatrick: 58 consecutive years oh my God, 58.
- 12:29Doug Eroh: We have a great team here.
- 12:30Jim Fitzpatrick: You really do no question about it.
- 12:32Jim Fitzpatrick: A lot of stuff to continue to win.
- 12:33Jim Fitzpatrick: In addition to a Starbucks, in addition to all of the other retailers that you find right there at Longo.
- 12:38Jim Fitzpatrick: So congratulations on all your success.
- 12:40Jim Fitzpatrick: Thank you so much for taking the time out of your schedule.
- 12:42Jim Fitzpatrick: I really appreciate it.
- 12:43Jim Fitzpatrick: I know a lot of our dealer gurus get a lot out of your visits with us.
- 12:46Jim Fitzpatrick: So thank you.
- 12:48Doug Eroh: Thank you, Jim, good to see you.
- 12:49Jim Fitzpatrick: We do.
- 12:51Jim Fitzpatrick: Thanks for watching Inside Automotive with Jim Fitzpatrick.